Carl Morris, author of "Dirtbag Dreams: A History of Mountain, Ultra and Trail Running," joins the show to discuss the past, present, and future of our community. Partners: Precision Fuel and Hydration - use code SINGLETRACK at checkout for 15% off your next order Norda - check out the 005: the lightest, fastest, most stable trail racing shoe ever made Raide - Making equipment for efficient human-powered movement in the mountains Janji - premium trail running apparel Momentous - use code SINGLETRACK for up to 35% off your first order Kodiak Cakes - my favorite oatmeal and pancakes Support the show
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_02Welcome back or welcome to the Single Track Podcast. I'm your host, Finn Melanson, and in this edition of our Sunday Conversation, we are talking with Carl Morris, a sociologist, historian, and social psychologist over at the University of Lancashire. Carl is also a passionate fell and ultrarunner who recently published a book. It's called Dirtbag Dreams, and it traces the development of mountain ultra and trail running in North America and the United Kingdom over the past 200 years. It's a fantastic historical accounting of our world.
SPEAKER_02I really enjoyed it and figured it was worth reaching out to Carl for a conversation that you would probably get a lot out of. So that's the gist of it. We spend about 90 minutes talking about pedestrianism, trans cons, early trail races like Mount Wilson, Mount Baker, and the Dipsy, the impact of the Kennedy administration on ultra running, uh how Western states influenced the modern era of our sport, and what to make of what's happening today in order to get a sense for what the future might hold. Carl Morris, it is a pleasure.
SPEAKER_02It's an honor to have you on the Single Track Podcast. How are you doing today? I'm great, Finn. Yeah. How are you? I'm doing good. It's it's 8 a.m. over here in Salt Lake City, Utah. And we have a relative newborn. She's 20 months old, and I didn't sleep much last night, but I told you I told you pre-recording, I am so excited for this conversation. And so got a cup of coffee and I'm locked in. Great. Okay. Um okay, coming into this book, and this this kind of predates the book. I mean, I've just always wondered like how, like, whether and how often the values of our sport are changing.
SPEAKER_02Yep. And how often that has happened over the centuries, at least in the modern version of this sport. And while we're trying to grapple with increased professionalism in our world today, it's fascinating for me to learn that we've already been here before. Like this was the predominant system in the sport in the second half of the 18th century. So I have a lot of questions off of this, but paint the picture of like the characters, the formats, the venues, the mainstream appreciation, the stakes in this world of pedestrianism in the late 19th century.
SPEAKER_00Sure. So thank you very much for having me on, by the way. It's really interesting to talk about this to such a dedicated, running audience. And much like you, I was fascinated really with how we've come full circle. And that's one of the things I wanted to explore in the book. So going all the way back to the 19th century, the late 18th century, 19th century, pedestrianism, which some people will be familiar with, but others won't be, I think, was really a type of early athletics.
SPEAKER_00It emerged in the UK. It was a sport that was almost predominantly based on gambling and all the sort of associated activities around that. It emerged in the UK simply because spectator sport didn't really exist at that time. It was emerging in the 19th century with industrialization and with uh crowds of people who would come to watch athletes run very extensive distances.
SPEAKER_00So the uh the most sort of famous of the race formats at that time was the six-day race. Um, it took off in the UK, and we're talking tens of thousands of people would come to watch runners compete against one another in open grassland running around a track, and then we had purpose-built stadiums and running tracks, which were built in the UK and then in in the US. Um and uh the the sport grew over the course of of the 19th century. I think reaching a kind of a high point in in the United States um with the Astley Belt series.
SPEAKER_00Maybe we can get into the details of that. But um it was very much a professional sport. These were these were working class, often people who would compete alongside one another uh over the hundred-mile distance, over the six-day distance.
SPEAKER_02Um It does. And I mean, the one one other what I mean one other question I had that just for context setting. If I understand this correctly, spectator sport really is only born post, at least in the on the American side of things, post-civil war. Because if I understand this correctly, the Industrial Revolution created more leisure time beyond the upper classes. Like finally, there is this there's a small but growing middle class. There's more free time during the day, and people are using this free time to engage in sport.
SPEAKER_00That's right. So professional sport didn't really exist up until that point. So baseball was only just beginning and it wasn't a professional sport. Athletics, pedestrianism was straightforward. You didn't need anything. You could, you could just run, right? So it attracted a range of people. Um, you know, most famously Edward Payson Weston, who was this sort of sort of colourful performer from Providence, uh, people like um Daniel O'Leary, who was an Irish immigrant who had come over, who was looking for work and felt he could make money.
SPEAKER_00And these two, these two athletes became the giants of the sport. These were the people who were first depicted on tobacco trading cards. Um, they gained notoriety across the United States because they were they were performing. And I think we need to think of pedestrianism as a performance. So I'll give you a sense of it, right? So in Chicago, for example, um Chicago was one of the one of the hubs of this pedestrian sport. And um in the interstate exhibition building, which is this huge indoor venue, um, you would have maybe half a dozen athletes, pedestrians, who would come and they would race against one another for six days in the inner hall.
SPEAKER_00Uh crowds would come and go over the course of the six days. You can imagine it, right? In sort of the in the 1870s, people jostling and and shouting and sort of eating roasted peanuts and swelling beer and and watching this, right? It was a kind of rowdy spectator sport, and people would come and they would watch these athletes run for six days non-stop, covering distances of around 500 miles or so to 550 miles over the course of six days. And people would be uh laying money down, gambling and betting on the outcome of this.
SPEAKER_00Um, and the athletes themselves would take a slice of uh of the gambling uh revenue for it. It was completely unregulated, um, very organic, but but very much a professional sport with these athletes gaining notoriety across across the US and indeed uh in the UK as well.
SPEAKER_02This is for the audience. And uh again, we have a largely American audience, just to give the audience even more scale. They're competing at Madison Square Garden in New York City.
SPEAKER_00Yes. Yeah. So Chicago and New York, these are the uh these are the the centers for for pedestrianism in the US. Yep, Madison Square Garden in in in the in the US. And uh yeah.
SPEAKER_02Aaron Powell And then people like Weston and O'Leary, the like the modern equivalent, it'd be like Jim Walmsley, Killian Jornette, Francois Dayne. Is that a fair but they would but they were even bigger in scale into in fanfare?
SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell Even bigger because they they reached a a wider audience. So if we think about trailrunners, ultralunners today, they they are increasingly well known. Someone like Killian Journette has sort of reached beyond the running community. But I think people like Edward Payson Weston, Daniel O'Leary, they were they were the superstar athletes at the time. I mean, just a nice little anecdote, Edward Pays and Weston, when he became famous for the first time, he he walked, ran down from Boston to DC for the inauguration of uh of President Lincoln.
SPEAKER_00He'd failed a bet, and that's why he that's why he did this. He'd failed a bet. He thought Lincoln was going to lose the presidential election, and of course, Lincoln didn't. So Edward Pays and Weston had to had to run down to DC for the inauguration. And he missed, he missed the actual inauguration, but went to one of the balls in the evening and uh and shook hands with uh with Lincoln there. So that dates it very nicely for you, really. It's fascinating.
SPEAKER_02You're reminding me of one of my favorite ideas that's ever been presented on this podcast. We had a guy, this would have been two years ago, Warren Doyle, who was on the show. And Warren is sort of one of the patron saints in some ways, at least in the modern era of the Appalachian Trail, yeah, you know him. And he had this idea ahead of the 1996 Olympic Games, where he he wanted to present this to the Appalachian Mountain Club, the ATC, the whole committee there, and say, look, hey, as a way to celebrate the fact that the games are going to be in Atlanta, Georgia this year, just below the southern terminus of the trail, let's start some international teams up at Mount Gatarin in in Maine.
SPEAKER_02And let's have this kind of hearkening back to the days of pedestrianism, this like either walking contest and or just like ceremonial through hike. And then they're carrying the torches and finishing right inside the state of it. I thought that was one of the coolest ideas ever. And it kind of just brings up this era of our culture in some ways. I just, anyways, just thought that was interesting.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, no, it is interesting. That's one of the things I was hoping to do with this book, really, to draw together all of these links between athletics, mountaineering, hiking, and all of the different aspects of the sport, really, and to to join the dots, uh, taking us all the way back uh to the 19th century.
SPEAKER_02If we look at the sport right now, at least the way that I see it, the bifurcation is happening like in terms of like the cultural conflict, it's all happening within this just like inherently now upper class nature of the sport. Like it's sort of like wealthy people, privileged people competing against the direction. And it seems like in the 1880s and 90s, as pedestrianism starts to unravel, the way you painted, at least the way I interpreted it, it's it's about class conflict. And like the stars of the sport, the fans of the sport, this was a working class sport that sort of chafed against some of the sensibilities of the upper class in society.
SPEAKER_02Can you talk about that?
SPEAKER_00Sure. So pedestrianism was very much a working class sport, as I've said. It was a professional sport because anyone could be involved and could make a living from it simply by virtue of being a good athlete. Pedestrianism began to decline at the end of the 19th century, mostly, I think, because amateur sport began to rise. And amateur sport had emerged from the public schools, the private schools, uh, these elite institutions amongst an upper class who resented working class sport.
SPEAKER_00They thought working class sport was somehow distasteful, that it was linked to something like gambling and all kinds of unsavory activities as they saw it. And they had this idea that sport should be about moral character. Sport should be about demonstrating uh your your mental fortitude, your physical fortitude, and your ability to compete. And it shouldn't be done for it shouldn't be done for money. So amateurism as a as an ideology began to emerge at the end of the 19th century, and it became established through two organizations which eventually became the national bodies of athletics in both the UK and the US.
SPEAKER_00The AAA in the UK and the AAU, um, the amateur athletics union in the US. And these these national bodies they had a very simple rule which completely changed the course of athletics, which is that if you competed for money, any prize money whatsoever, you would be blacklisted from their events. You wouldn't be able to compete in these amateur events. Now, these amateur events, particularly with the birth of the Olympic Games in 1896, began to become the most prestigious, the most competitive, and the most dominant events in both the US and the UK.
SPEAKER_00So if you wanted to compete against the best, you had to compete in the amateur sphere. And of course, what that meant is that pedestrianism, which was a professional sport, began to fade away because it wasn't attracting the same number of people, it wasn't attracting the same crowds, and it died, it died a little bit of a slow death, really, uh, with the rise of amateurism.
SPEAKER_02Is it fair to like group in some of the soul sport ideals that we talk about in today's era into this philosophy of amateurism, or is it somehow separate?
SPEAKER_00I think I think there is I think that is part of the tapestry of the sport as it exists today. I think we've become much more relaxed across sports in general, including in running, of course, with with professionalism and professional sport. But the ideals of amateurism, which which are about I mean, think about ultrarunning. So much of it connects to how we see ourselves as runners. This idea of um achieving something difficult, of overcoming something, of developing virtues and characteristics within ourselves, and that we use the sport to to become better people.
SPEAKER_00We often talk about that, don't we? In in in running, right? Um and I think those values, those ideas, they do date back to amateurism really, because they they became the dominant values of athletics, of running, and of sport more generally over the course of the 20th century. And I think we find that within the contemporary sport today, even if at an elite level, we have returned uh to professionalism, which we saw, you know, more than 100 years ago now.
SPEAKER_02I could be misinterpreted. Again, this is just my opinion. Reading the book and reading that particular section, it feels like uh our sport's original sin in a lot of ways, because I had I had previously I had the idea that like these ideas of amateurism and soul sport, they kind of just come like organically from this romantic notion about how to be as a human. I did not realize that it comes out of this like fairly violent uh class conflict.
SPEAKER_00It partly comes from that, but not entirely. So if we were to focus on athletics, I think that friction between professional athletics and between amateurism is part of the story. But one of the things I do in the book as well is I look at the the origin, because this is part of the story as well, of hiking culture, of mountain culture. And I detail and write about uh the romantics in the UK and the transcendentalists, you know, Emerson in the um in the US, and that appreciation of the wild and that sort of poetic uh magnetism that that the outdoors has, because that's part of our sport as well.
SPEAKER_00That's also interesting about about trail running, about ultrarunning. It is both an athletic sport, but also a mountain sport in many respects. And it's got all of that woven into the tapestry of the sport in quite interesting ways, I think.
SPEAKER_02Ray Research, the official equipment partner of the Single Track Podcast, and uh got some big news. Their LF5-liter running vest is here. Lots to talk about. Let's start with what you can carry and how it is all distributed. So comes with two 600 milliliter hydropack locking flasks up front, a rear hydration carry option for two additional 600ml flasks. Uh you've also got this rear pass-through pocket for secure large item storage. You can put a phone back there, another bottle. Um, and then it's got this awesome, also on the back, an integrated pole quiver.
SPEAKER_02And this all comes with Raid's chest tension system for no bounce carry. No bounce with their waistbelts, no bounce with their vests. Uh, really great, I think, for these longer outings. Exciting times. Go check it out, raidresearch.com. Also, thanks to Johnji, the official apparel partner of the podcast. Some also exciting news here. Their race division apparel line is here. And they've got some uh special, let's see, gossamer T's and singlets shorts as well for race day. The product that I have been putting in the most miles in lately from this line are their pinnacle two-in-one RD shorts.
SPEAKER_02They are fantastic. You've got this integrated balance proof, six-pocketed system on the waist, four large waistbelt pockets, two side linear pockets. You can carry everything you need for the most part. Uh, front and back bungee loopers uh that you can put trekking poles on. Um, yeah, fantastic. Uh microperf shell with deep side splits. They deliver really nice airflow, total range of motion that you need in a race environment on you know, demanding distances, terrains, et cetera.
SPEAKER_02Go check it all out. John G.com forward slash single track. This is a bit of an aside, but another book that I'm reading, or I was reading, um, Into the Silence by Wade Davis. Have you read it? No, no. I mean, it just talks about, well, one of the many things it talks about is just uh the selection process in that uh Royal Geographical Society group in the right after World War I uh for the group that would go and make the first attempts on Mount Everest. And I I bring it up here because uh like you had George Mallory, who's like a classic upper class patrician, and he was sort of selected from all of these like alpinist groups, the clubs, the amateur crowd.
SPEAKER_02And then there were other guys who were like just as qualified as Mallory, and they were just like soundly routinely rejected because they were um the working class type. Just interested in drawing connections across different sports. Like that was still going on, like post-World War I, like people were getting removed from consideration in these groups because of their economic status, despite being very qualified.
SPEAKER_00No, no, and that's part that's part of the story that I write about really. I mean that there is a connection to running there. It's we think of mountaineering as an adjacent sport, and in some respects it is, but uh particularly in the UK, uh through the early to the mid part of the 20th century, many of the many of the runners, I say runners sort of, you know, cautiously here, because they were they were alpinists really. They were making these attempts on the sort of British rounds, you know, circuiting the peaks in places like the late district in Scotland and setting records and speed ascent.
SPEAKER_00Um and many of them were quite privileged. They were from an alpinist background, they were members of the, you know, the Alpine Club. And um they, their class background and their class privileges gave them the access and an ability to publicize their their achievements, I think. That's a better way to think about it. Um so that that that's part of the story of running as well, mountain running, uh, that that class privilege. Um and many of those, many of those early alpinists, they were part of those teams that were going to to the Himalayas and to uh you know to the to Antarctica as well.
SPEAKER_00Uh so it's quite interesting, really, I think.
SPEAKER_02This is a little bit of a footnote, but you bring up the 1896 Olympic Games, the first edition. For the audience, is this an example of the philosophy of amateurism like being institutionalized and finally winning out over professionalism?
SPEAKER_00Or was the were these games going to happen independent of how the whole conflict with uh professionalism So the Olympic Games, they they were obviously extremely celebrated and they had been organized by these amateur organizations. So they were it wasn't they were amateur, it was an amateur affair. Um and because of the the fame that the Olympic Games achieved, I think that cemented the rise of amateur amateurism.
SPEAKER_00It didn't it didn't explain it. Amateurism was rising anyway. The Olympic Games was was almost the final nail in the coffin, I think, for professional sport. Um because the Olympic Games, and with that first marathon event, marathon which we take for granted now, but you know, up until 1896 in the first Olympic Games, people didn't talk about marathon. It was it it didn't exist in the public consciousness. Um that spurred the really the first proper amateur running boom.
SPEAKER_00Um and across, you know, following those first Olympic Games across cities in the US, in the UK, and in France, um, we see the marathon really begin to take off. Um and that that explains actually the the the deaf of interest in ultra running from that point, because people up until then had been competing over the hundred-mile distance, over the six-day format. But as the marathon rises after that first Olympic Games, as the center of athletics, um, people lose interest in anything beyond the marathon.
SPEAKER_00And gradually over time, the marathon becomes, you know, the the the furthest people think that you can run and compete in.
SPEAKER_02Were you uh researching this book, were you was it shocking to you at all uh how short the memories or attention spans were for each generation comparing itself to previous ones in the history of endurance?
SPEAKER_00It it it was, it really was, absolutely. Uh I think we do have quite short attention spans and runners drift in and out of the sport, and the sort of the the the lifetime memories of of those runners um fade fade away, really. So uh there is often an attempt over the course of this history over 200 years for athletes to to resurrect and to dig into their own history and to to almost uh to reinvent uh formats and ideas and disciplines which uh had been had been buried in the past.
SPEAKER_00I mean, the six day race is a really good example of that. Six day race Racing entirely disappeared for about 70 or 80 years. And it was in the eight in the 1980s that that attempts were made to revive six-day racing. But that was people researching and looking back at this sort of forgotten mythology of pedestrianism and learning about it for the first time and trying to reinvent it.
SPEAKER_02I was really interested to read the sections where you profile people that were either too late, too early, or just like plain, sort of existing in the wrong era for the commercial sport, like Charles Pyle. Can you talk about him a little bit?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so Charles Pyle was really interesting. He was, I've described him really as the first sports promoter because he, I mean, he tried to set up a professional football league, American Football League, you know, to compete against the NFL. Uh wasn't very successful. He became a promoter for the most famous tennis player of the time, a French tennis player. Uh, this was in the 1920s. Um, his background was in theatre. He was this really sort of rambunctious, really colourful, flamboyant.
SPEAKER_00I describe him as an American archetype because he, particularly writing as a British writer, that very larger than life um sort of promoting figure who is simultaneously creating something and yet conjuring something in a slightly um in a slightly unreal way. So he was this, he was this promoter in the 1920s, and he, and this again goes to generational memories because people had begun to forget about pedestrianism by the 1920s. He hadn't, and he remembered quite how successful it had been two, three decades before.
SPEAKER_00And and and Charles Pyle, he had this idea um to organize a race across America, the first transcontinental race, uh, which ran from LA um sort of overland up to Chicago and then down to Madison Square Garden. Um and he believed this was going to be the beginning of something he called, I think it was the age of the foot. He thought that there was going to be this massive upsurge in commercial running and that he he could be, you know, he could sort of have monopoly on this, really, selling products, shoes, and and foot care products.
SPEAKER_00And um, you know, he was all about making money. That was his idea. And the transcontinental race was going to be this huge money-making scheme. He was going to sell programs to people. The runners were going to run through towns and and and sort of villages across the US, and he would sell programs and have fairground rides and all of these associated money-making activities. And he he he believed he was going to uh you know become very, very wealthy uh because of this. Um he didn't make any money, so he reprised the race the following year.
SPEAKER_00So we have two race years of the transcontinental race, and in the second year in 1929, it it ran from New York uh the other way to to LA. But um he ended he ended up bankrupt. But he had this vision, he had this vision that running would become something uh you know that could be highly commercialized, monetized, products could be be created. And as you say, he was he was a man before his time, really, sort of maybe a hundred years too late, perhaps.
SPEAKER_02Well, I mean, it's I guess it's hard for me to really reflect on now, but I I guess in the 1920s also uh roads, like paved roads were a fairly recent innovation and in the rise of the automobile. And this is one of the first decades where I guess like runners could take advantage of uh like Route 66 here in the US. Yeah. That's pretty cool.
SPEAKER_00It was, yeah. So Route 66 was still under construction at the time. So the transcontinental races were 1928, 1929, and um, and it was partly about celebrating that as well, that that overland connection and the romanticism of the road and the old west and all of those connections. And um, they were partly paved, but many sections of Route 66 at the time was it was still a dirt track. It was uh it's it's fascinating looking at some of the photographs of the time um with these sort of old-fashioned automobiles on these rutted dirt tracks, which uh it was Route 66, you know, that famous, that famous connection.
SPEAKER_02When you're studying these historical characters, for example, like Charles Pyle, and then you look at our modern era or any of the times in between, are there any equivalents to them or are they truly iconoclass? Like, is there a Charles Pyle of the 2010s? Like, have you been able to draw any of those interesting like this is this person is fulfilling that role in the year 2005?
SPEAKER_00I've thought about it. I think it's difficult to make those comparisons somewhat really. I don't think there is anyone quite like Charles Pyle existing today in the running. The thing is, Charles Pyle was he was a bit shifty. He was a bit of a I mean, he screwed people out of money. He refused to be a good one.
SPEAKER_02Gary's only charging a dollar forty for both of them.
SPEAKER_00He's at the opposite end of the spectrum in that sense, in terms of his values, I think, which is um yeah, I don't know. I don't know. There's no one quite like Charles Pyle, really, I don't think. Um he was he was he was there in this brief flash of time, only for two years. His his legacy was was brief and ephemeral. Um, you know, he kind of appeared and and disappeared almost immediately. Whereas if we look at someone like Gary Contrell, you know, Lazarus Lake, obviously, um he's been involved in the sport now for 50 years, um, and his legacy is much more deeply rooted, I think.
SPEAKER_02So history, you've generally found that history is somewhat, but the characters are unique.
SPEAKER_00I wouldn't say it's cyclical. I'd say that we have I mean I I write about returning full circle and this idea that we began it began as a professional sport and we've re we've returned to that really. We've returned to some of those routes there. And it's been an interesting and and very long journey um along the way. So there is an echo of the past in in the present today, but it is it is very different to the pedestrianism of that early period, I think. Um in terms of the characters, it it's very, very difficult to draw comparisons simply because 200 years on, we're leading very, very different lives.
SPEAKER_00We have that accumulation of values and experiences and that history and the way that we see running and we see the mountains has changed. And and we have different perspectives on on life in general. So I think it is hard to make comparisons between the characters of the of the past and and the present day. Also, something that is quite difficult is it's very difficult to get into the minds of those people as well. 200 years ago, even the most celebrated events of the time, the events themselves are recorded, but getting into they don't they don't do the deep interviews that we would expect now.
SPEAKER_00We don't understand the motives of those athletes in quite the same way. We don't understand their personal stories sometimes in quite the same way. Um they're slightly more distant characters, I think.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, uh Weston didn't have his own uh you know mid-1800s version of the Riding the Wind vlog uh blog to look into. He did write an autobiography.
SPEAKER_00Did he? Um He did, yeah. Yeah, he did, yeah.
SPEAKER_02Okay, so you got to know him fairly deeply.
SPEAKER_00No, not really. He doesn't they have they have this way in the 19th century of portraying themselves in a quite an artificial, confected way, I think. Writing about their achievements in a way that is sometimes quite pompous and and quite stilted, and they don't have the same reflective approach to themselves that we would expect from public figures today. Um so you have to take everything that they say with a grain of salt, really, I think.
SPEAKER_02All right, Norda is the official footwear partner in the single track podcast. Two things to say here. First, I just got my hands on the new 055 model, and I will tell you right now, unequivocally, it is the shoe I'll be racing, the Bear 100, in later this year. Not only is it performance-oriented, but also super comfortable. If you liked the 005 model, by the way, I still do, and there are use cases for it for sure. This, I believe, has a more comfortable ankle and heel collar, a bit more stack, uh, more padded tongue, among other differences.
SPEAKER_02I really like it for the mountain, 100 mile distance. And look, I say that as someone that tests 25 to 30 shoes each year from all the brands. These are the real deal. Go check them out, nordaun.com. Also, thanks to Precision, Fuel and Hydration, the official nutrition partner of the show, also the official nutrition partner of our Twisted Fork Trail Festival taking place May 30th in Park City, Utah. If you want to check out their case study on Rachel Entrickin's nutrition strategy at the COGATONA250 earlier this month, it is live.
SPEAKER_02It's over on their Instagram channel. A lot of interesting insights that I will not spoil for you here. Go read it for yourself. Um, but we did talk about it a little bit on our post-race interview with her. Yes, she does have a gut of steel, but you know, her nutrition team on the ground, led by Emily Arrell at Precision, surely played a pivotal role in her landmark performance there. Go check it all out again uh over on the Precision Fuel and Hydration Instagram channel. I probably should have put this uh this topic earlier in the conversation, but we'll talk about here.
SPEAKER_02I have a note, and I'm gonna paraphrase a bit, but you have a quote from a philosopher named Isaiah Berlin in the book. And he basically makes the claim that this, and this, I don't know, this is kind of a big claim, but he says that the greatest shift in consciousness in the West happened in the early to mid-19th century. And it was when society started to view the wilderness and the mountains less as this like representation of the devil or something to be feared or conquered for industry, and more so like this arena to have an aesthetic experience and to invest in human creativity.
SPEAKER_02Um, can you talk about how this development happened, like who's responsible for that, how it happened? And actually, maybe whether you even agree with what Berlin is saying, like that, the the gravity of that shift.
SPEAKER_00Sure. So Isaiah Berlin was uh a British Russian Russian philosopher, and he was writing about the Romantic tradition. Um and the Romantics were um were poets predominantly in um in Britain, but also uh we can talk about the Romantics in Germany and then the transcendentalist writers who were, who were a version of the same thing, really, writing in the US. Now, all of these writers, the thing that they had in common with one another is they were they were pushing back against what they thought was the sort of cold rationalism of the industrial world, of science, of technology, of bureaucracy, of the sort of prison, the artificial prison that they felt was being created around around the human soul, around humanity itself.
SPEAKER_00And their view of the mountains and the wild, the outdoor world, um was that this was an arena of space where human intuition and creativity and emotion could be cultivated and explored in a much more authentic way. And Isaiah Boleyn's argument was that uh we see the shift in human consciousness where we begin to appreciate those things uh that we had before now taken for granted, uh, really.
SPEAKER_00And it it's it's only that march of industrialization and technology and science which uh encourages to focus in on those sort of inner uh human human features and um and we s we see that that lineage, that that tradition continuing through to today, really. And he thinks that's this huge shift in in human culture and human society, and one that has uh when he was writing towards the end of the 19th century and into the 20th century, um, had had had become absolutely central uh to what we think it means to be human.
SPEAKER_02Aaron Ross Powell And people like Ralph Waldo Emerson, Henry David Thoreau, they're participating in there, they I mean, is it is it too charitable to call them mountain runners?
SPEAKER_00Uh I don't know if they're running, but they they're going up onto the mountains, aren't they? I mean, this is the this is what they do. Um they're exploring, they're spending time, they're writing on the mountains, they're um they're spending time there. Uh they are part of that mountain running history. And I make that claim very, very clearly. I put them in the history of our sport because I feel that they, while they weren't runners themselves, they were keen hikers and walkers. Um their legacy, uh, the ideas that they generated have been just as important, I think, for shaping the sport that we have today as those early pedestrians, right?
SPEAKER_00It's all it all gets thrown into the mix in the 19th century. And over the course of the 20th century, it gets stirred together and thrown together, and you know, this it's it's led us to the to the present day, I think.
SPEAKER_02Aaron Powell So that that's an equally, if I'm understanding correctly, that's an equally formative time for how we understand the modern sport. Like we can't have we don't have like an outdoor recreation philosophy without those underpinnings back in the 1820s, 30s, 40s, 50s.
SPEAKER_00We don't have the philosophy, that underpinning philosophy. We also perhaps wouldn't have the culture of recreational hiking and long-distance walking that is also a part of our sport that's contributed towards it. So the hiking, I mean, we again we take it for granted this idea that people go out and hike in in the wilderness in mountains. It wasn't really until the end of the 19th century, and then in the early part of the 20th century, that this takes off as something that people do as a recreation, you know, as a recreational pursuit.
SPEAKER_00Um, and all of that leads into, I mean, the US is a really good case study of this. We take it for granted the trails. I mean, I wouldn't say we take it for granted we appreciate them, we value them, but they are there. That is a resource that exists for us to go and run on. Those trails didn't exist until the hiking and mountain communities which emerged um around this sort of recreational pursuit began to construct those trails and to preserve them and then to use them. So there is both a philosophical legacy, but also um a um a sort of a utility of uh you know of trails and all of those resources which have been have been left in that legacy as well, I think.
SPEAKER_02Okay. One last I want to just make one last point before we get into like maybe like the 1950s and 60s, moving on a bit. But d again, this is for the audience, because I know you wrote about it, but to the scale of pedestrianism, the celebrities that were involved, Mark Twain was doing this. That's amazing. Like that'd be like uh I mean, who would be the equivalent of Mark Twain today? I don't know. But that's just it's amazing that it got that widespread in society. I can't get over that. It's amazing.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's why we can't really make comparisons to the present day, because it it had such a cultural penetration. Um and and it was it was ultra running. They were running days at a time. It was it was incredible.
SPEAKER_02Another question, Seth for me, kind of moving. I mean, I guess we're gonna move like 100 days ahead. Over the decades, you know, what have been the inflection points in our sport? What have been the moments that have generated the most upheaval, both within the community and around it? Um what's been responsible for generating sort of the most significant change in our culture? One of the periods you point to in this regard is the 1950s and 1960s America. There's a lot of concern about increased leisure time and physical decline, increased obesity, lack of resolve to do hard things.
SPEAKER_02People are addicted to TV, fast food movies, all that stuff. It's so prevalent that the president of the United States gets involved, like President Kennedy. Talk about the influence that this moment had on the evolution of our community, ultra running.
SPEAKER_00So one of the aims of the book was to look at both the UK and the US, and partly that was around trying to show that there were broader moments of social change which weren't distinctive to one society or another, but things were happening in the Western world in particular, which allowed for the creation of sort of new athletic and recreational cultures. The 1950s is a really good example of that because both in America and in the UK, in the 50s, it seems remarkable, there is this widespread concern with health, and particularly around obesity.
SPEAKER_00Obesity levels were very low compared to the present day. Um, but there is a change of lifestyle. You know, cars are becoming uh much more commonplace now. People are doing much less in terms of physical activity. Uh, we have high calorie uh foods emerging. Um, people are much more sedentary. In both the UK and the US, there is this drive, and I think this is such an important moment. Um, there is this drive to uh encourage people to be active.
SPEAKER_00Um and they begin by trying to embed uh sport in schools because it doesn't exist in schools in quite the same way. In in in in your ordinary high school, sport is not as commonplace as it is today and as as it as it would become. Um so young people are encouraged to participate in sport in both the UK and in the US. And that starts to develop a generation, a new generation for the first time, which is accustomed to participating in sport and physical activity day in, day out at school.
SPEAKER_00Um and it does become a very high-profile issue uh for for politicians. So President Kennedy gives this very famous speech, um, and he he argues, I think it's in 1961, he says, we've become uh a nation of spectators, you know, and we should be a nation of athletes. And he he's calling upon Americans to to become active, um to stop just watching sport, but to actually take part in it. And it's that movement, and this is why it's so important, is that movement which eventually builds into what becomes the marathon boom of the late 1960s and and of the 1970s, and the kind of running cultures which emerge and which we take for granted now, you know, the sort of you know, the Nike and the sort of you know, the trap culture and athletics, which is so so significant, so huge, particularly in the United States, but it it didn't exist until until that big social shift began to occur.
SPEAKER_02Uh I'm laughing because I have a note here. I said, ask him about the soft American essay in Sports Illustrated. Uh I just, if anyone in today's age wrote an article titled Soft American, who is a public official or a public, I I don't know how well that would go down. And so like I know that the problem has only gotten worse 50, 60 years on. Um I would, I'm so curious to know if this was replicated in 2020 or 2025. How well this uh this analysis of society and the associated call to action would be received.
SPEAKER_00Well, it's it's interesting, isn't it? I, you know, I'm assuming the US, I don't know how similar it is in the US, but in the UK, we have all of these initiatives all the time to try and get people to be healthier. But there is always a public backlash against it. This idea that politicians are intervening to tell us what to do. And, you know, we have this term like a nanny state in the UK, this idea that the government shouldn't be involved in telling us what to eat and what to do. Um so it's it's quite controversial now. But it maybe, maybe that says something about the the change in how we see public figures back in the 1960s.
SPEAKER_00Someone like Kennedy, he had authority, didn't he? He had charisma, he had there was a a deference to to political leaders that that we've we completely lack, I think, now. So you're right, things have changed very significantly since Kennedy.
SPEAKER_02And his brother, uh RFK, uh does the 50-mile hike, the which becomes the JFK-50, like in one of those early years.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's right. Yeah. So off the back of the back of that call for Americans to become more active, um, there is a look, there is a focus on the military, and there's this idea that American soldiers are uh becoming a little bit overweight and and not fit and healthy. And um this goes back all the way to Theodore Roosevelt, who had a training regime for soldiers at the beginning of the 20th century. Um, and Theodore Roosevelt would have his soldiers sort of hike, you know, 50 miles. And um, yeah, I RFK calls for American soldiers to be able to hike 50 miles and um to demonstrate that they should be able to do it, he goes out and he does it in these sort of leather, leather shoes and slacks, and um he hikes 50 miles.
SPEAKER_00You know, I can do it, you should be able to do it. And uh we we get the the Kennedy uh walk, you know, Kennedy March uh craze, which starts to sweep across not just America, but um particularly Germany. Germans, West Germans, uh pick up on this hiking craze, this idea of hiking 50 miles. And you're right, um, you know, that becomes the um the origin story for the for the JFK 50, you know, which uh which eventually becomes a running race off the all the back of that.
SPEAKER_02Aaron Powell Especially given that the ultra trail distances were very, very, very few and far between at that moment in North America. Do you know how and why they landed on the 50-mile distance? And I'm assuming they did it on most of what's now the present JFK course.
SPEAKER_00Uh so well, so so specifically with the JFK-50, that and and that distance. I mean, the distance was uh was chosen because that is the distance that Theodore Roosevelt had demanded that his soldiers should be able to hike, right? So that his his claim was that you should be able to hike 50 miles in one go. Um it was a nice round distance. I mean, the the JFK 50 um that was that was set up to honour that legacy and the call um that Kennedy made for people to um to hike that distance, but it very quickly became a memorial race for Kennedy, which is why it persisted.
SPEAKER_00Um, because the the year after the first edition, uh Kennedy was was no longer alive. Um, and the race continued as a memorial hike, and it just got faster and faster, and athletes began to run it. Um and you you're right, there were there was nothing else comparable at the time, uh, certainly nothing that involved a mixture of trails as well. Um, because the 1960s hadn't we hadn't seen the revival of ultrarunning yet. I think it's important to remember that pedestrianism had disappeared at the end of the 19th century.
SPEAKER_00Ultrarunning hardly existed. There were no standard distances, there was no racing, uh, even at that point in the mid-1960s.
SPEAKER_02Another lesson from the book for me was uh just how interesting it was to see uh events in totally different areas of the country still finding a way to latch on to the same sort of like cultural memes or just like issues of the day and to build their identities around it. And I mean, the JFK 50 being one that we just described, but also like I didn't realize that Pike's Peak had sort of that same ethos to it in like the early days of the risk was like smokers versus nonsmokers.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. So I I I mentioned earlier this idea of joining the dots, and Pike's Peak is really interesting because so Pike's Peak was established in the mid-1950s, and um, you're right, it was it was initiated as a smokers versus non-smokers competition, and it that was because of the concerns that were beginning to emerge with not just health, but smoking in particular. Uh, most American men smoke smoked at that time, um, and we were only just beginning to understand the you know the implications of that on health.
SPEAKER_00Um, but the founder of Pikes Peak, Army Suiman, uh, who was a Finnish American, he had been one of the competitors in that in that transcontinental race in the 1920s as a young man. Um, so he had raced across America in the 1920s. He had been one of the race leaders for a time, but he he was injured and he had to pull out. And then decades later, uh he you know, he was a doctor um and he was concerned with health, and um he he established Pike's Peak, the race.
SPEAKER_00He he said, I will challenge any smoker to to race me to the to the summit of Pikes Peak and I will beat you. Um as a demonstration of the benefits of not smoking. Um and that was the that was the beginning of Pike's Peak.
SPEAKER_02Um tell tell the audience about Arlene Piper too.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so Arlene Piper, anyone who's familiar with Pikes Peak and is associated with that race will will know Arlene Piper. Arlene Piper was the was the first woman um to compete in in Pikes Peak. And um it she was she was almost a forgotten figure, really, I think, in the history of running. Um I mean, up until that point, women had not raced the marathon distance in the United States, certainly not officially. You know, the first woman's marathon finish was sort of credited with Roberta Gibb in the 1960s, but a decade before that, it was Arlene Piper who uh who had raced um you know to the summit and then back down in the Pikes Peak race uh towards the end of the 1950s.
SPEAKER_00Um and she was she was just a really interesting figure. She was uh she owned a fitness center with her husband, um and she um she she trained for two years to take part in in Pikes Peak. Um and I think one of the things that comes through in the book is is really the gender um pressures and and you know constraints that sometimes were were on women um you know throughout that history. And she had to look after her children, she would have to take them with her down to the running track to check to train, and she would take them with her um when she hiked up, you know, to bar camp on a Sunday uh for sort of altitude training.
SPEAKER_00And you know, wherever she went, uh training, she had the kids with her, and um she yeah, she eventually participated in Pikes Peak and she she hiked up to the summit with her daughter, and then she raced back down and became the first female finisher of Pikes Peak. And it's a story that was not really celebrated or remembered um until about 25 years ago, I think. Um what changed? I think with the way in which Pikes Peak had become such a celebrated and established race with such a history, um, I think it was just historians attached to the race itself who wanted to look back and to remember some of the key moments.
SPEAKER_00And of course, the first female finisher at Pikes Peak, that's quite a moment. And Arlene Piper was well, she she she's passed now, but she was alive then. And uh there was an effort to find her and track her down because she had moved away. And um, there is a story, you know, of journalists trying to find her and getting in touch with her and saying you you're a part of history, you're a part of history of this, not just this race, but of American athletics. You know, the first American woman to uh to complete a marathon. A marathon that ran up to the summit in Downton Pike's Peak.
SPEAKER_00You know, it's quite a moment. So uh yeah, it's a lovely, a lovely story, and she's a rightly a very celebrated figure uh in that history.
SPEAKER_02As an aside, for your own research, were there any people that you were trying to get a hold of that are still on your wish list for point of contact?
SPEAKER_00Oh, that's a good question. Um I don't I don't think so, no. Um no, I don't think so. I mean I I managed to reach out to everyone I wanted to reach out to, I think. I didn't always get responses, so that's all I can say. I'm not gonna yeah, I'm not gonna say who didn't respond because I don't want to, you know, it might be for completely innocent reasons, or you know, maybe maybe they felt I was pestering them. I don't know. But I managed to track most people down, I think.
SPEAKER_02This episode is brought to you by Kodiak. One of the things I hear all the time from runners who are struggling with their training is that they're underfueling. And honestly, a big part of fixing that is just having food that actually keeps you going between meals and efforts. Kodiak is built around whole grains, which means minimal processing. So you're getting the full grain, brand included. And that is where the fiber comes from. Pair that with real protein, and you've got something that keeps you fuller longer. I use it before long efforts, but honestly, it works just as well for recovery after a big week, and the variety is there.
SPEAKER_02Flapjacks, chewy granola bars, and their newer protein granola are all worth keeping in rotation. Real ingredients, no shortcuts. Find Kodiak at your local grocery store. They are the ones with the bear on the box. A word here from Momentous: roughly 95% of people don't get enough fiber. I assumed I was in the five tractor for a week and I was nowhere close. Fiber Plus is a triple action formula, soluble fiber, insoluble fiber, and prebiotic resistant starch. Three different jobs in one scoop, better gut function, better nutrient absorption, better recovery between hard sessions.
SPEAKER_02If you're stacking long days on trail, that compounds. Here's why I trust it NSF certified for sport, clean ingredient list, real cinnamon bark instead of the artificial flavoring that most fiber products lean on. I mix it in water first thing in the morning. Easy. Up to 35% off your first order at Livemomentous.com and use promo code SINGLETRAK. Livemomentous.com, promo code single track. If we move into the 1970s, and if I understand this correctly, when people are expressing a nostalgia or a preference for the quote unquote grassroots version of our sport, they're ver they're referencing the version that was born in the mid-1970s on the west coast of North America.
SPEAKER_02Do I have that correct?
SPEAKER_00In in ultrarunning specifically, sort of trail and ultrarunning, I think so. Yes. Yeah. Yeah. So well, remember, amateurism, amateur sport was very dominant then. Uh even in track athletics, it was an amateur sport. It wasn't something that was professionalized at all. Um with trail and ultrarunning, of course, we see in the 1970s, we see Western states emerge very quickly becoming um utterly dominant in the sort of American uh ultrarunning scene as it's beginning to emerge.
SPEAKER_00And um it it is grassroots, isn't it? It's it's it's an amateur volunteeristic uh event, um, as all of them were at that time. Um and I think the values which are quickly built up in the 1980s are within ultrarunning as a community, as it begins to see itself, are are rooted in that idea of participation and volunteerism. Um I think I think the best contrast that, and it's worth making this, is with triathlon because um They were in the same spot in the mid-80s.
SPEAKER_00They were, yeah. And I look at that story. So so triathlon and ultrarunning are emerging at the same time. They're almost comparable in terms of their origins and their size. And there is this debate within both ultrarunning and within triathlon about do we head towards professionalism or do we try and retain this as an amateur sport? Ultrarunning, and we see this in commentary pieces in Ultrarunning magazine. Ultrarunning broadly argues we're going to remain an amateur sport.
SPEAKER_00You know, we don't want to be corrupted um by sponsorship, uh, although there is sponsorship as it you know is developing, but it's very small. Triathlon is much more relaxed about going down a sort of more commercial uh path. Um, and they sort of branch off in in slightly different directions, really. And that's at the beginning of the 1980s.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, reading that was a bit mind-blowing to me because at least in like the last five to ten years, I always hear the refrain that triathlon Iron Man is quote unquote 20 years ahead of Trail and Ultra. And I've kind of always assumed it to be that way, but I didn't realize that there was this sort of like decision point, inflection point in the mid-80s where they were in the same position and like there was intentionality in that professionalism gap. Who were some of the like if you look back at the decision makers or the most influential people in the 80s, who who were the who were the people that were the most influential in keeping it uh steering us away from professionalism?
SPEAKER_00So this this debate is happening um at a grassroots level amongst runners themselves, but you have these public figures, these public voices, which um are particularly dominant in ultrarunning magazine, which has become, you know, in the 1980s, uh it that is the public for the public forum for the sport, really. Um and it is people like Gary Cantrell um who you know are arguing for uh sort of a retention of the things that make ultrarunning itself so special, you know, sort of camaraderie and um and volunteerism and participation and all of those values.
SPEAKER_00Um it is uh you know the uh kind of various uh you know, the race directors for Western states, you know, there are a succession of race directors who are also making those arguments. Um so it it is figures like that, I think, who uh hold hold hold hold the most weight. And um and the editorial uh sort of writers as well for um for Ultra Running magazine, which has a bit of a um you know an important uh influence, I think, over people.
SPEAKER_00Um but I mean that one of the most fascinating bits, and I loved reading through the archives of Ultrarunning magazine are the letters pages because it is the only it is the only space for ordinary runners to to make their voice heard, I think, at that time, you know, away from because it's a very small community. We're still talking about only a couple of thousand people across the whole of the US, uh geographically scattered. Remember, Ultrarunners are uh are based everywhere, and they might congregate periodically uh for a race, but the rest of the time they don't necessarily have huge amounts of contact with one another.
SPEAKER_00So Ultra Running magazine provides that that forum, and the letters pages um give you a bit of an insight into the views of ordinary runners at the time, and um we do get this sort of this deluge of letters, people writing into Ultra Running magazine, um, being very critical of what they see as commercialism beginning to creep into the sport. Um, because some of the early champions of the sport, particularly on the road and on the track, um, because road and track in ultra running is more important in the 1980s than it is now, I think.
SPEAKER_00Um and some of these early sort of champion athletes are beginning to get sponsorship in the 1980s, and there is a bit of a critique coming from ordinary runners about this. Um so there is a I think there is both a grassroots push against creeping commercialization and um and uh and also from key figures like like Gary Cantrell and uh and others.
SPEAKER_02Okay, I have so many follow-ups here. I mean the first one, and I'll say this as a footnote, but I I mean it as a question too. I did not realize that there was there was a mid-1980s equivalent of what we now know as the PTRA, which was the W E R A, and it was Jim King, Jim Howard, Sally Edwards, Bjork Ostream Smith. Can you talk can you talk about these people? Because were they representing the is it fair to say that they were representing the push towards professionalism?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so so the the early champions of Western states and those elite athletes who um were associated with Western states in those early years in the 1980s, you know, people like Jim King and Sally Edwards and, you know, your Gostream Smith, um they they felt that they were that they needed some remuneration, that they were dedicating huge amounts of their time, that they were semi-professional athletes, um, and that there needed to be some financial acknowledgement of what they were doing because they were looking at other sports, and even though most other sports were still amateur and there were restrictions on what could be paid uh to athletes, there were ways around that.
SPEAKER_00Um so, for example, it was possible for uh for athletes in the track and field world to be paid money for training purposes. Um that could be used for sort of you know residential purposes and and general living costs, as long as it was labeled for training, for training support. But these early athletes associated with Western states, they they argued that they were their accomplishments were very significant and yet there was no money coming in their direction whatsoever.
SPEAKER_00Um Western States itself, the race was beginning to attract sponsorship. Um Levi's sponsored Western States uh for a couple of years, and it it briefly put up a prize purse for Western States, which is you know one of those little nuggets of history that I mean sometimes forgotten. Um, you know, imagine a you know, you know, a non-endemic brand like Levi's in the early 1980s putting up a prize purse for Western States, which was still a very small race, uh, you know, comparably. Um so yeah, you get those early elite runners and they set up this organization.
SPEAKER_00I don't know how long the organization existed for really. It was kind of there in the archives, and then it just seemed to peter away. But it was it was an equivalent of the PTRA. There's this idea that athletes themselves, elite athletes, needed a voice, they needed representation. Um, and uh they they attempted to do that for a time.
SPEAKER_02Uh you write that the Levi Strauss prize purse was$12,000, which I think is about$45,000 adjusted for$20,$26. So it was, it was not nothing either. It was pretty significant.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, I know it was, yeah. It's interesting, isn't it? Amazing.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, uh reading that section too. I know that the founding of Western States is Gordy Ainsley, his horse going up lame, and then trying to finish it in under 24 hours. But I almost want to see like a companion appreciation for uh for Bjork, who runs 1846 at Western in 1981. She's a 30-something-year-old mother, two and a half-year-old kid, has been running for less than four years, has a Nike sponsorship, but she's in men's shoes because they don't have a female line yet.
SPEAKER_02That's an amazing story. And she's one of the early pioneers and runs 1840. Like, this is like Rachel Entriken, who just set the overall course record at Coca-Dona. Like that 1846, that's a time that until very recently would either win or be on the podium at Western in most years. Just incredible. This is for the audience, but I know you know about it. I'm just talking to the audience.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and that was the that was the aim of the book, really, to try and uncover some of these stories. Some of the some of these stories I I was familiar with already, others I wasn't. But you referenced earlier the fact that our generational memories fade quite quickly, I think. Um, and and they really do. And that early Western states history is so interesting. I had to tread carefully with it. You talked about that founding story of Gordy, and um, you know, it's got such an important legacy, does Western states? Um, and as an outsider, you know, I'm not American, I'm not a Western States insider by any means at all.
SPEAKER_00I wanted to handle that history fairly, but also very carefully, recognizing the special place that Western States has within our sport.
SPEAKER_02And then early years, the uh Mo Livermore and Shannon being two female race directors in a sport where like the progression on the women's side hadn't been nearly as developed as it was today. Like the fact that that exit that scenario existed in the late 70s, early 80s is amazing too.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. And again, I wanted to try and tell the story not always of athletes, but of the people who made things happen. Because we do focus on athletes quite rightly sometimes. Um they're an important part of the story. But there are also people who might maybe athletes themselves, but they they play more of a background uh supporting role. And I think that was the case in Western States. You know, if we talk about the Gang of Four, you know, like, you know, Mo Liv and Lithmore and Shannon Well, they were absolutely essential to to what happened. So I tried to bring that story out and foreground that a little bit more, perhaps, than than some of the the early athletes like like Gordy himself.
SPEAKER_02Before we get to like 2000s, 2010s, one more thing here. Can you talk a little bit about the regional differences in the 70s and 80s between the East Coast and the West Coast? And then just like how dramatically the nature of ultra finishes changed from like the beginning of the 80s to the end of the 80s. Because I find this fascinating too.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so the arc of the 1980s is really interesting because at the beginning of the 1980s, most ultra-running races in the United States are road or track still. Uh majority of those competing will compete on the road or on track. Uh, trail is a smaller part of the sport at the beginning of the 1980s. And of those trail finishers, people running on the trails, western states is a is a is a is the most central part of that, right?
SPEAKER_00Over the course of the 1980s, um, that begins to shift um as trail running becomes more significant, more popular, and more widespread. But the East Coast, West Coast divide is a really significant one because on the East Coast it it tends to be predominantly road and track. And trail running is really, for the most part, you know, in the western sort of you know, um side of of the US, uh in the in sort of the mountain running states, uh California and you know, Arizona.
SPEAKER_00Um so we start to see trail running grow from from from the southwest. And um by the end of the 1980s, as we go into the 1990s, uh trail running now comprises, you know. The largest part of the sport. And we're see we're seeing the sport shift from what I think of as sort of traditional mainstream athletics, you know, road and track, towards something which is a bit more of a mountain culture, a mountain running culture. So that is a that is part of that arc over the course of the 1980s.
SPEAKER_02What do you think is most responsible for that shift? Like why did it change so dramatically in 10 years?
SPEAKER_00I think Western states is an important part of that story. You see right from the beginning that Western states looms large in the imagination. Many of the hundred-mile races which are established after Western states are modeling themselves in Western states. They're trying to replicate something very similar. So we see Western states finishes founding races. So many of the founders of these races are previous Western states finishes. So I think Western states has that huge cultural role.
SPEAKER_00But it's also, there's also something else which goes beyond running, and that is the sort of mountain culture which is emerging. If you think about the rise of climbing, hiking, mountain sports. You know, we can look at things like snowboarding and skiing and all of these kinds of outdoor activities are becoming much more commonplace, much more widely celebrated. They're becoming much more visible in the culture, in film, television, literature. Um and I think that seeps through into the running world as well.
SPEAKER_00So it becomes it becomes much more natural to think if I'm gonna run 100 miles, I would much rather do it in the mountains or in the forests than I would, you know, in a city, right? Why wouldn't you? That makes sense. And I think people are developing the skills and the abilities and the confidence in the outdoor world um over that time as well. So there's something bigger taking place, I think.
SPEAKER_02It's and I'm not sure if you have a thought here, but it's interesting that Pike's Peak, Dipsy, Mount Wilson, Mount Baker, Mount Marathon, like they all predate Western states, but in reflection, they do not have the leverage to grow the sport like Western states ultimately does.
SPEAKER_00That's right, actually. And one of the things I was very surprised about is I was broadly familiar with the history of ultrarunning going back to Western states. I had a kind of sense of what existed. And I thought I would go further back and I would find this deeper and broader lineage of trail running type events in the United States. And it just wasn't there really at all. You go back before the war, before the Second World War, and there's very little you really have to look around.
SPEAKER_00And it is those celebrated races like Dipsy and like Mount Marathon. Um, and they are in Mount Wilson, you know, in in LA. And they they're they're just unusual. They're kind of these one-off events which are established and they keep going and they're celebrated and successful, but they don't have an impact really beyond the race themselves. They don't they don't spark anything bigger. There are moments where maybe that's going to happen. Dipsy was a good example of that. You know, at the beginning of the 20th century, Dipsy's founded.
SPEAKER_00And there are attempts to replicate something similar in California, but it never really takes off. I think that's because of the dominance of of road running at the time, um, and just maybe a lack of you know uh sort of travel connections and the ability for people to participate, but we we don't see those those sort of trail running races take off um until much later, until Western states and beyond.
SPEAKER_02It's amazing how much the uh the star power of the sport changes in a decade to like in the early 80s, it's like Burned Heinrich, right? Yep. And who I'm from Maine, local Maine, or so there's some Maine pride there. But uh and then like Ted Ted Corbett, right? Still to some extent. Yep. And then there's a total shift. I just and then then it's like the Jim Howards and the Jim Kings and uh anyone affiliated with Western States, which again in in retrospect makes total sense, but it's just amazing how fast that shifted.
SPEAKER_00Um we forget because people like Burton Heinrich, I mean, he you know, he didn't compete on the trail. He was a roadrunner and a track runner, and he was despite being a naturalist. Yeah, yeah. I mean, he set all of these records, you know, all of these American records, you know, with the hundred-mile distance and the 24-hour distance. And um yeah, I think easily forgotten because he he was he wasn't associated with Western States. He never competed at Western States. And I think now in trail and ultra running, we remember athletes over those kinds of events, right?
SPEAKER_00Western states, hard rock, you know, those kind of iconic races. But some of those figures like Bernd Heinrich, they they've perhaps drifted away a little bit, or Ted Corbett, because they weren't, they weren't trailrunners.
SPEAKER_02If we move into like 90s, 2000s, 2010s, from what I can tell, it seems like a lot of the same concerns from the 50s and the 60s are creeping up. Like people are feeling an anxiety around leisure. There's a need for more experiences, people are feeling more disconnected, the wellness culture is growing, the fitness culture is growing. Um and then at the same time, so there's like there's like that move towards like creativity and self-determination, but at the same time, there's also like a creeping professionalism too.
SPEAKER_02And so it seems like even though there was some critical decisions made in the 80s, in the 90s, you see the roots of what's happening today. Is that do I have that correct?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think so. So um it's interesting. I didn't intend to write a history book. I was gonna write a book which was much more contemporary about sport, actually. And the question I was trying to answer was why has the sport grown so much over the last 20 years? Almost the first thing I did was I put together some statistics to look at the growth of the sport. And you can see this tick, this big uptick in participation from around 2006 and 2007. And it's like this sort of steady, steady rise from that point.
SPEAKER_00Um, and I wanted to understand why that had happened. Um, and I ended up going all the way back because if you ask why now, you need to ask why not before. And that's why I ended up writing a history book. Um the sport as it is today, I think you're right, towards the end of the 1990s, despite the resistance from people within the sport sometimes to sort of professionalization and commercialization, it is becoming a bit more professionalized, it is becoming a bit more commercialized. Um, and we're seeing a sort of, you know, uh sort of business culture emerging um within the sport, with you know, uh brands like Montreal, for example.
SPEAKER_00And that's towards the end of the 1990s and the first proper sponsorship of athletes, you know, obviously very famously Scott Scott Jurek, but sort of almost forgotten figures like Ben Hyan as well. Um talk about Ben Hyyen. Yeah, so uh so so Ben Hyan, um many people will be familiar with him, many people won't be familiar with Ben Hyane. He was um he was a Californian athlete towards the end of the 1990s. He was just extremely fast, he just he just appeared on the scene, he was he was setting course records.
SPEAKER_00Um he had this intriguing sort of backstory, you know, um, sort of with with drug addiction and and and problems as a teenager. Um he was this sort of brash, um, sort of quite Gen X skateboardy type figure, right? He had this sort of charisma to him, sort of tattoos and you know, big blonde hair and all of that. And he he became the uh the the first sort of professional face of of One Sport, which became Montreal.
SPEAKER_00You know, he was the first sort of branded athlete um to try and sell trail running shoes. Um he was a precursor to the athletes that we you know soon become familiar with, like like Scott, like Scott Jurek. So um so all of that's happening at the end of the 1990s. And the argument I make is that that that commercialization of the sport is beginning to happen and it and it hits a kind of digital um social media culture in the mid-2000s, um, and there's a kind of synergy um between uh between the commercialization of the sport and the digital cultures which enable the sport to be to be shared and to be celebrated and to be visible to a broader public.
SPEAKER_00And there becomes an incentive for brands to you know to promote the sport, which in turn makes the sport grow, which makes it more commercially viable, which in turn makes it grow, and so on. So you have this sort of virtuous circle uh emerging in the mid-2000s between that commercial culture on the one hand and that digital culture on the other. And and that is perhaps one of the reasons why we see the sport grow so significantly. But the thing that you referenced about the sort of wellness culture and a turn to nature, and we we start to see around that time as well, uh across the Western world, um a rising interest in in mental health, in in this idea of um sort of personal me time and wellness and um and the sort of fastest growing recreational pursuits uh from that period um tend to be rooted in those kinds of uh areas.
SPEAKER_00So we're talking things like yoga, trail running, um, sort of adventure racing, um, anything which somehow allows you to connect to, you know, to the inner self, right? Whether that's in nature or or whatever it might be.
SPEAKER_02One of the one of the interesting, I think, moments from sort of the latest round of history is uh the parallel tracks of two different types of professionals, the Dean Carnassus type and the Scott Jurik type. And I'm wondering, in your research, did you find similar examples of that contrast in previous eras, or is this a relatively new phenomenon where like the Dean Carnassus type, the influencer entertainer type is competing for basically advertising partnership dollars as like the consummate professional Scott Jurik is?
SPEAKER_00So, I mean what what you're referencing there is the you know, the the famous, I don't know if it's a rivalry, I don't think it could be quite described like that, but Scott Jurik was winning races at the same time that Dean Carnazas was being celebrated as the greatest runner in America by right by by some of the kind of mainstream print media. Yeah. Um he was a very good athlete uh and a very charismatic and influential athlete, but um not at the same sort of competitive level as Scott Jurik. I think going back in history you didn't really quite have the same the same the same dynamic.
SPEAKER_00No, you didn't. I think you go back to pedestrianism, in some respects the the most serious athletes, the most competitive athletes were also the influencers of the time. They were also celebrity figures of the time as well. They were they they were able to do both. You didn't have a celebrity figure dominating the landscape at the expense of one of the most competitive athletes, right? You didn't have that dynamic, but but I think there is an echo of what existed between Scott and Dean today that's that's interesting.
SPEAKER_00You know, I mean you can look at um look at people like David Goggins, right? Kind of celebrated figure outside of the ultraran running world. Many people think he is the kind of greatest ultrarunner um right in ultrarunning. He's a very, very good athlete, but his his his profile is is is larger than his sort of competitive um standing in the sport, if that makes sense. So I think I think that's more of a I think it's more of a contemporary phenomena than um than one you find throughout history.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, trying, trying to pattern match it a little bit. You know, you you talk in the book about how um like in the 90s FKTs were this kind of burst onto the scene and there was like uh it was chafing a bit against traditional racing, but it was just like leaving it to the individual to find some sort of creative route to express themselves and uh showcase fitness and you know performance on, and that was interesting. And I almost see this uh sort of divergence of athlete types as another form of creativity.
SPEAKER_02Like this is a it it seems to be like a brand new model to make a living as a pro. And I mean, maybe it doesn't get celebrated as much as the innovation of FKTs does, but to me it seems like it it fits the pattern match of the era, the opportunities of the era.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think so. I mean, the FKT sort of phenomena, you know, that came back in the 1990s was really interesting. I think that was just a label for something which had existed before then, which was people trying to go out and explore the mountains and um, you know, to traverse those mountains as quickly as possible. Um so there there's always been those two sides of the sport, and I and I do trace that over that 200-year period. There is the mountain side, there is the romantic side, the the people who are who are sort of gravitating towards the sort of poetry of the outdoor world, and then there is the professional side of the sport.
SPEAKER_00But those two things are often combined at the same time, right? And not they're not paradoxical, they're not in conflict with one another. One can be both a romantic and a professional. One can be both an elite athlete and a sponsored athlete and someone who is drawn to that sort of poetry of the outdoor world. It's just that those are two strands which are sometimes woven together and are sometimes separate from one another. And I think I think that's so interesting, really. I think that's one of the, you know, the the interesting um sort of sort of dimensions of the sport and the way it exists today, uh, that I tried to explore and tried to think about.
SPEAKER_02Okay. As we get to today, I have this question written down for you. Are we becoming 1880 again? Like, is is this professionalism a similar strand to what we saw with pedestrianism in the 1880s or is it different?
SPEAKER_00I think I think it is a bit different, really. I think um I think the professionalism of the 19th century was was larger in many respects. So, you know, I've already talked about how it has and it did sort of penetrate the public consciousness in a much in a much more significant way. Um, and it was very much just an elite sport then. So in the 19th century, you had a very small number of athletes who would actually participate. And then you had very large crowds of people who would watch. The difference today is that, and this is something that I hope our sport retains, is that it is a participative sport.
SPEAKER_00We race alongside those elite athletes. We're we're all part of the same community. We watch them, but we we compete alongside them. We enjoy the same type of activity that they do, maybe at a different level and in a slightly different way, but we're all part of that participate participative community. So I think it looks different because of that. I think you know, we have um uh become a mass participation sport in many respects instead of a mass spectating sport. And I think that's one of the things that's that's most different.
SPEAKER_02Do you feel like that will persist for the foreseeable future? Like yeah, actually, like uh how how entrenched is this current model for the foreseeable future?
SPEAKER_00It's a hard question to answer, isn't it? Really, I think. I tried to speculate a bit at the end to give some suggestions. I think I think I think ultrarunning has reached, I wouldn't say a high point, but it has grown very, very significantly and it will continue to grow, but there is a there is a ceiling on I think its its penetration, its reach, its size. Um I think it will continue to diversify. One of the things I find so interesting is the way in which, and we can all witness this, can't we?
SPEAKER_00There are there are just different parts to the ultra-running world now. There are the kind of faster 100-mile UTMB style races, there are the growing number of 200-mile races with almost a different cast of characters quite often. We have the Backyard Ultras, you know, we have sort of the more FKT-style culture. There are these different worlds, these different ultra-running worlds, which are a little bit different from one another and they overlap and we're familiar with them all, and we step between them and and and into them.
SPEAKER_00But I think that diversification might be, might be the future, um, perhaps a little bit.
SPEAKER_02So maybe, maybe we're uh like should someone like me be worried that if we fast forward, let's just say 30 or 40 years, 2060 is gonna, from an opportunistic standpoint, it's gonna look like the 1920s for our sport, and it's gonna be a bunch of Charles Piles grasping at straws, and there's just like no, there's no demand, there's no momentum like we're we're experiencing now.
SPEAKER_00Oh no, no, no. I I don't I I think I think the sport is stable and has has reached a point of um uh of being able to sustain itself. I think that's quite clear, isn't it? Really? I don't I don't think we've reached a high point and there's going to be this this drop-off. I don't I don't see that at all. Um I think I I I just think the sort of sustained growth we've seen over the last sort of 10 years. I don't know. I mean it's anyone's guess, isn't it, really? Right. Yeah. Um I've written a book, I've written a history book. I don't know what lessons that history gives us because we can see over the course of that 200-year history uh the sport taking surprising turns in one direction or another.
SPEAKER_00Um so I don't know.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, that that was one thing I wanted to get your sense on is will the will the cycles, will the future cycles be as dramatic as the previous cycles? Because the just again reading the book, seeing what transpired in the late 1880s and 90s, to then up until like the sixth, like we had there was it was almost like there was a total reset in the sport for 80 years. And that Western States moment in the mid-1970s, it took like 80 years just to get back to that again.
SPEAKER_00It it did, yeah. And and that was because of the rise of amateurism, and it was just that that huge shift. I don't see the the professionalization of the sport being reversed in that way. I I I can't imagine that happening. Um I think one of the stories which is so fascinating is the is the internationalization of the sport. I think I think that might be the next chapter, um, particularly, you know, if we think about uh Asia and and the growth of trail running and ultrarunning across Asia, I think that's so fascinating.
SPEAKER_00Um and I think we might be talking about diversification, maybe international growth, but um whether the values of the sport are challenged and change, I don't know.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, what values and motivations do that like these other cultures bring to the table? Is are there any obvious ones that would uh disrupt the current order?
SPEAKER_00We don't we don't know, as far as I know, we don't know. So I was thinking about my next project, and that was one of the for a while I was thinking, wouldn't it be fascinating to write a book on the growth of the growth of trail running across Asia? Um, we're familiar with China, but um but Thailand, Indonesia, I mean, these places are seeing a massive surge of running rooted in a new and emerging middle class in these in these societies. Now, do they have the same the same view, the same way of experiencing the mountains and the outdoor world that we take for granted in in the Western world, in Europe and in North America?
SPEAKER_00It seems so, but we don't know. Nobody's told that story properly yet. And I think as these athletes become more visible and more more part of um this sort of media conversation, I think we'll have a better idea about that.
SPEAKER_02Do you suspect that over the next, yeah, let's call it three to four decades, we're gonna have even more people across the world with a ton of leisure time? Like one of the biggest problems to solve for societally is gonna be that same problem of leisure that yielded the spectator and sporting class in the uh in the 1800s around the Industrial Revolution?
SPEAKER_00It's a good question. So one of the key things I wanted to do with the book was to show that running, running cultures are connected to broader social economic changes that exist. And that is that is absolutely uh apparent. So industrialization, the sort of health concerns and the recreational cultures of the 1950s, 1960s, all of these things create the conditions which are allowed the emergence of different running cultures at different moments in time. So, what you're alluding to really, I think, is that there is technological change happening at such a pace that it's very, very Difficult to predict what the world is going to look at.
SPEAKER_00If we think about the rays of AI and automation, that is something that we we don't know what the world, the future looks like 20, 30, 40 years from now. Maybe we all have a great deal more time than we do currently. And that enables running, you know, the outdoors to be something that people can access and have the time to access in a way that they don't know. So that might be, that might be that kind of unexpected uh sort of social story that that we're not able to tell yet, perhaps.
SPEAKER_02Well, we we've referenced this book a couple times on the podcast, although it's been a while. Uh, A Philosophy of Regional Planning by Benton Mackay. And reading that book was interesting to me because he was convinced that we needed to build the Appalachian Trail pronto because he thought that the biggest problem by 1940 was going to be like everyone, everyone in society, top to bottom, was going to have an insane amount of leisure. And we needed to create a lifestyle that accounted for people no longer needing to punch in and punch out at the factor every day.
SPEAKER_02And he thought that like the AT was going to be that spiritual center. And so obviously that didn't quite come to bear. Um, but I wonder if he was just like a hundred years early. And that's going to be the thing in the century.
SPEAKER_00Maybe. I mean, the the problem is those predictions have been made, yeah, over the course of the last 200 years. Really, this idea that uh technology will reduce the burden of labor and we will all have more free time. And there have been many predictions, haven't there, that you know, we'll end up with 20, 20 hour working weeks, 10-hour working weeks. Um, it hasn't it hasn't happened yet, but maybe maybe maybe now we'll see.
SPEAKER_02Before we go, I'll leave uh final question for you. Uh, based on your research, based on how this book turned out, is there anything else about the past that we haven't discussed that you think um can tell us about the future if that's indicative of where we're headed?
SPEAKER_00Oh of the past of running, uh trail and ultra running. Um I think one of the most interesting stories is around diversity and inclusion. I think that is a really interesting one. Um the professional nature of the sport in the 19th century actually enabled uh anybody from any background to compete. You just needed to be a good athlete. And I think I think perhaps with the growing professionalization of the sport, um, you know, as it as it continues, I think that is going to open up avenues for people from from different backgrounds to participate.
SPEAKER_00I mean, we talked a bit about internationalization, right? I mean, if we think about African athletes, athletes from Asia, there are avenues now into the sport which maybe didn't exist 20 years ago. Um, and we might also think about those avenues potentially drawing people from not the predominantly middle class backgrounds, which, you know, for the most part runners have been from. Um, so I think one of the lessons of history is actually professionalization can open doors for athletes in a way that amateurism sometimes sometimes didn't.
SPEAKER_02Well, Carl, it it's been an honor and a pleasure to have you on the show. I I really appreciate it. I'm gonna put for the our YouTube audience, I'm gonna put the book on the screen, dirtbag dreams, a history of mountain ultra intro writing. I thoroughly enjoyed it. I reached out to you for this conversation. This is not a promotional thing. I I genuinely enjoyed it. It's an amazing, amazing contribution to the canon of content in our sport. And so maybe we end there. I just appreciate the fact that you're you're in the sport, creating and reflecting and just amazing stuff.
SPEAKER_02Thank you so much.
unknownGreat.
SPEAKER_00Thank you, Then. Yeah, it's been it's been wonderful. Thank you.
Alyssa Clark is back for another edition of Singletrack News. Timestamps: 00:00 Ultra-Trail Cape Town preview + South Africa's team trials 02:38 When will the US name its World Trail Champs qualifier location? 05:19...
Mark Dowdle joins the show for a wide-ranging conversation. Timestamps: 00:00 The 87-yard qualifying math 05:11 Where to chase 88 yards in 2027 13:43 The Dennis Rodman of ultrarunning, “Running is boring” 18:07 Loop 87...
Two winning margins under 90 seconds, a called shot, and an all-masters women’s podium. Brett Hornig and Leah Yingling join me to recap the 2026 Javelina Jundred. Partners: Precision Fuel and Hydration - use code...
Jameson Collins, Headquarters Manager for Destination Trail, joins me to walk through what happened at this year’s Moab 240, from the decision to start to the mid-race cancellation. We cover how the team read the...
In this week’s edition of Singletrack News, Brett Hornig and I wrap up the Backyard World Team Championships at Big’s. That includes the Belgian pair’s decision to stop together at a new world record, and whether...