What does it mean to truly be an expert? Pause for a moment and imagine having the power to choose the ideal trainer for your team. You'll find those answers as we dissect the unique advantages of both internal and external trainers, how industry and location can shape the training process, and the challenges that come with training across multiple locations. This episode is going to stretch your understanding of the 'train-the-trainer' approach and its limitations. We discuss how subject matter experts can help identify risks, and the importance of tailoring training to specific jobs. These insights are sure to get you thinking about how you can ensure your workers are not only fully equipped but also certified for their roles. We guarantee you'll walk away from this episode with a fresh perspective on training and expertise.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1A listener note the safety information discussed in this podcast are our views based on our personal first-hand experiences. Each safety situation presents unique risks and the solutions discussed in this podcast should not take the place of thorough risk assessments or evaluations based on your specific circumstances. Thank you, welcome to Safe, efficient, profitable a worker safety podcast where we break down real problems from real situations and discuss realistic solutions.
Speaker 1And here are your hosts owners of Allen Safety LLC, joe and Jen Allen.
Speaker 2It's been professional. Why we do this today.
Speaker 3Safety on a Sunday.
Speaker 2Good day. You can already tell this one's going to be a little different, can't you? We got some laughing going on and this is some kind of podcast we're supposed to be putting together today. And if you're watching this live on well, not live, I guess we're recorded, aren't we? If you're watching this on YouTube, you're like why are they setting like that? Well, we're setting across a table here.
Speaker 3Been a day.
Speaker 2We got headphones. It's a Sunday and we're trying some different here.
Speaker 3A day Just going through the outline on a candy-lion box.
Speaker 2Yeah, how are you going to edit it? I don't know, I'm too lazy to get something. So it was a candy-lion box in front of me and I used it because Ergonomics. Yeah, if you do anything on a Sunday, you play candy-lion Ergonomics. All right, here we go today. What makes a trainer and expert is the topic today, and we got some stuff we want to talk about.
Speaker 3I got a lot to say about it.
Speaker 2Let's talk about it. Well, the first thing is you got to decide do you want internal or external trainers? Those of you who don't know we actually train for a living. For those of you who are just now listening, like who are these people? Well, we train for a living and we are an external trainer, but we also don't believe that everything is done by external.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 2We believe that sometimes internal is better and the first thing you got to do, no matter what, is figure out what you're going to do and start breaking that down. So how do you decide? So maybe you've got some hot work you're going to be doing, or maybe electrical or forklift. I believe I'm a pretty good trainer. Most of my team thinks they're a pretty good trainer. I know about hot work, but I'm not a good trainer. I don't know about hot work because I don't know all the things about hot work or all the things that would make it be good or bad when they're doing it. So that doesn't make me.
Speaker 2It kind of makes me an expert, but not really.
Speaker 3I would say it would make you competent to be able to identify if there's a gap, not to necessarily train on all the potential risks and how to recover from it.
Speaker 2I'm with you on that because Arc Flash I know how to pick out the clothing. I know how to wear the clothing. I know what stickers look like. I'm CC Buckingham, but I do not know how to train on that. Do I understand the concept? You bet, but I'm not the expert at that. So you've got to figure out what that expert is. It could be an internal person or external. It's not just an absolute. Well, these people are better. These people are. I've seen some people internally do way better in some of the subjects than I've ever seen.
Speaker 3Well, I think it also depends on your industry, right? So I mean, based on what you're doing and where you're working, you may be kind of forced into becoming the expert.
Speaker 2That's correct.
Speaker 3I've got my farms. You know biosecurity, not everybody that's an expert can go in. So we have to figure out how to transfer that information and make the site manager an expert, because not everybody can go in every day when they've got something going on.
Speaker 2For those of you don't, maybe you understand on the live side whether it be hogs, chickens, turkey, there's a bunch of rules and you just can't have anyone go in and do work tomorrow.
Speaker 3Right, there's a bunch of rules. There's these controlled biosecurity stuff.
Speaker 2You make the same risk that you would happen in a plant and you say right now we have a problem and how maintenance come out. You can't do that the farms. So you got to train people differently. So you may have expert or tier system levels, but it could be you know how are you going to do that, so you do. You have to look at who you're going to train on that.
Speaker 3Yeah, well, I mean, you know, if you've got a company-wide trainer too, they're bouncing in and out of maybe a whole lot of different locations, so they may be going into case readies and harvest plants and mills and feed mills, and so that's really also kind of changing whether that person's an expert or not, based on you know how well they understand how to apply that information at all of those different locations.
Speaker 2Absolutely, so I know there's a lot of companies that are trying to do crossover for even like their corporate state to people, because it's hard. It's hard to manage if you don't know those businesses, but it's even harder to try to train. Yeah, it takes a lot of time to learn. It's really a lot of work to do. Is the trainer person an expert?
Speaker 3The train is train the trainer person. Does that make I went to a train the trainer class? Is that gonna make me an expert?
Speaker 2I think if you go to a trainer, trainer class, 16 hours, 24 hours or two million hours, if it doesn't relate to what you're gonna take back to organization, even if you don't know how to be a trainer. Some of these trainers, the trainer classes, they're not wrong, they mean well, but they spend the whole time maybe teaching how to drive a forklift. Okay, what you need to be training them is how to train someone else how to drive a forklift.
Speaker 3How to be an actual trainer. Yeah, so I mean, I guess from my side, getting any certificate and saying that now makes me an expert, or any certification like a CSP, that doesn't guarantee that I'm now an expert, because I think that there's a couple of different parts to that right there's you have to have the information and understand the subject matter but you also have to understand your business to be able to how to relate it to who you're training.
Speaker 2I'd been in the military, I'd done all those skill sets. I had a bachelor's degree in one of the best programs in the country oh, call me a state for those you don't know and I've done about everything you can think of, from firefighting to grope on the cattle ranch and all these things, and I've got certification. I thought I was ready to go. I walked into a plant and the first week I was there I was like there's no way, there's no way, I am not ready to go. There's a lot of subjects. I went down the list and there was more that I wasn't an expert at than I was, and I had that long background in history.
Speaker 3Well, as I'm saying, so I think most of the time people are like well, this has to do with safety, so the safety manager's the expert at this. Well, not necessarily. I mean you take something like lockout, tag out or confined space assessments. If that safety manager isn't mechanically inclined, they don't understand the mechanics. They don't understand what their maintenance teams are gonna be doing for PMs or troubleshooting. Well then they're not maybe the expert to be the person that would conduct authorized training for a lockout type situation?
Speaker 2Absolutely. For those you don't know, part of my degree is engineering. I can't do anything electrical or plumbing at this house, but theoretically I can and I've read a bunch of books and watched stuff on it. But that's not my thing.
Speaker 3I'm also a safety person, so I am the person that said he's not an expert.
Speaker 2Anyway, so that's how we go there. So you gotta look at, the main thing you wanna do is is that you gotta know your subject and you gotta make sure that any training you do as expert, you don't increase risk. You wanna decrease risk. So when I'm saying, what makes me, if they don't make my risk go down, whoever's doing the training, then that's the first problem. I have to reduce risk when I'm training.
Speaker 3Well, and when I think about risk, I think of like that weird gray area, right. So there's always this gray area. That's kind of the undercurrent. So when we have folks train that maybe aren't well versed at what the jobs are, or they don't understand the equipment or how you know the job interrelates to the environment around them, there's this weird gray areas like well, everything's fine during production, but then it goes crazy when we do sanitize.
Speaker 2I got a tie off during sanitation.
Speaker 3where I'm going to do that, it goes crazy during a PM or when we're doing a project on a weekend and it's that weird gray area that doesn't get captured, and that's where I think that you know, that's where the expert part comes in, and an expert knows what that gray area is and can address it with each group, as opposed to just kind of glossing over it Absolutely. But we won't talk about that, and if there's a problem, you should bring it up, because they don't.
Speaker 2Well, you brought up sanitation. You know, if you listen to some of the other podcasts, I spent a lot of time in sanitation and it's not that it's good, bad or different, but my crew has not spent as much as me. So what happens is I'm the expert for our company for sanitation. I'm not saying that other people don't have the knowledge, but they're not the subject matter expert. Now, as we go through and you look at these podcasts and others, you'll hear that we have different people on our team that are different experts and stuff. Even our team was broke down for different categories of it.
Speaker 3Oh yeah, well, I mean you know, and going back to identifying who's the right person to do the training in the area and kind of the lockout tag out authorized. You know we go to different places. I've got augers locked out all different ways. We've got them MCCs and some are, you know, done by disconnect, but they tell you have to go to the MCC room or or you got a farm where they have a feeder and that auger jams up.
Speaker 2The lockout's not the hazard, it's residual energy.
Speaker 3I got people saying the E-Sops are acceptable for lockout tag out, which they're not, by the way.
Speaker 2Right, so I may be able to manage that system. If I'm the manager, that doesn't mean I'm the expert, but that lockout procedure for how you do that task.
Speaker 3Well, and you know what PSM is like that too. Honestly, you know we've got PSM folks that they are managing a system, but they may not be the technical expert in regards to how to physically write the task procedure for a specific job task.
Speaker 2on the PSM side they don't have to be, but they have to acknowledge that there's the limit to there's somebody else that is, though.
Speaker 3Yeah they've got a note of defer to that person, so I think that that's huge too.
Speaker 2Yeah, we, you know, I was doing Find Space this last week at a plant down south and they did a great job, everything they were doing, and I was looking at some procedures and just we ended up taking six different ways of figuring out how to enter that space and get out of it. If I don't have all the people there who literally do it daily which is who I asked for the class then I could have never been successful in figuring out how to do it. I have to let them do the job the way they do it, and we had to. They were almost like an expert for me for that space, but I'm the expert given the data or the training.
Speaker 2So when you so, even though you may be a good trainer or maybe the expert, still rely on those sources that there's other people out there may have the data.
Speaker 3So well, and I think a big part of it too is just having done it before, right. So if you've never actually gone into confined space and you've never felt how that feels, or you've never actually physically had to lock out and perform it, I mean maybe you shouldn't be the one doing that right. I mean because there's just things that you learn by virtue of going through the steps of physically doing the action in different environments and different circumstances. But, you know, I kind of question is that person an expert if they've not gone through some of that and had some of that physical hands on time themselves?
Speaker 2Absolutely my biggest fear for 20 years ago, when I started being consultant. I would lose touch, day to day operations and I would not know what it was really like. For those of you who don't know us, we still deal with live leagues and we still deal with confined spaces, and we do them all the time and I'm fanatic about it because I'm afraid if we don't, then we've lost that knowledge and lost that edge and then I don't think we're an expert, no more.
Speaker 3Right, right, well, and you know that's. The thing is that if you know, you've got a safety manager, for instance, and maybe they used to run ops, but they haven't really gone on the floors lately, they've got other stuff going on or whatever it's knowing the time of. Maybe we need to start training somebody else and doing some of that succession planning too, to create someone else to be the expert and to fill in that gap, because if they're not going to the floor anymore and they're not out in the field, they're not going to the farm or whatever. They just can't get out there. Maybe they're not the expert for that specific department or that area anymore?
Speaker 2Absolutely, if you've got some of these large companies have hundreds of locations or they're spread all over the country with Labor B and so restricted there's no way people can get there more, so they have to be an expert. Part of that is training that next level expert that can do it.
Speaker 3Got the site specific person Well, and I think another part of it is you know, if you've got people in your spend in 50% of your day while they're on site with you they're supposed to be training or auditing or doing whatever it is that they're doing. They spend half of their time asking you questions and trying to understand your equipment and learn your business because they've never been there. That to me is a trigger point too, like maybe this person doesn't know what's going on or they have to spend a bunch of time. They keep upselling me on stuff and they're like well, you know we could do this training, but you know we don't. You guys don't have this gear, and so if you just got this gear from me, you know, then we'd be able to do it.
Speaker 3And it's like are you trying to sell me gear? Are?
Speaker 2we doing an infomercial or are you being an expert? Right yeah so because that's my thing. For those you don't know, we don't sell any products or anything, because I think to be an expert, you have to be able to look at realistic expectations and realistic solutions, and I think people don't always have to have the wrong agenda. So to be a true expert and to take care of that in person, that in task, you have to be able to look at it open-minded, and part of that is you know when you're looking at, you know a disconnect, you know people will tell me so many different ways they can lock out a disconnect, or so many different ways an expert told them to do something.
Speaker 2I don't know. All I know is that you got to stay focused on that moment, make sure it makes sense to you, and so anything I write, anything I do, always is a second person there. Even though I'm the person who's managing the system on the export, I'm still going to train you on lockout or train you in confined space, like we did last week, but I still let them show me where to lock out and we all had degrees and groups. I was just one of the people.
Speaker 3Yeah yeah, sometimes it is a group effort, but you know, kind of going back to you know on the training side instead of like more of the procedure side. I definitely agree, you want a bunch of people that are location experts when you're writing procedures. Because they know that equipment better than anybody. They're servicing it every week.
Speaker 2Well, I don't think you can do like a video PowerPoint for some of the stuff. I mean the stuff we did last week. You know, if I would have came in and been a trainer last week, it was a place I know where they don't go to, so I've only been there a couple of times. Well, the very first time I went there, there was no bill for some of the stuff I did, because I don't think it's right to build those people from me to understand the business, because how can I bid the product, bid the project, if I don't understand the business well enough? So what I did is I took time and learned as much as I could about reading ahead of time, googling stuff, actually being on site for part of that, and I didn't charge them for that because I can't give them the information they want and even give them an option if I don't understand it well enough.
Speaker 3I could take time to do that, and part of it is knowing how to relate to them and give examples from their specific departments or industry or whatever they're doing. And that's part of what makes you an expert is being able to pull those out when they keep saying I'm not getting what you're saying, I don't know what you're saying and you can come up with that example.
Speaker 2And if video is not going to solve that. So for those of you who don't know about us, we don't really do any videos for PowerPoint, because it's not that. It's right, wrong and different. Everybody has the way they do it. I've always learned better by physically doing it and since that's the way I learned, that's the way we teach it. I mean, that's just the way I am.
Speaker 3Well, what? My biggest pet peeve of some stuff, which you know. It was really important to me that Anytime we take on a new client that maybe I'm not as well versed in that industry. Nothing drives me crazier than when you bring somebody in and they want to keep talking about a different industry. Well, this is how they do it over here.
Speaker 2I want to how we do it here today.
Speaker 3You go over there and do it, then you're at my play here, why are? You telling me about something that is completely different industry. We can't do any of that stuff.
Speaker 2I want to know tonight how am I gonna do it?
Speaker 3Yeah, the stuff going on in Petrochem. I can't do it on a you know harvest floor that.
Speaker 1I'm well hog barn.
Speaker 3Well, I'm washing down every night. It's not the same thing.
Speaker 2So that's where we're at. So we're at. You know, look at your expert, think about what makes an expert. Maybe they're internal, maybe they're external, and then you got some stuff. That's the stuff that gets some of the weird training things that happen with the expert may say an example Maybe the expert wants to bring all the ring gear. Well, last week, where I was, I was like, okay, we're gonna use all your gear. And they were like, okay, in the past We've been trained with other people's gear and my view was, yeah, but you have to use this when I leave, not mine, so you should be trained on your gear.
Speaker 2And then what I had to watch is I know people bring trailers and people bring gear and people bring all this stuff. But the concept point was kind of generic and and after about 20 minutes of it, what? What is the excitement? Because part of the training and being an expert is to keep people engaged and and part of that is making it relevant. I Don't know how you You're creating some of these systems that people do and keep people bought in all day, but I do know that if I'm training them on their equipment and their stuff, they're a lot more bought in because they're gonna use it next 15 minutes.
Speaker 3They're going in next weekend.
Speaker 2Yeah, last Friday we did last last Thursday. Friday I was teaching a course for crying space and literally Friday they had to borrow some of my gear because they're going into live entry and some of the guys I just trained Thursday we're doing it. So I don't get this luxury of hoping they never go in. They're gonna go in or we wouldn't be there training. So let's try. And if you don't do that, if you decide to hire a company in their third party and they bring your stuff and there's nothing wrong with it. You want to learn general ideas about gear and stuff, whatever, but you still need to go back and train them on your stuff the next day. And right now in my world no one has any labor and no one has any time, so they don't have that extra step to get it all done and and they lose that time during the training.
Speaker 3Then well, my question becomes like why are they bringing that though? Why are they even bringing that to begin with? Is it because they don't know like an air pack or a meter or stuff well enough to be able to just take on whatever the people have? Because that's what it tells me right like, if you're not willing to train on whatever the people have, then maybe you're not that comfortable with meters, because they all kind of run the same. Yeah, well yeah, he's kind of right thing.
Speaker 2I think, especially the last few years, there's been a lot of concepts or ideas about different ways of training, and I'm not saying people did or didn't do training certain ways in the past. All I'm saying is moving forward. When you decide you're gonna pick somebody and they call themselves an expert to come to your location, do that task. Asking questions. Yeah asking questions. See well, how are you gonna do? What are you? How's it gonna be relevant to me tonight when we have to go in? And if I can't, if it doesn't, if I can't guarantee that we're good to go and not to retrain by next week, is that the right fit for your business today?
Speaker 3Well, you know. And another thing you know from a lockout tag out authorized standpoint I've seen like that, you know, the lockout tag out boards, right, you know right and I like those because there's that's a good general concept, but I can't use that for my maintenance guy who's locking out something that's four sources.
Speaker 2Yeah, that's, that's the idea of understanding how to do it. You're still gonna take them out. You're still gonna show them the equipment. You still have to walk it through.
Speaker 3You still got show the procedure late, so the equipment I feel like here's where the ball valve is, here's how I know what I've got it. Good, here's the here's how long it has to purge out, or whatever you know, the same thing goes. I don't know how I compare dropping in the top of a trailer to climb an end, something with an auger in the bottom and I've got to watch where I put my foot.
Speaker 2Or I'm going into a mixer blender, going into a receiving pit, or so I don't know well, this pit we went into Friday was really dirty and I asked them is it always dirty when you go in? They're like yeah well then, that's how we want to train in it. Yeah, I didn't want it to be clean and perfect, I wanted to be. It was 100 degrees and it was gross and we were sweating and it was dirty and we're filthy. I said that's what we want, that's what it is.
Speaker 3I got a boiler entry. Yeah, we got a great picture of everybody.
Speaker 2Literally Was stuff all over and I said that's a good training moment because that's how it's gonna be going any space in rendering.
Speaker 3You won't be clean when you can go.
Speaker 2Yeah and so. So that's the deal. You know. You got things like subjects, you know, so so you got to teach, like I had to teach your harness last week. We may have to teach an air pack or teach something else, but you got to make sure that that's not counted or other things. You know, if I'm teaching someone harness for fine space, I'm talking about how it relates to that subject, not all harness training all Far protection for the location needs. Now no, it's for that subject because that subject could have multiple variables tied into that subject.
Speaker 3Yeah, trying to group everything in. We're doing one class for certification but we're trying to count it for respiratory lockout Elevator.
Speaker 2We're trying to like you know bandwagon 52 things on it.
Speaker 3Yeah, no the are we really? The question is, are we really for doing All those other subjects? Are we really meeting the intent of the primary subject, which is, you know, find space for this instance? But you know, are we really covering what we need to for respiratory and Elevated work and lockout truly for the entire rest of the scope of what that person's doing? I mean, we see that all the time with with high-angle rescue and stuff too, that's like, and they cut, they couple it together and like, well, we just had to find space train, we just, you know, did all this stuff with ropes and I'm like, well, that that has nothing. Hanging off the side of a building has nothing to do With going in a hole.
Speaker 2Yeah, and I know people will make comments right running different after we're done with this. But I'm gonna tell you something we you've got to evaluate the actual Nob you want them to do. Yeah, and you know I've had just like 40 hours training. Well, we always do 40 hours training for hazmat. I'm like, well, I don't know where it says the way you're doing it here you need, for you know there's other parts of the law, it's just not one part. You know, and that's what's amazing, whether you take a combined space or hazmat or forklift or lockout or elevated work, whatever subject you want to take, you have to break down what is the goal of that subject and Compress that goal.
Speaker 2If you can't accomplish that goal, then it's irrelevant if they were an expert, not because they want to expert to your people and then communicate to your people.
Speaker 3Right, you're really trying to know what is the goal and then what are the skill sets the trainer needs to have in order to meet that goal, and then that's how we kind of decide who our experts gonna be absolutely so.
Speaker 2Your expert, to wrap up here, can be internal or external. Yeah, expert could be somebody who's really great at the subject and you know. You know that could be whether through time or history or certifications or training can be anything. But you have to evaluate what that expectation is, what that goal is, and then find the right piece of the puzzle that meet your goal. And then that's how you start determining and, like I said, sometimes it's internal, sometimes external, sometimes a little combo both. Yeah, but you need to manage that as a system and go from there. So, all right, before close out, I'll let Jim close out anything else.
Speaker 3I don't. That says all right with.
Speaker 2That was ours today. Thank you, everybody signing in.
Speaker 3We'll see you next week.
Speaker 4Thank you for listening to safe, efficient, profitable a worker safety podcast. If you like what you heard here, please take a moment to write us a quick review. Like, subscribe and share our podcast so that others can find us for questions or to request topics that you'd like to hear on Our next show. Please visit us at wwwalland-safetycom. Thank you, thank you, you.
You’ve got the signage and fire extinguishers covered, but what’s about the rest of what goes into a fire prevention plan? In this episode, Joe and Jen grab their coffee and talk about the fire prevention plan gaps they...
OUR MERCH STORE: https://3279d21216.nxcli.net/shop-2/ OUR MERCH ON AMAZON:https://www.amazon.com/stores/AllenSafety/page/65264DB0-B81B-4A23-BCB2-03D3DFFD28D0?lp_asin=B0GKBWZ4JW&ref_=ast_bln In this episode, Joe and...
Merch Links: Allen Safety Merch Store: https://3279d21216.nxcli.net/shop-2/ Allen Safety Amazon Store: https://www.amazon.com/stores/AllenSafety/page/65264DB0-B81B-4A23-BCB2-03D3DFFD28D0 In this episode, we talk about...
Want to support the show? Please share this to get it out there to those that it coudl help. Want to support beyond that? Shop our Amazon Merch Store Here:...
In this episode of Safe, Efficient, Profitable, we break down the top three Process Safety Management (PSM) trends we’re seeing across industrial ammonia refrigeration facilities - and why they matter. Episode details...