Didn't hear back from your dream school? Time to give up! A college coach told you you're not good enough? Give up! Your friends are getting recruited and you're not? Might as well quit! Sounds ridiculous, doesn't it? That's exactly the point. In Episode 202 of The Significant Coaching Podcast, Coach Matt Rogers tackles the unreasonable reasons student-athletes abandon their college recruiting dreams long before they've exhausted their opportunities. Rejection, impatience, comparison, unrealistic expectations, and the unwillingness to consider different college pathways can turn an already challenging process into an unnecessarily frustrating experience. But here's the reality: Just because the schools you want aren't recruiting you doesn't mean there aren't great schools that want you. With more than 25 years of experience in athletics, including serving as a college head coach, athletics director, and recruiting advisor, Coach Rogers challenges recruits and their families to stop making excuses, rethink their expectations, and recognize the opportunities right in front of them. Your recruiting journey doesn't have to go exactly as planned to have a significant ending. Send us Fan Mail Significant Recruiting: The Playbook for Prospective College Athletes Don't rely on mere chance. Be significant with your future. The easy 12-step book to owning your college recruitment. Get your copy here at Amazon.com Support the show 📰 Join my Recruiting and Coaching Community and get my FREE Weekly Newsletter at coachmattrogers.com 📆 Need help with your children's college recruiting needs? Schedule your FREE Discovery Call to discuss working together: Schedule FREE Recruiting Session 🎤 Does your school or organization need help with Recruiting Realities and College Athletics Education? Schedule your FREE Discovery Call to discuss bringing Coach Matt to speak: Schedule FREE Speaker Discovery Call 📚 Do you want to handle your college recruiting on your own but would like a plan to follow? Click HERE to get your copy of the Significant Recruiting Playbook and your Sport Specific Recruit's Journal for baseball, basketball, soccer, softball and volleyball. 📺 Do you wish their was an inexpensive, simple step-by-step recruiting class series you could follow? Click HERE to get full access to the Significant Recruiting Launchpad.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Hey, everybody. It's Coach Matt Rogers, and this is the Significant Coaching Podcast. Welcome back to another solo episode. I'm excited, as always, to talk to you about recruiting, coaching, and parenting. And if you've been a part of the Significant Coaching community for a long time, you know what I'm about I'm about learning. I'm about exchanging ideas, and a lot of times I'm about somebody changing my ideas and my thoughts. I'm about putting kids and parents and coaches in healthier positions, and today is no different.
My topic today is one that I'm constantly dealing with on the peripheral, and oftentimes with the students and families I work with. I'm very picky about who I start this journey with. I don't work with a lot of families. The most I ever work with in a year is maybe 10 to 12 families in a graduation class, and that's a lot for me, simply because I put so much time and effort into each kid and each family to make sure they have that concierge connection, and most of all, a support all the way through their high school and college careers so they don't make the mistakes I know they shouldn't make.
But the big thing I wanna talk about today is the idea of,"Okay, it's time to give up." And I've had to have that conversation with kids. "Are you ready to quit?" And as you can hear in my voice, there's some sarcasm there, and I take the emotion out of it because I'm starting to hear from them that they're doubting things. They're starting to doubt this path they're on, even though they told me six months ago, a year ago, two years ago, that they were passionate about playing in college. "No doubt, Coach Matt, no doubt." There was nothing that was going to get in their way.
They were determined to play, and that was it. No ifs, ands, or buts. 100%, Coach, I'm doing this." Well, for me, a lot of that comes down, when they do decide,"I don't think I can do this anymore," w- it comes down to unreasonable reasons why they give up, why they decide to end their journey. So I'm not afraid to give them a little push from that ledge they've put themselves on, and hopefully bring them back to reality.
And in today's podcast, I wanna talk about those unreasonable things so you can start talking about them as a family. Why are you putting yourself in this position to doubt the journey you're on for things that really don't make a lot of sense once you remove the emotion? And maybe they do right now from an emotional standpoint, they do feel like it's the right thing to do, but for the long term, for your life, for the next four years, for who you want to be, what you want to do, where you wanna live, and the things you wanna create for your future, okay?
It's unreasonable. It's illogical. It's oftentimes impractical. So let's talk about those things. Number one:"I'm not sure I'm good enough." Come on. Really? I'm not... You're not good enough? I'm doubting I have the ability to play at that next level. And I have to look at that kid and go,"Listen, think about what you and I have gone through. Think about the conversations you've had. We had multiple conversations about your ability and your experience before we even started to work together.
You sent me your film, and as a longtime college coach and college evaluator, I watched your film, and I told you the truth. I said,'This is where you're at.'" And I typically will under-evaluate a kid on purpose. If they can play D2, I typically tell them D3 or NAIA is kind of where their potential is today. I don't do this to lie to them. Now, they could grow five inches. They could put 10 pounds of muscle on. They could put a year into their skills and their speed, and they could blow up.
They could completely change who they were. They could have dramatic change in a very shmort am- sh- excuse me, in a very short amount of time if they want to put the effort into it. But when a family starts with me, I say,"Listen, I evaluated your film. I wouldn't have taken you on if I didn't think you could get recruited." And typically, if I don't see they're a kid that I could get 20 or 30 coaches excited about them, I don't take them on. And then I take another step before I work with a family. I send their film to a bunch of college coaches that I trust before we agree to work together, and I get those coaches to tell me their reality.
So why are we here? Why all of a sudden do you think you're not good enough? "Well, coaches aren't calling me enough. I'm not getting a lot of replies to my emails. Nobody's made me a big offer yet or a formal offer." And I have to tell them,"That's just the game we're playing." It's a journey. These coaches are trying to make really good decisions for their programs. And, and realistically, you have to continue to talk to a lot of coaches. You have to understand what they see in you.
You have to understand where that fit is. And it's important that you don't get too caught up in what's happening during the journey. That's essential. Instead, you have to go,"Wow, I just learned something about myself. That coach was critical of me, but I learned something about myself. This gives me growth. This gives me perspective." It's a big deal. This coach really likes me, but they want me to work on my defense. They want to see more intensity from me guarding the ball.
They want to see me more consistent in how I block out, right? They want to see me develop my arm at third base, if you're a baseball player or a shortstop. They want to see my pop time improve as a catcher. They want me to work on my footwork as an outside hitter, right? All those things. If you're a volleyball defensive specialist, maybe they wanna see you not fall down to your knees so much. They wanna see you get to your, get your feet to the ball and frame it without having to go to the ground.
These, these are pretty reasonable requests, yes? Kids, teenagers, you all hear those little critiques and go,"Oh, I'm terrible. I can't play. That coach doesn't believe in me. They don't think I have the skill set to play there." Really? That's what you heard? You do have a skill set. You have everything we really like about you. We think you can possibly play for us, but before we take that big step to make you an offer, really that's what they're thinking, we wanna see you work on a couple of things.
That's awesome. That's a coach who's challenging you. They're saying,"Hey, we like you. We want to see what you're going to do with a challenge." Right? Because if you don't take a challenge and attack it, well, now you've told us that we shouldn't make you an offer. You've decided that you're not gonna get better, and it's not worth it for you to get better. So if you quit or give up on us because we told you we want to improve, you to improve on something, great.
Thank you. As a college coach, you just saved me a whole lot of time. So that's number one. Doesn't that sound unreasonable? All right. We've gotta make sure we don't give up on ourselves. If you can play and somebody has evaluated you as a college player, maybe multiple coaches have, it's time for you to take that seriously and want that criticism. Don't forget that evaluation is a big part of your journey. Okay, number two. Well, I think I'm gonna give up'cause I have a boyfriend or girlfriend.
The second thing I find really unreasonable, and I'm not going to put a ton of time to this because I wrote a big blog on this about a year and a half ago, and I gave advice to kids that have that relationship, is, is about kids that are in love. Okay? And the idea of going away from that person they've connected with, for maybe the first time in their life for many of these kids, it's really, really hard, and I know all about that. And that moment, that love, that passion, that excitement, that connection,"Oh, I can't lose that.
It's been the greatest thing in my life. I don't wanna lose that." I'm not taking that for granted. I'm not telling you it's wrong. I understand that all too well. I was that kid. I had a girlfriend in my last year of high school, and I just couldn't imagine being without her. And I really ruined my first semester of college because of that girl, not because of her, but because I couldn't understand that my future was more important than that relationship in that moment. I was 18.
Because if we really did love each other, us going to different colleges and being far away from each other shouldn't affect our future, right? That's a mature thought. That future could still be there, but we had to get a degree. We had to experience adulthood. We had to learn to stand on our own. So it's important for young people to understand that the love you think you have right now, and maybe it is real love, but it can't get in the way of you growing up, becoming an adult, and getting that degree, okay?
Go talk to any 20, 30, 40, 50-year-old, okay? I have friends in their 40s who don't have a college degree, and they're trying to move up. They're trying to get a better job. They're trying to make more money But they don't have a degree. It's so darn difficult when you don't have that bachelor's. So get that degree. Then you're 22. Doesn't mean you have to go to law school or medical school- medical school. It doesn't mean you have to get a job right away.
Doesn't mean you're going to find another person to love for the rest of your life and marry, okay? Just because you got that degree doesn't mean you have to change your direction. But when you have that degree, all of a sudden you've got a future for whoever that person is you're going to share it with. You have an opportunity to do more for your new family. So you have a really good conversation, Mom and Dad, with your kids who have a boyfriend or girlfriend. It's time.
Just say,"Listen, you can love this person. You... But you need to start talking about that separation and what that separation is gonna look like." Because here's the big thing, and I wrote about this in the blog in much more detail. Talk to your daughter or your son about the fact that if they both go to college, okay, them and their partner, there's a really good chance they're going to resent each other if they decide to stay together because they're want- They're gonna get there, and they're gonna make all these friends, and they're gonna wanna go out with their friends.
They're gonna wanna hang out with other boys and other girls. They're going to want to have friendships, and some of them are going to be intimate, and you don't want that other person always thinking you're cheating or doing something inappropriate because you are having fun, and you're living your own. Okay, so now you're worried. "I don't want them worried about me. I feel like they're always looking over my shoulder. They're always, they're always think I'm doing something wrong when we talk on the phone." You don't want that.
You don't want that resentment. So as hard as this is for me to say, and probably for a lot of kids to hear, you may have to put a plan together with that boyfriend or girlfriend about what your breakup is going to look like. And not a breakup where we're never going to see each other again, or we're not going to talk, or we're not going to Zoom or FaceTime and continue to share a, a, a healthy friendship. We can still do all those things. But we're going to give each other the freedom to go to college, to be completely independent, and to do what we want to do.
And then a year, two years, four years, five years into it, if we're saying,"Gosh, we've been talking. We've each been enjoying our careers and college, but we've stayed commit- connected. I miss you. I still want that," and you both want that, well, maybe that's real.
It, it'll still be there But it's important to unleash each other and give each other the freedom to enjoy college without resentment. That's one of the greatest gifts you can give yourself and your partner for your future. All right, let's talk about number three. I don't think I wanna work that hard. And this is a tough one. I probably went through this one as well. And to be honest, I probably have gone through some of the... all of these at some point. A lot of kids just start doubting they don't have it in them to work as hard as they think they're gonna have to work.
Maybe they're starting to go on visits. They go to a practice or a game at the college level, and they see how fast it is, how physical it is, how tall the other players are, how strong and how athletic everybody is. And they go,"Wow, I don't think I can do this." They start allowing their brain to shift to a place where they think,"All right, maybe I need to give this up. I'm not gonna want to work that hard." Right? And there's some reality to that. Okay, let's talk about that reality.
You've got to come back to the fact that you went on a visit because these coaches asked you to. They believe in you. They like you. They asked you to visit because they want to see if there's a connection between you and them. They already think you can play at their level or they wouldn't have wasted the visit, and they believe in your work ethic. They've talked to your coaches. They've seen you over a period of time. They've watched you enough that they think they can mold you into a great player in their program. So when you start doubting yourself, you give yourself that little alcove, that little tributary, that little left turn to say,"Oh, all right.
I'm not gonna work that hard. I don't have it in me. I'm not gonna go down that path," and you start giving up. To me, that's unreasonable, and that's the beginning of probably you giving up the rest of your life. Remember, you went down this road because you love it. You love the work. You love the game. You love the people. You love the relationships. Why would you give up on yourself just because all of a sudden things look hard? Yeah, they're gonna be hard. But do you really wanna give up on yourself because of that?
If that's true, maybe it is time for you to give up on yourself. But I don't think it is. I think you're gonna resent yourself. I think you're gonna be upset with yourself in a year because you gave up on something you wanted simply because you didn't think you wanted to work that hard. When did that idea start? All right, let's talk about number far, four. It's too far from home. Too far from home? Oh, I'm gonna miss mom and dad. I'm gonna miss my siblings. I'm gonna miss all my friends.
I'm gonna miss Friday nights at Sonic or Dairy Queen where we all hang out together, right? And then the things we do. Wasn't that fun in high school? Well, guess what? All those things you do on a Friday night, you're doing them with a group of kids who are all leaving, okay? They're gone. They're going somewhere, too. They're going to college. And even the ones who are staying, do you really wanna be sitting there with them in a year when everybody else is at college?
You're gonna go,"This sucks. Everybody we know is going to parties on college campuses. They're going to football games and basketball games. They're taking these awesome classes and building these relationships with their professors." Ex- excuse me. "They're joining clubs", right? "And we're sitting here working at the mall so we can go to Sonic and Dairy Queen every Friday night?" What a bunch of baloney. Come on. Too far from home doesn't mean anything.
Okay, it does mean something. It means you get the freedom, the independence, and the opportunity to go to reinvent yourself if you do go to college. Isn't that powerful? That is what's cool, and I'm so glad I made myself do that. I'm so glad nobody got in my way so I could fail a little bit and learn to get over that failure, and then experience that ability to reinvent myself as someone who I wanted to be or at least I wanted to find out who I was. You stay with those people who are still here at your high school, and they don't go off somewhere, you're gonna continue to be that person you've always been.
And maybe you're okay with that, but you're not gonna really grow up. You're not gonna evolve. You're not gonna learn what's out there. You're not gonna get out of that cocoon and be a butterfly. Let's talk about number five, and I hate this one. So many kids give up because they only want the big name and the big school. They only wanna go to that school with the big football stadium that plays on Saturday afternoons on ESPN,"I wanna be a part of that crowd," or that great volleyball team that everyone knows.
"I wanna go to that big school and be part of those 20,000 kids- You wanna go somewhere because there are other kids having a great experience at what you tell me you love to do, and you wanna be a part of watching their experience? Does that make sense to anybody? Maybe it does to you. Maybe in your head, mom and dad are telling you that makes a lot of sense. Maybe your neighbors are telling you that makes a lot of sense. Go somewhere real big and be a part of that experience. Go to a big school so you can be a part of all that energy.
Or you go to a smaller school and be the one creating that energy. Be the one that other kids wanna come out and watch and wish they were playing with you. Be the one they wanna be a part of. Be the one doing something special with your skill. Don't forget that. You have the ability to be the one who's creating that energy you so badly want. Don't walk away from that. All right. Number six, and this is one, and I don't hear this a lot from my parents that I work with, but this is the one where parents get in the way because they start doubting.
Parents start giving alternative options. "Well, Susie, Danny, what if you just go to the local junior college and live at home for two years? We're gonna save$40,000. You can go get a job, make some money. We'll save more money, and then you can transfer and have that great four-year experience for your last two years." Okay. That's not a bad idea. Junior college isn't a bad idea, especially if you don't have a lot of money or a lot of savings to pay for college.
But to put yourself in a position to stay at home for those two years- It's just like those kids that are sticking around for Dairy Queen and Sonic on Friday nights. And I'm using Dairy Queen and Sonic because that's kind of what my daughter and the kids in our town do. They all meet at Sonic or one of the fast food restaurants, and they hang out on Friday nights. Okay? Maybe they go drive or go to somebody's house or go to a movie, but they go hang out there. It's kind of the same thing. You're not gonna grow up.
You're not gonna evolve. You're not gonna start your adult journey, Mom and Dad, if you're telling them,"Hey, it's okay to stay here. It's okay to stay in your bedroom for two more years where it's safe." Okay? And cheaper. Whatever excuse you want to give. Is there a junior college two hours away, three hours away, one that has housing and isn't gonna cost you an arm and a leg? Is there one a couple of states over that the coach really wants you? Cool. You can still save money, but you can start your adult journey.
You can start learning how to stand on your own two feet without Mom and Dad right there. Yeah? I think so. I think it's worth the conversation. And the final one we're gonna talk about, and this is real one as well, and that's money. And I'm not gonna downplay that because my wife and I, we have a senior right now, and we're always looking at each other as we're going through this journey going,"How are we gonna afford this? This is crazy. These college tuition numbers are ridiculous.
What are we gonna do? How much blood are we gonna have to give every Friday to pay for these tuition costs? What do we have to sell? What do we have to give up? How much of our retirement do we have to dig into to make this college experience work for our kid?" I, I get it. I get that money is real, and the cost of education is real. But to give up on your sports journey, your desire to keep playing your sport, your desire to go to college, to do those adult journey things we've been talking about, right, to make that decision based solely on money- That's where I believe this is unreasonable because there are opportunities for kids out there.
If you can play a little bit, you've got some ability, and you've got some desire, there's a place out there where you don't have to spend a truckload of money to get a degree and to keep playing. I mean that. You don't have to take on a ton of debt to do this, and you can keep playing. Yes, a lot of those opportunities are at junior colleges and community colleges But they're all over the country looking for great players. And oftentimes, you can go to one of those schools for 8,000, 10,000,$12,000 out of pocket, maybe 15,000, and live on campus, and have that adult journey experience.
Maybe you're eligible for the Pell Grant. Maybe we can get that 15,000 down to 10,000. Maybe there's a state grant you can get. Yeah? Maybe there's an academic scholarship you've earned, and we can get that even lower. Maybe there are four or$5,000 in private scholarships you can apply for to get that down any lower, even lower. There's money out there. I talk to kids and see kids all the time who apply for every scholarship they can, and some have 40, 50, 60, even$80,000 in scholarships just from things that they applied for.
Now, that's a lot of money, but those kids really want it. So don't let money be the thing that slows you down from your dreams and your goals. Again, it goes back to work ethic. You've gotta put the time in. If I apply for one scholarship every week, okay, it's October when I'm talking to you about this. So let's say October 1st through May 1st, you apply for one scholarship every week. What is that, about 30 scholarships you've applied for at the end of that spring?
Let's say you get six or seven of those scholarships, and they're all$1,000, or some are 1,500,$2,000, just because you put an hour's worth of work in. All of a sudden you've got that 10,000, 12,000, 15,000 that you didn't have before. All of a sudden you're going to college with maybe a couple thousand dollars out of pocket. And maybe you don't have that couple thousand dollars. Well, maybe you work, do some work study or you take a small loan. A$2,000 loan every year is something you may be able to pay back fairly quickly after graduating.
So don't let money get in your way. Find out what's possible before you decide it isn't. All right, let's wrap this up. I'm passionate about this, as you can tell. At the end of the day, it's about not allowing your excuses to keep you from your journey. And part of this conversation is understanding that we're just starting your adult journey today, not when you get to college. We're starting your adult journey by making hard decisions that are the best decisions for your future, and I really want you to think about that.
If you really don't love the game anymore, if your goals have genuinely changed, that's a different conversation. But if you still love it, if you still want it, and you're thinking about quitting because you're afraid, because it's hard, because somebody told you no, or because things aren't happening as quickly as you hoped, I want you to think long and hard before you walk away, because you may not get this opportunity ever again.
I hope this was helpful today. And remember, control what you can control, be humble, and keep chasing significance
What happens when the coaching profession changes faster than we do? In Episode 213 of the Significant Coaching Podcast, Coach Matt Rogers welcomes back Colorado Mesa University Head Baseball Coach Chip "Skip" Hanks for...
Getting recruited is exciting, but are you asking college coaches the right questions? In Episode 212 of the Significant Recruiting Podcast, former college head coach Matt Rogers shares five essential questions every...
Are you leaving thousands of dollars in college financial aid on the table? In Episode 211 of The Significant Recruiting Podcast, Coach Matt Rogers breaks down the 10 biggest financial aid mistakes college recruits and...
What really catches a college basketball coach's attention? And what can make that same coach walk away from a recruit? Karim MacDonald, Head Women's Basketball Coach at Green River College, returns for Part 2 of our...
What has to change before a struggling program starts winning? For Coach Karim McDonald, it started with the people, the relationships, and the environment. In Part 1, Matt Rogers welcomes his friend Karim McDonald,...