For much of the 1990s and early 2000s, I was tapped by women’s magazines to explain what guys think and why they do the things they do. I was Jake for Glamour, the Guy Guru at Cosmo, and a male “expert” for Good Housekeeping, YM, Twist, Redbook, and Women’s Health. I had zero expertise to speak of other than being a guy, but somehow was entrusted with this job. It’s still, apparently, one of the most interesting things about me. I wasn’t alone. There’s a small fraternity who share this odd magazine DNA - men who got paid, often under fake names, to translate men for an audience of women. I caught up with two of them, Ky Henderson (my editor and successor as the Guy Guru at Cosmo) and Andrew Postman (another Jake at Glamour), to talk about whether those reader questions were actually real, the topics editors wouldn’t let us touch, and whether we have any regrets about the advice we gave lovelorn Gen Xers and Millennials. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit jonsmalltalk.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_02Alright, we appear to be live right now. Hi guys. Welcome, welcome, welcome. Let me refresh my Substack screen and see if we are actually live on Substack. Come on, Substack. Give me a break. Well, I think we are. As far as I know, we are live on Substack. So welcome Kai Henderson and welcome Andrew Postman to Small Talk Live. This is like a conversation that I have wanted to have for a
very, very, very long time. We are going to talk about being advice columnists for women's magazines in the 90s
SPEAKER_02and the early 2000s. This is a question. Sadly, this is one of the most interesting things I've ever done in my career. And I didn't know it at the time. I was just doing something. But I don't know if you guys have had a similar experience where like I can talk about all these things that I've done in my career. Jonathan Smalls
SPEAKER_01For sure. I mean, so I am a professor at a university now teaching journalism. And when I tell students like, yeah, you know, I've done national security reporting, gotten angry calls from the CIA about stuff I did. They're like, oh, and then I'm like, and I wrote an advice columnist for Cosmo. They're like, what? Yeah, it's a thing.
SPEAKER_00I would say the same thing. I did the Jake Man's Opinion column for four years for Glamour from 1990 to 1994. I actually then did a men's column for Mademoiselle a little bit after that. But the idea that I was getting paid early in my writing career to write about men, women, dating, love, sex, romance, and doing it under a pseudonym. which gave me a certain amount of freedom and then knowing that it was women who
would really be interested that I was doing that even though it was supposed to be
SPEAKER_00this not so secret secret
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I mean, it was great being Jake that did give me an anonymity and I can't say the word, which was actually quite freeing, although I did kind of want to reveal to people that I was Jake because it was a good status symbol at the time. But, you know, I was also the guy guru. So just to I was I was to think I was what you guys are. Andrew, you were Jake, and Kai, you were the guy guru. The guy guru was Cosmo's answer to Jake. That was not anonymous, although they would always put a fake picture of us.
SPEAKER_02I don't know, Kai, if you got the same thing, or maybe it's just the way I looked, but they would put a picture of this really handsome guy in the quarter for the guy guru. Definitely not me.
SPEAKER_01Not me either, which is actually fine with me.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, it's probably fine with me. Well, let's talk about our origin stories of how these even happen. Andrew, I'll start with you because you are the veteran here. You did it the earliest among us. How did that job come about? A lot of people always ask me, how did you get that job as being an advice columnist for a women's magazine? How did it come about for you?
SPEAKER_00Well, my first real job out of college was at McCall's Magazine, which does not exist anymore, but it was one of the Seven Sisters women's magazines.
SPEAKER_02I worked in that building, 110 Fifth Avenue, right? When I was there, it was 230 Park Avenue. Oh, okay. So, okay.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. And my boss at the time told me that it looked like there was an opening for this men's column at Glamour, which I'd never heard of. And I guess she liked my writing enough that she thought I should apply. And I did. And I think the thing that got me the column is I wrote two columns on spec. One of them was about what a man thinks in the 30 seconds before climax during climax and right after climax
and then i did another one that was much more let's say tender and about i don't know sharing cooking obligations or cleaning things like that i wanted to make sure that i was
SPEAKER_00showing sort of the alpha and omega and i think because it was pretty Jonathan Small jonsmalltalk jonsmalltalk jonsmalltalk Jonathan Small Jonsmalltalk
SPEAKER_02Okay, so it's great that it led to, well, it didn't directly lead to it, but yeah, like I was writing mine, and I'll explain my origin story after we talk to Kai here, but at very different, various stages of my relationship, you know, when I was dating, but then when I was engaged, and then when I got married, I had to stop writing it after I had kids. It was just too ridiculous at that point. But Kai, tell us how you came about, right, and becoming the guy guru at Cosmo. I had written other stories for Cosmo for a while both I wrote
for a bunch of men's magazines and then got into that and I went in one day to talk about a feature story I was writing and one of the editors was like we have a deputy editor opening here would you be interested and I said I don't think so I was freelance and really enjoying it but you know you always you know see what the deal is and like two
SPEAKER_01weeks later I accepted the job So I was Cosmo's lone straight male editor I stayed there for two years or so And then it was John, I edited you Yeah, I forgot about that You did edit me While you were doing it and then this was you know around the great recession time so everyone was tightening their belts and so the editors were like why don't we just bring this in house and have you write it and i said okay
and then i learned an amazing lesson from you because i emailed you to let you know that they were doing that and i believe you called me and said you know because that's horrible news right it was such a good and good money and you called me and very nicely
SPEAKER_01you're like you know Probably a phone call would have been better about that. And I've never forgotten that lesson. It was great. And really, yeah, six years later, The same thing happened to me. I got a short email from my editor saying, actually, we're all done. So, yeah.
SPEAKER_02I hope you called the next person. Yeah, no, I mean, that's great that that meant something you got. It's amazing when you hear that later. Yeah, I mean, we all know as freelancers, you know, it's like a game of Jenga when you're, you know, putting together your career. I still have this situation. And it's like if somebody just pulls out one check a month, suddenly everything is like... you know collapsing so i was probably like that was probably a nice check that i was getting uh at least in those days from cosmo but anyway it was a very nice check yeah but now i understand the uh
the economics behind it that was also like towards the end of magazines um that was getting close to being you know the last final five years of of the actual print magazine so um my story just to so we're keeping track here um I was a staff editor at Glamour um and so and I was also the only uh straight guy on the staff it was
SPEAKER_02nice to be the only straight guy on a staff of I don't know if they owned it at the time that you were working there Andrew
SPEAKER_02But they own McCall's, they own Family Circle, they own Child Magazine. It was this crazy thing. The New York Times owned these weird magazines that you would never associate with the New York Times. But I was sharing a floor at the time when I was a child magazine with YM Magazine. And I was 23 years old and I would hang out in the water cooler area and I would always chat with the Dr. Justin Marchegiani
SPEAKER_02Jonathan Small jonsmalltalk.com Let's talk a little bit about the process. It might have been different for each of you guys.
SPEAKER_02Kai, you and I probably had somewhat of a similar experience, obviously, because we worked at the same place. But Andrew, let's start with you. A lot of people ask me, Where are the questions where the questions what you weren't you didn't get questions so let's specify Jake is more of a column about some topic that's on your mind that that is relevant right at least that's what it was that's relevant to women and relationships and understanding women and it's written by this anonymous guy Jake but how did you come up with the ideas for your column well
I mean, I never felt like I had to really dig to come up with the next month's column.
SPEAKER_00I don't even know if I ran it by the editor. It might be traveling together. It might be meeting parents of your girlfriend. It might be what is a long distance relationship like. It might be, I will say this. I mentioned that I met the woman that I married to while I was doing this on a blind date. And I had just written a column about how blind dates are completely oversold. They rarely work. um and so about six months after that i essentially wrote
retraction like okay maybe i spoke too soon um i didn't you're right that jake unlike certain other advice columns i didn't get questions and respond to them on the other hand given that it was a heyday for magazines and it was read by millions of women uh in a
SPEAKER_00certain demographic Every column would garner lots and lots of letters. And so I would get ideas from that. But I would say probably the biggest source of my ideas was my group of guy friends who I would go to. There'd be eight or ten of them Some were, you know, more Wildcats than others Some were in steady relationships Some were more down on themselves Some drank more Some were in New York Different industries And I would
rely on them I wouldn't want it just to be my view of things I would change their names And I would change their professions And I sort of got goofy with their
SPEAKER_00professions I would just sort of make things up like Jonathan Smalls Kai how did you what are you I mean this is interesting actually because you were
behind the scenes you were my editor there do you remember where Mike the questions were coming from like were they half coming from real readers and a half kind of
SPEAKER_02like not.
SPEAKER_01You know, they actually weren't made up. Um, mostly they came from readers who, you know, this was many years ago. So they either email just like a general email address for the column. Uh, they w we would get them like snail mail style. People would mail in questions now. So, so if editors had questions themselves, they submit them or their friends had questions. I mean, we of course did that. Uh, but they were all real. Like we weren't just making stuff up because we wanted to write about X, Y, or Z.
Right no I think and that's a good thing that we're dispelling that myth because I think there's a myth that like a lot of times people when they're talking to me about this they'll be like those questions weren't real right you you guys just made them up on staff and I'm like I don't think so I mean I didn't know the process because I was um you know when I was doing the guy guru column I was yeah you guys would send me questions every every month and then I'd have to kind of sit down and think or think about them and then when I was doing Jake it was really
SPEAKER_02just like Jonathan Small Talk You know, I wrote like about the third date, like how the third date is like the pivotal date. Like if you're going to go on a third and which is not a radical idea, but I think it was a fairly new idea back then. And I wrote about how much I hated Valentine's Day and I still hate Valentine's Day. It's the worst. So that was kind of fun.
SPEAKER_02Do you want that one thing?
SPEAKER_00I just want to say one thing I discovered. I told you right before we went on that I wrote a novel about my experience called Now I Know Everything. I love that. Which is basically about a guy who has the exact experience that I had. And in doing so, I did some research and I went back and I looked at some of the Jakes that started in the 1950s. And what's interesting, you talk about how the idea of the third date being the pivotal date and Valentine's Day. And of course, what you and I and Kai were writing about
SPEAKER_00were pretty much the same, only there's a different veneer on it. There's a column in the 50s, the late 50s, I think, a J column where he's talking about something about a woman who wears white gloves to dinner, something like that, that you would never write about now. But then it wasn't that far off from me writing about how formal do you feel with people and how comfortable it's all the same thing and it just sort of has the each era comes
SPEAKER_00with with its own Jonathan Small Talk Kyle asked you this question as I was looking back and looking
at the questions
SPEAKER_02from like 20 years ago. And I'm wondering, like, is that this form of like advice comment? Do you think it's dated now? Or do you think it would still resonate today? Or it still resonates today? Like the stuff the kinds of stuff you were answering back then? Do you feel like it? Does it feel like, oh, my God, that's so like 1990 or whatever? I mean, it wasn't for you. It was like 2006. But, you know, what's your feeling of that? You want to take that? Yeah,
SPEAKER_01I think people kind of still wonder the same things, but there's so many more outlets now to go find that information. I mean, some of the letters we got were wondering really, really, really basic things that any Jonathan Small Jonsmalltalk
SPEAKER_01But in reality, a lot of our readers were younger than that, right? Yeah. And so I think that, and so we're, you know, a lot of the questions. And so I think the idea of a dude with no academic credentials in his 30s giving like sex and relationship advice. A white dude, especially. A 17-year-old. Yeah. I would guess that most people wouldn't think that's a great idea now. And I, you know, I get it. I'm sure we all agree. Did you know work really hard to give good advice I had written about sex and relationships forever and talked to lots of experts so I had
You know by osmosis I had a bunch of that stuff in my head and I also talked to some experts when I was
SPEAKER_01writing those responses, but Yeah, I'm not surprised that it's not as common as it used to be Yeah,
SPEAKER_02and the messengers are probably changed Andrew. What do you think?
SPEAKER_00I would say to Kai's point I think right now um there could be such a columnist who could have a loyal following but i think it would be much smaller and it would be deeper because people want authenticity and they want to connect with a voice that sounds but To Kai's point, there's just so much fragmentation now that an individual cannot speak to all of those people. And many of those people don't think that,
SPEAKER_00as you said, a 30 year old white guy or white straight guy, whatever it might be, or a guy living on the coast, really can speak to what their I mean, now the Super Bowl is the one thing that, you know, everyone watches. It used to be.
SPEAKER_00There'd be 30 shows that we had in common and it's just, you know, technology and the way of the world has changed that. And that's true. Yeah. I mean, that's true.
SPEAKER_02Right. It's true. I mean, you know, I talk about this sometimes in my column. It's like back in the 80s when I was growing up, there was like, you know, five superstars, you know, and everybody knew like Michael Jackson, Madonna, Prince. You know, now it's basically Taylor Swift is the only person that's sort of like a, you know, a celebrity for all, you know,
SPEAKER_01and I feel like she's in that.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, Beyonce. Yeah, totally true. Beyonce is definitely in that place. Yeah, so I agree. I feel like, you know, it kind of started changing. I felt like when Dan Savage started writing about, did you guys, Savage Love, and he was suddenly writing about the gay community, which was great because it was an alternative to what we were doing, a little deeper into the sexual side of stuff, which kind of brings me up to the subject of like, what were the taboo Jonathan Smalls
Is my boyfriend gay or you know or maybe if i got that question would be like framed in kind of a bad way it wouldn't be framed in like it would be framed more like you know how do i know if he's gay so i so i shouldn't be dating him kind of thing um do you guys remember like any kind of taboo topics that you weren't allowed to cross and or do you i wouldn't say taboo i would say that i was pretty
SPEAKER_00good about staying in my lane yeah cliche and again to the point i just made thinking that if i said something true and thoughtful that it could apply to someone who maybe wasn't straight or wasn't white or wasn't yes or that um but i think it would have been i would have felt it was presumptuous for me to say anything about you know well certainly it wouldn't be about uh
SPEAKER_00Jonathan Smalls so yeah and maybe who knows maybe a more adventurous uh columnist than myself would have done that but i think you feel like okay i can have enough fun and say enough what i think are true things in this forum that i don't need to you know try to break them they're doing me a favor by giving someone in their
late 20s wants to be a writer and paying me a monthly check yeah that i can i can deliver in that way
SPEAKER_00that you know i'm not here to be Hunter S. Thompson or William Burroughs or whatever, you know, so.
SPEAKER_02And you can't be something for everyone. You are who you are and you can write to your authentic experience. Yeah. And it's like, that's my experience. And yeah. Kyle, did you have that? Do you remember being in the Cosmo room and being like, we can't really go there?
SPEAKER_01I mean, I mean, you had mentioned I definitely answered at least once or twice over six years a question along the lines of is my boyfriend gay? So, you know, we could answer that. But, you know, again, it's like you're learning someone maybe wrote a letter or it's like 100 words or 50 words about their life or about their boyfriend. So it's a hard question. Right. Yeah. The real answer is I don't know. Right. But in most cases, that's the answer.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, we could definitely do that. You know, when we wrote about, I mean, people want to think about this about Cosmo, but when we wrote about sex, we were pretty careful about not getting too graphic. So that was definitely something that we had to steer around. Honestly, for me, not that it was taboo per se, but I always say about 80% of the questions I answered, the answer was break up with him. That was the real answer. So true. But yeah.
you can't just keep writing that over and over right like usually i think it was six or seven questions per issue was what i answered and so often i'd be like okay which one of these is the most egregious and i can at least end my answer with maybe you should break up with them or something along those lines right everything else had to be more action actionable in a quote unquote positive way uh although
SPEAKER_01you could argue whether that was positive ultimately but um So that was almost the biggest taboo is I could just kind of keep repeating that.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, that's true. It's like you can also trying to find out other ways to write the word kissing or, you know, some of those words that keep coming up. My guy, your dude. Yeah, that's interesting. Then they came up, somebody at Sex and the City, and I should know his name, but I don't know his name all the time, but came up with the he's just not that into you, which was another kind of underlying thing, which I thought was pretty smart, actually. I was kind of annoyed that he came up with it and not me. But that idea that he's just not that into you. Sometimes that's just the case.
SPEAKER_02There's nothing wrong with you. He's just not that into you. And that's why he's doing these things.
SPEAKER_00Some guys are jerks. Yeah, I would... This reminds me of what Kai said. I'm taken back to when I was doing it. And you want to give, again, you want to be honest. And this is the idea of inside, what is a guy really thinking? And more often than not, when I would get mail, the women would be pretty much saying something that you kind of want to say, like,
SPEAKER_00I think you've answered your own question. You may want to hear this. um and yet again to Kai's point you don't want to say it over and over again but it's like well if those are the signals you've been getting if this were me if I were on either side of this and I had the objectivity um I would save myself the next two to five years for a lifetime of heartache um not that people can't change but again the whole point is what are you as a 20 something guy or a 30 something guy
thinking about uh and unfortunately in yeah cases like i can see where this is going and and kind of you know save yourself the calls coming from inside the house what were the questions that we got the most or the issues that came up, the topics that came up the most.
SPEAKER_02It seemed like there was a lot of a repeat. And again, Kyle, you read a lot of the letters that came in. I would get a lot of repeat questions. They would just be framed in different ways. Andrew, you mentioned that there was certain topics that had been repeating since the 50s. are there any topics to come to I'll go first year so one thing that constantly kept coming up was how do I know he wants to be more than just a friend that was a big one where it was like There was always this couple like it was the Harry Met Sally kind of thing was like
SPEAKER_02this couple that was like, you know, somebody at work or somebody that they've been hanging out with. And it's like, how do I get past the friend zone? And again, you know, the answer was sometimes like, well, if you haven't gotten past a friend zone by now, it's probably just meant to you're probably just meant to be friends, right? Because I think he would have let you know. But I got that question a lot. Did you guys get like, did you did you even write about that, Andrew, back in the day? Yeah.
SPEAKER_00I would say I got that a lot um so which really comes down to interpreting what someone says
versus what they really mean right which is right which is probably like 90 percent of it and again we had like zero background information it wasn't like you know we could do a background check like it was like we had the the hundred words that somebody wrote in a letter as our you know so it's not like we're a therapist who's like hearing this for years and like knows every detail and like their family background and
SPEAKER_02this guy and that I know an example that she gave me of something he might have done on one date and then I have to go off of that. So I don't know. Kai, do you remember any frequently asked questions from Cosmo?
SPEAKER_01It was so long ago. But the first thing I thought of when you asked that question was some variation of how do I read his mind? And again, the answer is talk to him, ask him. That's the answer to that question. But again, it's like, well, if he does this, maybe it means that. And if he says this, maybe you can do this. But I think that was probably the overwhelming thing that people wanted to do was it was almost like sometimes they didn't want to bother the guy
with their
SPEAKER_01insecurities or wants or needs or whatever. And unfortunately, probably sometimes I encouraged that sort of like, don't, don't do anything that might bother him, right? Yeah, that's true. You know, that's probably the thing I regret. Probably the only thing I really regret about that is any answers I gave that were like, here, you have to do all this emotional labor for this goofball rather than just like being honest with him or telling him what you need.
SPEAKER_02Either dump him or, yeah, just tell him what you need or say, you know what, you're not giving me what I need, so I want out. You know,
SPEAKER_00there's another prevailing thing, I would say, which is the idea of people writing you and knowing the answer, but it's a little scary to go ahead and do it. one of my favorite scenes in Notting Hill which is after Hugh Grant has decided he can't have his heart broken again by Julia Roberts and he comes back to his friends who've been with him for years and they ask him what happened and he explains yeah I just broke up with the gorgeous American movie star because
I'm just a little fragile whatever and they they're all kind of nodding and he's like I did the right
SPEAKER_00thing didn't I and they briefly nod and then I'm like How daft are you? You're just a prick. This is not the right answer. You know it. We know it. Anyone who would hear this would know it. And I don't want to say it's all quite that level. But I think a lot of us, again, it's kind of scary to confront what you sort of know. You wouldn't be writing about it if you didn't feel like, okay, there's something not quite right to begin with.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and I guess the advice is sort of like, well, if you sort of think there's something there, it's probably something there, right? I don't know. What's that something edge? What's that something's edge? Sometimes the simplest explanation is the is the one that's actually the explanation. Yeah, I am. I mean you said you have any regrets and I you know I always joke like oh yeah I'm the person who basically ruined your you know teenage years forgot you know like I make that joke that I'm the one who gave you horrible advice throughout your your teenage years I don't really have regrets I know that there
have been some like articles written more recently that like oh those magazines of that time were you know really bad for women and you know maybe perpetuated stereotypes that were not
SPEAKER_02healthy but Jonathan Smalls Well I have one by far the thing that I wrote and I'm not going
to say I regret it but I got more letters about this by a factor of 10 than any other column I did in the four years and I said I had a lot of throat clearing at the beginning of this column and it was talking about the volume of drinking on the part of women and men
SPEAKER_00and I wasn't saying I was very upfront saying this is not me Blaming women. This is not me putting the onus on women. I saw it more as a safety issue and saying that a 110 pound woman who's going drink for drink with her boyfriend or some guy she met at the bar who is, you know, 205. Right. Things can happen, not with the majority of men, but there are, you know, bad things can happen.
SPEAKER_00And so I wrote this column and It was not only was it the greatest volume I got, but you could cut it right down the middle. 50% of women thanking me and saying, you're so right. I'm glad you said this for me, for my friend, for whatever. And then 50% calling me a misogynistic pig. And why are you saying this? We shouldn't have to, you know, look out for what we do. But so again, I don't regret it. And I think I framed it the way it was meant to be framed.
SPEAKER_00But it certainly was, I guess you'd say the most provocative thing that I wrote in those four years.
SPEAKER_02Well, that's probably a good thing. It made people actually respond. I never remember getting any feedback from my readers. I sort of did it in the middle. I sort of did it after snail mail, but sort of too early to get lots of emails. Kai, is there any stories you ever worked on that you are like,
SPEAKER_01eh,
SPEAKER_02probably shouldn't have written that or whatever? Are you good? Your conscience is clear.
SPEAKER_01I think it's pretty clear. I mean, like you said, definitely stuff that I would have said or recommended that I probably for sure wouldn't do anymore. And just the nature, I think the nature of the job is you can't, you know, I had I don't know 100 words to answer a question and again from a let's say a 50 word email so you kind of have to be you can't really get into a ton of nuance right and I you know so as some of it was probably really reductive like men are like this and women are like that you know maybe wasn't
SPEAKER_01Always super helpful. But we worked really hard to make sure that the, you know, we're tired to make sure I gave good answers. And then the editors at Cosmo, I mean, were great and super smart. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02And so I always felt like I would be if I wrote the wrong thing, you guys would catch it anyway. So you're for something that could be particularly destructive or harmful. You guys would catch it. Yeah. You know, it occurs to me, though, you were saying that like most of the questions are like explain the male brain, you know, and I must have in my career written, you know, 100 stories that are in that vein of like, you know, I mean, I think the first thing I ever wrote was like a letter that a guy wrote To his girlfriend breaking up, but then or a love letter that a guy wrote to his girlfriend or
a girl that he wanted to start being his girlfriend and then like dissecting what every word
SPEAKER_02actually meant, like what he wrote and what he actually meant. That was always like the thing that guys decoded. Right. That was always like a big thing. And I in some ways I had to and I'm not like I don't going to say I'm like the most evolved man of all time. You know, obviously I'm probably more evolved than or I'm probably as evolved as or I don't know how do you put this I'm an evolved man you know kind of a liberal grew up a liberal man with you know feminist mom and you know I'm not I'm not like but I had to sometimes put on the hat of somebody that I not
really it's like almost more of an everyman hat that I had to sometimes wear when I was answering these questions so like the way I would answer for myself might be a little bit different than I think like most average guys would did you guys find yourself
SPEAKER_02having to do sometimes the same thing where I had to sort of like You know, like again, like instead of just saying, you know, break up with him, beep, you know, take agency. You know, this guy's a jerk. You know, I'd have to be like, well, you know, sometimes guys do this because they want to do this. But it wasn't me that I was talking about. I was just talking about like some every man that I I would have like this avatar that I would imagine. I don't even know if he had a name, but it was kind of like this guy that I knew in college that was kind of more of a
SPEAKER_01douche than I was. Right. But was probably more like most guys, you know.
SPEAKER_02Do you know what I mean? I don't know if that was a long way of explaining that it was sometimes I had to put on a little bit of an act to answer the questions.
SPEAKER_00I would say that one thing I wanted to do is not, I wanted to get at the nuance, not just the decoding, but that, you know, I know this sounds corny, but to make each guy, just like each woman, Be a complex individual and not like, okay, you can separate guys into categories. There's the there's the Crow Magnum. There is a different kind of douche. There is the sweet, he'll do anything and you can walk all over him.
SPEAKER_00You got to be careful of that too. There's a guy who's sleeping around but doesn't really want to and he's got mommy issues or this or that. And once you start doing that, I think it's untrue and i think then we as guys are not sort of uh would not be performing the service that women readers would want which is i don't really believe that about guys i don't believe that even the douches and the bros out there are just
douches and bros and i don't think that's true about anyone of any gender whatever
SPEAKER_00um so it takes a lot of work to get at What that guy said in that breakup love letter or the one where he wants to be your boyfriend, whatever. While knowing that to Kai's point, if you got 100 words or in my case, 850 to 1000 words, you can only get so nuanced, but at least leave open that window for we can't sit. If we paint in such broad strokes, then we've done, you know, service.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah, yeah. Do you guys remember the weirdest question you ever got or the one that or, you know, the kind of for you, Andrew, maybe the top, the toughest topic that you ever had to answer? I'll go first because I don't. And it's funny because I was looking for it. I guess I never saved. I didn't save everything I ever wrote, but I did save a lot of things. I'm glad I did now. But yeah, it was something about. My boyfriend has started wanting to expose himself a lot in public. And, you know,
SPEAKER_02at first it was kind of like I thought it was kind of funny, but now he'll do it in a restaurant and he'll do it. Is that weird? Is that something that I should be concerned about? And I'm like, yeah. You know, like that was a really weird question. And I remember I even called the therapist because I was like, I don't even know how to answer this in a way. Like, I don't feel like I'm qualified to answer this just on my own. I don't know anybody who does that. I've never done that. That was a weird question that I can't remember. I wish I'd remembered how I'd answered. I'm sure I was like, you're, you know,
SPEAKER_02get him some help or, you know, you should maybe talk to him about getting some help on that because that's not like there was there was definitely sometimes I would have to answer be like, I would suggest that you call a therapist about this. This is a little bit out of my wheelhouse. I would also say that's doubly troubling if the way she presented it was at first I
SPEAKER_00thought it was kind of funny.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, at first it was kind of funny. We would be on a subway and he would expose himself and I'd be like, oh, stop it. Then it was weird when we were at my parents' house and I'm like, what the fuck is this? I know but um but uh I was like thanks guys for sending me this question but I mean it was obviously a real question but Kai do you remember any like weird topics from back in the day man I wish I could remember specifics but what you just that sort of question that my boyfriend is doing this yeah please tell me
that's okay
SPEAKER_01Yeah, you're right. And it's like, no, you know it's not. It's not okay. Like even that letter that you just talked about, John, where she's like, at first, I thought it was kind of funny. I'll bet she did not think that at first, right? I'll bet she's just trying to tell herself that this is okay. There's a ton of that.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, or hoping that I would say, you're right, that is kind of funny at first, but then if it's too much, then if he's doing it too often, yeah, it's like, no, that's just completely inappropriate. So I hope if she's watching now, she knows and she's not with that guy anymore or he's gotten some serious help. Let's see. Let me think. I wrote a bunch of other questions. How much do you think your answers were Rewritten to sort of fit the tone of the magazine like of like what the message that the magazine wanted to get out to the world right I mean
we've kind of touched
SPEAKER_02on this already there was a sort of angle I think that they wanted to That might not have always conformed to reality. Does that make sense? Like, you know, and again, they're there. The editors are smart people. They're not trying to mislead, but they're also like cognizant of like what might upset an advertiser or what might upset the readers to the point where it's going to like, you know, not not conform with what they're trying to trying to put out there in the world. Do you think that that played a part in your answers somewhat?
SPEAKER_00Go ahead, Kai. I think just as I was there for part you know yeah you were you're on both sides yeah yep exactly um the short answer is yes I mean Cosmo had a pretty singular voice like some magazines were you know Esquire had all sorts of voices in it but Cosmo's pretty singular everything kind of had the same voice and so John you talked about like an avatar you imagined that wasn't you but was giving that advice
SPEAKER_01and I think I wrote in a way that was what Cosmo thinks of as a dude. You know what I mean? Yeah, exactly. But I will say, by and large, I we weren't edited like super heavily like no no no you have to say this and this and this they genuinely did want to know what someone who was male thought but every so often you know it'd be like we can't give them this advice or we you know that sort of thing or we just told them to do this on page 11
so you can't tell them to do the opposite thing in your column like every so often that sort of thing
SPEAKER_01would happen but yeah not a lot
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Yeah. I mean, it's remarkable how there wasn't a heavy handed edit unless you said something that really, I think, was like off, just totally off. I can't think of even a time that I did that. I think sometimes it would just be like the edits would mostly be in the sort of like language of like like you know i couldn't always say kissing like it would be like you know smooch i there would just be like kind of funny little like wordplay things that i i actually just having worked at women's magazines for a long time kind of became an expert in that kind of and it was it was funny because it
wasn't really the way people talked but it was kind of the tone of those magazines at the time was the kind of like a smooch fest or you know you would say things like that instead of
SPEAKER_02just saying like kissing you know you would have these like Ways of saying and it was funny because when i went to work later at maxim magazine or actually i went to work at stuff magazine I remember I was still kind of writing in that tone for men's magazines. And my editor, who is British, I never forget to Andy Clarkson. I don't know if you remember him, Kai, but he came up to me. He's like, why do why do American writers write in this weird way that they don't talk like nobody says that you write in this like strange, like coded language. And I don't understand why you do that. And I was like, God, I hadn't even realized that I've been writing like that for so
long for women's
SPEAKER_02magazines. I hadn't even noticed that I had kind of stopped writing in a conversational way. And I kind of it was actually a good note because we tried to make stuff which was new at the time a little more, you know, like the way a guy would really talk. But Andrew, did you have that when you were writing back in the 90s? Did you have to kind of put it in that length, that kind of coded language that
SPEAKER_00I actually didn't feel that. I felt I had a lot of freedom from Glamour, from my editors, from just the brand itself.
SPEAKER_02That was Helen Gurley Brown at the time. Oh, no. Who was Glamour's editor? Glamour was Ruth Whitney.
SPEAKER_00Ruth Whitney was the editor-in-chief. And then I had a couple of different editors over the column. maybe part of it being under pseudonym it almost seemed like it was yeah you know like we don't endorse necessarily the positions here um yep but given that everything you know Cosmo and Glamour weren't obviously exactly the same I mean cut what they're known for and so i felt like i was more the lone voice talking in this
way not not to you know just any of the jakes whereas cosmo everyone knew about the cosmo girl and
SPEAKER_00about sex and the single girl from helen girly brown and and Sex and relationships and all of that glamour had a lot of I think had not I think I I know had more about women's health and politics and policy and things like that so to have this not that they didn't have relationship pieces but they didn't have you know like the Cosmo quiz that everyone wanted to take and say oh where do I stack up on this or that so I felt like I was Jonathan Small jonsmalltalk jonsmalltalk
go do his thing and uh so yeah i i never you were sort of an anachronist yeah you were sort of a uh you you weren't quite like in the spirit of what glamour was about at that time i mean glamour would eventually basically just become cosmo uh right but but yeah but i feel like in the in the 90s maybe before the bonnie fuller era which is where i when i was there it was definitely more the ruth whitney was a
SPEAKER_02lot more had a lot more politics in it had a lot more Like it was more of a serious, not that I was like a regular reader of Glamour, but I, from my understanding, it's almost a difference between Cosmo was like Maxim and Glamour was like GQ or Esquire right like Cosmo was like the fun one for younger girls that want to write about sex of course they all read both Mac they both read the same magazines but but I think that was the way it was positioned at least for a time yeah so Jake would have been Jake would have been very different kind of when I was there Jake was just another
one of those columns
SPEAKER_00about what guys think kind of a brand extension instead of an outlier
SPEAKER_02Yeah, exactly. Kai, this is sort of off a little bit off the topic. You and I would later go on to work at men's magazines and or you might have even worked at a men's magazine before I worked because I remember before before. Yeah. Wasn't it very I had to start writing it not advice, but well, I guess, yeah, advice for men as opposed to advice for women. It was so it was interesting the difference. Did you did you note it when you started working on stories that were more targeted men? I always felt the men's stories were more about performance And the winds women's stories were all about,
SPEAKER_02you know, connection, emotional connection and men's stories were all about how to last 10 times longer, you know, like, you know, it was definitely different. Did you find the same thing?
SPEAKER_01Well, we so we always had women editors do our advice. Yeah, right. That's true.
SPEAKER_02Don Yannick. And yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. So so they handled most of that stuff. But yeah, like you said, completely different. But part of the reason I think I was hired on at Cosmo was because I'd had that experience and they wanted me to come on after not. I think Kate White, who's like the legendary editor there at the time. yeah they hadn't had someone like in my like the boy editor whatever since the 90s and this was 2008 um they wanted that real kind of voice but i will say once i
started it quickly became apparent that i'm not sure they wanted it really because it was too dissonant to to maybe what cosmo sort of was about and like like i said
SPEAKER_01how similar the voice was so um
SPEAKER_02You had to tone it down.
SPEAKER_01Definitely different, but it is interesting that men's magazines made sure it was a woman and then women's magazines made sure it was a man.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, that's good. Do you guys have favorable memories of any editor? Who was one of the best editors? Did you work directly with Ruth Whitney, Andrew? No, I had two...
SPEAKER_00I worked with Judy Daniels. I worked with Judy Coyne. I worked with the great Jill Herzig, who's also a friend. I was very lucky. I also did a bunch of features under my name that were kind of like, this is what men are thinking. I remember going on Good Day New York. And talking about it, you know, like back again when magazines had cover stories and they were selling enough of them that promoting it on a monthly basis was a big deal.
But yeah, I would say Judy Coyne was terrific and Jill Herzog was terrific.
SPEAKER_02Hi, I remember working with Jenny Benjamin. You were great. Jenny Benjamin. John, what was John's last name? Also the book, the novelist. I can't think of his name. He's been on my podcast. I'm terrible. Sorry, John. Searles. What's that? John Searles. John Searles. John Searles. Love John Searles. What made a good editor in your opinion? Was it somebody that just... I think someone who knows what they want and can clearly let you know what it is. Even if it's a total rewrite, at least I know where I have to go with this. At Cosmo, like I said, I felt a little like
SPEAKER_01Jonathan Small Jonsmalltalk
SPEAKER_02Oh yeah, she's great. She was at Cosmo. Yeah, she was great.
SPEAKER_01Then Nikki Bielen came in after her. Nikki was amazing, like so funny and like, you know, totally got it that, you know, some of this stuff maybe isn't for us, but it is what the magazine is. And that always helped me a lot. It was just kind of like a reality check or something. You know, you talked about the language like smooches or I had totally forgotten until you just brought that up. Jonathan Ballett & All those euphemisms that I had that right and there's so many only so many ways you could say hair hair was a tough one when I was when I was like editing beauty you can't say hair every single you have to
tresses and yeah it was just a nightmare a cutie I think that was actually way to say guy yeah I think that some of that the goofier euphemisms was a holdover from Helen Gurley Brown because she was such a titan and you know she I think stepped down the 90s and Then i think maybe it was bonnie fuller than kate white i forget but um around the time i left what they were really having a conversation about we need to maybe like update some of this language especially the younger uh women
who worked at cosmo were kind of like we don't say any of this stuff so i think they updated right
SPEAKER_01around that time it's so funny to read I would just add to what Kai said when you were asking about editors and he said that they know what they want one editor whose name I shall not mention with a couple of articles I wrote you know the man's point of view thing said to me yeah it's not quite working for me but I'm not sure why and it's basically I wanted to
SPEAKER_00say that could not be less helpful It's fine to say this or that or whatever, but that kind of ambiguous, ambivalent, you know, just go and do something else. Or I kind of like the subject matter, but is it the position? Is it the flow? Whatever. So I love editors. I've been very lucky to work with. Jonathan Small Jonsmalltalk Mr. Steele, Mr. Steele, Mr. Steele, Mr. Steele, Mr.
SPEAKER_00Steele, Mr. Steele, Mr. Steele, Mr. Steele, Mr. Steele, Mr. Steele, Mr. Steele, Mr. Steele, Mr. Steele, Mr. Steele, Mr. Steele, Mr. Steele, Mr. Steele, Mr. Steele, Mr. Steele, Mr. Steele, Mr. Steele, Mr. Steele, Mr. Steele, Mr. Steele, Mr. Steele, Mr. Steele, Mr. Steele, Mr. Steele, Mr. Steele, Mr. Steele, Mr. Steele, Mr. Steele, Mr. Steele, Mr. Steele, Mr. Steele, Mr. Steele, Mr a paycheck as an editor if that's your response.
SPEAKER_01Right, right. Go ahead. Real quick, this is from the Maxim days, the Dennis Publishing days. A guy who's an amazing editor did an edit on a colleague of mine, and my colleague walks over and shows it to me. He was kind of new at the time. He's like, what is this? And the editor, all he had done, like when you play the game Hangman, he had like drawn that hangman figure with an arrow pointing toward it and it just said me in other words oh really having to read this oh my god
and i wonder i might know who that editor that's so good well i used to have an editor who is kind of prominent today who used to just write lame he would just write in the column next to it lame lame like if you made a joke and i know exactly who you're talking about
SPEAKER_02exactly who will rename nameless that was a really not helpful note and it made me want to leave that job and i did eventually leave that job but it was yeah it was um obviously be specific guys this has been so interesting i don't know if there's any questions let me see if the guys if anybody has any questions no questions so far oh well okay well i'm glad that everybody joined us um are are you as good at Jonathan Smalls
SPEAKER_02That's my true confession here. Sometimes I feel like if I was just more Jake-like in some of my relationships, they might have gone a little bit better.
SPEAKER_00I don't know. I guess what I'd say, I want to go back to something Kai said about actionable advice that one gives. I think the role of the columnist, not to sound too high-minded about it, but what we guys did, um is just to get someone to think slightly differently or more openly about what it is that's troubling them but the idea about like yeah you
really need to break up or you're a wuss or you know change cities or do this or do that that there's so
SPEAKER_00many factors that go into that it's like yeah you shouldn't be listening to some anonymous guy but telling i hope in reading this column or reading these questions and answers that it gives you pause or gives you like a crack in the door to seeing a slightly different way of looking at it and that if we've done that then we've sort of done our jobs and that's probably the most but um Sure, if you're dealing with someone who says, my boyfriend likes to expose himself,
SPEAKER_00hey, is there something wrong? That's on the level of, okay, some professional help really needs to… that was where I went with it yeah but with a lot of the stuff at least that I was doing felt like you want them to like either smile or frown at what you're writing about because yeah darn that confirms what I think about guys or about my guy whatever or laugh at something that now you can look at a little bit lighter but I would hesitate to think that there's ever a moment where it's
like don't really don't follow what I'm saying just just read it and move on right what do you think
SPEAKER_00Kai
SPEAKER_02What do you think Kai?
SPEAKER_01I think when I was doling out this advice, I think one of the reasons I was maybe not bad at giving advice about boyfriends or guys who weren't Great was because I'm like, I remember myself in my 20s. This guy reminds me of myself in my 20s. And so I can now give advice about how to deal with that guy. But, you know, John, you said that you're not great at taking your own advice. I think I'm pretty good about giving advice generally. And like you said, Andrew, it's not like here's what you should do.
SPEAKER_01It's like, well, you should think about this. How do you feel about this? You know?
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. But terrible at taking my own advice. And I think just generally I'm pretty closed off. I try to avoid telling anyone about myself. That would prompt them to give me advice. Right.
SPEAKER_00Right. By the way, I realize in what you just said, Kai, that we've pretty much outlined what typical therapy is like. Like, well, how do you feel about that? How do you feel? And yet you don't say, do this, do that. It's like, you've got to come to it yourself. So.
SPEAKER_02Right. That is really the, if you haven't been in therapy, I mean, a good therapist would let you come to it yourself. You know, I ended up marrying a therapist, which is probably, again, my karma for having done this for years in my 20s, pretending to be a therapist. um and not really doing a great job and that was great because when she came into my life later when i was writing cosmo she would help me write a lot of those columns we would role play i'd be like yeah she would she would give me she would give me some great answers all right this has been i i realized i didn't even talk about what you guys are up to these days like andrew you you're
a writer you wrote you mentioned what what are you up to these days um i uh collaborate on a lot of
SPEAKER_00books uh almost all non-fiction um and i've been very lucky to have it be across a real wide range business health pop culture awesome what are some all kinds of things what are some of the most recent ones that we um well even though most of them have to do with um are helping people to tell their story uh one project recently which i enjoyed um i got the opportunity to update
SPEAKER_00How to Win Friends and Influence People, the Dale Carnegie self-help book, which I happen to love. And it had only been updated once in the last 90 years. And again, talk about giving advice. I mean, here's a book that is a cottage industry itself. and there was really more about updating language and you know every example there a woman was a wife and homemaker or a secretary or this or that and even though the
idea was not to suddenly make it seem as if Dale Carnegie was alive 70 years after
SPEAKER_00he Died um just being more aware for a reader now and how they might respond um so i had a chance to work i think a lot of the fights there like you're saying is timeless right a lot of it oh it's i i think it's the the kind of granddaddy or grandparent or whatever of advice books i mean if we if we remove religious texts as advice books um i i think it's so simple and so universal. I'm not shilling for it right now,
but I liked the book before I got the opportunity to do it.
SPEAKER_02You're making me want to at least listen to it again. I haven't read it in a long time. Kai, what are you up to these days?
SPEAKER_01I still do freelance journalism, a lot of celebrity-related stuff being here in LA, but I'm now a journalism professor at Loyola Marymount University.
SPEAKER_02Awesome. From guy guru to journalism professor, there is hope.
SPEAKER_01With a few things in between.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, exactly. You were at Vice. You were at a bunch of places. Yeah, I think that's what helped me get this game versus maybe the guy guru stuff.
SPEAKER_01Although I talked about that Cosmo and that stuff in the past.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, that's great. Yeah. All right. Well, guys, thank you so much for taking time and strolling down memory lane with me. This has been fascinating. I've wanted to meet some of my fellow advice columnists. So this has been really interesting. And best of luck to you. And thank you, everybody, for listening and watching this podcast. Please subscribe if you're watching Small Talk. We talk about, I don't know, things from the 80s, 90s, early 2000s. And so... That's what you'll find.
SPEAKER_02All right, guys. Until we meet again. Take care.
The year was 1984. Not the dystopian George Orwell version (that’s 2026). We’re talking about the real, actual 1984. When love had everything to do with it. The rain was purple. Some of us were dancing in the dark,...
Your 20s self thought 55 meant a rocking chair and walker with tennis balls on the bottom. So why do so many of us still feel 35 when we look in the mirror? On this episode of GenXellent Small Talk, Liz and I get into...
The other night, Democrats stirred up a Blue Tsunami, and I was out of my mind with excitment. I went out to celebrate with friends, watched strangers do some version of the Texas two-step, and felt hopeful about the...
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit jonsmalltalk.substack.com/subscribe
Welcome to the debut episode of GenXcellent Small Talk, featuring yours truly, Jonathan Small, and Liz LaPoint, talking about our g-g-generation. Because the rest of the world may have forgotten about us, but as the...