Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

SOLARCAST

SOLARCAST artwork

Radicle

May 8, 20261 hr 6 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

In this episode we embark on a learning journey guided by Fintan and Lorenz into the realms of forges, patches and repositories. Radicle is a code collaboration platform built for developers who value transparency, ownership, and open-source resilience, building on peer-to-peer and local-first infrastructure for censorship-resistant collaboration directly over Git. This conversation flows through many avenues from federated forges to DIDs and the next steps on the horizon for Radicle. Also mentioned is the Digital Identity report by Cade Diehm and New Design Congress. Connect to the Radicle team and community on their multi-lane Radicle Zulip chat and learn more about sovereign Git collaboration.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Hello and welcome to today's episode of SolarCast and with us today we have two developers and the core maintainers from Radical. Unfortunately in this episode today my main recording microphone broke down so what you'll be hearing is my backup microphone and luckily that was still going but the audio quality is maybe

not up to par for the usual episode. Just a forewarning but I think it's still good enough. I did my best to edit it so it will be a pleasant enough conversation. And the conversation that we'll be hearing will be going through a lot of different aspects and you'll be kind of with me on the learning journey of what it means to do peer to peer and local first Git

collaborations and forages. So if you are as curious as I am and was then tag along and let's dive in. Thank you so much for joining today for this episode of SolarCast and with us here today for those of you who cannot see us is Lawrence and Fintan from the Radical

project. Radical.xyz. So to get to know y 'all a little bit would it be okay that you tell us a little bit about how you entered Radical and what your backgrounds are? Yeah so mine was like a long winding journey of getting to work on like functional programming during college times, working remote for a

company that actually used Haskell. So yeah I became enamored with Haskell in particular during my university days and that eventually led me to OSCoin. And that happens to be the kind of like roots of Radical so to speak. So we kept in touch and I was interested in the project. It was kind of the idea of OSCoin

was to try and bring sustainability to open source projects through a kind of like weighted graph system, cryptocurrency and basically if you're dependent upon a lot then your project would theoretically get rewarded a lot. So there's this classic xkcd comic with the stack of blocks and we have the tiny little block holding up everything in the corner.

So in theory that block would be getting a lot of funding to make sure that the whole stack doesn't collapse. They realized that not only is funding a problem but also the like collaboration on code artifacts and repositories seem to be a problem as well because it's rooted in centralized companies and centralized countries let's say. GitHub being based in America under Microsoft.

So early indications of what we're seeing now in this like shift towards more sovereign solutions. So like trying to break away from the US. Yeah and it was right about then that I joined. That project was kind of like the first iteration and after that it was a Rust project and it was the second iteration of

what we call Radical. And then the name was Radical Link and instead of a kind of Lisp machine it was kind of back to basics. We've got Git, why don't we build on top of it. So that's around when I joined about six and a half years ago. I've been working on things since then. I can get into the why a bit more but maybe I'll hand it over to

Lorenz to kind of give his perspective of why he got into this. Thank you Fintan. Hello to all our listeners. I am Lorenz and I joined the project quite a bit later. So I was not around in this OS coin phase and the let's say the earlier explorations and iterations of the project. I joined quite a bit later just as a open source contributor.

So I first started contributing just out of interest because I liked the idea. I was actually as GitHub got acquired by Microsoft a few years back I started wondering okay like where is this going and I figured why aren't there more projects that work on the decentralization aspect and making the decentralized components of Git which are really strong more

usable and more user-friendly. Because the reason is that the underlying situation is that Git actually is very decentralized but the dynamics in the real world have unfolded in a way that we see lots of concentration so we see lots of people gravitating towards GitHub big part of the open source ecosystem and a few other forges but GitHub is the biggest by far. So at that time I didn't even really

know about Radical. Blockchains were more prominent but I had a few questions and reservations there so I didn't really engage much in these projects but then at some point I learned that Radical actually switched the implementation to Rust and switched to one that is not dependent on the blockchain but is more open to like opt-in

in the future or build on top but certainly not in the core of it as it was previously. In fact the situation that Fintan mentioned before about the graph to distribute the resources and funds among open source communities this is a project that spun out into so this still exists it's called DRIPS and we say it's our sister project but that kind of was realized that it might be better to split these two aspects and I do agree. So after that period I decided okay now

is the time that I start contributing to one of these projects and then I started contributing to Radical. As usual you know you find those things that you think could be improved you start with smaller ones then you somehow understand the code base you find a few bigger ones and that's how I grew into a more senior contributor to the project and then at some point I was asked whether I would

like to maintain the project together with Fintan and Adrian and yeah that's what I'm doing now. You mentioned something there as usual and then you describe this process of like finding these different projects that you want to contribute to. When you say as usual who are you talking about here like as usual? Yeah it's probably colored by my own view. I would say as usual for really an open source enthusiast you know the kind of

people that use open source software and if they see an issue or something that could be improved they really go clone the code figure it out do the fix and so on and yeah I have done that in like a handful projects those that I use personally and I like to do that when possible but of course it's not always possible to start with when the software is not free. So I've been having a lot of conversations with some friends recently who are new in

the open source space and they want to start exploring and I think one of the challenges is kind of what you touched upon here is like finding what project to contribute to and so we touched on it or so why did you find that Radical was the project worthwhile to contribute? I think that Radical is pretty far out there in terms of ambition and also in terms of challenge in bringing Git back closer

a bit to its roots or at least how we see it bringing this decentralization aspect back. So there are quite a few open source projects out there in terms of different forges for example many many will know Codeburg and that they use ForgeJoe others might know SourceHUD but as far as I know Codeburg is an association so they are structured as an

association registered in Germany they invite new members to join and the core offering is that they host infrastructure for you to collaborate on open source code open source software free software. And they're kind of like GitHub but open source? I mean I wouldn't go that far I wouldn't say they are like GitHub because GitHub is yeah is a bit of a different topic I guess but Fintan yeah please take

it away. Maybe it's good to just clarify what like a GitForge means in general so most people my favorite comment is like Git it's already decentralized when we talk about Radical and we fully recognize that of course it is it's a decentralized tool and how developers started using it is through a decentralized workflow called email so the Git core team and the Linux

team use email lists for collaborating through Git and so email can be one Forge and that the like step after that was SourceHUD which is an email based Forge where you get a website where things can be hosted and you can see the emails coming in and discussions. GitHub is another GitForge which is also a

platform and that's what people are most familiar with as a Forge. Other Forges now exist such as Codeburg and also Tangled on the Approto protocol if people are familiar with Approto and Newsguy. GitLab another Forge yeah so okay so I'm coming from the perspective of like peer-to -peer space and there's tons of different people coming from a lot of different spaces can

we go back like a little bit to the basics I think anyone working with code has encountered like Git has encountered repositories and have heard about Forges but what actually is a Forge? Yeah yeah exactly so it's I guess it's a home for collaboration so Git gives you the commits and files so blobs, treats, commits that allows you to version control your code

over time but as humans we have lots of other ways that we collaborate and that's where we see things like issues or task trackers or discussions on changes identifying as someone who collaborates on these Git repositories that's I think that's where Forges bring or like yeah yeah they paint the picture a little bit

more on top of Git. And in comparison to like something like CRDTs like we have this space that's become really really popular lately with Local First and all of that and CRDTs are a common means of facilitating collaboration like what's the differentiation there between Forges and CRDTs? I'll let Lorenz take it. So I think that CRDTs are a technology

and a definition of how a data structure should work and what features a data structure should have and you can build something like a Forge which is a little more abstract concept like a feature set of things that people want to do so you approach you can approach it from two sides you can say okay what does the user want to do okay they want to do code review they want to discuss the changes and then the CRDT is a bit on is a

bit of technology that can enable this and then yes what Radical actually does is it implements a Forge based on top of CRDTs so many of the things in Radical that we talk about like patches and issues are implemented as CRDTs so the underlying structure still is a CRDT but it is not critical for the user to know that when they open a patch there will be an operation on the CRDT that's abstracted away.

Yeah to analogize it would be like asking what's the difference between a page rank and a web search or like a search engine so page rank is just an algorithm and a search engine can like bring other features to the table. Yeah so we were on the topic of like why and so the why enters into the space now and then we kind of

like moved into what actually is Radical. I have an idea of bringing us back a bit here to where we were before talking about the different Forges and other solutions in this space and we talked about a bunch of those and you can you can place them on a line and you can think about okay how centralized are they and I think we have like peak centralization with GitHub and then you can place the others

right and then we have this concept of federation where as there are a few different ways of how to achieve federation but usually you have multiple servers and then the user logs into one of these servers and then there's data being federated between the servers so all of these solutions which includes Tangled on AT Proto and which includes the work towards federation in Forge Joe I would put them

in the middle. Email also yes you're very right to point that out email is also of that kind you communicate your email server and then the emails are replicated and then we have another category where Radical falls into which is basically where there are no servers there are just nodes in the network and they sync in a peer-to-peer manner yeah and there aren't really any other competitors in a sense

or any other projects that are currently ambitious and as active as we are to develop a really peer-to-peer Git layer. And I have so many questions in this regard I'm so curious and I've been hearing ever since I heard about Radical which was about two years ago now I've been wanting to figure out a little bit more to start from the perspective of why is it important to do it peer-to-peer in

this setting like what makes the big difference here and then how do you enable those peer-to-peer connections? So I think it's important in general to have a technology that works in this local first and peer-to-peer manner because it puts all the power into the user or at least very very close to the user they control their own hardware there is no central authority that tells them when to log

in or whether their account is blocked or not and it is a technology that enables this completely decentralized setting where you know I join Funkfeuer which is an association of people that put Wi-Fi antennas and on their roofs and then they might make direct peer -to-peer connections if you need internet access to let's say a data center in order

to use your forge then well you're tied to this access but with Radical it will just work in such a completely partitioned part of the of the internet just as well for example if Fintan and me work in a room and are logged into the same Wi-Fi then we can just directly exchange information over Radical and we don't need to go out to a data center and so

on so we are immediately much more resilient and much more sovereign than with these other technologies. It enables this routing agnostic perspective where you can route over different transport layers it sounds like could you use mesh, Wi-Fi, Bluetooth, sneaker net whatever kind of here? Yeah I have to admit that we are currently using TCP transport so we are a bit limited in that regard but we could extend so that's a limitation of the current

implementation but not out of the protocol design so the data structures that arise from the sync process they work even if you you know transfer via sneaker net or whatever but the current implementation expects to talk IP and TCP. I had a previous conversation with IRO and we talked a lot about map traversal or hole punching to establish these peer-to-peer connections. How do you go about that?

We know about IRO, we are actually in loose contact with them and we are really watching the awesome work they are doing and we are thinking of at least allowing connections via IRO to in a like a testing phase. It lines up really well on like the the cryptography of it so in radical nodes

are identified by an edwards 25519 key and the same is true for IRO so we might get the direct correspondence between IRO endpoints and and a radical node ids so it all looks it all looks really nice and they would give us the hole punching capability which we don't have currently. But it's an ongoing process and we're definitely eager to experiment more.

And this is actually we're getting into an area that has been a big part of my research in the past which is this what's starting to emerge is kind of an ecology of protocols from previous years like 10 years ago a lot of projects were trying to build the entire solution on their own which meant rebuilding the same wheels over and over but now these kind of protocols are entering more of a modular form of design

so it sounds like you're solving a quite a specific part of the puzzle piece of peer-to-peer networking and specifically for git. What is like where do you see yourself and what is your solution more concretely? Yeah that's a great question and I do hearken back to when I started a phrase that was thrown around was like protocols not platforms.

So yeah I guess where we're trying to fit in is building the protocol on top of git for collaboration and as we spoke before we're talking about we're talking about it in a self-sovereign way we also fit into this local first even offline first scenario where you can hop on a plane still

work on your collaboration not just your code so I can like reply to issues reply to patch comments and then come back online later and sync up with the network so yes putting that protocol first and hopefully making it repeatable so that people can come and boost the ecosystem with other implementations in the future I think so

I'm also thinking like you mentioned in the beginning like a question that a lot of people have asked you is like okay so why are you doing this git is already decentralized like what do you say when people ask that like where do you because okay I think it boils down to decentralization be a very fuzzy term because there's so many forms of decentralization and federation and peer-to

-peer are often dumped in as it clumps some under decentralization is it there in the distinction that by enabling what or by doing what you're doing with git you're kind of bringing it to a new level of decentralization my thoughts here are that we are we have realized and I think many people will agree that software engineering and managing a software

project being open source or maybe even not is not just about git commits and and tags and so on there's a lot that works on top like code review and discussions about the code and tasks and so on and these are just fundamentally not part of git so here we compete in a sense with these other forges so git is decentralized

in the aspect that you can you can put the repository on any computer and if you set those computers up well enough then you can have this network of git repositories and that is decentralized but you're decentralized only at the level of git features which aren't really enough to do all the things you want to do as alluded to before so this is one aspect you you need more than just git and you also want it

to be decentralized that at least we do and then one other thing that comes to mind is that for using git in a decentralized way you have to make careful configuration like you have to share these urls of all the murals of your repository with everyone so if five people want to want to collaborate on a git repository in a truly decentralized way then each of these five persons has to note down the git url of

all the four others and we make an improvement here because we have a globally consistent way to address git repositories and that's something that git itself doesn't have there is no standard way to say this repository which is agnostic over various locations of the repository that's something that we add and note that this is not centralized so there's not a global registry where you register the repository but this

is done in a decentralized way are you using dhts like distributed hash tables no we're not using dhts currently we do node discovery via a gossip network so at first you join the network usually via what we call a process of bootstrapping so you first have to know some node in the network and then from then on the nodes will give

out addresses of other nodes that they have found on the network and then very quickly you build an address book of other nodes awesome so i'm wondering now like you talked a bit about like the importance of enabling the collaboration aspects in connection to git and we also mentioned platforms and stuff like that where what is like dream scenario where do

y'all want to go like what is the roadmap what is a future that you envision when radical is like a project that's complete fully because i guess it's also still in development yeah um what does that look like for you that's a it's an interesting question because there's a question of when is it a software project ever done and i actually it reminds me of a post by moxie um one of the founders of signal

and in it they write about kind of like envy or jealousy of musicians where it's like you release a piece of music and then it's kind of just done and you're you're done i mean you can always like remaster edit remix whatever push software just like it feels infinite it can go on forever but yeah but then yeah is it mostly

like scope creep or is it like is it because there's maintenance what is the main thing that makes it infinite do you think maintenance does make it feel infinite the most but of course i think what makes it feel infinite is just like the power of ideas and um yeah maybe scope creep is kind of like a way of describing that but i guess it's all about like constant

improvements like git was

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Hosts

  • Zenna Elfen Host Feed-stated

Guests

  • Fintan Halpenny Guest Feed-stated
  • Lorenz Leutgeb Guest Feed-stated

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Horcrux

    Oct 18, 202648 minAudio

    Ever wondered how to get access to your account in systems where there are no admins? Originally Dark Crystal set out to solve this specific question for P2P infrastructures. The project closed down but made an impact...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. P2Panda

    Sep 15, 20261 hr 1 minAudio

    Adz, (also known as Andreas) joins us for todays chat about P2Panda 🐼 ✨ In this conversation we move through the past and origins of P2Panda, through the building blocks and modules of the protocol and into defining...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Invisible Internet Project

    Aug 12, 202643 minAudio

    In this interview we are joined by IDK from the Invisible Internet Project, I2P. I2P is a decentralized privacy focused and peer-to-peer network enabling anonymity online. Older than even the TOR-network, I2P does...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Willow

    Jun 18, 20261 hr 4 minAudio

    Known as a well kept secret and hidden pearl of the P2P scene in Europe, Aljoscha makes a rare appearance in this podcast and brings us into his mind and the theoretical computer science of P2P data structures. As...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. New Design Congress

    Jun 7, 20261 hrAudio

    This bubbly conversation traces the outlines of security work going beyond the raw code and into the nitty gritty of social webs and structural design. Cade Diehm walks us through the collapse of the third wave of...

    Credit the people on this episode