Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

SilviCast

SilviCast artwork

S.6 Ep.7: Black Gold

Jul 1, 20251 hr 9 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Eastern black walnut holds an almost legendary reputation as one of the most valuable timber species in central and eastern North America. A single, high-quality tree can fetch thousands of dollars - sometimes even influencing the outcome of an entire timber sale. With that level of interest, you’d think we’ve uncovered everything there is to know about this remarkable species. And while researchers and foresters have developed extensive knowledge around its silviculture and genetics, there’s still a lot to learn! In this episode of SilviCast, we delve into the silviculture of black walnut with Lenny Farlee, Extension Forester at Purdue University. Send us Fan Mail

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01Welcome to Silvicast, the podcast about all things silviculture. My name is Brad Hutnick. And I'm Greg Edge. We're both silviculturists with the Wisconsin DNR Division of Forestry and your hosts for today's show. Good morning, Gregor. Good morning. See, now you're getting into it, right? Like you're not German. You don't even this is oh that made my day, Greg.

SPEAKER_02That made my day. When I went to Germany, I learned all the lines I needed to travel, and that was Ein Bierbetter. Ah, see? And I think uh Wie viel is like how much? Asking how much. Anyway. Wow. My small amount of travel vocabulary. So, quick question for you. Yep. What are we talking about today? Well, today, Brad, on SilvaCast, you'll be happy to know we are going to talk about everything Eastern Black Walnut.

SPEAKER_01Oh, ooh, I love walnut. Yeah. You like walnut? Well, we can use it for a million things, right? Like you have the traditional uses, but we can use it for well, we can use it for the nuts. Yeah. You can put walnuts in your basement and keep spiders away. What? Yeah, you can do it. You can do it. Ask people from the Ozarks. That's what they do. Do you have to put the hus down there so you get like this gooey blob sitting in your basement? You might want to put them in a something. You know, I wouldn't want to lay them on the good carpet, you know, but it might get a little smelly.

SPEAKER_01Oh my god. Can you imagine? You can make syrup out of it, just like maple syrup. You can make walnut syrup. I've heard that. That does sound disgusting, but my favorite, Greg, is you can use it to make a walnut liqueur. It's called Nochino. Yeah. Oh, and it's it's fantastic. Well it's it's like a it's like a pastry in a in a shot glass. It's beautiful.

SPEAKER_02Is that the one that you make?

SPEAKER_01I know people who know people who have access to things that make this, and uh yes, they do a fantastic job with it.

SPEAKER_02Oh it sounds very interesting. I think the other day you said that there's a use for the nuts. Oh there was a trivia question you asked me.

SPEAKER_01There was. And what was that? Well, I can't remember what the trivia question was, but the essence of it is that walnut like pieces, like when you when you take a uh a walnut and you take the meat out of it, yeah, you have a hull left behind. And if you pulverize that hull, it can be used in sandblasting. And so it was used in the last renovation of the Statue of Liberty as the medium that they used as part of the sandblasting. So walnuts are celebrating freedom in America.

SPEAKER_02I did not oh yeah, I didn't believe you uh when you said that. I was I was picturing them firing walnuts at the Statue of Liberty.

unknownBunk.

SPEAKER_01That's an image right there, Greg. Like uh us trying to clean things with whole walnuts.

SPEAKER_02And I th I always remember I grew up in Appleton, which is, you know, kind of the flatland or Fox Valley over in the eastern part of the state. And uh we didn't have a lot of walnuts, but when we did come across them, I always thought, geez, these things are great for chucking at things. Oh and I always thought they look like a tennis ball, and they'd be really good in these cannons we used to make as kids. We used to take pop cans or beer cans and cut out the bottoms and then tape them all together in a tube, and then we'd put a tennis ball down that tube, and then we'd squirt like lighter fluid in a hole and that we'd make in the bottom, and then we'd light that and then shoot the tennis ball out.

SPEAKER_02Oh, and I thought you could throw walnuts that way.

SPEAKER_01That'd be cool. The only difference is the walnut would hurt as opposed to the uh tennis ball I guess. You just have to get the right size, yeah. Oh, can you imagine? No, I grew up in Stevens Point, and I remember seeing walnuts for the first time when I was in Madison and just being so impressed. Greg, you would appreciate this. I actually gathered up walnuts by the bagful, took them home to my family's farm, and planted them. Out on the sand. Out on the sand. And I think we have three survivors, and this would have been when my wife Mary, we were dating at the time, just dating.

SPEAKER_01So this is a long time ago. And those they have still not reached the at least the ones that are there, they still haven't reached pole size. I can't imagine why. I you know, but the quality, Greg, the quality planted alongside the potatoes, yeah, and the cactus. So, yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_02Well, at least they have like really tight growth rings. So if you ever want to, you know, make some cool wood.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, and you're talking about my grandkids. I think my great grandkids will be talking about those trees.

SPEAKER_02That was a very interesting rabbit hole, but I think today we're gonna talk a little bit more about silviculture and walnut. And I know we've had some listeners in the walnut range that have said, can you do an episode on walnut? So rather than sit here and listen to us prattle on about the many uses of walnut, we invited a real black walnut silviculturist today, Brad, on Silvicast. We're going to be joined by Lenny Farley, who is Extension Forester at Purdue University.

SPEAKER_02So Lenny's coming to us from the heart of the Black Walnut Range, Indiana, and he literally brings decades of experience in many facets of managing black walnut trees. So he's worked in the nurseries to private lands management to research and extension. So we're really going to be able to delve into some of the details on this unique species. Oh, fantastic.

SPEAKER_01You remind me, I'll have to ask him about walnut liqueur. Yeah. I'm sure he'll be all over that. This season of Silvicast is brought to you by the Nelson Paint Company, McCoy Construction and Forestry, and the Family Forest Carbon Program. You make the Silvicast world go round. So thank you. Lenny Farley, welcome to Silvicast.

SPEAKER_01For our audience, tell us a little bit about yourself, where you work, and what you do.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, thank you very much for inviting me. I work at Purdue University, West Lafayette campus. I'm an extension for a stir, 100% extension appointment. And so I'm working with private landowners and professionals doing extension programming, providing extension media of a variety of different types.

SPEAKER_01Cool. And you're working a lot with walnut, right?

SPEAKER_00Yes. Uh so I'm also attached to the Hardwood Tree Improvement and Regeneration Center. And I have to get an inhale after saying that. Uh, it's a Purdue and Forest Service partnership uh that is working on improvement of hardwood trees, uh, everything from tree improvement genetics to silviculture and ecology. Uh so uh I and walnut is one of our big species that we concentrate on.

SPEAKER_02Cool. You mean H T I R C doesn't just roll off the tongue?

SPEAKER_00Not exactly.

SPEAKER_02Took me a while to get used to that. When I was getting ready for this show, I looked up your bio over on the Purdue website. I saw like a number of different things there, and I thought, oh, I can relate to this. You've had a lot of different roles over your career, it looks like you've worked maybe in nurseries and you've worked as a sounds like a private lands forester and worked in research and extension. So I can kind of relate. I've never been in extension or research, but the nurseries and the private land.

SPEAKER_02And I'm just curious when you look back over all those roles, is there something that you think was the coolest job that you've had?

SPEAKER_00Probably. It's difficult. I really enjoy what I do now, kind of the bigger scale educational programming, reaching big audiences, but I really love the individual landowner contact on their properties of a private lands forest or district forest, they call it here in Indiana. So that was a great job.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I I missed that too. And but I also like, and I think you're kind of in this area, you're sort of an extension, that intersection between that field work and that research. And I think that's a really cool area to be in as well.

SPEAKER_00Great opportunities, yeah, to really spread the word of what we're finding out in the science side.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. It's it's kind of cool you both have a nursery background, because I wouldn't have imagined. Did that come with ch early childhood education, kind of a background like that too?

SPEAKER_00You feel like that sometimes when you're operating at a nursery.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, yes. Something like that, Brad. Yeah. All right. Okay. Something like that. We're, you know, raising the tree babies. Absolutely. Yep. So, Lenny, when Brad and I were looking into doing a show on Black Walnut, we kind of explored that because we had a lot of requests for doing an episode on this. We have a lot of listeners kind of from that black walnut heart of that range. And also, for people who are outside that area, they may not understand kind of the importance of eastern black walnut.

SPEAKER_02And so, can you just say something about why is there so much interest and focus on this one particular species?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's a great question. And so a lot of it goes back to the historical value associated with black walnut timber and particularly veneer. It has pretty consistently through history been the premier hardwood species in Eastern North America in terms of value both here and then also interest across the world for exports as well. And so folks that were interested in really tapping into a tree that had uh really superior marketplaces and great potential for high values, black walnut historically and still really probably is the best choice.

SPEAKER_01I'm always curious about this because I you hear about people talking about black gold, right? Like like these trees are so valuable, and you hear about rustlers. So I one of the urban myths well, you do like you hear about people like just ex absconding, and and I even I read an urban myth that said that people have done walnut with helicopters as well in the past. But is there a uh illegal demand for like are people stealing them in in actuality?

SPEAKER_00Absolutely, yes. And so, particularly occasionally in market downturns, we had a little spate of this, I think, back in 2008 to 2010. The amount of walnut theft that was going on across the countryside here in Indiana uh increased because people understood the values. We've got sawmills around that will buy gate logs, essentially, and so it was an opportunity for people to pull, like you say, black gold out of unattended properties. Uh, we've actually been able to tackle that a little bit by doing some genetic work to match the stump to the log and actually tag some people for illegally harvesting timber.

SPEAKER_00Uh so we've got some better tools now to actually track that down, where historically it was pretty tough to do.

SPEAKER_02Wow. For those that don't work with that species, can you give us an idea like what the relative value is? Say, you know, say for somebody cutting red oak, woods run versus what walnut is going for.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, so I actually pulled some figures off of a really nice Ohio State uh publication that looks at uh timber values in Ohio. And so 2023, Prime delivered log values were a dollar fifty to three fifty a board foot. Number one logs were a dollar ten to two two seventy-five a board foot. Uh and so when you start talking about stumpage, they had values of a dollar to three dollars a board foot for stumpage. And then you look at veneer, and you might be looking at trees that are upwards of fifteen to twenty dollars a board foot.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_00So the values are just in in some cases spectacular.

SPEAKER_02Wow. Yeah, whereas we're looking at you know, oak stumpage prices that are a quarter of that, and then doesn't even touch, like you said, Lenny, the veneer prices can go quite high. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, probably the the species right now that's that's in the same ballpark, although not as high on the upper end as black walnut is white oak, both in terms of saw timber and uh veneer values. And historically, 20 years ago, black cherry in our area popped up and saw log values were a little higher than black walnut for a while, but that's been kind of uh aberrations compared to what you know the normal trends have shown.

SPEAKER_01I was always impressed with the walnut sales I would go to where the trees were numbered. Yes. So there were like 20 trees in that sale compared to like when we put out acres of trees and you know approximately how many trees you have, because it's just that just a complete difference in the focus.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, it really is, and that's pretty common practice here in Indiana, particularly on the veneer trees, dub, to number them.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. And that kind of gets to something, Brad, you and I have discussed, and always curious about walnut is sometimes when we as foresters are discussing it, it's almost like we're talking about managing an individual tree or species, whereas everything else we sort of manage as communities or cover types or systems. So is walnut management is it single tree management or single species management, or are we managing stands or both?

SPEAKER_00Yes, that's a great question, Greg. Uh because a walnut naturally is pretty widely distributed, but also widely scattered. I think I saw a figure it's like 7% of the volume here in Indiana, not in the top 10 in terms of total volume by species. I think it's number 11 or 12. So as a natural part of our woodlands, it's typically kind of scattered trees. You will occasionally find small stands that are either mostly walnut or a high percentage of walnut, mostly in uh creek bottoms, small river bottoms that don't have a lot of high amplitude flooding.

SPEAKER_00As you go further west of Missouri and Kansas, you can kind of pick up density of black walnut. Some of their stands have a lot more black walnut in terms of total number of trees versus other species compared to us in Indiana. So for most people that are managing woodlands, yeah, it's really kind of individual tree management with the exception of those small little patches where we've got the right disturbance regime and particularly the right soils to have walnut that regenerated all together and formed a small stand.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, so they're focusing in on that species individually, and as you're saying that a lot of those walnut, and this is true in Wisconsin too, are sort of a mixed component of oftentimes a central hardwoody type of stand or absolutely. And so we're managing that larger stand component, but with a focus on that walnut because it's so high value.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, if you're interested in the economics, it's kind of an automatic crop tree in a lot of cases, if it's got any kind of quality to it at all.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. I know it's interesting in Wisconsin, and just doing a little research for this episode. Here in Wisconsin, it's like you said, walnut stands themselves are not very common, but the volume is actually concentrated. So where we do get those stands, and actually I imagine most of them are plantations, that's where the like almost half of the volume occurs in those areas.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. That that would not be uh dissimilar here in many cases.

SPEAKER_01If we were backing up or just thinking about, so we're managing trees, but we occasionally get to manage stands. I mean either event, we kind of have that background sylvix of of black walnut that we have to deal with. So for our listeners who may not work with walnut or may not be familiar with it that much, just thinking about basic things like is it is it shade tolerant or is it not tolerant of shade?

SPEAKER_00Not tolerant. And so it wants to be in full sunlight and it will strive to stay in the main canopy and typically will only survive as a co-dominant, uh, and really kind of wants to be a dominant, uh, particularly on good sites. And that's really kind of the other thing with black walnut is if you don't have it on the right kind of soils, and the right kind of soils are uh deep, three feet minimum without impediments in terms of drainage, high quality soils, so uh good tilth, uh silt loams, sandy loams, uh sandy clay loams uh is what we're really looking for.

SPEAKER_00It doesn't perform well, it'll grow a lot of places, but it doesn't do real well, and obviously a lot of times won't be very competitive on some of those more off-site type of locations for itself.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. I always thought that was interesting because our natural heritage folks complain about walnut peaking into goat prairies because it comes up in lots of different places, as you said, intolerant, so kind of openings and things like that. But yeah, the to get the quality to the stems, that soil has to be of that different nature.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, a lot of site amplitude. I mean, like you say, everything from marginally wet to dry, probably more to the dry side than the wet side, it really doesn't like saturated soils at all. But it'll plug along on those sites. But yeah, in terms of growth rate and quality, it's always struggling in those locations. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01You may remember, Greg, we had a forester that we worked with back in the day, and he had a saying because he loved to plant walnut. And even on those marginal sites, he would plant walnut. And he and I his saying was something along the line of, why plant a Pontiac when you can grow a Cadillac?

SPEAKER_00And we will sometimes do the same thing, uh, popping a little bit of walnut in just to see if it might, you know, handle the site. It usually doesn't hurt you much if you're you know doing high density tree plantings. You can kind of judge it after that 10 or 15 years, and you know, do I have something here?

SPEAKER_02Yeah. I always think uh some of the nicest walnut I see both naturally and planted is that depth of soil that you said, Lenny, but also I think you also mentioned drainage, so kind of that toe slope sort of environment. It just really seems to do nicely in that kind of that little niche here in the hills. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Absolutely. Almost think of it as a a cove species in some respects. You know, those those really high quality music sites. Good way to think of it.

SPEAKER_01Is it a pioneer on those sites? I've seen it in open areas pretty aggressively, but I'm curious about the rest of the range.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, if there's seed source nearby, and particularly squirrel planted, it can act like a pioneer. And one of the characteristics it's got that allows it to spread into the agricultural environment is it'll come through sod and other heavy weed growth, that big heavy seed. And so it'll actually pioneer some spots where other species that maybe are lighter seeded, things like tulip tree, uh, don't get in. So I see, you know, I've observed that here in Indiana of abandoned pastures or places where uh we've abandoned fields and got heavy weed growth, uh, the walnut will be one of the best ones to come into those areas.

SPEAKER_00Probably one of our challenges there is that because it is mostly animal disseminated, uh, the density sometimes isn't what you would want.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_00And so I really encourage people if they're looking at utilizing those old field areas to get rid of the competing vegetation so that you can get a bunch of volunteers, part of it being walnut, and then you're gonna have a stand that'll actually produce some quality walnut, not the orchard trees that you get with that really wide spacing.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. Uh speaking of seed, what kind of a seed producer is walnut? Is it really consistent? Uh does it have, you know, very specific mast years, like an oak wood? How does that work?

SPEAKER_00It tends to be pretty consistent. It does have up and down years, but it's uh heavier crops tend to come closer together than what I observe for oak. And so looking at some of the silvicultural information for it said it would have a decent crop every two to five years, and I think it that's what I observe on the landscape, and probably you could count on a really strong crop at least once or twice in in a five-year period. Seems to me almost like the really poor crops are less frequent than the good crops are.

SPEAKER_01Do we know what those are related to? Like what kind of conditions set walnut up for good crops or bad crops?

SPEAKER_00You know, I don't know exactly. I think there probably is some of that cycling, the carbohydrate balance in the tree, its capacity to produce a really good crop. The kind of prime bearing age for these trees is like 20 to 30 years up to a hundred years or so. But they'll bear as soon as seven or eight years, a lot of times from from a seedling. And being on a good side obviously also helps them a lot uh in terms of that carbohydrate balance. So all those kind of figure in.

SPEAKER_02It's the one hardwood seed in the nursery that we can usually count on will be able to get seed. Yeah, that's very true. So that tells you something, right?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, very consistent.

SPEAKER_01Actually, and I live in uh a small town, Spring Green, and we have walnuts everywhere. I I think on most occasions it's can people get rid of their seed here? Exactly. There's so much of it.

SPEAKER_00Bit of a nuisance in the yard, that's right.

SPEAKER_01Exactly. Yeah. Lenny, thinking about a walnut maybe from a different angle, and we know that it occurs. sporadically like in these natural stands historically. Do we know, like, do we know anything about the disturbance that might have lent itself to having to maybe favoring walnut in certain areas?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, so I haven't seen a lot of historical work done on that, although where we see it would suggest probably things like tornadoes and straight line winds would have been favorable to it to create open stand conditions. It will sprout back from fires. A larger fire that maybe would topkill quite a few trees in an area would probably favor regeneration of new walnut. So even perhaps really strong flooding events that cleared an area, you might get an opportunity from nearby walnuts on upland slopes that survive to drop seed down into those areas and pioneer.

SPEAKER_00Almost anything where you're really creating a pretty open light, highlight availability opportunity for walnut to come in, it can get in there if you can get seed to that location. I think that's the big limiting factor a lot of times.

SPEAKER_01I always knew I could get an old boss going because I would say you know I think it's a fire adapted species because then once you start talking about burning in a walnut stand, you know, everybody's hackles go up. Oh yeah. But we would talk about it you know being really late to leaf out compared to most of the other trees in our area and then losing its leaves really early and then like you said it'll sprout back like oak in a lot of ways. And and I don't know maybe it's even like the like the wood durability but I I just can't say I've seen that many hollow walnuts in my career.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Yeah it it has good wound compartmentalization, pretty thick bark. And so I think there's a strong argument to be made that barring the concern about quality issues, a fire could be used as a tool at least for preparations of areas to be suitable for walnut and maybe in that early period where it's not a big deal if you topkill it if you're taking back other uh competing regeneration.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. Potentially thinking about this lots of different significant disturbances that just created that more open light condition. But as you said it's a heavy seed so getting the seed to that location becomes critical. So that probably in a way limited how much it was dispersed across those areas.

SPEAKER_00I think so if they were floatable water could carry them to some extent but it's mostly squirrels that are doing the work for us.

SPEAKER_02Since we're talking here about natural disturbance regimes I wanted to talk a little bit ask you a few questions about natural regeneration. A lot of walnut as you know and here in Wisconsin as well is artificially planted and we're going to talk about that. But we often don't talk about natural regeneration in walnut other than working with what we got that comes along. So I tried to do some looking and I was couldn't find much but is there any research on sort of natural regeneration methods in walnut or is that very limited?

SPEAKER_00It seems to be very limited because I've done some of the same searching and you know most of our research here has been concentrated on planting and direct seeding. And so I I think you're right. I think people have taken what they've gotten but I think the good news is that if you have walnut seed source available you can oftentimes get it. You just have to create the right conditions for that seedling to do well. And so I I see it like like I say pioneering old abandoned agricultural areas and some of the really strong walnut patches or stands I've run into I'm pretty sure were either an old pasture or a field that got abandoned it had walnut on the edge.

SPEAKER_00And so I I think that's kind of the the natural approach. Something I've thought about in walnut stands in terms of harvesting management is I I think a shelter wood is probably going to still be too much shade for walnut to do well. It just does not last under shade any amount of time you really can't build up a seedling store uh they have to get sunlight quick. And so I'm wondering if a seed tree uh approach uh in some of these locations where you've got walnut that's casting good seed you create a an environment where those seed are close enough that the squirrels can spread it into your area but you don't have the shading that might be a possibility but I don't know if anybody's done any research on that.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01You know it is interesting and you mentioned that shade tolerance and we're kind of thinking about like a a shelter wood with something like that. It is curious you don't see walnut very often in the understory of like these open stands it's more like along the edges or kind of just out into an opening a little bit but not not all that common as an understory tree.

SPEAKER_00I see it for one at most two years. Yeah. And so I'll follow seed crops in some of these locations and we'll see a a flush of walnut come up in and like you say these open understories but that's a 70 to 80% plus canopy closure and yeah they don't last but a a couple of years and then they're done.

SPEAKER_01It's interesting to think about seed tree is there ever a problem and I don't know if I've ever seen this in a field where like you did say we get those loose or those open conditions where you kind of get those more oak orchard crowns. But I imagine it's a great sprouter you could kind of continually set things back until you had the density you wanted and work with something like that.

SPEAKER_00I think that's a potential management approach. Yeah just keep keep you know working things back at coppes so well you've got that established root system you're probably going to get better quality sprouts off of it once you've got that density up and so I I think that's a viable approach and yeah we just need some people to do it and tell us how it works out. So that's right.

SPEAKER_02What do you think if a forester was working you know we have a lot of just like you a lot of small wood lots kind of small area and maybe they're setting up a harvest prescription that has some type of groups or patches do you have any idea like how big an opening you think would be appropriate and maybe you have to put as you said some seed trees within that in order to have that dispersal of seed. But I'm just curious on a like an opening size.

SPEAKER_00Yeah so I I have actually done a little bit of that on my property and I think you know you could do one and two acre openings and have walnuts retained on the edges and squirrels would do some of that work for you. The the issue we've got here in Indiana is we've got a lot of tulip tree and so it moves faster than the walnut does. And so I I have done a combination of direct seeding seedling planting and also looking for natural regeneration and then I go in after three or four years and I start breaking the tops that are clipping the tops out of the tulip tree around my walnut to make sure they've got that cone of light and it does a great job of training them but boy if you don't do it they're two feet three feet above the the walnut after four or five years if you're not careful.

SPEAKER_02As we're talking about assisted migration with tulip poplar. Yeah yeah Lenny's going no don't it's it's a great tree but boy it's competitive yeah like you said all we need is some foresters out there to maybe play around with this some more and try some more of this but I I do like that idea of having you know maybe openings patches with either border or anchor seed trees within that to get that distribution.

SPEAKER_00I think it's a real possibility the other thing I've done is I have done direct seeding and I learned a hard lesson don't pick a poor seed crop year to direct seed because the squirrels find every single one of them but good crops, yeah direct seeding can work and it's a pretty simple process you know you go out there with a shovel put the seed in about you know about an inch or two deep you've got a good chance of getting a seedling in that location looking for continuing education credits?

SPEAKER_01Check out the SilvaCast webpage for more information. And now back to our show I'm curious you know Greg over our career you know so you've been with the DNR what Greg like 60 years now so you've been you've been here a long time. Something like that. Yeah but those of us may be here for a lot less you know so but over the last 30 years I'd say our plantings have changed you know we've gone from low densities to higher densities and and so maybe it's really good to get a glimpse of what things look like at the heart of the empire for Indiana.

SPEAKER_01I'm curious like we used to just plant straight walnut. Yeah like because you know it's like doing that. And do you guys do you still do that or do you mix the species up now?

SPEAKER_00I still see that happen but I really like the mixed plantings a lot better. I've done a lot of thinning uh marking in solid walnut plantations and if they're not mown it's no fun at all. Yeah uh that's a light canopy and so there's always heavy weed growth in the understory I don't think the walnuts provide the best competition for each other in terms of training and branch pruning. And so I see much better quality walnuts in mixed species plantings. A common practice in northern Indiana for years from some foresters up there was alternating rows of white pine and hardwoods.

SPEAKER_00And typically if they are in the right kind of sites they were throwing walnut in there and walnut really does pretty good in that environment if it's a good site. If it's a really good site the walnuts will whip the white pine with the combination of growth and ju clone. Yeah and you almost get some natural thinning if it's a little marginal you're gonna have to kill the white pine because they'll continue to hang in there with time but it it's a good system. And so yeah I'm I'm all for mixed species plantings because one of the things it does it knocks down the understory a lot better. Walnut solid planted just does not do that.

SPEAKER_02What do the densities look like that foresters are putting in down there now?

SPEAKER_00Yeah we're doing the same thing you folks are and a lot of it's you know deer pressure and and just the recognition of of uh competition and that's tighter spacings I think you know we commonly are recommending eight by eight for tree plantings with walnut in it. Uh some people are planting even a little tighter historically we were more on the 10 by 10. The early recommendations were 12 by 12 i I think both of those are too wide to produce the kind of quality you'd like to see on your walnut. So we're pinching down the the densities as well.

SPEAKER_02Yeah that's definitely been the trend here too I know when we started putting in walnut in the 80s with the CRPs we were at like 15 12 15 foot spacings and and now yeah we're probably down to seven eight foot spacings would be more typical and some folks especially with if there's oak in there would go high density. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01And I'm seeing a lot mixed up with oak in our area too yes uh kind of red oak and some other different species.

SPEAKER_00I think that red oak walnut mix if you can protect it from deer is a good mix. If the red oak aren't being chewed up by deer uh they are pretty good comparable growth rate with black walnut on on those good sites. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01I suppose that's a little bit of a challenge because walnuts are pretty fast grower. It's always that surprising thing to me it's it's really valuable and it's not a slow grower.

SPEAKER_00Yeah it once again you know site related if you've got it where it's happy it's a very aggressive strong grower that wants to be in the main canopy so that that's a big advantage.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_00What about plantings down there in terms of stock are most of the plantings still bare root stock or is direct seeding popular what's that look like still mostly bare root stock we've got an excellent state nursery and also several private nurseries providing stock uh in the bare root and so that's really quite common still uh there are some people that do a little bit of direct seeding uh I don't know anybody that's done as much as one of my uh friends now departed unfortunately in Iowa Larry Croats did yeah I know Larry do you do do you guys know Larry just a a legend and fantastic results with his heavy uh tens of thousands of seeds per acre direct seeding and I've saw his plantings and he's got some fantastic trees that you know just look like they're woods grown and producing great quality.

SPEAKER_00Yeah uh so you know more than one way to skin that cat but most people are doing uh bare root seedling planting.

SPEAKER_02Yeah I remember when Larry was around and he sort of evangelized the direct seeding route and a lot of foresters were skeptical but then a lot of foresters adopted some of it and goes oh this works pretty good yeah but he planted a lot of species right yes and maybe a tangent but but it was like if it's a tree I'll take it kind of stuff.

SPEAKER_00Yeah he was just looking to get the stocking and I think you know he was really intelligent to do that and had really good results as uh as a uh an outgrowth of that approach.

SPEAKER_02Yeah I think the biggest controversial item Larry would do was overseed with box elder seed. Yeah yeah with just to get that density.

SPEAKER_00One of the things I think that's an advantage to though and it's kind of the white pine here is there's really no great market for white pine and so the hardest thing we have to get landowners to do is thin after they've planted. And if you can tell them there's no value in keeping this right they're much more willing to do that sacrifice of that tree where our solid walnut plantings getting people to thin those sometimes is like pulling teeth.

SPEAKER_01Oh yeah yeah you know they're sure each one of those trees is going to make them money yeah and it just it just cannot happen you know yeah you know I've I have seen and we've had discussions about walnut a lot in a climate change perspective and thinking about assisted migration and the different forms that it takes but it seems to me like based on some of the conversation here I've seen it as a projected quote unquote winner with you know like basically having new habitat. But it sounds like we have to be careful so when we think about people doing enrichment plantings if it's in that understory you may really want to be much more cognizant about don't just put it in the understory and and what think it's going to be there in the future.

SPEAKER_01You may have to really set the stage for it.

SPEAKER_00Yeah it's not one that it's gonna hang around like oak in a you know a stand that's got 50 or 60 percent canopy cover it cannot tolerate that so you've really got to have the the daylight to to put it in. So it's something that's the result of a really open stand regeneration process or or planting. Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Lenny have you seen much of that in Indiana where what we would consider enrichment planting or going into those sort of degraded stands, pasture areas to try to reestablish it?

SPEAKER_00We I have done a little bit of that with some landowners here in woodlands and with some success so we have done plantings in forest openings with bare root stock. One of them was a eight by eight planting with walnut in the center and oak on the outside edge. It was about an acre opening and those walnuts they were on a near perfect site and they were growing four tenths of an inch in diameter a year over about a 30 year period. And those that that was the crop trees that we had selected to keep on that area.

SPEAKER_00So we had excellent results he worked really hard uh the first couple of years for weed control poke berry just came in like a flood yeah uh but after that couple of years it was kind of stand back for 10 12 years no pruning to speak of came in and started doing thinning we already had really great form stems and now it's it's off to the races. It's a great looking stand.

SPEAKER_02So it sounds like your cautionary item with that is though getting the right light conditions and the right site.

SPEAKER_00Absolutely essential you want to check your soils and make sure that you've got plenty of daylight and I think an acre is minimum. We had a couple of slightly smaller openings that did not perform nearly as well for the walnut the oak did significantly better. So if you're looking at those smaller openings you know you really have to grade your trees in terms of their intolerance to to shade and walnut wants a lot of daylight.

SPEAKER_02I get the question sometimes from landowners who have that sort of situation maybe small areas and they want a direct seed and I know we've had instances where direct seeding gets a lot of predation on the small areas like that. I don't know have you seen that or had experience with that.

SPEAKER_00Yeah you know in my woods I've done some of that and I I'll go back I think if you don't have a really heavy seed crop and a lot of other food available for the squirrels it's an exercise and futility unless you protect your your seed. And so one of the things we've done in some direct seeding with some of our approaches here at HTIRC is we actually will put a short tree tube with like a wire mesh cover on the top and sink it into the ground a little bit and just to keep uh the squirrels off of them. Now that's a big input in terms of effort and dollars for each of those little direct seeded seedlings but we've got a lot in those I think if landowners really pick a year where it's a big seed crop, if they've got a lot of walnut in the woods they've got an opportunity to move that stuff out from out of the shade into the sun they've got a pretty good chance of having some success there.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Well it seems like Greg you may remember I had another boss and you've had a lot of bosses. A lot of bosses that that's another story. I always remember landowners get really attached to like when they start growing these walnut in these plantations that's that's like it can consume them in some ways. Yeah I remember one one time he uh we had a landowner and he said because we went out there and it was hard to find a tree that hadn't been pruned or hadn't been stopped and looked at because the gator could reach every tree that he had you know his uh UTV.

SPEAKER_00And so I remember him saying some people like to golf some people like to prune walnut and that's what it felt like like there were two two sets of minds but they didn't cross but speaking of that pruning when would you start what like I it's something I've never done but when would you start to think about pruning and what would that look like so there's a lot of debate and philosophy involved in this my philosophy personally is I I kind of had a really good forced economics professor here at Purdue Bill Hoover who told me uh costs early in the plantation have to be carried through to rotation.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. And so if it's truly an investment you got to be thinking about how much money am I going to spend on this thing. Now if you love to prune I say start pruning relatively early. So maybe after three or four years literally you could go out and take off forks that's a good starting point. And so just try to maintain some level of apical dominance. That'll make you feel better. I will tell you that I don't think you have to do it. Yeah I think if you planted eight by eight you wait for 10 or 12 years let that develop you're going to pick out crop trees at that point in time you can look at doing some pruning you'll have enough density that you will have already killed a lot of lower branches and so you can take off the deads do the appropriate pruning with some branches that are maybe getting a little bit of size or take a fork out but I think I think the competition will have done a lot of that work for you.

SPEAKER_00For folks who don't want to do that high density or want to be really engaged I would say start with form and so you're always looking to keep a straight stem that's your job number one because that adds logs and we need that log length. And then number two remove the largest branches before they get larger and so you're taking off things on your bottom log before they get an inch and a half in diameter or so. Now that comes at a cost as does competition for reducing growth but I'm I tell everybody that planting walnut is an intergenerational activity.

SPEAKER_00Yeah and so just do the best job you can managing for your grandkids as opposed to thinking you're gonna get anything out of it and that's a good way to think of it. Yeah I think that was one of the draws with Larry's method of direct seeding was getting that density high enough that they actually self-pruned and I think uh Larry would say I don't like to prune so I want I want I want them self-pruning so I think that density is really really key to get around that absolutely and we've been playing around with what's the best nurse tree uh to some extent and you know white pine can be pretty good we actually used some uh river birch in some plantings and that worked pretty nice the shape of the tree and the kind of lighter canopy actually worked pretty well with walnut but I I'm not gonna say we've figured it out completely yet but I think those are a couple of possibilities.

SPEAKER_00And then we mentioned red oak is a possible companion too.

SPEAKER_01Lenny you could light a fire in our audience if you said that black locust was a really good trader for it I I'm not gonna do that.

SPEAKER_00There's some pop from the nitrogen but uh what I've seen here in Indiana is if it's not watched uh the black locust will overrun the walnut contrary to what I've seen in some of the literature my experience has been the black locust is is too aggressive. Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Lenny I bring up this topic with a little bit of caution because I think we could talk about a sh do a show just on this but I think talking to you at Purdue we would be remiss if we didn't talk a little bit about walnut genetics because when I first started you know the big hullabaloo was Purdue number ones and that particular patent of that walnut and we had landowners that wanted to plant it and and all of that.

SPEAKER_02But I know through some of your colleagues that you know walnut genetics have evolved since that time and there's a lot been done. So I just kind of get an idea from you sort of what the current state of walnut genetics is. What are people planting? Where is it going? That sort of thing.

SPEAKER_00Yeah I appreciate that question. And so you know Purdue number one did raise a lot of interest and it still is a good tree in terms of form. A lot of the thought and projections on growth ended up not being very accurate. It's kind of a moderate you know just a basically average grower. It's not a super duper in terms of growth speed but it does have a form advantage pretty consistently. But where we're headed now that was primarily clonal or grafting.

SPEAKER_00So you you got a a scion off and you actually had a graft of that copy of Purdue number one. Where we're headed now is much more diversity in terms of family lines of black walnut and then essentially taking the progeny of these improved orchards and planting the kids out. And so we're trying to figure out what moms produce the best kids. And those are the trees that are going to stay in the orchard and we're going to use that to produce a diverse set of walnut lines not just one line that'll be available for planting.

SPEAKER_00And based on the evidence I've seen so far I think one of the big advantages of this tree improvement program is we're starting to rogue out the low end of these selections. And so the the selections that have really poor growth that have poor form. And so when you get this improved stock what you're really getting is not something that's light years ahead of all other walnut but we've taken off some of the risk of having really bad genetics.

SPEAKER_00I think that's been one of the problems advertisements that we were going to be rich in 25 years. Well we've been doing this for longer than 25 years and that's not happened. Yeah. So it takes a long time to grow quality even on good sites. But if we've got trees that have been tested and shown to be on average even it's it if it's small percentages like in the teens better than nursery run, you could plant some of those out wider spacings in a higher density plantings, you know, 20 to 40 feet apart not have the whole planting there and you've got an opportunity to take advantage of those genetics.

SPEAKER_00But one of the things we've seen with genetics also is once again you've got to be on the best sites. Right. We're on marginal sites the genetic advantages disappear.

SPEAKER_02So keeping that wide genetic base but it still does not compensate totally for you know the silvix and the the silviculture of growing those.

SPEAKER_00Absolutely it's one part of a big system and really the low-hanging fruit is site selection and good culture, good silviculture.

SPEAKER_01And that's kind of the definition of long-term research right like you guys are looking at progeny how big do those have to get before you make a determination that hey this was a successful or better form than maybe some of its competitors.

SPEAKER_00Yeah there's been some research on that that shows typically around year eight to twelve we we've got a pretty good idea of what that tree is going to look like more in the future. And I think it's important to carry it out either a little further because a lot of times our first thinning in these plantations is somewhere between year 10 and 15 depending on growth rate. And that's where we're going to pick our crop trees. And so we want to make sure that we're seeing that performance at that point in time and that it carries through to make good decisions on that crop tree selection and when we start doing that thinning.

SPEAKER_00That's why it takes so long to get this done that's a waiting game to see how those kids perform from that first generation of selections.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. So you mentioned thinning I think a lot of us who've been you know we went to school we turned about walnut and then we heard about crown competition factor. Yes. And it was one of those that I I have to admit I never used you know we always just went in and looked at kind of the better examples and things like that. But now that we're talking to the you know the heart of the walnut empire and you Lenny what is crown competition factor?

SPEAKER_00So it's a measure of crown size. And so the idea is that they're looking at what is the kind of optimum size of a walnut that has the opportunity to grow without competition, how big would its crown be? And then how many of those could we put on an acre? And then we will go into an area and based on the relationship of crown diameter to actual tree diameter DBH, there is a mathematical relationship there. And so we can do uh diameter measurements and get an idea based on the average diameter and the number of trees per acre what that crown competition factor is.

SPEAKER_00If it's a hundred we have a site that is fully occupied with trees that have had the full capacity to grow to their best. If it's over a hundred we are diminishing the ability of individual trees to grow at their best we're diminishing that crown size. If it's under a hundred we've got still a little bit more room to grow those trees in a not super competitive environment. And so it's a it's a really pretty useful measure to get a gauge of when we're thinking about something like black walnut where we really want to target in on individual trees of really high quality is our stand in a position where we can kind of optimize the growth on those trees.

SPEAKER_00And so in that respect it's very helpful. It's kind of a big ugly calculation though. But the nice thing is that the Iowa State University years ago produced this forestry guide and in it they put a stocking chart that looks a lot like the Gingrich charts that every forester in the the Midwest has used only it uses CCF instead of stocking on one side and then it's got diameter basal area and trees per acre on the axes. And so you can access that and I think we've got that website available for the resources in this and print that that out and when you go into implantation use that and so once you've got either basal area and diameter basal area and trees per acre you can see what your crown competition factor is and make thinning decisions based on that.

SPEAKER_02It sounds like it's almost a form of relative density in a way it's yes and I think on the charts and you sent Brad and I those charts it's on the left side of the diagram just like just like we're looking at relative density of stocking.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. It's a handy little chart that I think foresters will relate to much better because they're used to use using the gangrich stocking charts and this is laid out exactly the same way.

SPEAKER_02I just remember trying to use the formula and using the walnut manager's handbook and and uh sitting in a plantation going ah I don't know yeah yeah just the new crop tree release so that's right I'll just pick out the crop trees and give them some release so I guess that you know that being the case so foresters can use this guide it'll help them guide them on sort of the timing and the amount of thinning but also like when you're approaching a stand for thinning maybe it's a plantation that's more solid walnut what are some of the things that you're looking for in that operation in the setup of it?

SPEAKER_00That's a great question. So one of the things I'm trying not to get in too big of a hurry because one of the things I recognize is that competition is my best friend when it comes to quality development. And so I see some people that want to get in as soon as they see crowns touching and start doing things and I'm not for that I think we want to see that competition and the lifting of the crowns the shading of those lower branches the forcing of those stems to grow straighter to produce the quality if you absolutely feel like you've got to maintain optimum growth through time yeah you're gonna have to get your printing equipment out and start to work.

SPEAKER_00And then you're having an impact on growth then too because you're taking off leaf area. But yeah I try not to get in a hurry so I a lot of times am not pushing people to do thinning until like year 12 or 15 on those eight by eight spacings. And then I am starting to look at what's the shape of that crown particular the trees that have produced the best quality logs am I getting compression or flattening on those crown surfaces? That's my first indication that I've got problems and probably need to be thinking about doing some some release although and I think this was one of the questions you maybe had coming up but I'm going to go ahead and tackle it is how much release do we give walnut in view of the fact that with veneer they really are looking for even growth for a couple of reasons the aesthetics but also the mechanics of veneer itself and talking to some of the veneer guys they say you know if these trees grow irregularly over time the veneer tends to buckle in the manufacturing process.

SPEAKER_00And so they do want a relatively even growth rate. So this three or four sided crop tree release for many of the trees that's been recommended is probably a little drastic for veneer quality walnut and it and obviously you know if you're working in a plantation and it's a landowner that's out there on the plantation they could thin on a slower schedule essentially removing one tree on that canopy maybe every three or four years and evening that growth out to keep that even growth and and that nice wood character that the veneer guys are looking for.

SPEAKER_01Does the walnut respond very quickly to release when you're applying it like that?

SPEAKER_00It certainly seems to yes yeah it does tend to respond to release and and will will grow aggressively into those areas to a point. I've seen walnut plantations that were planted 20 or 25 years ago and have never received any thinning and practically every tree is still out there. Just seems to be a characteristic of walnut not to drop out but just to gradually reduce canopy size. And usually they're all sprouting up and down the the columns of the trunks and you're way past when you can really do good work at that point because you really degraded the quality of the wood with the sprouting and you don't have a crown that's going to respond well to release.

SPEAKER_00So timely thinning definitely important.

SPEAKER_02Brad and I had a conversation with Jan Wiedenbach from the Forest Service about management of veneer and that was kind of one lesson that I walked away from that conversation was just trying to get that at least on those highest value trees because not all trees are the highest value trees but that cons just that steady consistent growth whatever that is is important.

SPEAKER_01That's what I've always heard too and and do buy into that absolutely so we start talking about thinnings we're really kind of thinking about maybe potential markets.

SPEAKER_00So it sounds like some of those very first thinnings those are non-commercial at least where you are when do you start to see those markets develop for thinnings yeah we had an unusual situation we've got a very large agroforestry planting here in Tippecanoe County that they did some thinning these were good high quality trees that have been pruned through time and grown on really good sites and he was actually selling to a local wood market particular buyer eight inch top diameters eight and nine inch top diameters so so uh what I'm hearing from some of the guys that are in kind of the bigger more mainline industry is they'll take 10 inch diameter black walnut but they don't like a lot of it they need it mixed with other larger diameter material.

SPEAKER_00Yeah uh they can utilize it but the small diameter stuff has such high operating costs versus the wood value that it's a killer once they start running it through the mill. So what can be marketed versus what is economical to market, you know, they really need that balancing point of they've got to have some bigger better material. They can take some of the small diameter stuff but it's it's tough to move. And so what we find is if we're not you know 14 15 inches dbh it's probably going to not look very good in the market a lot of times.

SPEAKER_02Lenny I have a question that kind of gets back to what we started with and that was are we managing individual trees or stands but when we're looking at markets and trees and we're trying to decide on rotating these trees or stands what types of things are you looking at in that sense when do you rotate a stand of walnuts or an individual tree are there cues that you use yeah yeah so actually one of the things you can look at on walnut is the bark texture and so this is actually pretty pretty valuable in natural stands a really long continuous running ridges with quite a bit of space between the ridges that tree is probably growing like gangbusters where real heavy alligator hide bark that tree is probably growing quite slowly.

SPEAKER_00And so it really will tell you a lot about its growth rate by the bark. And so that can tell us you know is this a tree that we're actually going to see any kind of return on in the situation it's in based on its growth rate. And then we can also think about you know what else is around it. And so if I've got a tree that is growing relatively slowly but I've got some younger trees a younger walnut that are its progeny around it may be a good time to think about marketing it even if it's not a super big tree because we're not going to get it much bigger with with any kind of you know movement in time.

SPEAKER_00Where if I've got a tree that either through looking at the bark or actually doing repeated measurements I see still making good growth there are market premiums for larger diameter plus that whole volume curve that we get on you know once you get to a certain area of diameter and also adding logs up the tree and with walnuts value even upper logs can you know add considerable value to that tree. So uh so looking at those conditions of tree health growth rate and then what their surrounding stand looks like and then recognizing if you want to regenerate walnut you're gonna have to create light and so that's gonna push you in some situations if you're really wanting to regenerate walnut you're gonna have to make some decisions about a larger area and multiple trees in a spot.

SPEAKER_02Yeah so it sounds like there's a balance between managing individual trees but then what your stand level objectives are and you're considering both at the same time and how to make those work together.

SPEAKER_00Yeah and a lot of times you know here in in Indiana with our smaller woodlots in northern part of the state uh the walnut is really the economic driver a lot of times in these woodlots and so it's yeah it's making a lot of the decisions for us in terms of when we're marketing because it's going to be the sweetener that sells the the rest of the woods.

SPEAKER_02Yeah for people who haven't worked with it I probably don't realize a single tree could uh sell a sale. It is literally yeah it it determines who shows up a lot of times yeah right yeah so it's just an interesting bit of silviculture that's a little different than all the other cover types we manage because that individual aspect comes into play and it's just interesting.

SPEAKER_01Yeah yeah very unique in in many cases that's right yeah and Lenny I'm curious we talked about you know like maybe that bottom end of when they become commercial but with walnut and you mentioned that there's more value in bigger trees but how big is too big or is there a limit with with walnut in some of the markets you've seen?

SPEAKER_00You know for a lot of people it's kind of a risk evaluation every time the thunderstorm goes through and you hear the lightning strike you you hope it's not that really nice walnut tree out there. Yeah. And so you know realistically you're probably looking at you know upper end I would be moving trees that are 26 28 30 inches in diameter even on good sites. I know a location just across the line in Wisconsin uh near Beloit the gentleman in the walnut council he had trees on his property that were in the 30 plus to 40 wow and they had a sale and that that sale did fantastic.

SPEAKER_00So if you got the ground and you have the patience you know I I think there's there's probably an upper limit in terms of what the folks want to handle in terms of size but I I think you know even in the 30 inches to you know three feet 36 inches that's a totally acceptable size if you're growing that good quality tree and it's on a good site and in good health. But it does become a risk evaluation then because that's also if you're talking about a veneer tree of that dimension that's an enormous amount of capital sitting on the ground there that you hope nothing happens to.

SPEAKER_01Yep. But Lenny you mentioned earlier you talked about a large agroforestry planting where you're at and we've been hearing a lot about walnut outside of just the maybe the traditional markets. Yeah so agroforestry's been one of those but it seems like it's there's a lot of things brewing with walnut that way.

SPEAKER_00Yeah you know one of the things that's popped up is the slab market you know that's been churning for a while and we get unit values uh competing with the veneer values with uh the live edge slabs uh a a Purdue professor here retired from our wood products group he has a slab mill and was cutting pretty much any kind of walnut and cherry and oak he could get a hold of and some of those boards had more holes than wood and he was still able to sell them for 75 bucks a board and some of the really nice stuff you know multiple hundreds for a really nice board so so there's that interesting marketplace of what normally would be pretty rough trees that we would have difficulty marketing otherwise and then what people are doing walnut syrup now too but I always tell folks you know the the syrup may not be very compatible with your veneer goals in terms of uh those tap holes don't don't uh heal they just seal so they'll always be there so that's an issue uh and the yield on that is not like maple syrup you don't get as much sap out of the tree and if you need a lot more sap to make the same amount of syrup with walnut uh so so those are options and then of course the nuts you know one of the big operators uh in Missouri Hamm and nut company kind of dominated the black walnut nut meat market and there's a lot of work involved in extracting those nut meats that's pretty specialized area but there there's a variety of of areas like that that folks could look at as possibilities.

SPEAKER_01Yeah I know on the agroforestry front Greg we've had discussions with people who were looking at it for a number of so they were planting it for in windrose or kind of rows within their agroforestry projects and they were counting on that black walnut wood you know so they could have that over time and they they were thinking about the nuts I think in a lot of ways they were mixing it with silva pasture and really wanted that shade for some of those for the cows too.

SPEAKER_00So yeah that's an interesting idea.

SPEAKER_01Yeah I think there's a lot of opportunity there.

SPEAKER_00And that light canopy probably would make it amenable to to some pasturing like that.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. Sounds like Brad you better start tapping those black walnuts that you got growing back on that little well sand prairie of yours.

SPEAKER_01Well it is interesting if you think about tapping sugar maple you know we do create that defect and we can get some discoloration and we get some other things. With walnut I guess we're really not worried about discoloration right it's going to be dark no matter what but it's that defect on the outside that gets kind of basically entombed within that tree over time.

SPEAKER_00Yeah and and you know you probably still will see a little bit of staining potentially and so it it would certainly you know have some impacts on the veneer area. Saw timber like you say you know if you've got if a defect is pretty even across the woods sometimes it's a plus rather than a minus. So it depends on what people want to want to do with it. Absolutely yeah I know I remember visiting a walnut plantation one time that was all wired up with the taps and uh the folks said now Lenny breathe easily this is their management objective and so I had to accept that you know so try not to judge.

SPEAKER_02That's right. That's right. Lenny I this have been a really interesting conversation about all things walnut. We covered a lot of ground there but it's just such an interesting species and Brad and I have both appreciated uh working with it over the years and it's just really nice to talk to you about some of these items and compare notes actually so I just want to say thanks. It's been a great conversation.

SPEAKER_00Yeah well well thank you I uh we all have a lot to learn on this still you know there's a lot of work to be done and I hope some of the conversations we have might encourage people to try some things and report back. We we can all learn from each other on this situation.

SPEAKER_01Lenny if listeners are interested in more information should they go check out like the Purdue website basically for more info?

SPEAKER_00Please do Purdue Forestry Natural Resources extension and the Hardwood Tree Improvement and Regeneration Center are all great sources of information. The other group that provides a wonderful connection to Black Walnut is the Walnut Council. And it looks like the Walnut Council is actually going to be meeting in either Illinois or southern Wisconsin for our next meeting in the Beloit area. And that'll be in late July of 2025. So that's an opportunity as well.

SPEAKER_01Cool yeah great great conversation thank you so much well Greg sometimes it's nice to receive some affirmation that Silvicast is On the right track. And this week we received a letter from a listener who really enjoys listening to SilvaCast. Oh yeah? Yeah. That's cool. I'll read you a little bit of it. I thought it was pretty good. Dear Greg and Brad, I wanted to write you not merely as a fan, but as a listener to Silvicast.

SPEAKER_01I've really enjoyed the work that you've put into this and think that Silvicast is something that the entire forestry community should be more aware of. I shouldn't say I'm really a listener. I'm an acolyte and and perhaps a worshiper at the cathedral of your sonic brilliance. From the first syllable of your intro music, I felt as though I were being pulled through a wormhole of enlightenment, flung headfirst into an alternate universe where clarity, wit, and intellect reign supreme. See now, Greg, this is this is good writing.

SPEAKER_01Brad. This is good.

unknownBrad.

SPEAKER_01Your insights are not opinions, they're revelations. Your banter, not conversation. It's verbal jazz played on golden saxophones by celestial beings. Brad, Brad. I would I would sooner forsake food and water than miss an episode. Brad, you've tried this before. My doctor is concerned, but I've made peace with that.

SPEAKER_02That is that's not a real letter.

SPEAKER_01One more line. One more line. In short, if Aristotle, Beyoncé, and David Attenborough collaborated on a podcast in heaven, it might approach the grandeur of Silvacast, but I doubt it.

SPEAKER_02I'm glad that, at least in your head, those are the words you hear.

SPEAKER_01Well, this is not what I hear. This is what a listener wrote to us, Greg. So, no, we did not get this from a listener. But it is a reminder that we would really like to get feedback from listeners, unless you want us to keep making up these conversations, and I guarantee we can make them deeper and richer than this. Just stop me and we'll just we'll read normal letters.

SPEAKER_02If someone tell Brad to get a grip on reality, that would be a more appropriate letter.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. So in any event, thanks for listening to today's episode of Silvicast. If you have ideas for future episodes or a question for the drop box, please let us know. You can reach us at UW Stevens Points Wisconsin Forestry Center by emailing wfc at uwsp.edu. Feel free to include a sound file of your question or comment if you like. And actually just send us anything, right? You can send us your recipes for next week.

SPEAKER_01We'll we'll appreciate it. Not a flowery letter. Not a flowery letter. But remember, we always learn best when we wrestle with questions, so please keep them coming.

SPEAKER_02And take care, everyone. And as always, thanks to our team, Susan Barrett, our editor in chief, Joe Rogers, our IT master, theme music by Paul Freder, and of course, UW Stevens Points, Wisconsin Forestry Center.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. S.7 Ep.11 - The Rise and Fall of Black Cherry

    Nov 1, 202658 minAudio

    Rome, Egypt, the Aztecs - history has seen the rise and fall of many once-dominant civilizations. But could we be witnessing a similar story unfolding in our forests, with the decline of a once-dominant tree species?...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. S.7 Ep.10 - Growing Quality White Pine: Knot What You Think!

    Oct 1, 20261 hr 5 minAudio

    Eastern white pine is making a comeback, but as experienced field foresters know, much of this second-growth timber can be challenging from a quality standpoint. In this episode of SilviCast, we talk with Rene Germain,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. S.7 Ep.9 - Plant the Seed

    Sep 1, 20261 hr 8 minAudio

    In this episode of SilviCast, we talk with regeneration experts Mike Reinikainen, Roger Bohringer, and Tom Hill about direct seeding - a challenging and often misunderstood approach to reforestation that establishes...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. S.7 Ep.8: Rethinking Black Locust

    Aug 3, 202642 minAudio

    Black locust doesn't have many fans among foresters in North America. It's often criticized for growing crooked, spreading aggressively, and producing poor-quality stems. But is the problem really the tree, or is it how...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. S.7 Ep.7: Beaviculture

    Jul 1, 202654 minAudio

    Beavers are often seen as a nuisance, but what if they're actually some of nature's most effective forest managers? In this episode of SilviCast, we welcome renowned ecohydrologist Dr. Emily Fairfax to explore the...

    Credit the people on this episode