Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Seeing Things

Seeing Things artwork

Live with Liza! A Conversation With Sari Botton

Aug 25, 202630 minAudio

It was a pleasure to chat with fellow Substacker, Sari Botton today. We covered writing, art, cartoons, and our love of connecting with people in the art we create. In the second half of our conversation, I did a drawing while she talked about one of her publications which is about aging every step of the way - from your 30’s and beyond. None of us have aged before, each year is a new experience, no matter what age you are. In anticipation of our live discussion together, I had thought of a drawing to do while we talked. Here it is, and below it are three captions - I wanted to hear Sari’s reaction to the captions, and get your input too. * “If I were younger, I would not be able to handle getting older.” * “Aging is not for the young.” * “The only people who can handle aging are older people.” * “Youth may be wasted on the young, but aging is best handled by the old.” I thought a poll would be fun, vote for your favorite! And, in the comments below, send me any you thought of. Thanks for being here, I hope you enjoyed our conversation! See you tomorrow. Thank you Bear Edwards, Liberal Old Lady, Inéz Na-Gíg, Vegan Cindy, Fay Coulouris, and many others for tuning into my live video with Sari Botton! Join me for my next live video in the app. Seeing Things is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. Get full access to Seeing Things at lizadonnelly.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01I have with me a guest today, Sari Botten. And she's somebody I wanted to talk to. We met through a mutual friend, Noah Rosenberg, who runs Narratively on Substack. You should follow Narratively. It's all about writing. A lot of writers on there. And Sarah, let me... Sorry. I'm sorry. Sorry. I know I get it wrong. You can call me Liz if you want. Sorry. So a bio, Sarah Botten is the author of the memoir,

SPEAKER_01and you may find yourself dot, dot, dot, Confessions of a Late Blooming Gen X Weirdo. She edited two bestseller anthologies, Goodbye to All That, Writers on Loving and Leaving New York, and Never Can Say Goodbye, Writers on Their Unshakable Love for New York. That sounds like me. She publishes Ulster Magazine. Memoir Land, and Adventures in Journalism. All those are on Substack. Is that correct? That is true. That is true. She has an Ulster anthology forthcoming from Harper One in the fall,

SPEAKER_012027, and an Ulster podcast sponsored by Ruth Ann Harnish coming soon. That's great.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Lots going on.

SPEAKER_01You're busy. I am. I really am. Yeah. I think we share that. We like to be busy. I like to be busy.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think about the Miranda Priestly character in The Devil Wears Prada 2, who at the end confesses to her underling and biographer, I like to work, don't you? Yeah,

SPEAKER_01I mean, it keeps me from, it just keeps me going. It keeps me from being depressed very quickly. Yeah, me too. Yeah. Um, but also we have, not only do we have Substack in common, but, um, and guys, I'm going to talk with, sorry for a little bit and then I'll turn around and draw something while, while we're talking, uh, something related to one of her endeavors. And, um, I have a couple of captions for it. I haven't figured out which one works and I want your input and

SPEAKER_01the audience can give us input too, um, on the captions that I've come up with. Um, So you and I, we're old enough to have started in the print era. That's true. Not long ago. So who were you working for initially when you started out as a writer?

SPEAKER_00My first bylines were with the I Love New York campaign. I was an intern there and I wrote these travel stories that were then picked up by small publications around the state. And then I had an internship at New York Newsday where they just threw me in the deep end and put me on the arts desk. And for three months, I was an arts journalist.

SPEAKER_01Wow.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, it was amazing. Then I got stuck in a... Trade Magazine, Rutt. I worked at Fairchild Publications on and off for many years at Women's Wear Daily, W, but also like Home Furnishings Weekly and the Daily News Record, which was like the men's version of Women's Wear Daily. And then from there, I freelanced for the New York Times, many women's magazines, New York Magazine. I'm writing again for New York Magazine now, writing for The Strategist.

SPEAKER_00But mostly it's digital. So yeah, I miss print.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Why do you miss print?

SPEAKER_00I don't know. It was really enjoyable. I mean, I still get print magazines. I subscribe to The New Yorker and New York Magazine and Harper's. And I love like pouring over a magazine. I just love sitting with a print object in my lap. And because I worked at them, I know how much thought and care goes into the presentation process. The layout. I mean, that happens digitally too, but there's something much more ephemeral about digital publishing,

SPEAKER_00obviously, than print, which I guess is why I keep making anthologies because I make these print publications. I just love a print object, which is why I have a bookcase with lots and lots of books.

SPEAKER_01Me too. So I was like you— Drawing for the New Yorkers in the 80s, but also drawing for Working Mother, Gourmet, I can't remember, Lampoon, all those print publications. I can't remember them all now. There were a lot. So drawing for them, I would send my rejects, I would drop them off, walk to the offices and drop them off. Anything that New Yorker rejected, then we'd take them.

SPEAKER_01As a group, we would walk over there. Cartoonists would walk over to these other places. Wow. Yeah, it was fun. And then we'd go out to lunch. But I wanted to ask you, and I'm trying to think of the answer myself. I know how the internet changed me in big, big, big ways. But does writing for print differ in the process or in your thinking than writing for online?

SPEAKER_00Writing and editing for online... Required me to rethink certain things. Attention spans on the internet are much shorter. So it's funny because I was at a publication called Long Reads for five years where I was editing personal essays of 2,500 to 10,000 words. And at the time, I think there was a craving for that. But even within that, I learned that I had to keep headlines very specific.

SPEAKER_00They couldn't be vague. They had to be something that people would click on. In the midst of receiving link upon link, what would make the headline something clickable for somebody? So I really learned how to make very specific headlines and sub-headlines. And I also learned that you have to really Give people a sense of where the piece is going. You have to grab them by the throat in the first three paragraphs in a way you don't have to with print. When I've taught personal essay workshops and I've said this,

SPEAKER_00people have asked me, well, what about an essay like Joanne Beard's The Fourth State of Matter that's in The New Yorker in which she wanders in for a long time before you get to the meat of the essay? And I say, well, first of all, that is an expert piece. But second of all, you know, it was written to be read in your hand in her essay collection and in The New Yorker. So, yeah, that's something I've really had to recalculate how I present essays

SPEAKER_00and also how I edit them for myself and others.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00How about for cartoons and drawings?

SPEAKER_01What was really interesting when the internet started happening, I discovered Women's E-News, which you may remember. Are they still publishing? I don't remember. I don't know. But they were taking my feminist cartoons, which was great. They were things very specific to feminism that the New Yorker didn't want. And that was exciting. And that was the beginning of sort of shifting my thinking towards I wanted to be a political cartoonist from when I was a kid.

SPEAKER_01And I discovered that the New Yorker had political cartoons in it. And I've sold ones to them. New Yorker style political cartoons, which most of our viewers probably understand what that means. They're not like newspaper editorial cartoons. I do those too. But for the New Yorker, they're usually politics coming in the side door, indirectly in the drawing. I've done those for them, but where was I going? Okay, so with the internet, I started publishing more specifically feminist cartoons for women's e-news.

SPEAKER_01And then I did my TED Talk in 2010, and that opened up all kinds of doors. And Forbes Woman came to me and said, an editor there, you want to write for ForbesWomen.com. And do whatever you want. It was very exciting. Do whatever you want. So I started drawing and writing at the same time, putting words and drawings together in various ways. I did interviews with women comedians because I'm fascinated with women comedians. But what I learned there was, and I guess I did that for a couple of years.

SPEAKER_01This is 2011, probably. Yeah. They really, you were writing for clicks and I didn't, my editor was very generous with me and she wanted me to do whatever I wanted. But that didn't last too long. And then they started saying, well, you need to do more stuff to get clicks. And I really didn't like that.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. So, editorship changed and I moved on. But now, so I did a lot more political cartoons, specifically for online, working for a place called The Nib, which was a political cartoon. Oh, I loved The Nib. Yeah. And the editor, Matt Bores, there was very encouraging to me and helped me push the envelope of what I could draw about. And I drew about rape and incest, not incest, rape and abuse and things like that, which I'd never done before. So the internet gave me a feeling of freedom and openness to,

SPEAKER_01To try new things, which say the gatekeepers, you know, the New York are great. They're great gatekeepers, but they are gatekeepers and they have a certain thing they want to publish. Right. And I had gotten used to what that is in my mind. So I had to sort of unlodge that a little bit and start thinking more about getting tougher and stronger with my opinions. So it's a long answer to your question, but yeah. And that sort of continues.

SPEAKER_01Substack is great because Substack, and I know you agree, it's a way there's no gatekeepers. And we have a direct connection with our audience.

SPEAKER_00And it's wonderful. It's been fantastic. Hasn't it? Yeah.

SPEAKER_01When did you join Substack?

SPEAKER_00I first joined Substack in 2019. It's a long time ago. I joined Substack when Hamish McKenzie was still doing tech support.

SPEAKER_01And everybody, Hamish is one of the owners, one of the co-founders, right?

SPEAKER_00Hamish. Yeah. What was the other guy? There's two others, Chris Best and someone else. But, I mean, you know, I've been on here a long time, but I didn't launch Oldster until 2021. We're about to celebrate five years of Oldster on Monday, the 31st. Congratulations. Thank you. But it's been really validating for me because I've been a writer,

SPEAKER_00I've been an editor, and all of the publications I've worked with have been wonderful, but also very limiting. And here with Oldster and Memoirland, I'm able to follow my instincts, my curiosity, and And it's taking me in directions that are mostly pleasing a large portion of my audience. So it's been very validating of my instincts and my, yeah.

SPEAKER_01How about you? Well, let me turn this around and start drawing because I want to, how about me? I, you know, I got to go back and find out the date that I started my Substack, Seeing Things. But it was around 19 or 20, I think. I don't remember. I should have an answer for that. But yeah. I know it's pre-pandemic. Anyway, let me turn this around because I want you to... I'm going to just push it on my... Okay. And I want you to talk and tell us what Ulster is.

SPEAKER_00Okay. Sorry.

SPEAKER_01Whoops. I think it's a really fascinating thing that you're doing.

SPEAKER_00Oh, thank you so much. So Oldster Magazine explores what it means to travel through time in a human body at every phase of life. So it's not just about old people or It's really about people of all ages, although I would say the thrust is late millennial to silent generation, mostly people over 50, over 60. But I do often include younger people because I'm trying to foster intergenerational

SPEAKER_00or cross-generational conversation. And I'm also trying to make a space where people can share And their experience of getting older in their own words. And, you know, there's a wide range of experiences of getting older from a variety of angles. And so I'm trying to really capture all of it, the good, the bad, the ugly.

SPEAKER_00And I'm also trying to destigmatize and normalize aging by showing that it's happening to everyone all the time. And A conversation I often have with people is I tell them I was really freaking out about turning 60 last year, but more than that, I freaked out about turning 30. 30 was really monumental for me, difficult for me, and I think that for a lot of people that age, getting older is hard because 30 is a big milestone in a lot of ways.

SPEAKER_00Are you on the right career path? You know, it's the margin. It's the not the margin. It's like the delineation between young adulthood and real adulthood. And are you set up for it? Are you ready to commit to a career path, a partner? For women in particular, are you going to have children? So I did a post on the quarter life crisis.

SPEAKER_00And I got responses from people who are currently going through the quarter-life crisis. What is the quarter-life crisis? The quarter-life crisis happens to people between 25 and about 30, give or take a few years. None of these things are really, you know, have hard numbers associated with them. But roughly between 25 and 30, people start freaking out about, okay, I'm I've been out of college a few years or I've been on my career path a few years and now I've got to go and become a real adult and I'm not sure

SPEAKER_00that I'm doing it right. And it's very common and I definitely went through it. I was in an early marriage and I left it at 26 and a half. And as I write in my memoir, I felt like I had been living a lie, although I didn't know what the truth was.

SPEAKER_01And so I had to figure that out.

SPEAKER_00And so, you know, I kind of threw over the game board of my life. And it turns out that's not very unique, that a lot of young adults start over, take new chances, try to figure out, try to reconfigure their career path, their life path. Mm-hmm.

SPEAKER_00Including, you know, from people in their late 20s and early 30s and also lots of people much older who said, I remember turning 30 and it was a big deal and it freaked me out. So that's part of why Oldster is not just about people who are old by our culture's standards. Yeah. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01I remember, for me, it was 26 that was difficult. Ah. Not bad. I felt like 26, I had to pretend to be an adult at 26. I don't know why.

SPEAKER_00I felt like I was pretending to be an adult when I married at 23. I was like play acting what I thought an adult was. I didn't know that. I didn't know I was doing that. When you're that young, you are so impressionable. And you are so eager to make the right impression that you make some wacky choices. What were you doing at 26?

SPEAKER_01I was living in New York on the Upper West Side. And I sold my first cartoon in the New Yorker when I was 24, I think, or 25. So I had a job at the National History Museum. In the art department, which was a great job, but I wanted to be a cartoonist. So it was at that point, actually, it was at the point where I, should I quit my job? I sold it to the New Yorker. Is that a good reason to quit my job?

SPEAKER_00I didn't right away, but I did eventually. So, yeah,

SPEAKER_01I mean, I was, I think with, I don't know, I always wanted to be a cartoonist, so it was not,

SPEAKER_00You weren't in the right place. Yeah. Yeah. Well, you followed, so you followed your, you know, your heart and you wound up a cartoonist. That's pretty cool.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Lucky sort of, not more than luck, but just persistence. And I don't know where that came from. I guess it just, I had a good upbringing that people, my parents made me feel I could do anything I wanted and I feel like I benefited, I'm older than you are, but I feel like I benefited from the hippie wave. I was too young to be a hippie,

SPEAKER_01but there was a feeling, even though it was just a feeling, it really wasn't true yet, that women could do whatever they want. Yeah. A certain demographic, of course, I'm talking about.

SPEAKER_00Right. And that was like the having it all years. That was like the, yeah, we can have it all. I mean, you can have things. You can't have them all.

SPEAKER_01So what kind of things does Ulster publish? Do you find people are stereotyping Ulster

SPEAKER_00as something for older people? Sometimes I think that some younger people don't get what it's about. But also I sometimes struggle to have older people Except that I include younger people. For a while, anytime I would feature anyone like under 68, they would, you know, kind of go nuts on me. And at the time, you know, early in Oldster's existence, I was, you know, 56.

SPEAKER_00And I would say, well, I'm 56 and I make this magazine and I'm interested in everyone's experience of getting older because I I'm just curious about everyone's experience and how it relates to mine and how it doesn't. I've mostly gotten the audience to I have a very popular feature called the Oldster Magazine questionnaire. It publishes on Wednesdays and every week I feature someone else.

SPEAKER_00But whether it's a personal essay or an interview or a comment that someone leaves, I have people talking about their experience of getting older in their own words. And I'm, you know, it's like a collection. It's like, in a way, Oldster is kind of like a study for me. I'm studying aging. Like, what is it about? Because I'm curious about it. And I have been actually since I was 10 because, and this is what I've told a million times,

SPEAKER_00but my uncle came to my 10th birthday party and the first thing he said to me was, wow, you'll never be one digit again. And it was just like, whoa, you know. It began this obsession for me of, you know, am I on track? Should I be doing something different at this age? What are other people doing? What are other people feeling? And so that's where it comes from for me. Yeah, so I mostly more than like I'm not really doing service journalism except

SPEAKER_00a little bit I'm recommending books. Yeah. And I'll also occasionally publish a study that I've read, about a study that I've read, or I'll interview someone who conducted a study, that kind of thing. But mostly it's not service journalism. I find that can be really flat. I really just want us to learn from other people's experiences. In the same way that I love memoir, and I also publish Memoirland, I prefer...

SPEAKER_00People's personal stories to self-help, you know, that kind of thing. But I'm also trying to highlight the possibilities later in life that our culture doesn't want you to know about. And every now and then someone will accuse me of being toxically positive. But I also, because of that, I also try to include people's difficult experiences. And yeah. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01That's funny, toxically positive, because I think I could be accused of that as well. What I love in Substack is the comments. I have mine set so that only paid subscribers can comment. So it's become a community of people that they give me their thoughts about what I'm writing about. And they give me their thoughts about my cartoons and how their cartoons make them think about somebody in their life or some episode in their life or And they'll tell me that they don't think it's funny,

SPEAKER_01which is helpful to hear too. So I love that kind of exchange with people because that's what, for me, that's what it's all about. Cartoon and writing is about interacting with other people and sharing what your life experience is about.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I really enjoy that too. And that's kind of where I'm coming from as a The person who publishes Memoirland and who has worked with memoir and personal essay for so long, and I've brought that over to Oldster. Yeah. Yeah. I just love people sharing their personal experiences. And most of the time it goes well. Every now and then people have harsh reactions to other people's experiences.

SPEAKER_00And that's a little difficult for me to engage with. But It is what it is. It's a community. And in communities, there are sometimes challenges and conflicts. For sure.

SPEAKER_01So let me turn this back over to the drawing. Oh, yeah. Tell me. In anticipation of talking to you about Ulster, really, and trying to understand what you're doing. And I love one of the things you say on your website, on the site, is all of us are as old. There's never been in any given time. So when you're 27, you've never been 27 before. So you're trying to figure it out. When you're 61, you've never been 61 before.

SPEAKER_01So I think that's so true and so fascinating. It's a great way to look at it.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I try to point out to people like everyone here is the oldest we've ever been. And so wherever you are on the timeline of a life, you feel old. The numbers sound like you don't necessarily feel old. Sometimes the number doesn't jibe with how you feel. Right. I mean, I still feel like I

SPEAKER_01still feel 40 or even 27. So I don't know. So here's the drawing. It's two women at a bar, obviously. And here's some of the captions that I came up with. And I don't know if I'm being... I'll just read them. Okay. First one is... And they're not in order of preference. They're just in order of how I thought of them. If I were younger, I would not be able to handle getting older. Oh, good. Thank you.

SPEAKER_01Aging is not for the young. Okay. Next one is, the only people who can handle aging are older people. I'm just tapping on wisdom, you know, as you get wisdom. So you feel like you could, 26, I would not have, I didn't even dream I'd ever be 70. So you have the wisdom to handle being 70. And then you look at people older than you and you get wisdom from them too. And then finally, I thought of the phrase, youth may be wasted on the young.

SPEAKER_01But aging is best handled by the old.

SPEAKER_00Oh, I like that one a lot. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01I think what I'll do is I'll post the drawing and I'll post all these captions on there and see what people think.

SPEAKER_00Oh, that's a great idea.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, let people vote. Yeah. I don't really like caption contests, but that's not what this is. It's just like a dialogue. It's like, let's talk.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's interactive.

SPEAKER_01Let's see what we like.

SPEAKER_00People think it works. And I love the drawing and I love the captions. Yeah. Oh, good. Thank you. Thank you so much. That was really fun.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. That was really fun. The other thing, I guess we're at 30 minutes now. Yeah. So we can wrap up by talking about, let's see what people are saying first. Aging is not for the sissy. Yeah. I've heard that before. Aging is not for the weak. Yeah. Positivity is so big and I'm broad, but I also have deep pain. Yeah. Joy can sit right next to grief. So true, Rebecca. Yep.

SPEAKER_00It's really complex. Like any life experience, getting older

SPEAKER_01is really complex. Oh, it's crazy. And then you have to have a lot of conversations with your body too because it's not doing what it used to do. Longevity is different for everyone. I'm 42, but my family doesn't. It's so variable. It's so variable. And it's so interesting to me to hear the range of experiences. Mm-hmm.

SPEAKER_00The work I succeed with most and best is when I follow my curiosity and my anxiety, the combination of both. So when I was leaving New York City and did not want to be leaving New York City, and then once I was living upstate, I had this anxiety about, like, should I be still living in New York City? Should I have found a way to stay there? And so that anxiety and curiosity about other people's experiences led to a book. And the same thing led to Oldster.

SPEAKER_00What's everyone else's experience of getting older? I'm so interested in everyone's various experiences.

SPEAKER_01And again, that's what we have in common. Maybe all writers are like this, but that's what cartooning is. It's curiosity. Yeah. And wanting to understand other people and

SPEAKER_00how they live their

SPEAKER_01lives. And, um, cause that's, it's just fascinating.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. And I'm so fascinated to see how you work and how quickly, how quickly you drew that. That's amazing. Well, thank you.

SPEAKER_01Um, all right. Well, I guess let's just wrap it up there. We'll post this on our respective sites, follow Sari on her various publications. And I have just one. So, um, You guys know you're here because you subscribe. And what else can I say? I think that's it.

SPEAKER_00That sounds great. And we live near each other. So hopefully one of these days we can cross paths up here in the Mid-Hudson Valley.

SPEAKER_01Definitely. Yeah. And we should talk also about New York and leaving New York. I haven't completely left New York. I'm there half the time in the city. But I think we share a Yeah,

SPEAKER_00yeah. Sounds good. All right. Thanks, everybody, for being here. See you later. Bye. Bye.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Live Drawing: Politics and Ducks and Therapists and Purple Umbrellas!

    Nov 13, 202630 minAudio

    During the video, we talked politics for a while (go Mississippi and Scott Colom!), and then I drew. Before we started, the only thing I had in mind to draw was an umbrella. I drew this below and jotted down some words...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Live with Liza On Election Night!

    Nov 4, 202626 minAudio

    Thank you Ellen Newhouse, Doosh Dooshenberg, TMJ, KIMBERLY K CUETO, Mary-Chilton van Hees, and many others for tuning into my live video! Here is the drawing I did live today, of the poll workers as I remember them, at...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Live Drawing (And No Newsing) with Liza !

    Sep 18, 202615 minAudio

    Thank you Robert Kalman, Laura Register, Lora Simmons, and many others for tuning into my live video! Join me for my next live video in the app. Get full access to Seeing Things at lizadonnelly.substack.com/subscribe

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Live with Liza: Drawing and Newsing

    Aug 14, 202617 minAudio

    Thank you to everyone who tuned into my live video! Join me for my next live video in the app. Get full access to Seeing Things at lizadonnelly.substack.com/subscribe

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Liza Live, Drawing and Newsing

    Aug 5, 202626 minAudio

    Get full access to Seeing Things at lizadonnelly.substack.com/subscribe

    Credit the people on this episode