This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.splitzoneduo.com MACtion is back as of this week, and the Toledo Rockets are once again right there in the mix to win the conference. How did the most consistent program in the Mid-American get that way? And what challenges has it needed to overcome to stay there? There are a lot of them. Inside this episode: 4:20: The Cignettification of Toledo 6:38: Mike Jacobs and the small-college coaching pipeline 15:38: Remembering Toledo coaches, from Nick Saban to Jason Candle 20:04: Giant-killing and the Glass Bowl 24:38: The university, the city, and the challenges of MACtion 34:07: Can anybody else in the MAC do this? Producer: Anthony Vito
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_02Hey, this is a free preview of a Split Zone Duo subscriber episode. To hear the entire thing, you can get a subscription at www.splitzoneduo.com slash subscribe. Thanks very much to our subscribers who make this all possible.
SPEAKER_00We're coming, and we ain't backing down. We don't need a bunch of cats in here looking in the mirror.
SPEAKER_01Everybody just do your job! You understand that? Hey, will you shut up? I'm bitterly disappointed with the officiating today.
SPEAKER_00Guys being dudes.
SPEAKER_01And they run through our **** like **** through a tin horn, man. Ah!
SPEAKER_02Thank you, Lee. Thank you, Roger Sherman. I'm Alex Kirshner. And Roger, it's match-in time on the Split Zone Duo Team of the Week.
SPEAKER_03I really wanted to celebrate a team from this conference. At this time of year, you know, the Christmas commercials come on. It doesn't mean anything to me. But you start seeing those Tuesday night match-in games. And it's a sign that the college football season is getting to the important part. And, like, we are gifting you this side quest. That has nothing to do with that. That's just random football teams playing in the middle of the week in front of 800 fans on cold nights in northern Michigan and Ohio.
SPEAKER_02Maction being back always makes me want to talk about the league in a context other than, oh God, this league is dying. That's like a thing that I like to look for.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, it's fun. It's fun. It's fun and removed from the context of the rest of the sport. Very much so.
SPEAKER_02I think that Mac discourse has, and sometimes we've been part of this, overly shaded toward points that have been made a billion times and are correct about demographic death and the decline of the league and all of the works. But there are always interesting stories to talk about, about teams that are trying to defy that gravity. And we've talked a bit about this in the past. With Miami University and a Dead Letters episode. And I think Toledo is the school that this year, and frankly many years, is most consistently good at defying the direction of the sport and continuing
SPEAKER_02to fight to be relevant. And often I would say succeeding, at least to be good if not to be irrelevant.
SPEAKER_03You're being wicked guy? You said you almost went defying gravity twice.
SPEAKER_02You said it once and then you almost said it again. I noticed when I was building up to that that I was pretty close to doing it.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I think I agree with you in that like Toledo, they haven't had a losing season since 2009. Much like every other school in the MAAC, they lose their players, they lose their coaches, kind of putting together a history, putting together a roster, a good starting five of coaches who have left Toledo for other schools. And yet like they just keep on pushing. We haven't seen any 1-11s, 0-12s.
SPEAKER_03They just put together good teams every year. This year is no different. So I guess we're celebrating them just really for the fact that they keep the football the football. And they've continued doing that year after year, no matter what happens. And I was impressed with how quickly they rebuilt. Also, the October Conference USA weekday night games have never done it for me.
SPEAKER_02No, it's valor theft is what it is when we really get down to it.
SPEAKER_03They didn't come up with a good name for it. They just write weekday CUSA on the field. No puns. They clearly were biting someone else's style. It's like warm there, which is bad. I think it needs to be a miserable looking experience. It's weird that Sacramento State is now getting involved. We should note that we are recording this before Toledo's It's a Wednesday night game against Sacramento State, so we don't know how that turns out. We probably should record an entire backup episode about
SPEAKER_02Sacramento State. Well, we're going to record a quick spot after where we just say we're absolutely shocked that they lost And we can include that in the episode if they did, but I don't think they did. I feel pretty confident saying from my perch here in the past that Toledo did in fact beat Sac State. Roger, to be a Split Zone Duo team of the week, you have to be doing something that nobody else is doing in college football. And I think this year that Toledo is doing that. I think they do qualify in a way that goes beyond we wanted to make sure we got
SPEAKER_02a MAAC team into this series.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, well, first of all, they're just successfully rebuilding in this league where you lose stuff every year. And, of course, Toledo lost something pretty big last year. They lost their head coach, Jason Candle, to UConn. He took 24 players to UConn, which is a lot. And it seems to be like Toledo might be the first program, I would say, North Dakota State aside, that just was like, we are going to transfer up an FCS program.
SPEAKER_02And that it worked.
SPEAKER_03It's working really well. Like North Dakota State probably doesn't count because they just were an FCS team and then they started playing in the FBS and it works. Like Toledo went out, they hired Mike Jacobs, who has been an awesome hire and who has won everywhere. And he's definitely got some Cignetti elements to him and we'll talk about him later from Mercer. They hire him from Mercer and he takes... All of these highly talented players from Mercer.
SPEAKER_03Their starting running back, C.J. Miller, is a Mercer transfer. Their top wide receiver, Ajate Dobbs, is from Mercer. And of course, you highlighted him before the season on some of the preview episodes. Andrew Zock, the reigning FCS Defensive Player of the Year, who has just been as good as advertised. In FBS, he's top 5 in sacks, top 10 in TFLs, he's number 4 in forced fumbles. A lot of those stets go together when you get a sack, you're often getting a forced fumble, and you're definitely getting a TFL, but still, just like, the guy is a game changer for them.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, he's sweet, and we always take pride in getting good calls right about which FCS to MAC transfers are going to be good. Because this is actually a league that I think has a better track record than most, both coaching and player, of successfully bringing in FCS guys and it just working out. It's oftentimes better on paper elsewhere, but in the MAC, it's often been pretty good in practice as well.
SPEAKER_03And it makes me wonder, like, we talked about it on the Oregon State episode, The quarterback for Mercer, Braden Atkinson, is over at Oregon State thriving. They could have just brought up the whole team. But John Allen Richter is doing a fine job for Toledo as well, a longtime Toledo guy.
SPEAKER_02So, Roger, the player or coach that is making this happen, probably time to talk about Toledo Signetti, if you will.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I think I've decided that Mike Jacobs is, in fact – A sort of Wario form of Kurt Signetti. They not just have similar lives, but almost directly opposite lives. You can go back, we did the Career Trajectory episode about Kurt Signetti and his wife and his family back in last December. There's so many things that ring exactly opposite. Mike Jacobs' dad was a coach.
SPEAKER_03Mike T. Jacobs, it's not a junior situation. They're both just named Mike Jacobs. He was a former offensive coordinator at West Virginia and Ohio State. He was the O-line coach when Orlando Pace was at Ohio State. Man, I was just looking at Orlando Pace's college career. He got Heisman votes. And he was the number one pick of the draft. Sorry, I'm off topic now, but I'm really fascinated that there was an offensive lineman who was named MVP of the Big Ten and got Heisman votes.
SPEAKER_03Anyway, back to talking about Mike Jacobs. Mike Jacobs, his dad... We talked about how Kurt Cignetti's father was the head coach at West Virginia and was fired in 1980 as he dealt with a cancer scare. Mike Jacobs' dad, also named Mike Jacobs, was on the staff that replaced Frank Cignetti at West Virginia. Kurt Cignetti's dad, Frank Cignetti, coached at Indiana University of Pennsylvania. Mike Jacobs' dad coached at California University of Pennsylvania for the Vikings.
SPEAKER_03They're on opposite sides of the... Of the Indiana University of Pennsylvania versus California University of Pennsylvania rivalry.
SPEAKER_02This is such an important point. That is a very serious rivalry. We have talked in passing about Cal U on this program before. I'm glad you brought it up. And it makes me feel like I know Mike Jacobs much better than I would from just knowing the resume.
SPEAKER_03So, Roger. It's now called Penn West Cal, by the way. And the other things that, like... Mike Jacobs has come up level after level. He has like an 80% winning percentage, which is pretty much identical to Kurt Signetti's at his various Division 3, Division 2 jobs. It's like so many things are exactly the same about them and their paths up through the sport.
SPEAKER_02One of Mike Jacobs' stops, one of his most prominent stops, in fact, maybe the one that was most formative to his story, was Notre Dame, but Notre Dame College, which is interesting, Roger, because do you know one fact, a fun fact, a not-so-fun fact about Notre Dame College, cradle of Mike Jacobs' coaching career today?
SPEAKER_03They don't have a team. It's sort of a grand opening, grand closing thing that Notre Dame College started a football program in 2010. They did not really have any success until Mike Jacobs showed up. He got them to the Division II semifinals. And then shortly after he left, they just closed up the program. So that shows you like the amount of, well, sorry, they didn't close up the program. They closed up the college. Yes. The college is no more.
SPEAKER_02All the above. But yes, in May of 2024, the Notre Dame College in South Euclid, Ohio, went out of business. And I actually think that for purposes of talking about what Mike Jacobs is doing at Toledo, though we'll get to this momentarily, a guy who can... Not just survive, but thrive in an environment where, let's just say there are headwinds going against not just the football program, but the university itself, I think is a very valuable experience
SPEAKER_02for a football coach at Toledo in 2026.
SPEAKER_03I think that Notre Dame College, it seems like, first, they were a women's college for most of the 20th century. And then they started a team in 2010, probably just to get attendance numbers up. And it didn't work. But it did briefly work when they made the Division II semifinal with Mike Jacobs. And the running back for those teams, Jaleel McLaughlin, is in the NFL with the Browns. And he set the NCAA all-division record for rushing yardage, which is kind of nuts.
SPEAKER_03Some of those were after he transferred up to Youngstown State. But like... Anytime you have a guy who takes over to school with a program that literally never had any success before him and no longer exists after him, and you're going into the playoffs, you're setting all-time NCAA records, that's pretty good. After Notre Dame College, he goes to Lenore Rhine in Hickory, North Carolina. Pretty similar story. It's another program that had never won a conference championship.
SPEAKER_03All of a sudden, they are, you know, making the playoffs. They are making the Division II semifinals, just like he did at Notre Dame College. Then after there, he goes to Mercer in Macon, Georgia, I believe. And again, a school that had never won a conference championship. He wins two back-to-back, makes two FCS playoff appearances. Like, this just keeps happening with this guy. I'm sorry, I gotta factor on there. I'm sorry. I wrote in my notes they never won a conference championship before Mike Jacobs.
SPEAKER_03That was not true at Lenore Ryan. It is true at Mercer.
SPEAKER_02Thank you for your integrity.
SPEAKER_03Lenore Ryan has a pretty decent division, Division 2. Also, you know what else is weird? Can I just keep doing fun asides?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I love your side quests.
SPEAKER_03Drew Cronick, the offensive coordinator at Navy, was the head coach at both schools directly before Mercer. Mike Jacobs.
SPEAKER_02Wow. So he was the head coach at Lenore
SPEAKER_03Ryan and left for Mercer. Yeah, that's next. That's next up. I don't think he runs the option. No. But I guess they were just like, who can we hire that can do a good job replacing Drew Kronick? And they were like the guy who just did it at Lenore Ryan. So that's his trajectory. Long story short, every single place that he has coached, he has had a top 10 finish. That's not going to be true at Toledo. They are not going to finish in the top 10. At this point, you'll have seen the college football playoff rankings. They're not going to have Toledo in them, most likely.
SPEAKER_03But, I mean, that level of success is a type of thing that I love when we talk about coaching candidates. Like, don't bring me the guy who's just been hanging out on staffs with famous people. Bring me the guy who's made something out of nothing over and over again.
SPEAKER_02Yes, he has very much done that. He is also following up in an unusually successful tradition of lower level head coaches coming to the MAC and seemingly doing pretty well. I say seemingly because it's still early, but it looks like this is going to be a success. The MAC has been a very good spot for Brian Kelly. When he went to Central Michigan, remember Brian Kelly was a Grand Valley State Dynasty builder at Division II. His FBS debut was at Central Michigan.
SPEAKER_02Jerry Kill in Northern Illinois. Lance Leipold from the Division II ranks at Buffalo. Or Division III, excuse me, with Lance Leipold. Division III, I think, yeah. Chris Creighton at EMU. There's just a good, long track record of this working, even from the sub-FCS level, sub-Division I level. In a handful of cases in the MAC, football is football. I respect when athletic directors making these hires take the approach that winners are winners, program building is program building.
SPEAKER_02We tend to focus on the biggest success stories, your Signetti's, your Jim Harbaugh's, your Kalen DeBoer's, but there's quite a few at this point of these guys who have taken pretty bad, pretty bleak jobs from even sub-FCS or FCS itself. Thank you for listening. This has been a free preview of a because he stopped over in FCS the last few years, but for most of his career has been a small at www.splitzoneduo.com.
Richard and Alex preview the second-to-last week of the college football regular season, featuring dozens of games. Just some of them are: * 8:45: Yale at Harvard * 22:42: San Diego State at Boise State * 34:38: Memphis...
Guest host Jessica Smetana joins Alex to talk through the third College Football Playoff rankings reveal of the season. This episode first aired as a live stream on YouTube and has been spruced up lightly by our...
Lane Kiffin’s first year at LSU is a failure, Colorado State has the worst defense we have seen in many years, Wake Forest is a playoff team, Texas Tech probably is too, and there’s much more to discuss from Week 11 in...
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.splitzoneduo.com Rodger Sherman joins Alex to talk about the most hyped Year 1 head coach in the history of college football, who is currently 0-3...