Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Singing Through Fire

Singing Through Fire artwork

Carrie Sheffield: Escaping a Cult, PTSD, and Finding Healing & Forgiveness in Christ | STF Podcast Ep. 22

May 12, 20261 hr 8 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

In this episode of the Faith in the Furnace series, host Lara Silverman sits down with journalist, author, and musician Carrie Sheffield to discuss surviving childhood trauma, religious abuse, mental illness in her family, and finding healing through Christ. Carrie shares what it was like growing up as the fifth of eight children in a violent, unstable motorhome lifestyle under her father’s extremist “prophet” claims connected to an offshoot LDS belief system. She attended 17 schools, performed classical music on the streets, and endured severe trauma, including sexual assault and emotional abuse. Despite her circumstances, Carrie excelled academically - scoring in the top 1% on both the ACT and the ACE (Adverse Childhood Experiences) trauma scale. She opens up about her struggles with PTSD, depression, anxiety, fibromyalgia, and the painful cost of leaving home at 18, including being disowned by her father. Carrie also discusses her years as an agnostic before becoming a Protestant Christian in 2017, and how faith, forgiveness, boundaries, mentors, and trauma-informed mental health tools helped her begin rewiring deeply rooted beliefs shaped by abuse. The conversation explores topics like generational trauma, healing the subconscious mind, somatic therapy, music’s role in healing, and the difference between forgiveness and reconciliation. She also shares about her nonprofit, Healthy Faith, her Bible and mental health conferences, co-writing the song “My Heavenly Father Is,” and the ways she has seen God redeem suffering and restore what trauma tried to destroy. Chapters 00:00 Series Intro and Guest 00:19 Carrie Story and Credentials 05:17 Trauma and Mental Health 06:14 ACT Versus ACE 09:33 Worth and Work 12:43 Conversion Timeline 15:46 LDS Roots and Jesus 20:26 Mentors and Forgiveness 22:58 Healthy Faith Mission 26:09 Song My Heavenly Father 28:39 Breaking Free Costs 30:01 HSP and Healing 35:22 Renewing the Mind 36:29 Rewiring Trauma Brain 37:37 Subconscious and Scripture 39:35 Atlas Project Breakthrough 40:57 OnSite and Therapy Debate 42:32 Somatic Healing and Emotions 45:33 God's Goodness and Pain 49:13 Locust List and Anti Resume 54:22 Anger Release and Singing 56:28 Memoir Singing Through Fire 57:46 Forgiveness and Self Forgiving 01:01:31 Near Death and Health Collapse 01:05:04 From Scars to Redemption 01:06:08 Mary Magdalene and Closing Hope Resources and Links: Carrie Sheffield's website Watch the Singing Through Fire podcast on YouTube. Listen on your favorite podcast streaming platform. Listen on Spotify. Listen on Apple podcasts. Connect on Facebook. Connect on Instagram. PODCAST DESCRIPTION: Welcome to the Singing Through Fire podcast! I’m your host Lara Silverman, and this is where we: Worship when it hurts Discuss hot takes from the furnace of affliction Explore a biblical theology of suffering with a side of sass and sarcasm From lamentations to laughter, this podcast is for anyone desperate for hope who has ever asked, "Why, Lord, why?” Don’t forget to follow/subscribe because I upload content every Tuesday and Friday! "For our light and momentary troubles are achieving for us an eternal glory that far outweighs them all." 2nd Corinthians 4:17.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Lara SilvermanWelcome back to Singing Through Fire. I'm your host, Laura Silverman, and today we're continuing our Faith in the Furnace series, where we interview Christian warriors with powerful testimonies of God's sustaining grace in modern-day lions' dens. I am so excited today to introduce you to my friend, Carrie Sheffield. Carrie Sheffield grew up fifth of eight children with a violent, mentally ill, street musician father, who believed that he was a modern-day Mormon prophet destined to become the United States president.

Lara SilvermanShe and her seven siblings were often forced to live as vagabonds, remaining on the move across the country. They frequently subsisted in sheds, tents, and most notably, motor homes. They often lived a dysfunctional drifter existence, camping out in their motor home in Walmart parking lots. Carrie attended 17 public schools and home school, all while performing classical music on the streets and passing out fire and brimstone religious pamphlets, at times while child custody workers loomed.

Lara SilvermanCarrie's father was eventually excommunicated from the official LDS church, and she was the first of her seven siblings to escape this toxic brainwashing of his fundamentalist creed. Declared legally estranged from her parents, Carrie struggled with her mental health during college and for most of her adult life, but she eventually seized control of her past and overcame those, that toxic inner voice, and a near-death experience, by the way, thanks to the power of Christ's forgiveness cultivated through her conversion to Christianity.

Lara SilvermanShe evolved from a scared and abused motor home-dwelling girl to a Harvard-educated professional with a passion for empowering others to reject the cycles of poverty, depression, and self-hatred. Today, Carrie is a writer, broadcaster, and a talented violinist and singer in the Washington, DC area. She authored the bestselling book, Motor Home Prophecies: A Journey of Healing and Forgiveness. A senior policy analyst at Independent Women's Forum, Carrie directed the Center for the American Worker and the Center for American Values at America First Policy Institute.

Lara SilvermanA former White House reporter, Carrie earned a master's in public policy from Harvard, concentrating in business policy. She earned a BA with honors in communications at Brigham Young University. And served as a lead analyst on a$5 billion portfolio of healthcare bonds at Moody's Ratings, and later researched for American Enterprise Institute economic scholar Edward Conrad. She has repeatedly testified before the United States House on Economic Policy, and while serving as executive director for Generation Opportunity, she spoke at the US Senate alongside key senators in favor of landmark tax reforms passed by Congress in 2017.

Lara SilvermanCarrie covered Congress for The Hill newspaper and was a founding reporter at Politico. She's published in The Wall Street Journal, Time, USA, CNN Opinion, The New York Times, and a host of other news organizations. Carrie has joined as a live broadcast guest on media networks including Fox News, Newsmax TV, MSNBC, CNN, PBS, and BBC. Carrie provided analysis for Fox News' first 2016 GOP presidential primary debate. She is the founder of Bold TV, a digital media network featuring newsmakers across politics, business, and lifestyle news.

Lara SilvermanLadies and gentlemen, her story, as you can tell, from tragedy to triumph, is just an inspiration. And when I first heard about Carrie, I just, I said,"I have to interview this woman." So without further ado, let's sing through the fire. This is Singing Through Fire, where we worship when it hurts, discuss hot takes from the furnace of affliction, and explore a biblical theology of suffering with a side of sass and sarcasm. From lamentations to laughter, this podcast is for anyone desperate for hope, who's ever asked,"Why, Lord, why?" I've lost my health, career, and husband, so we're in this fight for faith together.

Lara SilvermanWelcome to the show, Carrie. I, I cannot tell you how honored I am to just have you on my humble platform here and to give voice to your testimony. Thank you for joining us.

Carrie SheffieldThank you for having me, Laura, and thank you for what you're doing, too. I, I, y- you straddle this unique position of both just extreme sort of elite credentialing but also suffering. And it's just so rare to find someone who has both, and you're just walking that line so eloquently. So thank you for having me.

Lara SilvermanThank you for saying that. Y- you know, it's, it's hard because, and I know you can identify with this, where you go from such deep suffering. Or sorry, for me, it was sort of the reverse, where I was sort of at the pinnacle of my legal career and all this, you know what I mean? My audience knows the background, and then boom, I'm la- I've landed in this pit of suffering. But you tell this sort of beautiful suffering to redemption story. I mean, my story is being redeemed, too, so I don't wanna paint the, the wrong picture. But can you start by telling us, you know, I laid sort of the, the foundation.

Lara SilvermanDo you wanna give your story in a nutshell, just to kinda give your own gloss on where you've come from?

Carrie SheffieldYeah, yeah. So if folks want the full dive, uh, the 90,000-word book, uh, they can pick up a copy of Motorhome Prophecies: A Journey of Healing and Forgiveness. Um, I've been on the Dr. Phil Show, uh, on Fox News with Shannon Bream, a podcast CNN, Wall Street Journal. Over 100 interviews at this point about the story of the book, and I think part of why it's resonating right now is because there is a mental health crisis happening right now. And unfortunately, as a result of this childhood that you laid out, uh, I've had multiple siblings attempt suicide.

Carrie SheffieldUh, I was suicidal. I've been diagnosed with, um, PTSD, depression, anxiety, fibromyalgia. And so there's just a lot about childhood abuse and childhood trauma that most people don't know. And, and thankfully, thankfully, because we can dive more into how to, how to quantify child abuse and childhood trauma and neglect. But suffice it to say that, uh, I'm actually giving my first college commencement speech in a few weeks at College of the Ozarks, which, which is a Christian college in the Ozarks of Missouri.

Carrie SheffieldAnd I'm drafting the speech, and I'm starting it just to let folks know the dichotomy in my brain, which was that despite all of that, or maybe in spite of it because I was very motivated to get out I studied really, really hard on my ACT, and I ended up scoring in the top one percentile for all high school students on ACT. But I also scored on the top 1% when you look back on my childhood and the ACE, which is known as the ACE score. So the ACT top 1% and the ACE top 1%.

Carrie SheffieldACE stands for adverse childhood experiences, and that's how you quantify things that happened to you before your 18th birthday. And so my brain was constantly at war, uh, and I'm still fighting that war. But through the power of Jesus, um, I'm, I am winning that war.

Lara SilvermanOh my gosh. I... Wow. The, just the juxtaposition of what you said, like this, this young child, like looking back at yourself, you're saying you have this brilliant young child, but then this child who is suffering through so much trauma, and then the Lord rescues you years later, which we're gonna get into. I... So in your childhood, you know, you lived this nomadic motor home existence, right? It's like constant uncertainty. Can you tell us how that traumatic situation affected, you know, obviously your sense of safety and identity and more, most importantly, your worth, you know, at that time?

Lara SilvermanAnd I'm ass- you weren't a real Christian, I'm guessing, at that point. I mean, you were in the LDS. Anyway, you tell us.

Carrie SheffieldWell, yeah, I, I was in my father's very, very toxic interpretation of LDS theology, and as you mentioned, he was excommunicated from the LDS church. So I always let folks know when I start out speaking- That my father's theology was not, it was not endorsed by the LDS church. He added his own layer of his own false prophetic claims. And I, I try also to be as, as, um, sympathetic to him to really understand the roots of all of this because sadly, my father was sexually molested as a child himself.

Carrie SheffieldAnd so the book is about breaking those chains of generational sin. But he said, and this was a babysitter who assaulted him, and he was born in 1938, and his parents didn't know what to do. They didn't call the police on this woman. They didn't hold her accountable. Uh, they didn't call religious authorities to hold her accountable either because she was, she was LDS, the whole family was LDS. No accountability mechanism for this woman. Their response was to buy my father a dump truck to distract him and make him feel better which was apparently a big hit.

Carrie SheffieldHe, he, he said in very vivid detail that the neighborhood kids all loved his little dump truck. It was this mechanical one. It was very advanced for the time. Uh, but that was his sort of distraction from this. And to understand childhood trauma I thought I could just stuff it down which is the approach for many people. And, and again, because I was high-functioning academically, I was able to delude myself that I have- everything's fine. Um, but

Lara SilvermanRight

Carrie Sheffieldbut it caught up with me in middle age, and that's how I ended up, uh, almost dying, but that's another story.

Lara SilvermanRight. So but, and to get back to the point of, like, your identity and worth, like, I'm assuming you were struggling with that as a teenager or whatever'cause you're in this insane environment. Would that be true?

Carrie SheffieldYeah, yeah, and sorry, I got derailed myself. No, no. But but yeah, you're exactly right that typically when children have toxic childhoods, uh, there are two kind of main, uh, responses to that. They will either act out and go totally off the rails. They'll become a drug addict, an alcoholic, uh, get into prostitution, what, whatnot, just extreme just aberration from healthy behavior. The other response is to, which is what I did which is just try to be perfect and try so hard to, as they say it, uh, we develop hypervigilance so that we know, we read the faces of adults, what's going to upset them, and how can I be perfect so that I don't get the wrath of this parent to beat me.

Carrie SheffieldAnd so I, I wasn't, I d- I, my dad did hit me some, but nothing compared to my brothers or one of my sisters, you know,'cause I, I generally was able to read through my hypervigilance how to keep my nose clean. Um, and so that's, you know, I got straight As, did really well on the ACT, things like that. But that created this- Memory muscle, and as they say, the subconscious programming significantly occurs between the ages of zero and eight. And so the coding that I, I received was that I needed to work. I needed to work to prove my worthiness, and this is something that I'm going to mention to the students when I speak to them, um, at the college graduation because for folks who don't know about College of the Ozarks, they do not charge tuition.

Carrie SheffieldAgain, it's a, a private cr- Christian college in the Ozarks of Missouri, um, which is actually part of where the book takes place, which is part of why they, they've invited me. Mm-hmm. Uh, but their motto is, it's, it's informally called Hard Work U, like U like university- Right because they don't charge tuition. But in order to receive tuition free, thanks to generous donors, every student works. Every student must work. And so, uh, they also screen for, for need. And so about 90% of these students have, uh, come from backgrounds where they demonstrate financial need.

Carrie SheffieldAnd so a lot of these students are coming from high poverty- Mm-hmm potentially abusive backgrounds. And so what I, I will reiterate to them is that even though your, the motto of your school is Hard Work U, please, please, please do not, do not believe that your worth is determined by your work. Your worth is inherent, and it is, If it was not told to you as a child, this is something that you must know in your bones, in your subconscious, not just something to know theologically or at the conscious level.

Carrie SheffieldThe subconscious is so much more powerful. Uh, I've heard it d- described as like a, an iceberg, where the iceberg only has maybe 10% visible and then the 90% under the water. So you... I, and I thought, I thought I, I thought I knew my worth, but I eventually... This is why I almost died because I almost worked myself to death. So it's, um, it's been a journey.

Lara SilvermanOh, my gosh. And at what point, Kari, did you meet the Lord? So, like, you're a kid. You- you're going through all this trauma. I'm guessing, I don't know if you ever believed, you know, i- in your father's beliefs or not. You can maybe answer that. But at what point did you meet the Lord?

Carrie SheffieldYeah. So I was baptized as a Protestant Christian on December 3rd, 2017. It was a few weeks before my 35th birthday. But before that I spent about 12 years agnostic. Um, and before that I was LDS, and that's where you read I, you know, I went to Br- I'm a Brigham Young University graduate. I was more mainstream LDS, and before that I was in my dad's extremist cult. And I will say that when I turned 18, um, I, in the months leading up, I had been Because my, one of my schizophrenic brothers, well, I only had one at the time.

Carrie SheffieldNow I have two schizophrenic brothers. I have five brothers. Five brothers, two sisters, 10 people all from the same parents, the eight kids, and all living in a motor home. And so when I was 17, my schizophrenic brother sexually assaulted me, and I, as a result, I went on this big journey, is my father a prophet? And I really started to wrestle with that. I, I call it my first investigative journalism project, is my father a prophet? Came through on the other side and determined I didn't believe he was. And so I told him I was going away to college.

Carrie SheffieldHe raised his right hand and he said,"I prophesy in the name of Jesus, you'll be raped and murdered if you leave." And so as you might have imagine, eventually I really grew to not like the Jesus character. Well, it, it was more I just thought of him as sort of like, an avatar for whatever people wanted to use. Sometimes it was for good stuff, but sometimes it was for abuse. And so- Right I just thought of Jesus as a sociological construct something that, you know, that, uh, humans had made this God in our own image. And so sometimes it was good, but it was more a reflection of person.

Carrie SheffieldAnd so- Oh uh, that's where I was for a long time. And the book gets into the full story of how I became a Christian. And it's, uh... I can, I can tell, tell you, uh, sometimes the, the book, the chapter on my conversion, I started out, it makes people laugh because I say it was two main, two main forces that brought me to the Christian faith. One was science and one was Donald Trump.

Lara SilvermanYeah, no, it's such a good line. It's such a good line. I, I... Yeah, maybe we should... We'll leave that for the re- You guys have to get the book. I mean, we'll, we'll leave that to the reader's, you know, interest and curiosity. But, you know, I wanna say, you know how the Lord says in Psalm 34, like,"The Lord is near to the broken-hearted." And I'm just, looking back now as the mature adult you are, you know, looking back, where do you most clearly see the Lord's presence sustaining you through that trauma as a child, even when you didn't know the Lord yet?

Lara SilvermanLike, is that a testimony you can give? Like, this is such a unique testimony because you became a Christian later in life, and now I'm asking you, can you tell us whether you felt God's presence or not during that trauma?

Carrie SheffieldWell, this is a much longer conversation we can have about LDS theology because-

Lara SilvermanOkay

Carrie Sheffieldif you were to talk to an LDS church member- they don't like us to say Mormon anymore for the official big church, the one in Salt Lake City, headquartered, the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. They, they prefer to use the full name, but there are lots of offshoot groups. The biggest one is in Missouri. Um- Mm I sometimes describe it as like the Shiite-Sunni split i- in Islam, in the sense that the church in Salt Lake, they, they believed in a prophetic succession that was not genetic to Joseph Smith, whereas the one in Missouri believed it had to be a genetic descendant. So it's a smaller offshoot, just like Shiites are smaller than Sunnis, the groups.

Carrie SheffieldBut anyway. Yeah. Theologically, if you were to ask a member of the mainstream LDS church,"Are you a Christian?" They would unhesitantly say,"Absolutely we are." And so I grew up with the King James Bible, uh, but they also have three other books of scripture. They have the Book of Mormon, the Doctrine and Covenants, and the Pearl of Great Price. And so my middle name is Esther also, which is a very biblical name. Mm-hmm. Um, and so... And it was funny'cause after I took a pause for 12 years as agnostic, when I came back, I had these stories jumbled in my head sometimes of like,"What's a Bible story versus a Book of Mormon story?" And so it took time to disaggregate that.

Carrie SheffieldBut I do, I, I f- uh, and I mention this in the book and I quote from my journals, so LDS culture, um, is very big about journaling, partially because, uh, a lot of what we know about the LDS church's founding in 1830 is from contemporaneous journals of the early members, of which my ancestors were helping Joseph Smith. My ancestors worked with Brigham Young. And so they passed down their, their journals. And so I was given my first journal when I was age eight by one of my aunts. And so I have this big stack of journals now because I've kept a journal since I was eight. And so I knew what I was thinking when I was an eight-year-old, which, which as a journalist, that really helped me writing a memoir because a memoir, there's, it's, you know, you have to kind of create dialogue, um, which I hate as a journalist'cause I would record, if I'm interviewing a member of Congress, I make sure I get every single nuance correct in the transcript.

Carrie SheffieldSo- Right here I am making up dialogue just to to remember things as I remember as a child. But in any case, my early journals, I talk about how much that I love Jesus. Mm. And I, one of my entries I literally said,"I hope... I love Jesus and I hope that I never forget how much that I love Jesus." Oh. That's what I said when I was about eight years old. And so-

Lara SilvermanI'm getting chills.

Carrie SheffieldYeah. And so that's what's really interesting about LDS theology is that in my view, there is this foundation of loving Jesus, but then they pile a lot of things on top of it including very works-based thinking.

Lara SilvermanYeah. Um,

Carrie Sheffieldlike they have the phrase like"Work out your salvation with fear and trembling." And I remember h- hearing a prayer once basically saying that we have to qualify for heaven through our works. And- Theologically, that's not what the sacrifice of Christ is. Right. They also do not believe in the Trinitarian view of the Godhead. They believe that, that Jesus, God the Father, and Jesus are physically distinct human bodies that are different. Um- Okay and so which is a major, major departure from-

Lara SilvermanYeah

Carrie SheffieldOrthodox, Catholic, Protestant theology. So, so, but what's very interesting is that, and I've written a couple pieces about this recently, is that the LDS church has been going through a lot of reforms recently even in the past couple decades. Um, led by a guy who was their recent leader who just passed away last fall. He actually died a few weeks after Charlie Kirk. Um- Oh he implemented a lot of changes including getting rid of the theology that they believe you can have your own planet in the afterlife. Um, like a human could be God of their own planet. Like, they've-

Lara SilvermanRight

Carrie Sheffieldthey've gotten rid of that. So, so anyway- Oh, wow that is a, a long answer to your question, which is a, a nuanced question.

Lara SilvermanA- and so what you're saying is the little Carrie really did feel this sense of love for Jesus, and perhaps from Jesus. I mean, we respond to His love. So I think that's beautiful that, you know, the Lord was planting seeds in your heart, even as all this evil was coming at you with distorting who He really was. Like, just, you... W- I mean, yeah, I'm just digesting it. I mean, that's, that's so beautiful. And, you know, the, the question that leads to is, later on, okay, you're separated from this traumatic, abusive situation.

Lara SilvermanHow did the Lord start dismantling the harmful assumptions, like, about His character? Like, how did God help you trust His real character once you did become a real believer?

Carrie SheffieldYeah. Well, like I said, I, I walk through the conversion process, which folks can read. But but I do like to say, you know, as I, as I was a baby Christian after that baptism, um, I w- it was not linear, but by any stretch. But I, I did my best in a very nonlinear fashion, full, uh, full of sins. But I did try and show up for God. And when I did, God showed up for me. And so He helped me to separate what was a lie from what is true.

Carrie SheffieldUm- Yeah and as one of... And, and He also brought in amazing mentors into my life spiritual mentors. So one of those mentors I talk about in the book who, I call him my forgiveness mentor. I have a chapter on forgiveness. And Um, he's a reverend down in Charleston, South Carolina. And he, I met him in New York City because I was invited to a film screening in Tribeca, a, a documentary that he was featured in. The name of the documentary is called Emanuel, and it's about the- Mm-hmm the shooting down in Charleston in 2015- Mm where this evil white supremacist had driven from Columbia, South Carolina to Charleston because he wanted to hunt Black people and shoot up a Black church, and he did, and he killed nine Black people, including my friend's wife.

Carrie SheffieldUm- Oh. And so, Anthony's wife was leading the Bible study at the time actually, um, and I think it was her first time leading a Bible study. She had just been certified to, to minister. She had just finished her s- her ministerial certification, so it was just, it's, was really And then, and this guy had come to their, their service the week before to scope things out, and they had welcomed him with open arms to the study. And so it was just, the whole thing is just really heinous, and, but he wrote a book, and he's featured in this documentary that I went to, and I got to meet him there.

Carrie SheffieldUm- Mm. And the book is called, the title is Called to Forgive. Oh and he, he, it's just a, it's basically a forgiveness handbook. Um, it walks through some of the myths and a very important distinction that I, I like to let folks r- you know, remind them the difference between forgiveness and reconciliation. They're separate things. Forgiveness is my choice. It is my decision. I choose to forgive. Reconciliation is a two party, or more, but it's external to my decisions, and that is contingent on boundaries and behavior changes from other people.

Carrie SheffieldSo s- a lotta times people confuse that, and they think that if I forgive someone, then I have to let them back in my life. No. You, you absolutely do not. But anyway, I, I just, God brought- Mm other amazing mentors, Pastor Air Bernard. Um, I have, uh, had an amazing therapist who was Jewish. So I just, I, I founded a nonprofit called Healthy Faith, which is integrating mental health and faith together, um, because there is so much, uh, evidence that people who are, uh Uh, it's, it's funny'cause sometimes I, I cringe at the word religious because I, I associated religious, religion with abuse.

Carrie SheffieldUm- Yeah but by all the metrics, I'm a religious person in terms of- going to church every week, reading my Bible every day, praying a- as much as I can. But, uh, anyway, a, a major theme of the book is the difference between God and religion. But my nonprofit, Healthy Faith, is about exactly that, healthy faith. So my life kind of careened in opposite directions, which was abusive control religion, and then no religion, no faith and then that healthy middle ground. Because, uh, and so I've for the last two years, and we're in the process of organizing again for this year, third year in a row, um, a conference called The Bible and Mental Health.

Carrie SheffieldMm-hmm. And I've been able to bring in amazing scholars from some of the top universities who are, uh, practicing Christians, Jewish and they provide their perspective as scholars and therapists, um, on the integration. And, uh, I will say the overwhelming number of academic studies show a strong tie between faith and low depression, low suicide, low, uh, drug addiction, low alcohol addiction. But there are a few studies that show a, a, uh, negative correlation, and I would, I would put my religious experience as a child in that type of camp.

Carrie SheffieldBut what the media likes to do is they cherry-pick those few-

Lara SilvermanRight

Carrie Sheffieldextreme cases and- Right ignore, ignore the big whale of all, all this other mountain of evidence. And so much, so much of our mental health industry is very secular, to the point where around 70% of therapists self-identify as atheist or agnostic, so they're, they're totally disconnected from the healing power of God.

Lara SilvermanIt's like how can they teach truth when they're disconnected from the truth? It's like how can they heal, help heal hearts when the Lord isn't in their heart? And I, I don't mean it in a mean way, you know, but yeah. I- you guys, look at the redemptive story with this woman. Like, she goes from this abusive, you know, religious form of faith, you know. And now, what was the name of your nonprofit again?

Carrie SheffieldHealthy Faith.

Lara SilvermanOh, Healthy Faith. And now the Lord uses her testimony to flip it around. He always flips the script redemptively. What the- what Satan intended for evil, God intended for good. And now she's got this Healthy Faith nonprofit where she's flipping the script and helping others. I mean, it's so classic God. Like, I just love your testimony even though I hate the suffering that you endured, but look at how the Lord is using you so powerfully in this mental health space, trauma space. I mean, just, anyway, childhood abuse space. And I wanted to mention also, I, I loved how you said the Lord brought people into your life to kinda clear up some of what you might have been misrepresenting about who Jesus was.

Lara Silverman'Cause it sounds like you grew up reading the King James Version, so it's not like you were unfamiliar with the Bible, but then the Lord kinda came in and gently brought in the right voices to speak His truth to you when you were probably trying to parse out what kind of God are you. You know, what are the real truths versus the fake truths? It sounds like that's what you're saying.

Carrie SheffieldYeah. Yeah, and I'll just bring in, since I know you're a musician, the music part of that in terms of the musicians God has brought into my life to help further illuminate, uh, the truth of who God is. And so last year through divine appointments I co-authored a song, um, with three other musicians. One is Kim Walker-Smith, the amazing singer coming out of Bethel. And another is Mitch Wong, who is a Christian Grammy and Dove winner. Um, he's in Nashville. And the other is Mia Fields, who's also in Nashville. So we wrote the song in Nashville. Uh, Mia Fields comes out of Hillsong, and she signs- Oh with Scary Records.

Carrie SheffieldAnd so we wrote this song together. Um, and I've described it as my 90,000-word book in a 200-word song. And the title is My Heavenly Father Is. Oh. And I will be... Uh, I've sung it a few times for a few different events. I sang it, um, at the Museum of the Bible, um, in December for an event on helping persecuted Christians. I sang it at a men's addiction recovery shelter in Winston-Salem last year. And, uh, we will be singing it, I will be singing it with a choir, with the, the College of the Ozarks Choir. They just gave me the instrumentation for it yesterday, which I'm so excited for.

Carrie SheffieldUh, but the... It's called My Heavenly Father Is because it basically distinguishes between when we suffer child abuse at the hands of our earthly father, Mm-hmm to know who our true father is, who is our, our heavenly Father. And, and even who my, my father's earthly father, you know, didn't know how to take care of him and didn't know how to nurture him out of the trauma that he suffered. And so, but the, the, the lyrics are based on the passage in the Bible where Jesus says,"Who among you if your son asks for bread you would give a stone? If he asks for a fish, you would give a serpent?" Well, when there's child abuse, unfortunately the Father does give stones and He does give serpents.

Carrie SheffieldOh. And so the, the, the narrative is about how an encounter with Jesus helps us to drop the stones and, and in exchange we receive bread of life. Oh. And we touch the streaks and we, we receive the, the nurturing fish from our heavenly Father.

Lara SilvermanOh, I just love that. I have to listen to that song. I haven't... You know, it, it, it's public? It's released? Did you say it's

Carrie Sheffieldbeen con- Yeah. Yeah. Uh, if folks wanna check it out, I, on my homepage I have a music page, and, um, I've got a link to the, when we first... The first public debut was in Nashville at an event with Great American Media, and so I've got the, the song there.

Lara SilvermanUm- Remind me again, so you're a singer on top of violinist. We're gonna get to, to this later. Yes. But okay. Yes. Yeah, I think, yeah, you... I think I have seen you sing on your Instagram. I, I need to refresh my memory, but I, yeah, I, I mean, this lady is so talented. I've seen your violin performances, some of them on Instagram I believe. But I, I wanna ask you, you know, I know from your book that you were the first sibling, if you will, or the first child to break free from this toxic belief system. So what did that cost you? Like, I mean, sort of obvious, but you know, emotionally and relationally'Cause that takes incredible courage.

Lara SilvermanI mean, talk about like an Esther-type situation in some ways, you know?

Carrie SheffieldYeah. Um, so I am number five in the birth order, and I'm also the first girl. So I have four, I have four big brothers. Oh, wow and unfortunately, two of the older brothers are schizophrenic now. Just- Oh. Uh, and I, I l- I sometimes jokingly say I, I have a big, fat Mormon family. So I have, I have hundreds of second and third cousins. I have cousins who have kids who are having kids. So, you know, I, I'm one of eight, my cousins have 10, and other cousins, they have 11, another has eight. And those kids, you know, l- my aunts and uncles, they have kids who have eight and nine kids.

Carrie SheffieldAnd none of them have schizophrenia. And so I think when you have two in one family, where there's smoke, there's fire. Yeah and these two brothers of mine, they were, they were healthy boys. They were healthy. Hmm. Um, I mean, one has autism. He's been diagnosed with that, which is correlated with schizophrenia, but I do believe that and I would write an affidavit for this, that if it were not for this child abuse, they would not have schizophrenia. I do believe that, because child abuse is highly correlated with schizophrenia. And, um, and I get... I talk a little bit in the book, and maybe since I'm guessing you have musicians watching this, there's a really interesting concept that I figured out a few years ago that I talk about in the book, um, and it's, it's called HSP.

Carrie SheffieldAre you familiar with HSP, Laura?

Lara SilvermanNo.

Carrie SheffieldSo it's, um, it stands for highly sensitive people, which is- Oh I think they should get a different term for it. But, but in any case, um, it was discovered by this psychologist named Elaine Aron, A-R-O-N. And so there's a, a- Oh kind of a rubric. You can take a, an assessment. I think it's called the, the, the Ar- the Aron Assessment or something like that. And you can take it and just see, uh, it's, it's not a disorder, but it's a descriptor. So HSP people, and, and it's shown up in MRIs, so this is not just something made up. You can actually see the brain pattern activity is different for people who are HSP.

Carrie SheffieldAnd what it basically, how it manifests is that, and it's about 20%, between 15 to 20% of the general population is HSP. So about 20%, let's say, roughly. My amygdala, my insula, certain regions of my brain are more high- highly activated than the other 80% of the population. And a lot of musicians and artists- Mm and very creative people are HSP, which is part of why they are so good at music or art, because they, they have a really good ear or a good eye. They know how to see subtleties that the average person can't.

Carrie SheffieldBecause And I And it's funny'cause, and maybe you're this way, when I hear out of tune music or I, I just hear, I hear music, uh, that's played wrong, I just, I get s- It's painful. It

Lara Silvermanhurts. Yeah.

Carrie SheffieldAnd, and it is, it is, it is a biological reality. And so, and what's very interesting also, and I, I don't know you very well, but you seem like an extroverted person. Um- Oh,

Lara Silvermanyeah.

Carrie SheffieldMost people who are HSP are actually introverted. Um, and

Lara Silvermanso- Oh, that, that casts me out.

Carrie SheffieldYeah. Well, no, but here's the thing. Well,

Lara Silvermanyeah.

Carrie SheffieldSome are I, I, I am an extroverted HSP. Huh which is only when you do the slice and dice of the math, only about 2.5% of the people in the world are a female extroverted HSP. So add that to my, my layers of, of why in many rooms I don't feel like exactly I belong, because- No so many extroverts who I know, I, I'm like,"I don't understand how you're this way." I'm They, they d- they, they look at the world differently. They're Because literally their brains, most extroverts- Wow are not HSP.

Carrie SheffieldAnd so, um- Yeah it's, it was very helpful for me to understand that self-awareness. And I would- All that to say is that just to long answer your, your question about my siblings and being fifth in the birth order, when it comes to outcomes for parenting for a, parenting a child with HSP, they've, they have tracked that children who suffer child abuse and are HSP, they actually have worse outcomes than a child who is abused and does not have HSP. Mm. The non-ed- non-HSP abused child can be more resilient because their brain is less affected.

Lara SilvermanHmm.

Carrie SheffieldThe flip side is also true. Interesting. A child who is HSP who is loved has better outcomes than a child who is loved who is not HSP. Huh. And that, that is to me just, it was powerful for me to understand that wiring as an adult later on because it helped me understand s- why so much When I see my siblings, I, I have tried so hard to, to help them see how much God wants to love and heal them. And they w- they, it's very hard for them to accept it. And they you know, I think of in the Bible where Jesus asked the man at the pool of Bethesda,"Do you want to be healed?"

Lara SilvermanHmm.

Carrie SheffieldAnd instead of saying yes, he makes excuses.

Lara SilvermanYeah.

Carrie SheffieldAnd so w- that's what I've seen in my recovery, is that I had to say yes. And sometimes with childhood trauma quite often, it is hard to say yes because- Yeah your brain is telling you it's not possible. Your brain is telling you, your subconscious wiring has told you that it's You are stuck. You are, you are broken. You need to prove your worth. It can be very difficult to imagine something different. And so I, I, um, I The cost, the answer to your question, what was the cost of being the first?

Lara SilvermanYeah.

Carrie SheffieldMy dad said my blood changed. I was no longer his daughter. I was disowned. Oh. I was not allowed home all through college. But eventually several other siblings started to leave, and so the dam burst and then I was allowed back home if I wanted for Christmas or whatnot. So I would visit, but I, I've not spent a night under my parents' roof since I was 18, and I'm 43 now, because I just didn't-

Lara SilvermanWow

Carrie SheffieldI didn't, I didn't feel safe in part due to having two schizophrenic brothers, including one who assaulted me and another who said I tried to seduce him in- to have sex with him. Um- Oh and my brothers My dad said,"Yes, you dress like a slut. You, you deserved it." And so

Lara SilvermanOh. Yeah.

Carrie SheffieldSo it's just a very, um It's complicated. And so much of what I've learned recently is about boundaries. Mm-hmm. And you can't want healing more than someone else wants it.

Lara SilvermanHmm. I'm just digesting that. It's so powerful. It's like, it's hard because when you're the one When you did go through trauma, like I understand your siblings' perspective and your perspective'cause it's like your mind is just thinking,"Can I even trust this truth that I can change?" Like it sounds like a fantasy. Like, and, and this kind of hearkens to, I was gonna bring it up later but I'll bring it up now, like Romans 12:2 where the Lord says,"Renew your mind," like transform your mind. You actually have the mind of Christ. Like we are sitting from a place of victory right now, but when you've been traumatized, it is so hard to be like,"Lord, do I even believe that this is possible?" And B, how do I actually implement that?

Lara SilvermanAnd so I'm wondering if you can speak into-'Cause I know in your book you discuss how you did struggle with mental health struggles in college and early adulthood, like the depression and the, and the anxiety. I mean, who wouldn't? And then add on top of this your HSP, you know, s- st- situation, you know, or your, your brain, the way your brain works. So how did you go about, or how did the Lord help you start renewing your mind, like flipping the switch such that now, years later, you are this accomplished powerhouse who is not fighting these lies in your mind, or lies- Yeah about scripture, let's put it that way.

Carrie SheffieldYeah. Well, to be clear, I'm still battling it. I battle it every day. But- Th-

Lara Silvermanwell, that's the- I would say- Christian li- yeah the battle

Carrie Sheffieldis- Thank you for being

Lara Silvermanhonest

Carrie Sheffieldthe battle, It's easier now. It's definitely easier now, so that's, praise God for that. But I've, like, I've also sometimes thought of my, my brain as almost like a, you know like when your battery's charged, like it, it kind of goes up, like, like the level goes up. Like, I've thought of, like, as I get rid of my trauma brain, it's like the darkness is, is like, it's going, it's shrinking, and then it's, it's just... And I feel, I feel more filled with light and, uh, in my brain. And- Mm and so there are a lot of tools and techniques and things that have worked for me.

Carrie SheffieldI'm not giving advice here as a therapist. I'm not a licensed therapist. I thought about becoming one, but I just realized, you know, I am not, that's not my calling. I've, I've been through so much, and essentially these days I am essentially a social worker sadly, with my siblings.

Lara SilvermanUgh

Carrie Sheffieldand it's not something I wanna do, but, um-

Lara SilvermanYeah

Carrie SheffieldI just didn't feel called to then take on other burdens outside of that right now. Um-

Lara SilvermanRight

Carrie Sheffieldhowever, what I can do is share what worked for me and some of the tools that I have found, and that others, you know, I, I didn't make this stuff up. It's coming from seeing a lot of scientifically proven techniques. So, uh, finding a therapist who is trained in somatic techniques. So one of the big, like I mentioned the subconscious. The sub- Right brain is really just from a scriptural lens, I think of it as in the New Testament where it says, I believe it's Paul, he says,"I keep doing things that I don't wanna do, and I don't do the things I wanna do."

Lara SilvermanRomans 7, man. Yes. Yeah. That- I cling to it every day.

Carrie SheffieldYeah. I, that is what I, I interpret that as, uh, the subconscious, because like I said, I can think above the, the, um, the waterline of, of, of the, uh, the iceberg. I can think something intellectually, but if in my subconscious there is a toxic feedback loop, a toxic inner critic, uh, that is feeding me the below the water, the 90%, then- Yep then it's, it is at war with itself the conscious and the subconscious. And I would recommend reading works, uh, by Carl Jung, who, Oh, yeah created a school of psychology that was basically contradicting a lot of the Freudian stuff- And I will say as a sidebar our HHS Secretary, uh, Kennedy has said that he credits his recovery from a, from drug addiction to Carl Jung because, um, he said that I wrote a piece about this for The Daily Signal.

Carrie SheffieldUm, uh, he has said, Secretary Kennedy has said in his interviews that in the throes of his addiction, he had made a promise to himself that if there was e- even any modality that would give him just a 1% improvement, that he would do it. And so he came across this book, I believe it was God inspired to put a Carl Jung book in his hands. And basically Carl Jung said after seeing thousands and thousands of patients that it was those who believed in God, they saw the most growth in their mental health. And so he said,"Okay. Mm. Well, I told myself I would do it, so I'm gonna start believing in God." And so he credits that belief in God with his ability to break that addiction of drugs.

Carrie SheffieldAnd so all, you know, anything that can really retrain the subconscious, Mm is powerful. And I, I w- uh, a couple different workshops that I went to that I can recommend to folks. One is called, uh, Atlas. It's, um, it's called The Atlas Project. The website is just atlasproject.org. It's a nonprofit.

Lara SilvermanO- okay

Carrie Sheffieldand this essentially... And I can send you, I wrote an essay about what happened for me in it, but, um, it's, if you go through the whole program, it takes about four months because it takes months to create a new, a new pattern or a new, um, behavior. But that program significantly helped me rewire my subconscious. They have it in Austin, Texas, and they have it in Las Vegas, so it's, it is required to be in person. I went to Austin, Texas five times in 2024. Every trip was worth it. Flying from Washington, DC, it was that worth it to figure out how can I rewire my subconscious.

Carrie SheffieldAnd I realized how much, uh, of my inner voice was undermining me and I was repeating the lies that my father had spoken over me. And so, you know, my book is called Motor Home Prophecies, and I, uh, the, the, the, the Bible tells us that life and death are in the power of the tongue. Mm. And I would add that- Oh the inner tongue, the subconscious tongue, uh, the tongue that was encoded in our subconscious brains from zero to eight that we don't even realize. Um, and so this program resurfaced that subconscious and helped hold a mirror up to it.

Carrie SheffieldAnother program that was very powerful for me that I went it's an hour outside Nashville. It's called On Site. And, uh, it is clinically managed. The website is experienceonsite.com. It's, uh, run by therapists who help, help, um- identify and defeat, uh, these self-defeating narratives. And so here's the thing about therapy. I, I, I agree. There was a book that came out recently called Bad Therapy. And it's by an investigative journalist with the Wall Street Journal, and it's a fantastic book.

Carrie SheffieldIt's by Abigail Shrier, and it's a critique of the therapy industry and how so much of it has been overrun by people who, you know, encourage children to chop off body parts. And, Right

Lara Silvermanas

Carrie SheffieldI was saying, they, they are disconnected, a lot of them, from, most of them from the healing power of God. And that is where the deceiver wants us to fall in either ditch. You know, that's what, um- Mm-hmm that's what CS Lewis said. You know, the evil one either wants us to talk about him too much or not enough. Mm-hmm. And I think with therapy it's like the evil one wants us to either completely throw it out or to have it be taken over by people who don't understand what really works. And I, I believe, uh, there is always a third way. There is always the way of appreciating the tools of people like Carl Jung and therapists like the, the ones at OnSite, um, who, who really helped me develop boundaries.

Carrie SheffieldThere's a, uh, there's an amazing book called Boundaries that has sold more than 2 million copies by two very well-known Christian therapists. Um-

Lara SilvermanI've heard of that one, yeah.

Carrie SheffieldSo yeah, I could keep going on. The other thing about physical, um, healing, I, I'm really into experiences that help me become aware of my physical body and what, what, what are my emotions feeling. 'Cause again, this is something that as a, uh, you know, scoring in the top 1% of academic achievement people... You know, I can think. I could go to Harvard. I, you, you went to Stanford. We can think. We can think. You know, I, I, I worked at Goldman Sachs. This is y- Once you become a brain, just a brain on legs, you're disconnected from your emotions.

Lara SilvermanThat's good, a brain on legs. Yeah.

Carrie SheffieldYeah.

Lara SilvermanAnd- That's like me, basically, yeah.

Carrie SheffieldYeah. Well, and the thing about traumatic childhoods is that that's a very similar outcome too. So compounding that with having a big brain, where it's like... And again, I'm not trying to brag or whatever. I'm j- I, that's-

Lara SilvermanNo, I know what you're

Carrie Sheffieldsaying my, my reality that- especially I think as even as conservative Christians it can be so easy to cerebralize life. And, and yes, the principles of conservative Christian ideas, they, they work, but if your subconscious wiring is so misaligned, you can't think your way out of things. Yep. You have to learn how to verbalize feelings that you were not allowed to verbalize experiencing child abuse- Mm or as an adult experiencing significant trauma.

Lara SilvermanMm. And that's where the somatic comes in. I, I wanna thank you because- Uh, just for admitting that, like, the struggle is still real, you know? Because, like, we don't wanna put, like, some bow on it and say, you know. Like, no, the Christian life is difficult. Like, whether you've come from a place of significant trauma or not, like, like Paul says,"Fight the good fight," and it's for a reason, because our flesh is constantly warring against our spirit woman, like the flesh versus the spirit. This is Galatians. And it took me a long time to recognize that myself, like, just having gone through so many years of trauma, being bedridden myself.

Lara SilvermanAnd, but when I realized that, like, no, this fight is almost intentional as a way to sanctify you, and I mean, that's a whole other theological bubble we could talk about. But I kinda wanna look into this Atlas thing now, because I think it would help me, because even though the Lord has called me to c- you know, renew my mind, I still do have strongholds where it's like the enemy will plant a lie,"No, God is not good because He took your husband. God is not good'cause you're still on a bed," or whatever the lie is, you know, from the pit of hell, you know? It's like, so I, I, I think I will look into that, and I don't, I do think there is a role for Christian therapy.

Lara SilvermanLike, like you said, it's like we don't wanna go the opposite direction and be like,"Oh, no, that's all, you know, the devil's playground and whatever." No, like, the Lord has used people in my life, oh my gosh, so many people. I wouldn't have gotten through eight years on a bed without, like, proper counseling and whatever to be able to take every thought captive. Because like you have experienced when you've gone through trauma, you're going,"Lord, I want to take this thought captive and make it obedient to you, but I literally can't because my subconscious is fighting me." So thank you for articulating so eloquently, like, what I've gone through.

Lara SilvermanLike, it makes me feel seen that I'm not the only believer who struggles with this, and we're, we're, you know, we're not the only ones. I wanna ask, I kinda wanna pivot, and, you know, uh, you know how the centuries-old problem of pain, where Christians and non-Christians face this issue of, like, how do we hold God's sovereignty and goodness on the one hand with the very real evil that shapes us? For you, I'm wondering, like, how did you cope with that question, like, as you were maturing, you know, maybe hit your 20s, and you're looking back being like,"Lord, if you're sovereign, why didn't you protect me?" Can you talk about how that shaped your view of God's goodness and how He rehabilitated that?

Carrie SheffieldOh, yeah. I mean, I, I, when I was agnostic and I c- I call agnostic in the book, I call it a, a cosmic fence-sitter, because you're, you're not an atheist- Mm but you're not a believer. So you're just- Right sitting on the fence. You just say,"I don't know." You're a cosmic shoulder shruggier. "I don't know.""Maybe there's a God, maybe there's not." But I reasoned to myself, if there was a God, He hated me, and I hated Him back, if He existed- Mm-hmm. Yeah for putting me in this family.

Lara SilvermanUm- Right

Carrie Sheffieldand, and yeah, it's something that I, I have wrestled with a lot. I, I have some ideas that have helped me t- to understand, uh, and to, to feel systematically uh, is that, Well, first there's, there's the, there's the endemic brokenness of the human experience, which is, you know, our physical bodies breaking down and earthquakes and natural disasters, things that are just sort of, uh, out of the human control. And then there is the human sin. And, and I've wrestled with both, uh, as I know we all do. Mm-hmm.

Carrie SheffieldAnd so the piece of the, the human, you know, trauma, abuse, human sin, uh, generational abuse, trauma, um, it's, uh... I had a pastor explain to me really well, which is, uh,'cause i- we were talking about it and he, and he, he stopped me when I kept using the word,"Why did God allow this?" And, and he said,"That's not the right way to think about it." He said because essentially humans, you know, we have, we, humans have free will because we are made in the image of God.

Carrie SheffieldAnd so, and God is free, and God has free will. So if we are made in God's image, it is actually part of the exact blueprint that we have free will. And so it's, it's sort of like to say he allowed it, it's sort of like it's doesn't really fit because it is actually inherent in our design as a human made in God's image because God is free. And so God if we are in God's image, which we are, we have the freedom to sin- Right

Lara Silvermanum, to

Carrie Sheffieldchoose righteousness. Um, and so that was interesting in the sense that, I mean, I, I know this concept of free will is something that is you know, lots of theologians have written a lot about. Is the trade-off. It, the trade-off of free will is if the free will to sin and to abuse children and to commit all sorts of heinous acts like human trafficking and all that. And that is where the redemption of Jesus comes in. And, uh, the, the, the last line of, I've not read them, but I've seen the, the PBS, uh, you know, Lion, Witch, Wardrobe, the, the Chronicles of Narnia series.

Carrie SheffieldOh,

Lara Silvermanyeah.

Carrie SheffieldAnd, but it basically ends with this line that, um, through, through Christ, everything sad will be made untrue. Um-

Lara SilvermanOh, I love it

Carrie Sheffieldand that, when I first heard that, I just, I started crying. I was just like,"Really?"

Lara SilvermanIt sounds like a fairy tale, right? Yeah.

Carrie SheffieldBut, but I, but I have seen that in my life though, and that's what's, I've seen it even here on earth, and I just, I know that, um- Mm in the next life it will be even more true. Mm-hmm. Um, but I've seen it in my life where I've gotten to the point where I've created what I call my locust list.

Lara SilvermanOh. And- Oh, I love that verse in Joel

Carrie SheffieldYes. They're called-

Lara SilvermanLike, redeem the years the lo- the locusts have stolen locusts

Carrie Sheffieldhave devoured. Yes. And so I have created an ongoing list- Of- Oh love this list of, like, very specific ways God has redord- res- resteemed- Yeah resteemed and redord. Redeemed and restored specific things. I said,"Laura, I, I know He, He is restoring and redeeming those eight years you were in a bed."

Lara SilvermanUm-

Carrie SheffieldOh,

Lara Silvermanthank you so much He

Carrie Sheffieldis. And, and and the fact that yes, the, and I, I mentioned the story of Joseph, that because of the suffering Joseph went through, he wouldn't have been able to do what he did to restore and redeem the health and the, the vitality and, and preserve s- the civilization, including his own family, from famine. Um- Right he was at that place at the right time because, because of the abuse, because of the rejection, because of the lies. So it's almost like his, um, his resume, if you will.

Carrie SheffieldThis was his resume of trauma and rejection and betrayal is what qualified him with the ability and the connections. Uh, you know, it's, uh So I sometimes jokingly say that my book is my anti-resume,'cause there's, on LinkedIn we always post the things we're excited about-

Lara SilvermanRight and

Carrie Sheffieldproud of,

Lara SilvermanAll the accomplishments, all the 4.0s, all the accolades.

Carrie SheffieldYeah. But, but the things that qualify us the most, um, are the Joseph things. Those, those are the anti-resumes, you know? And I have a friend who works in fighting poverty and he said, uh, you know, I, I, I'm, I'm more interested in the kind of what you've been through than any credentialing after your name. And so, like for me, for example, the, that, that ACE score that I mentioned, Adverse Childhood Experience score, my score is eight out of 10, which puts me, again, in the top 1% of child abuse. Most Americans only have zero or one.

Carrie SheffieldIt's a scale of one to 10, and it's specific things that happen to you. Not having enough food, physical abuse, a family member in jail, different things. I have eight out of 10 on sort of the standard metric, and most Americans have zero or one, maybe two. Only about, if you have five or more, I think it's only about 15% of the American population. So the high- the more you get. And so I, I met a fellow ACE eight. At, and our, based on the statistics, ACE eight is 12 times more likely to attempt suicide, uh, I believe- Yeah between four and six times more likely to be a drug addict or an alcoholic.

Carrie SheffieldSo I have defied the odds of someone with my ACE profile. And I, and it turns out that the lead clinician at OnSite, he is an ACE eight. And if you look at his, on their, their website, this is the, the therapy program I mentioned in Tennessee he's got, like, six letters after his name. He's got n- he's got a, he's got a, he's actually got an MDiv. He's got a master's- Oh in counseling. He's got all kinds of- Right certifications for certified this, certified this, you know, registered this, all these letter, alphabet soup after his name.

Carrie SheffieldAnd I said to him,"Carlos, you don't have Ace Eight after your last name." I said,"That is the most important credentialing to me, that-" Wow that, um... Because I've never met another Ace Eight who is not decimated and, you know, drug addicted. And, like-

Lara SilvermanHmm

Carrie SheffieldI, you are a miracle. I said that to him, and I said- Mm and he's, he helped me, as I mentioned, through this program. And, and I said,"You know, this is why you are the king of the therapists," I said, because you, he's the lead clinician out of this, you know, l- people come from all over the world to this program. And, um, so that's, I do believe that, And e- and even just in, in trying, you know, the submission as a Christian to submit as Christ did- and be able to see the beauty and the redemption through the suffering, and that that is really what qualifies.

Carrie SheffieldNot, not to use a, a, an LDS lens of qualifying for, for, uh, healing or, or worth, but it just from even a resume position, if you will, or an anti-resume, coming through suffering on the other side gives a lot more credibility for those who are coming behind us.

Lara SilvermanI mean, you articulate it so beautifully. Like, the Joseph story is one of my favorites in the Old Testament and the whole Bible generally. I mean, it's Genesis 50:20, what, what Satan intended for evil, God intended for good. It's like in God's upside-down kingdom, again, everything is flipped upside down. Pain leads to promotion. Like, we, like, this is a Lord whom works power through weakness. Like, look at Paul with the thorn in the flesh. Like, look at the cross leading to glory. Like, the kingdom is so upside down. And one of the principles is, and thank you for reminding me and refreshing my own heart on my own story, it's like when He allows you to go through trauma, there is always a redemptive purpose for it.

Lara SilvermanAnd we might not see it on this side of eternity always, but He is working it. And I love the journals, the restoration journals that you are holding. I should, I do journal because I, you know, I don't wanna forget stuff. But I, I love the sort of locust frame on that. Like- Yeah

Carrie Sheffieldlike

Lara Silvermanfrom locust- I, I keep the-

Carrie SheffieldYeah I keep the locust list on my, my notes,'cause that's something I update in real time. I keep that separate from my journal. But yes, my locust list, I add to it. I just added something last week, so.

Lara SilvermanAnd, and so just to go back to some of the s- just for a brief bit, on the darker places, when you did respond in anger, let's say before you were more fully healed, how did the Lord respond to you? Like, was He tender when you were like,"Why did you steal a good childhood from me?" Or did you not struggle with those emotions? I'm just curious, like, was the Lord tender with you in those angry places?

Carrie SheffieldYeah. Oh, yeah. I've had many, many conversations, and screaming, groaning. Even the Bible says, you know, there are words that we can't even gro- we can't even articulate- Yeah those inner groans. And that's the thing about childhood trauma, is that it can be very difficult to even verbalize what's happened. Because when you're pre-verbal and trauma happens or, or you're not taught the language of emotion this trauma just becomes trapped in many ways in your body. And so to release it through tears, through...

Carrie SheffieldAnd I've done a lot of punching bags. One thing that is very proven to lower the limbic system is singing. Hmm and not just listening to music, actually singing with your own voice. Because singing with your voice, and this is why so many monks also will do chants like Gregorian chants and, uh, humming. Humming and singing of your own voice, not listening to someone else, calms your limbic system. It, this is

Lara Silvermanproven- It triggers the vagus nerve, right?

Carrie SheffieldExactly.

Lara SilvermanYeah.

Carrie SheffieldIt does. And so that's one thing that I love to do in my Christian services. I'm part of, uh, Christian worship teams, is I love to help lead music. And I just sang at the, the, uh, Trump-Kennedy Center in March, and I led The Star-Spangled Banner, uh- Aw for an event where we talked about, you know, the celebration of America 250 and Freedom 250 this year. That's so important, I think, as, as not only civically but also spiritually, to let your voice, your limbic system be joined in synchrony with others.

Lara SilvermanHmm. Yeah, no. I mean, I've... Yeah, music has healed a lot of my anger. I mean, iron- I mean, it's not ironic. It's... Yeah, music is just so healing for me, and the Lord has used that for me in so many ways, as I put in my book. And If you've ever felt like life's challenges are burning a little too hot and asking the Lord why, I wrote something just for you. My number one bestselling Christian memoir, Singing Through Fire, is about finding Christ's surprising joys in the middle of life's most severe storms. As someone who's lost my health, career, and husband, I have a lot to say about how God walks us through great grief.

This book is for those who have questioned God's will or struggled with bitterness, anger, or a thousand unanswered questions, yet who still dared to believe that Christ is right there in the flames with us. It's filled with honest theological wrestling, tons of comedy, and many biblical reasons why God allows suffering. Some will definitely surprise you. If you're walking through loss today, this book will give you powerful hope and faith to keep trusting and make you laugh and ugly cry at the same time. You can grab Singing Through Fire on retailers like Amazon and Barnes Nobles, or just copy-paste the link in the description below.

Some tragedies don't tie up in a redemptive bow on this side of heaven, but in Christ, redemption is always awaiting us in eternity. So let's keep singing through the fire together.

Lara SilvermanAnd it sounds like your story is very similar as well, because you do have that talent, and the Lord will use everything and anything to bring us back to Him. I'm wondering, were you able to get to a point where you said about your parents, you know,"Father, forgive them for..." I mean, you, for they do not know what they're doing." In other words, you mentioned this earlier, but have you been able to surrender to forgiveness? And I'm a-guessing the Lord has called you to that, because He doesn't let us... You know, I've experienced that. What's your story?

Carrie SheffieldYeah. And that's, I mean, that is one of the subtitles of the book,'cause if you look at the book, it's Murder and Prophecies: A Journey of Healing and Forgiveness.

Lara SilvermanHmm.

Carrie SheffieldMm-hmm.

Lara SilvermanUm,

Carrie Sheffieldand again, it's not, it is not a linear journey. It's not a perfect journey of forgiveness. But, um, but I have a whole chapter on forgiveness. And a big part of that was forgiving my dad. And, Oh, my gosh I talk about an, an encounter with him that I had where I came with a posture of forgiveness toward him. And and part of it was because of my friend Anthony, who I mentioned. You know, he forgave- Right he gave, he forgave the murderer Oh

Lara Silvermanmy gosh, I can't. Oh my gosh

Carrie Sheffieldit was actually, it was, it was just this international headline because in the bond hearing for this murderer who had killed his wife and these eight other people the judge let the family members speak to him, to the accused. Oh. And one by one, they forgave him. And a lot of them were Christians, including my friend Anthony, who is a pastor. Um, he said,"I forgive you. Give your life to Christ." And he's actually visited this murderer in jail and done his best to minister. He's, he's, he's very intransigent.

Carrie SheffieldHe has no interest in Jesus. Wow. But, uh, but Anthony's committed- That's good to forgiving him. And, um, so I, I mean, I just, I, after meeting Anthony, I was just like- Oh you know, I can do this. I can forgive my dad. But I think- Wow that a big part of recovery from trauma is forgiving ourselves, um- Mm and forgiving ourselves for the self-sabotage, um, that happens. Uh, I'll make a reference that, uh, is from a movie that you might not be expecting from a classical musician, but but, uh, Talladega Nights, if that movie, uh-

Lara SilvermanOh, I haven't seen, yeah

Carrie Sheffieldit's that, it's a movie about a NASCAR racer. But the father of the main driver, um, he's, he's a drug addict. I mean, he's an addict and maybe an alcoholic. I forget exactly his addiction. Some substance addicted father. Um, The Ballad of Ricky Bobby, Ricky Bobby's father. And there's a scene in there where the, toward the end of the movie, I don't wanna spoil it, but-

Lara SilvermanHmm the

Carrie Sheffieldaddict father, they try to have a nice family dinner, and it actually goes really, really well. But it goes so well that the ex-wife, who's the mother of Bobby, they're divorced, she's like,"Look how amazing we can be. Like, let's, why don't we keep doing this?" You know? And then the wiring- Hmm kicks in and, and, and the father can't deal with it, and he flips the table over. And he says,"I'm an addict. I can't do this." Um- Hmm you know? And it's just, that scene really spoke to me because that's what happens when we're s- when we are so subconsciously wired to believe a lie.

Lara SilvermanYeah.

Carrie SheffieldReceiving something beautiful, receiving a healthy relationship, receiving love, it actually feels like a threat. Oh. And so, so that's a whole other layer that we like, we can do in a different podcast. Um, but, uh, but it's, it's something that I know Jesus wants us to receive.

Lara SilvermanI mean, I, first of all, my jaw was on the floor about Anthony's forgiveness of the killer of his wife. I mean, I, I just can't even process that level of spiritual maturity. Like I, you know, I can't even forgive, you know, someone who gave me a Band-Aid in fourth grade or whatever, like, let alone... Or you know what I'm say- Like, I'm, I'm being facetious, but I'm just so encouraged by your own testimony that you have been able to find that peace, and it's only through the Holy Spirit's power, right? I'm not sure if you wanna get into this, and we can keep it brief but I'm wondering if you can give us a quick gloss on that near-death experience that deeply impacted, you know, c- I don't know if it, if you'd wanna talk about that or if we should save that, you know, people wanna get into your book or...

Carrie SheffieldYeah. I, I go in depth about it in the book, but it was essentially, um, in my pursuit for trying to prove my worthiness. I, I created a media company in New York, um, and I, I ran it for four years, but by the end it was running me. Oh. And it was a digital TV network. I was co-hosting a talk show with Clay Aiken, the American Idol singer. Oh. It was a bipartisan left right talk show because he's a Democrat, I'm Republican.

Lara SilvermanRight.

Carrie SheffieldAnd it was just growing. We were getting a ton of pickups. Back when Tucker Carlson was on Fox, he played one of our interviews on his primetime program. We had The View pick up one of our clips. W- it was- Mm-hmm we had citations, you know, from our clips in New York Times, Washington Post you know, all sorts of other programs and, and media outlets quoting these TV interviews we were doing with my media company. But I let this become a false idol, and I, I, I let- Oh this happen while I was a Christian. I, I really fell into the pit of, in some ways, prosperity gospel.

Carrie SheffieldAnd this was- Oh very early into my Christian walk, a couple years. And- Right I, I think I had in some toxic way sort of fused this idea that because I was now a Christian, everything had to work out for me. And that is so not true. And I ignored b- I ignored the pain signals from my body. I ignored the red flags- Mm-hmm my body was giving me. Mm-hmm. And so eventually one day about four years into, uh, you know, after I'd started planning the startup, about three and a half years after we'd launched I woke up with a severe pain in the back of my neck.

Carrie SheffieldAnd I describe it as like a taser implanted in the back of my neck, just throbbing, throbbing, throbbing in the back of my neck. Pulsating, pulsating, pulsating. And it was so painful. I, even lying down actually made it worse'cause it was compressing and making the pulsation more compressed and painful. And so I couldn't sleep. I, I started to get into insomnia. Um, and then just really bad migraines because of the insomnia. Oh. And so I just didn't know why this pulsating taser feeling was happening in the back of my neck.

Carrie SheffieldAnd so it started a long process- Just you can get the full story of the book, but I was in the hospital seven times in 2019. Wow. And two of those times were from allergic reactions to drugs- Oh in those five times, and one of them almost killed me. It was, uh... I did not know this, but I learned after that if, if the sodium levels in our body drops too low- Too

Lara Silvermanlow, yep

Carrie Sheffieldwe will die, because our brain- Oh needs salt. It's like salted meat. The sodium helps regulate the brain. If it, we don't have enough, the brain swells, and because the skull is fixed, then we die. So there's no room for the brain to go. And so I had an allergic reaction to one of the drugs they gave me in one of the other visits, and it caused hyponatremia, which is the dropping of the sodium levels. And thank God my friend called the ambulance. They took me to the hospital. They checked my levels. They're like,"Your sodium is at, like, approaching brain damage level." And they, they put an IV bag on, pumped me full of sodium.

Carrie SheffieldAnd it was interesting,'cause I went back and reviewed previous physical exams,'cause when you do, they, you know, they do labs for regular.

Lara SilvermanYeah. I've

Carrie Sheffieldalways had apparently borderline low sodium. Like, I've-

Lara SilvermanI'm that way, too. Yeah.

Carrie SheffieldYeah. So, so I'm never one of those where it's like I gotta watch... I have to watch my salt, and then I have to eat more salt. And so, uh- I salt my food. But I'll just close with this. I know we're wrapping. You know, I, I have these I- IV scars. Uh, you probably can't see them, but I have an IV scar here, and I have an IV scar here. I talk about these IV scars in my book. They're from those seven hospital stays,'cause it's just like,"Oh, here I am again. Poke the needle again. Hooked up to the machines." And, um, and I thought about those scars when I was singing at the Kennedy Center,

Lara SilvermanHmm the

Carrie SheffieldKennedy Center, excuse me this year how these two arms, you know, the same arms with the needles and the scars, it's like I'm now, I'm, they're outstretched, and, and I'm wearing this, this beautiful red gown that I love, and I'm singing with these wi- arms wide open, and I'm full of joy, and I'm just, I'm on the concert hall, main stage of the of, of the John Kennedy Center. Like, the most beautiful concert hall in my, in my view i- in America. And, um, and leading the national anthem as a soloist. Hmm. And I'm just like, wow.

Carrie SheffieldI have really... I think I've had pretty much kind of one of the lowest of the lows experiences that a human can have, but now one of the highest. And,

Lara SilvermanHmm

Carrie Sheffieldand I thought, you know, we just recently had Easter. I, I thought of Mary Magdalene and how Mary Magdalene, the Bible tells us she was possessed by seven demons. We don't ex- know exactly-

Lara SilvermanOh, right. Right

Carrie Sheffieldbut, um, but her encounter with Christ. And I, and I love, I love the TV show The Chosen because it really highlights this. It starts-

Lara SilvermanI love it, too

Carrie Sheffieldit starts with her. It starts with Mary Magdalene.

Lara SilvermanYep.

Carrie SheffieldUm, and it's just this violent, demonic possession that she's, she's fighting. She meets Jesus, and she's completely transformed. And she's this beautiful woman with flowers in her hair, and she's hosting dinner parties. Mm. She's a different person. And, and who was the first person that Christ chose to show himself in the garden?

Lara SilvermanMm. After

Carrie Sheffieldhis resurrection, the first human being- I

Lara Silvermanlove it

Carrie Sheffieldto witness this was Mary Magdalene. It wasn't the disciples. I love that. It wasn't even John, the one he loved. It was Mary Magdalene. And, and he- Mm instructed her,"Go and tell my brothers what you've seen." And that's, you know, in the Catholic Church, they call her, like, the evangelist to the evangelists. And so- Mm wow, Mary Magdalene had pretty much the lowest of the low and the highest of the high of the experiences in the human existence. And so I just, I, I've, I feel I've had echoes of that in my life, and I, I'm s- I'm sure you can, can relate to that, Lara.

Lara SilvermanThank you so much. I, I, I will close by saying this. Like, I have seen the Lord flip something evil into something that carries so much purpose and redemption in your life. Like Paul says, that his chains serve to advance the gospel, and I know that the Lord is literally using your suffering through your book to advance, you know, your testimony, and through that, his gospel. So I just cannot thank you enough, Carrie, for joining us. And for everyone listening, until next time, if you are suffering, this is not the end of your story. Christ has redemptive power. We've seen it through Carrie's story, and he's going to do it through yours, too.

Lara SilvermanSo thank you so much, everyone, and God bless. Be sure to hit subscribe because I upload content every week to help other sufferers. To God be the glory.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. From Prostitution to Evangelism: Alisa Spilberg's Testimony | STF Podcast Ep. 46

    Nov 17, 202655 minAudio

    In this episode of Singing Through Fire, host Lara Silverman welcomes evangelist Alisa Spielberg to the Faith in the Furnace series. From childhood trauma and a life marked by addiction and prostitution to an encounter...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Finding Faith After Losing a Child to Lyme Disease | Jody Hudson’s Story | STF Podcast Ep. 45

    Nov 10, 20261 hr 1 minAudio

    In this episode of Singing Through Fire, host Lara Silverman welcomes Jody Hudson to the Faith in the Furnace series. Jody is an award-winning author and founder of the Alex’s Hudson Lyme Foundation. She shares the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Mick Wienholt Survived an Avalanche. Then He Lost His Son. | STF Podcast Ep. 44

    Nov 3, 20261 hr 5 minAudio

    In this episode of Singing Through Fire, host Lara Silverman continues the Faith in the Furnace series with Mick Wienholt, host of Coincidence or God?, previously known as When You Look. At 19, Mick survived an...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. God calls us to JOY right in the middle of sorrow | STF Podcast Ep. 43

    Oct 27, 202632 minAudio

    Can we experience joy and grief at the same time? In this episode, Lara talks about what it means to rejoice in the middle of suffering without pretending the pain isn't real. Drawing from Scripture and her experiences...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. A Love That Endures: Ara & Esther Assilian’s 13-Year Journey with Their Son | STF Podcast Ep. 42

    Oct 20, 202649 minAudio

    In this episode of Singing Through Fire, host Lara Silverman interviews Ara and Esther Assilian about raising their son Hirad, who suffered severe brain damage at birth. After spending three days on a respirator, Hirad...

    Credit the people on this episode