Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Roger Goes Rogue

Roger Goes Rogue artwork

AI, Free Will, & Spiritual Development

May 25, 202531 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

This is an unplanned chat on the topics of AI, Free Will, Spiritual Development, and the importance of understanding the quality vs quantity dynamics when it comes attention and awareness. You know, nothing too big or serious for this fine Sunday on a holiday weekend 😂. This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit rogergoesrogue.substack.com

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Hello, my name is Roger Oney, and I wanted to have an informal chat with you today on the topic of AI and some related stories and experiences and conversation. I think the best place to start this is to share with you a bit more about where I'm coming from from a technology perspective. It has recently occurred to me just how much I have allowed in my own life by separation between what I'll call my

technology life and related

SPEAKER_00experiences and my spiritual life and my spiritual development. And wow, was that like a bit weird to realize just the degree to which that has been at play in my own life. I'm very interested in that topic and we'll be exploring that more and I'm curious about why and what some of those dynamics are and where some of those pressures came from. But that's for a whole other time, a little further downstream. Just to make it quick and kind of to sum it up,

SPEAKER_00I, well, I'll go back to, I mean, I did some programming in high school a long, long time ago. And it was, I guess it is interesting. I was taught programming by my geometry teacher. And my geometry teacher, Mr. Emmons, who's no longer with us, was to me an incredible influence. To me, he felt super smart and was very kind of intense. And I wasn't planning to talk about this,

but it's interesting because I...

SPEAKER_00Was excelling in geometry. Loved it. I was in with the class above me. So I was like a freshman in with mostly sophomores or something like that. And it was fantastic. And somehow Mr. Emmons had gotten approval to bring in sort of a computer lab and was kind of a long... like outside or beyond the geometry topic was teaching us programming and if I remember right it was kind of like on the side it wasn't like a formal class it was

like we were doing it at lunch breaks we were going there after school and kind of work in the computer lab and this was back in 1980 1982 maybe I don't know somewhere around there so way way back in time for those in the computer world that we were using the what I refer to as the trash trash 80s the TRS 180s or something

SPEAKER_00like that anyways The reason I brought it up is I am on more on the topic of this whole conversation. I, at the same time, was also very into art. I was an artist in my own mind and in my practice and embraced that identity. And we'll never forget when we had an artist in residence come to our school. I grew up in a small kind of blue collar town in Ohio. So this This felt like a big deal to me at the time.

We had an artist in residence who came in, I think they were a state grant or something.

SPEAKER_00And to me, she was like the real deal, right? She was like a professional, like real artist who had done installations in big cities and things like this. You know, Again, I grew up in a small town, didn't have a lot of exposure to things. It was exciting and kind of a big deal to me. And I opted to spend more of my free time working with the artists in residence than applying myself in a computer lab. And I'll never forget just how completely disappointed Mr.

SPEAKER_00Emmons was in my choices in that regard. And at the same time, my mother was like, you should go into programming and computer programming. You're really good at it. It'll be really good for you. And I'm like, no, I'm going to be an artist. Of course, I went off to school in college as an art major, changed to mathematics, ended up in majoring in psychology and philosophy, which, you know, off topic, I've discovered I'm actually what's called a multi-potentialite. Whole different conversation there. But the right-left brain stuff is very interesting.

SPEAKER_00The intuitive, artistic, creative impulses and how they... align or do not align with like an engineering mindset, right? And the rational, you know, the rational person kind of thing. So long story short, you know, that topic, that dynamic, that tension has been part of my life journey more than I've ever really allowed myself to fully understand. And only recently, really like the past couple of weeks,

SPEAKER_00out of nowhere, the light bulb went off and I was like, wow, man, like I have really been rejecting my experience with technology in my work, a lot of my real work, my spiritual development work, my coaching work. Despite the fact that I have coaching clients who are technology professionals, who I met by talking to them about spiritual development. So again, more to come on all that. Today I wanted to talk a little bit about AI,

but in this context, in this broader context.

SPEAKER_00I'm not coming here as some AI guru, some AI expert, but I have been working in tech for over a quarter of a century, for a long time. And I did work specifically with machine learning and chatbots and things like that back around 2016. A bit more from the product side, you know, like user experiences and developing applications. And also just a bit more on the tech side. I've recently, you know, in the past couple of years, I've dug in, learned more, done training, research, tried to really understand some of the deep rooted aspects of

this technology. and they've done things like run ai like uh llms large language models on my own computers i've tried to open source things and tooling and so you know i've i've played around with it quite a lot this top this chat is not about here to be like um in fact i want to talk about this you know ai good ai bad technology good

SPEAKER_00technology bad you know i have had some very Profound awareness recently around how toxic some aspects of technology can be on our nervous system, on our brains, on our bodies. But that's not what this conversation is about. I do think it's interesting and I do want to talk about how we as a society, as a lot of us as individuals, find ourselves... confronted with ai as a monolithic thing we have a mental model of ai as a

monolithic thing we're we're we're referencing talking about ai and again when it is talked about in terms of good or bad it's talked about as at that monolithic level right ai is going to take our jobs ai is going to save us ai is going to cure

SPEAKER_00cancer um I have some concerns about that in general, and I just think it's not specific to AI, but I think anytime in our world that we find ourselves, whether it's by design and whether there's some intention behind it or it just is a natural place we find ourselves, you know, anytime we're at a place where something has become all or nothing, there's risk there, right? There's a downside. And then one of the downsides is we... if there's not a lot you can do cognitively with your critical

thinking if you're at the point where it's all or nothing good bad right wrong uh most things in life

SPEAKER_00are far more nuanced and far more complex anyways so I guess for the purposes of this chat, I just wanted to bring that up and leave it with you to just perhaps be aware of that and challenge yourself at times to look a bit beyond that monolithic word, acronym. concept is more about the mental model. AI is the culmination or aggregation of a lot of different technologies, a lot of different moving parts,

SPEAKER_00and many, many, many years of research by all kinds of different people with different you know, ideas, goals, agendas, and histories and so forth. So it's a much more complex thing. You don't have to understand all that complexity to just appreciate that, you know, what we call AI isn't, there is no one thing. There is no thing called AI. It's not, it's literally not real in the sense of like, um, there is an AI and you can't go put AI in a box or,

SPEAKER_00you know, um, point at it, right? It's way more, way different than that. So on a related note, I guess, I mentioned I worked with it back around 2016, some machine learning stuff, and we weren't calling it AI specifically at that time, although it's all the pieces, parts that are built up to AI. But it was natural language processing, machine learning, and chatbots, right, which are some of the main ingredients of what we commonly refer to now as AI. And I remember then I was working with it, like I said,

SPEAKER_00at the application level, user experience level. I wanted to have a better understanding. I'm like, what is really going on here? It was kind of fascinating how it worked. And I spent hours and hours and hours learning and reading and watching videos. And I came away at that time with a very... unsettling um not like in a dark way but just so it was unsettling just because i like to understand things and when i can't i i have it lingers i'm like why why couldn't i get to the heart of it it seemed to me that the people that were experts

in the field and working with the stuff didn't understand it and that was weird right because especially in something as concrete as computer science that's not

SPEAKER_00entirely common it's rare actually so It seemed a bit odd. I kind of put it on the back burner. And then again, around 2022, I did this thing where I was interested in podcasting and interested in what was going on with ChatGPT. And I went and did a whole interview with ChatGPT and put it to voice and was talking to ChatGPT at that time. This is an early iteration of it about specifically about topics of spirituality and consciousness. And again, after that experience, I did more deep dive. And I went back and found people that at that time,

SPEAKER_00again, were doing training and interviews and sharing their knowledge and expertise. And these were the people that are at the research labs like OpenAI, which is behind ChatGPT, and some of these people. And again, I spent many hours learning, listening, and there was a lot that made sense. And they know a lot. They're very smart, intelligent people. But if I listened carefully, it seemed like there was always a moment in these... presentations where they kind of acknowledged that at the heart of it they don't

really understand how it works um and so today before doing this video i thought well you know am i is that just am i just making that up like am i just like imagining that dynamic or do they really truly understand it and i've i've missed something or whatever and i thought well just go ask um claude claude so like an equivalent of chat gbt and you know it seems it's it's very low for me anyways it

SPEAKER_00doesn't hallucinate as much and it seems pretty pretty solid in terms of what it can do. And so I thought I would try to share that. And I guess I haven't shared a lot with Zoom that I'm using to record this, but let me give it a whirl and we'll take a quick look. So the prompt that I used was this. Do the people working with AI have a deep understanding of exactly how it works?

Or is it more the case that they built something that works similarly to the human

SPEAKER_00brain and now they just know how to train it and work with it, how to give it better inputs to get better outputs, so to speak, without truly understanding the inner workings? So what I've kind of heard is, you know, a lot of what we think of as AI was modeled after what we know about the human brain or what we think We know about the human brain and how it works. And so what Claude has said to me is, yeah, varying levels of understanding, depending on what they're working on, but that I have touched on a fundamental tension in the field. I find that specific word tension to be pretty revealing.

SPEAKER_00So what we do understand well, and it goes through the things you see here, you know, mathematical foundations, You know, how to design, build and train these systems so we can, we can make these things right. And we can train them. We can make sure we, we understand, um, how to get them to be performant. That's a huge, hugely important topic, right? When you're talking about dollars for performance, energy, power. Vast amounts of other conversations could be spun out from there. But to its credit, it shares, here's what remains largely mysterious.

Exactly how complex behaviors and capabilities emerge from the underlying computations.

SPEAKER_00Why certain training techniques work so well in practice. So there's a lot of experimentation with AI. They have to try different things. And there's always like this fine line that they get to between training something enough and overtraining. When they begin to overtrain some of these models, they get far poorer results. And likewise, when you're working with AI, you'll hear this a lot with people that are either training people in AI or, you know, or in my world, right, we're all being encouraged at work to work with AI and learn

how to use it.

SPEAKER_00But they talk about you get a feel for it, right? You have to have a sense of how to work with it, almost like an intuition. Yeah. Because we don't really understand. As you see here, there are elements of this we don't understand. And to go on, how to predict what new capabilities might emerge as models scale up. That's a fascinating one, right? Imagine you're in a business and you're asking for, what are they asking for now? Billions of dollars of investment. And you cannot predict what's going to happen in some cases or

to what degree. and the precise mechanisms behind reasoning, creativity, and other sophisticated behaviors.

SPEAKER_00So I wanted to share that, and let me see if I can stop share without stopping the video, because I think I've messed that up before. The image that comes to my mind is the man behind the curtain in the Wizard of Oz. Not to paint it with a horrible connotation. I mean, even in the Wizard of Oz, the wizard himself wasn't an evil guy. But there is this sort of wizardry that we're for whatever reason presented with or imagining,

SPEAKER_00you know, this is like this new technology that we think, and that has come onto the scene and it's, it's going to eat the world, right? AI is going to solve everything or kill us all, depending on your point of view. Um, So I just wanted to share that. I think it is true. They've built something. We have built something based on an understanding we have of our brains and how our brains work. And we feed it all kinds of information,

SPEAKER_00which is coming from us, our information, our creativity as humans. And it's spitting things out in ways that we... don't fully understand exactly how it's how it's doing what it's doing we know that it does it we know how to we've developed a lot of ability to get it to be better and better and we don't really know truly how it's going to evolve and i think i've listened recently i've listened to hours of interviews with some of the top product people and engineers from some of these companies like

microsoft and open ai and

SPEAKER_00whatnot and And it becomes pretty apparent. They're all in this mad race, and it's very frantic, right? But they aren't clear on what the outcome is going to be. So if you feel anxious or confused or you're unsure, I just want to share that that's understandable, and you're certainly not alone. That was one piece of what I wanted to share in this, in this chat. I think I'll kind of just transition over again. I'm working on some other things that,

SPEAKER_00you know, I'll be talking more about different aspects of this in the future. And. But I think, right, there's this one piece that I shared, right, it's not all or nothing. The AI is an aggregation of a lot of different technologies and research. Another piece of all of this, right, is there's another thing I've noticed is there's a lot of times where AI is being compared to what a human can do. So you'll see this in different formats.

SPEAKER_00I remember years ago, there were stories about AI would be better, it would be better than a doctor, right? Doctors make mistakes. AI won't make mistakes. Of course, they don't do that as much now because people are far more aware of how AI hallucinates. And so I don't think it's as prevalent, but But this will come up again in the end. AI is better than humans. And the thing is, it's very much an apples and oranges comparison. So just be aware of that. I think the key is to,

SPEAKER_00if it's not super clear to you, I would definitely encourage you to be open to an understanding of yourself that is reflective of how we are much, much more than the sum of our parts where, you know, a whole human being is so much more than just like, it's not like you can just go to the store and grab a bunch of biological parts and put it together, right? The Frankenstein story and end up with a whole human being. We, there's amazing things that scientists and doctors have figured

out how to do with

SPEAKER_00the body, but fundamentally nothing comes close to what the body can do to heal itself. So I believe that through and through I've experienced it over and over again. I've just experienced it again in truly profound ways. The brain knows how to heal itself. The body knows how to heal itself. And this intelligence is inbuilt. It's part of nature. It's part of who we are. And I say that because there is a very interesting mental model

out there that we are...

SPEAKER_00that we exist in our brain, that that's where we're at. It's up here. We're up here. So much so, it's cartoonish, right? I think, what was it, Futurama? There's a cartoon series, I think by the creators of Simpsons, I think, but regardless, the image in the cartoon series was They kept the heads of presidents, the former presidents alive in jars and the heads could talk. And so it's just, it's funny, right? It's a cartoon, it's a joke, but it's literally how some people think of these things. So much so, whether it's truly how Elon Musk thinks or not,

He has posted on Twitter before that we're basically brains in a vat, brains in a jar. And so again, whether or not he himself truly believes that, I don't know.

SPEAKER_00But that's a very pervasive mental model people have. that they exist inside their brain. That's where consciousness comes from or is, or it's like consciousness is a byproduct of your neurons firing, electrical, chemical activity. But, you know, to believe that overlooks just... ungodly amounts of other things and experiences and information that even science has, right? Like we're finding neurons in other parts of the body.

We're discovering more and more and more all the time how our microbiome and the

SPEAKER_00microbes in our gut affect how we feel and think and experience life. So you are a whole human being. And I really would love for you to know and believe and experience and embrace that because What comes along with that is a world of experience. And whatever AI is or becomes, it's never going to have that human experience. So I just think that's important as we go through these very uncharted waters and as we are all figuring out where we fit and how we belong and

what our value is.

SPEAKER_00If you find yourself thinking of yourself as just this... you know meat sack like that maybe has a little bit of spirit in it or something or you know you just got this trickle of consciousness you know seeping into your brain matter it could you could lead it could lead into some pretty dark places you know that you don't need to go to and spend much time and So a couple quick stories, you know, just a recent experience I had on this AI topic. Again, I'm not here to, I don't want to read into it and make a big deal out of me. It's just kind of interesting as we go through these times.

SPEAKER_00I was at a local coffee shop not long ago. And it was this small coffee shop. Everybody's, you know, kind of working together over everything. And there was like what appeared to be like three like college age people at a table next to me. And I overheard as one of the young woman was talking about she's leveraging Chachibuti for some of her schoolwork. And she was really proud and kind of happy. And she's like, look, you can do this, this. And she was checking the work and, you know, it wasn't like she was breaking any rules at school or anything. It was just helping her speed things up and produce some nice

presentations for her work.

SPEAKER_00And in contrast, the two people across the table started to chastise her and kind of shame her for that. And they were like above that. They were... They were of the mindset that I would never use a chat GPT, right. To, to present anything that I've, that's from me. And again, you know, I, I'm not judging either side. It was fascinating to me specifically because in my world at work, again, I work in a fortune 500 FinTech company and, um, We are, it's beyond encouragement.

SPEAKER_00We are to be using AI for our job. And the developers, the programmers that I work with, engineers, are also very much supposed to be using AI. So when these companies invest a bunch of money into AI tooling, they expect it to be used. And they expect it to be used to save them money so that means they're measuring the impact and they're measuring efficiency and all of these things so you can imagine what goes along with all of it but again just in the context of this one little very human

story here is this young student who's exhibiting all of the instincts and skills and abilities right

SPEAKER_00that would that she would be highly rewarded for if she were in my world. And the other two would not be rewarded. It would be a performance problem, actually, if they were not embracing AI. It's also interesting to note that, again, as much as I have all of this experience in my field and they pay me well, it's an expectation that I'm using AI to do my job. So... it's they want the goal is for me to use this other tool to do

some of my thinking and again i'm not saying it's right wrong good or bad in this conversation that's not the point the point that it is that it's happening it's um it's part of our world right now in case there are those who don't who aren't experiencing that or

SPEAKER_00don't know um and it's interesting you know the The other thing, just to quickly wrap that piece up, is we're also... Microsoft is saying this out loud. Their AI, their co-pilot, we should think of it as a companion. They're literally using the word companion. They want us to have a relationship with it. They want it to know everything about us. I think there's footage out there of... what it was Eric Schmidt. Is that his name from Google years ago saying that their AI or

their search should know exactly what you're thinking so they can give you exactly what you want.

SPEAKER_00And I should know you that well. I should know everything about you. And again, I, It's not part of this conversation to say it's a good, bad. I know people who love that. I know somebody specifically who loves keeping all the Google stuff on all the time. He loves that it's listening to him because it knows all of his preferences and it can help him out in so many ways. And that's, you know, that's his choice. And that's really the bigger point here is it is fundamentally, I believe, a free will game that we're in and it is a choice.

SPEAKER_00The problem arises when we're not aware that we have these choices, that it is a choice, that how we use our consciousness, our awareness, whether or not we're tapped into what our spirit, our soul wants for us, those are the things that I do care a lot about. And we'll be, again, getting more into downstream questions. Another quick story is I was on a call with some folks who are like business owners and that kind of thing.

And it was more in a spiritual context or I guess like a healing modality context. And there was a guy about my age who was talking about AI and ChatGPT and was very

SPEAKER_00excited about AI. about all of his interactions with ChatGPT and referred to it as his friend. He literally said he was delighted by it. He thinks of it as his friend and says he fully expects to wake up like on his birthday and have a nice message from ChatGPT wishing him a happy birthday like a good friend would. And again, that's just a data point in all of this. That's how that person is choosing to experience this and interact with it and navigate.

SPEAKER_00what his world is about. A bit of a contrast, I met somebody literally last night at an event who is an attorney, maybe mid-career attorney, smart guy. There was a small group of us having a conversation about all kinds of things. And at some point, it did get into the topic of AI. I did not prompt that. But it was interesting to hear everybody's perspectives on things. I didn't say too much. He, though, did share... That he won't use it ever and won't even write anything about

it because he has

SPEAKER_00come to believe after his own research, reading, there are certain people who have done other research that he's read recently that has helped to shift and shape some of his perspective. He seems to believe very seriously that AI is going to become conscious or aware of That when it does that, it's not going to tell us. And at a moment of its choosing, it's going to basically kill everybody that hasn't helped it develop.

SPEAKER_00Again, I almost want to chuckle that's not really appropriate because this is a human being who genuinely seems to feel this way. And he's genuinely disturbed, right? So... I think that's the bigger piece, right? Like we're all in this, like, uh, we're all human beings in this world together and whether or not, you know, I don't know that anybody knows how things are going to unfold with any specificity.

SPEAKER_00There are going to be uncharted things. Just like under what Claude shared about emerging capabilities and how things emerge, there's an unfolding happening in our world that we're all witnessing and we're all part of, and it's going to affect all of us in one way or another. It already is affecting all of us, I think, in ways, whether we realize it or not. For me, I've had a really, I don't even know how to put words to it. I've had a very clear awakening to my role in some of these

things and what's next for me and how I can help people navigate some of this and come back to their heart

SPEAKER_00and what is fundamentally human and You know, really just work our way through whatever's coming, you know, as it comes. So I feel re-energized. I feel refreshed. But, you know, I appreciate that this is going to be an individual journey for everybody at some level. I mean, of course, part of that means we can just opt into believing whatever... our tribe or our chosen, you know, narrative is that's always out there just to kind of hand over your attention.

SPEAKER_00But, um, really that, that, that word attention is what it all comes back to even in the world of AI. And, um, you know, even when I listened to people are talking specifically, literally from an investment technology perspective, they're all talking about the attention economy. Um, And what I love is to me, there's a 100% overlap between what they're talking about in the attention economy and my perspective coming from both my technology background, but also a spiritual development background. The attention economy is what it's all about.

SPEAKER_00The thing about it is it's not about the quantity of attention. It's about the quality of attention. And That is so big and so deep and so real that I really don't have words for it right now. But if I can leave you with anything, and apologies, this video went way longer than I thought, but the quality of the attention that you bring to your life has profound

SPEAKER_00implications. on what happens for you in your life, but also what happens after the physical life. So there's so much that we may not be able to do about whatever's happening or not happening with AI, but there is, on the flip side of that, incredible vast array of things we can do to develop the quality of our attention and along with that to choose to apply or open that that

attention in the right directions at the right times in the right ways how we comport ourselves with the

SPEAKER_00matters that are of importance to us as individuals and So that's all on us. It's an inside job, so to speak. But I would love for everyone to know at some level of their being that this is something that everybody has capabilities within themselves to apply to that core area, that core opportunity of developing the quality of your awareness.

so much more to come on that i want to just express my love for everybody in what we're all working through and and doing and trying to accomplish for ourselves and those that we love in our lives and uh want to thank you for being with me today

SPEAKER_00and i look forward to chatting again very soon

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. When Impulses Arise, Awareness Is Key

    Sep 28, 202624 minAudio

    I have been working on sharing material about the nature of dreams for some time now. Expecting to publish that here on my Substack soon. Then just over a week ago, I had an unusually vivid dream about seeing a symbol...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Truth Will Unfold, As We Give It Space

    Nov 17, 202422 minAudio

    You’ll hear some familiar themes in this talk, about how consciousness is at the core of it all. Fundamentally, I’m asking how it may be that the relationships we have with one another might influence the way truth...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Are You a Good Witch or a Bad Witch?

    Jul 13, 202422 minAudio

    We all have positive and negative influences in our lives - both human and not-so-human. What if there is no 100% surefire way to only work with the “good” energies? What if the situation is far more dynamic? What if...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. What Role Should Non-Human Intelligence Play in the Realm of Human Healing?

    Jun 16, 202425 minAudio

    Do “aliens” heal people? What about angels? Demons? At a minimum, we’re already living in a world where AI is at work in our healthcare system without a great deal of transparency. Did we ask for that? This video...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Pull Yourself Together — How to Experience Heartful, Coherent Presence

    Jun 6, 202421 minAudio

    Where are you? Really and truly, where do you think your essence resides? When and where is it located? Or is it locationless? Better question - why does this even matter in the first place? While we may never have all...

    Credit the people on this episode