If you have ever wondered why you are holding water despite doing everything right, this episode is for you. I dive into the complex physiological mechanisms behind water retention, moving beyond the simple vanity aspect to explore its real impact on health. By understanding these root causes, you can stop second-guessing your plan, avoid the "screw it" effect, and manage those normal fluctuations with an objective, informed perspective. Topics discussed: - The health implications of water retention - The three main hormones controlling water balance - The role of stress and high cortisol - The Minnesota Starvation Experiment - The impact of poor sleep and circadian rhythm - Sodium and potassium imbalances - The relationship between carbohydrate intake, glycogen storage, and water weight ---------- My Live Program for Coaches: The Functional Nutrition and Metabolism Specialization www.metabolismschool.com ---------- [Free] Metabolism School 101: The Video Series http://www.metabolismschool.com/metabolism-101 ---------- Subscribe to My Youtube Channel: https://youtube.com/@sammillerscience?si=s1jcR6Im4GDHbw_1 ---------- Grab a Copy of My New Book - Metabolism Made Simple ---------- Stay Connected: Instagram: @sammillerscience Youtube: SamMillerScience Facebook: The Nutrition Coaching Collaborative Community TikTok: @sammillerscience ---------- “This Podcast is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute the practice of medicine, nursing or other professional health care services, including the giving of medical advice, and no doctor/patient relationship is formed. The use of information on this podcast and the show notes or the reliance on the information provided is to be done at the user's own risk. The content of this podcast is not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment and is for educational purposes only. Always consult your physician before beginning any exercise program and users should not disregard, or delay in obtaining, medical advice for any medical condition they may have and should seek the assistance of their health care professionals for any such conditions. By accessing this Podcast, the listener acknowledges that the entire contents and design of this Podcast, are the property of Oracle Athletic Science LLC, or used by Oracle Athletic Science LLC with permission, and are protected under U.S. and international copyright and trademark laws. Except as otherwise provided herein, users of this Podcast may save and use information contained in the Podcast only for personal or other non-commercial, educational purposes. No other use, including, without limitation, reproduction, retransmission or editing, of this Podcast may be made without the prior written permission of Oracle Athletic Science LLC, which may be requested by contacting the Oracle Athletic Science LLC by email at operations@sammillerscience.com. By accessing this Podcast, the listener acknowledges that Oracle Athletic Science LLC makes no warranty, guarantee, or representation as to the accuracy or sufficiency of the information featured in this Podcast."
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
There's nothing more frustrating than tracking your food, hitting your workouts, and all of a sudden you see the scale start to creep up and your stomach starts to look like maybe it's holding more water than it was a week ago. You might be thinking, what gives? Why is this happened to me? Why do I look puffy? Why are you not liking what you're seeing in the mirror? Inside today's episode, we're going to be talking about the plight commonly known as water retention. What's up and welcome to Similar Science, where you're joining me just over a decade into my personal journey of working to bridge the gap between metabolism, macros, muscle in
medicine, all while helping coaches scale the impact that they desire and deserve. If you are here, thank you so much for listening and for trusting me to help you elevate your coaching game or to lead you in your transformation to. Realize your true. Potential. In either case, each week I'll be sharing my methods, models, a message to serve as leverage for your. Specific goals without. Further ADO, let's get on to. Today's show, There's nothing more frustrating than tracking your food, hitting your workouts, and all of a sudden you see the scale start to creep up and your stomach starts to look like maybe it's holding more water than it was a week ago. You might be thinking, what
gives? Why is this happen to me? Why do I look puffy? Why are you not liking what you're seeing in the mirror? And in many cases, there are different factors that can contribute to water retention, and those vary from electrolyte imbalances, hormone dysfunction and more. Inside today's episode, we're going to be talking about the plight commonly known as water retention. To some, someone who's less informed about water retention can easily cause second guessing of your current plan or program and negative emotions that can definitely cause the screw it effect, which is typically when
people just go off plan or go off the rails because they see scale weight creep up or they're holding a bit of water after exerting any type of effort. Now, when you're informed about normal fluctuations and their causes, water retention during dieting can still mess with your head. But the purpose of this podcast is to give you the education to understand how to manage that negative of emotion and rumination with an objective set of eyes. And I think that can go a really, really long way. So besides just being a vanity thing, increased water retention can contribute to high blood pressure.
And that's an important health consideration. Depending on the context, if someone is lean and otherwise healthy, the effect probably won't be super noticeable. But in the context of someone having, you know, a history of being overweight or maybe they're pre diabetic, insulin resistant, history of high blood pressure or cardiovascular issues, water retention does have real potential to, you know, increase that blood pressure further. One of the factors contributing to blood pressure is just how much fluid volume you have within your arteries. And if there's more fluid, there's simply more volume pushing out against those arteries, potentially increasing
blood pressure. So increased water retention doesn't generally just mean underneath the skin. Some of the causes we'll talk about increased whole body water retention, including even that of your arteries. And when it comes to root causes of water retention, there's three main hormones that control water balance in the body. These are a big, big part of the root cause considerations and many but not all of the subsequent things that we're going to talk about in today's episode are influencing one or several of these three hormones. The first is anti diuretic
hormone or ADH. This is also known as vasopressin or arginine. Vasopressin and ADH is secreted by the posterior pituitary and acts at the level of the kidneys to reabsorb water back into circulation. There's a fun fact here, Alcohol inhibits the release of ADH, which is why sometimes you start peeing like nobody's business after a couple drinks. It's something that you may notice after alcohol. Now obviously water, sodium and things like that can influence that effect as well. Aldosterone or aldosterone normally released in situations of low blood pressure or dehydration is important because
it acts on the kidneys to increase sodium retention and potassium excretion. When more sodium is retained, it draws fluid with it and thereby causing water to be retained as part of that when the heart senses higher. Our trio stretch then is necessary as well as high systemic blood pressure and releases ANP which acts at the kidneys to increase their filtration rate as well as excreting sodium and water, which has the effect of decreasing blood pressure as well. We look at upstream causes. Stress and high cortisol are
definitely potential reasons for water retention. In an experiment known as as the Minnesota Starvation Experiment, Ansel Keys LED a study to look at the physiological effects of starvation. It involved 36 men over six months, and the men were doing hard physical labor and had baseline expenditures of around 3200 calories. When the study began, they were cut to 1500 calories and maintained the routine of hard labor. During the first months, the researchers noticed steady weight loss, usually around 2 to 4 lbs a week, depending on the individual. After about two months, however,
weight loss became extremely nonlinear, and the researchers noted that all of the men's scale weights would be stable for one to three weeks. And then one morning they'd wake up and they may even be many pounds lighter. This was called the whoosh effect, and anyone who's dieted extensively will know that sometimes this can happen even if that study was a small sample size and maybe not necessarily perfect for all applications across nutrition coaching. This is something that occurred at random, but always occurred after a high calorie meal. For example, at the halfway point of the study, the researchers gave them a 2300
calorie meal in addition to their other calories, and everyone woke up 3 to 4 lbs lighter the next morning. Your dieting or your calorie restricted and it's going well, but then all of a sudden you start to look worse. It's almost like you're puffier than you were before. And sometimes when you add additional food back in, sometimes known as refeeding, this can take care of it. So as you're dieting, you're going to have steadily increasing levels of basal cortisol. And mechanistically, one of the things that's causing the water retention in the situation is actually cortisol itself. Cortisol can bind to the receptor that aldosterone
normally does and cause sodium and fluid retention. Interestingly, cortisol has been shown to inhibit ADH, the hormone that normally conserves water. But it's been shown that under the conditions of psychological stress, both cortisol and ADH increase significantly. The increases in ADH could contribute to what we're seeing here as well. So any situation where you have increased cortisol for longer periods of time, you might be retaining more water. Consistent poor sleep is another example of where this might occur or have an impact on
cortisol and circadian rhythm. Another potential reason for water retention is going to be imbalances in sodium and potassium because that consumption can vary. While many mechanisms of water retention from other causes are generated by increased retention of sodium at the kidney, it also makes sense that increasing the sodium coming in relative to what you used to consume will also potentially cause water retention. There are many mechanisms behind this, and to detail a couple, when you have a large amount of sodium in the interstitial fluid, it's going to draw water
in with it. But then when you have a large bolus dose of sodium that exceeds the current homeostatic set point of salt balance in the body, in order to excrete the excess sodium, the kidneys concentrate it for excretion. And how you increase the concentration of something is by removing liquid. So the kidney reabsorbs significant amounts of water to concentrate sodium for excretion, leading to excess body water under conservation until the excess sodium is out, after which point it increases water excretion as well. Another reason for what we could
be seeing with water retention is carbohydrate intake and the hormone insulin. If you're interested in learning more about insulin, I've covered it before in the podcast feed. You can just give it a quick search on Spotify or your favorite podcast channel. Chances are if you've increased carbohydrate or had a high calorie meal, usually those have a boatload of sodium which is going to influence water retention. But a lot of times when people refeed or eat higher calories, they're also consuming a very large amount of carbohydrate. Carbohydrates can increase water retention by a few different mechanisms. First, there's an increase in intracellular fluid, and that's
largely due to glycogen storage, because when carbs are stored, they're stored with water. 2nd, and probably the real culprit of the puffiness for water retention is the high insulin levels from the resulting large amount of carbohydrate will directly act at the kidney to increase sodium reabsorption. Chronic hyperinsulinemia also increases the action of aldosterone at the kidneys. So you have a 1-2 punch of sodium and therefore water retention. Another reason, and we see this sometimes with people who are beginners in their fitness journey, not necessarily people who have been doing it for a while but not drinking enough
water. When your body senses that it's low on fluid has many water conservation mechanisms in place. This involves all three of the hormones that I previously discussed earlier in the episode. So when the body senses low fluid, it's going to increase aldosterone and ADH and decrease A&P, switching on these different levers for increased fluid retention. So when you drink enough water, and I do have some hydration episodes on this, if you do want to check out the science of hydration to learn more about how to do this properly. Some people do over consume water without adequate electrolytes and that can cause
issues like headaches and other imbalances as well. Our next potential root cause of water retention is inflammation, because when inflammation is present, the body releases histamine. Histamine causes the gaps between cells of the capillary walls to widen. This is to make room for white blood cells to come and fight any infection that may be present in the body. This is completely normal during an acute injury and any type of swelling. But when you have systemic inflammation present, the same capillary wall widening can happen even without the presence of white blood cells.
When the capillary walls widen, inevitably a bit of fluid will leak out into that interstitial space, which can contribute to or 'cause that puffy look that you're. Other conditions that parallel systemic inflammation may also cause a 1-2 punch. So things like metabolic syndrome, for example, the hyperinsulinemia is causing sodium retention at the level of the kidney. Plus the presence of systemic inflammation results in even more water retention. If you've had very overweight clients or people with significant metabolic syndrome or type 2 diabetes, you may have noticed that when they first
started losing fat, the initial water drop was much larger than average. With their lifestyle, training and nutrition changes. Another hormone to consider when it comes to water retention is estrogen. Estrogen mainly acts to lower the thermostat on when ADH releases. So normally ADH is secreted when plasma sodium reaches a certain level, estrogen rises. It lowers the threshold of plasma sodium which ADH is released. And remember that ADH anti diuretic hormone conserves and retains body water. It also has a small effect on the Renan angiotensin system
which contributes to water retention as well. Progesterone on the other hand acts as a natural diuretic. So when a woman has hormonal imbalances, mainly the common occurrence of high estrogen relative to progesterone, which is typically higher estradiol and lower progesterone, if you're looking at that in serum labs, she's going to experience significantly more water retention during certain times of her cycle than a woman that has a slightly more balanced set of hormones or hormonal profile. When you combine this higher estradiol and low progesterone and just the hormonal imbalances in general, this can make you feel a little more emotional and
less resilient to psychological stress. And that psychological stress can increase water retention via cortisol as well. So it can be a little bit of a nasty feed forward cycle there. Testosterone and derivatives are also considerations when it comes to water retention. Testosterone and normal concentrations in the body typically won't cause excess water retention. So for example, endogenous production in a male client at normal levels. But the variations day-to-day are pretty minimal for men and therefore testosterone does not normally contribute to changes in daily body water fluctuations
or water retention. However, with exogenous testosterone or super physiological levels of testosterone, this increases that Renan angiotensin system signaling and aldosterone causing sodium retention. People using anabolic steroids are therefore going to be significantly more sensitive to changes in dietary sodium as far as body water retention goes, which is sometimes you see people being a little more restrictive with sodium in bodybuilding communities. Testosterone has a mild influence on ADH itself, with increases in testosterone increasing ADH. Now, higher levels of
testosterone will mean higher levels of estrogen in men via aromatase, assuming that people aren't taking crazy doses of an aromatase inhibitor. And estrogen has a greater influence on increasing ADH than even testosterone does. So that normal conversion process of testosterone or rheumatizing an estrogen can contribute to water retention. Now this can get out of hand obviously, as those doses climb, but testosterone also increases the capability of glycogen to be stored. So more glycogen means more water retention. And higher levels of testosterone also increase the amount of creatine that can be
stored into the muscles. So more creatine, more carbs, more testosterone, more estrogen equals more water. So when we think about that in many of those cases like creatine, carbohydrate, intramuscular water or glycogen is important for training. This isn't just extracellular water. So it should actually make musculature look more full. It's not necessarily like your average general population client that just feels a little bit puffy when they look in the mirror. And while we're covering hormones, another important one to address is growth hormone. Super physiological levels or
performance enhancing doses of growth hormone can also cause significant amounts of water retention and even people who may be taking this for anti aging reasons, if those Ius start to climb can lead to increases in aldosterone and ADH. Most of the studies done to examine this water retention effect we're on patients with acromegaly. Increased GH secretion through either a GH secreting tumor or another mechanism is kind of how that's been looked at in a lot of studies. In additional hormones. We also have common client medications that might cause excess water retention. Certain hormonal birth control preparations obviously contain
synthetic estradiol. Testosterone replacement therapy can be part of this conversation. Non steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs. We have Prednisone, certain diabetes medications. So really there's pretty extensive list of common Western medications that are prescribed by doctors that lead to increases in water retention as well. So as you can see from today's episode, water retention is a multi faceted process. It's not just nutrition, it's not just sodium, it's not just hormones, and it's not just medications, but there are multiple factors that contribute to someone's water retention. Maybe that puffy look in the
mirror or changes in their scale weight. Obviously for your clients, you're going to want to make sure we're keeping an eye on nutrition and food intake since that can clearly contribute to changes in their scale weight and body composition. But for our consistent clients, athletes, performance athletes, and even people who are competing in bodybuilding at a higher level, if they're seeing changes in water retention despite really good adherence. We want to dig deeper into the science of water retention. Like we've talked about today. The impact of cortisol, ADH, the renin angiotensin system, other reproductive hormones and even
medications that are leading to this excess stored water and changes in the look of their physique. If you enjoy learning the deeper science of these hormones and the science of water retention and the connections to nutrition and transformation, as well as overall health, even our discussion around things like blood pressure, metabolic syndrome, insulin sensitivity, and more, or the conversation around reproductive hormone imbalance, estradiol, and progesterone, you'll definitely want to check out our functional Nutrition and metabolism specialization program inside Metabolism School. You can learn more at
metabolismschool.com. I also regularly host monthly workshops where we dive into concepts like this in real time on Zoom, so you can join and ask questions and get some additional instruction outside of the podcast. If you enjoyed today's episode, if it changed your perspective, if you got value, or you plan to use any of this from today's show in your own content, please do me a huge favor. Drop a five star rating and review to support the show on any major podcast platform where you listen. Chances are someone either shared the show with you or their rating and review helped you find the show when it popped
up in your algorithm so that you could hit that download button and listen to your first episode. We don't run tons of ads on the show and we don't have tons of paid promotions. So this podcast community has always grown from the original listeners and we've been fortunate enough to reach so many of you around the world over the last several 100 episodes, and I greatly appreciate that. Thanks so much for tuning into today's podcast. I will talk to you guys in the next show. This show is designed to help
you translate complex nutrition, fitness and Physiology concepts into leverage for your clients goals or your own personal goals. This podcast. Is for online education, meaning this. Podcast is for. General informational purposes only and does not constitute the practice of medicine, nursing or other professional healthcare services, including the giving of medical advice and no doctor, patient or coach client relationship is formed through listening to this episode. The use of information in this podcast, in the show notes or the reliance on the information provided is done at the listeners own risk. The content of this podcast is not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice,
diagnosis or treatment and is for educational purposes only. Always consult your physician before beginning any exercise program and users should not disregard or delay in obtaining medical advice for any medical condition they may have and should seek the assistance of their healthcare professionals for any such condition. By accessing this podcast and any other episode, the listener acknowledges that the entire contents and design of this podcast or the property of Oracle Athletic Science and should not be used or retransmitted without permission of Oracle Athletic Science. This is protected under US and international.
Copyright and trademark laws, except. As we're otherwise provided here, end users of this podcast may save and use the information contained in this podcast only for personal or other non commercial educational purposes. No other use, including without limitation, reproduction, retransmission, or editing of this podcast may be made without prior written permission of Oracle Athletic Science and Sam Miller, which may be requested the contact information in the show notes. By accessing this podcast, the listener acknowledges that Oracle Athletic Science makes no warranty. Guarantee your representation as to the accuracy or sufficiency of the information featured in
this podcast, and coaches and listeners understand that this information may change over time with different research and anecdotal practices in the field. It is the listener's responsibility to stay up to date on this information. As always, this show is designed to help you and I appreciate you listening to every episode. Simply understand it's for general informational educational purposes and we'll talk to you in the next. Episode.
In this featured guest replay on the Down To Health Podcast, I break down one of the most persistent ideas in health and fitness: that your metabolism is broken when fat loss stalls. I explain why this language misses...
The final months of the year can create a unique kind of pressure for health and fitness coaches. You are supporting clients through holidays, travel, family commitments, and changing schedules while also trying to...
Every year, the clock change brings more than just a few days of fatigue. This episode uncovers the profound physiological impact of Daylight Savings Time, particularly the spring shift, on your health. Moving beyond...
I joined my friend Andrew Coates for a conversation about the shift from PCOS to PMOS and what that change means for women, coaches, and practitioners. Hormones, insulin sensitivity, stress, metabolic health, fertility,...
In this conversation, my close friend Grant hosts an honest interview about navigating adversity, building a coaching career, and continuing to show up when life and business do not go according to plan. We talk about...