With Star Wars: Andor Season 2 just weeks away, we're revisiting our coverage of Season 1!In this episode, we dive into Season 1 Episode 12, Rix Road, the epic season finale. As our hosts gear up for the next chapter, they reflect on the powerful storytelling, emotional stakes, and unforgettable moments that defined Andor’s first season. Don't miss this deep dive into Cassian Andor’s journey and the rebellion’s fight against the Empire.Get ready for Season 2 by reliving the finale with us! **************************************************************************This episode is a production of Star Wars Generations, a The Ethical Panda Podcast and part of the TruStory FM Entertainment Podcast Network. Check our our website to find out more about this and our sister podcast Superhero Ethics.We want to hear from you! You can keep up with our latest news, and send us feedback, questions, or comments via social media or email. Email: Matthew@TheEthicalPanda.com Facebook: TheEthicalPanda Instagram: TheEthicalPandaPodcasts Twitter: EthicalPanda77 Or you can join jump into the Star Wars Generations and Superhero Ethics channels on the TruStory FM Discord. To learn more about co-host Erin and her incredible cosplay check out her Instagram, LadyTanoCreates. Want to get access to even more content while supporting the podcast? Become a member! For $5 a month, or $55 a year you get access to bonus episodes and bonus content at the end of most episodes. Sign up on the podcast’s main page you can even give membership as a gift! You can also support our podcasts through our sponsors: Purchase a lightsaber from Level Up Sabers run by friend of the podcast Neighborhood Master Alan Use Audible for audiobooks. Sign up for a one year membership or gift one through this link. Purchase any media discussed this week through our sponsored links.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Before we dive in, here's another show you can enjoy in the True Story FM family of entertainment podcasts. In a world where podcasts are a dime a dozen, one show dares to stand out from the rest. The Film Board, a podcast unafraid to tell it like it is.
Speaker 2We're here for one reason, and one reason only downloads.
Speaker 1That's right. We review new release movies because that's what gets people's attention.
Speaker 3But just because we're in it for the clicks doesn't mean we don't take our job seriously.
Speaker 2We're part of the next real family of film podcasts, and we're proud of it.
Speaker 1Our reviews are just as insightful and thought provoking as any of our other film podcasts.
Speaker 4It's just that this podcast is all about that sweet, sweet seo.
Speaker 2The nectar squows from the tree of being.
Speaker 1We're only human, but we're also creators, and creators eat clicks to survive.
Speaker 2So if you want honest, unfiltered opinions on the very latest movies right on opening weekend.
Speaker 1Delivered with the self awareness of a team looking for downloads, then tune in to the Film Board.
Speaker 2Where every download counts, but yours counts the most.
Speaker 5Do you like movies.
Speaker 4Do you like sports?
Speaker 5And we never thought I never played that sport on the screen, but I really enjoyed how the movie made me feel.
Speaker 4Well, then have we got a show for you.
Speaker 6The Adrian Moment is where.
Speaker 3My friend Ocean and I discussed the triangulation of sports, movies and life.
Speaker 5We dive deep into the movies, discussing how they relate to and have affected our lives.
Speaker 1We will talk about why the sport matters to the movie, why you don't have to love the sport to enjoy the movie, and mine a few nuggets of meaning inside.
Speaker 4The story you may not have realized was really there.
Speaker 5After listening to our show, come join us for more conversations about the movie that portray the thrill.
Speaker 4Of victory and the agony of defeat.
Speaker 5Find The Adrian Moment podcast on your favid podcast hap and join us while we cover the sports you love and the ones you never think about.
Speaker 1You will never see sports or sport movies the same again.
Speaker 3Hello, and welcome to this rebroadcast episode of Star Wars Generations podcast with the and Or show just a couple of weeks away, along with a lot of things going on from me erin and Alex at the moment, we wanted to pull back the and Or season one coverage that we did just to help remind you about everything that's going on in the show, what our thoughts were, what we think is going to be happening next, and help get you ready for season two of and Or. So please enjoy this episode and we will be doing live coverage every week of and Or as it comes out. Thank you so much for listening. Hello, and welcome to
Speaker 3this episode of Star Wars Universe Podcast. My friends, we have come to the end of the first half of our journey. And Or Season one is complete. We have watched episode twelve and we will only have two years to wait till it all has come to a resolution.
Speaker 4But don't worry. We have a lot to talk.
Speaker 3About and it's gonna be myself, Matthew Paul Happy, and returning guest Professor Matthew Copel.
Speaker 4We have all gathered together.
Speaker 3To ask the blessing of and Or and to enjoy chapter twelve of this first season of two. And we'll be right back with commercial break that we have no control over. That I hope doesn't ask you to buy a turkey because you'll probably be listening to this after Thanksgiving. Welcome back. My name is Matthew. I'm your host. I'm joined, as almost always these days, by mister Paul Hoppy, the
Speaker 3not a host regular guest and has been our tradition the last couple of weeks on and or Professor Matthew Coppell. So I'll say to both of you, happy early Thanksgiving, and how'd you like this episode?
Speaker 7The last couple of moments with that little tiny smile by Luthan made me reevaluate everything I've said on your podcast the last couple of times. I think it is indeed quite mythical now that I've thought it through.
Speaker 6So I was just wrong. So everything I've.
Speaker 7Said up till now, I think I was wrong. So I thought it was quite wonderful. I enjoyed it a great deal.
Speaker 4Nice.
Speaker 6I definitely want to hear more about the mythicality of it. And yeah, that that moment I thought was I was like, huh, that's that's a character arc and a smile like.
Speaker 3Yeah, it was very fitting.
Speaker 6Yeah, I loved the last episode. I thought it was fantastic. It wasn't exactly what I was expecting, but I was trying not to have too much of a clear expectation of anything. So I think it paid off what the series had set up in a way that was congruous with the series itself. To me, it didn't do something that I was like, this doesn't feel like this series. To me, it still felt like this series, but also like,
Speaker 6you know, big and bold and different from the earlier episodes, but also fitting with the earlier episodes.
Speaker 3Yeah, I think it all makes a lot of sense. I think I had largely as similar reaction. There were two things that I didn't love about this. One was a storyline that I kept waiting for them to bring up. The other was just one particular moment that felt all wrong. But otherwise I really loved it, and I'm glad you brought that smile, especially because I've seen some people on social media saying, so, so, what do you think is Lutheran gonna try and.
Speaker 4Kill and or what is that? I was like that, I think that smile is.
Speaker 3Your answer, very very clearly. But but I need to start with this question because what we saw now. I'm not going to defend the Empire in any way, shape or form here. I'm just comparison things. What we saw was, you know, an attack on the stormtroopers breakout, and the what happens is they start like you know, charging them and throwing things at them, and the stormtroopers put up their shields and and sort of, you know, let the people crash up against them. We don't see them really
Speaker 3fighting back, and the trooper in charge just keeps yelling hold the line, hold the line, which I'm sure is hurting people, but it is not being overly aggressive. And it's not until an actual legitimate bomb goes off that they start shooting people. And when they start shooting people, it's real bad because they're shooting anybody in everyone. I'm not defending that for a second, but just up until that point, I feel like, if there's a protest, I would rather have stormtroopers and the most American cops. Am I wrong on that, because I think they handle it better than most cops do protests these days.
Speaker 6I think there's a bit of nuance that well. So first of all, I don't disagree in terms of like, yeah, don't start shooting people, you know, like and they do eventually after a bomb is thrown, which again I'm not defending shooting people, but if there's like a point at which you're like, Okay, maybe this is now when we start shooting people after a bomb goes off. Seems like maybe one of the lines where we could discuss. Right. However, I will say I do not think this is because
Speaker 6this is the storm Trooper way. I think it's because Dedro repeatedly said I want him taken alive. I want him taken alive. Don't make me say it again. I want him taken alive. Right, So I think that's why they were behaving that way, as opposed to just they're like, oh, yeah, it's you know, it's a funeral. We're just gonna try to hold the line. I think it's because they're trying not to kill someone that they're commanding officer is like, maybe gonna have them killed if they kill off, you
Speaker 6know what I mean? Right.
Speaker 3I don't think anyone thought and Or was in that crowd, But I can really understand the idea of if this turns into a full on fight between both groups, the chance of and Or not getting killed in the crossfire goes down significantly.
Speaker 6Well, that goes up significantly. They also don't know that he's not in the crowd. I mean, it's it's a crap, right, I mean, they can't verify, so if you're going to shoot into a crowd, you might kill any given person who may or may not be in that crowd, right exactly.
Speaker 3I just thought that was funny watching them have a good deal of restraint in that particular situation.
Speaker 6Yeah, for sure, for sure not what you saw in the news in you know, twenty twenty exactly exactly.
Speaker 3All right, well, let's actually kind of jump into the episode. We have a number of different plot lines that all kind of come together. They don't necessarily all get resolved by any means, which I like, but certainly, like you know, it's all hands on deck.
Speaker 4Everyone's coming to Phinix Ferreck situation. Where do you all want to start?
Speaker 7I will jump in and say, I think we should start with the fact that we get to hear some of the manifesto. Yes, And I'm going to start there because I'm on the East coast, so I've gotten to listen to NPR's All Things Considered Today, that's National Public Radio, right, and they interviewed Gilroy who said, and I quote, I have a library downstairs right now on the Russian Revolution, so I.
Speaker 4Could go get you stuff if you'd like.
Speaker 6And it was a great quote.
Speaker 7I thought of you, Matthew very fondly when he said it. And I think listening to those little snippets of the manifesto are probably much more important than you'd think they would be.
Speaker 3I don't think of the Disney Corporation as often leaving money on the table, and maybe they want to keep some parts of it held back because they're going to be continually revealed in dribs and drabs. But if they put somewhere on an audio store a recording of that actor reading the whole manifesto for nine ninety nine, I'm buying it.
Speaker 4I think a lot of other people probably are too. Like it was, Yeah, it was really powerful.
Speaker 3The lines were great, the delivery by the actor, and just kind of like they didn't have to make it a big deal, didn't have to see and or like having a big reaction to it. But just knowing that he was listening to it was clearly a part of his thinking. I thought it was a really powerful moment.
Speaker 6Yeah, absolutely, and that he was listening to it then, But also I think it had been clear that he had perhaps been listening to it as well when he was like on Niamos as well, you know that this is something that he's kind of been absorbing a little bit of as at a time. And you know, one of the things that I really enjoyed about the interaction between Nemic and Cassian was when Nemic makes some statement and then Cassian's like, well, you got half of that right,
Speaker 6and Nemic's like, which half did I get wrong? You know, not like challenging him, like I want to know, you know.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 6So I think to me it seemed clear that he was someone who actually was listening to, you know, various perspectives and trying to kind of synthesize them, you know, as he went along.
Speaker 3Actually, because and I think this was very intentional. We hear two speeches in this episode. Well one's not a speech, it's him reading aloud of manifesto. But then we also hear Marva's funeral speech, which I kind of love the idea of everyone getting to give their own funeral oration.
Speaker 6Yeah, yes, says Superior.
Speaker 3Let alone having your ashes be literally made into a weapon to fight fascism.
Speaker 4Like watching him use the.
Speaker 3Brick that she's in hit Stormtroopers was so good. But like I definitely had this moment of like think like that I wanted this, but also thinking that and Or might have a thought of like I wish Nemek and Marv could have met, you know, because they're using different kinds of language, but they're expressing very similar ideas. And I have some issues with Marva that we'll talk about later in the episode. But I just thought her speech was so stirring, especially because of how you know, it didn't start out as let's go fight the emperor. Let's
Speaker 3let's go fight the empire. It felt very clearly written by someone and spoken by someone who wanted to build the crowd and build them up more and more, but in a way where she probably knew some imperial people would be listening and if she, like you know, hit the high point too early, they would shut her down.
Speaker 4And so she waited.
Speaker 3It was just and watching the stormtroopers and the imperial officers all looking at each other being like.
Speaker 4It is this wait?
Speaker 3What does she say, Oh, this is getting a problem, like seeing it slow build until that moment she just shouts out like fight the empire, and that's what kind of triggers things over.
Speaker 4Well, and then it's the attack on the droid.
Speaker 6Yeah, they actually tip over b before she says that, I think, and then she said or they try to put the cloak over her, like to cut her off, right, and then she says that, and then they flip over Bee and then they're like, what you flipped over b Oh no, yeah, you hurt the drawing.
Speaker 3It's like the whole community went john Wick, you know, right. So yeah, I just thought that was really interesting. And yeah, I don't really thought about the synthesis there until you brought it up. But now I'm thinking, like, I like the idea that for and Or, it's those two voices in his head that are you know, because he I don't think he hears the speech. He might have depending on what the amplification was, but certainly I think the idea is that, like she has said things like that to him before.
Speaker 6I think he definitely heard the speech because he said to Bis she was great, wasn't she?
Speaker 7Oh?
Speaker 6Yeah, you know, And I think Bix heard the speech. And I think the idea is that kind of like everybody hears it, you know, And I think that was kind of the point of this episode of like having everybody show up on farys, and a lot of things not happen that you might expect were going to happen, like certain people confronting one another. Right, there's a lot of that not happening. And I think the idea was that this is an event that's you know, whether it's a turning point in sort of the idea of rebellion
Speaker 6throughout the galaxy or whatever. All these people are witnessing that event, you know, from her speech to you know, the revolt basically right, And and so it feels kind of like this was I don't know, like a little bit of a sort of like Boston massacre type thing where it's like, you know, there was a there's an uprising, and it's not a we're going to actually overthrow the imperial presence here uprising. It's just, you know, it's a skirmish that a lot of people die. And and so
Speaker 6I think her being there, and you know, I mean Cassian hearing it, I think is important, right. But also I think as important or more important, is what she said to Braso to tell Cassian, you know. And then I also think Luthen is a is a third kind of voice in his head as well.
Speaker 3You know, yeah, yeah, Luthen was the first one who really was like, you can fight back, you can't make a differen right exactly.
Speaker 7And if I convince you of that, I get to kill you later.
Speaker 6Well. So, so the whole Luthen planning to kill Cassian thing I think makes sense in the end now to me, because like, for a minute, it felt kind of contrived, right, But I think ultimately I'm good with it because I think he started off trying to recruit him. He wasn't like I want to get this guy to do this one job and then I'll probably have to bump him off because I've given him too much information. In that first scene between them, you know, he's like, never carry
Speaker 6anything with you that you don't control, you know, always build your way out on the way in, right. He's teaching him, He's like teaching him to be a rebel operative basically. And then Cassian's like, yeah, I'll help you do this heist, but I'm not in you know, and so and then at the end, you know, he shoots Skiing, takes his money and leaves, and so he's clearly like I'm not going to be part of your thing. And then Claya is like, well, if he's not going to be part of the thing and you told him stuff
Speaker 6like you got it, you gotta kill him, right, And then he's like, all right, I guess that makes sense. And here at the end, I think, you know, when when Cassian's like, you know, bring me in, you know, bring me into to your circle, like I want to do this, you know, I've come around basically, and so Lutheren's like, oh, all right, I won't kill him. I'll just have him, you know, I have him do all the things that that I want done.
Speaker 3M hm, what especially with Lutheran and like this is pure conjecture and it might be wrong, and it might be that it doesn't matter, but I could also easily imagine giving how much he is sort of playing you know, wheels within wheels and deciding what part to sacrifice and whatnot on the chessboard like that, he was like, Okay, I'm going to tell these people to try and kill him, because if they can kill him, well it's good that we tied out that loose end. But if a turee that they can't kill him, then that's that's a good sign of him. Like, you know, they could be testing
Speaker 3him a little bit of like, because I think part of it is also that like not and granted it's because there was never like a confrontation that he escaped or something, but they were all on the same planet and they weren't able to find it, they weren't able to kill him. Yeah, and so that might be a further like cool, Okay, you kind of got tested, you and you came out well, all the more reason why, of course I want you on my team.
Speaker 6Yeah. The fact that he was able to have you know, the Empire after him and several rebels after him at the same time, and yet you know, evade capture or even he wasn't even like running from someone, right, like, he didn't get found, and that's you know, that that's proving some of his worth as a spy. Although I don't buy the you know, shunk chi like when WU sending his guys to go try and kill him although he knows he won't, they won't get killed, you know
Speaker 6like that that feels to me like something that would be a little a little contrived for this. But I do buy the and Or's value goes up in his eyes given the fact that he was able to you know, survive that and avoid catcher.
Speaker 7It's also one of those moments that makes it suddenly very mythic because it follows the exact pattern of refusal of the call and then acceptance of the call right he's like as soon as he's like, fine, I'm in. Suddenly, instead of kind of a threshold guardian in Luthen, we have a mentor in Luthen, which is a really important shift.
Speaker 3Especially because you know, of the numerous people we've been exposed to who have a part in this rebellion, Luthen is probably.
Speaker 4The one who is.
Speaker 3Maybe this is my perspective, but feels the most like morally compromised, you know, not in terms of like he like he's fighting a good fight, but he's taking a lot of actions that I think like maybe can be justified, maybe not.
Speaker 4But are surely raising a lot of eyebrows. And you know, we see that, you know, the they.
Speaker 3Do wind up letting that group of people get killed. The guy with the German name that begins with K, Yeah, you know, and I think that that's it's a really interesting choice for it fits for helping us learn more about who who Cassian is, and it's it fits where he already is. And it also fits like, you know, if man Mathma mentored him, I don't believe he winds up being the kind of guy who can take a person who's absolutely gonna help him, but is gonna slow him down and shoot him in the back or shoot
Speaker 3shoot him the way he did Ian Rogue one. So like it feels very fitting that, yeah, he's now coming under kind of the Leothen side of the rebellion.
Speaker 6Yeah, I think so for sure to address the sort of the mythology here, I think this is the episode where and or just to be a hero. It's the first, right, it's the first time he does something that isn't you know, for for his own ends, right, Like the very the first three episode arc, he's trying to find his sister and then he ends up, you know, killing two centuries and then bringing heat down on Ferris and his goal is to escape, and he escapes, right, and then the
Speaker 6next three is to do this heist that yes it's part of the rebellion, but you know, he gets a bunch of money. He's like, you know, I scored, right, and then he brings the money home and he wants to take Marvin B two E and you know, and get out of there. And then he ends up having to just go by himself because Marv's like, yeah, I'm not leaving, you know, And and then he just goes off on his own and he's like, all right, well, I'm just going to try and lay low. And then he gets you know, taken by the empire because he was walking in the wrong place right according to them.
Speaker 6And then the prison break, it's like, yeah, he inspires a bunch of people to break out of the prison, but like he wants to get out of the prison. That's why he does that whole thing, right, And then here this is the first time. Then it's he's like, I'm going to go and rescue bicks, Like I'm gonna you know, I was thinking when what Brasso said, like what you're going to take on in a whole imperial garrison, and Cassie is probably thinking, well, I've done it before, but like but yeah, he's just like, I'm going to go do the hero thing because now that's that's how
Speaker 6I see things, and that's that's what I want to be doing. And so all of the things, it's not like there was one thing that led him to that it's all of these things, which is like I believe how people actually change, right, Like, I don't think it's usually one event event. There can be one event that's a bit of a catalyst, But a catalyst doesn't do anything unless there's there's fuel there, right that if there's already things that have set up that change. And so I think here is where he's he's changed and and now he's a hero. I mean, he's still a hero
Speaker 6who you know, flip someone over and then just shoots them in the chest instead of knocking them out or whatever. You know, he's he's who he is.
Speaker 3But yeah, I think I agree with every word you said except hero. I might say that this is when he decides to join the larger fight, like because to me, hero is still a level of like I'm I'm like, he saves Bis in part because I mean Bigs is someone who's a personal connection to him, which I don't think makes his act any less awesome and important, but like especially joining up with Luthen. And maybe this is again I'm just putting too much morality on a hero, But it feels to me like he's joining a fight necessarily, like just not necessarily trying to like, you know, take
Speaker 3on a hero mantle, because I don't think he's trying to be like the one everyone sees doing it.
Speaker 4He's just trying to like be a part of it.
Speaker 6Yeah, but I just think, oh, go ahead, I was just gonna say, I think that's heroic. I think that's what heroism is. I don't think heroism is lacking any kind of moral compromise, you know, but like it's doing something that isn't you know, largely out of out of self serving whatever. And I don't mean that like as a judgment. I mean that's just like a I don't know, that's how I see the word that's fair.
Speaker 4Yeah, I like that, you know.
Speaker 7I think this entire season was about that arc for him, though, is he going to be a hero or not?
Speaker 2Right?
Speaker 7And I think where the three of us might come down on it determines not who he is as a character, but who we think heroes are, right, right, Yeah, But the Star Wars version of the Hero's Journey, and I have to say this, the Hero's Journey is kind of ridiculous, and it's so vague and generalized that you can make just about anything fit it. So everything fits it now and way too many screenwriting classes tell you how to
Speaker 7use it.
Speaker 6So yes, that's a problem.
Speaker 7And one of the reasons I thought that this was not a logical story at all was because of its kind of Marxist leanings. And I was like wandering around cleaning my apartment and I went, wait a minute, but Marx is really mythical.
Speaker 3Because they had a like they preserved Lenin's body in a tomb for sixty years. That that's a mythological figure.
Speaker 4I've heard well and very much.
Speaker 7The version of history that Marx gives us is the same version of history that Christianity gives us. Right, everything was great in the deep past, be it Eden or the classless society, and then Jesus comes and we get rid of the need for suffering or classes disappear and we are in a classist utopia. Again, is a very similar version of history. So of course this is very mythological. But the thing that was holding me back was of course, he dies, and we know he dies, but he his
Speaker 7journey is very much the hero's journey. He when he dies in Rogue one, he descends into the underworld. He gets the special tool, the elixir The only difference is he can't get it out himself, which is what happens to Beowulf. It's not what happens to Odysseus. And you know, Beowulf dies. But the thing about Beowulf is his payoff is everybody knows who he is, and he's famous as a hero. And the attempt to be more adult here
Speaker 7is that nobody is going to know who andor is after he's dead. And and I think that's a really actually kind of a beautiful form of the hero's journey, that he did it even though he wasn't going to be famous, even though he wasn't going to return with the boon himself.
Speaker 4So I'm really interested to see how they get there.
Speaker 7So I'm gonna keep talking for a second, Matthew. But so, one of the things that the hero has to do and that Star Wars has been really good at, is what the myth scholar Joseph Campbell called the belly.
Speaker 6Of the whale.
Speaker 7You know, you go into something that makes you re evaluate who you are. In Empire Strikes Back, it's that cave where Luke confronts the ghostly form of Vader. In Star Wars, it's probably the trash compactor in and Or, it's definitely the prison and you have to climb out of it. It's one of the things you absolutely have to do is climb out of it. And you know the way they the way they do this in most myths,
Speaker 7they will have somebody who keeps you from doing it, what they call a threshold guardian. So you can think of like the guy who doesn't let you cross the river sticks to get to eighties in Greek mythology, Sharon, and here it actually is. The guy who's going to be the mentor and the guy who's going to help you escape from the prison are both guardians. They both have to be convinced to become your ally. And that's that's the real, the real twisty part of it. Luthen has to and he does in that very last minute.
Speaker 7He's like, yeah, okay, you're in. But Keno Lloyd does too. Keno Lloyd is like, no, we are not going to do this, over and over and over again. No, you cannot do this, and then he's like, Okay, we're gonna do it, but like any good, like any good ally in a mythic story, then he must die.
Speaker 3I still think someone got keino afloaty of some kind. So but I do hear what you're saying, and yeah, I will say I think that has be more convinced and a lot of it. I think, Paul, You're right. It's just different kind of understandings of the word hero for me where it really stands. And maybe this is not about like hero over storm of the fight. It is, as you said, just kind of re understanding of the word hero there because to me, what I can't I think the single line maybe that most struck me throughout the whole episode was as part of Nimics Manifesto, his discription,
Speaker 3his description of how you know, what's going to stop the Empire isn't like sort of one noble person leading one group of people.
Speaker 4It's gonna be all these.
Speaker 3Little, you know, like holes in the dike that they can't plug up. It's all these little insurrections and all these different planets that are bubbling up to the surface, many of which won't ever be remembered. But it's the totality of it that the empire can't deal with because you know, as he said, the empire is just so fundamentally unnatural and I think that gives me a really good framework to understand what you're talking about. Of how like, yeah, it's not that what they did on Fenex is the one thing that happened. It's that what Andor's doing on FedEx is important, just like what so many people on
Speaker 3so many other planets are probably doing is important, and that it's the totality of that that that brings about what Nemex has talking never Nimic is talking about.
Speaker 6Yeah, for sure, I think you know. So, first of all, there's definitely certain connotations to the word hero that I don't think apply to and Or. That's you know, that's not what I mean. I think in the broader sense, I think he becomes a hero here. But I think you could also say that, you know, all of the people who decide to rise up against these stormtroopers with guns and superior technology and you know, the upper hand are all heroes in their own way, right, Yeah, And that's and so it's like when you have one hero
Speaker 6with the lightsaber, that hero has to do extraordinary things on their own, right. When you have a billion heroes, each one doesn't have to do a single act that is as dramatic, right, it's it takes. And I think that's you know, that's kind of where maybe a little bit of the sort of Marxist leanings of the show come in also, right, is that it's not it's not someone doing a thing, it's many, many, many people doing things together. Here. This was a group uprising, right. And
Speaker 6I think that idea of not being remembered also is echoed in Marva's speech here and in Luthern's speech in episode ten, right, like that it's like the point isn't to be remembered. The point is to do the thing, Like that's the point. And when you have so many people doing the thing.
Speaker 3Then I think that fits it well because I think for me, Hero is still very wrapped up in the kind of great man of history kind of idea, and when they got like ever since Rogue one, is that idea of kind of like pulling away from that, the idea of being more of a team and an ensemble. And so yeah, I think with nemics analysis, yeah, I can totally see what we're saying there.
Speaker 7Cool, if this isn't one person taking down the Berlin Wall, this is everybody taking down the Berlin Wall.
Speaker 6Yeah, right, which is like what happened, right.
Speaker 7Yeah, But it also actually I thought of the Berlin Wall when you were talking earlier, Paul, because it is the final episode and there's a lot of people in it that nothing really happens to. It kind of encapitulates that when you're part of history, but when somebody is like, what did you do, and you're like, well, I didn't do anything. It just happened. That was very present there. I mean I sat on a bed in Toronto and watched CNN when the Berlin Wall came down. That's my Berlin Wall story, right, and that's the story most people have.
Speaker 7Where were you when Kennedy were shot? Kind of stuff.
Speaker 3It's funny too, because earlier this week I was actually reading a very powerful article about like the continued effort to sort of really piece together exactly what happened at Stonewall, in the Stonewall riots that started this most recent iteration of the kind of Cape Pride movements.
Speaker 4And the like.
Speaker 3I mean, obviously they've been the versions of that thousands of years, and you know, there was a movie made that was about a white person who kind of like threw the first brick, and then it became sort of very popular stood that Marsha P.
Speaker 4Johnson, who was a trans woman who.
Speaker 3Is part of it, that she had thrown the first brick, and now kind of more stories are coming out. It's clear that she threw something, but that actually what's as this article was arguing and based on a lot of historical analysis and interviews and the like, that she had thrown something against sort of like the glass behind the bottles of the bar and shattered that and that was the kind of moment that everything broke. And I think it's so interesting that, like, yeah, it is a movement where it was a collective group of people who just collectively decided they had had far, they had had far
Speaker 3too much of what you know, the police had been doing to them. And I think probably things that like what Martha Johnson did were very heroic and very important, but kind of like that kid throwing the bomb in this episode, you know, like, yes, what he does is super important, but so is Marve's speech, and so is you know, all the other people who were involved, and like there's this desire to find that one person who did the one thing, and we should heroize the all the people who do the important things.
Speaker 4But then often it's not as simple as that.
Speaker 6Yeah, exactly, it's you know, individual people doing individual things that adds up to a group doing group things at the end of.
Speaker 7The day, because tyranny requires constant effort.
Speaker 6That's right, because it's so unnatural.
Speaker 4Great line.
Speaker 7Yeah, and and freedom is a pure idea.
Speaker 6That was the other one.
Speaker 3So what did we think about the budding romance that this showed us in one of our final scenes.
Speaker 7I am always disappointed by romance, which is a horrible thing to say for somebody who's as happily married as I am. Every time I see romance in a popular narrative, I'm like, how is this going to undermine the position of the woman in this story?
Speaker 3Well, to be clear, I wasn't even trying to talk about and Orn Bicks. I'm talking about yes.
Speaker 7Yeah, he's practically a Twilight vampire. He's so following her around.
Speaker 3It was that was the moment that I said, felt really wrong to me, because I felt like the show had been giving us this very interesting analysis of You know, Danielle came on our podcast a couple of weeks ago and talked about him as sort of like a proto, you know, kind of the type of person that often now goes onto the term in cell, which is not I think the exact definition that fits Cereal, but very much of that same, like, you know, rejected by woman becoming more radicalized to that and all the west that can go down, and certainly, as we saw in two episodes ago, her confronting him, confronting her and having this
Speaker 3kind of like, you know, very aggressive, very like no, but you're supposed to be with me, and to the point of.
Speaker 4Physically grabbing her, and I was like, I was really loving.
Speaker 3That the show had shown us that and so having her instead him save her and having this moment. I don't know if you felt this, but it very much felt to me like like are they about to kiss kind.
Speaker 4Of moment because she's like, what you saved me?
Speaker 3You shouldn't have doune you Why why did you do that? Like I really didn't like that moment.
Speaker 4I'm curious what you've thought about it.
Speaker 7In defense of the actor who plays Mirror, whose name is Denise Co, she really tried to sell it. She really tried to sell it so much in a way that suggested to me that she knew it wasn't the best use of the character, that it was going to ring wrong.
Speaker 4Deadream deedra, Yeah, that's it. Yeah, Deadroom.
Speaker 7Mirro the actor was like, I'm going to make this seem like the thing that would happen, but she was working so hard at it that it emphasized that it was probably the wrong move for the writers, well for Gilroy. I think she was like, this is not what this this should be ending this way, and so she really worked at saying working to make us believe that maybe that is how it should end, even though I don't think she thought it was correct. As a performer. Yeah,
Speaker 7the way she tried to sell it made it more obviously discombobulated.
Speaker 6And now I'm shutting up because I was rambling. So I'm not thoroughly convinced that this is the beginning of a budding romance. Like I can see what you see, I believe, right, But at the same time, I also see something else there, which was like the first conversation they had, I thought they were kind of very similar people at first, right then after his like oh no, but by the way, I'm totally a stalker, I was like,
Speaker 6oh no, that's not their dynamic, right, you know. And I was kind of pushing back on the idea that she felt maybe physically threatened or whatever. But this moment, not so much they're them talking to one another, but her sort of actions in the struggle, in the actual physical altercation, you know, the what was going on made me actually see them as kind of similar again. And
Speaker 6I do think that there's the danger of like undercutting her as a character, right, But at the same time, I think I think both of these characters are kind of showing something important, which is that, like there are people who you know, work these like desk jobs or whatever in whether it's intelligence or you know, law enforcement or whatever kind of agencies, you know, and they're not
Speaker 6necessarily these you know, street wise like know how to handle things in the moment kind of people, right, And so I think there was an interesting parallel of like from that episode three where Cyril comes to town and is like, yeah, we're gonna apprehend and Or and then he's just like totally shell shocked, but the reality of trying to go out and do what he's trying to go out and do, and here I think she ends up having that reaction as well, like she's I think
Speaker 6a brilliant strategist, right, and I think in terms of her understanding of how the rebellion might function, I think she's like top notch, right, clearly, like in a way that you don't want the fascists to have anybody with that level of capability, right. But then I think here she's kind of revealed to be like I don't want to say like Ivory Tower, but that kind of like more of a yeah, and it's not even like theoretician, right,
Speaker 6because it's like she is all about practical actions, like what are we going to do to get this response? Right, but kind of like kind of like a social engineering or whatever.
Speaker 3Whereas I think it's that both of them seem to have a sense of vulnerability.
Speaker 6Until they're confronted with the reality. Yeah, exactly, you seem to think.
Speaker 3As long as I'm doing the right thing, it'll be okay. And it's both in terms of enforcing the law but then dealing with bureaucracy, and for her it's I had the imperial uniform and like, yeah, I thought that scene where like she was under all the crowd and would tear her apart was fantastic and the same way, like maybe it's the way it was shot, or maybe to watch Captain America too much.
Speaker 4When when the bomb gets thrown and.
Speaker 3Cyril like runs towards it, I thought he was gonna, like Captain America jump on top of or something in what would be a like kind of heroic act in that one little regard, but also saving like he's saving his colleagues, giving up himself saving terrible colleagues.
Speaker 4But you know, there you go.
Speaker 3I totally hear what you're saying, and I could very much get if it is a moment of.
Speaker 4Finding a connection with each other.
Speaker 3I just I wish they hadn't shot it by having their faces that close in the very traditional Hollywood are we about to kiss moments.
Speaker 7And there's a sort of stereotype, I think, a trope maybe of like the secondary characters in the Nazi movie who are going to have a child for the glory of the state. And they felt very much like that right, like they didn't want to kiss, but you know, the empire might need them to kiss.
Speaker 3And I think the only other part of it for me is because I think you're right, Paul, I think there was an element to which you know they had a connection at first, but I think for her as someone who struggled, so there's almost kind of a respectability politics of it, Like for her, someone who's fought so hard to be taken seriously, with her somewhat out of the box ideas having someone who is never going to be taken seriously. She's like, I can't in any way be associated with you. I need to show that I'm reasonable because I'm not you, and you know, and I think we talked about how she so quickly dismisses him
Speaker 3in a way that you.
Speaker 4Could be like, yeah, what what's that about?
Speaker 3I didn't love And again, I don't know if it was even intended by the writers, And I don't certainly think we're going to see them like kissing lots.
Speaker 4In season two. I don't. It was just the way that moment was framed.
Speaker 3I think part of for me is also this idea that when she is physically threatened and her sense of vulnerability is cracked, all of a sudden, she's like, oh, man, who's been kind of chasing me? All of a sudden, I'm seeing your value. Like that is just so tied up with so many cliches and tropes that it just and maybe that's to me projecting some of those tropes under where that was necessarily was. But it's so close to that that it all. It was just one more reason why it rubbed me wrong.
Speaker 7Sure, but perhaps we should focus on not just that moment.
Speaker 4Yes, there's a lot more. I just wanted to kind of bring that up to be sure. We've talked it to dem.
Speaker 7I'm terrified of it, but much like the story of mon Mathma, I'm willing to wait for the next season to see where it actually fits.
Speaker 5How's that?
Speaker 6Yeah, Yeah, yeah, exactly. I mean there certainly wasn't a resolution to whatever you think wherever you think that story might be going, right with I mean with either Yeah, I would say in terms of actual romantic developments, I thought Valencinta, like who didn't end up actually doing that much there, right, in terms of interacting with other characters, except you know, a little little stabby stabby, but like,
Speaker 6I don't know, I'll say that their relationship, like the sort of struggle of it while you know, one of them is like super focused on work and the other ones like, well, can we maybe get a minute like say hi? You know, it felt very real. It felt as real to me as like any any relationship, really, any romance I've seen in Star Wars to date, well.
Speaker 4Because it's not romance, it's the I think.
Speaker 3Romance is often associated with like the seduction and the like will they won't they, and often once they kiss, that's the end of the story, whereas this is just about yeah, the tension of sharing a workplace while sharing a relationship right on your constant threat of death, Like, yeah, I wish there had been just a little bit more physical affection showed between them, just for the representation factor. But yeah, I did think it was very well done the way they showed that. And then it wasn't a okay, so this is the thing that will break them up. It was just no, this is just a tense moment.
Speaker 7Yeah, And nobody said I hate sand right, nobody said that. I mean, but how do you feel about that representation moment?
Speaker 3I And again, I am I'm a queer person, I'm not a lesbian, and so all the rest it goes along with that.
Speaker 4It felt like the crumbs are getting bigger.
Speaker 3You know, it is still pretty far away from the kind of representation I would want. Star Wars to actually have on screen, which, by the way, they are doing constantly in the new books, which I think is really interesting. Like we've now had numerous characters with non binary pronouns in Star Wars and numerous examples of like full on queer relationships the one kind in the Star Wars books. So yeah, it felt like, I'm very glad it was there. I'm incredibly glad that neither one died so far, just
Speaker 3because that's a trope we're breaking, at least for now. And the fact that this Paul said, I think that their relationship not only was like, oh, hey, look they're kind of giving a nice look to each other, so stop yelling at us for not having a queer people. Their relationship was actually a character development moment that was like an important plot point. It wasn't just hey, they're queer, so we can have representations. So I thought it was a lot better than it has been, even though still I would have liked a lot more.
Speaker 7I kind of think their version of representation is a corporate strategy, all right, because Marvel does the same thing, which is the stuff that's not going to be all that scene in Saudi Arabia and China is where you get it the books or the TV shows, not the films. And I'm beginning to find that problematic.
Speaker 4And I don't know sad.
Speaker 7That they don't have the they want to say, well, no, we're doing representation, read this book, but they don't have the guts that really just go all in on it.
Speaker 4This is a larger topic for conversation.
Speaker 3I think I think I have a little bit more hopeful view, which is that it seems to me more like the TV show is the testing ground, that it's sort of like, Okay, let's dip our foot into the water, and if we don't get the studio down, then maybe next it can go on screen.
Speaker 4But I do think you're right, there's certainly.
Speaker 3A lot of the like like like I said, like most of it's in the books, which probably has the smallest portion of the media.
Speaker 4So yeah, I think that I'm a little.
Speaker 3Hopeful that it's going to move forward, but it's moving forward way too slowly. And I think this is a very good possibility that it just becomes kind of like that's the place where we put it, so it never has to go anywhere else exactly.
Speaker 6I mean, I definitely think TV or series are often kind of the whether it's testing grounds or just it's just ahead of films, you know, depending on the and not like films broadly speaking, but like specifically like Blockbuster films, you know, because so much of the money from Blockbusters films comes from you know, international, like from being not even just international, but from being viewed like in all different places. Right, So I think not only is that
Speaker 6true in terms of representation, but also in terms of kind of what ideas you can put forth and you know, how how much you can go after your concept compared to having to kind of be like, well, you know, we're going to need to have the third act CGI battle. I mean, come on, you.
Speaker 3Know, yeah, having developing any kind of really interesting plot line, which you need if representation isn't going to just appear tokenizing. Yeah, it takes a lot more time, yeah, for sure, but you can still get it movies. So let's talk about speaking of representation, Let's talk about Marva a bit, because there's been a subject that I've been discussing a lot on Twitter and a lot of people have strong opinions on. We're probably gonna do a full episode on this topic with Danielle and some other people at a later date, but I wanted to kind of bring it up. The thing that was bothering me more and more as the
Speaker 3season went on, particularly as I heard and read and saw content from a lot of the Latina creators and other people of color creators who had issues with this is and Bail You and I talked about it a little bit at the beginning that the image of Marva kind of rescuing Cassian is tied up with a lot of things in our own culture about you know, kids of color being rescued by white parents and kind of raised taken away from their own cultures, and that happens with
Speaker 3excuse me, that's happened quite a lot with indigenous kids in a lot of different parts of the world, certainly in Australia that had huge issues with it happened all the time. Here in the United States and other places, it certainly happened. It happens all the time right now in our adoption and foster care systems. And there's been a lot more talk from kids who've gone through that who often you know, we are now adults, who often say things like yeah, like even if I was in a very bad situation, and I appreciate the white people who adopted me.
Speaker 4Or who raised me.
Speaker 3There's still a lot of problems with it, and in some cases I.
Speaker 4Wish that maybe they if they looked harder, they wouldn't have.
Speaker 3Seen that I had to be rescued, or even if I was getting be rescued, I wish there was more of an attempt to keep me connected to my culture of origin, stuff like that.
Speaker 4All of which is to say, I.
Speaker 3Felt like when they first showed us that scene, they left a lot open to debate, and they showed us Marves's perspective, and that from Marve's perspective, like they had to rescue this child or this child was gonna die. And I think it is completely legitimate to see that as the truth of the fact of the situation. I think it's also very possible to say that maybe there's more information that Marvin didn't know. Maybe certainly Marve could have maybe like asked him, she could have woken him up in some way that might have not been factually possible.
Speaker 4I don't remember the exact details there.
Speaker 3You know, there's a lot we didn't know, and especially like again, we don't know too much of it, but the fact that he is working to kind of reconnect with his sister tells me that, like, there wasn't much of an effort later to like go back and like see did anyone else survived? Well, you know, what did happen when the Republic came? Did they actually kill all these Excuse me?
Speaker 4Did they actually come and like kill all these kids?
Speaker 3Which I admit a part of me is like I don't know if that I can we one hundred psent believe that would have happened and there'll be no record or anything like that. All this is just to say that early on I thought one of the plot lines they were sort of planting, particularly in showing a lot of tension between Marva and Cassian and her not loving the idea that he's off looking for his sister, is that maybe there is some tension about this, and maybe it's an issue that's been fully resolved, or maybe it's just something they've learned to live with, but that there is some kind of like tension there that's in some way going to get acknowledged, and so to have her
Speaker 3have this very heroic funeral scene which I think she gives an amazing powerful speech but that we get and that it is so as possible that in season two we're gonna explore it two years from now. But I think for me, at least, it felt a little off to not address that, and having read the reports of a lot of people who are really loving the show, but who are because they've had personal experience with this, or they've been close to experience with this, and really because resonate with that part of the story, and we're really bothered by it not being brought up. It was one of their kind sour note for me, and I,
Speaker 3as I said, if you follow my Twitter, you'll see some discussion of it. I think, like a lot of things on social media, it's become a very binary thing of like, you know, either she rescued him and it was, as one person said to me, an unambiguously morally good event, or you know, she stole him and it was wrong and terrible and bad and she's just like an awful colonizer. And I definitely don't think that the second one is true. I think the first one is a lot more. I think the truth is probably a lot more common, nuanced, and complicated than all of that. And he's here's the
Speaker 3last thing I've been on a long modelogue. I promise i' let you guys jump in for me. I think when so much of the show, like you know, a lot of shows, I wouldn't expect them to get into that level of comp complexity and nuance.
Speaker 4But in this show, where I felt like the bar has been raised so high.
Speaker 3Of all the situations that you think, on the surface look purely morally good or purely morally bad, we're going to explore that they're much more complex and new once. I'm disappointed that they haven't given us that with this.
Speaker 7A quick myth aside, well that was a made up word, but I.
Speaker 6Mean that way is that how you am is the myth is.
Speaker 7One of the things that the myth has to do is give the kid a special childhood, right he's secretly a prince or or he's secretly a skywalker. And this does that very effectively and does what Paul really likes about it, which is given in universe reason for his accent, which I think is fantastic. So I like, I kind of like it from that perspective.
Speaker 6But at the.
Speaker 7Same time, there's a certain there's a certain generation of kind of like not quite radical Marxist thinkers in American culture who like to pretend like race is in a thing and they just they they see everything as a class issue, and it's weird. I've known a lot of those people in academia where they're like they they're the kind of people who are the leftists who say I
Speaker 7don't see race and and I kind of think that maybe that was part of Tony Gilroy's achilles heel there, that that while it was there, it's not going to stay there, not in season two.
Speaker 6Yeah, so I have a lot of thoughts about this. I'd probably rather have fewer, but I did read said Twitter discussion if you could call it discussion, and you know, it just reinforced my urge to quit all social media. I think, first of all, it's important to acknowledge, like, yeah, there's there's horrible things that happen in our world along these lines, right, and and that's that's real. And I
Speaker 6think there are sometimes things that maybe look like one thing and are actually another thing, you know, and a lot of times the the truth is complex. And you know, when when you talk about some some kids who were either born in a particular culture or place, or of of a certain race and then adopted by someone of another culture or race or in another place. Different people
Speaker 6have different experiences, right, And I mean I know a number of people with this experience, and and I've seen different opinions or different different experiences from the same type of experience, right. And I haven't had that experience myself. So I'm not gonna, you know, say anything about it, right, except that I've seen people have very different ways of looking at it themselves, right. And so I think sometimes
Speaker 6there's this idea that like a thing is just a thing, and it's like the context doesn't matter. And I think in the case of the show, I think there was very clear context, the context being that this is a planet that has been exploited by the Republic, right, and bad things have happened. And it's unclear whether Kasa is actually growing up in his culture per se or kind
Speaker 6of more in the remnants of his culture, right, does his entire culture even exist anymore? Like there's no adults, Like, I don't know, maybe that's part of the culture, maybe it's not. We don't know. And on some level I appreciate that we don't know, because maybe Cassian doesn't know, right, Maybe he doesn't remember what it was like to be Casa, right. I do think that in the very first episode they made it clear that the Republic might come and kill them all, but also that we don't know, right, right.
Speaker 6Marv clearly thinks that Clem pushes back, right, So I would say this is at least lampshaded in the show where Clem is like, he's got people here, and she's like, people who just killed a Republic officer, they're all going to get killed, which is like, maybe can you can you try and help them? I don't know, you know, maybe you can't because the Republic is like super powerful and you know whatever. But so I think it's hard to see her action as anything but well intentioned, but
Speaker 6also somewhat questionable, and not so much questionable in terms of like should she have done something different necessarily, but like that we don't know, and she didn't know, and so she was making an assumption and did what she thought was the best thing at the at that point in time. Right.
Speaker 7Could you say, could you say well intentioned but naive?
Speaker 6I think potentially, yeah, yeah, you know for sure, but then again, we don't know how much she knows about the situation on Canari, right, because we don't know that much about the situation on Canari. So I think I think they do show as it goes on though, Like she's still got his stuff from Canari, right, it's still there, And I think and she also talks about him having everything taken away, right, And so I think I don't
Speaker 6think that's like just about Clem. I think she understands and acknowledges that there was harm in that being his story. You know, I don't think she necessarily feels culpability in that regard. We're not really shown anything like that. You know, we are shown some doubt by Clem in the first place, But then then then it seems like I had like a generally I want to say, happy family life, although it seems like everything in this galaxy is largely misery
Speaker 6and suffering, but like you know, they had loving relationships amongst each other, right, And to.
Speaker 3Be clear, I think you and I are almost entirely in agreement in that regard. Like I want to be clear, I'm not saying I think that any that like Marva is evil or wrong for doing this, nor that I think it guarantees that she couldn't be a loving parent to Cassian. And like you, I've heard a whole wide range of these stories, and I think what I definitely have heard ones folks who have said, no, there's never any problem at all. I've definitely heard someone who said, like, my parents were horrible racists. In the minute I got eighteen, I left their house. I think the majority, though, have been much more nuanced and complex. Like we were talking about,
Speaker 3you know that there's one distinct thing I remember from a woman who give a speech on this, who said, look, and she was black and adopted by white parents, and said, I loved my mother. She was wonderful to me, she cared for me. But I wish she had any idea how to take care of black girl's hair, you know, And and she kind of she she used that as a perfect example of just like, you know, I wish my mom had thought more about the fact that she couldn't just raise me the exact way she would a white daughter or something like that, and a yeah, and so I don't, like, I'm not saying that like I
Speaker 3hate that the two of them loved each other, or that they had a good relationship or anything like that. I just I feel like there would it would have come up in some way at some point, and I wish that that. I wish the story had just acknowledged that in some way, and it could have been something fairly simple of just like while they were fighting, you know, her just saying like, yeah, you haven't been this mad at me since you know, we talked about why it took you away, or like him talking to Bicks about like, yeah.
Speaker 4You know, I was mad at her for a while when I was younger, and you.
Speaker 3Know, and you know, like her death could have been his chance to kind of process that a little bit and talk about how at one point in time he was very mad at her about it, but he came to understand her decision more or anything like that.
Speaker 4Like it's not like I want it.
Speaker 3I think she was a very heroic character and I think she's probably a very loving mother, And we don't know the complex what actually happened. I just wish we'd gotten a little bit more of that being a nuanced situation, That's all I'm saying.
Speaker 6Yeah, I mean, I hear you. I Also I'm like, we don't know that he was mad about that, Like we do know that he wanted. He still wants to find his sister because he thinks he has an unresolved idea of what happened there, right for whether whether that's legit or not, we don't know, right, I mean, I feel like you don't usually put that into a story unless the sister is going to show up in season two. But you know, again, we'll see or we won't see. But like she, you know, they did have a conversation
Speaker 6about that. They did talk about that, you know, right, and she's like, you know that it's a fantasy, like everybody was killed on pharik On, not on Pherriic's on Canari, which you know, maybe it will turn now that that was She's saying that just because it was an easier way of, you know, dealing with it, or maybe that is what happened, and maybe maybe we'll see, right, But I don't know. I mean that's the problem with like a series not all coming out all at once. It's like, yeah,
Speaker 6like I definitely feel like they're probably gonna circle back to the sister thing, you know, but.
Speaker 3It may well be that, Like again, because everything else has been so intentional, it may well be that they have intentions to cover this. It's just that it's not going to be for two years, and so it's kind of frustrating at the moment. Or it maybe, as Matthew said, it might just be that there's a bit of a blindness there. Although I am a little afraid, especially with the new control of Congress, that if there is any kind of like House of American on American Activities committee that starts up again, we are making sure that Tony Gilroy is gonna get to call to testify. So please, any Republicans listening, like, we don't think he's an I mean,
Speaker 3who the hell knows, but don't you don't use us as evidence in the House on American Activities against Tony Gilroy.
Speaker 4Anyway.
Speaker 3So yeah, I think that's all it needs to said about that. Lest Matthew and anything else or else, we can go to the one last thing I wanted.
Speaker 4To bring up.
Speaker 7I just want to be called before Congress now so I can say, have you no decency?
Speaker 4Hey? Listen, listen.
Speaker 3To some point we'll tell the story about how Paul and I were having an episode. We were trying really hard not to discuss actually like killing an important political figure. Just in the story and the police knocked on Paul's door in the middle of the episode.
Speaker 6It's true that happened.
Speaker 3It wasn't at all connected anyway we think, but it was a very freaky moment.
Speaker 7Well, but that does bring up something. So how do you both think about the fact that it's a riot. I mean, one of the central moments of this episode is a riot. I'm from Detroit, so riots are a big deal. My thesis for history, in my master's thesis was on the nineteen forty three Detroit riot, the nineteen sixth, the nineteen sixty eight riot was very much the cops still to this day say, man, we didn't do anything wrong until they attacked us.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 3I mean I live in Minneapolis and was I could smell the smoke during George Floyd, so like, yeah, I'm with you there.
Speaker 4And I think it was.
Speaker 3Very interesting the way that they portrayed it, because, like I said, I don't I think the desire to fight the empire was really interesting, and I think what they showed it was that the Empire was responding with appropriate full with a proportional response. And then it was one of the townspeople who hugely elevated the situation by throwing a bomb, and I liked that. I liked the idea that it's like, we don't have to just wait, you know. I think there's an awful lot of situations that are called riots that really shouldn't be, especially the last couple
Speaker 3of years. But also, like you said, nineteen sixty eight Chicago, where all these protesters who were starting things had lumps on the back of their heads from the billy clubs. Like my mother did was a lost student during the Columbia riots and said very similar things. So like, on the one hand, I think it's important to know that most things people call riots, the violence is instigated by the police, but in this case it wasn't because they would they It wasn't a we want to have a peaceful protest that's turning into a riot, like she said, fight the Empire, rise up. And I kind of love
Speaker 3that kid through the bomb to make it be like, no, this isn't just we're protesting. This is like we're supposed to be fighting these people. And I thought it was very interesting the way that played out, and I appreciate it.
Speaker 6Yeah, it's interesting because the whole funeral was played like a protest, right, Like they went the time that they said they were going to, I supposed to the time they were told to go. They didn't have forty people. They had, however many people they wanted, you know, And then they had a speech like a performance, right, and then the fascists said, okay, we're going to cut that off, and they flipped over a droid. And then then there was basically like a spontaneous revolt, you know, a spontaneous uprising,
Speaker 6but also not entirely spontaneous, because like that kid had been spending the last day making a bomb, you know, and there were some other bombs that blew up that I wasn't quite clear, like were those things the empire had sitting around or were those planted in order to be like secondary explosions. I wasn't certain that it was a good point.
Speaker 4I didn't thought of that, you know, regard.
Speaker 7I thought it was just like a box of grenades that fell over and ignited, right, So those were like it was part of their equipment.
Speaker 6Their equipment. Yeah, yeah, yeah, maybe you don't have a bunch of grenades hanging around where you're you're hanging out, you know, basic safety, I.
Speaker 4Mean, one thing that really struck me.
Speaker 3Although bringing a box of grenades, maybe he speaks against about to say yeah, But part of it felt to me like the Empire kind of as a macrocosm of what happened with Dedra of not really thinking like a group of people being mad could.
Speaker 4Become a big problem.
Speaker 3It felt like part of their sort of like not ramping up the intensity of the violence very early was because they didn't take it here.
Speaker 4They didn't think this was gonna be a big deal. They're like, Okay, they're gonna bang against their shields for a little while. And to me, one of the most like.
Speaker 3The best illustrations of that is you've got the guy in the tower banging on the sort of xylophone thing, which I just thought was fantastic. I keep waiting for one of the imperials to want to take care of it, and when finally they do, I expected that, like he's standing out in the open, you've got sharpshooters, just shoot him, like I thought that's what they were gonna do, And instead they're like, no, just go up there and tell him to stop. And then what he does, the guy on the xylophone, like he doesn't break rhythm.
Speaker 4He just like kicks out knocks the guy off the tower to his death.
Speaker 3And it was both a kind of like a little bit of like Star Wars campiness that we hadn't seen him the show, and so I appreciated that, but it was also this beautiful moment of like the Empire completely underestimating just how fervent this this uprising feeling is.
Speaker 7Should have been a Wilhelm scream?
Speaker 4What's that?
Speaker 6Oh? I'm so glad there wasn't.
Speaker 7There's this thing in sound design and movies called the Wilhelm scream, and you will hear it in every Star Wars film that Lucas did, and all of the Indiana Jones films too, and it's just like really campy scream of falling Oh yeah, yeah, and it's the same one that we've been they've been using it for decades and decades apparently.
Speaker 6Yeah, it's the same folly just over and note it's like, oh, there it is. That's that particular scream that I've heard before.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 6I mean it felt like kind of real to me, even though it was like surprising. I thought he was going to hit him in the Stormtrooper helmet with the hammers or something. They just just kicked him right over the edge, you know. But yeah, to me, the whole thing kind of speaks to me of it's like this is, you know, these people's home, and you know they've had this sentiment building up over time, and they know how the area works basically the ins and outs of things, you know, and so so yeah, just the I do
Speaker 6think that the Empire, you know, underestimated it, you know. And I mean, granted, it's like Dedra she did say no snipers, right, so they didn't have a bunch of snipers on the towers because she was like, we're not trying to kill her. Main thing wasn't like control this funeral procession. It's let's capture and or right.
Speaker 3Yeah, she didn't care that this might be like a minor rebellion on a minor planet.
Speaker 6Right, and kind of didn't see that coming, I think to some extent. You know. But and the the kid who threw the bomb, I think Wilman is his name or something. His dad was I think just hanged by the empire, right, that's the guy who his dad was, the one who ran the shop, and and Dedro was like, oh, I don't care whatever, do whatever you want, and the guys would call I'd liked to hang him in the town square to show, you know, you know, demonstrate our authority. It's like, how did that work out for you? And
Speaker 6on some way, like I would have it would have been more cathartic to see just like all the storm troopers and you know and imperials just like trounced and you know, yeah killed even right. But but this felt more like, yeah, that's that's probably like what would happen. You know, it's not it's not a it's not this like planned, oh, let's overthrow the empire here, right. It wasn't that type of rebellion. It was a you know,
Speaker 6we're we're mad as hell about you know, we're sick of this and we're just not going to just comply anymore. Yeah, I imagine going forward things aren't going to go very well on Perris.
Speaker 3I mean, one of the things that I was thinking of is the idea that the empire has this kind of overconfidence of yeah, which we have people with guns, We're going to tell the people what to do, they're going to do it. And now they're kinds of prop that you know, people like dead jar are Like, wait, I didn't think they would do that. Clearly, the Emperor and Invader and all of them have been known about the darths have known about the Death Star project for years. But in terms of like the rest of the military being okay with this like planet destroying weapon, like yeah,
Speaker 3a time when like your confidence has been shattered and you're feeling that like, yeah, where the Empire were in total control, these people are always gonna fear us has been broken. Yeah, and then someone comes along goes, okay, but don't worry. We've got a weapon that's going to put them back in line. Like yeah, this is a pretty good time where I could see some of the military being like, Okay, that's extreme, but we need an extreme measure right now.
Speaker 7I'm just glad somebody didn't stand up and go, you know, not all strongtroopers are bad.
Speaker 6There's just a few bad apples.
Speaker 4Oh god, yep, a SAB is that the SAB? Yeah, there we go.
Speaker 6I mean I do think that this did show that, like the stormtroopers aren't necessarily stormtroopers because they want to do stormtrooper things, you know. Yeah, it's just it's what they're doing, and they're they're not allowing their they're not having a conscience that prevents them from doing horrible things, but their their aim isn't necessarily necessarily to do horrible things.
Speaker 3Right, Yeah, I'm still struck by you know, it's hard to think of them as all like wah, fascism and fascism, we can kill all the people.
Speaker 4When we saw the two people who.
Speaker 3Were like, oh cool, we can see a fireworks show, you know. Right, So there's one last thing that I wanted to bring up. We've already passed an hour, so I don't want to us to go too much longer, but give you both the chance as well. And I'm wondering what you thought of that kind of one of the last scenes we got of seeing that man Mathma was going to kind of go ahead with what the the money money guy who's kind of a gangster had asked of at least allowing the daughter and the son to kind of meet up in a way that like,
Speaker 3you know, maybe it's not a forced marriage.
Speaker 4But one of the things that.
Speaker 3U TikTok or I follow pointed out that I felt was really good was like, in the first time it's raised, you're sort of.
Speaker 4Like, well, why don't you allow your.
Speaker 3Daughter to just meet with this guy's son, Because your daughter's not an idiot, She's not gonna want to jump into a marriage at fifteen, So why are you so worried? And then when we saw that the daughter is part of that organization where actually maybe, yeah, she would be very happy to like Mary, get married to the first guy she kind of you know, meets and flirts with in that way that you understand why it's much more of a sacrifice from Ma Mathama to do this. So yeah, I don't I don't think it was in like a definite that a marriage is going to happen, but certainly much more likely than just a first meeting.
Speaker 4What'd you all think of that? How that scene was portrayed.
Speaker 6I'd also like to address mon Mathma completely playing Parrien and the isb with making a fantastic that was that was money. I was like, oh, that's that's nice, you know, basically bringing up his previous gambling issues I think, which seems like that those were real, but then now they're not there. But this is the explanation for how you know, And so the empire thinks they have something on her, when in fact, they don't have the thing that they could have on her. It reminds me a little bit
Speaker 6of Cassian, like getting you know, arrested for jaywalking basically. But but but here's she's, you know, she's doing that on purpose. I think her, you know, it's tough because it's like, well, her daughter clearly wants to follow this tradition, which letting her daughter choose to do that feels like it's giving her daughter her agency. But on the other hand,
Speaker 6the tradition is all about not having agency. So you know, it seems like a very difficult parenting moment. And I think she basically maybe she tells herself, well, if that's what she wants, even though though it's not what I think she should want, you know, and it's clearly not what mon Mathma wants. But she's you know, kind of willing to allow her daughter to sacrifice herself for the
Speaker 6greater good without her knowledge of it, in a weird kind of you know, it's it's a lot like the Anto Krieger thing, right, except you know, it's basically Anto Kreeger wanted to attack Spellhouse, and Luthen's like, all right, go ahead, attack spell House. He had information that was like you definitely shouldn't do this, but he didn't give that to him. Here mon, Mathma's like, Okay, you want to meet some boy in the Chandrilline tradition, go ahead and meet some boy in some Chandrilline tradition, when in fact she knows like this is this is not a
Speaker 6good idea, you know.
Speaker 3Well, I think that's right, But I think there's one more step to it, which is that it's not that she's like, Okay, if you meet some boy in the Chanduline tradition, I won't stand in the way. It's okay, if you want this, I will then help facilitate a meeting with a boy. Sure that is completely for my own ends, my own Yeah, yeah, yeah, But I think that's the key is that she doesn't just let it happen.
Speaker 4She actively facilitates it with this one specific person.
Speaker 6Yeah. Although you could say that, you know, Luthen allows Anto Krieger to go into this doomed battle partially so that then the ISB will assume that there is no mole within the ISB, and then he can achieve his goals more easily going forward, because nobody's going to be looking at that, dude.
Speaker 7Yeah, I think that's true, the untrue Coventry story about Winston Churchill right in the Broken Code.
Speaker 4What was your what was your take on it, Matthew.
Speaker 7It seems like a perfectly reasonable thing to do in her position, and it's an also a completely horrible thing to do, and we should give her no like bonus points for being a good revolutionary because of it. But narratively, I think it. I think it does something interesting, which is we now have to wait like more than a year, and we have a number of female characters hanging in the wind in ways that we should be concerned about.
Speaker 7The daughter and Or's sister is out there, so.
Speaker 3Bas has just been rescued, but we don't really know what damage.
Speaker 7But what kind of what kind of psychological damage does you have? Whereas the male characters aren't in that kind of straits, And I think that's an I think that's an interesting place to leave it. I'm not going to offer a critique because I don't think there's you can at this point, but I think it's a really interesting place to leave it, because lord knows, I really don't like mon Mathma's daughter.
Speaker 4It's interesting.
Speaker 3I actually thought you're gonna go in a very different direction. Though I do love what you said as well, because what I saw as as the interesting narrative thing they were doing was up until this point they've kind of set it up as Luthen is the revolutionary who's willing to get his hands dirty, whereas mon moth Must still has this idea of kind of like the purity of what they're doing. And you know, before you know you're talking about so there's some lines that you don't cross. And I kind of think, you know, selling off your daughter to help the revolution, like it's outline a lot
Speaker 3of people would say they don't want to cross, and yeah, again because of the daughter's engagement with it, in involvement with it. It's that's that's an oversimplification of it. But to me felt very much like this was the moment when where like I think if Luthen had seen this, he would be a like, see remember what I said, Like because it is her realizing like she can't keep her hands as clean in someway especial because she kind of like throws both her family members under the bus in this episode, Like I don't think her husband gets really badly hurt, but now like people think he's a
Speaker 3gambling addict again, and her daughter's now getting involved with which it's not just I think that she's going through with this marriage tradition that they find horrible, but to the son of like a really bad guy. So yeah, I just really like that, like man Mathma ending in that position given where she started the season, I.
Speaker 7Can agree with that, yeah too, because remember she you could take mon Mantma's entire story out of this season because it's not significant to the rest of the story really, so clearly it's part of a huge setup, and that huge setup has to be her turning into somebody who's going to talk about lines we do not cross, as though she knows what happens when you do that.
Speaker 6Right, Yeah, She's a very important character going forward, right and here she's this is like, you know, this is her anti hero turn basically right like throughout the first season, like wanting to do a huge good thing and then coming around to maybe that's going to take a lot of smaller bad things along the way.
Speaker 3And this is what I do appreciate that we're starting to get overlapping stories because this is now happening right about the same time that Rebels is taking place, And my understanding is that the next show is going to be like moving closer to the time of Luke Skywalker, and so we're going to be directly overlapping and moder Mathama is a character who appears in Rebels at further along in her journey.
Speaker 4So I'll be curious to see where that goes.
Speaker 3All right, I think it's got a prett good wrapping up point. Any of the last things either, I think it's a pretty good wrapping up point. Is there anything else either of the two of you want to throw in?
Speaker 7I truly hope somebody writes down everything Karis Nemick said and hosts it somewhere please.
Speaker 4Yeah, I want. I will happily read it.
Speaker 3I'd much prefer if it it's like just a full audio like I said of him reading all of it.
Speaker 4But whatever it is, he's very good at it. Yeah, let's find it.
Speaker 6Yeah, I will say that, Like, in terms of representation, I would hope that Jazz becomes, you know, a more more of a character going forward. She's, you know, one of the daughters of Feryx, who's who you know flies the ship right for le Brosso and Dix and be two Emo and you know, just because like there really are not very many black women in Star Wars. So, like, you know, that is a really good point. It would
Speaker 6be it would be nice to, you know, to see that.
Speaker 3I mean, the only two ones I can think of primarily are both ones who start as imperial yeah, and then either before we see them or while we see them, have hero turned more of than being Riva, and the other one being the person who might be Lando's daughter in Rise of Skywalker. Right, So yeah, that's a really good point.
Speaker 7There's also the character in Jedi Fallen Order.
Speaker 4Yeah, yeah, and.
Speaker 3There aren't there There's a couple of others in Rebels, I will say, for sure.
Speaker 6Yeah. Yeah, but just like you know, just in terms of the in the live.
Speaker 4Action yeah, yeah, totally I agree.
Speaker 3Yeah, And I would say if you follow my Twitter you'll also see a woman who I follow did a great thread specifically on the lack of black women representation in Star Wars.
Speaker 4It's very worthworth reading. Matthew, any last things from.
Speaker 7You, I am done.
Speaker 4That's awesome. Well, thank you both as always so much being a part of this.
Speaker 3We have a lot of great feedback that we've gotten from you all, as as listeners that I'm really excited to get to go into.
Speaker 4We're probably gonna do two feedback episodes. I still have to schedule some of them.
Speaker 3We might even the third depending on how many more we get in, so please continue to send those in. We're still trying to figure out exactly what we're going to be doing with this podcast going forward.
Speaker 4I want to.
Speaker 3Restart Our Rebels cover, but just due to schedules, we probably can't do that. In the new year, I think we're going to talk some about some of the books that have come out. I'm going to finally start watching Star Wars Resistance again and talking about that somewhat.
Speaker 4I know Matthew had expressed an interest in doing the second.
Speaker 3Half of Tales of the Jedi about Count Dooku that we haven't done yet, which I'd really love to do.
Speaker 4So we'll have a lot of great content.
Speaker 3We'll probably take a break around the holidays at the end of the year, but we will have a couple good episodes for you, so please keep sticking around. Of course, you can find all of Paul's hoppy stuff under Zen Madman, and you can find Professor Matthew Kapel under that name and also at the links we will have in our show notes, and of course everything I do is under the name The Ethical Panda. You can just go to the Ethical Panda dot com or you can find us on Twitter, Facebook, all the places. If you want to email us, it's Matthew at Theethical Panda dot com. Although
Speaker 3hopefully I now have my other email addresses auto forwarding. Apologize didn't have that working for a while.
Speaker 4But would love note to think. Tell us for your feedback, tell us your thoughts. What'd you love about this episode? What are you.
Speaker 3Thinking for cassing in in a couple of years. What are you excited about next coming for Star Wars. I think we have Bad Match coming, we have Ahsoca coming, we have a lot of new content coming soon.
Speaker 4So on behalf of myself, Matthew and Paul. I just want to say, as we in the US at.
Speaker 3Least get ready to go into a time of giving thanks for the things that are good in our lives, tied up with a.
Speaker 4Whole bunch of really awful.
Speaker 3I mean, Matthew, talk about mythology. The Thanksgiving story has been a horrible event that's been mythologized, but putting even that aside, I just want to say thank you to all of you for listening, thank you for writing in, thank you for supporting us. This podcast has been such a great part of my life, and I love that so many other people have got involved and it wouldn't happen with that you all the listeners and the supporters, So.
Speaker 4Thank you all so much.
Speaker 3Hope you have a chance to do something great in the next couple of days, whether it's celebrating Thanksgiving or anywhere else in the world. Just you know, take some time to say thank you to the people and the things in your life that are at least going halfway decent. So thank you all so much, and have a good day.
Star Wars Generations is going on hiatus for a few months. We’ll be back in December to get you ramped up for Ahsoka Season 2! **************************************************************************This episode is a...
Would you give up your name to save your life, if a tyrant demanded it first? Matthew Fox and Erin McGowan open Star Wars Generations’ new episode-by-episode watch-through of Star Wars: Visions Presents - The Ninth Jedi...
Can lightsabers work like mood rings for your soul? Matthew Fox and Erin McGowan get listeners ready for "Star Wars: Visions Presents - The Ninth Jedi," the new eight episode series expanding two existing Visions shorts...
What happens when the people who raised you decide you’re guilty before you get a chance to prove otherwise? Matthew and Erin spend this episode of Star Wars Generations on one of “The Clone Wars”’ most consequential...
Before he became the paranoid revolutionary from Rogue One, Saw Gerrera was a scrappy fighter who thought sheer force could win a war. Matthew, Alex, and Erin head back to "The Clone Wars" Season 5 for the Onderon arc,...