Strange New Worlds is still gimmicking, but this time they're augmenting who they are instead of replacing it. We have thoughts, and they aren't all positive, but we have some great laughs on this episode! 🎙 Episode Reviewed: Star Trek: Strange New Worlds 4x06 - "Off-Hour" 👥 Hosts: David C. Roberson Matthew Carroll Note: This episode of Star Trek Universe continues Dave and Matt's ongoing journey discussing Star Trek as they have since the late 1980s. 🖖 Listen & Subscribe: 🌐 StarTrekUcast.com 🍎 Apple Podcasts 🎧 Spotify 📡 Spreaker ✍️ David C. Roberson’s Newsletter
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Another gimmick, bisected Mbinga, a bafflingly banal voice, and a surprisingly strong episode for Christine Chappell. We're talking Strange New Worlds 406 Off Hour, right after these words from our mystery snake oil neutrinos.
Speaker 2Welcome to Star Trek Universe Podcast, where you listen in on two lifelong friends sit and chat about Star Trek like we always do. My name is Matthew Carroll.
Speaker 1I am David C. Roberson.
Speaker 2What's up, Dave? How you doing, man?
Speaker 1Hey, man.
Speaker 3I don't know.
Speaker 1I'm just here.
Speaker 2Yeah. Yeah.
Speaker 1You know how it do.
Speaker 2Yes, I do. Yes, I do. All right. So, new Star Trek episode.
Speaker 1Yeah, man.
Speaker 2I gotta say, this was a Star Trek episode.
Speaker 1A little bit, yeah.
Speaker 2Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, it was 24.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2Well, they had a clock.
Speaker 1I think that's reductive. No, it's not reductive. They even did the split screen slidey thing with the different screens coming in that 24 did.
Speaker 2Yeah, yeah. That's interesting. I didn't really clock it while they did it. I mean, definitely there's 24 stuff going on, but before 24, there was a nick of time, which did it before 24 did it.
Speaker 1I remember a nick of time. Here's the thing, though, and here's why this one works where the others didn't. They used this to make Star Trek. They augmented Star Trek with this device, with this gimmick, whereas the others just did the fucking gimmick. So I think this one mostly works.
Speaker 2I agree completely. I found this episode really, really fun. I have my quibbles, but for the most part, I really, really like this episode. As a character episode, I love it. It was the officers doing the officer things they're supposed to do. They're talking to each other. It just felt like the kind of family with a purpose that like the Federation is supposed to feel like, you know, and,
Speaker 2and all of them putting themselves in danger in different ways, trying to solve problems. Um, and that, that therein lies my quibbles. I think the strong neutrino thing is ridiculous was, I mean, and they, they hang a lantern on it, but I'm sorry, your lantern's not big enough. Uh, the, the idea that like there are these two problems in the ship, Mbinga's car, carved in half and they're out of fuel and they will create a experimental technology that
Speaker 2will solve both of those in six minutes or whatever, like from the time they get the neutrinos to the time they solve everything. I was like, that is stupid. But... Otherwise, love this episode. I love all the Mbinga and Chapel stuff. Their relationship is just really well formed from years of them working together there in the thing. Going back, they showed that scene of her being kind of his accomplice in the Umbrella of War episode. And I really, really
Speaker 2appreciated that because it reminded me like, oh yeah, she's like his confidant.
Speaker 1So them....
Speaker 2Worried about losing each other and then embracing the possibility of her leaving– or him leaving while she stays. But also, like, her just being like, I'm not going to leave you to die. I'm going to fight through this. It was just special. And losing a finger, it was surprisingly– like, I really liked all of the Mbinga and Chapel stuff.
Speaker 1Yeah, I really like all of that. And, you know, there's always– there's this– This part of me who wants this version of these characters. And there's also this part of me who's trying to reconcile it with the version of the characters we got in TOS. And I think that's always ultimately hindering me in my viewing experience. And I think it also hinders the writers. Like, I feel like they would have been so much better served if they had just named these different characters and did that. Because...
Speaker 1I do feel like, you know, now they're trying really hard to, like, start to reconcile it and move these characters to where they think it should be for the original series. And I'm like, you should have just done other characters. Yeah.
Speaker 2For sure. If you're going to change them up so much, just create new characters. And, you know, it's the thing we've been saying forever. It's the whole prequel problem. It's the everything. But, like, if... In the scope of the episodes of the show, this was a really, really great outing.
Speaker 1Yeah. Yeah. You know, I also have my quibbles. Dr. Boyce, don't know why he's even there. This is the guy that was the doctor in the cage that happened previously in the storyline. We never needed to see him again. And they brought in a guy who looks and acts nothing like the original guy. And that's always going to bug me. It's like they're just grabbing people off the street or something. What they're really doing is they're grabbing their friends.
Speaker 2Right.
Speaker 1That's what they're really doing.
Speaker 2They're not casting to try to look alike, which they've never done, really. No. And I am fine with that. That doesn't bother me at all. You can swap it however you want. You can do whatever you want. That doesn't bother me. The characterization... I care more about in these situations. But if I'm being honest, most of these characters, with the exception of like the core six or seven, like I don't really have a strong impression of voice from the original series or really even that strong of chapel or, uh, or whoever else.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2Pike for that matter. Yeah.
Speaker 1I mean, I gotta, I feel like, you know, it's difficult for me because like I have my idea of those characters, but a lot of them were very, very static in the original series.
Speaker 2Yeah, for sure.
Speaker 1Um, so it's, it's sort of me always kind of pulling myself aside and being like, is this something you made up or is this, was, is this in the show? And, um, this is something that I've been able to go back and really like pay attention to watching these tier West and strange new worlds back to back.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 1And go like, no, it's not just me. There are very stringent differences in some of these things, but, uh, yeah, I don't know. I, for me is, I don't know why we're doing boys again or is boys coming back for, for good. Or, I mean, no, that they've got Thomas Jane playing McCoy next year. So, which is stupid. Like I'll never be able to see Thomas Jane as McCoy. Come on.
Speaker 2We'll see how he does. We'll see how he does. I, I, uh, yeah, I don't know, man. I don't know what they're going to do, uh, with, with the rest, but yeah, this was a fun, uh, what'd you think of Scotty Scotty's, uh, arc this episode?
Speaker 1I really liked him and P'Lea and him going into the whole Star Diver trauma, and that was cool. I liked it up to the point where P'Lea had to be like, you have to be a miracle worker. And I was like, oh, God, why do they have to ham fist every fucking thing? I hear you. I hated that part.
Speaker 2I hear you. But, like, I loved it. I loved it. It felt like something she would say, and it also felt like the kind of encouragement that would help him.
Speaker 1But aside from that, this is the most I've ever liked Palia.
Speaker 2I know. I was about to say, you saying you liked anything with Palia is a big deal. And I will say, this is my favorite Palia moment of the entire series. And her being the one to, like, impart... the idea of Scotty, like be one with the ship. Like you got to listen to it, listen to it. Like it, like it's a, like it's a being in and of itself and it's going to take care of you. Like the, the whole idea of like the way Scotty is as an engineer is, this episode was it. This episode was him like locking in. We talked about it
Speaker 2last week, how he's been this kind of goofy character and he started out so strong and he's been goofy, goofy, goofy. And then they were like, Oh, we knew they did the pivot. They did the pivot and then they did it well. And I think like he can still be like the affable funny guy, but now he has like a serious sense of the ship and he has like a purpose. And I just think, And I think the, the miracle worker line, like I thought was really nice. Like I said, it's the kind of thing Polia would say. And it's the kind of thing that like, we, we heard him last episode, how much he cared about sort
Speaker 2of like his own reputation, you know, and her like saying that, I think like made him believe he could be a miracle worker. You know what I mean? Yeah. And like, after she's been like kind of razzing him for the last, last episode, she was razzing him about, that the puppet and the guy and how, oh, well, he would have done better with this or whatever. She's picking on him, but when she knew he needed the encouragement, she gave him that line, and I think it inspired something in him, and I just loved it. Him stopping
Speaker 2and holding onto the ship, and it was like one of his last lines. I loved it. It's making me emotional thinking about it. I really loved it when he's just like, the Enterprise will hold. It's like, oh, yeah, that's Scotty. That's the Scotty we need. Yeah. Yeah.
Speaker 1I mean, I liked it. I liked that scene. I was like, ah, we get to see the first time Scotty has sexual feelings for the ship.
Speaker 2Yeah. Oh, man.
Speaker 1Yep.
Speaker 2And then I feel like those were our two sort of main storylines and everything else I feel like kind of was just pretty traditional. Like this person goes outside to save everyone. I mean, everyone got their little hero moment. Everyone got a hero moment in this episode. Una got her leg snapped in half.
Speaker 1That was rough. I don't know how she stood up after that, but a lot of it.
Speaker 2She's genetically engineered for it, you know?
Speaker 1Is she?
Speaker 2Isn't she? Yeah. Is she, though? I don't know.
Speaker 1Yeah. Like, I don't know how physically, if the gravity just snapped your leg, how you could still stand up for a second.
Speaker 2Oh, I think she just used the other leg. But, like, yeah. It was rough. And, like, I don't think. The thing that strained credulity to me was that, like, She didn't have to push anything into the computer. She just had to slap it. Like that was very convenient. Yeah. It's like, you need to go across the room and, you know, program the gravity properly and, you know, anything else on the ship, you have to be able to be like... like 30 little dupe dupe dupes on the thing she's
Speaker 2just like i just have to get there and slap it and that'll turn the gravity back on it was really silly yeah it's just a gravity slap button in the corner of the bar.
Speaker 1Um yeah i was very uh bored by the lawn una spock stuff for the most part like it was just a lot of like okay all right yeah get.
Speaker 2It over with it was just giving everybody a little hero moment for when the ship's in danger and everybody's gonna which is a silly thing to do honestly like you should have just given more time to the characters that you that really got cool stories this episode.
Speaker 1Yeah, I did laugh and saw somebody online refer to this episode and said, oh, finally an episode full of competency porn.
Speaker 2I wish. I wish that were the case. I really do.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 2I wanted that to be true of this episode. And I think a little bit, it's a little bit true with Scotty.
Speaker 1Yeah, sure.
Speaker 2But it is, when Chappell, when the computer had to tell Chappell that the table was holding Mbinga together, I was actively annoyed. Because you are, like, it should have been her saying that to the computer. Like, I knew that as a person who watches movies where this kind of thing happens. Oh, the table's, like, his stomach has been crushed. If you move that table, he's gonna, you know, like,
Speaker 2it said, like, external force is uh, is, is holding his organs in. And she went the lab table. Like it was a revelation. Like I knew it from the second it pinned him that he was going to have to sit there until she could figure something out. And like, she had to wait until the computer told her there was external pressure on his organs. And I was like, you're the doctor on the spaceship. You should know that that should be a thing. You don't have to realize. I really annoyed me. It, that, that was probably one of my, that and the neutrinos thing or my big, like, Yep.
Speaker 2Why you got to put such silly stuff in here? Why you got to do that?
Speaker 1Well, look, the neutrino magic solution was bullshit. Yeah. I'm used to that from Star Trek. I feel like they did go too far on this one.
Speaker 2They went way too far. Solving the ship problem and the fuel problem, fine. That is classic Star Trek. We're in this neutrino storm. Let's use our environment to get out. All right.
Speaker 1Mm-hmm.
Speaker 2But they wanted to do the Seinfeld thing where A story has to connect to B story just right for everything to connect. And like freaking, they were like, also, if you just spray neutrinos on his crotch, he'll be all better. Like, what are you talking about? That is insane. And like, it was research he had done, but it was a theoretical particle. It's not just like plug it in, collect it from the Bussard collectors and then just like
Speaker 2spray it on him. Like, no, it would be like, you know, developing a treatment, figuring out dosage, dah, dah, dah, dah, dah. Like it just, it's, it was so stupid. I hated it so much for the part of the episode that I love the most, which is like the Mbinga and chapel relationship. And then to end it that way pissed me off so much. I mean, honestly, just freezing him was smart and cool. Like, they should have just used a different solve. Give Ortega something to do. Like, she
Speaker 2was such a lump this episode. I was actively annoyed. She got the con. I think maybe for the first time, like, she's got the con. And freaking– Pike says, Ortega's, you have the con. And then he turns the shields on, which was badass. It was great. He's the first to do the sacrifice play. I loved it. Right. And then Ortega's did zero. She wasn't like– Right. Like, Uhura was making sure everyone's communicating.
Speaker 1Yep.
Speaker 2Ortega has never even made a decision. She's just, she's just sat there and like sort of acted like she just listened to the whole ship disaster. Like it was a podcast. I, I was so fed up with her. I kept cutting back to her and she's just sitting there.
Speaker 1I was like, well, that was the thing is like, that was one of the things that I wrote down that annoyed me is like, you have Pike deliberately electrocutes himself to get the shields back. He says, you have the con. And then she does nothing. And then he's back. And he's back so soon. And then he's kind of useless the whole episode because the crew is taking care of shit. So I'm like, his ass should have been unconscious and in need of medical help. That would have left us another little divot of emergency that we're thinking about.
Speaker 1but it also leaves the rest of the crew to scramble and give us more. Oh, you know, like just like, let's see what we're going to do. Let's see what Ortega, she's got the con. What does she got to do?
Speaker 2Exactly.
Speaker 1What's she got?
Speaker 2What's, what's her specialty? She flies the ship and they're in a situation that could probably use some fancy flying, like all these neutrinos flying by and stuff like some, do something. She did nothing. She had no ideas. She never gave a command. She has the con. She never gave a command the entire episode. I was so annoyed. But he comes back so soon. It undermines his sacrifice, too. Well, I agree he came back in a weird time. I
Speaker 2felt like it should have been the end of the episode. It should have been sort of the episode where Pike, as he's nearing his end on the ship, realizes... I'm going to be gone one day, but this crew can handle things without me. That would have been a nice message of this episode for him. But instead he wakes up with 15 minutes left. It's very strange. It's a very strange time for him to come back. I agree.
Speaker 1And it also would have been an interesting little tag at the end of it or something where Someone's like, yeah, I read the reports in Binga or something, whoever. Be like, Chris, I read the– maybe Boyce. That could have been why he's there. He says, Chris, I read the reports. You didn't have to be the one to make that sacrifice. What's going on? They've kind of been cluing me in that you've been getting more and more reckless. And maybe he's getting more reckless because he knows how he goes out.
Speaker 2That's what I was thinking. He knows how he dies. So he chose to do that because he knows it's not going to kill him. That's the way I took it, which is cool. I like that as a little thing he did, but it does... Just the whole Ortega's take the con meant nothing.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2Yeah. Yep, yep.
Speaker 3I don't know.
Speaker 1I don't know that I have much more on this episode. It was... All right.
Speaker 2Yeah. Okay. I'm going to run down some notes then. If you got... I feel like I agree with you, but I have tons of notes, so I'm just going to run down and see what I've got here. I really liked the relationship stuff between Mbinga and Chapel, as I said. I really liked there's a lot that I could say about you, but I don't. It's like, I know all your flaws, just like you know all my flaws, but I'm not going to throw them in your face. It's an interesting line, because I think of good friendship...
Speaker 2It's important to call your friends out when they've screwed up. That is important. But there's a flip side of that where it's like, you also know your friends' flaws that would hurt them to hear. And then you really got to say it. And you know they know them. You know what I mean? There's a certain point where to say certain things to your friends is just to drive a wedge in your relationship. And it's not really... And I just thought that was an interesting friendship thing that
Speaker 2I hadn't really given much thought to. It's kind of natural that you don't want to, like, be an asshole to your friends. But, like, that line was just– I liked that line a lot. I did.
Speaker 1Mm-hmm. Yeah.
Speaker 2Let's see if I can jump through here. I really– I liked Scotty's, ugh, let's see if it's my bloody accent again.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2Engineering. He's trying to get it to like, give him, get him to engineering. That was great. The engineering evacuation was done really poorly.
Speaker 1All those motherfuckers left behind.
Speaker 2I know. It wasn't an evacuation. He should have said, like, that was a moment for real... I, the person who said this is incompetence or competence porn. I disagree. This episode is sacrifice willpower porn. Like that's all this episode is. Nobody's being that competent, but everyone is being like, it's more like wish on a falling star for a solution and get neutrinos. And like everyone have the willpower to fight for their friends.
Speaker 1Yeah. It's not necessarily competency porn. It's more like more competent than normal for this show porn.
Speaker 2For sure. For sure.
Speaker 1But to be fair, though, like, even on TNG, like, we've done this before where it's like all of a sudden it's like, brr, brr, cool, leak, and the thing comes down and there's always a few people fucking trapped.
Speaker 2Right.
Speaker 1Totally.
Speaker 2Well, that's fine. That's not what my problem was with it. It wasn't you... The thing that was said was my problem with it. Because that could have been a moment of... We have to seal engineering. And then somebody says, you're not going to make it out. And it's like, we have to... For the ship or something. And press it. It's another moment for sacrifice. It could have upped everything even a little more. The sacrifice porn is on full display. But instead, they said... We have to evacuate engineering. And
Speaker 2instead of saying, hey, guys, get out of here and rolling under the door like Indiana Jones, Geordie LaForge over there grabbing his visor under the door. Like, hey, that happened, right? I'm imagining that happened.
Speaker 1Part of it happened.
Speaker 2Yeah. instead of saying everybody out get out of here he just hit the seal the doors button it's like he did it out of order you didn't say they said evacuate engineering and then they did not evacuate engineering i think the only person that made it out was the guy who hit the door button like he was like and just ran like everyone else died it was really weird it was great yeah yeah but importantly sorry
Speaker 2no one turned into a puppet no dinosaurs no puppets no nothing went black and white it was just a straightforward i mean like it is a star trek episode by its nature it is an episode about The freaking ship's in trouble, and everybody's going to do their job, and everyone's going to sacrifice for everyone else so that everyone survives. It was beautiful, except for those damn guys in engineering.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 1It's always those guys. It's always those red shirts.
Speaker 2Yeah. Indeed.
Speaker 1Whether it be engineering or security. Yep.
Speaker 2Just whatever's in a red shirt could die at any moment. Let's see. Let's hope I'm stronger than a piano made me laugh.
Speaker 1What was that?
Speaker 2Let's hope I'm stronger than a piano. Una is talking about having to walk over there and try to hit the automatic slap button or whatever. And she says, let's hope I'm stronger than a piano. I enjoyed that because the piano would just snap in half.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2I remember that now. I'm jumping around because this is in order of the episode, but I liked when she finally, she goes to Mbinga. Mbinga knows he's in trouble, but doesn't know how much he's in trouble. And she just goes to him and says, we're leaving the table where it is. And his acting was so good. And he had this line where he's like, okay, sounds like a plan. And it was just like him expressing full confidence in her. He did eventually ask her to show him what's up,
Speaker 2but he knows that she knows more than him. It isn't until he hears Boyce tell her to leave that he's like, okay, you got to show me now, because now I realize you're putting yourself in danger. But him being in mortal danger, he just had such trust for her, and I just really, really loved it. And there's all this talk at the beginning about how she doesn't like Boyce and how she's not going to do well under him and all this stuff. And then when Boyce gets on the radio, she says, Dr. Boyce, it's great to
Speaker 2hear from you. Because she cares about her fellow Federation officer. And I think that's the thing that this show misses so often when like there's little petty squabbles. Like let's say Ortega's and Scotty are like bickering and then they're in the middle of a life or death situation and they'll still bicker at each other. And that's not how that would work. It's like yeah, you have your petty squabbles on the ship and everybody's like laughing together or picking on each other or making jokes or pulling pranks.
Speaker 2But when the shit hits the fan, you are glad to hear from your fellow officer, you know? And I just thought that was, I love that little moment. It's so small, but I loved it.
Speaker 1I also love the little moment with the Ortega's where she mentions that, uh, Scotty is always available when, even in the middle of the night, she doesn't know when he sleeps.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1It's a nice little like sliver of like, oh, they have gotten to know each other and they are like legit friends. Yes.
Speaker 2At this point. This episode, I felt better about their friendship being like just a part of the tapestry of the episode. Whereas last episode I mentioned, I was like, they overdid it. They just became friends. Like they were overdoing it last episode.
Speaker 1That honeymoon period.
Speaker 2Just became friends. When she's talking to Dr. Boyce, there's that moment where he's just like, You need to put him in the best position for nature to take its course. And it's just so cold. Just so cold. And he's not wrong. I think he was wrong because there was one person.
Speaker 1Only because of magic.
Speaker 2Well, yes. But also, Boyce telling her she had to come to him to be his nurse. There is one person in the room with a broken leg. And the gravity was fixed. It might've, the gravity might've been still messed up at that point, but no, no, it wasn't because she'd broken her leg already. So the gravity was fixed. There's stuff happening all over the ship. There's other people getting hurt. There's a bunch of dead guys in engineering. Like, there's so much going wrong to be like chapel. You need to be where I am. Cause I need an
Speaker 2assistant instead of like, I got things handled. I got this broken leg handled. You go do it. You got to do like, maybe it's not, maybe it's not there. Maybe you need to be checking out Pike on the bridge, but like, it just felt weird to me. Like why he needed her there. Oh, well he had wounded there. And also that's where all the people were gathered because of, they were, conserving life support sure in certain areas.
Speaker 1There were there were more people in that room than most of the ship probably i i agree with that and they killed life support in in just in the corridors there's still like all the other functioning parts of the ship all the rooms not sick bay not sick bay for sure that's that's why it was getting so cold in there what was leaking though well she was gonna die if she didn't get out of.
Speaker 2There also she gets in this freaking uh I don't know.
Speaker 1Shia La'oub. Like the dune worm. outfit she's wearing around. And, uh, she's, she's like, those were blankets to keep her warm.
Speaker 2She's like, she's walking around in this, this little outfit she's built. Uh, and she's keeping as warm as she can. And then she puts on that little mask to breathe through the, and like have something in the cold. Her eyes are completely open to the cold. And so when he is cryogenically freezing enough to survive, uh, Like, the removal of the table. Her eyes are just open in the crisp air. You would lose your eyeballs. Like, that
Speaker 2was really weird. I don't know why they didn't give her, like, we've seen those full face masks before on Star Trek.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2That didn't make sense to me.
Speaker 1I don't know why they do half the things they do on this show. And I complain about all of them.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1Let's see.
Speaker 2I liked where sunblock go fast. I think it was Polia when she's talking about, uh, going outside the ship to go through all the neutrinos. She's like, I don't know where sunblock go fast.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2Oh, I really liked the lemons conversation and it didn't really go anywhere, but I did like it. And like, it kind of makes the episode work more for me. The lemons conversation where she's like, life never gave us lemons. We demanded lemons. Like, We created lemons and like, Palia had some great lines in this episode, like a kind of banger after banger. And then all the connection with Scotty, I was like, you have like justified your existence on this episode. Good job. Good job, Palia.
Speaker 1Yeah. there was some bit that i really laughed oh yeah when she was talking about the lemons and she's like i know i was there and it like cracked scotty up yeah yeah it distracted him.
Speaker 2Yeah and that's what she was doing she's trying to distract him but also her idea of the lemons and like demand we demanded it like it didn't exist and we demanded it because it's what we wanted what we needed uh it kind of ties in to the fact that they needed this solution for both of these things and they just demanded it from the universe and it showed up. Which I don't like as like a Star Trek concept. I think that's dumb. But for some reason there's a poetry to it that I kind of like. Lemons don't exist, but we demanded they exist. And like
Speaker 2in this... Again, if it had just been the neutrinos fixing the freaking fuel, I would have loved it. I would have thought all of that worked really well. The lemons tied to the neutrinos, tied to everything, is great. Fixing them, bingo, is dumb. It's dumb, dumb, dumb. Yeah, I agree.
Speaker 1Or at the very least, it was dumb how they did it. I didn't feel like they needed the neutrino shit. They're in the future. Yeah. The biggest problem is that they just had to get to it in time and she needed a team. That's what the solution was because they're in the fucking future. They replicate body parts all the time. Yeah. So the clock would have been like, oh, well, once we can freeze him and then just wait for
Speaker 1everything to get normalized and for some people to come in and help. That's the solution. Yes. Because you have magic fucking Star Trek technology.
Speaker 2Literally all you had to do was have her, and it would have worked better. It would have worked so much better. Just have her say, I know how to do it. And be like, you realize she's going to just open the door to freeze them. You know, like that is such a bold move and it could kill her. Like it puts her own life in danger to save him. And like, if I can just freeze you, there will be a chance for us to save you after all this.
Speaker 2And then she bundles up and she loses her finger and like all that stuff because she's trying to save him. And that's all it takes. That's the willpower, the sacrifice of this episode. That's what it's all about. the neutrinos needing to be tied to that made, did not matter. And so, yeah, I, I just, that, that's, that's my biggest complaint about this episode.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 2But I, I, I, uh, I almost just want to act like it doesn't exist and just say, yeah, she just froze, froze him. That's all she did. That's the version in my head. She just froze him. Cause if that had happened, this episode would be like, like, the top tier for me. I love, I would really, really like this episode if they didn't have to do that weird, convenient shit.
Speaker 1Yep.
Speaker 2Um, and they didn't have chapel not understand that the table was what was holding them together. Those are like my two annoyances of this episode, but the rest I just fricking love.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2Uh, last line I got in my notes is I trust a Vulcan's memory as much as any computer. Hmm.
Speaker 1You know, I actually liked that Vulcan incident a little more.
Speaker 2Oh, me too.
Speaker 1This time.
Speaker 2She was good. Everyone was good this episode. Who wrote this episode? We need to find out. What's this episode called?
Speaker 1Oh, Off Hour.
Speaker 2Yeah, I need to find out who wrote this episode, because I'm impressed. I am about 50-50 impressed. Yeah, there's a little bit of dumbness, obviously. I've been saying it, but for the most part, I'm pretty impressed.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 2Anyway, so we got any feedback?
Speaker 1We do. We do. First of all, over on YouTube, in response to one of our last episodes, I guess the black and white episode, whatever that one was called. Stu says, in response to us, our comments, maybe Cor grew his beard after this incident because his screw up made him a laughing stock on site. So he wanted to be less recognizable. And then he says, also, really, guys? A black and white planet with Klingons, and you don't
Speaker 1get the ho noir pun? We didn't get that.
Speaker 2I remember that.
Speaker 1Stu says, it's literally one extra letter away from honor. Oh, man.
Speaker 2H-O-N-O-R. Still didn't get it when he explained it.
Speaker 1Yeah. All right. So then Stu also. Looks too, we're not bright sometimes.
Speaker 2Yeah, we're not saying we, we know. So yeah, the writer of this episode is Bill Wolkoff, which I saw actually. I noticed it for whatever reason on the episode. But he has written, he wrote the movie, The Man Who Fell to Earth, which I have not seen, but it's true until Ejiofor, and I've been meaning to watch it forever. He's written episodes of Star Wars Rebels, three episodes. He's written in 10 episodes of Strange New Worlds. Uh-huh. I'm curious which episodes. Ghost of Elyria, Lift Us Where Suffering
Speaker 2Cannot Reach from season one. Those Old Scientists. He wrote Those Old Scientists. Okay. And Subspace Rhapsody. He wrote Shuttle to Confori. I'm not remembering that one. Yeah.
Speaker 1Was that the zombie episode? Shuttle to Confori?
Speaker 2I don't remember.
Speaker 1I don't remember.
Speaker 2This is season three, so I think that was season... No, you're right. That was season three.
Speaker 1Yeah, that was the zombies.
Speaker 2Okay. The Salat Who Ate Its Tail. I remember that episode title, but I don't remember what it was. And he wrote Off Hour, and he also wrote Like Chronotons Through the Hourglass, which is the next episode. All right. Well, all right. Whatever. Seems like a mixed bag. The zombies episode is one of my least favorites. It's like peak what is wrong with this show. But I do really want to see The Man Who Fell to Earth. I'm
Speaker 2going to have to check that out now.
Speaker 1Yeah. Now, Stu, I meant to send you this. Stu sent a link to a comedy sketch that he mentions that he says they referenced. So do you want me to send that to you and you watch it?
Speaker 2Sure.
Speaker 1And then you can talk about it? Okay. I'm sorry. I meant to send that earlier, and I just forgot that it was there.
Speaker 2All right. Yeah, it's pretty funny. And yeah, that does seem like it's likely a reference. It's two Scottish guys in an elevator trying to get the voice response to take them where they want to go. And they, try your American accent. Yeah, that's pretty good.
Speaker 1I'll include it in the show notes for anyone who wants to watch it.
Speaker 2Stu....
Speaker 1Has this email titled, the one where Mbinga gets his guts rearranged. And I guess because we didn't get his joke last time, he says, that's slang for sex. I was aware of that one. Stu says, hello, I just want to say to anyone offended with my calling the puppet episode something for the easily amused, I'm sorry. That you're a basic bitch.
Speaker 2Wink.
Speaker 1I don't think anyone, no one, well, I mean, you're the only one that wrote in. No one had a problem with it. Or if they did, they didn't listen anymore. They stopped. They just tuned out. That's all. They went away.
Speaker 2Whatever.
Speaker 1You're driving people away from the show. And I'm letting you.
Speaker 2No. All right.
Speaker 1So he says onboard chronometer. Just say clock.
Speaker 2Yeah. Just say the time. Like the onboard chronometer thing is a little silly.
Speaker 3Uh-huh.
Speaker 1Oh, my God. Martin Quinn snuck in a Burnistown reference in that Turbolift scene. Best episode of Strange New Worlds ever. That's the clip that we're posting with some Scottish variety show.
Speaker 2Yeah, that's super fun.
Speaker 1Damn and binga, I want Spock to show up in sickbay and pitch saving his life by somehow turning him into a puppet to Chapel's utter confusion.
Speaker 2That would be wonderful. We finally got the. We finally got the transporters working. I need you to run program Alpha Geppetto. And then, of course, Mbinga's a puppet.
Speaker 1Right.
Speaker 2That would have justified the whole puppet episode.
Speaker 1Instead of Geppetto, it should be Henson, but yeah, sure.
Speaker 2Yeah. Yeah, sure. Yeah. Yeah. Geppetto's funny. Geppetto sounds funnier. You got to admit. For the joke, Geppetto works better.
Speaker 1Sure. Stu says, damn, they actually cast boys, and it's with that guy. I've definitely seen him in stuff. Let me check. Oh, he's played several Star Trek characters before, including Voyager character Lieutenant Pete Durst and Chakotay while he was possessing the body of Durst. Jesus, Voyager, you really were a random-as-fuck show sometimes.
Speaker 2Duh. Voyager catching strays. Yeah, man.
Speaker 1Speaking of Voyager, he says, they're in danger of breaking the warp threshold. At least they'd disintegrate before turning into salamanders. Exactly.
Speaker 2I was thinking the same thing.
Speaker 1Yep. I did, too. Do you think they serve port at the port galley?
Speaker 2Of course.
Speaker 1I would assume, yeah. The new Vulcan is featured again. I just noticed that she has a mole, which as Austin Powers loving Dave knows.
Speaker 2Means she.
Speaker 1Is an undercover operative. Hashtag Cybok is coming. Why am I getting stuck with being the Austin Powers loving guy? Who doesn't love Austin Powers?
Speaker 2Yeah, that's like saying, you know.
Speaker 1Oxygen loving old Dave there.
Speaker 2Yeah, exactly.
Speaker 1Fucking, there's that Dave over there drinking water.
Speaker 2You got to it. I was like, what's the.
Speaker 1Piece of shit.
Speaker 2Trying to think of a thing and I couldn't think of a thing that everyone likes. So good job. You got to two of them. Yeah.
Speaker 1There's old orgasm-enjoying Dave. You know how Dave is. The only guy in the world who likes to cum. Couldn't they have given Spock magnetic clamps for his knees, too? Yeah, but.
Speaker 2Why is that a problem?
Speaker 1When he was on the hull, I guess.
Speaker 2I just didn't understand why it was a problem. I mean, I guess it would have helped. Maybe.
Speaker 1Or it could have hindered.
Speaker 2Yeah. The thing about those clamps, they're doing the Mission Impossible thing where you turn it off and move your hand and turn it back on and it sticks and turn it off and turn it on. I thought that was cool. And you do it in too many... How do you even disengage the ones on your knees? Your hands can engage and disengage it. Your knees can't. I mean, I'm sure that you could devise a button system of some sort.
Speaker 1Sorry, Stu, you've been scienced.
Speaker 2I'm sorry, Stu. Dave thinks that was science.
Speaker 1I do. Look, man, the only two things you got thumbs on are it. Disengage in the fucking magnets that you're holding onto. You can't, like, he moved it one time, he almost fell off the damn thing. He can't be, like, moving his hand back there to fucking fiddle with the fucking switch on his knees.
Speaker 2Yeah, yeah.
Speaker 1Christ's sake.
Speaker 2That was my point, but I do think there's a way you could, like, you know, develop buttons on the handholds to free your knees, you know?
Speaker 1Nah, that's fucking magic.
Speaker 2Or to have some good, like, knee backup, you know?
Speaker 1Yeah, nah, that's, uh.
Speaker 2Also, why knees? Why not feet?
Speaker 1I don't know.
Speaker 2He's just kind of crawling, I guess. Anyway, let's see what else we got. We can't get hung up on this.
Speaker 1I could. Pike jettisoned the pod at five seconds to go. Kind of a dick move, guy. You know, I thought that was a reference to what Kirk was accused of in court martial.
Speaker 2Oh, yeah? Yeah. Yeah.
Speaker 1Like, oh, man, you fucker. jettisoned that pod when it was still yellow alert on trial for murder by God.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 1That's a great episode. Unlike this piece of shit. No, I'm just kidding. Um, um, Stu says, uh, glad Vulcans don't show emotions that much of Spock's facial injuries are kind of what them blushing would look like.
Speaker 2Because of the green.
Speaker 1Yeah. Yeah.
Speaker 2That's a good point. That's a good point. An embarrassed Vulcan would be a whole horse of a different color, if you will. Yeah.
Speaker 1You know, I've headcanoned. That's why Spock, at the beginning of the original series, wears so much makeup. Oh. He's got foundation. He's got fucking light. Oh, yeah. All sorts of shit on. And, you know, I'm like, oh, it's just Spock trying to not blush.
Speaker 2Yeah, good point.
Speaker 1In front of the humans. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. I mean, you know, I'm sure it didn't hurt that he looked fabulous.
Speaker 2He did.
Speaker 1Stu says, wait, we just end the episode with no resolution to Boyce and Chappell's disagreement? Pike didn't even share a scene with his old confidant? Is Boyce even sticking around? You know, I don't know. We'll have to tune in next week or the next week or the next week.
Speaker 2Or whatever we're doing there. Yeah, I think that was the idea that they just set up the sort of tension between Chapel and Boyce and she decides to stay regardless of the fact that Boyce is going to be her new commanding officer because she likes the Enterprise and feels like she has something good here. And then Boyce and her are going to have to deal with their stuff next episode. I also, I really wanted to know about Mbinga's injuries. Like, is he just fully whole? I guess maybe we'll find that out too. I feel like, I know it's the future. But I still feel like
Speaker 2there should be recovery time for that. Yeah.
Speaker 1Oh, absolutely. That's why they have voice. They're going to use voice now.
Speaker 2Yeah, for sure.
Speaker 1And Benka's going to be like, I.
Speaker 3Don't have a wee-wee anymore. The table got rid of my wee-wee.
Speaker 2All the future technologies. We've done nothing for wee-wees.
Speaker 3They are slowly growing my wee-wee. It's because it was so large they have to Spend extra weeks growing it.
Speaker 2It wasn't before, but it will be now. Feels good to be chief medical officer.
Speaker 1I always said if I ever got disemboweled, bisected by a medical.
Speaker 3Bed, I would always give myself a giant wee-wee.
Speaker 2I said bigger. That's an order.
Speaker 3People will say his wee-wee is under the cloak of war.
Speaker 2Under the cock of war.
Speaker 1Okay.
Speaker 2I don't know why. I don't know why Mbinga exclusively using the word wee-wee is very funny to me.
Speaker 3It's like he's... They will call me Mbinga.
Speaker 2Oh, yeah. He's just like a... He's a medical doctor and he only uses wee-wee for penis.
Speaker 3I don't know why that's so funny to me. It is what my mother called it when I was a boy.
Speaker 2Your Mbinga voice was so spot on when you started. And now you have drifted to the Muppet shrimp.
Speaker 1And I really like it.
Speaker 3Mbinga.
Speaker 2My name's Mbinga, Rick. Okay.
Speaker 1I did not go that far. Stu says, anyway, very strong episode that had a simple premise with some, ah, Jesus Christ moments with the injuries.
Speaker 3Agreed.
Speaker 1It was fucked up, too. And a good focus on everyone pulling together to solve the problem. Yes, even Palia was useful in her soothing of Scotty. I do think it was maybe a bit too convenient that the neutrinos were the solution to both the ship-wide issue and the sickbay one. With the previously unstuffed from Mbinga season one plot, I was kind of expecting a just put him in the transporter buffer solution, but I guess we can't keep doing that or else we'll be wondering why that's not just a common solution for time-critical medical emergencies. Yeah, I
Speaker 1thought maybe a transporter buffer was in.
Speaker 2Me too. Me too. As soon as he was laid out or whatever with the thing, I was like, okay, his organs aren't staying in. Just get him in a transporter.
Speaker 3Mm-hmm.
Speaker 2And the other thing I thought with it showing his daughter.
Speaker 1And.
Speaker 2I think this could have been a beautiful end to his story, you know, that nebula, like this cloud took his daughter to explore the universe or whatever. Yeah. And like, what if she had come back from Binga before his death and he went with her? Oh, yeah. That would have been great. That's what I was thinking was going to happen when I saw that at the beginning and then he was so close to death and they have this beautiful conversation and like, it is so good to have a friend with me.
Speaker 3Okay.
Speaker 1And then when I come back, I will be using some sort of a British accent.
Speaker 2But yeah, I thought that, I thought that might be where we're going and I thought that could have been a beautiful end.
Speaker 1Yeah. If the character didn't have to be around a few years for TOS.
Speaker 2Right, exactly.
Speaker 1For two fucking episodes.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1Anyway, that's it.
Speaker 2That's it?
Speaker 1Alright.
Speaker 2That's it.
Speaker 1Stu didn't even say take care this time.
Speaker 2Stu.
Speaker 1Either that or I didn't copy and paste it.
Speaker 2Well, you know what? We won't take care this week. I never do. If we have terrible accidents, it's on you, Stu.
Speaker 1Oh, he did say take care. He did say take care in the actual email. I was really planning on a terrible accident. I wasn't. I don't want that. I'm tired. I don't have time for that. Do you have time for that? I don't think you have time for that.
Speaker 2I do not have time for that.
Speaker 1Yeah. Oh, man.
Speaker 2Well, I really enjoyed this episode. And this was fun casting with you, man.
Speaker 1Yeah, it was fun.
Speaker 2Yeah. Well, we'll be back on Star Trek Universe next week with another episode from the same writer. Maybe we'll get another banger of an episode.
Speaker 1No. An M-Banger?
Speaker 2An M-Banger, exactly. Let's see.
Speaker 3The wee-wee will be so big.
Speaker 1I tried to do the thing. Wait, what did you say?
Speaker 3I said, the wee-wee will be so big.
Speaker 2Yeah. All right. Well, we'll be back soon, guys. Joel on True.
Speaker 1Live long and prosper. Star Trek Universe is produced by Matthew Carroll and David C.
Speaker 2Roberson.
Speaker 1If you'd like to hear more from Matthew Carroll, check out all of his podcasts at strandedpanda.com. And go look for his music by searching Matthew Carroll wherever you get music. He did the theme for this show. Find out more about Effie Ophelder and her writing at euphemia.ophelda.rs. And if you want more of me, David C. Roberson, you can find links to my other podcasts, DC On Screen, my poetry, short stories, photography, artwork, and my free all-encompassing weekly slash semi-weekly newsletter at davidcrobertson.com. All links are in the show notes.
Speaker 1If you'd like to reach out and have your voice heard, email us at startrekyoucast at gmail.com.
It’s another classic watch/rewatch as Effie and I watch the Oracle scream, "SACRILEGE!" as Natira tells McCoy, “Get the pillow wedge!” McCoy got terminal, then he got busy, maman! He earned his nickname under the...
On this episode of Star Trek Universe, it’s another classic watch/rewatch: For Spock and crew it’s a race to rescue Kirk from interspace! But a new threat has Spock scratching his head! When the Enterprise is trapped in...
Let’s steal away to temporal frays - though the stakes are soft and hornless! Aye, tis time to close this gimcrack group of gimmicks gormless! 🎙 Episode Reviewed: Star Trek: Strange New Worlds 4x10 - "Tomorrow's...
Strange New Worlds has gimmicked their way to gimcrack! We're reviewing the gorgeous, mostly well-acted (but ultimately nonsensical) bit of uselessness that is the penultimate episode of season 4. 🎙 Episode Reviewed:...
Strange New Worlds finally got back around to making Star Trek for a second! There was a badmiral, tough choices to make, and ol tricky Kirk provin' his command worth! Pop-pop! 🎙 Episode Reviewed: Star Trek: Strange...