S 867: Silencing Your Inner Critic: How Follow-Through Builds Real Confidence Over Time
12 minAudio
Most people would never tolerate someone speaking to them the way they speak to themselves... and yet that internal dialogue often goes unchecked. This conversation explores where negative self-talk actually comes from, why logic and reassurance rarely silence it, and how confidence is built through evidence rather than motivation or affirmations. I break down why coaches and high-achievers are especially vulnerable to an overactive inner critic, and how repeated follow-through quietly reshapes self-trust. Topics Discussed: - The inner critic explained - Negative self-talk patterns - Confidence through evidence - Follow-through and self-trust - Coaches and self-judgment - Identity versus behavior - Small actions, big impact ---------- My Live Program for Coaches: The Functional Nutrition and Metabolism Specialization www.metabolismschool.com ---------- [Free] Metabolism School 101: The Video Series http://www.metabolismschool.com/metabolism-101 ---------- Subscribe to My Youtube Channel: https://youtube.com/@sammillerscience?si=s1jcR6Im4GDHbw_1 ---------- Grab a Copy of My New Book - Metabolism Made Simple ---------- Stay Connected: Instagram: @sammillerscience Youtube: SamMillerScience Facebook: The Nutrition Coaching Collaborative Community TikTok: @sammillerscience ---------- “This Podcast is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute the practice of medicine, nursing or other professional health care services, including the giving of medical advice, and no doctor/patient relationship is formed. The use of information on this podcast and the show notes or the reliance on the information provided is to be done at the user's own risk. The content of this podcast is not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment and is for educational purposes only. Always consult your physician before beginning any exercise program and users should not disregard, or delay in obtaining, medical advice for any medical condition they may have and should seek the assistance of their health care professionals for any such conditions. By accessing this Podcast, the listener acknowledges that the entire contents and design of this Podcast, are the property of Oracle Athletic Science LLC, or used by Oracle Athletic Science LLC with permission, and are protected under U.S. and international copyright and trademark laws. Except as otherwise provided herein, users of this Podcast may save and use information contained in the Podcast only for personal or other non-commercial, educational purposes. No other use, including, without limitation, reproduction, retransmission or editing, of this Podcast may be made without the prior written permission of Oracle Athletic Science LLC, which may be requested by contacting the Oracle Athletic Science LLC by email at operations@sammillerscience.com. By accessing this Podcast, the listener acknowledges that Oracle Athletic Science LLC makes no warranty, guarantee, or representation as to the accuracy or sufficiency of the information featured in this Podcast."
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
I will not let you walk through my mind with dirty feet. What's up? And welcome to Samler Science, where you're joining me just over a decade into my personal journey of working to bridge the gap between metabolism, macros, muscle in medicine, all while helping coaches scale the impact that they desire and deserve. If you are here, thank you so much for listening and for trusting me to help you elevate your coaching game or to lead you in your transformation to realize your true. Potential. In either case, each week I'll be sharing my methods, models, and message to serve as leverage for your specification specific
goals. Without further ado, let's get on to today's show. It's a quote I've come back to over the years because most people would never tolerate someone speaking to you the way that you speak to yourself. Not occasionally. It's a constant chatter. If you actually listen to your own self talk, it would probably sound harsher than most Instagram comment sections where you see people with random fake profiles chiming in. And somehow we justify it. We think, oh I'm just being disciplined. But it's actually none of those things. It's conditioning from that constant shatter that's always running in the background every
single day. And this isn't actually a new problem. Every culture has tried to describe it. There's parables and stories and ancestral tales. Even cartoons have the two different characters sitting on the shoulders. The idea of an inner critic versus an inner advocate. Different language, same experience. The idea is that there's voices inside of us, but they don't have equal influence. One always ends up in charge eventually. One the oldest ways that this idea shows up is in the story of two wolves. A grandfather explains to his grandson that inside every person there's two wolves, but they're in constant conflict.
One represents fear, anger, insecurity, resentment. Ego 1 is more calm, courageous, compassionate, and speaks the truth. The grandson always asks, you know, grandpa which one wins, and the grandfather responds that it's the one you feed. And as much as this is kind of an ancestral tale, it's true, even if it seems poetic. Most people aren't dealing with some symbolic battle between good and evil, but they are dealing with an internal critic that's shaped by their environment. It involves constant comparison, public metrics, and endless exposure to other people's highlights without context.
Because you're not just doing work anymore. A lot of times, especially if you're health and fitness coach, you're watching yourself and you're watching what other people are doing at the same time. And then after posting it, you're wondering how it's perceived that you're doing from outside. That's not necessarily profound or dramatic, but it is this constant chatter that's running in the background that never shuts off. And that the mistake that most people make is assuming that you need to argue with this voice. You really don't. You actually starve it. And the inner critic isn't always persuaded by logic or reassurance. It comes down to patterns and
specifically your ability to follow through. Because this is actually the root of where confidence comes from. And it's rarely talked about in this way because confidence isn't just a belief system or chanting affirmations, and it's not something you can convince yourself or just twist your arm into doing. It's a byproduct of proof and specifically evidence from your behaviors. So your brain is always evaluating this one thing, right? It's this pertinent question, can I trust this person? But the person that's evaluating is you. And so even in a small way, when you take action every time you
deposit a little bit of trust and when you don't, you actually erode it. There's no morality attached to this. It's more mechanical in nature. And people in their fitness journeys and even coaches tend to struggle with this more than most people. And it's not because they lack discipline or self-awareness, but it's a lot of times because of the role that they're in. So health and fitness coaches especially live in this state of outward focus. And I'd argue that people focused on their health and fitness and weight loss fall into this case too. But coaches are holding space for other people consistently, and a lot of times they postpone structures for themselves because of the support they're
providing for others. Results are visible, opinions are visible. Feedback shows up whether you ask for it or not, whether that be on social media or with your clients. And this creates a strange split where you can be confident and even effective, but you feel perpetually behind. And that's the pressure that comes with being a coach. You're expected to have it all together and put on a smile and be consistent and be the example when the reality is that it doesn't always perfectly match the expectation. Then the internal critics going to get louder, not because you're failing, but because the gap feels threatening to the identity that you're trying to
uphold. And unlike clients, many coaches don't actually give themselves a system for building trust internally. Instead, they just let that voice chatter on. You'd never tell a client to rely on motivation or belief alone. You'd give them small executable actions that create proof each and every day. But internally, that logic often gets abandoned, especially for health professional. So self judgment replaces self evidence. And that's why this micro progress matters. It's why you tell your clients to go to bed on time and go for a morning walk. Not because it always looks good or because it's pretty or sexy, but because it's repeatable.
That short walk you actually take makes you feel better, builds confidence. It's a promise that you kept to yourself when no ones watching. Those moments don't feel like much, but they snowball. They accumulate and compound into something really meaningful. And that's credibility with yourself. It's your reputation. And it completely changes that internal dialogue and hierarchy. So when there's a consistent track record of follow through, that critic loses leverage. Not because it disappears entirely or that you don't have a troll in your mind ever, but there's just less ambiguity to exploit and there's less room to question your reputation with
yourself and your reliability. If you routinely break promises to yourself. The critic doesn't need to invent a narrative. The pattern does this work for the troll? So it's not about willpower, and it's not about being hard on yourself. It's about alignment between your actions and your intentions, right? We can align the actions and intentions. Confidence grows quietly and when you don't, self doubt. And that inner troll just fills the gap. So negative self talk feels real. Because it often started as
protection or conditioning. It was maybe someone else's voice that stuck around longer than it should have or because of environmental cues or conditions. But understanding that can create context. But it doesn't create change. Change actually comes from proof. It's not always this massive declaration or like a New Year's resolution. It's not from motivation, but just simple proof and small little bits of evidence that stack up over time because the internal critic rarely just vanishes completely. It looks for opportunities to come back in the picture at any time. It's like a really annoying backseat driver or like a shotgun driver who's like
criticizing which Google Maps route that you took and oh, well, that light was yellow, why did you go through it? So it's just going to keep coming back tomorrow and then the day after that. And so you have to feed the part of you that follows through and you have to starve the part that feeds on inconsistencies, see, and just lives in this gap, right? That troll is going to be there. But for many of you, you've let that troll, you've fed it so much, it is this fat, chunky little troll that is in your mind who's worse than anyone's Instagram or social media comments section. And that's not fair to yourself, right? Would you ever do that to your
best friend or your brother or your sister, your parents or a client of yours? Or if you're a parent who has children, you would never speak to your children that way. I thought of this example recently too, right? The quote that I started with today is I will not let you walk through my mind with your dirty feet. I think that's actually a Gandhi quote. And think about it from a very basic like non emotional perspective. I recently had some workers who are helping out with stuff around the house. You know, anytime you're doing like construction or different projects, right? You either have you put stuff down on the floor to prevent people's dirty shoes from
getting all over your house, or you got the little booties that you can slip on over the boots. And best off, you could just take your shoes off and not let it completely get tracked all the way through your house. And so some times there's little actions that we can take, whether it's a little preventive measure, you know, taking a little bit of action so we don't get that dirt all over the place. Whether it's putting the booties on over the shoes or standing up confidently and just saying, hey, take your shoes off, leave them outside or wipe your feet on the mat. In a common sense situation to protect something like our physical property or a house, that doesn't seem like a big
deal. But people neglect to do that all the time when it comes to this constant voice and this chatter in their mind. So stand up for yourself and do something today that creates that small evidence. And don't be the person who is your toughest critic and the most harsh, right? Someone has to cheer for you and usually it's got to start with you. But you're never going to do it if you don't actually align those actions with your original intentions because that's where the confidence comes from. If you enjoyed today's episode, please share it. If you are watching on YouTube, hit that thumbs up. Hit the notification bell and
subscribe for future episodes. If you're on Spotify or Apple podcast. One thing that goes a really long way in supporting the show is a five star rating and review. Or you can post this on social media and tag me in your Instagram stories. I'm Sam Miller science on just about every major platform. So if you don't hang out on Instagram, but you post somewhere else, you can tag me there as well. I appreciate you guys tuning in. This episode's going to be intertwined with anything related to goal setting, anything related to resolutions, and just accomplishing anything great in your life. Because we're all going to have
a little bit of self doubt creep in from time to time. And we could all use that little recipe to have enough evidence to overcome it and keep working towards something big. I appreciate you guys and I will talk to you in the next show. Thank you for stopping by and for tuning into today's episode. It still amazes me that individuals like yourself from around the world take time out of your day to listen and learn from what I have to say. I appreciate you and I'm so grateful that you choose to spend time on this platform.
Do you think that someone else would benefit from the message or the methods that I've shared in this podcast episode? Please leave me a five star rating and review on Apple. Podcast or? Wherever you listen to the show, you can also screenshot this episode and tag me at Sammeler Science on your Instagram stories. My goal is that we can continue the ripple effect of coaching and continue to pay it forward so that this information ends up in the hands of those who are trying to make a positive difference in the world. Thank you so much again for joining me, and I'll talk to you guys in the next episode.
This show is designed to help you translate complex nutrition, fitness and Physiology concepts into leverage for your clients goals or your own personal goals. This podcast is for online education, meaning this. Podcast is for. General informational purposes only and does not constitute the practice of medicine, nursing or other professional healthcare services, including the giving of medical advice and no doctor, patient or coach client relationship is formed through listening to this episode. The use of information in this podcast, in the show notes or the reliance on the information provided is done at the listeners own risk. The content of this podcast is not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice,
diagnosis or treatment and is for educational purposes only. Always consult your physician before beginning any exercise program and users should not disregard or delay in obtaining medical advice for any medical condition they may have and should seek the assistance of their healthcare professionals for any such condition. By accessing this podcast and any other episode, the listener acknowledges that the entire contents and design of this or the property of Oracle Athletic Science and should not be. Used. Or retransmitted without permission of Oracle Athletic Science. This is protected under US and international copyright and trademark laws.
Except as we're. Otherwise provided here. End users of this podcast may save and use the information contained in this podcast only for personal or other non commercial educational purposes. No other use, including without limitation, reproduction, retransmission, or editing of this podcast may be made without prior written permission of Oracle Athletic Science and Sam Miller, which may be requested the contact information in the show notes. By accessing this podcast, the listener acknowledges that Oracle Athletic Science makes no warranty. Guarantee your representation as to the accuracy or sufficiency of the information featured in this podcast, and coaches and listeners understand that this information may change over time
with different research and anecdotal practices in the field. It is the listener's responsibility to stay up to date on this information. As always, this show is designed to help you and I appreciate you listening to every episode. Simply understand it's for general informational educational purposes and we'll talk to you in the next. Episode.
In this featured guest replay on the Down To Health Podcast, I break down one of the most persistent ideas in health and fitness: that your metabolism is broken when fat loss stalls. I explain why this language misses...
The final months of the year can create a unique kind of pressure for health and fitness coaches. You are supporting clients through holidays, travel, family commitments, and changing schedules while also trying to...
Every year, the clock change brings more than just a few days of fatigue. This episode uncovers the profound physiological impact of Daylight Savings Time, particularly the spring shift, on your health. Moving beyond...
I joined my friend Andrew Coates for a conversation about the shift from PCOS to PMOS and what that change means for women, coaches, and practitioners. Hormones, insulin sensitivity, stress, metabolic health, fertility,...
In this conversation, my close friend Grant hosts an honest interview about navigating adversity, building a coaching career, and continuing to show up when life and business do not go according to plan. We talk about...