
✦ In The Belly of the Whale
The film above, entitled “Enigma” was one of the more experimental short films our team at (circle) studios made out of the diverse perspectives represented aboard the crossing. We’re six days into a ten-day voyage across the Atlantic, navigating massive swells, and I’m conducting an interview in a commandeered cabin while the ship pitches violently beneath us. The man across from me is Boniface, a Kenyan activist released from jail just weeks ago, brought here by a coalition that rallied for his freedom. Tomorrow I’ll film an indigenous elder discussing how he and his people did the impossible - came back from near erasure. The day after, a financial economist explaining how a single living whale is worth $2 million in carbon sequestration. This is not a normal documentary project. Last fall, over twelve days, a small team and I documented an experiment that shouldn’t have worked: 400 humans from radically different worlds trapped together on a chartered ship crossing from Lisbon to Puerto Rico. Indigenous elders, crypto technologists, climate scientists, refugees, activists, industrialists. 125 of them were Fellows: practitioners and experts selected not despite their differences but because of them. Funded by patrons who believed the future depends on unlikely people solving problems together. The crossing was organized by a nascent alliance of “optimistic pragmatists” called Earth One, brought together to navigate civilizational frontiers. Bear, the founder, put it: There’s a threshold that needs to be crossed, and that threshold cannot be crossed by one group of people. It has to be a group of people representing the full tapestry of humanity … [but] once that foundation of trust is truly built, which is hard, it takes a lot of work and is a constantly evolving process - from there, miracles can happen. Our team of eight on the story team showed up as volunteers for what turned out to be a massive undertaking. Twenty-five long-form interviews, atmospheric documentation, drone capture floating above the ship in the middle of the ocean, an all-night edit sprint to create a live performance blending film and music. What I witnessed changed how I think about how we coordinate - not just our work, but our becoming. (ritual) creative is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. The isolation we’re not naming Our modern predicament: You’re on your third Zoom of the day. Everyone’s a thumbnail. The meeting ends and you’re alone with the weight of what you’re building. You want more than project partners. You want crew. People who’ll call out your blind spots, hold you accountable to becoming more than you are. But that’s not available to many of us freelancer, multi-hyphenate creators who have eschewed the traditional 9-5. So you keep grinding. Alone. Brilliant minds in adjacent fields solve related problems but never connect. Resources pool in one domain while another starves. Solutions discovered in one context could transform another, but the bridge never gets built. But there’s something deeper: We’re isolated in our becoming. Addressing civilizational challenges from an atomized position, carrying the weight alone, wondering if we’re growing or just grinding ourselves down. An old idea, a new frame: Guildcraft A dear friend and designer, Carson, and I had both been on a journey exploring systems change and new models for collaboration as we worked through this familiar angst. We’d been in inquiry around what it means to work together in association when there’s no real structure that fits. We didn’t just want to be part of a community. We weren’t ready to start a company. We felt there was another way to think about the relationships we wanted: to be creating together, but also supporting one another on each of our sovereign paths of growth. That’s when we started exploring guilds. Historically, guilds focused on supporting members deepening in their craft through apprenticeship models, while also providing common advocacy for the collective. We wanted to preserve this notion of being on a developmental journey, but not just in craft. Also in our becoming. The ethical dimensions. The spiritual dimensions. And we wanted to emphasize co-creation, not just the singular pursuit of excellence. The question became: What can we build together in the interstitial spaces between my gifts and your gifts? This became the dual commitment at the heart of what we were calling Guildcraft: // Co-creative: Making things together. Working on real solutions. Shipping outcomes. // Co-developmental: Supporting each other’s growth. Tending the inner work. Calling out blind spots with care. Recognizing you can’t transform the world without addressing what needs transforming within yourself. Traditional collaboration stops at co-creative. We make things, ship outcomes, move fast, get it done. But we’re not machines. When we pretend otherwise, we burn out. We hollow out. We produce competent work that has no soul. What if we brought the whole human into our collaborations? What if we cared about each other’s growth as much as the project? What if we created structure that actually holds us, challenges us, supports us, calls us forward, instead of just extracting outcomes? When Carson and another friend Bear Kittay started working on Earth One, they realized this could be an opportunity to test the framework at scale. They decided to organize the entire voyage around six guilds. The prospect of documenting it all felt like a waking dream. The ship as pressure cooker We departed November 3rd, 2024, traveling a former slave route. Not as metaphor. As fact. This specific path carried ships loaded with human cargo for centuries. Three days later, crossing the mid-Atlantic in international waters, the U.S. presidential election results came in. No algorithms curating reality. No unfollowing people you disagreed with. Just 400 humans from radically different worlds and vast ocean in every direction. 👆🏽A short clip we cut while on the crossing; it includes footage of the ceremony that initiated our voyage in Lisbon; a powerful inversion of an old story, as indigenous elders from many traditions led the way. The clip of Tom (one of the elders) repeats at the end; in the live performance it became a looped, sampled clip that merged with a live musical score. The whole thing was riddled with contradiction. A regenerative gathering on a resource-intensive cruise ship. Changemakers traveling a route that once carried enslaved people. Luxury accommodations for work focused on planetary healing. All of it happening when American democracy felt like it was tearing at the seams. Carson named it perfectly: “The future isn’t clean. The future isn’t going to be a binary shift into a new world. We’re mediating what is, and we’re shepherding it. This ship was crossing the ocean either way. It could have crossed empty, or with retirees. Or it could cross as a catalyst for a profound community to be born.” So we leaned into the paradox. Here’s what Earth One understood: If you don’t collapse the field, the tension between poles is generative. But without structures to hold the nuance and paradox, the field collapses into polarization. You get pulled into identification with one end of the spectrum. You make each other wrong. You other one another. The greatest achievement of the Atlantic crossing may have been creating a context where there could be generative friction between so many polarities. People from different backgrounds and political affiliations. Living inside these tensions and contradictions, not avoiding them, but increasing our capacity to be with them without making each other wrong. Earth One built three interlocking layers to hold it all: // The Guilds - Six domains organizing the work: Ocean, New Economies, Intelligences, Governance, Resilience, Biocultures. Each built around that dual commitment - co-creative and co-developmental. // The… Get full access to (ritual) creative at ritualcreative.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
