For our last rebroadcast, lets go back to the origins of Star Wars! What is The Hidden Fortress, and how did it influence George Lucas as he came up with Star Wars? Paul Hoppe joins me to talk about this Kurosawa classic about peasants and samurai in feudal Japan.Paul Christopher Hoppe AKA ZenMadman is a writer, teacher, and student of poker, chess, language, and life. Find out more here:http://zenmadman.com/ ZenMadman.comhttps://patreon.com/zenmadman ZenMadman on Patreon ZenMadman on Twitch.TVhttps://twitter.com/zenmadman ZenMadman on X We’ve started the conversation. Now we want to hear from you!Want to continue the discussion with us? Agree or disagree with what we talked about, or add your own thoughts? We’ve got options for you! Discord: Join in the conversation about this podcast, my other podcast Superhero Ethics, as well as the rest of the TruStory.FM Podcast Email: ✉️ swg@theethicalpanda.com 𝕏: SWGenerations Facebook: TheEthicalPanda Instagram: SWGenerationsPod TikTok: TheEthicalPanda Visit Star Wars Generations on TruStory.FM for more information, contact info, and more! You can find more about Alex Kormann’s work on Instagram or on his website. To see more of Erin McGowan’s cosplay adventures and fandom thoughts, check out her Instagram or Tiktok. Want to support the podcast AND get ad-free episodes and bonus content? Become a supporting member of The Ethical Panda Podcasts! Members get access to bonus content with (almost) every ad-free episode of this and my other podcast, Star Wars Universe Podcast, and we’ll be adding more benefits soon, including access to live streams!You can subscribe for $5 a month, or get a discount with an annual membership for $55.Plus, you'll be showing your support for this show and all things Ethical Panda. Visit our home on TruStory FM to learn more.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Here's another show you can enjoy in the True Story FM family of entertainment podcasts. Hey, Pete, ever wonder what Steven Spielberg's favorite film is?
Speaker 2You know, Andy, I've heard he loves classics like Lawrence of Arabia, Meme, and Saint Louis.
Speaker 1Imagine chatting with him about why those films resonate with him so much.
Speaker 2That's exactly what we do on our podcast Movies We Like. We've had incredible guests like actress Dee Wallace, cinematographer Eric Measureschmidt, director Steve Miner, and former Disney animators Tom and Tony Bancroft.
Speaker 1They share their favorite films and the impact they've had on their careers, offering fascinating insights into the craftsmanship and storytelling techniques that make these movies so special.
Speaker 2If you're curious about the magic behind the scenes, subscribe to Movies We Like from True Story FM on your favorite podcast app. New episodes are released on the fourth Monday of each month, with early access.
Speaker 3For our members.
Speaker 1Join us on Movies we Like as we explore the movies we all like with the people who make them.
Speaker 2And Stephen our people will call your people. Let's make this happen.
Speaker 1Bobby, subscribe today.
Speaker 4What's up, Most excellent friends.
Speaker 3It's Christy and Nathan from the Most Excellent Eighties Movies Podcast.
Speaker 4It's a podcast where a filmmaker and a comedian and their most excellent guests adventure their way through the eighties movies we think we love or might have missed with our grown up eyes to see how they hold up.
Speaker 3Join us for delightful discussion, rollicking recaps.
Speaker 4Ratings, and deep cut recommendations. Plus members get some extra fun chit chat with the hosts after the show.
Speaker 3Download the Most Excellent Eighties Movies Podcast today at true Story dot fm.
Speaker 4Or find it wherever the finest podcast are stored.
Speaker 5And do remember to keep the Most Excellent Eighties Movies Podcast.
Speaker 3Motto in mind.
Speaker 4Be excellent to each other and party Yon.
Speaker 5Dude's Hello and welcome to this the last of the rebroadcast episodes of the Star Wars Generations podcast. Next week will be back to new content, but for now. How many times have you heard someone say that George Lucas was inspired that one of his main sources of inspiration was the samurai movies he grew up watching. Well, there's one in particular that was very clearly a large influence, called The Hidden Fortress. It has plot points, scenes, dialogues that are taken almost shot for shot, straight into Star
Speaker 5Wars in ways that you would never quite imagine. It's a great movie all on its own, but it's just so fascinating to look at it and see how much it influenced what George Lucas wanted putting on the screen that we all love still to this day. So please check out this episode. You can watch the movie beforehand, The Hidden Fortress. I believe it's available on Amazon Prime. But even if you don't watch it, don't worry. We're gonna give you a summary, let you know what's going on and most importantly, how it connects to Star Wars. So please enjoy this. Please think about becoming a member sending us feedback. We always love to hear that. We'll be back next week with new content. We have spoken.
Speaker 5Hello and welcome to this episode of Star Wars Universe podcast. Asked today, myself and Paul Hoppy are going back into the historical depths. We're talking about a movie called Hidden Fortress. It's a Japanese movie from the fifties that is known to have greatly influenced George Lucas as he was coming up with the ideas for Star Wars. We're going to talk about that and a good deal of feedback. Yess. I promise we're finally getting around to it all that more. After a commercial break that I really hope is not from Struck Companies, Welcome back to Matthew, your host. I'm
Speaker 5joined as somewhat frequently by very much not a co host occasional guest, Paul. Happy Paul. How are you doing today?
Speaker 3We are doing medium today. Okay, you know, the weather's terrible, but at least I got to watch an excellent, you know, old time movie last night and get to talk about it with my dear friend today, so you know.
Speaker 5Yeah, thanks. It's kind of funny to me that you suggested this one, especially because one of the things that I've gotten into recently are the Godzilla movies, which are really quite good depending on what you're looking like. The first one is actually just a great movie overall. The later ones are just you know, it's guide to you movies, but are really fun. And so when you suggested another Japanese movie from the fifties, I was like, cool. This is kind of becoming my brand at the moment. Before we jump into that, though, I want to do a little bit of feedback at the very start, and then we'll do most of it at the end. We got
Speaker 5a great message actually through Patreon from Dylan Diggs. Dylan is a long time commentary and listener on both of my podcasts as well as a lot of the Stranded Panda podcasts. Dylan and I have some very big political gulfs between us, and I know Dylan sent me an email that I'm going to Dylan out to promise, but for everybody, I own to respond to what Dylan wrote on Patreon. This was after the message the episode that Rieky and I did about the strike, about what the podcast was going to do during the strike and how I was gonna be contributing twenty five percent of my Patreon to the strike going to the Entertainer Fund going forward.
Speaker 5Dylan wrote, I just become a patrear because of this cast today. My mother has been in sag her whole life. I don't always agree with Matthew, even necessarily on if Rebels is crossing the line, but appreciate the thoughtful approach you're taking to this every time I listen. I know the content produced here is handled with care. I'll apol respond as well, but I just want to say, don't thank you so much? Really means a lot to me. I agree that the FLUIDNT hear the episode. We were talking about why we were not going to continue covering Rebels, and you know, one thing that and I'll talk more about my stance in general at the end of the episode and give Paul a chance to comments as well.
Speaker 5Want to make very clear that at the very beginning there are specific rules being put out for actors and actor and potential you know, members of the unions. I'm not that, but then separate from that are guidelines where it's kind of like, hey, here's things we're asking content creators to do, you know, consequences if we don't. And Rebels I think itself was kind of edge case. I think because Rebels was made is animation and has been very very clear voice actors and animation are not part of the SAG union to the exampt that SAG specifically
Speaker 5said if actors want strike want to do voice acting for animation, they're very welcome to do so. I still decided that I didn't want to kind of use that. It's not a technicality, it's a valid point, but but it still didn't feel right for me, especially because now we've heard that the number of voice actors in animation are organizing a union themselves, which is kind of awesome specifically for WB. I'm curious to see where that will go. But yeah, so that would I wanted to Later in the episode, we're going to explain more of our stance pause and thoughts on that, but I want to just kind of say first to Dylan, you know, thank you so much, really appreciate the thought, and I'm glad that,
Speaker 5you know, people of very different stances on a whole bunch of issues can at least agree on this.
Speaker 3Yeah, and I'll just add to that that, I mean, my parents are both in film unions. I have thoughts about the whole thing, you know, and I won't get deep into that right now, but I do think that there is a sort of there's you know, what they're asking for, what they're telling you, which maybe I have some thoughts on that, but then also like just the spirit of the thing. Yeah, it's like I think there's something to be said for just you know, trying to make an effort listen to to what people are asking you to do to help in you know, really finding
Speaker 3kind of more of the imperial forces. It's like, I don't don't I don't like how the rebels always do everything, but I'm like, well, the Empire's definitely worse. Yeah. And then here also just I mean, a lot of voice actors in animation are in SAG right, right, They're just not operating. They're not doing SAG you know, union work, because it's it's just a voice. It's not their physical imager.
Speaker 5I don't know, yeah, exactly, it's considered a different kind of work. And maybe it's for me the case. Maybe we'll find out more about that. So anyway, let's now get into Hidden Fortress, which is a Japanese made movie. I think it kind of goes about saying, but you know, one of the reasons why we're looking at a lot of Japanese made stuff, I'm gonna be doing some stuff on BBC content, hopefully some stuff from South South Asia, you know, Bollywood and Hollywood and other content like that, stuff from all around the world, and if you suggestions please let us know. Is because it's hard. It's good
Speaker 5to remember sometimes that that Hollywood doesn't actually control all of movie making, and it never has, and there's always been a huge amount of cinema and TV shows being made outside the US by completely non often union it's not always depending on the country, but totally outside of that studio system that is being struck by the SAG and the Writers' Union. So that guy, we're looking at it, and Paul, why don't you kind of take it away? Why why was Hidden Fortress something you suggested?
Speaker 3Yeah, first, I just want to quote in reference to what you said, something I saw recently that if you know it, you know it. You know I didn't leave acting. I left Hollywood. Is a quote from something that we both saw recently that I think it's you know, Hollywood often thinks Hollywood is movies, Hollywood is acting, Hollywood is TV. Right, Yeah, but it's not. It's a place where some of it's made. Yeah, Hidden Fortress. I was thinking, you know, you were talking about not wanting to cover any of these things out of respect for the strikes and you know, Star Wars,
Speaker 3and then you were talking about things that were non you know, not Hollywood unions, right, that aren't directly related here, and so I was thinking, well, if you want to do something for Star Wars, why not do the film you know that was made nineteen years before you know, a New Hope, and you know, George Lucas said was a large part of the inspiration for I mean, after watching it, I think some of the plot mechanics, yep, you know, uh, there there are a lot of similarities, which I don't know how much we're gonna We're gonna
Speaker 3dig into those we can, but yeah, I just also like, I know, my dad loved a care of course howa. My mom loves a care of course howa. And like I I think I've only seen The Seven Samurai, Like I've never really had a big like Japanese cinema. I'm gonna look watch a bunch of movies, you know. And part of that is sometimes these days I'm like, well, I'll just wait till I actually learn Japanese and then I'll watch a bunch of and I'm like, okay, but I'm like trying to learn like three different Chinese is already,
Speaker 3so like that might be more of a ten year plan. So I was like, let's enjoy this movie now. And we'll circle back to more more others later.
Speaker 5You know, drive clarity. Is this a Kurosawa movie or do you.
Speaker 3Mean that this Yes, this is a This is a movie directed by Akira Kurosawa.
Speaker 5I thought after that's what I thought, Yeah.
Speaker 3Yeah, yeah, after he'd had some success in the West with some of his movies, but apparently, from what I understand, hadn't had as much success in Japan, and so this is I think one of the movies that kind of helped him achieve more success in Japan. That's from my very surface level, you know, googling and watching a few things about it. And it also has Toshio Mifine, who George Lucas actually one into cast as Obi Wan Kenobi Hu,
Speaker 3and who I think, for a long time was was you know, the most I mean, probably to this day, the most recognizable face in like from Japanese cinema, right and to the west, most recognizable face of the West, right. And so you know, not having been around in the fifties, I didn't I don't know what it was like these movies being out and how they were received, you know, in the United States and elsewhere. But I do know
Speaker 3that both my parents you know, loved them, and I, you know, I wanted to watch it. So I was like, yeah, why not cover that for Star Wars because it's like, you know, it's the back back story exactly exactly.
Speaker 5And if I haven't seen it yet, you know, if you want to go see it, I do think it's very good. I'm gonna talk a little bit of how accessible it is. We will give a plot summary in a few minutes, but so that either if you have seen the movie and help your member, or if you haven't seen the movie but to want to hear us talk about it, you'll get it. But I want to say a few other non spoiler comments first, and it's maybe by the way of helping to encourage you to watch it. I've said often that I find it very hard to watch things with subtitles, in part because of my ADHD and then I just you know, probably years
Speaker 5and years of being in front of a screen, it's hard for me to just do nothing but watch a screen. And if I can look away every now and then and still hear the dialogue, I'm fine, Like I'm falling laundry or something like that. When I'm just watching it's harder. One thing I've been finding with these movies, and yeah, I've enjoyed quite a lot of the Cure Soylo movies as well. He did a series of Shakespeare movies that I saw when I started Shakespeare in high school, including Throwne of Blood and rom which are I think Throwne of Blood is a Virgin of Macbeth, and I think Rams are in a king lear, but I saw them twenty five years ago, so I don't Grammary exactly, but
Speaker 5they will very good. But same goes with some of the Godzilla movies is and I think this is partially the style and partially just the time there's the dialogue is fairly slow in that it is often said and kind of a lot like I think a lot of the actors are coming from stage acting, and a lot of the people are getting into cinema are coming from the stage, and so that's they're saying that kind of like you make a declarative statement and then someone else makes a claire of statement a second or two later. And there's also just lots and lots of panning shots
Speaker 5of establishing the scenery, of showing you the army of the fight scenes that are happening where people are grunting and you know, maybe throwing at an insult every now and then, compared to like some of the anime I've tried to watch, for example, I just think the number of words per minute is far less, and so for me, I think that really helps me watch as well, because I enjoy those visuals and I probably lose a little bit by not, you know, having my eyes on the screen the whole time. I do probably watch it, you know, far more than I do some other things. But because
Speaker 5it is slower, because it's it, because the dialogue isn't rapid paced, and because there's all these kind of sweeping establishing shots, I find, as someone who struggles with subtitles, that it's a lot easier to watch, so that you might be kind of further And I think that is certainly helped by it being like I'm sure movies that are being made about you know, I don't know what the equivalent to like a rom com was, or you know, a movie that's much more talkie. It's not about like ancient you know history or you know, sweeping fighting or you know, things like that. They may be different from
Speaker 5Japanese moves at the time. But stally, the ones I've seen like this that are kind of like Samurai epics or things like that, I just found it much easier to watch.
Speaker 3Yeah, it's interesting that you say that. I actually found the subtitles harder to read because they're like written in white on black and white. It's a black and white thum. Yeah. And but having said that, there's not a ton of dialogue, right, there's not a ton of exposition there. A lot of the story is told through moving pictures, right there are there are long period there's probably multiple time when there's just minutes at a time without dialogue where there's you know,
Speaker 3and sometimes it's like there's a scene where it's like, okay, this is like two minutes long or five minutes long, and these days it would be like twenty seconds long or ten seconds. You know. It's like specifically they're climbing up this this like mountainous hill kind of thing, right, and there's all these rocks and they're stumbling and whatever, and you know, I think it's it's supposed to be you know, kind of physical comedy, right, And maybe it doesn't hit quite the same way now that it did then, or maybe in the US compared to Japan. I don't know,
Speaker 3but there are a lot of things where it's like, yeah, this this probably goes on a little longer than it would be indulged today. Like if you actually look at the number of scenes per movie or scenes per minute kind of, or you know, how many minutes long an average scene is, it's way lower now, right, it's like, do what you're there to do? Getting get out, boom next scene. And just in general, I mean, you know, I grew up watching a lot of movies from the thirties and forties and fifties because you know, my parents were both so into film and worked in film, and
Speaker 3so I think that pacing doesn't really bother me. But I do think I could feel in the beginning. I was like, you know, this is taking a while to get going, So it might it might take, you know, twenty thirty minutes to really feel for a modern viewer maybe to kind of get into it. But at the same time, there is stuff going on, and the dialogue isn't isn't the dominant force right, And a lot of the in the dialogue, like the tone of voice, the
Speaker 3way something's conveyed, is it tells you most of like the meaning anyway.
Speaker 5Yeah, I think it's very true. I think it's very which is a credit to the actors.
Speaker 3Again, absolutelytely.
Speaker 5And I will say I think again I by know me as an exalustive study of Japanese cinema from the time I've watched a couple of Carosylo movies and a couple of Godzilla movies, and like one or two others. But I will say, especially in those Godzilla movies that have more recently, it's very much the same. Like there are scenes where whatever monster, often Godzilla, but some of their Kaiju is starting to We're seeing that it's terrible and horrible and destroying buildings, and that destroys more buildings, that enjoys more buildings. Part of me is like, look, there's a guy in a rubber suit who gets to
Speaker 5stamp all over these toy houses. He's having fun. Let him have fun. It's great, But it definitely is like, Yeah, in a modern movie, this would be very different. One thing I'll also say, though, is that, particularly for this movie here we're going to kind of get in spoiler section, but I'll just say this one last thing and then definitely, if you want to see it, I would say stop. But I think for people who are Star Wars fans specifically and are watching it knowing that this is George Lucas's inspiration or one of them, you'll know that from the first shot. And that certainly helped me a lot, because it starts with two people arguing as they're kind
Speaker 5of in the midst of warfare, trying to figure out what to do, and now we'll get more into because boiler section, and then what happens is they decide to they have a fight, they go into different directions, and both of them get captured by the same group of people and then reunited and they're super happy to see each other. And I was like, oh, okay, okay, I get it, and we'll talk more about that. But Paul, when you first to keep kind of a quick summary of the of the plot.
Speaker 3All right, here is the quickest summary I can allow myself. R two and three po I'm sorry. Tahi and Matashi are two peasants who sell their homes to travel to the front and join the war between the Yamana and Akizuki clans, only to revive light and be mistaken for defeated Akizuki warriors then pressed into bondage and servitude for Yamana. They're forced to dig for gold in an old Akizuki fortress, and when their fellow prisoners pull it one way out, they wind up escaping and stumbling upon the gold elsewhere
Speaker 3hidden in sticks. A samurai named make Be Roku Rota stumbles upon them as they stumble upon is hidden fortress, and he decides not to kill them when they explain their plan to escape Akizuki territory by going straight into Yamana first to get to Hayakawa. So he likes their plan. He's like, okay, I won't kill them. Rokuota's main goal and his driving force of the movie is protecting Princess Yuki, who's the sole heir to the Akizuki clan, to the
Speaker 3point where he sends his own sister as a decoy to be murdered in her place. Lots of stuff happens. Tahei and Matashi repeatedly try to betray the Akizuki characters. Rokuota has a duel with an old foe, wins doesn't kill him, and then after being captured, Yuki wins this guy over by singing and demonstrating that she's a compassionate leader and wouldn't have had his face zukoed by like his lord did. He has a big scar on his face.
Speaker 3Tatakoro betrays this this is this general. He betrays Yamana, and everyone escape and lives happily ever after, except for roku UTA's sister, who is still dead without a head.
Speaker 5Yes, yes, good summary.
Speaker 3I think under one hundred seconds. I couldn't do a minute, but I did under one hundred seconds.
Speaker 5Yeah, let's talk about Let's first talk about kind of the way in which we can see how this inspired Star Wars, and then talk about some parts of the movie itself. To me, I think one thing that really because I think there are times where I think you look at a Western movie and then watch the movie that it was also made, like, oh, this is a Western remake of that movie, like right.
Speaker 3Like The Departed, which is like shot for shot from Infernal Affairs.
Speaker 5Shot shot for Internal Affairs, the Magnificent Seven, which is a remake of the Seven Samurai, and that one. Like Kurasawa and john Ford, My understanding is like they were friends, like this was not like they kind of communicated about it sure, and john Ford is definitely a big Admyra Kurrosawa. This is not a remake. There's massive plot differences, for sure, but you have three characters who I think are very clearly inspirational, and as you said, like the very, the very the Jawa scene is straight out of this movie with these two guys, I think art and I think
Speaker 5it particularly also helps inform it that when you remember that Lucas's first idea was to make a movie where the droids were the only were the two main characters, and other stuff was happening around them, and so you sort of get like, if he had made that movie, I just don't think it would be a remake, but it probably would have been closer to this, you know, because there isn't like a Han and a Luke that there's one character who's kind of Obi Wan plus Han and a little bit of Jaba and a little bit of all the Radian Palace Guard.
Speaker 3Yeah, I was gonna say it was like Anna, Luke Slobi basically exactly. Know, it's like all of those this one character got split up into a bunch of and in early versions of Star Wars, I think Luke and Han were the same character, yeah, I think character, and then they kind of got you know.
Speaker 5Yeah, and then so the adventures they have I think becomes very different. But you can see that there's a lot of similarities, and certainly the Princess I think is very much an inspiration for Princess Leah. We talked about how, even in the seventies, to have Princess Leah not be a damsel in distress, but to be I mean, she technically is, but then she you know, she starts yelling at her captors and telling her they're too short and that their plans are stupid, and she takes over and she's active and she fights, and I think having they
Speaker 5make a point in this one of saying that the princess her father didn't have a son and so they raised her as a boy, and so she wears pants and she has a stick that she uses, and she has some fighting ability and you know, and I think that there's kind of some older people who are sad about that, but I think we're prety most supposed to be that's kind of dumb, because she's just awesome, and so yeah, it was kind of fun. I think those three especially are very much like in rations for the three people who get.
Speaker 3Into the movie. Absolutely, yeah, yeah, just very direct, very clear. Yeah, she wears she wears shorts. Everyone wears shorts. Yes, like they're not wearing pants most of the time. It's like like pretty short shorts too, which you know, I don't know. Yes, it's interesting.
Speaker 5Yeah, definitely like pants as opposed to a skirt or a dress or a kimono.
Speaker 3Yeah for sure.
Speaker 5But yeah, there's a couple of and I don't think this is done for titillation factor, it's just historically accurate. There are a couple of people who are basically men who are wearing like the loincloft garment that like protects you in the front and then just goes up through.
Speaker 3The back and the back is just kind of the back.
Speaker 5We call it the thong. And it's like, oh yep, that guard is cheeked out, and there we go. Something we have not yet seen in Star Wars, and I think probably won't and probably.
Speaker 3For the best.
Speaker 5Yeah, I'm okay with What other kind of connections do you see between this and Star Wars?
Speaker 3Yeah, so, I mean, I I think those are the really obvious ones. I mean, also, you know, Princess Leiah is like the last of her planet. I mean not necessarily literally, but like her whole planet gets destroyed. Here, the princess is her whole her clan got destroyed, right, So that's that's a very direct kind of thing. There's also a you know, a lengthy duel between two old.
Speaker 5That like.
Speaker 3Antagonists. I don't know, I don't know how to describe them. Like basically, there's there's the duel between Kota and uh Tatakoro, and it's like it's just really long speir duel, which which I think we can get into and I don't. I don't understand spear combat at all, so like I was a little confused. I don't know how much it's supposed to be realistic or or what, but it's it's like really long, and it the duel between Obi wan
Speaker 3and Vader, you know, reminds me of that. Yeah. And then also the you know, this is kind of the the antagonist that we spend the most time with mostly Yamana, is this like faceless you know antagonist clan. We don't know if they're evil, and like, you know, Akizuki is like good, right, it's just like they're antagonists. I think historically they were like on different islands. So this isn't like really meant to be too much of a historical take. It feels like it takes place in the eighteen hundreds, uh, right,
Speaker 3when there's still swords, there's still spheres, but there's also guns, you know, like one shot guns basically right.
Speaker 5But yeah, yeah, I'll just say, yeah, it could even be seventeen hundreds. Rifles made it to Japan of the sixteen hundreds with Portuguese and I think these kind of rifles seventeen eighteen hundreds. But one thing I think.
Speaker 3That so it could be earlier. Yeah.
Speaker 5One thing I think that it's definitely showing is I think this is something that you see in Star Wars, is you know, the tension between the martial artist and the nameless guy with a gun and the idea of like, are you like a skilled warrior who belongs this warrior tradition and culture in which I mean the Jedi are very similar to samurai in a lot of ways. For sure, they're very similar to a white person.
Speaker 3They're intended to be. They're very clearly inspired by the idea of samurai that one might have growing up in California.
Speaker 5Yes, I think it's a perfect way to say it, and and versus like, you know, the nameless, faceless soldiers with guns and that that whole thing is a theme that in Japanese history that plays out a lot with the you know, the industrialization in the nineteenth century and stuff like that.
Speaker 3The R.
Speaker 5Rory Kenshin movies, which we've talked aboutout before, definitely cover that in course. Yeah, but I think all that was you were talking about the duel itself, so continue with that.
Speaker 3Right, No, I mean basically the duel. It feels to me like it served as partial inspiration for you know, Vader and Kenobi, these two people who knew each other for a long time, and here they're dueling for the first time. He's like, I never got to face you. You know, I always regretted that. And it's like okay, and he's like a duel and it's like, you know it in the in context, you know, roku Uta is like surrounded by dozens or hundreds of enemy soldiers and he's just like, oh, you want a duel, and then they duel and then he leaves, like you know, it's
Speaker 3like it's like, yeah, it's you know, and it's respected that that's the result of the duel. Is says I lost, you know, and he's like, why didn't you kill me? He's like, you're supposed to kill me. But then later that guy you know who Luke doesn't kill, I mean who Vader who Umi doesn't kill He ends up turning on the Empire and freeing them. Right, so that like the end of Return of the Jedi actually feels like maybe it's not super directly inspired, but it's like it's the same idea of like, you know, the the sort
Speaker 3of head general, the right hand whatever of the the main the imperial power or hear, you know, the rival clan turns on their own team because after they get spared, and it's like it's not he's paying him back for sparing him, it's because you know, Princess Yuki demonstrates the power of song like she's basically like, you know, you didn't fail me, because the you know, Roku Rota is
Speaker 3like I failed you. You know, this is all for nought and she's like, no, it wasn't. I got to see people as they really are, you know.
Speaker 5When they're in the wonderful and they all think they're going to die.
Speaker 3Yeah, yeah, exactly after they've been captured at the end, and it's like, well they've they've basically failed in their mission, and she's like, no, but I got to actually see the world, you know, I was in a way that I wouldn't have ever gotten to see it if I was just living in a castle with people coming and paying tribute and treating me like a princess, you know. And then that compassion for you know, her basically failed servant, right who didn't succeed in doing what he was trying to do for her. I think turned you know, Tatokoro,
Speaker 3who is just like, oh, yeah, maybe maybe things don't have to be awful. Yeah, you know, maybe maybe it doesn't have to be like if you fail, then you get your face slashed across and you get beaten so hard that you know, you're like so, I think.
Speaker 5That's a very important point. And again I'm not Japanese, but I have not like an expert in the history, but the one thing I've studied a lot is is World War Two and the time period after that and sort of cultural shifts and how cinema often displayed them. And one thing I know is that that's often talked about is that, you know, a big part of kind of the lead up to World War Two was kind of a government of the military that had a lot of a military spirit of the time in which you know, yeah,
Speaker 5honorable death in combat was, you know, what you looked for, and that to to not die was was shameful, and that to be taken prisoner or not commit suicide or die fighting was often considered very shameful. And you know, and so do I know this for sure, No, but I have a strong suspicion that that was a very intentional thing of he thought he was supposed to die in combat and then not only does he not and get punished for it, but then again when he switches sides, there's a moment where he's like, you know, you go,
Speaker 5I will you know, fight just to protect you. And you're like, dude, we've got a free horse come along. And he's like, yeah, well.
Speaker 3Do I just go with you?
Speaker 5And to me, that was a very pointed, like yeah, you know, that whole idea of like, you know, you have to honorably die instead of just getting away like yeah, maybe not the best. So I really appreciated that for sure.
Speaker 3Yeah, yeah, I it's funny because it was getting towards the end and like there was one thing that I really didn't like that we can you know, talk about. And then like there at the end, I was like, oh, it's going to have one of these endings where like they just all get killed, because like, yeah, that's just that's the way some movies end, you know. And then it was like, oh, it had this this kind of happy ending. Oh that's like uplifting and you.
Speaker 5Know, and I think that's very much intentional because after she sings that song, there's like a line or two of dialogue and then it all goes black and it stays black for a good second. And I was under the hands that was the end of the movie and I was like that's pretty metal, Okay, I can dig that. And then it comes back out escape and all that kind of stuff.
Speaker 3So yeah, and if you want the unhappy ending, you can just stop the movie there and be like, yeah, it's very sad, yes, tragic, they all died, that's how things go. So this is you can pretend it's a Game of Thrones whatever.
Speaker 5This is more on the movie making side of things. I do know a little bit about spear fighting, you know, because something that like I think spears are often thought of is just throwing weapons. They're not, and that the fight style that we see where it's kind of a sword fight with very long swords and just the blade is at the end. Watching it, though, there are two things that I noticed as I was watching it. One is that and this is something we talked about some after the scene in Rebels. I'm about to spoil something from season three of Rebels or no season four of Rebels.
Speaker 5I'm going to spoil something from Rebels. You haven't seen all of it. Maybe skip ahead for thirty seconds where Obi Wan kills Drouth Maul and it's not an epic duel. It's like three slashes of lightsabers and he's dead. And part of that's because that actually is how a lot of Samurai sword fights went. And in this movie, when people use swords, often the other person's killed like almost immediately spears. I feel like, if you wanted to shoot a it may be historically accurate that longer duels with
Speaker 5spears made more sense. But also I think that given the technology of the day and what they were doing filming, the kind of samurai sword fight that we're used to, just because they're very close to each other. The swords are moving very quickly and slashing against each other, and often you think about in fights like that, they're constant camera angle shifts. I think it would be very difficult to do that, especially in the kind of style that they're doing, and so having the fight be the two of them basically always being six feet apart, so they
Speaker 5could be separately miked, among other things and kind of poking up.
Speaker 3I wouldn't be confident that they were separately miked for what it's worth, yeah, in nineteen fifty eight.
Speaker 5Yeah, in a way, I think it would probably harder if they're like as close to each other as they are in a sword fight. But also it allows for that, Like it's probably like a five minute scene with maybe twenty or thirty seconds of actual like spears hitting each other. It's a lot of like Perry thrust back away circle for a little bit attack Perry thrust, et cetera, back away again.
Speaker 3And there was a lot of shouting right like like kiying yeah exactly, like, which is like it's as a martial artists, I'm like, oh yeah, that yeah, I mean, I've I certainly had plenty of fight. I had one fight. It's like it was like four minutes. I think it was two two minute rounds. It might have been two ninety second rounds. And like, I don't think anyone really threw anything in the first minute. It was just like, you know, you're just trying to get a read, trying to see how someone responds if you throw this faint, that faint, you know, you shout at them and see if it like freezes them. You know, it's like it's a thing. And it was just interesting to see that
Speaker 3in the context of like a spear fight, which I'm like, I don't really know how these weapons work. Yeah, but like it was it still it felt like it had a lot of drama very much.
Speaker 5It was not boring in the slightest. It made me think about how if this was being done in a modern movie. Often you'd intercut all those scenes of them kind of circling with shots of people in the crowd watching, or like someone back to someone else, so like that kind of a.
Speaker 3Thing, yeah, or you would cut to the other scene with the peasants, and then you would come back to this exactly exactly make it feel faster.
Speaker 5Does you know more about martial arts? I know you fight unarmed obviously, but does that and you also know more about filmmaking than I do? Does that make sense that idea of that the spear fight might just kind of work a lot better. Maybe it's more storically accurate, but also just kind of work better for what they're doing and the technology they have at the time.
Speaker 3A little bit so in terms of the mics, like I I think they probably just had like one mic. Yeah, you know most of the time, is my guess. I'm not certain, but but yeah, in terms of them kind of you get you know, you're gonna have broader shots basically, right, there's I do know that Krosawa was like known for also for sword fights. And I actually this morning trying to trying to find a source of like a Japanese
Speaker 3speaker saying some of the names, you know, I was, I was looking at something and and I mean, I'm I'm sure I'm still not going to do a great job, but you know, I'm gonna do my best. But like I was watching a scene where he's talking about it's a Tatsuya Nakata in about shooting Sandro and he has a scene where he's like facing directly Tosh and like
Speaker 3it's I watched the scene. They show the scene. It's like seconds long, you know, And I was like, I feel like Dave Filoni watched this just before writing that exact scene that you mentioned about Maul and Obi Wan, you know, and like maybe not, you know, maybe not. There's there's a lot of sword fights throughout history. But I was just like, and he was talking about how they did the fight, you know, and and how they went about it, and that it was like that the process was you know, it was it was like surprising and like nobody knew exactly how it was going to go. And I think the script actually said the action that
Speaker 3will take place cannot be described in words on the page, you know, So like I do imagine that a spear fight provides a different sort of the opportunity for a different kind of spectacle, a different kind of tension. And but also like you know, if sword fighting is generally going to be more like you know, it's over, then well if it's a duel, and it's like, you know, I've been looking forward to this for a long time,
Speaker 3it's like, yeah, let's let's do spears. You know, like, do you want to play a game of bullet chess or you want you want to play a classical game, let's play, let's play daily. You know, you get to pay for a move, right. It's like so, so I do think there was an idea. I think it's more about the pacing of the fight, but also the framing of it, you know. And they have these big wide shots because they have these spears. They're long spears, and there's they show the crowd. They don't do close ups on the crowd. They not cutting. It's not fast cut, right, but it is like they show the and the crowd like backs up and then comes in they go oh,
Speaker 3you know, it's like there are reactions from the crowd without being like okay, let's let's pull in tight to get a reaction shot.
Speaker 5It's like no, it's you know, in one of the brilliant like oh, look, they just had a state. They just had an actor to do a stage hand move, like so he rides in on this horse, gets off the horse, and then he's like going to different soldiers to test their spears to find the right faryants to fight with. And one of them. He takes the guy's spear like no, it's no good, throws it down, and in shame, the guy walks off to take his horse and then take the horse out of the shot. I was like, that's that's brilliant, Like it makes total sense
Speaker 5you would do that. But also it's like, yeah, how are you gonna have this fight with.
Speaker 3His horse right there?
Speaker 5Yeah?
Speaker 3Yeah, yeah, you gotta you gotta take the horse out of the shot if you're gonna be doing this long combat scene like with a lot of shouting.
Speaker 5One other thing I thought was really noteworthy in that scene is at one point they're kind of battling in this uh kind of a little bit like a like a collection of walls that are made of the flags of the Yanada. Is that what you say it.
Speaker 3Yamana? Yeah it might be yamana, but yeah, yes.
Speaker 5Yamana, thank you of that clan. Their flags are kind of like hung in from these wooden things that are kind of like making their like separations and stuff like that. And during the fight, the the general from that clan, uh, not our hero, is like slashing at at our hero through through the flags and is often cutting them and like creating them open, and I thought that was an interesting bit of foreshadowing that maybe he is more like he's more connected to uh, you know, his fellow samurai
Speaker 5and the Samurai code. Then the clan necessarily that he was fighting for. And again I know a little bits of the history. I know that often like the person might be of the clan themselves, but often they were, you know, a clan would hire a samurai and their troops to kind of work for them and fight, fight wars and stuff like that. So whatever his connection is to the clan, I thought it was just a cool bit of foreshadowing of him, like in his attempt to fight the other samurai destroying the flags of his lord, who winds up right so bad to him?
Speaker 3Right, Yeah, I love that. I didn't pick up on that at all, but that's a that's a great spot. Yeah, and then that's really.
Speaker 5Cool one of the things they're talking about the movie didn't like or other high points.
Speaker 3Who want to mention, Yeah, well, so the one thing I really didn't like was, you know, you were just calling him our hero, and I'm like, I think, like me is like a fantastic actor. He's so good just the moment he walks in. He's just standing there. You know, it's like, oh, that's the guy. You know, this guy is the guy, and like he's awesome and like the character's very cool. A lot of the time he sends his sixteen year old sister to go get beheaded, to like buy like a day's time or something, and distraction,
Speaker 3like it doesn't even work that well, you know, like they figure out pretty quickly. Oh wait, no the prince, that wasn't the princess. Oh, using a double's nothing new, Like geez, monarchy is just the frickin' worst. This is where you know, our our good friends at the you know, Hype is my superpower podcast. We're talking, you know, in our in our little chat thing like about about monarchy. Like if you're telling a story about monarchy, yeah, you know. And I do think it's interesting because here it's like he's basically I am doing my job to serve the monarchy,
Speaker 3and it's like, you know, to the death right for all of us. And and she, the princess, is like I hate it.
Speaker 5I hate it.
Speaker 3I hate it. You know, I'm sixteen, she's sixteen, Like, what's the you know, what's the why should I live and she should die, you know, why should she die? So I can live in like and so I feel like it was at once it was like a little critical of that, like in story right, but at the same time it's like, oh, these monarchies, you know, it's just these.
Speaker 5Yeah, but he and some of her older advisors kind of the point they make is like, no, she was honored to do this. She happily did it, and like, yeah, okay, well I would I wish we could have heard her say that, you know exactly, And yeah, but I do think I think that what they do with the character of the princess is one of my favorite things in the movie. There's another scene where I will say, for me, one of the low points of the movie. It's not quite the Game of Thrones level, and it's never shown,
Speaker 5but the movie is very happy to tell you about the general attitude of women in times of war, the general attitude towards women in time towards war of being you know, things you could buy and sell and use against their consent in whatever ways you wanted to, and that's pretty horrific. Again, it's not shown on screen anyway, which I definitely do appreciate, but one thing that is nice is that and again showing the princess like because she has a little bit of that kind of the innocence of I don't know how the real war works,
Speaker 5but the power to say, but it's dumb. I don't want the word to work like this. And so at one point, which actually is a thing that happens in Game of Thrones, and now I wonder if I was going to say, because at one point she she is in and in and she's listening to these men talk about wanting to purchase her and and how there's another girl who they have already purchased and he's like her her owner, pimp is enslaver is offering her, you know. And so she she goes to the others and it's like you have to buy her, you have to buy her,
Speaker 5and they want selling their horses and like switching to this card system in order to do that. So yes, I like how empowered she is, and I like how much she is like not okay with the way things are. And yeah, that thing about the princess, it's funny that that wouldn't be why I thought that he's not heroic type. It's also because he's kind of an ass to our.
Speaker 3Like our peasant friends, well yeah are peasants, but they also repeatedly try to betray him, like there the.
Speaker 5Awesome Yeah, Like like R two Dito's lovable scamps is something that Lucas uh uh. You know R two and C three po uh turned up. The morality on those two characters going a good deal.
Speaker 3I don't know. I just feel like they're both three po Yeah, that's fair, that's you know, like three PO is like, oh, we've been abducted by these rebels and you know, and then they have to fight and blah blah blah and you know, yep.
Speaker 5Yeah.
Speaker 3Spoilers for Rebels episode three or four.
Speaker 5Yeah, I guess. I don't know if this was intentional or maybe this is just me reading my own politics back into it many years later. I don't like, for the most part, I'm not angry at the peasants because I think part of what you're seeing is like, wait, why does this gold belong to like the princess, you know, and and the nobility, and especially because all that when like the her noble advisors talk, they're very clear to be like they totally look down on these peasants. They
Speaker 5think the peasants are idiot, they're going to use them as scamps and like, yeah, yeah, they don't plan to pay them. And we earlier saw how they kept getting caught up in war like because the other big generals are just like, oh, you look like you might be part of the klan. We're gonna now later. They then talk about doing horrible things to the princess when she's sleeping, and that's when I'm like, yeah, okay, well there went my ability to be you know, kind of on there, so right.
Speaker 3Right, yeah, And to me, it's like if you want to steal the gold whatever, steal the gold, yeah, I mean you get yours, you know, but like if it's like, oh, we're going to turn them in so they can get beheaded and we get like three gold pieces, like you know, no, that's for me that now, you know, But you know, to each their own. I wanted to comment on the kind of the end scene where I felt like, I mean, I share some of your discomfort, you know, but also I kind of liked how they handled it where I feel like they're showing kind of like not even showing
Speaker 3it is more telling, right, kind of like this is kind of how the works in these you know situations, and then the actual outcome was favorable, you know, And I thought it was funny, hilarious, appalling, how like they're all like, oh, well, she's cute, like to the princess, and they're like, oh no, she's mute. Ah, Like, like they're literally trying. They're fine with like sexual slavery, right,
Speaker 3but they're like, oh, but if she's like disabled, you know, like like really that's your that's a deal breaker for you in this scenario. Seriously, And that to me, that that to me speaks of the you know, maybe the ableism of the times as well, right, that like someone wouldn't even be physically attractive because they couldn't speak, Whereas I think I think some you know, some misogynists would would see that as a feature, not a bug. Yeah, but but yeah, no, I I I saw one one
Speaker 3recap that was referring to the girl that they purchased and freed and tried to be like get lost, get lost. She's like, no, I'm sticking with you, who incidentally was of the same clan. Yeah, she'd been captured in the war, right, So I think there's a little bit of like you know, it's she's like, no, that's one of my people, you know, and like I'm responsible for, which I almost like undermines it a little bit. But I saw her referred to, like as a prostitute, and I'm like, I don't, I don't think that's what that word means. I think the
Speaker 3term you're looking for is sex slave, like you know, so yeah, not in a you know, kinky way like in a No, this is literally someone is being imprisoned and forced to you know.
Speaker 5Yeah, like sex work. You would hope that there's least some degree of consent given. Often Unfortunately there's not today, of course, much more often than people think there is. But yeah, I think I agree with you. I think calling her a prostitute really kind of rates that really kind of like puts a veneer on really the horribleness of what's happening to her.
Speaker 3Absolutely.
Speaker 5Yeah, one little detail I I thought about that, one little detail that that threw me and it just got me onto a Google uh uh search for dumb reasons. But so, one of one of the things that is kind of a plot point in the movie, kind of part of the mcguffin of it all, is, as you said, they've hidden these bars of gold that all have the insignia of the of of the princess's clan on them in sticks of wood, and the idea that like they've
Speaker 5hollowed out these sticks that just can look like firewood that people are carrying around and uh, but in them or the gold, and they they find them actually when one of them is like fighting with each other, that the R two and CNP or fighting with each other, and they break the stick and they find it, and it is an ingenious idea. I really like it. I'm kind of curious whatever happened historically. But then they get caught up in a fire festival, which is this like awesome, it's a great scene. It's an awesome kind of like and I'm sure it has a lot of roots in
Speaker 5Japanese history that things like this happened. That's where the princess hears the song that she then sings later. And part of it is they're trying to kind of blend in but people see them with this cart full of what they think is firewood, and I'm like, hey, throw that in the fire. Throw that in the fire. And they can't argue too much or else they'll be suspicious, and so all that gets thrown in the fire.
Speaker 3Yeah. No, but just to clarify, they decide to throw it in the fire. Roku Rota says, throw it in the fire, right right, Yeah, you know, it's the circumstances that compell that. But he's just like, no, just just stick it in. We're gonna be fine, right.
Speaker 5I think he means it in a like cause we're going to be looking suspicious to be captured if we're not, like.
Speaker 3Oh, absolutely, But I'm just saying it wasn't an external force that decided that, like just pushed it in. It's like they decide it, and the peasants are like, no, no, no, He's like, shut up, just do this. This is the way we're going to get through this.
Speaker 5Definitely, And because what happens apparently is that once the fire burns out and everyone's gone, they're able to find all these gold bars in the ashes. Now, at first I thought, since gold was fairly soft, it had a low melting point. I was like, that doesn't make any sense, and I looked it up and it turns out gold actually has one of the highest melting points of any metals. Its melting point is at about eighteen hundred degrees. I think it's like eighteen fifty seven or something like that. This degree is fahrenheit.
Speaker 3That's pretty hot.
Speaker 5Okay, that makes sense. But I was like, what's the temperature out of bonfire? They and then I kept looking and said, oh yeah, in you know big bonfires temperatures walking it up to like two thousand degrees.
Speaker 3That's even hotter.
Speaker 5It's even hotter. And so like the idea that at the end of it they have these still like perfectly pristine bars of gold. I was like, yeah, I'm not gonna roll my eyes too much. It's a little bit of an eye roll, but I don't know if you had people had done that measuring yet that that's fine as a mcguffin, go for it.
Speaker 3Yeah yeah, just just a real momentary just.
Speaker 5I'm using the mcguffin wrong.
Speaker 6Yes, I realized that, yeah, like that's that's not that's that as a plot point, but yeah, yeah, yeah yeah, and just sort of it is a hand wavy like oh yeah, this is fine, And it's like, I mean.
Speaker 3If it says up to two thousand and something, maybe it's not always that. Maybe it's possible. Maybe the reason they could only find some of the gold is because some of it melted and some of it didn't, you know. But yeah, I was also I was like, is that gonna melt? And if it, you know, because there and I think there's metals. Like if you said melt, like the fire will burn a different color? Yeah, you know, so so I don't know. But then maybe people just think, ooh that's super cool, you know, yeah, but like, yeah.
Speaker 5Who knows that anyway, that's our science deep dive.
Speaker 3We can move on now, yeah yeah, yeah, yeah. Maybe the fire did burn a different color and since it was black and white, we just couldn't tell.
Speaker 5Yeah, and who knows. Maybe wood is a good Maybe it's that like you know, by the time the fire actually gets direct directly to the gold, all the wood has burned to ash and so the fire is dying down. Like sure, I don't know. I don't know how hot it gets inside a hollow piece of wood when the piece of wood is on fire. I mean, there are wood ovens, so anyway doesn't matter not.
Speaker 3I shared your kind of like I wonder if this really would work, but you know, okay, it's fine.
Speaker 5But also, I mean, given the amount of plot holes like that that I have with most modern movies. If that's the only one I had, we're winning the movie.
Speaker 3Sure. Yeah.
Speaker 5Any of the comments on the movie you had, not a lot.
Speaker 3I mean I didn't take notes, you know, I just had a few things here that I jotted down while we were chatting. I would say that also, in terms of Star Wars connections, Stormtrooper aim quality seems to be, you know, commensurate with whenever any of these people are shooting at any of the main characters, except for the you know, the freed girl who then does get shot and then is like apparently fine anyway, She's like leave me, leave me, and they're like, no, we'll not leave me. Yeah, we paid five silver for you now. So yeah, I
Speaker 3just like, overall, i'd say I enjoyed it. You know, it took me a little to like really get into, but I mean that's not super uncommon. I mean the Batman, I was like, the first ten twenty minutes, I was like I don't know about this, And by the end, I was like, this is the most well made superhero movie.
Speaker 5Ye.
Speaker 3So, like, you know, because.
Speaker 5There's a long distance from the end in those ten minutes at the start.
Speaker 3Is there is a lot left and this movie is over two hours. Yeah, you know, which you know, I don't. I don't know specifically the fifties, but I know historically for a long time, movies were considerably shorter than they have kind of become recently, you know, so it.
Speaker 5Yeah, I just say quickly on that a lot of movies at the time were shorter. The original Godzilla is like ninety four minutes seven samurais three and a half hours, right. Kirasawa was known like that was one of his things which he shook his time a lot more than.
Speaker 3Other movies exactly, you know, And it's interesting, I mean to me, like apparently, like Corosawa was not loved at first in Japan, like as a filmmaker like films, partially because a lot of people thought it was like did too many kind of Western things, you know, but then also tons of directors and writers in the West, in Hollywood, in you know, other other places, like then we're heavily
Speaker 3influenced by Krosawa. And you know, to me, that's that's a I think it's great when people get influenced by you know, disparate influences, right, and aren't like, oh, I just only want to watch the things that are you know, right here, and it's you know, and I appreciate Lucas saying like, yeah, this movie that I obviously copied a whole lot from, Like I did this, this is the movie, you know, naming it and and not kind of being like, oh, yeah,
Speaker 3I came up with all this stuff in a dream. I had a dream one night. And you know, I do think it's really important to name one's influences. And you know, that doesn't mean that you're you're stealing whatever it is, you know. And I mean, obviously there's this whole lot of stuff that you know, we can talk about in that kind of vein, but like just I think, you know, kind of sometimes you can do something concrete within a film that's like paying tribute to something, and then sometimes it's just like outside of your actual film, you know, just kind of talking about influences. And that's
Speaker 3something as a musician that I think is so super common, you know, and I mean it happens in film as well. I just I guess I kind of wish that people that more people took the time to kind of listen to what their favorite filmmakers talk about learning from being inspired from being inspired by and then go and actually watch some of that, you know, And and I.
Speaker 5Think it's a good point. Like I'll be honest, I don't know if I would have gotten around to watching this without the strike, and I think that's a mistake, sure, you know, especially because like I hadn't know about this one. But the Kirosawa influences are all over Star Wars. And that's both you know, in the in the original movies obviously, but up to you know, the very recent and there's a number there is both an episode of the Clone Wars and an episode of Mando that is very much a remake of The Seven Samurai, which, by the way,
Speaker 5there's something like thirty different TV shows or movies have been inspired. It's an incredible yeah. Yeah, And it's very much kind of the like anytime you think of like a band of misfits and and people whose society has given up on come together to defend a town or end a thing like that, that's a cliche, trope, that's a trope. At Seventh Samurai really kind of started at least in cinema or at least put its stamp on but also, as I said, the Seventh Samurai there, and
Speaker 5then if you heard people talk about how The Last Jedi has the rashaman Uh scene where you have the same scene of Luke confronting Ben when Ben is waking up from three different perspectives, that's something that happened in Rashamaan, which is another Kurasawa movie. So yeah, these influences definitely run deep. And yeah, I'm talking about.
Speaker 3Them, and I just want to mention that one one year, my mom gave me DVDs for The Seventh Samurai and the Magnificent Seven.
Speaker 5Oh cool.
Speaker 3Yeah, so I got to like watch them like back to back and kind of see how you know one in spot I mean, one is a direct adaptation really of the other one.
Speaker 5Very much so. But as you said, also like Seven Samurai has some Western influence, like not Western culture, but like the Western style of movie had some influences on. So yeah, so it's kind of a fun yeah thing around if you still have those dvd as, if we fund do those three movies at some point for a superhero, yeah, yeah, that'll be great. I think it'd be great. All right, Well, again, it's a great movie. Definitely recommend people watch it, recommend that people check check it out, and certainly if you have thoughts about it, either haven't watched it or not, let us know in feedback, because we are I so
Speaker 5much happened. I very much apologize. We have a backlog of feedback. I'm not gonna do like all of it at once. Some of it's rebels specific, so I want to do that when at least Wreaky, but hopefully Wreaky and Sarah with on the podcast. But I want to talk about some of this with Paul now. And first, just we got a couple of comments about the strike, a couple of quick comments, but then one pretticular email that raises a good question that we'll talk about. Some people just you know, very very positive. One sent thank you for taking a stand. I'm excited to get this chance to hear about non screen star Wars union. Strong
Speaker 5you guys rock. One person said they are unsubscribed thing because we have gone too woke, which I was like, what podcast.
Speaker 3Were they listening?
Speaker 5Yeah?
Speaker 3How are you not like.
Speaker 5Every time we get them, because every now and then we do, we do get a message that I'm like, what, I'm deeply offended that you ever heard a full episode and didn't come away thinking we were somewhat woke, Like what the heppened?
Speaker 3I mean, well I have Yeah, Well go ahead.
Speaker 5There you go that you didn't come away thinking that we are what you mean when you say the word woke, which yes, perfect, perfect, Well we did get a full email also from Emma. Emma writes, I appreciate the stand you're taking, and I really hope the actors and writers get what they need. But are you really not going to cover Ahsoka when it comes out? I understand why, but I've gotten so used to watching Star Wars along with you. I'd hate to not have your commentary when the episodes are coming out. Emma. Paul, I'll let you
Speaker 5kind of respond first. Yeah, and just to be clear, it was a decision that I I made unilaterally. Yeah, I did not. Paul was one of the many friends who I talked to about it. But it was my decision, So I'm not I can Paul you defend my decision. Just you know what your thoughts are.
Speaker 3Yeah, I mean, first of all, I'll say I don't know whether I would have made the same decision. You know, I'm not. I don't run a podcast right, Like I enjoy being on your podcast and occasionally on another podcast, but like it's not you know, it's not a big deal for me to not cover a given thing, right. I cover things when I'm like, oh, I love that, I want to talk about it, you know, and then yeah, we might as well record it, right, But like that's kind of where I'm coming from. But I will say also a while ago, I mean, but right at the
Speaker 3beginning of the strike, I was thinking, without anyone saying anything, just like, you know, do like do I want to cover anything? Do I want to be on any podcasts of you know, things that are coming out new? You know, is there a difference between things that are new things that were from before? You know, what kind of what do I want to do with regard to whatever. Also, though, after watching Mandalorian season three, I have like several thoughts on Ahsoka, including like, first of all, I would just always like to watch a series all at once or
Speaker 3in my own rhythm, right, And I don't know, I don't know if I would even want to be doing day by day right, And we talked about a little bit before you came to this decision. I was like, yeah, I probably would be willing to just because I enjoyed the experience of doing it with you and you know, but like but then also like going forward, like I'm like, ah this timeline, I don't like where this timeline goes, Like, you know, I really want to see live action Ahsoka.
Speaker 3I really want to see live action some of the other characters might show up there. I wish it was more in the Rebels time period, you know. But then again, like I don't want her in the and Or show. I think she needs her own show, and those things shouldn't really you know, cross particularly much. But I'll also say like if I mean, first of all, it's up to the producers, right or the studios or whatever, like they can then to strike tomorrow, you know, by just acceding to certain demands or coming to the table and making you know, good faith negotiations. So you know, there's
Speaker 3an extent to which is like you don't know whether you're covering Ahsoka. Right. It seems like they have said they don't want to come back to the table until October, when they think, you know, the writers will be hungry basically like literally like having a hard time paying for things, and you know, that's atrocious, and that makes me go like, well, whatever the unions do that I don't love, like this is clearly worse. And so I know whose side I'm on regardless of like whatever specific actions I want to take. But I'll say another thing, like I tried so long
Speaker 3to get my mom to watch and or because she doesn't she didn't have the thing, you know, to watch it, and she's finally watching it, loving it of course because you know she has taste. No, but and she watches an episode and then she listens to our podcast and then actually actually she watches an episode. She calls, we chat about her impressions of the episode, she listens to the podcast, and then we talk about all these thoughts about the episode, and then she watches another one the next day. So like, you know, I'm not saying you should withhold your your viewing of Ahsoka, but like it's
Speaker 3an option, right, Like I mean, Matthew, I assume you are going to watch Ahsoka at some point, assuming that you know, the strike ever gets resolved, and I assume at that point you'll probably do coverage, possibly episode by episode possibly you know, overall, I don't I don't want to put anything on you. Yeah, right, that's you can talk. But if you do, you know, a viewer can also. It can be your second watch. You know, you can watch it yourself the first time and then watch it the second time. I understand the for me, the reason
Speaker 3I watch things when they come out when I do is because spoilers. Right, It's just like I would love to wait and whatever, but it's just like I'm like, am I going to I literally found out a spoiler for Spider Man No Way Home the day before I saw it, and I didn't see it until it was on streaming it that long. I went that long without like significant spoilers about particular characters appearances, and then I saw the actual spoiler for it, and then the next day I watched it, and you know, I was like, great, yeah, you know, it's like whatever, but you know I feel
Speaker 3you there, you know, Yeah, for sure, Yes, I.
Speaker 5Got a lot of thoughts. I totally appreciate where you're coming from and agree. I think we're mostly in agreement. Again, I want to kind of comment that I think part of what I think is causing confusion is that and I ad meant I was confused for a while and sought out. Hearing from other people is that I think that the you know, the union is doing the best it can. I'm not really putting them at fault for this, but I do think that the communication that's been coming out has been confusing at times. First in part because and I think part of this is how also the
Speaker 5content sphere, and then like I love Neo Gayman, but I think he kind of became a lot of people were looking to him, and some of the stuff he was posting was not necessarily always the most accurate part of it is anything, there's been a lot of confusion again between what are the union rules and how those rules apply to people who want to be in the unions one day versus the things that they're saying of hey, we'd like you to do this if you are supporting the strike.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 5And the further confusion is because right now we're using words like influencer and content creator and no one has any idea what those words actually mean. And there are some definitions by which it is a kind of narrow definition which the union sometimes uses in its language, especially for rules, is when you are doing paid promotion, and there are definitely and this is anything from like, hey, we'll give you free tickets because we know you're going to do you know, you're generally and positive of it,
Speaker 5to like, you know, we're inviting you to the pr to you know, yeah, we have a check with you that we want, you know, make like five you know, tiktoks about this in a week, you know, et cetera. And I think it's a left of folks, a lot of folks like myself, really not sure where we fit. I'm certainly not getting paid money in the studios. I make some amount of money from podcasting. Some is from the Patreon and I love you all from it, but that's still very small amount. Some is from those ads that you hear. It's not my full income, but I
Speaker 5definitely am working. It has been growing steadily, and I would like it to eventually be a significant part of my income, and so I want to There's a part of me, honestly that feels like when I'm staying, oh, I am a content creator and so I am one of the brave ones who sag is asking not to do this, and so I will do it. Part of me is like, am I having delusions of grandeur? Like I, you know, I we get about eight hundred to a thousand downloads for episode, which is definitely good.
Speaker 3We're in like this, Ohsoka, would problem be on the higher end of that?
Speaker 5Yeah, yeah, yeah. When things like Ahsoca come out, when Vanna comes out, we go up into the fifteen hundreds. Often that puts me in I think, like the top ten percent of Star Wars podcasts. But that's because there's tons and tons of podcasts out there that have like three people, or like where they made an episode a year ago and haven't done anything with it since, or something like that. Like the numbers are all over the place. But here's kind of where I eventually came down on it. And first of all, I'll also say something, and this is now kind of getting directly to your question, I
Speaker 5will be honest with you, with everybody, I hope that I would have made the decision if the strike happened a week before Ahsoka came out, But I don't know. What I can't say reality what I would have done. What I can say is I did look at the calendar and did say to myself, I think it is there's a decent possibility that if there's enough good pressure that the union that this will get settled before SOCA
Speaker 5and that that was definitely a factor in my decision. As Paul said, you know, the companies are now saying they want to not you know, do anything until like even October. So it may we'll be we're in that situation. It may well be that. And again I worked in unions for a while, so in a something like union strategy, the kind of full boycott is a it's a bullet and the gun that you don't want to use until you absolutely have to. I was talking with some other
Speaker 5friend union organizer friends of mine from way back in the day. We're all saying that, like, among other things, the union is smart and the if they had tried to ask for a full boycott before Barbie came out, it would have just been a disaster, you know. And like if you look at like the the incredible grounds full of support that movie has and being seen as such a like important feminist movie, I the lines of where exactly you're promoting a movie are not I will
Speaker 5just say I agree with that. Uh, you know, I saw the movie and the fact that I get into though on a second, but you know, just because it was like one of the biggest movies this This weekend was one of the biggest. We're recording this shortly after the bar the Barbinheimer Weekend as it was called, when those two huge movies came out. Do I think there's gonna be a call for a full boycott between now and October? Quite possibly? Do I think it'll happen and then be enough to bring them to the organizing table before Ahsoka comes out in what is now about a month.
Speaker 5A couple of weeks ago, I would have said yes. Now I'm not sure, And so my hope is that at this point in time, I think that we will not cover Ahsoka when it comes out, that we will, as Paul said, do coverage of it. When the strike ends, we will do our coverage of it then. Also, as Paul said, because part of why I did go to
Speaker 5see Barbie and part of why I will watch Ahsoka when it comes out is I don't want to be spoiled. Although having watched Barbie and now not trying hard not to talk about it on social media has been driving me utterly crazy because they're great conversations going on about it, and part of me is like, you know, but I don't want to take part. I don't know if I have the fortitude to not talk about the Ahsoka show if I watch it. What I might even do is like we'll watch the episode, record the episode that week,
Speaker 5and then just put it into the archives and like the minute that the strike ends, drop all these episodes like one a day or something like that. I don't know. Am I going to promise you all now that I absolutely will not watch Ahsoka when it comes out. No, I want to see where things stand. I do think that, as Paul said, the big shows like this are often one of the ways we get in huge numbers of visitors. I'll say that we had I had a whole plan of like week by week things to bring in new visitors to get ready for a SOCA. I'm not doing
Speaker 5that intentionally. It's cost me some potential, but I think it's worth it. I think I probably won't cover AHSOCA when it comes out if the strike is still on going. But I'm gonna see what's being said. I'm gonna see what the union is saying. I think we've had a four more weeks, maybe longer five or six more weeks for other content creators, and like all these conversations to get kind of a little bit more decided. And I will say that part of why I decided to do it is because a lot of the other Star Wars content creators that are really respect also decided not to keep making content. And I was like, I respect your
Speaker 5decision making, and I think that that's a good reason not too as well. I want to see what they do. I want to see what some other folks do. I want to see what happens with the union, Like if the strike is still on, but some real brain throughs have happened, what the union is advising. Certainly, if there's a boycott called for, then I will have canceled the Disney Plus and I won't watch it. I'm fairly certain I won't watch it. I'm fairly certain I won't podcast about it if the strike is to laun But there's a lot of factors and I just want to say, you know, we'll see, We'll see what happens when we
Speaker 5get there.
Speaker 3Cool. Yeah, I actually have a few things I want to say. One one, I wanted to say that I really respect that, you know, the amount of consideration you've given to the whole thing. Yeah, and the fact that you know, you are taking the stand that you feel is right, and that's the only thing anybody can do, yeah right, is say this is what I think is the right thing to do, and that's what I'm going to do. Yeah right. And I mean, you know you're not sending your sister off to get beheaded, like it is an actual sacrifice, right, like you are. You are
Speaker 3giving up money, exposure, and the opportunity to do something you love at a time that it's a very good time to do that thing, you know. So I just want to say that I respect that a lot. Thank you, And then also to the writer of the feedback that I love that you like to watch the thing and then listen to the pod and it's kind of like watching it together. I love that sentiment. Personally, I probably won't. No,
Speaker 3I'm not probably. I'm not going to watch it when it comes out, unless, like you convinced me that like watching it and then recording a thing and then releasing it later like makes sense. I like to not make too big of pronouncements about what future me is going to think makes sense because I always want to be open to an argument that I'm like, I hadn't thought of it that way. Let me think about that. Okay, you make a good point, and I've changed my mind, right. I think the ability to change one's mind is power, right, which is.
Speaker 5Also why I'm not making a declarative statement.
Speaker 3Yeah right. I think it's exceptionally unlikely that I will watch it when it comes out. I'm like, you know, I'm more of a like Haun shot first kind of person where I'm like I would fire the big gun right away and be like, no, I want everybody to stop watching giving you any money like this is you know, and like let's go. But like, you know, it's like at the end of Iron Man too, it's like, why didn't you lead with that thing that just destroyed everything? But like that's fine, But also I don't I don't
Speaker 3actually really give any of these companies money in the first place, so like I'm not really you know, it's like I don't really have any more to withhold from them.
Speaker 5If I start boycotting Paulster that stops watching exactly.
Speaker 3Actually, actually I have alternative sources for things that and I will acknowledge that, yes, then money does go to these things somewhat on my behalf, you know, not not literally directly on my behalf, but like I obtained value from money that is sent to them by various entities. And then just one last thing that I'd say is that I think you know you made it. You brought something up that I think you know. I think solidarity is easier than trying to take a stand alone, you know.
Speaker 3And that's not to undersell the effort that goes into solidarity, but that when a bunch of people who you respect, a bunch of people who can benefit from the situation by not taking a stand, are taking that stand, it's much easier to be not just to go with it and to be like, yeah, we're all going to do this, because first of all, there's a much better chance it's going to have like a significant effect, and second of all, it's not like it's not the same kind of opportunity cost of like, well, I'm missing out on revenue and
Speaker 3they're not, and so they're actually grabbing my market share and whatever. It's like when you know, when there's one crack in the damn kind of like you know the river's going to break free. And historically, personally, I've often been like the things that I've taken stands on are not things were my indo visual action is like causing huge ripples and whatever, you know, But I do. I do like the idea of solidary and I have seen you I'm talking about like being a vegetarian or whatever, right,
Speaker 3I have seen like the the power that like, yeah, when the numbers go up, it causes an effect on industries, you know, like the dairy industry changes its behavior because because there are a lot of people who aren't consuming dairy, right, And it's like being the first or being the last. Who's who finally plugs the dam? Like it doesn't matter, just be you know, if you're I don't know, whatever, do what you think you should do, and I you know, and I just I always have respect for that.
Speaker 5Thank you. I appreciate that. And certainly if there's ever a point, you and I are not always in the same place. And I think have some disagreements where the union stuff in terms of the way the unions are doing things. But I know we're both details very much against the on the side of the strikers. Sure, I can't imagine am when I would be ready to podcast but you weren't, well, I mean schedule, but like where I felt comfortable doing so, and you weren't. But you know, at that time came. Of course I'd always respect that. I would be you know, everyone do what they want they Sure. I do have one potential guest who sometimes
Speaker 5would come on who's like, I don't want to talk about Star Wars in any way, even the books or the content. Yeah, and I respect that, Like, I'll be the first to admit we're talking about things that people are interested in, probably because they saw the movies and TV shows and talking about them may cause people to want to go see those again. And so is there an extent to which the entire Star Wars Universe podcast is by definition promoting the TV and movies? Probably? Am I making some choices to try and mitigate that. Yeah,
Speaker 5Like one example, I've said I don't want to do book content. One of the books that actually I was planning to do as part of the like Road to Ahsoka, was the Ahsoka novel because what better thing to talk about? And me and Aaron McGowan, who's on for a lot of the a lot of episodes by now, the bad Batch especially, both read the books to get ready to talk about it. And then I was like, eh, I don't feel right doing that. It is a book, it's not on screen, but like.
Speaker 3To do it.
Speaker 5If you read it, you're gonna be even more excited to watch the show, all right, right, and so I may still record it. We'll see, but there's all I will just books out there.
Speaker 3Yeah, go just on that note, Like, I do think it can be an opportunity though for someone to say, you know what, I'm going to read the book instead of watching the show, Like that's I think that's an option. Now maybe at the end of the book you're like, oh, but I really want to watch the show now, you know, I don't know. I haven't read the book. But yeah, at least Disney has always paid their authors the full amount that oh wait.
Speaker 5Yeah, that's a whole other thing.
Speaker 3And like they're not calling you know, they're not calling for a strike because they don't have a union.
Speaker 5And it's funny because yeah, because they're writers for Hollywood companies and often the plots that they come up within those books appear on screen, but they're not part of w GA. That's a whole other fight that also should be thinking.
Speaker 3Although some are here's a question that sorry tangent Land, if a book is written by a wj w GA author writer, so basically like someone who's in the you know, the Writer's Union and maybe adapts their own screenplays right from their own material. Do you feel like all of their books then you wouldn't want to cover or maybe this is along too far down?
Speaker 5Yeah? No, no, to me, it has nothing to do with the unions off. It's just specifically a book about the the probably biggest show of year that Star Wars is coming out.
Speaker 3Sure, yeah, that makes sense.
Speaker 5We'll see all right. We have one of the non piece of strike feedback. We've got a lot of feedback on that, but I want to just read this one as well. This is from Mandy t Rebel, great name. I finally got around to watching and Or and I found your commentary. It was like watching it with friends. I love it. Here's my question, who's a character who you would want to see get their own and or style show?
Speaker 6Right?
Speaker 3It's a good I mean literally, any character can have their own and or style show and it will be one of the best shows of all time. Because to me, that's what it means to have an and or style show. But if what you mean is more specifically who deserves to get a full backstory show, Yeah that.
Speaker 5A backstory or a like what happened next? But like to take a character who is mostly there only as a side character in one of our main stories, which and Or is a main character in a movie that's basically a side story Tarmian characters, right, yeah, like someone like that? Who who would you want it to be?
Speaker 3I mean, I think you can just keep doing more more characters from Ague one, Like I would like to see Charott and what's his name Beze? I'd like to see their backstory. I want to see what happens to them after except they're just space us now.
Speaker 5I was thinking, should I say a character or perhaps a pair of characters, but I was like, no, I think Paul's gonna go there no matter what.
Speaker 3So yeah, no, I just I love them in that, and I feel like they represent a really interesting you know, like, what what does happen to all the people who are into the force and like Jedi adjacent after Order sixty six, before you know the Battle of Yavin or even the Battle of and Or you know, what, what what do those people do? You know? What does it? What does
Speaker 3it mean to you know, to be one of them, you know.
Speaker 5Yeah, and like I think you could do a story that's about two of them and about their journeys and and and I think they meet on Jeda, but maybe they don't, but you could do it that or I think you could even do like Jetta be the show and those two are the most characters, but maybe there are others. And yeah, what we get is like five years on this planet, you know that is sacred to the Jedi, or maybe even like you start with Order sixty six. Order sixty six has been on screen a lot, so maybe not, but.
Speaker 3Like sure, yeah, maybe maybe start a year after.
Speaker 5That, yeah, but just like seeing what was life there like and then the Empire take over and then eventually saw Gerera and his people kind of coming in because I think his story is one that I would really love to see more of. So yeah, I think that would have been great. Sargarero was one of the her few I was going to say, because he's appeared a lot, but almost always as an antagonist to someone else's.
Speaker 3Story, yeah, or like a rival almost like right, like he's that he's that I forget. There's a there's like a very specific word for it, but like where he's he's sort of an antagonist, but he's actually on the same side. Yeah, where they're like kind of trying to do the same thing, but he wants to do it in a different way, right, you know. Yeah, And I do feel like would it be an and Or style show if it's someone like Saw who's already spoilers in and Or? But also like he's I mean, he's appeared in so many things, but like, you're right, he's never
Speaker 3gotten it's never been the Saw show.
Speaker 5It's never been from his point of view, or even the point of view of someone in his group. So I think that could be really good to think people who aren't I had a couple of ideas of people who aren't in Rogue one.
Speaker 3But yeah, who aren't in Rogue one?
Speaker 5I think sport of one made it so good. It was that's such a good ensemble. It's so many small characters, you know. For a while, we had talked about Lando getting his own show and the idea of Billity Williams being kind of a narrator while.
Speaker 3Like over a game of cards while Glover plays, you know, the younger.
Speaker 5He's actually a good person. Yeah, I think that would be absolutely fantastic. I think there was like that was in discussion at some point, not I thought for a minute, especially after watching this movie, if I'd want to see the Droids get their own show. I don't think I would. I think we have seen so much of C three, PO and R two at this point, and I don't know if I could take two hours of then bickering, and frankly, episodes that were focused on them in Clone Wars and Rebels were often not the best.
Speaker 3Yeah, and they're just they're in so many episodes of so many things. I feel like it's no longer that's not an and or style. I mean if you just mean, like just take a character who hasn't been a title character and make them a title character. Sure, but it's like, you know there it's it's like, you know, doing a laya show. It's like, well, that would be awesome. I think that would be awesome, you know, especially in after the you know, after end, or like an actual laya show. You know, but like that would be hard to do live action. It's like what do you even do?
Speaker 5Yeah? You know, Like I mean, I'm not a fan of the like I know, stanzeb Astroan looks like Luke. I don't need more Luke stories and I definitely don't want like ghost AI type stuff.
Speaker 3Yeah. Yeah, it's funny how Rogue one, like it was so interesting that Peter Cushing was like in it. But also I remember at the time being like is this okay? Yeah, like you know, it's like this this this feels bad, and then re looking at it, I'm like, it also looks it has more of the At the time, my brain didn't process it the same way, you know, like just in terms of the look of it. Yeah, and like it looks it looks off to me now more than it did then, I think. But it's like, yeah, it's just it's rough, it's hard. It's like Yeah.
Speaker 5On that Strike episode I did with Riky, we actually talked a lot more about this in depth because AI is one of the major things happening in the Strike. And I think as a counter example, you know, James Earl Jones like made a contract with Lucasfilms. He went into a studio they recorded enough of his voice that they can basically now use his and he signed a contract and he got very well compensated where he they can now use his voice in perpetuity for a future Darth Vader character, and like, yeah, I don't. I definitely don't love the AI visual. Maybe they're going to make
Speaker 5that better, but to me, it's especially like Peter Cushing was long was dead, long before anything that no one ever asked him, and even like exact family, like, you know, I do believe that Carrie Fisher gave permission for that to be used as it was, but I don't know the details there. But yeah, I think it's a great question. I think there's abviously so many I think, you know, I've often talked. The other one I would put is and this isn't a specific character as much as just like another behind the scenes kind of thing. I would love to see more about the Senate, you know, I'd love to see more about during the Republic ordering the Empire,
Speaker 5you know, just like what that life was like. So yeah, great, though it was a great question, Paul, given of the kind of last comments on it.
Speaker 3Uh No, I just wanted to kind of double down on the consent matters, you know, aspect of like if you're going to use AI to impersonate someone, if they say, yeah, that's fine, go ahead and do that. Give me this much money and we're good. Cool, that's fine. You know, I think the proposal to be able to like hire an extra and like download their likeness and then use them in perpetuity for a day rate is like what are you? Honestly, the AI is the spot where I feel like the studios and the Union are both out
Speaker 3of their mind. And I think it's probably because none of them have any idea what the technology is, what it is capable of, what it will be capable of, and like what a reasonable way to move forward given you know how fast it's going to change. And I think it's a question that requires a lot more than they're going to be able to do. Really, probably you know, in the negotiation, so you're probably going to end up with something goofy, But like, yeah, to me at the end of the day, consent is like yeah, it's a
Speaker 3big deal. It's just always a big deal. It matters to me, and.
Speaker 5Consent, especially in economic terms, you know, when people are starving and are willing to accept any kind of wages even though it's a terrible deal, Like that's not a consensual employment agreement. And you know, I'm not saying, you know, a background actor is starving. But like when someone's trying to get into Hollywood and they may take you know, it's like this is the only option you have. We should try to make sure that that option. You know, there's a reason why there's a minimum wage, there's a reason why there are minimum standards of contract for the You need to be like this is too much, is
Speaker 5completely fair. So yeah, Emma, thank you so much for the content, for the comment, as well as Mandy and Dylan and everybody else who wrote in. And Dylan of course we talked about how he joined the Patreon. It's very easy to join. It really helps this podcast helps me do all the things that we're doing. And right now, anything you donate, twenty five percent of what all their Patreon donations go will go to the the Entertainment Fund. I believe that's what it's called. I'm kind of a link to it in the show notes. That's the fund
Speaker 5for out of work actors, out of our writers. But also, like Paul mentioned, you know, there's a lot as like Paul's parents, there's a lot of other people who work on movies and they're in unions. Their unions aren't on strike, but like the people whose jobs are catering movie sets, the people whose jobs are security at movie sets, lighting sound, all this stuff costuming. Most of those people are not working right now. Some of them are being able to get other kind of jobs, but a lot of them aren't working. And they're in unions. They're support the unions.
Speaker 5They're not you know, making it, they're not fighting against it. They're supporting the unions. But the members are suffering too. And so I'm really glad that the strike fund that SAG helped set up is being distributed among those folks as well. So yeah, twenty repisdent of the Patrons will go to that and I'll talk more about how to give us feedback and like, But first, Paul, where can people find you?
Speaker 3I don't even know. I used to be Zen mad Man on Twitter. Apparently now I'm zend Madman on x or something. I don't even know. I mean, I'm going to keep trying, said mad Man in various places. You can find me various places, and like, eventually maybe I'll have some more coherent spiel, but like, for now, I don't know, the world is on fire and I'm just trying to stay in the air. Conditioning.
Speaker 5Look, when I type in Twitter dot com, I get to the right site. I don't know where I would go if I typed in X dot com. But I don't think it's family friendly.
Speaker 3I don't think you want to find out.
Speaker 5And so I will keep calling them tweets, and I will keep using the words cis gender right and no elon kicks me off, and and and frankly, like, I know it takes you to Twitter. Yeah, oh, okay, I guess you know X dot com. I guess he bought that, so well done.
Speaker 3That's an expensive domain name. I mean, you know, that's some commitment to the to the big that's.
Speaker 5Probably least one or two Emeralds fro daddy's mind that got used to pay for that. So yeah, So I am on Twitter. I've not yet gone onto one of the sites, just because we're still in that like every week it sounds like all my friends are going to a new one, and I just I don't have the patience to set up one file five ones. So in like a couple of months, I'm gonna see where people have settled. It might be, you know, there's a couple bunch of options out there. We'll see if you've got suggestions for me, feel free to write and let me know. But of course you can still find me on Twitter. You can also find me on Facebook on TikTok, and
Speaker 5you can email me all that informations in the show notes, But the best way to find it is go to v ethicalpanda dot com and there you'll find information about this podcast, my Superhero Ethics podcast. Like I said, it's a little harder to find non screen Star Wars content, although there is a ton, But you know, we've in the past had non Hollywood screen content on Superhero Ethics, and now it's all we're doing. And so we have stuff about Discworld, those books. We have stuff about a Have,
Speaker 5about the character of a Have and disability and Moby Dick. I finally got around to learning the plot of that book. I did not read it, but in true high school, in true American high school English class standards, I looked it up on spark Notes, which is apparently what cliff Notes is now. And we had a great discussion with someone who wrote a thesis on Ahab and Moby Dick. So that was a great episode. We're gonna do stuff on Godzilla, a lot of stuff We're can do stuff on some BBC things. There's so much great cinema that's happening outside of the United States, so take a chance.
Speaker 5Check it out, check out super Ethics, check out Star Wars. If your patrons stick around. We got a little bit of bonus content, but just a little bit because Paul's got to go soon. Most of all, thank you all so much for listening. We have spoken welcome back patrons. Thank you so much. We're gonna to keep this very brief because Paul has to go very soon. But Paul, I'm just gonna ask you. I know you don't read the books much, what has been your contact with have Star Wars offscreen?
Speaker 3I mean, I'm just gonna hold something up for the non viewing audience who can't see it. But this is a lovely lego Darth Vader head that Matthew gave me for a holiday and I assembled and it was great fun and I enjoy looking at Will Friedland's giant Millennium falcon in the background. So I actually this might be my I think this is my first Star Wars lego. But I had a bunch of the you know, the og Star Wars. I had a Millennium Falcon like the
Speaker 3original one. I had a Chewbacca and I think I lost the Chewbacca in a diner and it was like it was traumatized, like I'm sure, you know. And they had the C three po in the little like came into parts and then fit in a backpack of Chewbacca's. So yeah, the Empire Strikes Back Edition, I guess. So yeah, mostly mostly like through the toys. I played the RPG back in the in the nineties with some friends and
Speaker 3you know, we have a friend who's whose brother was like the most Star Wars the you know, person I think I'd ever known in terms of just having their entire room was just outfitted solely with you know, the toys and and I think they had the Lego set by then, and like, you know, just tons of Star Wars stuff. And I played some of the games. I played the the Empire Strikes Back game actually for like Super Nintendo or something. And I you know, played one of the Starfighter games like one time, you know, but
Speaker 3so so not not huge, you know, mostly just like the toys and like a little bit with the games and you know, reading or listening to some like you know, George Lucas and Joseph Campbell kind of talking about sort of the hero's journey and whatever, and so yeah, I would say mostly toys and games.
Speaker 5Yeah, and what Yeah, I think in too recently, I was like that I had read the Throng novels when they came out, the original ones, and I really liked them. But then I tried some of the other Extended Universe stuff. It really wasn't for me. And then I think, I'm you know, I'm of that generation that was I think just I don't want to say too old for Clone Wars, because for the prequels, because I think a lot of people love the prequels, but I think a lot of people of my age just the prequels were not my favorite, and I kind of went all Star Wars for a while,
Speaker 5and then Force Awakens really was the thing that really brought me back. You know. As many problems they may have with the sequels, I think, oh, so much of them is fantastic. Ray is fantastic. You know. I I'm with someone who really enjoyed most of the sequels. The last one I was standing. And then when I saw the kind of revit, part of I think the fact that the problem with the EU also was that it was so intimidating. It got to the point where, you know, because like, you know, I could have read those books
Speaker 5as they were coming out when I was like twelve or thirteen, but then you skip forward some years and it's like there's now forty books, and like every book is reference. They did a good job of referencing each other, although some of them contradict each other, but like I just felt like, where in the world do I get started? And so I just never did. And then when Star Wars started, the whole new set of books, a lot of it filling in some of the apps on things that I wanted to learn more about, like the Padme books that I've been talked about, Queen Shadow, Queen's Peril. I got really into those. But I think, honestly, the piece of Star Wars media that I think I probably
Speaker 5most engaged with it wasn't screen, was the x Wing and tie Fighter games. These are games I had on a IBM maybe three eighty six, maybe even older, Like I think I think I had the first x Wing. I think I had even pre Windows maybe, and it was most of the a you know, fairly simple space combat game, and granted I had not been playing many video games at the time, and so many other people tell me this was actually a lot more common than I thought, but it actually had a story that was ongoing through it, and the rebel one was fairly basic,
Speaker 5but the tie Fighter one, like you got to be a you got to eventually become a first of like, this is kind of interesting. I'm gonna be like fighting for the Empire, and I'm just be realized like this was. They were not quite in the point in the nineties of like, yeah, let's like be the bad guy for the whole game. So eventually you do spoilers for a game that's thirty years old. Eventually you do wind not joining the Rebellion as a high fighter pilot. But yeah, I just really love those and I've enjoyed I think Jedi Survivor was a great well, I think Jedi Survivor
Speaker 5was a great story told through a video game that I found far too difficult. That if you know platformers you're good at hand eye coordination, I think it's probably a lot easier. I'm not that person. There's a Star Wars RPG coming out, like an open World kind of Skyrim kind of a game that next year I believe that I'm really excited for. And yeah, and I think the books are great. The comic books are still the barrier for me. I just have not ever believe been able to get into them. My visual acuity is really not good. But I love hearing people talk about them.
Speaker 5And yeah, I'm I'm just glad there's there is so much else out there besides the TV and movies, and even when I can't watch it, I love hearing people talk about it.
Speaker 3Yeah. I've actually really enjoyed the book podcasts that I've been on for the books that I didn't read, you know, like it's it's fun kind of agetting to sort of ask questions and listen to, you know, what's going on in those things. And most books you can dig into a level of depth that you can't do in most series, you know, or movies. I I almost like wouldn't want to read an and or book, you know, because I feel like the series actually manages to kind of I
Speaker 3actually saw Tony Gilroy referred to it as a like more like a novel than a movie or a series, you know, And it's but but I think that is the sort of thing like probably that maybe speaks to like I probably would like some of the novels, you know, if I know. The quality of writing varies, right, and sort of the target audio audience, I'm sure varies, but I'm sure some of them are very well written. And just in terms of getting into Oh, I tried that
Speaker 3that collection of short stories that you sent me, the story a certain.
Speaker 5Point of view and you hate it, and I love.
Speaker 3The idea, I did, Wait what did you say?
Speaker 5The collections are called from a certain point of view because they're all like little evenly they're like three to four pages often, so.
Speaker 3Yeah, they're like flash fiction to short stories, yes, exactly.
Speaker 5Vignettes, and they're all from the perspective of like characters we never actually met, or characters we saw forage at a half second or two, but who are witnesses to important moments in Star Wars, right, And they've now done that for multiple books or shows, and the first one is just called from a certain point of view A new hope.
Speaker 3Yeah, yeah, and I just I love the idea of it, but I just I just couldn't with the writing, like like you sent me in Sensitive and this I don't want to say this will be everyone's experience. I'm sure it's not. If they've done multiple books, I'm sure plenty of people love them. But like I actually had to look up the authors and be like, are these like professional authors or just a collection of fan fiction? And I'm like, oh, professional authors, But it is a collection of fan fiction. That's the thing about something like Star Wars is.
Speaker 5Like it's all fan fiction to somebody, fan.
Speaker 3Fiction since you know the the prequel trilogy, right, the prequel trilogy wasn't fan I mean you could say Star Wars was fan fiction for the Hidden Fortress, but like you know, well, and.
Speaker 5Like there's a book that came out. There's a book that came out a year or two ago that Wreeky and I actually covered in last week's episode. There's a book actually that came out a year or two ago that Wreeky and I covered if and you heard us cover it in last week's episode Resistance Reborn. And it's not. I think some of the books are incredibly well written. And I also want to say I think some fan fiction is incredibly well written.
Speaker 3Of course not, but.
Speaker 5It wasn't my favorite book, but it did a lot of things, like, as far as I understand, the author set out to say, Okay, you know those massive plot holes from Last Jedi to Rise of Skywalker, what if we fill in some of those What if we give people some backgrounds? So like the book, the focus of the book is, Okay, Leah put out that call on crate and no one came. What do we do now?
Speaker 5And so you get to see them change tactics and start to do new things that start to get more people on their side in a way just calling for help didn't. And so the whole armada showing up in Rise makes more sense. You get to see, again, here's the thing you can't really do in a movie unless it's incredible done TV show like and Or. You get to see much more of pose interiority, and you get to see him really wrestling with like the mistakes he made and horrible cost it had, and also like some of the other pilots being like why would we follow you?
Speaker 5You made these terrible decisions? And and I just really appreciate how much the book bridges the gap between those two movies, and in the same ways that like the TV show The Clone Wars, I think bridges the gap between the second and third prequel movie in a lot of ways. I think the gap is much larger to Rise a Skywalker, But however you see it, I think it was just because it's trying to do so much. I think it suffers a little bit just as a worker. But it was enjoyable and there's so many things that
Speaker 5read where I was like, ah, okay, now this is something I can believe. Now I get this right.
Speaker 3Right, It's like giving you a headcanon download. Yeah, like, yeah, here's some ways that you can watch these movies and have them make sense together instead of just being like wait what, yeah, like did did the director of this even see that movie?
Speaker 5Among other things, Wedge is a major character in it, and how Wedge comes back into the Existance is a major thing rather than just like, oh, the actor had some free time, so we threw him in at the end of the movie with every.
Speaker 3Right, right, right. I feel like Wedge would be an interesting character just like follow through the entire of yeah, like his career, you know.
Speaker 5I mean you could kind of do like this is kind of going back to that feedback question we have, and then we really should wrap up. Yeah, you know, Wedge I think would be another one to get his own show, but instead of it being about like his life before or after, I think he would be kind of kind of like a Rosencrants and Guildenstern version of Not Worth Movies.
Speaker 3Sure, sure, yeah, no, I think that's funny. I also though, was thinking like, actually Biggs would be an interesting character to have an and or like show. I mean it's the same time frame, yeah, and I don't know, who knows, maybe it'll show up, but like you know, just that sort of like leading up to the rebellion, Like how does someone who's like pals with Luke on Tatooine like then go and actually join the rebellion? And like you know, like what what is that? Like what was what was the rebellion then before we saw it? Really?
Speaker 5Yeah, like yeah, I think you know, we got some Wedges backstory and rebels. But yeah, for some like Bigs or something like that would be always actually because what has never been answered is when Luke wants to forward his application to the Academy, the only academy we have actually heard about is the Imperial Is the Imperial right exactly? And so was there just this line of like Wedge and Big and all these pilots going off to the Imperial pilots being like cool, I got my skills, but I'm gonna find X wing instead of a tie fighter.
Speaker 5See you later. I don't know.
Speaker 3Exactly, and like how did the empire deal with that? Like did they know that there? They were also this pipeline and like then were the administrators at the academy like, oh uh, you're in Slytherin slo okay, griffindor Griff Yeah, sorry for the Harry Potter reference, but you know, I feel like it's you know, it's school where it's like a good guys, bad guys, Like yeah, who does that? That was always one of the things that I was just like, these movies are weird.
Speaker 5Yeah, not gonna get another topic. I am not a you know, that name is dead to me, never mentioned again. I'm never gonna promote it in any way. I'm never gonna give money to anything involved with J. K. Rowling ever. Again. I'm going to distance myself from those who do. But yeah, like it is a cultural reference in our lexicon that it is used from time to time. It is fine. So anyway, all right, this has been awesome, Paul, thank you so much for all this. Thank you patrons, you really make all this happen. We have spoken.
Star Wars Generations is going on hiatus for a few months. We’ll be back in December to get you ramped up for Ahsoka Season 2! **************************************************************************This episode is a...
Would you give up your name to save your life, if a tyrant demanded it first? Matthew Fox and Erin McGowan open Star Wars Generations’ new episode-by-episode watch-through of Star Wars: Visions Presents - The Ninth Jedi...
Can lightsabers work like mood rings for your soul? Matthew Fox and Erin McGowan get listeners ready for "Star Wars: Visions Presents - The Ninth Jedi," the new eight episode series expanding two existing Visions shorts...
What happens when the people who raised you decide you’re guilty before you get a chance to prove otherwise? Matthew and Erin spend this episode of Star Wars Generations on one of “The Clone Wars”’ most consequential...
Before he became the paranoid revolutionary from Rogue One, Saw Gerrera was a scrappy fighter who thought sheer force could win a war. Matthew, Alex, and Erin head back to "The Clone Wars" Season 5 for the Onderon arc,...