Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

על המשמעות - ערוץ פילוסופי פוליטי בהנחיית תמיר דורטל

על המשמעות - ערוץ פילוסופי פוליטי בהנחיית תמיר דורטל artwork

#1035 Victoria Coates | "Anti-Zionism is a danger" - What happened after Oct 7?

Oct 3, 202630 minAudio

In this episode of the podcast, Adv. Tamir Dortal hosts Victoria Coates, Senior Fellow at the Davis Institute for National Security and Foreign Policy at the Heritage Foundation, for a conversation about the vital US-Israel relationship and the rising global threat of anti-Semitism. Following the devastating events of October 7th, the landscape of global politics and cultural dynamics has shifted dramatically. Coates brings her extensive experience from the highest levels of the American government - having served as Deputy National Security Advisor in the Donald Trump administration - to dissect the complex ties between Israel and the United States. We dive deep into the roots of anti-Semitism and anti-Zionism, exploring how these dangerous ideologies threaten not only Jewish lives but the very fabric of Western democracy itself. What exactly happened on the global stage after October 7th? How is American culture responding to this unprecedented crisis? And what does the future hold for the conservative movement in America and its steadfast support for Israel? Listeners of this episode will gain a rare, behind-the-scenes perspective on American foreign policy and national security from a leading conservative voice. Coates breaks down the ideological battles currently raging in American culture and offers practical insights into how we can confront and defeat these toxic narratives. She shares her firsthand experiences, detailing how policies are crafted to protect American and allied interests. The Heritage Foundation's proactive approach to shaping a conservative agenda is also brought into the spotlight, demonstrating the active measures being taken to counteract anti-Semitic rhetoric in the public square. By tuning in, you will learn how to identify the subtle ways anti-Zionism masks itself and why strong leadership is more crucial now than ever. Don't miss this compelling dialogue that bridges the gap between Washington D.C. and Jerusalem 00:00:00 Introducing Victoria Coates and Her Background 00:02:15 The Heritage Foundation and National Security 00:05:30 Working in the Trump Administration 00:08:45 The Threat of Anti-Semitism and Anti-Zionism 00:11:20 Analyzing the Aftermath of October 7th 00:14:15 The Deep Bond Between Israel and America 00:17:30 Shifts in Modern American Culture 00:20:45 The Impact of the NatCon Speech 00:23:10 Strategies for Protecting Western Democracy 00:26:00 Concluding Thoughts on the US-Israel Alliance #פודקאסט #על_המשמעות לתמיכה בכח התערבות - גוף האקטיביזם של על המשמעות: https://www.peach-in.com/cmp/j4l1xeyiq Support the show תוכנית המנויים "על המשמעות פלוס" ➕: https://www.peach-in.com/cmp/j4l102oyl לתמיכה בכח התערבות - גוף האקטיביזם של על המשמעות: https://www.peach-in.com/cmp/j4l1xeyiq גישה מוקדמת לפרקים 🎧 קטעי פרימיום 💎 מפגש שבועי 🖥️ גישה לקורסים 🧮 תמיכה בכלי תקשורת עצמאי ומשפיע 📢 מרצ׳נדייז 👕🏷: https://bit.ly/AlHmMerchandise פניות עסקיות 💼 - מתן: 058-424-2590 רשימת המלצות קריאה 📚: https://bit.ly/3rXRwvN ניוזלטר 📧 - https://mailchi.mp/0fbfc9fdc9dc/bnhqvcbmzu האזנה נעימה!

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Welcome back to Unmeaning. My guest today is Victoria Coates, one of the most experienced voices in American national security and foreign policy. Victoria served in the Trump administration as a deputy national security advisor after holding senior positions in at the National Security Council and the Department of Energy. Today she is the vice president of the Davis Institute for National Security and Foreign Policy at the Heritage Foundation. She is also a member of the committee of the National Conservatism Conference, which is coming to Jerusalem next week, where she will deliver a speech with the rather provocative title Antisemitism and Socialism Are the End of Democracy.

SPEAKER_00So today I want to understand the argument behind that title. Well, we'll talk about Israel and America, what October 7th revealed about the West, the rise of anti-Semitism in universities and cultural institutions, the changing American right, and why national conservatives believe that the nation still matters. Victoria Coates, welcome to Unmeaning.

SPEAKER_01Great to be with you. Right. No, this is a very interesting phenomenon that we're seeing here in the United States, which is the forces of socialism. And you would think we would know better, uh, having fought the Cold War against the communists now struggling that that communism and socialism are antithetical to the American experiment, which is based on free markets uh conservative economic principles.

SPEAKER_01And what we found is the folks that are pushing socialism are also the folks who are pushing anti-sanded states and anti-Israel sentiments. And so the purpose of my talk is to point out this conversion and also, you know, make that point that this is happening here in America. This is not just an Israel problem. This is an American problem as well.

SPEAKER_00And do you think it's it's just the personality of the people who are pushing against the West? Like it's it's only because those are the same people, or is it basically the same ideology?

SPEAKER_01No, I think this is ideological, not personality driven. Certainly there are big personalities. Your audience may have heard of Hassan Piker, for example, who's very prominent in this movement, pushing a lot of the very far-left candidates we have going into our midterms. But it at its root, as you say, it's ideological, and it is a hatred of Western civilization. And that's where we find, you know, the both both the socialism, which is, you know, it can undermine Western civilization, but the same thing with the anti-Semitism.

SPEAKER_01It's always the leading, the leading indicator of folks who are going after civilization writ large.

SPEAKER_00Can you put yourself in the shoes and try to understand why they hate the West?

SPEAKER_01Well, I mean, I think they they have divided the world up into the oppressor and the oppressed. And they've decided that America and Israel and the Jewish people writ large are the oppressor. I know that's difficult to understand when you've had things like October 7th happen to you, when you've had things like the incident with the uh Dubai airplane. Uh, you know, how are we the oppressor? But that is their worldview. And that the United States, a country that has lifted more people out of poverty, given freedom to more people than any force in history, is somehow the oppressor.

SPEAKER_01But in that worldview, then, you know, you have to battle against the oppressor. And so I think that's that's where they're coming from. I assume they believe these things sincerely. I think they're utterly misguided, but they're certainly very passionate about it.

SPEAKER_00Do they believe in those ideas or do they maybe feel those ideas as something and that is deeply rooted inside of them? Which means like sometimes people who couldn't succeed feel that people who did succeed did it on their expense. But it's not rational. It's uh maybe jealousy or stuff like that.

SPEAKER_01No, I think you've really put your finger on it. This is a culture of grievance, that it's not that everybody should be lifted up. It's that somebody needs to be dragged down for them to be successful. And, you know, they they look at the math. I was having a conversation with a friend yesterday who said, you know, if you're Jewish, you are 50% more likely to win a Nobel Prize than if you're not. And rather than saying that's industry, education, and hard work, that a lot of people would like to say that's just not fair. It's it's it's inequitable. And we have to we have to level the playing field.

SPEAKER_01That's the line they use over and over again. You know, we're not trying to do anything negative, we're just leveling the playing field. No, what they're trying to do is undermine success. And we're seeing this anti-Semitism, interestingly, drift into anti-Asian sentiment here in the United States for similar reasons. And, you know, it just it just winds up being ethnic divisions that they're sowing in order to make their path easier.

SPEAKER_00Why why do you think that the socialism contradicts democracy?

SPEAKER_01Socialism is governmental control. Democracy is government by the people. Participate, you know, the people participate in their government rather than having their government dictate to them. But in socialism, you know, you have the government taking over private industry, so you can't succeed. And I was really struck by the recent visit of Chairman Xi of China to Washington. And uh originally he was supposed to be bringing a number of top Chinese high-tech CEOs with him.

SPEAKER_01And you know, he wound up not doing it. And you look at the table that the president convened, just the president's uh table, eight or 10 people, the net worth of that table, those American CEOs, was 1.13 trillion. And of course, we had an ace in the hole with Elon Musk, uh, who's worth a whole lot. But overall, 1.13 trillion is a lot of money. And I looked up, you know, what are the top 10 high-tech CEOs in China worth? 360 billion. Now that's a lot of money, uh, you know, averaging 36 billion uh a tech CEO.

SPEAKER_01But the Americans so hugely outweigh that because we right now, under our capitalist system, reward success. So that's why socialism is really antithetical to what we're all about.

SPEAKER_00But don't you think that the Chinese experiment um maybe contradicts what we thought about socialism? Because we once thought that socialism leads people into poverty, into uh being hungry, into being uh dead because of the big uh jump forward that Chinese did, but maybe they found a model where socialism can work.

SPEAKER_01Well, they certainly found a model, but I think as we look at the next 15, 20 years, we're gonna see the enormous success of the American economy, the Israeli economy, which is really a miracle. Uh if you think about it, what's happened in Israel from the 1990s on. Uh, and I think we're gonna see real degradation of the Chinese model because it's really based on government subsidies and government control. And so, you know, now as they face the sort of AI revolution, they're gonna face some very difficult choices because if they want unfettered AI, they want creative growth, they're gonna have to release control.

SPEAKER_01And bear in mind they keep very, very strict control of the internet in China. I always find it fascinating that TikTok, their favorite video app, is banned in China. They don't let the Chinese people use that. Uh, but they love exporting it to the rest of the world where they can control our algorithms and what we see. But I think this is really going to wind up being a negative model as we look forward.

SPEAKER_00But how do they have so much money to fund to fund those um bad industries? If like if they are like um centrally controlled, so they should be um spending too much money on things that don't really work. And uh capitalism or free markets economy usually funds things who does work. And the market is really the big test for what does work and what doesn't work. So how where do they have their money from?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, no, I mean they have the money because they they take most of it. Uh so they they have they have that kind of income. But look at the things they invest in. And one of one of the topics we've covered uh deeply at the Heritage Foundation is their attempt to dominate what renewable energy infrastructure. So think solar panels, wind turbines, that kind of thing. And they put a huge amount of money into it, subsidizing those products. So they put our businesses out of business, our our manufacturers.

SPEAKER_01And they did that very effectively. Uh and then particularly during the Biden administration, uh they the the US policy was well, we have to buy this stuff because it's cheaper than ours and we're gonna force a transition to renewables. It would have been a disaster for us, but it's wound up being a disaster for the Chinese because everyone stopped buying those things and they put so much uh investment into it. So I think that's where you're gonna see some cracks really emerge in that model.

SPEAKER_00Let's go to the Middle East. When you joined the National Security Council, what did you learn about the Middle East that you hadn't understood from the outside?

SPEAKER_01No, it was a real, really educational experience during the first Trump term because we went in, president assumed, and you know, those of us who worked for him assumed what we had been told for many, many years, which is that we had to reserve uh resolve the Palestinian issue before we could get to additional normalization deals between Israel and Arab neighbors. And, you know, everybody believed this to be true. And so we worked on it for over a year. We came up with what is actually a pretty good offer to the Palestinians, got Israeli buy-in, and the Palestinians refused to engage.

SPEAKER_01And at that point, the president said they don't get a veto anymore. You know, this is over. It's been going on since 1975, essentially. Uh, and you know, they just aren't serious. And so he redirected us to say, hey, you know, maybe the rest of the region is starting to feel this way too. And they said, you know what, we are. And so we did get to the Abraham Accords before there was a deal with the Palestinians. And, you know, I think that is the fact that those endure. And, you know, we've had the meeting in New York of the Abraham Accords company countries, just right around the United Nations meeting at the end at the end of last month, you know, that that means after October 7th, those cords were not destroyed.

SPEAKER_01They were not undermined by that horrible event. That's what they were trying, what they were trying to achieve, what Hamas was, and they failed. And as horrible as it was, and that the aftermath has been, and I wish to heaven it had never happened, but they failed. And that's really, really important. And so that was really a learning curve for me, you know, that what might be possible.

SPEAKER_00I think that the most um um interesting point that to make is that first let's um let's get the conflict between Israel and the Palestinians, and then all the other problems of the Middle East will solve just by solving this this issue. How come really rational people believe in such a weird assumption or argument?

SPEAKER_01I mean, uh that I can't tell you, because I mean I I now know it uh to be utterly untrue. And you know, I think it it was sort of construct after you know the early 70s when the Arab nations pretty collectively decided they didn't want to attack Israel anymore because it was expensive and painful and they lost. And so they sort of decided they weren't gonna do that, but then they created essentially this to kind of give them cover.

SPEAKER_01And it's it, you know, nobody told the Palestinians that they lost. I mean, it it by any conceivable metric, they have lost. And so, you know, there isn't a cause. The Arabs aren't going to come and wipe Israel off the map as a matter of so you know, figuring out how we express that truth to the Palestinians and say, look, you know, this is the best deal that's on offer. You may may as well take it and start building something. Until they get into that mindset, though, you know, I don't think we can force them to hate children more than they hate Israelis.

SPEAKER_01And so, you know, we're we're sort of stuck on that front. But fortunately, that doesn't mean we can't move ahead in other areas.

SPEAKER_00How would you understand the current situation between Israel, Iran, and the United States in the Persian Gulf?

SPEAKER_01Right. I mean, we're coming into what I would say is is going to be a very late stage in the conflict. Um, and it's been interesting to watch, obviously, the kind of dramatic collapse of the regime that might have been projected in the early days of the conflict. That didn't happen, but a whole bunch of other interesting things have. I mean, the two assumptions the Iranians had, which was that closing the Strait of Hormuz would be intolerable to us, and that President Trump would be forced to the negotiating table in the June-July timeframe because of the U.S.

SPEAKER_01midterms coming up in a couple of weeks. You know, both of those proved wrong. Uh, you know, the president did try to negotiate a good deal uh to end the conflict more or less in that timeframe. But when the Iranians just tried to string it out, he reversed that on them with the blockade, which has proved intolerable to them. And then, you know, when he couldn't get the deal he wanted over the summer, he pretty much said, okay, you know, how about this? I'm gonna wait you out and we're gonna start Operation Economic Outcast, which has been utterly devastating to them.

SPEAKER_01And, you know, after the midterms, you've got two more years of me, because we're not a parliamentary system. Even if the midterms go poorly for the president, he's not going anywhere for two years. And so they now are coming to the realization that, you know, it's it's six weeks and two years that they have to to at the very least that they have to get through, and that given what's happening to them economically, that simply may not be possible.

SPEAKER_00Do you think that the the fact that maybe Trump is waiting for the elections and that the American public doesn't really understand the foreign policy is something to criticize about democracy, that the people that don't really understand what uh professionals like uh like you understand?

SPEAKER_01No, I mean I would never criticize the American people for being focused on domestic issues. That's right and natural. And those are really what are driving this election. Uh and then I know it's it's it's kind of hard from the outside. You say, you know, aren't you concerned about the war in Ukraine, the conflict in in the Gulf? I mean, and yes, I mean the American people do have views on these things, but really what they're most concerned about are, you know, uh inflation, prices here at home, rule of law, you know, uh immigration, those are the things that really that really drive this election.

SPEAKER_01So I think, you know, certainly there are long memories of the very negative role Iran has played over the last 47 years. You know, a lot of American servicemen, you know, are were killed or wounded, particularly during the Iraq conflict by Iranian proxies. You know, they know Iran was uh ultimately behind October 7th. So nobody has any love lost for Iran. Uh, but you know, of course, they're cautious about foreign wars. Nobody likes war at the same time.

SPEAKER_01So, you know, I don't see it as a driver of the midterms, but I I wouldn't be critical of the American people for not being foreign policy experts.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, because because I I just came back from the United States uh a week ago. I was in uh LA for two weeks, and you know, people I I kind of like it. People are living their lives, they are not feel uh they don't feel threatened by anyone. Like they live in an empire, basically. Uh you have your own uh uh things to cope with, and you're uh str struggling with the economy and with prices and with uh stuff like that, with immigration.

SPEAKER_00But basically you know that what could happen to us in Israel couldn't happen to you. Like America is not going uh in the near future uh to be in a risk of uh devastation or collapsing. But if uh like our soldiers will hold their weapons for maybe 10 hours, I think it's the end of Israel. So maybe people in in the United States don't really understand how much foreign policy issues are uh affecting their lives.

SPEAKER_00But not in the immediate uh future, but in the long future.

SPEAKER_01Well, certainly we have a very different neighborhood uh than Israel, and that you know that's just a fact of geography. We do have our two oceans, our most proximate neighbors, Canada and Mexico, are very unlikely to invade us or at least to be successful should they make that that bad decision. Uh so yes, I mean that that is a reality of the United States. But at the same time, you know, Tamir, we just marked, as I had said, the anniversary of 9-11 when we were attacked domestically. We've had other terrorist attacks. And, you know, at the Heritage Foundation, we're very concerned about what may have been brought in during the Biden administration when we essentially had open borders.

SPEAKER_01And we know uh Iranian affiliates came in at that time, and we just saw, you know, the Air Dubai plot, the Fairfield plot potentially in the United Kingdom. And those were all other third-party nationals, UK uh citizens in in Great Britain, and then a potentially an Omani pilot on that that flight. So they tend to use other parties for these attacks, and we are vulnerable to that, and we have to pay attention to it.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, so let's move on to the fly Dubai flight from uh Dubai to Tel Aviv that was forced to land in Saudi Arabia after the um trying to crash the plane. So the Saudis refuse to allow an Israeli aircraft to come in and to bring the Israelis uh home. Does that incident tell us something broader than the Saudi attitude towards Israel? And why does uh uh Riyadh sometimes seem to expect Israel to accept Saudi terms almost as if Israel needs to normalization more than Saudi Arabia needs normalization?

SPEAKER_01I would I would be hesitant to read too much into this. I think that we're in a process. I think for starters, I mean, the the flight was using Saudi airspace to go to Israel. That would have, I mean, if I had told you that was happening 10 years ago, you'd have told me I was crazy. So, you know, that in and of itself is something when you know that I know there were concerns both in Jordan and Saudi Arabia about this, what the status of the plane, whether it was a hijacked plane, and you know, whether that would be a danger to their citizens. When it was established it wasn't, you know, the plane was allowed to land, the passengers were taken into a terminal.

SPEAKER_01There were those pictures of them, you know, getting food, getting care, what the whatever they needed, you know. And so I I think that what we're seeing is, you know, a gradual process towards what can be a very productive uh relationship for both. But you make a good point. That's not all on the Saudi side. I mean, they're they're good, they would get enormous benefits from normalization with Israel, uh, you know, that's commensurate with what Israel would get. So I think we should see it as a process and not see this as a step back.

SPEAKER_00I I I just feel like an Israeli right-winger that Israeli, like Israel foreign policy, like the classical foreign policy of Israel, and also Netanyahu's, is begging for peace or begging for normalization and not uh telling the other neighbors, you know, if you want to do business with us, if you wanna uh if you want us to help you with the intelligence or with uh uh uh our armed forces or with uh whatever we can bring to the area.

SPEAKER_00So come on, let's do it. And if not, you know, you can go to hell. This is my this is my approach. But like our neighbors are kind of Middle Easterns, so they're uh really um keeping their uh integrity and respect and honor. This is the things that are most important for them, not to beg anyone for anything, so they're uh winning uh negotiations.

SPEAKER_01Well, I tend to think actually your approach then is it's gonna be quite successful. And and what actually will I think move this along most effectively is showing, demonstrating how successful these relationships are. In UAE, Bahrain, Morocco, you all you have expanding trade over every quarter since the Abraham Accords were signed, even after October 7th. Uh Jared Kushner funded or founded rather the Abraham Accords Peace Institute after uh the first Trump term.

SPEAKER_01That incorporated into heritage. In April of 2025. So we have those analysts who continue to do that work, tracking the accords across the economic and security sectors. And folks can find that material on our website, heritage.org. But what they've demonstrated is every quarter, as I said, even after October 7th, those relationships expanded. So I do think you're going to see increasing interest in participating that just because the proof, you know, we've got proof of concept now.

SPEAKER_01And so so I think it will happen.

SPEAKER_00So let's move on to October 7th and the aftermath. Your book is called The Battle for the Jewish State, which um so why should an American who is neither Jewish nor Israeli see Israel struggle as his own concern?

SPEAKER_01Well, and in the subtitle of the book, thank you for mentioning it, is how Israel and America can win. And the whole point is that that this battle that started on October 7th, that's this fight uh for for the Jewish state is not confined to Israel because, you know, in the worldview of the terrorists, you're the little Satan, we're the big Satan, but we're both Satan. And so if we abandon Israel at this point to the terrorists, that doesn't mean they're not coming for us. And so we have to realize that those terrorists on October 7th, they didn't ask for anybody's passport.

SPEAKER_01They wanted to kill Americans as much as they wanted to kill Israelis. Uh, they just wanted to kill Jews. And so they didn't differentiate between us. And I think we need to turn that into our strength, that we don't, you know, we don't let any daylight between us uh as we confront the terrorists, and then we get much stronger.

SPEAKER_00So apparently not many people in the West uh understand what you just said. So I wanted to ask you what surprises you more? What happened in the Middle East or the reaction that you saw in the West after October 7th?

SPEAKER_01I would say they were in many ways equally shocking. I mean, obviously the attack that day, and as we tried to piece together what was happening, was was just fundamentally horrifying and awful. But then we had within days folks who seemed ready to go on our campuses in our most elite universities, Columbia, my alma mater, the University of Pennsylvania, Harvard, uh, just these immediate demonstrations. I wouldn't call them spontaneous for a moment because they seemed very well organized, well funded, well equipped, and they were very much on the side of Hamas.

SPEAKER_01I mean, that should be shocking to Americans. And maybe the most shocking thing is that what it didn't seem to be. You had a lot of people who were immediately sympathetic to Hamas. That doesn't happen by accident. That has happened because it's crept into our education system. Yes, our institutions of higher learning, but also our K-12. Uh, you know, those curricula in the public schools are increasingly pro-Palestinian, anti-Israel, and even anti-Semitic. And so that's something we're working very hard on as well.

SPEAKER_00So uh next week we are going to meet in Jerusalem in the Natcon uh conference in uh Jerusalem. Um, why does the national conservatism matter at this particular moment? And why, especially in Israel?

SPEAKER_01Well, I'm obviously very happy to be back in uh Israel next week. I was just there in September, so uh I appreciate everybody's hospitality. But what NatCon does is really try to bring together conservatives, and it's an opportunity to really explore what we consider to be fundamental American conservative principles. And I think that's one reason it's really important that the Heritage Foundation, which is our largest conservative think tank, you know, is very well represented and that we make common cause with Israelis who have similar principles.

SPEAKER_01You know, this really isn't so much about the US-Israel relationship in terms of the alliance. It's really more about the principles we have found beneficial. And we're going to have a number of European conservatives as well. We're seeing some very interesting trends towards uh towards more conservative governments in Europe. We think that's a good idea. But as the title of my speech uh indicates, you know, we want to also be very clear that the creeping anti-Semitism, it's not creeping on the left, it's an article of faith for them, but we do have an issue with it on the right, that that's something we're going to get after because it has no place in true conservative values.

SPEAKER_00So uh to summary, I'll ask you a final question. Tell me from now, what uh would have to change what would have to change in America, in Israel, and in the relationship between them for you to say we won the battle.

SPEAKER_01Well, what I want to see is the United States and Israel develop a mature relationship that what we've seen up until now, over the roughly 80 years of modern Israel, you know, is Israel growing into itself, if you will. But you know, what had been a very tiny, beleaguered country is now one of the top 20 uh economies in the world, certainly one of the most powerful uh militaries, the most powerful in the Middle East, and a global power in that, and a global power in high technology.

SPEAKER_01And so, you know, what we've advocated for from heritage is, for example, you know, the phasing out of the security support for Israel, but not ending the security relationship. That's what's critically important. We want it to move into its next phase. So those that money would go from being foreign military financing to foreign military sales, would invest robustly in joint programs that have been so successful, particularly in missile defense. And, you know, Israel, as it has economically, will militarily develop into a great friend and partner uh to the United States, but an independent one.

SPEAKER_01And I think that that would be what I would define as success, and you know, the that the enemies of that kind of partnership and success, you know, have failed. And that October 7th, as awful as it was, didn't work.

SPEAKER_00So I'll I'll say amen about that. Um few months before um Charlie Kirk was murdered, he was sitting with his students and trying to clarify with them what's the hardest point uh for them, for conservative students in America who are part of uh Turning Point USA. What's the hardest point for them to defend about Israel? And they all said that the foreign aid that you give us, as if we are like uh some uh nation from I don't know, af uh southern uh Africa or something like that.

SPEAKER_00So this is the hardest uh point for them to defend about Israel. And I really uh beg you stop giving us money uh as an Israeli, as a proud Israeli, and we don't really need it. We are a successful uh high-tech uh uh nation, and we uh will be better off um helping others than you helping us.

SPEAKER_01No, I agree, and that's we it's in our Israel report from uh 2025, it's been translated into Hebrew, and from my perspective, it as a policy matter, it's the right thing to do, and it has that secondary beneficial effect, as you said. It removes an irritant that we don't need, it's not necessary. So I think it's going to be best for both of us going forward to phase that out.

SPEAKER_00Dr. Victoria Coates, thank you very much for your time.

SPEAKER_01It's a great pleasure. See you next week.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. על הכותרות | איש הימין הקיצוני בעד ממשלת אחדות?

    Nov 20, 202635 minAudio

    תמיר דורטל, "איש הימין הקיצוני", בעד ממשלת אחדות - וטל קופל, "איש הימין העוד יותר קיצוני", מתחלחל ממנה. ב"על הכותרות" השבוע: למה טל חושב שאחדות רק תעשה "קונסולידציה ליוריסטוקרטיה", הממצאים מהקלפיות בחברה הערבית, ו"אתה...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. #1066 ד"ר עינת רמון | "אנחנו לא יכולים להרשות לעצמנו שיהיה פה נישואים אזרחיים" - למה נאבד את הרוב היהודי?

    Nov 19, 202656 minAudio

    בפרק זה של הפודקאסט עו"ד תמיר דורטל מארח את ד"ר עינת רמון, חוקרת הגות ציונית ומדעי היהדות, מכשירת מלווים רוחניים ולשעבר רבה קונסרבטיבית, לשיחה על הפמיניזם הדתי: מה הוא נתן לבית היהודי, ולמה הוא מתקשה לשים גבול. תמיר...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. #1065 הרב נריה נווה | "כבוד הרב, אל תמכור לנו את ערכי המערב" - ביקורת על "בדרך האבות" של הרב בני לאו

    Nov 18, 20261 hr 6 minAudio

    בפרק זה של הפודקאסט עו"ד תמיר דורטל מארח את הרב נריה נווה, שהגיב בביקורת על "בדרך האבות", הספר החדש של הרב בני לאו על חוויותיו ביהודה ושומרון. הרב נווה אינו מבקש לתקוף את הרב לאו אישית, אלא להצביע על תפיסה רחבה יותר,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. #1064 ד"ר מלכהלי בלוי חנוכה | "צריך 1,800 נשים בשביל להתחיל להניע שינוי" - מי משפרק את החברה החרדית?

    Nov 17, 202651 minAudio

    בפרק זה של הפודקאסט עו"ד תמיר דורטל מארח את ד"ר מלכהלי בלוי חנוכה, מנהלת השדולה למען האישה החרדית והדתית בכנסת ודוקטור לסוציולוגיה ואנתרופולוגיה, לשיחה על הדרך שבה רעיונות פרוגרסיביים חודרים אל החברה החרדית - דרך הנשים....

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. #1063 ספי גלדצהלר | "בלילה אחד הפכתי מיהודי לעברי" - מי היה מניטו?

    Nov 16, 20261 hr 10 minAudio

    בפרק זה של הפודקאסט "על המשמעות" עו"ד תמיר דורטל מארח את ספי גלדצהלר, ראש בית המדרש "הרוח הגדולה" ועורך הספר "מהפכת העבריות - מניטו ללא פילטרים", לשיחה על הרב יהודא ליאון אשכנזי - מניטו: הוגה, מקובל ואנתרופולוג שנולד...

    Credit the people on this episode