Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Second Brain Podcast

Second Brain Podcast artwork

🎧 Why I still cook with seed oils (audio version)

Jul 18, 202619 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

In this week’s Second Brain newsletter, I cover the best evidence behind seed oils and your health, in a 19 minute deep dive. Every few weeks, the audio version is free for everyone. This is one of those! If you’d like access to both the full previous audio issues, and of course the future ones too, you can upgrade to paid at the button below. Chat soon, Emily xx This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit dremilyleeming.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Hi, I'm Dr Emily, nutrition and gut microbiome researcher, and this is the audio version of this week's Second Brain newsletter. This one is free for everyone, there's no paywall, and I'm finally tackling seed oils, the ones you've probably been told to bin, and what the best research actually shows, including which oils I cook with at home. One quick aside before we start, so twice a year I step away from Second Brain, and next week is one of those weeks where So instead of finding me knee-deep

SPEAKER_00in research papers, I'll be hiking across the Lake District. I take these breaks because I need them. Nature gives me time to slow down, recharge, and a chance to be grateful for all the small things in life that are already all around us. And of course, return refreshed and inspired. If you leave a comment before I go, I'll try to get back to you. And if I miss you, I'll reply as soon as I'm home. And next week's newsletter will be a roundup of some of my favourite previous posts rather than the usual deep dive.

SPEAKER_00I'll be retreading the steps of my grandmother who passed away over 10 years ago. She'd take me up to the fells as a child and teach me to water paint rocks, sheep and the sun shimmering across the lakes. When we got back we'd always have sticky toffee pud slathered in gooey rich caramel sauce and it's still my favourite to this day. Now back to seed oils. This is a topic that I have been avoiding writing about because honestly, I was a little bit hesitant to.

SPEAKER_00Not hesitant about the science, no, but what happens when you say you're not anti-seed oils out loud? And I say this from experience, from seeing others torn down from sticking their head above the parapet, And when I had my own small taster last year, when I posted back my Daily Mail column, busting the myths that seed oils are inflammatory. Cue a mob-like pile-on, not a conversation, just who could shout the loudest, tear down my credibility, question my motives, and have the last word.

SPEAKER_00Everything but the science itself. Angling so hard to prove that I'd been bought by big oil, That even my research funding from world-renowned cancer charities became proof I was in on it, because apparently they're in the pocket of big oil too. I do welcome a different opinion and an open, balanced discussion, but this just wasn't that. I can also see why so many of us think that C-laws are harmful, when it's coming at us from every direction, podcasts, headlines and Instagram.

SPEAKER_00And normally when most people are saying one thing and a few are saying another, I'd be one of the first to say that's roughly where the truth tends to sit. But this is one of those cases where it's not. Because in the best studies we have, seed oils are tied to lower rates of disease, not higher. So if you've binned your canola or rapeseed oil, or swapped it for butter or tallow thinking that's a safer choice, this is exactly why it matters. Here's what the research actually shows, including which oils I cook with at home.

SPEAKER_00It's a long one, so feel free to skip to the end if you want to get straight to it. Before we get into the why, one thing you can do today is eat more omega-3s. Aim for oily fish at least once or twice a week, so think SMASH. S-M-A-S-H, that stands for Salmon, Mackerel, Anchovies, Sardines and Herring. Or try adding in an extra handful of walnuts or a spoonful or two

SPEAKER_00of ground flax seeds every day. So, seed oils. Highly processed equals toxic. Extra virgin olive oil, you can picture the olive being plucked from the tree. The fruits crushed and the oil carefully collected. For seed oils, so sunflower, rapeseed canola, corn and soybean, the process is very different and more industrial. The seeds are cleaned,

SPEAKER_00heated and the oil is pressed or drawn out with a solvent called hexane, then refined, bleached and deodorised into a pale neutral liquid. Yes, that does seem unappetising and alarming. But some of it does sound worse than it is. Bleaching isn't bleach, nothing whitening is added. Instead, the oil is passed through a natural clay that soaks up the colour then filtered out. And deodorised is just done by passing steam from water through, carrying off the strong smells.

SPEAKER_00Hexane is the one that's a fairer worry, being a petroleum-derived solvent. Most of it though is driven off during refining. It has a low boiling point, around 65 to 70 degrees Celsius, meaning the heat of those stages evaporates it away, though it may leave a small amount to trace residues. The reassurance is thinner than it looks on the potential impact of those leftover amounts. The US sets no legal ceiling for how much hexane can remain in oil and doesn't require testing for it.

SPEAKER_00The EU caps residues at one milligram per kilo, but the safety testing behind that figure is old and mainly looks at hexane breathed in in factories, not the tiny amounts eaten in food. And a fresh EU review is due in 2027. It's also worth saying that the long-term effects of eating trace hexane residues hasn't been well studied. But as these oils have been eaten and studied for decades, a signal from the trace amounts left behind would have had plenty of time

SPEAKER_00to surface. Until we know more on hexane specifically, it's useful to look at what the research actually says about seed oils and health over time. Do seed oils cause disease? To find cause and effect, we need controlled trials where people are assigned to eat more or less of something and follow to see what happens. People given oils and margarines to cook with, swapping out saturated fat, for example butter, for seed oils, found coronary heart disease events dropped by 19%.

SPEAKER_00That's based on research on eight trials, including over 13,000 people. That's because swapping saturated fat for seed oils improves heart health measures like your cholesterol profile. And again, that's based on 60 controlled studies. What about your metabolic health? When research has pulled 102 trials in over 4,000 people and swapped some of their sugar and starch for the fat that seed oils are rich in, blood sugar control improved and insulin resistance eased, not the reverse.

SPEAKER_00Let's zoom in to a particular type of omega-6 present in seed oils called linoleic acid. Scientists gathered every US study they could find from 1959 to 2008 that measured the levels of linoleic acid in people's body fat. Now, body fat is a slow turnover tissue, so what's stored in it can be a decent record of what someone's been eating for years. The finding is striking and real. The amount of linoleic acid in Americans' body fat has more than doubled over that half century.

SPEAKER_00Closely mirroring the rise in seed oils in the food supply. By the late 2000s our body fat held about 136% more linoleic acid than it did in the 1960s. A clear signal of how our modern eating habits have changed written into our tissues. What it can't tell you and what the study authors honestly don't claim is whether that shift is good, bad or neutral for health. If carrying more linoleic acid were the danger,

SPEAKER_00the people highest in it should fare worse, yet consistently they fare best, linked to lower cardiovascular disease and stroke, and that's across 30 cohorts, lower risk of type 2 diabetes across 20 cohorts, and lower mortality across 44 cohorts and more than 800,000 people at the highest levels. A marker of intake that tracks with less disease and not more.

SPEAKER_00Could it be too much omega-6 and too little omega-3? Both omega-6 and omega-3s are fats your body can't make so you have to eat them. Omega-6 like linoleic acids are found in seed oils whereas you'll find omega-3s in oily fish and in a less easily used form in walnuts and flaxseeds. The theory is that we've evolved eating them in roughly equal amounts, about one to one, and that modern diets have drifted to something more like 15 or 20 parts omega-6

SPEAKER_00to one part omega-3, as we eat more omega-6 and less omega-3. On the surface, yes, a UK study of more than 85,000 people found that a higher ratio, meaning a lot of omega-6 compared to very little omega-3, was linked to a higher risk of dying over the following years. And that result often gets passed around as proof that CEDOLs are the problem. But in the same study, when researchers looked at blood levels of omega-6 and omega-3 on their own,

SPEAKER_00both were linked to living longer, not dying sooner. More omega-6 went with lower risk and so did more omega-3. So that high ratio that looks bad for health It's the low omega-3 that's really being picked up here, not the omega-6. In other words, a high ratio isn't a red flag for omega-6, it's mostly a sign of a low omega-3. So the useful move is the one at the top of this audio newsletter.

SPEAKER_00Topping up your omega-3, making oily fish a weekly priority, or taking an omega-3 supplement. Does linoleic acid cause inflammation? Here's the theory. Critics of CEDAWS point to a biochemical pathway seen in cells and studies on mice and rats, where linoleic acid raises arachidonic acid, the raw material for molecules that drive inflammation. What happens in cells, mice and rats doesn't always translate to humans,

SPEAKER_00and in this case it wasn't simply that rodents and humans are different species, it's also the way these studies were designed. Many of those rodent diets stripped out the other essential fats, then fed linoleic acid against that unnatural background, sometimes at doses far beyond a real human diet. Feed animals a realistic diet with all the fats present and push linoleic acid up across a wide range, and the rise doesn't appear.

SPEAKER_00There's no meaningful change in arachidonic acid, matching what's seen in humans. In reality, the body converts only a tiny fraction of linoleic acid to arachidonic acid, roughly 0.2%. Consistent with this, a systematic review of controlled trials found that increasing dietary linoleic acid up to six-fold produced no meaningful change in tissue arachidonic acid. So the mechanism that was being held up as a problem isn't happening.

SPEAKER_00How does that translate to inflammation in humans? On the best evidence we have, it doesn't. A review of 15 randomized trials found no significant change in a wide range of inflammatory markers. A finding echoed by a meta-analysis of 30 trials in nearly 1400 people And a study of nearly 2,000 people found a higher proportion of linoleic acid in the blood was linked to lower levels of several inflammation markers.

SPEAKER_00It's also too simplistic to call arachidonic acid harmful. The molecules it makes don't just switch inflammation on, some switch it off again. An arachidonic acid itself is a building block your cells, immune system and blood vessels need to work. What about heating seed oils? Is there a danger there? Push any fragile oil hot enough for long enough and it starts to break down and oxidize, forming reactive compounds such as 4-HME.

SPEAKER_00In lab studies, in high enough amounts, they can damage cells and drive inflammation. A quick note, this isn't related to an oil's smoke point. The temperature and oil starts to smoke. The smoke point of an oil is a useful cooking guide where a higher smoke point at a high heat means your kitchen is less likely to feel full of smoke or turn your food bitter, but it's not necessarily related to how easily an oil oxidises. While seed oils tend to have a high smoke point, they are also more prone to oxidation.

SPEAKER_00Because the polyunsaturated fat in them has more of the fragile bonds that oxygen attacks. These compounds build up most with sustained high heat and repeated reheating over multiple hours. The kind more closely resembling oil we use for days in some commercial fryers than home cooking. And a lot of the scary sounding oxidation research in rodents uses oil that's been prepared in a way that just isn't reflective of how we cook in real life. Like being baked low and slow for four weeks straight.

SPEAKER_00That's about as far from a home stir fry as you can get. Standard home cooking times put little into your food and it's repeated reusing the same oil or cooking for very long stretches that can drive the levels up. So if you do fry at home, simply do this instead. Match the oil to the job. For everyday cooking, a quick shallow fry or a saute, any of these oils are fine, seed oils included. If you're cooking for a long time,

SPEAKER_00a more monounsaturated oil like olive or avocado holds up better since it has fewer of the weak spots where oxidation starts. Avoid reusing oil. These compounds build up the more times oil is reheated. So start with a fresh batch each time rather than the same one over and over. Keep the heat medium high or below. The hotter the oil and the longer it's held there, the more of these compounds form. And again, if seed oils were meaningfully harmful here, you'd expect them to track with disease.

SPEAKER_00And on the best evidence we have, they do not. What about the elephant in the room? Some of the confusions around seed oils come from looking at patterns in a population where some studies seem to show that seed oils track with disease. On the surface, it looks like the seed oil is causing harm until you dig a bit deeper. Instead, the seed oils are a marker for ultra-processed foods with seed oils in almost everything ultra-processed from crisps, biscuits, takeaways and ready meals.

SPEAKER_00So as ultra-processed food intake goes up, seed oil intake goes up alongside it. Take the oil out of that pattern and test it on its own in rigorous trial and health markers either remain the same or improve. So it's when the large part of your diet is made up from ultra-processed foods that the real problem and not the seed oils per se as an ingredient. So if you've cut out seed oils and feel better, it's almost certainly because you cut back on the ultra-processed foods they come in and added in more whole foods instead.

SPEAKER_00The oils I cook with. The move the evidence backs isn't finding the perfect oil, it's swapping saturated fats like butter and tallow out for plant oils. Among the plant oils, it's more about what suits the job best than which is best. Olive oil is my personal default, but the seed oils have their place too. Olive oil. This is my go-to for dressings, roasting and shallow frying, though not really because trials rank it above the seed oils.

SPEAKER_00On cholesterol, they match it and canola even edges it. So what really sets olive oil apart is its polyphenols, which in a randomized trial lowered LDL and modestly raised HDL. Extra virgin olive oil is eye-wateringly expensive though, so I tend to cook with plain olive oil and keep extra virgin olive oil for dressings and finishing touches. Canola slash rapeseed oil. Neutral flavor and cheap, so a real all-rounder for frying and baking.

SPEAKER_00I tend to use this or vegetable oil for Asian-style dishes where olive oil isn't the right flavor profile. It's one of the best-studied seed oils and lowers total and LDL cholesterol. Vegetable oil, usually soybean or a blend in the US, more often rapeseed in the UK, so it behaves like whichever it is. And again, it's a cheap, neutral-flavored workhorse for frying and baking. Soybean oil, the most used oil in the US with a neutral flavour. It also lowers LDL cholesterol when it replaces saturated fat.

SPEAKER_00Avocado oil, high in monounsaturated fat like olive, also a good option for high heat cooking. But there aren't many studies yet on avocado oil itself, so there's nothing directly concrete to say yet about its supposed benefits. For now, fine rather than better, and unfortunately, like olive oil, very expensive. Butter. Mostly saturated fat, lovely for flavour and baking, and all foods fit, so I'm not anti-butter. But in a UK trial against olive oil,

SPEAKER_00four weeks of butter raise LDL more, so move to enjoying it occasionally and switching to a plant hole most days for your health. Tallow is also mostly saturated fat. Lovely for flavour in high heat cooking, but as with butter, not a health upgrade. To be fair, in a small study, it raised LDL less than butter, but it still raised LDL more than olive oil, so the same logic applies. Swapping a plant oil out for it isn't the move for your heart.

SPEAKER_00Let me know what you think in the comments. What oil do you use when you're cooking? And that's it for Second Brain. Thank you so much for listening. It really does mean a lot to me. I am off to the Lake District next week. So while I'm away, you'll get a roundup of some old favorites rather than the usual deep dive. And then I'll be back to you properly soon after. Take care and chat soon.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. 🎧 How to calm an irritable gut (audio version)

    Oct 23, 20266 minAudio

    This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit dremilyleeming.substack.com I’ve lost count of how many conversations I’ve had with people struggling with funky gut symptoms who feel it’s just something...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. 🎧 7 ways to beat the bloat (audio version)

    Oct 18, 20267 minAudio

    This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit dremilyleeming.substack.com Bloating is one of the symptoms I get asked about most, and one of the most confusing. Let’s go through which signs are worth...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. 🎧 Tired all the time? Check your iron (audio version)

    Oct 10, 202612 minAudio

    Tired all the time and can't work out why? This week I dig into iron, what it does in your body, how it's tested, and the new US guidelines that mean lots of people told their levels were "fine" could actually be...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. 🎧 What to eat on Ozempic (audio version)

    Sep 6, 202616 minAudio

    Ever wondered whether to weight loss injections are for you? This week I dig into GLP-1 medications like Ozempic, Wegovy and Mounjaro, how they work, who they’re really for, and what they mean for your muscle, bones and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. 🎧 What organic buys you (audio version)

    Aug 30, 20267 minAudio

    This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit dremilyleeming.substack.com Ever wondered whether organic food is actually worth the extra money? This week I dig into what the organic label really means,...

    Credit the people on this episode