How to deal with a narcissist, recognize Narcissistic Personality Disorder (NPD), and handle narcissistic clients or partners without losing yourself. Narcissistic clients often intimidate therapists, partners, and family members into giving in, walking on eggshells, and constantly apologizing. Wendy Behary, LCSW, author of 'Disarming the Narcissist' and a member of Dr. Jeffrey Young's original schema therapy development team, has treated narcissism for over thirty years. In this episode, she breaks down early maladaptive schemas hiding behind bravado, overt vs. covert narcissism, and how gaslighting and entitlement manifest in session and relationships. Wendy demonstrates empathic confrontation - the essential schema therapy technique for setting firm boundaries while holding compassion. Essential viewing for clinicians dealing with countertransference, as well as anyone navigating narcissistic abuse, toxic relationships, or a narcissistic parent. (CE available for LCSW, LMHC, LPC, LMFT). 📌 In This Episode, You’ll Learn: • Overt vs. covert narcissism: How to spot "virtuous victims" and "diva zones" • What empathic confrontation actually sounds like in practice • How therapists can escort their own "vulnerable self" out of the room • Setting limits when clients interrupt, storm out, or vanish • How partners pick narcissists and how to hold boundaries without escalating #SchemaTherapy #Narcissism #WendyBehary #Psychotherapy #CovertNarcissism #NarcissisticAbuse #TherapyTools 0:00 - Cold open 0:11 - Is narcissism as common as social media claims? 2:38 - Thirty years treating narcissism on Dr. Jeffrey Young's team 5:17 - What is schema therapy and what is a schema? 8:26 - The schema profile of narcissism and its perfectionism overlap 11:01 - Overt vs covert narcissism and the virtuous victim 13:52 - Narcissism in women and the diva zone 17:25 - Narcissistic mothers and developmental narcissism in children 19:54 - Delivering the diagnosis with a "once upon a time" narrative 25:24 - Empathic confrontation technique explained 27:41 - Therapist sturdiness & countertransference with narcissists 30:43 - Leverage and how it transfers to the therapy relationship 32:25 - Signs the treatment is working 33:42 - Setting limits when the client keeps interrupting you 37:22 - When clients storm out or vanish from treatment 40:41 - Can narcissists actually change? (The 30% rule) 41:28 - How to set boundaries with a narcissist 44:21 - How humanness gets lost and the art of the apology 49:18 - Why partners choose narcissists and the discovery mission 55:57 - Noticing and naming discomfort in the moment 57:44 - Rescripting the demanding internal critic 1:00:00 - Behary's self-care ritual: childhood photos of clients CONNECT WITH WENDY BEHARY Website, courses, and lectures: https://disarmingthenarcissist.com Book: Disarming the Narcissist CONNECT WITH LORAIN Podcast and personal curriculum: https://lorainmoorehead.com/podcast Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/theselfcareapist Listen on Apple Podcasts and Spotify: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/self-careapist-therapist-podcast/id1821324484 Not sure where you're stuck clinically? Take the free Stuck Point Quiz at lorainmoorehead.com/quiz and get resources matched to your answers. Self Careapist Therapist Podcast is a biweekly, therapist-to-therapist conversation hosted by Lorain Moorehead, LCSW, PMH-C, EMDRIA Approved Consultant. Guests include psychologists, researchers, and the developers of the clinical models they teach, with practical takeaways for every level, from intern to clinical supervisor. Many episodes offer a free CEU for Arizona licensure through the Board of Behavioral Health Examiners. New episodes every other Wednesday. If this episode was useful, leave a review on Apple Podcasts. It helps other therapists find the show.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Welcome to the Self-Cherapist Therapist. I'm Lorraine Moorhead, and this is a Therapist to Therapist podcast for mental health professionals who want practical, evidence-based skills they can actually use in session. Each week I'm joined by leading experts in the field as we talk interventions, modalities, client populations, clinical supervision, and sustainable self-care, the kind that helps you do meaningful work without burning out. If you're a therapist, counselor, social worker, psychologist, or graduate student looking for real continuing education, you're in the right place.
SPEAKER_01Welcome back to another episode of Self-Cherapist Therapist. Welcome, Wendy Bihari. Thank you so much for having me on. Yes, I've been really looking forward to this. Right off the bat, I'm curious. If you or anyone listening is on social media, many of us would be led to believe that narcissism is very common in relationships, in dating. Do you agree with that? Or do you think it's less common than social media portrays?
SPEAKER_01I have a lot to say about it, but I'm gonna try to be brief because I know you have questions.
SPEAKER_00Media is just flooded with the term narcissism, as is the internet in general. And unfortunately, I I think there's a certain mythology out there. So often what we're seeing is not necessarily narcissism, but antisocial personality, psychopathy, sociopathy, and not narcissism. Do I think there is a lot of narcissism out there? I think, you know, because narcissism or NPD or I'm using abbreviated versions.
SPEAKER_00I know there's no such real clinical term as narcissism, but if it happens along a spectrum, and I think it does, and I think most experts would agree, then surely there's plenty of folks who have narcissistic traits. The question is, to what degree are they moderate, severe? Are they impacting a relationship in a really deleterious way? Um, but there is a lot of mythology on the internet, and certainly things like in social media, especially, they can't be helped, run for your life, demons, date, you know, devils, Satan, no empathy, impossible.
SPEAKER_00They could never experience empathy. This is just not true.
SPEAKER_01Yes. Yeah, I think that is is a really important way to phrase it and way to look at it. And something that I think is so interesting about you and your work is that in your clinical practice, you work with narcissists and their partners and even the couple together. Is that right?
SPEAKER_00I do. Couple together under conditions that warrant that, because there are conditions that certainly don't. But yes, I do. I would I've worked for 30 years with narcissistic, mostly men, some women, and yes, with partners and family members and other people who have been offended in these relationships.
SPEAKER_01Will you take us back to 30 years ago and and give a description of how you got started in this work and what you've been doing throughout this time?
SPEAKER_00Just so everyone doesn't think Wendy must be a masochist. Um, just don't want to treat this population, and it's really unfortunate because it's doable, it's hard, and it's overwhelming. And 30 years ago, I was overwhelmed and triggered and doing all the wrong things, making lots of mistakes. And I was so curious about why I could feel so incredibly intimidated when a certain type of person came into my treatment room. I was also in the middle of working with a phenomenal team of clinicians under Dr.
SPEAKER_00Jeffrey Young in Manhattan, who was developing schematherapy, which is the model that I practice. And I was so fortunate to be part of that developing team. And so my reports of being just flooded and floored by narcissistic people led to okay, you're assigned the task of working with us to figure out how we can modify and adapt this model to treat that population. Um, so it became really clear very early on that one has to be very sturdy to work with someone who's narcissistic, particularly the more severe form, you know, the the higher end of the spectrum, where they become abusive and loud and cynical and critical, demanding entitled, all of that, or interrupting you all the time.
SPEAKER_00Um, a lot of limit setting is necessary, a lot of accountability. You can't do that from a triggered state, because in a triggered state, we're we're rendered vulnerable. And I was aware that it was my vulnerability that was leading me to react in ways where I was just giving in, I was avoiding, I was apologizing, I was ignoring things. So working on ourselves becomes very important, an essential element to being able to be effective in the room. That's one element of several elements of being able to do this.
SPEAKER_00You have to have a good model that that works deep, engages emotion, goes to those early experiences as schematherapy does. And you have to have leverage because if the narcissist is coming in and there's no leverage, there's no high-stakes consequences that you know, something that matters that they don't want to lose, it's really hard to get the ball rolling, it's hard to get traction, it's hard to continue the journey. So that's what I learned 30 years ago.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I want to talk about leverage, I want to talk about sturdiness, just to get a little overview because I know we're gonna keep uh referring to the model. Could you give a description for anyone who hasn't heard of schematherapy and what is a schema?
SPEAKER_00I think it's the most beautiful model on the planet, but I am biased. Um it is an evidence-based model, has a lot of science support. It was uh founded by Dr. Jeffrey Young. And it evolved out of CBT and attachment theory. It is an integrative, not eclectic, an integrative model, meaning that we integrate strategies from other evidence-based treatments to do the work that schematherapy does, which is to try to meet core unmet emotional needs, to try to help our clients have a corrective emotional experience.
SPEAKER_00In other words, getting what they didn't get in early childhood through the beautiful use of imagery rescripting, the therapy relationship. We posture ourselves in a limited but, you know, kind of important we call it limited reparenting. You could think of it as agents for change, advocates for vulnerability. It's hard work. It was it was designed for personality disorders originally, but also expanded to more chronic symptomologic issues and now kind of expands into many different modalities, including couples and groups and children.
SPEAKER_00So, what is a schema? We look for these early unmet needs and how those early unmet needs can inform certain traits, which means beliefs that have a high emotional quotient can be felt very strongly in the body, get exaggerated when they're activated because memory is being engaged. So beliefs like no one will ever be there for me, people are gonna hurt you, everyone will leave me, I'm no good, I'm defective. There's 18 early maladaptive schemas, and they are all linked with early unmet emotional needs, which originate in early experience, not necessarily always with parents, but with significant caregivers, school, uh, neighborhood, teachers, etc.
SPEAKER_00And they form in childhood and adolescence. We have reactions to them. So the model is really uh best known by many as the schema mode approach, which means that we look at how one has learned to survive given these experiences and schemas. And so we work really hard to understand what modes are presenting themselves as a form of adaptation, but they are typically maladaptive. In other words, narcissists, for example, have deep insecurities and often a lot of a great sense of defectiveness and not being good enough despite what we see.
SPEAKER_00But they overcompensate for that with a strong bravado and a strong sense of entitlement and confidence and approval seeking, and we would call that a mode. So that's just kind of a little thumbnail. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Um in the last year, we did a perfectionism episode with Dr. Paul Hewitt out of British Columbia, and his years of research with perfectionism have identified for him safety and belonging being two of the core unmet needs of perfectionists. And I I imagine those two are each their own schema.
SPEAKER_00Yes, that's exactly right. Yes, you might say in the belonging domain, it could be anything from emotional deprivation, being deprived of support and love and guidance and affection, even. Um, abandonment would fall into that category, stability and security of having someone there. You know, defectiveness would fall into that category, that sense of belonging and being accepted for who I am and and mattering and having worth and value. So, yes, they they would all correlate with schemas.
SPEAKER_00But the schema of perfectionism, which we call unrelenting standards, is a schema unto itself, often acting in kind of in conspiracy with other more core schemas.
SPEAKER_01Are there any schemas that are more common for you to see among your clients with narcissism? Or is it a mixed bag?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's a good question. It there are schemas that are more common or what we would call a profile of in narcissism of schemas. And there's probably about 10 pretty popular schemas in that profile, give or take, depending on whether they are more grandiose types, more covert types, where there may be higher degrees of neuroticism and vulnerability and trauma even in the background. We find but these schemas can also apply to all of us. So what really determines the diagnosis is how they have learned to cope, what their survival mechanisms have looked like.
SPEAKER_00And that's when we get into, you know, narcissistic responses to these schemas. For example, you know, partners of a narcissist may also have emotional deprivation, but what they learned how to do were become people pleasers and be self-sacrificing and silence their voices and be subjugated, whereas the narcissist, you know, raise rises above that, overcompensates, and acts entitled and get becomes demanding and self-righteous and perhaps perfectionistic too.
SPEAKER_00I'm not going to need anybody.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Can you explain covert versus overt and what you might see with each?
SPEAKER_00Sure. Yeah. I mean, the grandiose overt type that we see is sort of what we think of as the textbook classic narcissist, you know, beating the chest, wearing the crown, you know, larger than light. Yeah. Absolutely. Um, showboating, all of that, they do tend to have higher degrees of confidence. They are typically those who will uh emerge to leadership positions, to high status professional positions, they have high degrees of entitlement, low empathy, um, similar in covert narcissism, they kind of share that, uh, those traits, but they do tend to have lower neuroticism.
SPEAKER_00And although underneath there may still be these that unmet need for unconditional love and acceptance and higher degree of burden placed on the child for performance and achievement, do tend to be able to pull it off, if you will. Whereas the covert narcissist will often struggle a bit more. They have higher sensitivity, often a higher need for reassurance, more both are sensitive to criticism, but the covert types are really sensitive to criticism.
SPEAKER_00They hear everything as a criticism. What's really important in differentiating the two, and this is why covert types can be what I call hiding in plain sight, is that the covert narcissist gets their extraordinariness from being a victim. Whereas the overt type gets their extraordinariness from all their wonderful achievements, acquisitions, accomplishments, etc. Covert types tend to be the martyrs or what I write about in my book, the virtuous victims.
SPEAKER_00Uh, nobody appreciates me, nobody recognizes me, I do everything, nothing is ever good enough. It's it's that constant need for reassurance. And you can never really meet that need because it is part of an identity. I'm I'm smiling because there's an absurdity there, but certainly there is a there's a wounded child underneath all of this. It's just hard to get to.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think that an example I liked in your book too was being invited to join mom at the table with her friends. And it turns out to be sort of just a bragging event of look how well I did, look how adaptive, you know, look how her develop my child's development is going. Look how well they're doing because of me, rather than a true moment of connection. That's it. You know, that that reminds me of something that I think we notice a lot of people talk about narcissism in women when it comes to the mother-child relationship.
SPEAKER_01I it seems to be more easily spotted when the person becomes a parent rather than when they're a friend or earlier on. What makes that happen that way?
SPEAKER_00First of all, you know, when we think about development, this came up in a in a conversation I was having with a bunch of women this past week, and they asked the question about can a can a child be considered narcissistic? And I said, Yeah, of course, because they're supposed to be. It's developmentally appropriate. If it's it's the developmental imperative that, you know, it's all about them because they're little toddlers, babies, children, and adolescents, absolutely. Imaginary audience.
SPEAKER_01We expect that, yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. And it's really, it's going to really rely on a good parent who knows how to set limits and help the child or adolescent learn to tolerate frustration, get comfortable with being uncomfortable sometimes. These are preparations for life, right? How to be empathic and recognize the impact on someone else's experience when you've hurt them, how to own it, how to be responsible, how to be remorseful, reciprocity, all these good lessons that are hard but important without assassinating the character of the child and turning it into something that's more like a toxic shame event.
SPEAKER_00So we don't diagnose narcissism until adulthood. You know, we can see maybe a burgeoning possibility. We can see that early phase, and you can go, uh-oh, you know, looking at the origins, looking at the child who perhaps has been terribly indulged or has not learned limit setting, and they're going off now to college, university, and not prepared, you know, really not prepared, really expecting and feeling entitled to have someone do their bidding and to get what they want when they want it.
SPEAKER_00So you can start to see a pattern that may turn into a full-blown narcissistic presentation. Um, but that will, we're gonna spot it later because of these developmental processes.
SPEAKER_01You mentioned diagnosis. How does it go in treatment giving the diagnosis and how do you have that conversation with a client who is demonstrating those traits?
SPEAKER_00It's a tough issue, Lorraine. It's an and it's a good question. I mean, this is a pejorative label, you know, and the internet has done no one any favors in the way that they present it. I mean, narcissists hurt people. They do. They they do things that are that are harmful, that are painful, that betray, um, that abuse in some cases. So it's true that having a narcissistic personality might mean that this is someone who's doing some really tough stuff to another human being or other human beings, including their children at times.
SPEAKER_00It's not their intention to hurt. You know, they don't take pleasure in hurting, but they will hurt you. They will do it in service to their ego. Different than psychopathy. You know, there's no sitting there diabolically thinking, how can I hurt you? Because that would be oh so fun. It's more of a what can I do to preserve my ego, even if I have to mow you down in order to do that. So it's not that it's okay, it doesn't make it better, but it's not driven by a pleasure-seeking principle in doing harm, which means there's a fragility underneath, an opening for therapists to be able to go in and take a look at this reactivity, this way of coping when they get activated.
SPEAKER_00So, how do you talk about it with them? Well, anybody who comes to me and Googles my name is going to find, you know, 5,000 pages of Wendy Bahari next to the word narcissism. So they come in already defensive. And they come in often, not of their own accord. You know, they've come in because somebody, you know, you better get some help. But I start talking about it in schema terms. So I I I they might say, so I guess I'm a narcissist, or you think I'm narcissistic, or what are you calling this, or how would you diagnose this? And if they ask me bluntly, do I meet the criteria for narcissistic personality, I go through the criteria with them because they've asked.
SPEAKER_00But I say I'd much rather we talk about it like this. Once upon a time, there was a little boy who grew up, you know, with the idea that all he had to do was be the best of the best. He had to prove himself, he had to win, he had to give up kind of just being a kid who could be scared and sad and frustrated and upset because that was pathetic and shameful. The focus was on raising the status of the family, you know, continuing a legacy of greatness if that already existed.
SPEAKER_00So I I tell the story and he learned to cope with this by learning how to shut down his his feelings, detach from them and disconnect, and really focus on performing, winning, achieving, developed a pretty unrelenting set of standards in order to do that. Became pretty hyper-autonomous. I'm not going to need anybody because he was so let down and felt so used in his family of origin. And this is what we would call some of the narcissistic traits that have developed, that sense that I'm entitled.
SPEAKER_00I can break the rules, I can make the rules, I should have special privileges because I did all those things that were expected of me. So I much prefer telling it in a story form, really sharing the narrative, so they can see how A led to B, led to C, led to D, and and how this happens. How we all have stories that will help us to understand how we become the way we are under certain conditions, not all the time. Because so often they'll come in and say, It's just who I am.
SPEAKER_00It's just who I am. And I say, It's not who you are, it's how you become under certain conditions. You get triggered. And when you're triggered, you flip into this mode because it feels like someone's trying to control you or criticize you or manipulate you. That's old story, but it lives in your memory, so it becomes very active and you react to that. You might attack, you might interrupt, you might start bullying someone, you might start showing off, you might change the subject, you might slam the door and and just walk away.
SPEAKER_00So that's how we start to talk about what it is.
SPEAKER_01That feels like a really compassionate way where someone could actually hear you. I uh highlighted this earlier also, but you see both parties. You see the person in relationship with the narcissist as well as someone exhibiting narcissistic traits. So it feels like you can have the compassion in conversation with either person, given that you're intimately familiar with the other person's perspective, also.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, there is certainly compassion for vulnerability and pain and hardship and and things that are scary, you know, like losing a relationship. But most of this is empathy.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Because empathy is not about, you know, people say, Oh, you're so soft on the narcissist. I'm not soft at all. I mean, I'm soft on the vulnerable side, but I'm not soft on the narcissistic modes. One has to be quite sturdy, strong, and direct and assertive in confronting those modes. So it's really empathy. What I'm saying to the narcissist is, I get it. I get it. I get how this happens. I get how you became you, how you became this way. I get it.
SPEAKER_00I can see what you you know, you're allowed to assert yourself and get loud and yell and demand whatever you want, and you get what you want, and people are afraid and they cower and they don't want to lose their jobs, so they they do what you tell them to do. I get that. But that's called empathic confrontation. So the empathy is, I get it. It's not your fault, right? This is what you learned, and this is what you practice, and this is what you've been enabled to do. But this is why you're having a problem in your relationship, because this doesn't work in relationships.
SPEAKER_00And I would suggest it's not even working well in your work relationships, even though you tend to get what you want. And you're gonna tell me I don't care, I don't need people to like me, and I'm gonna say that's just crap. Yes, you do. We all kind of do need people to care. Not everybody, but we want people to care and think well of us. And so it does matter. It does matter. It's not your fault, but it is your responsibility if you want to make this better and you don't want to lose your marriage.
SPEAKER_00Right. So empathy, I get it, I see you, I understand, it makes sense to me. No doubt you would respond this way, but here's the problem, and I can help you with it. Yeah. And that's a strategy that just weaves its way right through the whole treatment process in pathic confrontation.
SPEAKER_01What does that sturdiness look like and require? For the therapist. For the therapist, yeah.
SPEAKER_00It means you have to be sitting in your healthy adult mode. It means that when you're triggered, you need to be able to imagine, I mean, literally, imagine being able to put that vulnerable part of you out of the room, right? So it's like I will sit there and imagine little Wendy goes to her safe place. She's not responsible for the narcissist sitting in the treatment room who's getting very, you know, upset and animated and or shutting down and becoming very huffy.
SPEAKER_00A five-year-old can't do that work. And when we are in that five-year-old mode, we must remove that part of ourselves. And we have the beautiful imagination. We can use that powerful resource to imagine. I mean, of course, this takes a lot of practice before you enter the treatment room. I like to call it the dress rehearsal. You imagine, okay, you're going to the treehouse, you're going to the blanket, you're going to the little chair in the corner, you're going to do what kids do.
SPEAKER_00You're going to go have some ice cream, and I'm going to go into the treatment room in with my back straight, with my chin up, with my eye contact, you know, poised in the skills that I've learned and what I understand about this person who's coming in. And I do a quick once upon a time there was, and remind myself of the client who's coming in, or the one who's sitting in front of me who's now wagging their finger at me like this. We take that moment. A lot of therapists are just not comfortable with saying, but how do you take a break with a narcissist?
SPEAKER_00How do you do it when you're in the middle of it? So you just simply take a pause. You say, uh, I need a minute. I need a minute. Wait a minute. Wait a minute. If I'm getting triggered, nothing good is going to happen here. So I need a minute. And in that minute, I can re-escort myself to a safe place, my little self. I can be reminded of the person sitting in front of me and what my mission is to get to that vulnerability and understand why are you wagging your finger at me right now? What just happened?
SPEAKER_00What's happened? You've just shifted into another mode. What got triggered there? What is it you're trying to tell me? Because I can't hear it. This is distracting, and this is what happens in your life outside. So something important, something happened that the level of intensity just rose, and I don't know what you're trying to tell me, but I can see you're in this mode. So that means something got activated. And the only way you can say that, which is by the way, a very effective way of being able to confront the narcissist, because we're saying, I want to hear you, I know this is important.
SPEAKER_00Try it again. Not like that. That just pushes me away. That just makes me want to just give up. Right?
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00And by now, when you're doing this, and I say by now, this has to happen pretty early on in the treatment. You really want to try to get that leverage that they came in with. I don't want to lose my marriage. I don't want to lose my adult children, whatever it might be. You want that leverage to transfer to the therapy relationship. I don't want to lose Wendy. She's helping me. This is important to me. I can see that this is necessary. You want them to feel your confidence and credibility.
SPEAKER_00So you must be sturdy in order to do that. I have to be able to say, well, no, that's this is just the I know you think this is a bunch of fluff, but this is how the brain works, okay? This is memory. And we all live at the mercy of our memory. You and me. Right? So it's not just, well, aren't I entitled to do X? Well, you're entitled to do anything, but if you you can live with the consequences, but you're not living well with the consequences of those actions. And that's all being drawn from memory.
SPEAKER_00So we must be credible. We must show our confidence and our capacities to do this work and get that leverage transferred over. And it often transfers once they feel that you know you are a real person. You're not just someone spouting a bunch of psycho jargon. You're you're a real human in the room who gets it, who has some degree of intelligence. They're going to scope you out for your level of intelligence. And you don't have to speak in in you know magnanimous terms in order to be believable and to be real.
SPEAKER_00In fact, you don't want to.
SPEAKER_01When do you notice that they realize that you're helping? How can you tell as the therapist that you've gained that leverage or the leverage has transferred?
SPEAKER_00Well, they start following the rules for one thing. They can't come to therapy consistently and on time. I often used to make this joke and say, you know, I love working with narcissists because they never call you. Um, they actually start reaching out, you know, because they are feeling maybe the need for additional support, or they want to report like a victory, or they'll come in and say, you know, I could have gotten really triggered by this, but I had your annoying voice in my head, Wendy. And there it was saying, you know, like be careful and take a breath.
SPEAKER_00And um, so they start feeling the benefits of the therapy, and they're reporting that to you. And you know that now the leverage is moving in a new direction. There's something happening in the therapy relationship that's powerful and important to them that may help them to continue the long ride, you know, to success, which it's a long road. It it it's not fast.
SPEAKER_01I would have expected there be a degree of reinforcement of the boundaries and um redirection, but it sounds like it from what I understood, by holding that empathy, you're attuning more to what point are you trying to get across and how can you do that rather than in this room we speak calmly or you know, in this, let me finish my thought and then you can go more than maybe overtly reaffirming the boundaries.
SPEAKER_01It sounds like you're really dial trying to connect back to what they're trying to do and how it's coming across.
SPEAKER_00Well, it's actually both. That's a really good point. I'm glad you said that because I don't want that to be confusing. It is actually both. So it's something like, I know you have a lot to say and I know you want me to hear it, but you're interrupting me. Remember, in this room, we both have rights, and we both agreed because you have guidelines right at the opening of working with someone like this. You have to put your guidelines, you know, you should state them very loud and clear, right? Remember, we both agreed that we both get to be respected, we both get a turn.
SPEAKER_00I know this isn't about me, it's about you, it's your treatment, but this is a relationship. And part of the a lot of the problems you're having are relationship oriented. So it's not the same kind of relationship, but it's still a relationship. So it's as good a place as anywhere we can practice. And right now you keep cutting me off. So I'd like to finish a sentence, and I know you're rolling your eyes, you don't like what you're hearing right now. What are you feeling? What's what's going on? Right?
SPEAKER_00So we start digging in. They're wounded, they're upset, they're frustrated, this is ridiculous, this is stupid. We want to get to all of that because that's all camouflage, you know, for the deeper hurt, the deeper shame that's often living at the core of that experience. So yes, we must use empathy, we understand, but there are still limits. We understand, but you know, there's this pattern that I keep noticing. This could be the first session.
SPEAKER_00You know, I I know there's a lot to say, and this is not meant to be a criticism. And I always start with this is not meant to be a criticism because they're so sensitive to criticism. We want to mitigate as much distraction as possible. But um in the last 15 minutes you have interrupted me about four times. And so I'm not I'm not sitting here to blame you. I'm sitting here to give you feedback. You may have heard this before, but I want to tell you that I've noticed and I want to tell you that I want to understand it.
SPEAKER_00And we need to respect each other so that we can both hear each other. If you tell me it's too hard to listen, I will shorten the sentences, but we still have to take turns here because I'm sharing something with you or I'm asking a question. How does that feel? Right. So you're still setting limits, setting boundaries, holding accountable, but we do it with a lot of appreciation for the fact that it's gonna go sideways if you don't start with something like, I'm not saying you're a bad guy.
SPEAKER_00I'm not saying, you know, you're stupid, I'm not trying to control you. All the things that you know that they are on the lookout for.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00I don't even know they're on the lookout for it. It's all automatic, but they are on the lookout for that.
SPEAKER_01Do you contract for them to speak with you in person before they decide to quit therapy? Or how much re-engagement do you do? Because I imagine that inevitably there's gonna be a session where they feel so exposed that they don't want to come back.
SPEAKER_00Oh yeah. Oh yeah. And especially when I'm working with partners, you know, they will feel this is a conspiracy, you're both ganging up against me might be a feeling. They might even get up and and start to walk out of the room, and I'll say, look, you you can do as you please. You have the right to feel safe and to to exit if you need to. I said, but I think what you're feeling is probably important. So I hope you'll come back when you feel a little calmer and we can investigate, you know, what it is that you're trying to share that's important, but not in this escalated way.
SPEAKER_00Because that doesn't feel okay. Particularly when it makes partners feel unsafe in the room. Or I might use it as an example. I might say, look, I know you're not trying to hurt me, and I don't feel afraid of you. But if I were your partner or I were someone else in your in your work environment, that would feel scary. That could make me feel unsafe. So I'm always kind of speaking on behalf of what I know might be the response of the population out there, because I get enough of a twitch, you know, as a human to appreciate what that might be like for them.
SPEAKER_00So self-disclosure is really important as part of confrontation as well. Contract about return? Um, they they know from the beginning if if you if you feel this is not right for you, it's not a good fit for you. Hopefully we can talk about that before you just vanish. I would like to know what's not working for you or what would make it better for you. But it's of course always your right to elect to exit therapy or terminate therapy if you if you decide to.
SPEAKER_01Well, do you do anything in particular if they just don't show up again? No show and then don't reschedule.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, well, I'll always check in just to make sure they're um and just to say that that you know, doors open if you'd like to reschedule, if you'd like to talk about what happened that changed your mind about treatment. I am more than happy to hear, would love to hear what that's about. Uh I leave it to you. And that's it. I don't chase them down. You know, I won't chase them down. But if they say, well, this is just not helpful to me, and or I need some time, or um, I'm done with this, I'm done with this BS.
SPEAKER_00This is just it's not me. I'm not the problem. And that will happen. So any therapist listening to this has probably had the experience of a narcissist decline who's just aborted therapy. Because sadly, despite the fact that we have a a pretty good treatment approach here. And if you have leverage and and you can be sturdy enough, you have a good chance of being effective. But even with all that, there's no yeah. And that's why the numbers are low. You know, probably 30% of my population will go on to what we would call meaningful sustainable change.
SPEAKER_00Not perfect, nobody changes completely, but they will have faster recovery, you know, when they do get triggered and they will have lower intensity, they will have less frequency of these activations, and it will be more sustainable, which for many that's good enough. You know, it's actually great. Um, but a big number will not continue because typically the leverage drops. And for other therapists, it might be that they just feel too intimidated and the client is picking up the scent and it doesn't work.
SPEAKER_01Does it ever happen that in the members of the 30% category who make valuable changes and reducing emotional intensity, do the partnerships ever end up dissolving because of that? Because the narcissistic person has made progress?
SPEAKER_00Not because of it, that I'm I'm aware of. Not because of the changes, but maybe because the partner was done already. You know, they were done, so fed up, and it's just taken some experience this. They haven't actually ended it. But I've experienced scenarios where partners are so suspicious of the changes and so reluctant to give any kind of notice or any kind of um appreciation for the changes that are occurring.
SPEAKER_00And that's a problem, and it's a phenomenological problem, really, when you're working with couples with these issues, because I understand a partner who will say, I'm not saying thank you. So he thinks everything is fine and we go back to the way things work, he's gonna think he's done with therapy. So I very often coaching partners to say, you don't need to say everything is great, but you could say if you want this to continue to be duplicated, these efforts, you could say, I really appreciated it the other night when you asked how I was doing on the anniversary of my dad's death.
SPEAKER_00I it meant so much to me that you not only remembered, but that you, you know, you sat down with me and you asked me, I I know this is just a beginning in our work. And I I see the signs that you're trying and I appreciate it. And I know there's a distance to go yet. I know we still have more to go. And I I'd love to say I trust this completely, but I'm not quite there yet. But I would like to at least acknowledge the effort that I see. So I coach them on how can you tell your truth and still hold the boundary?
SPEAKER_00And this will often be helpful to both parties, right? Because it gives room to be able to speak out loud to that's what matters to me. And for the narcissist to feel some sense of not just wow, I won, but oh, oh, it's the ordinary things that make a difference. It's not just me coming home with a gigantic gift that's worth a fortune, it's those little ordinary human gestures that matter.
SPEAKER_00And that's the hard work when you work with narcissists, that they can begin to appreciate that humanness is important and it matters and it makes a difference.
SPEAKER_01And we love Yeah, it's interesting to think about it that way. How does the humanness get lost?
SPEAKER_00In performance and achievement, when everything is about how am I doing, how did I do, how do I comparison, uh, how am I measuring up? What are people thinking of me? Are you approving of me? Are you impressed with me? Are you envious of me? Everything is about my status, evaluating, reaching a metric. Yeah, exactly, exactly. Yeah, and so the thing is gets lost, things like I care about you, or um, you know, you matter to me, or just reaching in.
SPEAKER_00You know, when people say, are narcissists really not capable of empathy? My answer is I think empathy is a tough thing for a lot of humans. We all think we have this capacity to be empathic. We do, but we confuse it with kindness, we confuse it with sympathy and compassion. And it's hard to sit in a position of empathy because it it's not necessarily agreement. A lot of times it's not agreement, it's just I get it, you know, I get how you are the way you are. I don't really agree with it, I don't like it, but I get it.
SPEAKER_00And empathy is tough, but narcissists, it's really tough because of that last question you asked, you know, which is all about performance and achievement. It's not about what's happening in the inner life of another. And until they can go into the inner life of themselves and really get to know that vulnerable part of them at the core and begin to reimagine their lives in ways that those needs were never met. To get them met, it's an inside-out approach.
SPEAKER_00So they have to go inside first in order to clear up all of that shame and distraction and defensiveness, and then they are free to look inside your world and understand what might be going on for you, or even be accountable for things they've done. You know, they can do that thing that I sometimes begin to teach them when they're ready, which is called the art of the apology, which means I own it, right? I did it, and I'm sorry for it.
SPEAKER_00And I can imagine, I can truly imagine how that must have felt so terrible for you. Empathic awareness. And I'm committed to changing it, right? So I own it. This is mine. I've got to figure out why I did that. I can see how much it hurt you, and I'm committed to changing it. That's a remorseful apology. And that's pretty hard and almost impossible until you've really cleared the path of shame in here. Because the narcissist's apology is often, I told you I'm sorry.
SPEAKER_00What's your problem? I mean, I know I'm a terrible person. I suck. What do you want to do?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Are you going to keep bringing this up? This might be a you problem.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. And and I look at them and say, well, that's all about you. That's not about your partner. That's all about you. So that's not really an apology when you've just made it all about you. And uh, but they can't do it because the shame is so high. And and so they they go into their attack mode or they just shut down and get fed up. So the deep internal work has to come first. And then empathy is possible.
SPEAKER_01It it's really interesting to hear you explain how that, how you see that to be a partner that can trust the behavioral change when you're in partnership with a person who is really, really skilled at mastering this behavior and replicate the behavior. But to your point, it really is that in-depth work, like even some parts work or schema work about how am I really feeling? How is that showing up when I feel like I'm threatened?
SPEAKER_01How do I respond? That that you can duplicate a behavior, but at its core, that really needs to be unwound to make that long-term change.
SPEAKER_00That's so true. It's so true. I mean, and so many of them will just say, tell me what to say, tell me what to do, I'll do it. Yeah. Maybe even for a little while until you get triggered again. Because when you get triggered, all bets are off. Emotions will override, and all those memories and all those habits that have been formed for your survival, not really helping you, but they were formed for your survival, will be back on track again.
SPEAKER_00And all these new learned practiced behaviors are not going to stick, not until you do the deep internal work.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00And that's proven over and over again.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. How often do you see someone with narcissistic traits pick a really successful partner and then ultimately end up frustrated because their partner is so successful or So appealing to people.
SPEAKER_00Oh, that's so often. I mean, that's a that's a really interesting question and observation because you know the narcissist is either going to pick someone who will do their bidding, you know, someone they can control. Um, because it just depends on how strong the need for control is. Some of them can be really coercive in controlling partners and alienating them from others. Some are going to choose that partner who just is is a shining star like they are, because it makes them look good, right? Like, look what I got.
SPEAKER_00And then feel frustrated and jealous and envious and angry when that successful partner gets any attention for their success. It's like, uh-uh, I get the spotlight. You don't get the spotlight, my spotlight. You're you're part of my spotlight, but it's my spotlight.
SPEAKER_01So that becomes how would you describe the dynamic where a partner continues to go for relationships that end up like that, where they're admired for all their accomplishments and achievements and maybe how they look, and then the partner ends up angry at them not to value them because of those things.
SPEAKER_00I've worked with a lot of partners who will say, you know, either they've been in it for um and some of them will stay because they really don't have the resources, and I don't mean money necessarily, but they don't have the support. They're they're fearful for their children if they have children. So leaving isn't always um, I know that's not what you asked, but it is important as part of answering this question that there are those who are going to stay for a very long time, and you have to be careful not to judge them and not to let our biases get in the way.
SPEAKER_00We may think better that they should be out, but for them, protecting their children, their finances, there's um maybe their number one priority right now, which is also understandable.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_00For some of them, co-parenting with and co-parenting, which can be a nightmare.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Um, or the vengeful. Um but then there are those who will go in and out of relationships with narcissistic types and they'll ask me, why do I keep doing this? What is with me? And you know, we we look back again, we look back at what might be the kind of chemical attraction that's going on there. What is it that draws you to this? Um, there's usually something to explain it, like maybe a parent that they could never really get the approval from once upon a time.
SPEAKER_00And so this feels very soothing and nurturing. And it's not and it's not narcissistic, it's just really more for comfort and security and a feeling of belonging.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. That familiarity feels safer than actual safety a lot of the time, doesn't it?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and I and I will spend a good deal of time kind of coaching them on how to best scrutinize when you're out there trying to meet someone after you've been through one, two, three, or a series of narcissistic relationships. I mean, one's enough, but you know, that you go out there on what I call the discovery mission, and it's more the discovery of yourself. So notice yourself when you're sitting with someone you're meeting. Are you agreeing with everything they say, even when you don't want to? Are you feeling yourself sort of swelling up a little too big in the moment because of all the charm and the things that they're saying about you?
SPEAKER_00Does it feel like like a lot really fast coming fast? Almost irresistible. Like really good chocolate, but too much of it. Right? Are they asking questions? Are they listening to the answers? Are they really listening to the answers? Meaning, not that they've just stopped talking so they can hear you. Are they connecting with your enthusiasm? Are they connecting with any of the words you're using? Are they connecting with the story inside of you? There's a lot of interesting ways in which we can see, you know, what we might be up against.
SPEAKER_00You won't know necessarily on one date or one meeting, but you start to collect your data and you're mostly watching how it feels like in here. What am I doing? Oh, I just made an offer to do something that I don't want to do. I just said yes when I meant to say no. I just apologized for myself. I didn't say anything wrong. Right, but you're noticing yourself sort of falling into that same bracket that maybe you have in the past. And that's a really important gauge when you're out there meeting people is watch yourself.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that seems to be a a really important theme with both parties. You have to drop in and with some mindfulness and really evaluate what you're doing, what you're responding, what you're hoping to get to.
SPEAKER_00Yes. Yes. I had a friend recently who was out, you know, sort of stepping out in the dating scene again and said he was coming on really strong, you know, in the first 20 minutes that they were sitting together. And I was really uncomfortable with it. And I said, And what did you say? And she sort of smiled and said, Nothing really. I didn't say anything. I didn't want to offend him. I said, Okay. And so you sat feeling uncomfortable while he continued to be a little too forward and a little too too much, um, making you uncomfortable.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I even agreed to see him again. Okay, how are you feeling about that now? She's like, uh, not good. What are you gonna do about that?
unknownLike, okay.
SPEAKER_00I mean, she she noticed herself. She's like, wow, I still have to work on this. I am just not good at saying, uh, you're coming on a little strong. Yeah. Making me uncomfortable.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, you know, and I'm really noticing that even in the therapist role that you're describing, there's gonna be a growth point for folks listening to be able to in that moment clock it and then attune to it and mention it, you know. So as a dater or as a therapist in this session, being able to really state what you're noticing is is challenging. I I hear the need for that sturdiness.
SPEAKER_00It really is. And but you know what? There's always repair, you know. In the words of John Gottman, we can always go back, reflect, and repair. And I said to her, you can call him and say, you know, upon reflection, I was so aware that I wanted to tell you that you were coming on too strong. And I got a little tongue-tied in it, and I wasn't able to do that. I didn't want to offend you. And then I thought, but I'm feeling offended. So I just wanted you to know that maybe you should have that feedback. That was too strong. I'm not comfortable with that.
SPEAKER_00And I don't really think I want to have another date at this point in time. Right. You can always prepare and repair it, and that will feel good because now you have your own inner advocate working for you. And oh, that's always a victory, right?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. I uh liked what you said earlier about being able to take a pause, also. I think it feels like we either have to address it in this second or the moment is gone, but even pausing to think about how do I want to regroup in myself first, and then how do I want to address this? I think that pause is really a valuable. Good. Yeah. Thank you. I know we're uh coming to a close, but what is the path to rescripting and addressing an internal demanding critic?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, good question. Um, the demanding critic is very much the kind of chief vocalizer of all things about performance adequacy. You know, you're not trying hard enough, do better, do more, make it perfect. Um, the rescript is going back to the origins of that. Sometimes they're remembered, sometimes they're not. So when they're not remembered, we can just go back and see a little child who's feeling the pressure to be perhaps has too much on their plate at such a young age.
SPEAKER_00The rescript might involve even just the experience of being a child, being playful, being sad, being scared, and getting comfort for that, making mistakes and being okay with that, being forgiven for that. So there's so many creative ways in which we can rescript taking on the demanding critic is sometimes even just confronting it, like what are you doing? Why are you here? And and often critics will be a demanding critic will often hold the position I'm trying to get, you know, I'm trying to promote the best in John.
SPEAKER_00And, you know, we say, well, you know, that's a really nice intention, but it's having the effect of being very painful and very burdensome and making John feel like nothing is ever good enough. So it's not really working. So then we try to adapt that voice to a voice that is more aligned with a healthy adult message, a good parent who would say, You're doing well. It's not going to be perfect. And if you're needing a little support around X, Y, or Z, ask for some help with that.
SPEAKER_00Right? And take it. So rescripting can be confronting critics directly, imagining a life that's a little less burdened for the child, where they can have more ordinary childhood experiences and experience emotions with comfort. Um a variety of different ways we would use imagery rescripting.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I love that. Um as we close, is there something that you've used for self-care over the years to show up in these challenging sessions you've been doing?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, I I collect photos of my clients as children, and I like to keep them in the chart so that before the session I take a look at two or three photos that I've collected with their permission. Um, we can have them digital now. I mean, I started this before digital photos, so I always had actual photos. Um copied the photos. And it's just a way to remember that it's not to excuse bad behaviors, it's to remember what's behind them. And our work is to get to those vulnerable parts behind them so that we can shrink these really powerful, painful, and destructive coping modes.
SPEAKER_00And so photos will help me sort of align myself again, along with again practicing and myself putting myself in that little safe place and you know, feeling myself in a in a healthy adult mode. So those are the things I I do to kind of prepare and care for myself. In addition to, you know, we all have to do self-care stuff outside of treatment room.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Make sure we're doing all that we can to not forget about our own needs.
SPEAKER_01Yes, I love that. I've never heard that idea before, but I think that is really special. A really neat idea to attune to the humanness, to use your word. If people are interested in learning more about any of the elements that we've talked about, where can they find you?
SPEAKER_00They can find everything, all of the resources. I have a lot of goodies on my website, which is disarmingthenarcissist.com, or just go to Wendy Bahari on Google and it'll take you right to my website and to a lot of my courses and programs. Um, and reach out to me if need be, wendy.beharry at gmail.com. I'm always happy to answer a question or point someone in a direction for more learning.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Do you do supervision or consultation on these topics? A lot. Yeah. Okay. And your book has the same title, Disarming the Narcissist. And I told you that I really enjoyed reading it. So that's a great resource, also. Well, thank you so much for your time today. I've learned so much. It's so neat to hear your just calm presence. I can imagine what a force you are in your session. So thank you for your time.
SPEAKER_00I appreciate that. Thanks for having me. It's been a pleasure to be with you.
SPEAKER_01Thank you. Thank you for listening to the Self-Cherapist Therapist. I hope today's conversation gave you insight, clarity, or a tool you can take straight into your clinical work. If you found this episode helpful, be sure to subscribe to the show on YouTube and leave a review on Apple Podcasts or Spotify. It helps other therapists find the show and keeps these conversations going. Until next time, keep learning, stay curious, and take care of yourself too.
In this episode of The Self Careapist Therapist, I talk with Dr. Germer, co-developer of the Mindful Self-Compassion program with Kristin Neff and author of the new book Self-Compassion for Shame: A Step-by-Step Guide...
Over half of the PSYPACT psychologists Dr. Margaret Sibley's team surveyed said they were hesitant to treat adults with ADHD. Less than a third had any training on adult ADHD at all. Meanwhile, clients are showing up...
It takes about 200 hours together to turn an acquaintance into a close friend. So what do you tell the client who tried once, heard nothing back, and decided they're bad at friendship? And what about you, after a full...
CBT is the most evidence-based first-line treatment for eating disorders, but Dr. Susan Simpson kept seeing the same pattern in her caseload: roughly half of clients relapsed, and dropout rates ran between a quarter and...
A couple sits across from you saying they both want to repair after an affair, but you're not sure either of them, or you, agrees on what "infidelity" actually means. Dr. Talal Alsaleem is an infidelity researcher and...