Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

SIMPLE + INTENTIONAL, decluttering, intentional living, habits, decluttering tips, minimalism

SIMPLE + INTENTIONAL, decluttering, intentional living, habits, decluttering tips, minimalism artwork

184// Saying No to New with New York Times Editor Eric Athas

Sep 21, 202656 minAudio

New York Times editor, Eric Athas used to love new things. A self proclaimed early adopter until the pandemic hit and he saw the problems buying new things can cause. This spurred him to write Saying No to New. In his new book he shares what the research has to say about happiness, buying new, marketing and how we respond. Want to learn how to avoid getting stuck in the traps? Then this episode is for you. Find out more about Eric and his book here: https://ericathas.com/ Follow Eric here: https://www.instagram.com/eric_athas/ On Substack: https://substack.com/@ericathas Join me Wednesday November 18th at 1pm EST for a FREE masterclass, details and sign up here: https://simpleintentional.kit.com/cuttheoverwhelm Want to work with more or learn more? book a call here Love the show? Leave a five star ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ on Apple Podcasts - it means the world to me and helps more women find the simple + intentional podcast Instagram @simpleintentional hello@simpleintentional.com

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Do you feel overwhelmed by clutter when you walk through the door? Are you tired all the time and stuck just getting by? With each day being a carbon copy of the next and no time or space for yourself? Hi, I'm Sarah, and I was you, so I understand. You're a busy mom, whether at home or working full-time, feeling like you're in survival mode. There isn't time for more because you're just putting out fires, overwhelmed by all the stuff and aching for something more. That's what the Simple Intentional Podcast is here for.

SPEAKER_00To support you. Whether it's to clear clutter, ditch the overwhelm, and create ease and simplicity, figure out how to be more intentional in your life, or inspire you into action. Each week I'll share things like practical and actionable tips you can start using immediately to start living more intentionally and create your life, as well as interviews with people that will inspire and educate you. I'm a full-time working mom, wife, and lover of all things simple. After a stage four cancer diagnosis in 2014, I started on a path to change how I was living.

SPEAKER_00And I'm sharing with you everything that has helped me move from a stressed-out, people-pleasing perfectionist to calm, in control, and feeling like the best version of myself. So grab your earbuds, a cup of tea, and join me to start making powerful shifts in your life today. This is about so much more than stuff. Hello and welcome back to the Simple and Intentional Podcast. New stuff is great. We're all faced with the enticement to buy new things every single day.

SPEAKER_00Upgrade your life, make things better, faster, more convenient. But that's often not the outcome. I mean, a dishwasher makes life easier, but do you really need to upgrade your very functional one to stainless steel with five more settings? And shoes are awesome, but do you really need 20 pairs? The world around you tells you that you do. But my guest today, Eric Athis, is going to build a case for saying no to new. Eric is a journalist at the New York Times, where he helps journalists learn new tools and skills they can use to tell stories.

SPEAKER_00Before joining the Times in 2016, he worked at NPR and the Washington Post. His work has been published in the New York Times, The Washington Post, Fast Company, Harvard Business Review, and the Nyman Journalism Lab. He is also the author of Saying No to New: Why New Things Are Stealing Your Time, Money, and Happiness, and How to Take Back Your Life. Eric lives with his wife and two children in Brooklyn. Hello, Eric. Welcome and thank you for being here.

SPEAKER_02Hi, Sarah. I'm so glad to be here.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I would love if we could start with just a little bit more about you and who you are and what prompted you to write Saying No to New, which I think just came out as we're recording.

SPEAKER_02Right. It is funny enough, a new book that is now available. But sure, I I am, as you mentioned, I'm a dad and a husband. I live in Brooklyn, New York with my family, which also includes a dog and two cats. So we we got a full, full house. And I have actually been someone who's always really loved new stuff. I've I was proud to consider myself an early adopter for most of my life. I would always go out and buy the latest new gizmo or software.

SPEAKER_02And so I've I've for most of my life have been someone who's really loved new stuff. And there there have been a few big changes. And the first one was that I'm sure a lot of people can relate to. When I had kids, I started to get exposed to all of these child raising products that there's this whole economy of things that of gadgets and gizmos for the stroller for your carriers, and there's different types of carriers, and there's different types of apps.

SPEAKER_02And and so that was this whole marketplace of stuff that I had no idea even existed, but now I was buying all of it and acquiring all of it. And then my kids themselves became, as they got a little bit older, became targets by influencers, by advertising to new things that they should get. And these new things that they were exposed to, that kind of changed as they got older. And of course, when they were earlier, it was toys.

SPEAKER_02And I don't know. Yeah, I bet a lot of your listeners remember and maybe still know about this YouTube uh personality. His name was Ryan from Ryan's World. Anyways, basically, this kid that there's this kid that would just open up new toys, and he amassed this massive YouTube following and made all this money. And my kids discovered this early on and just became glued to these unboxing videos where this kid would just open up new stuff and and and then play with it.

SPEAKER_02And it was just they were just hooked on that.

SPEAKER_03Oh wow.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, it's it's it's interesting. Um but but that was and then like the new things they were attracted to kind of have evolved over time. But the big change for me, Sarah, came during the pandemic when we were all trapped in our Brooklyn apartment. And well, how do you pass your time when you're really bored? One really easy way is to just buy a lot of stuff, download a lot of things. There's all kinds of new technology you can use. And I started looking around at that point and realizing that so much of this new stuff that was designed to solve problems for me felt like it was actually creating a lot of new problems, whether it was spending a lot of money, all the clutter in our house.

SPEAKER_02We've got this closet that just I think everyone has that one closet where you're just like, what do I do with this? I'm gonna put it in that closet, and then before you know it, it's just like overfilling with stuff. And and also technology that was distracting me. So I I became interested in this concept of newness as something that I had always considered to be good, was now actually creating problems. And and I wanted to know why, and I wanted to know how can I avoid some of those more those problematic new things, but actually keep getting the good kind of new things.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yeah, because I'm sure there's a distinction between like good new things and you know, things that aren't adding to your life, and and that's something maybe we can talk more about because I think that is probably a hard distinction to make sometimes. And um, you know, when it comes to like all the marketing we're exposed to and all that. And it's funny you mentioned the kids' toys because um I have this, I've always liked the Baron Steam Bears, and and like they're a bit old-fashioned. I'll say, you know, some of them not necessarily the greatest messages, but we have this one that's called something like the toy craze.

SPEAKER_00And because it was around the time that like laboo-boos were the thing that like every kid wanted. And my daughter asked about it. And I said, Yeah, we're we're not gonna get that. Like, you know, uh one, I always preface it with like, we really care about animals. And um, you know, when you buy something that's like really disposable, we know it ends up in a landfill. It's like sort of a short-term thing, and like let's think about the things that you really actually like. But in the Baron Steam Bears book, it's kind of the, you know, the journey of like a hype toy like that, you know, where at the end they end up with all this stuff and they have no idea what to do with it.

SPEAKER_00So she kind of got to see the journey of the laboo-boo and how like it ended up not being, you know, like there was another toy that replaced it, right? And so she kind of got to see that. So it's it's funny what you say about kids' toys because I think, yeah, they're exposed to so much. Um, and it's like the, you know, the I don't know. I mean, maybe you can talk more about this too, but like the peer pressure and that kind of thing that I'm sure adults experience as well. But but anyways, yeah, it's interesting that you bring that up.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, boy, the labu-boo is such a great example.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. Like an isidor, I'm like, it's not even really cute. Like, you know, there's so much about this that we could talk about. Um, but thankfully we we got through the labu-boo phase with no laboo boo.

SPEAKER_02Well done, yeah, Sarah.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. I mean, I've had years of being a teacher to practice saying no a lot. So um, but I think maybe we could start with like a big question. Like, why is it so hard to resist new things?

SPEAKER_02Well, there's a science behind it. And if you think about the ways that you navigate the world around you, when you're really young, everything is new. When you're a baby, everything is new. And as you go, you start to experience things. And then your brain, which is trying to create almost like a model of the outside world, it sees something new, it tags it as a memory, and now it understands it. And so it's no longer new, it's familiar. And as we grow, you have fewer new experiences because you're understanding what a car is and and how to walk, and you know what your neighborhood looks like.

SPEAKER_02And I think a lot of people can can relate to that experience of walking around uh just a regular neighborhood with a toddler and they're just kind of wide-eyed because everything is amazing because so much of it is is new when you see that excavator that's you know crashing down on the side of the road, and and they're just amazed by the fire truck, all this stuff is new. So, but as we get older, our our brains recognize all of these things and they become familiar. And so the brain is trying to sort of predict what this outside world will look like.

SPEAKER_02And what that means is that the brain naturally cares much more about new things than it does about old things. The old familiar things, it's got that. It doesn't have to worry about the couch in your living room or what your car looks like, it knows that, so it it starts to sort of to ignore that so that it can focus its attention on new things. But where it gets really interesting is there's research that shows when we encounter something new, our brain releases dopamine that pushes us to go explore that new thing.

SPEAKER_02And there's actually an evolutionary kind of explanation for this, which is that you can imagine our ancient ancestors and how important it was for them to find new food and to find new places to hunt and to find new places to live. And so there is for most of our existence, it's been very useful to just go out and try to find new stuff. So that's sort of the the the science that's underpinning why when we see, I don't know, a new iPhone or something, yeah, our our eyes light up and and it and it's interesting we go and and check it out.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's so interesting. I mean, I mean, it's so interesting about so much of our behavior, how you can really trace it back to like why there's a good reason for it.

SPEAKER_03Right.

SPEAKER_00And I think understanding that is so helpful. And also for a lot of people who feel, you know, kind of shameful about buying things or like can't understand why they can't control themselves or they struggle with, you know, the impulse of it. I'm sure that understanding that piece is helpful because you can kind of look at it like, like, of course we want personal responsibility, but that also that there's there's pieces of us that are drawn towards the novelty and that that's inherent in us. So that when we can understand that, then you can, you know, maybe talk yourself out of it a little bit and be like, oh, that's just that, you know, that part of me that likes that new thing and um it's gonna, I'm gonna get over it.

SPEAKER_00You know, like the I've always said um to people, you know, wait 24 or 48 hours before you buy something because it's just amazing what happens in the span of 24 hours and how differently you feel about something. Um, and so maybe it's just that little bit of you getting more accustomed, and that thing is like slightly less novel than it was the day before.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, that's a I I love that rule of just waiting 24 hours. But you're right, Sarah. This is this isn't a bug. This is a feature. This is the way we're supposed to be. It's the environment around us that's the problem. It's the fact that we are overloaded by new stuff. That's the issue. It's not us, it's not you. You go in and wanting new things is a natural part, it's a biological instinct. And so you then have to create these rules and and figure out how you can change your relationship with all this new stuff and with novelty in general so that the environment around you is a little bit less of a problem.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. So I I mean, like marketing is obviously very clever, and we've all gotten pulled into those impulse buys. Um, you know, like being on Instagram and suddenly buying something that you weren't expecting to. What are some of the marketing tactics that we should know about and like that can help us become more aware as consumers?

SPEAKER_02There are a lot of them. I was really amazed in writing the book at how sophisticated the influence machine has become. Businesses use our own psychology against us, they use data to track us, they use influencers, employ influencers to go out and build parasocial relationships with us because we trust people who we feel like we know. They, and this is the big one. We spend so much of our time online. So many of us, I mean, I once you start to think about it, you're like, Yeah, I do so much of my shopping, I do so much of my I read news, go on what social media.

SPEAKER_02And so one of the central ways in which businesses are influencing our choices is through design, design of websites and design of apps, and those newsletters, those emails you get about the the the this flash sale that's going on, those sort of visual cues that are are presented to you. So here's here's one that I that I find I come across every once in a while, which is you're at the checkout point of a product and you're you're kind of like, uh, do I want this?

SPEAKER_02Can I afford it? You know, it's that last step where you're like, okay, am I gonna do this? And there's a little a little ticking clock, a little clock that shows up that says you've you know you have five minutes to complete this purchase, or save 25% if you complete this in five minutes and it starts to tick down. That's intentionally designed to whip up stress and anxiety within you because you feel like you now you're in a rush and you're gonna miss out on something.

SPEAKER_02And you want to relieve that discomfort. Well, one way to relieve it is to buy the thing, and so the business is sort of trying to push you in that direction. And so there there are a lot of these. I mean, the biggest one, or one of the biggest ones, is just the concept of new. I mean, how many times do you see a product and then you see the next edition of it? You see the upgrade, you see every season we get a new fashion line that we have to keep up with, or uh, uh the fall season. And so, yeah, there are so many of these.

SPEAKER_02And I think what I've personally found is the more you can become aware of them, and I find this kind of fun, you can start to spot them out there in the wild and start to see, oh, I see what they're trying to do there.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's it's interesting. You know what? I was just in the store the other day and um I was going quickly because I had to get one thing and I didn't have a lot of time. But as I passed, I thought, oh, I'm gonna check if goldfish are on sale. Because, you know, it's just I like to get them when they're on sale. And I was looking at the shelf and I had noticed that there was like a new, because I mean, how many types of goldfish are there now? Like a dozen, you know, just they keep coming out with like different types. And I noticed that they came out with like sort of more a sweet version now.

SPEAKER_00And I and I thought in my head, I'm like, oh, that's so interesting how like even goldfish has the pressure to keep evolving and coming out with new things to like keep up in the marketplace. And so you think about all those products that we buy, just even an everyday thing like that, right? Like, even if goldfish stuck with classic goldfish, they would probably be okay. But um, you know, that they still have that pressure to evolve. And that also what you said about like that pressure when we're in a rush.

SPEAKER_00And and I it was just I'm thinking forward to another question I wanted to ask you because a lot of my listeners, um, well, I would say most of my listeners are women and I would say busy, often parents, not always, but that, you know, they're that statistically women are often like household managers and, you know, um carrying a lot of the mental load, you know, tracking birthdays, buying the gifts, replacing clothes, researching products, like all of that labor that goes into purchasing. And so it requires them to be constantly engaging with new things on a regular basis.

SPEAKER_00Um, and also that because they have a really full plate, they're often doing things quickly. Like I can relate to that. Like I'm like, oh yeah, I forgot to do this. And then like I jump on and start spending the energy and time like researching the thing and trying to make the best choice. And, you know, oh, there's that 25% off for that thing I need. And so you really get caught up in it. And I'm wondering, like, I guess what are some ways that we can protect ourselves from consuming the extra? You know, when you go to buy the shoes and you end up leaving with the shoes and the socks, or like you go to buy the pajamas, and I'm like, oh, she could use more t-shirts.

SPEAKER_00You know, like you kind of get sucked into it and you're making these quick decisions. So yeah, I guess like, how can we try to, you know, pull ourselves out of that consumption and um protect ourselves a little more?

SPEAKER_02It's really difficult because we're, as we just spoke about, our brains are designed to go find new things and we live in a world filled with them. And the problem you just described is such an important one, which is that if you're rushing around to take care of business, you are gonna have to be moving quickly. And the one of the first things I tell people is you have to regain at least a little bit of that time to think about what you're purchasing.

SPEAKER_02And I know that can be very hard when you're in a rush. And so if you but if you can sort of create a little bit more friction between you and the new thing, that's the first step. Because if you don't have time to think, you're set up to fail. These businesses don't want you to think. There's been research that's been done that shows that we are much more persuadable when we have less time to deliberate about a choice. And so you have to regain at least a little bit extra time.

SPEAKER_02I loved your 24-hour rule. And maybe you make that rule, that rule, it's it's because it may not be practical for everything. Yeah, you you've got to get order socks for the kids because socks always seem to disappear into some black hole. Well, you're maybe just you need those, and you don't have to, you can't wait 24 hours. So maybe there's a price threshold, something over$20,$30,$50, whatever makes sense for you. Those sort of rules are called commitment devices. And it's almost as if this is something I learned from a professor at the Wharton School.

SPEAKER_02Her name is Katie Milkman, and I interviewed her for the book. And she talks about how governments and and parents and schools have rules for the people that they are overseeing. And so you almost have to act as your own government and create some practical rules for yourself. And what it does is it makes it a little bit harder to complete the purchase or to acquire the new stuff, and that balance things out, balances things out a little bit. So you're not just drawn into the shiny thing, but you're having to take some extra steps, or you have these rules that just slow you down and and make you think and and make it a little bit more effortful to get the stuff.

SPEAKER_02The the the the sort of example I give in the in the book is if you have a slice of chocolate cake right in front of you, well, that's easy. You're just gonna, at least I know I'm gonna plunge my fork in and start eating it.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_02If it's in the refrigerator and it's wrapped up, that's a couple extra steps, but I'm probably willing to go in and unwrap it if I'm if I'm craving it. If it's at the bakery across town, now I have to get in my car and I have to drive there and order it. That's a totally different equation. And by the way, if you can get it on Uber Eats, well, that changes the equation too. Now it's also effortless. So you can kind of think about what are your cravings, what are the things that you want, the new things you want less of in your life, and how can you make it a little bit more difficult to actually acquire them so that your future self, who's in that position of having an impulse, will have to do a little bit extra work to get it.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I love that. I I talk about the idea of friction a lot in a different way when it comes to like creating habits, like removing friction for the things you want to be doing. But um, it's such a great idea for you know, like preventing yourself from doing the things you don't want to be doing to create some friction and make it just a little bit harder for yourself. So like I think about those things like. You know, the autofill for your credit card information or like um it's a good one. Yeah, like that one.

SPEAKER_00I mean, honestly, it just makes it like click, click, click now to just to buy something and it's so easy. Um, another thing that I've developed is really making sure before I purchase something, I know um the return policy. And I know maybe not everybody's really good at following through on returns, but I am. Like if I I recognize that sometimes as a busy parent, I'm gonna get caught up in buying stuff quickly and that when I hold on to my receipt, um, if I've made a mistake, I can go back and reverse it, you know, or I can say, like, I actually didn't want to spend that money and I was caught up in a moment.

SPEAKER_00Cause I think we're all really fallible in that way. Like you said, there's all this stuff that's um that's set up to have us purchase. So if we can make it so that um we can reverse it when we get caught up, I think that that that's been um a saving grace for me some of the time too. Even as somebody who is a minimalist, you know, it happens to us all.

SPEAKER_02It does. Those are really great tips. I'll give you another one, which is how do you say no matters? And what do I mean by that? Well, I mean that there's actually science and and psychology to the way that you are trying to resist something. And there's this researcher, her name is Vanessa Patrick, she's at the University of Houston, and she wrote this great book called The Power of Saying No. And what she found is that how you say no actually matters. So if you just say, I don't uh if you just say I really want to try to resist this thing, or I I can't keep buying new stuff and whatever it might be, that that may or may not work, but it's a little bit less effective in the psychology of actually making you empowered to decline these things that are luring you in.

SPEAKER_02And so what Dr. Patrick found was saying I don't actually empowers you to be more resistant against your temptations. And she did all kinds of research around this, where people who said, I don't eat fast food, I don't spend too much money on products that I don't need, actually were able to resist their cravings and resist these temptations they were trying to avoid much better than people who said, I can't.

SPEAKER_00That makes a lot of sense. And I think I want to link it a little bit because I will say that perfectionism and people pleasing is another thing that a lot of my listeners struggle with. And so, you know, when you go to write a response to something, and I mean, I still do you start to type it out and you say something like, Well, I feel that or I think that, and you start to like sort of soften it a little bit, you know, because you're trying to be pleasing. But that actually when you use this really like affirmative language for something, you know, and like empowering, like you said, that um that yeah, you're really owning it.

SPEAKER_00And whether you slide or, you know, make a mistake or whatever, but that you just keep coming back to it and get more comfortable with saying um saying that about yourself with that strong language, I think is is actually like a really great thing for people to walk away with from this episode because um it seems like a simple thing, but I actually think that that's probably really challenging for a lot of people who are listening. Um, you know, it takes practice. I mean, I I catch myself all the time when I start to write a response or I I start to type something out, and then I think to myself, no, no, like that's actually not what I mean.

SPEAKER_00I actually mean, you know, what I'm saying. So let's be direct. So being using that direct language is is really helpful.

SPEAKER_02Well, can I that that's a great example? And can I just say one more thing about that, which is that you're talking about people pleasing, and in this case, it's almost like people pleasing, but for your for yourself. And and you're giving in to things that that that maybe you don't want to, and and actually underpinning this is this concept of self-talk, which is just the words you say to yourself out loud or in your head. And oftentimes the the self-talk that we give to ourselves is not very useful.

SPEAKER_02It's right, oh you failed again or you made that mistake again, or why can't you why can't you keep up with this? And and it can actually be, I think I'm sure we've all experienced this, it can really be demoralizing when you start pushing yourself down with your own words. And those words matter, they're very powerful. And and so if you can flip that around and and like you said, it's not easy, it takes practice, but yeah, but use that tool for for good and actually say, I don't do this, or I'm I don't I don't consume new things when I don't want to.

SPEAKER_02And and and by the way, I I think I do want to make sure it's clear that uh that the goal here isn't perfection, and the goal here isn't to to just implement some tips and tricks and you're done and and that's gonna be easy. There are going to be moments where we're all gonna acquire stuff that we don't need or we don't want or that we we regret. And so the point here is not to try to get to some place where you're perfectly, you know, uh declining the things you don't need, not spending enough money.

SPEAKER_02So that's never gonna happen. And so that what matters is what you do after that and how you kind of deal with the decisions that you make. And and certainly, you know, don't beat yourself up and don't, you know, um don't stress too much when you slip up and make a purchase that you you wish you hadn't.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yeah, that's such an important thing for people to hear because uh, you know, we have this expectation of ourselves a lot where we come up with the idea of what we're gonna do, you know, like, okay, I'm not gonna buy ice cream anymore or whatever the thing is, you know. And then you do it. And then immediately people feel like, oh, I failed, and they just give up. But the the reality is if you've been somebody who routinely bought ice cream every single week when you go grocery shopping, that you're gonna take some time to not be somebody who buys ice cream anymore.

SPEAKER_00Some people, you know, may be able to cold turkey and do it, and that happens with some things. Um, I've certainly had cold turkey things that I've been able to switch on, and I have other things that I've not. And so I think it's about, and I just like to tie this to intentional living because I think all of this is about intentionality. It's really about getting to know yourself, you know, that self-talk, like you said, of just being like, okay, well, this time I made the mistake. I didn't want to do that thing and I did it.

SPEAKER_00Next time I'm gonna try again. And just like being really kind to yourself because it's hard, like you said. There's all sorts of things out there that are really sophisticated to get us to buy and to go against what our real desires are. So I think that that's really, really important. Perfection is never the goal. Like I've been um decluttering and like thinking about my stuff for about 12 years, and I still make impulse purchases sometimes. You know, I have like lots of uh, you know, strategies and self-talk and all sorts of stuff that like really prevent me from doing that.

SPEAKER_00And I'm really clear on what my values are and I know the things I don't want to do, but it doesn't mean that I never make a mistake. You know, I I'm a human, I run the gamut of emotions like anybody. And so I think that having that kindness to yourself is like you said, is just really, really important.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. I mean, I I've just written a book called Saying No to New. Yeah. And I'm far from perfect. Yeah. I I definitely don't don't have this, have this uh down pat. But but the point is is that I'm conscious of it. And and I spoke to someone in in the book whose name uh I used the the name Margot her name's not actually Margo, but she had this great outlook on it. She had tried to do one of these no-buys where she went cold turkey for a few months on only necessities to buy.

SPEAKER_02And what she found is a little bit of the ways through it, she slipped up and she bought something she didn't need. Yeah. And then that led to another slip up and another. And but what she realized after that slip up where she broke, you know, she broke the the pledge, was okay, I could either just ditch this pledge because I've failed, or I could just get back into it. Because the whole point is that I'm I'm being more thoughtful about what I'm doing, about my choices, yeah, and and learning from my mistakes. And so she just went back into it.

SPEAKER_02And the point, as she said, was not perfection, but it was the way the no-buy was more of a way to just get her thinking about the things that she was acquiring, not to get her to completely revolutionize the way that she made choices about new stuff.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, I love that because I I mean, in in what I do, those no-buy challenges for sure have popped up many, many times in my feed over the years. And I I definitely have sort of mixed feelings about them. And one, I think that when we get too restrictive about things, um, we can set ourselves up to fail, you know, because the it's difficult, life happens, we get in those busy moments, you know. And so I think it's, you know, knowing your personality.

SPEAKER_00Like, is it gonna be really are you gonna be really hard on yourself if you fail at that? Like what's maybe there may be a middle ground for some people, whereas some people do really well with structure and restriction like that. So it's it's sort of knowing yourself. But um yeah, I think that the the thoughtfulness and what you learn from the experience is just so beneficial. Like if you looked at it like that, like what am I gonna gain out of this, even if I don't nail it? You know, what am I gonna gain out of this experience?

SPEAKER_00It's probably gonna be something positive.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah, exactly. And and just there's there's uh an expert, her name is Amy Edmondson at and she's at Harvard, and she's an expert on failure. She's probably the most leading expert on failure. And she has this very simple concept, she calls it stop, challenge, and choose. And what she recommends is at that moment of failure, whatever it is, you made a mistake at work, or in this case, you bought a whole bunch of stuff at Target or something that you know that feeling you get after you make one of these purchases, and you're like, why did I do that?

SPEAKER_02Stop, challenge, choose. And what what Dr. Edmondson says is stop and and and hold before you kind of get carried away, you're gonna have this rush of emotions. Before you get carried away, pause for a second and then challenge the feelings that you're having and challenge them. Are they being useful? Is this gonna help you the next time you're at Target or you're on your online shopping late at night? And then choose what to do with that. Choose what to do with the failure, choose what to do with the feelings that you're having.

SPEAKER_02And this very simple framework is just a way to sort of short circuit all of the negative emotions that that rush in after you've slipped up and and can kind of help you on the path toward making it a productive learning experience.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. I mean, that one question, like, is this helpful for next time, is just really powerful in itself. Like, um, because how many patterns of thought could you interrupt by just asking yourself that one question? You know, especially if you tend to be somebody who thinks quite negatively about themselves, you know, really just stopping and saying, is this helpful? Like, is this really gonna get me where I want to go? Or is this just keeping me in the same pattern? Um, that next time, you know, the same thing will happen and I'll repeat the same thoughts.

SPEAKER_00And, you know, it's not gonna necessarily prevent me from doing it again. Um, so I wanted to ask, because the subtitle of your book is Why New Things Are Stealing Your Time, Money, and Happiness and How to Take Back Your Life. And since this is a decluttering podcast, we are with you on that. Um, and I know you did a lot of research that's clear for your book. How do new things steal from us, like, you know, time, money, happiness? What are some ways that they steal from us?

SPEAKER_02Sure. Well, we'll start with the easiest one, which is money. It's just much more straightforward. If you have$50 that you spend at the store, that is$50. If you have$50 that you spent at the store on things that you don't need or don't want, or ultimately will end up in the back of a closet, that is$50 that you no longer have to spend on something worthwhile, whether it's uh dinner out with friends, or you using it to go toward a trip that you want to take, or by the way, something new that really will be useful and valuable, because there are new things that are useful out there, they just get buried in the overload of needless and meaningless new stuff.

SPEAKER_02So that's the most straightforward one. But I also write about time and attention, which is a lot less straightforward and much sneakier, which is to say that when we acquire new things, there's all kinds of ways they may be eating up our time and attention. And to give you an example, right now I'm looking around and I can see there's a little bit of clutter in this room that I'm in. There's a uh uh an old fan that I don't use anymore that's just sitting there, and there's a pencil cup that's kind of overloaded with pens and markers and pencils, and all of the physical things in our environment actually matter for our attention.

SPEAKER_02And so the more things we acquire, the the more we have to distribute our attention across all of these things. And related to that, the definition I use for new things in the book is actually a really broad definition because today, of course, we can acquire material new things, products that we can hold in our hands, but we also acquire a lot of new things in the form of digital experiences, content on social media, or for kids, it may be gaming, video games, and digital currency.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Like if you've ever had a kid that's been on Roblox, there's this digital currency and they're called Robux. And it it's the feeling that uh that someone gets from buying something new online that is not real, you can't hold it in your hands, but it's the same kind of feeling that you get from buying something in person. And so the digital things that you acquire, whether they're apps that you download or social media you consume. And again, the the important thing to note here, I'm talking about the things that you personally don't want to consume.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_02There are plenty of things, of course, technologies we use that are that are useful and that that that will will help improve our lives and make us more productive. But but the things that we all know, I think, deep inside, that I I really actually don't want to be spending all this time in this app or whatever it might be, that is that is where it's it's really kind of it's really kind of drawing from our valuable time and attention, which is also finite, just like our money. We only have a certain amount of time to distribute across experiences and only have a certain amount of attention that we can give to anything at once.

SPEAKER_02And then the last thing is happiness, which the problem with new things and happiness is that there's actually a psychology to why do we go and we acquire new stuff? Well, because it gives us a little bit of a sense of joy sometimes, at least in the moment. I think when you think about opening a new box that just landed on your doorstep, and there is that feeling of anticipation and excitement and and and maybe a little bit of joy when you've got this shiny new thing in your hands. Yeah, but the science says that that feeling never lasts.

SPEAKER_02We're not we're built to get back to equilibrium. So the things that feel really good and the things that feel really bad never last forever. And so that feeling of joy that you feel by getting that new thing is gonna fade. And then it's off to the next new thing, and that feeling is gonna fade as well. And so Lori Santos, who's a happiness expert at Yale, what she the way she described this is it's like you're on this treadmill chasing after new things, and and it's impossible to sustain the happiness that you're seeking out because the feelings of joy that you get from things are never gonna last, they're never gonna last forever.

SPEAKER_02And so you can burn through your resources and your time and your effort trying to capture this feeling and sustain it.

SPEAKER_00Huh. Wow, that's so well put. Because it's really, I mean, ultimately saying that we have to look for happiness outside of things. Like, I mean, right and and that, yeah, you won't find and that I mean, it sounds like I mean, really with anything, like I I've always sort of stuck to the m-the mantra that like everything will change, like even with hard things, you know, like when you go through grief or whatever else, like those feelings are ultimately gonna change. You like you said, you know, so it can be good feelings and bad feelings, but that, you know, as a human being, we're going to experience this up and down.

SPEAKER_00And so it's about seeking, um, I don't know, like I've always been a big uh proponent of gratitude, of practicing gratitude because I think that the sense of contentment, um, not that I don't chase happiness, but I think contentment also is like a really good thing to go for because um there's times in life where things aren't going to feel super happy, you know. So um, when can you find contentment when things are hard?

SPEAKER_02And Dr. Santos pointed at gratitude as one of the feelings underpinning happiness. If you can have gratitude for what you do have, there's research that shows that your overall well-being will be higher. But of course, new things are all about what you don't have. By definition, new things don't are not in your life yet. And so looking out at all the new things out there and constantly chasing the new things is in many ways in direct conflict with the concept of gratitude.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yeah, that really makes sense. Um it really does. Because I think that um one, gratitude really is a practice, you know, like it's something that you have to kind of continually do. Because although I do think there are times where you can think about something um and frame it with gratitude and feel good right away, like I think it can give you a quick response. But like things like meditation or exercise or anything that you really practice, sometimes the first time you do it, it's not gonna feel very good.

SPEAKER_03Right.

SPEAKER_00And it might actually take a few times. Like, I don't know if you've ever, you know, gotten the flu and stopped exercising for a week or two, and then you've come back to that first workout. Like it often doesn't feel great the first time. Maybe it does later on, but you know, we don't always get the the benefit immediately.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, uh, I I can relate to that since I've been working on this book of my exercise has slipped a little bit. So I'm good, I'm about to feel that feeling of of trying to get back into a routine. But you're absolutely right. And and and if you going back to our previous point, if you try to to seek perfection in all of this, if you think, oh, I have to be grateful all the time, and why aren't I grateful for everything? Well, that's not the route to go. And so it's just being a little bit thoughtful, giving yourself a break and and and making it a habit and and and forcing yourself to just understand the the the sort of the mechanisms underpinning why we interact with new things, why we're drawn to new things.

SPEAKER_02And because our brains are programmed to ignore old things, the things that we may be grateful for, you do kind of have to force your brain and train your brain to to go and actually, oh, pay attention to this. Look at this. You know, for me, it's been recently there is I've got a shelf full of old board games. And I like board games because it's a great example of something where you could get the digital version of that, which is like a video game or some game on your phone. But the board game is something that's very old.

SPEAKER_02It's a concept that's old. And in fact, these specific board games are ones that that me and my kids haven't played for in years. And I pulled one out and and it was just as enjoyable this time as it was when it was new.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yeah, it's so true. Like, I mean, really what you're saying about how we yeah, we just kind of become blind to the things that are around us all the time. And just even if you had the practice of just thinking about something in your home once a day for a minute, you know, and just like why it's great. Um, and just kind of train your brain to think that way. Cause I I know like I mean, I think I probably came across the concept of gratitude a little bit earlier than when I started my minimalism journey.

SPEAKER_00So it's been over 12 years. And um I will I will say it's completely reframed the way I think about life in general, but that it is an ebb and flow. Like there's sometimes I really focus on that and other times I don't, but I can still access it, you know. Like, like I think like any of these things when, you know, we're thinking about our consumption patterns or when we're looking at new things, like all of this, you can, you know, train your brain to think a certain way. And it doesn't mean that you're constantly on like that, but that when you you need to access it, you can.

SPEAKER_00And that's the great thing about a practice.

SPEAKER_02And on that topic of happiness, here's another trick that I've found to be really useful, which is I think we can get into our heads that we have to keep these things completely separate, that there's there are the new things that are valuable and the new things that are not valuable. And and these are two categories, and we're trying to push one away and we're trying to go to the other. And in some cases, this may be true, but I found that there are ways you can leverage one for the other.

SPEAKER_02And what I mean by that is I write about in the book about sort of frivolous trends that we tend to chase, and they may not be frivolous for everyone, whether it's the cookie trend. And I know I've been in in Manhattan and I've seen these long lines outside the cookie shop for the next cookie edition. And it's it's kind of silly, right? Yeah, it's not a big deal, it's not a big deal if you want to wait in line for a cookie. I'm not saying I'm not trying to to shame people's trend chasing.

SPEAKER_02But if you feel for yourself, like this doesn't seem like a good use of my time, right? This doesn't seem like a good use of your money. Well, here's a trick. If you go and you you go after these trends and these fads and and you do it with a friend, and now you're creating an experience out of it, and new experiences tend to be more valuable in the long term because they're they you create these memories and you create these stories, and you're you're socializing, which is another uh behavior that can can help with your well-being and happiness.

SPEAKER_02So you can take these these behaviors that maybe aren't quite what you're looking for and combine them with an experience, and now you're waiting in line and you're catching up with an old friend or having a laugh with with your significant other, or maybe in some cases it may even be shopping with with a family member. I've I've spoken to people who have these memories of shopping with their grandmother or with their their mother, and and and so you you could see how this could could also get easily get out of control like anything, but yeah, it's kind of a way to relieve some of the pressure that you can't do this and you have to do this.

SPEAKER_02But you know, maybe it's not that simple and we can actually blend together some of these behaviors to make one a little bit better by using the other.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I really love that. Um, I really think that's great because yeah, the experience thing, connection, all of those things are really what I think most of us are really after, right? When you're when you're stuck in consumption or you're seeking something, you're looking for a feeling. You know, we often like go to shop because we're trying to pat down like a negative feeling, but when we you like you're saying pair it with something, it's like positive. And um yeah, I love that.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, that dopamine we talked about earlier. Oftentimes I spoke to someone named Judd Judson Brewer, who's an expert in addiction, and it's those moments of discomfort where we want to relieve the pain. And one way to relieve it is to go find something we know is gonna be rewarding. And that might be a sweet treat, that might be shopping online, it might be going into social media. It's not necessarily going to be rewarding in the long term, but in that moment of the kids having the tantrum or something didn't go well at work or whatever it was, our brains are gonna push us to the instant gratification, the instant rewards.

SPEAKER_02But to your point, you can those rewards can come in all different shapes and sizes. And of course, spending time with people in social connection is is is also rewarding.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Um, yeah, so just I guess like a parting thought for people. Um, is there one thing you would want them to walk away with or like a concrete practice they could take with them, or um, you know, from your book, what would you want to leave people with?

SPEAKER_02Here's what I would say it's you can create kind of a mantra for yourself, which is that new isn't always better. Everywhere we turn, we're trained to believe that new is always better. Yeah, and sometimes it is, and there are a lot of really useful new things out there. And I just recently got a new backpack and it's great. My other one was falling apart and zipper was ripped. It's a new backpack and it's and it's serving a purpose. So we can come up with all of those examples.

SPEAKER_02But if you go into a store, if you go online, you're going to be, there's going to be businesses that are going to try to make you believe that new is always better. And so the thing I would ask people to walk away with is think about this phrase, this very simple phrase that you can carry with yourself, which is that new isn't always better. And I personally have taken that mantra with me wherever I go. And so when I go into a store, when I feel the pull of novelty and newness, or and this probably happens more often, one of my kids wants something new.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I can sort of pull that that mantra out because it's because that's equally as hard, which is that your children are are are pleading with you to buy the new toy or the whatever it might be. New isn't always better. And that can just start to get you to interrogate the thing, whatever it is, and and to try to help yourself understand is this one better? Is this one better than the last one, or is this version better than the previous version? So I would that's what I would ask, you know, suggest people can take away as kind of a useful little trick that they can bring out as as they go navigate the world of newness.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, no, that's fantastic. Very portable. I like those little things that you can take with you everywhere. So I have three final questions that are just for fun that I ask everybody. The first one is um, what's something you can't live without?

SPEAKER_02For this, I chose my notebook, which like my actual physical notebook that I I carry around. And I've found that it's just a really nice way to break from screens, yeah, particularly when I want to take I still use computers. Like I use like a lot. Like I I've got these to-do lists and all this stuff, but I I like having a notebook where I can doodle and I can jot down ideas, and it's not the most practical thing, but I like having it.

SPEAKER_02And so that would be the thing that that I would choose for that that I would, you know, that I that I couldn't live without.

SPEAKER_00That's great. And what about um yeah, because I use I use like my notes app a lot, like the voice to to notes app. But but you know, when you do want to get away from phones, you're right, like a notebook. I I it can be cumbersome, but it is nice to be able to like write things down.

SPEAKER_02It is nice. I'm also a fidgeter, I'm constantly fidgeting. And this is this is another the notebook's another way for me to to fidget where I'm actually doing something.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. Yeah, me too, actually. Um, and what about a favorite quote or saying?

SPEAKER_02If it ain't broke, don't fix it. I love this, it applies to so many things in life, and it's certainly relevant to the idea of saying no to new. I have this old coffee maker that is maybe too old. It doesn't look great, but it does what it needs to do, which is it it makes coffee and it's programmable and it doesn't have many settings. Those are probably the only settings it has. But I could go to Target and find a hundred different coffee makers that are certainly look cooler and do a lot more, but this one's not broken to me.

SPEAKER_00Well, and you know what I think too, when it comes to like appliances, is that older appliances I think are better made. And like having been um, you know, like uh my life's turns out is I recently got separated, so I had to buy like a whole bunch of new stuff. I kept saying to my daughter, I'm like, this is not a normal amount of buying. Like I just wanted to know that. But I will say that there are certain like when you have to buy new appliances, you can just really get a sense of how poorly made things are. So the longer you can hold on to small appliances, I think the better it is.

SPEAKER_00Um and the last one is an easy go-to dinner.

SPEAKER_02Okay, easy go-to dinner. I did a little bit of research because I I I there are a few to choose from. And but I went with the Ritzy, the Ritzy cheddar chicken breasts. And this is full disclosure, this is a New York Times recipe. I work for the New York Times. Yeah. So I'm a little bit biased, but I love the MIT cooking app. And this one is relatively simple. Once you do, it's one of those recipes where once you do it once, you can whip it up pretty quickly. But but the basic idea is you've got chicken breasts that you slice in half, you get uh egg white, and and then you get some cheese and some breadcrumbs.

SPEAKER_02And here's the secret breast, here's the secret ingredient to this, which is a sleeve or two of Ritz crackers that get crumbled up with all of this, and it creates this really crispy chicken breast that you can kind of throw it all together onto the chicken breast, pop it in the oven, and it's a great meal. And once you get the hang of it, you can make it very quickly.

SPEAKER_00Oh, that sounds delicious. Like crispy and savory.

SPEAKER_01Exactly.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Well, so for those listening who want to know more, they want to buy the book. Where can they find you? And where can they buy the book?

SPEAKER_02You can buy the book, saying no to new wherever you buy books. And if you want to learn more about it or learn but learn more about me or sign up for my newsletter, I've made this very easy. You can go to saying not to new.com.

SPEAKER_00Awesome. Oh, thank you so much for your time today. This is such a great conversation.

SPEAKER_02Thank you, Sarah. This has been great.

SPEAKER_00That's all for today. I'll see you again next week. And if you like today's episode and found it helpful, I'd be so grateful if you would write a review. If you do, your name will be entered for this month's giveaway. You can also share with another mom who would be helped by listening. And be sure to follow me on Instagram at Simple Intentional. Thanks for listening.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. 198// My Interview on The Millennial Minimalists Podcast: Simplify Your Home + Mind

    Nov 17, 20261 hr 1 minAudio

    Are you looking for ways to simplify your home, reduce overwhelm and create more ease in your everyday life? Kelly Foss, host of the Millennial Minimalists podcast speaks with Sarah Horgan, decluttering and intentional...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. 197// Just Start

    Nov 14, 202619 minAudio

    Beginning is hard, sometimes we just have to start. Join me Wednesday November 18th at 1pm EST for a FREE masterclass, details and sign up here: https://simpleintentional.kit.com/cuttheoverwhelm Want to work with more...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. 196// What’s Inward Is Outward: Healing Your Relationship with Stuff with Lili Pettit of Clutter Healing

    Nov 10, 202651 minAudio

    Clutter is about so much more than stuff. It’s an outward reflection of our inner world: what we believe, what we’ve lived through, our self-worth and the mental load we carry. This week I’m joined by Lili Pettit,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. 195// Why Decluttering is Important

    Nov 3, 202615 minAudio

    I see so many women stay stuck in overwhelm because decluttering doesn't make it to the top of the list. Here's the case for why it should. Join for the bonus session here: https://simpleintentional.kit.com/challenge...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. 194// Ditching Shame-Based Money Advice with The Finance Girlies

    Oct 28, 20261 hr 11 minAudio

    Do you feel financially confident? Does that question make you uncomfortable? Money is practical but it’s also emotional, and like clutter, avoiding it only makes things heavier. This week I’m joined by Emily Batdorf...

    Credit the people on this episode