A head hunter went viral on TikTok after warning Gen Z job candidates not to walk into interviews carrying their iced coffee because it makes them look unserious. Some people agreed with her. Others thought she was the spawn of Satan. So fellow Gen X Substacker Liz LaPoint of GenExcellent and I decided to debate it live. We had no idea what the other thought, so it was fun to hear each other’s takes in real time. Like any good Gen Xer worth their salt, we had our own strong opinions. And we didn’t just talk about coffee. We also talked about the unwritten rules of the workplace, who gets to make them, and what happens when different generations don’t agree on what “professional” even means anymore. We also got into ageism, work-life balance, Zoom etiquette, AI, and whether Gen X should keep adapting to younger generations or finally make them adapt to us. We laughted about this video that brilliantly imagines the scenario of a Gen Zer walking into the office with her iced coffee in hand. You can watch the whole conversation above. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit jonsmalltalk.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_02We're live. Yay. There's two of us here and that's us. That's the two of us. Hello, Tracy. Hello, Alicia. Hello, Danielle. This is so exciting. Okay. Well, as people kind of gather in the room, I am so thrilled to have with me Liz LaPointe from GenExcellent.com. Um, wonderful Substack, Substacker. Um, and she brought up this idea to do this, um, live chat.
SPEAKER_02And I'm so, I'm happy you did because this is something that has been on my mind and I think on many people's minds and certainly like took over the internet. And if you don't know what we're talking about, we're talking about the great coffee debate of 2000. Oh, the great iced coffee debate of 2026. And, um, I'm going to set it up. I actually recorded the TikTok heard around the world that kind of like apparently initiated this discussion. And maybe there was a discussion before because it's one of these things when things become memes like this, who knows where it really originated.
SPEAKER_02But the first I had ever heard about it, well, I read an article about it and it was based on this TikTok. Basically, what you're about to hear is, you know, I'll play it and we can talk a little bit about it. So here we go. Here is the TikTok heard around the world.
SPEAKER_00My Gen Z candidates are showing up to their interviews with iced coffee, iced latte in hand. And here's how I perceive that as a recruiter with 16 years of experience that deals with mostly Fortune 500 super buttoned up corporations. Is perceived from my opinion, my hiring standpoint, that when you show up with an iced coffee or an iced latte, that this interview is just like a stop on your list of errands for the day. It looks like you went to Target and you went to Starbucks.
SPEAKER_00Now you're stopping by your interview. Then you're on to the next thing. It looks a little too casual to me. And again, this is like your perception of how you're perceived in this 30 to 45 minutes that you have to interview. This is important. Don't show up with iced coffee or the iced latte. Save that for well before the interview or after the interview. Go and get one. But don't like waltz into your interview all casual with an iced coffee. It just looks like you didn't have time to finish your coffee beforehand. My Gen Z candidate.
SPEAKER_02So that is it. That is the great iced coffee debate that basically this HR executive is saying that she's getting complaints that Gen Zers are showing up to job interviews with iced coffee. And it's driving people crazy. You know, I don't think I've seen this much anger at a generation since the avocado toast crisis of the millennials, right, 10 years earlier. So Liz and I, we don't know each other. There's opinions on this. You're seeing this live.
SPEAKER_02We have not really actually discussed this topic at all. So, Liz, I'm going to open it up to you and give your sort of opening feelings about whether you agree, disagree. Should people such as Gen Z bring or really any generation bring iced coffee to a job interview? And first, give me your opinion. Then I want to sort of understand why you think this is really like taken off as such an issue on the on the Internet.
SPEAKER_01Well, my first opinion is Who gives a fuck? Like, come on. Come on. Of all things to judge a candidate for a position, that is one of the flimsiest, most shallow, absurd.
SPEAKER_02It is.
SPEAKER_01I just, I can't. I can't. But to go a little backwards, I came across this opinion only because somebody on Substack in their notes had written, hey, have you guys heard about the recruiter? You know? Yeah. And Apparently, this person also agreed with the recruiter because I think they said something along the lines of, oh, young people, Gen Z doesn't know how they make themselves look. And I'm like, how do they make themselves look? I could not wrap my head around it.
SPEAKER_01And so I go to the comments because I'm an intellectually curious person. I don't immediately assume the worst. My opinion right off the bat was, well, that's ridiculous, but I want to hear the arguments because maybe I'll change my mind, right?
SPEAKER_02Right.
SPEAKER_01I can't speak from experience. I have never been a hiring manager or a supervisor or anybody in that position to hire people. Maybe there's something they know I don't. So I go to the comments. And comment after comment... Nobody was saying anything that enlightened me. Nobody in this particular stream of comments, yeah, nobody was saying anything reasonable or rational or that made sense to me. And so I would push back a little bit.
SPEAKER_01So I would hop in and ask questions like, wait, but why or what about this? So for example, one of the worst arguments I saw in the comments was, Iced Coffee says, I deserve a treat. While Water says, I'm a responsible adult.
SPEAKER_02Hmm.
SPEAKER_01Wait, what?
SPEAKER_02First of all, I think both are silly. But anyway, okay, that's so funny. Water says, I'm a responsible adult.
SPEAKER_01Okay, that's good. And that was, I think, in response to somebody asking, what's the difference between water and coffee or whatever, right?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_01And... This very same person, I'm quoting, by the way, I'm reading the actual comments.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, this is not your actual, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Right, and so that same person wrote, it telegraphs that you're overly attached to comfort items, which in turn telegraphs immaturity, self-centeredness, and lack of discipline. If you need to feed your need for pleasure at all times, such that you can't go an hour without putting sweet treats in your mouth, you need to grow up. And so I had replied to that person. To me, it says nothing about that person other than they preferred their coffee iced that day.
SPEAKER_02Right.
SPEAKER_01Like to read so into someone's character and personality based on one tiny thing about them, like, really, this person could show up to the interview and Overqualified, perfectly qualified, tons of experience, well-dressed, articulate, confident. They've got it all, but the iced coffee is going to do them in? How is that reasonable, especially during this economy?
SPEAKER_02I know. Well, that's a real issue. Like, it's so unfair in a lot of ways. But okay, so I love your take because it's not exactly my take. So this is great. Okay. And I know that I am not going to convince you otherwise. And I think my answer is a little more, maybe a little complicated or more nuanced. I don't know. I didn't have the visceral reaction you had. We're like, what? Like I actually I actually could relate a little bit to to the people that were complaining about it.
SPEAKER_02And I think it's I kind of felt like it was analogous to the feeling I get sometimes like when somebody is talking on their when they have their speakerphone on their on their cell and they're like in a public place. Right. And you're just like. Why aren't they doing that? Like, don't they know that that's rude? And to them is the most normal thing in the world to just be doing that. But to me, it's like, ooh, I don't like it. And then I'm like, is this generational? Like, is it just like, I don't, I'm not used to people talking on their speaker phones in public. So here, here's my take.
SPEAKER_02I, I agree that it's very superficial to just judge somebody on their iced coffee ring. Um, but I have interviewed a lot of people and I tried to imagine if I was in that, if I was that interviewer, cause in my career, I've had the opportunity to interview a lot of people. And, um, Yeah.
SPEAKER_02It really depends what the job is, what kind of a company they're working for. But to me, what that does signal is that somebody is like, like I've never brought a liquid or food item to an interview. Like I just have you, like I've never, I would never think to come into an interview with a Coke in my hand or in this case an iced coffee. And I think one of the reasons it resonates so much is the iced coffee so much like the symbol of like today's like Right. Right. Right. Right.
SPEAKER_02I think what it signals to me is that you're a little bit, like, disorganized. Like, you sort of, like, you're kind of, like, the kind of person who maybe didn't, like, should have maybe had the coffee before the interview. Like, so you're running late. It feels a little bit like I might have been running a little bit late. And, oh, I think right before my interview, I'm going to just grab a coffee. I have a little time. But I don't really have quite enough time to finish it. So I'm just going to bring it with me. And, you know, because what's the idea? You're going to sip your coffee during... Yeah.
SPEAKER_02So I think it shows a little bit of disorganization, a little bit of priorities, not quite getting your priorities, not organizing your day correctly, not scheduling your day correctly. That said, it would not be disqualifying for me. I would not see somebody sip on an iced coffee and be like, I can't imagine this person Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_02You know, obviously he or she is is like like cool and young and like this is like the cool young person. If it was like my CFO, you know, I might have a different opinion. So I feel like we can't like discuss. The signals that we send are activities. So that's to me what that signals. Just because I can only sort of judge people the way they would judge me. And I cannot imagine or I guess do unto others as I would have.
SPEAKER_02I don't even know what this expression is. But the idea being that would I ever do this? And like I would never bring iced coffee to a meeting. Would you? I mean, I guess maybe you would. Like you wouldn't have a problem with it. I did bring nice coffee to this one. Is that rude? Is it rude to sip your coffee during a podcast?
SPEAKER_01I don't know. How dare you?
SPEAKER_02I'm doing it. Sorry.
SPEAKER_01So this was actually something I brought up in that debate, discussion a few days ago. I asked somebody, I said, So one of the arguments people made was what you said, which is I would never bring a beverage into the interview. I would let them offer it because a lot of companies offer it.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01A little something, a little coffee, a little water, whatever. They always do.
SPEAKER_02They always say, hey, some coffee, some water.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02I usually say no because I feel like that's a test. But anyway, do you usually accept?
SPEAKER_01They're trying to get your DNA. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, they're trying to get. No, but I always feel like it's like, oh, he's one of those. We'll take anything. I don't know. I just I'm always like, I'm good. I'm good. I'm good. I don't know. I'm curious to know what people in the comments think. I always say no to the to the free water coffee offer.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Well, so and then I said, but they usually if they usually offer something like that, why would it reflect poorly on you to bring something in that they would have offered anyway? Yeah. It's not like a job interview is the same thing as a dinner party or a restaurant where, yeah, tacky, you don't bring in an outside beverage into a restaurant. You don't bring in your own booze when you go to the bar, you know, things like that, right?
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Exactly. Not the same thing. It's a job interview. You're there for them to see if you are a good fit for the position. And honestly, whether you need something to sip on during the time you're there, Should, I mean, not even be a factor. But, so, personally, I take a medication where one of the side effects is a dry mouth. So add, yeah, so add to that the fact that talking creates a dry mouth.
SPEAKER_01I can't even do these types of things without having water right in reach because I need to constantly be sipping.
SPEAKER_02So I hear you
SPEAKER_01factor in. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02And so if you don't know somebody's situation.
SPEAKER_01Exactly. You don't know what people's personal reasons for bringing something like that.
SPEAKER_02Well, maybe I don't want to hire a dry mouth person. I have a bias against dry mouth employees. Yeah. Yeah. No, but I hear you like people could have their own issues for for bringing in. I obviously it's the substance of what they say. I think what you know, what came up, though, is it's immediate. And the reason we're talking about this, other than the fact that it is interesting, is that it became also a little bit of a generational war. Right. Where like the assumption was that older people are too rigid to.
SPEAKER_02Mm-hmm. And they're so stuck in their ways that when a young kid comes in with his or her, you know, iced coffee, that just sets them off because it's something they're not used to seeing. And they have their way that we have our way that we do it. And they have their way. And like, why won't they adapt to our way? And then vice versa. That's what the young people are saying. And the old people are saying, yeah, well, we're running the show right now. And this is our way. And our way is that that's inappropriate and not, you know,
SPEAKER_02to that's like coming into a, you know, equivalent of like coming into an interview, you know, wearing, I don't know, like shorts and a, you know, and of course, a lot of people do this shorts and like a T-shirt or whatever.
SPEAKER_01People do that, really?
SPEAKER_02People do do that. I mean, it depends on the job. I guess if you were interviewing maybe for, you know, the head, I don't know, ice cream maker at the local ice cream shop, you might come in there.
SPEAKER_01Or a lifeguard or something.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, lifeguard. That would be pretty, yeah. And, you know, and the flip side of this is that I had on Colleen, I can't think of her last name right now, but she's a Gen X, like, headhunter. And she was telling me that she had heard from one of her clients who was Gen X that he went to a job interview with In a suit and tie. And he didn't get the job because the person interviewing them who was like 20 years younger thought that they were too like they wouldn't fit in the culture. They were too like formal. So there's like a you know,
SPEAKER_02there's all these signals that we send and and there's all these biases that we come into these interviews with and this sort of preconceived notions. And I feel like. I get that. Like it's I am who I am. So what do you so what do you think of that argument that let's talk take the Gen Z argument that like we are sometimes a bit rigid in our thinking less Gen Xers like that we need to adapt to the the the ways of the younger people coming in.
SPEAKER_01Well, in the conversation that I saw, nobody brought up Gen X or boomers, I think. I mean, maybe I just didn't read all the comments, but I never saw us brought up because, of course, we're always forgotten, right?
SPEAKER_02That's true. They would say boomers anyway.
SPEAKER_01It doesn't matter. Exactly, yeah.
SPEAKER_02Once again, you and I are trying, you and I in our little way are trying to figure this out.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01So, I mean, here I am in older people. And I am on Gen Z's side on this, but, you know, they probably were mostly referencing boomers in this, but the only generation I saw in the conversation specified was Gen Z. And I think the rigidity, see, when we were coming up, we were taught to conform to whatever job environment we were applying for, right?
SPEAKER_01Like get to know that environment, all that. It might be one of the reasons why a lot of us just opted out, period. Because we were like, well, F that. I don't want to be part of that environment. I'm going to go do this over here. I'm going to create my own environment with my own startup. Things like that.
SPEAKER_02Whatever. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01But now Gen Z is going, well, no. How about we meet in the middle? Like they're trying to maybe, I don't know. I'm just guessing. What?
SPEAKER_02I said, I hope that's their signal. I hope that they're trying to, like, adapt a little bit of our way of doing things into their way, rather than saying, like, this is the way we do it now, old man boomer, right? You know, which is kind of like the attitude I feel like I get a lot. Now, I get that a little bit more from millennials than Gen Z. Maybe I'm biased towards Gen Z because I have two Gen Z kids, and I think we just love our kids, or at least I do. So I'm a little bit like, I like Gen Z. They're cool. Millennials, on the other hand. No. But I hear what you're saying, that they kind of want...
SPEAKER_02They're just like, hey, old man, look at my life. I'm going to... I want you to adapt to who I am. This is their whole work-life balance thing. We did not believe in that. That was not a thing we talked a lot about when we were younger. Yes, I wanted to have a cool life, but my goal in the corporate world was to get ahead and succeed at any cost.
SPEAKER_02I grew up in print magazines. I'm such a dinosaur. I'm like the cliche 90s guy who worked at a magazine in New York. That was my job. We would come in on the weekends to close issues, which was when we were going to ship to the press. Nobody complained about it. Nobody got paid for that. Nobody got paid extra to come in on the weekends. I can't even imagine asking a younger generation now person to work. I would feel guilty.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02We played the game, too, and, like, we didn't think about our mental health that much, and we didn't, like, push back. So I admire that part of Gen Z. What do you think? Do you feel the same way?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and there is something to say for playing their game just to get in and get ahead and then changing it from within, changing the culture and the rules from within once you're higher up. I mean, there's that, too, which I'm pretty sure we did.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Like we inherited the reins. I'm trying to think how we changed it from boomers. I mean, I, I certainly was more open door. I mean, it's kind of like, I guess maybe it's the equivalent of us being helicopter parents now that, you know, like our parents basically like ignored us, at least mine, you know, like we're like out of sight, out of mind. And, and then of course we overcompensated when we became parents and maybe we're doing, we, we kind of do a similar thing in the workplace. That'd be an interesting article. Like have we become helicopter employees? The problem is we haven't been in charge Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I think the way I used to run departments was very much like, okay, always check in, check in, check in, check in. How you doing? Have lots of like meetings, like weekly meetings with the team. You know, but it was hard for me because culturally a lot of, and at this time it was a lot of millennials would like, Like, complain to me a lot. And I would always think, like, oh, God, I never used to complain to my boss. Like, I would just never do that. So it was hard for me to adjust to that. But I think they were right,
SPEAKER_01like, to, like,
SPEAKER_02at least, you know, not just, like, take it because, like, they're in a position, because I'm in a position of authority and you need to do what I say to do. So, but, you know, it's just hard. I wrote this article recently about how, you know, we talk to each other differently, how we communicate differently in offices, like how, you know, Gen X likes to do email or we like to talk on the phone, but like Gen Z and millennials like to use like Slack and text and,
SPEAKER_02you know, that kind of sets up this weird kind of like communication barrier sometimes.
SPEAKER_01Agreed, yeah.
SPEAKER_02A lot of people pushed back and said, like, why do we have to adapt? Like, why did Gen X have to adapt? Or why do the older generation, because now we're kind of in charge. Like, don't they have to adapt to us? Like, why do we have to adapt to them? And I understood that there's probably somewhere in the middle that you have to, I think what you're saying, like, meet in the middle somewhere. It's like, you know, but, but, and, but I, I also get that argument. Like, I always find myself trying to adapt and maybe it's just because I want people to like me or whatever, but I'm always trying to like, trying to like adapt to the younger, like, oh, that's just a Gen Z thing.
SPEAKER_02So I'm just going to like, that's fine. It's fine. If they want to talk on their phones, on speakerphone in the middle of the office at like a volume 10, then maybe I'll accept it because that's kind of what Gen Z does. You know, if they want to like call me bra or, you know, like, or like, you know, like, Talk to me. I'm 12 years old or whatever. That's a Gen Z thing. Or if they want to basically say, I am out the door by five because that's my rule.
SPEAKER_02And even though work really should go to six tonight because we've got a lot going on, then again, it's like we're constantly being asked to adapt. One of the things that drives me crazy that the younger generation does is that on Zoom calls, they turn off their camera.
SPEAKER_01Oh, really?
SPEAKER_02Have you noticed this?
SPEAKER_01No.
SPEAKER_02So people turn off their camera on Zoom calls a lot, like not on Zoom calls. Well, yeah. I mean, even one-on-one Zoom calls or like group, I don't know. Does anybody else, hearts, has anybody else noticed that a lot of times, and I don't know if they learned this during COVID, but it's because nobody wanted to be on camera during COVID, right?
SPEAKER_01Oh, yeah. I could see that.
SPEAKER_02You know, but, but that kind of drives me crazy because I'm, you know, I want to see the person, like, can you imagine if you were off camera right now and I was talking to you? Like, I just, I just, and it, to me, it also, it also implies that they're not, they're not listening and they're off, like, you know, whatever, like taking a shower and they're not even there, you know? So I don't love that. So I guess this is extremely long winded answer of, I don't always know how much to, um, You know, basically honor, like, what I believe in, like,
SPEAKER_02the way I grew up and what kind of, like, what I'm comfortable with, but also, like, honor what they, uh, is normal to them, you know?
SPEAKER_01Can we go back to something?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, please. I've been saying so much. Talking too much.
SPEAKER_01There was something the recruiter said in the recording you played.
SPEAKER_02Oh, you want to play the recording yet? No, we don't.
SPEAKER_01No, there was something that... No,
SPEAKER_02please don't. Please don't play it again.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, no, you don't have to play it again, but just... There was something that she said that I want to address. She mentioned, and I think you did too, actually, that it can give the impression when somebody, a candidate shows up with an iced beverage, it communicates that the interview was just a stop in between a bunch of other things, running errands and so forth, right?
SPEAKER_02Right.
SPEAKER_01To which my instinctual response is, As opposed to clearing out their entire day only for the interview and they're not allowed to do anything else that day without being judged for it. I'm not sure I understand. I need to pick that. I need to pick your brain for trying to understand.
SPEAKER_02Well, that's an interesting thing. I think that you you. Yes. So that's a really interesting point. And I did see that point made in the comments. It's like, yeah, it was a stop along my way because my whole day is not devoted to this one thing. Like, I'm a big person.
SPEAKER_01Why is that bad? They had to pick up their dry cleaning. They wanted to get a little caffeine. So they were a little more alert and focused for the interview, which is usually a good thing. Why would that look bad?
SPEAKER_02Right. It really depends. Cause to me, I'm trying to play devil's advocate here. Like if I, if somebody came in, I might be like, I want this job to feel very important to you. And I want to feel like you prepped for this, that this is like, you know, yes, this is, it doesn't have to be the only thing you've done today, but I like to think that like You thought through like, how am I going to dress? What am I going to say? And part of that is not like being, you know, the iced coffee thing gives a little bit of frazzled vibe.
SPEAKER_02What's the way of Gen Z, frazzled feels or whatever. It gives the feeling of like, oh my God, like I just got up. Like, I'm like, oh, I got to get my Starbucks, like grab. And it's like running to the interview and it's just like, oh, I'm here. Hello. Hello. There's a really funny TikTok of a, I sent it to you, I don't know, you said it, I don't know if you thought it was funny, but of the girl who imagines being the girl with the iced coffee showing up to the interview and she's slurping. It was so funny.
SPEAKER_01I'm so glad you brought that up because that actually affected my opinion a little bit. Oh, really? Okay. Yeah. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02So, um, now I forgot my train of thought, but the, the, the point being that, um, it does give off a little bit of a frazzled kind of like disorganized, I keep saying disorganized, but just like not, um, not, uh, you know, uh, Not like disciplined a little bit person. Now, again, like it's not going to be a disqualifier for me. It just is like a little thing that comes up. Now, that's why I felt like the recruiter like making it such a big deal. It was like a little bit overblown.
SPEAKER_02It's just like, It's the equivalent of me showing up in a suit to an interview at a Silicon Valley startup and I probably should have showed up in a t-shirt. Should it be a disqualifier? No, but it's like, should the person maybe have thought it through a little bit before? Yeah. Like I, I would not show up with a nice coffee, nor would I show up with in a suit to a, you know, startup job. Like I, I, I think these things through, like, you know, and so I like to think that it is important to you, like this job is important to you because this is going to be what you're doing most
SPEAKER_02of your day. And I want to feel like you care. And I guess my, my, and I'll, I know it's a long answer. My impression, a little bit of Gen Z is they, and I think it's right, is that they don't really want to They're different than us in the sense that like they're not on some like career path. And this is because of the way the nature of the economy anyway. But they're not the kind of people like, OK, this is like once I get this entry level job, you have me for like five years or 10 years. Like I am I am in like they might be gone in six months. Like so I guess I want to think that the person because it's a pain in the ass to find somebody and hire somebody and train somebody. So I would like to think that the person coming in the door,
SPEAKER_02serious about the job, isn't going to make my life hell and is thinking about sticking around. Right. And so the coffee thing kind of gives me the impression that like they're also writing their novel. And they are they're working on a startup with their friend and they are, you know, like they have like a lot of things going on, in which case that's good for them. But is that somebody that I want to hire?
SPEAKER_01So it sounds like what you're doing is describing how things have changed from when we were coming up. It was. The job, the supervisors, the managers, the people looking to fill their position are the ones who get to judge us, the people showing up hoping to get hired. But it doesn't get to go the other way.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Like, almost like a lot of the complaints around this come off to me like, The hiring managers and recruiters and whatever, they want to only see nervousness and anxiety from the, oh, I hope you hire me.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, not just, yeah, but just like, yeah, yeah, kind of like, yeah, you want, yeah. But the thing is, if that's what people want, do you give it to them?
SPEAKER_01Well, and what I'm getting at, though, is like, I guess Gen Z is understanding that, look, this interview is me interviewing you too. I don't know if I want to take the job. I don't know if I want to work for you. This is also them ascertaining or assessing, I mean, assessing the work environment and the person who will be their boss if they get offered the job or whatever. And so that's them going, because there were a few people who made the point, if my bringing an iced coffee is Yeah.
SPEAKER_01You seem very cool and laid back and not scary and rigid and, you know, whatever. But I and I get that point of view, too. Like, in other words, they would be like, well, that was me assessing you. And I don't want to work for you if that bothered you that I brought something to sip on. So back to the video, though, that you sent the TikTok.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Oh, I wish I could show that.
SPEAKER_01I know, right? It was great. So this woman does a TikTok where she does kind of a, she kind of spoofs or does an impression of the average Gen Zer who goes to a job interview with an iced coffee.
SPEAKER_02Yep.
SPEAKER_01And it was, in my opinion, and I, of course, I'm not basing this on real experience because for all I know, it's not greatly exaggerated, but it came off to me like it was greatly exaggerated to be humorous.
SPEAKER_02Yep.
SPEAKER_01You know, the way something on SNL would be or something, you know. Yeah, like, but what she did was so irritating.
SPEAKER_02Sorry, my God, my computer's doing weird things. Keep going.
SPEAKER_01But anyway, so what she did was so irritating, though, because in the interview, she keeps shaking the ice, making that awful sound, right, while the interviewer's trying to talk to her. And then and she's and then, of course, she sips when it's at the end. So you hear that awful straw sound trying to suck up the last of the liquid. Right.
SPEAKER_02And she's like, yeah, he's asking for the resume and she's like got like she's like she can't because her coffee is like in the way. And it's like the focus of everything. But it's like the worst case scenario. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, exactly. And the iced coffee, you know, the condensation makes it wet on the outside. And so you have to worry about that getting on papers or whatever. Right. And so watching that made me go, oh, well, if this was actually even close to being accurate and representing how irritating is, now I at least understand why people nitpick about iced coffee versus hot coffee.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Because at first I was like, what's the difference? Who cares? Coffee is coffee. You know?
SPEAKER_02It's true.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And then I also realized one of the reasons why I didn't understand why people would have a problem with it is because a lot of the mistakes she was making in her impression in that TikTok were things I don't do or never would do. For example, the condensation. I always wrap my iced drinks in paper towels or towels. So there would be no dripping. There would be no mess.
SPEAKER_02Let me write that down. That's a good one. I'm always dripping everywhere.
SPEAKER_01Right. And so it made me realize, oh, the reason why I didn't get it is because I wouldn't do any of the things that I guess some people do in these interviews if they brought an iced coffee. That said, I don't drink iced coffee. So I would never...
SPEAKER_02So this is all a moot point, this whole thing. I don't know. I don't really like iced coffee either. So what the hell are we talking about? I would have bring a hot coffee. There's no condensation. The problem with hot with my latte is I could have a little milk mustache, which my kids, I mean, would probably say, yes, that you would have a milk mustache because every time you eat or drink anything, there's something on your face to reveal it. There's some interesting comments we have. And this is actually good. I want to read Terry of Mondo Popsicle. Nice name, Terry. He says, jobs suck. These companies are lucky to even have employees at this point.
SPEAKER_02Most companies can barely pay a living wage and are lucky it's an iced coffee and not the
SPEAKER_01applicant smoking crack.
SPEAKER_02Okay, that's extreme. But, you know, I have had a fentanyl taker during my interview. And, you know, I figure that's what the kids are doing these days. Wow. But no, I'm just kidding. I was going to say. No, no, no. But the, the, the, I think he, the, the point that I, and it's a good point, Terry, and thanks for writing in, is that, you know, Gen Z apparently looks at jobs a lot differently than we do now. Back in the day,
SPEAKER_02if you were going to get a job, that meant you were probably going to be on a career track and this was like your entry. I'm assuming now an entry-level job, whatever, but any kind of job, this is going to be a serious job with benefits and actual real salary that's a livable salary and you'd be able to pay your rent and all this stuff. Nowadays, Like the way Gen Z, they don't, they're not as career focused because why would they be when like things change every 10 minutes and companies go under and they don't pay a lot of money and AI, who knows if AI is going to take their job in six months.
SPEAKER_02So it's such a different attitude going into the interview anyway. Not to say that that sort of excuses you being super casual about every job and you'd be like, oh, fuck this job. Oh, yeah, I'll sit for this job interview. Yeah, you're going to fire me in six weeks anyway. Like you probably shouldn't have that attitude. But I get like why this kind of comment would annoy somebody in their 20s when like, dude, like there's no jobs anyway and they don't pay. So like, why do I even care what these people think about me bringing iced coffee? Like, why don't they just hire me? You know, and I get that.
SPEAKER_02I think it's. What do you think about this whole thing about, like, do you have kids? I forgot if you have kids or not.
SPEAKER_01Yes, I have one 15-year-old son.
SPEAKER_02Okay, cool. So your kid's not quite at the getting job phase yet. My kids are 20 and 16. My daughter actually has a job, like at the laser tag place, which is cute. Very 80s job. Yeah. Right. It's like so like fast times at Richmond High, like at the mall, that kind of a job. But anyway, but I know that my kids, you know, they're worried about that. Like they're worried about, you know, like what, like, is there even going to be such a thing as a career? I'm a lawyer.
SPEAKER_02Um, so I'm like, but I like, I just listened to an interview with Bill Gates yesterday saying that he doesn't even think like law is even going to be like a profession, like in a year, like, because it's, or yeah, well, he basically was saying like lawyers are really going to take a huge hit with AI because AI can do so many things that lawyers normally do. Not the like more sophisticated stuff, but on the lower kind of level.
SPEAKER_01I was going to say like a
SPEAKER_02paralegal. Yeah. Paralegal work like draft.
SPEAKER_01Okay.
SPEAKER_02And that's going to affect law. So, you know, some of these professions haven't really been hit by AI yet, but they will be, according to him. By the way, if you want something that is going to make you want to commit suicide, listen to the Ezra Klein interview with Bill Gates about AI.
SPEAKER_01Like, it's freaking...
SPEAKER_02It is terrifying. I couldn't even barely listen to it. He's basically screaming at the top of his lungs, like, we are so screwed. You guys have no idea what's coming. I trust Bill Gates. I saw Bill Gates speak In 1994, to the Magazine Editors Association, he came and spoke. And I remember him telling us, there's going to be these things, they're going to be little pads, and everybody's going to be able to read their magazines on these pads, these like screens. And can you imagine, in 1994, this is way before cell phones,
SPEAKER_02way before iPads, everybody's like, what the fuck is he talking about? And my God, he was like, So this guy knows what he's talking about. Um, so that scared me. But anyway, back to, um, so what is your thought about that? Like maybe going into an interview, like, yeah, like we have to, like, let's respect these poor people. Uh, you know, God, give them a break. Like they'll bring an iced coffee. Like I'm happy they're even showing up for a job interview. A lot of people in their generation don't even like think like it's worth their time to even go to a job interview because what's the point?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I agree. And it is really scary because we're hearing all the time about all the jobs that AI is replacing and jobs that people were, we would never have expected AI to replace. But when you read about why, you're like, well, I guess that makes sense. It's scary and it's sad and they don't know what the future holds. So I get it. At the same time, we still need to earn a living. We still need to pay our rent. We still need to You know? And so, I mean, but it goes both ways, right?
SPEAKER_01From the perspective of the person doing it, the interviewer, like, do you want to fill that position or not? You know?
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01And so maybe be not as picky about... Somebody made a really good point, too. You know how I said, because I take a medication that gives me dry mouth, I carry a water with me everywhere? Somebody else pointed out... How do you know that the person isn't diabetic and the reason they bring in an iced coffee is because that's something that they can quickly sip that elevates their blood sugar when they need it so they don't pass out? Or something like that. Like, none of us really know.
SPEAKER_02That seems like such a Gen. Yeah, nobody else really knows. It seems like such a Gen Z. And I'm not making a joke about this. It's just the way they think about things. Because they're so much more oriented towards, like, mental health.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Like, we didn't ever think. At least, I mean, I love that you are bringing this up for you, you know, and you're a Gen Xer. Like, that that's actually a consideration. Because we'd be like, oh, buck it up kind of thing. Or kind of like. It wouldn't even be in our radar to think like, oh, maybe this person has like an issue. And so they need to like, that just wouldn't be the way we're oriented because Gen Zers and millennials think a lot about mental health and a lot about like their physical well-being and safe spaces and all these kinds of things. So maybe it's a good thing.
SPEAKER_02I mean, I love that everybody is like, yeah, like kind of making excuses for this person bringing, um, I would hope in the interview process, if you did have some concerns, that you'd figure out ways to kind of Get those out rather than just the impressions that, you know, somebody is giving on a very shallow surface way. I mean, job interviews are ridiculous anyway.
SPEAKER_02And now that I think about it, I mean, what the hell can you really learn from a person in a 45 minute interview? But or even like it's you'd be lucky to get 45 minutes, a 15, 20 minute interview. But I that's why I guess. You know, we're just human and we make, we have, we, people make impressions on us. And so I guess the message this woman was trying to send to that is that even though it's completely unfair and there could be a million reasons that including dry mouth,
SPEAKER_02they were, you know, they just, you know, whatever, all the reasons they bring the nice coffee, it might send an impression that Yeah. I think it should be just all fine.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I don't think it should be disqualifying. Exactly. Yeah, I just feel like that is, yeah, you're definitely sending a message. Okay, so for some people, you are now behind the eight ball a little bit because you've now, you know, maybe what she's saying, and again, now I'm trying to defend her a little bit, this HR person. Your video froze.
SPEAKER_01I don't know.
SPEAKER_02Oh, it did? Am I still frozen? Oh, man. God damn it. It was going so well. All right. Okay. Am I still frozen? There you are. Yay.
SPEAKER_01Now you're back. Okay. Two
SPEAKER_02Gen Xers. Yeah, go ahead.
SPEAKER_01No, no, no. What?
SPEAKER_02No, no, no. I was saying two Gen Xers doing a live chat. There's bound to be some technical difficulty.
SPEAKER_01I know. Nothing ever goes smooth for me.
SPEAKER_02No, no.
SPEAKER_01No, anyway. By the way, I love what Terry, my husband, by the way, that's my husband, Terry of Mondo Popsicle.
SPEAKER_02Oh, he is? I love Terry. He's got great comments. Hi, Terry.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Everyone follow him.
SPEAKER_02Is he also on Substack? I gotta follow.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_02Terry of Mondo Popsicle.
SPEAKER_01So I love that he said, you don't have to worry about AI bringing a nice coffee to the interview, I guess.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, that's true. Yeah. Or you don't have to, you know, listen, headhunters, you know, you don't have to worry about, I mean, AI is probably going to replace you. So that woman who made that TikTok video, I mean, why do you need a headhunter to make introductions when an AI can probably do that eventually? You know, I mean, all these, we're all screwed. I mean, there's no job is safe, except for maybe being a plumber. I've decided that I should have done like manual, like a kind of those kinds of jobs, jobs that are more hands-on, seems to be safer, at least for now.
SPEAKER_01One of the terrible arguments I read against bringing an iced coffee to an interview was somebody who had, this was, I'm quoting them, they said, in response to someone pointing out people get thirsty, people get thirsty, what's the big deal, right? And this person wrote, well, people pee too, but usually you hold it during the interview or go beforehand. And my thought was, in what world is peeing during a job interview akin to just sipping on a beverage
SPEAKER_01while you're talking to someone? How are those two things equal? Is that reasonable to even make that analogy?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, it's hilarious. Yeah. I mean, would you... Remember when Marco Rubio was doing the, I don't know if you remember this back in the day, but he was giving his reply to the State of the Union, and in the middle of it, he just reached to get a Coke, and that was the only thing people remember, is that he kind of got dry mouth and reached for the Coke. Again, it's like, yeah, there was nothing wrong with Marco Rubio, and this is the only time I'm ever going to defend Marco Rubio in my life,
SPEAKER_02just ever. But there's nothing wrong with Marco Rubio drinking a soda. It just sent a weird, it just looked weird. And it's the thing that stuck with us, you know? So again, it's like, it's so unfair. I mean, I just think... Just be aware that people think differently about stuff than you. I think maybe if the message is next time you think about bringing the iced coffee to the interview, it's totally up to you and it shouldn't be disqualifying. And if you have dry mouth or you have issues that require you to have that thing,
SPEAKER_02then by all means do it. But if it's just because you're just bringing it in because it was something that was in your hand, maybe think twice because some people might respond to it. I think that's fair enough.
SPEAKER_01And I understand saying something like you arrive and you say, my apologies, I hope it's okay that I brought this. I'll set it down over here. Is it okay if I put it over here? Or I was just super thirsty on my weekend. And just bring it up. Or even if you are.
SPEAKER_02And that's very human. I like that. I might not say about my physical disabilities in the interview.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, maybe not.
SPEAKER_02Maybe not. I did not because, again, it's not fair and it's completely unethical to not hire somebody based, but it definitely puts that in your head. True. I mean... How often do you think people are influenced by your age? I mean, I know that we're getting off the topic here, but like I now worry because I've gotten older that if and I haven't done a job interview in a long time. But but when I you know, if I were to go back into the full time type workforce, I basically right now everything I do is freelance. But if I were to try to get a full time job,
SPEAKER_02I would worry that I would walk into that office and people would think that I am old. And so I might wear this really cool baseball cap. Or I don't know what I would do. Do you think that people judge you based on your age when you walk into that room? And is that just as unethical as judging you by your iced coffee in your hands?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. I mean, I can't speak from personal experience because like you, I have not been on a job interview in a long time. And I was a stay-at-home mom for many, many years now. Did a lot of freelance work. What's up, Terry?
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Carrie hooked it up.
SPEAKER_01But I think the reason people misjudge people, older people, like our age group and up, is because there's an assumption that they're rigid and unchanging and stubborn and can't adapt to new technology, can't adapt to new information. You know, the old thing we heard all the time about you can't teach old dog new tricks, right? Yeah. Okay, so there's that misunderstanding,
SPEAKER_01assumption, because what I always found strange is why wouldn't it be a benefit to be older?
SPEAKER_02Wisdom. Yeah, like why wouldn't
SPEAKER_01you want— And you're bringing maturity that young 20-somethings don't have. The ones that we were just talking about are more likely to just up and quit without notice and be like, F you, I don't even need this job because I live at home still or whatever, right? Somebody older you would think would be a benefit. What's the word?
SPEAKER_02An asset.
SPEAKER_01Yes, exactly.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, like, I mean, I totally agree with that. I think it also, but it also depends on what role you're bringing them into. So like, I tell this story, like, I remember being in my 20s and interviewing people who were older than me, like 10 years older than me, and having a little bit of a bias, being worried about bringing them into the workplace, not because I didn't think they were competent, but because I thought they might not know the material. So like, I worked in magazines, right? And magazines is like the purview of like, you know, young people. So if I worked at like, I don't know, at the time, I was working at Glamour Magazine.
SPEAKER_02I worked at Glamour Magazine at one point. And that was like a magazine. First of all, I had no right being at Glamour Magazine. Like a single straight dude at a magazine for women 20 and under. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02So I but I do think that like if you're applying for certain types of jobs, there might be a bias that comes with like, OK, this person is not going to get social media, even though like Gen X, we freaking get everything. We've gone through so many different technological struggles. Exactly. I mean, here we are in Substack. I'm sure you're the same way. Every new technology that comes around, I try to figure it out. I'm already totally down with AI. I don't know if I love it, but I understand I
SPEAKER_01use AI.
SPEAKER_02If it comes around, I'm going to figure out how to use it. Now, I don't know if I'm unusual in that way, but I think part of Gen X is our superpowers that we're very adaptable. So anyway, but the impression might be, you know, that this person. So I think that's where it I think sometimes that's where it comes from. It's like the culture is there. Are they going to fit into the culture here? You know, like while everybody's out like drinking their matchas, you know, are you are you going to be drinking your health drink, your your your athletic greens?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it might be rooted in, I see my workplace as a place to find potential suitors and suitors. Do I really just say suitors?
SPEAKER_02I like suitors. You know, you can take, yeah, no, you're cool. But anyway. Suitors is good.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, but anyway, you know, it's going to be my place where I make friends. Friends, possible boyfriend, girlfriends, whatever. Yeah. So, yeah, obviously, if you don't want to date somebody in their 60s, you might go, eh, or something like that. But should that be a factor?
SPEAKER_02Yeah. No, it shouldn't be. I mean, what is the factor? I mean, again, we can do a whole other separate thing about ageism and about job interviews and like how to do, you know, what's fair and not fair. Because, you know, sometimes people don't get the job. I would say that 94. I sometimes I feel like 90% of the time that I don't even get a callback on a resume is because of my age and there's nothing else like and I can't prove it. I can't. But I just I to me,
SPEAKER_02like when I see what the job is and my qualifications, I I am so, I'm almost overqualified for a lot of jobs. I think sometimes we probably find ourselves in that situation a lot because we've been doing this for a long time. And I feel like the only thing I could think of, the reason they haven't gotten back to me is because they somehow figured out that I'm, you know, in my 50s.
SPEAKER_01Well, I was just going to ask you. Yeah, I was just going to say, before you said because they somehow figured out I'm in my 50s, I was going to ask you, if this is not an interview situation, how would they know how old you are? Because it's... It's illegal to ask someone during an interview, right? I know. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02I know. I mean, I guess you could go on AI. You could probably figure it out. I mean, it's totally illegal, but I just, again, I can't prove it. I know there's some people who work in law firms on this chat. I know maybe they can enlighten me or people who maybe work in HR, but they could look at my resume and be like, I don't even put things on my resume anymore that are from the 90s, right? Because I know, like if I start putting all the print magazines I worked for, everybody's going to be like, oh, dude, this guy's like a dinosaur, you know?
SPEAKER_02I mean, it's hard for me to believe. That used to be the coolest thing about me. Now it's like the biggest liability as far as like professionally. I say I worked at Fitness Magazine in 1996. That's like a disaster. Cosmo. Forget it. What is Cosmo? So, yeah, I think people can figure it out. I mean, I think I could probably figure out looking at your resume, like around how old you are.
SPEAKER_01I suppose there's also the they look you up and find your social media. And if you have your real pictures up or something. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Amy says, Amy Gabriel says, yes, age is the most unethical but prevalent in hiring. Recruiters assume older people don't know new tech, right? Will want higher pay, will raise group insurance rates, and illnesses will retire and leave. Look, I get it. Like, you know, I mean, one of the only reasons I would try to get a full-time job right now is to get insurance. But then insurance, you know, it does, because I'm older, it will raise, you know, for a company, it raises the rates for them. So that is like a factor. It's not fair. Hard to prove, probably.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Yeah, HR will Google you and look at your social media. I think at this point, yeah, you can pretty much determine somebody's age, even though you're not allowed to. All right, we've been going... By the way, I love doing... Can we do more of these together? We could be like the... I don't know if they have Kevin and Bean in your... We could be like the morning radio jocks talking about... I would love that.
SPEAKER_01I would too. Yeah, I agree. This is great.
SPEAKER_02It'd be super fun. All right. Liz Lapointe is the author of Gen Excellent, which is a Gen Excellent substack. You guys have to subscribe to her. She's got such great insights onto things. And I say that as somebody who is We both love to write about generational differences and that kind of thing. So please, please subscribe or follow to follow us because it shows it's the it's just shows that you care about what we're doing and
SPEAKER_02And we would really appreciate it. And we will be back. I would love, like, suggestions of other topics that maybe we can talk about. And I'd also love to bring people in from the live chat to sort of make this a kind of a more of a group exercise, sort of like a breakfast club, a little Gen X reference, where we can kind of, like, discuss ideas. Because one thing that I have noticed is that Gen X does not have a lot of places where To commune and be together because it seems like everybody is either older
SPEAKER_02or younger than us. We're the smallest generation either. And yeah, I have found that people really crave our age kind of creative community. And so this could be a place that we could all get together. I'd love that. We can talk about other ideas I have for creating community for Gen X in a way that would not be gross me out and gag me with a spoon. And so until next time, Liz, any last words? Any, any, I feel like I'm dominating the conversation.
SPEAKER_01No, I guess maybe we could just summarize our opinions on the matter. I guess for the most part, I think it's ridiculous to judge somebody at a job interview with their iced coffee. That said, if they are making the mistakes I saw that woman in the TikTok video make, then I get it. Don't be shaking the ice. Don't be constantly sipping and interrupting the interviewer. Don't let the condensation get all over everything. Don't hold it in your hands the whole time so you can't even pick up papers or look
SPEAKER_01at something without worrying about it toppling and everything. Obviously, this is a great example of how context matters.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Yeah. Context matters. I think that's a great closing argument. I'm not even going to try to outdo that. Thank you all for joining. Liz and I will be back. I think we both agree that we like this. And I also got the nod from your husband that we need to do more. So we got the ultimate nod there. And I'll see if my wife agrees. I'm sure she agrees. So until next time, we'll see you guys later.
The year was 1984. Not the dystopian George Orwell version (that’s 2026). We’re talking about the real, actual 1984. When love had everything to do with it. The rain was purple. Some of us were dancing in the dark,...
Your 20s self thought 55 meant a rocking chair and walker with tennis balls on the bottom. So why do so many of us still feel 35 when we look in the mirror? On this episode of GenXellent Small Talk, Liz and I get into...
The other night, Democrats stirred up a Blue Tsunami, and I was out of my mind with excitment. I went out to celebrate with friends, watched strangers do some version of the Texas two-step, and felt hopeful about the...
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit jonsmalltalk.substack.com/subscribe
Welcome to the debut episode of GenXcellent Small Talk, featuring yours truly, Jonathan Small, and Liz LaPoint, talking about our g-g-generation. Because the rest of the world may have forgotten about us, but as the...