Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

She Persisted

She Persisted artwork

196. EXPOSING the Troubled Teen Industry: How it Scams Parents & Harms Teens feat. Maia Szalavitz

Jul 22, 202455 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

#196 Today's guest is Maia Szalavitz - an award-winning author and journalist. She first advocated against the Troubled Teen Industry in her 2006 book, Help at Any Cost, and has since written several New York Times articles and appeared in the 2024 Netflix documentary, The Program, to discuss this dangerous industry further. In this episode, we discuss: + The history of the troubled-teen industry & what it looks like today + What proper mental health care for teenagers should look like + Why teens with substance abuse or behavioral issues can't succeed in troubled teen programs + My personal troubled-teen industry experience + The real reasons why parents are sending their kids away to treatment programs + The dangerous accountability model behind many troubled teen programs + The unethical ways that troubled-teen programs earn massive profits + The trauma that troubled teen survivors face due to these programs + Regulations that could eliminate these programs for good MENTIONED + The Program + Help at Any Cost + New York Times article + Trails Carolina article + Maia's Website + Unsilenced SHOP GUEST RECOMMENDATIONS: https://amzn.to/3A69GOC STARBUCKS GIFTCARD GIVEAWAY: Want coffee on me?! Each month I'll be randomly choosing a winner to receive a Starbucks giftcard! To enter this giveaway, all you have to do is leave a review of the podcast on Spotify and/or Apple Podcasts and DM me on a screenshot of your review on Instagram. Win bonus entries by tagging the podcast on your Instagram story or TikTok! Good luck! LET'S CONNECT + Instagram (@shepersistedpodcast) + Website (shepersistedpodcast.com) + YouTube (Sadie Sutton: She Persisted Podcast) + Twitter (@persistpodcast) + Facebook (@shepersistedpodcast) + TikTok (@shepersistedpodcast) + inquiries@shepersistedpodcast.com © 2020 She Persisted LLC. This podcast is copyrighted subject matter owned by She Persisted LLC and She Persisted LLC reserves all rights in and to the podcast. Any use without She Persisted LLC’s express prior written consent is prohibited.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Welcome to She Persisted. I'm your host, Sadie Sutton, a 19-year-old from the Bay Area studying psychology at the University of Pennsylvania. She Persisted is the teen mental health podcast made for teenagers by a teen. In each episode, I'll bring you authentic, accessible, and relatable conversations about every aspect of mental wellness. You can expect evidence-based teen-approved resources, coping skills, including lots of DBT, insights, and education in each piece of content you consume. She Persisted offers you a safe space to feel validated and understood in your struggle, while encouraging you to take ownership of your journey and build your life worth living. So let's dive in. This week on She Persisted.

One of the things that is absolutely horrific is that people who come out of these places almost never want to seek any mental health care again in their life. And they truly may need it because now they probably have PTSD on top of whatever they had before. So that's one very bad outcome. Another is that they are estranged from their family because oftentimes the family has been told to expect reports of abuse and not believe them. Hello, hello, you guys. Welcome to a really exciting episode of She Persisted. We have a really incredible guest today, and this is part one of a three-part series where we are talking about the troubled teen industry. This is not the first time that we've touched on this on the podcast. I will link the past episodes we've done that kind of dive into this area and industry. I've had peers on that were in the troubled teen industry with me. I've had on

a few experts that are really working in the advocacy area. And then I'll also link an episode with Dr. Justin Mohat, where we talk about evidence-based treatment programs and how to find an ethical, compassionate, and effective treatment program that is not in the troubled teen industry. So you're probably like, that's a lot of conversations. Three more episodes after that is also a lot of time. We're investing in this topic, and it's one that's really important to me because I was in the troubled teen industry for 14 months as part of my treatment journey. And it's something that I've been doing a lot of work to process and come to terms with and cope with since I've started the podcast. I actually started the podcast while I was still in the troubled teen industry the last month that I was in that program.

And you're probably like, if you were in the troubled teen industry, you weren't able to actually start a podcast. And I can do a solo episode about my experience and I can dive into all the funny parts of that, like getting the website blocked and all the things. But yes, I was at a therapeutic boarding school in Montana called Chrysalis. We talk about that and a little bit about my experience in this episode and this conversation with Maya. But there's going to be a solo episode coming up where we talk all about my experience and I give you guys kind of a rundown. What it was like being in the troubled teen industry, what it was like to then leave that industry. And they call it kind of like waking up and becoming more aware of what I had been told about some of those experiences and what was accurate and what wasn't.

what is actually necessary for treatment and what was just a lie, like having to have custody signed over. So we're going to get into that in a future solo episode and you'll get to hear all about my experience at Chrysalis and also what I've done after the fact to kind of try and heal from that and cope with the emotions that arise because it is a really big, experience to navigate, but I'm really excited for this episode to come out this week, and I waited and chose this week for a couple of reasons. One is that Maya interviewed me for a New York Times op-ed about the troubled teen industry, which was such a huge, crazy, exciting moment, and that will of course be linked in the show notes, but...

It was just really incredible to be able to share a little bit of my experience. And she paired it so beautifully with a really interesting case study in New Jersey of different ways that we can get teens help without feeding into this industry. And it was just such an incredible, full circle, really exciting moment. And so that is one of the reasons why this episode is coming out this week, because we recorded it a long time ago. The other reason is that we have a second interview as part of this series with Katherine Kupler, who, She is the director of the program, which you probably saw on your Netflix homepage at some point because it was in the top Netflix shows when it came out. And this is just such an incredible documentary. I talked about it on Instagram, but she did such a beautiful job describing the industry, really making it accessible and easy to understand for people that aren't familiar with the Trouble Teen industry because it's the craziest network of

people and programs and she just did a really incredible job distilling that into a really powerful and moving show but she also spoke to the survivor experience and what it's like to fully go through a program and put your head down and comply to get out and what it's like to leave and not ever had that experience in the program where you're like this isn't right and this is wrong and I'm going to push back on it. But like that fight or flight survival mode is to just do what you're told and put your head down. And so what it's like after the fact to be like, wow, all these things that I thought I believed and thought were right were actually really unethical and really not okay. And I wasn't listened to when I tried to speak about that experience.

and so i'm really excited for that conversation we're recording this next week and so you guys are going to have really incredible people on she persisted one is maya salvitz she is this week's episode i'll give you her bio in a second she is an expert in almost any troubled teen documentary you'll see she's just done so much incredible journalistic work and her book is incredible we talked about in this episode And then Catherine, who you also hear us mention in this episode, is obviously the director of the program, which has been one of the biggest, if not the biggest, troubled teen documentaries to date. And it really touched a lot of survivors. It went super viral on TikTok, and it was really a very healing experience for me to watch that. So thank you.

If you're curious about the troubled teen industry or you're a survivor yourself, definitely watch that documentary. It's on Netflix. It's called The Program. And then you get me. You're stuck with me again. We're going to do a solo episode and talk about my experiences. This is going to be the first time that I've ever really dedicated an in-depth episode just talking about my whole experience and my emotions and feelings about these things. I've done a couple of interviews on other shows where I've touched on it or thrown in Q&As like what I think about therapeutic boarding schools or... waded in conversations, but I've never done like a full breakdown, deep dive solo. So you're going to get that from me. And then we're back to normal programming. And of course, you guys are going to get Monday minis, which are just normal episodes, not all about the troubled teen industry. But I really hope you guys enjoy this series because it's a cause that's

really really important to me and as you'll hear Maya and I talk about there's 5,000 programs in the United States 120,000 teens and they're at any given time and it's a multi-billion dollar industry so this is not just one program this is not a handful of teens it's extremely widespread and we also talk about this over 350 children have died in these programs and so it's really no joke it's a really important cause and what's so important sad about this is these are teens that they just need help. They need support and they've done that brave thing in a lot of scenarios of asking for help where their parents are doing anything to try and get them support and they're just completely taken advantage of. And so it's a really, really sad situation that could be so easily solved with more regulation.

And Maya has a really interesting idea of how we can get to that point, which you'll hear in this conversation. And then the last thing I'll mention before I introduce Maya is that unsilenced.org is a nonprofit that is really at the forefront of all of this advocacy work. And bringing regulations to these programs, helping different survivors navigate lawsuits, helping connect survivors with others that have been at their programs. If you want to learn more about this industry or get involved, whether it's reading about different survivors' experiences or understanding survivors' experiences. which different members of congress are pushing for regulation in the industry unsilenced.org is a great place to start and meg applegate is the founder of unsilenced and she's also a survivor of chrysalis and so she is just absolutely incredible and doing incredible work at unsilenced and meg will come on the podcast we want to film in person so someday somehow it's going to happen so unsilenced.org for more resources and information and then maya salvitz is on the podcast this week

She is a neuroscience journalist and she covers drugs, addiction, and public policy. She has a number of books out, but the one about the troubled teen industry is called Help at Any Cost, and that will be linked in the show notes. She is both a New York Times bestselling author and a contributing opinion writer for the New York Times, which you can read the article where she interviewed me linked in the show notes. She's also written for numerous publications, including Time, Wired, Elle, The Nation, and Scientific American. And her 2006 book, Help at Any Cost, which I just mentioned, was the first to expose the damage caused by Tough Love Youth Treatment and help spur congressional hearings. She is.

absolutely incredible i loved this conversation so much and like i said she is truly one of the if not the most prominent experts in the community that is working to bring awareness and regulation to the troubled teen industry so it was just such an honor to have her on the podcast and i know you guys are going to learn so so much from this conversation so let's dive in and survivors i know this is a heavy episode so if anything comes up you have any thoughts you want to share your opinions after listening, please don't hesitate to send me an email or a DM. All the information is in the show notes. So, longest intro ever, but let's dive in. Well, to get things started, for people who haven't watched the program or haven't read your book about the troubled teen industry, can you give a little bit of context and background into your career and how you became such a voice for this cause and this research? Yeah.

Sure. So the troubled teen industry is this sort of collection of boot camps, wilderness programs, therapeutic or emotional growth, boarding schools, behavior modification programs, residential facilities, wilderness centers, all of this kind of stuff. And the commonality in the troubled teen industry is that the facilities are residential in that they are away from where the teenager lives and the abuse is the treatment. The idea is that we will break you down in order to fix you and that this is a perfectly appropriate goal to deal with everything from rebellion to autism.

In reality, troubled teen is not a diagnosis and breaking people down creates PTSD more reliably than it does help anybody. Yeah. It is still so surprising to me that more people aren't aware of the troubled teen industry because we see the numbers. We know how many kids have gone through these programs and yet it's not something that's commonly understood. So for people that are like, okay, maybe I've heard of a program, maybe I've seen this on TikTok – Can you give some context to this industry? It has a very interesting history with regard to how it came to be and kind of just explaining how this popped up because we obviously have evidence-based mental health treatments. We're moving in a great direction as a field, but we still have a huge number of programs that are really on the other side of things. So can you kind of explain for people that are like, I don't know how we came to be here. I'm not familiar with this. What people should know.

Sure. So we do not have the equivalent of an FDA for behavioral health. So if I want to start my is kicking your butt treatment for addiction or ADHD or whatever, I can do that. And I don't have to prove that kicking your butt is a successful therapy. Yeah. And so this is basically how we ended up in this mess. We really don't have a mental health care system for teenagers. We know that there are evidence-based approaches that can be effective, but they are really, really difficult to find.

And over the years, through the whole drug war, we've developed this kind of alternative, punitive approach that often centers on drugs, but then gets expanded to, oh, we can use this to make gay kids straight, or, oh, we can use this for depression, which, again, not true. But this industry has sort of capitalized on the fact that they're really... isn't any way for parents to know what good treatment is for addiction, for drug use, for all of these things that parents might be worried about. It's just a wild west out there. And so we really need to regulate these facilities. And if we did, most of them wouldn't exist because they do not provide evidence-based care for teenagers or anybody.

Yeah. You mentioned initially that abuse really runs rampant in these programs, and we see that it's not always as horrific as it has been at times. Conversion camps aren't as prevalent. Some of the early programs have gotten shut down, but there are still so many programs. And today, an article just came out confirming the death of a kid at Trails Carolina. And so, The fundamental problem is that we don't have a good mental health care system. We don't have a good addiction or drug problem treatment system. We just don't have good care for teenagers. And into the void steps this business, which claims that by abusing your child, we can fix them.

And it's really important to emphasize that in these places, the abuse is the treatment. Because historically, people have claimed that, oh, you know, it's a few bad apples or, oh, you know, these kids are just whining and complaining or, oh, they don't want to do the tough work of therapy or any of this stuff. But the tactics that are used in what I call the troubled teen industry are. are by their nature abusive, keeping people out of contact with the outside world. Food deprivation, sleep deprivation, very rigid schedules, rules that are so complex that nobody can avoid breaking them. Incredible punishments that are way out of line for whatever the behavior is.

A lot of use of restraint and isolation and attack therapy where the idea is to tell you you're a bad person and tell you horrible things about yourself. And this is supposed to be honesty. And the participants are taught that being honest is saying bad things about other people and that this is good and healthy. And that if you want to help your friend, you should tell them, yes, you look fat in that. or whatever kind of thing that you think would be the most inappropriate, basically. And so it's really about using shame to create conformity. And so there are residential facilities for youth that do not do this, but it is very difficult to tell which ones those are,

Because these ideas are so prevalent and because there is no requirement to not do this stuff and because the staff is often very poorly educated. Because if you were to actually provide evidence-based care, you would have to employ much more trained people and you would not be able to make a profit. Yeah. What do you look for? Like if you were a parent at this point and you were looking for a program, what questions would you be asking? What red flags? I would not be looking for a program because the reality is that for every single mental health condition and for addictions, the best way to treat people is generally at home.

And again, there are some exceptions, some severe addictions, cases where a child has been through multiple foster homes and has extreme PTSD and is a danger to themselves or others. But short of that... The idea that sending your child away to fix them is the way to deal with teen mental health problems is just false. Essentially, what we know about what works best across the spectrum for a lot of different conditions is family therapy. And that's with the kid at home. It may need to include family.

antidepressants, for example, if the kid has depression, or specific trauma treatments, if that is an issue for the child, or specific things for ADHD, or specific things for being on the autism spectrum, whatever the thing is, there are specific things that can be done to help that child cope better. But what's typically going on when a kid is sent to these places is that their parents are getting divorced and they are acting out. And I sort of have this joke that if you're getting divorced and your kid is acting out, you should go to boot camp, which, of course, they don't like. The reality is that kids are very, very sensitive to what's going on within the family.

And a lot of time, what's going wrong between a child and their parents has to do with the fact that adolescence is difficult. Parents don't want to let go of control. The kids are hormonal or whatever. And they need new ways of communicating. And family therapy often helps with that. Now, when kids are using drugs, there are some complexities here. But the reality is that the vast majority of kids who take drugs do not get addicted. And although they may do scary things, the vast majority of them, so long as they stay alive, are going to be fine.

Now, this doesn't mean that teenagers can't have addictions or that we shouldn't worry if there are severe signs of problems. But the idea that, oh, my God, my kid's smoking pot. I want to protect them from moving on to fentanyl, so I'll send them to a place. That actually is more likely to result in harm because when you send a child from their home environment where very few people are doing these sorts of things and concentrate them in a situation where most of the kids have some kind of problem.

you will end up introducing the pot smokers to the kids who are doing the more serious drugs. And then you will make the problem worse because now they know where to get them. Also, in these places, they sort of tend to tell the child, OK, you have the disease of addiction and you're going to have it for the rest of your life. So therefore, you must be abstinent from everything forever. And they're like, and I didn't even get to try the good stuff. You know, it creates a backfiring sort of effect. If your kid is smoking pot and drinking to the point where, you know, they're passing out or they are just stoned all the time and not doing anything, that's a problem. What you want to do to work on that is help them within their own environment to realize for themselves why this is a problem.

And this is much more effective with individual counseling because that way you're not exposing them to more troubled peers. And you are also giving them the opportunity to work out for themselves what's going on. Because oftentimes when teenagers are using drugs and almost always when teenagers have severe problems, mental health and trauma are involved. So, for example, a kid who is, you know, getting plastered every day. There's a reason for that. It's not just because alcohol hijacked their brain.

It's because they are depressed. They can't fit in socially. They just lost a parent. They are extremely anxious. They are trying to achieve something with this drug use. It may not look rational from the outside, but you have to understand it from the inside if you're going to be able to intervene successfully. And I mean, if kids have gotten to the point where they are doing extreme behaviors around drugs, they have got to the point where that has become a habitual behavior. And when that happens, it is hard to change.

If you just think about something like trying to change your exercising or your eating, like nobody does it perfectly overnight. Everybody misses a workout. Everybody eats the donut. It is hard to change habitual behavior problems, especially when you are using that behavior to cope. And if you don't have alternative ways of coping, you're not going to solve that problem. And so you have to recognize that this will not change overnight and that kids are going to do dumb stuff. So what we want to do is minimize the harm that they're exposed to when they're doing the inevitable dumb things that kids are going to do. And I think when you look at a lot of our attempts at prevention, like they scare the heck out of parents.

But the kids are often like, oh, that sounds interesting. It's just like the teenage brain works differently. And this is a good thing because you have an extraordinary capacity to learn and to innovate and to move society forward. That, you know, once your brain is sort of like, I have this brain that is now very highly tailored to my expertise on addiction. It's not so good at math. If I were still a teenager, I might be able to, and perhaps with laborious effort at this point, I might be able to get really good at math. But there's reason that the adolescent brain is the way it is. And we shouldn't just demonize it. We shouldn't just see this as like kids are dumb. You know, it's like I say it jokingly, they're going to do dumb things because when you look at it from a mature perspective, some of those risks are insane.

And when I think of some of the risks I myself took, I'm like, oh, my God, how could you have done that? Like, you could have died. But, you know, my brain is a lot more mature now. And I thankfully survived some really rough stuff. And I think what we need to do in order to really help teens that are acting out or misbehaving or just struggling is with empathy and compassion and evidence. figure out what's going on, and work with them where they are. If you do that, first of all, you're not going to do harm. And second of all, you will most likely be able to significantly help.

Yeah. So many things. I loved what you said. Like, mental health challenges don't happen in a vacuum. Treatment can't either. I think that's a message that should be intuitive, and for some reason, it's not. I think about my own experience of going to treatment, and it's like you were saying, the extreme outlier, where I was locally hospitalized four times in a year. I did outpatient twice. I did the PHP's twice. I did outpatient DBT two times. We did family therapy, in-group, all the things. Like, harm to myself. All those things where it's like there was no other option and we were working with the best of the best and getting as much support as possible. And some of these behaviors are so hard to change, like you're saying, especially when you only have those coping mechanisms and you're not in a position where you've learned other ways of tolerating distress. And I was really lucky with one program, Three East at McLean. They do evidence-based, compassionate work with the

My parents flew every week to do the parent groups. We visited every weekend, called them every day, like all the things where it's family's very involved, but I was able to be in a different environment where it was like I'd been so conditioned with how I coped and responded to things at home that having that less stressful environment for a very short period of time, I was there way longer than most people. It was 14 weeks. Most people were four to six. And then it's the next step. And this is where it's like, You want your kid to succeed. And McLean doesn't have long-term programs because they know the evidence doesn't support that. And it's like the next step isn't clear. And then you get into this really challenging situation. And it was really interesting being in the troubled teen industry because I was such a rarity. Everyone else I knew came from wilderness. A couple came from home. Yeah.

And it's like you're saying the things that I was exposed to were wild. I have never done drugs. I never drank before I went to treatment. I was just a really sad, depressed kid and didn't know how to validate my own emotions and ask for help and be vulnerable and so much shame and all the things. And then... you're surrounded by all these other mental health challenges. And that was one of the reasons why I started the podcast, because it's like, if you're a teen that's doing well, no one's talking about how they're maintaining their mental well-being. But if you're struggling, you are in a vacuum of other people that are struggling, and it's all feeding off each other. And there's no other teen being like, it gets better, I've done this. There's adults, but of course as a teen, you're like...

you don't get it. It's not the same thing. And so that was a big goal for the podcast because that is such a challenging dynamic, especially when you're in those treatment environments. But yes, I loved so much of what you said. I am wondering if you have any theories about where this desire and messaging and urge comes from with parents to either send kids away or for us to like treat normal teenage behaviors, because this is, I assume a newer phenomenon. This wasn't happening hundreds of years ago. But like, what is it their discomfort? Is it like, we didn't do this? Yeah. Yeah, I think there's a number of things going on. One of them is the rise of economic inequality, which means that people in the middle class are completely panicked that their kids are going to fall out of the middle class.

And so this just strikes fear into the hearts of parents. You know, we want you to go to a good school, blah, blah, blah, because the economy is seriously scary and we have created no safety net. So part of it is that. Another part of it is just that because parents feel like they might have caused the problem, They have a lot of shame. And so, like, if your kid has cancer, you call your aunt at Sloan Kettering and you do all the stuff that is going to help you find the best care. With this, you're searching the Internet in the middle of the night. And, like, this is why parents, you know, get these con people, basically. The other part of it is that psychiatric medication is complex.

And a lot of parents are like, I don't want to drug my kid, which is obviously understandable. And you should obviously not use drugs unless you have to. And so there's a lot of fear around that. And these places tend to like prey on that because they're like, well, we're not going to label your kid. We're not going to drug your kid. So what ends up happening is that this whole sort of alternative thing. sells itself to parents. Now, the uglier thing that goes on is that America worships youth, and parents are sort of pushed to be, like, jealous. Their kids are young and hot and enjoying everything, and we're not anymore, you know, we're cranky. And this becomes a battle over control, and there is this desire to punish that is unconscious that sort of filters into this.

And so that jealousy, which of course you are not allowed to acknowledge, really kind of poisons some of this stuff and poisons relationships in some ways and makes the generation gap sort of worse. And so I think that is also a part of it. So you've got all that in with this very toxic individualistic ideology, because what these programs are teaching you is that everything that happens to you is your fault. Everything you chose to do that you chose your parents, some of them even argue, or you chose to be raped is absolutely crazy and wrong. But what it does is it absolves the perpetrators because you chose to be abused and it means that everything that goes wrong is your fault. So yeah.

It's like if you get you need to take accountability. Exactly. And it's like, no, that is wrong. That is the complete opposite of what most trauma survivors need, especially when you're talking about sexual abuse. I mean, I have talked to people who, you know, and unfortunately, this is like a sort of bad offshoot of 12 step programs. But unfortunately, in the AA Big Book. There's this whole thing about taking accountability for your actions and like looking at what was my part in sort of all the things that are on your moral inventory. And oftentimes that moral inventory is just kind of a life story. And so they're like, what are your resentments? Well, I resent my parent for raping me. Okay, what was your part in that? No, no.

Oh, no. And this is because it was, like, written by rich white men who their resentments were somebody was a jerk to me or I didn't make enough money rather than I was actually a victim. But applying that to teenagers is really crazy because so many times, you know, I mean, yeah, like... Everybody can be a little jerk sometimes, but most of what's going on is not the child's fault. And they should not be accountable for it. They shouldn't be making amends to their parents. Their parents should be making amends to them often. So it just becomes very toxic.

And that ideology is itself abusive. And it is sort of this real exaggeration of this American idea that we're all responsible for our own fate in every possible way. And economic conditions don't matter if you work hard enough. And you know what? That is not true. Obviously, working hard can definitely benefit you, but there's lots of other ways things can go wrong. And there's lots of ways where you are not empowered to make a difference. You get lucky and not acknowledging that.

The role of luck and the role of just chance in where we end up means that we blame poor people for being poor and praise rich people for being rich when, in fact, that's not about virtue. Yeah. The accountability letter is such an insane experience. And everyone I spoke to who went to wilderness did one. It was also the first thing, like the very first phase where you get off orientation and safety at the boarding school and you write this accountability letter, you have to read it to your parents. And I remember like,

taking accountability for being depressed and anxious. And it's just such a strange experience to look back on. And it's like you're saying that the shame that it induces and also now as a psychology student, when you think about how we attribute our experiences and challenges, it's most effective to say these were external circumstances, they were specific to this situation, and this is temporary. And the troubled teen does the complete opposite. They say this is internal, this is on you, it is global, it will apply to every situation, and it's going to last forever. And so even when you just think about the mental consequences of teaching people to think like that... You're teaching people to catastrophizing. The health outcomes are bad, the mental...

everything becomes a disaster. It's insane to think about. Yeah. And it's so divorced from everything we know about what works out. Like, you know, with people with depression, what do they need most of all? Love, connection, support, community. Validation. Yeah. And sometimes antidepressant. Yeah. Because I think what's important to know is that like sometimes you're in that state for a chemical reason and it's not anything you did or whatever. You have a gene or your gene was triggered by some kind of trauma or whatever it is. The bottom line is without chemicals, you're not going to get out of that state.

And, you know, we don't like that to be true. We think that you should be able to do everything with therapy or whatever. But the reality is like having personally experienced depression and having personally experienced just sort of being neurodiverse in a strange way without antidepressants. I am a person who is so vulnerable. vulnerable to the environment that I don't function well and that I think everybody hates me and I do all these things just to feel okay and thankfully I can get that chemical support from you know Prozac and Welbutrin and not heroin but when I have not taken medication I have had an

any less moral than somebody who conquers their depression via cognitive behavioral therapy. The outcomes show that CBT alone and medication alone aren't as effective as doing both together. And yes, we're overprescribed as far as Gen Z, but for severe depression, the evidence shows that it works and it works well, especially when combined with talk therapy. I would love to talk a little bit about the economics. because this is one of the most mind-blowing things. And also objectively, people can be like, that's crazy, why aren't we talking about this? These programs are so expensive. And like you mentioned, they have a really low bar for hiring people, which is how they are able to turn a profit. Can you kind of speak to how this works, that they're charging so much, but they pay staff so little, the living conditions are so horrible. Can you kind of just explain that side of things? I mean, yes, sure.

One of the great virtues of using abuse and neglect as treatment is that they are cheap to do. In the wilderness, you don't even need a facility. All you need to do is hire a few guys off the street, send them into the woods. You don't need to pay for food because, you know, the kids can eat lizards. I mean, literally in Utah, they have in their regulations a certain number of calories that are required for kids to be given when they're in the wilderness. And if you don't know that you have to feed the kids, I think you shouldn't be in the business of dealing with kids. You know what I mean? Like, it's not okay. I certainly get that if somebody voluntarily wants to go into the wilderness and, you know, conquer mountains. Have so much fun. Go for it.

But you should make that decision. Right. You should be doing that as a challenge. And this is the way our stress system works. Like if you are sort of challenging yourself and doing a thing that you chose to do, the stress is so much different than if you were forced and powerless and under somebody else's control. And so anyway, yeah, so it is really cheap. You just hire people at minimum wage. You don't require any training except you get them to train each other. You get the bare minimum facility. because the bad conditions are a selling point because it's helpful to harm people and to make them live in deprivation. Like a sleeping bag and a tarp. No structure. Just sleeping bag and a tarp will be fine. Yeah, it's just crazy. And so some places you build your own backpack, you whittle your own spoon, like no expenses here.

Yeah, no. And even the places that do have facilities, they make them as bare bones as possible and they put multiple kids in the same room on very cheap food. Maybe there's a psychiatrist on call. Maybe. But, you know, most of the staff doesn't even have to have a high school education. And yet they charge as if they're running hospitals. Yeah. Out of pocket. Yeah. And I mean, this goes back to the addictions field where the model of, you know, the 28 day inpatient rehab, that was a hospital model. And so like you could charge thousands of dollars a day.

Because it's a hospital. It's expensive to run. But the actual care that people were getting were sitting in 12-step meetings and being given lectures about, you know, this is the only way to recover. And 12-step meetings are free. You know, the lectures are free. You can just run the thing on the computer or TV. And you're not being seen by doctors every day. You are being charged as if you were being seen by doctors every day. You are being charged as if you're getting therapy from a licensed person every day. Maybe you would get therapy from a licensed person in a group once a week. And it's the same kind of model. It just focuses on the bottom line.

Yeah. No, you have to think about, like, I was hospitalized in an actual hospital, and there's five to six nurses at any time for maybe 15 kids. The psychiatrist multiple come through every night. You're meeting with them. A social worker is meeting with you every day. Therapists are running three to four groups a day. You're being checked on every 15 minutes. You're being given medications. security guards are walking. It's expensive because you have so many people that are very qualified to do this and doing it from an evidence-based perspective and even just from a legally, like, ethically perspective where they're checking all their boxes and doing all the things they need to do. The troubled teen industry, we saw a psychiatrist maybe once a month. He came in from a local town, spoke to people for five minutes, and that was the entirety of the medical thing. One of the therapists was a life coach. Like, it's absolutely...

Unreal. So your parents sent you to this place after you'd experienced the evidence-based treatment? Yeah, because there wasn't really a clear next step and I'd struggled so much at home. And so they were aware that I could continue my school kind of side of things at a therapeutic boarding school while also getting support. They did the tours. They asked all the questions. They definitely saw some where they were like, she's not going there. And this one is like the best of the worst because no one's died. They hadn't been sued until recently. And... What's it? Chrysalis. Okay, yes. It's in Eureka. And it was started by people that used to work at Montana Academy. Yeah, crazy. But yeah, and so...

Were you allowed to talk to your parents without supervision there? Nope. It was you would earn the privilege of a five minute supervised social call once a week after about three months. Prior to that, you would only talk to them in family therapy. And my parents are very like on things. So sometimes they would be talking to therapists being like, what is happening? What's the plan for the entire session? So I wouldn't get to speak to them. you could write letters that were read and faxed by staff that had no business reading what you were doing and what was happening and so no it was absolutely a privilege that was controlled and absolutely something that was supervised and censored and yeah i think like not have a child abuse hotline in in their houses they publicly were like kids will just say things to get out of treatment which is not what the research shows

And also like my feeling on that is if a kid is so unhappy that they're saying stuff to get out of treatment, your treatment ain't working. Yeah, yeah. I remember being at McLean and being like, I don't want to be here, but I know this is what I need to do to get like I was very much like this is hard and I wish I was at home. But it wasn't crossing my mind to say these things because it was working. And even though it was hard and a lot of work and emotional and challenging, it was something that was necessary because I had hit rock bottom with being so depressed and anxious and ineffective with all the coping skills.

Yeah, no, and I mean, what's just so terrible about it is you would probably have been fine at home. But the other thing is like one of the things I say if people ask me, oh, well, how do you find a good place? Can your kid talk to you with no supervision from the day one? Yeah. And I don't think any of the bad places allow that. Yeah. And the other thing that I think would be essential in order to fix the situation would be to require an absolutely independent evaluation of the child. before they can be sent to any facility. And this person cannot have any affiliation with any residential, anything. And they need to be able to evaluate the child, evaluate the family, and really figure out if this is, you know, advisable.

Yeah. You've spoken to a lot of survivors when kind of doing your research and painting a picture of what this industry is like. Can you speak at all to the after effects and the kind of trauma and experience that survivors go through? And because you're recovering from recovering, basically. Well, I mean, one of the things that is absolutely horrific is that people who come out of these places almost never want to seek any mental health care again in their life. And they truly may need it because now they probably have PTSD on top of whatever they had before.

That's one very bad outcome. Another is that they are estranged from their family because oftentimes the family has been told to expect reports of abuse and not believe them. And one of the things that's really essential in recovering from trauma is being accepted into the community and being believed about what happened. And so, I mean, one of the really painful things when I was writing that book, like I was often the first person that believed these kids. And that is terrible. And, you know, some families never recover from it. So there's that. But beyond that, and even worse, is that there are enormously high rates of suicide and overdose.

And we don't know exactly how elevated because nobody has done a study. I mean, I'm hoping that out of the program, they have all the records. They could potentially fund a study if they can get somebody working on a PhD to do it. But I'm going to be going to grad school and I want to find someone who would be open to doing that. So. Fingers crossed. Yeah, well, keep me posted because any one of those programs, if you have a complete list of the patients and you can just track them down and see what happened, I guarantee you that the rate of suicide and overdose is...

probably at least twice what it is in a matched group of equally troubled kids who did not get sent. And probably worse than that. I mean, when you look at the stuff from the Family Foundation School, which Liz Ionelli has tracked, I mean, 50, 60, something like that, suicides and overdose. Catherine from the program is tracking suicides and overdoses from Academy of Ivy Ridge, again, enormously elevated. And, you know, when you think about it, like a lot of the kids who went Did not do any drugs and did not, you know, I mean, they had depression or ADHD or any of these things, or maybe they were binge drinking or what did she have? Like one Mike's hard lemonade or something like this. Totally normal teenage stuff.

And then they come out and have experiences of addiction that are just crazy. Like most people in my experience of interviewing survivors, a lot of them go through a period for maybe a year, six months where they're completely compliant and just kind of infantilized and just do as they're told because they're terrified of being sent back. Then they often go through a period where they do absolutely crazy binges. Unfortunately, a lot of women end up in sex work or stripping sexualized fashions, which again, can be totally fine if you choose that for yourself. But if you have been coming out of a place where you got like lined up and had boys yell out.

What in horror, which this happens in some of these places, is it surprising that Paris Hilton ends up making his sex tape? You know, when you know the backstory here, it's just awful and misogynistic. And again, there are certainly people who choose to go into sex work for reasons that have nothing to do with this. But when you have been in a sexually abusive situation... And you go into sex work, there is likely a problem there. And, you know, the other horrible thing is that oftentimes parents have spent the college fund on these places. Or put themselves in so much debt. Right.

Yeah, exactly. And so now the kid can't go to as good a school as they would have gone to. And, you know, maybe they can't go to school at all. Also, the education that kids get in these places tends to be terrible. And this is often why I'm surprised that like, you know, upper middle class parents would stand for that level of education. I sort of understand why they might be conned into the abuse. But if, you know, no actual teachers, like you're learning from a computer. I mean, I imagine they're going to have a harder time getting away with this now post-pandemic. Only know about how bad remote learning is for so many people. This is not preparation for college. And oftentimes what happens is the kids are so emotionally destroyed by what has gone on.

that they can't function and they end up dropping out and end up, you know, getting in college debt that they can't pay because they don't finish. And, you know, all of these, it's just awful. So you got to think from broken family to suicide to overdose and worsened addictions and sex work. I mean, it's just, it's not a pretty picture. And what I think is beginning to change is that I think they're going to start to be vulnerable to lawsuits. Because, like, for example, what Catherine found at Ivy Ridge, all those records, the video, it's very hard. You know, they're not going to be able to deny what they did. But also just previously when people were not aware of the troubled teen industry, what you would have is a person who tried to sue.

And they'd be like, well, look, the kid's doing fine. So therefore it worked. Or, oh, look, this kid's a drug addict. You can't believe anything they say. So it's not our fault. And so that is why, like, with the exception of Phil Elberg, most of these cases did not result in settlements for parents or, you know, I mean, no. They've also been conned by a bunch of lawyers that like actually took cases and didn't do anything with them where they could have probably won. But again, there needs to be standards and it needs to be the case that you can sue these places for malpractice when they commit malpractice, which is pretty much every day.

Yeah. My last question for you is related to that, which is, what do we do? Obviously, the regulations are increasing. These programs are becoming confined to very specific states that have very specific regulations, if you can kind of speak to that. But also, like you're saying, legally, these cases are now having precedents that we can look at and discuss. building kind of a case for this being a pattern of behavior. There was also a congressional hearing that happened after you released your book and they pulled from a lot of your work. But what do you wish would happen with this industry, whether it's like an FDA for treatment? Is it they get sued? Because a lot of the times they'll get sued, they'll shut down, open with the same people and a new name. So what do you think needs to happen? Yeah.

I think you need to ban people from an industry if they have worked at a place and been shown to have engaged in abusive practices. Like you would take kids away from them, from their parents for doing some of these things. Yeah. Why shouldn't people get a second chance to work with children when they have at the very least looked the other way? in an environment where severe abuse was occurring. So the people that did this, the people who ran these places should be in jail, and the employees should be banned from working in this field, period. And this is why you need federal regulation, so they can't move from state to state. And, you know, okay, so maybe they will go outside of the United States, but at the very least, then you can warn parents, don't send your kid outside the country because the regulations aren't there.

That's one thing. I do really think that, like, if you're going to claim that you treat depression, ADHD, any diagnosable disorder, that you have to provide treatment that is a standard of care for that disorder. Right. And if you don't, you shouldn't be allowed to sell your services that way. I mean, the fact that these places can call themselves emotional growth or therapeutic boarding school and they don't actually have therapy for the conditions that they claim to treat. Or they're treating like impulsivity or self-esteem, which are not conditions. Exactly. I mean, the thing is, nobody needs residential treatment if they don't have a diagnosis.

And if they do have a diagnosis, they need treatment for whatever the diagnosis is, not troubled teen treatment. So it's like I can't set up my cancer center without, you know, I'd have to have an MD. I would have to like have training. I'd have to do a fellowship. Like there's all these things that I'd have to do before I could like. You'd have to jump through so many hoops to even like get chemo. There's so many things you have to do. Yeah, the same thing should be true for mental health care. It shouldn't be that complicated. Now, I get that it is harder to regulate speech than it is to regulate a drug. But professional speech has been regulated. And we recognize that conversion therapy, many states have now banned it. And if we can do that, we can ban therapies that are not proven. I think, again, you will always get people trying to go for loophole.

And you need to work to minimize those. But I think if we educate parents and regulate stuff appropriately, nobody's going to go for this. You know, I do think there is this minority of parents who actually want their kid to be abused. And that is a whole different story. Dealing with them is going to be a very different thing than dealing with the 80, 90, 95% of people who are abused. were conned into sending their kids to such places. One of my main goals with the book, and we're hopefully going to be putting out a updated edition, one of my many goals is to just have parents know. Because informed consumers will not do this. The vast majority of parents want what's right for their kids.

You know, they may be annoyed with them. They may be having communication issues, whatever. But most parents want the best for their kid. And they would not do this if they knew what was sexually happening. Yeah. Well, you have a number of books out. Everyone, I'm sure, is going to want to keep an eye out for the updated edition. Where can people find you, read your books, read your articles, all the things? Sure. So my website is maiasz, that's M-A-I-A-S-Z, like zebra, dot com. And so you can see the info on my books and sort of the latest stuff with me on there. I am also a contributing opinion writer for The New York Times, and

And so roughly once a month, I have a column in there about various things along these lines. And yeah, I'm hoping to, you know, sort of work more in this area because it's so great to see that we're finally getting some attention. And in that group, there would inevitably be someone who had themselves gone to one of these. They knew somebody who went. They knew a parent that sent their kid. Because this is a huge kind of underground thing that we've just never talked about. And we really need to talk about this now, especially because, you know, Gen Z and just in general, we just went through this pandemic. Yeah.

And that was an enormous stress on the entire society. And stress is what, you know, especially severe stress is what turns predispositions to mental illness into actual conditions. And so we're dealing with a lot of this. Like we've never dealt with it well. And the brain is part of the body. We expect our body to get ill many times in our life. Why don't we realize that the brain is not an exception to this, right? that like it is quite common to have anxiety, depression, all these things. And that's not just, you know, pharmaceutical marketing. The reality is that, of course, it's common. You think the brain's going to be exempt from everything? Like, why would that be? So we have to learn to do this better.

And I really think, you know, we know so much more. And we know if a kid is like seven or eight and they're kind of sad and they're interpreting the world in a negative way. Like if we can intervene then, not labeling them, not nothing, but just be like, hey, what are you thinking? How are you thinking about that? And look at like. Maybe that's just your head. Maybe it's not really that way. Maybe you're just seeing it in a different way. Like the more you can do sort of cognitive stuff with people before they grind that groove into their brain with a false nature that they may or may not have, the, you know, the easier it is. And we can prevent that.

But we have to do it right. And we have to not be like, oh, you're a depressed kid. We're going to like label you and now you're never going to be able to change. But yeah, so I do think there's a lot of stuff that can be done. And that despite the fact that we have a lot of challenges, we also have a lot more information than we used to have about what worked. Yeah, I agree. People are talking about it a lot more. And I think at least now the conversation has shifted. And I hope that parents that have felt shame because they sent their kids to these programs and didn't know what was going to happen, that 98%, that they were victims as well. And they were scammed out of money and lied to. And I really hope that there's a lot of grace for survivors and parents alike in this process. And that

People speaking out really does bring change to the industry. Amazing.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. why you procrastinate (even when you really care)

    Nov 21, 202649 minAudio

    do you struggle with procrastinating… even on things you truly care about?! are you aware of your worst procrastination habits but don’t know how to change them? in this episode, i am once again joined by dr. sarah...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. i thought college would make me happier (what i wish i knew)

    Nov 7, 202635 minAudio

    if you’ve just started college and are wondering why everyone seems happier or better adjusted than you are, then this episode is for YOU! in this solo episode, i break down what i wish i’d known when i started college...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. why does it take a crisis to be taken seriously?

    Oct 23, 202644 minAudio

    do you want to start therapy but are worried about what your parents might think? are your parents making you try therapy but you don’t know what to expect? whether therapy is your idea or theirs, this episode breaks...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. why you know the coping skills but still feel stuck

    Oct 12, 202632 minAudio

    if you know what you need to do to improve your mental health, but struggle to implement these changes into your life, then this episode is for YOU. today’s guest is shireen rizvi - a licensed clinical psychologist who...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. 263. what i wish i knew when i didn’t want to be alive

    Sep 27, 202626 minAudio

    are you currently at a low point with your mental health? do you hate it when people tell you “it will get better” - mostly because you don’t believe it ever will? in today’s solo episode, i’m answering the questions i...

    Credit the people on this episode