[Episode 46] Jealousy, Shadow Work & The Ideal Muslimah
20 minAudio
Straight to the point. To the young people who are finding their way around the “practicing" sphere and may be wondering how someone could present as religious and a “good person” but behave in passive aggressive, catty or competitive ways. What you're seeing is real, unfortunately. Don't dismiss your instincts because it's an “Islamic” environment and deny your gut feelings because you thought this didn't happen. Stop doubting yourself when you notice that the energy is off and you receive the confirmation from their behaviour - it’s your cue to exit stage left. Walking away from unhealthy dynamics and toxic environments does not equate to turning your back on the dawah or service to the faith. It just means this may not be the right place for you to serve from. Call it what it is, no matter what it looks like on the outside. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit sumayah.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Hey guys, Assalamualaikum. So I have so much to say on this topic and I'm going to try to be as concise and clear as I can be. The thing I want to talk about today is jealousy and it's a specific kind of jealousy that is found in the Muslim community and the way that it shows up and the way that it's kind of disguised as piety and advice and A reminder and a warning
SPEAKER_00about not losing yourself or someone coming to help you stay humble and remember to be grateful and all of these kind of side doors that they try to come in to the same room. And ultimately, what it is, is that there are people who have the desire inside of themselves to achieve something, to do public facing work. To have attention, to be famous, to have work that has an impact,
SPEAKER_00to be known by people, to grow what they're doing, to scale, to whatever it is. And inside of themselves, they have this strong desire, but they have rules about what's possible and what's allowed and what's good and what is not. And so the parts of themselves that are not in agreement are in a fight. So you imagine two people tangled up in a brawl and they're rolling around on the ground and wrestling each other. And this fight is over whether or not they can, should,
SPEAKER_00will be able to, would be successful at, it would benefit or harm, all of this kind of hesitation and doubt and shame, self-reproach. Inner criticism, old voices, their own voices, other voices, all of these things are in this fight. All these hands are throwing punches and this person is struggling with that internally. And then they come across someone who they don't know from Adam out in the world who is doing the very thing or is doing something similar or who Relates to them
SPEAKER_00in some ways such that they consider themselves their peer. So they look at that person out in the world. They think that person's kind of like me. And yet that person is doing the thing. That person is out there. That person does speak up. That person uses their voice. That person does the very thing that they're wrestling with themselves about being able to do or being allowed to do. And so instead of addressing that internal brawl and seeing what steps they need to take in order to get clear about what it means for them and where they want
SPEAKER_00to head, instead of seeing that person and whatever they've done and whatever they are doing, As an expander, meaning as someone who kind of is an image of what's possible, like a role model or someone who's achieved an aspect of something that you want for yourself. The brawl stops. All of their parts turn and direct their attention to the shiny person. And they have this burning, desperate desire to say something nasty or condescending or to put the person in their place or to humble the person or to chastise the person.
SPEAKER_00And yet they want to do it in a clever way that doesn't compromise their image. They don't want to do it in a way that makes them look jealous and bitter and pent up and repressed. They don't want to show the reality of what their internal situation is actually like. So they dress it up in religious clothing. They dress it up in nasiha. They dress it up in an email where they say, be careful because being out there will get to your head. Remember to be humble. Remember to thank Allah.
SPEAKER_00Remember you don't need to always put yourself in people's face. Remember that there are men looking at you and maybe you shouldn't show your face and you should cover your, like whatever form it takes. It comes in some form where it's trying to come across as caring and malevolent and, oh, you know, like I don't, Benevolent, that's the right word, meaning you mean well and you're looking out for the person and you're just advising and you're just a sincere advisor, right? But really underneath it, there's a sting and it comes out in their words and they're not aware.
SPEAKER_00It actually shows in their manner. It shows in their words. It shows in their behavior, even though they put on a smile and they're like, oh my gosh. If you meet them in person, they'll try to come across as Genuine fans. They'll try to say something about the impact of the work. They'll try to, you know, they'll hug you. They'll embrace you. They'll do the whole thing to try and mask what's underneath. And what's underneath is all of this nastiness, all of this unfinished shadow work, all of this lack of self-acceptance, all of this internal...
SPEAKER_00Incongruence, Criticism, Negativity. And when they say something, it spills out. It shows in their behavior. When they get an opportunity to try and say something to knock you down a few notches, they say it in a snide way. It shows in the subtleties of their behavior. You can see it in the way they interact with other people versus the way they interact with you. And all of these things play out and you just start to realize, uh-huh, I suspected something was off. But I didn't have evidence.
SPEAKER_00And obviously, nobody knows what's inside of someone's heart. Nobody knows. I cannot say with certainty what someone feels or thinks. I cannot say I'm certain this person feels this way or thinks this way. I can only perceive something or understand it or make meaning based on my actual experience, meaning based on evidence, based on their behavior. And so... I may carry a suspicion. I may be aware of something. I may observe something, but then I hold and I'm going to see.
SPEAKER_00And the behavior is either going to confirm it or it's going to deny it, right? And so I think that this is a bigger problem than we let on. And it's something that we don't really talk about because you give people the benefit of the doubt. Muslim women tend towards self-doubt. Not listening to themselves, not trusting their instincts, not speaking up. They tend to do the sweeping under the rug thing because it helps not rock the boat. It helps keep things going. And on some level,
SPEAKER_00we're taught to believe that a good Muslim doesn't complain or rock the boat or call out toxic behavior or bad behavior because their understanding and their forbearing and their patient and all of these other things. This is a real problem. And I'm not talking about it in the sense that I think that we should go out and confront people and be like, I think you're a hater. And here's my evidence. You just create distance. For me, if I read something and it's confirmed, the answer to that is distance.
SPEAKER_00Why am I putting myself in an environment where people are secretly haters? Why am I working with people who actively take steps to try to diminish my impact? And it's baffling because you think, why invite someone to the table, tell them to sit down, serve them, and then actively keep taking food off their plate? What was the purpose of this exercise? Don't invite them to the table. What is it for? Unless the invitation serves another purpose,
SPEAKER_00unless they are trying to gain something else from your presence other than what you're there to do. And so it's so It's so large and I have endless example. I have seen it in so many places and I want to reiterate that because the work is under the quote unquote Islamic sphere does not mean that people are immune to this type of behavior, the cattiness, the competitiveness, the desperate desire to be the top or the chosen or a sense of You know,
SPEAKER_00inferiority, superiority, why you and not me? How come? What makes you think? Why are people considering this person to be deserving and not me, for example? What makes them so special? I don't know what people see in them. You know, all of this kind of, this is an internal conversation or a conversation that happens on the sidelines. It's not something that you actually hear, but it's something that you get to see play out in behavior. And so while There is no way to address it or stop it.
SPEAKER_00I just want people to be aware, especially if you're somebody who presents as naturally shiny. You're not intentionally doing something. You never come into the room with the intention of making other people feel small. You never approach something with the intention of shining a light on yourself and making yourself the most Any adjective you want in the room. You don't set out to do that. For some people, it just happens to them. It's just the way it is. They walk into a space and it changes the vibe.
SPEAKER_00It throws it off in some way and it's not intentional. In a bad way, in a good way, I don't know. But these people have an impact and other people respond to that. It's not intentional. It's not intentional. They didn't set out to do it, but they are going to be receiving the response. So whether you intended to or not, people respond to you based on whatever they have going on. And it is always entirely about them. They are in that brawl. They are in that internal struggle. And so they turn to you and think, well, how dare you violate my rules?
SPEAKER_00How dare you step out of the box that I drew around myself? Who do you think you are? And so they're kicking off, not because of you, they're kicking off because of whatever's happening inside. And so it's very, very important that you don't doubt yourself when you clock this. When you notice it, don't second guess your read. Don't think that means, no, I should give them the benefit of the doubt and stay longer. No, I should continue to expose myself to this kind of environment. I should continue to allow this type of behavior to And by unchecked,
SPEAKER_00like I said, I don't mean a fight or a confrontation. There may be no benefit in doing that. What I mean is that you decide that you don't want to be around that anymore. Ultimately, whenever you're in a space where you feel like being yourself or doing what you set out to do is going to cause problems, either you're going to start to decrease and diminish and dim your light in order to not rock the boat, or You're going to continue to do what you're doing and you're going to face harmful response and repercussion and there's going to be pushback,
SPEAKER_00there's going to be snide remarks and passive aggressive behavior and attempts to humble you and attempts to cut you down or try and drag you into insecurity and self-doubt because that's what they've got on the inside. And so you have to make a conscious decision as soon as you see it, as soon as you know that this environment is harmful to walk away from it. You have to decide that. To do what will preserve you and protect you. You have to walk away from it. You have to say, I'm not, this is not for me. And I remember the first ever episode of Sincerely,
SPEAKER_00Sumayah on Spotify is called It's Okay to Walk Away. And in that episode, I'm talking about how sometimes people in the dawah sphere realize that they're in a toxic environment. They realize that this is problematic. It's way harder to do the work that I made the intention to do because of the environment. And when they realize that, they think, oh gosh, if I walk away from this organization, mosque, environment, ISOC situation, then that means that I'm turning my back on God and the work.
SPEAKER_00You're not turning your back on the dawah. You're not turning your back on serving the faith. You're just turning your back on this specific environment and opportunity because it's not aligned and it's not healthy. And I think there's a difference between the two. So your services can be better Used elsewhere. Your voice will have more impact elsewhere. You can do the same work with more reach and more impact in another place sans the resistance. And so we have to be a lot more clear and bigger picture about it.
SPEAKER_00None of this is personal. Like I started this whole episode talking about how these people are in an internal struggle. These people have not done their shadow work properly. Shadow work is dealing with the sides of yourself that you hide away because they are labeled with shame. They are labeled bad. It's the part of you that you think is a bit needy. It's the part of you that you think wants attention. It's the part of you that is hungry. It's the part of you that may be greedy. It's the part of you that may be jealous.
SPEAKER_00It's the part of you that may be competitive. You consider all of these things. And so if I was to say that part was a child, was a piece of you, you would take that child with all of her negative qualities and you would lock her in a closet or lock her in a basement and keep her put away because she doesn't make you look good. And every time you're reminded that she's there, you feel bad about her being a part of yourself so you don't accept her. To accept all of your parts and bring them in is to integrate.
SPEAKER_00It's to become one whole. People who haven't acknowledged the parts of themselves that they're ashamed of or their shadow parts are people who are not integrated. They're people who are fragmented. They're people who are not whole. And that means internal conflict. And that internal conflict manifests in this toxic behavior that I'm describing. Those people have yet to go on that journey of integrating. Once they're able to accept that all human beings have Aspects of themselves
SPEAKER_00that are less than praiseworthy. All people feel these things sometimes. All people are visited by insecurity, are visited by a sense of jealousy, are visited by a sense of competitiveness, are visited by a negative thought. Can be a hater. It's possible for any of us to be a hater. Once they accept that it's possible and it's not that big of a deal and it's not actually something to be ashamed of, they're able to embrace that girl and bring her out the closet and they're cool with her and the judgment goes down. And the burning need to tear other people down evaporates.
SPEAKER_00They just haven't done that integration work. And it's not my responsibility to force them to, teach them to, let them know that they need to, wait around until they do, interact with them until they have. None of that is mine. I'm not going to take that on. It's not my responsibility. That's theirs. So they can hold that bag. For me, I just recognize it when I see it. And that means I'm not going to be around them because I don't want to be exposed to all the nonsense. And I'm advising you to do the same. Recognize it when you see it and take your distance and protect yourself.
SPEAKER_00These are people who are struggling in their own right, but that doesn't mean that I need to put myself on the train tracks for them to run over. I don't need to be around it. I don't want anything to do with it. And it's way more prevalent than you would imagine. It's specifically And they haven't accepted that we're all less than ideal and that we're all human.
SPEAKER_00And that we're all just people. There are people I'm going to get along with. There are people that I'm not. There's people that I'm excited to see. There are people that I'm not. And that's okay. I don't have to switch it on. I don't have to pretend to be something that I'm not in order to meet what metric, in order to be what, to meet whose standard of being the ideal Muslim or a good person. Whose standard am I trying to meet? Who am I deceiving by pretending that And take your distance. Be cautious.
SPEAKER_00It is prevalent on all levels, not just in grassroots organizations. It's something that you can find out there as well. And the higher you climb and the more kind of well-known people can be, the more this thing can be found because you don't understand how sometimes people are touchy. They are hungry for it. They are competitive. They are trying to climb. They do have something to prove. Sometimes that's the case.
SPEAKER_00Not always, but sometimes it's the case. And you can feel it immediately. And because that's their game, they assume it's your game and they enter into a competition with you. And they feel like only one of us can win. And when we get to the other end of the pool, I'm going to try and drown you. And that is because of how they're presenting. It's not because of you. But you just have to be aware that That if you're swimming next to someone, there's a chance that they may try to push your head under the water once you get to the other end of the pool. And I just want you to be aware of it and to anticipate it and to position yourself correctly.
SPEAKER_00That's what I wanted to share. I know that I said a lot and I'm also aware that it's going to upset some people. Who may feel like they need to come out with the, no, we have to give our brothers and sisters in faith the benefit of the Tao and all of that. Broadly speaking, and in principle, I agree, that's correct. But that you also know that the believer isn't bitten from the same hole twice. Being a person of faith does not mean that you're a doormat,
SPEAKER_00does not mean that you're a fool, does not mean that you get taken for a ride periodically. It means that you're aware. The believer is somebody who's intelligent, is somebody who's switched on. When Allah subhanahu wa ta'ala gives the believer insight and gives them basira and gives them awareness, they're able to read things and see things. And it's their responsibility to acknowledge what they're seeing and act accordingly. Ignoring it and pretending it's not there and putting your head in the sand and allowing yourself to be harmed.
SPEAKER_00So I want to make that distinction before I get the thesis in the comments, quoting and pasting a hadith from ChatGPT about how the believer should act a certain way. That's not what I'm talking about. I'm speaking about something very, very specific. And like everything else that I say or that anyone says, you listen, you discern whether this is for you or not, whether it resonates or not, whether it has to do with you or not. And if it's good for you, you take what parts are good, and if it's not, you leave what parts are not.
SPEAKER_00Jazakum Allah khair for listening, and I look forward to sharing more. Assalamu alaikum warahmatullahi wabarakatuh.
For everyone who’s drowning or treading water. Here's the video I'm talking about: https://youtube.com/shorts/GN8HkZpyGD0?si=aB13zkKSU7siDk_E This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other...
Assalamu alaikum warahmatullah, I have been intending to record this for weeks and finally, here it is. This episode is about the mechanism of spiritual attacks and how they affect your journey. I'm talking about the...
Heads up: there's a brief silence between the two questions, hang on, the episode continues shortly after. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes,...
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit sumayah.substack.com This episode is for anyone who has been putting in months and years of effort, dua, worship and hope in Allah but hasn't seen their...
This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit sumayah.substack.com Restraint: rɪˈstreɪnt: noun The act of holding back, controlling, or limiting someone or something as in discipline: the checking of...