Transcript
Dr. Peter: "Jesus saw Nathanael coming toward him and said of him, 'Here is a true child of Israel. There is no duplicity in him.' Nathaniel said to him, 'How do you know me?' Jesus answered and said to him, 'Before Philip called you, I saw you under the fig tree.' Nathanael answered him, 'Rabbi, you are the Son of God. You are the King of Israel.'"
Elizabeth: Welcome back to Scripture for Your Inner Outcasts. It's Monday, August 24th, 2026, the Feast of Saint Bartholomew. Today's guest presenter is Dr. Peter Malinoski. He's a clinical psychologist and the co-founder of Souls and Hearts, our parent organization.
Dr. Peter: Okay, here we are, Scripture for Your Inner Outcasts listeners. It is so good to be with each other across all our parts. Many of you know this, but just for clarity, Bartholomew and Nathaniel are generally considered by most Catholic Scripture scholars to be one and the same person, just different names given to the same person. One is like their given name, and the other one, Bartholomew. Bar means son of and like tholome or something like that is his father's name. So there's just two different ways to refer to the same person. But we're talking about Nathaniel or Bartholomew today. So I'm focusing in on the Gospel, John chapter 1:47-49. "Jesus saw Nathanael coming toward him and said of him, 'Here is a true child of Israel. There is no duplicity in him.' Nathaniel said to him, 'How do you know me?' Jesus answered and said to him, 'Before Philip called you, I saw you under the fig tree.' Nathanael answered him, 'Rabbi, you are the Son of God. You are the King of Israel.'" Okay, so as is often the case in Scripture, so much is said and then so much is left out. There's a lot of gaps in this story. Why would there be the reactions and and counter reactions going on in this dialogue between Jesus and Nathaniel? What was happening? Why would Jesus say, "Here is a true child of Israel. There is no duplicity in him."
Dr. Peter: And then why would Nathaniel say, "How do you know me?" And then why would Jesus say, "Before Philip called you, I saw you under the fig tree." Well, there's various interpretations that have been given by various Scripture scholars, various doctors of the Church. Saint Thomas Aquinas has got a very simple, straightforward approach that Jesus had supernatural sight. He was able to see, in his own perception, Nathaniel under a fig tree when there was no way possible for, you know, the lines of sight to have allowed that. So it was just a miracle. Jesus was able to see from afar. He had like this great sight, this capacity to see what couldn't ordinarily be seen. That was Saint Thomas Aquinas's approach. Saint John Chrysostom believes that Jesus overheard, miraculously overheard a conversation that Nathaniel was having with Philip, something they were hashing out between each other, and that in that conversation, there was evidence for Jesus to know that there was no duplicity in Nathaniel's heart. And he could also, he just knows everybody, right? So he can see into Nathaniel's heart. But I find those both wanting.
Dr. Peter: Now these are both doctors of the Church, right. And so speculation here, but I think something was going on in Nathaniel's heart. In other words, I think there was some internal conflict, some struggle, maybe some polarization going on. In other words, parts were up in Nathaniel as he was sitting under the fig tree. My imagination of this is that under the leadership and guidance of his innermost self, parts came together, exiles came together, firefighters maybe came together, managers, they came together into a unity and a harmony around what was right, true, and good. Anything that was duplicitous, parts let go of, parts gave up their agendas. Maybe there was some kind of healing that happened. There was some sort of internal work that Nathaniel did. That's what I believed happened, because when Jesus told him there is no duplicity in him, you know, there's no duplicity in you, he responded to that. He knew that Jesus knew what happened inside of him. He knew that Jesus recognized this triumph inside. And not a triumph of one side being victorious over another, that some spiritual managers were finally able to dominate those problematic firefighters, but that there was a coming together, that there was a victory for the entirety of Nathaniel over any duplicity that had been there, or that could have been there, that he came to a decision point.
Dr. Peter: And that decision point included many or all of his parts. That's what I think happened there. And that takes cooperation, that takes collaboration, that takes accepting exiles, that takes managers accepting exiles, that takes exiles accepting managers. That takes some of what Saint Thomas Aquinas would call this internal unity, this interior integration. That's what I think happened. And that was one of the things that just was so attractive to Jesus. And it led to Nathaniel becoming an apostle. Think on that. And we're going to have these same moments under the same sort of figurative, if you will, fig tree. So just wanted to share that with you. It's a way of understanding Nathaniel's experience from a parts and systems perspective through an IFS lens, grounded in a Catholic understanding of a human person. Maybe that's helpful to you. Maybe we could pray to Nathaniel, to Saint Bartholomew today, to help us with our internal struggles, given how, at least in this speculative, hypothetical interpretation of this Gospel passage, at least how I'm understanding what happened inside of him, which opened the door to being able to respond to the call of our Lord Jesus Christ.
Elizabeth: For more content from Dr. Peter, you might consider subscribing to his semi-monthly emailed reflections. I'll put the link in the description of today's show.
Dr. Peter: And with that, we will invoke our patroness and our patrons. Our Lady, our Mother, Untier of Knots, pray for us. Saint Joseph, pray for us. Saint John the Baptist, pray for us. And Saint Bartholomew, pray for us.