Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

RUSHKOFF

RUSHKOFF artwork

Disaster Capitalism and the Case for Leveling Down - Rushkoff on Crazy Town

Mar 27, 202656 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Have you ever had that feeling in your gut, when you suddenly realize that the person you’re talking with might have a screw or two loose? What about when you’re the one others are trying to slowly back away from at the punch bowl? The question of who’s the real nut often arises for us collapse-aware folks living here in Crazy Town. Since Mr. Peanut is no longer returning their phone calls, hosts Rob, Jason, and Asher invited Rushkoff to answer the question. In this far ranging conversation, they discuss why “leveling down” might be the best strategy for navigating late stage capitalism and bringing ourselves back into right relationship with each other and the planet. You can stream and subscribe to Crazy Town wherever you get your podcasts. Support Team Human for access to exclusive Q&As with Rushkoff, early show premieres, bonus webinars, live events, and more: https://www.patreon.com/teamhuman Follow Team Human with Douglas Rushkoff: Instagram: https:/www.instagram.com/douglasrushkoff YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@douglasrushkoff TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/douglasrushkoff Bluesky: https://bsky.app/profile/rushkoff.com Our Sponsors: * Check out Uncommon Goods and use my code uncommongoods.com/TEAMHUMAN for a great deal: https://www.uncommongoods.com Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

[SPEAKER_00]: Hey, team producer Josh here. [SPEAKER_00]: I just wanted to gift you with a special bonus conversation. [SPEAKER_00]: It is a conversation that Rushkov had with the hosts of crazy town that expands upon the work that Rushkov talked about in a monologue. [SPEAKER_00]: You are not. [SPEAKER_00]: crazy that was published earlier this year. [SPEAKER_00]: It is a great podcast from resilience.org. [SPEAKER_00]: And if you like what you hear, you can subscribe to their show. [SPEAKER_00]: There will be a link in the show notes.

[SPEAKER_00]: And if you'd like to discuss what you hear in this conversation, you can head on over to the team [SPEAKER_00]: to support the work as well as gain access to add free episodes of the show, interactive Q&A's, books, and much, much more.

[SPEAKER_04]: I'm Jason Bradford. [SPEAKER_02]: I'm a sure miller, and I'm Rob Deetz. [SPEAKER_02]: Welcome to Crazy Town. [SPEAKER_02]: We're I'm not crazy, you're crazy. [SPEAKER_02]: The whole damn world's crazy. [SPEAKER_01]: Have you ever had that feeling in your gut when you suddenly realize that the person you're talking with might have a screw or two loose? [SPEAKER_01]: Well, what about when you're the one others are trying to slowly back away from what the punch bowl? [SPEAKER_01]: The question of who's the real nut often arises for us, claps, aware of folks living here in crazy town. [SPEAKER_01]: But since Mr. Peanut is no longer returning our phone calls, Rob Jason and I invited Douglas Rushkoff, Media theorist, professor, and host of the team Human Podcast to answer the question.

[SPEAKER_01]: In this far-ranging conversation, we discuss why leveling down might be the best strategy for navigating late-stage capitalism and bringing ourselves back into right relationship with each other and the planet. [SPEAKER_05]: Welcome to Crazy Town. [SPEAKER_05]: Here we are with our friend Douglas Freshgoth, who makes the team human podcast, which you should go to immediately after this is over. [SPEAKER_05]: Teamhuman.fm.

[SPEAKER_01]: I think that was the introduction. [SPEAKER_04]: That was beautiful. [SPEAKER_01]: I don't think we need to do another introduction. [SPEAKER_04]: You're in crazy town. [SPEAKER_04]: Oh wow. [SPEAKER_04]: We're gonna reuse that when we're gonna loop it. [SPEAKER_04]: Hey man. [SPEAKER_01]: Douglas, we've had you on a couple of times already on crazy. [SPEAKER_01]: Really? [SPEAKER_05]: And you welcomed me back. [SPEAKER_05]: Look at that. [SPEAKER_01]: And there's a specific reason we wanted to do a mind belt of team human and crazy town. [SPEAKER_05]: Yeah. [SPEAKER_01]: Because you wrote a piece recently, and I found greatly reassuring because you wrote, you were not crazy.

[SPEAKER_01]: And I was like, [SPEAKER_01]: I think God. [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah. [SPEAKER_01]: You were channelling crazy town when you wrote that because, you know, the reason we do crazy town is that experience that we have in our listeners, I think, resonate with, which is you walk around the world, it looks absolutely bad, chitten, saying to you, the interactions you have with people make you feel like you're nuts. [SPEAKER_01]: People treat you like you're nuts oftentimes, but it's actually [SPEAKER_01]: The secret is, as far as I know, the world is actually pretty crazy. [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah. [SPEAKER_01]: And we're the rational ones.

[SPEAKER_01]: So maybe talk a little bit about what the experience was. [SPEAKER_05]: So like 2018, I wrote this piece on medium that got a lot of buzz about meeting these five billionaires who wanted advice on their bunkers. [SPEAKER_05]: And it didn't make me a bunker expert or anything, but it was like, Oh, my God. [SPEAKER_05]: Why do they come into a media theorist for this sort of apocalyptic? [SPEAKER_05]: visions. [SPEAKER_05]: And I wrote this piece, saying, look, the richest guys among us, the super tech pros are planning for the end that they've got so little faith in the ability of their technologies to actually solve anything that they're preparing for the event, you know, the end of the world thing.

[SPEAKER_05]: And then that turned into a book and all this stuff. [SPEAKER_05]: So a bunch of TV shows ended up being developed around the central premise of that book. [SPEAKER_05]: I mean, I would never get paid for them because it's an on-fiction book. [SPEAKER_05]: In terms of that, you don't have to pay or get rights to do a story based on an on-fiction book on the fiction. [SPEAKER_05]: Oops. [SPEAKER_05]: I should have just put it as fiction. [SPEAKER_05]: Yeah, I'm fine. [SPEAKER_05]: But what shows? [SPEAKER_05]: What shows? [SPEAKER_05]: Oh, Mountain Head used a lot of stuff from it and this one called Paradise.

[SPEAKER_05]: which is one of these Hulu shows, it's about a post-apocalyptic underground giant city that was created by a tech billionaire. [SPEAKER_05]: And as I thought would happen, the show is about the relationship of the tech billionaire to the security staff. [SPEAKER_05]: How do you maintain control of your security when your money is worthless and you're in this bizarre post-apocalyptic [SPEAKER_05]: But it's fine. [SPEAKER_05]: It's as good as any of these shows.

[SPEAKER_05]: It's a good one as far as the billionaire bunker genre go. [SPEAKER_05]: And I mean, I didn't really know about the show, but they invited me to be on the companion podcast. [SPEAKER_05]: You know how the nice, the high-brow streaming shows have these companion podcasts that they air after the thing. [SPEAKER_05]: So I go on and it's with the star of the show's wife [SPEAKER_05]: and they have me on a cheap. [SPEAKER_05]: The producers told her I was a bunker expert. [SPEAKER_05]: And then one of the producers is there.

[SPEAKER_05]: The thing it says, oh, you know, we loved your buck. [SPEAKER_05]: It was so, you know, it really inspired us to do this whole show. [SPEAKER_05]: So I explain that I'm not really a bunker expert or anything but and then she could like is this realistic and the way they do the bunker Could that really happen and that it's like that's not my thing. [SPEAKER_05]: I said no. [SPEAKER_05]: What makes the show important is that the bunker that you're talking about the city that they've built to go live in after the apocalypse [SPEAKER_05]: those cities already exist. [SPEAKER_05]: It's already happening.

[SPEAKER_05]: This is Prospera in Central America. [SPEAKER_05]: This is the land that they're buying, and whatever Solana near, or whatever they call that, just to forever city here, or whatever they call that one. [SPEAKER_05]: It's knowing there are [SPEAKER_05]: Neon in Saudi Arabia, yeah, it's the sea-steading project. [SPEAKER_05]: It's San Palo today with a very super wealthy city center protected by God knows how many armed guards from the rest of the work that's in South Africa was like, right, under apartheid.

[SPEAKER_05]: Right, and other parts are like still. [SPEAKER_05]: So I explain that these cities exist and then explain about the sort of division of wealth [SPEAKER_05]: And I'll say something like the apocalypse that you're envisioning is actually it's happening now that the show is not realistic as science fiction. [SPEAKER_05]: It's realistic as a metaphor and allegory for what's happening now. [SPEAKER_05]: So I explain how. [SPEAKER_05]: You know, in the Soviet Union, when the Soviet Union collapsed, it was a way to privatize a whole bunch of stuff that had been public assets and that in America, it looks like what our government is trying to do is to create the conditions of disaster capitalism so that things could be bought up.

[SPEAKER_05]: So, you know, we do tariffs, that puts farmers out of business, and then a sovereign wealth fund can come in and buy the farmland. [SPEAKER_05]: And she goes, oh, [SPEAKER_05]: And as I'm describing a sovereign wealth fund, which is basically, you know, if you live in a nation that has a resource curse, meaning that you've got something like oil that you make money from, you've got no motivation to educate your people because you're making all the money from that. [SPEAKER_05]: And then what do you do with all the money that you've made if you don't give it out to the people you create a sovereign wealth fund and then invest in productive assets or crypto currencies.

[SPEAKER_05]: And right, and then she was like, really? [SPEAKER_05]: And I kept going back and almost having to like explain the roots of capital and the more I explained, the more I did, her eyes got wider and wider and I realized I sounded like a conspiracy theorist. [SPEAKER_05]: Yes. [SPEAKER_05]: What do you mean, sovereign wealth fund? [SPEAKER_05]: Yes. [SPEAKER_05]: Disaster capitalism intentionally, you know, intentionally crashing the U.S. economy so that they could buy our ports. [SPEAKER_05]: with money. [SPEAKER_01]: It's like you're talking about the free mason's or something, you know? [SPEAKER_01]: Right. [SPEAKER_01]: Yes. [SPEAKER_05]: Private equity or any of these things that are completely normal are they are crazy town.

[SPEAKER_05]: Right. [SPEAKER_05]: So I went through it and I just realized there's no way. [SPEAKER_05]: I can tell the basic simple story here without sounding crazy because that's how crazy it's become So her eyes are bugging out not because she's like, oh my god, it's like she was learning stuff and realizing the things you were saying were true She was her eyes are bugging out because she's like, oh shit, no, I'm with a crazy person and I don't know I don't know whether she was humoring me the way that art bell used to humor people when they talked about their UFO experience

[SPEAKER_05]: Wow, that must have been scary. [SPEAKER_05]: I couldn't tell if she was like because it's good entertainment to have a guy I have no idea, but my sense was she was Thinking who the fuck did they book right? [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, you're supposed to be a bunker expert You're supposed to talk about the depth of the concrete right? [SPEAKER_01]: It's poor. [SPEAKER_01]: Do you know how wide is it? [SPEAKER_04]: Yeah, exactly. [SPEAKER_04]: Yeah, I think all of us [SPEAKER_04]: on this program have had similar experiences.

[SPEAKER_04]: And I've had so many that I came up with a term for it. [SPEAKER_04]: I called that a tilting. [SPEAKER_04]: So you know, pinball machines. [SPEAKER_04]: You're playing, this is old, old people used to play pinball machines. [SPEAKER_04]: I don't know if it works, happens anymore. [SPEAKER_04]: But there's these things. [SPEAKER_04]: OK. And if you were too violent to the machine trying to like move it back and forth, the machine would say, you off balanced me. [SPEAKER_04]: And I can no longer play with you. [SPEAKER_04]: right because you're cheating it didn't want you to be a cheater and so I feel like what happens is that you just draw so they're mind too much like too much activity happens too fast that they're unfamiliar with and now they're not sure because you've gotten so far with them like they're like yes okay okay and then suddenly you push a little too hard on the brain and

[SPEAKER_04]: and tilt mode occurs and you get that look, it's a classic look. [SPEAKER_04]: And I think it's a kind of an uncertainty like, where am I now? [SPEAKER_04]: What's going on? [SPEAKER_04]: You know, what's true? [SPEAKER_04]: Is this person okay? [SPEAKER_01]: Slowly back away from you like Homer Simpson into the bush, right? [SPEAKER_01]: Yes. [SPEAKER_01]: Slowly try to move away from you. [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah. [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah. [SPEAKER_05]: Yeah, it's the state that happens, you know, what they choose to call the grew-in transfer. [SPEAKER_05]: And you walk into a shopping mall. [SPEAKER_05]: The traditional shopping mall, you know, people's eyes glaze over and their jaw drops. [SPEAKER_05]: And that was the intent of the mall was to sort of overwhelm you and put you in a passive childlike state where you then wander aimlessly and forget.

[SPEAKER_01]: So be there by shit. [SPEAKER_01]: You by shit, you don't need. [SPEAKER_04]: Oh, oh my god, there's Abercrombian fish. [SPEAKER_01]: Oh, I need to get myself a synobond. [SPEAKER_01]: I see, but yeah. [SPEAKER_05]: it is that they get overwhelmed and then you kind of have to shut off. [SPEAKER_05]: So that's part of the flood the zone strategy, you know, the ban in Magarate. [SPEAKER_05]: If you do so many things every day you have a new outrageous unprecedented thing, then the novelty of each thing it kind of detaches you.

[SPEAKER_05]: Which is why you need, you know, people like me, I would think that's why I ended up doing the [SPEAKER_05]: History, where did this come from? [SPEAKER_05]: Where did money come from? [SPEAKER_05]: Why does it work like it does? [SPEAKER_05]: What other money is we're there? [SPEAKER_05]: What's the operating system of our society? [SPEAKER_05]: What's the software on it? [SPEAKER_05]: And once you no longer see these things as given conditions of nature, but as inventions by people at particular moments in time, the crazy factor goes away. [SPEAKER_05]: It's just, oh, we built this.

[SPEAKER_05]: You know, we built this thing. [SPEAKER_05]: It's like we're living in a water park and forgot that you don't have to [SPEAKER_01]: But this is an interesting question for me to this. [SPEAKER_01]: So I see the rationale what you're saying, which is in some ways, what we're seeing is crazy or the logical outcomes of a system that was created. [SPEAKER_01]: This is kind of rational in a certain way, what's happening here. [SPEAKER_01]: but at the same time there's things like is it just that it's like capitalism is now put into hyperdrive and so it seems like you know the way for example the AI companies or tech overlord types are behaving is very similar to what you know people did in the gilded age or whatever

[SPEAKER_01]: it's all consistent, it's not anything unique or different, but it's just done on like hyper driver like a much larger scale. [SPEAKER_05]: Yeah, I think there's the differences that they don't believe they have to live in the same world. [SPEAKER_04]: There's a delusion there. [SPEAKER_05]: Right. [SPEAKER_05]: So the Lord of the Manor, [SPEAKER_05]: they had the upstairs downstairs and part of what they were doing by being lords was maintaining the employment of the entire manner or the castle or the whatever and they did have relationships of a sort of social relationship with the underlings even if they were highly coded.

[SPEAKER_05]: It's based in capitalism, which the real rule of cap, people think capitalism is about making money. [SPEAKER_05]: No, no, no, no, no. [SPEAKER_05]: Capitalism is a very particular way of making money, where someone else does the work, and you level up. [SPEAKER_05]: You are one level above. [SPEAKER_05]: the worker. [SPEAKER_05]: Someone pays the rent, you are the landlord. [SPEAKER_05]: Someone does the work, you are the owner. [SPEAKER_05]: Someone is the owner, you are the shareholder. [SPEAKER_05]: Someone's the shareholder, you are the dividend. [SPEAKER_05]: Someone's the dividend holder, you are on the stock exchange. [SPEAKER_05]: Someone is the stock exchange, you are on the technology.

[SPEAKER_05]: So you keep leveling up. [SPEAKER_05]: Peter Tio says go from zero to one. [SPEAKER_05]: Exist one order of magnitude above the people who are doing something. [SPEAKER_05]: So you keep leveling up. [SPEAKER_05]: digital technology kind of did more than just amplify that. [SPEAKER_05]: Because digital technology is itself leveled up. [SPEAKER_05]: It's a digital symbol system, an analog of reality, right? [SPEAKER_05]: It's leveled up. [SPEAKER_05]: It's an augmented reality with infinite scalability that's not directly connected to down here.

[SPEAKER_05]: So I think the difference with these tech bros versus the gilded age is gilded age, Rockefeller, Carnegie, whoever they wanted the approval of the masses, and they wanted to feel like they were contributing in some way. [SPEAKER_05]: They built libraries and hospitals and they did things for legacy because they were still living on the same planet. [SPEAKER_05]: as the others. [SPEAKER_05]: Macy's made a parade, right? [SPEAKER_05]: They want their kids to be liked.

[SPEAKER_05]: These guys don't see that. [SPEAKER_05]: Their kids are going to be on another planet. [SPEAKER_05]: They've leveled up so their abstraction is an existential abstraction rather than just an instrumental abstraction. [SPEAKER_04]: This reminds me a bit of living in St. Louis. [SPEAKER_04]: I live in St. Louis for nine years. [SPEAKER_04]: And during the gilded age, [SPEAKER_04]: all these mansions were built and what's interesting is those neighborhoods are still there. [SPEAKER_04]: But nowadays when mansions are built, they're built way out in the county like they're not in the city.

[SPEAKER_04]: And it's because you have now the freeway system, right? [SPEAKER_04]: You have the ability to ship anything to your door and you have supermarkets in these now exorban areas that are nice. [SPEAKER_04]: But in back in the day, [SPEAKER_04]: to get those high quality goods and services, and like you're saying, Douglas, this sort of neighborhoods of these mansions, and they were adjacent to working class neighborhoods because the people had to walk to get to work in these places.

[SPEAKER_04]: Right. [SPEAKER_04]: And of course, back in that day, it wasn't too far of a stretch to drive out in the country and see farms that were growing the food that you ate in those mansions. [SPEAKER_04]: But we're so disconnected now, I think it is so abstract. [SPEAKER_04]: They've leveled up so much, they don't know about all this or care anymore. [SPEAKER_01]: But also the technology piece of that is there are some conversations about the biophysical impacts of like data centers, you know, NEI and all that stuff.

[SPEAKER_01]: But [SPEAKER_01]: For the most part, you could just be utterly divorced about the environmental impacts of what supports the internet and the virtual world that so many of us women. [SPEAKER_01]: So for them, they don't necessarily see those, not only do they not have to deal with other humans very much. [SPEAKER_01]: They don't have to actually see that what they're building and growing at ridiculously fast, exponential rates might actually have a limit on them, you know. [SPEAKER_01]: In fact, they're talking about harnessing the power of the sun, right, in order to keep going.

[SPEAKER_01]: I guess maybe that's a recognition of some women. [SPEAKER_04]: Data centers in space. [SPEAKER_04]: That'll be cool. [SPEAKER_03]: Sounds like a muppet show, skit, data centers in space. [SPEAKER_05]: But I like that better than then data centers on Earth. [SPEAKER_01]: Sure, except one is physically possible. [SPEAKER_01]: They're doing it right now. [SPEAKER_01]: The other is not scalable really. [SPEAKER_01]: But if it were, if it were, yeah, they're working on it. [SPEAKER_05]: I'd rather them do that than drink up all our water and pollute our little children and put other kids in minds to get cobalt.

[SPEAKER_04]: Well, the thing is, if you heard of the Kessler syndrome, if you heard of this, now it sounds but dangerous though. [SPEAKER_04]: Okay, we're on the verge of this right now. [SPEAKER_05]: And what do you think this is one of those people talking about weird things? [SPEAKER_01]: All of our eyes are getting lighter now. [SPEAKER_01]: Douglass is backing up. [SPEAKER_04]: Keep going. [SPEAKER_04]: We've got to look up the Kessler syndrome. [SPEAKER_04]: This is what it is. [SPEAKER_01]: Douglass is moving away from his microphone. [SPEAKER_04]: What it is is that when you get too muddy satellites in space, all it takes is some little accident.

[SPEAKER_04]: It could be a solar flair knock some of them out, and they no longer have gyroscopes that are working, and they're electronics fry. [SPEAKER_04]: And these things require slight control. [SPEAKER_04]: Sometimes you have to move them, you have to move them out of the way. [SPEAKER_04]: You have to do a little rocket thing, and they kind of move back into higher orbit slightly to keep them up there for years. [SPEAKER_04]: As soon as you get enough of these failing, there's a cascading reaction and essentially you have uncontrolled space junk because to get rid of one of these satellites, you have to do it carefully.

[SPEAKER_04]: You have to actually get them to fall down and not become space junk. [SPEAKER_04]: Right. [SPEAKER_04]: And as soon as you have too much space junk, you can't safely get anything into orbit anymore because your investment is likely going to get waxed by something that's size of a quarter flying at 20,000 miles an hour. [SPEAKER_05]: Didn't you see that movie? [SPEAKER_05]: And like George Kulini rescued her, but he wasn't really there. [SPEAKER_05]: He was just a dream. [SPEAKER_05]: But all that space junk can fly and crash. [SPEAKER_04]: That's the Kessler syndrome. [SPEAKER_04]: So the thing is, we're actually very close to that already. [SPEAKER_01]: But Elon's got to be worried about that because he's playing with a march, so he must be aware.

[SPEAKER_04]: Well, I'm not aware that or worried about it, because what happens, the worst happens to me is like GPS goes down, weather satellites disappear, you know, these kind of things. [SPEAKER_04]: Right. [SPEAKER_05]: And rich people get poor. [SPEAKER_04]: Yes. [SPEAKER_04]: Yeah. [SPEAKER_04]: And we can't call in as Mars or have a international space station. [SPEAKER_01]: I don't know. [SPEAKER_01]: I don't know what all this relates to there. [SPEAKER_01]: But there are a lot of people in the world who rely on their mobile phones to do all kinds of commerce now. [SPEAKER_05]: But will it kill like will grandma's pacemaker break? [SPEAKER_05]: Maybe I guess could it would be bad It would be bad, but you know this is the price you pay But I saw someone showed a picture somewhere of the they have this thing that can like get space debris

[SPEAKER_01]: Oh, is it like the same thing like getting plastic pollution in the ocean? [SPEAKER_05]: Yes, yeah, that kind of thing. [SPEAKER_05]: They grab, errant satellites. [SPEAKER_03]: It's like one of those claws you see at the arcade that can pick up a stuffed animal, right? [SPEAKER_01]: Except it goes off because it's going to be a very large claw band if it's doing that. [SPEAKER_04]: Everything's a question as scale is a problem. [SPEAKER_03]: You know, yeah, once again, my level of wonder comes in around why there's so much trust put in all this technology you guys are well aware listeners might not be but I went to radio silence just now because my computer decided to have a meltdown like we can't even get a laptop to function during the the length of a podcast, how are we supposed to put a data center in space.

[SPEAKER_05]: Dude, it didn't decide. [SPEAKER_05]: You're anthropomorphizing your technology. [SPEAKER_05]: Yeah. [SPEAKER_05]: It didn't decide to do that. [SPEAKER_05]: It had no volition. [SPEAKER_03]: I thought you were going to say that the bad guys out there made it do that. [SPEAKER_03]: Then I was going to think you were crazy. [SPEAKER_05]: Closer, it's more likely that the greater chance of that than that the computer decided to do it. [SPEAKER_01]: I want to get back to this topic of being in a crazy world and how people navigate it. [SPEAKER_05]: Yeah, when you take a dollar bill and show it to someone and say what is this and they say it's a dollar, oh what's a dollar and you actually go through with them that this is a piece of paper that has been printed with words.

[SPEAKER_05]: that mean nothing on some level. [SPEAKER_05]: You know, that there's a social construction and that there were many different currencies and those currencies were outlawed by monarchs who were forcing us to borrow money from a central treasury so they could make interest. [SPEAKER_05]: They could make money off our need to transact and money is expensive for no good reason. [SPEAKER_05]: Other than enabling the rich, [SPEAKER_05]: You gotta tell that story really slowly, right? [SPEAKER_05]: Because if you tell it too quickly, it's overwhelming as crazy town citizens.

[SPEAKER_05]: We are slowly pulling back the curtain from the Wizard of Oz. [SPEAKER_05]: And saying, don't look up there, look over here. [SPEAKER_05]: This guy's actually making that. [SPEAKER_01]: just showing the ankles first and then moving up. [SPEAKER_01]: Exactly. [SPEAKER_05]: You kind of have to do it slowly and you have to do it in a way that the person discovers these things for themselves rather than being told and has to be a bit secretic. [SPEAKER_05]: It's a set of questions. [SPEAKER_05]: I mean, I was raised in New York. [SPEAKER_05]: I thought all cities had grid patterns that they were all used

[SPEAKER_05]: You know, I get, go to friggin' England when I'm in college, like, what did they do here? [SPEAKER_05]: Where this isn't a city, this is random, this is what? [SPEAKER_05]: And I was like, oh my god, the New York was designed that way. [SPEAKER_05]: Someone chose, I thought they'd just somehow it, if you don't know. [SPEAKER_07]: Sure. [SPEAKER_05]: God didn't make that grid, someone planned it, they wrote it down, they laid it out. [SPEAKER_05]: But you know you don't accept that so many aspects of society have been designed by people It's not all conspiracy. [SPEAKER_05]: It's just everything was designed by someone language was designed by people.

[SPEAKER_05]: You know It's all social construction. [SPEAKER_05]: You know, accept what the feeling you get when you look at another person in the eyes When you hold your baby when you make love when you [SPEAKER_05]: encounter a tree, there's things that are not social construction. [SPEAKER_05]: And I think the more the more we engage with those, the more calibrated we are, and then we're ready we are to accept these seeming laws of nature as inventions of humans. [SPEAKER_03]: So Douglas, I don't know if you have a user manual, say, for residents of crazy town.

[SPEAKER_03]: But I would be my book team human was meant, yeah, literally as that. [SPEAKER_05]: You'll be better off. [SPEAKER_05]: It's easier to do with friends. [SPEAKER_05]: Just don't try to do this alone. [SPEAKER_03]: Yeah, this is the thing, like when we're speaking with say collapse aware people, it's all fine, you know, like Jason and a share can send me all sorts of crazy making topics and I'm on their same world view their same wavelength, but occasionally when I have an entry point with somebody who is outside of our world view, I'm wondering about some tips, so let me let me give you an example, okay, so.

[SPEAKER_03]: I happen to be taking an airplane flight and we were happened to be flying over the desert. [SPEAKER_03]: And my seatmate was this really nice woman we were just chatting and she just seemed super friendly and of course it comes around she asked me what do you do? [SPEAKER_03]: and then I tell her about my job and how I'm exploring the limits to growth and how we need to build an economy that respects the limits and stabilizes at a size that doesn't wreck the ecosystems. [SPEAKER_04]: Well set. [SPEAKER_03]: So her response and I should say I try to tell those things in ways that

[SPEAKER_03]: maybe aren't overwhelming, like, you know, sort of like you are suggesting Douglas, and then she turns around and tells me that she's a highly religious person. [SPEAKER_03]: God said in the Bible that we need to be fruitful and multiply. [SPEAKER_03]: And when I look out the window here, I don't see any people down there. [SPEAKER_03]: And you know, then I tried to talk about water a little bit, but then it was just the water is you know, she clearly thought my world view my idea about the scale of the human enterprise was absolutely nuts and I kind of thought she was sort of off the deep in so we and I don't mean because she was religious I just mean her idea of trying to populate the deserts with as many people as we can.

[SPEAKER_03]: What's the manual out of team human for continuing to engage with somebody who is just so far removed from our world view? [SPEAKER_05]: The team human answer for that is that [SPEAKER_05]: But for the most part, it doesn't matter what 99% of people believe about the world. [SPEAKER_05]: What matters is how they behave. [SPEAKER_05]: It matters if she needs a tool, if she's going to go to the Home Depot and buy it, or she's going to knock on her neighbor's door and borrow it.

[SPEAKER_05]: if the neighborhood is under threat, because of a storm or a flood, is she part of the network of people that knows where the old people live, who need to be checked up on, it doesn't matter whether [SPEAKER_05]: people are on board with the club of Rome, which I'm now a member, they may be a member, who club of Rome, talk about limits to growth, right? [SPEAKER_05]: It doesn't matter if they understand the carrying capacity of the lived environment, because

[SPEAKER_05]: The idea that the planet has limits is much less likely to motivate people to live within its limits than rediscovery of the joy of sharing. [SPEAKER_05]: Right? [SPEAKER_05]: The human species, it's part of what made homo sapiens homo sapiens is our ability to share to share resources. [SPEAKER_05]: It's so core. [SPEAKER_05]: So I would have a different conversation with that woman.

[SPEAKER_05]: You know, the, yes, you can look at it. [SPEAKER_05]: Oh, isn't it terrible? [SPEAKER_05]: I was like, [SPEAKER_05]: or what, or what, oh, so we should use less energy or this or that. [SPEAKER_05]: I prefer to engage with people, even people who I suspect may have vastly different views than I do. [SPEAKER_05]: I prefer to engage them in conversations that reinforce their most pro-social tendencies, to have a conversation that would make that person want to, [SPEAKER_05]: join a bowling league or become a dead mother or you know share an activity with other people.

[SPEAKER_03]: Hey, this is Rob. [SPEAKER_03]: Crazy Town is planning a male bag episode in which we read and respond to your emails. [SPEAKER_02]: So if you have a question, an idea for an episode, maybe an insult to hurl at Jason or a [SPEAKER_03]: Or maybe you've got an example of how you navigate the mean streets of crazy town. [SPEAKER_03]: Well, we'd love to hear from you. [SPEAKER_03]: So, please send us an email to crazytownatpostcarbon.org. [SPEAKER_03]: That's crazytownatpostcarbon.org.

[SPEAKER_01]: That's why I actually think that your example Rob of a woman who says she's religious might be actually a lot easier to engage with than someone who's anti-human, right, transhuman or whatever, like it just don't like people, right, don't believe in community, don't want to have those relationships, I feel like those people are the hardest, or the hardest for me actually. [SPEAKER_01]: in terms of finding the others is sometimes you feel like you found the other and you're like 90% aligned with them and then you discover that there's this 10% thing and that 10% is just huge right and we see this a lot I think in our space when it comes to renewables for example like

[SPEAKER_01]: You're so long, yeah, we have a climate crisis, this is a big problem. [SPEAKER_01]: We have all these issues. [SPEAKER_01]: You can sort of analyze the predicament a little bit. [SPEAKER_01]: And then you get to, well, technology is going to solve the problem. [SPEAKER_01]: You know what I mean? [SPEAKER_01]: Or markets are going to solve the problem. [SPEAKER_01]: Or whatever it is, you know, human innovation. [SPEAKER_01]: You know, once we unleash human innovation, I also have the problem. [SPEAKER_01]: And it's those people that I actually find it the hardest to, that's where I actually feel almost more crazy, you know? [SPEAKER_05]: Yeah, well, when you get with when we get with our own right, so I mean it's like since I have been involved with with Nate Higgins for five or ten years, he's a sort of an environmental theorist.

[SPEAKER_05]: He's got a great podcast and stuff of his own and he was the one who first explained to me that battery electronic vehicles don't solve the problem that [SPEAKER_05]: You know, when you look at the whole carbon footprint and all that and all the stuff that has to be done to make one and the energy from the grid, it's like, yeah, there's nothing coming out of the tailpipe, but it doesn't really solve the problem. [SPEAKER_05]: It's just to can kicking at best. [SPEAKER_05]: Cory Doctero will say, oh, but it's in improvement. [SPEAKER_05]: It is better and you're doing the R&D on things that will be yet better and the amount to percent that it's better is still worth better than the other.

[SPEAKER_05]: And those two perspectives in some ways are irreconcilable, even though they're both yearning for the same thing. [SPEAKER_05]: You know, and it reminds me of that joke about the, they find this Jewish guy on a, [SPEAKER_05]: desert island that he's been stuck on for like 20 years and he's built two synagogues and are like dude, Jaime, whatever. [SPEAKER_05]: Why did you build two synagogues and he goes, this is the synagogue I go to and that's the synagogue I won't set foot in. [SPEAKER_05]: As if he needs that in order to believe in what he has.

[SPEAKER_05]: So it's a tendency and it's a tendency way more among the left. [SPEAKER_01]: Totally. [SPEAKER_05]: And it's good that we can argue about these things and use our facts, but we can't let it undermine our more fundamental solidarity to get ourselves out of this predicament. [SPEAKER_05]: And I think, but you guys are in that sort of camp with me, the sort of the Schumacher camp, the, we get accused of being malfusions. [SPEAKER_05]: But the idea that there's nothing wrong with limiting gross.

[SPEAKER_05]: with enjoying the fruits of our labors, you know? [SPEAKER_05]: And people, again, they don't want to know, they don't want to find out, but the requirement for exponential growth has nothing to do with reality. [SPEAKER_05]: It has nothing to do with economics. [SPEAKER_05]: It has only to do with a very particular money system that was invented in the 1100s by monarchs who didn't like that the middle class was getting rich. [SPEAKER_05]: and created a way to make money off other people, which was you are only allowed to transact if you borrow these chips from us and pay us to use them.

[SPEAKER_05]: Stop using those free chips that you've been using to transact and pay for hours. [SPEAKER_05]: the only way for them to keep paying for our money is for the economy to grow and that's not required as a condition of nature. [SPEAKER_05]: It's only required in the very particular monopoly board game that was created to let the rich stay rich for being rich. [SPEAKER_01]: Well, it's ultimately anti-nature, right? [SPEAKER_01]: It's fundamentally unsustainable, right? [SPEAKER_05]: Yeah, which is again, and anytime I talk to a libertarian, I'm like fine, free market as long as we can have free market money, I'll go with your free market capitalism.

[SPEAKER_03]: Yeah. [SPEAKER_04]: The thing I think about a lot is about how many people feel trapped because they live in a way that requires money, like everything nowadays requires money. [SPEAKER_04]: You got to pay rent, you got to pay tax, you do need money. [SPEAKER_04]: Right, but it's kind of a scale problem, right? [SPEAKER_04]: You need money for everything. [SPEAKER_04]: I think there definitely was more of an informal economy dominated our past in the United States. [SPEAKER_04]: And it's still dominated to another part of the world. [SPEAKER_04]: But I guess the question is, once you make monetary requirements for more and more things, how do you back out of that?

[SPEAKER_04]: Like, is there a path for people? [SPEAKER_04]: to downscale their needs for money and what things would you focus on? [SPEAKER_04]: Like what are things you would focus on to salary money and what can we learn from people maybe even in our neighborhoods that don't have money? [SPEAKER_04]: What do they do? [SPEAKER_01]: Well they share resources. [SPEAKER_01]: That's one thing they do. [SPEAKER_05]: What if we take some percent, some share of the stuff that we need to make money to get and do that in a more sharing local way?

[SPEAKER_05]: Like what if just tools, instead of having all of your own tools that you use, how often do you use your electric drill? [SPEAKER_05]: I mean, two times a year, what if you have a tool library in your block, or in your library? [SPEAKER_05]: somewhere is they have two or three shows you borrow one for a couple days and bring it back. [SPEAKER_05]: It's like, wow, isn't that efficient or snowblowers, what to have one snowblower on your block? [SPEAKER_05]: You know, rather than every house having to have its own snowblower or lawnmower, whatever it is, that's a really simple way to need less money.

[SPEAKER_05]: Now, if the problem with that and whenever I bring that up in a talk, someone always gets up and says, well, yeah, what about the lawnmower company? [SPEAKER_05]: you know, what about, you know, the people who have stalking the lawnmower company. [SPEAKER_05]: So again, they're, they're thinking this, that this house of cards will fall down the minute people lose allegiance to consumption as the salvation of America. [SPEAKER_05]: And it's like, it's, don't worry, it's not going to all happen at once. [SPEAKER_05]: You know, we're not all going to start borrowing at the same moment unless we're all put out a work by the AI, isn't then we'll start pulling resources pretty pretty don't fast.

[SPEAKER_05]: But what we can do is reduce our dependence on these brittle top-down systems, reduce our requirement for cash, for cash money, and start slowly and steadily replacing some of those things with more common based [SPEAKER_05]: networks of sharing. [SPEAKER_05]: And again, it's again, we talk about this and to the people who are not in crazy town, it sounds like socialism. [SPEAKER_05]: Oh, no, socialism or communism worse or something, and our chasm. [SPEAKER_05]: And I would just say, just take the isms away.

[SPEAKER_05]: You know, it's social. [SPEAKER_04]: It's common. [SPEAKER_04]: Well, I thought I'd think it is maybe village life and still the day, like I've been to places where most things are not paid for. [SPEAKER_04]: I've traveled around the world enough to see that. [SPEAKER_04]: Right. [SPEAKER_04]: Some Pacific islands, you go to these places on some of these Pacific islands and they're making everything out of natural materials. [SPEAKER_04]: Maybe they got a metal roof. [SPEAKER_04]: Maybe they've got a well that has got a hand pump on it in the center. [SPEAKER_04]: But they're growing all their own food. [SPEAKER_04]: They know how to

[SPEAKER_04]: It's incredible like human beings live most places of the world most times without all this stuff. [SPEAKER_04]: But then people say, okay, I need this high-tech thing to stay alive, right? [SPEAKER_04]: So we create a code and residency and an expectation. [SPEAKER_04]: Like, so it's like it's interesting where people be willing to go. [SPEAKER_01]: I actually do feel like there's been a crack opened up, you know, we're talking about money. [SPEAKER_01]: I think what happened in the great recession and how the banks have built out effectively.

[SPEAKER_01]: And then profited off of the recovery and people saw that and they were, they did not receive those same. [SPEAKER_01]: But if it's led, I think, did lead some people to look at cryptocurrencies, alternate forms of money, you know, trying to get away from those intermediaries, like that, and COVID, I think, whatever you want to think about the pandemic, and all that stuff, led people to question the medical system, because they didn't feel like it worked for them. [SPEAKER_01]: And so now you have Maha movement, and people looking for alternative things, the weird

[SPEAKER_01]: the rentier class, kind of solutions, does still feel like they're looking for individualistic ways of profit seeking, right? [SPEAKER_01]: It's not like, it's not like people ran up to Western Mass to start figuring out how you could do a Berkshire program, you know, and have your own local currency. [SPEAKER_01]: No, they were investing a Bitcoin and then they tried to make a shit [SPEAKER_01]: So the system still finds its way in to get people to be fixated on how they individually can benefit from these alternatives.

[SPEAKER_05]: Right, exactly like crypto really originally emerged at the same time as occupied as an alternative to Wall Street blockchain peer to peer verification. [SPEAKER_05]: We're going to make our own money and then the token became more important than the blockchain right now the token. [SPEAKER_05]: How are we going to make money off that until we see. [SPEAKER_05]: Oh, it is just fucking bullshit.

[SPEAKER_05]: And we don't want to substitute for trust as a way of moving forward. [SPEAKER_05]: We want to enable trust. [SPEAKER_04]: You know, I trust people that I know in real life, I RL is, I guess, the threat, which is crazy. [SPEAKER_04]: If I know somebody, I RL enough and I work with them and I see them and I laugh with them, then I trust them. [SPEAKER_04]: Like this something takes time. [SPEAKER_04]: But I feel like I want to be with people, you know, doing things together. [SPEAKER_04]: to get trust. [SPEAKER_05]: But you show, you show, but that's why the local and itemsmith wrote about this.

[SPEAKER_05]: That's why local economics should always take precedence over generic global economics. [SPEAKER_05]: We do have a local advantage. [SPEAKER_05]: And those local advantages, many of them, are have been outlawed even by the court. [SPEAKER_05]: They'll say, oh, well, this community, we can't let this community do its own ISP because they have an unfair advantage over us because they live there. [SPEAKER_05]: Right, you know, it was a legal case. [SPEAKER_05]: It's just like Jesus with the fuck. [SPEAKER_05]: So yeah, you do that stuff. [SPEAKER_05]: And again, you're not going to get your iPhone based on a trust network with local people, right?

[SPEAKER_05]: It's that's assembled in a global thing. [SPEAKER_05]: So that's what you have the untrusted money for the enforced money, but [SPEAKER_05]: I really think 80% of our transactions and the stuff we do could be within those trusted communities. [SPEAKER_04]: Yeah, that's the kind of stuff mentioned, like focusing on it, the interesting to know what people do in different circumstances. [SPEAKER_04]: Like, I live on a farm, so I grow food, you know, and so I don't have to buy food. [SPEAKER_04]: I mean, I buy some food for avocados, citrus.

[SPEAKER_01]: Don't know. [SPEAKER_04]: Milk. [SPEAKER_04]: Don't know what we're doing. [SPEAKER_04]: It's cold out. [SPEAKER_04]: I put on a jacket. [SPEAKER_04]: But your food is still growing out there in the cold. [SPEAKER_04]: Or you have stuff in a cellar. [SPEAKER_04]: We still have stuff growing. [SPEAKER_04]: We have broccoli growing that cabbage growing. [SPEAKER_01]: We were picking two days ago. [SPEAKER_03]: It was a little really. [SPEAKER_03]: And to be fair, we're not as cold. [SPEAKER_01]: Right. [SPEAKER_01]: Where we are. [SPEAKER_01]: Two feet of snow like you does. [SPEAKER_01]: OK. [SPEAKER_03]: Well, okay. [SPEAKER_03]: So I've been reading this very little known book called Privileged Goods. [SPEAKER_03]: It's written by a guy named Jack Mano.

[SPEAKER_03]: And his whole thesis is, I haven't finished it. [SPEAKER_03]: So I'm sorry, Jack, if I'm getting anything wrong. [SPEAKER_03]: But his thesis seems to be that we Privilege goods that can be commoditized. [SPEAKER_03]: That's kind of jargony. [SPEAKER_03]: So the example would be, [SPEAKER_03]: And it's a children's for kids to have entertainment. [SPEAKER_03]: The goods that get privileged are things like Barbie dolls and action figures that are easily turned into commodities that you buy and that are made in cheap ways.

[SPEAKER_03]: And then there's a, if you step down a level, [SPEAKER_03]: the goods are things like handcrafted dolls that you might buy at the farmers market and you feel like maybe you're getting to that relationship you're talking about a little bit Jason of I know the person who made this thing and then you can step it to another level which is bolder kids just go out and pick up a stick and pretend it's an animal or something and you know you're using their imagination in cahoots with nature so our worldview we would kind of say

[SPEAKER_03]: people to be in that nature and imagination space much more so than in the Barbie space and you know sometimes you go to that midspace and this book is making the point the world is really privileging those highly commoditized goods so how do we how do we undermine that what kind of resistance do we have to that and how do we get to where we value the playing in nature as much as we're [SPEAKER_01]: the breakdown of that global supply chain.

[SPEAKER_01]: I help. [SPEAKER_03]: The place collapse would help. [SPEAKER_04]: I would be great. [SPEAKER_04]: Yeah. [SPEAKER_04]: I mean, yeah, really. [SPEAKER_05]: The collapse does assist that. [SPEAKER_01]: You're done with Trump telling people only to get $2 for their kids. [SPEAKER_01]: That helps. [SPEAKER_05]: When I was little, and it seems like a long time ago to your listeners, but it doesn't seem like that long ago to me. [SPEAKER_05]: When I was little, we did have those toys, those, [SPEAKER_05]: wanted things, GI Joe's, which we generally played with when it was raining out, you know, when we couldn't play.

[SPEAKER_05]: And in real life, if we did our homework, our mom would kick us out of the house and say, don't come back until six o'clock in the dinner. [SPEAKER_07]: Yeah. [SPEAKER_05]: You weren't like allowed to come back. [SPEAKER_05]: No. [SPEAKER_05]: And it was like, so what do you do? [SPEAKER_05]: You know, you look for frogs. [SPEAKER_05]: You find a stick. [SPEAKER_05]: You ride your bike around there. [SPEAKER_05]: What do you do? [SPEAKER_05]: We were kind of delightfully bored wandering around, looking for trouble, breaking things. [SPEAKER_05]: Did you ever start a fire at a vacant lot, I did?

[SPEAKER_05]: Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha [SPEAKER_05]: Yeah, well it's only got out of control. [SPEAKER_05]: The only one ever got out of control from me was behind at 7-11 Oh, that's so good, which was not wise. [SPEAKER_05]: But everyone survived, everyone survived. [SPEAKER_05]: But you know the dumpster at the 7-11, that's a world of it's own. [SPEAKER_05]: Yeah. [SPEAKER_05]: I just sound now, now we're not selling it well, but um, no, it was for the frogs and the sticks and the love and the throw it twig down a stream and follow it like we need the poo.

[SPEAKER_05]: Yeah, I [SPEAKER_05]: don't feel like the highly branded experiences are even that great. [SPEAKER_05]: My daughter did it when she was three, four years old. [SPEAKER_05]: You know, she got bored with that stuff. [SPEAKER_05]: And it was more about, you know, imagination and repurposing, repurposing toys to other things. [SPEAKER_05]: The virtual space is a whole, the amount of screen time that kids want. [SPEAKER_05]: That looks like [SPEAKER_05]: to be the main parent-child thing now. [SPEAKER_05]: It's, at least among my friends, they have these kids and they want another hour on the iPad to get to the next level of some game or to do this other flat dimensionless activity.

[SPEAKER_05]: So are you really asking, how do we cook people, young people, offline and into three-dimensional? [SPEAKER_05]: Three space and it's really tricky when we live in a society that seems to avoid friction at all costs. [SPEAKER_01]: We have word boredom. [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah. [SPEAKER_01]: I mean. [SPEAKER_05]: Well, we have word friction, the friction of reality of the unexpected, who are you going to meet? [SPEAKER_05]: What's going to happen? [SPEAKER_05]: How hard is this? [SPEAKER_05]: You've got to pedal up the hill.

[SPEAKER_05]: You know, the any of these points of friction seem to be things that we've created convenience and de-socialized, de-socialized landscape to avoid that friction. [SPEAKER_05]: And that, to me, the friction is the fun. [SPEAKER_05]: The friction is the potential for everything cool. [SPEAKER_03]: Yeah, you, you can't start a dumpster fire without friction. [SPEAKER_05]: Oh, that's right. [SPEAKER_05]: Yeah, I mean, not, you shouldn't do that. [SPEAKER_05]: It was not a good thing. [SPEAKER_05]: That was a bad thing that happened. [SPEAKER_05]: But I mean, everyone survived, so I'm saying.

[SPEAKER_03]: Yeah, no, I do think there's this dichotomy between, say, [SPEAKER_03]: the randomness of the journey, the unexpected thing happening, and even some danger, right? [SPEAKER_05]: I mean, certain kind of danger, you know, there's different dangers in the other extreme. [SPEAKER_05]: Right? [SPEAKER_05]: There's the danger of suicide, depression, anxiety, social conformity, autoimmune disease, microplastics everywhere.

[SPEAKER_05]: Yeah, there's all that. [SPEAKER_05]: So yeah, it's a matter of balancing danger, not to get to RFK on you, but you know, there is something to be said for letting your kid play in the dirt so they get exposed to the right bacteria that colonize their gut biome and they end up with a good strong gut biome that knows how to eat other things as opposed to sticking a kid in a sterile room with an [SPEAKER_01]: I think to answer your question, Rob, the U.S. earlier, is like, how do we take steps towards what we're talking about here?

[SPEAKER_01]: And it feels to me what you talked about leveling up Douglas, maybe we'll we need to be doing a thing about leveling down, you know, like maybe that is a framework for thinking about the choices that we're making, so we [SPEAKER_01]: We level down from, you know, experiences that literally are on the internet are virtual to human ones. [SPEAKER_01]: We put ourselves back into situations where we're trusting are somatic senses or gut on things. [SPEAKER_01]: we level down the things that we can do and allow ourselves to stay leveled up on things that we just can't replace, you know, like an iPhone.

[SPEAKER_01]: So we're more selective about those things. [SPEAKER_01]: And then the other thing that you said Douglas, which I think we can't, you can't stress enough, which is find the others, you know. [SPEAKER_01]: We're talking about living in crazy town, what it feels like. [SPEAKER_01]: a few weeks ago about how insane it feels that we're just rushing towards this AI future that basically no matter how you slice it is bad news either be successful when we'll lose our jobs or they'll be an AI bubble and we'll lose our jobs or you know it'll become we'll get an AGI situation and they'll kill us it's like there's nothing in there that seems positive

[SPEAKER_05]: will work and we don't have to have jobs if they do all that stuff like you don't have to be a mortgage actuary, you don't have to be a cubicle thing, you don't have to, you know, line up the, the ex house, but some of those things only exist because of capitalism and the complex system that is unsustainable, right? [SPEAKER_01]: Like how many of those things do we actually need? [SPEAKER_05]: We may not need any of them, but then as I'll figure that out, I'm all for the AIs and the robots, telling the fields, adding the numbers and doing, if they could do it, if they could actually do it, but if they could, if they could, and it wouldn't require just other jobs for little children in the Congo, getting the rare earth metals at gunpoint in order to do that,

[SPEAKER_05]: I mean, so far it does not look like labor is being erased, it's just being downscaled. [SPEAKER_05]: The same is the assembly line downscaled, the craft person to an assembly line worker. [SPEAKER_05]: AI seems to be downscaling intellectual people to ditch diggers. [SPEAKER_05]: Which I mean, you can argue that some ditch digging is noble and fine and all that, but not at gunpoint in the Congo, not the people who are lined up in the Philippines in digital sweatshops tagging all this data to make it look like AI has retrieved it, and it's not, it's humans.

[SPEAKER_05]: Humans is around mechanical turk devices so far, but that said, I've had a few engagements with AI that have been useful. [SPEAKER_05]: Sure. [SPEAKER_01]: Do you react to your girlfriend? [SPEAKER_01]: Is this, is it? [SPEAKER_05]: No, no. [SPEAKER_05]: I'm not that. [SPEAKER_05]: I mean, no, for, for research, like, um, doing, uh, research on my daughter, the combination of my daughter's autoimmune conditions, um, doing some meta analysis that specialists that she has in different fields haven't had time to do, um, to look at overlapping relationships

[SPEAKER_05]: You know, it was made some perhaps useless but insightful discoveries about what might be going on in her system. [SPEAKER_05]: That's been useful. [SPEAKER_05]: Sometimes before a particularly knowledgeable or intimidating team human guest, I'll give the interview questions that I have to a cloud agent that I've trained [SPEAKER_05]: And they'll say, you know, these are good, but you don't asking him about this, this and that.

[SPEAKER_05]: And he wrote this other book. [SPEAKER_05]: You haven't even mentioned that really ties more into what your theme is here than what you've done. [SPEAKER_05]: It's found holes for me that I'm and I'm using it in a more intelligent way than most people I think. [SPEAKER_05]: You know, rather than just do my paper for me. [SPEAKER_05]: But as a thinking partner, it's interesting. [SPEAKER_04]: I think you're absolutely right. [SPEAKER_04]: I think this is probably some of the best use cases, things like as long as you don't use it as such a crutch that you no longer able to write it anymore. [SPEAKER_04]: You no longer able to like think critically. [SPEAKER_04]: In other words, people can outsource too much to these tools and use them inappropriately.

[SPEAKER_04]: That's what's dangerous. [SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, I don't know. [SPEAKER_01]: I like the A-slop of B-Videos is Steve Nauking and is what you're racing under NASCAR track. [SPEAKER_01]: I mean, that works for me. [SPEAKER_05]: The other dangerous tendency with AI is to use it to increase your volume of production beyond what you would actually like it to be. [SPEAKER_05]: Like, as someone who does a podcast and to sort of a substacky thing, I feel compelled by the technology and the platforms. [SPEAKER_05]: To produce more than I'm comfortable producing right doing one show a week is really the most I can do while I do my other work and they kind of it seems to you do better if you do like two or three shows You can build audience.

[SPEAKER_01]: You guys do what one a week less, maybe every two weeks and their half is good So I mean our our our batting rate is is great [SPEAKER_01]: But this is an arms race problem because now you're in a competition and so again Oh, I think it's virtuous stop it, but we'll just we'll have our AIs listen to the podcast That all the other people are creating an explain it to us yet [SPEAKER_04]: Yeah, and then we'll train our affetars to do the actual interviews and then we'll just, yeah, we'll just point to the podcast goes away, right?

[SPEAKER_05]: Yeah, which was, did you want to hear be a fly on the wall in a conversation between interesting people? [SPEAKER_01]: But we'll give views from all the AI agents watching that we've hired to take notes for the AI agents to watch your AI agents. [SPEAKER_05]: It's all perfect. [SPEAKER_03]: more time for us to dig ditches. [SPEAKER_04]: But I am very skeptical that in the real world we are going to get agents that are very good. [SPEAKER_04]: I am very skeptical on that kind of stuff. [SPEAKER_04]: When I go and I walk, there's no agents in the real world.

[SPEAKER_04]: Well, that's a saying you have to make robots. [SPEAKER_04]: You have to essentially have a gigantic type of things that are robotic. [SPEAKER_04]: Do you do this stuff you were talking about? [SPEAKER_04]: Like, to replace farm workers or whatever, or to replace girlfriends. [SPEAKER_04]: And then replace girlfriends. [SPEAKER_04]: I don't think it's ever going to be that good. [SPEAKER_04]: I don't think these things are going to have the skin contact, the gut biodiversity that creates emotions. [SPEAKER_05]: I understand that you're thinking that permaculture, style, agriculture may actually require the human hand for the foreseeable future.

[SPEAKER_05]: You know, in terms of turning the soil and planting the seed that are recovery from industrial agriculture will make for a droidless, a droidless future. [SPEAKER_04]: I think that the best thing we can do for the earth is to actually put people back into [SPEAKER_01]: be in relationship with it. [SPEAKER_04]: Ecological relationships. [SPEAKER_04]: And that it's going to be the thing that heels us better. [SPEAKER_04]: Yeah. [SPEAKER_05]: The other thing is the other argument for that that I've made when people say, oh, I don't want to go farm, I don't want to farm.

[SPEAKER_05]: Is like, look at any retired billionaire. [SPEAKER_05]: And what are they doing? [SPEAKER_05]: They have a fucking organic gardener. [SPEAKER_05]: They're doing you handcrafted beer, you know. [SPEAKER_05]: It's like they're doing all the things that we're saying people should start doing again that we get poo pooed for. [SPEAKER_05]: Yeah, are the retirement careers of the ultra wealthy. [SPEAKER_05]: So they're probably four. [SPEAKER_04]: They go to some like a historic estate and tuscany and work for a week, you know, you know, pick olives. [SPEAKER_04]: But the difference is that if you're working on a farm because you need to

[SPEAKER_04]: And you need to, like, your responsible for helping produce food for hundreds of people, like, at least they're, like, solid. [SPEAKER_04]: That sucks. [SPEAKER_04]: If you're working on a farm because you're growing food to yourself, that's not that hard. [SPEAKER_04]: As long as you know, some skilled. [SPEAKER_04]: Right. [SPEAKER_04]: If you're skilled in that as you are with, you know, you're podcasting in your media, I stay in teaching classes. [SPEAKER_04]: If you take your level of skill on that, you apply it to actually, like, I know what I'm doing when I'm on a farm and I'm growing food for myself. [SPEAKER_04]: it's not any more work than a normal human would do.

[SPEAKER_04]: How do you think we got here before the Industrial Revolution? [SPEAKER_04]: Exactly. [SPEAKER_01]: And maybe you don't have to do it all for yourself. [SPEAKER_01]: You could grow some and share it with neighbors and they could grow something different and share it with you. [SPEAKER_01]: And maybe that's a lay for it there.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Jonathan Larsen: Infrastructure Collapse (Preview)

    Nov 20, 202617 minAudio

    🌍 Listen to the full conversation, plus exclusive livestreams, Q&A and more with Douglas Rushkoff: http://patreon.com/rushkoff Jonathan Larsen, editor of The Fucking News, and I engage on the real reasons for multiple...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Nick Plante: Summer of Ludd (Preview)

    Nov 18, 202616 minAudio

    🌍 Listen to the full conversation, plus exclusive livestreams, Q&A and more with Douglas Rushkoff: http://patreon.com/rushkoff Douglas Rushkoff is joined by activist and organiser Nick Plante to explore the rise of a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Sherry Turkle: Conversation (Preview)

    Nov 11, 202614 minAudio

    🌍 Listen to the full conversation, plus exclusive livestreams, Q&A and more with Douglas Rushkoff: http://patreon.com/rushkoff Douglas Rushkoff is joined by MIT professor, psychologist, and author Sherry Turkle for an...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Networks Don’t Throttle. Platforms Do: Zuck, Musk, and the Eugenics of Selective Reduction

    Nov 3, 202615 minAudio

    🌍 Become a Patron to receive ad-free access to videos, exclusive conversations and livestream Q&As with Douglas Rushkoff: http://patreon.com/rushkoff The internet was supposed to be a decentralised network of people...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Setting Team Human Free

    Oct 30, 20267 minAudio

    🌍 Support to receive ad-free access to videos, livestream Q&As with Rushkoff: http://patreon.com/teamhuman I’m retiring the podcast title Team Human, but I’m going to use that channel for my conversations and research...

    Credit the people on this episode