In this episode of RPG Blokes, we explore the various traits and behaviors of 'bad DMs' that can negatively influence the tabletop role-playing experience. We define archetypes such as the "Tyrant DM," who stifles player agency; the "Storyteller DM," who enforces a rigid narrative; and the "Rules Lawyer DM," whose strict adherence to rules disrupts the game's flow. We also tackle the "Fudger," who alters dice rolls, and the "Killer DM," who presents relentless challenges that diminish enjoyment. The conversation further examines the "Monty Hall DM," "Absent Prepper," and the "Perpetual Side Quest Giver," underscoring the need for balance between structure and player freedom. As we reflect on our experiences, we emphasize the importance of learning and adapting to create enjoyable sessions, culminating in a lighthearted segment sharing memorable session quotes. Support the show Sign up to RPG Blokes Actual Play and gain access to all our adventures. Check us out on our official Website. https://www.rpgblokes.com Join Our Discord Community and continue the conversation with us. https://discord.gg/JyVcd8PNHn
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
MarkWelcome to RPG Blokes, the podcast that proves you don't need to be Matt Mercer to sit behind the screen. Today we're tackling the dreaded bad DMs. Yes, the railroadin' tyrants, the rules-obsessed overlords, or the ones that think their campaign is a 200-page novel that they're reading out loud. If you've ever sat at a table and thought, this could be great, if only the DM wasn't sabotaging their own game, then this episode is for you.
Markintroducing the rpg blokes i'm your host mark and to my left is barry the eternal player he's never dm'd never will and honestly that's fine because every table needs a barry The one who keeps the rules straight, keeps the in-game pints flowing, and triggers the occasional TPK.
BarryGuilty as charged.
MarkTo my right is Stephen, the gardener in the group. He cultivates campaigns, carefully pruning away nonsense, watering down the plot when it gets dry, and pulls up players like weeds when they call him out for his loaded dice.
StephenNever had any.
MarkJohn, opposite me, is still traumatised from my Ravenloft campaign 30 years ago He's always believed he was the victim of bad DMing, No. How many times do I have to say I'm not paying for a therapist?
JonI'm not going to see one of them guys again. Jeez.
MarkRight, so bad DMs. So I've got a lot of categories of bad DMs here.
JonHave I got a bingo card to fill out? Because I'm pretty sure I'm going to.
MarkSo all of us, because we've DMed for so long, are probably guilty of the whole lot of these. It's true. But would we describe ourselves as having any of these traits inherently and kind of consistently? Well, we could probably tell each other now if that's the case. And Barry, well, it's. open season for you mate i mean you've got nothing to lose have you apart from us dm into you ever again in the future i suppose oh no oh to show you starting straight off right we'll um was it the tyrant dm is the first one that i'm gonna ask us to talk about that's the tape that's the dm that runs the table like a dictator so no player agency only obedience those kind of dms, exist because they're quite insecure or maybe they're just less experienced than perhaps others that might allow the game to flow a little bit more they can get quite worked up when things don't go the way that they expect them to go i mean we've all had those feelings as a dm especially when i was younger i did have those feelings where you know you start to sweat and, think oh shit this is not the way it's meant to go and this player these players are trying to stitch me up here and i think it's quite easy to kind of take offense of that and and get upset at it happening it's quite i don't know particularly when you're younger in.
JonFairness you get a ref like that they'll last for what two three sessions the only reason that's going to continue is if there's no one else that wants to ref in which case that's on them.
MarkSomebody you've.
JonGot to adapt change i mean it's like a gateway, heading into other types of bad reffing but it's not going to work long term.
MarkI know the feeling yeah it's uh it's a terrible feeling to have as a dm if you're you're in that position and if that's your approach in the first place then you're asking for it.
StephenI think it's a trait of an inexperienced dm i think that one the tyrant dm i think yeah because you want everything to go exactly how you planned it before you came along to the session and i think john's right it is a learning curve. I think all these traits, I think the worst DM would be the one that did not learn and then just stuck to it throughout. And then, yeah, as I say, I don't think there'll be a DM for very long. Sort of fraud games. Everyone seems on the edge. Nobody really enjoys it. So either the DM sort of shifts the way he does it or, yeah, it'll finish.
MarkBarry, as a player that likes to kind of do quite unpredictable things in the game, you would be a nightmare for a tyrant DM. I mean, have you ever had that happen? A DM kind of say, what the fuck are you doing like i.
BarryMean honestly only you, and even when you were doing that it was it was in jest i think you know i've been very lucky that all of my role-playing experience has been in our club and we do have a you know a pretty decent crop of dms from so you know i'm not saying that they're all as good as each other and i'm not saying and it's the other thing i think john you know it was a really good point that yeah no one starts out being brilliant at stuff like do you know i mean it's like it's it's it's the it's the people that that that don't learn from those things and don't move on and change but no i apart from you mucking about i haven't experienced that.
MarkRemind me of that one.
BarryIt was uh it must have been too it must i mean we were talking about it before we started recording but it must have been tomb of annihilation i did go completely fucking gung-ho like once i had my first my first character i think was called seth, he lasted like two sessions dragonborn wizard and but.
MarkForgotten all about so.
BarryNo no yeah yeah and i just decided that do you know what i wonder how many characters i can get through the campaign, and that i do have a i do feel a burden of responsibility to some extent because it did kind of set the tone for the rest of the campaign once i decided do you know what i'm not going to get attached to any of these guys i'm just kind of playing as as as i remember.
MarkThat clearly now because we you went out in the garden didn't you had a bit of a smoke and i and i remember you coming back and say that one hit me i quite like seth he was my he was my go-to he was going to be my next he was a what was he uh.
BarryHe was he was a dragon dragonborn wizard first time i played a wizard first time i'd played a dragonborn and was that your first time i had and i know it's the kiss of death but um i had a miniature and the i got i got paint monkeys to paint that miniature, magnificently for me looked absolutely wicked and I think it was literally the week that I turned up with the miniature yeah so we were probably three weeks in we probably did session zero then I turned up with a miniature that.
MarkIs the most dangerous session for a character the first one you bring a miniature along to.
BarryAnd then I had a monk I think three sessions I didn't get a miniature for her I didn't realize.
MarkIt had such a profound effect on you and it wasn't because.
BarryI was being a tyrant it's.
MarkJust that is a meat grinder of a campaign and yeah you were.
BarryGonna get killed a lot in that it's.
StephenAlways old school.
BarryThat's what it is i got i got killed more times than he's healthy but but again and it's like and i say this to people like people get really hung up about character death and i'm like i mean i love this game and i really really enjoy it but the brilliant thing about character death is you get to roll up another one.
StephenCharacter death if it's unfair may come under the tyrant.
BarryYeah yeah it needs.
MarkTo be aware of that doesn't it and kind to back off from something that that does appear to be unfair.
BarryYeah if.
StephenIt's unfair you just if you've got a minute just bring back his twin brother.
BarryAnd exactly the same pretty much just like junior i've come to a bit yeah and the entire dm looks yeah all right and also i would no but i would say as well if you see a dm go out of their way to make sure a character survives i feel as badly about that as i do about them dying because that's that character's overly kind dm that's that character's story yeah so we move on that's.
MarkA great start but the next one i've got here is the storyteller dm he won't let go he's written his scenario he's written it like a novel and this is the way it's going to happen whether you guys like it or not so he's he's literally, wants this idea he has to play out word for word i know some of these dms can be excellent actually if you were to just go go with that and you kind of know what you're getting yourself into and you're prepared to play that sort of game they can be great, But a lot of people don't get on with those particularly well.
StephenIt sounds quite similar to the Tyrant DM, I suppose, isn't it? It's going to be my way or no way. But I think maybe DMs like that come into the hobby in a different, maybe they've read a lot of books. Maybe they're thinking, you know, maybe Lord of the Rings, maybe they think it has to be a very structured kind of scenario. I think they've got the best intentions there. I think if they can just release the reins slightly, become less tyrannical with it.
BarrySo I have a question for you guys as DMs. And it's like, I know that people do like homebrew, but also people work from pre-written modules. So, I mean, can the storyteller DM ruin a pre-written module by sticking to it that rigidly? Or is it exclusively if they...
StephenI think they go for the homebrew. I think you find most of these are...
MarkYeah, they're less likely to do pre-written. And I think it's more forgivable if they do it with their own material.
BarrySo we played at Dragon Warriors, and I was chatting to the DM after that had come to an end. and it was the whole thing was a plot to an old black and white U-boat movie. And I was just like, that's brilliant.
MarkThat's the game I think about when I think about this type of DM. He really had put a lot of effort into the story. He thought about it and the complexities of it and it was his intention to tell that story. And there weren't many places where you could deviate. He didn't give the illusion that you were in a sandbox at all.
BarryFor me, it worked. I didn't feel like I was being railroaded.
MarkOh, he's done a great job.
StephenSome players might like that kind of style that they don't have to make too many decisions and a lot of the stuff is already pre-written for them and they don't mind going with it. I mean, it depends what sort of player you are as well with these sort of DMs, but specifically that one, I think you might enjoy it, you might not.
JonThere's been pre-printed scenarios that have been based on novels or films, so you had, second edition brought out the one based on second conan barbarian movie and you got to play the characters and stuff like that i don't see the major attraction in it.
MarkYeah it's harder as a dm i think to play that sort of game because we know where things could where things are being controlled and where they're not and it's quite clear for you perhaps barry you can't really see those moments where you're being railroaded quite so clearly. Because as a DM, you gain that experience to see things from the other side.
BarryYeah, and I get that. And it's another reason that I don't want a DM because I feel like it might lessen my enjoyment of playing because I'll be like, yeah, I know what you're doing here. And I don't want to know what the DM's doing. I don't want a DM.
MarkWe're not going to give up until we get it.
StephenWe don't get it.
BarryBut what I should really do is to use this episode to convince you guys that I would be fucking terrible at it. Why didn't I think of that before we started?
JonAll the self-doubt.
StephenAll the.
JonWorry that is what would make you.
StephenExactly we've all got imposter.
JonSyndrome we just cover it better than so that's true so the next one i've got here is the rules lawyer so behind the screen obsessed with every.
MarkRule and um doesn't really.
StephenLike the rule of.
MarkCool very much and kind of holds back things a little bit in that respect.
StephenYeah there's certainly uh describe a lot of dms i think a lot of dms want to play the rules but i think it's fine just as long as they apply the rules consistently i mean it's what's worse when the dm only applies those rules to the players and not to themselves i'm okay with the rules like dm just as long as it's consistent we're playing to the same rules everyone knows where they're at and that's fine that works just as long as nothing else is sort of controlled like that if it's just that then i think playing with a rule set is is fine yeah.
JonBut as long as it's down the line that's okay uh usually you'll find people drift out of it once they become more experienced and relaxed within the system, you double down the rules when you don't know, adaptation you're not familiar with the scenario the characters and then other times that really fucking works we're going to go with that.
MarkBut then if you.
BarryAre going to make.
MarkThose calls and eventually kind of change the nature of the game and go rule of cool occasionally and don't play as written you've got to be fair about that as well haven't you because the rest of the players feel as if they're in this sort of very very strict game and then suddenly you give somebody an out or somebody an advantage by passing the world breaks down it could you could end up having some kind of player amnesty at least between them it should develop.
JonOrganically in the group it can't start off with oh well this is the mpc that i put in because he's really important to me to the plot and he gets to do that thing no fuck that.
MarkAnd barry you um i think you're a bit of a contradiction i don't know you.
BarryKnow it when it comes to rule of call i hand on heart i was just going to open my bit on this with i'm in two minds about this and i am and i am you've got to have the rule of call from time to time just to make stuff happen just to move the plot on i also really like it when dms use the rule of call to reward outstanding role play or you know with me quite often if i get the rule of call applied to me it's because i remembered something that happened more than a month ago like people go Barry remember something quick give him give him a little biscuit away he's a ref but then but then at the same time but at the same at the same time I really love challenging a fucking role and you like.
MarkThings to be fair too.
BarryI get the impression absolutely 100% absolutely 100% again I've always been lucky I don't feel like any I don't feel like there's ever been any, been in a game where a DM has had favourites or the opposite of favourites, if you know what I mean. I've never felt like grudges were being borne out on my table. I don't know if I'm just lucky or if I'm oblivious to all of that shit.
MarkMaybe a little bit, because it's probably going on, but I'd say that it is something that could be quite damaging to player versus player relationships if somebody's being given too many advantages in the game.
StephenYeah, definitely, yeah. People get jealous, I imagine, in the game. Everyone wants their character to thrive, and if one person's thriving more than the others, yeah, it would, of course. an issue um so.
MarkMaybe this is not a weakness the rules lawyer.
StephenWell yeah i suppose there would be a weakness in there is chinks in there if you kind of in the armor it's if you sort of bend the rules or if you know the rules better than someone else and you abuse the rules by sort of looking at rules rules lawyering basically so you kind of examine the rules more than probably humanly you should have done and you've created a character or you've done certain situations to use the rules to, kill things in the game or to get an advantage you.
MarkMean as a dm using their npcs to kind of really.
StephenI think it's more of a player issue that players have over studied the rules and then suddenly throw them at the dm to be honest and suddenly oh this rule says this this this is this that means that that i've just gone through this without having to do anything that's.
JonAn awful lot of shorts on youtube isn't it.
StephenSo many.
JonPeople doing exactly.
StephenYeah yeah it can it can lead into rule bending and sort of like getting around things circumnavigating things via rules that's when it becomes too rule heavy and then you've got to make a judgment call Okay.
MarkNext one is the fudger dice rolls always seem to be accidentally in favour of their monsters or just conveniently in favour of wherever he wants that to go and you know this you can fudge not just with dice rolls I guess you can make, NPCs have higher hit points or keep them alive longer than they should.
BarryFirst of all, I don't think... The vast majority of DM's dice rolls should be done secretly. And generally speaking, particularly in combat, I think everyone's dice should be down and on the table. I don't have a problem with, like, if a DM has thought, right, well, so we've got four monsters here, we've got three party members, I think this is going to... And the party just storm in and make it look like they're going through them with such ease that it's almost not worth having the encounter. I don't have a problem with a DM flexing under those circumstances and saying, right, there's another three monsters coming down that corridor, and funnily enough, they've got double the hit points that these guys had and making that campaign making that encounter worth playing i don't have a problem with that kind of fudging but dice you know how i feel about dice.
MarkThe sin here is actually being discovered or yeah i was gonna say you.
StephenHave to be subtle about.
MarkIt if you're.
StephenThe dm i mean if you can do it without anyone knowing then fine and then nobody known you're fudger but it's the obvious fudger that's the issue i mean if you're not rolling the dice in front of everyone then people are going to assume you're cheating or fudging you know i mean if you're not.
MarkNot just with dice with everything i've met the ultimate at fudger it's my own son and he described to me how he's dm in his game but.
BarryHold on a second hold a second just you did like is this game still ongoing.
MarkYes i'm going but i don't think anyone would listen i'm giving away a secret this comes out yeah they will listen to it one day he says he says he has his laptop open with the adventure on it but it's not on it he says i'm pretending i'm reading an adventure and everything i'm doing i'm making up as i go along and when they when they do things and think i pretend i'm reading i said let me just check yep and i create an illusion that they're playing something very well written into the to the book because that's what they want they want it to all be fair so they don't want to think that i'm making it up or being in any way sort of making an opinion about whether they're you know they should be succeeded or not but if the adventure says so he's literally sitting there pretending and he says sometimes i wait a few minutes and i just yeah i'll just double checking that yeah okay so you're, That is dishonesty, isn't it?
JonLegendary. That is... No, seriously. If he's keeping track of a story, keeping them engaged with that, and not going... that's fucking epic i was quite impressed i mean it takes some balls i wish i could do that it's working it'll.
MarkFall down when they realize that it's it's not an adventure.
JonNo it shouldn't.
BarryIt's gonna all fall down when any of them listen to this mate.
JonThey're done well that's sounding ovation shit that is that seriously you know i know we've got.
BarryAn audience outside of.
JonOur own society but we also have an audience within our own society I'm going to trust that nobody will actually listen to names on that one. Yeah, but those kids aren't going to listen to the fuddy-duddies doing that.
MarkYeah, that's the way I'm thinking. John, what do you feel about the fudger of you? Ever fudged? That's a silly question, of course.
JonSometimes it's a good thing. So say you're interacting with some NPC. You've got to stop doing roles to see if that NPC knows the thing. and that I've absolutely dropped the fucking ball on that time and time again.
MarkWell, you're going with the role and come to the adventure shortcut.
JonYeah, sticking with the rules that the scenario has. Oh, this is the person who does this. They've got this knowledge skill. But if they failed the knowledge skill, you don't. Fuck that.
MarkSo you consider that to be a fudge? Probably, it is by definition. And one that you were not likely to do in the past, but you've learned the best thing to do.
JonNo, I'll make the role. Not anymore, I'll just do the thing. Other examples of fudging, one I've brought up before, You know that the big boss fight is that they're losing. Action, economy and everything else, they're on the way out. You keep them alive just so that everyone else gets to do their cool finishing move.
MarkOh, I see.
JonOkay. Because that gives everyone skin in the game. They will feel like they've done something.
MarkThat's one of the kinds of fudges that nobody probably would resent, even if you said, I'm doing this, like keeping him up on his feet until you've done your thing. you've got.
JonTo narrate it so they're on their toes it's still not fucking dead and.
MarkThe look.
JonOn their faces when they get to.
MarkThat's subtle fudging.
JonIsn't it I mean that's part of your job folks you're telling stories do you know what I mean it's like.
BarryThe only fudging that I don't like is.
JonThe dire stuff I would say to that again it's the railroad in storyteller isn't it if you're fudging it to make sure they stay on that rail then you're fudging it i think it probably ties in with player agency.
StephenSomewhere along the line.
JonIf you're fudging that much players doesn't go don't matter what i do.
MarkYeah you can break the spell yeah it is something an experienced dm can do well but yeah i wouldn't i can come across as a as a flaw in in some dms i think and i've done it myself and i've i thought that was fucking obvious when it you know i've lost i've lost somebody there you know like you say there's that agency they're no longer field yes you do too much all right the next one is the killer dm thinks their job is to beat the players steven you want to kick us off on this because i know you've had more recent experience with that type of dm than yeah i have yeah again.
StephenIt's similar situation i think very described as we sort of like cleared a room out in a dnd dungeon somewhere and it wasn't good enough room we didn't take enough hit points so a whole lot more come flying down the corridor we killed those, still not good enough and a load more come down the corridor oh it was just it was just relentless and we was killing them killing them in the end he killed us in the end yeah because it just felt so unfair and it was just it felt like us versus him in the end it's kind of like yeah okay yeah.
JonYeah it doesn't work didn't like it yeah but a little bit of us versus them can be quite fun and i bring that into my dm in.
MarkA little bit frustration when i'm losing and you know i like a bit of competitiveness there but it has to be fair you know you're not going to change the rules or do that i'd never do that but.
JonIt's quite fun in it and i know you quite like that i love that when as soon as you enter combat i want my dm to be playing the monsters npcs whoever we happen to be in combat with to the best of their ability i want them to be playing those characters to win i want the dm to be competitive in in that part of the game i want that fair yeah absolutely fair that's what i'm saying especially like especially in combat like those dice rolls should be out and about for.
BarryEveryone to say i don't get me wrong i don't want my dm specifically targeting us to kill us because i'm yeah that's that's what we're talking about here but you know if the if if the.
JonDice have said i'm dead i'm fucking dead yeah you don't want him being soft on you yeah absolutely and listen i i might go home and shed a tear but i'll get some d6s and i'll roll up.
BarryAnother one it's.
JonNot the end of the world that is some old edition bullshit right there isn't it yeah but what we would say majority of dms when we were young.
MarkThe they would be like that that was that was what a dm was yeah.
JonIt's got no real place uh but apart from say particular scenarios if it's set up like a tournament situation and you are there and it's also all antagonistic not the players and the DM but the, what's on the table and that's fine, for normal role-playing, cooperative storytelling.
MarkSo I just wonder whether any of these things so far that we're feeling, you know, that's me. Are we self-aware enough? Because I don't know, John, this next one.
BarryI think it's you.
MarkThe Money Hall DM throws out treasure, magic items, and XP like confetti until nothing matters.
JonAgain, that was early on to try and keep people ticking along.
StephenDon't do that.
MarkWhat type of people are you trying to keep ticking along?
JonWell, the ones that would have left otherwise. Yes, you're making a rotary iron bag.
MarkAbsolutely.
JonYou can only have so many shinies and then you expand. And from the Monty Hall, you then go automatic power gamer.
StephenWho's Monty Hall, by the way?
BarryThe game show host.
JonYeah. Monty Hall is just mega shit tons of treasure. So it comes a lot from the old computer games where you kill a cob old and it would have a randomly generated amount of money on it for no fucking reason, because they never used the stuff. But it just carried on from there, and you'd have expectations, especially when D&D used to have experience points awarded for treasure value, in addition to monsters, puzzles, and all that stuff.
JonSo the more you had, the more powerful you was. A bit like real life.
StephenI think it's fine to give treasure in games. It's the over-giving a treasure to a specific person to sort of like placate them or to bribe them.
BarryI would say, is the issue. I think that's really important.
JonAnd power items.
BarryBut this comes into players' responsibility as well, though, because for me, and I've seen this happen, and I'm looking at someone and going, really? Really? So you find a magic item that clearly is suited specifically to one player in the party, and the person that found it fucking keeps it. But, you know, no, no, no, give it to them. That's the reverse, Monty. Yeah, so, you know, players have their moments as well.
MarkAll right? Yeah, that's true. But the absent prepper is the next one. Turns up with no notes, no plan, and then spends the session Googling monsters.
BarryNot as bad as having a blank computer screen and just making it up, is it?
JonLet's go over that again.
BarryNo, no, no.
JonFucking awesome.
MarkBut I think this one is worse because, yeah, they're not able to roll with it, not able to sandbox and think on the fly. So what they're doing is they're coming unprepared and then they're reading the adventure.
StephenVery stop-start. I think I've played some games like that when someone hasn't really prepped. You can tell.
BarryAnd listen, I've had really good DMs that have delivered the odd session like that because life, I would rather they did that than cancelled.
MarkI do have trouble sometimes if I want to stick to the adventure. It's really dangerous to come into a session and just think, fuck it, I'm going to just go with whatever happens here because you've got to deal with the consequences the next week. So I am very dependent on trying to figure out what should happen. And if I'm not well prepped, I will sit there and I will waste players' time trying to figure it out. When I do it, I feel very self-conscious about it.
StephenYeah, I must admit I do try and avoid that one as much as possible. by pre-prepping or over-prepping early. So even if you don't have time to prep, you've kind of prepped in the past and you kind of can get through it in that respect. So try and minimalise it as possible. It does happen. You might have to look stuff up. But I think as a default setting, you should avoid it. Shouldn't just sort of like say, okay, I don't need to prep. I'll just read at the time because it's not a great experience for players.
BarryNot every session is going to be perfect. You just... sometimes i feel like you guys actually kind of set too high a bar for yourself sometimes and things i mean i know this from dj and i've listened to recordings back of sets that i've played and i'm like oh that was pretty average but then when i look at the response on the dance floor you're like well actually i smashed it it's like your experience is not their experience and it's it's don't beat yourself up about stuff like that you're noticing it 20 times more than your players are it's just the way of the world it's just it's just how our brains were let's how my brains work i'm much more critical of my own flaws than i am of other people's do you know what i mean yeah.
MarkFair point uh this next one barry i'll start with you because i know that you joke about this i don't know how much it really does bother you uh the perpetual side quest giver.
BarryOh for fuck's sake you know someone's lost their widget and they won't tell you where the other widget is until you find the widget that they've lost like i don't get me wrong i'm not like completely anti-side quest and and obviously you've got to structure it so you're getting information from bits and pieces here and there but it it can get excessive when literally every person you speak to goes ah i have a job for you yeah literally every single motherfucker in on in this entire town apparently has a job for us.
MarkIt wasn't until you.
BarryPointed that out.
MarkTo me that it started to bother me because then it's so yeah you're right fucking everybody.
BarryAnd i can't get anything done around here having to.
MarkGo through a computer side question.
BarryYeah and and obviously like you know we've talked about how much we enjoy like sandbox and stuff like that but you've There's got to be some balance between the constant side quests and the plot moving forward.
MarkYeah, yeah. So the side quests can often feel like random encounters, can't they?
JonThe computer game type side quest that you're talking about. Yeah, Kill 100 Rats. Now, yeah, if I'm playing a computer game, I'm a completionist.
BarryYeah, yeah, yeah, I hear that.
JonI do the fuck out of a lot of them. um if i'm playing a role play game and not not so much side quest but if there's an interesting npc, i'll go out of my way to help them to do something it will have no impact on the game you don't get xp for it or reward it's just in your head canon that you know i think that's why it probably works more with you because you're thinking more dynamically about it people that.
MarkI get caught out on this kind of thing are running preset adventures many of the.
JonDnd adventures.
MarkKind of just fall into that side quest.
JonThey all have side.
StephenQuests between the sort of the chapters some of them they make as optional but some of them are quite integral to the um the.
JonPlot and sometimes i've run.
StephenThere's one particular i think the planescape one it was ridiculous on side plots it was i felt i cringed at just giving out some of these side plots because i thought oh god yeah.
JonThey're gonna hate this but there's another guy who wants you to do something i don't want it to feel completely linear either i mean it is it.
BarryYou know it's a.
JonBalance i you know i'm not saying.
BarryWho side quest i'm just saying you look.
JonSide quest shouldn't be 80 of the fucking game which sometimes it feels like they are do you know what i mean i think presentation um if you do it as oh yeah if you do this i'll do that or i'll give you this information that's not brilliant it now it'll take a lot more prep work and it's not going to suit everyone but if you've got those things and they need to happen you play the npc i guess is that.
StephenA side quest though if it.
JonNeeds to.
StephenHappen that's the thing about.
JonSide quests sometimes you.
StephenThink well does it need to happen.
JonNot need but say you want to ref it yeah or you want to see how the player or the character both sometimes react and deal with things because you might be trying to sort of build up your an idea of what who you've got on the table and how they can deal with things for later um if you can just blur the line so they're not asking but in conversation um that they'll mention something and then they carry on and with whatever they were doing and see if the player or the character if they're in character pick up on that that makes it a rewarding thing that they've chosen to do yeah.
StephenBooks better i think there are.
JonLevels of.
StephenSide quests isn't there there's ones that are.
JonJust pointless.
StephenAnd they're just obviously pointless just to kill some time. Yeah. Or there's ones that are a bit more subtle.
BarryThe dinosaur race from Tomb of Violation.
MarkThat is a classic.
StephenIt's a great one.
BarryYeah, it's absolutely fantastic. If you are going to prepare some side quests, make them bloody good ones.
MarkAnd that's one of the few times where I've actually bought toys for us to play with ourselves. I know miniatures are technically toys, but I went to the toy shop and bought loads of those little dinosaurs.
BarryWe had little plastic dinosaurs. Oh God, you've never seen so many old faces is smiling like children.
MarkYeah, there's a great home smile.
BarryDo you want to be a T-Rex or a Stegosaurus? You're like, I want to be a Stegosaurus.
JonThat's ridiculous.
MarkI've got only a few more left now. So the next one is the Spotlight Hog loves their own NPC so much that they overshadow the players. Do you want to go with it?
StephenYeah, I hate that. It's personal hate. When someone brings in an NPC, I say in a better commas, and they are the best character, they're the hardest, they're the highest level, they're the most charismatic, they can do absolutely everything the party can do.
MarkIt's a bit like Wayland in our game.
StephenYeah, him, yeah.
JonOh, you hate me to it.
StephenThat arse.
MarkHe finds himself away, you know.
StephenIt is, it's just like that, exactly like that. Yeah, but some people take it beyond that, beyond the level.
MarkI've got a story about somebody that does this quite quite badly he has his he had a character uh that played this same campaign the first time and i dm'd it to him and he brought these his own character into the campaign when he dm'd it again after and he managed to make it look like it was continuation of my campaign into his his character become the main character in this like off the scale he said at one point he said that my character was trying to battle the main creature and everybody else all they had to fucking do was keep keep everything else at bay so i could continue my character could continue and this is how they had to succeed but they just couldn't engage with it they weren't interested in just fighting the zombies so his character died no exactly no he did it anyway and he's telling me this and i'm going well you know you lost you you lost your players a little bit there did you and he goes yeah yeah that.
StephenIs it that is terrible horrible don't do it.
MarkWe don't.
JonPlay these games to be a, play it in something else.
MarkNo, you've got to make it play as the main protagonist.
JonI mentioned it before with, again, it was a D&D campaign from the time of Troubles. As written, and this is you're going along in the wake of certain events, which I get a meta plot and that they've all happened, but you don't get to influence anything. We pull this little sort of personal victory by blowing our resurrection on, a random little halfling that had been killed just to piss off the guy that killed him.
JonBut the ref took that, altered it, changed it, and we were the protagonists in that, and it made it brilliant. We wouldn't have got even caught all the way through if it was as written.
StephenYeah, I think if you're going to put NPCs in, you've got to make them kind of background a little bit more, a little bit more subservient, a little bit less kind of, sort of like infallible.
BarryIt's tricky, isn't it? Because like, NPCs are just such an important part of the game and your characters' relationship to those NPCs are really important as well. And like some NPCs end up becoming like more important than I think that DM could have ever imagined because the characters felt something for them. Do you know what I mean? It's like one of my favourite pieces of advice that I saw about it and it was his DM, he was saying like, you know, no one's interested in these important NPCs. And they were like, no, no, no, no. Make a load of characters. The ones that your players love are the important NPCs.
MarkYeah.
BarryYeah.
MarkLike you say, so then when, when the moment comes, the players are forced to take over the narrative and be, be the main protagonist.
StephenYou've got to, yeah. These characters we're talking about, I don't think they're really NPCs. They're, dm players yeah dpcs yeah dm player character yeah and they're fucking annoying right yeah the dpcs yeah i've isn't part of the story then fine people can live with it but when it's not it's just been shoehorned in as your your character you played in the last campaign is now the best coverage in this one and everyone else is the supporting cast yeah no no and then they're doing.
JonThe big fight and rolling lots of dice looking up and share grinning as.
StephenThey're visualizing if we I wonder what.
JonSomeone play with themselves. We wouldn't be at the club. That's what that boils down to.
StephenYeah. I know that one.
MarkThis one is cruel. It's the voice actor wannabe.
JonGuilty as fuck. I will be again and proud of it. Well, it's a good day.
StephenAren't it? Yeah.
MarkI suppose the wannabe.
BarryThe wannabe bit inherently applies. But again, this is one of the things as well. it's like you have to accept that that like people can get better at stuff like cut people a bit of slack if that is the thing like this i like i've said on the podcast i've said it in public i don't do voices when i play everyone sounds like me because i know i don't i don't enjoy doing it do you know i mean but if someone enjoys doing it and they're getting better at it then yeah come some slack also i think it's really funny when you get like there's a dm that can basically do one accent really fucking well and so everyone in wherever this is set all of a sudden is from fucking birmingham on some way okay you're right yeah you're experiencing that at the minute but it still works i was there too it's great.
MarkBecause he's putting an accent on and it works and for everybody.
StephenI think it's a podcast endemic it's it's never happened before podcasts youtube nobody cared about accents until people were listening as an audience.
BarryAnd it become and it becomes sort like more entertainment. See, but that's interesting as well because obviously you guys have been doing this a lot. a lot longer than me like i had always assumed that i don't know if i'd.
JonAssume i don't want to make it sound like i was giving it conscious thought but part of my thought process was that that was expected no and i've never had it as a child playing the game for man and boy i know that now steven it is one phenomenon that people now think that everyone's listening to me i need to put on an accent for this character all right we move on to the last part anyway and the last thing is uh the passive.
MarkDm just sits back and lets chaos reign no rulings no boundaries it's just you know are.
JonThey even a dm i would say with that what's that can be fun but especially say your sprogs i'm looking at you too there um for some of the drag morris stuff because they would come up with stuff that was completely hat stand but yeah fuck it, I just let them know what happened in response it's a sandbox then by all.
StephenIntents and purposes encourage it doesn't they some of the rule sets of some modern games they kind of don't have a.
JonDM as it were and they just let the players run right as it were so we'll tie it up there I would like to end and I know this might be difficult because you might not remember everything we said but which DM would be the one that would.
MarkPut you off the most in playing their game if they had a particular trait that you would say can't do that Barry do you want.
JonTo go first I don't.
BarryI mean, I think it would probably be the, probably the railroaded. If I'm conscious that I'm being railroaded, that would take the enjoyment away from me for sure.
MarkAnd Stephen?
StephenOh, without question, the DM that puts their own player characters front and center.
BarryOh God, yeah, you see.
StephenHonestly, I couldn't play the game. I wouldn't.
BarryCan I change my answer? Can I change my answer? Can I change my answer? Can I change my answer? Can I change my answer?
MarkYeah, yeah, yeah.
StephenBecause they're doubly annoying.
MarkThe answer is no, you can't.
BarryOkay, all right. Okay.
StephenI can't ask that. I'm annoyed at it now.
MarkMine would be, I think, the fudger. I don't like fudging yeah can I.
BarryChange my answer can I.
MarkChange my answer can I change your answer can I change my answer no no no yeah I don't like I don't like fudging I just think it just takes away everything that I think the game should be about and go with the flow go with things and don't worry about which direction it leads you can always bring it back a good DM can always bring it back to the point that he wants it to be, and it's fun that journey's the most fun I think especially as a DM the idea of fudging just really I can't imagine it would ruin my enjoyment moment of DMing. So, yeah, I don't want to see it in a DM either. John.
BarryJohn.
JonI notice you've left out a few. Some of you can target me specifically. The tech fail online DM. That is definitely out here on my laptop. The John Blake DM it says on my list.
MarkI guess we can do the list so that I didn't, I left a few of them out.
JonNo, no, it's good.
MarkBut, yeah, if you identify a few that are left out.
JonAgain, bingo card. All the way, baby. I win. I mean, lose.
StephenBut which one would you hate yourself the most about?
MarkYeah, who couldn't you play a game with? That's the question. Yourself.
JonProbably.
StephenRandomly roll it, if you like.
JonYeah, it's getting there. Yeah, probably The Tyrant, which sort of tallies up with the all about me on the last.
MarkYeah, okay.
JonBecause you are there. It's a cooperative game. And I get the amount of effort that people can put into their compelling narrative and everything else if they want to write like points in that and see how people react and maybe pad that out later and make a write a book of it that's fine that's actually brilliant yeah but you can't if you're just they've got to do this they've got to do that it's got to be done in this way with no no agency okay.
MarkSo let's just uh be honest no you'll not find one dm that's i think, None of these. I think everybody, every DM has a bad session, as well, as Barry says. And I think as a DM, we're kind of guilty of these things on and off. And perhaps we've ironed them out as we gain more experience. But yeah, be kind to your DM. It's a lot of work. So this is a bit tongue-in-cheek.
StephenTherapy session for us.
MarkYeah, a little bit. Right, so we round things off. We're no longer doing Stephen's Words of Wisdom. We are doing Barry's, what do we call it?
StephenEveryone's learnt the Words of Wisdom.
MarkI can't remember now. Hold on, hold on.
BarryHold on. Hold on, hold on. Now, the conversation we had, and there is a bit of a theme here with you, Mark, and I love you dearly. The conversation around was that I suggested these as a thing, and we're all in games, and that we could collate funny things that were said at our tables.
MarkOkay.
BarrySo, how did you guys get on with that?
StephenYou should have reminded us of this. My table's not very funny.
BarryFortunately, my table is hilarious.
MarkYeah, go on, then. That's just as well. You left the supplies with a few.
BarryBut this is the hand-on-heart bit. I can't remember the ones I've already read out. And what I should have done was highlighted them so that I knew that they'd been done.
MarkWell, we might remember.
BarryIf there's some repetition.
MarkYeah, it doesn't matter.
JonIt's still funny.
MarkWe just cancel your slot.
BarryI'm going to just go with two from fairly recently. So this, I do love a bit of alliteration. So the creepy cretin crept into the crypt.
MarkDid you say that on the floor?
BarryThat was a genuine, genuine sentence said at our table. No one that writes poetry is happy. I'm going to go with those two.
MarkYou said that one.
BarryHave I said that one for fuck's sake? He's really in it. And what I should do now is remind you guys that...
MarkIt's our responsibility.
BarryMy experience of civilisation is that it's full of dickheads.
JonWords to live by.
MarkRight, okay. Thanks for listening. We'll be back in a fortnight's time.
The Hooded Man RPG is all about the gritty, mud-soaked reality of medieval outlaws! Designer Graham Rose dives deep into the historical underbelly of real-life gangs like the Coterels to bring you a Robin Hood game...
Get ready to head into Sherwood Forest! In this episode, we dive into The Hooded Man, a fantastic Robin Hood role-playing game by Graham Rose and published by Osprey Games. We are huge fans of the genre and couldn't...
In this episode, we discuss a miniature painting competition we set up for our RPG Blokes characters, with each of us painting a figure based on our alter ego and sending it to Little Mark for judging. We go through how...
The second part of out two part Session Zero, with Lore By Night. The transition from regular blokes to blood-drinking fledglings is almost complete, and now we have our fully created characters. Next stage is to fish...
In this episode of RPG Blokes, we discuss the essential concept of player agency and its role in enriching role-playing games. Mark, along with hosts Steven, Jon, and Barry, explore how meaningful choices drive player...