Fear of failure isn’t really about failure - it’s about what failure means to us. We’re not scared of messing up; we’re scared of being judged, embarrassed, or proving our worst insecurities right. But the people who actually succeed at anything are the ones willing to suck at it long enough to get good. Today, we break down why failure feels so terrifying, how social comparison messes with our heads, and why the loudest critics are usually the ones who’ve never done a damn thing themselves. Tune in for some practical tips on overcoming all of this. We also dig into the science of why boredom can spark better ideas, why our addiction to content might be making us less creative, and whether we should all do a digital detox before our brains turn into overstimulated mush. Finally, we wrap things up with a simple but profound question: If life is just an endless series of trade-offs, what are the best problems to have? Because problems never go away - you just get to level up to better ones. The Creative Benefits of Boredom: https://hbr.org/2014/09/the-creative-benefits-of-boredom CHAPTERS Chapters 00:00:00 Introduction: The Morning Workout Experiment That Failed 00:02:39 The Fuck of the Week: Fear of Failure 00:03:47 What You're Really Afraid Of: It's Not the Failure Itself 00:05:25 The Spotlight Effect: Nobody's Watching You Like You Think 00:09:35 Reframing Failure: You Have to Suck at Something First 00:11:43 Why Fear Is Really About Relationships 00:13:49 The Paradox of Cringe: Growth Requires Embarrassment 00:16:02 Five Tactics to Conquer Fear: Exposure Therapy and Beyond 00:22:43 Building an Identity Around Doing Hard Things 00:25:18 The Key Takeaway: Focus on Process Over Outcome 00:27:27 Brilliant Bullshit: Does Boredom Make You More Creative? 00:35:07 The Creativity Crisis: Why Art Feels Less Innovative 00:39:39 Practical Tips: How to Use Boredom to Boost Creativity 00:42:18 Reader Question: What Are the Best and Worst Problems to Have? 00:48:22 The Red Paperclip Story: Life as a Series of Trade-Offs 00:51:43 Wisdom of the Week: Mark's New Favorite Joke ⇨ Sign up for my newsletter, Your Next Breakthrough. It will help make you a less awful person: https://markmanson.net/breakthrough ⇨ Get clarity on what actually matters. Try Purpose, Mark's AI mentor app that learns your patterns, challenges your blind spots, and helps you take action. Get started at https://bit.ly/4w46FMH FOLLOW MARK Mark's IG: https://www.instagram.com/markmanson Solved IG: https://www.instagram.com/solvedpodcast/ Twitter: https://x.com/markmanson LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/markmanson/ YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@IAmMarkManson Theme Song: Icarus Lives by @Periphery, used with permission from Periphery.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
I made a discovery this morning, Drew. Okay. And maybe, I don't know, maybe there's actually a lesson for the audience here. This isn't just me talking about myself as usual. I'm not a morning workout person. I can't. Same. I can't do it. And I've tried on and off for years. And, you know, in the last year and a half of the business where I've been shooting a lot more videos and doing the podcast and everything, like there are days where I'm at the studio all day and I come home and, you know, I usually work out. I used to work out like 4 or 5 p.m. after work. And, you know, now I get home. I'm just exhausted. I don't want to do anything. I just want to like melt into the couch. And so my wife and a friend of mine, they were like, you know, you should really pick up the morning workout thing. Like it energizes you for the day and, you know, all this stuff. So, like, that's been one of my 2025 things is like I'm going to become a morning workout person. And not working, huh?
No, man. I was, I was in the gym at like six 45 this morning. I got one rep into my second set of deadlifts. And I was like, fuck this shit. I'm going home. And I left. I feel the same way. I don't know what it like I get up. I want to get up in the morning and I want to like start working on shit. I don't like, I'm the same too. My brain, I don't feel energized by it. I don't, my brain is super alive in the morning and my body is super lazy and tired. Yeah. Yeah. And it's like I'm most intellectually productive, like, say, between six and nine. So if I'm spending half that time in a gym, it feels like I'm wasting that. Yeah. And meanwhile, I'm like physically making myself miserable.
So, yeah, it just felt like a very bad trade off. Yeah. So as of today, I have abandoned my morning. Hey, what's the saying? You set your goals in January, abandoned them in February. Here we are. Consider it abandoned. Yeah. Consider it abandoned. But I did learn something about myself, which is actually what's most important. I think that is really important for people to understand, though, too, to kind of work with your own personality around those kind of things. Like there's no right or wrong way to do it as long as you're just doing it. Right. And I believe we're going to talk later today about like what can you actually change about yourself and what can't you. And I think this is – yeah, this is a huge thing, which is like recognizing that –
There is no one size fits all advice. Yes. Everybody's body is slightly different. Everybody's brain chemistry is slightly different. Everybody's lived experience is different. So if something's not working for you, let it go. Yeah. Stop trying. Let it go. Stop trying. Let it go. Do you want to sing Frozen? Let it go. Let it go. I never, I haven't seen Frozen actually. I'm like. We should, you know, we've talked a little bit about doing a live podcast. We should do a live podcast musical. Oh yeah. Hey, I'm for it. You could play some guitar. I'll sing. Give the people what they want, girl. Let's give the people what they want. Okay. It's the Subtle Art of Not Giving a Fuck podcast with your host, Mark Manson. All right. What are we talking about? Something completely different. What are we doing? What are we doing here? It's not that different. No. Mark, the fuck of the week this week. Yes. Failure, specifically the fear of failure. Okay. You get a lot of questions around this. Yeah.
No bullshit, Mark. We all fear failure in some way and we're going to get into the nitty gritty of it here. You do get a lot of questions around this though. And it is probably one of the most common fears, you know, if you got heights, spiders, failure, like they're all up there. Sure. Death. Yeah, sure. What I did was I kind of went out and gathered. You've never really specifically addressed this. I mean, you have in like maybe a paragraph here and there in your writing or you've had some questions. I don't know what it is. We've never really like specifically addressed this. But you have written a lot around fear. You've written a lot around failure and how to deal with it. And so now we're going to marry the two fear and failure.
My initial take here, and this is probably why I haven't written a lot about it explicitly, is because it's not really the fear of failure. It's a fear of what the failure means. Yes. Right? So to some people, what the failure means is that they're going to be laughed at by others. For some people, what the failure means is that they're a loser and they're not worthy. Like they suck and they're never going to have a good opportunity in life. For some people, the failure means that they shouldn't have even tried, that there's no point to anything, right? So it's – think of it this way. If you tried to do something very difficult in the privacy of your own home, in your bedroom, nobody's watching. There's no stakes involved. There's no judgment involved. You're just like trying a thing. Chances are you're not very afraid of failing at it. Like you're not really worried that you're going to screw it up. It's as soon as –
other people get involved that the fear starts to emerge. And then, and that other people, it's both concretely, you know, it's like if people are watching, but also it's abstractly, right? It's like if you're trying to do something that is, you know, can be socially compared to others, right? It's like, okay, all your friends are really good at this thing. And now you're afraid to try it because if you're not good at it, you're going to feel worse than all of your friends, right? It's the social comparison and it's the status comparison that like is actually driving the fear. It's not the failing at the thing itself. Right. Yeah. And that's a point you've made in several different spots. You know, why we feel the failure, what you kind of alluded to there was one is the spotlight effect. We think people are paying more attention to us than they do.
So that's a factor in this is that we tend to overestimate how much people are actually care if we're doing something or not. Right. It's a, you know, if, if all of our friends are, uh, are experts at acro yoga and we try acro yoga and are terrible, we tend to overestimate how much they care and are paying attention and might judge us. The interesting effect though, is that generally people who are. The better people are at something, the less they're going to judge you for trying. That's a little side note. What do you mean by that? Like, let's say you want to start your own business, right? Who are the people that are going to criticize you? It's the people who haven't done a fucking thing. The people who have actually started a business are going to be the ones who are like, yeah, you should totally start a business. It's really hard, but it's amazing. Here, let me give you some tips. Let me help you, right? It's like the bodybuilder at the gym is never the guy like...
insulting people right for because they can't pick up heavy weight it's other people who can't pick up heavy weight who are insulting you because that bodybuilder has been there he's been there before totally he's been he's like oh i know the struggle he's going through exactly yeah exactly and so they're not going to sit there and shit on you exactly yeah you you had uh this is we're jumping ahead my little plans that i have ruining your plans never works anyway i don't know why i make outlines for these but You have this great quote that you posted recently is like if you wouldn't take their advice, then fuck their criticism. Yes. This is kind of what you're getting at. Yes. As well. Well, and it's I think. OK, so this is I guess this might get into one of the one of the strategies to kind of alleviate the fear of failure is like. Yeah.
Look, what is the social comparison driving that fear of failure? Like, what is the thing? Like, look at the thing you're afraid to do. What is the social meaning behind that thing driving the fear? And then ask yourself, do you actually respect those people that you're afraid to fail in front of? Because in a lot of cases... People are not. Actually, it's the people you respect the least that you're afraid of embarrassing yourself in front of them. And like that makes no fucking sense whatsoever. Why would you be afraid to embarrass yourself in front of somebody that you don't respect their opinion in the first place? That's just that's completely illogical. So that's like one kind of mental reframe that people can use to get a little bit more clarity around this.
Yeah. If you want a less vulgar quote that you could attach to this to, I came across this and digging some of this up. There was this famous, it used to be a famous evangelist. I don't know how famous he was, I guess, but an evangelist. So going kind of the other way here, Mark, his name was Dwight L. Moody. And a woman came up to him one time and she said, well, I don't really like the way you preach. And he said, well, I like my way of doing it better than your way of not doing it.
Like that's OK. That same sentiment. Yeah. You're communicating with that. But yeah, it is always the people on the sideline. Yeah. Who are the hecklers. Yeah. Like what's the famous Teddy Roosevelt quote about the man in the arena? Right. It's like it's never the other guy in the arena who's going to talk shit unless I mean it's a competition. But like. It's always people on the sidelines who are afraid to do it themselves. And the reason they are talking shit is because they're afraid to do it themselves. Right. So it's like the reason you're afraid of failing at it is because they're going to judge you because they're also afraid of failing at it. And so you get this weird like game theory thing where it's like if just one person wasn't afraid to do it, then maybe nobody would be afraid. Right.
Right. Yeah. But I mean, it does go back. So it's not the failure itself that you're afraid of. Like you've just outlined, it's the judgment, it's the rejection, it's the embarrassment. Yeah. And so those are the things we need to focus on. So another way to put it too, and I think you've said this in some way or another somewhere, is anxiety. So failure, the fear isn't the problem. It's the avoidance that's the problem, right? Avoiding even taking action in the first place is the actual problem there. So we've already jumped into this, but there is like a, you can do all these different, you can try to reframe failure in a lot of different ways. And one of those, first of all, is the criticism part that you're talking about where you can, you can reframe that as, oh, these people doesn't matter. Sure.
A number of other reframes that you've brought up over the years, though, too. One of them being failure is necessary for growth. Yes. Another way to put that, too. Another way I've been thinking about this lately is you can't get good at something unless you suck at it first. Totally. Like you have to suck at it first. You have to. Yes. Yes. That and like once that sinks in, it's like it's so obvious. But yeah, you have to suck at it. You're just going to have to suck at it. There's no NBA player that just woke up and started hitting every shot. Right. Right. It just doesn't exist. Right. Yeah. The prodigies are the very rare exceptions. Yeah. The rule. Yeah.
And even they, you know, at some point they need to start working and failing and screwing up. So yeah, it's, it's failure is a fundamental part of the process. And I think, and it's funny because again, in areas of people's lives where there is no social judgment, uh, they seem very comfortable with that. Like if you think about picking up a new hobby at home by yourself, again, there's no like sort of judgment or pressure to perform or anything. You just, you know, and accept. So I'll give you an example. Like a really good friend of mine, guy I grew up with, um, started renovating his own house. Uh, you'll, you'll appreciate this. And like, he's always been handy, but he didn't know shit about home construction. Right. Right. And so he just started pulling up YouTube videos.
Yeah. And going on online forums and asking questions and like buying the stuff. And he screwed a lot of stuff up, but it's, it's three years later and his home looks incredible. Right. And it's just that long process of like screwing things up, buying the wrong material, installing it the wrong way, uninstalling it, installing it again, watching the YouTube videos, trying again. And it's in the absence of that social judgment, uh, It's it there's there's no pressure to perform. There's no like fear of the fallout of like, oh, I installed my new water heater incorrectly. Like it's just you just take it down and you install it again. Again, we accept that in most areas of our lives where we don't have this status game going on in the background.
It's as soon as that status game enters into our head that we start obsessing and becoming very neurotic about like, well, if I don't do it right, then, you know, I'm a loser and God, I fuck everything up and nobody's ever going to want to hang out with me again. You know, it's like all those narratives start growing and taking place. So it's. I guess I've never thought about it this way before, but like, I think it's not too much of an exaggeration to say that like fear of failure or fear of action is an extension of relationship issues, essentially. The way you relate to people in your life, right? Like if you have a very unhealthy relationship with the people in your life or with what you believe is gonna get you approval from the people in your life, that's gonna drive the fear of trying and doing things.
If you feel like you're supported and people care about you unconditionally, then that removes the downside costs of screwing something up, right? Like then you're not afraid to like install the water heater incorrectly. Like there's no consequence, you know? Yeah. That totally checks out with me too. Because like all my friends think, oh, yeah, Drew can come and fix this. And I will. I always fuck something up. Yeah, yeah. But then the thing is like you have the confidence enough to go fix it. Yes. Like that's the – yeah. That's the – like I don't – I might doubt that I'll be able to do something, but I have the confidence that I'll be able to fix it if I do fuck it up. I mean another way to put it is that like fear tends to occur in proportion to like the perceived stakes of something. Right? So it's like if you perceive the state – and this is where the spotlight effect comes into because like there are some people who do have supportive –
people around them, but they're just incredibly insecure and neurotic and think that like everybody's going to hate them all the time. And so if that's the case, then yeah, you're going to have a really intense fear of failure pretty much perpetually because you have this irrational, uh, sense that you're going to be judged for a ton of things that you're not going to be judged for. You also say though, like you have this, uh, kind of related to that, what you call the paradox of cringe. Do you want to explain that one a little bit? Do you remember that? Remind me. Yeah. So I like it, though. The cringe where the moments of our lives are often hold the seeds of our growth, basically. You know, you call this the freedom to be misunderstood, too. Yeah. So and this this really hits home for me, too, with the with the podcast over this last year and kind of seeing like we go back and I look at those early episodes. And Jesus, I cringe hard at that.
But now I really do recognize, even after all these years of working with you and hearing these things, is that that is – that's the process. Yes. We were willing to suck at it. Yes. And put it out there. And there were a lot of people who were like, what the fuck is this, guys? Yeah. And I was like, oh, that's – Part of it. Yeah. I remember if you cringe at your past self or you've said this before, that's a good sign. That's yeah, exactly. Like it's, you should be cringing at your past self consistently because that is a signal that you've grown or gotten better at something. And, uh, it's interesting hearing you say that too, because it's like, you've been in the business for a long time. And I think you've seen that externally. You've seen me go through it. Oh, I intellectualized all of this. Yeah, totally. But it's now you're living it. Yeah.
And it is a very different experience when you live it, right? It's like – because, yeah, you go – like I've not watched our old podcast episodes, but I'm sure if I did, I would totally cringe and be like, oh, my God. It's like what was I thinking? Oh, Jesus. That lighting. What the fuck? But – That – I mean at this point in my career, that's just been a constant of everything. So yeah, it is weird that like you want a certain amount of cringe in your life. Yeah. Yeah. You said something to affect too at one point that the world rewards people who are willing to be bad at something long enough to get good at it. Yes. That I think too – that's a really good way to sum this all up I think in those terms where –
If you're just willing to, you have to sit through the suck. You have to sit through the criticism and the cringe and all of that. Yeah. Some of the ways though that you've, we can, we can get into a little bit more of the, the prescriptive stuff here too. You, you wrote this article, it's called how to conquer your biggest fear. And you have these kind of five things and we can go through as many of them as we want. These five kind of tactics you can use. One of them is exposure therapy. And I think this probably comes from like CBT and stuff like that, right? Sure. Where you gradually face what you fear in manageable doses. Right. What's the advantage of that? So if you are, let's say you have experienced a lot of social anxiety. So it's you, what you do is you look for a sweet spot that feels challenging, but not overwhelming. Right. So you experience a lot of social anxiety. Actually, we did a video with a woman who had social anxiety. And that video is basically just the exposure therapy over the course of 30 minutes or edited into a 30 minute video. So she had extreme social anxiety.
We took her to a mall and just had her talk to a few – like small talk with strangers and kind of ask a couple awkward questions. And at the time, that felt absolutely terrifying and difficult, but it was also manageable. It wasn't – it didn't seem outside the realm of possibility. And then as the video goes on, we like put her in more intimidating situations slowly but surely. And then by the end of the video, she had to give an impromptu speech in front of 50 people and something that like was completely unimaginable to her. when we had started shooting and exposure therapy is basically just stair stepping your fear. So if there's something that feels terrifying and overwhelming, just break it down in the smaller parts and look for the smallest action that does feel challenging, but not overwhelming. And it feels within you, within the realm of possibility of your, like your current ability. Yeah. Okay. Um, there's another one too. It's kind of related as orthogonal exposure. Yeah. Call it, which is tackling, uh, related, but different activities to shift your perspective. Yeah.
Yeah, so this one's a Mark Manson harebrained theory. I'm not aware of any research behind this, but it's just something I've noticed in my own life and with other people. If you can find something that is related to your big fear, so let's say your big fear is large social gatherings, right? Like being in a party or standing up and talking, giving a presentation or something. There are smaller... adjacent things that you can do that can perhaps build a comfort that will then relate to that. Right. So let's say you're really afraid of giving presentations at work and you freak out. You know, maybe you start looking up jokes to tell to a group of friends, you know, like that's a way to like, it's not the same thing, but is orthogonal to the thing that you're afraid of. And so it builds, it builds some reps that are like related to it. Okay. Okay. Yeah, that makes sense.
And that can be applied like if you're afraid to start a business, like, well, don't quit your job and like start a little side hustle. Like sell something. Right. One thing. Like, yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So it's related to the exposure therapy, but it's like it doesn't have to necessarily be the exact same thing. It can be like a it can be like a separately kind of related thing. OK. All right. Next one, altitude training. Push yourself slightly beyond your comfort zone to make the original challenge feel easier by comparison. So there's like a – and you talk about the Goldilocks zone of doing that too. So we have another YouTube video where I do this with a guy who – his issue was he just was uptight and –
You know, really, really like perfectionist about everything in his life. And I just, I put him through the most extreme, absurd circumstances repeatedly. So we finished that video. I think I made him put on a chicken suit and invite strangers skydiving. And it's basically, it's like turning up a volume knob to 12 and then realize, and then once it gets turned back to the three or four that was bothering you before, it feels so quiet and simple and easy that it's just like by comparison. Yeah. You know, you kind of ask yourself, you're like, why did I worry about this stuff before? There are strategic places to do that. Right. Like if if I would say if it's an anxiety related issue, you probably don't want to do that. But if it's more of a difficulty, like letting things go or it's like a control issue or if it's just like.
there's kind of a low-level intimidation or procrastination of something, that can be effective. You just dial it up to 11 and then bring it back to where you actually want it. And then when you bring it back, You're like, oh, this is actually easy. So a simple example for my own life, back when I was dating and I was, you know, like a lot of young men, I was intimidated by dating or found it frustrating or often found myself in front of attractive girls who like I didn't know what to say. I went and lived abroad and I like tried to date girls who didn't speak English and I didn't speak their language. And it was so fucking impossible. Yeah.
that that when i came back to the u.s like a date with an american girl was so easy i was like this is fucking gravy yeah i'm like this is nothing so so that's one example okay okay yes well actually okay so the next tactic is making it fun yes gamifying it bring friends in i think that's a big one make it funny in some way uh it takes small small failures as a badge of honor like you did with the rejection game or something like that i think that's a really good way to go about it. Yeah. And it's, it's kind of funny to suck at something. Yeah. Right. Like when you, when you, if you don't take it so seriously, I think you're absolutely right. Like, Oh God, look at how bad I suck at this. This is hilarious. Right. Like I'm thinking about, I, uh, so I'm, I'm just thinking of like handyman stuff. Um, uh, I guess from the previous example, I remember like a number of years ago, um, my mom was moving and she asked me to like hang up a towel rack and, uh, uh,
And so I went and I did it for – I did such an awful job. Like I put – She's never asked you again. I like mismeasured everything. Like the thing was crooked. It was so bad that I actually brought her in and we started laughing at it. I was like – like you really should just hire somebody. Like this is – I'm useless. I'm absolutely useless. Okay, the last one, which might be a little more serious, would be to focus on identity formation where you challenge beliefs like, you know, I'm not good at X, which is like an identity thing. Like, I'm just not good at this or not someone who does this. Some of this is like growth mindset, fixed mindset, right? Like, I think a lot of people who struggle with fear of failure, it's because they –
they see it as something that can't really be changed, right? Like you mentioned earlier, the process of like failure is part of the process of growth. Well, you have to believe in the potential of growth to even like accept that. So if you think that you're just never gonna be good at something, then it makes sense that there's no upside to failing at it, right? You might as well just avoid it. So I do think a lot of that is growth mindset related. I also, I mean, just something that I think developed in my early adult life, kind of being into all this stuff is like, I started to notice by, I don't know,
by my late twenties, I started to develop an identity as I am a person who does hard things. I am a person who is willing to fail and embarrass. Like I actually kind of wear as a bad badge of honor, uh, like how difficult it is to offend or embarrass me. I hit that point somewhere, maybe 10, 15 years ago. And, And once I hit that point, I started to become very proud of it, like almost consciously because it's like, okay, that's a trait I want to keep. That's like a very valuable trait to have in life. And so let me like build some pride around that and put some of my identity into that because that's going to pay off later, right? Like if there's something else that I'm afraid of or intimidated of down the road –
I'm not going to be as scared to do it. Like anything else, just the same way feeling like nothing you do is ever going to succeed can become a piece of your identity. And that's a terrible thing to build an identity around. You can also build an identity around – I'm the type of person that will persevere through anything and figure it out and I will grow and eventually succeed at it. And then, of course, the next question people have is like, okay, well, how do I build that identity? Well, the only way to build an identity is to do things. Actually go do the things, right? So your brain is like –
anything else, which is it only believes something that it is perceived repeatedly. And if you haven't actually proven that you are willing to do difficult things and fail multiple times and weather rejection and embarrassment, uh, your, your brain's not going to believe that that's who you are. So you, you have to like earn it to a certain extent. So in many ways, like that's kind of like the last stage I would say of like, kind of figuring this out. It is funny. I joked at the top of the show of like, oh, what does that feel like? Like, I honestly... You're not normal in this regard. No, like, it's been a long time since I've really... Because it's like, even this show, right? Like, let's say this show bombs. Yeah. I'll feel bad for like,
30 minutes. Yeah. Yeah. And then I'll immediately be like, okay, pull up the data. Like what, what did we do? Right. What did we do wrong? Like, give me a report on like what we could have done better. Right. Like that's just how I approach everything. And that's the biggest thing I've taken away from all of this too. Just this learning experience from that too is like, yeah, you're going to feel shitty about it. That's okay. On to the next one. Yeah. It's, yeah. It's just, that's part of it. Yeah. And I think that's kind of like the, the, the key takeaway here is that the focus on the process over the outcome is really what you need to kind of reframe. Again, it goes back to that quote. You said life rewards those willing to be bad at something for long enough to get good at it. That's the whole process. Yeah. It's not the outcome that matters. It's just, it's.
And anytime, you know, cause your mind, you know, your monkey brain will try to trick you and make you focus on any particular outcome. And like, again, another mental reframe, a tool that people can use is like, anytime you find yourself kind of obsessing over one outcome, try to zoom out and see it as a large, as a larger process. Um, I find that helps me all the time. You know, it's like whether it's a, you know, a video that bombs or a newsletter that I get a bunch of angry replies from or, you know, a speaking gig that the audience is just not into it. You know, it's.
It's easy to get caught up in like, oh, my God, I fucked up. This is terrible. But then if you kind of zoom out and say, okay, but I'm going to learn a bunch of things from this and that's going to make me better in the future. And actually in the long run, I'm going to benefit from this having happened. You know, if you can consistently find that perspective, then yeah, you're golden. Yeah. So I'll end it with this. And I kind of already said this, but fear is not the enemy. It's the avoidance that's the enemy. Yes. What's the, what's the, the only thing we have the fear is fear itself. Was that Franklin Roosevelt? Yeah, that was Roosevelt. Yeah. Pretty sure. We got both Roosevelt's in this episode.
We are fucking killing it. All right. American dynasty. America. America. All right. We'll be right back. All right. We're back and we are going to talk about some bullshit. What are we talking about? Oh, the brilliant bullshit this week. Mark, is boredom the key to creativity? Does boredom make you more creative? Yeah. Okay. I was just going to say the key or a key. Yeah. Can boredom make you more creative? We've kind of – we've danced around this a little bit. So I'm going to preempt all this by saying this is an area I'm not familiar with the research. So I'm going into this purely blind and based on my personal experience. I think boredom probably is helpful for creativity, but it's not necessary. Oh, okay. That would be my –
That's my initial take. Okay. I'm curious to see where I end up at the end of this segment. Okay. Yeah. I'll tell you a little bit of what I found on this, and then we can reassess that. Okay. Okay. Let's see what that is. So it does turn out... That there are some studies that show inducing boredom in people can make them more creative in certain ways. Now, they've measured this in a couple of different ways. One of them is by measuring what they call divergent thinking. Okay. Okay. Which is being able to come up with a lot of different examples or solutions to a problem or something like that. Sure. Many different examples.
So, for example, anyway, there's this one study where they found that if you assigned a group to a very boring task, like copying down phone numbers from a phone book. Yeah. They could come up and then later you give them, OK, come up with as many uses for a plastic cup as you can. Those people who had a boring task rather than watching like an entertaining movie or something like that. They came up with more ideas and more like varied ideas as well. Interesting. Okay. So that's like divergent thinking. Okay. And then they did a follow-up study with that too. And they're like, okay, let's make them even more bored. I mean, this is poor college kids. Probably came into this, right? They're like, as if copying down phone numbers from a phone book wasn't good. Like, don't even copy them down. Just read the phone book. Oh, my God. Like reading the phone book, right? Okay. Okay.
That was even better. They came up with even more ideas and better ideas from that too. Okay. Now there's also what they call convergent thinking, which is if you have all these disparate ideas and you can come up with a one solution for them. So a common research paradigm for this is like, I'm going to give you three words and you have to come up with one word that ties them all together. So for instance, string, cottage, and goat. What word would you come up to unify all? Cottage cheese. Cheese would be that. Cheese, yeah, yeah. So that's called convergent thinking. Okay. How quickly and how well can you come up with those types of solutions? Same type of thing. If you make people more bored, they're better at that too. Okay. Now, but the thing is – I'm very bored right now. So that's why I nailed that. That's why I nailed that question. Okay. Well –
Spice it up, Drew. Actually, that's that's really a really good little transition here to what another thing that they found in studying creativity and boredom is that there's state boredom and there's trait boredom. So the state boredom is like a temporary. We're going to induce temporary boredom. And you don't have anything else to do. And we're going to just your books. Yeah. Yeah. Then there's trait boredom, though, too. OK. And so there's people who are just more prone to boredness. They just get bored super, super easily. Yeah. I'm going to raise my hand. Let me – I was just going to say, let me see if this sounds familiar to you, to anybody here. Yeah. Trait boredom is you're just – you're more likely to get bored in situations. You find things unstimulating. You just –
Things are just boring to you, basically. That's trait boredom. And what they found is mainly that people who have this trait, they're higher in boredom proneness, I guess. Okay. That's what they call it. They're higher in that regard. They're not as creative. Right. Okay. Which seemed to where I thought I was going through this list of like trait boredom. I'm like, oh, this is Mark. He gets, you get bored so easily. You get bored so easily. You do. And I'm like, that's weird though. He also comes up with a lot of like creative ideas. I always thought my creativity was like the solution to my constant boredom. That, okay. That's actually kind of what they found too. Okay. Was that more recent studies, just within the last like year or two, more recent studies came out. And if you have...
You can protect against that if you have a high learning goal orientation. So you are very goal oriented person. A high need for cognition, which is like you like to think about things and wrestle with complex ideas in your mind. High openness to experience. That's definitely you. And a high internal locus of control. So you think you have some sort of – You have to have all those things? Well, those four things can contribute to – Oh, gotcha. So those are like moderators. They'll moderate that whole relationship. I think you're high on all four of those. For sure. Yeah. What they do find too is that if you do get bored during a creative activity, that can be destructive to your creative pursuits as well.
See, I've always experienced it as I get desensitized to stuff quickly. Yeah. Like I actually am interested in tons of stuff, but then I get desensitized very, very quickly. So this is – I think this is where the fork in the road happens. You need that extra stimulation. Yeah. And so for some people, if they're just bored by things, then they're just impulsive. They go – they chase whatever novelty is right in front of them rather than be able to focus. Oh, I've done that. Yeah. You do have those tendencies as well. I'm sure I've definitely seen that. Sure. But you've also been able to find like a creative channel for that. Yes. Part of creativity is kind of that renewal and that pursuit of novelty. Well, it is interesting. I mean, again, this is just subjectively speaking. If you hang out with a bunch of creatives, if you like –
I don't know, go to a party with a bunch of musicians. I mean, there's a lot of novelty seeking going on all the time, right? And there's all sorts of stereotypes of artists being alcoholics, drug addicts, sex addicts, completely impulsive and self-destructive and all sorts of stuff. And so it does strike me as logical that a lot of creativity is driven by this just constant need for, for stimulation. Right. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, there's a novelty seeking about it too, but that in order to be creative, it has to be novel, both novel and useful in a way. And I think that's the, that's kind of another one of those little forks in the road where can you make it useful as well? It's not just, am I just seeking novelty? Let's say somebody is bored listening to this right now. Okay. Okay. What can they do to be creative? Well, okay. Okay.
Let's bring this home, Drew. All of our bored listeners, how can they be more creative? There are actually some tips you can take away from the research on this. If you are bored there, it does create a motivation to seek stimulation. Yes. Just like you're talking about. And so you should embrace that. Be like, okay, I'm bored right now. What's in my environment that I can interact with? As long as it's not like a digital distraction or something like that. So I was just going to say, I wonder... I wanted to talk about this. Yeah. So this is... To me, this is where it starts to get interesting. I'm sorry. I keep ragging on you. It's just ironic that this segment is about boredom. Because I'm totally bored with it. No, but this is interesting because it makes me wonder. And I... So...
There are, there's a lot of criticism. If you look at like, say, uh, people in the music industry or people in the film industry, like there's a, it's a very common criticism. And I think there's a lot of legs to it that art has become less interesting over say the last 15, 20 years. Okay. Um. The movies are not as good as – there are not as many novel or interesting movies as there used to be. I agree with that. There's more quantity of music, but it is less innovative and it's more repetitive and cookie cutter than it used to be. You're seeing this criticism happen in most of the artistic fields. I think there's probably two aspects of this. One is just that –
Everybody has access to so much stimulation that as soon as somebody finds something that is able to cut through all the distractions and really engage a large number of people, everybody else quickly copies it. And so you get this effect of just like everybody's copying each other. Everything sounds the same. Everything looks the same. All the stories seem the same. But I also wonder if there's a factor of this. It's just that like – a lot of creative people aren't as bored as they used to be. Like if you're a screenwriter, you're probably stimulated all the time and are exposed to stuff all the time. And I've noticed this a little bit myself as well. Like I definitely, I mean there's an age component of this, but like I definitely don't find myself having as many novel ideas today as I did today.
say five, 10 years ago. And some of that's age, some of that's experience. It's like the more novel ideas you've had, the harder it is to have the next novel idea. But part of me wonders is if I'm just like stimulated all the time. Well, you mentioned in the podcast with Arthur Brooks that you have a lot of good ideas in the shower. So I think that is probably part of it. Yeah. That's the cliche is like, oh, I have all my best ideas in the shower. Well, yeah, it's because you have nothing else to do. Yeah. But think in the shower, right? It's true. I get this too, though. I feel like, oh, if I'm not sitting in front of a computer, I'm not working. Yeah. I'm not doing something. But then I'll...
Just be like on a walk or something. Lately too, the last few weeks, if I've been like in my woodshop or something, I haven't been wearing headphones. I haven't been listening to podcasts while I'm in there. Yeah. Because another thing that Arthur Brooks said during that podcast was what you're doing is you're pushing all of those ideas out of your head while you're. Yeah. You know why? If you're listening to a podcast, you're watching a video or whatever it is, you're not allowing your, your brain to just think. Yeah. And so I think there is something to that. Definitely. It's interesting because podcasts have definitely kind of infiltrated every, every nook and cranny. Right. Yeah, exactly. It's like, if I'm just walking to the corner store, I like put on a podcast. I've been trying not to do that as much. Yeah. I love podcasts. I do too. I wonder, maybe I do an experiment. Maybe we do like a month.
of just of like a little bit of a content detox or something. Maybe, maybe I do that like a stimulation detox. Maybe I should experiment. Cause I've experimented with that in the past, you know, like three, four years ago. And sure, it was nice. Like there were some nice like little marginal benefits, but it wasn't – when I've messed around with stuff like that in the past, it was never a significant enough benefit that I was like, oh my god, this is life-changing. It was just kind of like, oh, well, that was interesting. I wonder if I tried it now because I just feel like the – every year, the volume knob on –
the quantity of content and the stickiness and engagement of content goes up. And I have definitely found in my own life that it's just like, I am being stimulated from the moment I opened my eyes in the morning to the moment I closed them at night. Yeah, same. And yeah, I wonder what it's like to not do that for a while. I mean, I think this is maybe a cop out a little bit, but I think there is a balance you can strike there. Like I think you need the inputs coming in. You also – you need to consciously take time to just not have any – go for a walk without headphones or your phone or anything like that. Sometimes if I'm just driving down to the store or whatever, I won't have any music on in my car or anything like that.
You know, what's funny is like I used to give the advice to cut out distractions. Like it was a similar version of this advice, which was just like we tend to get sucked up in bullshit. We tend to get like doom scrolling and all this stuff. So like really get conscious about who do you follow online? What do you listen to? What do you read? And be like very selective about those things and just like cut out all the other stuff, which I have been and I still am a big proponent of that. What is new and recent is that I'd say in the last year, year and a half, I do feel good about all of my information diet. I feel like all of the stuff that I follow and consume is good stuff. It is interesting. It is smart people that I trust.
but I've hit that saturation point where like, I literally don't have more minutes in the day. Right. And that's a first, right? Like, yeah, it's, it's no longer, I'm no longer doom scrolling tick tock, uh, in my free time. Like I never really did that a whole lot. Now it's just like, I don't have enough time to listen to all the podcasts. I want to listen to, I don't have enough time to watch all the YouTube videos or watch the shows that my wife and I want to watch. Like, it's just, I don't have time for everything anymore. And, uh, Yeah, maybe we go the other way and just like cut stuff out even further and see what happens. I've heard extreme examples before of like writers. Somebody's – they're planning to work on a book. They're going to write a book. They'll take like two weeks and do nothing but just like sleep. Yeah. Just – they won't do anything. They won't write. They won't read. They won't do anything. They just like are just – they bed rot basically. Yeah.
For two weeks. And then they go and they're just like, boom, they go. Yeah. So I've heard that. That's probably an extreme end. I don't think you have to go to those kind of lengths. But, you know, from the research, there are tips like engaging in mundane tasks before you do creative work. If you need to sit down for a while, like you need to bang out two hours of real hardcore creative work, like take 30 minutes and go clean the house or just do something really fucking boring. Yeah. You know? Yeah. Or allowing for those unstructured periods in your schedule where it's just you're just thinking now I'd like I do some time boxing and stuff like that, which is superior to the way you do things as we've established.
And I'll put, I'll put a time box in there. 30 minutes of just, it's just called flex. And I'll just like kind of sit there and do that. You know, I remember, I remember seeing that Bill Gates had a thing called think week, which is he'd go to a cabin with a stack of books and no phone. And, uh, he'd do it once a year and he'd spend like five days just reading and writing and sitting, staring out the window. Didn't you try to do that recently? And it didn't really count. It was a fucking failure. It was a massive, massive failure. Well, that's why you're not built in case maybe. Yeah, there were other reasons for that. I don't know. Maybe start with a day or an afternoon or something. I think afternoon or think day. Cool. All right. Good talk. That was stimulating. Thank you. My brain is saddest. My dopamine is churning. So thank you. You're welcome. You're very welcome, Mark. We'll be right back.
All right, we're back. We have a reader question. Reader question. No, listener question. Yes. What is the listener question? This one comes from Justin. And he asks, if life is all about a never-ending trading of problems, what are some of the best problems we can have and what are some of the worst? You've talked about this a lot. What are the good problems and the bad problems they have in life? Yeah. I think maybe we can give some examples and some general principles that we can derive from them. That's a great question. It really is. Yeah. Yeah. I would say the thing that's coming to mind is that the higher quality problems that your tradeoffs are happening further up the ladder of like – if you think of like Maslow's hierarchy of needs. OK. Right? Like a bad problem is you're having to make tradeoffs between like do I eat tonight or do I buy myself a jacket so I don't freeze to death? Like that's a terrible –
Life problem to have because that is relatively low on the hierarchy of needs. The good problems generally happen like very high up on the hierarchy of needs. Right. So it's I would say the best problems are fundamentally like problems of trading your time for something. Right. So it's like, do I want to trade my time for something? to write another book or do I want to trade my time to launch a podcast? Like, both are going to be lucrative. Both are going to have impact on a lot of people. Both are going to be creatively engaging. Like, that's a really fucking great problem. And that's something I stressed about last year. And it's like,
You know, it's a really good place to be. If that's the biggest stressor in your life, like it's a really great problem to have. So, yeah, I would say that the more your tradeoffs involve like your identity, time, and aren't affecting any of your like lower rung needs – Your physical, physiological, financial and family are like all secure. You're doing pretty well. Right. Yeah. So like, for instance, you could have money problems. Yes. Again, like, you know, how do I pay rent? Warren Buffett has money problems too. Like, where do I put these billions? Yeah, exactly. And that's one of those is clearly better than.
The other. Yes. Another one too. Like if you're just, if you're a capable, competent person and you can help others, figuring out where to put your time to help people or your time, money, resources, whatever it is. That's a good problem to have. Totally. Those sorts of things where it's like, hey, I'm in a, I'm in a position where I have options. That's usually a better problem to have than not having options. A quantity of options is generally going to be a better problem. There's always going to be a trade-off. Yep. But, but you get to choose the trade-off. That's a good problem to have. I would say problems of leverage versus say linear problems, right? So it's like a leverage problem is I've got all this money. I can either invest this in a retirement account or I can invest this in my friend's startup. Like what is the best use of that investment? Like that's a very high quality problem. A trip to Mexico and now cocaine and hookers and all that. Yeah, exactly.
Right, yeah. Whereas when you're kind of like, again, on the lower rungs of the needs ladder, like you're tending to look at everything very linearly. Like it's like, okay, I either have enough money to put gas in my car or I have enough money to buy dinner for my family next week. And it's like that's a – tradeoffs like that are – it's hard to compound when you're like looking at things very in like a one-to-one basis like that.
So, yeah, I would say like looking at things that like making tradeoffs that compound is like generally a very great place to be. Why is life just a never ending series of problems? Because the question, it just assumes that as we have here, that life is just a never ending series of problems. One, a lot of us don't treat it like that. We think we're looking for the end goal where there are no problems anymore. And you've talked about that a lot. But why is that impossible to achieve? I just think that the human brain is like, if you imagine our, like our software, it is hard coded in our software, our brain software, uh, to pretty much be mildly dissatisfied in almost every circumstance. Like that's, that's actually evolutionarily speaking. Like that's a good thing, right? Like if you ever got complacent for too long, uh, you just, you wouldn't do anything, right? Like it's, it's the creature that is, is not complacent. That's.
gonna go do things that help it survive and procreate and provide for its family and its tribe. So it is like we've evolved like a constant mild dissatisfaction with everything. And also like, so I think it's a combination of two things is like A, everything's a trade-off because resources, whether it's just food, money, attention, time, expertise, like all those things are finite. So because all resources are finite, there's a tradeoff between everything. And then you combine that with the human propensity of the grass is always greener on the other side of like overvaluing things that we don't have and undervaluing the things that we do. It's like the combination of those two traits or realities is you just end up with this.
this like constant need to to find a better trade-off like just it propels everybody forward in a way that they are never completely satisfied with the progress they've made. Right. Right. And I think a slightly different way of looking at this too is that you always do – there are always options. Yes. They might be shitty options that are presented to you. But the goal is to find the less shitty one and then keep trading up the chain. That's kind of what you're saying. It reminds me of – do you remember the red paperclip thing from years ago, like 20 years ago?
It was like an early internet thing. The red paper cloud. You never heard about this? I don't. It's an incredible story. So it started, I think it started in the early 2000s. So a guy posted on a, on a, I think it was on Usenet, like the old, old internet forums. Oh, I do remember this. Yeah. And he said, I have a red paperclip and I'm willing to trade it to somebody for something else. And it's – and basically I want to see how – like what I can eventually trade it into over a long enough period of time. Because the idea back then was like it was still very novel the fact that you could post something and – Interact with someone. Thousands of millions of people you never met could potentially read it. So he like leveraged that and say like I have this red paperclip. I'm willing to trade it for something. And I think he traded that for like a pen –
It was like a goofy like children's pen. And then he traded that for something. I think it was like a doorknob or something. And then – and it was like there were months between all of these trades. So he would like post the thing. He would get, you know, hundreds and hundreds of offers. And then he would like look for the thing that he thought had the best long-term potential to trade for something else. Anyway, long story short, over the course of multiple years, this guy eventually traded up to a house and started a red paperclip, ended with a house. Mm-hmm. And I just feel like that is, that's life essentially, right? It's like every day, every moment you're making some sort of trade-off and that trade-off is either going to pay off for you in the long run or it's not. That trade-off is either going to compound for you. It's like a leverage, like there's some leverage behind it or there's not. And your job or essentially like what personal growth is or self-improvement is, is like
Finding the good trade-offs throughout life and trying to end up – trying to get from your red paperclip to a house. Like that is the game. Right. Except instead of trading an object, you're trading your time, your knowledge, your energy. And you're starting where you are too. Yes. That's the important part too, I think. Yeah. You start where you are. Yes. I remember this – like it was in my 20s and I was terrible at saving money. I couldn't save – I mean I wasn't making any money for long. So it's impossible to, you know. Yeah. So I remember what I did was I would go in and I would go on a log on my bank account every single day. I would take $1 and I would move it to my second savings account. I did this every single day for like a few months at a time. I'm like, this isn't going to make me rich. I know it's not, but I'm developing that habit. Yeah. You know, and I started where I was and it's kind of like a paperclip. This is where I'm starting. Yep. So, yeah. Yeah. And it, I mean, the, the beautiful thing about life is that the, the, the, the,
That ladder of trades, it extends infinitely in both directions, right? So it's like literally if you are on the brink of starvation, there's some sort of tradeoff you can do somewhere to like find the next meal or whatever. And then if you're Warren Buffett, I mean Warren Buffett is still actively trading in the markets, right? Trying to find the next – big trade for himself. So in his nineties, my God. Yeah. Yeah. So it's, yeah, it never ends. That is, that is essentially life. It's just, it's the game of trade-offs. Yeah. What's the, uh, wisdom for the week. Okay. Mark wisdom of the week. This one's a little different. Okay. Okay. I heard a joke over the weekend. Okay. And it's probably my new favorite joke. Oh, wow. All right. Okay. If you have kids, turn it off now.
Kids are listening. You've been warned. Okay. What's the last thing you want to hear when you're giving Willie Nelson a blowjob? My God, what? I'm not Willie Nelson. That is so funny. Yes. That is so funny. That is a funny joke. Yes. That's my new favorite joke. God damn, that's wise. That is so wise. That's all. We'll be back next week, folks. You're welcome. The Subtle Art of Not Giving a Fuck podcast is produced by Drew Burney. It's edited by Andrew Nishimura. Jessica Choi is our videographer and sound engineer. Thank you for listening, and we will see you next week.
You’ve probably lied to someone today. You also probably think you lie less than everyone else. Welp, I have some bad news. We all manipulate, we all get played, and sometimes, the smarter you are, the easier you are to...
Fail fast. Fail forward. Fail better. As a society, we’ve turned failure into a slogan to celebrate, but somehow we’re more afraid of it than ever. So what's going on? Most of us say failure is our best teacher, but I...
You've been told your whole life to explore, keep your options open, try new things. And you've done exactly that. Moved cities, pivoted careers, taken every personality quiz. But here's what nobody warns you about: all...
Ask most successful people how they got where they are, and the answer is usually some version of "good timing." Everyone else swears they earned it. We're terrible at seeing our own luck clearly, and even worse at...
Confidence isn't something you build. It's what's left over. You've done the pose. Hands on hips, chest out, an affirmation on a sticky note stuck to the mirror. And then you walked into the room feeling exactly the...