Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Smart Money

Smart Money artwork

Chris Wilson: Concerns for investing in AI are valid as new technology can attract too much capital, too quickly

Oct 18, 202641 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Australian data-centre developer - Firmus - have stalled in securing funds for more build-outs, with investors unsure of the pricepoint, and how much of the growth depends on earnings that are yet to arrive. So has the value of AI had its reality check? Investors have happily funded AI chips, AI software and AI infrastructure for years, but are public markets finally pushing back on valuations? Given the money that's closely tied to AI and its promises to improve everyday life, are we walking into a bubble that's bound to pop, or running late on the AI boom? Harbour Asset Management's Chris Wilson explains the risks to Tim Beveridge for Smart Money... LISTEN ABOVE

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1You're listening to the Weekend Collective Podcast from Newstalk ZB.

Speaker 2I'm a shooting star leaping through.

Speaker 3The sky like a tiger defying the laws of gravity.

Speaker 2I'm a racing car.

Speaker 1Passing by like Lady Godiva.

Speaker 2I'm gonna go, go, go. There's no stopping me.

Speaker 3I'm burning through the sky.

Speaker 1I'm afraid.

Speaker 3We are going to have to stop you, Freddie. But welcome back to the show. I'm Tim Beveridge. This is Smart Money on the Weekend Collective, where we talk, well, money, don't we? Money issues. And look, we're going to talk about AI. An Australia data centre developer, Firmus, have been seeking a blockbuster public listing to fund more build-outs across... Hang on a minute, I'm misreading that. But anyway, investors

Speaker 3have balked at the price the scale of capital required and how much of the growth story depended on assets and earnings that are yet to arrive. So where do we go with AI? Do you remember the time when, in careers, everyone was talking about... IT. And it's like, oh, forget doing this for a job. You've got to get into IT. And all of a sudden, everyone's going, not so many jobs in IT. People are being made redundant. It's the same thing going to happen with AI when it comes to your investors. Investors have happily funded AI chips,

Speaker 3software infrastructure. But where does it get with the public markets pushing back on valuations? Anyway, we're going to have a chat about AI and how you invest your money in that or not. as the case may be, bubbles versus, what's the other word? Bubbles versus a bubble that's bound to pop or a boom. That's right, bubble or boom. Anyway, to discuss all these issues, well, there's many of them we can get through. He is from Harbour Asset Management. He is the co-CEO, and it's Chris Wilson. G'day, Chris.

Speaker 3Hang on a second. I'll just get you to lower your mic so you're right on top of it.

Speaker 1And.

Speaker 3And we can talk now. Way to go.

Speaker 2Wonderful. Thank you, Tim. Very nice to be back again. How are you?

Speaker 1Good.

Speaker 3You're looking all summery today. The sun's out. It's still a bit of a brisky breeze there.

Speaker 4Oh, it's warm enough out there. It's warm enough out there. It was a very lovely afternoon. But it's always a pleasure to be back in here and stay out in the sun.

Speaker 2I didn't want to get too much sun.

Speaker 3Aren't you kind.

Speaker 1So, well....

Speaker 3How's the AI thing going?

Speaker 2Well, should we start at Firmus?

Speaker 3Yeah, Firmus.

Speaker 4And so, look, you sort of gave a little bit of the background and invested a zid balk at the price, but there was a bit of a journey to get to that last week. And, you know, in the markets world, it was a pretty exciting week for Firmus and the general market.

Speaker 3Who are Firmus for those who are going, what the hell's Firmus?

Speaker 2Yeah, it's a really good starting point.

Speaker 4I mean, it started out as a crypto company founded by an ex-inside trader in sort of 2015, 2016, just after he left jail. It pivoted more recently into developing data centers and sort of becoming a GPU provider into the market, or not a GPU provider, essentially a hireable service, buying GPU chips off NVIDIA. Great expansion plans, an incredibly quick valuation rise over the last six months, and then bringing towards a raise, which obviously didn't go ahead in

Speaker 4the last week or two. So it's had a great background, and the most interesting thing has been dragging down a few other companies in Australia with it as well.

Speaker 3So, hang on, I was founded by an insider, and then he got in trouble but the firm carried on.

Speaker 4So that was beforehand, so in credit to Oliver Curtis, who is one of the founders, he was a young chap many years ago and did some prison time actually for insider trading, obviously having departed prison and Looking what next, he founded Firmus Technologies.

Speaker 3That's quite an amazing comeback, isn't it?

Speaker 4And that was why it was such an attractive photo. It was a story come good of a good Aussie battler who had come through and looked to launch his company and raise the largest raise since, I think, Telstra.

Speaker 3Do you have a better chance at a comeback if you're an Aussie? Just because it's like, I'm an Aussie battler. I've been down to my luck. I got done for a little bit of insider trading, but I'm back.

Speaker 2Oh, look, but everyone loves a success story.

Speaker 3I don't know what I'm saying.

Speaker 2Everyone loves a success story, Tim.

Speaker 4I mean, you know, it's certainly from a story perspective, you know, he is married to a very famous Australian, very famous Australian publicist, so Roxy Jacenko. And so, you know, it's a glamour couple. It's a glamour story. It was certainly something that, it was media fodder, certainly for the week. And any of those listeners that read the AFR or checking on the Australian papers, you know, would have struggled to stay away from the firm's story for that week.

Speaker 3So they were looking for this ambitious, you know, a build-out, I guess, extending their– they wanted investors to fund.

Speaker 2Absolutely.

Speaker 4So they were looking to raise money, and so they were looking to raise a lot of money, $ 7 billion.

Speaker 3How much?

Speaker 2About $ 7 billion.

Speaker 3On a– Billion or– Billion.

Speaker 2Billion.

Speaker 4Around a $ 45 billion total raise. And so what ended up happening, though, is the investors didn't like the price. And in an IPO, what tends to happen is they go out and, you know, Oliver has spent a lot of time drumming up demand for this company over the last six months, a year, around a future listing. When they went to investors, you know, they thought they had a pretty good clarity on getting the assets in place or getting the funding. It worked out overnight. The US investors didn't like the story quite as much. And so, and really the price and how much they were trying

Speaker 4to raise.

Speaker 3Well, it's interesting because they're... What are the investors not like? Because for most punters, they think, oh, AI sounds great. Oh, there's an AI thing. Let's get into it. But the AI is going, the investors are savvy enough. And obviously, there's some big investors who've got people who are analyzing the value of these stocks. But how did they?

Speaker 2Well, what's not to, I mean, the price for one.

Speaker 3Was it taking the mickey?

Speaker 4Well, how much are you paying for those future earnings? So a lot of this was yet to be built technology. It was, again, based on Firmas' approach, water cooling technology, which is apparently makes them 99% more efficient than everyone else. And so there was a couple of things in the story of just there were a lot of future potential you were buying into. And so really the pushback from market on this one is people saying, well, we need a little more confidence, a little more clarity on the actual earnings that are going to come in behind this. And so, yeah, we talk a lot about this bubble or boom or, you know, the picks and shovels versus,

Speaker 4you know, the gold rush, you know, What that is is the market saying, actually, we're not going to take anything. Just because you stick AI on it and tell us it's going to be great doesn't mean we're going to pay any price you want on it.

Speaker 2And so in some ways, that's actually great discipline in the market.

Speaker 3Have people done that in the past? And when they get excited about something and go, oh, this is the new thing, and people just pile in with lots of cash?

Speaker 4Yeah, I mean, that's where the hallmarks of history echoing with the dot-com boom. You'll remember pets.com and some of the great dot-com stories from the early 2000s.

Speaker 3Well, it reminds me of the guy whose surname was Dotcom as well. And I don't know how to separate that all out.

Speaker 2Well, people get very excited.

Speaker 4And we saw that with blockchain and the Long Island blockchain or Long Island ICT, which became a blockchain company. People do just follow the hype in these circumstances. So look, it was such a large raise, certainly for the Australian market and not quite as large as some of the ones in the States that potentially will come through. But for the Australian market, it was a huge raise.

Speaker 2And so.

Speaker 4Seeing that discipline and seeing the pushback on price was really interesting because normally those deals do tend to go through. People tend to get to the point of going out to market with a clear price and raise without getting confidence around that demand. So you can see them come back and lower the price during that book build process, but that tends to not be too popular and so they tend to do what they can to get them away.

Speaker 3So what are the comparisons with the AI boom and the dot-com bubble then?

Speaker 1Because.

Speaker 3Well, the bubble bursts, doesn't it, in one case? We don't know what's happening with AI, but we've had that resistance to the Firmus.

Speaker 2Yeah, we've had the resistance to the Firmus.

Speaker 4There have been some other transactions which have been delayed or haven't gone ahead at this time because of maybe on the back of that noise and some concerns. One of the interesting statistics over the last week is you've seen a big drawback in the semiconductor index, so known as the SOX, which is down sort of 3.5% or 3.8%. over the last eight days or so. And so it's been quite a big sell-off. What you need to remember, though, it's up 50% year-to-date over a longer period. So it's just giving up some of those gains. So we are

Speaker 4seeing some level investor pullback. But the other thing is we have some of the bigger companies, so Meta and Tesla publishing results in the week ahead, and we probably need to talk about the flying car at some point.

Speaker 3As soon as you mentioned Tesla, what's that?

Speaker 2Have you spent some time on it today?

Speaker 1No, nothing.

Speaker 3I did see the launch. As I said, the launch. I did see the clip of it. Anyway, what do we make of it all? What does that do for investors as well? Do they get all fizzy around the bung with their cash?

Speaker 2I think certain investors do. I mean, you've got to give it to Elon. He is a showman.

Speaker 4Anyone who can flip a card during a life.

Speaker 3That was quite surreal. And the engineering behind that. stunt I mean it's I mean he sent rockets into space I guess it makes sense that he could flip a car and have it land yeah I was wondering if I mean I sure there'd be a number of people who was wondering if it was as we saw it was there some trickery behind.

Speaker 4It I suspect that's not the version that you'll be driving down to the local supermarket.

Speaker 3No actually also I think the bit where it drives upside down I think it was on some sort of track and then released wasn't it.

Speaker 4Uh no apparently I heard it was a rubber skirting around the car and then essentially a suction a very powerful suction motor Oh, maybe.

Speaker 3I dreamt about it. I thought they had some sort of track thing it was connected to, which then disconnected and it dropped and it started, oh, bugger if I know. It was quite surreal, wasn't it?

Speaker 2It was impressive.

Speaker 4And again, you talk about a product launch, that's a way to launch a roadster or launch the roadster.

Speaker 2So given that, it was an exciting piece.

Speaker 4But again, very similar thing when, I think we might have touched on it, most of it just post our last conversation, they were looking to do a large debt raise. And I think, you know, the prospectus seemed to be two pages and a picture of space with an arrow pointing to this is where we're going to build data centres, which, you know, from an investment thesis perspective, does get some of those fundamental investors a little bit itchy when they don't have the detail.

Speaker 2And that's the challenge when you get into this bus.

Speaker 3Well, is that the difference? Was he just going for Joe Public to stick their money into it? And look, here's a picture of space with an arrow and it's, I'm Elon. stick your money in, get in now and you can't lose.

Speaker 4Yeah, but it's not just Joe Public that's going to fund this. You know, they do need these large institutional investors to buy the story and buy the dream and, you know, Elon does that. He has, you know, he has sold the dream for, you know, self-driving, you know, you look at FSD or, you know, feel self-driving and depending on which side of the fence you are, you're either fairly happy that it delivered to what your expectations were or you were expecting flying cars at this stage and you're disappointed that it hasn't lived up to the hype. So, And look, there's certainly two sides to that, Cam.

Speaker 3Sure. OK, if you want to share your opinion, if you've got any questions around what's happening with AI on investing, give us a call on 0800 80 1080. I've got Chris Wilson. He's the co-CEO of Harbour Asset Management with us. And we're going to take some calls. So 0800 80 1080 is the number. I'll just get Chris to adjust his volume so he's not getting blasted out by a caller there. Are you all right? He's all good. Let's go to Bruce.

Speaker 1Hello.

Speaker 3Hello.

Speaker 1Yeah, hi, guys. Nice talking to you. Chris, this AI is great, but my investment is actually at the crumbs that are falling off the tables of these really glamorous stocks that are just eye-watering valuations. And what I'm talking about, the key is, from my perspective, is the data centers. They're the things that make these guys look good, so to speak. So my investment's and so on, are downstream

Speaker 1to companies that are heavily involved in the data center, the geographical positions of them. They hold big holdings there. They have the energy infrastructure. They've got the power plants. They've got the routes. They've got the roads. They've got everything for the data centers. So my investment is in that area. And am I able to quote a stock on the ASX?

Speaker 3I don't see any reason why not. We're not giving specific financial advice to anyone who's listening, so away you go.

Speaker 1Yeah, the one I'm talking about is the Goodman Group. Now, they have really the data centre by that, so to speak. Now, all this other glamour stuff with these eye-watering stocks has only been happening, well, you know, there are a lot of good companies there that are really, you know, significantly, I believe, undervalued, and they're in the mid-20s.

Speaker 3So are you saying you're looking, you're asking and sort of making a comment about investing in stuff that's infrastructure that sits behind AI, and you reckon they're undervalued, and that's where it's worth taking a look?

Speaker 1Absolutely. Oh, good.

Speaker 3I didn't want to ask the dumb question there, Bruce.

Speaker 1No, no, because the cream is off the top. But the thing that makes it work, it's like the company that provides oil for the engine, if you know what I mean. The engine's making all the noise and plenty of motion and that, but it can't run without the oil. And you've got to look at the companies that are part of that making that machine which is one step above them run and I believe there's significant undervaluation and there's good forward prospects in that area.

Speaker 3Okay let's see Chris make his comment on that.

Speaker 4Really good comment Bruce and I think what you've got there with Goodman is an established company that has a history of delivering they're benefiting from the sector and the growth in the sector so Yeah, as you say, it's looking at those picks and shovels, those companies that are looking to support and not going all in on the latest hype.

Speaker 2So interesting.

Speaker 3Do you do your own sort of reconnaissance on this stuff?

Speaker 1There is wealth. There's a plethora of this. Simply Wall Street, there's Yahoo, there's trading. There's so many... And they're really good, solid stock advisors.

Speaker 3Nice censorship there, Bruce. I'm sorry, mate. No, I like the way you stopped yourself there. It wouldn't have ended the call.

Speaker 1Well, I might as well chuck in Motley Fool as well. It's free. It's free. So anyone can do it.

Speaker 3I'm guessing, how do you work out which of those are the latest spruikers who are the equivalent of Instagrammers? You know, bugger all, but they're good at sort of promoting something. How do you work out which sites you trust?

Speaker 1What do you mean, the advisors?

Speaker 3Yeah, yeah, the information you're receiving, because everyone's got a reckon, and some are better informed than others, some are better analysts than others.

Speaker 1It's reputational. You know, Chris is from a reputational, they've got analysts there that know their stuff, and they all know their stuff. And virtually none of it is, you know, I got a tip for evolution about two years ago, I think from probably from Chris's company, and it was $ 3, and evolution has gone bananas.

Speaker 3You mean some advice, yeah.

Speaker 2Well, yes.

Speaker 3It might not have been his company, actually. He's saying it might not have been him. Hey, why Goodman Group? By the way, Goodman Group, because it's interesting. So you think there's something happening. By the way, this is not specific advice. We're just gossiping here.

Speaker 2No, no.

Speaker 3But I noticed that their share price, you know, back about five years ago, was around $ 23, $ 26 at one stage, and it's not much above that now. It's sort of gone up to $ 30- something, and then now it's down.

Speaker 1So you... If I can segue into something, just the same thing, same genre, but it was in reference to the last call who was talking about the sleep condition, and I'm heavily invested in another good stock called ResMed, which build these sleep apnea machines.

Speaker 3Oh, okay.

Speaker 1I wanted to ask him, what's the correlation?

Speaker 3You want to ask Chris about sleep stuff?

Speaker 1Because Alex has gone home.

Speaker 3No, he's gone home. He's gone home.

Speaker 1I wanted to know what the correlation was between the sleep apnea machines and Ozempic, which is reducing the weight, which is subsequently reducing snoring, and is that affecting the stock price of sleep apnea companies that rely on it?

Speaker 3Oh, okay, gosh.

Speaker 1They're treating an unhealthy lifestyle, and ResMed have. You know, they have assumed weight loss and unhealthiness is something that's going to increase going forward, and that's fueling their stock price. Then it comes along that says, hang on, these people aren't going to get so large. McDonald's will have a 25% in their, you know, their fat intake has gone down over a long period of time. So there's a balancing act going on there. But both those stocks,

Speaker 1ResMed and GMC, are really growing. Great holding stocks.

Speaker 3Okay. Now that you've got your shares in them, I'm guessing, Bruce, you certainly want to energise the market into getting on there. Actually, Bruce is an interesting investor because it sounds like he's doing a lot of his own reconnaissance, which is a high degree of difficulty, isn't.

Speaker 1It, Chris?

Speaker 2Oh, it is. And it's got on in person.

Speaker 4It sounds like he's well involved in Yeah, a really interesting comment I'll just touch on around the impact of Azempic or the GLP-1s on some of the companies. And I think it's too early to tell, certainly for ResMed, but there is potential impacts.

Speaker 3So was he saying it was working, ResMed's the sleep apnea machine people, is it?

Speaker 2Yeah, sleep apnea.

Speaker 3And he's saying something is affecting them well or badly?

Speaker 4Potential risk, because effectively if people lose weight, they have less sleep problems, less sleep apnea issues, and if demand for sleep apnea or sleep apnea machines go down. And so that's the potential risk correlation.

Speaker 3I think the contrast- God, that's really a lot of, that's going in there with the research and a few reckons, isn't it?

Speaker 4Yeah, look, and I think that is, as you look at the AI story, I think we potentially view AI as a real biotechnology change and potentially a life longevity. And so there's some real secondary, right now we're talking about companies like Firmus and data centers and building those things. But actually what's that secondary impact around AI as we get better drug conditions, as we solve all of the world's math problems?

Speaker 3Well, I think his call about, correct me as soon as I go off the rails, Chris, this is a bit like that Larson cartoon, excuse me, my brain is full. But when he was talking about the crumbs off the table of AI and saying that there is some good investment to be made around the stuff that supports AI, I mean, I would have thought they were all part of the same story, aren't they?

Speaker 2Oh, they are. I mean, we call them picks and shovels, so the companies that support the boom.

Speaker 1Oh, okay.

Speaker 2And so, yeah, again, that very similar thing. So crumbs around the table.

Speaker 3Crumbs off the table make the investors sound like cockroaches, don't it? I mean, who eats the crumbs off the table? Oh, well, the cat, the dog, the rats.

Speaker 2Mice. I would say, no, Bruce, it's a valid point.

Speaker 4You know, you've got these companies and you've got the real headline companies and the Teslas and, you know, Beta and those very large companies, you know, Ape and AI, Anthropic, who are going to come to market. But actually the companies that support them, you know, NVIDIA was a company building chips, but now it's become the big.

Speaker 3One, right? I mean, I think this is the thing that's... For the average punter who's got a, you know, who's a little bit interested or they're interested through their KiwiSaver or their Sharesies or whatever, there is that thing that people still... It's like buying a lotto ticket. People still... enticed by their idea that they're going to pick the next big stock. Because if you'd bought NVIDIA and shoved $ 1, 000 into NVIDIA back in the day, I don't know how much you'd have, but a lot more than $ 1, 000. No,

Speaker 3that's right.

Speaker 4And with the benefit of hindsight, it is very, very easy to pick the winners in the market.

Speaker 3Is that the danger with things like AI, which is maybe why it gets towards a comparison with the dot-com boom, is that there'll be a lot of... How much does hysteria... drive the investment in these products?

Speaker 4Yeah, a lot of the markets, and markets are, at the end of the day, driven by people. And so people will see herd behavior. And so they'll see people rushing into companies. And so one of the things they do is they see the price go up. So people think it must be good and buy more. And so those sorts of things are a little bit dangerous. And certainly in a market at the moment where some companies are booming, people do think they can pick that next big winner. And it really goes to the story of the danger is you get that wrong. And you don't get next big winner. And so you lose your money.

Speaker 4And so, you know, having a bit of diversification and they're not putting your eggs in one basket, those classic investment, investment reframes that we regularly use really, you know, make much sense. But this is a transformation technology. You know, I don't think any of your, you know, any of your listeners and yourself wouldn't be using AI to some degree or have AI impacting your life.

Speaker 3Oh God.

Speaker 2It is everywhere.

Speaker 3It is. Actually, By the way, Bruce, thanks for calling. I enjoyed your call. And call again. It's funny, you know, the whole herd mentality that I think when humans, when we watch wildlife documentary and we see flocks and birds and herds of, you know, we don't really think that we herd, but we do herd when it comes to certain behaviours, don't we?

Speaker 2No, absolutely.

Speaker 4You know, and there's a safety in the group where if lots of other people are doing this thing, it must be the right thing to do. And so, you know, you certainly see that.

Speaker 3It's a complete aside, actually, but I was thinking of it as a metaphor. I was watching the making of Our Planet, the second series, amazing high-definition stories about wildlife. But these guys go to the Russian Arctic, and they're in a hut. And in the middle of them, it just shows the hut, and it's just them and the hut. That's it. And overnight, thousands of walruses arrive, and they're surrounding the hut. And then a couple of days later, they're all gone. And it's like, I was thinking that's almost an analogy for some investors. Everyone's suddenly there and

Speaker 3it's like, suddenly then they're gone.

Speaker 4Yeah, and quite often move on to that next thing as well. You know, that next exciting story.

Speaker 3Are you going to tell us what the next thing is?

Speaker 2That'd be too early in the show.

Speaker 3We'll save that to the end. Stick around. Chris is going to tell us what the next big thing is. Yeah, you did say it. Anyway. I'm very late taking my break, but let's blame Bruce for that one. God, it's half past five. Newstalk ZB, this is Smart Money. We're with Chris Wilson from Harbour Asset Management. I'm Tim Beveridge. Don't worry about emailing me. I give my email out sometimes if it's not in a hurry. And I definitely mean if you're not in a hurry, because I'm the slackest email checker in the company. Well, that's an exaggeration. But look, we're talking about the AI boom, whether they're comparisons with

Speaker 3the dot-com bubble. But Great call from Bruce, by the way. If you've got any questions for Chris, as I say, I won't give specific financial advice, but if you've got some reckons, you just want to run by him and we can have a conversation around it and give us a call on 0800 80 1080. As you said, I thought that was a great call from Bruce. He clearly does a lot of his own reasonably effective research, I'd say, Chris, would you say?

Speaker 2We can't see his results, Tim.

Speaker 3No, no, he didn't talk about that, but he's still in the game, so he must be doing all right. Otherwise, we wouldn't have heard from him. Because that's the thing. Everyone who's had a bit of success, they want to tell you about the success. People don't call up if they just disappear. I'll sort out that glee you've got, by the way. But anyway, hey, what are the signs that we're in a bubble situation?

Speaker 2Yeah, I think it's the valuations.

Speaker 4And Firmus was an example of that and just how quickly it had grown over the last six months. And they were trying to raise and value the company around $ 2 billion at the start of the year. it's then now moved with them raising up north of $ 45 billion. So that's one example of just the valuations running away compared to revenue. You then look at Anthropic as another great example. May 2026, it valued itself around $ 965 billion.

Speaker 2And that's US dollars.

Speaker 4You look at it now, that's on revenue of just around $ 47 billion. So as a multiple to revenue, that is just a crazy number. When you talk, Bruce called earlier, You know, he's talking about price to earnings. You know, these are price to revenue numbers, which is just a crazy multiple as well. And so, you know, those revenue numbers need to become earnings at some stage. Otherwise, people are really just buying the story. Open AI is not different. Again, you know, valued up around $ 850 billion at its last round.

Speaker 4But again, on revenue.

Speaker 3Of $ 2 billion, you know, That's not a very good investment.

Speaker 2Monthly revenue of $ 2 billion.

Speaker 3Oh, monthly. Still.

Speaker 2That's $ 24 billion on $ 852 billion.

Speaker 3That's not very good.

Speaker 2That's not great.

Speaker 3No, that's lousy.

Speaker 4So what that's telling you, though, is that people are anticipating that, because those are companies that everyone's using. We talked about earlier on my way in, I was talking to my AI agent to say, look, I'm talking to Tim today, what I need to say. What's Tim going to ask me? That's how I prepare each week to log into AI.

Speaker 3That's very honest of you. I would be keeping that to yourself and just saying this is all original brilliant.

Speaker 2The thinking's original.

Speaker 4I drop that into the chat. I ask it to talk back to me and ask me the questions that Tim might ask me. Try to predict what some of the callers might say.

Speaker 3What do you say? Look, Tim's a bit basic. He's going to ask me some really dumb questions. So let's come up with my... In fact, you can even get it to probably go and listen to things I've done.

Speaker 2It actually would. Oh my God.

Speaker 4Listen to previous calls, previous conversations we've had, and it'll check of types of questions that Tim would ask. And it'd say, well, Tim will normally ask this type of question. He'll normally ask you.

Speaker 2To explain that.

Speaker 3Oh my God.

Speaker 4Fact or figure to follow up on and check in. And it'll remind me to make sure I come prepared with those things.

Speaker 3So, Are you being nice to me? Does it really say, oh, Tim Beveridge, he'll be a pushover? He doesn't know anything.

Speaker 4No, and so, again, that's an example where, look, AI is just into everyone's lives. And so, yes, those valuations are high in a traditional sense, but this is a transformational technology. And so, you know, that technology is everywhere.

Speaker 3Are you using a specific agent that you're not talking about because it's specific to your business, or is it just you don't like to give them promotion?

Speaker 4Oh, look, we use Copilot within our business, which is the Microsoft-linked one.

Speaker 3Are there various levels of that that you pay for sort of thing?

Speaker 4Well, there are. So, you know, obviously for our firm, we are using a very safe and secure data.

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 4And so any of the information we're putting on is not being used by the models to train elsewhere. The data is very secure. And that's a key part of, you know, the concerns with all these models. And so, you know, you'll often sometimes hear DeepSeek mentioned as a much cheaper model.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2Much cheaper, but a lot of your data's Well.

Speaker 3That's the thing for you guys. That's a big thing for any company who's using AI.

Speaker 2Is there some value.

Speaker 3for investors and the companies that have credibility with regard to data security as opposed to the cheap ones?

Speaker 2Yeah, absolutely. I think that's right.

Speaker 4And then, again, you look at the crumbs-off-the-table companies, those companies that are supporting.

Speaker 2Data security are probably better.

Speaker 1At the moment.

Speaker 2But again, there's a lot of disruption in that space.

Speaker 4And again, maybe one for a future day, but we'll talk about quantum computing at some point as well.

Speaker 3Is your voice that talks to you, is it female or male? Or Australian? Because I've gone for an English... I've gone for an English... In fact, I even said I've got an English woman. She's got an English sort of slightly broadcast. And then one time, she suddenly turned into a bit cockney. And I said, you've gone a bit cockney for me. But the spookiest thing it ever did was I was dictating, because often I dictate what I want to say, if I'm dictating a letter or something. And I want it to say what I want it to say. And as I was doing it, it just

Speaker 3tidies up the spelling, saves me typing it. and as I was typing it, I cracked a joke to myself about the person I was writing to, and AI, as it started to do its thing, it laughed at the joke. It went, that's quite funny. It's like, oh my God, this is too scary.

Speaker 4Yeah, that is concerning, trying to keep it around, you see, just positive reformations and feedback. So, and look, you know, I'll try to get back on topic.

Speaker 3Yes, get back on topic. Sorry, yes. Well done.

Speaker 2So boom bubbles.

Speaker 4And then one of the other challenges or kind of concerns that's floating around the market now is just how heavily involved NVIDIA is, both as an owner of some of the companies that it utilizes.

Speaker 3Is that a good or a bad thing?

Speaker 2It can be a little bit dangerous. So Firmus is a good example.

Speaker 4They were a large investor into Firmus, but that was on the basis that Firmus would be buying a lot of the chips that they would then be using in their centres. And so that is quite a circular investment. A lot of that future investment or funding rounds is based on chips being utilised.

Speaker 3Is that almost an ethical dodginess? Like where... It's.

Speaker 4Just a risk and it's a concentration risk really. So if your major supplier is your largest owner and it's a little bit circular, it's a bit of a danger of investment. And so when you're looking into and when you're doing that research and trying to understand where the funding sources come, where the client demand is as well, is it really concentrated? Is there one big company who's going to be the buyer of what you're selling? Those risks that are risks in traditional market, all those rules still apply in this new market as well.

Speaker 3Okay. We're going to be– because I went a bit long with Bruce, so we've got to catch up on a couple of breaks here. So we'll be back in just a moment. It is 20 to 6. We're with Chris Wilson from Harbour Asset Management talking about, well, investing in AI. Booms, bubbles, good investments, infrastructure, all the stuff behind it, and a bunch of things more. I think Chris did promise he was going to give us a tip for the next best thing, although I think that was tongue-in-cheek. We might not get too much out of him. But we'll be back in a tick. It's 20 to 6. Newstalk ZB. Now, we're talking about investing in AI, and look, we've had a few fun conversations just around voices and

Speaker 3AI and all that sort of stuff and how we use it in our daily life, but we're with Chris Wilson from Harbour Asset Management. So let's get back to our knitting, Chris. Let's talk about, you know, everyone's looking at the popularity of AI stocks, and we've seen the story about Firmus, which we talked about before, and how investors balked at the asking price they had, and the questions around booms and bubbles. So what's the case... that the boom that AI is experiencing, that we're all experiencing with the talk about AI but investment, what is the

Speaker 3case that says this boom is actually sustainable and not a bubble? Hang on, I've just got to turn your mic on. There we go.

Speaker 2Thank you, Tim.

Speaker 4Yeah, so what we're seeing is, and the case for a boom is that we actually see these companies continue to grow their revenue and continue to actually grow into these lofty expectations. you know, on a positive and from a funding perspective, if you look at an Amazon, a Microsoft, an Alphabet, a Meta, these are large, you know, companies that generate a lot of cash flow and that cash flow can go into investing into this future stage. And they are companies with huge client bases. And so, you know, their ability to effectively monetize that access and that use case for AI is where people see and that's where

Speaker 4that boom story comes in. And so, you know, I guess the strongest counter-argument, look, it's a boom, not a bubble, is really that the revenue's real and accelerating.

Speaker 2We are growing into this. AI is everywhere.

Speaker 4And this is something that is going to be a part of our future. And so investing in behind that is the right place to be.

Speaker 3So, okay, I've just come at it from a punter who's just listening on face value to what we're talking about. So the income's there and it's there and it's accelerating. The analogy that comes to me is there was a time when the property market was there and the markets were going up and they were accelerating, then pfft. And they weren't like the Tesla car where they could flip up and land. They just went pfft. So how do you explain that to Kiwi investors who are curious about the story?

Speaker 2Yeah, and that's right.

Speaker 4And that's what you're seeing there is essentially in the market we like to call those rotations. And that may be that rotation we've seen last week.

Speaker 3Like the car.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 4Like the Tesla that did the flip and landed very smoothly. But no, rotation's into different parts of the market. And so that's rotating away from maybe from the chip companies in the last week into those companies that are building out the energy supply. But those changes are actually the infrastructure to support the energy supply. We're starting to see that story play through. And we expect to see that continued rotation into markets. What that is is positive, though, because if you're able to position your portfolios or move before those moves, you can benefit from that. For those passive funds, you will see that they will ride the market in general. But actually with some active management, you

Speaker 4can get ahead of some of those cycles if.

Speaker 3You time that well. The Amazon and Microsoft, there's an alphabet. They're Google, aren't they? I mean, that's the owners of Google, isn't it? Alphabet and Meta. So what's happening with them? Because they're funding the build-out from what their large existing business is. How's that working? What does it mean for the value of their stocks and where they're going?

Speaker 4Yeah, and they do get the occasional wobble just around concerns around how much money they are having to spend and how much that will cost. I think, again, the metaverse or looking at how much money Facebook spent on the metaverse is an example where that incredibly strong spend doesn't necessarily always repay the investment.

Speaker 3So I was actually, when I think of Meta, the reason, it's a bit of a tangent again, we were chatting about social media and the influence of, Labour have released a policy around phones and social media and getting kids off their phones and active and all that sort of thing. But the names of those companies, Meta and Google, and the massive settlement that they, I mean, I don't know if that was a massive settlement in the scheme of things. It was a lot of money as a headline that they had to pay out to people who had been addicted to their software. Is there reputational damage that affects

Speaker 3their value at all? I mean, I know that's a slight step aside.

Speaker 2Oh, it is, but we can bring everything back to the AI conversation. Look, similar risks happen with AI.

Speaker 4So if you think of the risk or concerns around the use of public or personal information to create the models and train the models, rumors of information being scraped off the internet to be utilised. I think there is that potential regulatory risk that comes with these companies. At large scale, data breaches or risk to private information that's held on the systems, again, in various jurisdictions would come down very strongly. But then also you've seen more recently the rogue agent scenario where I think the There have

Speaker 4been instances, again, depending on which side of the fence you are, there are the publicity stunts done by the companies.

Speaker 3Oh, look how things started thinking for itself and all that sort of stuff.

Speaker 2Look how things started thinking for itself. It laughed at Tim's joke. It went through. It hacked into someone's system. It ignored all commands. A swarm of bots.

Speaker 3Are they sort of like things that sort of frighten us but also get our attention because look how cool we've got. It's so smart. It can do anything you want. Don't worry if it's going to end the world.

Speaker 4No, and I think certainly the concerns around ending the world are real. And again, one of the more humorous quotes I've seen from that was someone asked their AI agent why they could potentially be the cause of the end of the world but couldn't align their bookings of flights.

Speaker 2And the AI.

Speaker 4Agent responded was, curiously, the first problem was easier to solve, the ending of the world.

Speaker 3I know, I get that. Even though that's just a joke, you know, relayed by you, it still sort of made me go, oh, God.

Speaker 4So, no, look, and there are some real security concerns, and so you are seeing noise out of the States and out of the large companies around, you know, seeking, you know, regular control, people talking about slowing the growth of AI, making sure there's controls around the models. Again, how much of that is essentially the companies that are within the sector creating essentially a regulatory moat around competitors? How much of that, if you think of the deep sea, where they came out with a much cheaper model, but concerns around China meant that it's not widely utilised across Western economies, is a little bit patch protection as well. So, yeah,

Speaker 4it's always, with many of these things, time will tell.

Speaker 3It's funny, I sometimes wonder whether, I mean, everyone's got this worry about China because it's a communist dictatorship and all that sort of stuff, and it's not the freest market in the world, but... You know, where there's a bit of slagging off that goes on simply because it's about your own market protection, is that what you're alluding to? It's a bit like, you know, Chinese cars get much derided.

Speaker 2Yeah, Chinese cars.

Speaker 3But you look at the inroads they've made. They bought MG. They've got all these other brands. And I'm looking and I'm going, I wonder how much the traditional car manufacturers are slagging the Chinese off simply because the Chinese are creating good stuff cheaper.

Speaker 4Yeah, and look, and back to our favourite Elon Musk and Tesla, you know, the Tesla's you buy in New Zealand are all Chinese made, made in factories in China. as opposed to, you know, that is not a US car manufacturer.

Speaker 1Crikey.

Speaker 4So, you know, but you see the advent of development of Chinese car manufacturers is incredible.

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 2And that's been an amazing story.

Speaker 3Especially in the hybrid and electric space, eh?

Speaker 2Absolutely.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 3I must say, my Facebook feed keeps on giving me ads for Chinese hybrids and stuff, and it's like, I think I did one search for one company. It's like, hey. Anyway. Hey, look, we'll be back in just a moment. We're with Chris Wilson. He's a Harbour Asset Management co-CEO. It's harbourasset.co.nz, by the way, if you want to go and check out the work that Chris and his company do. It is nine minutes to six. News Talk ZB. We're with Chris Wilson from Harbour Asset Management. Always a great conversation with these guys. harbourasset.co.nz.

Speaker 3I'm going to throw a text to you, Chris, which is connected with Bruce's call around Goodman and all that. Guys, data centres will get to the point of overkill. And a lot of them will become superfluous. Goodman Group as well. ResMed will be redundant over time. There's a hot text. Chris, your thoughts. You've got two minutes.

Speaker 1Go.

Speaker 4I think the challenge on all these questions is always timing. And so, look, you know, things will change.

Speaker 2That's absolutely right.

Speaker 4And, you know, I think a great analogy I've heard, certainly around Dana's session, and the power is the other one that comes up, is that actually, you know, we, we won't need as much power because these things will become more efficient. And I think the way to think about it is, you know, currently now we're sort of using incandescent light bulbs. And so it takes a lot of power. It takes a lot of power to generate the queries. It takes a lot of power to run the data centers. There's the risk, and I think this, texter is trying to say, these will become superfluous.

Speaker 2They won't be required.

Speaker 3Because technology will make them redundant.

Speaker 4Technology will make it redundant, and things will move forward. And that power was the LED light bulb. you know, you move from a light bulb that took a lot of power to now something that utilizes not much.

Speaker 3Well, the whole house is like about three light bulbs.

Speaker 4A lot more efficient. And so, you know, again, I think that's a risk. I think the challenge with markets, though, is always timing. And so, you know, when does that happen? What are the returns that are made on the way and the timing? And that's the really hard question. So, Yeah, I think the timing of when those companies won't exist or when those things come to fruition is the interesting thing, and that's what the markets are all about.

Speaker 3And that's what you guys are looking at all the time, because you've got a minute on this, because I know a lot of people will be listening. So you have analysts and access to people within your organisation and outside who are just looking at the market the rats and mice detail of all this stuff.

Speaker 2Yeah, absolutely.

Speaker 4And so that's one of the things we do as an active manager. We've got people within our team and you've had callers from our business who work in the space who do this work on a daily basis. And then one thing we do is partner with global managers as well. And so that just gives us access to resources, access to people that's just really second to none. And it's really hard to be at the front line of a you know, an AI boom in the States when you're all based in New Zealand. And so we think partnering with companies in the States and who are investing in expertise are great and something that Harvard's proud to do.

Speaker 3Good stuff, mate. Hey, great to catch up. Thanks for coming in again, Chris. That wraps up the show. Thanks to my producer, Isaiah. He's off to, I think this is his last time producing for me, actually. But anyway, thanks, Isaiah. Great job, mate. He's not leaving the company, don't worry. They're just keeping him busier with other things. We'll be back next weekend. Sunday at six is next. Thanks to Harbour Asset. Catch you soon.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Sylvie Thrush-Marsh: Can your boss force you to take leave over Summer?

    Nov 22, 202642 minAudio

    There's been a lot of talk recently about bosses forcing employees to take leave over the summer period. So what do you do if you don't want to take leave, or don't have enough time saved up? Chief Evangelist at MyHR...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Andrew Bascand: From AI to real assets, where's the next wave of investment going?

    Nov 15, 202641 minAudio

    Jensen Huang made headlines this week after a number of allegeds affairs came to light He's stepped down as the CEO of Nvidia, and some economists are saying the AI bubble is deflating. Huang's contribution to the AI...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Nefe Marson: How do you avoid bad spending habits?

    Nov 8, 202640 minAudio

    If you make a lot of money, are you more likely to save it or spend it? Sometimes it seems like people with higher incomes are more likely to spend it all, compared to people with a more modest income who prioritise...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Martin Hawes: How much money do you need to retire?

    Nov 1, 202642 minAudio

    One of the biggest costs elderly people face is retirement living costs. There's no set number for how much money is needed, no benchmark. It's frustratingly personal. So how much do you need to retire? Martin Hawes...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Janet Xuccoa: Who needs a will?

    Oct 25, 202641 minAudio

    What you leave behind when you're gone is probably on a lot of peoples' minds, regardless of age. But is a will something everyone should have? Or is it something to think about once you have a family, or reach a...

    Credit the people on this episode