Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

River City Mystery - Investigating mysteries in southern Indiana, southern Illinois, and western Kentucky

River City Mystery - Investigating mysteries in southern Indiana, southern Illinois, and western Kentucky artwork

Who Killed Jean Cook?

Feb 5, 202527 minAudioEpisode 19
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Who Killed Jean Cook? In this episode, we revisit a painful local cold case: the murder of Georgia "Jean" Cook. On October 6, 2005, Jean, a 56-year-old mother of two, was working her shift as a manager at the former Busler's gas station on Highway 41 North in Evansville, Indiana. Three hours before the end of her shift, an armed intruder walked into the store, shot Jean twice, and fled after taking money from the register. Despite being mortally wounded, Jean managed to use her phone to call for help before passing away, leaving behind a family still searching for answers two decades later. The investigation was plagued by complications right from the start. The store surveillance system was not recording that day, leaving police without video footage of the killer. The primary lead comes from a customer pumping gas outside who reported seeing a white woman with bushy gray hair wearing dark clothing leave the store and drive away north on Highway 41 in a bluish-gray domestic sedan. However, there has been long-standing confusion over whether the shooter was actually a woman or a man wearing a wig or disguise, creating a major obstacle for investigators. This episode features conversations with two people close to the case. First, Jean's former coworker Andy Hinton shares his memory of the day, including receiving the distressing calls from Jean right after the shooting, and offers his perspective on what might have been happening at the store. Later, Jean's son Fred Cook talks about the toll the unsolved investigation has taken on their family, how quick access to major highways allowed the killer to vanish, and why he holds out hope that advancing technology or a lingering conscience might finally bring the truth to light. Someone out there knows what happened that morning on Highway 41. Take a listen to the episode, check out the composite sketch materials linked in the show notes, and jump into the Discord server to join the conversation and help keep Jean's memory alive. Show notes: https://www.rivercitymystery.com/19 Join the River City Mystery Discord server to meet others from the tri-state area who are into true crime and the paranormal. https://www.rivercitymystery.com/discord Other links: https://vanderburghsheriff.org/#send-a-tip-form https://www.14news.com/story/9134480/unsolved-murder-jean-cook/

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker: I was there at Saint Joe and Speaker: Diamond working, you know, mid Speaker: morning. Speaker: You know, my cell phone rings. Speaker: I don't recognize the number. Speaker: So this woman, I didn't Speaker: recognize her because she was Speaker: distressed. Speaker: Jean had already been shot and I Speaker: was the first contact on her Speaker: phone. Speaker: She she says this man come in and shot me.

Speaker: You're listening to River City Speaker: Mystery, a podcast that delves Speaker: into the Evansville and Speaker: surrounding Tri-State area's Speaker: mysteries, including unsolved Speaker: crimes, murders and Speaker: disappearances, a show that Speaker: isn't afraid to jump down the Speaker: rabbit hole to investigate Speaker: reports of local hauntings, Speaker: sightings of UAPs and cryptids, Speaker: among other paranormal Speaker: phenomena. Speaker: With your host law office worker by day. Speaker: Insomniac researcher of the unknown by night. Speaker: Matt Deig Speaker: It's been twenty years since

Speaker: Georgia Jean Cooke was shot to Speaker: death while working at the Speaker: Butler's on forty one North in Speaker: Evansville, Indiana. Speaker: Jean Cooke was a fifty six year old mother of two. Speaker: On October six, two thousand and five, she was just working a Speaker: shift to make ends meet. Speaker: Three hours to the end of her Speaker: shift, when someone wanders in Speaker: with a gun, shoots her twice, Speaker: leaves her on the floor to bleed Speaker: to death in the gas station Speaker: while they steal money out of Speaker: the register. Speaker: Absolutely senseless. Speaker: Leaving two children without a mother for whatever was in the

Speaker: register at the gas station. Speaker: Unbelievable. Speaker: And this person, twenty years later, is still on the loose. Speaker: They have not been caught. Speaker: They got away with it. Speaker: And to make matters worse, the Speaker: video surveillance wasn't Speaker: working at that location that Speaker: day. Speaker: So there's no video of this happening. Speaker: What we what we do have, however, is a witness statement. Speaker: There was a man pumping gas at the time of the shooting, and he Speaker: says he saw a white woman with bushy gray hair about forty five

Speaker: to sixty years old, standing about five feet six inches tall Speaker: and wearing dark clothing. Speaker: He says that she got into a mid-size, bluish gray domestic Speaker: four door sedan and headed north on forty one. Speaker: That is the extent of our description of the killer. Speaker: There is an artist rendering of that description, and I've got Speaker: that in the show notes. Speaker: And I've also kind of played around with some AI programs. Speaker: So I converted that sketch into a real human might look like.

Speaker: So I've posted those as well because, you know, who knows, Speaker: maybe that might trigger somebody to recognize somebody, Speaker: but there really isn't much to go on there. Speaker: It's kind of a vague description of a woman, honestly. Speaker: And there actually were. Speaker: There's debate over whether it was a woman or a man in a wig or Speaker: in some sort of disguise. Speaker: And we're going to talk about that later in the episode. Speaker: But I speak with Andy Hinton, who actually spoke with Jean Speaker: after she was shot.

Speaker: She says, he shot me, so she thinks it was a man. Speaker: Or maybe just when you're shocked after you've been shot, Speaker: you don't think clearly. Speaker: But but she seemed to indicate that it was a man that had shot Speaker: her for some reason. Speaker: So speaking of Andy, he's. Speaker: He actually reached out to me and asked me to look into this Speaker: case a little bit. Speaker: So that's why it was brought to my attention. Speaker: Andy was friends with Jean, and it was a coworker of hers. Speaker: And after Jean was shot, Jean Speaker: actually called Andy's phone

Speaker: first. Speaker: And so Andy shares his insights into the case. Speaker: And you know what his thoughts are as well as that, the events Speaker: of that day. Speaker: I also speak with Fred Cook, who is the son of Jean cook, and he Speaker: shares some of his thoughts on this case as well. Speaker: I reached out to Bobby Jo, the daughter. Speaker: She's dealing with some medical issues right now, so she's just Speaker: not feeling well enough to be able to talk. Speaker: But the invitation is always open. Speaker: If Bobby Jew would ever, like in

Speaker: the future to speak about this Speaker: case with me, it's an open Speaker: invitation. Speaker: Just just reach out to me and we're on. Speaker: But first we have Andy Hinton, who again was Jane's coworker, Speaker: who received that call from Jean after she was shot. Speaker: This is my conversation with Andy. Speaker: Yeah. Speaker: So, you know, I worked with Jean Speaker: a couple years on Saint Jo and Speaker: Diamond, and she was a good Speaker: woman. Speaker: I mean, really sweet, family oriented.

Speaker: So we I guess Buster's was struggling with that, uh, Speaker: location up there at forty one in Old state. Speaker: So they had sent her up there to Speaker: kind of turn the store around, Speaker: you know? Speaker: You know, when you get a good Speaker: manager, you know, you can kind Speaker: of maybe if you're not making Speaker: any money, you can kind of make Speaker: it profitable. Speaker: Sure. Speaker: So they sent her up there and I don't even remember how long she Speaker: was up there for. Speaker: But this incident happened, you know, one day I was there at

Speaker: Saint Joe and Diamond working, you know, mid-morning. Speaker: You know, my cell phone rings Speaker: and I don't recognize the Speaker: number. Speaker: So this woman, I didn't Speaker: recognize her because she was Speaker: distressed. Speaker: Jean had already been shot, and Speaker: I was the first contact on her Speaker: phone. Speaker: You know, a you're the first one Speaker: to come up, you know, but I was Speaker: kind of her contact for a lot of Speaker: stuff within, you know, the Speaker: workplace.

Speaker: She she says this man come in and shot me. Speaker: I said, who is this? Speaker: You know, I didn't know who it was. Speaker: I couldn't tell it was Jean. Speaker: So. So I kind of listened in the Speaker: background and I hear Simona, I Speaker: thought it was just a prank Speaker: call. Speaker: And so I kind of share the phone around the office. Speaker: I said, does anybody recognize this number? Speaker: Nobody knew. Speaker: Nobody knew. Speaker: And finally, kind of hung up.

Speaker: Well, she ended up calling like three or four times. Speaker: And, and at that point, I don't know if you know, nobody knows. Speaker: I put people on the phone, pass the phone around. Speaker: Does anybody know what this is? Speaker: And she's not really making sense. Speaker: You know, she kind of moaning and whatever. Speaker: Like, you know, maybe if it was a landline, she may have just Speaker: said it on the counter. Speaker: Something like that. Speaker: So. And this is a long time ago, right? Speaker: You know, so whenever we had contacted each other, you know, Speaker: I was like, I'll try to recall, you know what I can.

Speaker: But anyway, later on, you know, I think kind of a little Speaker: disturbed, you know, not not thinking anything of it. Speaker: And, and we have the radio on Speaker: and we hear it over the radio Speaker: and we all kind of realized what Speaker: that that was Jean, that was Speaker: Jean. Speaker: She was calling us to say that she had been shot and, you know, Speaker: had some sort of emergency. Speaker: Wow. Speaker: Yeah. Speaker: And so you were the first contact on her phone. Speaker: So that's why you're she's probably punching away at Speaker: numbers on her phone and like, your name comes out probably

Speaker: the, the Saint Joe store pops up on the list there. Speaker: So she's just calling that over and over. Speaker: Yeah, this was my cell phone. Speaker: Your cell phone. Speaker: Okay. Speaker: Yeah. Speaker: And so you guys were were you Speaker: guys good friends or because you Speaker: had worked together, you had Speaker: said, yeah, yeah, we yeah, we, Speaker: yeah, we worked together for a Speaker: couple years there on Saint Speaker: Joe's. Speaker: Just really close my, my desk was real close to her, her Speaker: little desk and office. Speaker: And she did the paperwork and, and kind of manage the little Speaker: convenience store up there.

Speaker: And she had was friends with Speaker: everyone, no enemies that no Speaker: one's ever reported there being Speaker: any enemies or anything like Speaker: that. Speaker: It sounds like no doubt at all. Speaker: She, she knew a lot of people on the West Side. Speaker: I think she lived off of Rexing Speaker: Road somewhere, um, for a while Speaker: and, uh, no, no, she everyone Speaker: loved her. Speaker: And, uh, she's a good woman. Speaker: Was she the type? Speaker: I mentioned this on my discord server, and we were just, we Speaker: were just kind of tossing around ideas and brainstorming before, Speaker: you know, talking to you. Speaker: And some people thought, well, was she the type to if she had

Speaker: overheard or maybe witnessed something she shouldn't have at Speaker: that gas station? Speaker: Was there any sort of drug activity or anything that she Speaker: might have witnessed and maybe threatened to go to the police Speaker: or say, hey, I'm going to call a tip in or something like, would Speaker: there have been possibly some sort of weird activity going on Speaker: that she might have overheard? Speaker: Well, you know, there's a story here, right, Matt? Speaker: And and I don't know how much did I know to be true? Speaker: Okay, so I don't know that I want to comment on anything

Speaker: that's not factual. Speaker: Sure. Speaker: But I do know that it was a different time at that point. Speaker: You know, gas stations and Speaker: convenience stores and Speaker: drugstores sold pseudoephedrine, Speaker: right. Speaker: You know, which is used to make methamphetamine, right? Speaker: Correct. Speaker: Yeah. Speaker: And, um, we, you know, all the, Speaker: all the gas stations did, we Speaker: weren't doing something that Speaker: anyone else wasn't doing at the Speaker: time. Speaker: And at the time, I think if I Speaker: could recall this because I

Speaker: didn't have anything to do with Speaker: the convenience store side of Speaker: things, I ran more of the oil Speaker: company side. Speaker: Okay. Speaker: So I believe the laws were like, Speaker: maybe you could buy two boxes a Speaker: day. Speaker: Mhm. Speaker: I don't really know, to be honest with you, I don't know. Speaker: We had a woman that kind of managed that whole program. Speaker: Her name was Nancy Markham. Speaker: She kind of managed the gas stations. Speaker: And then Charlie Wolfinger, he was the president and he which Speaker: Charlie is a he was the next sheriff, uh, deputy. Speaker: Okay. Speaker: At one point. Speaker: So he's very he was very

Speaker: knowledgeable on the on the Speaker: case. Speaker: Right. Speaker: He was working really close with the authorities. Speaker: Um, because I, I think he still sworn in as a, as a deputy. Speaker: So you might reach out to him because he knows more facts on Speaker: the case than I do. Speaker: But anyway, back to the pseudoephedrine. Speaker: So you kind of got some shady characters coming in. Speaker: Mhm. Speaker: You know, I think you could buy a couple bucks a day. Speaker: I, you know, you had to record it, put their names down. Speaker: So there's a record of who's buying this stuff.

Speaker: And I always suspected that it had something to do with that. Speaker: Okay. Speaker: Like, so someone might have been pretending to be someone else to Speaker: get maybe a bigger supply and then possible maybe she Speaker: recognized that person and said, hey, you're so and so. Speaker: But it didn't. Speaker: She didn't say that on the phone call, though. Speaker: She said, I've been robbed by. Speaker: Well, no, she said, I've been shot. Speaker: I've been shot. Speaker: But a man came in here and shot me. Speaker: And I know that you know, which is crazy because everybody has Speaker: been looking for a woman, right?

Speaker: Uh, it could have been a a man with a wig. Speaker: I, I don't know, but she had said a man had come in and shot Speaker: me from her own work. Speaker: Looking through some old newspaper articles, there was a Speaker: witness who I guess came in the store after she was shot and Speaker: called nine hundred eleven. Speaker: Apparently he was able to ask Speaker: one question, the article said, Speaker: and it said it was this a Speaker: robbery? Speaker: And she says yes. Speaker: And that was literally all he could get out of her. Speaker: You know, if she's struggling to Speaker: talk and maybe disoriented or Speaker: something. Speaker: Sure, sure, I don't know. Speaker: But that's what she told that person.

Speaker: And, you know, and I guess they saw a woman with curly hair and Speaker: forty, forty five to sixty years old, you know, leave putting Speaker: something in her purse. Speaker: But she told you it was a man. Speaker: Like you said, if you're shot, you're maybe you're not making a Speaker: whole lot of sense. Speaker: Eyewitness is going to be a better, a better, um, you know, Speaker: than a phone call. Speaker: You know, eyewitness is better testimony, I guess. Speaker: Well, I mean, it just sounds Speaker: like there's confusion all Speaker: around. Speaker: I mean, because the police don't Speaker: even know if they're looking for Speaker: a male or a female or, you know, Speaker: somebody in disguise or what the

Speaker: motive was. Speaker: And I guess that's how this person has remained so elusive Speaker: for all these years. Speaker: And unfortunately, it sounds like she when she started the Speaker: day she had left the video surveillance running all night. Speaker: So when she got to the store, she actually turned it. Speaker: She thought she was turning it on and apparently she was Speaker: turning it off. Speaker: So there was no surveillance, right? Speaker: I, I had heard something about that. Speaker: That's a little something Speaker: doesn't sound real, you know, Speaker: doesn't put past smell test is Speaker: what what some would say, you Speaker: know, you know, as far as I

Speaker: know, those were on continuous Speaker: loops. Speaker: I don't really remember the, the style they had, but I think it Speaker: was VHS at the time. Speaker: Okay. Speaker: Um, not really. Speaker: I don't think it was digital. Speaker: Um, but like I said, some other people, uh, like Charlie or Speaker: Nancy might even be able to know more than I would on that. Speaker: Did you ever know if they. Speaker: I can't find that they actually saw a license plate on this car Speaker: that drove up. Speaker: Apparently they saw a bluish Speaker: gray four door sedan drive off Speaker: heading north on forty one after Speaker: the. Speaker: The shooting. Speaker: But no one has ever mentioned if

Speaker: they had someone like caught a Speaker: glimpse of the license plate, I Speaker: wonder. Speaker: Right. Speaker: No, I have not heard that. Speaker: But you know, we're really close to sixty four. Speaker: You could go east or west and Speaker: and be gone in a matter of no Speaker: time. Speaker: So it could have been a random robbery. Speaker: It could have. Speaker: But with with the things that were going on up there. Speaker: I just don't think so. Speaker: And that was my short discussion with Andy, and I appreciate he Speaker: reached out to me to put this case on my radar very much. Speaker: And I did reach out to Charlie Wolfinger, the president of

Speaker: Bussler Enterprises, and he basically directed me to the Speaker: detective, Randy Chapman. Speaker: He said that Randy's going to know everything, have all the Speaker: answers to the questions I have. Speaker: So I went ahead and just went with the interview with Randy, Speaker: which is coming up here shortly. Speaker: And up next, we've got my interview with Fred Cook. Speaker: Now, Fred is Jean Cook's son, so Speaker: we get to hear his perspective Speaker: on what this case is like for Speaker: him and his thoughts on the Speaker: investigation and things along Speaker: those lines. Speaker: So this is my discussion with Fred.

Speaker: I guess to me, knowing where it happened at is probably why it Speaker: is not solved, because that is one major thoroughfare. Speaker: And with the limited amount of, Speaker: you know, back, back, I guess Speaker: obviously back then, even though Speaker: there was cameras there, there Speaker: was just not enough stopping Speaker: people stopping by there at that Speaker: little store. Speaker: You know, nowadays you see every convenience store around packed Speaker: on every corner. Speaker: But that one there was not, you Speaker: know, a very busy store with the Speaker: big ones just right down the Speaker: road. Speaker: Yeah. Speaker: And it was kind of isolated where it was too.

Speaker: It was kind of like it's in its Speaker: own little area there where Speaker: there wasn't a lot else around Speaker: there. Speaker: So, um, I guess it would be easy Speaker: for somebody to get in and out Speaker: of there. Speaker: Now, there were a couple of witnesses who saw the person Speaker: coming out, they say. Speaker: And there's been kind of conflicting information about Speaker: that as well. Speaker: Like, was it a man or a woman? Speaker: Somebody in disguise? Speaker: Yep. Speaker: That's the that's all that's been the one that's bothered me Speaker: the most is it's went back and forth between whether it was a Speaker: man, whether it was a woman. Speaker: It was a gray haired. Speaker: It was an older.

Speaker: Nobody really knew. Speaker: You know, there were speculations of the car. Speaker: So, you know, it's hard, you know, and you think about it Speaker: every time you drive by there. Speaker: Now that it's an empty lot, what Speaker: was missed, what could have been Speaker: found and what could have been Speaker: seen had it not happened right Speaker: there? Speaker: But yeah, everything that I talked to, whenever I was Speaker: talking to the detectives on it, you know, I would get phone Speaker: calls and of course, reach out. Speaker: You know, in the days that Speaker: pretty much took place after Speaker: that, in the weeks, you know, Speaker: then, you know, as I said, you Speaker: know, it's like, hey, you know, Speaker: we'll, we'll reach out if we get Speaker: something promising.

Speaker: Um, you know, they, they Speaker: traveled, they went to a lot of Speaker: places. Speaker: I mean, there was even there was a lead even down under the Speaker: bridge under the twin bridges that we actually I actually got Speaker: to travel with down there. Speaker: And just to kind of see at the same time and it was, you know, Speaker: there was even that close of one, they went down, they looked Speaker: for a specific vehicle that was supposed to be down there. Speaker: And so they went down, checked out one of the trailers that was Speaker: down there, and it led out to be nothing at all.

Speaker: But there was all kinds of people talking, you know, Speaker: certain people that were in jail talked about it, and they tried Speaker: to get their way out of it, but it turned out to be nothing. Speaker: And we would get phone calls on it all the time. Speaker: So, hey, this is what we're going on. Speaker: This is what we're hearing. Speaker: You know, we're going to go check this out. Speaker: This could be a possibility. Speaker: This person was in the area. Speaker: This person knew it. Speaker: But over the years it all faded out and then nothing has really Speaker: transpired again after that. Speaker: And then, you know, I pretty much talked to all of them until Speaker: they, I guess, have transferred cases to different detectives

Speaker: over the time. Speaker: And because detectives have retired and so forth. Speaker: Like what? Speaker: What do you think happened? Speaker: Like if you had to put all your Speaker: money in one on one bet, like Speaker: who do you what do you think Speaker: actually happened? Speaker: I mean, I would I mean, I would have to say it was a random one Speaker: off, uh, at this point because, you know, I don't, I honestly Speaker: don't know why or who or anybody like that in their nature would Speaker: do that again. Speaker: But it was such a secluded, small convenience store that Speaker: would make it easy for somebody to go in and do something.

Speaker: I, you know, I don't, I honestly Speaker: don't know why or how, but Speaker: that's the only thing I can come Speaker: up with. Speaker: I don't I mean, never to my knowledge, you know, across the Speaker: board, my mom never had no enemies across the board at all. Speaker: You know, she was an older lady just working to make ends meet Speaker: and survive like everybody else does, you know, and yeah, it Speaker: doesn't sound like she had anybody who had anything out for Speaker: her or anything like that. Speaker: I mean, one thing you wonder if maybe she had staggered upon a

Speaker: transaction she shouldn't have seen or something. Speaker: And maybe somebody tried to make sure she wouldn't have gone to Speaker: the police with it or something, I don't know. Speaker: I mean, you have to just get creative at some point and say, Speaker: you know what in the world? Speaker: But like you said, sometimes maybe it's just a random thing Speaker: where some lunatic took advantage of a situation and Speaker: wanted to rob her cash register, you know, and that's the only Speaker: thing that I can come up with, you know, there's no rhyme or Speaker: reason to it. Speaker: I could, I do not for the life Speaker: of me, I've ran every possible Speaker: scenario through my own head, I Speaker: bet. Speaker: Yeah. Speaker: Trying to figure it out, you know, and, you know, I never Speaker: even got to talk to her. Speaker: I mean, by the time I, you know,

Speaker: by the time I was at the Speaker: hospital, she was already to the Speaker: point of not being able to Speaker: communicate. Speaker: And so that was kind of where, you know, it would be nice to Speaker: have been able to say, hey, what did you see? Speaker: Give me something. Speaker: Talk to me. Speaker: But you got to think about it. Speaker: Even by that time, they're Speaker: within a twenty minute span, Speaker: down forty one to sixty four in Speaker: any direction. Speaker: Oh yeah, that's a lot of miles covered for anything nowadays. Speaker: if you look at every single Speaker: convenience store and grocery Speaker: store and campus, there is a

Speaker: camera on every light pole gas Speaker: pump. Speaker: I mean, you're not. Speaker: Every vehicle is scanned. Speaker: And one of the things that has always been brought to mind is Speaker: if you're standing there pumping gas and something was to happen, Speaker: would you be able to identify even two vehicles around you in Speaker: the drop of a hat? Speaker: Probably not. Speaker: So that question always comes up Speaker: is that's one of the things, you Speaker: know. Speaker: I mean, my wife would even be one to tell you too. Speaker: I said, I never said with my Speaker: back to the door anywhere I'm Speaker: at, I always look out to where I

Speaker: can see what's going on around Speaker: me. Speaker: It's something that I've always done my whole life, and I'm Speaker: always diligent about what's going on around me. Speaker: I still say to this day that even if somebody walked up to me Speaker: while I was pumping gas, as soon as I got done and put the gas Speaker: pump up guy in the car, they said, can you tell me what car Speaker: was left and right of you? Speaker: I would, even though it's as diligent as I am about it, I Speaker: would probably say, could you draw a blank? Speaker: Instantly you draw a blank almost as soon as somebody Speaker: corners you with it. Speaker: But then you also feel like you should know. Speaker: So does your brain, like, fill in the gaps and say, oh, it was

Speaker: a four door bluish gray something or another. Speaker: And it's like, oh, yeah. Speaker: Then you, you remember trying to Speaker: remember that and like, it's Speaker: like a false memory kind of a Speaker: thing. Speaker: So that's one of the, that's, Speaker: that's one of the things about Speaker: it. Speaker: It does, I mean, you're always, you think, you know, just with Speaker: that one, I think they even try to do some hypnosis on some of Speaker: the people that were there. Speaker: Yeah. Speaker: To try to bring them to try to get them to do a little memory Speaker: because they did. Speaker: I knew that's what one of the detectives said. Speaker: He goes, we're going to try to do hypnosis, see if they can't Speaker: bring back some of the subconscious to see if they can Speaker: bring back some memories and some of that. Speaker: And and that was pretty short after, you know, while

Speaker: everything was still fresh. Speaker: Yeah. Speaker: They didn't lead up to nothing. Speaker: It might just be something they never released, but it seems Speaker: like there's a lot of questions and it's just not a lot of Speaker: answers in your mom's case. Speaker: So it's like, not at all. Speaker: And it went, it just went quiet. Speaker: You know, I feel like they knew. Speaker: I feel like they chased every ghost that they could chase. Speaker: I think they and I don't know how detectives work, but, you Speaker: know, I'd like to think that it's always still sitting on Speaker: somebody's desk when there ain't something going on. Speaker: It's like, hey, let's dig back into this for a little while and Speaker: see what we can come up with.

Speaker: Yeah, a lot of times something has to happen. Speaker: Like somebody cracks in a, you Speaker: know, somebody gets arrested and Speaker: it turns out that they end up Speaker: telling one of their cellmates Speaker: something else that leads to Speaker: something else. Speaker: And then it kind of breaks everything wide open. Speaker: So that just apparently hasn't Speaker: happened yet, but fingers Speaker: crossed that something does Speaker: happen and they find this Speaker: person. Speaker: Those conversations have been had, too, about the fact that Speaker: they're waiting on, you know, this, that usually the bad Speaker: people are usually end up either in a bar in jail and start Speaker: talking, he says. Speaker: And then when you get that person start talking, that

Speaker: usually leads to this other person saying, this is my Speaker: opportunity to get out of here. Speaker: I'm going to say something. Speaker: I was told that by the Speaker: detectives once because we're Speaker: just kind of waiting on that Speaker: break. Speaker: My thinking is that maybe, you Speaker: know, in twenty years have Speaker: passed. Speaker: So I was thinking maybe somebody who might have thought a certain Speaker: way twenty years ago might have had a change of heart and been Speaker: like, you know, I didn't want to say anything back then. Speaker: Somebody did say something. Speaker: But I'm in a different point in my life now, and I think I'm Speaker: going to come forward. Speaker: Um, because you never know, somebody just might not want to Speaker: mess with the police and they, but they do know something

Speaker: that's kind of important. Speaker: So. Speaker: Right. Speaker: And, you know, they may think Speaker: it's going to end up putting Speaker: them in a position where they Speaker: think they're going to get in Speaker: trouble. Speaker: And exactly. Speaker: Because you just, you know, just Speaker: like you said, nobody ever Speaker: really knows what they can and Speaker: cannot say, you know, so it's Speaker: always just kept in the back of Speaker: their mind. Speaker: But you figure conscience would eat at you after a while, right? Speaker: Especially the older you get, maybe you start. Speaker: You'd think so. Speaker: Some people. Speaker: But I mean, usually these people aren't brilliant. Speaker: So they say something to the wrong person and just somebody Speaker: has to come forward. Speaker: Somebody knows something you would think is my guess.

Speaker: So it's just a matter of time Speaker: or, you know, something that Speaker: could happen is the person was Speaker: arrested for something else and Speaker: may just be sitting in jail or Speaker: something else and just never, Speaker: you know, nobody ever connected Speaker: the dots. Speaker: I guess we just never know that to them, just keeping it to Speaker: themselves the whole time. Speaker: Like, I'll take this to my grave and I'm not worried about it. Speaker: I feel horrible for you guys, and I just you've always been on Speaker: my mind for the last twenty years, and I remember seeing the Speaker: billboards of your mom up, and it's just hopefully putting the Speaker: spotlight on your mom's case helps out in some way. Speaker: Just gets it out there and gets people talking about it again.

Speaker: Yeah, I mean, I hope so. Speaker: I mean, and I'm, you know, I'm glad you reached out. Speaker: I appreciate it. Speaker: And I've had news people call Speaker: multiple times and you know, in Speaker: the news is one thing, um, you Speaker: know, it does get out there, but Speaker: sometimes, I mean, they, they Speaker: battered it pretty hard during Speaker: that and they did their job and Speaker: so on. Speaker: But you know, sometimes they're just looking to fill in time and Speaker: it's like, you know, it's just not all about that, right? Speaker: You know, I'm more interested in more of a casual situation. Speaker: If I'm going to discuss it, just kind of let it be at that. Speaker: And my sister, she is in a bad way right now.

Speaker: So she, she fought it for a long time. Speaker: She, she stayed diligent with it for, for a very long time, you Speaker: know, trying to keep it up. Speaker: I mean, you can only put so much Speaker: energy into something before it Speaker: starts affecting your own health Speaker: and well-being. Speaker: And it's like, you know, you have to kind of, you know, I Speaker: can't imagine being having a family member, you know, lose a Speaker: family member like that to have to deal with that in any way, Speaker: shape or form. Speaker: So and you hope that the law, you know, and you leave your, Speaker: you know, you leave the side of it to the law to make sure they Speaker: do their job. Speaker: That's what they're trying to do every day. Speaker: Just like people are trained to do a lot of things, you, you

Speaker: reach out to professionals and say, hey, you know, this is all Speaker: in you guys. Speaker: So but again, that one right there, just like probably many Speaker: others that go unfound every day, every year, it's like Speaker: finding a needle in a haystack unless it's just cut and dry. Speaker: And so, you know, I give them I'm glad they're out there. Speaker: I'm glad they did what they did, and I'm glad they're doing what Speaker: they're doing at this point for this one and for many others. Speaker: Yeah, just to, you know, they Speaker: have their work cut out for Speaker: them. Speaker: Yeah. Speaker: The thing is, the technology is always improving. Speaker: So their ability to connect the dots is always made easier with

Speaker: the technology, I think. Speaker: So maybe something will happen Speaker: somewhere else and that'll Speaker: trigger something in a system Speaker: where they'll be like, oh, wait Speaker: a minute. Speaker: And you know, having that Speaker: building gone, I feel like Speaker: sometimes probably put a hurt to Speaker: that. Speaker: Yeah. Speaker: Um. Oh, no. Granted, it hasn't been gone for terribly long, but Speaker: going back up there and being able to step over everything, Speaker: maybe even with the technology, maybe figuring out that there Speaker: was something going on with the cameras and they were actually Speaker: recording and they and they just didn't see it. Speaker: You know, nowadays you could

Speaker: have probably pulled that out Speaker: and maybe seen, you know, who Speaker: knows? Speaker: There's all there's a lot of that if ands and buts. Speaker: Yeah. Speaker: That trail back across the board to, you know, we'll see. Speaker: Maybe, you know, maybe you Speaker: throwing this out there might Speaker: actually, you know, stim it up a Speaker: little bit again and get people Speaker: just like you said, talking, Speaker: looking around and questioning Speaker: things. Speaker: And that is one of the main goals of my podcast is to bring Speaker: a spotlight on some of these cold cases that people are not Speaker: talking about, just to kind of stir up the conversation again.

Speaker: And cases like Jean Cook's that Speaker: have been sitting there for Speaker: twenty years and hopefully maybe Speaker: somebody sees this and maybe Speaker: recognizes a picture or Speaker: something, and it might start a Speaker: conversation that leads to Speaker: something. Speaker: That's the goal anyway. Speaker: And if you have any information Speaker: on the murder of Jean cook, Speaker: contact the Vanderburgh County Speaker: Sheriff's Department at eight Speaker: one two four six one six two Speaker: zero zero. Speaker: Andy Lasher is the detective Speaker: currently working on Jean's Speaker: case? Speaker: You can submit an anonymous tip on the Vanderburgh County

Speaker: Sheriff's Department website, and I've got a link for that Speaker: down in the show notes. Speaker: I want to thank Fred and Andy for taking the time out to talk Speaker: to me today, and hopefully we're one step closer to solving this Speaker: case and bringing some closure to the family. Speaker: I want to thank everybody for Speaker: listening, and until next time, Speaker: take care.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Rose Hotel

    Nov 2, 202630 minAudio

    In this episode, Matt speaks with author and veteran paranormal investigator, Bruce Cline. Bruce shares his incredible journey from starting Southern Illinois' first paranormal club, the Gaslight Ghoul Club, out of his...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Heralds of the Ascendant

    Oct 29, 202642 minAudio

    Is the Heralds of the Ascendant a dangerous cult in southern Illinois or just a misunderstood pagan community? In this episode, Matt speaks directly with the group's anonymous founder, "the Prophet," to learn more about...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Kratzville Phantom

    Oct 13, 202610 minAudio

    In January 1916, the rural farming community of Kratzville, Indiana, was gripped by fear when residents began spotting a mysterious, glowing ball of fire floating through Earl Goldsmith’s farm and the surrounding...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Plum Tree Murder

    Sep 28, 202612 minAudio

    On Halloween night in 1925, an Evansville couple returned home to a nightmare. They found a stranger hanging from a plum tree in their front yard. The victim was a 35-year-old factory worker and World War I veteran who...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Disappearance of Debra Ann Wilhite

    Jun 29, 202648 minAudio

    The Disappearance of Debra Ann Wilhite On October 14, 1974, 19-year-old Debra Ann "Debbie" (Pfettscher) Wilhite finished her shift as a waitress at the Windmill Restaurant on Highway 41 in Evansville, Indiana. She was...

    Credit the people on this episode