Send us Fan Mail Spoilers abound in this latest Netflix release starring Robert DeNiro, Adam Scott, Michelle Monaghan, Hamish Linklater and Michael Keaton. It's a short episode so take a listen to see if The Whisper Man is worth your time. Podcast may contain minimal profanity. Podcast may contain spoilers. Music by Moodmode on Pixabay https://pixabay.com/users/moodmode-33139253/ https://www.youtube.com/@moodmode - Check out my Youtube channel. https://www.tiktok.com/@mood.mode - TikTok Thanks for listening and be sure to like, subscribe and come back next week!
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SeanWelcome back to Scenes from the Screen, where we talk about all types of films and TV. Obscure, forgotten, prestigious, rotten, from must see to "Are you kidding me?" Big screen and small, we cover it all. Who knows? You might discover a new gem or be reintroduced to an old favorite. My name is Sean, and I'll be your host. Well, I do have to apologize to you.
HollieWhy?
SeanWell, Friday was the premiere of The Whisper Man and unfortunately, I didn't get a red carpet, did not procure one. We didn't have fancy food, but we did have Mineo's that day.
HollieYou did, you cheated me out of a lot of special things for a premiere.
SeanI did, and for a premiere, that is ridiculous.
HollieNo paparazzi. I couldn't wave at anybody.
SeanNo, I mean I could have probably flashed some stuff in the room.
HollieYeah, we could have flashed some lights.
SeanRight. I mean, to make you feel you know at home like you're walking down a red carpet. Well, The Whisper Man, as we said, was released for those of you listening in the future, it was 2026, the end of August, so August 28th. And it stars... has several stars. Robert De Niro plays a retired detective who at one point put away a serial killer known as the Whisper Man, who would tap on little kids' windows, lure them out, and then eventually kill them. His estranged son is played by Adam Scott who moves back into that hometown with his son. His wife is deceased And at the same time, the cops, including the I guess the lead detective played by Michelle Monaghan, they want De Niro to come back and work the case.
SeanHe refuses because it's taken some emotional toll on him. But when his grandson gets taken, then he decides to return to action, so to speak. Because that's like pretty much cover the gist of it.
HollieThat about sums it up, yes.
SeanOkay. Okay. Uh so yeah, so you know, The Whisper Man. It is what it is. Here's the way I think about it. I didn't like it, I didn't hate it. It just kind of exists.
HollieNo spoilers, right?
SeanWell, we'll have spoilers? I'm gonna put them in the yeah, at the beginning on the not the transcript, but the episode notes.
HollieI feel like it was just an amalgamam. Is that what...?
SeanAmalgam?
HollieAmalgam of a bunch of movies that I've seen before.
SeanThat's absolutely true. And one in particular, do you know which one...
HollieSilence of the Lambs.
SeanAbsolutely Silence of the Lambs.
HollieThat's what I wrote down. I was like, I wonder if he's gonna think it was Silence of the Lambs at the end. It was even her like shaking with the gun, like come on.
SeanWhat with the tea kettle and everything, and he's in the other room at one point, and yeah it was...
HollieAnd you see his shadow? Like that just pissed me off.
SeanYeah.
HollieI'd like to...
SeanWas that what you thought we wrote down at the same time? That we...
HollieYeah, remember I said...
SeanWe don't discuss this uh ahead of time, uh which kind of like is...
HollieSee? Silence of the Lambs.
SeanRight. Yeah, that's not what I wrote down. Um, I wrote down this is a big spoiler, so if you haven't seen it, I mean we're gonna spoil it.
HollieWe're gonna spoil it. You watched any cop/ serial killer movie, you've seen it.
SeanI'm going to tell you this. This reminded me of an episode of Criminal Minds.
HollieIt was an epi... that's what I was gonna say too.
SeanThat's basically all it was. It was like a two-hour Criminal Minds.
HollieThere was...
SeanI will say this... the one, the best thing about this movie? Adam Scott.
HollieYeah, he was fantastic.
SeanHe was great in it.
HollieYeah.
SeanDe Niro kind of showed up, wandered on to the set, and wandered off. I've never seen him look so bored.
HollieHe looked bored, he did. I agree. It was almost like so easy for him to do, like it wasn't a role that he had to think about.
SeanNo challenge whatsoever.
HollieNot at all. It it was like, I don't know, I don't know why he did it, to be honest. It was that...
SeanWhy did any of these people do it? I mean, Michael Keaton's in it, for God's sake.
HollieOh, yeah, I forgot Michael Keaton, who was phenomenal in it.
SeanHe was he was all right, he you know I mean he's he's good, but he's that's basically every serial killer. It was done that was done better in not only Silence of the Lambs, but Manhunter.
HollieRight. It was also it, yes. I got a Manhunter vibe from it, Dr. Lecter.
SeanBut not as bold and brash as Manhunter. No, now we're talking about Manhunter, not Red Dragon, because Red Dragon sucked, but Manhunter...
HollieWell, the idea of the cops going into the serial killer, and it actually was an episode of Criminal Minds where the son or the daughter of the of the serial killer was carrying on in their parents' name. It was because they didn't have a bond with the parents, and it was the same storyline. I was like, oh my god, because I really, really liked the beginning. I thought it started off so great, like it just started with action.
SeanI think it didn't really start with action, it started with them walking in a field looking for...
HollieLike looking for a body already.
SeanRight, but I mean, that's not really action.
HollieWell, I mean, it would the storyline had started. It wasn't like, oh, there's a quaint little town. Oh, you see this happening. Like the the serial killing already started for the movie. So I did like that. I did like the score.
SeanI suppose.
HollieI thought the music was really cool over some scenes.
SeanSo it is based on apparently a crime no... by Alex North, who is the actual British crime writer, Steve Mosby.
HollieWho watched a lot of TV and just copied everything?
SeanApparently that's what he did. Uh...
HollieI could have seriously written this movie.
SeanIt was yeah, I mean, it was like I'm not even demeaning the writers in a way because it's I don't know if it started off with bad source material. One would think it would have had to if they if it's kind of based on that book and they found out they can change it a little bit, but...
HollieThe fact that he moves back home, rents a house, wasn't his house, but that just so happens to be the house where one of the previously killed kids are buried. Come on.
SeanWell, here are a couple things about...
HollieThere were just way too many coincidences for it to be even remotely appropriate. It was just terrible.
SeanHere are a couple things about that house at the very beginning. So when Adam Scott is going through the house and he goes up into the attic and he steps, oh, it's a it's a weak floorboard. I just started, I think I was laughing to myself because I'm like, you know that's gonna come into play at the end.
HollieExactly.
SeanAnother one is when Hamish Linklater, who plays the serial killer collector...
HollieAnother person I really like in movies.
SeanYeah, I do too. When they show that that pick or whatever that he has, that little stabby, you know that's gonna play a part in it.
HollieIt was like a a screwdriver.
SeanScrewdriver type, yeah, whatever it was. You knew you knew that was gonna play a part. Everything was so predictable in this movie.
HollieYes. Very, very predictable. Like I said, it was nothing I haven't seen, and it was like five movies that I really enjoyed, all smashed into one.
SeanYeah, and this isn't one I I enjoyed at all.
HollieNo, I I really was disappointed just because as much I love serial killer things. I love Adam Scott. I love Robert De Niro, like...Hamish Linklater I love him.
SeanYeah, I like all the actors.
HollieLike these are people that I like to see in film and I like to see on TV, and I really did not enjoy this movie.
SeanNo, and and so uh in addition to the stuff we just mentioned about that you know you could see coming a mile away because it was very predictable. You mentioned that the and again, spoiler, but there's one kid that they find buried in the basement. Now, what makes this even funnier is that the crack police unit had the entire house taped off. Wouldn't you think they'd go through that house with a fine-tooth comb, especially when Adam Scott already said, Oh, I found someone that was in the basement and I chased them. So wouldn't you go through the basement?
SeanHey, what were they looking for? Didn't even bother.
HollieNo, not at all.
SeanDidn't even bother, and that's where they uh, but all of a sudden De Niro and Scott find the find the bones of the kid.
HollieNot the police.
SeanNo, granted, De Niro was a detective, but it they should have found that already.
HollieRight. They should have. It just was too too convenient for him to be in the house with his son that that's buried, and his father was the cop who put the serial killer's father away. Like that's just too coincidental. And they just happened to did like it never said, but I assumed he was getting vengeance on Robert De Niro by abducting that kid, but they never really told you if he knew it was the cop's grandson because they had different last names.
SeanRight and that... did they explain why Adam Scott's character had a different last name than...?
HollieWell I guess they didn't really go into it, but was I think the relationship with him and his family because the serial killer took over everything, so they left and changed their name. I and they didn't say they left and changed the name because people were hounding them about the serial killer, but that's what I assumed. But it would have been nice if that's what they would have told us.
SeanRight, or if the if the mother was so estranged from Robert De Niro that she changed their names and yeah, something like that.
HollieYeah, well, he was an alcoholic, and yeah.
SeanThat's a piece of information that literally would have been helpful.
HollieSo, did this guy just randomly choose Adam Scott's son, who happens to be the cop who put away his dad's grandson?
SeanApparently.
HollieI mean, come on, give me a break. Like it was just too convenient, too contrived. But you're right, Adam Scott was was really good in it, but I love Adam Scott.
SeanSo what they should have called this movie was daddy issues.
HollieOh, yes.
SeanBecause that's pretty much all that ran rampant throughout the whole thing. Oh, my son is you know against me on this. Well, he hates me because of the... no strike against him, but I was surprised Tom Cruise wasn't in it because that's all he did at the beginning of his career was daddy issue movies, which are all great, don't get me wrong. But I mean, this one is and again, I didn't hate it, but it's it just exists.
HollieWell, another thing that bothered me too, and I did like that they did talk about the little boy being afraid of stairs because his mother he found his mother at the bottom of the stairs when she died. So I did like like that was a nice little story backstory that that was nice to know.
SeanAnd again, that came into play.
HollieThey really barely used it and came into play. Barely.
SeanOnly twice.
HollieRight but what they tell...
SeanI mean you forget about it.
HollieBut if you're gonna rent the house, just you and your kid, just two of you, why would you rent this gigantic old house with steps everywhere when your kid's terrified of steps?
SeanWell, the plot called for that.
HollieBut that's what I'm saying, like it was just everything was a fixture, nothing was a story.
SeanDid you ever hear when Roger Ebert referred to certain movies as using the idiot plot?
HollieNo, I never heard of that.
SeanOkay, so basically Ebert's and I guess it wasn't originally coined by him, but he really brought it to fruition in terms of his reviews. The idiot plot is a movie where if one character does anything that has common sense, the movie would be over. This is an idiot plot because they all do stuff that they shouldn't do, like you just said, he bought a house with all these stairs in it. So it's really plot contrivances.
HollieYeah, everything was contrived, everything was predictable, everything was like it's like the writer or whoever thought of okay, I'm gonna do something just like my favorite TV show, but I'm gonna use every movie I liked and I'm gonna make everything mean something.
SeanThere's no subtlety.
HollieNo, nothing subtle at all. Like the whole I I like the estranged dad with the the the son, he's a writer. I liked all that. I thought that was creative and and I enjoyed that. I just didn't like that it was his son and they didn't know who he was. They should have known who he was. Why would they take his son? In the end, when um...
SeanMichael Keaton.
HollieMichael Keaton's character goes into the cell, why would they let him do that? Like that doesn't even make any sense.
SeanThey kind of arrange for it for some reason...
HollieYeah, like why?
Sean...but if that did right, it still didn't make any sense as to why they did it. They did mention that earlier that he said he just wanted five minutes with him.
HollieYeah.
SeanHannah's really over.
HollieYeah, she's she did not like this.
SeanNo. She's huffing and puffing here.
HollieYeah, I just felt like that was like a stupid thing. It didn't show the relate like why would this why would the why would security guards in the prison have such a relationship with Michael Keaton's character? It's just...
SeanI don't I don't understand that either.
HollieHe was the child murderer, it's not like he was just a regular run-of-the-mill serial killer, he killed children.
SeanAnd usually they don't look upon that favorably in prison.
HollieIn prison, yeah.
SeanAnother thing I just I had a note about uh there was one point where they were looking at a prisoner who kind of helped them out, and it's like, well, they found a burner phone in his cell. And I I actually kind of laughed at that because that was always a plot thing on Castle. But I've never heard seen anybody with a burner cell, but apparently criminals, it's it's...
HollieThey have those burner cells.
Sean...rampant in the criminal underworld.
HollieYeah, uh and I thought that character being in the town to the collector in that same town. It was just it was just like uh...
SeanEven if he wasn't right in that town, it's too close to the proximity.
HollieIt was what I mean, he was right there.
SeanHe was right, yeah, almost right because it was what where his kid Adam Scott's kid went to school, and yeah, I mean he was like almost right there, but yeah, it was just too...
HollieToo much.
SeanYeah. And there was what was one oh so we mentioned the the scene with the detective Michelle Monaghan's character where she's at the killer's house, and again it's all reminiscent, so it's like basically a shot for shot Silence of the Lambs, and she calls for backup. Okay, well, earlier in the film, but not too much too much longer before that, or maybe no, it was it after that, it was somewhere around that time. The killer gets the police car that was watching the house away by saying, like, hey, I just saw the killer and he's over here, and and that cop takes off immediately.
SeanShe calls for backup. I'm like, where are these goddamn cops? Man, they're like there's no...
HollieIt's a small town.
SeanUh right, where are where are they? They should have just been like somewhere around there.
HollieYou have a serial killer in the area. Why didn't they come faster? And why was she alone?
SeanYeah, well, she you know, she had like Starling was alone, you know, and it wasn't like she had to prove herself like Starling did.
HollieRight, but it was it was just like I said, I was very I was disappointed because I expected more from the actors, everyone in it, and it's not their I don't necessarily think their acting was bad, I think the movie was bad. Their acting was great.
SeanWell, De Niro's was again, he kind of he sleptwalked through the film.
HollieHe did, but like I said, it was almost like let's put Robert De Niro in this because this is Robert De Niro. Like it's not he didn't have to stretch, he didn't have to do anything, he just had to roll out of bed and read the line.
SeanWell, the little kid was good too. The kid that played Adam Scott's son was Acston Luca Porto, I believe I hope I'm pronouncing that correctly.
HollieHe was good.
SeanHe was very good in this.
HollieI didn't love Hamish in this, and I do love Hamish in everything. He annoyed me. Well, his character did it was so more pretentious than he had to be, it was more over the top than it had to be. But I I I love I did really enjoy Adam Scott, and then I did like Michael Keaton.
SeanWell, one of the final notes I want to touch on is we have actually seen one of that director's works before when I looked him up.
HollieDid we like that?
SeanWe we liked it. It was The Rule of Jenny Pen. Remember it had John Lithgow and Jeffrey Rush. John Lithgow was this they're both in a retirement home. Yes. That was decent. It wasn't great.
HollieIt was not...
SeanIt was better than this.
HollieIt was better than this, right. It had a nice story to it. At least that had a story. I feel like this was just not even a story, it's just bits and pieces of other stories.
SeanYeah, I yeah, I completely agree with that. Yeah, and like I said, it I I wouldn't recommend watching it, but I I'm not I didn't feel like I wasted my time.
HollieBut this was a hard one for me to keep quiet on because and I kept talking because I was getting frustrated. I I know you were, and I was trying not to let you see my frustration, and I'm like, he has to be thinking the same thing I am, and it was driving me crazy not to not to talk to you about it.
SeanWell, when we talked about the only thing we we mentioned was I wrote something down and you said you wrote something down, and you said it was Silence of the Lambs.
HollieWell, I wrote predictable and I wrote Silence of the Lambs.
SeanWhat I wrote was, and this was pretty on early on in the film, and again, we've spoiled it a ton of the I wrote down is Michael Keaton's kid the killer? And I was like, when I when that happened, I'm like, of course, of course it happened. Of course it was.
HollieWhen when he said the line, forget what Michael Keaton...
SeanThis was before that, because you did say something at that point, and I just kept quiet.
HollieYeah, but there was something and I oh no, when they said his wife and his son were in hiding federal federal witness protection...
SeanRight.
HollieI was like, nope, why would you say that? Like there was no reason to even have that information there. Why would I mean the wife, yeah, you could talk about her because you know they did talk about how she was there, but like that wasn't necessary, so you knew there was something up.
SeanAgain, it's it's you know, they banged you over the head with stuff, and uh yeah. So the the final point, unless you have anything else.
HollieI I got I got nothing on this one.
SeanYeah, like I said, it was this is a pretty short one. I I wish I I can't get excited, I can't it's the it exists.
HollieI do want Adam Scott to know I did appreciate his acting in this.
SeanI think it it's amazing because we always mention Parks and Rec because we're big Parks and Rec fans, but he's really good at drama.
HollieYes, but we're also says...
SeanSeverance.
Hollie...Severence fans.
SeanYep.
HollieAnd I used to watch him in that Party Down he was in that too.
SeanYeah, I've never seen that, and I've always wanted to, but I yeah, I just yeah, I've never seen it.
HollieI've liked Adam Scott for a long time, and I think he's amazing in comedies, but he's also very, very good at at drama.
SeanWell, one last thing. So I I got an email the other day from Netflix, and it says in the subject line, Netflix Tudum, T-U-D-U-M. And I was looking at I'm like, what is Tudum? So I had to look that up, and it's like, oh no, it's Netflix Tuh-Dum.
HollieNo.
SeanAnd the the gist of the email was The Whisper Man's ending explained. I'm like, what the fuck do you need to explain to me? It's there's nothing to explain, it's not mysterious, it's not even like a twist, it's just what do you need to explain?
HollieThe the the ending of the serial killer line or the very, very end because I don't really need much explain ing.
SeanNo, and I will tell you this that that that movie did go on a little bit too long at the end, too.
HollieYeah, and I think that too, they did. I think for that ending to even be even remotely decent, you needed to explain Michael Keaton's wanting to do that. I do, I don't want to spoil it. Like...
SeanWell, they kind of did in saying like, oh...
Hollie...they said you covet, and I understand how you go after what you really can't have, and that's but why? Why did he want to kill his own son?
SeanBecause he wanted to be known as the Whisper Man, and they they said, Oh, he's gonna take away your legacy.
HollieNo, no, that's why he did it now, but why did he want to kill little boys initially? Because that's what they said.
SeanOh, I see what you mean.
HollieYou couldn't kill your own son, so you killed other little boys. Why did he want to kill his own son?
SeanI don't know, man, he's a serial killer.
HollieBut that's not a typical, but that's not a serial killer thing. I watch a lot of serial killer stuff. That's not a serial killer thing.
SeanHey, for this one it was.
HollieThat was stupid. You needed to explain it.
SeanYeah, so uh it it's not it's not rewatchable at all.
HollieNo, I'm not watching it again.
SeanNo, but like I said, uh I've seen worse...
HollieAnd it's...
Sean...but you can put on the background and still go do whatever you need to do and pick up, and it's you're still gonna be able to follow the plot.
HollieYou can follow it if you put it on the last last 10 minutes, you could pretty much figure out what the rest of the movie was about.
SeanTrue. True.
HollieIt's called Silence of the Lambs meets Criminal Minds.
SeanThat wraps up another episode. So make sure you hit that subscribe button and download new episodes every Saturday on your favorite podcast platform. For Scenes from the Screen. I'm Sean, and thanks for listening.
Send us Fan Mail In this extended trailer, I talk about the past (i.e. what worked, what didn't, etc.) and look toward the future as the show evolves into...something. Update contains some profanity. Music by Moodmode:...
Send us Fan Mail Hollie joins me for the final night of our 31 Days of Halloween celebration and we talk about the sequels, the legacy and even our own tradition with the film. Thanks for listening to what will now...
Send us Fan Mail We look at two very different films involving corpses. Both supernatural but one is definitely superior to the other. Either way, we hope you enjoy this double feature suggestion for the penultimate day...
Send us Fan Mail Hollie was unaware that I'd seen this cult classic before but how could I not want to see a Rockabilly zombie musical again? Podcast may contain minimal profanity and spoilers. Music by Tunetank on...
Send us Fan Mail Join me in today's travel down a lonely highway with the creepy Dead End. Podcast may contain minimal profanity and spoilers. Music by MaksymMalko on Pixabay...