Time travel shows up in Halloween Town, and suddenly Sally’s job as Pumpkin Queen gets a lot more complicated. We wanted a sequel that lets her stand on her own, not just as “Jack’s partner,” but as a leader with real judgment, real scars, and real power. So we dig into The Hour of the Pumpkin Queen by Megan Shepard, the second book in Disney Publishing’s Nightmare Before Christmas-inspired YA fantasy romance trilogy, and talk about what hits and what slips. We get into the big themes the story keeps circling: trauma, belonging, and identity. Sally’s past with Dr. Finkelstein isn’t treated like a throwaway detail, and we call out content notes for listeners who prefer a heads-up. Then we follow the book’s biggest swing, time travel and Father Time, plus the new realms and characters that still feel like they belong in a Tim Burton flavored world, including stops like Timetown and Fabletown. Then we go honest on the craft. Some of the structure feels like a repeat of book one, and when the “big reveal” arrives, the villain’s motive doesn’t carry the weight the story builds toward. We also talk about how repeatedly pulling Sally back into the same doubts can flatten her growth, and we compare our take with a few Goodreads reviews that noticed the same patterns. If you love The Nightmare Before Christmas and you want more Sally, we think this one is worth the ride, with a 3.5-star verdict and hope the third book pushes bigger. Subscribe, leave a review, and share the show with a friend, then tell us: what do you want Sally’s next chapter to be? Hey there, podcast pals! Need a morning boost? Look no further than Dunkin' Donuts! Our freshly brewed coffee and irresistible donuts are the perfect way to kick-start your day. From classic favorites to new flavors, there's something for everyone. Join DD Perks for exclusive rewards with every purchase. Swing by your nearest Dunkin' today and treat yourself to something special. Dunkin' Delights - making mornings brighter, one sip at a time! Want more of Second Emulation? Stay connected with us by following our social media channels! By clicking the link below to stay up to date with us on our socials and Game review streaming channel. https://www.arcadeveritas.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Hi, hello, welcome to Second Emulation. Okay, you're just so lucky right now because you are literally about to spend like the best time with my amazing friend Sean. He is like the expert on all things movies, anime, and gaming, and he just has like the best opinions. Seriously, talking to him is like a whole thing. In the best way. So get comfy, maybe with a little drink, I don't know, a kombucha, a latte, whatever is your thing, because Sean is going to take you on like a total journey.
SPEAKER_01Okay, love that. Here he is.
SPEAKER_00Welcome to Second Emilation Podcast, where we dissect books like A Book Club of One. I'm Sean, and today we're going to be unraveling the Hour of the Puckpin Queen by Megan Shepard, this fantasy young adult fiction Halloween romance retelling novel. It is a second installment in a book trilogy based around the nightmare before Christmas movie, which is that a long time ago, and it follows the adventures of Sally.
SPEAKER_00Let's get into it. Now I chose this book because it is a sequel to Long Live the Pumpkin Queen, which I didn't really expect that they were going to do or a continuation. I thought Long Live the Pumpkin Queen was going a standalone, isolated story, which served as a sequel to the film, which I would have been perfectly fine with. It wasn't until I went on to Libby, and then I saw that there indeed was a sequel, not just a sequel, but there's going to be a trilogy.
SPEAKER_00So that very much piqued my interest, and I had to again get the audiobook and listen to it. And mind you, I am a big nightmare before Christmas fan. So this did really f you know fulfill me in that light. And another story involving Sally and her progression as a continuation from the prior book is very much needed.
SPEAKER_00Now we the difference I feel with these books is that it is a continuation that that is to be said and another progression of who she is as a character. But I do that is a it is a sequel and it's building upon that. And I I love I love that they're going in that direction. Which is also like we're in an era where nostalgia is becoming a great way for profit, and certain companies that fall you know don't know how to capitalize on that.
SPEAKER_00And we have the bucks that if you just give us what we want, we will pay for it. And nostalgia, I know some people might be burned out on it, but yeah, nostalgia makes money, it's one of those things, and yeah, Night Before Christmas is a big IP, and there's a lot of fans behind it that would definitely pay money. Not for this book, but if him Burton decided he wanted to utilize this to make a sequel, I'm sure people would flock to theaters.
SPEAKER_00It was published in July of 2025 by Disney Publishing Book. The book has about 368 pages, paperback, and a kind of fun backstory. New York Times best-selling author Megan Shepard grew up in her family's independent bookstore in the Blue Ridge Mountains. She is the author of several young adult and middle grade novels. She now lives and writes on a 220-year-old farm outside of Asheville, North Carolina, with her husband and two cats, and her especially scruffy dog.
SPEAKER_00Which it didn't dawn on me until I actually got the audiobook and purchased the physical book itself, that this was two different writers, which I did also look into when the third book is going to be coming out, and Megan Shepard is going to is publishing or writing the third book. So to put everyone's mind at ease, I thought that going forward they were gonna have a separate writer for each installment.
SPEAKER_00That is not the case. I don't know what may have occurred that maybe the writer for the first book wasn't going to be available for the second or third. Maybe contracts were different, they couldn't have her available, who knows? But I can confirm that this for this the C the second and the third, it is going to be Megan Shepard. I just was not aware that it was a different writer for this one and the third book.
SPEAKER_00And I don't know if it's going to stop just three. I'm hoping it doesn't. I feel like Sally's story could continue beyond just three books. But some other content notes, and it adds up on some themes that there are some themes that kind of carry over from the first book, which is trauma, especially with Sally herself of just emotional trauma of Stockholm syndrome.
SPEAKER_00We do know that because of Sally was a prisoner or a captain of Dr. Fingelstein, and kind of like being an Indian indentred servant to him, which we kind of get more of a backstory in the Long Live the Pumpkin Queen, she does carry some of that trauma of realizing who she is in the first book, and that's more evident in the second book of her kind of dealing with who she is and that trauma that she's dealing with of the person who was her oppressor for all this time in the field of Night Before Christmas.
SPEAKER_00And I do think that type of story or that type of story element was something that needs to be addressed. And I do they I do like how they handle it for Sally's character, even though she is fictional, but the way she kind of addresses it and kind of tries to handle it and how it kind of pops up at different points in the story, it is triggering sometimes because we still for we still kind of brush it off a little bit that in Nine Move Before Christmas we kind of brush it off to the fact that she is a prisoner or an indentured servant to Dr.
SPEAKER_00Finkelstein. And spoilers for those who don't haven't read the first book, we find out later that she was abducted or taken from another land and not brought to Halloween town and she remained there for the remainder of her existence and was subjugated to forget where she came from by drinking the soup and stuff like that.
SPEAKER_00So like we we get those notes and stuff where she's torn between these two different places and having to decide where she belongs, and then you throw in the themes of like belonging, trauma, and then time travel. I think it's a big trigger in this having to go back if you can reset and kind of eliminate the things that were done and start fresh.
SPEAKER_00You kind of you throw that into a mix, and I feel like this story and this the themes in this book particular kind of I feel with a lot of pressure on Sally, which I feel like I think from where she's been to where she's at does a lot. So for those who don't know, those are like some type type of triggers, and it still does deal with that, and that's some contact notes I feel like should be aware when we read it.
SPEAKER_00Not they're not very heavy handling, but they do pop up. So I feel like those are some things that it need to be addressed that she still deals with. First impressions, I think, more so of we find out or we learn how Sally is fitting into the role of queen of Halloween Town. She's more comfortable in this role because the first book she was unsure of how what her role was and how to really navigate that because these were things that Jack did, and he was the king, and so she knew everything to do and say, but now she's the one that everyone goes to for advice, and she's the one who's organizing, and she's the one that everyone looks up to, and she's delegating, so it's very different from the force book, and I feel like that's the impression that we're getting is that this is not the same Sally that we're seeing from the movie, you know, not before Christmas.
SPEAKER_00The inkling is still there that she's still brave, but I feel like the foundations of what we found in the movie and the first book these are built upon. We are seeing her kind of step into that role and being someone that can be relied on, as someone that Jack himself can depend on, because Jack was the one who had to be the defender of the realm for the most part, and the one that even Oogie Boogie fears for the most part, and now based on her actions on the previous book, she can also be disdependent on, and I like how she is also learning to be a diplomat amongst the different realms and doing cultural exchanges, so she's also allowing the cultural exchanges from different holidays and them coming.
SPEAKER_00She's done a lot. So I think the biggest impression for this book is that we're seeing a big leap of what were the growth in Sally then when we first left off from her from the film, and then the prior book, we're seeing a huge level and growth in her character, which I think is very impressive.
SPEAKER_00She was so unsure of herself that she could even f even be next to Jack, let alone stand beside him. And then in the book, long Long Live the Pumpkin Queen, she wasn't even sure that she could even be a be a the queen herself and even do anything to help delegate or defend Halloween town. So I I do like her character growth, and that's what we're seeing.
SPEAKER_00I do like also we're interested we're interested into some new characters and themes. So this one, the previous book was Dreams and The Sandman. This one is time travel and father time. So this one was a a big kind of interesting thing that were being introduced of time travel, so and how that plays into the overarching, like interconnecting of all worlds and her world as well.
SPEAKER_00So I thought that's pretty cool of how they're using that amongst her world, how time traveling works, and also again, her own trauma, like her identity is also being introduced as well. Does she want to still be queen? Does she still want this life, or does she want to go back to her organic home, her dream land? And the characters that were introduced, like it still brings on we're it kind of makes fits in the realm like a Tin Burton film.
SPEAKER_00Almost we're introduced into some new characters that you would see in this world. They're nothing that would be in the realm of pot like out of the world or possibility, so they would fit perfectly. So like the holiday worlds, another land, like another realm. So like everything would fit perfectly here. And the writing style, I want to say, is almost identical and a little bit like I felt like it to me didn't feel any different from the first book.
SPEAKER_00But then again, I listened to the audio, so the audio book from Barnes Noble, so I couldn't really tell the difference. But then I'm sure those who maybe take up the physical and read it, maybe they could have pointed out like certain cues and things that might have been different to them. But me personally, since I listened to it, I can't tell the difference at all. I very well enjoyed it. To me, it still felt to the realm like if you wouldn't have told me Magnus Brad wrote this, I probably would have still assumed that the prior author had written it.
SPEAKER_00And we'll still enjoy it in the same regardless. Because I feel like the tone still matched to the prior book and to the film. So I think Ronnie Styles pretty on par with the prior book, to me personally. What didn't work? I felt like even though I love it, I felt like the author still tried to follow the same pacing as the original book and beginning, middle, end, and try to do like a big reveal.
SPEAKER_00The kind of when it got to the climax, it didn't carry the same type of weight, or if you were looking for like a big kind of like who done it type of thing. The big reveal or that type of moment, I felt like when you get to that point, it kind of loses its kind of loses all its power because not gonna spoil it, but when it gets to the reveal of how to the climax of this book of what how why who is forcing Sally to go onto this adventure, putting her through time and making her do all these things to get to this point.
SPEAKER_00When the reveal of the villain behind this is revealed, it kind of just loses weight. And then you find the motives of who's making him do this, her do this. It kind of just isn't that big of a deal because it the motives seem lessen to them. And like more so the the Sandman seemed more threatening in the first book than what was occurring in this the sequel.
SPEAKER_00So I feel like the risks and the danger weren't of a threat in this book than they were in the first one. Because, yeah, they were dealing with time and time travel, but those could have been easily dealt with when the culprit of it, it wasn't something like it wasn't someone the big bad villain that they were that they revealed to put Sally on this path didn't really have an actual motive, is what I'm saying.
SPEAKER_00Is that when they reveal them and then they actually explain it, the motive seemed weak. It's like you did all this for this. So, like I do the book as a whole, but this one point just seemed very weak. It made it seem like everything that happened could have just been a wash. So that point I feel like it didn't really work. And if you just take out that one character, then the book itself would have been perfect because then everything would have been fine.
SPEAKER_00Just for like that one character didn't work. Like once you get to that point in the book and everything gets revealed, if you remove him, then it's per then it's all then it's perfectly fine. And I feel like that's like you you try to they try to make it feel sympathy for this it, this one individual character, and it's like, okay, whatever. So that's one thing I feel like didn't work. It's like the big bad at the end, his motives didn't work.
SPEAKER_00Another thing I felt like also was it tools that they kept doing I feel like didn't need to work. Also like letting me know, or in the book, letting the readers know, hey, Sally is dealing with drama, like trauma, and having to retell the reader, like, hey, she's dealing with this, we know that. Having so like moments where she's like she's having to have those moments resurface and letting the readers know, okay, she's dealing with these moments, we get that.
SPEAKER_00Like, I just felt like, yeah, there were tools to help progress the story, but to bring those back kind of diminished the growth of her character if you're trying to revert her back to the weak version of herself, the timid version of herself, and have her question, like, oh, all the things that she's done. Because she is a strong, independent woman, heroine character.
SPEAKER_00She has feats and accolades that she's done and overcome those trauma, but have to bring to keep bringing those back and kind of threshing them in her face every time and have her question those things. I felt like it was kind of like doing a disservice for her, for Sally. Yeah. Fingelstein was an asshole, but having putting he is an asshole, don't get me wrong, but having moments where she had to remember those things every time she doubted herself, bringing him up every fucking time, and then having her have like moments of weakness every time and remember him.
SPEAKER_00Years have come about, like, years have gone by. We don't know how long between the set the first and second book have gone by, but she is a very strong person, and yeah, she might have moments of uh weaknesses, but to keep using that as like a way to show that she hasn't had any growth, I feel like diminishes her character and all things that she's done in the previous book.
SPEAKER_00So I feel like that for me didn't work because anytime something comes up or she comes into a challenge and she can't overcome it, are we just gonna keep referring? She just gonna keep looking back and then just remembering Fingelstein and everything like a quote or have a Flashback of when he treated her like shit, and then just have that as being a memory. Because that's not something cool, but that's not something I want to be reminded every time.
SPEAKER_00Like, we know we get it, we know that. Like he he was a bad person, and he's paying for it, but like I don't want to be reminded that he's a shit person every time she comes into a challenge and she has to question herself because she's beyond him. Like she even says she's no longer shackled by him. Like she there's moments where she's even tells herself that she's she no longer needs to be held down by this individual, but yet in the book, there's moments where she has memories, flashbacks, like a flashback of him, and whether it's a small conversation where he might not be as being a dick, or they might have a conversation where he's in type, you know, so he just talking, but in his tone might be like some form of superiority.
SPEAKER_00It's just Dr. Fingelsen is just a dick in general. And I think as long as we you know, if they keep using him in an aspect to like as a tool for her family or whatever, she comes across something and just using him to like as a cattle prod to like push her to overcome something, I don't think it's the best. I don't think it works. And so that's like my only gripe about it is that I don't like having that as a tool in the story.
SPEAKER_00And to me, it doesn't work for me. Now let's hear from fellow readers on Goodreads. I picked three reviews that stuck out to me. Number one is gonna be from user Jessica McGee. She writes, This was a cutish, honestly. I just think I'm too old for this one. Long live the pumpkin queen was adorable. But I think the original is what made me love it. This is kind of more of the same, but with new characters, so it's cute, just a little repetitive.
SPEAKER_00It's a quick read, so it wasn't too it wasn't a total waste of time. Like I told my fiance, if I was in the fifth or sixth grade, I probably would have loved this. And I agree with her. Again, it it was like the same rinse and repeat type of model for this book, copying the first one, a little repetitive. I feel like they didn't do anything different. I feel like they didn't challenge themselves, so I have to agree with Jessica on this one that I kind of wish that they did a little bit more.
SPEAKER_00Now, again, I don't know if the based on the new author is at how much time did they have to actually write the book, and did they already have a theme and everything that they wanted them to write from? So I don't know what the what happened in the in the background that brought this story along to where we got what we got as a final finished product.
SPEAKER_00Review comes from either I'm not a centipede, they wrote This was a pretty average book, which is also how I felt about the previous one as well. I will admit that I enjoyed the author of the first book's writing style and voice more than this author, but I did admit that they have very similar styles, so the story doesn't feel disjointed picking this up. This reader nailed it, and I have to agree with the them on this one because it's a different author, I felt like they had to either follow the same tone for the sequel for the second book, so that not everyone would be confused that it's a new writer for the sequel and be turned off from it so that you can get the new the second book out.
SPEAKER_00And it felt like everything felt diff like the same, so I don't know what's gonna happen with the third book. I would it be like the same writing stone, or hopefully that they're gonna change, expand it up the story a bit, get us more, hopefully not keep the same running tone, expand it, change it up a bit. It felt very safe. The tone was very safe, and I didn't want that, to be honest. I wanted it to expand. If she had a different tone, it probably would have worked a little bit better for her and not caught it felt very mimic.
SPEAKER_00So but yeah, I guess in this context, it I guess it it was best that it didn't have a different style because then the story would have been off, so I do agree with him on that part. This was a good sequel to Long Live the Puffin Queen. I really love traveling to Timetown and Pabletown.
SPEAKER_00Were these two rattles, please, but I didn't enjoy the repetitive of a lot of the central themes that we already saw in the first book. Sally had already gone through her identity crisis in the first book and finding the place that she belonged. We didn't need to go through it again. Let's discuss this in the comments. I agree, and that's kind of and I agree with this as a user, and that's kind of what I also had an issue with in my kind of like my earlier review, was that I had an issue with this in the book, was that they kept bringing that back as a tool to progress the story, like her identity issue and her trauma.
SPEAKER_00Like she wrote she's already dealt with this and she's already resolved it in the first book. Now, I could understand if there was a villain that maybe wanted to use this against her, and that she had to had a mental break, fine, I get it. In this book, there was no such big bad who knew her, who couldn't manipulate her, or who used that against her. They just kept utilizing that or have her dealing with where she belonged in her trauma.
SPEAKER_00Does she belong here? Does she belong there? Like, where does she belong? And then just having that question hang over her again, which she was already she had already dealt with that in the previous book. And so hopefully with this one, she dates to watch it again, because the third book comes out and hopefully I think in July or August. And I hopefully the same, hopefully the repentance of the same issue is not seen again in the third book, because if it is, then it they just don't know how to write female heroines at this point.
SPEAKER_00That is the only thing that you know a strong character like Sally is, and yes, Sally is a strong heroine character. She is strong enough to stand side by side with Jack Scotton of Pumpkin King. He is a strong character, and she's able to stand next to him, her fighting capabilities, her intellect, her she is strong, which is why she also holds the title as queen and him as king.
SPEAKER_00If they if the author doesn't realize that and still use the same tactics of the divisiveness of just she has still has to deal this torment where she belongs, then they just don't know how to write Sally. Then everything that she's gone through is just a wash, then they're openly admitting that she is not, she is just a timid character.
SPEAKER_00They are admitting that she is not a strong character, that she is she is need she needs saving. If she can't deal with where like where she belongs, then they're just straight up just saying, you know what, then she is not great as a character. If they keep utilizing that type of device again in the next book, of saying that if she's torn and she doesn't know where she belongs between Dreamtown and Halloween Town, because they can't use that again, or her trauma.
SPEAKER_00So I hope that we don't have to deal with that prep yes again. If it does, I it it'd be pointless. It the it felt like it was it was a central theme, as the Heli Alchemist mentioned. It was a central theme of it. It took more focus of anything else, and it was pointless. And I get it, they were using that again, but it cannot be the main focus of the book when you're dealing with the synopsis of Time Town and Fable Town, like all these other things.
SPEAKER_00It can't be when you're introducing other characters and other towns, you can't have your main heroine be dealing with the same shit again. It doesn't work, it just eliminates all of the character progression. So, yes, this user nailed the head, nailed it the nail on the head hard this time, and I'm glad that they were able to see it. And looks like a lot of the users that I picked for the reviews, a lot of them could see that a lot of what I was saying when I read the book or listened to the book was pretty there.
SPEAKER_00It was pretty evident, and hopefully with the third book, it doesn't show up. I'm hoping it doesn't show up because it would do the book a disservice and Sally a disservice if they keep using the same story pots again. Now, who should read it? So if you're a fan of Night There Before Christmas, I feel like if you read Long of the Pumpkin Queen, this is a good book to read as a sequel.
SPEAKER_00Again, it does have its shortcomings, and it is the second installment to a trilogy. You might as well read this and gear up for the next book, which is gonna be coming out, I believe, in August. Don't want me to have to double check. But the next book will be coming out soon. So I feel like nightmare before Christmas, rejoice. But if you're a fan of this type of book or night before Christmas, this should be a good book for you to read.
SPEAKER_00The verdict. So I'm gonna give this a three and a half stars. Now, three and a half is really good. It did have some shortcomings for the book, and again, a lot of those had to do with just repetitive central themes of just things that were utilized in the first book that were resolved, and just bring those plot points up again in the second book. Now, if again, if those did not occur, then I would have given it a four, maybe a possible five.
SPEAKER_00But the book itself is a 3.5, still pretty good. Again, I feel like we are getting a third book, which I'm very hope for. But yeah, my rating for this is gonna be a 3.5 going forward. Good story for the most part, a good sequel to what I feel like is gonna be a grand sequel to a Nine Remember for Christmas movie.
SPEAKER_00So I'm very excited. Final thoughts. Don't have much final thoughts. I yeah, I do like you can find I found this book on Libby on audio. You can find it at Barnes and Noble's, any bookstore. You could probably get it on an Audible if you like the audio version. Pre-orders for the next book is coming out soon, so if you like the physical book, you can. I recently got the I think it's the collector edition of the of this book, which I thought was pretty nice.
SPEAKER_00It's very hardcover. The pages are like go-tattened. I thought it was very well done. I might have to get like a just a standard regular book, because I don't think I'm gonna read it, but it's something I'm gonna use to just have a cult to collect. But yes. I think the artwork for this book is pretty nice. I'm am going to go in probably pre-order the third book.
SPEAKER_00I am very excited. I am excited that Barnes and Nobles is doing pre-orders. I don't know if they're doing midnight releases. I will have to ask, but I am excited. I don't know, book guys are a thing, but I am a Barnes and Nobles member and I do collect and buy books. A lot of my books are through Barnes Nobles audio and through Libby.
SPEAKER_00I am very selective with my book buying through physical media because I have very limited space. So if I do buy many physical books, it's very selective and it's for collected collection per purchases or purposes. And if I do, I get the e I get an ebook version of it. So I'll get uh an ebook, audio, and physical for collection. So those are my final thoughts.
SPEAKER_00So I've been very happy going to my local Barnes and Nobles bookstore, and I've been very happy to actually read this book. Right now, as final thoughts, I am reading Nosferatu. I don't know if that's that's my current read right now. There's a few other books are on my book list. I have to go to Barnes and Nobles and get their whatever their current read book list is because I'm running out of books to read.
SPEAKER_00So there's that. I do want to thank you for tuning in to this episode of Second Emulation. If you enjoyed the show, don't forget to subscribe, leave a review, share it with your friends. You can also follow along with me on our social media, which will be in the episode description. For more anime recommendation and updates, let me know what your thoughts are of Hour of the Pumpkin Queen, and I'd love to hear your thoughts.
SPEAKER_00And for any more book reviews, you could also, you know, tag us in our social media. I love to hear more recommendations. So if you're you know have any book recommendations as well as gonna make recommendations, you know, you know, shoot us you know a message on our social media. We have a website that's gonna be in our in the social in our episode description, but the website's going to be arcadeveriktos.com.
SPEAKER_00And once you go to that website, you'll see you'll be brought to our media hub, which is gonna show our Goodreads page, and you'll be able to follow along with what are what books I'm reading, uh, you know, and recommend books as well. We're also going to be trying to start up a book club. So if that is something that is of interest of you, let us know, and we'll you know, try to, you know, get that going.
SPEAKER_00Not sure when that's going to be, but we are in the process of maybe doing a book club of some sort where we can all read books together. All right. Thank you for listening, and I'll catch you in the next one. Bye.
1A rom-com anime about an otaku and two “gals” sounds like it’s headed straight for recycled tropes, but the first episode of Gals Can’t Be Kind to Otaku surprised me in the best way. Instead of leaning on cringe fan...
100 million yen shows up in the mail, and suddenly your life becomes a test of how well you can lie. That’s the hook that pulled us into Liar Game, a new drama suspense anime from Madhouse directed by Asami Kawana, and...
A “hero” who’s forbidden to die sounds powerful until you realize it’s a punishment. We jump into Sentenced to Be a Hero, the new action adventure fantasy anime from Studio Kai, and unpack why its hour-long premiere...
Nicolas Cage as Spider-Noir should not work this well, and that’s exactly why we had to talk about it. We’re still moving through Cage’s filmography, but this time we detour into TV with Amazon Prime’s Spider-Noir and...
A wish-granting app sounds like a shortcut to everything you want, until it comes with a timer you can’t stop. Sean digs into Netflix’s new Korean mystery drama horror series If Wishes Could Kill, where the Promising...