Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Saving Democracy

Saving Democracy artwork

LIVE with Tim Snyder: Talking Ohio, the Campaign Trail and Laboratories of Autocracy

Feb 24, 202650 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

It was a true honor yesterday to talk with Ohio native Tim Snyder about the campaign for Governor in Ohio, the issues we are hearing about on the ground, and Dr. Acton’s brand of leadership (vs. Vivek Ramaswamy). If you have time to watch it all, you’ll enjoy it. And here are some clips from the conversation: * Dr. Acton’s unique form of leadership: “factuality - begin with the facts, respecting the truth”: * “Ohio itself deserves to do better than we’ve been doing…a great state is suffering under broken and corrupt government” * Among many problems in Ohio is the non-stop attack on public education, including the undermining of rural schools: * The Vivek story: “they sent him off to destroy Ohio,” Medicaid was a “mistake,” and the contrast to Amy Acton * Why Ramaswamy would be such a bad fit for Ohio, at this moment of struggle: “on every single issue which matters, like healthcare, education he is all for taking eveything which should be a public good and turning it into something scammable” * The contrast between the two tickets: * And finally, the energy and hope we are feeling out on the trail: Folks, this is a real race. We have real momentum. To help us succeed, please consider supporting the campaign HERE. Thank you Michael Scarmack, Wendy E, Virginia Smith, Katie Steedly Curling, Nancy Petro, and many others for tuning into my live video with Timothy Snyder! Join me for my next live video in the app. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit davidpepper.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01So you and I are live, and people are starting to come in. Now they're flooding in. All right, so we can move from the small talk part to the actual conversation. So welcome, everybody. This is Tim Snyder, and I'm on my substack, which I'm grandly calling Thinking Live, when I do a live conversation like this, with my friend David Pepper, who... has a terrific background as an analyst of Ohio politics and

national politics, and has taken the incredible step of actually deciding to run for office in

SPEAKER_01midlife, which I think is a positive form of midlife crisis, but it requires a lot of courage, and we're going to round to that. So I'm hoping to have a conversation with David, who's in Columbus, Ohio right now, about why he chose to run for office, what it's like to be with his remarkable running mate, Amy Acton. Amy Acton is running for governor and David is running for lieutenant governor of Ohio, as many people know. And Amy is a remarkable person, a remarkable person with a career in public health. who looked after Ohioans during COVID and has terrific,

SPEAKER_01as I see it, ambitions to transform the state into a place where a lot of things that don't work will start working, especially in schools. And David has been helping her a bit with her campaign and has now jumped on as a candidate for lieutenant governor. And I find it also incredibly interesting. Personally, I find it incredibly interesting when people who write books decide to run for office. So I wanna start, so greetings, David. It's really great to have you. And I just wanna start by asking you how you're doing. What's going on in Columbus? What is your day like now that you've taken this big step and decided to run?

SPEAKER_00Well, thank you, Tim. Thank you for having me and welcome everyone for joining us. It's an honor to be with a fellow Ohioan, proud Ohioan, as Amy and I both are. I'll just say it's going well. I was a local office holder years ago in Cincinnati in the County Commission, but then as you suggest, I've been out of it for a while, which gave me time to write the books and think more deeply on a lot of things that when you're in the process of being in office, sometimes you just don't have the sort of the time to digest. So that was really helpful for me to have some years to think

back through what I'd

SPEAKER_00seen and how we approach it. But when obviously Dr. Acton, first of all, I was so thrilled about her running. As you know, I've been helping her long before I knew I would be running myself. But when she asked me to consider serving, I was honored to do it. And I really, so far, I would say she's getting a great response. We've gotten a great response as sort of a ticket. We are seeing a lot of energy around this state. In some ways, and I think you'd appreciate this, given how difficult things are in so many ways,

SPEAKER_00I think for a lot of people, it's giving them an outlet to be hopeful and to see that their work can make a difference in some way as they look at sort of a national picture that's alarming and disturbing. So I think a lot of people are showing up She's such a, as you're saying, sort of a unique, refreshing candidate. I think she's bringing hope to folks when they want to feel some of it. And then helping on the campaign is giving people something concrete they can do at a time where democracy itself feels so sort of under attack.

SPEAKER_00So it's off to a good start. We know it's going to be a lot of challenges to running, including in this environment, including against someone like the person we're running against. We'll talk about But overall, I think we're off to a great start and we feel good about where we are. And there is an energy happening. You're seeing it in special elections. You saw it in Virginia, New Jersey. We are seeing it here in Ohio, which is wonderful.

SPEAKER_01Okay. I want to follow through on some of these things. So we've got about We got about 900 people on now, and I'm sure many of them know all about Ohio, but some of them probably don't. Some of them are probably watching from other countries even. So I wonder if we could just zoom back for a second and talk about what... the November 26 election means, and in particular, what gubernatorial races mean and why Ohio is important on a

national scale.

SPEAKER_01And also, you know, related to that, why you and Dr. Acton think that this is a state that can be won.

SPEAKER_00Great questions. So obviously my first and I think your first commitment is Ohio itself deserves to do better than we've been doing. I was a kid who went to law school and college out of state. And I was at one point, you'll like this, I was elected most likely to be president of the Cincinnati Board of Tourism. Because I would brag about Ohio all the time, like the Reds and Graders and Bengals. And so I'm one of these folks who grew up in Ohio. We were the heart of it all. We were the place of John Glenn.

SPEAKER_00And so for Ohio's sake, we have to do better. And a great state is suffering under broken and corrupt government. And so that's obviously my and Dr. Acton's first commitment. But let's be clear. The national implications of Ohio changing our direction for governor is And being blue this year are enormous. It likely means we also are winning the Senate race. It means we are protecting House seats they've tried to gerrymander, which is a big part of the House. It means longer term, we have a shot of ending the gerrymandering here that has done

so much of the

SPEAKER_00damage and the corruption we've talked about. So this is a really important race for Ohio. But if you look around the country and you and you and you're watching D.C., know that if we can switch the trajectory in Ohio, the national implications are profound and in some cases immediate, like winning the U.S. Senate. And I do think and so just so folks know what's up in Ohio this year, every statewide office. the Senate race that is essentially a tie between Sherry Brown and John Husted.

At least three House seats that are kind of up for grabs that we currently have Democrats in. They try to gerrymander them, but I think we have a shot of all three if we have a good year. You start adding all that up, and as I said, the implications are enormous.

SPEAKER_00And then longer term than that, I mean, I think one thing that we have to all, you know, let's say Democrats, and I'm assuming you have folks of multiple parties watching, but also internationally, if the only thing Democrats do is contest a few states on the coast, that's not really a long-term majority. And so if you can start moving a state like Ohio into a broader expanded map that's at least contested, it really creates a much more sort of stable picture long-term in the federal government.

SPEAKER_00So that's why this, and you know this, The normal, the best predictor of how you do in Ohio is the top of the ticket, which is the governor's race. So success of Amy Acton against Vivek Ramaswamy has has the rest of the ticket often follows that success. And I think right now, to be really blunt, we're at least tied, if not slightly ahead of Ramaswamy in the polls for a lot of reasons. So there's a real opportunity to have those national implications this year in the state of Ohio.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's fun talking about Ohio with you, and it's also fun listening to you do Ohio politics because there's always a humility to it. You're saying, well, we might be even better than Tide. Whereas in fact, it's remarkable. I mean, you guys are... Neither of you came out of any kind of particular deep pockets, like hugely backed situation. And you were behind the poles when you started and you've been doing nothing but climbing ever since.

SPEAKER_01Right. I'm just saying this for the record for people who don't know. They're actually leading at this point. And, you know, in a state where. And a state that people like to call a red state, but I don't believe in red states and blue states. You know, I believe in Ohioans. I believe in Americans. I believe in citizens. And, you know, the whole and, you know, you made a nice reference to the different kind of past that Ohio is coming from. I mean, when I was when I was a kid in high school, which is around the same time you were, we had two Democratic senators and,

SPEAKER_01you know, and Glennon Metzenbaum. And I met them both as a high school student. And that, you know, that that is an Ohio reality which existed and which was possible. And so the notion that we have to be trapped in this reality, like you say, where, you know, there are blue coasts and there's and there's a red center. That's not that's that's not acceptable for Ohioans, I think, because or anybody. I mean, Oklahomans, Kansans, Indianas, it doesn't matter, because if you only if you're in a one party state, That means that you actually have no future, like you have no chance,

right?

SPEAKER_01And it's not tenable for the country, as I think you were suggesting as well, because it sets us up for this polarization and for this sense of us against them. And it makes everybody super tactical and magnifies differences. So I appreciate you're talking about the national significance of this. I want to zoom in, though, on what is fun about running for office, because I just want to start by saying the thing which you probably won't say, which is that It's incredibly courageous to run for office. I mean, if you've got a life going on anyway, if you run for office, you can plan on that life ceasing to exist,

SPEAKER_01basically. It's incredibly hard work. You have to be with people all the time. You've got to make contact with people that don't agree with you. You have to be charismatic, communicative, organized, right? There are all kinds of work, and it's like thankless because everybody expects you to be perfect all the time. Anyway, I said that stuff so you don't have to. What I want to do is I want to ask you, like, what's fun about this? What's fun about being with Dr. Amy Acton, who, by the way, I think is one of the most interesting people in politics right now and who is getting more attention and deserves it.

SPEAKER_01What's it like being on the campaign trail with her? What's it like talking to Ohioans? You mentioned volunteers earlier. What have been some high points about about meeting volunteers and going out into the field?

SPEAKER_00So first of all, it really is an honor to run with Dr. Acton. And I think you saw it earlier than others. She is such a unique figure. I tell crowds, I never forgot the first time I saw her in action during COVID. She showed up standing there with a Republican governor and exhibited the kind of leadership that we all hope to see, but almost never do. You know, professional, steady, empathetic, putting all the truths on the table.

SPEAKER_00It was a masterclass in leadership. And no shock, it skyrocketed her to this unbelievably high public approval. A cross-party, nonpartisan, really. Her leadership style was this nonpartisan, and it's why, you know, all of a sudden we saw, you know, little girls in Ohio dressed up for her as Halloween. You saw bobbleheads. And what we're seeing right now in Ohio, just so it's clear, although memories are short, so it took a little while.

SPEAKER_00As you said, we're seeing movement in the polls largely because people are recalling, oh yeah, that's that woman during COVID. She was amazing. Right now, even in sort of surveys that are an electorate, let's say, that voted for Trump by 10, She is by far the most popular public figure of either party, and it's not even close. Most people are underwater in a time where people are divided and people don't trust public figures. She is always way into plus territory. And so she is it's truly unique circumstance that someone

launches to this public

SPEAKER_00positive notoriety, not through politics, not through a partisan lens, but simply through being a great public servant. And that is still the case right now. So I get to travel the state with a woman who beyond Ohio, people may or may not know her. But in Ohio, is viewed in this incredibly positive way as a doctor, not a politician. And every day the campaign that goes by, even, we're not running TV ads yet, we're not doing that, but every day that goes by, people are, oh yeah, I remember her now. Wow. And so that's been, you know, it is to your question,

SPEAKER_00That is as fun as it gets. We are largely, and I've said this at Dr. Acton for a couple of years now, for my experience, despite all the negatives of what we see on TV every day, most of the time, if done right, campaigning for office is enjoyable. It's fun. You meet people every single day that, yes, are telling you about their challenges, but are looking for answers, want to help. So the right kind of campaign, and you'll like this, Tim, I don't even order at Dairy Queen anymore to exit 50 in Wilmington.

SPEAKER_00They know what I'm getting. So you're also out in communities. Like I drive through the drive-thru, like, okay, we know, small vanilla cone with the sprinkles. So the other thing you're doing, if you're doing it right, is you're seeing new communities every day. You're hearing stories, again, challenging stories that you want to solve. but also positive stories about how Amy made a difference in their life, or maybe I served at Cincinnati and people remember that. So for the most part, it's actually quite enjoyable, but it's especially good when you're literally campaigning with someone who is

viewed in such a positive way and is bringing people hope every single day on the

SPEAKER_00campaign trail.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. So I'm watching the numbers go up, and we're at about 1,500 people now, and some folks are asking who we're talking about. And remember, people are coming in who are not from Ohio or not even in the United States. And so I just want to mention that we're talking about the Ohio gubernatorial ticket for November of 26, which is headed up by Dr. Amy Acton and Dr. In the number two slot, lieutenant government slot, is David Pepper, with whom we're talking now. And I also wanted to mention, apropos of this, that I had a similar conversation with Dr. Acton a couple of months ago.

SPEAKER_01So that's also up on my substack. So if you want to hear from her directly in a nice long conversation, that's a format where you could just check in and do that. It's accessible to everybody. Okay. I want to pick up on the thing that you said about not being political. And of course, you're striking memories. COVID is a difficult period to think back to. And I remember it much the same way. I was in several different places during COVID. And I remember coming to Ohio to see my folks and seeing Dr. Acton on TV.

SPEAKER_01And then also hearing my parents say, and other family members say, of various political convictions, by the way, that this was a presence that was calming them down. Right. You know, that was something which was very different between her and some of our national leaders at the time. Like she said, this is coming.

SPEAKER_01It's going to be like this. Her predictions were correct. But she also gently told people there are things we can do. We can do these things and it will make a difference. And I'm going to be with you here. You know, every week, I think it was. along the way and that had this it had this incredibly calming effect and it makes me think that like she mixes these two things which we really need number one which is empathy but number two which is like factuality like being being with the facts respecting the truth right

SPEAKER_00Absolutely. I mean, it really was. And as she says now, and I think it's sort of a genius way to lead is she knew that people running systems in our state, schools, hospitals, nursing homes, they had a lot to do. And she couldn't do it for them. But by telling the truth about what was coming, what to expect, she knew she was empowering them to lead as well. And I think in politics today that never happens. But she understood a state of nearly 12 million people.

SPEAKER_00There can be a lot of heroes doing a lot of different things. And my job is to is to solve some of those issues. But it's also to understand they need facts, hard facts, truth so they can do their job. And then between the 24 hours of these press conference, she would also obviously interact with a lot of those folks. And she was leading the state. But it was the daily sort of truth telling and facts out there told in a steady way that allowed many other people to also save lives and keep lives going and make

SPEAKER_00decisions that if it had been just chaotic and confusion, they would have known what to do. So it's, I think, a really important lesson in leadership in the way she did it. And empowering other people to also be good leaders.

SPEAKER_01I want to pivot from there. Yeah, I think that's a really important point because, of course, it's not that government does everything for us, but a good government or a good governor can tell us what government can do and how we can be government halfway and actually solve some problems. So, you know, it's not that everything is hopeless or that there's some magic solution to everything. It's more that with the right people in charge, we can meet halfway and actually get some stuff done. Right. And on that note, I wanted to pivot to a couple of issues that I think have been

important for you

SPEAKER_01and Dr. Acton in the campaign, which are health care and schools. And since we've talked about health care a bit already, why don't we start with public schools? Because this is one which is, I mean, I went through Ohio public schools. I've watched Ohio public schools as the next generation has gone through Ohio public schools. You mentioned Wilmington, Ohio, which is the county seat of Clinton County in southwestern Ohio, which has some terrific public schools, but they, like a lot of other places around the state,

are being hurt by this voucher business and the siphoning away of Ohioans' tax

SPEAKER_01money away from public schools towards other stuff. I wonder if you could explain how that I mean, essentially scam works and then how one could fix Ohio public education so that it can be what it should be.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, this is a huge topic here in Ohio, and it's in a number of states we're seeing the same exact pattern, which is that, you know, in our state, billions are being diverted from public schools that are systematically underfunded, underfunded to the point where there are conversations in different communities. In Toledo, the headlines were, we may have to have four days of school a week in Toledo. And in Columbus, can we even have buses take kids to high school? You know, obviously, class size is too big, you name it. And so much of this is being driven by,

SPEAKER_00you know, a generation of policies of diverting money into these sort of, you know, in some cases, outright scandalous schools. We had a for profit charter school here was I put school in quotes. It was an online quote school system that was basically a moneymaker for the founder. And so much of that money would then flow back to the politicians. It was a pay to play scheme. And it was at one point its enrollment was close to a major university, but they were destroying educations and not improving them.

SPEAKER_00And it was essentially a money making scheme. Now we're seeing the same type of thing when it comes to vouchers to private schools. They've got, you know, and one thing that has to be made clear, the old myth of vouchers, oh, this is for like struggling schools and urban community and giving kids a chance. That's not what this is. I mean, there are no income limits. There's no thinking through, are they going to a better school? That's not even considered. And what we have now is an unlimited system of vouchers that is

largely going to

SPEAKER_00kids who are already in private schools, who could largely afford those private schools, getting a huge break on tuition, And and in the meantime, the money is coming right out of the public schools and that that are already underfunded systematically. The school system was found several decades ago to be unconstitutionally underfunded. The percentage of state funding to public schools now is less than then, while the money is going out the back door. And here's there's so much to say about I won't I won't go through it all. We've we don't have any transparency.

or accountability on how the money that is going through these private vouchers is even spent.

SPEAKER_00So my sense is over time, we are gonna find there's a lot of things just like that for-profit school that's such a scandal happening. And we don't even know because there isn't one amount, there is not a sliver of transparency or accountability. And I ask anyone, where else in government do we let billions be spent and not have a clue if it's even going to education? And the one thing I'll say finally is this is at a time where we all know the world is changing so quickly.

We don't even know what jobs are going to exist five or 10 years from now with AI and all this.

SPEAKER_00So we need a better system than ever. If we were all in good faith trying to create the best public school system imaginable, it would be a very hard assignment. So what's so frustrating is we're not, not only are we not doing that, we're actually taking billions and putting it into unaccountable systems based on ideology and pay to play and not on what's actually good for kids, communities, and our state. So it's something that we have to do a lot of about, and this is true in other states as well, but Ohio is sort of a case study of how problematic it can be.

Yeah, thank you for articulating so well what if you're in Ohio specifically or if you have friends in Ohio, your friends or parents in Ohio, you pick up anecdotally.

SPEAKER_01There are schools that I know something about, and this has affected all of them, and none of them is as good as they were before. But more broadly, what I find very sad is the exploitation of children, basically, and parents, because parents do want what's best for their kids. Yeah. People are being told that this system is somehow going to make things better. But for almost everybody, it makes things worse. And it leads to, as you've already said, at least with transfer of wealth from people who were going to

send their kids to public schools to people who were already sending their kids to private schools. And that's not the direction of a transfer of wealth of what I ought to have.

SPEAKER_01And then also, it's undermining this thing. which was so important in Ohio in the late 20th century, which I think we have to get back, which is the public school and the public university as the engine of social mobility, as the thing which allows kids to learn, to have choices, to see a better future. If the public schools and the public universities aren't doing that, then no institution is going to do that.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01I want to move from there.

SPEAKER_00One issue there is rural communities are, frankly, in many ways, the ones who pay the biggest price for this. As you would know, and my wife grew up in Adams County, a rural community right on the edge of Appalachian in Ohio. That school is the center of everything. There's not in the voucher program. It's going largely to suburbs who are doing quite well. And the money is coming out of all these schools around the state. You know, urban schools are paying a big price for it,

SPEAKER_00but also rural schools where, you know, where there's just that's the school and they're losing the money and it's going 100 miles of hundreds of miles away and they get no benefit. One little interesting thing is if if we frame this the right way. It is actually a political loser for Republicans. In Kentucky, there was a voucher referendum on the same day, a pro-voucher referendum on the same day that Trump won two to one. It lost in every county. And the more red and more rural the county, the worse it did because of what I just described.

SPEAKER_00That local public school is the heart of everything. And these voters were saying, and I talked to them myself in person, they're saying, why do we want to undermine our current rural school to go to some private school hundreds of miles away that we can never get to and that we can't afford. And so there really is, if done the right way, if Democrats talk about this the right way, I think this is a really hidden unifying issue across rural, suburban and urban, where there's a there still remains more than almost any other institution, a real affection for their local public school.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's a great point because the school, I mean, in Ohio, but also in many states, I mean, the school is like sports at school, field trips from school, school is a gathering place, school where parents see other parents, you know, and just the facilities of the school can serve the community in many, many different ways. And I have this feeling that like what Republicans do is they just tear the heart out of the institutions, the people who vote for them, you know, like,

SPEAKER_01you know, you can be more bipartisan than me if you want, but it seems like that's like, that's the way it goes. Like you vote Republican and then Republicans just tear up your institutions. They tear up They tear up your local newspapers, you know, which is one important institution. And then they tear up your local school, which is the other important institution. And then the sense of, like, communities are lost and the sense of community is lost and people feel worse, you know, and they want to know what's going on. And those institutions have to be built back. But I want to pivot now to— One thing I'd say, in a world in a— I don't think the voucher programs would

survive in a world

SPEAKER_00without gerrymandering. Right. Because if you were attacking your local public school in the way that vouchers do, you would lose office if you had anything close to a fair district. Jerry, it's one of the many examples where issues that would never survive in a world of fair districts in a real democracy would, you know, it fuels these kind of unpopular policies to continue when in a world of fair districts, they would lose if they voted this way. Sorry to interrupt, but.

SPEAKER_01No, you're not interrupting. You're actually making a much better segue than I could have made because I was going to pivot to laboratories of autocracy, but you've just made a very important point, which I want to generalize from, which is that... when voting is corrupted, you get bad policy as a result, right? In other words, the more democracy you have, the better it is. Democracy isn't just a slogan. Democracy is a way of making sure that you don't have atrocious

policies that

SPEAKER_01affect your children. And the So vouchers and gerrymandering go hand in hand. But there are a lot of examples like this, like the cost of gerrymandering isn't just unfairness in a narrow political sense. It's also unfairness in every other sense, educational, social, every other sense, because if the vote, if the vote is just proportional, then the resources are also going to be swung in a disproportionate way. And you're not going to be able to do anything about it in a, in a, in, in in a gerrymander district so if i want to just take a step

back and you know and zoom out and actually geek out and ask you about the idea of um the states as laboratories of autocracy which is by the way um david has written a couple of books one of them is about how states um it's the states which are the testing

SPEAKER_01ground for the autocratic methods of the federal government and and another, which is a guide for bringing back democracy. So have a look at David's books. But I wanted to ask you to just explain the basic idea of Ohio or the states as laboratories for autocracy.

SPEAKER_00Sure. And just so you know, Tim, not to brown nose a professor, but when you mentioned the word laboratory autocracy at that forum you were at in Cincinnati, I thought I should just retire. Because when Tim Snyder is quoting your book title, you've accomplished everything you need to accomplish in writing. So I really appreciated you mentioning it and asking about it today. So my premise was, and this is what I said, when I wasn't into politics, I had a little time to look back on everything I experienced. And, you know, we like to focus on Washington, D.C.

SPEAKER_00as the place where bad things happen when certain people have power. And what I was trying to show people is, and it goes back to our founding, where states have so much power over not just the most issues we care about, but also voting itself, the drawing of district lines, that for a long time, and in law school, you would be taught this very positive view of states in the right hands could be laboratories of democracy, and we could learn and do great things. And I almost tweeted this, and then I turned it into a book.

SPEAKER_00Right now, too many states, and going back to the Koch brothers and others figured this out, can be used to accomplish things that would never get done in Washington. Because they're really unpopular and because you have enough state Senate races and House races that the politicians wouldn't do it. But state houses, if Jerry made it enough, can be a laboratory of autocracy where you can get really corrupt things done, really unpopular things done.

And you can create a system where the people doing these really bad things never

SPEAKER_00are accountable. People don't even know who they are. They're not newspapers covering them. They may not be contested in half the districts. So it turns out that if you want to get a really sort of dark, corrupt agenda done, state houses are much better than the federal government in Ohio. And we all know the term, like ALEC was created, this associate, what is it? The Legislative Exchange Council was created to basically weaponize this insight. And so what we see in states across the country is you see

SPEAKER_00gerrymandering, taking out any accountability. And then you see this intense rush of the same bills in all these states that are essentially harnessing the power of state houses, not to benefit the people, the states, but to benefit sort of a very moneyed elite agenda or an extreme agenda. And so one thing that gerrymandering, one reason gerrymandering is so important in this overall sort of laboratories of autocracy model, I would call it, is that essentially what's happening in these states,

SPEAKER_00and this is why we have to win them and unrig them, is the people serving these state houses, we are misleading ourselves when we call them public servants. They are literally using public power and public assets to serve private interests and And the reason the outcomes are declining in states like Ohio is the corruption of public service means the public assets are not being put to the benefit of the common good or better outcomes education-wise or policies that

lift everybody. The powers and assets are being used to serve private interests at the expense of

SPEAKER_00everybody else. And that's essentially these lab and the laboratories of autocracy. So certain people behind these things, they know that that's how it works. And they're benefiting in huge ways. You know, energy policy. Again, these these education policies that may serve narrow interests, but aren't serving the broader interests of Ohioans in most corners of the state. So that really is the model. And until we break that model up. I think you're going to see many, many states continue to just see these.

SPEAKER_00They're far more extreme than their people are. And the results in these states are terrible for the average citizen. But gerrymandering locks the average citizen out from able to do anything about it. And so, yeah, that's sort of the book I wrote and I used Ohio as a case study, but you won't be surprised. The minute that book went out, I heard from so many other people in all these states, Missouri, Oklahoma, Texas, Florida. Oh my gosh, David, what you are describing, this downward spiral in your state is exactly what we are experiencing.

SPEAKER_00So I've been going around the country as you do, talking to other states about this, about what we do about it. And I do think to your initial point, Once we categorize states as red states and blue states and decided that red states didn't matter, we actually kind of, you know, put the problem on steroids because we've allowed all these states that have been more rigged than anything, you know, have become these laboratories. It just gets worse and worse and worse. And we have to start pushing back the other way.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, thanks for landing on that point. I mean, because when I say I don't believe in red states, I mean several different things by that. One, I mean, every election we should wait and see who votes. And then another thing I mean by it is that we shouldn't be complacent about what a state is going to do. So politically, everything should be considered up for grabs. But the third thing is what you just said. Once we accept that there are red states and there are blue states,

SPEAKER_01it's not just that we ignore the red states. It's that we allow the red states to develop political technologies. Sorry, I come from Eastern Europe, and that's how we talk. We allow the... We allow the red states to develop political technologies, which are not only bad in themselves, but which then become federalized. They become normalized, people get used to them, and then they become federalized. And then the only way to get to this is you've got to reach down the throat of the dragon. You have to completely reverse it all. You have to un-gerrymander.

SPEAKER_01You have to un-dark money. You have to realign the vote with the policy outcome. And I think I just want to underline an important thing that you said, which is that people stop being public servants because it's sad. It's sad to say, but it's really true. You watch it happen when people don't have to contest their seats. You know, they don't have to communicate with their people. They don't have to listen, right? They don't have to listen. And then you get lazy. You know, you're not competing. You get lazy. And then that goes with another phenomenon you mentioned,

SPEAKER_01which I also want to underline, which are these like, mimeographed legislation, like carbon copy legislation. I noticed this when I was writing about history policy, when a whole bunch of states at the same time suddenly were passing laws which basically said you can't teach history that offends anybody, which is ridiculous because if history isn't irritating you, it's not history. It's something else. But what was weird was watching this happen and then in state after state after state, It was basically everybody had the same Microsoft Word document and they had just

SPEAKER_01altered a few words. You know, they'd altered the name of the state at the top of it and so on. But it was all coming. It was clearly all coming from some kind of private sector push, some kind of lobby. And so people go from being public servants to essentially being like, you know, third tier, you know, corporate bureaucrats who are delivering a product to the people who are actually behind. And that's that whole evolution. It's exactly what it is. It's very sad. Okay. They are sent to conferences under what are called scholarships as if they are students.

SPEAKER_00And one other thing I'd say is they don't just get complacent. In this broken system, all the incentives are the opposite of public service. They're incentivized to be extreme so they don't lose a primary. Right. And they're incentivized to do the interests of the moneyed interests or they will get primary. A bunch of Republicans in Texas, to their credit, voted against vouchers in rural Texas because they knew it was bad for their schools. What happened next primary? DeVos and others put massive money into primarying them and they lost. So the incentives are not just to not care about your voters.

SPEAKER_00They're actually to do the opposite. Do the bidding of the private and be an extremist so you don't get primaried. That's how you survive and thrive in this laboratory of autocracy system. That's why it's kind of always getting worse. You never do well by being in the middle in that system. You always do well by doing what the ALEC group tells you. Don't create enemies there and being as extreme as possible so no one primaries you from the middle.

SPEAKER_01Yep. You get flown places, you listen to some lectures, all you're really doing is waiting for them to give you the document that's the draft piece of legislation. You go back, you pass it with a huge majority, and you just become more cynical. And then everybody else around you becomes more cynical. The state becomes more cynical. People stop believing in politics. People stop believing in democracy because they think this is what democracy looks like. But this isn't what democracy looks like. It's what autocracy looks like. So we're well north of 2000 now,

SPEAKER_01and we're rounding the corner and heading towards the last stretch here. Right. I wanted to also just for those of you who are joining, I'm Tim Snyder. I'm talking to David Pepper, who is the extremely interesting candidate for lieutenant governor in my home state of Ohio, running together with Dr. Amy Acton. And one of the many interesting things about David is that, as you have been hearing, those of you who have been with us, he can articulate at a very accessible but also at a very high level some of the basic policy and political problems we're facing as a state and

as a country.

SPEAKER_01And he's out on the campaign trail right now with, you know, trying to do the right thing, trying to make things happen. So I wanted to land on the race itself and what it looks like in terms of the options. So we have been talking about what is wrong with Ohio in terms of systems. We've talked about a couple of policy areas, schools, and healthcare. I want us,

SPEAKER_01if you don't mind, I want us to land by thinking about the future of Ohio in terms of alternatives, right? So we have this fellow, Vivek Ramaswamy, whose main... so I see a qualification for running for governor of Ohio is that he, they didn't like him enough to let him destroy the federal government basically. Right. Like they didn't allow, he was going to destroy the federal government with Elon Musk, but he wasn't liked enough to do that. So they sent him off to destroy Ohio. I mean, that's, I think you don't have to say it,

but that's certainly what it looks like to an observer of national politics. He wasn't, you know, he wasn't important enough in MAGA to destroy the federal government.

SPEAKER_01So they sent him off to destroy Ohio, which frankly, I mean, is bad in itself, but it also just seems kind of insulting to Ohioans, you know, like dispatched this guy to do our dirty work in Ohio. He was just dispatched. So now he's off running an errand. But so if you won't mind like thinking about presenting it in terms of alternatives, right? So Like, imagine a Ramaswamy, Ohio. What would that look like? What would be lost? And if we imagine an act in Ohio, what would that look like?

SPEAKER_00Sure. So, one, you're right about that background. But he also brings, you know, he made money sort of incredible, incredible amount of money. And somehow there's an out of touchness to him that's stunning. I mean, he's saying things that if you take him seriously, only months before running for office for governor, he said Medicaid was a mistake. He said Medicare was a mistake. He said he basically says they should be dismantled. in a day where we know that we lost 120 000 people from the ac

exchange in ohio in the last few months because it's the premiums are going up so he he has you know on issue after issue he clearly has no sense of what the average ohioan is dealing with and talks about it in a way that every single day that becomes clear those are

SPEAKER_00just some examples more broadly though He, I believe, will accelerate everything we just talked about. So, Amy, I'm honored that she picked me. But one reason I hope she picked me is because she knows I spent the last five years we've talked about saying this corrupt. The statehouse is broken. It's taking us in the wrong direction. It's not really public service. Ramaswamy picked the Senate president from that institution who sits on the board of directors of ALEC. So, I mean, we are seeing if you're looking for change versus status quo,

you have this guy who flies around in a jet saying things like Medicaid was a

SPEAKER_00mistake. He thinks all teachers, he thinks teachers unions should not exist. He wants to double and triple down on vouchers. He's made that very clear. And he picks a guy from the very institution that we know has cost Ohio so much. And I also think, you know, and this is just me speaking, this is clearly, you know, Mike DeWine was asked the other day by a national reporter, Do you think Vivek Ramaswamy is more interested in being governor of Ohio or sort of a national political celebrity? And even the current governor of Ohio said both.

I think he is much more interested in sort of what we see too much in Ohio, someone burnishing a resume to do something beyond Ohio pretty quickly as in 28th. That's also very dangerous for the state because we need serious people with real solutions.

SPEAKER_00We don't need to be anyone sandbox anymore. It's been that way for too long. We've been Alex sandbox. And with the last thing we need, and right now, what is Ramaswamy saying? He's going to get rid of the income tax. His first promise was get rid of the property tax. We saw what Sam Brownback did in Kansas when he made these kind of reckless promises, you know, double down on vouchers. So a state that's already going in a bad direction, would, both because he's already saying these things, but also why he's doing it, I think we would double down. And one thing we should talk about,

costs are impacting everyone right now. Every citizen of Ohio is paying the cost of these broken policies in higher energy

SPEAKER_00bills, property taxes, tuition, you name it. That's only going to continue. So that's the clear choice. Go with him, double down on all that's not going well, and pick a guy uniquely out of touch with the concerns of everyday Ohioans. John Kasich, there's a lot of things I don't agree with. He expanded Medicaid here. Good for him. He understood. This is a guy who says it should be dismantled. There was a mistake, so it'd be even worse. What you get in Dr. Acton is what we talked about the very beginning, a serious problem solver, serious about taking on the issues that we're talking about.

SPEAKER_00Near-term solutions, long-term solutions, and something that I believe to her heart and will work with anybody to do it. In Ohio, you won't get far unless you're working cross-party lines. And as she did as the COVID director, where no one even knew what party she was. And as she says all the time, she will work with anybody, who is willing to be serious to solve the kind of problems we're seeing, be it healthcare, be it education, be it the higher energy bills that partly have come out of this corrupt deal called HB6,

SPEAKER_00where there's a trial going on right now. So I don't remember a clear contrast in a campaign from someone who will double down on the worst stuff versus finally, and I'll include myself in this, adults in the room who can actually start fixing these problems that have built up over years a very broken government, afflicting a wonderful state.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, no, thank you for that. We're like 2,500 people here. People keep joining. I saw that the great Ruth Ben-Ghiat just joined us, who was the author of Strongman, which is one of the terrific books that is at the very top of the can that folks should be reading right now about the moments we're in. And I'm glad that Ruth is paying attention to Ohio because I think— I think you're right. I mean, I'm going to put it in a slightly sharper way, which I'm allowed to do because I'm not running for anything. I mean, it seems like, you know,

SPEAKER_01Ramaswamy, it's like he's like what a 3D printer would produce, you know, if you were saying like, let's generate someone who would be like the worst possible person ever. Ohio or for any other state, like someone who has not had any actual political experience, someone who made his money by exploiting people, someone who's insofar as he's been in politics, it's been as kind of like, you know, the second or third Muppet, you know, in the Trump show where he's just like he's like in the comment section saying the things that Trump is saying, you know,

SPEAKER_01like it's It's just this almost cartoonish contrast. And on every single issue which matters, like healthcare, education, he is all for taking everything which should be a public good and turning it into something which is scammable, basically. Every public good should become scammable for people like me is essentially the platform as it looks from here. Whereas, you know, whereas...

SPEAKER_01Dr. Acton is someone who has this record of the most kind of humble political service, which she did for as long as she could, which involved empathy and factuality. And you're a guy who spent years figuring out what was wrong with political systems where it matters the most, in my opinion, at the level of the states. And both of you are running for office. I mean, I think like that is that itself, like even before we get to November, that itself, that lineup is worthy of a lot more. It's getting some national attention now. But it's worthy of a lot of national attention that the two of

you are running as a ticket.

SPEAKER_01No, no. Thank you for running because like you talk about how great it is and I'm sure it is great. And I'm sure running with Dr. Acton is a lot more fun than running with pretty much everybody else. In politics, but it's it takes it takes courage to actually put yourself out there. And I really appreciate that you're doing it. And I appreciate that you're taking that you're that you've taken the step of trying to apply all the things you've been thinking about here and that you're out that you and Dr. Acton are out in places that I know and places that I love and

places other people

SPEAKER_01know and love in Ohio and doing. the work. I wanted to give you just a chance to leave us with any parting thoughts. I try to nail these things in about 45 minutes, and we're just about there. But if there's anything that was on your mind you didn't get a chance to say or any last words.

SPEAKER_00Sure. I wouldn't be a good candidate if I didn't encourage the 2,500 people on here to go to the actinforgovernor.com website. Learn more about the campaign. If you are inspired, we'd love your support. Financially, if you can give, that'd be a huge help. And if you're in Ohio, want to volunteer, we'd love to have that too. So actingforgovernor.com would be a great, is where you go. We would love your help. And after you interviewed Dr. Acton a few months ago, Tim, you should know we got great response from people all over the

country to do this.

SPEAKER_00So I'll just close by saying thank you for having us. I do think we have a unique opportunity. And in many ways, what you said is me running is sort of an extension of what I've written. And it starts solving this, not just at the federal level, which gets all the attention, but But at the state level, and I love that we're seeing, by the way, in many states like Virginia, many more people running for state houses, many more people contesting what used to be uncontested races. And here in Ohio, as I said, and you were bragging more than I was, we have a real shot here,

SPEAKER_00folks. Amy Acton is the most popular public figure in the state of Ohio, not even close. She earned it by being a wonderful leader. No other health directors were largely leaping to this level. She earned it because she was amazing. For the reason you're saying Ramaswamy is viewed as not trusted, he is underwater consistently. His numbers are high as if someone had spent millions of dollars attacking him. No one has. He's earned that all by himself by saying the kind of things he said, like Medicaid was a mistake.

SPEAKER_00So right now, as you're saying, we see movement. We see what was a slight deficit tie, a lead. So there's a real shot here. If you're in Ohio, we can turn the state blue. We can win the Senate race for shared. If you're beyond Ohio, know that doing that in Ohio, not only is a strike against laboratories of autocracy that are afflicting us in so many places, it really does have the huge national implications that we've talked about. So We'd love your support. And Tim, putting this race on the radar of your followers is a huge help.

And we'll keep doing that with anyone else who's interested in working with us.

SPEAKER_00Thanks so much for having us. Yeah, no, it's been a real pleasure and an education talking to both of you.

SPEAKER_01And I hope we'll do it again before the big November comes around. And I just wanted to mention, just to repeat to folks that this is not it's not just that politics at state level is important. What's important is that we all think of ourselves as citizens and do the stuff we can do. And that may mean donating to candidates, which I'm already doing, but it also can mean volunteering for a campaign, which can make you feel really good. You know, like as we were saying at the very beginning of this conversation, it is a time in national politics and in the world generally

where it's pretty easy

SPEAKER_01to feel depressed and alone. And there's only one antidote for that. And that is to go out there and do something on a small scale, on the scale you can do it. And hooking up with a campaign like the Act and Pepper campaign is one thing that folks in Ohio can consider doing. Okay. Thank you. This has been really, really good, David. And I'm really glad we were able to get together and talk.

SPEAKER_00Right. Thanks. We'll see you next in Ohio in person.

SPEAKER_01All right. I look forward to that.

SPEAKER_00See you later, everybody. Take care. Okay.

SPEAKER_01Thanks, everybody. We'll be posting this on our pages later on for those who missed it. Great.

SPEAKER_00All right.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. WATCH: Amy’s interview with Statehouse News Bureau

    Sep 14, 20261 minAudio

    Happy Monday, Ohio! Amy recently sat down for an extended interview with Statehouse News Bureau’s Karen Kasler. They discussed everything from property taxes, to corruption in our Statehouse, to Amy’s decision not to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. “We All Know Garbage When We See It”

    Sep 12, 20261 minAudio

    This week, we released a new ad, “Garbage.” The ad calls out Vivek Ramaswamy and his extremist out of state billionaire allies for spending millions of dollars on attack ads lying about Dr. Acton and her family, and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. WHITEBOARD: Ohio Court Halts $600M Billionaire Giveaway

    Mar 14, 20262 minAudio

    Vivek Ramaswamy’s running mate, Rob McColley (Ohio’s Senate president), was one of the leaders in raiding $600M in private, unclaimed funds and handing it over to a billionaire donor for a Cleveland Browns stadium. But...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Vivek’s Mistake: Millions in Ohio Rely on Medicaid

    Feb 7, 20262 minAudio

    Vivek Ramaswamy says that Medicaid and Medicare were mistakes. The real mistake would be letting him anywhere near those lifelines, and the millions of Ohioans who rely on them. Watch above: This is a public episode. If...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Filing Day!

    Feb 3, 20262 minAudio

    Yesterday was a big milestone in the campaign: we filed our signatures to be on the May and November ballot in Ohio. Thank you to our army of statewide volunteers for circulating and signing our petition. With all that...

    Credit the people on this episode