Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Star Wars Generations Podcast • Beyond the Screen

Star Wars Generations Podcast • Beyond the Screen artwork

The Acolyte • Episode 4

Jun 19, 202446 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Erin and Matthew dive into the thrilling events and revelations of Star Wars: The Acolyte season I episode four, exploring character developments and plot twists in the Star Wars universe. We’ve started the conversation. Now we want to hear from you!Want to continue the discussion with us? Agree or disagree with what we talked about, or add your own thoughts? We’ve got options for you! Discord: Join in the conversation about this podcast, my other podcast Superhero Ethics, as well as the rest of the TruStory.FM Podcast Email: ✉️ swg@theethicalpanda.com 𝕏: SWGenerations Facebook: TheEthicalPanda Instagram: SWGenerationsPod TikTok: TheEthicalPanda Visit Star Wars Generations on TruStory.FM for more information, contact info, and more! You can find more about Alex Kormann’s work on Instagram or on his website. To see more of Erin McGowan’s cosplay adventures and fandom thoughts, check out her Instagram or Tiktok. Want to support the podcast AND get ad-free episodes and bonus content? Become a supporting member of The Ethical Panda Podcasts! Members get access to bonus content with (almost) every ad-free episode of this and my other podcast, Star Wars Universe Podcast, and we’ll be adding more benefits soon, including access to live streams!You can subscribe for $5 a month, or get a discount with an annual membership for $55.Plus, you'll be showing your support for this show and all things Ethical Panda. Visit our home on TruStory FM to learn more.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Quick programming note. I know we've been having audio trouble for a couple of weeks. Now in this episode, in the second half, we have some real problems with I want to apologize for that, to tell you we're absolutely working to fix it. I don't think we're gonna have any more episodes as bad as this one. Again, it's only in the second half, and it's only my audio, so I still think there's a lot to listen to. But just to know that we are taking new steps. I think we're gonna need to upgrade some equipment. I'll be taking care of that as soon as I can, well, making sure we get back to the good audio quality that you all got used to. Thank you so much for listening. Of course, become a member is the great best way to help support us

and help make all this possible. We have spoken. Hello, Welcome to this episode of the Star Wars Generations podcast. I'm Matthew, your host. I'm joined by unfortunately only one of our two co hosts. One of the others couldn't be here. Alex can't be with us. But we have the May Stand Herself, the Ahsoka cos player, the forgiver of Anakin, the reminder of things, the person who has many different names that I can't hold, but is a princess of some sort or another on some planet somewhere in the galaxy. How we're doing today, I'm doing pretty swell. I don't

know if I'm excited or disappointed that the child has no longer made it into my intro, but I feel like I've grown since we first started here. The child's always there. It's always like something I can draw upon when necessary. But we're not watching the show that has the child at the moment, so exactly. Our child is Jeckie, and she's very not like a child, very true, very true. This will be going out in a day or two later, but I do want to just start by saying we're recording this on Juneteenth, which I've been on my own social media. As I

know a lot of people are Blue Child, lift up a lot of the voices of black creators in different spaces, just because you know what Juneteenth is all about, and paying attention, Like folks like me tend to get a lot more of attention on social media, and there are some amazing creators of all kinds of backgrounds, especially today, we're paying attention to some black ones in the show notes, I'm going to listen to my favorites in terms of Star Wars creators, but I would definitely do some searching for so the black creators and what they have to say. This show obviously has a couple of very important black characters, but also just you know, when they're talking about

anything about Star Wars or the things you love, So definitely check that out. With that being said, though, okay, we're talking about the Accolyte episode four. We have a great bit of listener feedback that we will get into in just a few moments, But Aaron, let me just first start by asking what do you think the episode? Oh, I really liked it. I did it was It's kind of like that we talked about this a lot in the Bad Batch, but it's like the Gang's altogether, you know, like the whole squad shows up on one planet, so you kind of know things are about to get real. But yeah, I just I really

love I do love May as a character a lot. Yeah, So I like being able to spend more time with her after seeing episode three and kind of that like anthology of May and Osha and just understanding her better. I don't know. I really loved what we saw between Jeckie and Osha and kind of the tea that goes down within the Jedi Council. Like Saul was specifically

taken off the mission and he used Osha to get himself back on the mission. Yep, Like my guy got booted and he said, I'm gonna do it. Anyways, So there's lots of shit going down in this episode. There is a lot, and I'm really enjoying it. I'm really enjoying how Like the Jedi are not a model of the institution by any means. And let's just start with Saul, because I think Saul is a very good character who is a Jedi and is doing quite a lot of things that I think

he's doing very well. And my microphone is moving around a little bit, so apologies if my sound is a little uh all over the place in this episode. Trying to figure out the best way to position it me one second, I'm gonna try it there. Hopefully it stays fairly certain for next episode I will get it fixed. So the point is, Saul is a very good character who I think is doing a lot of good and I think as a Jedi is doing a lot of good. But the thing he tells Osha to draw upon that he says, gives her her strength is her connection with

her sister. And he talks about his connection with Osha and with May like this is a man who is all about attachments and recognizing that attachments can have power. And I don't know if it's because the Jedi are a little more like, yeah, maybe that's okay, or they're just like, uh, there goes Saul with the attachment stuff again. But I'm not quite as strict about it. But this is not what makes Window and Yoda would practice. Absolutely not. This is not the Jedi council that I know. Then again, Saul is not on the council, so there's probably reasons for that.

He kind of he's giving very Shoot, what's his name, Quinlan Voss Vibes. Yes, yes, that is, but just older and a little slower, you know, so he can't quite do all the crazy shit. Yeah, but yeah, I agree, Like Soula is a really great character, but he's not He's not a bad Jedi, but he's not a great Jedi. He's not like a model Jedi. Right. Well, again, that's that's what it's to me, It's kind of like with Canaan, where like,

if the duty of the Jedi is to bring peace and justice and balance and harmony to the galaxy and to people who are in need, I think he's doing fantastic. Yeah, if it's to avoid attachment, he's really bad, you know. And so the question really becomes like who gets I think that's I think it's what I like about the show most right now. It's really asking us to define who what is a good Jedi and who defines that? Yeah, I mean it's the forever question in Star Wars. I feel

like this at this point, we've seen so many different iterations of Jedi, so many different people feeling the Jedi should be one way or another way, and at the end of the day, it's all flawed. But it is just interesting to see it play out kind of a few hundred years in the future, how we're still having very similar kind of debates throughout the Order, for sure. I also thought was really interesting was the well, if we tell the Council, the Council will tell the Senate, and then the Senate will tell the people, and the people have to have a very good like

you know strong idea of us is unchallenged, so therefore we're not going to tell anybody because a there's like I know a lot of people are very concerned about well it's supposed to be that no one knows this or that or that kind of a thing. And we'll get to some of the details of that. But I like it very specifically, we're saying, off the bet we don't have you know, one Jed, I learned something. It does not mean everybody knows it. Yeah, people are actually hyped. Yeah, yeah, like the count does not know all At the end of the day,

there's many councils happening. For an Estra Row has just decided to make her own counsel apparently, but she kind of kills it, so go off. But about that, it's interesting because you said you see it as they can't appear challenged. To me, it's more I saw it or heard it as they were afraid of the people finding out that a Jedi left the Order and

is training someone in opposition to them. So not only like yes, they shouldn't be like they should be unchallenged, but the idea of we're the ones, like we are part of the problem that's like what I saw as like the big part they're trying to hide why they don't want to tell the Council or the Senate is like this, let's look at the hollow this clearly this person has been trained by a Jedi, and this person is killing Jedi. That's a problem. No, I think that's a really good point, especially when you think, you know, think ahead to the Clone Wars when Ahsoka

is thinking of leaving and you know, she's told and like later they're told when I'm talking about Doku or not done beforehand, you know, but that this is repeating a number of time, Like I think only sixteen or whatever it is, have ever left the Order, and the idea that Duku after he left could ever kill a Jedi is just unimaginable to obi Wan, probably because obi Wan never learns of what's happening here because it's covered up, you know, like some of those always in Forever type claims that were made about the Jedi and the Clone Wars. I think we're learning probably there's a lot

of cover up involved. Yeah, it said uh one of one of our bigger fans who's very active in the discord, Corossan. Uh Corsusano, I think is the person you're uh Corsicano, I'm pretty sure that Alex schooled us on this last time. Yes, you're right, thank you, Corsicano, Uh wrote in because he's he's following along as anyone, Kenneth. They're on YouTube. Yeah, the secrecy seems almost dishonest, which foreshadows some of the Heubors and later eras. And yeah, I think that's exactly it. Yeah,

a great point, real quick. Good just on the Jedi and kind of that scene that opening stuff we get on Coruscants when Soul comes to Osha and you know, asks her, will you come like finish this mission with me? It's so it sucks. It's sad because she looks at him and she says, you want me to rejoin the Order? Yeah, and she looks so excited and he said no, not officially, well like not officially like just this thing, and she goes, you need me to get to

her. It's just like that sucks, Yeah, because OSHA's been just such a lovely character that's just so insecure and so self doubting and so like this idea of this master who clearly is still very fond of her, this master who came back to her and believed in her all these years, doesn't even want her back. Like I just saw it as such a moment in her character. Kind of yeah, that kind of to me, it seems like

it's ceiling. Okay, May is not Jedi. May is maybe not sith Osha is not of the Jedi. Yeah, maybe probably not sith. I mean that's an assumption I've made based on this one little thing. But I don't know, it's just kind of interesting to see how that is. No. I think that's a really good point, especially because to me, what part of what it gets at is that the Jedi are just terrible at actually saying what they feel and what they want. Because I think the way Saul is approaching it, it's kind of a classic like every bad TV romance where

two people never quit. Two people both assume the other one isn't interested and so say things that make the other feel the wrong way. Yep. I think the SAAL's perspective, she has no interest in joining the Jedi, and so he has to say no, no, no, I promise I'm not trying to pull you back into the Jedi. I know you don't want that I just want you to help with this, but of course what she hears is, Oh, you don't want me, you just want to use me for this other purpose. And it's yeah, it's tragic because I do fully understand where both of them are coming from. But they could just say what they damn feel and want, use their words. Mm hmm. Yeah,

so very silly, So very silly. We're gonna let's get into may in this in just a moment. But I first want to ask, because it's been talked about a lot, what do you think about the young Kyle Mundy of it all? What mister Kiati Mundy just showing up. I'm like, first of all, Alex texted us about it and was like, I don't know. Something about this confirms that he's a sith because he didn't say anything, which is a joke obviously, and I was like, Mondy is with Palp joking. But then I was like, well, first I was like,

Alex, no fucking way, Like, there's no way he's alive because as to my knowledge, Syrians live less than a century. That's what I've seen before, Like you pointed out out, Matthew, that is what's on Wikipedia. So technically it's Legends at this point, Well it comes from the Legends novel. But then so I thought it was only a Legends and it's certainly possible in Disney that that's wrong. But then Alex pointed out something that was printed. Well it was printed when it's in one of the like you

know, guides to the the prequel, Yeah, which it says happened, which is during the Legends era, but is also an official lucasfilm, like not a It is not, I believe, part of the extended universe that was supposed to be made non conomical. Yeah, the difference is only about in theory. He is, like, the times don't exactly line up. Let's be clear about that, because nothing else right now. The novel that

was just released three days ago or so maybe a week ago, about the High Republic, describes a time that is only one hundred years before what is happening in the show, and it's a time when another evil force has literally divided the galaxy and a half and there's war and chaos and starvation everywhere. And the show opened by telling us that we've had hundreds of years of peace, So already I think you're kind of playing a little fast and loose with the numbers, and I think we just kind of have to accept that instead of trying to line things up exactly. So that's kind of where I'm at.

And but I think the other question you're getting at is really gets to I think what the whole stuff with may reveal to us, and I'm out a bit of a actually whole on second, we have one or two questions from the chat that I will get into quickly. Is it Kyle Mundy for sure? Our friend asks, is it? Says in the credits there's the characters specifically named a young Kyle Munday. Yeah, so that is confirmed. Unfortunately, because that's the first thing I said. I said no, and

that Alex was like, it's in the credits. I was like, well, shit, I can't. I can't argue with you now, But why is he here? Nobody likes him anyways? Well, a lot of people in the fandom clown on Kiati Mundy because yeah, he's got a big old head and he fucks a lot of women. I kind of like that. In the Clone Wars episode where Anakin is having the stupid competition about how many drones he's killed, that Kyle Mundy actually is like, no, actually I have I've killed even more. He's like forty seven doesn't that make me the

winner or something? And he's like what do I get? But okay, so the jokes about him, he must be stiff, he must be Palpatine. I think is a good leading to May, because I think a lot of us have been assuming, myself included that May is a stiff acolyte working to an apprentice, working for an actual stiff, and this episode, I think blows a lot of that out of the water, reminds us that is not what we've been told in the slightest. What do you think of May's turn and kind of where all that is right now? Well, it's just

very interesting. It was a very quick turn, but it also made total sense after the episode that we had last time. You know, like, how do you say his name is a chimeer? Is that her companion? Yeah? I think so. I wanted to tell from the good place, from the good place. But that's although there was a little more of that character coming out today in him being a little clownish, which I have some theories on, but yes, there was. Yeah, I've got lots of theories anyways, But yeah, Chymeer said something about, you know, Osha

being a live changes nothing. You know, you still have this task to complete and is like, no, I can't do this, this is impossible. How am I supposed to kill a Jedi without a weapon when they can't attack people who don't have weapons? Like this doesn't logic, it doesn't make sense, Like this is clearly a fake task, and she just gets like frustrated with it, and it kind of convinces herself, ah, like fuck it. And then she's also thinking to herself, well, Osha being alive changes everything, right because her and it's said in the episode, but like

what is important to her is her family, which is Osha. She doesn't really actually care about her training or anything else. It's just something she found to dive into when her entire world was shattered, when she thought she was completely alone, and now that's changed. And so even though we kind of talked last episode about how there was a quick turn in May just kind of like suddenly being like, oh, I'm gonna burn anything down, and we had a quick turn here too, but this one made a lot of sense and I think it paid off what we learned in the last episode very well

of their like loyalty to each other and just that little saying they used to do back and forth about like you or me and I'm you or something like that. But yeah, what did you think about May this episode? What are your thoughts on that kind of turn? Yeah, I think so. I do think that she brought into some of the Dark Side ideology or whatever it was. But I think it's you know, it's kind of like imagine if ten years after the Clone wars, pad May and Luke and like young Luke and Lea all of a sudden show up and Vayner meets them and they're

like, hey, Dad, how you do it? Like part of the whole ideology of the the Dark Side is that you're driven by emotion, but you're driven mostly by your anger, by your rage, by your jealousy, by your hate. Well what if all of that is focused on, like, you know, the death of someone, and then you realize like, wait, no, they didn't die, Yeah, they're not dead, Like, and I think part of the idea is that the hate so consumes you that eventually, like not even that can pull you back, as evidenced by like, I'm so wanting to protect Padme that I will go down this that

leads me to killing Patme. But I think, you know, May's still quite young, and the idea that she hasn't done that yet, I'm a little lost on it because she has like it would be one thing if she hasn't really done anything with the dark Side yet, but she's already killed the number of people, but she's assassinated to Jedi, and she's I believe killed other people in like getting to those Jedi, So we know that's a thing

as well as it does make me ask more questions about what happened in the flashback, because if her hatred is all about what happened to her sister and they took my sister away, that's one thing. But we also don't know how her parents died, and we don't know what guilt, Like according to the story we saw, she should feel all the guilt about what happened to her mother's and her whole community. It was her fire. We talked about how we don't think that's actually what happened, in which case, like like

I do feel like there's a lot of other emotions that the story has told us she should be holding even though yeah, so like but her so, I don't feel like she's like totally gonna come back to the light side by any means. But her breaking with her uh her Master and Camire, and the question with those two are the same person or not is when we'll definitely get into it in a few minutes like that. Definitely, I don't think she's had a break from the dark side, but her having a break from that towards like OSHA's my emotional focus. That's what I care about. That

totally makes sense to me. Yeah, and my thought on that would be that, yes, she's killed people using you know, quote quote the dark side. Let's remember the witches. I think that she had that connection to that side of the forest anyways. I think that growing up that is something that would be considered acceptable to kill people if you need to get to where you're going. And so part of me is kind of like, I don't it's a possible. I don't have a huge opinion on it either way right now, But it's a possibility that she hasn't really delved too deep into the

dark side itself because she's just pulling on what she was taught since she was a kid, because this tragedy happened when they were probably like ten. Maybe would you say, yeah, I don't know very well what kids look like at different ages, but I would guesstimate about ten or so. And so they've had, you know, ten full years, They've had a decade to learn from all of their mothers and kind of have this this version of the Force steeped, have themselves steeped in that version of the force. So,

yeah, that's just the thought I had as you were kind of running through that is maybe it's a bit of both. Yeah, I think it's very true. And to me, the question that leads to now is what was she actually a part of? Because we have not heard the word Stiff said once on screen. We know that she has learned the dark Side. As you said, she already has some exposure to it, but she's been learning more of it. She has been taught to hate the Jedi, and she's

been taught to use a red lightsaber, and she has a master. But she is an acolyte, not an apprentice, and an acolyte is not an official term as far as we've learned within the Stiff in the Disney canon. It is in the extent universe Cannon, but again, that's not what we're dealing with. I think it's entirely possible that this is an offshoot, that this is some other group of Dark Side using people who are not actual Stiff,

and maybe she's going to be noticed by a Stiff. That's like, I do think a Sith character is going to be revealed at some point. I think it's possible with someone we've already seen. I actually have a little bit of a suspicion about Venestra. I'm perhapsing your name wrong with the Green Jedi. I'm probably entirely wrong about that. Just a little bit of suspicious vibes they get from her. I think I'm probably entirely wrong on that one. Interesting, but at this point, I especially with like how like she's

not instantly killed for going off, which not I mean, it could be a good lesson to like teach her, like to isolate her so that she has to turn back to the Sith. But it doesn't feel like the Sith to me. So that's and someone else pointed out the question it might be that she actually isn't the Acolyte. I think it is actually something that coras Kana was bringing up earlier, someone I know definitely was of like, maybe someone else is the acolyte of the show and we just haven't and they get recruited in the course of the show. Or maybe her master is the acolyte.

That's certainly possible, you know, maybe Jeckie or Yrd is gonna fall or even sall, you know, like, oh god, he's saying at the beginning Saws all about his detachments and an emotion Saul, No, what if he becomes the acolyte? And that's part of why Kyle, Mundy and Yoda and all the rest are like, no, No, there's no attachments that would happen to Saul. That would be wild Darth Saul Darth'saul. Maybe I don't think so, but maybe that would be quite the plot twist.

I'll tell you that I'm very curious about this Vernestra theory. But I also haven't read any of the books that she's in, so I don't have any basis of her character. I don't remember her from the books because there's just a lot of characters. I don't think there's any real basis for it. It's just a little bit of a like she's a little suspicious. She's she's the one who's a little bit darker and a little bit like we should do the things we have to do. So I thought May I was just like,

what if it was a Jedi? I guess it could be an Estra, Like it was literally something just came to me right now. Yeah, gotcha. Yeah that doesn't make sense though she is she's incredibly stern and like grave in everything that she does. You know, she doesn't fuck around, which could I mean, that's makes window as well. So yeah, it could go a couple of ways exactly, But yeah, what do you think are are you convinced that these are stiff we're dealing with? Do you think it could be something else? I mean, since we saw the first trailer and we saw those kind of like snapshots of witches, I never thought that

the Sith were going to be involved in this, and at this point, like, I kind of hope they're not. I've said it before, I was lay again. I'm an easy to polase fan. I'll be happy regardless, but I would kind of love to see the Sith not be involved, or like you said, I would I would really appreciate if May is not the accolyte. That would be really cool if it's misleading in that way. But also, I don't know. I have a lot of trust and love for the execs and whatnot at Star Wars. I think they always give us a really fun story, So I know, however it's told, even if

it's not the outcome that I predicted or I would have wanted, I'm sure that it'll be regardless. But yeah, I kind of I'd prefer if it's not necessarily the Sith and it's kind of something different, because that would be a fun little trick that they played on everybody. I think right now. The only reason why, like there's an argument that it has to be the Sith is that in Phantom Menace, darth Ball appears and all he does is have a red lightsaber and clearly know how to use the force and know how

to use a red lightsaber, which Qui Gon says means he was trained in the Sith arts. So therefore, if shark Man basically has the exact same things, like why is it the Qui Gon to think Sith but here we don't think Sith. Yeah, at the end of the day, if that's just inconsistency. I think I'm okay with that, Like I think I don't. The story at this point has gotten so big with so many writers that I think we just have to accept they're going to be inconsistencies, and then it's okay. And if we spend all our time arguing about and I know

this is me sort of breaking with what I've been before, but I'm kind of willing to let go with some of that stuff, Like Okay, actually, wait, I'm gonna send this a bit. To me, there's a difference between a plot inconsistency and changing the emotional meaning of estee. So for example, okay, why does he know it's a stiff and not just some other dark side user? There was something Maybe there's something else that Darth Maul did that we just didn't notice. Fine, but something like you know,

your devotion to that ancient religion when it turns out into religion that actually every person in that room knew twenty years ago, or like you know, when last we met, I was but a student. Now I am the master. When I actually they met again ten years after, when we thought that we're talking about, like those to me feel different than this does. And maybe that I'm just justifying the ones I like, and you know, I don't know, but but does that make any sense? There's like emotional tenor versus just like lat detail. No, totally, yeah, because some things are just semantics. Some of it's just like I mean, the silly little

things that we see explained away in the point of view book. You know, there's plenty of those little things. But I agree there's some changes that it's like, Okay, well that did. It's starting. It's changing the way that people see the original material if they see the original material after the newer material, right, and I see, yeah, how that's like very different and more frustrating and more of the problem to like die hard fans. Yeah, I mean, do you think there's a sense of the Jedi are

very invested in the idea that the Stiff haven't been seen in a very long time, and so it's possible that when things turn up, they're like, Nope, nope, can't be saff, can't be Saif, And Qui Gon just isn't, like we know, Qui Gon is very different from that. So yeah, of course, Dono writes, considering what a what a Kaiber has to go through, to be read. I feel like that's a lot of pain, which in his opinion, their opinion equals stiff. I think I think that could be it. But because again, to create a red light serh you're talking about last time, you have to inflict a huge amount

of like torture and pain to the chiro crystal itself and have it be around that. But I think there can be. I think that's the point that other people can use the dark side, like you know, and be very high, and that can be people can be very sadistic and torturous and evil, uh, without the being stiff necessarily. Yeah, So what do you think about dark shark tooth? Oh? Is that who you're talking about? Shark guy? Yeah? I was so fucking confused. I'm like, what are we talking about right now? That has like the weird teeth, Yeah,

the big old mouth. It reminds me of the Oh, it's just me, I'll I'll tell you what I was thinking, uh till Matthew comes back. It reminds me of fifth person or the dark side person who should hold in high reverence and was the chat. So that again, with all due reverence to the very scary person with the lightsaber and the t on their helme. Yeah. So what I just said to everyone who's here that wasn't you, is that this character really reminds me of the Mouth of Saron from

the third Lord of the Rings movie, with like the helmet that comes out and it's just like literally just a mouth. The name is what he is. He's a mouth. That's what that made me think of, which that character is very gross and menacing. So I was just like ew, like honestly just ew. And the way the way that they floated down from the trees, I was like, oh God, I want to crawl out of my skin, like that makes me so uncomfortable. I don't know why Osha turned and just kind of stared like bitch, run, I don't get it.

Yeah, I didn't think I could be scared by another dark skyd user, but I click, you knew that they were going to ignite a lightsaber, but they just the timing of him being so close to Osha and they just that snap his and the red booming like it was really good. Yeah. I like how they did that a lot. I really I don't know other than that I don't have a ton of or wait, are we going to talk about what we're going to talk about. I think he might be

Dathan, he might be kinder, if that's how you say it, because like my guy talking about, oh I owe him a debt. Oh no, I care about you. No, it's not an impossible task talking about oh my god, just oh shit changes nothing. Like literally, you could not be more obvious unless he's not the sith in which they have played us all, or at least have played me. Because I really feel like, okay, sorry I use the word sith when we just talked up and down about how this person probably isn't the Sith. Yes, but yeah, I

kind of really hope it's him because I love a good goofy villain. I love a villain that like isn't what they seem. Yeah, it's funny. I was really hoping it was him for that same reason. This episode, I feel like they hit you over the head with it so many times that if it is I'll feel like, Okay, you did a good setup in the first three episodes. I wish you hadn't made it quite so obvious in this fourth episode. But otherwise that's fine and good writing, you know.

But I also think it's possible that it's supposed to be Read Herring and it's going to be someone else or that as I said, like the person in the mask is Queen, and I can't remember quite what is it. It's Q I M I R. So I've been saying, kymere, kymer. I think it's right. So I think it's very possible that it's him, and they maybe overhit the reveal of it, but I think I think it's possible for someone else or what I think it might be is it is him, But as I said, the big reveal is going to be that he's not a stiff and that he's actually being played by someone else who is just

kind of watching the shadows. Hmm. I had that thought. Good. Oh, I just had the thought along the way that like, maybe he was the acolyte and he still is a separate person from Shark Face. I would prefer if he just was Shark Face, but that would be interesting if like, yep, he's not what he seems, but they didn't like fully tip their hand in this episode. Yeah, I think it's very possible. The other thing that I keep thinking about, especially in terms of being kind

of Sith adjacent, is and again this is an extended universe comment, but I think it's relevant here. If you remember in those Dark Fain books that we like so much, with the exception of how the female characters are written, one of the things that Bane talks about when he creates the Rule of Two. Yes, extended universe, but I think it's irrelevant is the idea that they want these little groups of like pseudo dark sided people to pop up every now and then so that Jedi can stamp them out and go, oh, look, we defeated them. They were just pretending they weren't really the Sith pout ourselves back specifically, we won't. Yeah, I think that's the

most likely thing, is that it's something like that. But can we talk a bit about did you have more to say on this subject before we move? Okay, can we talk a bit about just like OSHA's journey in this episode, right, and I have a couple points when I bring this up, So, like I talked about on Coruscant, you know, she kind of was very hopeful that maybe Saul was asking her back to the Jedi Order, and that hope was kind of just crushed and then oh, well,

for I just want to get into Basil love that character. Such a great, funny little thing. I really loved that when Osha goes over to Jeckie, she asks is he or they with us? And I just like, I really loved that, especially because Amandla Stenberg uses she they pronoun so I kind of liked that that they got to use those pronouns in like a Star Wars on screen thing. I always love little nods like that to the community.

But anyways, and so you know, we see that she's kind of developing this friendship with Jeckie and kind of leaning on her, but she has just all this conflict with Yord, right Yord, dear God, this guy, he's the worst, but he's fine. Anyways. You know, they first get to the planet. He's like, you need to give me that gun because you're a civilian. And she's like okay, and he's like no,

Osha, She's like, I bet you, like if you also don't want me on the mission, like join the club, and he's like no, I'm just worried about your safety. She's like what the fuck. Anyways, but it's interesting that like Jeckie is someone new that she's clearly Osha has started to bond with but when she needs something, she still goes to Yord because they grew up together. And she goes and she asks him basically says, if it comes to it and we need to kill May, you have

to do it because I can't. Yeah, And even Yord kind of like appreciates that, like he doesn't say, like you have to break your connection with her, you know, like he seems okay, And maybe because he sees her as not a Jedi and non Jedi can have a Yeah, and like the rivalry makes a lot of sense because you know, like basically like she is the X you know, yeah, she was before. And it's a little weird because they're the same age. I think what it must have

been, like wait, what, No, they were young things at the same time. Yord was not Saul's padawan. Jeckie is, oh, that's right, okay, right right right there, Okay, but enough. Yeah, but yeah, I did have like a quote from him after she says that, he said, I've known you since we were young. Ling's May has always been your wound. Maybe Saul brought you here to face her,

but maybe he brought you here to face yourself. And I was like, damn, like at the end of the day, Like he might be all cold to her and she might be all you know, teasy to him or whatever, but it's just that thing of like I love the feeling of like childhood friends. Like I recently got in contact with a friend who I was like, I mean, we've always stayed in contact, but we just hadn't hung out in like five years or something, and we hung out, and like, there's something so wonderful about like feeling so seen by someone who like

knows where you came from. Yeah, And I think that that was portrayed well in that conversation between the two of them. Is like you don't get along, but like just having that history with somebody, they know something about you, Yeah, and they know how to like encourage you or how to like really get a point to you. I mean, Paul and I have been friends since high school, which is coming upon thirty years now of our friendship, you know, in the part of my life for a very long time. And you know, he knows things about me that my wife does

know that I'm like, not that I keep secrets from her, which is that you use there who over time? Yeah, what else has so Yeah, I totally get that. Get that. Yeah, we can say so much about this episode. I want to just go and read this awesome comment that we got, and then we need that to wrap up and we will have a quick bonus section about we are going back to those stories from from a certain point of view, and so, of course Kno writes, I'm excited about the possibilities inherent in the story, the characters I know nothing about, but I feel that I'm still kind of waiting for the show to finance putting. I'm watching episode four now and still wondering where it's going. Is

may the act lite is the red bladed mystery man or someone we don't expect that expect expect like maybe it's Alved, Okay, so it was, so, of course kind of give is that I'm starting to get the impression that we as the audience needed simply trust that the story will take Ah, I'm starting to get the impression that we as the audience need to simply trust that the story will make sense and have a satisfying ending. I find each episode to be simultaneously interesting, get frustrating, and cliche. I'm all just out there with the Yeah, I totally agree in. Honestly, this is a

show that I think would be work, would work much better as a bench because it feels like it's very intentionally week by week giving us one more piece of the puzzle. But because of the world we live in, that means that we after each week, we're like, Okay, it has to make sense now, so let's spend a weak debating it when we still don't know most of the rest of the puzzle yet. And I think that's a really good reminder of Yeah, like the stuff we saw on May's flashback doesn't make sense, so let's wait to see what else we learned about it. Yeah.

I kind of chuckle to myself there, because Matthew, we've watched many shows together over the course of the last year or so, and you say that about every show you just want to binge, which is so valid, but it's just kind of funny. Yeah, I think it's true. I think, honestly, if it's doing an episodic show on week to week show I wanted to be more. I don't mind episodic. I think Monster of the Week that would like I would love a show that isn't about a huge plot, or if it is it's in the background, but it just gives

us, like week to week the different adventures of the Jedi go on. I would love that, but I think it asked me that I think a serialized story episodic is, which it doesn't work for me. Yeah, it's like you want to release season by season kind of an idea. Yeah, which makes sense. I'm sure a lot of people relate. Yeah, continuing that comment, I think the episode three Podcasts was right off, thank you so much, in that the flashback episode was one faulty memory replated recollection of that's We'll see another perspective in later episode. That's try, I hope. So at this point I'm cautiously optimistic, but only because I love Star Wars,

unfortunately concerned that for each ending that will be amazing, there'll be like a hundred that would just be a huge disappointed. After Knobe, I absolutely see so many ways that could misfire and if you totally heartbroken with this premise that has so much potential, just like Kenobe. For the record, just like Kenobe. So the record, I personally hated Knobe and I literally held my hand head in my hands after the first two episodes and set out loud. I am so disappointed. Flite works on a high note. This is funny too, because my Today's trintineth of this day. So we had a day off. My partner I wanted binging obi Wan because she had never seen

it before, and I was really wondering if I'd like it more on a second route, I don't. I would say though that I do like it a lot more. I like the first five episodes quite a lot, and I think the sixth episode is completely irrelevant and just makes everything worse. Like if Knobe just like tricked Vader and got away and I didn't have that fight, if Reva never goes to catch me, and because there's no reason to do so, I just think it much better. But but anyways, that's a little bit of editorial comment. Uh to the side. But back to

this, what do you think this episode of? Like we just have to trust even though some of us may be disappointed by something so far. Yeah, okay, I've got a few more little things here before we go. No reaction to that, what's whatsoever? I did that thing, the ADHD thing where my brain kind of restarted, So I'm so sorry. I just stop from don't remember what you said. That's fine, that's fine. Well

was the last thing you wanted to go on. I'm so sorry. No, don't worry about that. Just I like that we're seeing Osha becoming more in touch with the force as this goes on. You know, she said something about, like she sensed that roly poly creature thing, and she was very effective of the fact that she knew it was a creature when she touched it, you know, in an accident that she touched it and she disturbed it and nounced dead, and like she really took that on. And Jackie some point later in the conversation said something about, we're not defined by what

we lose, We're defined by what we survive. Yeah, and I think that that's like a very interesting it's an interesting thing thing to think about. I don't know that I fully agree personally, but yeah, like I said, I just like their little relationship. But the most interesting thing we got this episode, in my opinion, is when Saul says, you're going to face your past. Both of us will. Once we get May safely to

the ship. I'll explain everything, I promise. What the fuck did you do, Saul? What did you do? Well? I think that what did you do applies on two levels because by all the walls of a there's the like he's explaining the past what actually happened to me and him, to May and her and him, But also by all the laws of TV piche, that means he cannot make it back. I'm so upset, like he just precides so death by saying that he did. Maybe maybe that's maybe he

becomes accolade. Yeah, maybe that's why he doesn't explain anything. I hope they write that cliche because I do want someone to just like, I'm so curious how us what happened, but we'll please pretty explain. I feel like a Dalek, explain, explain. I do want to say one thing about what you said. Also, I love that moment for recognizing that by her interacting with this world, she disturbed one of the creatures to the point where they thought it was a threat and wound up killing it. Because if you

remember one thing that I talked about a lot and Paul talked about a lot in The Mandalorian, but also in some shows since then, is I don't really love it when people go to other Our heroes go to other places and going to the territory of predatory animals that become predatory because that's what they do, and our heroes have to kill them, and we're like, oh, good, have a fun fight scene against that big scary monster which is actually just an animal living its best life. Yeah, and so I kind of liked her having a bit of guilt of like, oh, I need be more aware of how my presence affects those around me, because he if something

about like our relationship with animals, but also just surrounding It's like, yeah, when you're going to a strange new place, be aware of it and don't just assume you have the full ability to go where you want and touch what you want, to do what you want. Yeah. Yeah, I did like that moment. Last thing I'll say she Could's a fun wrap up and kind of proves the point of like different people can like or dislike things for very similar or completely different reasons. Corasnando pointed out that it's hilarious because he tells people to only watch the last two episodes. So he and I

did not like Obi Wan, but for a different reasons. So oh interesting. See if we ever want to have an after chat about Obi wan. I recently one of my clients at one of my jobs had listened to the episode where we talked about it and was like, actually, I have thoughts and he's like in his mid fifties, so I'd love to share those opinions at some point, but that doesn't apply today, So y'all will just have to join our member club. Generations is an ethical band of podcast the true

story of the members of course for doing the show. They share at the rating review in your podcast episode best will support us about becoming a member. Information and all the links in the show notes so great, thanks for listening to uh please think about that? Please how to give giving us feedback? All the notes from in the show notes half myself Aaron Alex can I be here? Thank you all so much. I have a happy Please check out some black readers stake last wherever the hell you are. No. I just

looked at all these quotes and not a single thing. Maybe soul brought you here to face her, but maybe he brought you here to face yourself.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Hiatus 2.0

    Aug 27, 20262 minAudio

    Star Wars Generations is going on hiatus for a few months. We’ll be back in December to get you ramped up for Ahsoka Season 2! **************************************************************************This episode is a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Ninth Jedi • Episode 1

    Aug 6, 202628 minAudio

    Would you give up your name to save your life, if a tyrant demanded it first? Matthew Fox and Erin McGowan open Star Wars Generations’ new episode-by-episode watch-through of Star Wars: Visions Presents - The Ninth Jedi...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Ninth Jedi • A Primer

    Jul 30, 202635 minAudio

    Can lightsabers work like mood rings for your soul? Matthew Fox and Erin McGowan get listeners ready for "Star Wars: Visions Presents - The Ninth Jedi," the new eight episode series expanding two existing Visions shorts...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Ahsoka vs The Jedi • Clone Wars S5: Eps 17-20

    Jul 16, 202646 minAudio

    What happens when the people who raised you decide you’re guilty before you get a chance to prove otherwise? Matthew and Erin spend this episode of Star Wars Generations on one of “The Clone Wars”’ most consequential...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Onderon & Saw Gerrera • Clone Wars S5: Eps 2-5

    Jul 2, 202631 minAudio

    Before he became the paranoid revolutionary from Rogue One, Saw Gerrera was a scrappy fighter who thought sheer force could win a war. Matthew, Alex, and Erin head back to "The Clone Wars" Season 5 for the Onderon arc,...

    Credit the people on this episode