Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Spoil Me

Spoil Me artwork

Abaddon's Gate, Chapters 47-49

Nov 21, 20261 hrAudio

If you'd like to get these episodes early AND ad-free, please go to https://www.patreon.com/unspoiledand become a patron, or just follow us as a free member for updates! Thank you very much to John for commissioning this episode! In these chapters, we are experiencing some dire fucking circumstances. Anna manages to talk to Clarissa and I am pleased and relieved at the result, but very disappointed in Cortez, even though I figured that is exactly how it would go. Thank you all so much for listening, and I will see you soon with a new episode! Wanna talk spoilers? Join the Discord! https://discord.gg/rEF2KfZxfV

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1This is an unspoiled network podcast. This is Spoil Me, covering The Expanse, Book 3, Abaddon's Gate, Chapters 47 through 49. In these chapters, I'm so relieved that 49 ends where it ends, because I thought that I wasn't going to get to find out Until the next section. And I

Speaker 1was so relieved that I fist pumped and my husband was like, what's going on? And I was like, I got to find out the answer in this section. Welcome to spoil me. Welcome to the show everyone. I am Natasha.

Speaker 1Thank you very much to John for commissioning this episode. John, if you're out there, appreciate you. Might show up for the live a little bit later perhaps. This is a harrowing few chapters. And I didn't mention Bull in my intro because I'm low-key in denial. I don't really think he's alive. Not really. It seemed that he was in

Speaker 1such bad shape already that even a healthy man doing what he did, that had been questionable to survive. And I just think that considering the injuries he had already sustained, That's a wrap. I think Bull is gone. But I really don't want him to be, and I don't want to admit it. So I'm just going to deal with

Speaker 1that when we have to. But my goodness, this is grim. It's like essentially almost everybody on our side is killed. except for our Rosinante people. Like, otherwise it's like practically fucking everybody. And I wasn't ready for this to be so high casualty, like everybody. I, um, Austin says, and Anna,

Speaker 1I'm not counting her. When I say on our side, I mean like the, the people in combat, but yeah, guys, I just hated it so much. It's such a series of like really awful moments of realization. And, you know, we even have this dude from Mars that I grew to like, and the way that he dies in, in such a way that it's not immediately clear to them

Speaker 1that he died. And they're like, mid-sentence talking to him and he doesn't answer it was just really terrible this is a section that you know I am not very much into war fiction or studying actual like real life historical wars war movies it can kind of depend sometimes I can get kind of hype sometimes not but With

Speaker 1any of this stuff, you get to a place where sometimes you can kind of stumble into a person really glorifying things. I don't even want to say glamorizing because I feel like that's not it. Glorifying is more accurate, I think. And I can always appreciate an author who makes you feel as beleaguered and full of dread as I imagine one would feel. in this place, you know,

Speaker 1it's just really like the, the amount of luck involved, sheer luck, you know, being in the exact right place to not get hit by something, not get attacked by somebody. It just, it's, Harrowing is the word I used and I'll say it again. So let's begin with Holden. This

Speaker 1is so awful because we had just ended the previous chapter with Clarissa, with them realizing that they're fucking around with the elevator. So when you start chapter 47 and you have jumped back in time just a little bit, Holden is thinking... It could be worse. It didn't look like Ashford expected anyone to come at the bridge that way. And like, it could be worse. And it is pretty abruptly.

Speaker 1The part that really kind of breaks my heart is the fact that Clarissa keeping the air from, you know, from the nitrogen that they were going to try and flood the place with. Her managing to thwart that is part of why we go so high casualty, why everything is so dire. And I just, if we had just been able to talk to her before that, man, you know,

Speaker 1if we had been able to knock them out, then perhaps everybody in their fucking power armor wouldn't have continued the fight. It's kind of hard to say sometimes there are people who would keep fighting just because they figure, well, I'm going to be either like executed or severely punished anyway. So I may as fucking well, especially if you're already in that armor, um, depends also like, are you able to convince them that their leader is actually dead? Or

Speaker 1are they going to think you're, you know, like you have to provide proof. You have to show them a body. Um, There were wheels in motion that I don't know how difficult they would have been to stop. But I think that historically speaking, a lot of people who are led by a figurehead that they seem to believe in, as much as you would think those people would continue on with the vision after that leader is gone, that's usually

Speaker 1not what happens. And I feel like probably if we had been able to knock everybody out, that could have just wrapped the rest of it up. I don't know. I might be telling myself a lie. The power armor maybe would have allowed them to at least get to a place where they could like escape the ship to get to a different ship. But I don't even know how that would be. Like, there's just I don't really know enough to to know. Um, and when I say

Speaker 1I don't know enough, I don't mean like the story hasn't told me. I'm saying that I am ignorant about how much of this would work. So anyway, I, uh, start this chapter knowing that both Jim and, um, who's with him starts with a C. I've forgotten her name already. Shit. But they like, feel like, okay, at least we're coming in a back way that they won't expect it. I know that they are about to get caught. It just

Speaker 1sucks so bad. And there's a comment here. He's listening to the radio free zone, free slow zone, and is considering the fact that like, even though what Anna is saying is kind of bananas and, Because there's like gunfire in the background and things are getting so chaotic, she actually is coming across as sounding quite reasonable by comparison.

Speaker 1And he thinks so far the sounds of fighting seemed like Amos was probably bored, which I thought that was a pretty funny line. They made a plan and so far everything was more or less going the way they'd hoped. The thought left Holden increasingly terrified and, uh-huh, yes. Honestly, this is unfortunately the way that I think a lot of us are built, you know? When things go our way,

Speaker 1when we're having a streak of luck, it's really, really hard to let ourselves enjoy it because all we can think is that it just can't last, you know? This all has to be a prelude to absolutely everything going to hell. Corinne, that's her name. That's who he's with. So he gets in touch with Bull. And Bull said, we're hitting either home runs or strikes here. We own

Speaker 1the essential systems. We've got the laser down. and we're working on killing the reactor. Naomi can't get into the bridge systems. They've got her totally locked out, which means no knockout gas for the entry. And that's when he's like, so there's going to be 15 conscious people and us. That's it. We can't do that. We're sending some help, so sit tight at the command deck entry hatch and wait for- He stopped and Holden could hear someone speaking

Speaker 1to him, though the words were too low to make out. It sounded like Naomi. What's up? Holden asked, but Bull didn't answer. Okay, new problem. Bigger than the we-can't-get-into-the-bridge-without-dying problem? Yeah, Bull said. Holden felt his stomach drop. Naomi caught something on a security cam they missed in the corridor outside the bridge. Four people in power armor just left the command deck. It's the armor we took from the Martians.

Speaker 1No way to track them, but I can guess where they're headed. Get out. Get out now. Bull chuckled. It was not a reassuring sound. Oh, my friend, this will be a problem for you before it is for us. There are only three ways to get to us. They can go down through the drum, but that's messy. The maintenance corridor on the other side of the drum can't be accessed when the drum is rotating. That leaves one

Speaker 1good way to head south on this beast. Right through us? Yep. So guess what? Your mission just changed. Delaying action, Corinne said. Give the lady a prize. We might still be able to win this thing if we can buy Naomi a little more time. You get to buy it for her. Bull, Holden said. There are two of us with light assault rifles and sidearms. Those people have force recon armor. And

Speaker 1Bull tries to reassure him. I took the guns out. I took the ammo out. And he's like, they could just tear us apart. And Bull's like, yeah, so don't let them grab you. Buy us as much time as you can. Bull out. Bull is just so matter of fact, and I really do respect the shit out of it. I could never. I simply couldn't. I just don't have

Speaker 1it in me, I think, to ask other people to die. I'm not saying that he is causing their deaths, and I don't think anybody sees it that way, but It's very difficult for me to separate those things, especially if it were me, you know? So there's this moment I love, again, talk about matter of fact, where Holden says, okay, time for a last stand. And she's like, okay, well, over there has some cover that we can use. And Holden

Speaker 1is like, have you ever seen those suits and how they work? And she's like, no. Would knowing how they work change anything about what it is that we have to do here? No, he said. I guess it really doesn't. Thank you. Yes. This is also how I am, the way that she behaves here. There are times where we can wring our hands and talk about how terrible a thing is going to be. And there are times where

Speaker 1that doesn't help in any way at all. And it's just Fucking don't, you know? So, this is when he calls Naomi. And I really enjoy this. I am often not here for Holden's romantic schtick. But this was a time where it felt like he was seeing himself very honestly. And there is much less... Vaseline on the lens, so

Speaker 1to speak. You know what I'm saying? And he starts to say like that he fell in love with her the moment he saw her. And then he's like, God, that's such a lie. I barely noticed her. And once I did, it wasn't in a romantic way at all. It took so long. And he's thinking about who he had been at the beginning of the books. Basically. He remembered a man filled with righteous certainty. Right was right. Wrong was wrong. You drew the lines thus and so.

Speaker 1His time with Miller had stripped him of some of that. His time working for Fred Johnson had, if not removed, then filed down what remained. A sort of creeping nihilism had taken its place, a sense that the protomolecule had broken the human race in ways that could never be repaired. Humanity had gotten a two billion year reprieve on a death sentence it hadn't known it had. But time was up. Oddly, it was Miller who had given him his sense of

Speaker 1purpose back. He couldn't remember the version of himself who'd known exactly where all the lines were drawn. He wasn't sure of much of anything anymore. But whatever had climbed up off Venus and built the ring, it had built Miller too, and it had wanted to talk. To him. Holden realized he'd found a lifeline. He recognized latching on to the idea that the protomolecule, or at least their agent Miller had picked him, fed all of his worst

Speaker 1inclinations to arrogance and self-importance. But it was better than despair. and now only starting to see that murky path out of the hole the protomolecule had dug and humanity had hurled itself into, now he was about to be killed because of yet another petty human with more power than sense. It didn't seem fair. He wanted to see how humanity bounced back. He wanted to live to be a part of it. For the first time in a long time,

Speaker 1he felt like he might be able to turn into the kind of man who could make a difference. And he wanted to explain this to Naomi. I like you, he said instead. Jim, she replied after a moment. Her voice was thick. I've enjoyed your company ever since we met. Even when you were just an engineer and shipmate, you were a very likable one. Thank you. Thank you for everything.

Speaker 1I love you, Jim. she finally said. Holden felt his body relax. He saw his coming death and wasn't afraid of it anymore. He'd missed all the good stuff to follow, but he'd helped make it happen and a very good person loved him. It was more than most people got in a lifetime. And this is when the ship begins to vibrate and We all find out that Bull, what

Speaker 1Bull tells him, Ashton has turned off the drum. This was, the delivery to by the narrator is so good. Why would they do that? Just to stop the broadcast? Nope, Bull said. with a tired sigh. He sounded like a man who'd just been informed he was going to have to pull a double shift.' It means they think we

Speaker 1fortified the elevator shaft, and they're coming the other way.'' We' re on our way back,' Holden said, gesturing at Corinne to follow him.' Negative,' Bull said.' If they get the laser back online here, while Ashford's still sitting at that control panel, we lose.' So what? We're supposed to get up there, break into the bridge, and shoot everyone while their guys are down there breaking into engineering and shooting all of you? Bull sounded tired. Yeah. Oh, it's so stupid.

Speaker 1It's so stupid. God. God. I hate it here. All right. We go into Bull's POV. A lot of his POV is simply him watching everyone die. So I don't feel that I have to go through it sentence by sentence.

Speaker 1I feel like Jim's chapter, there's a lot of moments of realization, honesty with himself, thinking about his place in everything that I felt I really wanted to talk about specifically. But Bulls, there's a lot less of that until we get to a certain point. And I do want to say, when it comes to Jim talking about how like are

Speaker 1we going to be able to repair ourselves after all of this has happened I want to see it I want to be there for it I just really I think that is such a thing where we talk about a fear of death and I think when we say that a lot of what we are all sort of ascribing to that fear of death is not knowing what's on the other side. But I think truly, if we were to like to talk it out, the fear of

Speaker 1death is less fear of death than like jealousy of the people who are still alive. It's not exactly that you are afraid of dying. It's that you resent that the world is just going to keep going and you're not going to get to know anything about it. People are going to keep living their lives and you love them and were part of that. And now you're not. And they just are going to keep going. And there's like genuine like envy happening there that this moment of

Speaker 1him being like, I, but I want to see. even if it's not something that I would have a direct hand in, I would feel that way. I just want to, I want to know, I want to see, I want to do everything, you know? And I don't know. I, I really liked, especially that he says, I like you because I love you is what we would expect, especially of Jim. Him holding back is sort of growth on his part in a way. But I also think that I like you is just in the, a few different

Speaker 1ways more meaningful sometimes because like you can love somebody and not like them. That is very real. And it is something that my husband and I will say to each other like a lot. Hey, I like you, you know, and it's just like different. It just feels different. So, okay. Bull. Bull. So we're going up against these fucking power armor guys.

Speaker 1The last of the attackers out of the shaft tried to leap across the room, but the armor's amplification made it more like a launch. The red and black blur careened off the far wall with a sound like a car wreck. And that, Sergeant Verbinski said across the radio, is why we spend six months training before they put us in those things. He sounded amused. good thing that somebody was. Yeah, this is terrifying. It's like we're fighting

Speaker 1a bunch of Iron Mans. You know? And Bull is talking to Naomi and she's like, I can dump the core, power it all down, just give me three minutes. And he's like, that's not happening. And she's just telling him, hold on, hold on, hold on. And she says, I got the core out, I can drop the grid too, just have a few more minutes. And he... Keeps saying no and she keeps arguing until finally he's like, you are going to die and that isn't helpful. And finally

Speaker 1she's just like, oh, god damn it. Which I really, look, I'm somebody who has a very difficult time switching tasks. It's an ADHD thing where like once you zero in, trying to get out of that headspace and into a different one is so hard. And I cannot imagine being as close as she is in this task to succeeding and that everything riding on her success and then having

Speaker 1to stop with like a minute left. Oh my God, that would grind my gears. Let me tell you. Bull saw another of the enemy struggling with something, a gun. The massive glove was too thick to fit through the weapon's trigger guard. As Bull watched, the enemy snapped the guard off and settled the gun in its fist like a child's toy carried by a large man. Bull fired at it a few more times without much hope of

Speaker 1doing damage. And four Earthers shouted with one voice and launched themselves at the one with the gun. The attacker didn't fire. just swept one big metal arm through the air, scattering Bull's people like they were sparrows. Ugh. I bet this on screen was really difficult to watch. Like, just,

Speaker 1they have, there's certain tech that has made it so that we can be a lot more convincing with the appearance of people getting tossed around, slamming into walls, falling off buildings, where there used to be a certain amount of weightlessness and almost a slowed down image that makes you feel outside of it in a way that's safe. And that's Hollywood. And nowadays, those same things are really visceral.

Speaker 1And it feels like you did genuinely see somebody topple out of like a seven story building. And I bet this was really, really rough. Austin says in the chat, there are some changes they do, but it was a good adaptation. I feel like there are fewer mechs. That makes sense because that probably is like super expensive to do accurately. There's only four mechs. like according to what

Speaker 1bull said, I don't know if like the show just went down to two or what, but considering how powerful they are, apparently, I think you could probably pare it down and it would still be pretty intimidating and terrifying. So fewer isn't necessarily going to make it better, I guess. Yeah. Um, Austin says also bulls character is very different. So that's paralyzed and is in suit. Okay. Um, don't tell me too much more though, if you guys are wanting me

Speaker 1to cover it, but I know that you're careful. You're all careful. Just, just saying. Um, so they are falling back. The shaft's in vacuum. If that's the way we're going, we need to get suited up. Lockers are over there. Might want to hurry. And Verbinski says, you're not going to fit with that on. And Bull's like, yeah, okay. He's fully like, leave me here. And they don't ask.

Speaker 1They don't wait. They just get him out of there and pick him up. And he's like, oh, there's a sense of almost like he says he was a cripple again. And then he's like, no, no, I just have fewer tools. And I've worked with less. And I just love the fact that there's no question to them of leaving him behind. That's just not even on their minds at all. And that he corrects himself as soon as he tries to be like, everything is terrible again. He's like, no, no, no.

Speaker 1It's changed. Don't get into that headspace either. You know, if we're not staying, we'd best leave. Verbinski said, let's go. Bull said, Naomi cycled the door to the shaft. One by one, they pushed off Verbinski and the security man, Naomi and the Marine, then Bull and Juarez. Without discussing it, they'd all paired off with someone who wasn't theirs. In Bull's sagging mind, that seemed important. And I really, really

Speaker 1liked that. I agree. And I feel like Anna would be very touched by this if she had a moment to like see this and, and understand, you know? Um, so they're just kind of waiting for the other guys to breach the airlock. And, uh, Rabinsky is like, do you think you could crack the visor on one of the suits? And Juarez is like, maybe yours. I kept mine in good condition, which I did sort of enjoy

Speaker 1that dig the crack for the, the, not the visor crack, but there's like the, um, What do you call it? Breach. In the airlock. Breach. That's the word I was looking for. Juarez turned, his rifle steadied between his feet. The man's face went calm and soft, and the rifle flashed silently. Got one, Verb, he said. And then... Sergeant? Verbinski didn't answer.

Speaker 1He was still floating, skimming along the steel tracks that would guide the elevator, but his eyes were closed. His face was slack and foam flecked his lips and nostrils. Bull hadn't even known the man was injured. Sergeant, Juarez yelled. He's gone, Cass said. The fact that it's not that he just gets suddenly shot, but that he is injured and doesn't say anything is somehow so much worse, you know, because...

Speaker 1there's just this like understanding that they were pushing forward and he knew he wasn't making it and it didn't feel important enough to say because he knew it would like just fuck everybody's heads up. It was just like me being about to die is not worth it. ruining everybody else's chances of getting out of here and, and like just trashing their focus. I'm just going to keep that shit to myself and die quietly. That is a

Speaker 1level of like, I just, that's crazy. I look anytime that I, I encounter a character who is able to shut the fuck up on a certain level at a certain time with certain things going on. It just blows my mind because shutting the fuck up at the best of times is just so hard for me, and I can't imagine at the worst of times. Ugh. I hated it.

Speaker 1In the body of the elevator car, Juarez took a position firing down the hole at the pursuers. Bull didn't know how much ammo the Marine had, but it had to be getting close to the end of his supply. Bull would have slouched against the wall if there had been any gravity. Instead, he shifted his suit radio to the channel for Naomi. Give me a gun, she said before he could speak. Give me something. You keep going. Get to the top of the shaft. But maybe you can get the hatch open for them. Get into command.

Speaker 1You can't access the controls from inside the shaft. In this piece of shit boat, you never know. Someone might have put a self-destruct button there. Wouldn't surprise me. That's your plan B. I think we're pretty much on plan Z at this point. Anyway, you're the engineer. There's fuck all you can do here, and I heard you with Holden before. You might as well get to see him again. Not like it costs us anything. He watched her face as she decided. Fear, despair, regret, calm, in that order.

Speaker 1Impressive woman. He wished he'd had a chance to know her better. And if she was able to ship with Jim Holden and love him, maybe he wasn't as bad as Bull thought either. I adore when characters have this kind of logic. You know, who your friends are doesn't necessarily always say something about you. I think in broad strokes,

Speaker 1it definitely does. But everybody has like a friend that just kind of feels out of place. Some people date folks that they are super wrong for. But I think that in this case, the particular circumstances of their relationship and what they had gone through. And I think that it's pretty safe to say that this is like, a real connection with people who trust each other in a

Speaker 1way that a lot of relationships don't have. And seeing that and being like, oh, well, clearly I should take that as a reflection of you, I think makes total sense and is logical. And it's a shame in a way that Bulldye's not able to find out whether or not There's something with Holden that he could have, like, stood behind, you know? There's just so much possibility that

Speaker 1gets cut off. And it just makes me think of Tyrion saying death is so terribly final, you know? There's just no opportunity. And I love that when she says thank you and heads off, Bull actually thinks that was sweet. And there's no irony in it. It's not mockery. He's genuinely like, oh. And I was just like, oh, wow, bro is fucked up right now. You know, like, damn.

Speaker 1You two should go head up top. See if you can storm command. You sure? Cass said, her voice calm and professional. We've got cover here. There won't be a better place farther up. Yeah, pretty sure. What about you? Juarez asked. I'm staying here. Bull said. Okay, bro. Juarez said, and then he and Cass were gone too. They don't argue, they just fucking go. And he has the grenades on him still. So he was going to die here. Nobody

Speaker 1would have picked, but what the hell? It probably beat going back and having his spine grown back wrong. He'd seen guys who lived their whole lives in a drug haze, fighting the pain of a bad regrowth. He hadn't really let himself think about that before. Now it was safe to. And that is something that felt very real to me. The idea of like a thought connected with a potential future that you just shy away from every time it

Speaker 1begins to come up in your brain to the degree that like, once you let yourself think it, you're like, Oh God, Yeah, I've been really like avoiding going down this road at all, even in my head. It's a little devastating to know that even in this future where so much is accomplished that this sort of thing is a common injury, growing it back wrong. Like it's, that

Speaker 1just sucks. And it makes me think of like the opioid epidemic, you know, And how back pain is like a major part of a lot of people starting to get hooked. He tried to decide whether he regretted dying, but the truth was he was too fucking tired to care. And he couldn't breathe for crap. He was sorry he hadn't killed Ashford, but that wasn't new. He was sorry

Speaker 1he couldn't avenge Sam or find out if Pa was alive or whether Ashford would actually be able to destroy the ring. If he was sad about anything, it was that everything was in motion. It was that everything that was in motion now would keep on being in motion without him. And he'd never know how it went. Never know if anything he'd done had made a difference. And this is just a really like the fact that he and Jim are have been at odds in certain ways without even realizing they're at odds. And they're having almost

Speaker 1the exact same thoughts at this moment. It's just, I imagine a lot of people have the same thought, you know? So this is when Monica comes through and she somehow thinks that he's going to save them. She says, I think Anna's dead, which I never even for a moment considered that that might be true. And he has to

Speaker 1be like, yeah, pretty much everybody is dead. And I'm pretty much about to die, too. He doesn't say that, but it's like, you know, between the lines. And she says, what are you going to do about it? So the thing where we power down the ship and save everyone, we're probably not going to do that. You can't give up, please. There has to be a way. Doesn't have to be, he thought, but didn't say. Anna thought there was a way.

Speaker 1Where did that get her? But if there is, I hope one of you folks finds it. How bad is it in there? It's... It's terrible. It's like the catastrophe happened all over again. Yeah, I can see that. We can't go on. Oh, God, what are we going to do? Monica, look, I'm sorry, but... But I kinda gotta go now, okay? You folks just do your best. Hold it together and they're alright. Hey, if it all works out... Yes? Tell

Speaker 1Fred Johnson. He fuckin' owes me one. He dropped the connection, unplugged his hand terminal. He took a grenade in each hand, his thumbs on the release bars. A head poked through the hatch, then back down, fast. When no one shot at it, the head came back, more slowly. Bull smiled and nodded at it, welcoming. The opaque cowling went clear, and he saw Casimir staring at him. Bull grinned. Wow,

Speaker 1that was a pleasure at least, a little treat on the way out. Hey, Bull said, even though the man couldn't hear him. Hold this for me. He tossed the two grenades and watched the man's expression as he understood what they were. That's a hell of a line. Hold this for me. God damn. God damn, God damn, God damn. Guys,

Speaker 1remind me about Casimir. Because this is like an encounter that he had had, right? But I'm trying to remember the specifics of it. So next chapter. is Anna. And this is really, it's a beautiful chapter on a lot of levels. Anna wakes up. She had been quite injured, knocked out. She shakes her head and her spine hurts

Speaker 1when she does it. So she's clearly sustained pain. an injury difficult to know just how serious, but probably pretty serious. And, uh, Amos is there and just like, Oh fuck. I thought you were dead. And I was like in trouble for not keeping my promise. And he says that she should go into the middle of the room. Oh, and I said, tugging on the woman's arm, wake up. We need to move.

Speaker 1Okju's arm flopped bonelessly when she pulled it, and the woman started slowly rotating in the air. Anna saw that her head was tilted at an acute angle to her shoulders, and her face was slack, and her eyes stared at nothing. Anna recoiled involuntarily, the lizard living at the base of her spine telling her to get away from the dead person as quickly as possible. She yelped and pushed against Okju's body with her feet. sending it and herself floating away in opposite directions. Ugh. Poor Anna. She really been

Speaker 1through it, man. For just a regular person, you know what I mean? Like, god damn. And... Thinking about the fact that all of this was Ashford's call, I just really... We are thinking that we need to sacrifice ourselves to close the gate because the protomolecule is evil. Because it brought all the ships to a stop and hurt us.

Speaker 1So what we're going to do is team up with a guy who decides to do the exact same thing. But when he does it, it's different. Like, you know, it's just... I watched Sinners on Halloween again. If you

Speaker 1haven't seen it, fix yourself. What are you doing? And there's a moment that I don't feel like I quite fully absorbed the irony of in the moment. But when Remick comes up to the door and he's saying, well, you know, they were going to kill you. He's going to kill them. And he's acting like he's saving them, but that's not what he plans to do. But it's

Speaker 1fully like, well, when I do it, it's different. I'm saving you, actually. It's just, it's just this, this action should have been what caused both Clarissa and Cortez to change their minds. This action should have been evidence, but

Speaker 1nobody's thinking anymore. You know, they're just not. So this is when Anna is like, Monica, can we get back on the air? And Monica is just like, I thought you were dead. And she's not answering the question. And Anna is like, we have to keep doing what we were doing. What do we have to do? And Monica is like, what do you think is happening? They're trying

Speaker 1to kill us. Bull and his people have lost the engine room. Anna planted her feet against the doorjamb, grabbed Monica by the shoulders, and slammed the reporter up against the wall. Does the broadcasting equipment still work? Even now, Monica is like, it got banged around some, but does it work? Yes, Monica said. It came out as a

Speaker 1frightened squeak. This is Anna being the Corinne to Monica's Jim Holden. You want to sit here and wail about how unfair and dire this situation is, and we have fucking shit to do. Okay? We don't have time for you to wallow in fear and despair. We have a job.

Speaker 1Suck it up and shut up. And it's just evidence of the type of courage that Anna has. Maybe she is not willing to kill people, but that does not mean she is any less brave in any way. And she gets on there and gets in touch with Jim and he tells her the overall situation gets drowned out

Speaker 1almost by all of this gunfire. Is there anything we can do? Anna yelled. Sounds to me like you're in your shit. You're in some shit there yourself, preacher, unless you got the bridge access controls nearby, I'd say you should concentrate on your own problems. And, So Anna is like, okay, I'm going to broadcast. To anyone on the behemoth that's still listening, we failed to hold engineering, so our plan is to shut down the reactor and get everyone home.

Speaker 1Our plan to shut down the reactor and get everyone home is failing as well. If anyone is listening and can help, we need you. And Monica, think that will work? Anna was about to say no when the WALCOM panel buzzed at her. A voice said, how do you know that? A young voice, female, sad. Clarissa. What you said about destroying the earth if we attack the ring, how do you know that? Clarissa, where are you? I'm here on

Speaker 1the bridge. I'm in the security station. I was watching your broadcast. Can you open the door and let our people in? Yes. Will you do that? How... Do you know what you said? James Holden got it while he was on the station. So he told you that this would happen? Yes. So how do you know? I don't, Claire.

Speaker 1I don't know. But Holden believes it's true, and the consequences, if he's right, are too extreme to risk, so I'm taking it on faith. And then she hears Cortez. It is absolutely fucking infuriating. Don't listen to her. She's just afraid. And Anna actually yells, which is the correct reaction. The

Speaker 1fucking nerve. As if you aren't doing this whole thing out of pure fear yourself. But he doesn't see it that way. You're afraid to make the necessary sacrifices to protect the people we've left behind. You're only thinking of yourself. This is so... I... Look. This is when she starts saying, The people waiting outside the airlock are going to be

Speaker 1killed if you don't open it. It's Holden and Naomi and Bull. Ashford will have them all killed. Three people who all made the choice to give you a second chance. Bull chose to protect you from the UN fleet's vengeance when he had no reason to. When I asked her to, Naomi forgave you for almost killing her. Holden agreed not to hurt you in spite of the many provocations you gave him. Those people are criminals cortez tried to say over the top of her but she kept her voice

Speaker 1level and continued oh they're criminals it's just so utterly irrelevant that it makes me want to laugh but like only after i punch him in the face you know like the laugh isn't the substitute i also have to get to punch him in the face or no deal These people, the people who forgive, who try to help others, the people who give their lives to save strangers, they're

Speaker 1on the other side of that door dying. I don't have to take that on faith. That's fact. That's happening right now. Those are the people I'm asking you to help. The person I'm asking you to betray is a man who kills innocent people. for expedience's sake. Forget Earth and the Ring and everything else you'd have to take on faith. Ask yourself, do you want to let Ashford kill Holden and Naomi? No faith, just that simple question, Claire. Can

Speaker 1you let them die? What choice did they make when the same question was asked of them about you. I don't like the idea of those people being killed any more than you do, Cortez said. He sounded sad but committed to his position. But there is the necessity for sacrifice. To sacrifice is literally to be made sacred. Seriously? Anna gave a humorless laugh. We're going to do dueling etymology.

Speaker 1What we are facing here is more than humanity is ready for. You don't get to decide that, Hank. Think about the people you're killing. Look who you're working with. And tell me that in clear conscience you know you're doing the right thing. Argument by association? Really? God's tools have always been flawed. Those people are criminals, he was saying literally five seconds ago. But now, why are you

Speaker 1bringing up old shit? Let's be very fucking for real. And also, Cortez, I'm so sorry. I have zero doubt that you are also a criminal. I bet there's probably in your finances, if you had an auditor go through. Some truly wild accounting happening because that just strikes me as the kind of guy you are. Just saying. Slander. No evidence. Don't need it. That's how sure I am.

Speaker 1I am as sure about that as you are about this. And I think that I have even more evidence on my side than you do. Cortez. But when Cortez's voice came, he wasn't speaking to her. Clarissa, what are you doing? Clarissa sounded calm, almost half asleep. I opened the doors. And that's the end of the chapter. And I was like, oh, thank God. Because I really thought, I really thought that my session was about to end. And that I wasn't

Speaker 1going to get to find out what she did. And I was just like, if you do this to me, I'm going to lose it. I, this, because of listening to audio books and knowing that like I have to cover something and, and this is my job. I will often be able to like turn off the audio book that I'm listening to set it aside while I do stuff because I know I'm going to get the time

Speaker 1to listen later. I really want to know, but there are things to do. I'm covering this tomorrow. So I will find the time because that's my job. But last night it was like, if I don't listen to this whole section now, it's like the book will be deleted off of my phone. Like it was, it was like urgent. I have my earbuds in my ears when I got in the car to take the dogs to the park with my husband who I hadn't seen all day. And like, it wasn't like he was trying to talk to me

Speaker 1and I was ignoring him. We were both focused and not talking, but like I am not a person who is around people and just leaves their earbuds in their, their ears, AirPods, sorry, earbuds, AirPods. I don't do that. Cause I feel like it just looks rude. Even if they're not on the person talking to you, doesn't know, you know, but last night I was just like, I will be damned if I press pause on this right now. I was like midway through Anna's chapter as we're getting like dogs in the car. And I was just like,

Speaker 1Oh my God, I have to finish this. And like, because I still have a cast on my ankle, he drops me off at the park and we bring the dogs in and then he goes and parks because the parking is a little far away. And I just instantly turned the book back on as soon as he got in the car and started to drive and went into the park to set the dogs up with their water bowl and everything. And as he reached me, when he came back into the park, I got to that sentence

Speaker 1and I was so relieved because I was just like, he's coming and I'm going to have to take these AirPods out. And I'm almost there. I'm almost there. And then I got the sentence like right before. And that was why I like fist pumped and why he was like, what's up? And I was like, I got to find out. I'm so glad. So anyway, it was just so tense. Any, any time that it's like dialogue, where you're trying to convince somebody of something in a moment like this, I

Speaker 1find that often way more compelling than action. It's just, especially when the writer is good at creating intelligent characters who can make sound arguments that feel like they're based in bigger truths than whatever is in the book, you know? And, this was exactly that kind of thing. It's not her trying to argue about like, well, the legality of it.

Speaker 1It's about setting aside even, do you think what you're doing is right? And looking at who you're associating with, and do you trust that person to give you the kind of salvation that you seem to be looking for? Is that a person that you think should triumph over these other people? And guilt by association is not always,

Speaker 1you know, it's the same thing as like judging people by who their friends are, you know, with Bull earlier talking about this with Naomi and Holden. It's not always fair, but I think Cortez knows. I think she's right when she says, ask yourself, because I think he has had misgivings about the way Ashford's been behaving. And some people, when they begin to have misgivings, are unable to really

Speaker 1face that and just go into denial and defensive mode. And I think in a way, unfortunately, Anna was exactly what he needed to cement his position in his own mind Like he was grappling with himself, but when he gets an external opponent, it's almost like he can talk himself into it by virtue of feeling superior to her in the midst of the argument. Like that's all it takes.

Speaker 1It's not about if he's like making more sense than her, it's about his ego and his emotion, not logic. So, I don't blame her at all for trying to convince him. I get totally what she was doing. And I wanted somebody to talk to him because I was curious, like, can we win him over? But I really didn't think so. And considering how much ego ties into it, the way the whole argument goes makes so much sense, especially to

Speaker 1be sacrificed literally means to be made sacred. What the fuck does that have to do with anything, dude? And you're not willing to make the necessary sacrifices. It's the kind of backward, you're unwilling to consider that perhaps what you're about to do is going to kill the entire human race. And you literally have no more evidence to work on than what she has, but you just won't

Speaker 1even consider that. You've got less evidence because you haven't heard Jim Holden's story. story unless he's been really paying attention to what they've been saying but i don't feel like he has been really i think that they were too convincing and that he wouldn't want to see it because that would just start to wedge another crowbar and he already has enough of that with the way the ashford's behaving so yeah very compelling um john says I can't,

Speaker 1I'm a degenerate reader. I'll stay up all night to finish books. I need to be careful when I start a book. I understand. And like, look, I've been doing this a long time and I have those muscles now where I can make myself stop and be like, I will come back to it. And it's not always easy like that. You know, like last night I was just really, or the night before, I guess it was Tuesday night. It can be really hard sometimes, but it's kind of funny how, as somebody who has ADHD and has a

Speaker 1lot of problems and difficulties with task switching, that is something that I have developed a little bit more of an ability to do. And I probably need to include some other things in my like job description that require me to task switch. So I can start to be better at that. Maybe that's just all I need is like, it has to be required for my, to make a living, you know? Um, All right. i have to wrap my throat is starting to go out i don't know why

Speaker 1but uh yeah i really i really should wrap up thank you guys again so much for hanging out in the chat thank you to john for commissioning this one appreciate you a lot and i i hope everybody is enjoying the coverage until next time to the loom motherfuckers

Speaker 1That was an unspoiled network podcast.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Paladin Of Souls, Chapters 7 & 8

    Nov 20, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    If you'd like to get these episodes early AND ad-free, please go to https://www.patreon.com/unspoiled and become a patron, or just follow us as a free member for updates! Thank you very much to Megan for commissioning...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The City Of Akul, Chapters 22-24

    Nov 20, 20261 hr 5 minAudio

    If you'd like to get these episodes early AND ad-free, please go to https://www.patreon.com/unspoiled and become a patron, or just follow us as a free member for updates! Thank you very much to Michael for commissioning...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Abaddon's Gate, Chapters 44-46

    Nov 20, 20261 hr 4 minAudio

    If you'd like to get these episodes early AND ad-free, please go to https://www.patreon.com/unspoiled and become a patron, or just follow us as a free member for updates! Thank you very much to John for commissioning...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Abaddon's Gate, Chapters 41-43

    Nov 18, 20261 hr 1 minAudio

    If you'd like to get these episodes early AND ad-free, please go to https://www.patreon.com/unspoiled and become a patron, or just follow us as a free member for updates! Thank you very much to John for commissioning...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Paladin Of Souls, Chapters 5 & 6

    Nov 17, 20261 hr 14 minAudio

    If you'd like to get these episodes early AND ad-free, please go to https://www.patreon.com/unspoiled and become a patron, or just follow us as a free member for updates! Thank you very much to Yrys for commissioning...

    Credit the people on this episode