Episode 111. What do you get when extreme sake goes mainstream? Chances are, you're looking at a popular style known as Super Dry sake. Referred to as "cho-karakuchi" in Japanese, these boozy, ultra-dry sakes pull a full 180 to the super sweet dessert sakes we've tasted before. Prepare yourself for a sake that puts the alcohol aromas, flavors and finish front and center. The bracing texture of this sake style really wakes you up and might be just the right fit if a dry martini is your favorite cocktail. Super Dry sakes styles are popular with a fair amount of mainstream appeal but might they lack balance? This week John and Timothy explore to see what puts the super in super dry sake. #SakeRevolution Support the show
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
John PumaHello, everybody. And welcome to Sake Revolution. This is America's very first sake podcast, and I am your host, John Puma from the Sake Notes. I'm also the guy who made the internet sake discord and on this show where I'm often surrounded by sake samurai. I am the sake otaku.
Timothy SullivanAnd I am your host, Timothy Sullivan. I am the sake samurai. I'm also a sake educator, as well as the founder of the Urban Sake website. And every week, John and I will be here tasting and chatting about all things sake and doing our best to make it fun and easy to understand.
John PumaSo Tim, it we're back. It's just you and me. It's you and me, Tim. It's not like these past two weeks where we've had these interlopers, uh, doubling up the count of people in the, in the room here. It's actually being completely honest. It's a little quiet. I think I might have some empty nest syndrome without having guests on the show.
Timothy SullivanYeah, we have been doing a lot of interviews lately, but there is a certain topic that has a gravitational pull we cannot escape. And that is the topic of extreme sake
John PumaMm-hmm
Timothy SullivanWe are going in for another. Exploration of something pretty extreme, pretty wild
John PumaUh, yes, extreme sake series. I enjoy making these episodes. I, I hope everybody enjoys, uh, listening to them. Uh, we get to do such interesting topics as extreme rice polishing, we've done extreme sweetness, Tim. We've done. we we've people who took namas and they, they aged them. They aged the nama,
Timothy SullivanHeresy
John PumaYes.
Timothy SullivanYeah, we've, we've done some pretty, pretty extreme sakes, but I think of, of all the extremes you could go to the, what we're tackling today is probably the most desirable, I guess, of the extremes. What do you think about that?
John PumaUm, I, I wanna say it's the most in my mind, at least it's the most mainstream of the extremes.
Timothy Sullivanthat's,
John PumaIt is. It is the most socially acceptable
Timothy Sullivanthat's a really good way to put it. I love that. It's the most socially acceptable extreme of the extremes.
John PumaYeah. You want to tell the good people at home, what we're doing
Timothy Sullivanwe are doing super dry sakes,
John Pumasuper dry
Timothy Sullivansuper dry.
John Pumathat's that, uh, that British clothing company that kanji and their logo, right?
Timothy SullivanThey're not from Japan. Super dry.
John Pumalogo, right? No they're but they, but they use, uh, Japanese iconography to promote their product.
Timothy SullivanHmm.
John Pumaso yes, um, super dry. So tell me more about super dry sake.
Timothy SullivanWell, I think that most people have an idea of what dry means, but what do you think dry means when it comes to alcohol? I'm sure you've heard about dry wine
John PumaMm-hmm
Timothy Sullivanwe've talked about dry sake before.
John PumaYeah. So, so Tim, when we talk about dry, what are, what exactly are we talking about? What is dry anyway?
Timothy SullivanWell, the simplest way to give a quick definition for what dry is. It's basically the lack of sweetness. Yeah.
John PumaOkay. That sounds good. So, so we're defining it as simply lacking another quality. Okay.
Timothy Sullivanabsence of sweetness gives you dryness.
John PumaAll
Timothy SullivanPeople always make the joke about how can sake be dry when it's wet. but that's not the kind of dryness we're
John PumaI'm not done with my sighing. Thank you very much. uh, no, I've, I've heard that about dry wine also. Oh, so dry. Oh, but it's wet. Haha. Yeah, no, I get it. I get it. right. But it is. As you mentioned, it is just the absence of sweet. There's no, quality to it. Apart from that, no unique quality to it is simply, um, of, of the void of sweetness.
Timothy SullivanIt comes in different degrees and different amounts, but the less sweetness you have than the drier the sake is going to taste and it can express itself in a couple different ways. One is a little more alcohol flavor, and one is a little bit more acidity. So both acidity and alcohol flavors can read as dryness on the palate, but it's a lack of sweetness. But we experience sweetness on the palate.
Timothy Sullivanyou can also think about the finish of the sake, So you wanna look at the overall impression and how much sweetness or lack of sweetness there is, and that can give you a sense of how dry it is. Now. When I talk to people about how to envision what dryness is, if you've ever sipped on a martini and it has that super, uh, drying effect on your palate. That is, I think kind of the essence of what the dry impression on the palate is.
Timothy SullivanI almost call it like a little bit of a pickling effect on the sides of your tongue. You know, when you have a Martin pickling. Yeah. Like a little, uh, drying out of the palate and that comes from the higher, more overt alcohol impression that you would get in a martini, but if you scale that way down and soften it a lot, I think that gets us into the zone of what a super dry sake impression might be on your palate.
John PumaNow, on the show every week we talk about, the, uh, SMV
Timothy SullivanYes.
John PumaAnd when we talk about that, we're trying to let people know kind of, and we'll say why in a minute, but kind of where a sake is on the, on, you know, with regard to dryness versus sweetness. And we say kind of, because there's a lot of other factors that way into this, apart from that's just where it is on the sake meter value scale, but, how exactly is that sake meter value let's feel refresher for way at home. How does that exactly work?
Timothy SullivanWell, yeah, SMV, which we talk about pretty much every week when we introduce our sake, that means sake meter value. And the Japanese word for sake meter value is nihonshu-do so. You can hear either nihonshu-do or SMV or sake meter value. And this is actually a measurement of the density of
John PumaMm-hmm.
Timothy Sullivanthe sake. The SMV measurement of zero on the scale is the same density as water. And then there's plus numbers and then there's negative numbers above and below zero. the plus numbers actually go up the scale and they indicate increasingly less dense sake. And that often reads on the palate as a dryer impression, less sugars remaining. And as you go down the scale. You get negative numbers and that indicates more density than water.
Timothy SullivanAnd that usually indicates more residual sugars hanging around. And as you go lower things in general, tend to get sweeter.
John Pumaright.
Timothy SullivanThese are kind of broad generalizations. There's exceptions all over the place, but if you need a rule of thumb, just to get you oriented in this higher is dryer. So plus numbers on this SMV indicate a drier and negative numbers on the SMV indicate a sweeter sake
John PumaHmm, excellent. Excellent. And so we're, we're talking super dry today.
Timothy SullivanExtreme extreme.
John Pumawhere, so where exactly do we go for our extreme? It's like, what's an extremely dry sake. Then. Number wise, numerically.
Timothy SullivanYeah.
John PumaMm-hmm
Timothy SullivanI did some research into how extreme we could actually get on this show. meaning. What is the highest SMV I could legally obtain in the United States
John Pumaand, and I think that's a very important, note, because I think we have both encountered very extreme sake overseas. That is even drier than anything that we could find in the States.
Timothy SullivanYes. So the driest SMB I could get my hands on, on this scale is a plus 15. Yeah. That's high.
John Pumalot's.
Timothy SullivanAnd in Japan, I've had sakes that rate like a plus 20,
John PumaYeah. Uh, I have also had, a sake in Japan that was a plus 20 and you know what? I really liked it.
Timothy Sullivanyou did.
John PumaUm, and it surprised me because I didn't think I would, but it was plus 20 and it was, and this was a weird moment for me when I had this, because it was fruity
Timothy SullivanHmm.
John Pumaand yeah, in my mind, at the time specifically at the time I thought. Fruity and sweet are kind of hand in hand in a way like sweetness and fruitiness. I kind of associate the two. I equate the two to a certain extent, but I'm sitting there and I'm sipping on this sake and it's nice and fruity, but then this like dry finish is extremely dry. Um, situation takes over and it, it kind of isolates the fruit in a very interesting and.
John PumaLike pure way, right? It is like, it is fruit with the absence of sweetness and it was very interesting. It was a very fun sake to have
Timothy SullivanHmm. Yeah. Often in sake, when we get the impression of fruit, it's the esters or these aroma compounds coming off the sake they're produced by the yeast and they waft off the sake and give us the impression of maybe tropical fruits. And that can be totally divorced from the residual sugar. That is causing actual sweetness on our palate, but there's a disconnect in our brain cuz when we bite into a mango or a strawberry or our favorite honeydew melon, you know, there's, there's this linked experience with sweetness and fruity aromas that we have a hard time separating ourselves from, but in sake, you can get very fruity aromas and have a drier body, not as much residual sugar.
Timothy SullivanReally interesting.
John PumaMm-hmm it's very, uh, it's a fascinating thing that I had never really experienced before. And, you know, and now I've experienced since with some dry sakes. again, some dry sakes are just really fruity and it's a fun little experience to have.
Timothy SullivanYeah. Now when I've talked to consumers and people who are just getting started with sake, sometimes I do a somm night in a restaurant and I'll work as a sommelier on the floor of a restaurant. I often meet people who are like. I wanna try super dry sake. Give me anything. That's dry. Just number one. Important thing to me is dry, dry, dry, dry, dry. I hear this regularly. So why do you think that there's this group, subset of people getting into sake that insist on dry or super dry sakes?
John PumaI are they like afraid of like sweetness or
Timothy SullivanI think that's the answer. Yeah. I think it's a overreaction to maybe having had a sake that was a little too sweet for their liking and to avoid that happening again, instead of seeking out balance, they go to the opposite extreme, and they're like, just to hedge my bets, just give me something super dry. And you and I have talked about balance a lot, right?
John PumaYeah.
Timothy SullivanBalance is so important balancing out
John PumaI'm trying to say that when you go super dry, you might be giving up a little bit of balance.
Timothy SullivanYes. and there may be people that just love that super dry impression, and we're gonna taste a super dry sake today and we can, you know, have our hot take our live reaction to it. But. I think super dry all the time or without is you're
John Pumaexhausting.
Timothy Sullivanyou're missing out on some nuance and you're missing out on some balance, but that may, that may be my preconceived notions coming through. Who knows, but I think you're right. Fear of sweetness is at the root of these people who demand super dry Uber Alles, you know,
John PumaThere it is. There it is. It's toxic masculinity. That's fear of sweetness.
Timothy Sullivanof sweetness... they demand super dry sakes because they may fear sweetness. But, uh, I think it's time for us to put our own palates to the tests and go a little extreme. So, John, I hunted down this super dry sake. It, this is available for sale in the U.S.. Do you want to give us the rundown of this sake and let us know what we are to expect here?
John PumaI would love to Tim. So this is the Kan Nihonkai Cho-karakuchi. And we, we talked about karakuchi in the past. That is dry mouth there. Dry taste Kaci plus 15 Junmai. This is from nihonkai Shuzo over in Shimane Prefecture, the, um, Sake meter value or the Nihonshu-do is, as we mentioned a plus 15,
Timothy SullivanPlus 15 that's
John Pumaplus 15, that's our extreme right there. it is also Gohyakumangoku. Now I wanna take a quick second here and discuss that with you because, gohyakumangoku, when I think of that rice, I think of Niigata
Timothy SullivanYeah.
John Pumaand also when I think. Crisp dry sake, open your fruit, but dry, nice and balanced, but a dry finish. I think of Niigata so is, is like gohyakumangoku, maybe preferred for people who wanna make a dry sake.
Timothy SullivanI think that's fair to say. Yeah. gohyakumangoku is known for producing lighter airier sakes, and if you're going for dry or super dry. You don't need all the elements that, uh, yamadanishiki is going to bring to the table. You'd bring that in. If you're going for something more fruity or rich, and because you're going dry and airy, you would probably lean towards this gohyakumangoku rice, which is kind of known for that Stripe of flavor.
John PumaNice. Thank you. This gohyakumangoku is milled down to 60% of its original size. The acidity is a touch high at 1.8. and Tim, the alcohol percentage on this, you didn't tell me that we were going extreme with the alcohol. It is 18%, sir.
Timothy SullivanOh, that's not extreme.
John Pumaoh, no, no, but it's a higher than average. That will be our, our new series a bit higher than average coming to Sake Revolution. After we're done with the extreme stuff, it's slightly above average. It's slightly below average.
Timothy Sullivannot too extreme.
John Pumayeah, no, you know, meza-meza So anyway,
Timothy Sullivanis, uh, I think this might be a genshu as well,
John Pumawell, the 18% made me think it might
Timothy SullivanYeah. I think we might be be in Genshu territory for sure. So I wanna mention this word in the name of the sake, Cho C H O. So it was Cho karakuchi. Cho means very, or we often translate this as like super dry. So karakuchi is dry and Cho karakuchi is super dry
John PumaOoh, Cho karakuchi. Oh, I like it. Nice. Well, I have my glass here and I have my bottle. Do you have yours?
Timothy SullivanWell, I do we have to mention this bottle too,
John PumaIt is so all right, everybody at home, let me paint you a word picture sake bottles are typically, you know, brown, maybe
Timothy Sullivangreen.
John Pumauh, summer sake could sometimes be light blue or clear. Um, this bottle is red.
Timothy SullivanFire Engine Red
John Pumais Fire engine It's it's still translucent. It's not like, uh, matte, but it is red. It is letting you know something is up the label is predominantly kanji, but on the, on the right side where it's telling you that it is, the cho karakuchi, it also has a giant plus 15 in, in the same font as the, as the Cho karakuchi kanji. Um, it is a, clearly this sake is celebrating how dry it is.
John PumaAnd I think that's a lot of fun. They're not messing around. They want you to know you're gonna have a good time. If you're looking for a dry sake, Sake ah,
Timothy SullivanYes. And it does say Junmai Genshu, and it does say plus 15 on three different places on this bottle.
John PumaThey don't want, they don't want anybody to have this and be like, look, you know, it's kind of like the thing with McDonald's and the coffee where it is like extremely hot in five places. Now somebody complained it was too dry and didn't know, they didn't know it was gonna be plus 15. So they put it three times on the label. That's plus 15.
Timothy SullivanYes. And if you put a light bulb on this bottle, you've got a, um, like a police siren flashing light. It is bright red and ready
John Pumacan, you can, you can, do like your Izakaya lantern with put a light in there.
Timothy Sullivanwell, it is very striking though. You have to admit, like, if you see this bright red bottle on the shelf, it's going to grab your attention. Don't you. Yeah.
John PumaI don't think I can like be looking at a shelf of sake and be like, I just didn't notice it.
Timothy SullivanYes, let's get this. kan nihonkari cho karakuchi plus 15 Junmai Genshu, let's get this in the glass.
John PumaAll
Timothy SullivanNow, before we get too far into it, I have to remind our listeners that we're kind of dealing with two things here. One is the plus 15, which is the super dry density of this sake. But as we've discovered, it's also a genshu. So the alcohol percentage on its own is very high as well. So we're gonna be balancing these two things out and seeing the interplay of the density and the alcohol. So let's go ahead and give it a smell.
John PumaMm. Hmm.
Timothy SullivanHmm.
John PumaSo, um, I, I am, I am sniffing out of a, a wine glass today as I, as we often do. And I'm getting a lot of, I think we we've talked about like the sweet rice, the like, uh, the mochi rice a little bit, and I'm getting a lot of that. It's very rice-y.
Timothy SullivanYeah,
John PumaVery nice. And is a little alcohol
Timothy Sullivanthe aroma is very rice-y almost. I don't know if you would agree. Almost a little creamy as well. Like the rice pudding smell a little bit and.
John PumaI'm right with that. Yeah.
Timothy SullivanYeah. And there is an ethanol smell as well. So ethanol is a way word we can use to describe when you have the kind of more overt alcohol aroma on the nose. And that's coming through a little bit here, but it's not distracting and it's not, it doesn't feel like imbalanced it's there. And when you have a super dry 18% alcohol sake, I think you'd expect there to be a little bit of the boozy aroma on the nose, but it's not, it's not whackadoodle out of balance.
Timothy SullivanI don't think.
John PumaUh, and I like, I like how you, you jumped straight onto the calling it ethanol, so you can head me off at the past before I start referring to the aroma as boozy
Timothy SullivanI wanted to throw the professional descriptor in there. Head you off at the pass. right.
John PumaI, sometimes Tim, I need to be saved from myself.
Timothy SullivanAll right. Let's give it a taste. Oh, wow. That is dry. Oh my gosh.
John PumaTame. There's a burn.
Timothy Sullivanthere's a, there's a slight burn
John Pumanot,
Timothy Sullivanit's not unpleasant. It's not unpleasant. Okay. This has that bracing quality to it, right?
John PumaMm-hmm
Timothy SullivanI feel like it might have slapped me on the cheek as well as,
John Pumathey just challenge you to a duel I will say. Um, so we mentioned the rice aroma and it makes good on that. Like the first thing you taste is that rice and then. Gives away to that bracing
Timothy SullivanHmm.
John Pumalittle slap in the face. Uh um, boozy dry like B like a burn tingling, almost really nice finish, uh, long finish.
Timothy SullivanYes.
John Pumaand I always think short finish on dry sake, but this is a lingering, dry boozy finish. Ah, I did it. Didn't I a layering dry ethanol finish. I'm sorry, Tim. I
Timothy SullivanYou can say boozy, this is, this is a safe space here.
John Pumaoh, okay, good.
Timothy SullivanI think John, if we're ever gonna say boozy about a sake, I think this this might be the one where they are not gonna take too much offense to it.
John PumaYeah. Yeah. I, I wouldn't.
Timothy SullivanSo it's very, this sake is, as I said, very bracing.
John PumaMm-hmm
Timothy SullivanAnd would you describe it as crisp? I don't think it's not crisp in the way I usually use it.
John Pumathis sake is very far from Niigata
Timothy SullivanOkay. Now we've established. This sake is rice-y. It is bold.
John PumaOh,
Timothy SullivanIt's ethanol driven as Tim would say, or boozy as John Puma would say, and it has a lingering. Martini-like finish, like the finish is alcohol driven and, Really wakes you up
John Pumayeah. oh, alright. I'm a hundred percent with you on that. It's I am awake.
Timothy SullivanYes.
John Pumayes, I agree. and it's, it is, you know, this is a fun sake and, we know we make jokes about when we do some of the extreme stuff, we may be like, oh my goodness, this is so weird, blah, blah, blah. And it. you know, it's a little bit outside of the, the norm here, but it is, it's, it is quite enjoyable. And, uh, I don't know about you, but I really I want some food and I want that food to be greasy.
Timothy SullivanMm.
John PumaI just, when I, when I'm something, this dry, I feel like I, I imagine it kinda just cutting through the oils, um, and just, just resetting my palate in a really fun way.
Timothy Sullivaninteresting.
John PumaThat's my thought.
Timothy SullivanYeah, it makes me think of maybe using this in a cocktail.
John PumaThat would also, I was my, that was a thought I had earlier. Um, but then I, I couldn't think of exactly what kind of cocktail I would use this with.
Timothy SullivanYeah. But I think greasy, greasy food or fatty fish is something that I think would pair well with this. But
John Pumasure.
Timothy Sullivanyeah, if you have someone who's like, I only drink dry. So man, like you give them this and you can see what they're really made of, you know,
John PumaHmm.
Timothy SullivanYeah. This, this is a dry it's it's the aftertaste is like, you know, like when you have a shot of something boozy. Yes.
John PumaYes, yes. In fact, yes.
Timothy Sullivanafter you sip it, people make that face. It's not unpleasant, but oh, this is interesting, John, you know, the word karakuchi means dry when you talk about sake, but karakuchi can also mean spicy. Yes. Right. And this is, I think the bridge between spicy and dry is a sake like this, cuz it's almost like you sip on it and you have that reaction that makes you go, wow.
Timothy SullivanWow. Like that was spicy slash dry. I think.
John Pumaright.
Timothy SullivanWhat do you think, do you think? I think, I think this is a, a bridge between those
John PumaI can get some of that. Yeah, I can get with that. I can feel that this is a night, it's a fun sake to drink and talk about because there's a lot of ways to interpret what's going on it's not simple by any stretch of the imagination.
Timothy SullivanWell, I, I think this might be a challenge for people who are more into either sweeter or balanced sakes. And this might be a little too extreme in the dry direction, dry, spicy direction than most people would expect. That may be why it comes in the fire engine red bottle. Just to warn you, you don't pick it up by mistake.
John PumaYeah, it's nice. I think the whole extreme series. We're, touching on the, the outskirts, the, the, uh, the not everyday stuff. And this is a, a different one. It's a lot of fun. I wanna say of our extreme episodes, uh, with extreme sake, this is one of the more enjoyable to just taste it's been nice. And that might be, because again, we talked about earlier that, uh, you know, extremely dry sake is kind of a little more acceptable. It's kind of a little more, a little bit more mainstream.
Timothy SullivanYeah.
John PumaPlus 15 might be teetering on the edge of what's mainstream, but, um, but it is, you know, it's a little something that's a little bit more socially acceptable. as I mentioned earlier.
Timothy SullivanDefinitely. And I, I think that this, this style of sake would be the, of all the extremes we've tasted. This would probably be the most common style that you would come across in your everyday social situations. This dryer super dry. Really does flirt with mainstream, I think. I'm super excited to see what extreme sake we have next
John PumaYeah. Uh, I, I uh, this is, again, this is a really fun series to do and. Uh, and yeah, like it's, it's nice to be able to try out these, these sakes that we normally in my day to day life. I don't go very extreme, Tim. I don't live the extreme sake sake lifestyle. Uh, typically my fridge is quite mundane. It's not very extreme. so getting the opportunity to go a little bit extreme with you, uh, has been a lot of fun and, I can't wait to see what you have in store for us next.
Timothy SullivanYes. And, uh, we have to reassure our listeners that, we're not extreme sake junkies, and this is all for educational purposes. all right, John, it's so great to taste with you again, and I'm looking forward to our next session in the studio. And until then, I also want to thank our patrons as well for supporting Sake Revolution, a big greeting, and thank you to all our patrons, your contributions, help us to produce, host and edit a sake revolution episode each and every week.
Timothy SullivanIf you'd like to become a patron, please visit our patron site at patreon.com/SakeRevolution.
John PumaAnd did you know there are other ways to support us such as leaving a review on apple podcasts, Spotify, podchaser, Stitcher, whatever you're into, get the reviews out there. It really does help get the word out about the show. You can also just tell people that's the much more direct way to get the word out about the show. You know, pour'em a little bit of extremely dry sake. And then when they say, what is this? You're like, well, it's extreme sake. And I learned about it on Sake Revolution. There you go. so, uh, with that, we will bring this, uh, a lovely episode to a close.
John PumaPlease grab your glass. Remember to keep drinking sake and
Break out your calendars and clear your schedules, because Sake Day 2026 is almost here! October 1st is World Sake Day and this marks the traditional start of the sake brewing season in Japan, and here in the US, the...
Episode 190. Honjozo sometimes gets a bad rap. Somewhere along the way, "added alcohol" sake became viewed skeptically by some and Junmai sake wound up with all the glory. On Episode 190, John and Tim go back to basics...
Episode 189. After six years of audio-only podcasting, Sake Revolution is officially on video - and we're celebrating by doing something dangerous... dangerously delicious, that is! John and Timothy are trying their...
Episode 188. Pack your bags - and your sake glass. This week on Sake Revolution, John and Timothy kick off an exciting new series: Sake Destinations, your insider guide to buying and drinking sake like a local wherever...
Episode 187. Ever wonder where the sake bomb actually came from? Spoiler alert: it probably wasn't Japan. This week on Sake Revolution, John and Tim dive headfirst into one of the most divisive topics in sake culture -...