Star Wars Generations dives deep into Disney+'s Skeleton Crew in this wrap-up discussion. Host Matthew joins returning guests Riki and Danielle to explore how this coming-of-age adventure series fits into the broader Star Wars universe while charting new territory with its young protagonists.The hosts tackle key questions about the show's unique approach: How does Skeleton Crew manage to be both a "kids show" and compelling viewing for adults? What makes the series stand apart from other Star Wars content by focusing on ordinary suburban life in the galaxy? The discussion explores how the show handles complex character development, particularly with antagonist Jod, whose villainous turn avoids typical redemption arc tropes.Why did Skeleton Crew avoid the controversial reception that met other recent Star Wars shows? The hosts examine how the series balanced traditional storytelling with modern family representations, featuring diverse family structures while maintaining broad appeal. They also analyze how the show succeeded in giving each of its young protagonists meaningful character development within just eight episodes.Other topics covered: How SM-33's character serves as an improved version of the Jar Jar Binks archetype The significance of Neel's pacifist nature and his relationship with Hayna KB's groundbreaking representation of disability in Star Wars The show's potential connections to The Mandalorian timeline The future possibilities for these characters and the planet At Attin Comparisons to 1980s adventure films and Stranger Things The conversation concludes with speculation about potential future storylines and whether the show needs a second season, with the hosts agreeing that while the story feels complete, there's rich potential for these characters to appear elsewhere in the Star Wars universe. **************************************************************************This episode is a production of Star Wars Generations, a The Ethical Panda Podcast and part of the TruStory FM Entertainment Podcast Network. Check our our website to find out more about this and our sister podcast Superhero Ethics.We want to hear from you! You can keep up with our latest news, and send us feedback, questions, or comments via social media or email. Email: Matthew@TheEthicalPanda.com Facebook: TheEthicalPanda Instagram: TheEthicalPandaPodcasts Twitter: EthicalPanda77 Or you can join jump into the Star Wars Generations and Superhero Ethics channels on the TruStory FM Discord. To learn more about co-host Erin and her incredible cosplay check out her Instagram, LadyTanoCreates. Want to get access to even more content while supporting the podcast? Become a member! For $5 a month, or $55 a year you get access to bonus episodes and bonus content at the end of most episodes. Sign up on the podcast’s main page you can even give membership as a gift! You can also support our podcasts through our sponsors: Purchase a lightsaber from Level Up Sabers run by friend of the podcast Neighborhood Master Alan Use Audible for audiobooks. Sign up for a one year membership or gift one through this link. Purchase any media discussed this week through our sponsored links.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Before we dive in, here's another show you can enjoy in the True Story FM family of entertainment.
Speaker 2Podcast What's Up, Most Excellent Friends, It's Christy and Nathan for the Most Excellent Eighties Movies Podcast. It's a podcast where a filmmaker and a comedian and their most excellent guests adventure their way through the eighties movies we think we love or might have missed with our grown up eyes to see how they hold up. Join us for delightful discussion, rollicking recaps, ratings, and deep cut recommendations. Plus members get some extra fun chit chat with the hosts after the show.
Speaker 3Download the Most Excellent Eighties Movies Podcast today at true Story dot fm.
Speaker 2Or find it wherever the finest podcast are stored.
Speaker 3And do you remember to keep the Most Excellent Eighties Movies Podcast.
Speaker 1Motto in mind?
Speaker 2Be excellent to each other.
Speaker 4And Pardi Yon Dude's.
Speaker 5Oh there you are.
Speaker 6I was hoping i'd cross paths with you today. I'd like to invite you to visit the Story Well. It's a place where storytellers of all stripes gather. From improp performers to authors, screenwriters to playwrights, we all tell stories. But we're not here to talk about craft. We're here to make something out of nothing. Each episode of the podcast, your host that's me sits down with a creative person and based on a series of random prompts, we get elements that we make into a story. Will it be a noir novel about King Kong or a Broadway musical
Speaker 6about JFK Even We don't know. That's the fun part. But what do you get out of this besides a good time with fun people? Simple? The idea is then yours.
Speaker 1That's right.
Speaker 6Whatever we come up with, we give it away for anyone to use however they'd like, no strings attached. It's like each episode come through a free prize inside the story. Well, with Kyle Olsen, we'll save you a seat at the table.
Speaker 7Hello, Welcome to this episode of the Star Wars generation's podcast Friends. We talk a lot about hearing from multiple different voices, hearing from multiple different perspectives, and while we've had a lot to say about Skeleton Crew, two of the people who have been some of the biggest contributors to this podcast, Riki and Danielle, have both know had a chance to weigh in on Skeleton Crew and there's a lot more I've wanted to say about it, so I have both of them on today for our final final Skeleton Crew wrap up.
Speaker 5That's a lie.
Speaker 7I'm sure we'll do more about it, like down the road when Skeleton Crew Season two comes out, if it does, but for now, I'm just happy to have you both back. So, Danielle, you're probably it's been a couple months since I think you were lasting one of our podcast.
Speaker 5Can you reintroduce yourselves to our listeners.
Speaker 1Yeah, I'm Danielle. I'm mostly usually on TikTok got written in the Star Wars also on x and Instagram now, but yeah, I mostly talk about Star Wars, but also lately the Bear has taken over for the past probably like eight months. And I'm also well, really big on The Last of Us, so when that comes back, I'll be talking about that. But yeah, I'm really looking forward. I love Skeleton Crews. I'm excited to talk about it.
Speaker 5Nice. Nice.
Speaker 7We've had Danielle on the Superherotics podcast a lot for Hunger Game stuff and for the Last of Us stuff, and well, I'm not sure I can work a superpower into running a restaurant in Chicago. I will say that Danielle has given me new reason to rewatch, to watch season two and three, even though I found them a bit of a slog. But you can tell exactly when I have watched an episode of The Bear by looking at my door dash history, because there's one restaurant, and one restaurant only in my neighborhood that does a good Italian beef and I always order it.
Speaker 5When I watched The Bear? Or did they after you have?
Speaker 7Do they have any good Italian beef sandwich Chicago. Italian beef sandwiches in Scotland.
Speaker 1I've never seen, But I'm actually going to Chicago in July, so I'm going to have one when i'm there.
Speaker 5Nice. Nice, I'm not too far from that area. We were to actually meet in person.
Speaker 1Oh yeah, that'll be nice.
Speaker 5So let's talk.
Speaker 7Let's get into this though, and Riki, let me have you start reeky Is was a co host along with his partner Sarah, on this podcast for quite a while before it became Star Wars Generations. He is currently my podcast host on Superhero Ethics. But we chatted about this a bit. What do you think, Skeleton Crew?
Speaker 4I think the phrase this show saved Star Wars is a little over dramatic, but I do think that this show really set a good direction for the franchise and was just such an excellent show and made me excited again to be a Star Wars fan and to think about the future and what kind of more different projects we might get. That isn't you know? There was a kind of maybe question mark Jedi, but like it shows without Jedi, right, without light side versus dark Side, I
Speaker 4guess is where I'm getting at. Yeah, and to really expand Star Wars as a as a universe, as a franchise, A very good show for that.
Speaker 5Yeah.
Speaker 7Yeah, this to me is something that is very much a Star Wars show, but it is in no way, shape or form a part of the Skywalker legacy.
Speaker 5And I just really love that, do ye know what about yourself? Yeah?
Speaker 1I really loved it. I saw someone say once that this was like Star Wars, like people in Star Wars watching a show like that's what it that's what it felt like, And I agree because it was. It was. It was an adventure show, and I love that they leaned so heavily on the like the kind of eighties nineties adventure movie aesthetic. I think that really went a long way in separating it from what we've gotten kind of used to and what's kind of I think overdone a bit in Star Wars, and it allowed it to feel,
Speaker 1like you said, rekuet fresh and exciting and just, I don't know, something for everybody. I think the little hints at, you know, the Jedi history, but not making it the center of it, the you know, something for the kids too, I think I love I love that this was run by kids, Like the stars of the show were actual children, and I was thinking about it. This is the first Star Wars live action to do so, to have the
Speaker 1main cast be mostly majority children. We get that in Young Jedi Adventures, the High Republic animated show, the kids who voice the kids are actually kids, but as far as like live action goes, most of the shows are helmed by adults, by adult actors. Most of the movies are as well. We had you know, Jake Lloyd and the Phantas Menace, but he was just there for a little bit. He wasn't the main I mean, he was the main focus, but not for a long time. And
Speaker 1so I really loved that we had this four kids kind of you know by kids essentially, and I thought it just it gave something so so new and fun to follow along and to watch what they did and the act the kid actors were amazing, like absolutely amazing. I think that speaks a lot to the direction as well, which I'm sure we'll get into. I think the directors did a great job at making those kids feel like they had a safe space to really bring their best to the show, and they did.
Speaker 5I think that's really true.
Speaker 7And I think that, you know, I think Star Wars has had kind of a spotty history with child actors on things, and I think it's been there's been an awful lot of cruelty towards child actors that has been really unfair and really horrible, Jake Lloyd being probably the primary example of that. But I also think that most people don't think of not not blame him, but that still his performance is not sort of one of the the high points of the Star Wars experience. And we did have Leah in the Obi Wan show, which I
Speaker 7think and I thought she was very good and good acting and directing and dialogue, but even that, like she wasn't on the level of.
Speaker 5You and McGregor or.
Speaker 7Christian Haydensen and and so having these kids be such the focus was so nice, and in part because.
Speaker 5It wasn't as dark as something.
Speaker 7Like Stranger Things, but it also to me was not a To me, there's a big difference between a kid's show and a kid friendly show, and this to me was very much the second, and that this felt like something that like kids could watch on their own and like adults didn't have to be like super worried about, but also kids could watch with their parents and the parents would you know.
Speaker 5I have a number of parent friends who.
Speaker 7Talk about like they'll like deal with watching Thomas the Tank Engine, but they're a lot happier watching Bluey with their kids, you know, like there are things that they enjoy more, and this is like even more on that level. Like this, it reminds me when my mom would talk to me about watching the Muppets and how the Muppets had like all this humor that I loved at three, and then a whole bunch of other humor I loved at twelve, and then a whole bunch of other humor I loved at twenty five.
Speaker 5And I just thought that was great.
Speaker 7And I also thought it threaded this really interesting line, and in somewhat it was a back to basic Star Wars story. It was about just kind of a fun adventure. It wasn't getting wrapped up in a lot of the stuff that I love, but that's been a lot more controversial in terms of like everything from the taxing of trade routes to the good and evil of the Jedi and all this kind of stuff.
Speaker 5But also, as you said, it expanded things.
Speaker 7I know a lot of people said it didn't feel like Star Wars because because it wasn't.
Speaker 5It was set in a world so different.
Speaker 7Everything we've had has mostly been about either the empire or all the the people in like the highest of power, or the people who are the most getting stepped on.
Speaker 5By all of this.
Speaker 7We very rarely seen just like the suburbs, but of course Star Wars would have suburbs out in this uniform both on this weird planet, but also are probably on coorissants you know another plate. Well no, it Carson's all urban, but you know what I mean, like affluent middle class who are privileged enough that they don't have to notice the problems happening around them, and they're kids who are still good people and are just kids. And yeah, I just it felt to me like it made the Star Wars world so much bigger in a ways I really loved.
Speaker 1Yeah, it felt like, I mean, we all think about like if we were dropped into Star Wars, how it would be like with the Jedi and in the middle of the Clone Wars and all this, but realistically, like if we were dropped in the middle of Star Wars, it would be like Skelton Group ending up on like a pirate planet running from your life. You see, you get a light you pick up a lightsaber, you turn it on, and it hits you in the foot because you have it upside down. Like that's what the reality of. So it just, I don't know, it felt so I don't want to say real because I mean it's obviously side fantasy, but it felt like if I were to somehow,
Speaker 1you know, end up in the Star Wars universe, that's what would happen. Like that little adventure is what would happen. And I loved that we got to It was an adventure for the kids, but it was also an adventure that we got to go along with them on.
Speaker 4Yeah, I want to acknowledge that the two Ewok movies do exist, and they were live action with kids, like centered around kids. They were okay, not me there. I don't even know if they're cannon like in Star Wars because it doesn't quite make sense anymore. But I do agree like the aspect of this show that was four kids but wasn't pandering to them, I think is what
Speaker 4what made it so good for us as adults. Yeah, right, Like many people did not like the jar Jar Binks character, which was for kids, and a lot of kids growing up I've enjoyed it, and that's what they loved about Star Wars and have become Star Wars fans, as is the point of this podcast, right generations. But for adults who were like, come on with this with this character, there wasn't really much of that in the show, and it was like very believable. Yeah, like these kids are on an adventure and they're acting like kids in a believable way. But it didn't. It never felt like there
Speaker 4was a moment that was like pandering to the younger audience.
Speaker 5Yeah.
Speaker 7I never missed connection before, but I'm kind of thinking that in some ways s M three three clearly the SMEI character like he kind of plays a similar role to jar Jar, but it's a much better done. Jar Jar first of all, doesn't have all the awful racist connotations that Jarjar had, but just the element of like, yeah, he's there to be the babysitter for the kids, and and he's silly in a lot of ways that kids can love and like overly literal, but also he plays this really first of all, he's a pirate, and just every adult loves pilots if there's a kid at heart
Speaker 7and some way. But just like there's just so many ways in which it feels like it was done, like like I think you said it's four kids, but it's not pandering to kids, and adults can really like it too well.
Speaker 1And kids aren't gonna be the one who catch the ones who catch the SMEE reference. That's that's going to be the adults. And so it's a good balance a character like you said that kids can enjoy but adults are like, oh, hey, I know, I know where that's from. That's what this is supposed to be.
Speaker 5Yeah, which I.
Speaker 4Have genuinely terrifying moments too, like when his programming takes over, he's like, I have to tear you limb from limb like that was scary, Like even for me as an adult, I was like, oh no, like this is bad.
Speaker 7Yeah, And I love that, especially because I had a friend who's done a lot of I think, either a PhD or Masters. I forget which went on fairy tales and how one of the things about children's stories is that often they have to have rules, and the rules might be kind of ridiculous, but they work.
Speaker 5And and I.
Speaker 7Think I as too often a lot of fairy stories, like about the fay and things like that. And so the fact that like that me responds to you know, unclaims these claims these and now I claim it in the name of children only. But that's a kind of silly game eight year old's play or ten year old or six year olds whatever on the playground or whatever. And the fact that it works, and it's like pirate Robot is like, well they called on claims these my program.
Speaker 5He acknowledged that it was so beautiful.
Speaker 4I love Yeah, it was fun, and I think it was a really important character moment four thirty three that he was an individual who cared about these kids and was like looking for any loophole he could find to be able to help them. I think was the important part of that. It wasn't just like, oh, like you have triggered my programming. It was I want to help these kids, like give me it out.
Speaker 1And I think that that was so important, Like juxtapositioning that with or juxtaposing that with oh my god, why can't remember his name? Ju Blow's character? God. Yeah, So like juxtaposing thirty three with Jod, because Jod was an adult figure they thought they could trust, but then he turned on them, stabbed in the back, and there are kids, so of course they're terrified. Like their entire concept I
Speaker 1think of life has kind of been flipped on its head when Jod does that to them, because they grew up being able to trust everyone around them, every adult around them, and they didn't trust Jod at first, but then they did, and then now it's just that trust has been thrown in their face. And so thirty three, who and Jod, had a choice there. He could have helped them, He could have let his trust or their trust in him be worth it. But thirty three, who is supposed to be based on programming and not have a choice, went out of his way to try and
Speaker 1find a way to keep their trust, and I think that was an important thing to have for them so that like they didn't lose all hope or all innocence when it comes to being able to trust the figures around them.
Speaker 5Yeah. Well, let me use that.
Speaker 7To ask you more about the character of John, because I think as the show went on, he was one of the ones that people had the most theories about and the most questions about. And there's a lot of feeling that like, oh, we're setting him up to have some big, like hero turn at the end, either he'll realize that the kids who protected or that he had a plan all along. And then also as we started to see him use force powers, a lot of things about like, are we going to get some big you know yet again have an early sixty six flashback, or that you know, we were told that he was the apprentice of the specific Jedi. We got very little of that,
Speaker 7and his backstory is left incredibly vague. What was your feeling on all that, and like, did you feel like he was going to have a hero term? Were you surprised at the end? Were you not surprised?
Speaker 4I was, I guess a little surprised. First off, like, I hope we get a season two and that we do get to explore more. I'm fine with them not doing that in this first season. In season one, I hope we get more. But I did want him to end up being a good guy at the end and being like a friend and a caretaker for these kids. But I don't mind what they did with this character. I thought it was consistent, and once he did make a heel turn, I'm glad they didn't try to redeem
Speaker 4him after that.
Speaker 1Yeah. So I was one of the people too who was like, he's gonna he's gonna realize the error of his ways and he's gonna he's gonna help them. But then, like the more we got from it, and obviously that didn't happen, I was glad they didn't go that route as well, because I liked I don't know, I felt like there was an important lesson in that, not just for the kids but for him. Clearly he had a very very rough childhood, and I view him as kind of the foil of Canaan Jaris right now, Canaan was
Speaker 1also a young he was a Jedi. I think I don't think Jod realized that he was for sensitive until afterworder sixty six, and I think maybe, I think we don't know yet, but I think that that's what happened. But Canaan was also a young for sensitive kid who you know, lost his teacher and who was just trying to find for himself in the galaxy and realized very quickly that the galaxy is not a friendly place to kids. And he also had his dealings with pirates and and
Speaker 1but he changed his ways, he became a good person. He decided to fight for good and for hope and everything, where Jod held on to his resentment of how he grew up and the things that happened to him. And you can see that when he looks at the kids towards the end of the show, just how angry he is at them that they had this nice childhood and they had this innocence that was ripped away from him and he and I think that that was a really beautiful story for adults, especially because I don't know if
Speaker 1kids would grasp that, but the adults watching one hundred percent do And I'm sure all of us have felt that way, even not on that scale maybe, but in smaller ways about seeing kids get to grow up, you know, having things that maybe we did, and I know, like you know, if you're if you're queer, even just ten years ago, it was completely different than it is. I go back home to my hometown in Texas and I go into a bookshop and there's a queer shelf there that would have never happened when I was growing up,
Speaker 1Like people didn't utter the word. And so in those ways, I think adults, we can relate to it as being you know, like I wish, why couldn't it have been that way for me? Like I'm glad it's that way for you. Is how most of us feel, and John doesn't feel that way yet. But but I just think that that was such a beautiful way to kind of show that, and it wouldn't have been as hard hitting if they'd him have that redeeming moment. I think maybe in the future we get more, but for now, I think that was a good ending on his character.
Speaker 5I think you're right. I think for me that hits on a couple levels. For just on example, you were using.
Speaker 7Rieky and I did an episode recently on for Superhero Ethics on the movie, I saw the TV Glow, which is phenomenal, really good, and one of the things that it's about is about kids discovering their queerness in terms of sexuality and gender at a time when people didn't really have words for.
Speaker 5A lot of it. And I talked about how, like, if I had heard.
Speaker 7The word non binary when I was seventeen, my life would probably have been very different. But I didn't hear that word until I was probably in my thirties, and I always just felt like, well, I don't feel like a woman, so I must be a man, because I didn't know that there were other options. And so you definitely relate to that, but often even more specifically to John, Like we often talk about the trope that this movie, that this show is kind of aping, and so is Stranger Things. Which I think this show owes a lot to is the kids on bikes idea of the you know,
Speaker 7suburban kids who ride their bikes and go they see the danger that the adults don't see, and they go have this big adventure and they're able to fix the things that the adults aren't fixing. But they are suburban kids who lead carely comfortable, suburban lives. I watched those as a new York City kid who came from my parents divorced. They went in very different economic strata, and so my father was pretty well to do, but my mother was very much not so and I got split my time, and so I had a ton of resentment
Speaker 7towards those kids, And when I got to college, I had a ton of resentment towards a lot of those kids, as well as also realizing that I had been a scholarship to was quite literally the school that Gossip Girl is based on. So I thought of myself as the poorest of the poor, because even with my dad, we were vacationing in Connecticut instead of or Vermont, instead of going to Europe, And then realizing a whole bunch people were like, oh, you only went to New Hampshire. Poor, poor kid, you.
Speaker 5Know, because that's the and that's part of what the.
Speaker 7Show is about, is that you only know the perspective that you have as a kid.
Speaker 5And so I related to John in a lot of those ways.
Speaker 7And I like that they let him be a villain, as you said, but they didn't make him like evil, you know, Like I do think that like he's probably more on the dark side of the force, but he does genuinely seem to not want to hurt the kids. He is genuinely upset at the idea that the kids are fighting against him because he might have to hurt them and he doesn't want to. And especially when KB almost crashes her plane her ship, he hates that.
Speaker 5And I just.
Speaker 7So off to me if every character who has some remorse about the harm they do has to therefore be redeemed, it's actually kind of cheapening the idea of villain. It's because it means that the only villains are those who are just inhumanely evil. The fact is that's not most of the people who do much in the harbor of the world.
Speaker 4Yeah, he restrains himself in such an interesting way when he's threatening the kids and is almost begging them to stop resisting him or else, like he feels like he would be forced to do something that he clearly doesn't want to do.
Speaker 5Yeah, And I think.
Speaker 4That makes him a very compelling character. And I do hold out hope that it makes him redeemable again, Like not in this season, because I think it would have been too quick of a turn back and forth. But I do think like the character seeds are there that in a season two and we could get a longer redemption arc for him where he comes back around in a meaningful way. And I think that that seed being planted here in the way that he is absolutely a
Speaker 4villain in this season, but he's not an irrideemable villain's very valuable.
Speaker 1Yeah, I think I could see him eventually ending up a little bit like hondo Onaka sure who never fully like you can't ever fully trust him because the only thing you can trust is that if he gets a better opportunity, he's going to take it. It doesn't matter if that means like ditching you or turning his back on you. But you can also count if you're a kid, that he's not gonna hurt you, because he never he never does. I mean, I have a lot of complaints
Speaker 1out the way i Ahsoka storyline is handled in the Clone Wars when it comes to that particular thing. But when we look at like Katuny like he names his ship after Katuny and Ezra even though he ditches Ezra, and Ezra has to learn that he can't trust everybody. Whenever it comes to hon to Oaka, Ezra can still kind of trust some things about him and still likes him and us him as maybe not a role model, but but someone who's who's at least not going to hurt him. And and I could see John going down that route, still still a scoundrel, still breaking the laws
Speaker 1and working for himself.
Speaker 4But but Hondo Hondo shows up for the final Battle of Lothal to help Ezra and specifically sites like I'm doing it because he's Ezra. So yeah, like that's that's the kind of you know, semi redemption, like at least like does the right thing in the end, but is still a scoundrel. Absolutely, Like would love to see that for John.
Speaker 7And there's a part of me, as as the leader of the Hondo and AKA fan club along with your spouse Sarah, that there's a part of me that is sad that he didn't show up in a pirate show. But yeah, I think he's the perfect person to bring into the conversation here because first of all, he's also the pirate who believes in rules, Like he has his own kind of code, even though part of the code is screw people over at every opportunity, and like, to me, the sign of how much afection he has for Ezra
Speaker 7and how much he does feel like a mentor to Ezra, which is really kind of funny given how much there's like a Darth Maul and Canaan fighting over who's the mentor to Ezra. Like in some ways, like hand it really is. And it's when like Ezra screws him over and Hondo's like.
Speaker 5Oh my god, you screwed me over.
Speaker 7I'm so proud of you, like because it's that kind of like, yeah, we're gonna screw each other over and that's great. And I just, to me, that's such a good sign of a character who has a very different mortal slant but still has one that makes sense. And yeah, I can easily see John going that kind of route. I also agree with you that I really didn't want yet another Order sixty six flashback, and I kind of felt like both just the limits of his powers and the backstory, Yeah, I don't think this is a guy
Speaker 7who ever.
Speaker 5Saw the inside of the Jedi Temple.
Speaker 7To me, this is like if you think about it, in rebels like every now and then, or like even in obi Wan, like they across young people who are for sensitive and are trying to figure that out. And and to me, the way I understand the story is like some Order sixties six refugee who is being chased down by the inquisitors, like found Jod, measured him for a couple of months, maybe half a year or something, and then eventually was killed and then Jod somehow got away.
Speaker 1Yeah, I agree, that was how I understood it. They actually did film his Jedi Master or or we assume is his Jedi Master, but they didn't use any of the scenes. Wow, So they have that in their back pocket for if they do another another season.
Speaker 5So I want to know it was it was.
Speaker 1A woman, It wasn't anyone we know, Okay.
Speaker 7Yeah, And I think that's also important from making the story feel like if it was like shock Ta or like someone you know, Pokluon or you know Plocun, I mean, you know, I think it would have again it made the world feel smaller something that it wasn't her, wasn't any of those people. So one of the questions, since it's come up a lot, unfortunately, just with the context that we're in, it's very A lot of the conversation about this was comparing it to Acolyte, and a lot of that I'm not really gonna get into and there's
Speaker 7like a lot of like bad faith arguments and a lot of that from all the haters around Acolyte. And again, you know, I think I and Riki and others, and I think you didn't yell efy knowledge like a lot of things that weren't the best about Acolyte. But for me at least, it's still a show I really love. And then I like with all these projects, I think there's a big difference between oh, I thought this story pacing wasn't the best versus oh my god, it's so woke, I hate it, and.
Speaker 5Which sometimes becomes oh my god, it's so woke, I hate it.
Speaker 7There fall claiming the dialogue was terrible even though I've never actually watched it.
Speaker 5But putting that aside, why was it you think.
Speaker 7That this was so successful and didn't bring up a lot of that hate the way Acolyte did because it.
Speaker 1Didn't challenge anything, to be honest, I mean, I love this show, Don't get me wrong. I love it. I think it was really good for Star Wars. I think that they need to use it as a lesson for what they should maybe focus on in years to come. But like I say that from a storytelling point of view, like the type of story that they're telling, the type the type of of of of you know, topics and lessons they have in in the show itself. But it
Speaker 1didn't challenge really anything. It didn't the the main character wasn't an outspoken black woman. Uh. The show wasn't run by a lesbian uh whose wife was was playing a character in the show. And I think that also it comes down to the Accolyte had stuff in universe that challenge people's conceptions of Star Wars too.
Speaker 5Yeah.
Speaker 1Uh. And I think anytime you have that, especially when it when there are a black women involved and queer women involved, you're going to have pushed back from a certain demographic of Star Wars fans. Automatically. It doesn't matter what they say, it doesn't matter if they say nothing, it doesn't matter anything. They will hone in on that because there are certain people making content whose names won't
Speaker 1leave my mouth because I refuse to talk about them, who make money off of that, who make money off of knowing that there are people in the fandom who are racists, who are sexists, who are homophobic, and will click on their material if they think that it's going to be someone kind of reaffirming their beliefs, and that just snowballs into more and into what we saw with Accolte getting absolutely horrendous reviews on Rotten Tomatoes before it
Speaker 1even came out and before people saw the episode. So it's just I think that that was a big thing. Skeleton Crew didn't have that automatic setback for it, which unfortunately was was setback for the Accolyte. Not saying I view it as a setback myself, but it didn't. It didn't challenge anything. Really.
Speaker 5Yeah, I think that's true, and it kind of goes to.
Speaker 7I feel the word that I kept coming to mind was safe, and then I don't think it's bad to have some of your media be safe. And in some ways, as much as I think the Acolyte is really important for Star Wars and I'm glad it happened, and same with Last Jedi and same with the prequels, I think sometimes you need like a reset, and Riki you talked about this kind of saving Star Wars. In many way, I feel like it played a very similar role to the Force Awakens, and the controversies with the prequels were very different. But I do think there were a large
Speaker 7number of fans who had walked away from fans of my generation who had walked away away from Star Wars because we didn't really like the prequels and we felt that they didn't live up to what we wanted, and there was a lot of tension between fans of that generation and the fans of people who did grow up with the prequels and loved them. And I felt like The Force Awakens was something that was kind of groundbreaking in some really important ways, like with Ray and with Finn, and you know, having a woman Jedi and a strong black character and a lot of other things, but was
Speaker 7also like plot wise, like basically a retelling of a new hope, like down in some ways, like Shot for Shot remake, and it really kind of was a palate cleanser for a lot of ways. And I kind of hope that this show is I'm both hopeful and fearful because I'm hopeful that the lesson from this is that if you have content like this that everyone can get on board with, you can then also have content that is pushing the boundaries some and you can have that balance of safe and challenging. My fear is that Disney is then going to say, Okay, so everything's gonna be
Speaker 7Skeleton Crew going forward, and we're never going to push the bounds, which means we're never going to tell stories other than those focused on like white men and aliens, which this wasn't oddly enough, and it did get some pushback around the DEI casting, so to speak, as ridiculous as that is, but it felt like that was very muted because the story itself was very safe.
Speaker 1Yeah. Yeah, I think I was thinking about what there was someone who got screeners and they posted before episode two came out or episode three that there was a lesbian couple that and they were and they were like, why are they pushing their woke agenda again? And I was like, they're on screen for a total of like five minutes maybe throughout the entire season, but even that like got people like, oh, why are they doing this?
Speaker 1Why are they doing this? And then all of a sudden, it feels like it's fifteen years ago again and where you can't have even one you know, you have one gay kiss on TV and it's the end of the world. And I was like, have we really regressed that far back? Like come on, guys, but but even that, if that had been imagine if they had been bigger characters, if they had been like the main focus of the show, and or we knew about them from the beginning, from the trailers, from whatever, then I think we maybe would have started to see a little bit of similar tone
Speaker 1as we saw with Yaclat, probably not as big, but more than we did. And because it was in the third episode, and you know, we didn't know beforehand, and there was no time for for the for the the bad side of the fandom to to gather and and and make their their little pathetic posts. Unrun to me.
Speaker 4But yeah, I mean there was so much there that I agree with both of you on I just like on the on the subject of the families Fern single mother yep, whim, single father KB.
Speaker 5And women with women father are are black mm hmm.
Speaker 4KB two mothers. Neil. I believe Neil is the only kid who has a traditional family of father A traditional I say, but you know what I.
Speaker 5Mean, a father elephant and a mother exactly.
Speaker 4And the father elephant was like the most believable, like disciplined father.
Speaker 1He's kind of scary. Yeah, Neil have tusks.
Speaker 5One day Neil's whole family.
Speaker 7It was funny because they were the most like suburban, like because a lot of times you had the annoying little sibling is such a stock character of those you know movies, and the annoying little sibling gets to do something to help and that's all the way through to you know, from like you know, the eighties stuff to Dawn and Buffy, and so it being Neil's family that has the annoying little elephant child who you know gets the way but then is helpful at the end.
Speaker 1I thought it was funny that, Yeah, like you said, like he has the most suburban family of everyone in the most kind of like nuclear family, I guess is what nuclear is that?
Speaker 4Right?
Speaker 1But and he's the alien of the group, like he's the non human of the group. But he's the one who has the family that we're like maybe used to seeing or that's more stereotypical to show in in these like family shows or kids shows. And I feel like that says like that was I feel like that was a choice to have, you know, the human kids come from from families that look more similar nowadays, I think than maybe before two moms, as you said, single parents,
Speaker 1and and that gives more kids a chance to relate to that and to kind of see themselves in that.
Speaker 7I mean, we talked a lot about this after I think it's episode six or episode five or six, one of those two. But the KB character is one of the best representations of disability and just the way it can be hard for disabled people to talk to their friends about what they need and hard for the friends to figure out. And like, Yeah, that wasn't a like push the boundaries of something super controversial, but it was an issue that almost never gets talked about and got really beautifully represented.
Speaker 1Yeah, I loved that so much.
Speaker 4The important thing to me here is a like any like it's such bad faith to be like, oh, like it's a lesbian couple as parents, I think that it doesn't make sense like they exist in the world. And so the important thing here for the context of this show is that each of these four kids has a family and has parents who care about them and love them and come together to do everything they can to help their kids and save their kids in the same way that all of the media that this is kind
Speaker 4of like riffing off of from the eighties, Like the same thing happens in all those movies, but in those movies, it's almost always just.
Speaker 5The most and father.
Speaker 4And this is just acknowledging that different family structures exist, but they still all love their kids the same way.
Speaker 7Right, yeah, yeah, And that the parents themselves coming together from the different backgrounds and stuff like that, you know, and it being like a single mother a single father, and also that the single mother and single father don't therefore flirt with each other, like yeah again sometimes yeah.
Speaker 1I mean that they were willing to change the way they thought for their kids too. Like Fern's mom is so kind of like, you know, she's very strict, she's very by the book, and Fern asks her at the end, she's like, please trust me, and she does. She trusts her daughter and and I think that's something so important to show, not only kids, but parents as well, Like when it comes down to it, who are you going to trust this entity that has been telling you what
Speaker 1to do for your entire life or your child? And I think that's an important lesson for everyone. But also Whim's father, who's again you know, very kind of buy the book very you know, he and Wim don't have the best relationship at the start of the show, but then he changes everything and he opens himself up more to his son and realizes I think that he can't expect whim to to you know, kind of obey him or follow him if he's not willing to be honest with him as well. And and I think that that
Speaker 1was just that was a beautiful, a beautiful moment for everybody involved.
Speaker 4The parents didn't get a lot of screen time over the course of the series, but the parts they did get were really important for the relationships with their kids, and it was really well done. And and I think that is something that some of the past media hasn't been the best at, like where the parents will you know, be caricatures or just not get enough time, like they'll be the for the kids at the end, like for the big finale. But the development of the relationships and
Speaker 4having them fight John together, I think was such a good choice for these characters.
Speaker 5Yeah, no, I think that's so true.
Speaker 7And I there's a black creator who I saw on TikTok who talked about how important it was to him that both women and his dad were big old nerds, because that a lot of times in this like the Black Kid is on the group because he's the most athletic, you know, and if there's a single dad, the dad's pushing him to be more athletic and to be more like manly and stuff like that, all these racial stereotypes and then for him to be such a nerd and to have that breakthrough moment of like, yeah, I like living and.
Speaker 5You know, cutting loose a little bit and related that.
Speaker 7Danielle, I want to ask you specifically because one thing we talked about some but I'm curious your perspective on because I don't think, actually this is something I think about, but.
Speaker 5I think we everybody brought it up.
Speaker 7One of those stereotypes that often played in those eighties movies, because the eighties was I think the high point of music. That's something ever can agree on, but was not the best necessarily in terms of gender relations. That a lot of times you'd have a young male protagonist and the girl he was interested in was flirting with, or at least was kind of along for the ride, was very bossy. And I say that word very intentionally because it's a very kind of known word that's used in very sexist ways. And the first two episodes I was kind of nervous.
Speaker 7They were doing that with Fern, and it felt to me like that they really kind of subverted that stereotype of having it be that like for you know, she did have some breakthrough moments where she listened more, but first of all, it was primarily with her female friend that she had that big breakthrough. But also that women acknowledged like, no, I don't want to be the leader. I know I struggle with you telling me what to do, but you're smarter and you're better at this stuff.
Speaker 5I want you to do it.
Speaker 7How did you feel about that Fern's character in terms of that stereotype of the bossy, bossy young girl.
Speaker 1Oh, I loved And I think I think it worked here because they spent a lot of time developing her character on her own, so not just how she is around whim and the other kids, but how she like we see her, you know, how she how she is with her mother, and how she feels like she can't really you know, be her true self around her mom, and and that her bossiness maybe comes from a deep rooted need to have control of her life and and
Speaker 1to not have to do what's expected of her, and and and you know, just want to just want to do what she wants to do, and and she's not just I think it was important to show that she wasn't just that way with the boys. She was that way with KB too, and and KB, but k Ban has known her and and loves her, and they have that conversation eventually about how you know, and Kb's not not really refuting her bossiness. She's refuting you know that I need you to listen to me and I don't know how to talk to you. But it's not because you're bossy. It's because we've just never had to have
Speaker 1these you know, this communication before. I think it was really important that, Yeah, like no one was really mad at at Fern for her her bossiness, Like that's just she takes charge, and when people are around her long enough, they realize that she takes charge for a reason. And then we get to see her in the same episode where thirty three thirty three's programming takes back over have a vulnerable moment and like you said, when Wim says, you know, no, I don't want this job. You were better at it, But she's doubting herself, And I think
Speaker 1that was really important to show that she's scared. She doesn't have all the answers and she knows that, but she feels like, you know, she has to take charge. But she's just she's just a kid still. And I felt they handled all of that really really well by focusing on her, giving enough space to her on her own instead of just showing her around all the kids.
Speaker 5Yeah.
Speaker 7Like, I realized that I was, on some level expecting Whim to be home the primary protagonist of the kids and the other kind of sidekicks, and that never happened.
Speaker 1Yeah. I was surprised too because I thought that as well. And I was really surprised when he wasn't getting as much attention as I thought he was going to. And that's not to say that he was sidelined. I don't think he was at all. I just think he just took an interesting route that many people weren't expecting, and I think it sets it up for a really good story for him later if they decide to go back to it.
Speaker 4Okay, y'all are ignoring my boy Neil character on this show.
Speaker 1I love Neil. He's my favorite.
Speaker 3Oh to me, Neil's I mean, you can call it naivety, but just goodness was so refreshing, Like all of his interactions were like they come across a bad situation and he's just like, why can't you just apologize?
Speaker 5He was like, oh, what, it's not quite the same.
Speaker 7But I think Neil is the Sam Wise Gamgee of the Star Wars universe, Like he's the closest we've got yea.
Speaker 1Yeah, there was something about him that is just incredibly refreshing, like you said. But also I think that that episode where he was like, why can't you all just apologize? I think this is really important for him and and for I think it's Hannah was her name, in that you know their their kids, and they don't understand how the other grew up. Hannah doesn't understand what it's like to grow up in a in a world where where you don't have to fight. Neil doesn't understand what it's
Speaker 1like to grow up in a world where you do have to fight. But ultimately they take the lessons they learned from each other and use it. We assume Hannah is going to use it in her world and Neil Neil uses it in his When he gets that gun at the top of the of the building, he remembers Hannah using it, and and he's not a very violent person. He's not one to go to action immediately, but he does that because he knows that his friends need it, he knows that his home needs it. And it was
Speaker 1just a really beautiful, like full circle moment there. I think of them showing that Neil has maybe learned that that just because he didn't grow up that way doesn't mean that he can't learn something from from that. And they're different, there are different ways and different perspectives, and he was the character I think that needed that the moment, or was most I think most built for that type of lesson.
Speaker 7Yeah, yeah, I think it's really true, And yeah, it's kind of an interesting His interactions with Hannah are such an interesting dichotomy to Jod and what we're talking about, because I think Hannah has just as much like and her people have just as much like resentment towards these very entitled kids and like, you know, who have such a better life than she does and and.
Speaker 5Don't take account of it.
Speaker 7But it plays out so differently and that they do get to see each other and and rieky, as you said, like it's not over the top but like like Niel's got game, like he he clearly they kind of like you know, exchange phone numbers at the end and maybe they're gonna grow up and see what happens. And I just I love that about him because it's I think again, it's that he often would be this the the sideline, he'd be the sidekick, and he'd be there for the comic relief and to help our hero have a moment
Speaker 7of realizing that they're you know, they need to be more innocent about things. But for to just be like no, he he's just as much of a fully realized character as as the other three.
Speaker 5Was just great to me.
Speaker 4Yeah, and he saves all, Yeah, he saves them. They all they all got their moments in that finale to do something. And that's that is a great balance to bring to these characters and a great way to because I think we do think of like Fern and Whim as like the main duo, but I think KB and Neil also brought it and did very important things and
Speaker 4developed like a skill because you know, like you get kind of tropy with these and like someone has to be the mechanic, right, it's KB and all that kind of stuff, but I think it's fine, Like they did it in a very realistic way.
Speaker 5Yeah.
Speaker 7Yeah, they're kind of introduced as women, and Fern are the main characters, and then each of them has a sidekick, and like I do think like in friendship, especially of that age, often you have one who's the more like social and outgoing and the other one who kind of follows them around, but they're just as fully realized people in the show.
Speaker 1Yeah yeah, I thought that was really a testament to the writing because there were what eight episodes, and I didn't feel like I need it anymore, like I want more, but they gave I feel like each kid had not only their own moment in the finale, but their own episode where they were were really able to kind of, you know, dig deeper into who they are as characters, really understand them a bit better. And even even though they had I have episodes that I view as their own, within those episodes, all the other kids still had a
Speaker 1lot to do too, And so it's just really really amazing to me that they were able to pack all of that into eight episodes without it feeling so overwhelming and without really leaving much to be desired and I mean that in a good way, Like they gave me the story that I wanted on here, and I want more from it. They left me wanting, but I'm satisfied with these care not only the story, but with these characters. And I feel like even in the Accolyte, whenever the
Speaker 1season ended and I was happy with the story being wrapped up, I was happy, you know, of the story that it told there were still characters that I was wanting more from, and that I felt our story beats that I felt didn't get the time it deserved. But it with Skeleton Crew, I think that they they kind of they figured it out somehow, they got the balance right.
Speaker 5Well.
Speaker 7That actually a perfect way to lead into the final question, what have We've got a little long so I don't want to go too much longer. We will have bonus content, of course for our members, but he is, what do you want to see next from these character? Do you want a season two? Do you want these characters to show up in other people's stories? Do you want there not to be much about this? What's your feelings?
Speaker 4I mean that doesn't have to be I think that's like the most satisfying thing is I think this is a good rap to this story, and there's there. I don't believe there was any like teaser to like, oh like this this thing is still unresolved. So I'm very happy with this season, but I want more because I love these characters and I want to see what they do next, like all of them, really like the four Kids job, Like, I want to see what happens to
Speaker 4them and what they do. And I think that is that is the best kind of season. Like it's similar to and Or, like and Or wrapped there there's obviously a teaser because we know where and Or ends up, so there's like there's more to fill, right, but like it's just a perfectly fine season and that's great.
Speaker 1Yeah, I feel the same way. I think they did a really clever thing, which again all writers should do with the shows like this is they they left enough intrigue for if they they created a foundation for a continuation of the show. But it's not a foundation that that leaves you kind of like just kind of out in the cold. I guess as far as storylines go, it is like if you if they want to explore more, Okay,
Speaker 1at Atton is now open to the galaxy.
Speaker 4Yeah, do you reintegrate that society is a huge question, you know that you have to answer in season two.
Speaker 1Yeah, Jodd had a little mischievous splint to his eye at the end. What's he got going on? I feel like he didn't seem as downtrodden as I expected him to be. So what's he thinking? He's got something like the why the the wheels are turning in his head? And I would be interested to know what he's thinking, how he's going to get himself out of this where he's going next? When looking up at the X wings in the sky and with like a wab, Yeah, he wants to be a pilot. Suddenly his options are out there,
Speaker 1Like Neil says, you don't have to take care assessment anymore. And and you know what's going to happen with the kids now that they know what's out there? How again, just how is that going to fit with that Aten's place in the galaxy? Has the New Republic going to react to that? And so I think going forward they would have to integrate themselves more into the wider galaxy of Star Wars, leading kind of into the Skywalker area of it. But and that's okay for me because we got this season where it was separate from that, and yeah,
Speaker 1so again, I would be happy with another season or another show that had them or them showing up later on in the sequel trilogy era. I think that would be a lot of fun. But I'm also okay if we don't see them for a while. I'm okay with this story as it is.
Speaker 7Yeah, I think I'm with you, guys, And I think kind of of the many different ways I think that they could their stories can continue to live on. I think a Skeleton Crew season two or season three is the last thing I want. And part of that is what I think of as the Stranger Things effect, which is that it is very difficult to get a number of acts, to get a number of great child actors, and also to get them to all look the same age, because our perception of them all looking the same age is actually different because the reality is like kids go through puberty at very different times. Yeah, and so sometimes
Speaker 7when you have four actors all playing like twelve year olds fifteen year olds, maybe one or two of them are that age and one is younger and one is significantly older. But like if you watch Stranger Things in the first one or two seasons, it is absolutely believable that all those kids are the same age five years later. Now in the most recent season, some of those actors puberties hit them with a truck, and some of them it hasn't, and it just it is not believable anymore that they're the same age in the same way, in part because a couple of them were already quite older.
Speaker 5And so I think, like, I don't.
Speaker 7Want to see more of that, But I think what you picked up on is to me, the biggest hanging thread is at.
Speaker 5Atton, and.
Speaker 7I would love to see it live on, But I think there is an alternative to it being a part of the Skywalker saga necessarily and the movies, which is I wonder if it's going to continue on in the kind of Mandalorian verse. And I do have a theory actually, which is that because I know these things are scripted long in advance, and originally Mandalorian and Grogu was supposed to be season four of Mandalorian, and it was supposed to come out this year, not next year. So I wonder if the introduction of at Eton was going to
Speaker 7then be a plot point for the next season of the Mandalorian that all of a sudden, all these pirates and bounty hunters are all very interested in this, and maybe their new republic is like, hey, can you help us track these people down or help figure out this and that kind of stuff. I don't know if it's now going to appear in a movie a year later, but I do think it would be interesting if to explore that way, or even like, how did this become the Treasury Planet?
Speaker 5How did it become creative? Ay as Barrier? Did that happen in.
Speaker 7The High Republic for instance? Did it happen at some later point? Like I don't actually need a whole story about it, but I would love for it to be mentioned in both some of the past stuff like how did it happen?
Speaker 5And some of the future stuff.
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, I agree.
Speaker 4Give us a continuation of Vain's story.
Speaker 1That's the spin off.
Speaker 4I need this hard luck pirate. He's okay. So to clarify, Vain is the pirate who is a part of a pirate crew in Mandalorian season three and their ship gets destroyed and he escapes, and then he joins up with John's crew and now their ship's been destroyed. He's maybe under arrest or stuck on this planet. Now, like I just it's a fun easter egg to like connect him across two shows. But now it's like he's kind of become the Wedge. I don't want to know his story.
Speaker 7Actually he's the Turk if you think about like Daredevil in the Netflix MCU, that one like Eddy Arms dealer in criminal who keeps like getting busted by every superhero in Netflix EMPTU.
Speaker 5Yeah, but yeah, that's.
Speaker 1Sun Comic in a few years.
Speaker 7Or even like I could Jude Law is a big enough and well known actor who I know he himself loves Star Wars and wants to be in this. I could see him being like one of the people that Ray kind of rounds up if she's rebuilding the Jedi or something like that.
Speaker 1So we'll see, there's always potential.
Speaker 7Yeah, all right, well, thank you to all of you. Thank you for our listener so much. This episode is recorded at a weird time, but just letting you know that we are for the most part, I'm gonna try to announce this on our social media every week what the topic's gonna be. But we're going forward gonna be pretty much always recording Star Wars Generations episodes on Wednesdays at five thirty Central Time. We will make changes, especially for like Danielle, because I think that means that we've been recording it about one am her time or midnight something like that. But generally it'll be set Wednesdays at five thirty.
Speaker 7And of course you can listen to the episode when it comes out, but you'll also join us for the live stream.
Speaker 5It's on YouTube. All the informations in the show notes.
Speaker 7Next week, we're gonna be talking about we've kind of kicked off with Star Wars animation and so we're gonna be talking about the first Star Wars animation. Well, the first is technically the Holiday special, but that goes in the same category as Ewoks movies. But we're gonna be talking about the original Clone Wars animated show, not the Clone Wars TV show that everyone knows and has good feelings about. So check that out next Wednesday five thirty. Actually this is probably gonna come out if recorded that, so don't listen, never mind what topic it is, but
Speaker 7just know every Wednesday at five thirty.
Speaker 5Check our social media.
Speaker 7Just search for the Ethical Panda on TikTok, Twitter, all these places and you'll find it Facebook and you can find the information. Of course, you can also become a member five dollars a month fifty five dollars a year.
Speaker 5You get access to.
Speaker 7Bonus episodes, free episodes, bonus content at the end of every episode which we're about to record, and you need to help help us keep the lights on. So half of myself, Ricky and Danielle, thank you all so much for we have part of it, livelong and prosper.
Star Wars Generations is going on hiatus for a few months. We’ll be back in December to get you ramped up for Ahsoka Season 2! **************************************************************************This episode is a...
Would you give up your name to save your life, if a tyrant demanded it first? Matthew Fox and Erin McGowan open Star Wars Generations’ new episode-by-episode watch-through of Star Wars: Visions Presents - The Ninth Jedi...
Can lightsabers work like mood rings for your soul? Matthew Fox and Erin McGowan get listeners ready for "Star Wars: Visions Presents - The Ninth Jedi," the new eight episode series expanding two existing Visions shorts...
What happens when the people who raised you decide you’re guilty before you get a chance to prove otherwise? Matthew and Erin spend this episode of Star Wars Generations on one of “The Clone Wars”’ most consequential...
Before he became the paranoid revolutionary from Rogue One, Saw Gerrera was a scrappy fighter who thought sheer force could win a war. Matthew, Alex, and Erin head back to "The Clone Wars" Season 5 for the Onderon arc,...