Foresters are pretty good at stand-level silviculture. But what if we want to make changes to forest vegetation at a much larger scale? Silviculture at scale to impact landscape-level change is much trickier, whether that’s aiming for a target age-class distribution or meeting the broad habitat needs of birds. Where do we even begin? In walks the concept of Dynamic Forest Restoration Blocks, or the strategy of breaking up the landscape into manageable and biologically meaningful units where we can focus on specific forest management objectives. Join us on this episode as we talk with pioneers of this concept, Jeff Larkin, professor in the Department of Biology at Indiana University of Pennsylvania and Forest Bird Advisor with the American Bird Conservancy, and Dan Heggenstaller, North Central Regional Forester with the Pennsylvania Game Commission. Send us Fan Mail
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_02Welcome to Silvicast, the podcast about all things silviculture. My name is Brad Hutnick, and I'm Greg Edge. And we're both silviculturists with the Wisconsin DNR Division of Forestry and your host for today's show. You know, I really think uh they did a nice job on closing out this timber sale.
SPEAKER_01IKR. Really careful work on those OSR and IR areas. Right. And I really appreciate the CWD. They left for the DLs. DLs? The drumming logs. NGL Brad, BMP-wise, they could have put a few more BBDs on this run. BBDs? Well, those are broad-based dips. Oh. Still, I think this road is well away from the RMZ.
SPEAKER_01And I didn't see any other WRs on the SWDV.
SPEAKER_02So if I got this right, Greg, you had an extra helping of Alphabet Soup for lunch. Uh what do you mean? Well, you know, uh hanging out at abbreviation station.
SPEAKER_01I mean, I give, I give uh conjunction, junction. There you go. What's with all the acronyms? Oh, I I don't know. And you know, I'm just trying to be efficient with my conversation, I guess. You know, you know, conserve words. Well, that's what I'm doing.
SPEAKER_02Okay, let's just hope it's not the alphabet suit fallacy, which where you basically, in order to confuse someone, you may use words that kind of mask your understanding of something. So let's just hope it's not that. Otherwise, we're IDK. Oh boy. You know, we're just gonna call this the Dunning and Krieger show from now on, and then people can make their own assumptions about what we do and how we do things.
SPEAKER_01What does a country band have to do with this?
SPEAKER_02Yeah. You know, we're just gonna leave it right there, Greg. Hey, you know, I you know, you didn't get the memo that I'm supposed to be the crazy one in these things either, right? Well, no, I don't know about that. I had a guest actually say, Oh, you're the crazy one, right?
SPEAKER_01Which was oh, that's good.
SPEAKER_02It was, it was uh it was one of those things, but my plan is working perfectly. Yeah. But talking about acronyms, today we're going to be talking about DFRBs or dynamic forest restoration blocks. Now, these are units meant to help us better plan forest management on a landscape level. So let's meet up with our guests, Jeff Larkin, professor in the Department of Biology at Indiana University of Pennsylvania, and Forest Bird Advisor for the American Bird Conservancy, and Dan Higgenshaller, North Central Regional Forester for the Pennsylvania Game Commission.
SPEAKER_02Jeff and Dan have pioneered this concept across thousands of acres of forest land in Pennsylvania. And Greg, don't embarrass me with even more of your verbal shorthand. What E? This season of Silvicast is brought to you by the Nelson Paint Company, McCoy Construction and Forestry, and the Family Forest Carbon Program. You make the Silvicast world go round. So thank you.
SPEAKER_02Jeff Larkin and Dan Hegenstahler, welcome to Silvicast. For our audience, tell us a little bit about where you work and what you do. Dan, why don't we start with you?
SPEAKER_03Sure, yeah. I'm a regional forester for the Pennsylvania Game Commission's North Central Region. And in that role, uh, essentially, I work with our forestry staff, our land management staff, and our biologists to manage all the forested habitat on uh our state game lands. That's the public land owned by the game commission in Pennsylvania, all the state game lands in the north central region of Pennsylvania. So we do everything from you know lots of commercial timber sales to prescribed burning and non-commercial habitat projects.
SPEAKER_03So our aim in the forestry division and the game commission is just to improve wildlife habitat on state game lands for the whole range of wildlife species in Pennsylvania.
SPEAKER_02I know, Greg, we get a lot of material that comes from the east, and I'm always impressed. It seems like Pennsylvania is kind of an eastern version of Wisconsin in some ways, maybe a little more hilly, you know, in in that regard, but very similar in the kind of the just the landscape.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, a lot of where I work is at that interface between kind of the oak and the northern hardwood ecosystems. That brings some challenges. A lot of stands kind of could go either way, what what they're gonna be. But it's also fun because you get to work in a lot of different forest types, and I think it is pretty similar to some of the lake states. Cool.
SPEAKER_02And how about you, Jeff?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I'm Jeff Larkin. I'm a faculty at Indiana University of Pennsylvania, and I'm also the forest bird habitat advisor for the American Bird Conservancy. I guess in those two roles, I think I have a terrific position in that I'm I'm able to work with partners, collaborators to do a lot of the conservation science and that leads to recommendations that we that we target uh for use by individuals like Dan and the Game Commission and others.
SPEAKER_00And then on the on the flip side, I'm I'm able to work with them directly, and as uh as an advisor for the American Bird Conservancy, I'm able to work with them directly to apply those best management practices or what other uh guidelines we might have on the land. So that's it's really exciting for me to be able to do science and see it be implemented full circle.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. I love the idea that you're kind of at that nexus between implementation and then what the science tells us. So you get to actually see does something work or not work, or you know, kind of take something from theory and actually see it on the ground.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's it's been tremendous over the last you know 15 years, actually going on 20 years since I've been here at IUP, starting with the conservation science. What is it about the ecology of the species that we work with that we can learn and then synthesize into applied information, right? The applied information is critical. We always say that you know, not too many species have been saved by glossy documents. It's it's when those glossy documents are put to use.
SPEAKER_00And being able to be to think about how we implement the science that we do, working with folks like Dan and the Game Commission and and others, and then seeing that implemented, and then going back on the on the opposite end and doing the monitoring, right, and assessing the outcome assessments, being able to see if what we thought was going to work actually works, and if not, how do we improve that, right? That that process of adaptive management.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so I'm quite fortunate to be in that in that position.
SPEAKER_02So today we're going to talk about dynamic forest restoration blocks or DFRBs. So both of you, what are dynamic forest restoration blocks?
SPEAKER_03Well, essentially, DFRBs are simply landscapes where we are kind of putting into practice the notion that age class diversity all across the landscape and structural diversity within stands are gonna that's the approach that's gonna benefit a wide range of game and non-game species. In particular in Pennsylvania, a bunch of species of greatest conservation need that we really care about. So things like Rough Grouse, Golden Wing Warbler.
SPEAKER_03And so as Forester working for a wildlife agency, I feel like over the last 10 or 15 years, we've kind of been inundated by all those glossy documents that Jeff mentioned. They all seem to be about birds. The bird people seem to make really nice BMP documents uh for us. And the kind of through line in most of them was that, you know, we need to diversify our landscape, you know, increase age class diversity.
SPEAKER_03But at the same time, some of those species, like wood thrush or cerulean warbler, the emphasis there was really on the other end of the spectrum on late successional forests or, you know, increasing structural complexity in those stands. And so I think it's important to make sure like the DFRB concept isn't super revolutionary. Like we already had comprehensive management plans for all of our game lands. We were, we have, we had goals and objectives. But what is really important about it is that, you know, in our region where we have almost 390,000 acres of game lands, sometimes your work ends up being quite distributed out there across all those those areas.
SPEAKER_03And you might not be moving the needle on those landscape-level habitat metrics in any one landscape, if if you're uh you know not kind of in attentively working in the same place for a little while. So what DFRBs really do is just focus your uh resources, of course, personnel and and uh funding, and also really your attention on a particular landscape that you've you know designated with the goals and objectives you have for it, and kind of throwing everything at it in order to get it moving closer to the habitat conditions that we need for some of these species like like rough grouse or or woodcock or or others that need that you know high level of interspersion.
SPEAKER_03And so you know in in most cases, we're you know looking to meet goals that we already have set for the game lands. It's just a way to really concentrate efforts.
SPEAKER_02Dan, you know, you said, well, it's not really revolutionary, but it kind of is because your management is informed by what's happening at the landscape around where you are. And I thought there was a really good line in I think some stuff that I read about your work in Pennsylvania it was described this work as sustainable forestry applied at ecologically meaningful scales. Yeah. Which I think is really important because I don't think a lot of us get the chance to do that.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I I think that's a that's a great that's a great point. You know, this the science is increasingly clear that forest management activities that strategically and responsibly, right, I think that's an important thing to keep in mind here, attempt to diversify age class and structural complexity at the at the at biologically and ecologically meaningful scales is going to be essential if we're gonna be recovering many of these wildlife species that have that have been exhibiting long-term population declines, whether they're game or non-game species.
SPEAKER_00It was through I would say a a a collection of of research projects, not just from you know my lab at at IUP, but but through throughout the East, folks looking at kind of the the hidden lives, if you would, the hidden parts of bird lives that we might not have really had a good grasp on previously, that brought us to this conclusion that, you know, it's it's not just that a wood thrush needs an old forest, right?
SPEAKER_00That might be where their nest is, and that might be where they sing most conspicuously, and we always then became, you know, uh somewhat you know associated with uh with oh wood thrush, they need mature big forests. But as as researchers began to look at the secret lives of the post-fledging, like what do they do when they leave the nest? And golden wing warblers, uh, Camp Fist, a student in my lab, and and then thinking about Doug Raebuck's work with cerulean warblers, we quickly learn that where these species build their nests is not at all what it looks like where they bring their fledglings.
SPEAKER_00And, you know, just because you successfully leave the nest does not mean that you're gonna grow a population. You need those juveniles to survive and migrate to Central and South America and and return the next year. And you have to remember that these things they pop out of the nest at like eight days old. They don't have tails, they barely, you know, they barely have feathers, they're terrible fliers. Everything wants to eat them. They can't move very far. So they're trying to eat and evade predators and and to think about the limited mobility they have relative to where they nest, it just screams that we need to do better at a at a local landscape scale at making sure that they have those various conditions that will allow those populations to grow.
SPEAKER_00And that's really where the dynamic forest program with American Bird Conservancy um evolved is really through that conservation science and thinking about, all right, we've got to do better. There are folks like Dan and and other groups, private, private landowners as well, that have been doing this work in the in the forest, right? They have, it's not like they haven't been out there doing work in the forest. Resources, when you have a shared vision, brings forest and wildlife together and these goals and objectives together.
SPEAKER_00And we think about how we can work as a partnership to focus our resources, like as in money, to do a lot of that non-commercial work that has, you know, that's that's really important in order for us to be able to move on to some of the of the more impactful practices. That's really where the dynamic forest restoration block concept came from.
SPEAKER_01So, Jeff or Dan, like how big are these dynamic forest restoration blocks, or is that driven by the bird species and the habitat needs of those birds?
SPEAKER_00They range between three and I'd say thirty thousand acres. It depends. Oh. We we we primarily work in three parts of Pennsylvania. And those three portions of Pennsylvania being the the Laurel Highlands, the North Central region, and then the Poconos region, those regions in and of themselves support bird forest bird communities. Canada warbler, wood thrush, cerulean warbler, golden wing.
SPEAKER_00A lot of those species that are most imperiled. So we we focus on those regions of the state, and then within those regions, what makes all of this work is that we have partners, right? We have folks that manage the land that that share the vision that we have. So it's not like we identify where the dynamic forest blocks are going to be. We identify that, hey, we are happy to work in this region because there are important there are important avian conservation needs in this region, populations we need to keep on the landscape.
SPEAKER_00And we let our partners identify which of the land units they particularly manage that are going to basically be adopted into the dynamic forest restoration block program.
SPEAKER_02Is it kind of dictated by like those willing partners too? Like you might really want it in a particular place, but without the partners you go to wherever that there's a willingness to actually work?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, no doubt about it. I cannot overstate the importance of the partnership, right? And the partners Dan does not need, and Dan's foresters nor any of the of the partners we work with, they don't need us telling them how to do what they need to do. We they might need our input as as far as like spatial arrangements and what some of the nuances of the species we're most interested in um require. But no, in most cases they have places where they have been for whatever reason limited in their ability to implement forest management for whatever it could be resources, could be access.
SPEAKER_00We want to work with them to to eliminate the bottleneck. Whatever it is we can do within within our grant funds, we're happy to work with them to overcome those challenges that they face.
SPEAKER_01How many of these do you have across Pennsylvania?
SPEAKER_00We started in 2017. This is really for for your for your listeners, I think this is really important. Because I'm gonna throw some bigger numbers out here, but I I want to say we started small. Since 2017, we've designated more than 366,000 acres across 35 unique forest blocks. Again, they range from three to thirty thousand acres in size. They sometimes are adjacent to each other, so we might have we might have a private hunt club with 4,000 acres that's adjacent to a game lands, that's adjacent to a state park.
SPEAKER_00So we might have collections that are kind of like uh connected landscapes. But we have that many, but I but I really think it's important to point out that in 2017 when we first applied for external funding, and we thought we could apply for about$250,000 is what the RFP said we could ask for. We um wrote the the grant and the the funder came back, a terrific supporter of our program, uh National Fish and Wildlife Foundation, came back and said, Yeah, I know it said 250,000, but we really only have 72,000 this year.
SPEAKER_00Can you do? And we're like, no, we'll do, we'll take it. We we will absolutely take it. We will do something good with it. And that's where we started our first block. It wasn't even an it wasn't even an entire game lance, it was half of a game lance in the Poconos. We took that opportunity and we did the best we could with it, and we we brought more partners to the table and we demonstrated that drafting a dynamic forest uh comprehensive plan, the the monitoring of birds beforehand, and of course implementing actual, you know, actually implementing forest management, we showed that at scale within that half of a of a DFRB.
SPEAKER_00And from that point on, I think we're up to about 15 million dollars since 2017 that we have been able to raise either as partner matching or from our our funders.
SPEAKER_02So that's a kind of like start small and get big.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_02But then each of those areas, so each of the dynamic forest restoration blocks you mentioned has a plan. What does that plan look like? Is it is there uh is it very, very detailed or is it more broad in scope?
SPEAKER_03So I I can talk about how the the DFRBs on Game Land, how we do the planning for those. So uh so the the Game Land system in Pennsylvania is it's really cool in that the their parcels range in size from just a few hundred acres to I think almost 50,000 acres. And so we're looking at I think all of our DFRBs, at least in my area, are kind of between that five and twenty-five thousand acre range. So e each of those game lands all along has had a comprehensive management plan that lays out kind of what we want to do there.
SPEAKER_03And I think working through the DFRB concept, for me at least, has helped really improve those plans. So kind of we we use our comprehensive management plans as the DFRB plan. And, you know, really needing to dial in on what the desired future conditions are gonna be from an age-class distribution standpoint, where on the landscape things are gonna happen, what type of management regimes we're gonna use has really, I think, improved a lot of our comprehensive management plans.
SPEAKER_03And so there is a little bit of a range of detail. We like our our foresters, kind of like uh everybody, and I'm sure you've met the foresters that kind of they have everything planned out almost like to the tree for the next uh 15 years. And then there's all there's and I'm I'm not so much that way. I'm more of a like we're we're gonna delineate you know this portion of the game lands that's gonna be, you know, managed in a certain management regime, and and you know, within that area we're gonna try to hit X number of acres during this planning period.
SPEAKER_03That's kind of how uh the the approach uh I like. So each game lands that's that's BFRB or even the rest of our game lands, the forested areas are uh given a kind of a tag that we call management type. So every acre of forest on the game lands is falls into one of four management types. So kind of the the big one is mixed succession, and you can kind of shorthand that is even age management. So that's where we're gonna you know get our age class diversity in the mixed succession uh stand.
SPEAKER_03So those are gonna be you know where we're gonna primarily be doing shelter woods and overstore removals and you know, create that kind of pipeline of of young. Forest habitat. Then we've got late successional management type. And so that's where we're going to be doing active management toward late successional conditions. We're going to be in there doing stand improvement things, maybe looking to increase coarse woody debris or increase structural complexity, deal with invasive pests and diseases.
SPEAKER_03But ultimately those stands are going to be left to kind of mature into old forests. And then the third one is reserve, which those are places we are not doing anything. There's no intended management there. Maybe we can't get to them. Maybe there are really sensitive sites that were not just not going to work. And then the last one is fire management, which I think is maybe better described as kind of like oak woodland or savanna management type. So where we have those kind of real fire-dependent ecosystems.
SPEAKER_03For us, it's going to be like pitch pine scrub oak areas. Then you can really start to build a picture of what that DFRB can provide you from a habitat standpoint down the road. Because, you know, in many cases, you know, in a mountainous part of the state, just not, you're not going to, you may only have 50% of a game lands that you can even do even-aged management on.
SPEAKER_03And so that's going to just kind of limit how much age class diversity you're going to make using kind of conventional forestry, but maybe you have a lot of opportunities for within stand kind of structural manipulation through hand cutting or late successional work. So that's that's kind of what our plans look like. And you know, the the level of detail, you know, there's a base level we we we want to see in all of them, and then beyond that it's kind of up to what what the foresters think is the best thing for them.
SPEAKER_01It sounds like you almost take that stand level detail and then build up to, as you said, what that block is capable of. And then really the key link that sometimes, Brad, we miss is jumping to that landscape and what's the desired future condition, as you said, Dan, you want to get to in that block. So how is that desired future condition like determined in terms of your age class distribution or the different cover types?
SPEAKER_01Do you just look at you know what the resource is and then what the capabilities are? And how does that planning process look?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, that's a great question. It's you know, it on many landscapes, because of topography and site limitations, and you know, steep slopes, we generally want to make maximize that age class diversity within that mixed accession area. So the the goal for that that mixed accession area is kind of like, well, it's to balance the age classes. And so that's that's kind of the standard goal in that management type. And that seems to generally work because you know, when you have a uh a 10,000 acre game lands and only half of it is is really in that bucket, you're really not butting up against having too much young forest problem.
SPEAKER_03Because if you're gonna run that half of the game lands on a 100 or 120-year rotation, you know, if it's an oak-dominated game land, you're you're you're still only gonna have 10% of that area that's really in that zero to 10 bucket at any one time. So in a in a quite a few cases of just having that general goal of like maximizing diversity, you're gonna put a lot of what you know, almost all of what you can put into mixed, you're you're gonna probably put in mixed.
SPEAKER_03But I want to be very careful in saying there are many cases where we're also, you know, working with our biologists, our land managers, and like the planning team that writes the plan to identify places, and they might be great timber, you know, easily operable. We could make young forest there, but for whatever reason, maybe the species composition or just the location on the landscape, we think they're really important and and would be better served as as late successional stands.
SPEAKER_03So it's not just about operability by any stretch. We're we're putting stands you know right along a road with you know, a good example might be a a really nice 120-year-old saw timber sized white oak stand with maybe a hickory component or something. Boy, that's a stand that just has a ton of wildlife value as a as a mature forest. And so you might want to think hard about whether that should be late successional.
SPEAKER_03And we can go in there and do some kind of stand health management and increase you know, regen in case something happens to the overstory, but not ever actually regenerate that using even age method. So the approach that we take a lot is we kind of take a first swipe at the plan, kind of looking at what the landscape can kind of provide us. Then we might dial, dial in and look at what is are there a per particular wildlife species on this game lands that are really important?
SPEAKER_03So, for example, maybe snowshoe hare in parts of our region, or uh rough grouse are kind of important all over. Or could is it a species that really benefits more from kind of big mature forest patches? Then we start to kind of tweak it one way or the other to reach that desired future condition that makes the most sense for the species that are important on that landscape, and you know, realistically what the landscape can provide. And I mean, you'll you'll hear numbers, particularly for things like grouse, that we want to have you know 15 or 20 percent of a landscape and you know that young forest habitat.
SPEAKER_03Well, the reality is just a lot of our landscapes have a hard time providing that sustainably because you know, with our rotation lengths and the forest types we have and the uh kind of inaccessible places, it's just hard to hit those those numbers. So we can do the best we can within the landscape constraints and then kind of push it one way or the other to try to meet specific goals. So each plan has you know kind of what we expect those desired future conditions should be in it, and then we do uh like a five-year checkup in in the middle of the plan.
SPEAKER_03It's a 10-year plan to kind of see if we're moving in that right direction or not.
SPEAKER_02Do you ever look outside the boundary of your area to kind of maybe sway your goals one way or the other, thinking maybe this part of the landscape's gonna provide it, so maybe we don't have to provide that part?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, absolutely. We have a game lands in our region that is surrounded by a uh a wild area that's managed by our Bureau of Forestry, where as far as I know, they do they're not gonna, you know, no planned management in that area, and it's almost 50,000 acres. And so if there's gonna be any young forest in there uh other than you know, wind throw and kind of natural events, it's gonna be on our our game lands. Uh, the the the one interesting uh kind of twist to that is you what I find is when I start looking at the landscape, you can start looking at it all different ways.
SPEAKER_03You you could look at it and say, well, maybe we should lean into that and have an enormous area of mature forest habitat, and maybe we actively manage ours, but you know, push it towards late succession, or maybe we should provide the thing that's not being provided in the landscape. So that's where you know talking to our biologists and working with folks like Jeff can help us kind of you know make those decisions. And just another example of that is like we have a lot of the smaller game lands, you know, maybe a thousand-acre game lands that's it's in an agricultural landscape.
SPEAKER_03Those would not be places where we're using this approach because we're not looking for kind of maybe maximum diversity of age classes there. Maybe in that landscape, mature oak stands are so limiting that almost all of them are going to be managed as late successional forests. So yeah, we certainly look at that landscape context when trying to you know pick out what those future conditions should be.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and I would I would add that there are some dynamic forest restoration blocks that that are that do not have a comprehensive plan. They didn't start with a comprehensive plan. They might be from partners, large private landowners, for example, some of our other uh public lands outside of the game commission, where there's not a forest management plan. And the first step in that process is we have four foresters out there right today that are DFRB foresters.
SPEAKER_00They are inventorying these lands, they're delineating stands, they are identifying the what we would say the assets, the opportunities, the threats, and all of that goes into uh our GIS and and a plan development. And at the end of the day, we come out with a 15-year dynamic forest restoration block plan and maybe the identification of a few kind of low-hanging fruit projects to get those landowners kind of moving in the direction of diversifying their their their forest landscapes.
SPEAKER_00What's most important is Yeah, you could have a five thousand acre reserve on the outside of a DFRB, but we have to keep in mind the really important driver of why we're doing dynamic forest restoration, right? It's it's the ecologically and biologically meaningful scales. So, you know, you could have a five thousand acre forest block that's mature, right? And and the the iconic oven bird of s uh of that mature forest, we know in recent decades that they take their fledglings to places with dense understories, sometimes regenerating timber harvests if available.
SPEAKER_00They have to get there. So, you know, being being in a five thousand acre block of mature forest and being some great distance to some place where they need to bring their young that's that's that's quite a distance away. That that is what could be driving a lot of these bird population declines. So we have to be cognizant of the biology that's going on here.
SPEAKER_01So it sounds like to me that there's a lot of customization that goes into the blocks, depending on what resources you have within there and what the needs are of the species that you have within that.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I I think a great example, Dan, is DFRB uh 89, where the the intention was that that shelter wood and to regenerate that one stand. And uh I'll never forget Dan uh one one mid-May, Dan uh calling me from the field and sending me a video, and this stand had just had its first entry of the of the of the shelter wood, and it was just dripping with cerulean warblers.
SPEAKER_00Songs of cerulean. He was just like, and you know, I you know, I make fun of Dan. You know, don't know if he knows all his birds. I didn't think he knew Cerulean Warbler, but he did after that day. He's just like, I think these are cerulean warblers, and I mean it was impressive. And then later to find out, Dan and and his his foresters uh in the north central region said, Hey, that stand's not going to regenerate anymore. You know, that's where it's staying. We're gonna manage it, you know, as as cerulean warbler.
SPEAKER_00Nesting habitat, the response was so great. So kind of the ab the ability to pivot to be able to say, hey, we just learned something here. We just we just the monitoring aspect, right? This was not officially identified through the monitoring process. It was Dan monitoring, you know, just doing his due diligence as as a manager of those lands in the midst of a timber harvest that they came to the recognition recognition that hey, this this place has got a great response of a species that's really not doing that well. So let's let's leave it as is and and try to sustain the population here on the site.
SPEAKER_02Looking for continuing education credits? Check out the SilvaCast webpage for more information. And now back to our show. I'm curious, and this is maybe just a side tangent to it, but how do you guys wrap climate change and climate change considerations into this?
SPEAKER_03When I think about that, I I think that climate change is really just like one more stressor that we're gonna be dealing with on top of the pile of other stressors. We have a lot of spongy moth issues. Pennsylvania have had for 30 years. So, you know, our oak stands are are at risk of being defoliated every, you know, once every decade or so. We've had a bunch of late frosts the last couple years that have really hammered some of our white oak stands.
SPEAKER_03And so the like what I see when those stress events happen is that when you have a landscape of age-class diversity, when the young stands can handle that stuff. So you don't want all your really nice oak stands to be 120 years old. You know, you want some of them to be 10 years old and some of them to be 25 years old. And I think those stands seem to be much more resilient to those to those types of events.
SPEAKER_03And something I think just kind of on the stress front that you know I've really been thinking about lately is as our oak stands in particular continue to kind of accumulate these stress events over the years, are are they really going to last 150 years, 200 years, like we kind of think of oak being able to do? I'm not so sure. So one of our big focuses in these in our our game lands and on these DFRBs in stands, those late successional stands that we've designated for some reason because we like what's growing there now.
SPEAKER_03You know, it's a a really nice mature oak forest that's important for let's say, you know, acorn production for for game species or something. We better be working toward establishing regen in the understory of that stand, even if we don't have any intention of regenerating it. If we want that to be a permanent, as permanent as anything can be, a long-term uh oak resource on the landscape. So kind of just creating that resiliency, I think, is really important for all those all those stressors.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that gets to a lot of conversations we've had, Brad, with folks like Dan Day and Joe Herring, Pat Rose and all about oak stands and creating those advanced regeneration conditions.
SPEAKER_02And even you remember Joe Herring with in Iowa talking about just like you were saying, Dan, the the immediate problems with these stands aren't holding together as long as they thought they were going to. What about the original or the stressor? When I think of Pennsylvania, we always think of one stressor that and that would be deer.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_02So what about deer? How do you how do you incorporate deer into these?
SPEAKER_03Well, they are incorporated, but that's for sure. That deer are a constant thing that we have to consider. Deer impact is is variable across our all the different game lands, as I'm sure you you guys know, it's it's localized much, much worse, but in some areas not as bad in other areas, but in general, they all have some level of deer impact that that is a big challenge for us. And so some of the resources that we are allocating towards these game lands are for things like deer fences.
SPEAKER_03We actually use quite quite a lot of deer fencing on all these blocks uh in the regeneration process. And I mean nobody likes deer fences, they're they're expensive, they're they're hard to maintain, but we do have certain landscapes where we just aren't able to move forward without some kind of deer protection. And I I think, you know, as a as a deer hunter, and and Jeff Jeff deer hunts with me on some of these DFRBs, you know, the thing is we're improving deer habitat uh all along by you know by by creating young forest and by you know making making browls.
SPEAKER_03We're we're just making better conditions for deer, so we're kind of pulling them into these to these places. I've not really seen, at least on our landscapes, the ability to kind of hit that landscape level of browse that we can kind of uh overwhelm them. Just haven't seen it in in the north central region. It maybe is just because there's so many kind of deep dark canyons that they can hide in uh in deer season and and then come out and forage on our air on our sales and project areas and and prescribe fire areas.
SPEAKER_03So it's a constant challenge for us. And we're kind of always thinking ahead about you know, sail layout, sales shape, that like if we have to put a fence around something, you know, we we need to be able to do that. And of course, it also you know, deer impact also sometimes means that you have to be more aggressive at treating interfering vegetation that you might not have had to. The desirable seedlings weren't you know being hindered in their height growth.
SPEAKER_03So if we played a drinking game, you know, uh talking about deer, I'd be in I'd be in big trouble because I talk about it all the time.
SPEAKER_01Is that ever a is that ever an objective within a block you mentioned, Dan, of getting to a certain percentage in Young Forest? Simply I kind of think of just a conversation we had with Susan Stout about the Kinzawa unit, which is in Pennsylvania as well, and uh that idea of getting to a certain threshold on the landscape of Young Forest where deer browse is lessened because they have more forage. Is that ever a goal within the blocks, or are you just you said you haven't seen that?
SPEAKER_03It's not a goal uh for a couple reasons. I I think it and it it it could work in certain landscapes with certain deer densities, but I think we may have in in some places kind of tipped over into where that's going to be challenging you know in in in in some of our landscapes. And the other thing about it is you you kind of end up subsuming all your other goals for interspersion and landscape diversity, uh, if you're trying to hit that big number.
SPEAKER_03Now, we actually have done that in in places where we've had a lot of spongy moth mortality and have salvaged, you know, three, four, five thousand acres uh in just a few years. And no doubt in those areas, this was maybe 10 to 12 years ago, we did see uh pretty good regen response. The problem was once all of that hit stem exclusion, there was nothing to eat on that landscape. Yeah, that's the problem, right?
SPEAKER_03That's the problem. Like it's uh one of my colleagues that I work with here, she has said, what's a lever you can pull exactly one time on a landscape? And I think that's that's exactly right. And so, like on that landscape that had all that young forest heading towards STEM exclusion, some of those stands we didn't we weren't super thrilled with the kind of the regen uh species mix in there, and so we were gonna start, and we also wanted to kind of try to break up that like giant age class slug so we could keep some of that young forest going a little bit longer.
SPEAKER_03So we started in on burning some of those stands. And I'm not talking, you know, we were burning 20 acres. I mean, we were doing, you know, maybe 200-acre burns in these, you know, eight-year-old clear cuts to try to, you know, improve the competitive situation of the oak and also to kind of set some of them back. And the problem is at that point, because most of the landscape was heading into STEM exclusion, when we burned that you know, 200-acre stand, it just got kind of annihilated in a landscape that just five years before that we were seeing really positive results because you know that was the only 200 acres right there that pulled the deer into that yeah, into that re-sprout.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, it seemed to. So it's yeah, it's a it's a big challenge.
SPEAKER_01I got a whole bunch of questions. I'm just trying to think about imp Implementing this year. We've been looking for different ways to try to do a better job at the landscape level. And Jeff, you had mentioned monitoring and how maybe you use the songbirds to maybe monitor what the results are. What does that look like? Do you do like pre-monitoring before you start a block or when you first start a block and then afterwards?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, we sure do. So we kind of think about collecting baseline data and then kind of longitudinal down the line and probably down the line long after, you know, Dan and I are on the job and thinking about, you know, you have to consider just how long it's going to take for us to respond, right? We we implement a treatment, a practice, and then and then Mother Nature needs to do her thing, and hopefully deer allow that to happen and you know recognize that deer might be a part of of that structural complexity as well.
SPEAKER_00So, yeah, forest birds, right? They have this intimate relationship. We have such diversity of forest birds because they have this intimate relationship between forest structure and species composition. And what are the things that we are manipulating when we're managing landscapes is structure and composition. When a DFRB comes online, we monitor it for the first two years. So that what we first do is we randomly assign, well, it's kind of like a systematic random, stratified random, because we're we are trying to sample if there is some diversification already in this block, then we want to make sure we have some points in in those places as well.
SPEAKER_00But think about a couple of hundred points at least in a dynamic forest block scattered all over the place. And during the breeding season, avian breeding season, we have point count technicians that visit each of those points twice. They visit them for 10 minutes each, assessing bird communities. We then go back at the end of the season and we do a vegetation assessment at that point count location. In 2020, we started using autonomous recording units. We teamed up with Justin Kitz's lab at the University of Pittsburgh, a terrific bioacoustics lab.
SPEAKER_00That's really a we we started realizing, you know, when you start out, you're like, oh, 200 points to do this year, 400 points to do this year. We're up to almost 4,000 points that we have in our monitoring program. Now we don't obviously monitor all four 4,000 in a year, but you know, you start to run into constraints, right? Where you have to have people who A, can know their birds, know their forest birds well, so you get rigorous information and are comfortable working in pretty remote, rugged places, you know, encounters with with bears and rattlesnakes and ticks and all that comes with that and steep terrain and being able to navigate, you start to come to a little bit of a limitation.
SPEAKER_00But what's beautiful about the autonomous recording units is we put them out that we can we can program them, we put them out there now. Actually, we have a crew out there putting autonomous recording units out. We can we can capture the rough grouse drumming period, we can program them in the evening for woodcock, we can program them at night in May and June and July for Whippoorwill. We can get the morning song bird, all on one, you know, on one set of batteries that we you know, we put a unit out, we visit it, right? We put it out today, and we don't collect it until June or end of July.
SPEAKER_00So we have this terrific amount of baseline information on both the the bird community as well as the as well as the the forest structure on those on those points. And we should also think about those recordings, they're recording everything, right? So Katie dids, whatever, coyotes, whatever makes some kind of an acoustical cue. We're actually having a baseline signature for baseline data that we can then go back and and compare 10 years down the road when we go back and reassess these places using the same methodologies.
SPEAKER_00Cam Fiss, uh Dr. Fiss recently finished his PhD from SUNY ESF. He is the student that he he was actually originally a master's student of mine on Golden Wing and wanted to go on for his PhD. So he studied under Jonathan Cohen at ESF, and his his PhD analyzed uh many, many thousands of those uh of those locations, the data from those locations, and combined it with LIDAR. And he subdivided those landscapes into like sub-landscapes, 600 hectares in size, thinking about the kind of relatively thinking about like the size of a typical forest compartment, if you will, a collection of stands.
SPEAKER_00And then his analysis using those LIDAR data, he looked at the the avian conservation value of a landscape relative to forest diversification, structural diversification. And lo and behold, his you know, the hypothesis was was supported, right? As landscapes became more diverse in their canopy height diversity from a canopy height diversity perspective, the more important those landscapes came to conserving forest birds as a community.
SPEAKER_00When you rank all of those birds and they're and give them a conservation score, and then take that into account when you're looking at the response of the forest bird community to the dynamic forest management that's occurring. You know, we look forward, we're we're gearing up for a big push here in a couple years, we're gonna hit the 10-year mark. We should start to see even more response of our forest management from a bird perspective, and look forward to be able to report back on that.
SPEAKER_02You know, it's interesting, Greg. I think I learned about this talking to John Steigerwalt and reading about it in the Rough Grouse magazine. And I've been impressed that they've been a real big proponent of it, you know, not only the young forest, but you know, like the the forest as a whole. And I think that that says a lot about the organization. So you guys are what, like in in IT terms, you're the early adapters.
SPEAKER_00I think so.
SPEAKER_02And now the rest of us are kind of like maybe coming to play or coming to the table and saying, This is this is really cool. So what do you see as the future of this tool? Do you see a lot of other places kind of getting interested in it or maybe even expansion again within Pennsylvania?
SPEAKER_00I think that our program is serving as a terrific model. Yeah. To date, we've we've been invited to share our process, uh, share our successes and our lessons learned with agencies and conservation groups from let's see, Massachusetts, Maryland, Virginia, Tennessee, Kentucky, Michigan, Wisconsin, Minnesota, probably missing a few there. Just, you know, whether they be agency folks interested or conservation groups like RGS, and sometimes very much collection of partners are interested in hearing about our approach.
SPEAKER_00I love the fact that there is interest, and you can think about how that might bring competition for scarce resources for a group to be able to do the work that we do. But at the end of the day, this is you know conservation through cooperation. And if everyone can, you know, we believe we believe strongly and passionately about the approach we're using, the dynamic forest restoration block approach. And because of that, if we can have more entities adopt this approach, test the approach, monitor it, I think it's important that if if you're going to adopt it, you adopt it in its completeness, right?
SPEAKER_00This is about young forest, middle-aged forest, old forest, all distributed on the landscape, interspersed on the landscape, and in in significant proportions, right? They are all represented. That's not what we see on most on much of our forested landscapes today. Our contemporary forest landscapes are quite skewed to middle-aged forest. We need we need that interspersion of young, we need that interspersion of old, and we need to find a way, as Dan pointed out earlier, how the heck we're gonna keep like this, isn't a one-shot and done, right?
SPEAKER_00We need to figure out how you're gonna keep it, perpetuate that kind of a ratio and interspersion on the landscape. That's gonna take an immense number of partners to be able to continue to do this work. We weren't able to raise seven million dollars from NIFWIF and other foundations over the last seven, eight years by just us. We had folks contribute to the matching requirements, right?
SPEAKER_00Because they believed in the program, because they believe in in the shared vision that we have. So yeah, I'm I'm delighted when I when I hear you, when I hear you say that you know you're at a meeting and you you know you hear Rough Grouse members and and and staff speaking highly of the of the Dynamic Forest Restoration Block program.
SPEAKER_01So one last piece of advice, if we're out there thinking about starting this particular system on the landscape, do you have a piece of advice for us starting out?
SPEAKER_03I'll say if if you're a manager and you and I'm I'm sure every every land manager or forester is is in this boat where you you just you have a list of projects you would love to do, but you just have not been able to get the resources, to get the the money, uh, to to deal with the the the vegetation issues or whatever it is. This is a way to kind of focus efforts. And this is not what this is not, is a way to force on you some goals that you probably don't already have.
SPEAKER_03Odds are you're gonna be able to fit this approach really into your your planning process already. And as Jeff said, it's a way to kind of deal with those bottlenecks. And so I think you know, foresters are I think kind of a curmudgeony group sometimes and and don't, you know, don't want uh people telling them what to do. That's not what this is. This is a way to facilitate work that you probably have kind of sitting somewhere that you would just you know love to do and haven't haven't been able to do.
SPEAKER_03So be open to it, you know, to partnering with whoever you need to to to kind of get this done and kind of you know really achieve the goals that you may have had for for many years.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's kind of a structure to follow. Yeah, to help guide what you're already doing, as you said, Dan.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I'd agree. And I I also think it's important to recognize, as I mentioned earlier, like it's it's okay to start small. And before you know it, like I can't believe it's 2025, right? I just can't believe that in you know, 2017, when we first wrote that proposal and we were awarded funding, if you would have said, hey, in 2025 you'll have 366,000 acres, 35 blocks, you'll have private private land blocks with TNC and and Buck Hills Conservation Foundation and and and other groups, and you'll have partners like State Parks and the Game Commission.
SPEAKER_00Like never would have dreamt that. Certainly we knew that we weren't gonna stop at, you know, we weren't just gonna stop there. We had some kind of a of a goal, but we didn't really think that we were gonna grow this this big. But you know, that's it's important to keep in mind that you you start somewhere and and you take advantage of the opportunities. And then I guess my last piece would be that if you're starting out and you're interested in this, we welcome anyone to contact us.
SPEAKER_00We don't have all the answers. You know, that's one thing we haven't really mentioned here, Dan, and that is that Dan and I use the word humility quite a bit. You have to approach this with a with a certain amount of humility because, well, in the history of managing forested landscapes, no one's really tried to do it at this scale before. You like, and there are a lot of challenges on the landscape that we've talked about here today. So, you know, approach it with humility.
SPEAKER_00If you want to talk to us, if you want to come out to Pennsylvania and see a DFRB, we welcome folks. We do tours every year, whether they're private landowners or or public uh agency staff and everything in between, academic groups. We're happy to share. And and we have a lot of lessons learned and things we do differently, just as much as we have successes. So yeah, that's what that's what our recommendation would be.
SPEAKER_01Well, there you go. Open door invitation. There you go. Be careful, we'll be on your doorstep tomorrow. Be careful what you say. We'll do it. Jeff and Dan, thanks a lot for this conversation. And I think this is something we'll be looking at more here in our state as we try to figure out different ways to manage on on a broader scale at scale. And so this gives us uh a lot to chew on. So I really appreciate your time and talking about it today.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, great conversation, guys. Thanks for having us. We appreciate it.
SPEAKER_03Thanks a lot.
SPEAKER_01Brad, for a lot of reasons, we've not been that great at managing at the landscape level. So I really like this idea of breaking up that landscape into more manageable chunks, uh, like we talked about. It's kind of a simple concept, but I think developing targets at that level would be much more efficient.
SPEAKER_02I think you nailed it with saying that we're not, I think you're actually being polite and saying we're we haven't been good. I don't think we've even tried, really. I mean, we we talk about, oh, well, we we uh okay, yeah, I won't go to a dark place, but I think this is a real opportunity, something we should really be talking more about. And hopefully everyone will get just as excited and say, hey, how would I do something like this? I could see something like this being related to like your management assistance program or maybe integrating something. I love that idea of like the Kinsua where you have maybe multiple landowners getting together and kind of informing their management with knowledge about what's happening in the landscape around them.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. That'd be very cool. Very, very cool.
SPEAKER_01So, Brad, also today, I have an announcement to make.
SPEAKER_02Ah, let me guess, you're going to plug the 2025 Northern Hardwood Conference this August 5th through 7th in Syracuse, New York.
SPEAKER_01Well, yeah, you just stole my thunder, but yeah, but that's what I was gonna do. Well, it is the third biennial Northern Hardwood Conference. So I'm really pleased that that whole series is continuing to move on and we're continuing to bring together folks working with uh this particular type. Yeah, so if you're available, registration, I believe, is still open. Cool.
SPEAKER_02Greg, I was gonna ask you a question about it too. So are there gonna be tours associated with it? Do you know much about the agenda yet?
SPEAKER_01I believe, and don't quote me anyone on this, but I believe the first day is kind of in-house presentations, breakout sessions. I believe the second day is all tours, multiple sites. Okay. And then it wraps up with some more breakout sessions, presentations for like not a full day uh on the last day. Okay, cool. So I think that's the general agenda, but it's early right now. Uh, they do have a website up.
SPEAKER_01I think I just today Googled 2025 Northern Hardwood Conference. The website came up, and you can get whatever the latest and greatest information is. Cool.
SPEAKER_02And Silvicast will have the 24-hour hospitality room associated with it.
SPEAKER_01Well, I'm not going, but you're going. And so you will have to hold down the hospitality room. Yeah. Oh boy, there will be stories, Greg.
SPEAKER_02There will be stories. Well, thanks everyone for listening to today's episode of Silvicast. If you have ideas for future episodes or a question for the drop box, just let us know. Actually, contact us anytime you want. You can call us 247-365. Greg Brad's personal cell number is call at two in the morning. You can reach us anytime. But a better way to reach us would be to email UW Stevens Points Wisconsin Forestry Center by emailing wfc at uwsp.edu.
SPEAKER_02Feel free to include a sound file of your question, and we'll put you on the air so you'll hear yourself as a part of a silvercast episode, which I think would be really cool. And but you just send an email, whatever you want to send. I think anything would be great. And always remember, we learn best when we wrestle with questions. So please keep them coming.
SPEAKER_01And take care, everyone. And as always, thanks to our team, Susan Barrett, our editor-in-chief, Joe Rogers, our IT master, The Music, still by Paul Freder, and of course, UW Stevens Points, Wisconsin Forestry Center.
Rome, Egypt, the Aztecs - history has seen the rise and fall of many once-dominant civilizations. But could we be witnessing a similar story unfolding in our forests, with the decline of a once-dominant tree species?...
Eastern white pine is making a comeback, but as experienced field foresters know, much of this second-growth timber can be challenging from a quality standpoint. In this episode of SilviCast, we talk with Rene Germain,...
In this episode of SilviCast, we talk with regeneration experts Mike Reinikainen, Roger Bohringer, and Tom Hill about direct seeding - a challenging and often misunderstood approach to reforestation that establishes...
Black locust doesn't have many fans among foresters in North America. It's often criticized for growing crooked, spreading aggressively, and producing poor-quality stems. But is the problem really the tree, or is it how...
Beavers are often seen as a nuisance, but what if they're actually some of nature's most effective forest managers? In this episode of SilviCast, we welcome renowned ecohydrologist Dr. Emily Fairfax to explore the...