
Prof. Michele Gilman on AI bias and the law
Get full access to The Little Law School with Kim Wehle at kimwehle.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Get full access to The Little Law School with Kim Wehle at kimwehle.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
SPEAKER_01Hi everybody, this is The Little Law School with Kim Wehle, and I am really delighted to welcome my longtime friend and colleague at the University of Baltimore, Professor Michelle Gilman. The Little Law School with Kim Wehle
When it comes to now the implications of artificial intelligence and other forms of
SPEAKER_01technology on the rights of impoverished people and everyone. So Michelle, thank you for coming today to The Little Law School. Let me ask first if you could just explain, you know, your expertise and how you got into the intersection of poverty law, which is your longstanding, you know, focus for many years. And now privacy rights and, you know, the digital age and the tension there.
SPEAKER_00Sure, thanks for having me, Kim. Unfortunately, we still have a lot of people experiencing poverty in this country, but thanks to AI and different data-centric technologies, new legal problems are emerging that poverty lawyers like myself have to be prepared for. And I'll tell you how I first really became aware of this new dynamic. About 10 years ago, in the law clinic at the University of Baltimore, where we both teach,
I was supervising one of our student attorneys on a case for a client who was
SPEAKER_00elderly and disabled, and her home health care hours were drastically cut by the state. And this is a Medicaid program. Kim Wehle The Little Law School with Kim
So we go to a hearing before an administrative law judge and it was in the course of that hearing when we heard from the state's expert who was a nurse that we found out the reason for this drastic cut of 50% in the client's hours was due to a new
SPEAKER_00algorithmic decision making system that the state had purchased. But here's the rub. But one, we didn't know about it beforehand. But as we were trying to learn about it in the hearing, the nurse couldn't answer any questions about it. What factors does it weigh? How does it weigh them? What sort of outputs is it programmed to Kim Wehle
SPEAKER_00a technological tool being used to make very important decisions, sometimes life and death decisions about you, and you can't interrogate it, puts us in a horrible position. At the same time, we're dealing with another phenomena, and that is that the administrative law judge is thinking, well, it's a computer determination. It must be correct, right? Like, Thinking it's almost like a calculator. Anything that it churns must be a correct outcome. Nothing could be farther from the truth.
SPEAKER_00There are so many ways that AI tools fail us. But that psychological phenomenon has been well studied. It's called automation bias. And it is the tendency of people to put too much faith into computerized outcomes. So that whole situation put us and our client in a very difficult spot. And once we stumbled on that algorithmic system, I started seeing ways that algorithmic decisions were shaping
my clients' lives
SPEAKER_00across our dockets. We have a general civil poverty law practice. So we do housing and employment and public benefits and consumer law, a little bit of everything. And all of a sudden, I'm seeing that my clients' life opportunities are being shaped and determined by these automated decision makers. Kim Wehle
SPEAKER_01Now, you said that's 10 years ago, and technology has really changed. I think this chat GPT clawed, you know, ubiquitous use now of what we call artificial intelligence, which included, you know, the topic of artificial intelligence. Kim Wehle Kim
SPEAKER_01Kim Wehle Kim The Little Law School with Kim
SPEAKER_00It's a little hard to know because of this black box problem, right? We are acted on by these systems, but we can't see inside the black box to know how they're operating. There has been a spate of litigation against some of these systems and I Can't Say If They Are
SPEAKER_00Well, there's a couple transparency problems here. One is people often don't know that they're being subject to these tools because they're like running in the background. And even if they do know, as a lawyer, I want to get my hands on it. You can bet that the vendor and the company or entity that bought the tool is going to claim it's a trade secret, right? So now we're dealing with all these claims that the black box is proprietary. And so the people who are being impacted don't have a right to look at it.
SPEAKER_00And then we have even have a third layer of transparency, which is even if like I could get the source code, what am I going to do with that? Right? You can't interpret it. And even computer scientists will say that these generative AI models, they don't really understand how they work. They can't explain how certain inputs deliver certain outputs. So you have like just multiple transparency barriers layered one on top of each other. So that's a long way of saying it's hard for me to know where
generative AI is
SPEAKER_00exactly playing a role, but certainly there are advanced neural network models being used to make decisions about all of us every day. So it's not limited to my clients who are all low income that we provide pro bono services to. This is happening to all of us. But when you're dealing with marginalized populations, the harms tend to be a lot more harsh. So that's, you know, it's a society-wide problem. But as is often the case, poor people get hurt the worst.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Just for the non-lawyers, I know I can see we have some of our students that have joined us, so welcome to UB students, graduates, and anyone of interest with this topic. Can you just really briefly explain what are the constitutional and legal implications of having the black box decision maker or the black box expert? How is that different from what it was like when you started in
SPEAKER_01the world of poverty law and the clinic. And I know you've now probably had thousands of clients and thousands of students. So why is this problematic from a pragmatic legal standpoint? And what are the broader constitutional and legal implications of this black box that it sounds like is pretty entrenched and isn't really moving? Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, great question. So when I started practicing law in Baltimore almost 30 years ago, yes, we worked on computers. Kim and I aren't that old. There were computers. The Department of Social Service had a computer, but it was more just for Kim Wehle Kim
The Decision-Making Authority Is Now In The Computer Program Okay So That's A Huge Change And It's Putting Pressure On Constitutional Doctrines That Poverty Lawyers Like Me Have Relied On For A Very Long Time And That's Primarily The Due Process Doctrine Okay So Before The Government Deprives Us Of An Entitlement Or Cuts An
SPEAKER_00Entitlement And By Entitlement I'm talking about public benefits, but there are other entitlements as well. You're entitled to notice in a hearing, okay? But think about the case that I talked about when we started this conversation. If I don't know how this algorithm is working, and I can't get an explanation of the decision impacting my client, that violates due process, okay? Because I don't have notice of the reasoning. I don't have an explanation, which I'm entitled to.
SPEAKER_00And while I have a hearing, the hearing is basically a sham, right? Because I can't interrogate the decision and As I said, I can't cross-examine a black box. So that really undermines our notions of due process, which are supposed to protect us in our relationship to the state. Now, there are a lot of these systems operating in the private context where we don't have constitutional rights,
SPEAKER_00so like a private landlord-tenant relationship or your credit score, things like that. So the constitutional issues come up when we're dealing with the government. That being said, the government is buying these tools, in most cases, from private vendors. And that shifts a lot of democratic accountability and judgment to a private vendor. Are they state actors? I know you've done a lot of work, Professor Raley, around state action and who's a state actor. When you have these companies interpreting law
If they're not state actors, then where's the accountability for those decisions?
SPEAKER_01They also have a different incentive, right? Their incentive is to maximize profits. Exactly. I know we're getting some questions about, you know, determinations relating to health care. And I just want to, in preparation for this conversation, I did a little bit of just poking around about the implications of this. And because I think when we have these conversations today, Sometimes people don't necessarily know how it impacts your life, right?
SPEAKER_01So, you know, if you're not someone who's in the position to rely on public benefits or have some kind of disabling condition and can't work and things, then maybe, okay, well, we could have compassion. Somebody posted a question about what about programming AI to be more compassionate. But I just want to walk through, and these are not necessarily, as your point, To your point, governmental decisions, but this is what I found. AI bias has been identified against older women when asked to write resumes against older people when it comes to long-term acute care coverage and
melanoma diagnoses.
SPEAKER_01Wehle Amazon's AI-based recruiting tool downgraded resumes that included the word
SPEAKER_01women's, like if you're part of a women's book group. Facebook's AI revealed age bias, enabling employers to exclude older workers from viewing jobless The Little Law School with Kim Wehle
SPEAKER_01in a lot of ways that we, you know, everyday people who might say, well, this doesn't affect me.
SPEAKER_00It absolutely does. And all these examples of bias might raise the question, well, a computer's got to be better than a person, right? Like people We Know Have A Lot Of Conscious And Unconscious Biases I'm Not Holding Out Human Decision Making As The End All Be All By Any Stretch And That's Part Of The Pitch For These Tools Is That A Computer Is Neutral A Computer Is Objective We Can Get Rid Of Discrimination If We Just Use A Computer But As All The Examples You Just Listed Show We Can't And Why Is That?
because people program computers and people design the algorithms that the
SPEAKER_00computers turn, right? And when you are designing an algorithm, there are so many human decisions that go into it. You know, what data are you going to feed it? How are you going to train the Kim Wehle For example, you mentioned the Amazon resume situation.
So Amazon was testing an algorithm to help it choose employees for its white collar jobs.
SPEAKER_00Understandably, most employers are going to automated tools because they are just getting thousands and thousands of resumes and they need some way to sort through it all. So what Amazon did was it trained its hiring screener on the last 10 years of resumes of successful employees. Okay, that makes sense. You want to replicate what makes a successful employee in these jobs. But here's the problem. because these are technical fields the resumes were dominated
by men so the training data was about male workers and the algorithm thus learned to disfavor anything with the name women on it as you mentioned like if someone's resume said I played on the women's soccer team or I went to a women's college or I'm part of
SPEAKER_00like a professional women's network the algorithm automatically rejected it, okay? Now, to its credit, Amazon did not deploy the tool once those shocking results came out, but algorithms like that are churning away all the time every day without being necessarily tested or audited for bias or, you know, without being caught. So you can see how historical patterns of discrimination just get embedded and programmed into these screening tools.
SPEAKER_00And so they just replicate, as you mentioned, biases against women, minorities, older people that have existed for a long time. So we can't count on the computer Kim Wehle It's an open question right now whether law will actually be an
adequate restraint
SPEAKER_00on these dynamics that we know are happening. You listed just like 15 circumstances that I've heard about as well, and I could list like 20 more. Like, this is endemic. There's a big case actually going on right now involving Workday, which is used by many employers to screen resumes. And I'll tell you a little bit about that because it's pretty interesting. In that case, Mr. Derek Mobley was a Black job applicant over 40 years old with very significant,
SPEAKER_00impressive work experience. And in his complaint, he alleged he was rejected for over 100 jobs by Workday. Which a variety of employers were using His lawsuit claims these tools penalize protected groups for basically the same sort of phenomena I was just describing They say, look, Workday was trained on biased historical hiring data So he was like automatically rejected within hours, sometimes minutes from these jobs without any human intervention,
SPEAKER_00right? It's just a screamer bouncing people out Now, Workday on its part argues, hey, we just provide the software. We don't do the hiring. It's an employer who does the hiring. And you know what? Our anti-discrimination laws were written in the 60s and 70s when you didn't have as many players in the game right you had an employer and a candidate you didn't then have like an algorithmic developer and a data provider and like so many potential people in the chain
and so our civil
SPEAKER_00rights law is struggling right now to adapt. So the case has not gone to trial yet, but there was an early ruling by the court in California that because the Workday AI tool acts as a gatekeeper to the jobs, it's an agent of the employer and can potentially be held liable and a nationwide collective action was certified. That doesn't mean Mr. Motley's going to win. Because we've had similar cases on the housing side where I do
a lot of work where courts in similar types of cases have ultimately agreed that the final decision is
SPEAKER_00the landlord. It's not the algorithmic designer. and they can contract away their liability. So I don't know where this Mobley case is going, but it's a good example of, you know, using an analog era law for a 2026 kind of problem. And there's just a mismatch there. And we haven't updated the laws and we haven't created new laws to capture all the many different players who now have a hand in this type of
decision making.
SPEAKER_01To walk through the various, just break down a little bit more, the various ways of addressing this. You mentioned going to court. And, you know, when you talk about, well, the arguments made that computers are more neutral and they're trained on biased information because we live in a biased culture. I mean, I'd like to think of it more, and I know you've written about this as well, this is really about core fairness, even not even discrimination or non-description it's about fairness
and the idea of a court is that you get to challenge assumptions and then you get to understand what went into a decision that affected you or an action that affected you maybe you can get relief meaning maybe you get money or maybe you'll get a court order telling them to give you the job but at a minimum I think it functions to hopefully give
SPEAKER_01people a Since they got a fair shot, that you just get a fair shot. I mean, maybe you can talk about some of the recent social media verdicts we're seeing. Some things break through in the judicial system, but I really wonder, given that we're 10 years before your first experience where, wait a minute, does anyone else notice this is what's going on? Is technology because it is a black box and the designers don't
even know how it
SPEAKER_01functions so it cannot be cross-examined even by the experts? Does that just ultimately rule the courts out? as a mechanism. I want to start with there and then I want to shift to legislation. But just so people understand, you know, I mean, courts are inherently democratic, right? You get a jury of your peers. I mean, you got to have money sometimes to hire a lawyer. But in theory, you know, it's a David and Goliath and a Reno where you can go after the big guys. I mean, the federal judges in our moment of flailing democracy and authoritarian forces
SPEAKER_01rising, the judges are holding. So can you talk a bit about your hope or despair over the courts being a mechanism for addressing this?
SPEAKER_00Yeah. I mean, courts, they're grappling with these very novel issues and they don't have necessarily, usually the kind of technical skills to understand these systems. So that's a challenge. I also teach evidence law and evidence law is under a lot of pressure here. Traditionally, if you bring an expert into court, they have to be qualified. You can cross-examine them. You get to understand the basis of their decisions,
and you can query that as the opponent.
SPEAKER_00What if now the decision-making is a computer? What do we do about Daubert, right? Which is this famous Supreme Court case telling us that an expert shouldn't be allowed in the courtroom unless their opinion is reliable, right? And based on reliable methods. Well, what if the expert is now workday, right? What if it's now a computer? So there's a lot of... talk about potentially amending the rules of evidence, and there are some rules changes being considered right now. Like, that's just yet another example of all the pressure these
technological changes are
SPEAKER_00putting on our judicial system, right? Not just the substantive law, but even, like, evidence, the rules that govern what a jury sees and hears. Well, if Congress doesn't act, if Congress doesn't act, then it does go to the courts.
SPEAKER_01I mean, because somebody needs to be relieved. And I wonder, I mean, could you foresee... At some point, the court's saying, listen, you know, Daubert is the no-snake-oil-salesman expert, right? Like, you really need to have a serious doctor, you know, in cardiology testify about your heart, right? Could you see a circumstance where a court just says, listen, that's not qualified, period. We're not going to allow that evidence the black box in so
employer or defendant if you can't come up with some other rationale then you lose and then that would incentivize different ways of making these decisions and maybe that would motivate companies to set aside some of these wackadoodle black box mechanisms that let's
SPEAKER_01face it are really about Shareholder value and profit. They're not about fairness. They're not about making sure it's the right decision. It's about making sure it's the quickest and cheapest decision. Right I mean vendors make a lot of claims about efficiency and cost savings and they kind of come with this mantle of objectivity these tools and we as the public need to be very very skeptical of that um you know there's a very well-known case
SPEAKER_00uh involving a criminal algorithm. Also, it's like 10 years old where a defendant was sentenced pursuant to an algorithm that is known to have a racial bias. And what he wanted was like give me give me the information how did it weigh these factors about me what was it programmed about he challenged his sentence and in that case the highest court in Wisconsin upheld the sentence they said that using these kind
of predictive
SPEAKER_00algorithms for sentencing did not per se violate due process In those cases, the judges didn't rely on the algorithmic output as determinative or dispositive. It was like one factor among many, but it was still a factor that the defendant to this day has no idea how it works. Except for a bunch of studies showing it's racially biased And they said due process did not require the vendor to turn over its source code
to the defendant So
SPEAKER_00his sentence is upheld and to this day Kim Wehle Kim Wehle the employment case I just talked about like it's a good sign that the court is saying no no no a vendor might still be responsible here but that doesn't mean they'll ultimately be held liable like we're closely watching
that case as I said a similar case in the housing context that the tenants lost so yes courts have to
SPEAKER_00grapple with it and they're kind of decisions you know more favorable and less favorable decisions but some of the leading cases are not building a lot of faith in their ability to really understand what's going on here I know you mentioned like legislation so in Europe they have more laws governing AI and governing data privacy and one thing you have right to in Europe
SPEAKER_00that we don't have a right to is if An automated decision-making system is making a major decision about us, like, where are you going to go to college? Where are you going to live? Where are you going to work? Level of health care. Any kind of significant decision, you are entitled to an explanation. Okay? We... We should have that in cases involving the government through the due process clause We definitely don't have anything like it on the private side and in our due
process cases I can't say that courts are really demanding that sort of explanation
SPEAKER_00There's a lot of deference to the tool as being valid So, you know, it goes to show you you could have a law that changes the terrain here Other countries have it Our friends in Europe have a right to an explanation. We don't. So these are also policy choices. And some of this should be resolved by our elected representatives and not courts, like putting all the onus on courts to navigate. The Little Law School with Kim Wehle
SPEAKER_00into the mix and adopting their own laws. Companies hate this because they'd rather have to comply with one law and not 50 variations on a theme. But some of the states are providing sort of early test cases of best practices and things that we can do going forward. But the action now in the U.S. is at the state level. Congress is not doing anything.
SPEAKER_01Well, and Congress made a fateful decision, right, in, I think it was 1996, about social media platforms and liability for posting. Can you explain? I mean, it seems like that was really, that was a, that was a watershed moment or a red line or however you want to say, that seemed to be a defining moment in how the law in the United States treats these behemoth monster tech companies that are raking in billions and billions and are essentially not regulated.
SPEAKER_01I mean, we've got to wear seatbelts. You know, we've got to, you know, safe cars, right? Like companies have to build safe cars and have responsibility to wear seatbelts. They have to put The Federal Trade Commission You've got to put How to clean my shirt In the tag Yeah That's literally a law To be fair to people So you don't put your sweater In the dryer And the sweater's like Big enough for your cat So could you I know we'll have to wrap up pretty soon But could you Just lay out
SPEAKER_01what the federal law is like. And I mean, I think maybe it's partly they can't agree, but they're also not incentivized in this moment to do anything. I think the idea is, OK, Congress is out to lunch. And and we've had some questions in the chat about, well, what do we do about it? And, you know, in a lot of ways, all roads lead to Congress. And they're just it's not functioning right now. But maybe you could talk a bit.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, because legislative solution. Sure, and also the social media cases are a bright spot from a consumer perspective, so it is important to talk about those. So when Congress passed what's called Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act, it did want to promote innovation in the technical sphere, and it makes big tech companies, platforms not liable for the content that is posted, right?
SPEAKER_01So it's sort of like a bulletin board at the church, right? So they're a bulletin board and whoever puts walk the dog or babysitting or whatever, that's on them. You can't go back to the church and say, listen, other people posted stuff on your bulletin board. That's essentially the theory behind, you know, Meta or Facebook or Google or whatever.
SPEAKER_00Right, and so that immunity from liability has, in some people's eyes, allowed some of the worst aspects of social media to flourish. Misinformation, disinformation, misogyny, racism, because you can never sue Facebook or Google or YouTube or Snapchat for that because they didn't post that content. They're just the bulletin board. But they're not, right, Michelle? They're not, because then enter the algorithm, right? Right. Well, here's some new cases. So there was a big lawsuit against Meta and Google that went to
verdict just a few weeks ago.
SPEAKER_00And this is about social media addiction, something that as a society we're very worried about, particularly for our young people. So in that case, the plaintiff called KGM said, argued that she had been addicted to these platforms since childhood she was spending up to 16 hours a day on these platforms and she suffered depression anxiety suicidal thoughts she had very serious mental health harms as a result of
SPEAKER_00this addiction Okay Well under Section 230 The platform's not available You know They didn't post Whatever content She was looking at About celebrities Or fashion Or diets Or whatever it was Okay But the plaintiff's lawyers Were very clever here They said No no no we're not suing for the content we are suing for the way the platforms design the tools to addict us okay it's a design defect theory a negligence a tort theory so it's not a bulletin board right there they are because does a
bulletin board have infinite scroll never never turning off no does a bulletin board have autoplay and
SPEAKER_00push notifications no that does a um Bulletin Board Reward You For Engaging With Likes And Comments And Followers No Does A Bulletin Board Recommend Content To You And Push It At You Tailored To Impact You And Suck You In No Okay And So This Case Kim Wehle
And the jury came back with a negligence, with a verdict against the companies.
SPEAKER_00So Meta has to pay $4.2 million in various damages. YouTube has to pay $1.8 million. That's not a big number for these companies, but there are 10,000 other pending cases. And this was an early test case. So that impact potentially will grow significantly. Also, up next are a bunch of cases. Pending and brought by school districts claiming they're having to spend a big portion of their budgets on counseling and mental health
services for students who are addicted and it's destroying their budgets and five counties across the nation
SPEAKER_00have been selected to Kim Wehle Kim Wehle misleading consumers about the safety of these platforms and for enabling child sexual exploitation on the platforms. And that was also about the design choices of the platforms. And so there was a big verdict in that case.
SPEAKER_00And a lot of When states took on the tobacco industry and got millions and millions of dollars in verdicts and settlements to then work on anti-tobacco programming in their state. So this is like the new frontier of products liability law and it is so far from consumer perspective a more upbeat story than some of the civil rights cases I was telling you about and it really shows the power of creative
lawyering on the plaintiff's side because they got around this 230 barrier that has just like let as you said let big tech off scot free right and they said we're not doing the content we're talking about your design and you did that and that was intentional and the jury saw all the information heard all the testimony and agreed with the
SPEAKER_00plaintiffs so Again, the companies are going to appeal. We don't know where this is going. Could it ultimately go up to the Supreme Court? Yes. So the story's not over yet, but it's a big breakthrough in terms of bringing fairness between the relationships between us and big tech.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. It's just about incentives. They'll just continue to make money as much as possible. They have a statutory obligation to maximize shareholder value. And if there's no counter pressure through the courts or through Congress they're just going to keep going can you talk a bit about what's happening in law schools and with lawyers around AI this is for viewers you and I met at a luncheon where this topic was discussed at the law school. And I said, listen, we have to talk about this outside of the scope of the law
school classroom. But it seems that it's not fully taken hold within law school classrooms or the bar
SPEAKER_01because it's happening so quickly. And it's also changing the dynamics on how you teach law.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, well, I would say the situation now, it's very chaotic because change is happening so fast and it's disrupting higher education. So a lot of law schools right now are very focused on skills. So what does a lawyer need to know about AI to deliver services to clients? And there are a lot of cautionary tales about, you know, lawyers who citations into briefs that didn't exist because the generative AI hallucinated. It picks things up.
So a lot of the focus right now out of the gate is how do we use generative AI ethically as lawyers and how do we use it efficiently and help make our students practice ready because law firms now expect our graduates to come in and know how
SPEAKER_00to use AI responsibly. Kim Wehle Kim Wehle
SPEAKER_00because we're good at teaching skills to our students. You know, we're a professional school. But the substantive law doctrine is where, like, the general public is really being impacted.
SPEAKER_01Right. And we're seeing the Constitution under strain with this administration, the due process clause with people being deported to third-party countries without any kind of hearing. We're seeing pressure on the Fourth Amendment with these stops that are based on just people's skin color, whether they speak Spanish. And we have a Supreme Court that's kind of green lighting some of these really pauses on constitutional guarantees. So this whole due process component that you've identified that
really isn't in
SPEAKER_01the, it's not in the discussions around AI, not even within lawyers. It's so crucial because that is, you know, goes back to the Magna Carta in England. The idea that, listen, King, you can't just throw people in the dungeon unless they get to see a judge and explain their side of the story. It's the most basic concept. And of course, when you're talking about people being Kim Wehle
The stakes are really high, but they're really high for other things too.
SPEAKER_01High for everyday things, not only through the courts and vis-a-vis the government, but in our regular lives. Understanding this is so, so important. So second to last question, the ultimate question. If people want to learn more about this and they want to do something about it, what should they do, Michelle? Michelle?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, well, there are a lot of good groups advocating around these issues, pushing back against surveillance, arguing for greater data privacy, bringing these kinds of test cases, organizations ranging from the ACLU, which is focusing on these issues, the Center for Democracy and Technology, the Electronic Privacy Information Center, EPIC, the Electronic Frontier Foundation, EFF, Data and Society, where I've been a research fellow. So there are great civil society organizations and lawyers
working on these issues
SPEAKER_00where you can like educate yourself and What about when you go through your day Are we just pawns and there's really nothing we can do besides awareness?
SPEAKER_01I think that's the first step. I'm not trying to minimize education and awareness. But have you come across any just little tricks of the trade or hacks, as my kids would say?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, there are privacy protective steps that you can take. There's like online, like a digital defense playbook that's very good with a lot of like steps to protect information on your phone from apps hoovering up information about you. Kim Wehle Kim Kim Wehle
Push Back Against Big Tech Like The Resources Are So Unequal That Is Just Really Crazy So Yes There Are Things We Can Do But The Bigger Thing We Can Do Is To Work As A Collective And Demand Our Rights To Man Fairness If We Have To Sue Sue If We Have To Go To Our State To Lobby For Better Laws We Need To Do That Because It's
SPEAKER_00Really A Collective Obligation And Not An Individual One So last question I love that frame by the way that's that's a really empowering one and it puts the focus on the government which is failing in a lot of ways and I
SPEAKER_01think collectively If we have millions and millions of people understanding this and insisting on accountability, stuff changes. It's just little pockets is not enough. I guess my last question, and this is really just where you are in this as a professor, as a person, as a parent, whatever. How are you feeling about the AI revolution? Is it mostly good, mostly bad? I mean, where are you, Michelle Gilman, on it? Yeah I'm you know I'm concerned and in part concerned because
we're not we're not discussing it enough so it just feels like it's to your point going on in the background and it's like whoa where are we headed I just like to know I like to
SPEAKER_01know what the heck is going on that's just my brain I think right now it's mostly bad because the public has no say and no power to
SPEAKER_00shape the tools that are shaping our lives. That is bad. It's not that technology is inherently bad. Obviously, I love my GPS map that helps me communicate. If my doctor wants to use some diagnostic AI to give me a better medical outcome, of course. I'm not anti-technology. But when we're talking about these massive AI systems that are secretly making decisions about us, The Little Law School with Kim Wehle
like the technology on its own you have to look at how it is like socially situated and how it's used so I always ask like if there's a certain tool I'm like who's benefiting from this and who's losing from this is this tool empowering people or is it oppressing people and who are those people right so we have to look at it in
SPEAKER_00a specific context and right Now, in most contexts, billionaire oligarchs are getting very, very rich, and we are at their mercy. Sometimes, you know, we win. Like, if you have a good credit score, good for you. And sometimes we lose. Like, if there's a name mismatch about you in a tenant screening report and you're being bounced from houses and you don't know why, that's not a good thing. So I think, again, we just really have to ask this question. Who's winning? Who's losing? Right now, the balance is completely...
SPEAKER_01Yeah, well, it looks like, I mean, that was a, I couldn't agree with you more, why certain people need to have hundreds of billions of dollars when others can't buy food or health care or put gas in their car. It's really, it's just a sign of an extremely sick society. But I'm hopeful that with these conversations, we can make a change. My dogs are barking. I think our Wi-Fi is going out, but I just want to thank you, Michelle. Such a great conversation.
SPEAKER_01Really, really interesting. I hope we can do it again. And thank you for all you've done for all these years, for low-income people and others in Baltimore, for our students, and for all those watching. More people like you would really help with the conversation.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Follow Michelle and everybody have a great evening. Thanks again.
SPEAKER_00Thanks for joining us.
SPEAKER_01Yep. Bye everybody. Thanks for joining The Little Law School with Kim Wehle.
SPEAKER_00Love it. A good use of technology. Yes, exactly.
SPEAKER_01Exactly. Bye folks.
Nobody is credited on this episode yet.
Last Friday, I spoke with my friend Glenn Kirschner about RFK Jr.’s stealth announcement that the Trump Administration is effectively stripping migrant kids of counsel as part of DJT’s mass deportation obsession. I’ll...
Hey friends! Greetings from Dulles Airport in Virginia! I am preparing to board a flight to Amsterdam where I will be coordinating a research group at NIAS, the Netherlands Institute for Advanced Study in the Humanities...
Get full access to The Little Law School with Kim Wehle at kimwehle.substack.com/subscribe
On President's Day, I joined Robert P. Jones on his Substack, Redeeming Democracy, to discuss how legal authoritarianism took hold in America. Robert is the president and founder of Public Religion Research Institute...
On Tuesday, President Donald Trump posted the following on Truth Social: This is so silly, I hesitate even to credit it with a response. According to his logic, Trump’s own “un-pardon” is meaningless because he did not...