PHP VUlnerability from the Other Side (Fan Perspective with Simon Hania)
32 minAudio
Send us Fan Mail Welcome to the Serious Privacy podcast, where Paul Breitbarth, Ralph O'Brien, and Dr. K Royal connect with Simon Hania, former DPO at #Uber. Simon reached out with a comment on a prior week in privacy to share his disagreement on something we said. So we invited him on the show to share his pespective on the PHP vulnerability and potential complications and impact. @trustarc If you have comments or questions, find us on LinkedIn and Instagram @seriousprivacy, and on BlueSky under @seriousprivacy.eu, @europaulb.seriousprivacy.eu, @heartofprivacy.bsky.app and @igrobrien.seriousprivacy.eu, and email podcast@seriousprivacy.eu. Rate and Review us! Subscribe today HERE Powered by TrustArc From Season 6, our episodes are edited by Fey O'Brien. Our intro and exit music is Channel Intro 24 by Sascha Ende, licensed under CC BY 4.0. with the voiceover by Tim Foley.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
TimYou're listening to the award-winning Serious Privacy Podcast sponsored by Trust Arc. Please welcome your hosts, Paul Breitbart, Ralph O'Brien, and Dr. K Royal. Automated transcript. For accuracy, listen to the audio
PaulIt is the day after the U.S. elections, and it is clear the Democrats will hold a majority in Congress the next two years. But does this mean we will finally see some movement on U.S. federal data protection law? Time will tell, but there's always hope. In the meantime, cyber attacks continue around Europe with another wave of freezers set to extreme temperatures, and not just this time in supermarkets, but also in blood banks. And if that wasn't enough, hackers have stolen six billion dollars worth of cryptocurrency at Binance, maybe the biggest bank heast in history.
PaulSo enough to discuss today, including with a listener who disagrees with some of the previous observations. And of course, we are happy to engage, and especially with this listener. So today we welcome Simon Hania, previous DPO for Uber, but most of all, well-known privacy voice around the world, to the podcast. My name is Paul Breitbart.
RalphMy name is Ralph O'Brien.
KAnd I'm K Royal, and welcome to Serious Privacy. So, Simon, I did not realize I you might have worked with a professional friend of mine, Ruby.
SimonDefinitely.
KAnd Uber? Okay, thought so.
SimonWorked with is an understatement.
KY'all probably basically lived with each other.
SimonUh she called us Yin and Yang. So no, together we made quite some difference. Yeah. It was a joy to work with her.
KI adore Ruby. She is absolutely amazing. So, Ruby, if you're listening, and we've had her on before, big shout out to Ruby. Okay, unexpected question. Let's see. Last week bombed. I asked a question that meant nothing to my colleagues, but it made for wonderful conversation. So this one, what is the strangest food combination that you secretly enjoy? Or not so secretly enjoy?
RalphOh, I'm gonna jump in straight away there.
KOkay.
RalphEverybody has a real problem with the fact that I eat fish finger sandwiches with melted blue cheese.
PaulThat sounds gross.
RalphFairly regularly in that.
KThere we go.
PaulBut I don't do cheese, so that's my defense.
SimonI I my my one is actually peanut butter with acheslog, which is sprinkles with chocolate. I ate it once, it's horrible. So it's but I have tested it.
KThat sounds like one I need to try.
PaulIt's very Dutch.
KVery Dutch.
PaulIt is very Dutch, yes. Can you remind me that I'll bring you some chocolate sprinkles the next time we meet somewhere around the world?
RalphNot only apple sprinkles, but there's a real thing whenever I go to the Netherlands where you tend to have applesauce with everything.
PaulThat's only in certain hotels. It tells me something about hotels you visit rather than the Netherlands.
KOh, well, sure. You said you sounded like you had one that came to mind.
PaulYeah, some people find it strange. Again, in the Netherlands, this is fairly common, but that would be peanut butter and sambal, so hot sauce. Oh. And then either with some cucumber or maybe some fried onions on top. That's that's a go-to for me.
KWait a minute. Peanut butter, hot sauce, and cucumbers?
PaulYeah.
KOkay, I'm done. Y'all don't even need an example from me. I that that's weird enough to cover the whole King Caboodle show. I will say that in the South, there's probably some food combinations that people hear about that's weird. People always ask me what's the food like in the South? It's sweet, it's fried, and it's got sauces on it. Spicy is Cajun or Creole influence. It's not southern, but fried sweet or with sauces on it. But I will say one of the weirdest ones, which I didn't think was weird, is kind of like you, Ralph, it's chicken fingers, which is kind of hard for me to get fried anymore and sour cream.
KAnd I used to eat that every Wednesday at a truck stop when I was pregnant with my second daughter. We'd go there because they had great nana pudding at the truck stop. Truck stops have excellent food. But it was my standing Wednesday order, and after I had my daughter and I came back to work, I went in and they didn't bring me any sour cream for my chicken. I'm like, where's my sour cream? They're like, we thought that was a pregnancy thing because that's really weird. No, that's a me thing. Bring me my sour cream for my chicken nuggets.
RalphIt's normally at this point I try and put in an inventive segue, but I can't really say talking of sour cream, silent.
PaulNo, but talking about chicken fingers and fish fingers, what do they look like when the freezer sets to 50 degrees?
KWell, and that makes me think that due to the PHP thing, there may have been some risk to people's utilities, their food, and their livelihoods over the past week or two. Does that get your segue, Ralph?
RalphYeah, yeah, indeed. Simon, actually, before we do jump in, we normally do ask our guests to just give them, give the audience who may not know them a little introduction to who you are and what your background is, and all of the relevant points that you feel that thumbs up a career in data protection as venerable as yours, Simon.
SimonYeah, so my career in data protection is actually only 15 years old compared to some others that's just because I started out as an engineer and managing and running IT data centers in a Dutch ISP and uh TomTom, the navigation company, you may know. And then due to certain events relating to that company, I jumped into privacy and data protection back in 2010-ish, triggered by an investigation by the Dutch Data Protection Authority. And then I took a bit of a different course, because I'm not a lawyer. I had to learn the law and ask questions to the lawyers, and that taught me a lot.
SimonAnd that's how I actually ventured into combining, let's say, management of stuff with data protection and knowing what actually happens with the data. So that that turned out to be something Uber was interested in back in 2018 when GDPR came around, and they had just done their first level of GDPR program. And Ruby was onboarded as a CPO, and I was onboarded as a DPO. We just talked about Ruby, and we were there to help the company build what we tend to call Uber 2.0.
SimonSo Uber had its worst year in 2017. The CEO was ousted, new CEO still there, building a new company, and that's actually what we were up to and we tried to do. And then after seven years of being on that roller coaster on a kind of uh volcano, because that's the best description of Uber, I I decided that it would be better for me just to take a break. And I'm still taking a break, a sabbatical of an indeterminate nature, and and actually I'm enjoying it.
SimonI'm enjoying it because having worked 12 hours a day for 25 years, it's now time to spend some time to myself, and I can recommend that to everybody. So it really is. It's taking me longer than I expected, but we'll see what the future brings, because everybody asks me what's your plan, and my plan is to not have a plan, but to stay and get healthy. So that's the trajectory I'm current on, which doesn't mean that I don't take a good look at what's happening in the world of AI, cybersecurity, data protection, and also the infamous Platform Work Directive, and we'll see what comes out of that.
KSimon, I'll throw in there, of course you still pay attention to it because we all work in what we love, right? So when you're passionate about it, it's not work, it's a calling.
SimonAnd actually, what I'm most passionate about, and I think you touched upon it the other day, as well, we're into protecting people. And that Uber I was protecting people, working with great people. And then you can really move Neil. Now, of course, and most privacy professionals will know that what you've achieved is not necessarily up for discussion externally, because you're you there's always room for improvement, although you have improved a lot. Yeah, that's that's the kind of conversation we may have over a beer rather than on a podcast, but it's still very much worth it.
SimonWe it's with people for people, and that that's exactly actually what attracts me most.
PaulI hear an amen from Ralph, I think. Amen. Yeah. Yeah, that's what we're here for, protecting humans from problems. Yes. Absolutely. So, Simon, you reached out to us because you had a bit of an issue with some of the remarks we made, and maybe I'm making it bigger than than you intended it to sound, but some of the remarks we made around the whole freezer hack situation and the threat it poses to society.
SimonIt's indeed the threat it poses to society, because I actually think that no one died, no one was injured with this freezer incident. Now, obviously, putting an industrial freezer onto the internet does require some serious adult supervision, and that may have been lacking, but we should also recognize that the blood bank you mentioned, that's getting more serious. But I actually find this entire chain of incidents a good example of why the European legislator was so good at defining critical infrastructures as something to focus on.
SimonI really think that we should not necessarily now start spending all of our precious cybersecurity and data protection resources on fridges, but we should put them onto airports, trains, and so on. And that that's so this is a wake-up call, but we should take a step back and add adult supervision to a lot of these things. And I actually think that a lot of folks who listen to this podcast will agree with me that in the end it is what the Germans call Chefsache.
SimonIt's chiefstaff for the CEOs, but also the supervisory boards. And what I've seen in many companies, and actually the companies I was part of, have also helped me able to help change that a bit, is that a lot of supervisory boards and boards in companies do not consider cybersecurity as something they need to take care of. They have outsourced it to a company or to their CISO, but they are not talking about it in the right way. And I think that's a root cause because if you use industrial freezers, it's pretty clear you have some idea about food safety.
SimonNow, food safety builds on cybersecurity safety. So it's very easy to explain to a board this is something you need to start asking questions about. This is what you need to do to source stuff. Even when you know that this freezer was bought 10 years ago when we were still running Windows XP almost. So I understand. But yeah, things live long and they may not prosper. Things live long and may not prosper. That's beautiful. That's what you need to be.
SimonAnd this is also what what stuff like the Cyber Resilience Act does. It puts the owners on management and boards to ask the right questions. They do not have to be the experts, but they need to be able to involve the expert. And that's why I'm saying there's not enough experts. Let's put them to use properly, and let's not try and get public opinion on uh on a track in which they start politicians to ask questions about freezers and forgetting about the really harmful stuff. Now that was basically my point. So my point is freezers do not pose risks to society.
SimonNegligence and insufficient adult supervision. That's the case I'm trying to.
PaulSo how do we get the adults in the room? Because we do have new legislation. You mentioned the EU Cyber Resilience Act, we have the Network Information Security Directive, all of which say, hey, this should be board material. And then there will be companies who say, Well, yeah, I'm I have a board meeting coming up, and we will take all the security stuff that we do, we put it on the agenda, it's at best a two-minute conversation, they agree with what's what's documented, and they move on without a real serious discussion.
SimonThe discussion should be about risks. It should not be about the security stuff itself. You can get carried away with all the technicalities there. It needs to be presented in a way that boards know and understand. How are financial risks reported? Amen. How are business continuity risks to pro And that's what we, and maybe actually the privacy professionals, are a bit more advanced in that respect than many security folks who still tend to be very, let's say, instrumental and technical, but you need to lift it up to a level in which boards can recognize the risk, prioritize the risk on your proposal, and then assign appropriate budgets to it.
SimonAnd then you can get into a management cycle. This is not rocket science. This has been done in food safety, in transportation safety. Learn from what's being done there and start applying it. Do not try and explain to your board what a firewall is, but tell them we you need some form of proper access control before you put your fridge onto the internet. That was Blyfair's question.
RalphIt was like, why have you put your fridge connected to the And I get it? I get the fact they want temperature control and they want to monitor it remotely and all of that interesting stuff.
PaulThat's the thing. For the blood bank, I fully understand why they would want to have them connected, because it is easier to monitor. And this time they were able to take out the blood in time, actually, because they saw something was wrong. So the blood was not affected, and they were able to save it all. But indeed, why would a supermarket freezer be connected to the internet?
RalphYeah, that was my concern. And second to that, going back to Simon's point, we talk about services that are critical. Getting food into people's mouths is just the basic sustenance we all need to live. But you are right. We've done the last 2,000, 3,000 years of people providing and buying and selling food without having fridges connected to the internet. And I'm not saying we should turn back the clock, but at the same time, we do need to consider sometimes whether everything we own does need an internet connection.
SimonI was talking about the supervisory board of the individual company. And it's very well possible we don't know that it has been discussed and that they didn't find the risk material enough and basically said we can survive if that happens. Could be. Probably not, but could be. But then still, if all food suppliers, all supermarkets use the same brand of fridge and are connected in the same way, then you have a monoculture of software, and that's risky. So it's also about diversity and resilience, building that into the system.
SimonAnd that is something which also affects how we view competition or anti-competition law. So if we get two large conglomerates who buy the same stuff and have the same operational procedures, then you get risky. We had this incident in the Netherlands with a supermarket chain which has a 30% market share, and then you start to feel it as society. And that's why I think it's very good that we now have a conversation between the larger supermarket chain sanctioned by the competition authority in how are we going to deal with food continuity, so to speak, when something like this happens, how would we want to deal with that and what are the costs?
SimonAnd are we willing to take those costs? So it is not just supervisory board material, it's also one level higher in the government material, what happens to food safety. Now, some fridges going down in a certain area of the country. I think we can survive that. There's a lot of press about it, so that amplifies the severity and the urgency a bit, but it's so it's very good to have a proper fact-based conversation about this and then decide what to do.
SimonI would be way more worried with trains being obstructed, which doesn't even require digital hacks, could be done in other ways, or yeah, planes. And maybe they have you could also think maybe it's been sorted there, and that's why the miscreants are now attacking where the issues are. So we don't know. So let's not cry woo too easily. Let's get the facts straight and let's have the adult conversation about this.
RalphSo there's a certain irony here in the by by saying, oh, perhaps this isn't something that we should be talking about and not focusing our time on, we're now focusing another episode on it.
KOh gosh.
RalphWhich is fine. Because be no, but it's good.
SimonI think it's good to, after the fact, just when things are becoming clear, have this kind of more reflective conversation about it, and then, based on that, decide what to do next. And I think it's an excellent way to use podcasts in general to do this stuff as well. Not just jump on the latest and greatest, but also be a bit more reflective on this. I think there's a place for that.
PaulSo do you think the intent here is just scaremongering, or is there something bigger behind this? Is this also showing, hey, we can do this, we have the capabilities to hack these systems and you don't know what's next. So just start being afraid.
SimonI d I don't have absolute facts on this, but I've seen in the past two scenarios which typically are there. There's someone, uh a lone wolf, who could do it and just did it. That's one. And I've seen that in some of the data breach cases. I've been on the inside, we've seen that happen. And everybody thinks it's a state orchestrated attack. But it could very well be someone who is put into position to do that. We don't know. We simply don't know. And the way to get this kind of knowledge, yeah, it requires intelligence services if it's really a state actor.
SimonAnd that's yeah, that's a tricky bit. At the same time, yes, if you, as a state actor, would want to use such a mechanism, then you're sending the signal, which now will make everybody beef up their security on fridges. Okay, fine. So we're good there.
RalphSo the the wide point here, the wider point here is basically focus your resources where the risks are, right? Focus your time where the real problems are rather than on a sort of a flash in the pan media story. Is that your sort of main association here, yeah? Definitely.
SimonWhich could be different per country. So in the Netherlands, you will want to uh make sure your weather management systems are great, whereas in other countries, that's low risk. So don't bother.
KYou might want to make sure your election systems are good. Exactly.
SimonYeah, very fair point. Absolutely.
KFair point. I want to take you back a little bit because my team actually just brought this up this morning, specifically in conversation about the PHP, because of course, like every other company, clients are reaching out, going, were you impacted? And we're sending letters and all that good stuff, and reaching out to our vendors. But specifically in relation to that, they brought up January or I guess December 31st and January 1st, 1999 to 2000 with the Y2K. I was a nurse during that time.
KAnd I was head nurse on the cardiac unit. And yes, I worked both those nights. And yes, the production and lead up and fear-mongering and technical research that was done back in that time, and then nothing happened.
RalphOr did nothing happen because everybody put in the activity to make sure that it didn't.
KI was gonna say, but did nothing happen because everybody put in the prep work and making sure there were backup systems, or did nothing happen because it really wasn't a thing to worry about? But nobody knew that until it actually happened because they'd never been in that situation before. So I take to heart your caution of don't scare people over smart refrigerators or smart toasters or smart everything that hackers use to hack into houses and take down, I don't know, the United Kingdom's internet, which I think happened about seven years ago.
KOr do we really do focus on critical things like airlines, election systems, weather systems, whatever is most critical to the country? Your thoughts about the correlations there?
SimonWell, first of all, it reminds me of the fact that it's very easy to reward people for fixing problems and much harder for to what for preventing problems. Yes. So this is so it's really important that when people come up with a plan to prevent stuff, that you reward them, we recognize them for that as well. That's key, I think, on putting stuff on the internet. When I was back when I was at the ISP where I ran some of the technology operations, we the issue we had was folks putting all kinds of computers on the internet, which currently were used as bots to start attacking others or to send spam.
SimonIt was a serious problem at the time, and it was recognized also by legislators, and actually I lobbied a bit for that in Europe, that if you connect stuff to the internet, consumer electronics, it actually needs to be sufficiently cybersecure and privacy aware. And actually, they put it into the the Radio Equipment Directive, which is the directive which governs radio equipment safety, and everything with Wi-Fi is supported, is subject to that. And you need to, strictly speaking, self-certify with a CE mark that your device is sufficiently secure and adheres to privacy laws.
SimonWhat's the issue? The great news about it is if you don't do it properly, then it's an economic offense, so they can come after management of the company. The biggest issue is that it was never operationalized into standards and enforcement. And hopefully that can still happen on consumer electronics. I think similarly might be required to do so on certain levels of professional industrial equipment. I think it's completely fair to say. Fridges need to have a minimum level of security, which includes change the password, software updates, all the stuff we have in consumer electronics, a minimum of that, which then allows those who buy and source that equipment to rely on the fact that there is a minimum level of security, just like they can expect the car to be sufficiently safe.
SimonThat's part of the work that could also be done. This is about prevention again, and how to ward people for that.
PaulYeah. Tricky. So there should be a by design approach, like we argue that we need to have data protection and privacy by design built into our data processing operations. Also, security needs to be there by design. Absolutely.
SimonBecause an afterthought may not work, maybe too late, and maybe very expensive. And one of the challenges actually is that we have legally put the owners and the responsibility on the buyer rather than on the producer. I still think it was a huge mistake at the time in GDPR to not include producers, like that was intended to at least push some of the responsibilities towards the producers of systems and IT to deliver systems that, by design, out of the box, at least have sufficiently safe defaults rather than have everything open.
SimonEverything is possible. And if you have a problem, it's your problem rather than ours as event.
PaulSo we have made a little bit of progress there in the EU with the introduction of the provider criterion in the AI Act that also comes with similar by design requirements and all kinds of documentation. Are those sufficient, or should those also be further strengthened going forward?
SimonWhether they will be sufficient, time will tell. It's currently focused on the highest level of risk. The challenge, of course, is that if you have those requirements, you need to be able to verify, which requires standards and certification schemes, which in Europe is an industry of its own. If you are in a product company like I was at Tontum, you learn and also learn how complex it is. And the reality is that it will not expediate innovation. So there is also a good reason to only apply it initially on the highest ones, but then also, and I believe the European Commission is doing proposals for that, expedite the standardization, the certification processes, and not aim for 100% coverage.
SimonI would already be happy if we meet a 60% target. So this is where perfection is the enemy of excellence or even good enough. So it's also about being willing to have an adaptive incremental improvement approach. And this is something which is also important for policymakers, politicians, but also the press to not only cry foul when things go wrong, but again also let's demonstrate why things are moving into the right direction.
SimonThat encourages and gives people more hope.
KI really like that.
SimonToo soon to tell. But not a problem. Let's move forward on this.
PaulOkay, what about the US? Because this is all very much focused on Europe. Is this something that in the US would qualify as state legislation? Is this federal? Is this both?
KIt could be either. Think about here in the United States, let's just use HIPAA for an example with the privacy rule and the security rule, and it absolutely sets the foundational standards across the United States, of course, if the data is subject to that law. But other laws like FERPA don't even really think about security, right? So we don't have a federal omnibus law that addresses this, but we're trying. And I think, frankly, we'll probably move closer with AI than we will with privacy, let's be honest, right? People think AI is sexy.
PaulCybersecurity, is that a federal issue?
KThat's what I'm saying is I do think that if you take it into account with technology, we'll probably come closer to having a federal cyber bill before we'll probably have a federal privacy bill. And I do think that is valid, right? It would set a foundation across the United States. But on the other hand, the states aren't backing down. They're moving legislation forward. So we already have states that have security requirements out there, even if they don't have a privacy at this point. And so it could be both.
KI guess the answer is it depends. It could be both, right? We're like Canada. We they have federal and provincial law. So different things like that. So it could be both. A lawyer's favorite answer, right? Ask two lawyers the same question, you'll get five different answers.
SimonAt the same time, I would also say legislation is one method, one means to achieve the objective of a safer environment or a more productive environment. And I think that it actually starts with what are the policy objectives? And maybe across the US and Europe, we can align on policy objectives, which which relate to freedom, which relate to a lot of the shared values we have. And then the method to achieve that, it could also be mass claims. That's fine with me as long as it in the jurisdiction we're talking about is an effective means.
KYeah, agree.
SimonSo if we can set this is what we expect from you as an industry, as a government, to do in order to protect people, in the broadest sense, and then more specifically, this is what it means, then drafting the laws becomes an important technicality, but we can still have a conversation at board left.
KAgreed. And the mechanism, I think, is critically important. So we asked about is this a thing in the U.S. for the laws? The laws don't always provide the best way of addressing an issue because you can't write laws to account for future technology. Look at what we're running into with chatbots and recording laws and tracking cell phones, and the laws themselves get interpreted to apply to newer technology, future technology that people can't imagine. So passing a law might not be the right thing.
KPassing an executive order is probably not the right thing. But self-regulation across the industry or commerce-driven solutions are not the worst thing, right? So where clients require their vendors to do certain things has always been effective, right? Because you're driven by commerce. You're driven by being able to do business, and that will motivate many companies to do so. Does it motivate the government? Not really, right? So that's when the industry self-regulation might provide a solution where the law may fall down on it.
PaulVery clear. I think that's a very good note to end on, Simon Fenn. Thank you very much for joining us and sharing your views. That's always appreciated. So, listeners, this is the hard evidence. If you have opinions, just share them with us. Let us know. You may end up being a guest on the show. Thank you very much. Until next week, goodbye. Thank you.
KBye, Al.
TimNow that was serious privacy. Please subscribe on your favorite podcast app and leave us a review. You can find us on LinkedIn, Instagram, and Blue Sky as Sirious Privacy. Feel free to drop us a question or a comment. We'd love to hear from you.
Send us Fan Mail Welcome to the Serious Privacy podcast, where Paul Breitbarth, Ralph O'Brien, and Dr. K Royal connect witih Thiago Luis Sombra, partner with Mattos Filho. We talk all things privacy spice in Latin...
Send us Fan Mail The unexpected question - do animal crackers translate? A week in privacy with Paul, K and Ralph, including AI, Data Protection by Design, Are Controllers and Processors the right terms, Digital...
Send us Fan Mail Welcome to the Serious Privacy podcast, where Paul Breitbarth, Ralph O'Brien, and Dr. K Royal review hot news over the past week including enforcement against Meta - Cambridge Analytica just won't die,...
Send us Fan Mail Welcome to the Serious Privacy podcast, where Paul Breitbarth, Ralph O'Brien, and Dr. K Royal connect with @Noel Luke, of @TrustArc to discuss all things certifiable... pretty sure we can all agree that...
Send us Fan Mail Welcome to the Serious Privacy podcast, where Paul Bretibarth, and Ralph O'Brien cover a smashing week in privacy! Dr. K Royal is at the @Association of Corporate Counsel in Boston speaking on...