Time for an origin story. Our origin story! Gamebooks and the Fighting Fantasy Series in particular were very much responsible for our discovery of RPGs, and in today's episode we're incredibly pleased to have welcomed Jonathan Green joining us. One of the true titans of the Game Book industry. Jonathan discusses what defines a gamebook, distinguishing branching stories with a problem to solve from simple choose-your-own-adventure formats. He looks at the history and appeal of Fighting Fantasy, including its role in combining fantasy, role-playing, and interactive fiction, and explains why the books attracted children through accessibility, brevity, and reader agency. He also talks about the importance of cover art and interior illustration, and how printing changes affected artistic style. Jonathan describes his path into writing, from childhood book-making to his first published game book, Spellbreaker, and then outlines his later work on Game Books, role-playing material, and adaptations of public-domain works. The interview ends with his more recent projects and his view that good gamebooks need meaningful choices, fairness, and a playable structure. He contrasts this with role-playing games, which allow broader freedom. This episode is also available to watch on Video at; https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9iUJmJ8pBkk You can visit Jonathan online at the following places. https://jonathangreenauthor.blogspot.com/ https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=613290139 Fighting Fantasy Fest, on Saturday 5th September 2026 https://www.eventbrite.co.uk/e/fighting-fantasy-fest-6-tickets-1985538518157 Support the show Sign up to RPG Blokes Actual Play and gain access to all our adventures. Check us out on our official Website. https://www.rpgblokes.com Join Our Discord Community and continue the conversation with us. https://discord.gg/JyVcd8PNHn
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
MarkToday, it's time for an origin story. Our origin story. Game books, and fighting fantasy in particular, aren't strictly tabletop RPGs, and they certainly weren't originally aimed at older players either, but there's far more to this than meets the eye. We'll be, right back. And to help us dive into the world of interactive fiction, we are joined today by a true titan of the genre, an author with more than 80 published books to his name, over 30 of which are game books, including eight official entries into the legendary fighting fantasy series.
MarkOn top of that, he stands as the genre's foremost historian, having penned the history of fighting fantasy game books, You Are the Hero. Please welcome to RPG Blokes, Jonathan Green.
Jonathan GreenHello.
MarkHi.
StephenHello.
MarkGreat to see you.
Jonathan GreenThank you very much for having me.
JonDidn't over-hype, did we?
StephenWe were under-hyped.
MarkOkay, good. So I do want to just lay out the format of our podcast today. For our listeners, which we are used to introducing to new systems and new concepts, and I think a lot of people that listen to us are quite new to the hobby in general, we'd like to start at the basics of game books and just explain what they're all about. And then look at the impact they've had on the hobby as a whole, their ongoing appeal, and how they cross over into RPGs. And then your work in particular, what you've published, and ask you some other questions toward the end if we have the time, too.
Jonathan GreenOkay. So, at its most basic level, a game book is a branching narrative. So, you'll have section one, you read to the bottom of the page, and then you're given two choices, say. Go to two or three, for argument's sake. and then you make the choice and the story unfolds based on the choices you have made so I'm a bit of a purist so people will sometimes say oh I could choose an adventure book and that is a it's a bit like a hoover or a tannoy that's a particular line of books they're specific publications, and for me those aren't actually game books because there's no problem to solve it's literally you go to here and it splits into two ways and they'll split and they'll split and L split.
Jonathan GreenSo there's not a puzzle to solve. There's not a quest to complete. It's just let's see what happens if we go this way, which is rather like, I think, rolling dice for a game of snakes and ladders, because snakes and ladders isn't really a game. There is no strategy involved at all. It's purely what happens with the dice. So for me, a game book has to have some element of a quest. So that doesn't mean you have to have dice to roll. You can have a branching narrative that is a game book that has no other embellishments, but there's some sort of puzzle or a route you have to find that's the correct one. But of course, most people think of game books as having some basic role-playing game element to it.
Jonathan GreenAgain at its most basic that's rolling dice but then there have been diceless game books as well the virtual reality series, that dave morris was involved in those have there's no random dice rolls but depending on choices you make you can lose stat points and gain stat points so there is still that element to it yeah so for me it's a branching narrative with a problem to solve and some sort of basic rpg mechanics attached.
MarkYeah so when you say the rpg mechanics because i looked into the history of these books, and like you said, the Choose Your Own Adventure books, that's very much what it is all about, especially for our American listeners. They would be very familiar with those type of books. They didn't have a very strong fantasy feel or narrative about them. So in the original game books as we know them, that led us into the role-playing game hobby, the Fightin' Fantasy series. were they the first to come along with that kind of concept character sheets and sort of almost merge Dungeons and Dragons tropes into game books?
MarkWere they the first to do it?
Jonathan GreenYeah, they were. I mean, there's a slight question because there was Tunnels and Trolls, which around the same time might have been slightly beforehand, but you can get really pernickety with these sort of things. But I think that's one of the early solo role-playing games. It wasn't a game book in the truest sense. I'm not an expert on Tunnels and Trolls by any means, but with fighting fantasy, yes. And sorry, just go back what you said about the point about the choosing adventures not necessarily being fantasy. I think that's one of their strengths, in that they showed literally anything can be a branching narrative and interactive story. And because fighting fantasy had such a massive impact on the genre and wider culture, and then Lone Wolf did in a similar way, they were both fantasy settings.
Jonathan GreenAnd you'll see now loads of people who are of a certain age, like myself, who are then now writing their own series. They're not always, but they're almost always fantasy. The fact that Steve Jackson and Ian Livingstone were riffing off Dungeons and Dragons without obviously rubbing the serial numbers off, so there's no copyright involved. But I think that's where it started. And also that kind of Tolkien-esque element to it. So a lot of people now, they think of game books, they think of fantasy adventures. They didn't pitch a game book to begin with. It was they had Games Day that they were holding in London.
Jonathan GreenAnd Geraldine Cook, who is a Penguin commissioning editor, so the adult branch of the publishers, approached and they got chatting. And I think they effectively persuaded her to publish a how-to book about role-playing games because it was a new phenomenon. But then when they sat down to write it, they thought that the better way is to actually show people what it's like. And they were proved right because later Ian Livingstone wrote Dicing with Dragons, which was effectively a how-to play role-playing games. And it didn't sell half as well as the Fighting Fantasy books did. So, fighting fantasy threw you into it by getting you to actually do it.
MarkYeah, that to us was the most important part of them and what drew us through into role-playing games. I mean, it was a phenomenon at the time. It crossed over, didn't it? It drew people that wouldn't have normally been reading books into doing so. Was that something that was planned?
Jonathan GreenHonestly, I think that was a side effect. Geraldine couldn't persuade anybody at Penguin to take it on, but instead she took it to Puffin. So it then became a children's book. So although I think the series grew up with its readership, which there's positives to that and negatives, it was primarily aimed at children. So the books were shorter, partly because it was just a little bit at a time. The fact that the reader had the agency, they were rolling dice. And also, it wasn't very long before something exciting happened.
Jonathan GreenThere wasn't lots of exposition or, dare I say, character development. But it's no, you're the hero. And not only that, but it's like, you might be like I was 10 years old and I picked up the first one, not very good at sport. And then suddenly, I could wield a sword and kill a dragon. You know, it was a real bit of wish fulfillment, I think.
MarkSo you were 10 years old when you bought your first book. Which one was it, by the way?
Jonathan GreenIt was the Wallach of Fartop Mountain. Yeah, so that came out in 1982, and I was 11 in the October of 1982. Well, the way I remember it now, whether this is true or not, but this is how I remember it, is that I got taken into Bath. I lived just outside by my mum to, I don't know, buy new shoes for school or something. And then we went into Waterstones, and it was on a table in the middle of the bookshop. And the first thing that stood out was the cover, which had the wizard conjuring this dragon from a crystal ball. I didn't appreciate it at the time, but the actual layout of the cover is really unusual because it has the title of the book in the middle of the page, in the middle of the cover.
Jonathan GreenAnd you generally don't do that because if they're stacked in racks, you wouldn't see the title. I think that was because Peter Andrew Jones had sort of recycled a painting he'd already produced for something else, as I understand it, or maybe he'd adapted it. So I picked it up, opened it. And again, what I remember is Russ Nicholson's drawing of the ghoul which is looking directly out of the page you know it's a corpse with its flesh all.
MarkRipped up it's.
Jonathan GreenGot claws it looks like it's about to tear your face off so the first thing that grabbed me was the art I don't remember how much of it I read to find out what it might be about probably the back cover but my mum said yep and I then you know the rest is.
MarkHistory yeah that was it we haven't covered artwork much but the artwork like you said when you first picked up the warlock, that's what drew you in and it there's almost like spoilers aren't they so you you look at them and you analyze them and you look at you love them and you're thinking i want to i want to get to that part of the adventure.
StephenOr the blood beast yeah i've got.
MarkOne of.
JonThose in there.
MarkThe art was so brilliant that it just made you want to play the book and that'd be the first thing i did if i went into a bookstore and wanted to buy another writing fantasy or any any book i'd look at the art first there was also a.
JonFairly iconic style wasn't there there's the thick i'm sure it's done for printing purposes but the thick like heavy black ink.
Jonathan GreenUh stylings.
JonThat appeared in that whole era for almost.
Jonathan GreenAny it's.
JonLike dnd they were really yeah a lot of them have been.
Jonathan GreenDone by the same artists but like you say it has a certain feel and it's amazing there's still people who do great pen and ink work like that now but, as printing techniques improved so the artist could try the things so if you look at martin mckenna's work throughout fighting fancy it starts off, i think his first one he was only 17 years old when he illustrated Daggers of Darkness. And there's lots of pen and ink, but he also used the letter set shading, the dots on the things. And then later he started working digitally and he almost did a scraper board style. So you can see it quite clearly in Hull of the Werewolf.
Jonathan GreenHe didn't just draw in black, he sometimes drew in white on black, or he had sort of a grayscale shading. And you can see grayscale now in people's illustrations. And it's, yeah, what you can do with the printing, is more advanced but equally it was that kind of necessity as the mother of invention isn't it you have this amazing use of shadow and negative space just by having simple pen or you'd say simple pen and ink but to try and replicate that is incredibly difficult.
StephenYeah amazing what.
MarkWe've spoken in a previous podcast about the satanic panic was fighting fantasy, caught up in that at all in the in in the 80s i can't remember whether.
Jonathan GreenIt was it did yes.
JonHouse of hell probably caught of their flack.
Jonathan GreenPeople wrote puffin books complaining i'm not sure if it got into the press but there was one piece or some bit where a mother had written in saying that after reading one of these books her child levitated so, as sirian tells it one of his stories you know kids think for sort of one pound 25 i can learn to fly i like some of that, and there was a vicar who threatened to chain himself to the railings outside penguin offices but there aren't any railings there.
JonI will install the railings wherever it wants to.
Jonathan GreenSome of my mum's friends were slightly concerned about it, and as she pointed out, you know, it's made up. I mean, she was a teacher and a great advocate for reading, so she's And she's pointed out that the idea in the books is that you are the hero. Of course, looking back now, when you look at the first one, Warlock Far Top Mountain, later on, it's retconned so that Zaygore the Warlock is a properly evil character. But in the first one, there's rumors that this old guy lives under the mountain with his treasure, and you basically break and kill all his servants and nick his stuff. So as they say now, murder hobo.
Jonathan GreenBut yeah, I wasn't going to point that out to my mom. I probably didn't realize it at the time anyway.
MarkNo, because we've spoken about this in the past. We looked at it and think, what are you worrying about? We're the least likely people that you know that's going to get involved in anything untoward.
JonToo busy with our snouts in books.
Jonathan GreenYeah. I think part of it is that now that fantasy has become mainstream, it doesn't have that fear. People much more understand what fantasy is and probably have some sort of fantasy show or movie or book series that they enjoy themselves. They look more kindly upon it. But, you know, still, they're still popular children. children i worked as a school librarian for a few years and they would love pouring over the books when the scholastic reprinted them and playing them together which is it's funny because that then makes it more like a role-playing game but that's one of the really nice things to see with children when they're sort of supporting each other in that way yeah.
MarkWe are going to talk about the crossover into role-playing games we thought we'd leave that until later in the podcast because there are many ways to cross over from game books into into role-playing and they're a brilliant gateway to do so not for adults.
Jonathan GreenToo and.
JonAlso they're a brilliant bit if you're in a dry spill between games or not knowing other.
Jonathan GreenPlayers.
JonEarly 80s for me.
Jonathan GreenYeah.
JonLong dry spells and the fight and fantasy books and a few others in the genre definitely got me through.
Jonathan GreenI do think that was part of the appeal and probably still is and that yeah you maybe meet your gaming gaming group once a week or once a month and in between times or you go away on holiday and you can still get that that quick fix.
StephenYeah we always took them on holiday didn't we in fact we bought them on holiday didn't we our books.
Jonathan GreenYeah there are so many stories about people first coming across them on holiday because it's that sort of you know go to a, caravan park and it's raining um not like it is at the moment of course um so they get taken to local bookshop and then what's this oh if i'll keep you quiet yeah i'll get that for you absolutely and again everything about them it's, i liken them slightly to the girls magazines of the year when i was growing up and that just 17 was targeted at 14 year olds so you've got these kids books which have, as you say artwork which wouldn't be out of place on a role-playing game that would maybe be played by adults so i think that's a massive draw for the children.
MarkYeah and you mentioned the price already like 125 for a book that's pocket money territory even back in the 80s isn't it.
Jonathan GreenYeah rather than saying i want the red box dnd you know to say i want a paperback, and the fact as you also mentioned they were in libraries so no libraries doing their good work.
JonAnd smiths that was what made it accessible w.h smith's in every.
MarkTown on the high streets yeah and what i do notice about them too is that the protagonist who you are being placed through the eyes of is an adult within the books as well isn't it it doesn't come across as the fact you're playing a child it It seems like a very, I'm playing a man. I guess that was quite appealing at the time, but something that's maybe helped their longevity in respects of people of our age still dipping into them.
Jonathan GreenThat is a good point. There's only... Because now you mention that, there's a couple I can specifically think of. The Crimson Tide, you start off as a child, and part of it is you grow up during the course of the book. And also, Battleblade Warrior, you're the child of the Queen of Vimorn, which is a city under siege from Lizardmen. So I think that implies you're a youth, maybe, but I guess a teenager. But yeah, you're right, you're effectively an adult in this fantasy world.
MarkYeah, I think that helps for me to sort of dip back into them now.
JonYou was a monster in Creature of Chaos.
StephenI was going to say the Creature of Heaven, you was a monster. I remember, yeah.
JonHavoc, Havoc.
MarkSo you were very young.
Jonathan GreenI mean, that was one of the things was Steve Jackson particularly. He didn't like writing the same book. So if you look at his, he didn't do as many, but they're all very different. So he co-wrote The World of Far Top Mountain with Suryan, the first one. Then he did, they each did their own solo ones. So he did something quite similar, but it was Citadel of Chaos and it introduced a magic system. You had to choose your spells and there was a cost to using them. And the final battle isn't just a, here's the bad guy, here's his stats, roll some dice. You get to choose how you conduct the battle, which spells you might use what other tricks you might try then is next on the starship traveler so sci-fi further down the line he wrote appointment with fear which was a superhero one.
StephenYeah i love that.
Jonathan GreenOne um creature of havoc in which you are the monster and part of that is you wake up at the start with no memory of who you are and so many people have riffed off that since there are so many yeah it's quite a familiar trope now in game books yeah i love.
StephenThat one yeah it's a piece to give the language i think in that one didn't you and you sort of like gobbledygook on the page and you had to.
Jonathan GreenWork it out. That was really hard. I mean, Steve also used to write puzzles. I think it was for the Daily Telegraph, so he loved all that sort of thing.
StephenI love that, yeah.
Jonathan GreenI mean, that's so hard because the spacing between the words means nothing. The gaps aren't actually gaps when you translate it. It's very cleverly wet.
StephenYeah, I remember.
Jonathan GreenVery difficult.
StephenYeah, I played that for you a few times and thought clever the second time around. It was go back and just sort of piece together some of the things that were said to you really early. It was all great, yeah. It was all well thought about, yeah.
JonCitadel of Chaos, my first one.
Jonathan GreenYeah.
JonTo date, I've still not managed to finish, honestly finish Warlock. can't can't make my way to it always get lost in the maze bit but yeah city love chaos i played that over and over um.
Jonathan GreenI think.
JonThat was the precursor for the magic system in the sorcery books.
Jonathan GreenIt was yes so i think i have to get right now i think it might have only been by a year or two but yeah what he'd sort of done in city love chaos he then expanded of sorcery.
MarkYeah i love the sorcery books.
Jonathan GreenYeah i mean that's another thing where and it was a first they're all a connected epic. And the fact that a locket you can find in book one can influence events in book four. I mean, it was very, very cleverly worked out.
MarkYeah. And the books got bigger and bigger as you went along. I loved that part.
Jonathan GreenThey're fighting fantasy books. People don't know were generally 400 sections long. Some of them were a bit shorter. Freeway Fighter was one of those. And I think Starship Traveller, the first version. But then, yes, the first sorcery book, The Shamatanti Hills, was over 400 sections. And the final one, The Crown of Kings, I think is about 800.
MarkBeautiful. I never completed it, but I did love it.
StephenYeah.
MarkI mean, we're getting to the point, really, in the podcast where we're talking about the fact that you eventually wrote writing fantasy books within the series. What a proud moment that would have been, I can only imagine. It was, yeah. How did that happen for you? How did you end up doing that?
Jonathan GreenAs long as I knew that writing books was a thing, I wanted to be a writer. I knew that. So when I was about six years old, I'd make small books out of bits of paper and staple them together. Often there wasn't really any content, but I'd draw the covers and I'd come up with the titles. And I still think Stubby Pencil is a good name for a character for a book. But anyway, I haven't written it yet. Almost 50 years later, who knows? I then started writing as I became more proficient. And I remember when I was seven or eight at school, our teacher got us to write about an alien called Big Eye who came down in the spaceship.
Jonathan GreenAnd most people just wrote a story and that was it. And I just kept going. But also it was utter drivel, partly because I thought quantity was quality. So if they went down a long corridor, it would say they ran down a long, long, long, long, long, long corridor. And some people would still say that I overuse adjectives, but they should have read that stuff. But I worked it through the system. So any creative writing work at school, I loved. Then I discovered fighting fantasy books. So, of course, I started pastiching those. And at the end of, well, what would it be now? It'd be called year eight, wouldn't it?
Jonathan GreenMy teacher wrote to my parents in my end of year report about the fact that I'd spend form time sort of writing these adventure game books. Again, they never really went anywhere. I never finished anything, but I kept plugging away. And I think I was maybe 15 or 16 when I wrote my first 200 section game book and actually finished it, but I also illustrated it myself. So when it came to actually writing a fighting fantasy game book, I hadn't written one that length before. But when I left university, I wrote to Puffin saying, can I write game books for you?
Jonathan GreenThey could have completely ignored me, but instead I got this letter back from somebody called Mark Gascoigne, who was the consultant editor of fighting fantasy. And obviously Mark and I have a long history now and we're both working together on fighting fantasy in different ways again but at various times he's been my co-author my editor my publisher he was my landlord for about 15 months. So yeah so we go way back now but yeah he wrote the letter and it said what you need to do you need to, write a quarter of the book as it would appear you need to give a detailed synopsis what happens next he made the point about not hiding the ending which anybody wants to get their book published, never send a letter saying, and if you want to know what happens, you'll have to buy my book because that's a guaranteed way to get filed in the round filing cabinet in the corner.
Jonathan GreenBut I remember him finishing off by saying, I should warn you that your chances of publication are very slim. So I sat down to write, I called it the Outlaws of Khan, because I'd read a name on one of the maps of Alansia as Khan, and it was actually Card. So it was K-A-A-D as opposed to A-A-N, but the way it was written on the map, it was slightly confusing to me. And I submitted this, I think it was maybe the end of my first year at uni. I wrote this idea up, sent it off, and Mark replied a polite feedback, but saying tactfully it's not very good, and it wasn't.
Jonathan GreenHe said, no, have another go. So I did rework the pitch. And he wrote back saying, yeah, I still like this bit and this bit, but it's not really going anywhere. Maybe have a rethink. So I then put it to one side. And at the end of my second year at university, I started writing what would become Spellbreak in my first published book. And that took, I think it was, I had to rewrite it once for Mark. Then he thought it was good enough to send to the commissioning editor at Puffin, Richard Scrivener. I had to do another rewrite and then I realized that I'm telling this completely wrong way around because it must have been the end of my first so end of school I wrote my first idea end of my first year I started on spellbreaker because at the end of my second year I got the commissioning letter to say yes you can now write your game book wow and Mark wrote again on that one that sticks in my mind it said I'll now let you pass out with happiness, and my dad said to me and no don't get nervous now and not finish it, but that's never been a problem since but yeah so I spent my summer I had a gardening job and I wrote my first book so my first my university summer job paid far better than everybody else's but um yeah I'd like to say that the earnings then went up incrementally but.
MarkAnd that was your first book that was the actual first thing you had published I know you've written a lot of other things other than game books um we're.
Jonathan GreenNot really.
MarkHere to talk about those so much today but that was that you say.
Jonathan GreenYour first.
MarkPublished work was was that game book.
Jonathan GreenIt was. So it was published in 1993. Yeah, so it's 33 years old now.
MarkYeah, by that time, we were in our early 20s, and we're moving on to a different stage of our life. So we, we'll be honest, we haven't played your game books as much as we have done the early ones, but we know of them, of course.
Jonathan GreenDon't worry, a lot of people had moved on by then. I think lots of my friends at school, it was a real craze, Fighting Fantasy. Everybody read them up to about number 10. And I don't really know what happened, but lots of other people I know discovered the opposite sex. Me, not so much. But I never stopped reading them. people, when I was at uni, they knew that I enjoyed them. Friends of mine bought them for me. I didn't buy every single one because I couldn't afford to, but my friends at uni would buy them for birthday presents. They always knew I wanted to be a writer. The third one is actually dedicated to some friends from my course. And again, I've dedicated various ones to them since.
Jonathan GreenI always say that I've had various jobs, one of which was a teacher for many years, but I am a writer. I was a writer before I was paid to write. And it's something that even now, if I don't do it for a while, I get antsy. I have that urge to get something down on paper.
MarkYeah. So what makes a good game book then? What did you do, you think, that drew their attention?
Jonathan GreenWell, with Spellbreaker, there is a lot that's wrong with it. As people who've read it will know, my early game books were incredibly hard, possibly impossibly hard. And part of the issue is that I was writing books for people like myself, because you always say as an author, you are your first reader. And by that point, I didn't roll any dice. So I cheated. So I tried to make the books cheat proof.
JonThat was a question.
StephenYeah.
Jonathan GreenBut in the process, I forgot that people also want to have fun. And what you should be doing is writing a book for the people who want to play it fairly, because if they want to cheat, well, it's up to them. And it probably means they're enjoying the story. So I will say in Spellbreaker's defense, I think it's quite a good story. And I was inspired massively by Stephen Hand. He wrote Dead of Night with Jim Bambler, but he also wrote Moon Runner and Legend of the Shadow Warriors. So with Dead of Night and Legend of the Shadow Warriors, there's various villages you can visit. So it's not like I go down a road, you turn left or right.
Jonathan GreenYou were given proper destinations, and then something happened at that place. So I mimicked that. So it wasn't so much of a, you go down a corridor and open a door, and there's this in the room. It's, you go to this village, and they've got a rat infestation. You go to this village, and there's plague. You go to this village, and a witch is on trial. So it kind of created interesting encounters and scenarios that way. So I think the story and the atmosphere is good. The game design is poor. So going back to what makes a good book, I feel you do want a compelling plot, a compelling story.
Jonathan Greenbut you have to give your readers agency as well, because there are other game books I've read where it feels to me like the person really wants to be writing a novel. So you'll read a section and then at bottom it'll say, now turn to 14. So you turn to 14, you read that, now turn to 28. And it's like, well, when do I get to make a choice here? It's kind of, they've just broken it up a long section to make it easier to read maybe. So I feel you have to give the player agency, you have to give them choices, but also meaningful choices. So gone are the days where you can say, do you open the left or the right door? You open the right door, a fireball hits you, you're dead.
Jonathan GreenYou've got to give some sort of clue to give people the opportunity, or if they make a mistake, there's a way to get out of it. And for me, yeah, some sort of fun mechanic, maybe some tweak to the rules or something that hasn't been done before. Because quite often, the fighting fantasy books, as they went on, they added more bonus rules. And some of them, there was quite a lot of bookkeeping to do. But if you've just got maybe one or something, which is particular to that book or one or two i think makes it more manageable yeah so engaging plot agency meaningful choices, and some sort of fun mechanic.
StephenYeah oh i was just going to ask is there a minimum amount of fights you had to put into these books because obviously they're called fighting fantasy i just wonder if it's tempting just to.
JonSomeone got into.
Jonathan GreenTrouble no i was never given a number count i would imagine if you'd sent in a pitch where you didn't really fight anything they might have said something but equally they were originally sold on the idea that you could complete them with minimum stats which quite quickly wasn't the case at all it wasn't true particularly not of mine.
MarkSo your books are very tough but that's hard because i thought warlock of fire top mountain the one that kickstarted it all off was was one of the toughest ones of the ones i've played like john said he hasn't managed to complete that.
Jonathan GreenYeah so.
MarkYours were impossibly difficult some of them but.
Jonathan GreenYeah well the first few were because there's one of the bad things about spellbreak which i can see now is that to complete it you have to fail an attribute check, so you have to fail a skill score i think it is to end up in prison to meet a trainee witch which is completely unfair.
MarkOr when everyone's cheating on their statuses.
Jonathan GreenWell you always want to win you always want to win so that was bad for a start it's that classic thing now which again with hindsight but you shouldn't ever hide vital information behind a dice roll it's just it's not good game that.
MarkPasses over into role-playing games as well if you.
Jonathan GreenWant somebody.
MarkTo know something do not ask for them to make a perception check you know.
Jonathan GreenYou exactly.
MarkJust tell him anyway that's right but in the book you've lost them at that point yeah.
Jonathan GreenKnights of dean which came after again i think it's a good story i think it's a bit more linear which maybe isn't as good there's some interesting encounters but there's lots of very highly powered enemies, which if you're playing failure and got a chance of fighting. And there were some quite complicated codes. And again, I've got a horrible feeling one of those was hidden behind a mistake, shall we say. And then the third one, Curse the Mummy, is probably one of the worst for the number of things you have to collect. And that said, at the end of Blood Bones, there is a whole sequence or a temple where you keep making dice rolls and any one of them could end your game completely, which now I'm talking about it. It's like if I was an editor, I'd say that's terrible.
Jonathan GreenSo I like to think that since then, there was a bit of a break. blood bones is a weird one because it was commissioned by puffin but was never actually published but from then onwards when i got the opportunity to write more i started to be more fair the downside of that is i have had some of my game books criticized by fans for saying they're too easy you can't win, swings around.
MarkAbouts because you mentioned about blood bones and you we're going to talk now a little bit about why well it hasn't come to an end completely but it did stop didn't it the blood bones was meant to be what the 60th book was it.
Jonathan GreenThat's right yeah.
MarkIt must have been a very disappointing time.
Jonathan GreenYeah. So I got the commission. I wrote the book. But at the time, they didn't know what to do with the series. This is Puffin, I should say. And there were all sorts of things suggested. And one of them was that they were going to get Mark Gascoigne to rewrite all of the books to make them only 300 sections, not 400, which would have been a nigh on impossible task.
MarkThat sounds like an awful idea.
Jonathan GreenOne of the more interesting ideas is they were going to put a bit like you used to have those really slimline calculators with the little solar cell to power them. They're going to do something like that on a gatefold cover with dice, which would randomly roll. That never happened. But not did the shortening either. As to why it came to an end, I think there was one thing was that Steve and Ian had moved on to other things. They were both in computer game industry at that point. They had other things to focus their attention on. Again, I've not spoken to them directly about this, so this is supposition.
Jonathan GreenBut also I think the sales had dropped off, but the issue was that they'd sold so many, sales if you look to sales graphs suddenly have gone down here now they were probably selling just as well as any other puffin publication it's just when money men look at it it's like oh well that's that's making a loss now that's not doing as well as it was.
MarkAnd they all went out and printed at the same time did they just literally disappeared off bookshelves yeah.
Jonathan GreenYeah so i imagine just whether stock shops had or whether there was in the distribution centers was was used up and they weren't reprinted so with blood bones the publication date kept getting delayed so for a while it appeared on Amazon, um and so every couple of years it would go forward a few years and by that point I knew that the book wasn't coming out but I'd been paid my advance I mean yes it shouldn't be frustrating uh I wasn't completely out of pocket.
MarkNo okay that's good and then it came out eventually anyway.
Jonathan GreenBut yeah so but when it was published by Wizard they got Tony Hoff to, to do the artwork again but that was good because it meant I got to change some of the things that were illustrated when I got the original illustration I thought maybe that's not as interesting as this might have been and there were some things which weren't in my original draft which got added in the new version, um yeah so it did straddle those two worlds.
MarkSo we're talking about a point here where the fighting fantasy books started to disappear from bookshelves did that coincide with you then doing your own game books and.
Jonathan GreenWhen did you begin most no.
MarkIt didn't right.
Jonathan GreenSo i left university i trained to be a teacher but during my final teaching practice I decided I didn't want to teach because all the teachers in the school I worked were miserable and the head was a horrible person. And I thought, I don't want to be like that when I'm ancient and 40. By that point, I'd been commissioned. So from having written one book for Puffin, I then became part of the annual roster. So I was pitching ideas. So I was one of the people who had something published each year for the next couple of years. So I basically persuaded my parents that I could go and give it a go at being a freelance writer.
Jonathan GreenBut I didn't want to live at home. And that wasn't for any negative reason. It was more to say, look, if I'm going to do this properly, I'm going to move out. I'm going to rent somewhere. Otherwise, it ended up being lodging with Mark Gascoigne. And I'm going to go to Nottingham. Because by that point, Mark had told me about his friend Jervis Johnson, who worked at Games Workshop. And he said, they're looking for someone to write the color text. So that's the little vignettes, the little snippets of short stories or descriptive passages in the rule books. So sometimes it's literally a paragraph. It might be a full two-page thing describing a scene in a moment in the battle, or it might be, I did one for Dark Elves where it was showing the kind of Machiavellian machinations.
Jonathan GreenIt was never published in the Dark Elves book, but it was used in one of the Games Day programs instead. So based on that, I went up to Nottingham and I met Jervis, got taken out for a pub lunch.
MarkWhich is nice. Always nice.
Jonathan GreenAnd yeah, from there, I basically moved, finished uni, moved to Nottingham, was trying to write, well, I was writing Fighting Fans of Game books. So I was trying to write other things and I was doing freelance work for Games Workshop. So to make ends meet, I also started doing supply teaching. And that was really where I kind of thought, actually, I can do the teaching thing. And it's maybe not as bad as I thought it was. So I kept that going for two years and it got to the crunch point of thinking, I probably need to do something else now. And I applied for teaching jobs. I still wanted to write, but it's kind of in a reality bite. So I've been doing it for two years.
Jonathan GreenAnd bizarrely, I applied for teaching jobs in Nottingham and including schools where I'd done supply and they'd had me back. Couldn't even get an interview. And I applied for jobs in London, got two interviews, and one of them led to a job. And that's where I worked for a long time. It's where I met my wife. My son went to school there. So it's really tied up into our history, family history now. So I've done a few army books for Games Workshop. I did second edition, Codex Chaos, Angels of Death. Although I was commissioned, Jervis got me to write this. I was the person who first wrote that the lion was still trapped inside the rock.
Jonathan GreenSo the first official publication of that. And then I was there when they started talking about the public, starting the Black Library, which started with Inferno magazine, which was originally going to be called Carnage. And so from that, Mark, who was his lodger at the time, Mark Gascoigne, he then started having worked for Workshop. He started freelancing for them again and then got taken on board with Andy Jones, setting up the Black Library. So I ended up working for Mark again, but in a different capacity. So by that point, he'd been my editor on Fighting Fantasy.
Jonathan GreenI'd co-written a couple of Sonic and Hedgehog game books with him when we were in Nottingham. And then he was commissioning short stories from me again. He then became the publisher and it led to novels. So it worked out that while I was in my early days of teaching, in my holidays, I would write short stories for Infineau Magazine. At the time, I couldn't cope with doing it during term time. And in the summer, it ended up I was writing novels. But it got to the point where I was teaching full-time, I was writing two novels a year for Games Workshop. That got quite tough.
Jonathan GreenAnd I also then started writing, pitching steampunk novels to Abaddon Books, which became the Pax Britannia series. I know that's not game books or role-playing games, but that was the time when... My wife and I, because I was married by then, we had a young family and she sat down and said, why don't you give up your job as a deputy head? We'll job share together. And then when you're not, basically a mix of teaching, childcare and writing. And then having done that for a year, she thought, yeah, I want to go back to teaching full time. And I gave up teaching. So that was a, I had a good chunk of five years there where I was just a freelance writer.
MarkYeah. Okay.
Jonathan GreenAlthough having said that, I still did some supply and exam invigilation, things like that.
MarkMade it work. Yeah.
Jonathan GreenYeah and it swings around about so i've talked full-time in between i was a librarian but for the last four years now i've been completely full-time writing yeah.
MarkAnd the games workshop stuff in particular is that still in print a lot of the stuff i noticed you've done something with sylvania which is a we played the fantasy role play game a lot we've been to sylvania once or twice isn't it sylvania the vampire.
Jonathan GreenYeah well because um eventually they did some game books of their own yeah so they only published four and i wrote two of them so one 40k one which is Herald of Oblivion and then The Vampires Shadows over Sylvania. You can still get my stuff as e-books on the website. So there's a few of my novels on there in short stories. But the last thing I wrote for them was an Age of Sigmar story called Krakenbane's Curse, I think. yeah okay but that was a few years ago the.
MarkSylvania one i'd love to get hold of but it's about 500 pound on ebay at the.
Jonathan GreenMoment i know it's rare as hen's teeth and it's really frustrating yeah the disclaimer is that i didn't write the rules because they're a games company they did that bit but i wrote the game book part and i still think it's one of the best that i've written yeah but hardly anybody's read it.
MarkThat's beautiful warhammer role play it's a it's a solo adventure isn't it it's a game.
Jonathan GreenBook so it's it's set at the time i think it's about 200 years or 300 years before the current timeline, which probably means it's about the setting of the old world now, I think. But the idea that it was, I've forgotten which vampire it was, maybe Vlad von Karstein or something had lost a battle, and there was a power vacuum in Sylvania. So that's the premise, is that you can play one of three different vampire factions, and whoever your master or mistress is sends you out to whatever the MacGuffin, I can't remember now, to find something.
Jonathan GreenSo you go through sylvania one of the fun things was you get to fight things like chaos and goblins and skaven but you also get to fight the empire, and then you also fight other undead so that was a lot of fun to play with and it's kind of a bit of a hub system so you can choose where you go at different times.
MarkYeah and you've written for many other popular ips i mean you've done teenage mutant ninja turtles sonic the hedgehog and odys you've done.
Jonathan GreenJudge dread.
MarkYou've written this is not game book stuff either is it some of this although the.
Jonathan GreenSonic yes sonic was one of the weirdest gigs was the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles because it was for Russia. but they were commissioned and written in English, then they were translated, but it meant you couldn't do any word puns. So I remember there being quite a lot about pizza, and there's one bit where you fight some, or they end up fighting some mutant turtles, which are named after Impressionist painters rather than the Renaissance painters.
MarkSo moving back into game books, I guess, where we said at the beginning, you've got over 30 game books published, and a lot of these now, you publish yourself through the Ace game books.
Jonathan GreenYes. Snowbooks published the first seven Ace game books, but um in the uk but it's it's my thing ace game book so that's under license and then various overseas publishers have published them i've started self-publishing them myself as well now in the uk.
MarkYeah and you you adapt like public domain stories quite often don't you within that so, i think you began with alice's nightmare and wonderland the dracula one which is my favorite one of yours i've got that one in print i've got the rest on pdfs i i think that this genre of game books. I think having them in print is the way to go.
Jonathan GreenI do have a couple of short stories and books that have been published only as e-books, just as zeros and ones. And it's frustrating because I can't put those on my writing shelf.
MarkOh, that's true.
Jonathan GreenYeah, how I keep score.
MarkBeen on demand, maybe. But yeah, so tell us a bit about the Ace Game books and how do you retain player agency when you're dealing with like a well-known story?
Jonathan GreenWithin the Ace Game book series, there are some which are a much closer adaptation. For example, Dracula. That follows the novel very closely. But having said that, as you will know, it's not particularly linear in adventure. There are lots of options where you can do other things which weren't in Stoker's original or which I've extrapolated from his original ideas. So it's never stated, but it's implied that Dracula is Vlad Tepes III, Vlad the Impaler, whereas in my book it's explicit. So I sort of got to riff off that a little bit.
Jonathan GreenBut yeah, generally, some of them are very, very loosely based on things. So Twas the Krampus Night Before Christmas is based on a visit from Sir Nicholas by Clement Clark Moore, which is the poem, Twas the Night Before Christmas, when all through the house and the creature was stirring not even a mess. So obviously there's only so much you can do with that. But for me, the main thing is that you need to hit certain story beats. Otherwise, what's the point in adapting that story? So, for example, when I did Alice's Nightmare in Wonderland, that is written as if it's a sequel. And to begin with, it starts off very like the original, but then it quickly diverges. And it's following the nature of a dream in that Alice doesn't remember having been there before, but other characters in Wonderland do. And she gradually pieces the puzzle together.
Jonathan GreenSo you've got to meet the Cheshire Cat. You've got to have the Mad Hatter and the Tea Party. There's got to be the Queen of Hearts and things like that. But then within that, you can extrapolate on ideas. Another one which is quite close in terms of events of the original poem is Beowulf Beast Slayer. What I discovered in writing that is lots of people knew about Beowulf and his mother, but didn't know that there was a third act with the dragon. So that came as quite a surprise to them. But then you can still add things in. And sometimes it's that typical thing where I kind of want to turn everything into a game book. Because lots of my novelist friends often say, how on earth do you write one?
Jonathan GreenAnd it's, well, when I'm writing a novel, I'm thinking, well, they could now do this or they could do that. And if you write a game book, great, I get to write both. I don't have to choose one or the other. I think maybe it's because they were the first things I had published. They're just so ingrained, laminated into my soul now. But at any opportunity, I'll write it as a game book rather than anything else. I was talking to my wife recently about a new series I've got an idea for children and she said how about not making it a game book and it's like, and you say that.
MarkFor children but these books that you've written here what age are you targeting I mean they seem more adult friendly than ever before.
Jonathan GreenIf I'm honest I'm targeting at the people like me who enjoyed reading game books back in the 80s when they were kids but they're not kids anymore.
MarkOkay right good.
Jonathan GreenIt's one of the weird things is that in the UK although there's all sorts of games published they're still seen in the wider culture or within publishing as being a children's genre. Whereas overseas, I say overseas, I just only mean in Europe, but there's a much wider variety. People have published all sorts of things in Germany, Spain, France, which are nothing to do with children, but they're still game books. And they've always been popular and people accepting them. So they kind of got stuck with that label. And then I don't know if why it persists. Maybe it's people think, oh, I used to enjoy these as a child and I'll give them to my children. It just perpetuates. Although that's good and they're passing it on.
Jonathan GreenIt's also saying you can do other things with game books. You can, like I say, make them more adult. Primarily for most of my game books, I would say, a literate 10-year-old is fine going upwards. There's nothing too graphic. That said, I do say to people when they're asking what to start with, I wouldn't recommend Dracula for children. But when I say not for children, I'm thinking, I read kind of Stephen King and James Herbert when I was about 14. So it's probably all right from then onwards, really. And there's certainly nothing graphic. As I put it, there's no sexy fun times. There might be some gratuitous murder. That was one of the things, writing for Games Workshop, having people, no space rings, ripping people's heads off and a spinal column coming out that was fine to suggest that somebody might have made love to somebody else no no no no.
JonIt's amazing what you can get away with you can do sacrifice and everything else like that and barely.
Jonathan GreenRaises an eyebrow.
MarkYeah yeah there are some quite gruesome themes aren't there when the old you were talking about house of hell those uh.
StephenYeah it must be sacrifices and that wasn't there wasn't i remember the chris knife.
Jonathan GreenYeah is it the district nurse yeah exactly yeah i mean yeah when you say there's a satanic panic it maybe wasn't completely no i think.
StephenWe earn it in some way don't.
JonWe i was wondering do you take commission.
Jonathan GreenThey do well i do work now um so at the moment i try and publish one ace game book a year but i don't always manage it because of other commissions but for example just happen to have one here, valiant is the first in a series i've written for war cradle studios so that came out earlier this year and i've finished the second one for them we're talking about a third, I write Arkham Horror investigator game books for Fantasy Flight and Aconite, so again there's three of those I'm working a pitch for a fourth at the moment yeah pretty much you know we'll work for money you know it is my job, and while it's fun to indulge myself and do my own things if someone comes along saying well we'll pay you some money up front to do something it's you know, and then again it's things that there's something about the setting I think oh that'll be fun at the end of the day that'll be, That's something I might be able to enjoy.
MarkI noticed the Arkham Horror stuff that you had on sale. I didn't realize it was associated with Fantasy Flight. So with the board games, it's all linked in with their board games.
Jonathan GreenIt's completely linked in. So with those, we have the conceit that, although it's still you, you're one of the investigators from the game. So they're all invested already in the game. Each book has three different investigators in it. But while they're in that particular book, and you do get your own introduction for that character, the idea is you can play any adventure with any character. so you could play this one with the character in the first book or you could take the character this and go back and play the first one yeah so, three so far but i think there's already about 14 maybe 16 different playable characters some in different books there was one which was in the back of, a graphic novel they did the terror at the end of time sometimes they just released other downloadable characters when a new book comes out so it's yeah we're gradually getting through them all.
MarkSo because we're a role-playing game podcast initially you're talking about the role-playing game spin-offs of your own game books because you've done that with a number of well at least two i know is the bear wolf one you did and the twas the night the christmas one.
Jonathan GreenYes um.
MarkThey were originally game books that you've then converted into role-playing games so do you play role-playing games yourself or is it just something you saw as a natural way to to sort of take take your writing in that.
Jonathan GreenDirection i have on and off i don't i'm not currently part of a role-playing group i was a couple years ago and i definitely did it as a child but it was just one of those things where i thought, i'm not completely done with this idea i think i could do more with it and rather than write a sequel to bell of beastlayer for example it's like well you could use that setting and have group adventures it was actually herot which i wanted to write first but then i went with twas because i, i don't really know why but it kind of again it was that's extrapolated from the game book so if you played the game book there'll be things in the role-playing game to be familiar but then there's other random elements and Having done that, I then went back and wrote Twos, which is only very slightly more complicated. I mean, they're very rules-lite in there.
MarkYeah. The Twos series is a Christmas-based role-playing game. And they are a more children. I played them with my own children. We played them the last few years at Christmas.
Jonathan GreenI mean, the conceit is with the Twos game book is that, again, interesting you say, Matt, you're not a child. Lots of people assume that the hero of that is a child. because the first thing that happens is you hear a noise downstairs on Christmas Eve and you go downstairs in your pyjamas and your dressing gown and your slippers. And people always think that means it's a child. It's never stated that you're a child. Yes, the conceit in the role-playing game is that you're a group of toys that are brought to life by Father Christmas. But then... There's plenty in that that's still a bit sort of creepy and unsettling.
Jonathan GreenAnd Tony Hoff's artwork is brilliant, invoking that sort of slightly unsettling fairy tale look. The problem was it's a Christmas role-playing game, which kind of limits your audience. So I did publish Christmas in July as a conceit based in the same setting. I do have more plans for that. But again, it's time and what makes the most sense to spend my time on.
MarkIt seems obviously you have a great affection for Christmas, because you've released, I think there was something else about Scrooge. I've noticed one of your previous releases was a story.
Jonathan GreenWasn't it? That's a game book I want to write, actually, is one based on Christmas Carol, sort of. Certainly on the characters and Dickensian characters. But years ago, I wrote a book on the history of Christmas, and it's been republished by another publisher with extra stuff in it. So the first version was called What is Myrrh Anyway, which was one of those things where the publisher gives you the title and it's like it didn't sell because people thought, well, that's a weird title. but it's a quote from um monty python's life of brian and then it got republished later as what was it called robins kings and brussel sprouts everything you wanted to know about christmas yeah okay so i've done a lot of research on that which is then i think partly why i thought i can throw it into a role-playing game now got.
MarkIt all there and um box of delights of course and i i noticed that this didn't begin as a game book i'm quite disappointed about that actually because i'd have loved it to have been a game book it's one of my favorite stories and of course the.
Jonathan GreenTv series.
MarkTwo but there's a role-playing game which yeah immediately caught my eye do you think you might do a game book version of that or is that.
Jonathan GreenIf you've read twos i don't know if you have but there is a section in that which is the box of delights um. So i've already kind of uh scratched that itch it's not the proper plot i mean maybe it would be a fun thing to do but i think i've probably done that oh that's in there is it yeah i didn't play the twos game book i just yeah that was having written the game book and then put that little nod to it in there so you've got Cole Holdingson is and Barney Dogg, and the Box of Delights itself. I then just thought, because I have random thoughts like this sometimes, I thought, no, I wonder if you can get the rights for that, because I'd also written the role-playing games. I thought, oh, I could do a supplement based on the Box of Delights.
Jonathan GreenAnd I contacted the estate via the Society of Authors. I said, this is what I'm proposing. Are you up for that? And they said, yes. And they said, this is what we charge you for the rights to do that for this period of time. I was lucky because it was around COVID. So while I was rather slow at writing it, I was able to get my license extended slightly. But as I started doing it, I realized this is way bigger than a supplement for Twos. So I decided to do it a self-contained game because I thought equally there'll be people who come to it because it's Box of Delights.
Jonathan GreenAnd I wasn't convinced I'd be able to sell them that and then sell them the role-playing game. So I thought, although the rules are very similar to Twos, the role-playing game, it's all self-contained. And I think that comes from having written game books. And also watching lots of unbookings where, that they get these great supplements and they think, well, now I've got to buy another book or you get a role-playing game and then there's no adventure in it. So I've kind of thought, no, everything you need is in that one book. You don't need to buy anything else to enjoy this.
MarkWell, we're hoping to do a live play of that ourselves. Absolutely. I'm looking forward to that. Yeah, over our Christmas episodes. Yeah, we do a lot of it as live role-playing. And my son is going to be playing Kay Harker because I think you need a Charles voice. His voice hasn't quite broken yet. I hope it doesn't in the next month or two.
StephenIt might do.
MarkIt might do. He's 14, so he's coming. And, yeah, so it's great to see a role-playing game of that. So with the role-playing game side of what you do, is that something you think you're going to do more of? Is that something that's been rewarding enough for you financially, I guess, as in sales? How does that compare to the rest of your work?
Jonathan GreenSo it's something I would like, I have a desire to do more. When it comes to practicalities, at the moment, it appears to make more sense for me to write game books and role-playing games. It's good and bad. I've got loads of ideas. It's not that I'm short of things, but every so often I think, oh, that would be fun. Because at one point I thought I'd like to write a role-playing game in the setting of The Wicked Wizard of Oz. I think probably I wouldn't do that one now, but I had ideas for doing something, based around Neverland, Here Be Monsters.
Jonathan GreenBut in terms of the reach I've managed to get with those with the crowdfunding and also then later sales, it doesn't compare to my track record with game books so.
MarkNo okay although.
Jonathan GreenIt might take me just as long if not longer to write the role-playing game than the game book.
MarkSo we're going to move on to final random questions i think now um i think the first one isn't particularly random i'd just like to make sure i don't forget to ask you what what are you working on at the moment what is um what is your next release likely to be.
Jonathan GreenSo what I'm working on at the moment is Fighting Fantasy Fest. I don't know when this will go out, but I'll give a quick plug. So it's on Saturday, the 5th of September at the University of West London in Ealing. So we do every two years a day's event celebrating Fighting Fantasy and Game Books. And our guests of honor are Serene Livingstone and the artist Carl Kapinski. And they've both collaborated Donian's new book, which is The Tomb of the Golden Skull. And there'll be exclusive hardback releases. we've got other guests authors editors writers from the series history, we've got role-playing game companies gaming merchandise all sorts of stuff around game books and they all come for the day to Ealing have a fantastic time and this is the sixth time we've done it now, so yeah okay so that's what's taking up most of my time in terms of what my next release will be it's another ace game books it's number nine and it's called hundred acre wood, So it's inspired by Winnie the Pooh, but it's if Winnie the Pooh met Pet Sematary.
Jonathan GreenI can't just do something nice. I have to do something twisted and horrible. And it's unusual in that it's only 100 sections long. And that's intentional because it's 100 acre wood. And it's also 100 years since the publication of Winnie the Pooh this year. But because of when it comes out of copyright in the UK, it's not till next year. So that will come out early next year. It's all written. the art's all done the next i've just got to get it to lay out and then get it printed but that will be the next release and it's also unusual when you say about who do i write game books for this is definitely not for children because.
Jonathan GreenThe way i sum it up is it's a game book about grief and guilt, and i'm not aware of that i certainly haven't read any myself where somebody's done that before, because part of it for me is it is that that challenge of what else could you do with the game book and then you get an idea and you think you know it won't leave me alone i've got to sort of work that one out and exercise it fingers crossed i think i've pulled it off because it's quite a tricky one to do yeah and then after that, uh well like i say there'll be another valiant game book which will be coming out i'm not entirely sure when yet probably not before the end of the year so actually that could be the next release but there's one of those waiting in the wings yeah and and then after that, it depends on commissions and fitting my own stuff in but i know what i want to do for ace game book number 10 but i'm always very cagey about those because it does take me a while to get around to putting them out. I don't want to kind of give away all my ideas.
Jonathan GreenNot that I'm making out there better than anybody else's, but it'd just be annoying if I released one. And then, because I have heard other friends who've written novels, they've had some pen name publicized, then somebody else has put out a self-published book under that name, and it's completely tarnished their brand and any hopes of being commissioned by the, publisher in the future. So it does have real repercussions.
MarkOkay, yeah. Keep it under your hat, for sure.
JonYou've turned up in some artwork in 40K. I was talking to a new game shop I found yesterday in Lee, just off of Lee Green. And he pulled out this book and it had a picture of you amongst playing one of the characters, I think it was.
StephenEmortalised.
Jonathan GreenFirst, I've definitely been drawn into a Troika book. Get it at Cutler's. So Tony Hoff drew me in the back. I'm wearing a kind of, it looks like I'm wearing pyjamas with a green man on the front. I'm going like this.
JonThat's it, yes.
Jonathan GreenI'm in a few now because Ian Livingstone and Steve Jackson appear as cameos in various fighting fantasy illustrations. and Ian quite often still has himself drawn in. And I didn't do it for Aidan. I thought, actually, I'm paying for this artwork. Why not? So I am in some of the Ace Game books now. So the latest one that came out was Shakespeare versus Cthulhu. So I'm Dr. Faustus in that. And I'm Renfield in Dracula. And in Herod, I'm a scold telling the tales in the feast hall.
MarkThat's exactly what I left to look out for those.
StephenAwesome.
MarkYeah. One random question.
StephenA random one. Okay. Yeah, you mentioned that you made up some new mechanics for the fantasy books. I wonder what your favorite new mechanic that you come up with was. Or was it something dastard Lita to kill him off?
Jonathan GreenI've done it in a couple of them now. Actually, we did it in... I helped Steve Jackson write his 40th anniversary game book, which was Secrets of Salomonas. and that you have to keep track of the days of the week and it effectively allows you to keep track of time, as you can choose different tasks and things but i did a similar thing with a game a fighting fantasy book called storm slayer which was published when icon books wizard books were doing it so probably not very well known, but that has a day of the week tracker, and it's all based around the weather and elements and in fighting fantasy people know there are days of the week named after particular elements so there is earth day fire day storm's day and certain elemental creatures will be, stronger on the days associated with their element and the opposite element they'll be much weaker on those days so that was that was quite a fun thing to put in.
StephenI love that that's great.
MarkIt wasn't too difficult was it.
StephenYeah it feels like a.
Jonathan GreenFair mechanic no that's fair apart from the sequence in the volcano i got a bit carried away.
StephenHave you put any unfair mechanics in you regret or.
Jonathan GreenYou think oh goodness probably loads um.
StephenI think that's a.
Jonathan GreenBit harsh i think the poison one in curse of the mummy probably didn't help an already very difficult game book where you gain poison points until eventually there's enough that it kills you.
MarkOh yeah that's.
JonYou know that's i think i might have played that one yeah do.
StephenYou have any new mechanics in mind and for new books anything to sort of like evolve the genre.
Jonathan GreenI'm trying to think now what i've i mean i something which i've done with the ace game book series as i've become more confident is you can play as different characters, and the story changes based on that character. So that's an ongoing thing. And I manage that by rather than saying every so often, if you're this person, it's just that there's an icon at the paragraph. And you know that if that icon is linked to your character, that you have to either deduct 10 and go to that section or add 10 and read that section instead. So it's a way of changing the story based on the character. So it can mean that sometimes there'll be an encounter where if there's four different characters, it's completely four different experiences.
Jonathan Greenbut in most of the cases it will only affect one of the characters or you can split it up in different ways just by using the icons.
JonThey introduced that in Scorpion Swamp didn't they? I think it was the first time we had a choice of alignment.
Jonathan GreenYeah you can choose three different quests. So you can do the one for the good wizard, the neutral wizard, or the evil wizard. So this is slightly different in that the character you play has different reactions to certain things.
MarkI was put off with Scorpion Swamp. I remember because it was the first one that came after the first seven.
JonYou wanted to play evil, didn't you?
MarkI always thought it was odd. You could actually go back to locations you'd been at before. And that kind of didn't quite get my head around that because I like the idea that you always...
Jonathan GreenEarly open world.
MarkYeah, really open world.
Jonathan GreenI think it's one of its strengths.
MarkYeah, do you?
Jonathan GreenYeah so with for example uh the next ace game book number 10 there are four different characters you can play as and i realized as i was starting work on it one of them would be illiterate, so there's a bit where you read something but if you're that character you have to go to something else because you can't read wow yeah so yeah playing with it that way.
MarkI like that yeah so another question what is your favorite game book monster or villain doesn't have to be fighting fantasy.
Jonathan GreenThe ones which spring to mind are fighting fantasy so the uh blood beast and i think just because of the illustration on the front of Death Trap Dungeon. In terms of the book itself, it's just another encounter, but it was so vividly portrayed on the front by Ian McKay. I mean, when you look at it, it's a big fat slug thing in a pool of slime in a dungeon. I'm not sure how lethal it would actually be because it looks like it's stuck there. But that said, equally, there's so much menace in it and the way that the eyes of the extra blister eyes and things, I just love that one and it's a good name and then in terms of villains I think probably Balthus Dyer just because he was that kind of warlord sorcerer and, the fact there's that element of strategy to how you, how you conduct the battle at the end. And also just the idea that, big spoilers now, if you haven't read Cicidale of Chaos, if you expose him to sunlight, that's one way to kill him.
Jonathan GreenAnd the idea that going down that path of dark magic has effectively corrupted him so much that daylight is anathema to him.
MarkYeah. This is a question we might all answer, us blokes too. Which is your favorite fighting fantasy book?
Jonathan GreenI was intrigued because I'll be honest, I was sent some notes before this, so I'd have an idea what to talk about. And you did say, I think we can all guess. So I'm interested to know what you think it might be.
MarkOh, I think it's probably Warlock of Firetop Mountain. because it's the first one that you bought.
StephenYeah, that's all I'd have said. Yeah, because mine's my first one as well, so maybe Warlock, but I don't know.
Jonathan GreenThat would probably be the politic answer, but the actual answer is Dead of Night, which was the first Stephen Hand adventure. So again, it's number 40 in the series, so maybe not as well known. Covered by Terry Oakes with a demon coming out of like a volcanic rift in the ground and a tower in the background. Illustrated by Martin McKenna, who was one of my favorite fighting anti-artist much missed and again just the game design the idea of going to different villages there was a map by leo hartas in the front it just had everything and i and also there's, clever things in it in the one of the some information you're given in the text, if you then look at one of the pictures carefully it it gives you a clue without ever making it explicit what the choice should be when it maybe looks a bit more random, yeah um so i just think that one and all sorts of the encounters themselves there's things like a land blight which is effectively this demonic factory which has sprouted up on the spot and it's uh i just i'd say dead of night.
MarkYeah okay uh what was your.
StephenStatement oh if i had to pick one i suppose the first one i bought was city of thieves which i absolutely love but i quite like the ones where we the genre deviates i like rebel planet and i love appointment with fear i absolutely love those.
Jonathan GreenOnes yeah and creature of chaos.
StephenSo i've got four yeah well uh yeah city of thieves i i played that again and again and again i loved it black sand.
MarkIs a great place to hold while playing game adventures isn't it.
Jonathan GreenYeah oh yeah brilliant creation absolutely.
StephenYeah so that one yeah if i was for.
Jonathan GreenI loved what um mark gascoigne and pete tamlin did with the advanced fighting fantasy the dungeoneer series it was the second one was called black sand and they really expanded the town for the city and there's a lot of humor in that book as well that's that's down to mark that's classic mark lots of tongue-in-cheek puns and sarcastic comments and things.
MarkYeah warhammer fantasy role play feel about it as well yeah.
Jonathan GreenYeah john.
JonYours i guess citadel but um i was very much into martial arts at the time as well so they they did a way of the samurai one and i really liked that.
Jonathan GreenSort of a samurai and then there was the way of the tiger which isn't fancy fancy but that had there yeah jamie thompson mark smith.
MarkYeah the citadel of chaos number two yeah yeah mine was death trap dungeon that's the first one i bought does stand the test of time it become a computer game didn't it swell and i noticed that dragon meat where we see you every year by the way, and anybody that wants to come and see you in person dragon meat's a great place to come along and.
Jonathan GreenBuy your.
MarkBooks um i noticed that there was a death trap dungeon release i think it was the figures and blood beast as a miniature i didn't buy it i wish i.
Jonathan GreenHad yes it has the fighting fancy heroes which dan jack of bluejack studios has sculpted them and they're being put out by my mini factory i think it's still live on backer kit if you want to check it out is it still there okay i i think so so fancy heroes let's have.
JonA look at.
Jonathan GreenThat yeah i do love death i have to say city of thieves and death trap i think is where they really got into their stride, and there are links between the two books as well because um sour belly one of the troll guards in port black sand his sister is poison ivy who was in death trap dungeon okay and also by that point ian in particular, was building the world of Alansia. So it's sort of implied that you go from City of Thieves to Death Trap Dungeon, and from there you go to Island of the Lizard King and things. So it's, yeah, I like that.
MarkYeah, I love them all.
JonYeah. I've got some more reading to do, apparently. So I didn't realise that, A, there were quite as many, because I'd just gone into regular role-playing.
Jonathan GreenBecause Scholastic now have the licence to publish writing fantasy. So like we said, there's a new one out from Ian. I think they've published five new books, to check that now yeah new fighting fantasy game book since they got the license which is back in 2017 now yeah.
MarkAnd you've worked with steve jackson on his latest.
Jonathan GreenRelease yeah.
MarkThat must have been great was that the first one you've actually written with one of the the co-creators of fighting fantasy.
Jonathan GreenYes and then syrian and i co-wrote uh magic realms the art of fighting fantasy, as well which came out last year.
MarkI did have another question here about the history of fight and fantasy when you were researching and writing you are the hero was there anything any little things you discovered about the culture around the early game book boom that perhaps surprised you.
Jonathan GreenThere are some interesting stories which is frustrating now because it's that kind of thing where i can't share them so there are things i discovered which people asked me not to them yeah okay there are a couple of those which were.
JonBut the fact that there are those is bad enough.
Jonathan GreenI think when you look back at the success of the series and now is how much of it they were just winging it because you know we've had one book and it's been reprinted reprinted reprinted now we want two more now we want one every two months now we have to get other people in and you'd think there was some sort of master plan but it was just rising that that wave of success and it's incredible when you look back and what was achieved just within those first 10 years getting to 50 game books, I was trying to get to 10 game books of my own ace game book series I managed to get to eight within 10 minutes.
MarkYeah, that's true. So it was a crazy time.
Jonathan GreenAnd just now looking back, how many people who are movers and shakers in the industry were influenced by fighting fantasy, I've forgotten his name, but the designer behind Dark Souls, the computer game, was a huge fan.
JonOh, that's why it's so easy to die.
Jonathan GreenDara O'Brien, just a celebrity name that springs to mind. Charlie Hickson, people like that are reading them when they're teenagers. So yeah, the people who are running publishing companies and games companies and designing things now, they were all brought up on it. It was like you say, it was their gateway to role-playing and tabletop war games and things.
MarkSo the effect is there.
StephenAmazing.
MarkYeah. Any other? you were going to ask Jonathan whether he cheats but we've I think we've established that we've covered.
Jonathan GreenThat yeah yes.
StephenIt was volunteer yeah he must have cheated didn't it.
Jonathan GreenWell as Sir Ian calls it it's the five finger bookmark, so you make a choice and you keep the fingers in the page to see why I didn't like that one I'll go back and try something else, so yeah I absolutely cheated partly because I wanted to get to the end and enjoy the story and then also as it got further on it's wanting to see how the game works are constructed and what happens if you do this and yeah Yeah. So yeah, I try to write my books now for people who want to play them fairly. Beowulf Beast Slayer has been criticized for being much harder to get to a certain ending, but my reason for that is that if you follow the true story, as in the epic poem, it leads to one ending.
Jonathan GreenAnd to fight that ending, you ought to do something exceptional. So that's my justification. But at least I knew that that's what I was doing with that one, rather than, oh dear, I've designed this poorly. It was a...
MarkDefinite intention well i think now now i know that when i play your game books which i'm i'm going to be doing i won't cheat and i'll play them because they've been written in the right spirit i'll i'll believe what you say i'll be checking i have stated in.
Jonathan GreenThe rules because again some people it means a lot to them to be given permission should we say so it says you can because with the ace game books you can use dice or playing cards so i say you can play it that way and i say or you can ignore the dice rolling and the random number generation, and you can just read the story you can.
MarkSucceed you.
Jonathan GreenKnow win every battle succeed at every attribute test but you still might not succeed in actually completing the quest so i kind of accept that everyone's going to want to sit there rolling dice on the commuter but they still might want to enjoy the story.
MarkYeah good idea that's a good idea yeah.
JonYeah some of them printed dice random dice rolls at the bottom.
MarkThe new fine fantasy releases yeah.
StephenHe flipped the books did he yeah.
MarkYeah that's right and play him on the train so for repping things up i think what we're but obviously primarily focused on here is introducing people into different elements of the role-playing game hobby and i think this is a perfect gateway the game books are um to be doing that yourself i mean if you're if you're listening to this podcast and you haven't played a role-playing game yet and you're thinking of doing so then pick up some of these books pick up jonathan's stuff and keep you ticking over in the meantime but also give you a good groundwork into to what, a role-playing game is ultimately in any case and as i say we we this was a gateway way for us directly.
MarkWithout fighting fantasy, I don't know whether I'd be role-playing. Let's be honest. I don't think I would have encountered it or thought about it. It was one thing and then the next for us as children. And I think as adults, that can do the same for you too. And a lot of our listeners have children too. And- then buy them a game book you know you still get more can't here it's.
Jonathan GreenAlso the.
JonOther thing something i did with the bloodsword ones was uh you extrapolate on what's in there to do a.
Jonathan GreenRole play.
JonGame so you can reverse engineer it and.
Jonathan GreenThat encourages.
JonYou to maybe not get your players to read the game book until afterwards but you can always uh.
Jonathan GreenOh yeah absolutely yeah reading one of them is a classic example is you just, increase the number of enemies by however many players you've got as basic as that so yeah you can definitely do that with them as well, yeah i think the main difference between a game book and a role-playing game is is you do have a finite number of choices you can't do absolutely anything whereas in the role-playing game you have much more freedom of choice as long as, your dm or your gm is open to suggestion and is can sort of do a bit of theater on the fly and isn't completely hidebound by no you've got to go this way because that's what i've written notes for, yeah i mean it can really go anywhere whereas in the book the book is the dm but can only have so many responses otherwise it gets unwieldy.
JonYeah really works.
MarkSo jonathan thanks for joining us.
Jonathan GreenWell thank.
MarkYou i'd like to think that we're going to see you again soon because we're always a dragon meet.
StephenWe'll say hi.
MarkThat's it but yeah thanks for joining us and i'm hoping everybody's a bit clearer now and there are many routes into this hobby and many different elements and facets of it and this is certainly one of them and you should not not let it pass you by it's.
StephenA great one.
MarkYeah recommend.
StephenIt to everybody yeah.
Jonathan GreenThank you.
MarkIf people wanted to find you online and and discover more about you i'll add some extra bits and pieces and links in the know.
Jonathan GreenYou can follow me on facebook um twitter instagram blue sky i've got jonathan green author.com ace gamebooks.com they'll get you to my stuff and see what i'm up to right yeah yeah thank you.
MarkOkay so we're done thanks jonathan really appreciate your time.
The Hooded Man RPG is all about the gritty, mud-soaked reality of medieval outlaws! Designer Graham Rose dives deep into the historical underbelly of real-life gangs like the Coterels to bring you a Robin Hood game...
Get ready to head into Sherwood Forest! In this episode, we dive into The Hooded Man, a fantastic Robin Hood role-playing game by Graham Rose and published by Osprey Games. We are huge fans of the genre and couldn't...
In this episode, we discuss a miniature painting competition we set up for our RPG Blokes characters, with each of us painting a figure based on our alter ego and sending it to Little Mark for judging. We go through how...
The second part of out two part Session Zero, with Lore By Night. The transition from regular blokes to blood-drinking fledglings is almost complete, and now we have our fully created characters. Next stage is to fish...
In this episode of RPG Blokes, we discuss the essential concept of player agency and its role in enriching role-playing games. Mark, along with hosts Steven, Jon, and Barry, explore how meaningful choices drive player...