Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Welcome to She Persisted, the Gen Z mental health podcast. I'm your host, Sadie Sutton. Let's get into it. I think where people get stuck, they've gotten into blaming themselves for things that have gone wrong. We take it to heart and we blame ourselves. We think we're unlovable or we think we're incompetent. But it's usually not the case that people are accurate. It's usually something in their behavior. Hello, hello, and welcome to She Persisted. If this is your first episode, buckle up. You are here for a good one. If this is not your first episode, welcome back. I am so excited for you to listen to this. We are doing our first ever mental health mashup. So we have compiled a bunch of expert advice on navigating depression and understanding why we get depressed, how we can shift those feelings and behaviors, and really what it is that you're experiencing and how to support someone navigating that.
So you are about to get really a masterclass from some of the top depression researchers, clinicians, professors, authors, podcasters, and voices in this space. I know you will leave this conversation feeling empowered, educated, and having a better understanding of what you're experiencing, why you feel the way you do, and what you can do to shift that. So before we dive in, you're going to hear from Hans Schroeder, a clinical assistant professor of psychiatry at the University of Michigan Medical School. He researches the beliefs and messages about mental health and their impacts. You are also going to hear from Dr. Ayelet Ruscio, one of my professors at Penn. She researches anxiety, depression, why they're different, why they're similar, and how they show up in our lives. You're going to hear from my therapist, Dr. Caroline Fleck, a licensed psychologist, consultant, and adjunct clinical instructor at Stanford University.
She's also the author of Validation. You're going to hear from Dr. Judith Joseph, a board-certified psychiatrist and researcher at Columbia University and an assistant professor at NYU. She is an expert on high-functioning depression and also a major voice in the social media space. You're going to hear from Catherine Gordon, a licensed clinical psychologist, speaker, and author specializing in cognitive behavioral therapy and using CBT skills to prevent suicide. podcaster, psychologist, and author. She is the originator of the perfectly hidden depression term and offers expert insights on why some individuals might be experiencing really intense depressive symptoms but might not show those outwardly. You're going to hear from Cornell professor Dr. Jonathan Rottenberg. He is also a top researcher
who explores long-term functioning and well-being after depression. You are gonna hear from one of the greatest depression researchers of our time, Dr. Stephen Hollen. He is a professor at Vanderbilt, and his work has completely shaped the field of depression research. And lastly, you will hear from authors Liz Fosselin and Molly West Duffy. You've definitely seen their doodles across social media, and you might've read their books, No Hard Feelings and Big Feelings. There are a lot of different theories about why people feel depressed. Listeners might have heard of the chemical imbalance theory or maybe heard that it has more to do with the context you're in or how you're thinking about the challenges that you're navigating. What is your perspective on what causes depression? Yeah.
I like to think about this as needs not being met. There's universal needs that we need. We need to love. We need to be loved. We need to have a sense of respect. We need boundaries and we need space. We need meaning in our lives. And if something's gotten in the way of us being able to meet those needs, depression is going to come up and tell us about that. And it's going to try to tell us that at least. Kind of on a neurobiological level, what is often happening in depression is individuals have a heightened sensitivity to stress, and a heightened reactivity to stress. So areas of the brain, particularly the amygdala, are sort of heightened in individual with depression. So a tendency to experience negative emotion to react very strongly to stress. And we see that prefrontal cortex areas of the brain that are involved in plebiscence,
planning and in self-control, self-regulation are reduced. Activity in those areas are reduced. And in terms of the crosstalk between the limbic system and the prefrontal systems of the brain, there's sort of less tamping down of emotion by those frontal regions of the brain. And so people with depression, kind of a universal feature, is the sort of heightened sensitivity and heightened reactivity when stressors occur. And all of us experience an increase in distress, an increase in sort of that cortisol response when we're stressed. That isn't normal. It's actually very adaptive. What seems to happen in depression is that people have trouble shutting that process off in a prompt way.
I'm very much interested in the evolutionary perspective. No evolutionary biologists would think about anxiety, pain, or depression as being aberrations. They would think of them as being evolved adaptations that served a purpose. What they would do is follow the energy. And if you've got an infection, the energy goes to the immune system. You don't want to date. You don't want to think. You're not interested in food. If you're starving, the energy goes to foraging for food and preserving the vital organs. If you're clinically depressed, the energy goes to the cortex. And the energy goes to really thinking long and hard and carefully about whatever's going on in your life. That's probably not a bad thing to do from time to time. You don't want to make a habit of it, but it's not a bad thing to do. So that's where I think that goes. But I think we're wired up to think carefully about things when we get depressed.
I think that, you know, with early education, we start off in the right place these days. We spend a lot of time with face charts and emotion charts and children looking at charts and saying, like, I feel pain. I do think that in certain circles, we tend to move away from it. It's like we start off in the right place. We teach kids that it's important to feel. You got to look into your body. You got to know when you have to go to the bathroom and eat and be hungry and need soothing. Yeah. But then when you become an adult, it's like, well, stop thinking so much about your emotions and do stuff. And so a lot of us will sit through, you know, an entire exam holding our urine, not pee, or we'll sit and study and like be starving and then like overeat at night. You know, we don't listen to our bodies. We don't listen to our emotions. It's almost like the more higher level that we get in terms of our intelligence and our stature and our careers, the less attuned we are to our emotions. So I think we do need to go back to the basics in many ways.
There's almost certainly a multitude of factors that are going into it rather than a single factor. And the world's not a controlled experiment where you can isolate the factors. So all these things are happening simultaneously. But I do believe that depression often is about expectations. So not only the expectations for the way that you're feeling, but also expectations about where you should be in life. relative to where you're actually in life. You do have a lot of people who have very, very high aspirations. They may not be fully plugged into reality. So people saying, well, I'm going to be a millionaire before I'm 20 years old. I'm going to be Instagram famous. I'm going to get into Harvard or wherever. And they may not, to the extent that they don't have a plan for making this happen, that's opening the door to tremendous disappointment. Yeah.
That's not necessarily depression all by itself, but disappointed aspirations, I think, is a part of the mix. And part of that does this disappointing aspirations. And I'm sure you've heard this is it is harder. It is harder to make it in a complex, competitive society than than maybe it was for parents or grandparents. It's hard to break in economically. It's hard to finish your education. There is such rapid change gets really quite a rich area. And there's lots of room, I think, to improve our ability to explain what's going on.
I'd love to kind of hear your perspective. Are there any shifts that we see in people that are depressed with the way that they feel and think and behaviors where you're literally thinking and acting differently when you're depressed, which when you're first diagnosed, a lot of people aren't told that. It's really a challenging thing to understand. One metaphor I use, and these are kind of extreme, but it would be like if you had your hand on a burning stove, all you would be able to think about is getting your hand off that stove. Yeah. Yeah. Not what you were going to wear to the party. Not getting your math assignment done. It would be hard to focus on anything else. You can't see clearly in that amount of pain. We can understand that because we've all experienced physical pain. When we're suffering and struggling, it's actually hardest to do the things that would help us most.
For example, we know that connecting with people when we're depressed or anxious, in a lot of ways, that's really helpful. We know that when we fear things, the thing that helps the most is to face those fears. And yet the nature of those mental health struggles is that you want to avoid those things. They seem like they're too much to even take on. That hopelessness feels like there isn't any point in doing anything. And when someone says to someone who's hopeless, well, why don't you just do these things and you'll feel better? Unfortunately, that can make things worse because it can feel, the person can feel ashamed for not thinking about it that way or not being able to do those things that might help them.
I feel that there's a natural pull for people to want to not feel alone. Someone else is experiencing this too. Wow, that is super validating in and of itself. I'm not alone in this experience. And we can take that too far and say, oh, this is my identity now. This is who I am. So we're seeing the entire world as this is just my depression. I am depressed. I'm a depressive person. And this is how it's going to be. The depression experience in and of itself is... By definition, it engenders a sense of hopelessness, low energy, low motivation to address the things that you might need to address. So it becomes kind of this reinforcing cycle where I don't even know where to start and I'm too tired to do anything about it. So then depression lasts for a lot longer and then we think this is just how it's going to be.
You know, people who haven't gone through depression, they might be sympathetic, but not understanding this, they could be quite confused about why depressed people are doing certain things. So, for example, depressed people might do things to themselves like they might burn their arm or pick their skin and do other things where the person is like, well, how could that be helpful? And don't they know? Don't they know that you should go for a walk and do yoga? Depressed people are not stupid. They have this unique experience of cycling through all manner of emotion regulation strategies, including all the ones that were suggested to them on numerous occasions, and finding that they didn't work. So then depressed people might start doing things that they might actually not be such great ideas, but they're trying. They haven't given up.
And they might get locked into some of these counterproductive strategies. But you can only really understand that if you have empathy and also knowledge that depressed people don't on day one. The first day I'm depressed, I go immediately. Start screaming into a pillow or, you know, banging my fist through the door. Like, that is not what happens on day one. So not as much research as you would imagine tries to take people through time to understand how the experience changes. One of the interesting things, and we know from basic research, I find this fascinating, is that...
Non-depressed people, they tend to mispredict. So for example, if you have a favorite team and someone asks you, so if your team doesn't win the Super Bowl, how are you going to feel? And the people systematically, they overestimate. They say, I'm going to feel horrible. And man, I can't even imagine it's going to take a long time to recover from. But the truth is that even things that are more significant than your football team not winning. people tend to bounce back from. And so this is the normal experience that people have, that these really strong moods don't last. So it's only people who are in these clinical states where the mood might last for three months, six months, a year, two years.
that they really don't experience as much relief. And it's quite confusing because their whole previous life, when they were able to either change what they were feeling or just spontaneously experience change in what they're feeling, they're no longer experiencing that. And it's confusing. I think where people get stuck, at least the folks we usually see clinically, they've gotten into blaming themselves for things that have gone wrong. As opposed to, I didn't study hard enough for the test, or as opposed to, you know, most relationships are practiced relationships, and you get better with practice, et cetera. We take it to heart and we blame ourselves. We think we're unlovable or we think we're incompetent. But it's usually not the case that people are accurate when they make a global, stable, internal attribution to some defect in themselves. It's usually something in their behavior, and they can move.
Gen Z has really been a leading voice in trying to decrease stigma, speak more openly about mental health challenges. What are your thoughts on how stigma shows up with respect to depression? Are there any issues specifically relating to feeling depressed that we need to be more open about and give a voice to? So general population surveys in the U.S. have shown that approximately half of the adult population in the U.S. will have a mental disorder at some time in their life. That's probably an underestimate because people may be reluctant to report, especially since these surveys are usually done with lay interviewers who are strangers. And these are sensitive things to talk about, especially with some stranger who's come to your home. Right? Right.
And so when people are followed forward in time, we actually see rates as high as 70 or even 80% of people will eventually develop a mental disorder. Now, that's really important and hopeful in a way because it tells us that it need not be stigmatized to have a mental disorder. In fact, the more rare and unusual situation is the person who reaches, you know, the age of 80 or 90 having never had a mental disorder. So I think it's just important to recognize that mental illness is all around us in one form or another, and that having experienced this, we're not alone. We're actually in the majority. There's a lot of stories that we hear about in the media of people having suicidal thoughts and acting on them. And I'm glad that those stories exist because it's really important to share those as well, as painful as they are. You know, there's, there needs to be more stories of people having these thoughts and,
and being able eventually to go through periods where they don't have those thoughts anymore, or they don't have those thoughts as frequently, so they're not disrupting their lives as much as they were. I think the more people become familiar with it, the more it gets detoxified, and it becomes a little bit less radioactive. It's still not easy. There still is a tremendous amount of discrimination that happens, for lack of a better word, and often in high-stakes situations. situations like applying for jobs or forming relationships, there's a lot of fear, a lot of fear of mental health problems, and they can be seen as absolutely disqualifying. And we're wasting just a huge amount of some of our most talented people because of the difficulty of understanding what can be a wide gulf between people's experiences. So I think we really do need more of this and not just kind of speaking in some of the cliches that the
easy to do, but just not that helpful to give people the 3D picture of these sorts of experiences and bringing them back into the things that are discussable in polite conversation. And it doesn't make you weird, but it is a real shame. I'm curious what strategies, interventions, tips, skills, etc. Do you recommend for people that are struggling with depression and they're working to alleviate those emotions and shift those behaviors? I think listening to your bodies is so important. It sounds like simple, but we really do have to go back to the basics.
And remember, a lot of us are just pushing through life, not feeling, not acknowledging, and just hoping and holding our breath and hoping that it gets better. It's not going to get better. You know, we have to acknowledge it. We have to respect how our body and our minds feel and honor that. And that's a good place to start, which is not easy. It sounds so granola, but it is so not easy. It can be very painful for people. And there are people who are in treatment with me for years. And it They have to relearn how to get back in touch with their bodies and their minds and their emotions. So that's a good place for us all to start. So I think about a couple of different types of behaviors. And one thing that I use as a therapist is the idea that there have to be a menu of options because different things work for different people. So if one thing doesn't work, OK, well, we have nine other things or 10 other things. And that in itself can build hope.
getting through it. So one category I would say is self-soothing. And when someone's struggling with a mental health problem, they often are punishing themselves. They don't even think, oh, now's the time to actually soothe myself. So I think about if you have the flu or you're sick, at least some part of you knows it's not your fault. It's just something that happens. And you kind of have to go easy on yourself. You have to have... comfort foods you you can't do the things you normally do hopefully you can call out of work and so I try to make that analogy that when you're struggling in a lot of pain that is the last time for more punishment and self-criticism so things that tend to soothe people I think a lot of it a lot of people go to music a lot of people go to I like stand-up comedy because it's kind of the
When you're laughing. And I think the other part of it is that actually there's so much comedy now about mental health stuff. So I have like two functions where it's funny and you can resonate with it. So those are a lot of them. Getting outside, like just changing the perspective, going for a walk, taking a lunch hour. Anything that captures your attention and feels positive. Yeah. And then the other piece I would say with the behaviors is trying not to isolate. And one way to do that is to reflect on your values. And so a lot of it boiling down to basics is spending some time to reflect what are my values and what am I doing in life that connects me with those values? And they don't have to be huge things. If you value yourself.
being compassionate or charitable or educated or whatever it is, you can find something, something to do that just kind of connects you with that value. And then life doesn't feel so empty. And so it's worth thinking about those types of things and making action plans for what's something I might do to enhance that meaningful feeling. Generally speaking, doing activities that are active are good. So exercise is always recommended as a way of improving mood as well as keeping you sort of healthy and fit. Doing activities that give you a sense of mastery and accomplishment are good. So these can be pleasurable activities.
But they can also be things that aren't all that pleasurable that gives you a feeling of accomplishment. Like, okay, did the laundry. Check. Right? Yeah. You know, I ran this errand that had to be done. Check. Where you feel like, okay, I'm accomplishing things. So those are good too. But especially good are activities that give you a sense of pleasure. Things that you really enjoy. That can be by yourself or with other people. It doesn't have to be a great big thing. It could be as simple as, okay, I'm going to go for a walk with a friend. I'm going to spend some fun time with a sibling. I really enjoy, you know, reading this particular author. I'm going to go to the library and get a book I really enjoy reading. All of those are good things.
I suffered from depression when I was in high school and in my early 20s. So I was in a pretty serious episode of depression for what felt like almost 10 to 15 years. And I had just tried everything. And I frankly found many of the providers that I spoke with to be really invalidating. I found therapy often was punishing, confusing, and not helpful. Yeah. And so in addition to therapy, I had tried a bunch of other interventions, meds, X, Y, and Z, and nothing had really helped. And what I had found to be really helpful for me...
The only thing that seemed to have any real substance to it was meditation. Meditation for me was just the only space in which I could kind of calm my mind and maybe get a sense, just a slight taste of what freedom from suffering would be like. And so I was really interested in mindfulness-based therapies. It gave me insight into the judgmental voice in my head and I was able to see that I was not that voice, which sounds incredibly meta. I'll be straight, like sitting in meditation for 45 minutes when you're super depressed, like two thirds of that was very painful. Yeah. But I was fortunate enough to have just like these moments within that sitting where I would just have like freedom. Yeah.
from just the suffering and the voice and everything else. And so it was those moments that I was like, ooh, there's something there. Like, I'm not seeing this in anything else. I'm not getting this anywhere else. Like, what is that? So for listeners who have a loved one who's struggling with depression, how can they best support them, open up that conversation, and really be in their corner as they're navigating this experience? I think we often try to jump to problem solving or there's often this tendency to be like, I'm going to fix this. You know, like your life isn't that bad. Like, look at this, look at the bright side. You're, you have all these privileges. And what we don't realize that that does is like really just minimizes someone's emotions. And so I think the biggest thing is just like creating space for them and saying like, I hear you. I acknowledge you. Like, I love you. I'm here for you.
If you did something really drastic, I would miss you. So when my father-in-law was dying, I also found that a lot of people that I knew loved me and cared about me didn't know how to show up for me. And I just didn't have like, I had no energy to help them show up for me. And so they would kind of like send me a text and be like, let me know if you need anything. And I was just like, I do not have the time to figure out like what I need from you right now. And then one of my friends who had gone through something really similar sent me this text that was like, hey, I'm thinking of you. Here are three things. You just text me one, two, or three, and I will do them for you. One, I will get you food at your apartment. Two, you can call me and I'll pick up the phone right away and I will just listen. And three, I will send you something to distract you, like a funny joke. And like, whenever you need me to, as soon as I can, I will try to respond with these things.
And I thought that like, she just got it. Like she just totally understood that I didn't have the capacity to come up with those things, but it was just like, I don't even think I ended up texting her that much, but it just like knowing sometimes at night when I couldn't sleep that, like I had someone to text to, to that she would like immediately respond made me feel so much better. And I think it was just the like really kind, trying to see it from my perspective and not, it wasn't the fixing, it was just like, I'm just gonna be here for you. Here are three ways for me to do that. But you don't have to like creatively come up with a full way for me to show up for you, I found was like, just so, so helpful.
I think so many people with depression hear invalidating statements like, oh, you just got to take a walk outside or you just got to get up and go to work. One of my groups, this made me so mad, they said their dad said, just have an ice cream cone. And it's tricky because, of course, our parents and family love us and they want they're trying to be helpful. But it's kind of actually makes us feel less connected. more alone, less understood when we use the J word, just, just do this, just that. So validating, oh my gosh, I see you as really struggling right now. This sounds awful. Even something like that can go a long way to get that one connection going back.
The other piece that I'm a really big fan of, and I just learned about this actually on Monday, is validating and then giving language that says something along the lines of, and I believe that you can get through this. I know that with effort you can get through this, that with support, I have no doubt that you can overcome whatever it is that you're going through. And you need both. You need both. You can't just have the validation and you can't just have that, oh, you got this. You have to have the validation and the kind of the messaging that says, let's talk through this. I think checking in constantly. So I had a friend who, when I opened up to her, you know, I said, I I'm feeling like I don't want to live anymore. And she then stayed on the phone with me, but then she texted me every day. She just, and it wasn't, didn't require a response, but just like, you know, checking in, she would tell me something about what was going on with her or, you know, it was really thoughtful and it's people who you don't always expect who, who call and check in and it doesn't need to be a big thing, but it, it, it really does help in these moments. Yeah.
I think you have to talk about yourself. You know, you say to your friend, sometimes I realize that our relationship feels unbalanced, that I talk to you a lot about what's going on with me, and you're a great lister, and I appreciate it so much, but I want to give to you as well, and that seems like something that you're not okay with. I'd like, you know, I notice that you struggle with letting me in, or it seems that you do, and I... I would love it if we could work on that or something. You address how you're feeling, what you're seeing, not an accusatory way. And you say, sometimes I realize that I don't talk about all that I experience with you. I am scared to do that or I don't know how to do that.
And then if it's a truly caring friend, they might say, well, you know, you can anytime. And you say, I know, but I just needed to say that one thing. That's where I need to start. And you start where you are. And then, you know, if you feel like someone else is struggling with this, then basically, I guess an invitation and just to have some remarks about what you're observing and what it feels like to be you in the relationship with them. In general, I'm in favor of being direct, open, and honest, because anything else just confirms that idea that it's unspeakable and that the person can't talk about it. And so I think just starting with open-ended questions. How do you feel? What do you think led you to feel that way? That sounds really hard. Simple, empathic, non-judgmental statements like that
I think that's really hard to do because it's uncomfortable and painful to hear that people are in those situations where they're feeling suicidal. So often the urge, which is totally understandable, is to jump in and problem-solve things. or to kind of push away the conversation. So being direct is really helpful. There is evidence that if you talk to someone about suicide and they are struggling with suicidal thoughts, that even talking about it can reduce some of the distress and intensity surrounding it. If you enjoyed this episode of She Persisted, make sure to leave a review, subscribe, and share with a friend or family member. Follow along at She Persisted Podcast on TikTok, Instagram, YouTube, and more for bonus content. Thanks for listening and keep persisting.
do you struggle with procrastinating… even on things you truly care about?! are you aware of your worst procrastination habits but don’t know how to change them? in this episode, i am once again joined by dr. sarah...
if you’ve just started college and are wondering why everyone seems happier or better adjusted than you are, then this episode is for YOU! in this solo episode, i break down what i wish i’d known when i started college...
do you want to start therapy but are worried about what your parents might think? are your parents making you try therapy but you don’t know what to expect? whether therapy is your idea or theirs, this episode breaks...
if you know what you need to do to improve your mental health, but struggle to implement these changes into your life, then this episode is for YOU. today’s guest is shireen rizvi - a licensed clinical psychologist who...
are you currently at a low point with your mental health? do you hate it when people tell you “it will get better” - mostly because you don’t believe it ever will? in today’s solo episode, i’m answering the questions i...