Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Sasquatch Odyssey

Sasquatch Odyssey artwork

The PGF: Why Is Bob Gimlin Not Talking?

Nov 20, 202651 minAudio
  • Apple Podcasts
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Is the Patterson-Gimlin Film finally beginning to unravel? And what does newly discovered footage reveal about the most famous Bigfoot film ever recorded? On this episode of Sasquatch Odyssey, Brian welcomes back author and veteran Bigfoot researcher Daniel Perez to discuss their experience attending an October 13 screening of Mark Evans’ documentary Capturing Bigfoot. The film introduces fascinating Patterson-family history, previously unseen archival material, and a mysterious 40-second film clip that could raise serious questions about the events surrounding the legendary 1967 Patterson-Gimlin footage. The newly surfaced footage appears to show a man on horseback, believed by some to be Bob Gimlin, alongside a figure resembling the famous Bigfoot subject known as Patty. But when was it filmed, who was wearing the apparent costume, and why has this footage remained hidden for decades? Brian and Daniel examine explosive statements from Patricia Patterson, Clint Patterson, and Roger Patterson’s sister Iva DeAtley, all of whom have reportedly described the original film as a hoax. While Brian questions whether these admissions and the new footage undermine the film’s credibility, Daniel challenges their significance and argues that the physical evidence deserves greater consideration. The conversation also explores accusations of AI manipulation, missing film reels, the possibility of scientific spectral analysis, Dr. Jeff Meldrum’s reaction to the documentary, and the unanswered questions surrounding Bob Gimlin. Is the Patterson-Gimlin Film authentic, an elaborate hoax, or a mystery that has survived nearly 60 years because critical evidence remains missing? Get Daniel's Book Email Brian Join Our FREE Newsletter Get Brian's Books Leave Us A Voicemail Visit Our Website Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/sasquatch-odyssey--4839697/support. Have you had a Bigfoot encounter, Sasquatch sighting, Dogman experience, or other cryptid or paranormal encounter? We’d love to hear your story. Email brian@paranormalworldproductions.com to be featured on a future episode of Sasquatch Odyssey. Sasquatch Odyssey is a leading Bigfoot and cryptid podcast exploring real encounters, field research, and scientific analysis of the Sasquatch phenomenon. Follow the show and turn on automatic downloads so you never miss an episode.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1Anyone, what are you reporting? I got a strange going on out here. Something just killed my dog. Something killed your dog? My dog was flying through the air over the tree. I don't know how it did it.

Speaker 2Okay.

Speaker 1Damn it, I'm really confused. All I saw was my dog coming over the fence and Nate was dead when she hit the ground. I didn't see any cars. All I saw was my dog coming over the fence.

Speaker 3911, what are you reporting?

Speaker 1Uh, we got someone or something crawling around out here.

Speaker 3Did you see what it was?

Speaker 1It was, it was standing up. I'm out here looking through the window now and I don't see anything. I don't want to go outside. Jesus Christ, you better... Sheriff?

Speaker 3See ya!

Speaker 4Hello?

Speaker 1Get somebody out here.

Speaker 3What's going on now, sir?

Speaker 1That son of a bitch is about six foot nine. I don't know.

Speaker 3Do you see him now, sir?

Speaker 1Yes, I'm looking right at him.

Speaker 5All right, folks, I want to welcome my guest to the show. It is author, researcher, newsletter, producer, Daniel Perez. Welcome to the show, my friend.

Speaker 2Thank you for having me.

Speaker 5I have been looking forward to this conversation since I met you for the first time, IRL, out in San Francisco back on the 13th. You and I were out there watching the Capturing Bigfoot screening and attending the Q & A out there.

Speaker 4You've been on the show, obviously, before.

Speaker 5People have heard you here on Sasquatch Odyssey, but that was the first time you and I actually got to meet in person. It's good to have you back on the show. I appreciate you sitting down and doing this. So let's get right into it. Let's talk about this Capturing Bigfoot thing. You and I got to see it at the same time, in the same theater. I think we had some different reactions to that. Why don't you take us back to the 13th and talk a little bit about that experience and what you thought about capturing Bigfoot?

Speaker 2Well, it was my first time to meet you. It was my first time to meet Roger Patterson's oldest son, Clint Patterson. First time to meet the director of the film Capturing Bigfoot, Mark Evans, and his colleague, the producer, Tamir Hale. I think his last name is Ardon. Capturing Bigfoot, I would recommend to everyone who even has a remote interest in the Bigfoot subject, a remote interest in the Patterson-Gimlin film, I think it was done very well. The

Speaker 2background material about the Patterson family, about Roger himself, and all the people that were in his orbit at the time in question, I think was very well done. There was a little bit of bouncing back and forth as though you were going forward in time and backward in time. But this is how documentaries are done. I think anyone who has even the remotest interest in this should see the film. It's fascinating. In fact, I would say it's probably one of the best Bigfoot documentaries that has ever

Speaker 2been produced. Specifically because it is on Roger Patterson and there's so much background material. Also, I should add, there was a lot of footage and photos that I have never seen before. I'm absolutely going to rent a film or buy a copy. I've never done something like that on Amazon with videos, but I think it was very worthwhile.

Speaker 4I definitely agree.

Speaker 5I've said the same thing since I saw it. No matter where you're at on the Patterson-Gimlin film, being real, being a hoax.

Speaker 4If you're remotely.

Speaker 5Interested in the subject at all, and I've been a part of documentaries that I thought were fantastic. The documentary that we did, My Bigfoot Life, a couple of years ago, was one of the best documentaries I had ever seen. Obviously, I'm a little bit biased because I was a part of that project, but I tell you, capturing Bigfoot is really well done. The archival footage, the archival interviews from Greg Long. I just had a conversation with Greg last week and talked about some of those tapes. And I was so glad that they had access to those and were able to use a lot of that audio and us get to.

Speaker 4Hear some of that stuff for the first time. I think.

Speaker 5For me, the conversation that Greg Long had with Al D'Atli was very eye-opening, and it was one of my favorite parts of the documentary.

Speaker 4Let's get into the nitty-gritty.

Speaker 5I asked you right after we came out of the screening, we didn't get a whole lot of time together, but I did ask you, and now that we've seen this... Did it change your mind on the Patterson-Gimlin film? And you said, oh, no, it did not. So let's talk a little bit about that. What about capturing Bigfoot? Was there any parts of it at all that started leading you down that road? Are you just completely convinced that the Patterson-Gimlin film is what we thought it has been for the last 59 years?

Speaker 2First, there are two different films, obviously. The one thing that I'll agree on is that the person on the horse in the first part of the mystery film That's supposed to be about 40 seconds long. It definitely looks like it's Bob Gimlin. I would have no doubt that is Bob Gimlin. But to be safe, because he is a primary witness, and if it is him, it would be interesting to see what he has to say. So on Saturday, I dropped a letter to him to see

Speaker 2if I can get a response about this very question, because it does appear after watching Capturing Bigfoot, He's sitting outside in a chair, presumably in front of his house, with a laptop in his lap. And he says something to the effect, who's that man on the horse? Once I saw capturing Bigfoot, it certainly looks like it's him. So I want to know if it is him. I'm more interested in finding out when this footage was shot.

Speaker 2But in terms of the actual things that you see in the footage, I saw something that seemed to be stooped over a little bit. I saw the subject in the film that seemed to have an area where you could see this is where the spinal column is. I saw the light-colored feet. I saw the lower leg, I think the left foot, where it seemed to be parallel to the ground. I saw the head that seemed to be bulbous, but with intent to be conical. It felt

Speaker 2to me like, where did they get that information? And it was my idea that this is probably from the original PG film that was shot in October 20th of 1967. So that's my opinion about it. In terms of costume making, because we know the mystery film is Amanda Costume. Everyone agrees upon that. In terms of costume making, if it was before 1967 or after 1967, I think it's the

Speaker 2best fit for a PG film, the best costume I've ever seen, because other people have attempted, such as the late Eric Batchourde. the late Leroy Blevins, and maybe some of the people on documentary films, one from the BBC or something, they did a documentary using the same type of camera. I think they came the closest to the PG film.

Speaker 5I definitely agree with what you're saying about the footage. As soon as I saw it pop up, it immediately looks like to me that it was Bob Gimlin on the horse in the very beginning of that footage. And then we see this creature, and I thought the suit was very good as well. I thought it was a very close match. I've since seen the screenshots are out there. Once the documentary came out for wide release on Amazon, people were starting to screen grab and show these things on Facebook, and I was inundated with all of these

Speaker 5side-by-side comparisons. Somebody sent me a link today to Cliff and Bobo's Bigfoot and Beyond podcast, where It was Cliff, Bobo, and Matt Pruitt were on there. I guess it aired today is when I got it. So they were talking about the film, and Matt even said himself, he said, it's laughable to me. He's questioning why Mark Evans and Tamir and the people behind the film didn't use a better... clip of that mystery footage that we're talking about to go side by side to compare with Patty, because some

Speaker 5of those side by sides are a little laughable. There's one where this thing is looking back at the camera. And it doesn't, at face value, just a cursory look. If you glanced at it, it does look very different. And that's what I'm seeing the most online that people are using to laugh and say, oh, yeah, it's obviously the same exact suit. I didn't get to hear the entire podcast, but listening to Matt and Cliff and Bobo look at it and break it down, they were seeing a lot of similarities. Once they were able to watch it multiple times, they were pausing it, they were doing

Speaker 5screen grabs and going back and looking. Matt was pointing out, very astutely as usual, he was saying that one side-by-side comparison he was doing, it looks like a trapezius muscle in what we know to be this guy in the suit, whoever this is in the mystery film. And he said, I could see now, comparing these things together, how you could see or think you see that in the Patterson-Gimlin film, which is one of the things that people have argued with me about since I come out and said I believe that the Patterson-Gimlin film is a hoax. is what

Speaker 5about the muscle movement? What about all these things that have been scientifically proven over the years? And I was like, not so fast. I don't think anything's been scientifically proven. If anything was scientifically proven about the Patterson-Gimlin film, I think we could say that Sasquatch would probably be closer to being a known, recognized species. There's been some scientists, like the late Jeff Meldrum, several scientists that have taken a look at this and given the opinion that they thought the Patterson-Gimlin film was a real live creature, i.e.

Speaker 5a Sasquatch, but I don't think that's proof. I think it's an opinion given by some in the scientific community. And I think those things are two different things. But honestly, let's shelve for a second the newfound footage, this mystery footage that we're talking about. You say possible recreation. I say it looks more like a rehearsal to me. So we can split hairs on that later. But let me ask you this. This is one thing that I have been screaming to the rafters, and I want to get your thoughts on this, is beyond that. The whole first three quarters of this Capturing Bigfoot documentary have to do

Speaker 5with the Patterson family, i.e. Patricia Patterson, Clint Patterson, and by extension, Roger's sister, Iva Deatley, Al Deatley's widow, confirming that this film is a hoax. They're saying that it's a hoax. Clint is coming clean. The entire story is laid out for us in Capturing Bigfoot. And that's the first thing that I went to because my cop brain says, if I were going to prosecute this as a crime, let's say we're talking about a robbery or a murder,

Speaker 5and you have a person that's accused of this, let's say Roger Patterson's on trial, you have his wife and his son and his sister pointing the finger at him and saying, this guy's guilty, he did this. In this case, we're talking about film, the Patterson-Gimlin film, but it's the same in a court of law. If they were pointing at him and saying, I saw him rob the liquor store, or I saw him shoot this guy in the parking lot. And I know what kind of weight that carries in

Speaker 5a criminal case. If you have somebody in this person's family, much less three family members, pointing the finger. Why are we not taking a closer look at that? So I'll ask it specifically to you. How much weight do you put on Clint Patterson's story, Patricia Patterson being involved in coming out and saying this is a hoax? And we saw together in the same theater, Iva D'Atli, although her interview was cut short, she said, I just want to talk to you guys and I want.

Speaker 4Everybody to know this is a hoax.

Speaker 5So beyond the mystery film, That was a convincing part of this for me. I want you to weigh in on that because I don't think I've heard you talk much about that outside of just saying they weren't there.

Speaker 2That's why I want to buy a copy of the Capturing Bigfoot so I could study it better and see exactly what they had to say. Clint Patterson, his mom, Patricia Patterson, and Roger's sister, Iva D'Athle, to see exactly what they said. But for me... Maybe this is maybe some built-in bias, but I wasn't really too impressed by their confessions in that I've heard people, or if you read about the JFK assassination, do a Wikipedia on it,

Speaker 2there's quite a few people who claim or have confessed that they were the person that killed JFK. And from a logical and common sense point of view, we know it's probably one or two individuals at best. So I wasn't really too moved by the confession. I'm more moved by the strictly the empirical evidence that's seen on the PG film, the subject in it, and also the empirical evidence that's seen on the 42nd mystery film, or if

Speaker 2you want to call it the rehearsal or reenactment film. So that's where I'm at with this matter. Mind you, on October 13th, like you, it was my first time to be introduced to this mystery film. So it's not even the end of October. So I'm all brand new to it. And so I'm trying to put things together to find out more about it.

Speaker 5Let's go back to the mystery film then. That's something that everybody's talking about right now. I mentioned it a little while ago when we first started the interview. That's the big thing right now is the still photos. And I've even seen Todd Gatewood coming out claiming that it's AI because the hat disappears and part of the film. There's so much that's circling the drain at this point. Let's stick to the empirical evidence here.

Speaker 2I loosely keep track of Todd Gatewood and I saw what he's posted that it's AI. In fact, some people sent me an email asking about that private message on Facebook. And at the present time, I have no reason to believe that the mystery footage was an AI creation or anything like that. The film of presumably Bob Gimlin on the horse with the rain slicker and a gun is where he says that the hat is not there at a certain point and the gun disappears. I think you're

Speaker 2saying there is just camera blur and that's it. And he's making a lot out of nothing. But you had another question, I believe.

Speaker 5The thing that has been hammered over and over is we don't know when this mystery film, this newly found footage was shot. That's the thing that everybody goes to because They're saying that it really matters if it was shot before the Patterson-Gimlin film or after. And I see where that could be an issue if you're trying to argue that the Patterson-Gimlin film is real and they just tried to recreate this. So let's go down that path for just a second and talk a little bit about how ridiculous it is, in my opinion, that they would

Speaker 5go back at any point in time and try to recreate this. I'll give you a couple of talking points to respond to here. The first thing that I would say is they were out making money. They were touring with the Patterson-Gimlin film almost immediately after they shot the film, allegedly on October 20th. I don't really believe that the film was shot on October 20th because the timeline doesn't line up for me to be able to shoot that on a Friday and show it in Al D'Atli's house on Sunday. But I have no evidence. That's just a personal opinion. But it doesn't make sense to me that

Speaker 5they would stop touring, making money off the film. We see how much money that they made off the film. They talk about it in Capturing Bigfoot. I think the number they gave was something over $ 600, 000. They talk about one specific night in Utah, I believe it was, where they made $ 84, 000 in a night showing this film. And they were turning people away because they couldn't bring everybody that wanted to see it in. So I guess that's the first question for you is, How does it make sense that even.

Speaker 4A year later or two years later or three years later.

Speaker 5They would spend time, money and effort to go back and try to recreate this? And secondly, now that we've pretty much established, I think everybody that I've seen, I don't think anybody's saying that's not Bob Gimlin on the horse. I did hear somebody try to say it was Bob Hieronymus, which made no sense to me. But I think that's a generally accepted thing that it.

Speaker 4Is Bob on a horse.

Speaker 5We got to remember that Bob and Roger had a major falling out to the point where they had to hire another Bob Gimlin to make some appearances while they were on the road showing the Patterson-Gimlin film because Bob checked out and he wasn't a part of that. So why, number one, would they stop making money and go back and try to recreate this? And secondly, why would Bob be in that footage smiling after the Patterson-Gimlin film was created? because they had a falling out and he wasn't making money off of it. So how do you reconcile those

Speaker 5two points?

Speaker 6Stay tuned for more Sasquatch Odyssey. We'll be right back after these messages.

Speaker 2I don't have an answer to that question. That's why I wrote a letter to Bob Gimlin, because it sure seems that he's on the horse. I agree on that point. I just want to see what he has to say, because This is what I suspect is Al D'Atli and Roger, because Bob Gimlin wouldn't go touring with them, he said he had to get back to work and find a steady source of income, is they pretty much cut him out as a one-third partner. I guess that he got

Speaker 2together with Norm Johnson to do this and I don't even know who's in the suit. See, it's all new to me. I've heard that it's Aldi Attlee in the suit. I'm wondering how that's been established. I'm not even certain if Roger Patterson shot this film. If he did, my question is, why is that film in the possession of Teresa Brooks and not the Patterson family? So to me right now, there's just a whole bunch of questions that swirl in my mind about the whole thing. So- If

Speaker 2you're looking for an authority to give you a definitive answer on all of this stuff, I can't because I'm puzzled by the whole thing. To me, like I said, it looks like that's Bob Gimlin on horse. And if you take the position that this was before the PG film. then what did Bob Gimlin know and when and how did they know they were going to do this film in terms of the characteristics that you see in the film? Because it also has breast or it looks like it appears to have breast. And to me, if I were

Speaker 2going to go fake a Bigfoot movie at that time up in Yakima or thereabouts, I don't think I would tell people that I was working with because there's a person with a camera, there's a person on the horse, there's a person in the costume, so that's three people. I don't think I would say, let's go make a female Bigfoot, because historically, all monster movies have been male-dominated, so that's really strange to me that they would start off, let's make it female. And then later you see in

Speaker 2the actual PG film that it appears to be a female there, so I'm caught up with these questions myself, and I can't tell people I have a definitive answer to any of the questions. Like I said, if Roger Patterson shot this film and he didn't want this to be seen, it seems like he would entrust it to his wife, Patricia Patterson, and say, don't ever show this again. Why does Teresa Brooks have it? I don't have an answer to the question, but eventually want to interview Teresa Brooks to find out what she knows about all of this.

Speaker 4I'm right there with you.

Speaker 5I have so many questions that I heard Matt Pruitt say something today that really got me thinking. He's a very smart guy. He said it doesn't make a whole lot of sense to him that it was Al D'Atli in the suit because we've pretty well established, again, it is anecdotal, it is not fact, but it is a pretty well-known and established thing that Dave Johnson, Norm Johnson's brother ran around with Roger Patterson and presumably Bob Gimlin and in that crew. And he was known, at least

Speaker 5by most people that tell the stories, that he was running around in a costume. And Mark Evans even talked about that, I think, during the Q & A, that he got shot in the ass by somebody. It might have even been Jerry Merritt, him running around outside his house. I think Jerry Merritt's wife supposedly saw this creature and Jerry took a pot shot at him. And Dave got shot in the ass because he was running around in this Bigfoot suit. So Matt postulated that it was more likely he would be a better candidate. And I think the reason that everybody landed on Al D'Atli was because literally,

Speaker 5I've talked about it in my review that I put out after watching Capturing Bigfoot, Clint Patterson sat right next to me in the theater and I was able to watch him and hear his reactions. And when that part of the film came up and he saw this mystery film start, He said out loud, man, that looks like Al's walk. And I think the other thing that really pushed Mark and Tamir and potentially Clint even to the point of thinking it was most likely Al D'Atli was, again, those anecdotal stories that did not make it in the

Speaker 5documentary that Iva D'Atli was telling them when they were there to interview her at their house in Yakima. She told him stories about Al coming home and bitching and being upset that Roger had him traipsing around in the woods in this Bigfoot costume. And he had hair and glue and things stuck to his feet. So I think they put those things together and they're just assuming that it was Al D'Atli.

Speaker 2Here's another thing, too. Iva D'Atli is still living. And presumably, she is the person in charge of the Al and Iva D'Atli trust. So... I still have trouble with the people coming in during the filming. How did they know they were being filmed at that time to shut it down? Because Iva D'Atli still living is to write or talk to her to say, hey, I want to go over these issues if she'd be willing to talk and tell her my connection to Pat Patterson, who I still speak

Speaker 2with every once in a while, to get her story because it wasn't presented in full in the documentary Capturing Bigfoot. So Iva D'Atli is still living, so hopefully she's willing to answer more questions, and so is Bob Gimlin. And hopefully he's willing to answer more questions, because I agree with you 100%. It does appear to be Bob Gimlin on the horse, but as for the person in the costume, I'm not sure. But if anyone would be able to

Speaker 2recognize him, it would be Clint, because presumably Clint is a young boy. Iva is Roger's sister. that they had seen one another during family gatherings.

Speaker 5Here's the other question that I have for you is, why do you think it is, if Bob Gimlin is the man on the horse, and I recall what you were saying in Capturing Bigfoot, Bob did have a couple of moments where he appeared to not really understand. It appeared that he was having a hard time hearing what Clint was saying when they approached him at the Yakima Bigfoot Con, maybe even during his interview. And he was shown the film on a smaller screen, a laptop. Again, it looked like, as you said, outside of his house during that interview when he says, who's the man on

Speaker 5the horse? But if you recall earlier, there's a very well-known photo that I've seen circulating for years of I think it's five or six people. And one of those people was Bob Gimlin. One was Roger Patterson. The other one was Bob Hieronymus, his brother. And I think the other one might have been Jerry Merritt. I don't remember. So don't quote me on that. But Bob didn't recognize himself in that photograph. And it's a well-known, established photograph. That didn't really surprise me. But here's the thing that has surprised me. Bob has talked about this story for

Speaker 559 years. He started with interviews right after it happened. I've listened to some of those interviews from just days after the film allegedly being shot. And he's talked about it up until 2019, 2020, and he's even made appearances after that. And I don't know anyone who has ever heard Bob Gimlin say anything about being on a horse, being filmed with anybody in a Bigfoot costume before, during, or after a The Patterson-Gimlin film was allegedly shot. Does

Speaker 5that bother you at all?

Speaker 2It bothers me 100%. It bothers me tremendously. I wrote about it, I guess, in April, the April edition of the Bigfoot Times newsletter, that I made a statement to the fact that if Roger and Bob were in cahoots doing this mystery film... that they should have got ahead of this story a long time ago, even before Roger died, and put it out to the public to say, hey, this is what we did at such and such a time. So right now, capturing Bigfoot does strongly suggest that mystery

Speaker 2film was shot before the PG film, not after. But because Bob and Roger are presumably tied to that film, they should have put out a statement that this is what we did and this is when we did it. But right now we don't know. Bob is still living, so I'm hoping that he's willing to come forward with more information. That's why I wrote the letter to him. The first letter I wrote, he wrote back, so I'm hoping he writes back. The reason I don't call Bob anymore,

Speaker 2I think the last time I spoke with him on the phone was 2021 or thereabouts. His wife had to get on the phone, too, because it was very clear to me that he was having trouble hearing what I was saying. And I started shouting into the phone. I thought to myself, this should probably be the last phone call, not because I don't want to talk to Bob, but because of his hearing problems. So this was... maybe 2021. And then Judy got on the line too. And we

Speaker 2had a, just a little chat had nothing to do with Bigfoot. So if this recording for capturing Bigfoot, when he did that Yakima Bigfoot corner, whenever it was a couple of years ago, I'm just assuming that he probably had trouble hearing. I don't know, but that's what I suspect. That's the only reason I don't call Bob Gimlin anymore. It's because he can't hear.

Speaker 5The other thing that stuck out to me that I want to get your opinion on, you got to see this and everybody obviously that's seen Capturing Bigfoot saw this, is the late Dr.

Speaker 4Jeff Meldrum. He was there.

Speaker 5I've talked about it in my review, but it was clear that he was doing.

Speaker 4What he's always done.

Speaker 5We've always heard him talk about the Patterson-Gimlin film, how sure he was. And then it just kept going in the movie. You could tell they were leading him. And Jeff very astutely, as always, said out loud in the film, it seems like you guys are leading me to a precipice that you're just going to push me over. And then they show him this newfound footage. I've known Jeff for four or five years. I didn't know him well. We didn't go out to dinner every evening. It wasn't like that. But I have spoken at conferences with him. I have had dinner with him. I have had conversations

Speaker 5about Todd Standing and other things in the Bigfoot community. I've had him on the show multiple times. I've seen him in conferences. I got to talk to him just a couple of months before he passed away when I saw him up in Tennessee. We got to share a moment and I got to show him some casts from right here on my property. I said all that to say, I think I have a pretty good understanding of Jeff's demeanor and how he carried himself.

Speaker 4He's always very careful.

Speaker 5With his words, no matter where you were at a private dinner or if he's up in front of 500 people talking at a podium, he was always very careful with his words. And he said some things in the Capturing Bigfoot documentary that didn't seem to be, in my opinion, as some people have suggested, creative editing to try to put words into his mouth and make it look like something that it's not. I'm of the opinion, and I got the feeling watching him, that he had a shift. I don't know how large that shift was, because obviously

Speaker 5I didn't have a follow-up conversation with him, and I have not reached out to Cliff, but I'm going to reach out and have a conversation with Cliff about this, because I've seen some things. I think it was a tweet that someone sent me, a screenshot, that Cliff put out that he had talked to Jeff after this, that anybody who's suggesting that Jeff shifted from believing that the Patterson-Gimlin film was real to it being a hoax is misguided or something. And obviously, I'm paraphrasing this comment. I got the impression that Jeff felt differently after seeing this

Speaker 5newfound footage. The thing that stuck out to me was one of the last things that he said on camera in the follow-up interview they had after he had processed that for a couple of days. Mark Evans had told me during his interview they went back to see Jeff after he had 24, 48 hours, whatever it was, to process what they had showed him. And I'm paraphrasing here, but I'm getting very close to his actual words as I remember them. The Patterson-Gimlin film may have ran its course. but that does not mean that Sasquatch doesn't exist. So

Speaker 5I don't know how you felt about that, but did you feel watching that that Jeff may have had a shift in his belief about the PG film?

Speaker 2He may have. I can't speak for him. Those were his thoughts, not my thoughts. So he may have shifted, but One thing that I'll tell anyone who's willing to listen is the Patterson-Gimlin film, to me, is a piece of evidence, or at least it looks like a piece of evidence for the existence of Bigfoot. But then when you talk about the subject in general, we don't know Bigfoot as a species to be a fact. That's basically the start and the beginning of it. Until a body

Speaker 2is brought in, we don't even know if this species is out there. It seems like it is, but no one can prove it.

Speaker 6Stay tuned for more Sasquatch Odyssey. We'll be right back after these messages.

Speaker 2So if you can't prove Bigfoot's for real, you're probably never going to be able to prove that the Patterson-Gimlin film is real. I know the jury is out, and after capturing Bigfoot, it's even more out. We did a podcast, I guess it was last week, a whole group of us on Sasquatch Secrets. I guess the lady's name was Nikki. I prepared some statements, and I said, even before the mystery film came along, the world was divided over the PG film, in that some thought it was just a

Speaker 2man in a suit, while others felt it was a female Bigfoot. So with the release of Capturing Bigfoot, nothing has really changed in my mind. In the court of public opinion, it may be proof, but in a rigorous scientific setting, it will likely come up short. I still stand by that statement today that Capturing Bigfoot maybe has shifted some people's mind, but we don't know for a fact that the PG film is real because we don't know for a fact that Bigfoot is real. It's still

Speaker 2a great mystery on the planet. I've spoken with people all over the United States and in Australia and in Russia, people claiming to have seen Bigfoot-like creatures, but no one has a body to show us. So it's an open question.

Speaker 5This is the other thing that I have seen circling the drain in the Bigfoot community that.

Speaker 4Has just driven me insane.

Speaker 5Again, I've pretty much accepted the fact that I believe the PGF is a hoax. I know there's a lot of people on the fence still. There's still people that believe it's 100% real. But people are talking about the secondary evidence, particularly the trackway. That's one of the first questions that I asked when I got the opportunity to talk to Mark Evans was, is that addressed at all in the Capturing Bigfoot documentary?

Speaker 4It is not.

Speaker 5Because they're working from the angle that the film is fake. And if the film is fake, then all of the secondary evidence that goes along with that film is also fake. And that's one of the things that I did hear Cliff talk about. I'm going to go back and listen to that full episode of their Bigfoot and Beyond podcast probably tomorrow at some point. But I did hear Cliff speak specifically about the footprints and how obviously Jeff was convinced. That's one of the first things he told me when I had him on the show years ago. was Brian,

Speaker 5I am as convinced as I could possibly be based on the footprint evidence alone that Patty is a real live Sasquatch. That's something that Cliff is obviously very interested in. I'm also interested in that. I would love to figure out, because obviously if this is a hoax, then that means Patty is a man in a suit, most likely Bob Hieronymus in the suit. So how did they create the trackway and ultimately the cast that we see So there's all kinds of things swirling around. But how do you

Speaker 5feel about the secondary evidence? Obviously, if you're looking at it from an investigative standpoint and you're approaching it from a scientific approach, you have to prove that the subject's real for any of that secondary evidence to even matter.

Speaker 4But where are you? Because I've seen you post a little bit about that.

Speaker 2Let me explain from my point of view, the trackway, the plaster of Paris castings, the footprints, the film shot of the footprints. Most people maybe are unaware that after Roger Patterson ran out of film of the creature, that he put a second roll of film in the camera to document the trackway that was left behind. And this was happening the same day. As time went on, and this is why I do bibliography on the PG films,

Speaker 2is that Rene DeHinden made a statement, and this was probably around 1975, after Roger Patterson passed away. He said, we have no evidence that the subject in the Patterson-Gimlet film and the tracks that it allegedly left behind are related. That's a very profound statement. But in 2006, a researcher from Mississippi, M.K. Davis, demonstrated by way of the actual PG film, that as the subject walks, it leaves a

Speaker 2wake behind as a boat in a water when you see the waves and you see the indentations in the ground of where she had just walked. And so at that time, we had no other choice but to make M.K. Davis our Bigfooter of the Year for 2006. But I thought that was a very profound observation and something that no one had noted before because there are certain frames there I wish I could show them on your podcast or show them on the internet where the subject in

Speaker 2the early frames, you see the indentations in the ground where she had just walked. And it seems to make sense that those are her footprints and you could definitely tie the footprints to the subject in the original film. And so my analogy is that if someone were robbing a bank and say the bank was brand new, a Bank of America in a brand new city, and they hadn't did any paving outside. It was just all dirt outside. And the bank robber ran away with the money, and

Speaker 2his shoes are in the dirt. And then you have this trackway of the bank robber. In an investigative process and in criminal proceedings, they would say, hey, we have the cameras rolling, so we have the picture of the suspect. Then we also have his tracks in the ground because witnesses had seen him come out of the bank and there's the tracks in the dirt. The two pieces of evidence go together, the image of the bank robber on camera and the trackway that is left behind once he

Speaker 2leaves the bank in the dirt soil. And the same thing with Patty. So I think people will eventually revisit MK Davis and this novel observation that he made in 2006. And I was at the time just casually following him. And when I saw that when he put this out, I think I phoned him up and asked for more information. He said something to the fact that he was an astronomy buff and that he called it secondary image tagging.

Speaker 2And I guess this has something to do with astronomy. But he was able to see very clearly that that there's the trackway, the indentation of the subject in the sandbar as she walks, and this is right behind her. So I think that's very profound, and so if someone said that because the subject's fate detracts her of no value. I disagree on that point.

Speaker 4I hear what you're saying. I totally get it.

Speaker 5I think for me, there's a lot of things that M.K. Davis has put out there, the massacre theory and the baby Bigfoots and all the things that have come after that.

Speaker 2We talked about it in my book, Bigfoot at Bluff Creek. We talk about his novel observation, comma, and say after many other colorful observations throughout the years. I get that. I understand that.

Speaker 5Bill Munns was the first person that I had an interview with after I had Eric Palacios on, after he saw the Capturing Bigfoot documentary at South by Southwest back in March, I believe it was. I spent probably an hour with Bill Munns and Bill obviously laid out the case for why he believes that the Patterson-Gimlin film is real. And it's all based for him on the fact that the technology simply didn't exist to build a suit that way. And he laid out many things. everybody that's listening can go back and listen to that if you want. But

Speaker 5it seems to me that is clearly, even in this conversation, you and I, I believe we agreed on that point, that the suit that we see in this newfound footage is very impressive. There are side-by-side comparisons. Again, anybody can take that and splice it and make it look very different from the Patterson-Gimlin film with different angles and things like that. Again, I'll go back to what Matt Pruitt said today and the conversation he was having with Cliff and Bobo on their podcast, Matt was talking about how the hands are spot on, the feet are spot on,

Speaker 5the shoulders are spot on. He's seeing the same what looks like a trapezius muscle. Obviously, he conceded that the head looks different, the face looks different, the mammary glands or the breasts on this creature in this newfound footage are smaller or appear to be smaller than than what we eventually see in the Patterson-Gimlin film. So I think there were alterations made, and that's another point that I'll just throw out there now. If this were a recreation, why would we have a completely different suit than what

Speaker 5we had in the Patterson Gimlin film? Why wouldn't they just use the same thing? That's a whole other conversation for another day. If Munns is so convinced, and that's what he's been belaboring the point on for decades in looking at the Patterson Gimlin film, what we see, I think we can all.

Speaker 4Agree, is a really good suit.

Speaker 5Even if you say it doesn't look anything like Patty, it looks better than anything that we've seen to date, in my opinion, to even come close to that. Do you feel similarly as far as what we see on the suit?

Speaker 2I agree 100% that whoever made that suit is the best I've ever seen in terms of matching the PG film subject. I agree on that point 100%.

Speaker 6That's why.

Speaker 2This whole thing, again, you and I saw the footage for the very first time October 13th, and it's October 26th. I work full-time, so I'm still trying to process the whole thing. My mind is swirling with all these ideas and questions about the whole thing. My jury is still out there, but I'm still convinced that the original PG film depicts a female Bigfoot. But I have all these questions, and if Bob was on the horse like I think he is... I want to know, I asked him in

Speaker 2my letter to him and I made a copy of it. And two of my other questions is, is that you on the horse? Maybe your memory wasn't too good the first time I wrote you. Two, when was it shot and where was it shot? Because a lot of people would like to follow up on that question because I think it's very intriguing. And in my statement on the Sasquatch Secrets podcast, I said, I think the film that has been produced and shown on Capturing Bigfoot is very significant and worthy of our attention. But with that being said,

Speaker 2I made another statement there, and I'll read from my notes here. The runtime for a standard 100-foot roll of film at 18 frames per second is about 3 minutes and 42 seconds. The mystery film, as per Mark Evans, is about 40 seconds long. So obviously, a section of the film was cut out. So the question is, where is the rest of the film? So no matter what, if you were to buy a car and you drive it off the lot, you say to your spouse or

Speaker 2whoever the case may be, it only has three tires. Everyone knows most cars have four tires. And you go back, hey, where's the fourth tire? The guy will say, don't you know, cars only come with three tires. But no, we all know cars come with four tires. So that's my question is that the film is 40 seconds long. It's just short. There obviously has to be more of the film that has been cut out of the mystery film. So that's the question. I can't say that film is edited, but

Speaker 2it's obviously been chopped or spliced in the sense that When you process a 100-foot roll, you get back a 100-foot roll because there's no negative in film. They put it in soup, and that's how it's processed, and then you have the developed film. It's only a short piece of a longer segment. So I'm wondering, did they chop the rest off because it shows something that might be incriminating in the sense that it'll give you a time period when it was shot? So maybe you'll see a

Speaker 21970 film Mustang in there and say, how can a 1970 Mustang be in a 1966 film? That, I think, is a very valid question.

Speaker 5Lots of great questions. I guess this will be the last question for you. Again, I'll go back to Cliff and Bobo and Matt today. Just because it's so fresh, I heard some rumblings on social media right before Capturing Bigfoot came out. People were posting about Bobo had made some comments, and I don't know this to be factual. I'm just throwing out there what I've heard. that he couldn't wait to tear down the Capturing Bigfoot documentary and tear it apart or whatnot. But I can tell you, just from what I heard today, it sounded like he, Matt,

Speaker 5and Cliff were all leaning towards the Patterson-Gimlin film being a hoax. And Cliff, very much like you, said astutely that there are some questions.

Speaker 4Where's the rest of the film? What about this? What about that?

Speaker 5He certainly has questions. And he said, look, I think those are fair questions coming from somebody, and he said this a couple of times, who is, I'm pretty much convinced that the Patterson-Gimlin film is probably a hoax, but I still think those are valid questions. And he's urging people not to jump to conclusions. I guess I'm probably in that category because I watched the film and I immediately said, It's a slam dunk for me. I guess I just need less convincing than other people because I tend to look at the totality of the circumstances because that's how I was trained to do it, right? If

Speaker 5you go out as a street cop, you got to answer a 911 call and there's five more calls that you got to go answer after that one. You don't get the opportunity to spend 14 hours investigating something. You have to take in all the facts pretty quickly and make an informed decision. And that's basically what I did with Capturing Bigfoot. I came right home from the trip. As soon as I was able to buy it, I bought a copy of it on Amazon and I've watched it a couple of times since then. I'm certainly going to go back and do very much like you were talking about and pay more attention to what's actually being said and then study the mystery film a little bit

Speaker 5more and maybe see some things that I didn't get to see the first time. But just to hear someone like Cliff and Bobo and Matt Pruitt say they're leaning towards this thing looking like it's a hoax and I guess the question for you is, with all these questions that you have and all the knowledge that you have of the Patterson-Gimlin film from years of studying it, what would it take for you to convince you, beyond a reasonable doubt, let's say, that the Patterson-Gimlin film was in fact hoaxed?

Speaker 6Stay tuned for more Sasquatch Odyssey. We'll be right back after these messages.

Speaker 2I think I made this analogy on another show. If you brought out, say, a 1985 Ford Mustang, and then you wanted an identical match, you bring out another 1985 Ford Mustang, but maybe one car is black, the other is white, and you said they're exactly the same except for the color. But if you brought out, say, a 1980 Ford Mustang or a 1983 Ford Mustang... and you put them side by side with a 1985 Mustang. They look alike, but they're not exactly. This is where I'm

Speaker 2at with the PG film and the mystery film, is the resemblance is remarkable, but not exactly. And so if someone could come up with something that is exactly the same, because if you assume it's a suit, then someone should be able to build a suit. But with that being said... If the proponents say that the PG film is in the mystery film, the same suit, as someone has stated, it's exactly the same suit. So I throw this out.

Speaker 4I'm a union.

Speaker 2Licensed electrician, not a detective. I made this statement on another show. I think a great litmus test for both the mystery film and the PG film would be a spectral signature as both films are simply light hitting a piece of plastic through a lens and reacting to chemicals. If the spectral signatures are the same, a case can be made of the two films being the same. If the spectral signature is different, it is very likely the two films represent a man in a costume and a female Bigfoot. With the cooperation of Teresa Brooks, the owner

Speaker 2of the mystery film, we might be able to go forward with more rigorous testings on both films. It's almost like when you're testing for elements, I guess they shoot light and you get a certain spectral signature. I think you could do the same thing because I think they do this photographic testing with fake fur to figure out what's fake fur and what's real fur. And so if we can proceed with that, we might have a definitive answer. If they come back the same from the spectral signature,

Speaker 2they're one of the same. But if they're vastly different, then you say, hey, we know one is a man in a costume, but the other is coming back different. What is it?

Speaker 5We've mentioned it a couple of times. Before we get out of here, tell everybody about your book, what they can expect when they pick it up, and where can they get it?

Speaker 2The book I wrote was before Capturing Bigfoot came out, so there's no Capturing Bigfoot in it because I had no knowledge as to what these people were up to. It's called Bigfoot at Bluff Creek, a Pictorial Discussion. You have a copy. It's a coffee-sized table book, 8 1⁄2 by 11, full-color, printed in the United States with never-before-seen images and photos from the Patterson-Gimlin film site that were shot in June of 1968. It's loaded with all sorts

Speaker 2of information that you've never read before, interviews with primary eyewitnesses who were witness to the Bigfoot tracks right after Patty departed, such as Lyle Laverty and Richard Henry, people that most of the Bigfoot public are not familiar with. And if you want to get a copy, simply go to bigfoottimes.net.

Speaker 5And I will make it easy for everybody. As always, I will link to it right here in the show notes. You guys go pick up a copy of the book. It is an excellent book. As always, Daniel, thank you so much for spending time with us, man. I've had a blast talking to you.

Speaker 2Thank you for having me. It's always nice. And it was very nice to meet you, October 13th.

Speaker 6They say you don't gotta go home.

Speaker 3Bye. Bye. Thank you.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Slate Branch Bigfoot File: Part Two

    Nov 22, 202657 minAudio

    On October 7, 2017, Tom Rigsby watched something large, dark, and walking upright cross a remote logging road in western North Carolina. The encounter lasted less than five seconds. Tom waited two days before reporting...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Arrangement: Part Eight

    Nov 18, 202650 minAudio

    For four generations, Jimmy’s family kept an extraordinary secret hidden on eighty acres in the mountains of North Georgia. But as the legend of Bigfoot captured America’s attention, protecting that secret became...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Run! Bigfoot In Alaska

    Nov 15, 202641 minAudio

    Fred from the SubArctic Alaska Sasquatch YouTube channel is back with two terrifying Bigfoot encounter stories from the remote Alaskan wilderness. First, Trina and Dave travel by boat up the Yukon River near Ruby,...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Does Bigfoot Want To Be Seen?

    Nov 13, 202643 minAudio

    From terrifying encounters on an Oklahoma reservation to mysterious figures lurking in the California wilderness, Jerry joins Brian on Sasquatch Odyssey to share a lifetime of experiences he believes are connected to...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Slate Branch Bigfoot File: Part One

    Nov 11, 202649 minAudio

    On October 7, 2017, a road maintenance contractor traveling an isolated logging road in western North Carolina encountered something he initially believed was a black bear. But when the creature crossed directly in...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode