Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

RuralTalk

RuralTalk artwork

Rural Voters Don’t Want Your Data Center

Nov 18, 202633 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Two weeks after the election, I’ve been watching more cable news than I have in two years. Mostly it has reminded me how much of the conversation is stuck in an old paradigm. But something new is happening. This election cycle seems very different. Republicans poured money into anti-trans ads this cycle, and a lot of people inside their own party don’t think it moved anything. Elon Musk spent half a billion dollars and had little to show for it. New political fault lines are emerging. Data centers are one of the clearest examples. For most Americans, data centers have become the symbol of the American economy where a few billionaires get rich while the rest of America absorbs the costs. On this week’s Rural Weekly Live, John Ray of YouGov Blue walked through new Rural Progress polling that digs into rural voters’ attitudes toward data centers. Here is what we found. Who we talked to The survey covered rural voters in about 16 battleground states, the places that will decide control of Congress and the White House in 2026 and 2028. Think rural Texas, North Carolina, Ohio, Kansas, New Hampshire and Arizona. It was in the field a few days before and a few days after the election. AI is a top issue for a real share of rural voters About one in five rural voters say AI is their top issue or one of them. Among rural Democrats, it’s one in four. Corruption and inflation still rank a little higher. But AI touches nearly everything else on the list, from jobs to health care costs to what our kids will face. A lot of the worry comes from parents. They think AI will take jobs away from their kids and make social media addiction even worse. Most rural voters don’t want a data center in their community About 70% of rural voters say they would oppose a data center in their community. Among rural Democrats, it’s 80 to 90%. A narrow majority supports a ban on new data centers altogether. A majority says AI regulation has not gone far enough. The tech-bro position, deregulate and let the chips fall where they may, has the support of barely 10% of rural America. Cash payments move some voters, but not many We also ran a message test. Half of respondents were asked whether they would support or oppose a data center in their community. The other half were asked the same question with one addition: the company would pay their community a lump sum. The payment moved support by 5 to 10 points, driven mostly by independents. That’s a statistically significant shift. It’s also not much. In both versions, a clear majority stayed opposed. A jobs guarantee is popular, even with the price tag attached One of the strongest results was support for a jobs guarantee for workers who lose their jobs to AI. We were explicit in the question: this would mean more federal spending, new federal regulations, and the government helping people find work. Those details usually turn voters off. Not this time. The idea was popular with rural voters overall, with independents, with Democrats, and with people who stayed home in 2024. Republicans were net favorable too. That doesn’t surprise me. Fifteen years ago we told coal miners to learn to code. Now the coders are losing their jobs. Rural communities have a long memory of losing out in technological transitions. People know there will be winners and losers, and right now it looks like Elon Musk wins and everyone else loses. Neither party owns this issue Asked which party they trust to handle AI’s impact on jobs and society, rural voters split. About four in ten didn’t pick either party. This is a rural battleground sample that leans Republican, so that is an opening. Voters are anxious, and they are open to whoever shows up with a credible plan. Rural people are using AI About 40% of rural voters use an AI product like ChatGPT at least weekly. About a quarter use one daily or more. So the answer can’t be “AI is bad, don’t use it.” That message won’t land with most rural voters. Democrats need serious policy commitments that make the future more fair, not just opposition to the technology. The bill moving right now Polling like this matters because Congress is acting this month. BAAJA (S. 5653), the Senate permitting bill with data center provisions, is moving fast with backing from big tech and the oil industry. The policy in that bill reflects the politics of this past February and March. That was before Haley Stevens lost her primary in Michigan, where AI was a big part of the story. It was before Texas Republicans were wiped out in a historic landslide, driven in part by frustration with Elon Musk. The politics have shifted all summer and fall, and the next Congress is far better prepared for them than this one. Rural voters have made themselves clear. Now it’s our turn to make sure the Senate hears them. This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit ruralorganizing.substack.com

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01We'll go ahead and get started. I think we're live here. I'm Matt. I'm here with John Ray. Joe's not here with us today because he is on some other fancy show talking to fancy people but John and I will keep things flowing here for our conversation. I'm really excited to talk today. A little bit more about all that's happening on the data center front.

SPEAKER_01So We're going to dig into that a little bit. Before we get into that, John, how's it going?

SPEAKER_00It's going good. We're now in that period between the election being on and the post-election being on, so obviously everybody's trying to figure out what happened, how happy are we allowed to be as a party? We're so rarely Really allow ourselves more than a few days of excitement, but it's still a very exciting time. How's it going over there?

SPEAKER_01I'm in this kind of the same boat. I was talking to Ethan before we went live that it's like when you do this work, you have a real high coming off of the election and especially when things go well. And then it's like, wait, what did I do before election season? And then you have to Remember like, oh yeah, there's all these emails I haven't responded to and all these things we said we would do back in March. And then it just all gets kind of sideswiped by election activity. But now that we've had a couple weeks to process what happened this cycle,

SPEAKER_01where are you at on this? Because I would like to talk about how big this actually was for Democrats. Because for me, I'm hearing a lot of different takes and I'm interested in how you understand politics. Just how big this election was.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. So I've been going into this increasingly feeling like, unlike a lot of people, I think there's been from some, there's been this anxiety like, okay, Democrats hit this new high watermark among, you know, we, we won all this ground among, you know, rural voters and independents and this group and that group. And, you know, the, the Latino vote did great, but OG, you know, we need to really prepare for kind of, um, You know, the water to come out of the moat. I think there's been a lot of anxiety about that.

SPEAKER_00Frankly, what I'm seeing in the polling is that right now, Democrats actually have a lot of huge opportunities that I think they can capitalize on as long as they take the job seriously. Two reasons for that. One, in the polling, the issues that people care about, we're going to talk about some of them in just a few minutes. Democrats still have a pretty strong hand on those. So last week, we talked about How important corruption as an issue is to a lot of voters. We talked about how kind of the depravity and the incompetence of the Trump administration, first and foremost, in many voters' minds.

SPEAKER_00We have no evidence that that ship is going to ride itself anytime soon. Imagine losing this election as badly as Donald Trump did, and your first instinct is to hire Stephen Miller. To me, it feels like Republicans are going to keep fucking this stuff up, to use the technical term. They really do not show any apparent ability. Behind the scenes, I'm sure there have been some serious arguments about this, but at least what voters are seeing so far is not painting a rosy picture. Second, even as we prepare to transition to a government where Democrats control

SPEAKER_00the House and the Senate, the wheels are continuing to come off of the economy that Trump claimed would be his entire responsibility as president just over the past few days. Apologies in advance to any of our listeners who may have tried to be on a plane in the past three days. You may still be at the airport. Your luggage may still be at the airport. Maybe you tried to check your Bank of America account yesterday on payday and were not able to do so. Maybe today you own an Apple product and are getting all these warnings about how

SPEAKER_00the shop just doesn't work at the moment for many, many users. A lot of this ties back to At least from what we're hearing so far, the kind of unfettered, unregulated approach to, you know, AI adoption, letting, you know, the sort of AI czars kind of run our economy right now, not paying dividends in a very, very real way for the American voter. So people, not only have they punished Trump for his stupidity and his incompetence, but Trump looks at those results and he doubles down on stupidity and incompetence.

SPEAKER_00And I think that gives Democrats a lot to work with Even when they don't have the presidency, but Matt, I'm curious for how you're feeling as well.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I'm in a similar place. I mean, for me, I've been watching a lot more cable news the last couple of weeks than I have at all over the last couple of years. I mean, I literally... I watched MS Now. I missed the whole rebrand because I stopped watching cable news after I worked at the presidential campaign for Vice President Harris. I came out of that campaign and I was like, I'm never watching cable news again.

SPEAKER_01And really kind of maintained that course until really election night this year. This this last year, so just this November. But we renewed our YouTube TV subscription and we have a couple more weeks before like the free trial goes away. So we have it. And I just. I just forgot how much so much of the media is stuck in an old paradigm. And there's a lot of conversation right now about, you know,

SPEAKER_01the future of the Democratic Party that's really stuck in an old paradigm. And I just am not sure that we're going to be able to understand politics, especially from like 2027 forward with an old paradigm. So many people are focused on the left-right paradigm around things like trans issues versus religious conservatism issues.

SPEAKER_01And the fact that so much money was spent on the anti-trans ads and so many people within the Republican Party don't feel like they really had an effect. It is really interesting to me. And I don't think the media has caught up with that. I also don't know that we fully understand what it means for Elon Musk to have spent half a billion dollars and have had no impact on the elections. And, you know, old paradigm was like billionaire money makes everything happen.

SPEAKER_01And obviously, Democrats spend a ton of money, too. And that cancels out a lot of the Elon Musk money. But really. Something else is happening beyond just money and politics. You know, so it's been hard to understand the moment. And I just have been really disappointed with the lack of like rigor that's happening right now. And, you know, one example I'll give is like. I went back and looked and there was 206 counties that voted for Obama twice and then for Donald Trump in 2016. Democrats this cycle only won about a third back.

SPEAKER_01And so, you know, that's a really huge improvement, you know, compared to like where the backslide had been. But- There's still a lot of people out there that that and I think probably every single one of those counties improved compared to 2024. So the margins were getting cut. But in terms of what actually flipped back, like it's not as as. It's not as big in some places as you might expect. So I do think the country is going to continue to be divided, although it's not going to be Trump versus everyone else as it has been.

SPEAKER_01And so I think there's a huge chunk of the United States right now waiting to see who picks up the mantle, whether it's Tucker Carlson or Theo Vaughn or Joe Rogan or whoever. And I just don't know who that is. But anyway, so that's that's I'm going to be really interested to see what happens with those types of conversations moving forward. And and, you know, obviously, young people swung back really, really hard for Democrats, communities of color. I mean, I think that's like the big story coming out of this cycle is folks

SPEAKER_01in the cities and the suburbs, especially communities of color, you know, were really mobilized this cycle. And I think rural margins were definitely cut. But I think it has a lot more to do with deeper issues that we haven't really talked about. I mean, costs, obviously, was a huge part of this. But how do you separate costs out from Iran versus sort of the America First narrative that's been out there for the last 10 years now and what's happening with Israel and costs?

SPEAKER_01I mean, it Everything is kind of the same thing, which is just shit's fucked right now. And that's just the bottom line. And then what happens next? I don't think we've defined it. So last thing I'll say is people like Shane Gillis, who is pretty right-wing coded, has gotten kicked off. He's a comedian that's gotten kicked off of SNL every time he goes on or has some big scandal. Was posting videos talking about the need for Medicare for All. And I just don't think we have... Uh, you know, uh, context for what it means.

SPEAKER_01Like when those, like those people don't really hit left, right paradigms in a traditional sense. And I think we're struggling to understand the moment. So that's where I'm at. Uh, but that's why I like talking to you because I think pollsters, you know, you can kind of see what's actually moving and what's not moving and where, you know, where there's cracks and where things have been overstated. So, um, on that note, I do want to talk a little bit. Sorry, my dog just showed up. I have to take her collar off because it's so loud if she wants pets right now. So on that note, I think data centers is probably one of the best examples

SPEAKER_01of like new, I'll say political symbols in the United States. Because I'm not sure how much of it is actually about data centers as, you know, a server farm that's down the street from your house versus sort of capital D, capital C data centers. And I want I wanted you to help us understand what's happening right now in politics because we have a bill that's moving in the Senate, at least for right now, that I think is very old paradigm. And I think it's going to be interesting to watch how the politics play out

SPEAKER_01between kind of how things used to be in the Trump days and how things are going to be moving forward as people are starting to realize, hey, you know, Trump's really in the last part of his career.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think that's sort of a great way to frame kind of your initial comments about how is politics going to actually be suited for kind of this new paradigm that we're in? And so I think talking specifically about the AI issue, that I think really is kind of one of the biggest challenges for politicians right now because the sort of rollout of this new technology suggests that we really are potentially headed into like a very different world than the one that many politicians You know, grew up in and kind of prepared to lead.

SPEAKER_00It's an issue where I'm going to pull up some data in just a second showing that people have great reservations about, but also are feeling it kind of seep into their lives in different ways. And I think the way that you put it just now, this question about the data center in your neighborhood versus kind of the symbol of the data center, I think gives us kind of a peek into the more expansive approach to politics that we're going to need to take in the future. So let's do this. I'm going to pull up some results from a recent survey that we ran with Rural Progress.

SPEAKER_00So again, we discussed this a little bit last week, but what I'm going to pull up, we're going to look at some results that are specifically for rural voters in kind of the battleground states. And folks who listen to the show broadly know what I'm talking about. We're talking about the states that were or will be decisive in 2026 or 2028. So you're thinking the rural voters in Texas, North Carolina, Ohio, Kansas,

SPEAKER_00really across the country. There's a lot in New Hampshire, Arizona. There's a lot of states in this sample. It's fully about 16 states. And rural progress, as we're digging our way through this data, obviously, we'll make these results available Interested parties and all that good stuff. But so I want to pull up some data, but what you're going to be thinking about when you're looking at it is these are the attitudes of rural voters in the most electorally consequential states For 2028 and for 2026. And I'm going to specifically focus on some of the findings we have around

SPEAKER_00the questions of AI and data centers. And I think our data is really interesting because I think it suggests from a lot of directions that these actually are two things that politicians have to tackle. There is actually a separate data center question and a separate artificial intelligence question, both of which feed exactly as you were saying that into those kind of Broader concerns about shit being fucked right now in the kind of the general sense to concerns about kind of the overall economy to corruption

SPEAKER_00in our political system. So I'm going to go ahead and I'll pull those up and I'll walk us through some of the highlights here. So doing the thing. So what we're going to look through are going to be some results that, again, focusing on rural voters. And again, this was in the field right around the election time. So this is all pretty hot off of the presses. So again, just to be clear, we asked rural voters about kind of some of their top issues in the country and AI is one of the top concerns

SPEAKER_00for pretty significant shares of rural voters. Now, of course, in questions that pollsters ask that include things like this, This is, you know, AI was kind of alongside issues like, you know, inflation, the availability of jobs, healthcare costs, education costs, things that AI also touches. So there's going to be a lot of spillover on those issues. This is a bit of a noisy measure, but what this is showing us is that, you know, across, you know, our rural voters and kind of voters overall, you know, fully about one in five, one in four are telling us that AI is kind

SPEAKER_00of their top issue or one of their top issues. For context, Things like corruption and inflation will be a little bit ahead of that, but AI is certainly at the top of people's minds for a significant share of the rural population. Some of those results, I'm going to break these out by some of the key groups where we find some particularly interesting results on some of our key questions here. What this shows us is the set of policies that we asked rural voters about concerning AI.

SPEAKER_00So this is a fairly expansive set of questions. The top row here is asking people, what percent of our rural voters just oppose having a data center in their community? And as you can see, just generally speaking, right off the bat, It's pretty high. What this first bar shows us is about 70% of rural voters say that they would oppose having Data Center in their community. That number rises to around 80 to 90% for rural area Democrats.

SPEAKER_00I also included parents on this chart. This will make some sense towards the end when we look at how AI usage differs across generation. But a lot of the reason why we're finding in our data that rural voters are worried about AI It's because they think it's going to take jobs away from their kids and it's going to make sort of social media addiction even more virulent among young people. So I also included data on how parents feel about this stuff as well. I think that gives us some important context.

SPEAKER_00Similarly, right below that, a narrow majority of our rural voters overall support a ban on new data centers and also support Having a jobs guarantee such that if AI takes your job, somebody's going to help you find a job. I think this third row in particular is really important because this is actually a policy domain that both Democrats and Republicans are really thinking about hard. And I think both parties are going to have a pitch on this in some form in 2028,

SPEAKER_00something that we need to keep our eyes on. Finally, again, fairly similar to the other results, majorities of people feel that AI regulation overall has not gone far enough. But on the other hand, we're going to look at some different data here that gives us some idea of what are the big companies going to be doing about this state of affairs. So on our previous slide, we see Most people oppose data center construction, okay? So with this information in mind later in the survey,

SPEAKER_00we tried out something that's called a message test. And the idea of a message test is pretty simple. We ask half of the people in the survey one version of the question. We ask the other half a different version of the question. And we compare the differences to get an idea of, okay, what if the argument for data centers was different from what it currently is? So basically the way that this worked Half of our voters were just asked, do you support or oppose a data center in your community? Just that question by itself. The other half were asked,

SPEAKER_00do you support or oppose a data center in your community if the data center provider provides you a lump sum payment? So basically half of our voters were asked, should there be a data center in your community? Half of our voters were asked, should there be a data center in our community? If the company that builds it pays your community for it being there, okay? So this slide breaks out the differences Across the two versions of that question. And it's like, you know, I'm not sure we don't sort of squint on the results here,

SPEAKER_00but generally speaking, what we're finding is that if these companies offer a lump sum payment, that's these blue segments of these charts over here on the right hand side. What this shows us is that if you compare the overall rural sample That receives the lump sum payment versus the share that doesn't. It does actually move a statistically significant share of the population in favor of data centers. The difference isn't huge. You can see it's about 5 to 10 percentage points driven by independent voters

SPEAKER_00who would have lower allegiance to the subject either way. So not a huge difference, but it is possible to move people on the question of data centers. Again, just to be super clear, in both of these, Versions of the questions you can see from the giant red bars on the right hand side, people remain squarely opposed to new data centers, but a significant chunk of them are actually movable if these AI companies promise, you know, a buyout or a bailout or a payout in some fashion.

SPEAKER_00And I think that's what we should expect them to be doing going forward. So something for us to be aware of is that this issue is actually, you know, it's clearly leaning one way, but it is not settled, is going to remain a top priority for voters in the future here, okay? I'm going to jump through this quickly to make sure we focus on the highlights here. I want to drill down a little bit on one of the questions that we included in the survey that asked about support for a jobs guarantee for workers displaced

SPEAKER_00by AI. The wording of the question was pretty explicit that what this would require All the bells and whistles. We were quite explicit that if you were gonna have this sort of jobs program, that would require spending more money, that would require new federal regulations, that would require the government getting involved in helping people find jobs. Things that typically turn off Large shares of voters in this particular case really did not. So what this chart shows us is that among our rural sample overall,

SPEAKER_00among our independents, our Democrats, and those who stayed home in 2026, excuse me, in 2024, we see that this is actually quite popular. And I don't have Republicans on this chart, but they are actually also kind of net favorable towards this idea. This is important because It reminds us that people are, you know, have such anxiety about kind of the AI future that it actually cuts across the expectations that observers and commenters and pundits,

SPEAKER_00yada yada might have about what they think rural voters want. Often in this work that, you know, I know that Matt deals with every day, that Rural Progress deals with, is this stereotype that like rural equals this sort of kind of, you know, bizarrely kind of ideologically right wing sort of, you know, capitalistic, obsessed Republican. That does not bear out in what we know rural voters actually tell us when we ask them about stuff like this. There's clearly an appetite for new policies that will help people Kind of mitigate

SPEAKER_00the uncertainty that AI has created in their lives that, okay, if your economic life is going to be disrupted, they're actually quite supportive of the government stepping in to provide help for their communities. And again, just to be explicit, I want to keep us moving here. Majority is that, you know, that majority that supports this kind of government intervention also extends to saying that, you know, AI regulation has not gone far enough.

SPEAKER_00The notion of this kind of like, you know, AI kind of tech bro person who, you know, really wants us to sort of deregulate this industry, let the technology kind of be the technology, let the chips fall where they may statistically is a really, really small share of the population. It's barely 10% of rural America. A much, much larger share of voters say, hey, we need to make sure that we're actually regulating this thing, this thing properly.

SPEAKER_01I'm going to pull up one more slide,

SPEAKER_00two more quickly. So just quickly, this again, to sort of put a fun point on it, this is an issue where voters are not actually sure which party they trust on the subject of AI. This is particularly important because this is rural voters in battleground states. So this is a... A fairly Republican sample, but if we look at our rural voters overall, if you're asking them, who do you actually trust on the question of responding to the impact of AI on jobs and society,

SPEAKER_00they're actually pretty split with about 40% saying, Some version of neither party really has this on block. So this is an issue where both parties are facing voters with severe anxieties and also severe, I think, kind of openness to understanding that whatever this technology is, I'm going to be receptive to whoever actually has kind of a credible plan for what to do about it. Okay. So one last thing that I think is relevant for us here is that What this last chart shows us is

SPEAKER_00how many rural voters are actually using artificial intelligence in some form. So what this shows us, what sort of the blue shading shows us, Is on the sort of left hand side here are the most heavy AI users in rural America. And what you can see just sort of squinting at it here is that fully about 40% of rural voters say that they use an AI product, you know, such as ChatGPT on at least a weekly basis.

SPEAKER_00With about a quarter saying, you know, multiple times a day or about once a day. So pretty heavy AI usage. I think that's an important thing for us to sort of end these remarks on because it reminds us, yes, people have all of these concerns, but this is going to be like a part of their lives. Neither party can actually just have this answer that says, hey, AI sucks, don't use it. That answer is going to fall on deaf ears to the majority Not just a sort of America overall, but even in rural America,

SPEAKER_00in these rural kind of battleground areas where this technology is seeping into people's lives. These numbers actually represent, I can say over the past few years, the share of voters who are in that using AI sort of column has grown fairly substantially over the past couple of years and will continue to do so. So that means that the party's answer to this technology can't just be, it sucks, don't use it. We hate it. Don't let anybody have access to it. It's going to actually have to be a little bit more, I think,

SPEAKER_00kind of serious and in-depth than that. So two things for us to square, widespread suspicion and concern about AI. AI very clearly involved in a lot of people's lives, generally speaking, which I think is going to be one of the big political challenges for this cycle. That was a lot of me talking, so Matt, I think I better let you weigh in there.

SPEAKER_01No, I appreciate the analysis because I think this is super timely right now on multiple fronts. One, we have this piece of legislation that's moving through the Senate very, very quickly. I mean, it's crazy how fast things can move. When you know, um, big, big backers like Big Tech and the oil industry behind it. And part of the reason I'm so concerned about the piece of legislation is that just from a political standpoint, I think the politics are shifting on AI in data centers on a daily basis.

SPEAKER_01And I think a lot of the policy That people are looking at right now was based on politics in February and March. These are the politics before Haley Stevens lost, largely due to AI, before the Texas Republicans were wiped out in a historic landslide. I think a lot of that had to do with AI and just frustration with Elon Musk. One of the biggest things when I'm talking to rural folks about AI, it's not just the technology or the server farms or whatever we call them now, but it's just how uncomfortable they With people like Elon Musk and the big,

SPEAKER_01you know, big tech billionaires soon to be trillionaires gaining all the money while everybody else is losing work. So I'm not that surprised to see how popular a jobs guarantee for those who lost work through the AI transition is. I think we've seen that in other situations. You know, there was this idea back 10, 15, 20 years ago that we were going to teach all these coal miners that were losing their coal mining jobs to code. Well now all the coders are losing their jobs and so I think there's just

SPEAKER_01a long history in rural America of communities losing out to technological transitions and I think That's What people are responding to when I talk to them. They know there's going to be winners. They know there's going to be losers. And right now it looks like Elon Musk is going to be a pretty big winner and everybody else is going to be a loser. So the fact that the politics have shifted so much over the summer and into the fall and that this next new Congress, I think, is a lot more prepared for the new politics of AI and data centers.

SPEAKER_01And this last Congress was pretty unprepared. So it feels like they're trying to move this bill through as fast as they can because they don't want to have to take it through the next Congress. And I think that's something we need to be paying attention to. That's why we're driving calls into Congress right now about this piece of legislation. So I'm not super surprised by the results, but I think that they're absolutely important. And I do think it's important going back. One of the things that hit me was how little the cash actually moved the You know, there's a lot of conversations about community benefits agreements.

SPEAKER_01I've been a part of negotiating some community benefits agreements on other, you know, technology things with, you know, wind and solar and stuff. They're absolutely critical for small towns and rural communities. But if you look at what's actually moving voters, in this case with AI, it's just outside of, you know, it is bigger than the margin of error, but it's not as big as, you know, Responding to the big changes that are happening with jobs guarantees and stuff like that.

SPEAKER_00So any other things that stick out to you, John? I mean, I think it's back to the first thing you were saying is this notion that what we're talking about here is this widely shared, widely held anxiety about the future. This technology is coming. It appears to be driven by people who have Values that are widely at odds with those of a normal person. And I think that just plays into the fact that this is all part of a larger story

SPEAKER_00that I think Democrats need to concern themselves with about how corruption poisons everything, about how the incompetence of this administration poisons everything. But at the same time, their answer to this can't just be, we got to kill the tech. Most people would not find that plausible. So I think what Democrats need to be thinking about Is there way their way through that where we think about this and make actual kind of credible and serious policy commitments that make the world of the future more equitable

SPEAKER_00and less like the world that Trump has made?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's an amazing moment in human history. I can't think of any. Moment in my lifetime where you've, I mean, maybe nuclear bombs have had this much of a impact on society. But even like when you go back to the early days of the Internet, which I can remember, I don't feel like, you know, there was a few people that were like scared about it. And there was, you know, nightly news coverage every time somebody stalks somebody online. And, you know, oh, our kids are being, you know, targeted by, you know,

SPEAKER_01Crazy people online or older people are being scammed online. But it wasn't this large of a transitional moment. And I think back to Y2K and how everybody was sort of freaking out about Y2K is going to shut down our entire system and like what Y2K was going to do? It's like going to make airplanes not be able to fly, which I guess we just saw this last week. So, I mean, there is just it just and then we just move on from it, you know, like it's just like we're seeing these massive moments happen.

SPEAKER_01And I think because we live in a post -COVID world, we're just used to crazy things happening and us being like, well, I guess that's the world now. I guess we just ground every plane in the United States. And then the next day, the banking system collapses. And I just saw something today that one of the super secret communications infrastructures just collapsed. I just don't feel like we've ever lived through something like this in such a punctuated time. And that's why I think the politics of this are going to be really a defining issue.

SPEAKER_01For the next couple of years at least. And I'm really nervous because I think a lot of Democrats are frankly on the wrong side of this because they were taking their guidance from the people who were making money off of the transition and not really paying attention to the voters and what the voters feel about it. And I feel like that lurch that we saw in the Democratic primaries, especially in Michigan this last year, but we saw it in so many other places. I think that's going to be happening for a while now. Well, any last thoughts? I know we went a little bit over today,

SPEAKER_01but anytime we have this polling data to go through, I get excited.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, so as we've been saying, this polling that I talked about today is part of a larger project. I think there's still so much more that we have to unpack here. We've been talking through kind of what this data means for the Democratic Party's future strategy, kind of the prospects as 2028 approaches. I think we should unpack in more detail. But in the meantime, We have a lot more to go through. There's a lot of survey here, Matt.

SPEAKER_01There's a lot of data. We'll be unpacking it as we move forward. But I think that's it for now. I don't think we're going to be doing this next week, right? Next week is Thanksgiving. I think I'm going to be out of the office. So we'll probably pick this up first week of December. And thanks for tuning in.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Rural voters sent Congress an anti-corruption mandate

    Nov 10, 202631 minAudio

    We’re still working through all of the polling results we’ve seen this cycle. And on this episode of Rural Weekly Live, I sat down again with Joe Sudbay and John Ray of YouGov Blue to walk through more results from the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Democrats’ 2026 Rural Performance Matched Pre-Trump Levels and Our Election Week Poll Tells Us Why

    Nov 5, 202631 minAudio

    There’s no doubt about it, rural voters moved toward Democrats this cycle. They moved because Democrats ran on what rural voters care about: costs, chaos, and corruption. And Republicans did not. On a special episode of...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. "Republicans appear to be struggling with white rural voters this cycle, and Maine is no exception”

    Oct 27, 202629 minAudio

    My internet went out an hour before this week’s Rural Weekly Live, so I hosted from my truck in a coffee shop parking lot. With the election one week away, Joe Sudbay, John Ray, and I weren’t going to skip this episode....

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Rural Weekly Live: The Trump Moment Is Over in Iowa

    Oct 20, 202629 minAudio

    I called into this week’s Rural Weekly Live from a parking lot in Ames, Iowa. We have spent the last few days handing out “Vote November 3rd. Our Healthcare Depends On It” yard signs across Iowa, the last phase of the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Three Weeks Out, Republicans Are Acting Like They’re Losing

    Oct 13, 202629 minAudio

    Joe Sudbay and John Ray joined me again for this episode of Rural Weekly Live. We’re three weeks from election day, and the clearest signal right now about the state of critical battleground races isn’t just the polling...

    Credit the people on this episode