Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

RIA+

RIA+ artwork

The State of RIA M&A: Beyond the Numbers with Fidelity's Laura Delaney

Jul 1, 202440 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

In this episode of RIA+, Mark Bruno talks with Fidelity's Laura Delaney - one of the leading RIA M&A researchers - about dealmaking activity in the first half of 2024. While overall volume and valuations remain strong, this interview goes beyond the numbers and focuses on the drivers of successful M&A activity and uncovers what the RIA industry has collectively learned over the last five years - a period of record-breaking and transformational M&A.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Welcome to RIA Plus, a new podcast dedicated to understanding the drivers of growth and success at the upper end of the RIA industry. I'm your host, Mark Bruno, Managing Director and Head of Strategic Advisory at Emigrant Partners. I'm fortunate to have access to some of the most well-run and most strategic RAs in this industry. And with this new podcast and my new role at Emigrant, I'll be highlighting the stories and strategies of leaders who have created and empowered true independent enterprises in the wealth management industry. In this episode of RAA Plus, I sat down with Laura Velaney, Vice President of Practice Management, Consulting and Fidelity, who leads their MA research on the RAA industry.

SPEAKER_00We looked at overall MA activity, deal volume and valuations in the first half of 2024, but more importantly, we went beyond the numbers and talked about the strategic shifts in RAA deal making. With more options than ever before, we explored how sellers can best prepare for a potential deal, both at a personal and business level, and how they can best attest cultural fit and alignment. Enjoy episode 12 of RAA Plus.

SPEAKER_00Welcome to RAA Plus. It's Mark Bruno, managing director and head of the strategic advisory team at Emigrant Partners. I can't believe it, but we're already up to episode 12 of RAA Plus. Time really does fly by when you're talking to really smart people who do really interesting things in the RAA community. And that is no exception with our special guest here today, Laura Delaney, Vice President, practice management consulting at Fidelity. Thank you so much for being here. I appreciate it.

SPEAKER_01Really, thank you so much for having me. I'm super excited to be here.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, the timing is perfect. The topic is perfect. And what else could we talk about, right? But MA in wealth management in the RAA space more specifically. Laura, you were at our Emigrant Partners Leadership Summit back in April, presented to the group there, talked through some of the MA activity, but more specifically, some of the drivers and the fundamentals of what's going on in our space. Thought it was really, really powerful. And I don't just say that. I've done research on MA, and there's a lot of research out there.

SPEAKER_00You go well beyond the numbers. So we felt it was really, really important to have you on here and give sort of a state of the state. Also thrilled that you know we're about a day away from the release of your new data. So what we're talking about is as fresh as it gets here. So thank you for making us one of the first here at RA Plus. Appreciate it.

SPEAKER_01Oh, I'm honored to be here. Thank you so much. Looking forward to it.

SPEAKER_00So before we get into the nuts and bolts of MA, what you're seeing, you know, most importantly, really how our listeners might be thinking a little bit differently around, you know, what's ahead. We'd love to just kind of start with your story a bit. Yeah, obviously everybody knows Fidelity in this space. Most people who listen are probably familiar with the research that you do on MA. But maybe you could start just by telling us a little bit about your role at Fidelity, how you work with the various Fidelity RIAs and how you got to focus on this crazy world of RIA MA.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, thanks. I'm happy to. I've been in the industry for 25 years. Uh I started way back at a firm that doesn't exist anymore due to merger. Uh, and then I had a 16-year career at a competitor custodian before finding my way here at Fidelity. And I've been in the role for almost two years, and time really does fly. But I was a succession plan for somebody who had retired. His name was Scott Slater. I know a lot of people in the industry remember him. He had built a great program. So I was thrilled to come in and do some really good things with the program going forward.

SPEAKER_01But yeah, that's that's where I sit. I'm a business consultant. I focus on MA pretty much all day. Um we have fantastic research here at Fidelity. We do pull from public sources. We work with some great teams, with research teams, marketing teams, communications teams. So it really does take a village to put out the reporting that we do. But in it really speaks volumes because, as you said, data and numbers sort of, you know, drive discussion, but it's it's thinking beyond that. What's really driving these numbers?

SPEAKER_01What are what why are things happening the way they are? And what trends are we seeing because of that? So that's my role.

SPEAKER_00It's great. It's uh great work that you do. I can say being at Emigrant Partners now and having access to all the different MA reports that are out there and using them on a regular basis to just inform our thinking, right? To stay, make sure that we're staying on top of and sort of educating our partner firms, right, around what's happening in the MA world. Thank you for what you do. Appreciate it. And really looking forward to kind of learning a little bit more about what you think is ahead, right? In the I can't believe I'm about to say second half of 2024.

SPEAKER_01It's going fast.

SPEAKER_00It is the last day of school today for my kids, right? So we are turning the page on something. Yeah, as I look at some of the data that you've put out, I think we've been saying for what feels like five or six years now, every year we'll be close to or a new record level of MA activity, right? I think it's safe to say, and feel free to disagree with me, but I think it's safe to say that after 10, 11, 12 years of record activity levels or near record, MA is here to stay.

SPEAKER_01For sure.

SPEAKER_00Agree or disagree.

SPEAKER_01Oh, totally agree. And I think there's reasons behind that. There's very fundamental reasons for MA in our industry specifically. And it's funny because I was sitting next to a gentleman on a plane uh earlier this week when I was coming back from uh DC to do an event. Um, and he he asked me, because we started talking about what we do for a living, and he asked me, why do you see MA, you know, declining? And he just assumed that MA in our world and wealth management was declining because it isn't his, right? We're seeing interest rates that are high, we're seeing cost of capital, we're seeing inflation, all the things.

SPEAKER_01And I actually said, you know, in wealth management, it's quite the opposite. It's strong and it's continuing to remain strong because of those fundamental reasons, which are really the fragmentation of our industry. We really have more firms forming each year than are being acquired. So that's one of them. We have capital backers who are very excited about the space. They're coming in, they're seeing the recurring revenue of our firms, they're seeing the stickiness of clients, and again, the fragmentation of the industry.

SPEAKER_01And then there's reasons for from one firm owners to really want to get a transaction underway. And that's really falls into three buckets. It's either number one, clients are not expecting less of me, they're expecting more. So, how do I increase my set of services that I can't do here naturally, maybe I'm beyond where we can do within our four walls? So, increased set of services is number one. Number two is look, I've I built this business, but it takes me away from working with clients on things like all important things, legal compliance, HR, cybersecurity, all those important things take me away from really doing what I love to do.

SPEAKER_01And I want to get back to that. So, how can a firm sort of uh hate to use the word offload, but you know, offload those things from my plate? And then lastly, geez, you know, I'm not getting any younger and nobody here is 40% per surreality data, 40% of advisors are expected to leave the industry in some way in the next 10 years. So succession planning is still a huge issue and MA can be a solve for that. So until those reasons going up go away, and until capital backers stop being excited about our industry, we're going to continue to see MA.

SPEAKER_01It's going to remain very strong.

SPEAKER_00No question about that. And I think the way you just summarized the fundamental drivers, right? It helps us as an industry collectively, those who are who are participating in every day probably see this already, but just have the general understanding that it's not a trend. It is now part of the maturation, right, of this channel in particular. Obviously, there's been a tremendous amount of growth. So you might expect to see more. I don't even like using the word consolidation, right? Because the industry is so fragmented that it would take at this pace decades to really truly be consolidated.

SPEAKER_00That being said, though, for where we are now in June of 2024, you know, obviously MA activity levels have stayed strong, you know, valuations have stayed strong. I am curious kind of where you see things trending. And if you can maybe go a layer down from the top, right? How is MA activity different today, right, than it may have been, say, a year or two ago, right? And how will that play out over the remainder of this year?

SPEAKER_01For sure. Yeah. So we have seen record breaking, to your point, record breaking activity year after year after year until 2023. And 2023, we saw 227 RIA MA transactions versus 2022, we counted 230 RAA MA transactions. So I'm not saying we're 3% off. I'm saying we're three transactions off, right? So literally three transactions. I'll name names because this is all public information, but Pure Financial came out in February of this year and they said, hey, we closed three deals that were really for uh 2023.

SPEAKER_01So there you go. Did we tie a record? Sure. And then other strategic acquirers tell me that they purposely don't announce every one of their deals at the request of the seller. So do we break a record? I'm gonna say off paper, absolutely. On paper, you know, geez, three transactions off. So that's where we were. And in terms of where we're going and then and what we've seen in Q1, we hit 50 transactions in Q1, not record-breaking levels, not record-breaking activity. We're now at the end of May, 86 transactions in.

SPEAKER_01And May, we had 33, 33 billion in assets. So I'm calling the start to 2024. And geez, I can't even believe I'm saying start to 2024 because we're in June, but very purposeful. Strategic acquires coming in with a very good set of um goals and ambitions for the acquisitions that they're doing. I think that things like interest rates and inflation certainly do come into play, but we're financial planners, right? That's what we do for a living. So I think everybody's planning for these high interest rates and planning for the interest rates to stay where they are for a little bit.

SPEAKER_01And we saw the Fed come out, I believe it was yesterday, saying that they there maybe just be one cut this year. So I think we we're all planning for that. But we're at a very purposeful start. It's very solid. And one more thing, when you're saying about the sort of decades before we could become consolidated, I actually did the math. And at the run rate where we're going, if we say about 230 to 250 transactions a year, it's gonna take us at least 50 years. It's five oh years before we're at a place of consolidation.

SPEAKER_01And that's still leaving about 4,000-ish firms out there. There is, I think, a ton of opportunity. It's still very competitive on the buy side. And yeah, it like I said, until these fundamental reasons go away, I I really think MA is going to continue to be strong.

SPEAKER_00I love that. And that that will 100% be the stat of the day, and not just because I sort of did back of the envelope math in my head and proved to be right.

SPEAKER_01Right, exactly.

SPEAKER_00I mean, I think it's uh it's a really telling statistic around you know, just how much you know fragmentation there is in our industry right now, and how much there is, quite frankly, to learn still. And what I mean by that is I'm just gonna give a quick story and I'll sort of ask the for your perspective. When I was at investment news, overseeing our research probably about 10 years or so ago, we had launched a bunch of databases, advisors on the move, the broker dealer data center, and then we launched the deal tracker.

SPEAKER_00And that was intended to basically take any time there was a deal that was announced, put it in our database, and let's just track activity levels. I'd say within six months of launching it, we shut it down because there was no activity.

SPEAKER_01Interesting.

SPEAKER_00And if there was activity, it was like one deal a month. That being said, I wish we would have kept doing that because I think you can look back now, and there's a real track record. There have been thousands of transactions that have taken place in the last, say, 10 years. Question is, you know, what have we learned? And maybe more specifically, I'd love to get your take now that there is this track record, and we can look back and say a number of these deals have been successful, a number of these deals have not worked at all. But when you do look at the deals that were the most successful and the deals that are most likely to be successful moving forward, what have we learned right from the previous you know five to 10 years?

SPEAKER_00And how have buyers gotten smarter about you know doing deals and making them work?

SPEAKER_01That those are great questions. And and I think that because uh geez, you were cutting edge uh tracking all those number of years ago, but but I think because the data is more prominent and uh I think buyers and sellers are becoming more educated from the buy side, there's only a very specific cohort who have ever made two or more transactions, and that's 92 firms. 92 firms since we started tracking in 2015 have ever done two or more deals. So I think that they're becoming much more efficient at what they're doing.

SPEAKER_01In fact, our data tells us that too, because in our valuation and deal structure study, uh, it used to take nine months to get a deal done, and now it's down to about seven, seven point two, seven point five months to get a deal done. So that shows the efficiency. They uh strategic acquirers have the capital, they have the strategic teams, they have the strategy and the why going in. On the sell side, I also think that sellers are more educated. Um, I think that they're reading a lot more. There's a lot more coverage on MA and investment bankers, I think, are playing a prominent role as well.

SPEAKER_01I can't remember the stat offhand, but in our valuation deal structure study, I believe it was 68% of sellers were represented by an investment banker, which is good because it's an emotional thing to sell your firm. There's a ton of emotion that goes into it from even making the decision to sell and whether or not you're reacting to a phone call or you're proactively saying, hey, this is the best thing for our firm, all the way through LOI and all the way through the purchase agreement, the seller is going through a multitude of emotions. So when you're saying, you know, deals could go really well or deals might not have gone well, I really think it's because of the communication and of uh the seller doing the same level of due diligence as the buyer.

SPEAKER_01So uh I think you know, culture, we talk about culture all the time. That's it's certainly prominent. And culture really does need to be at the forefront because when things go well, everything's wonderful. And when things don't go well, how do you work together to solve a problem? But I really think from the the fundamentals of where we are and where we're going, it I do think it's the the level of information out there and the level of coverage out there and just education and the the representatives that are out there, like the investment bankers and the attorneys that are helping in this process.

SPEAKER_00Oh, absolutely. I think your point around the investment bankers, the percentage of you know firms that are working with with bankers, it's critical to have somebody to go to who is not as emotionally invested. Absolutely at all times. But you know, I I actually think you kind of touched on this subject of seller due diligence. You know, I'd love to spend some time there because for me, you know, having the banker, having your team is critical. There's no question about it. But the reason it is as important as it is now is as a seller, you have more options than you've ever had before, right?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, there have been you know, not just traditional transactions, but if you're looking at minority investments as well, right? What Emigrant Partners does. There's been a lot more in terms of minority investments over the last five years than there ever was before. I'd love to just get a sense from you when you're talking with an RAA, they're in their early stages and they're thinking about what's for me, regardless of like, are they run by a team of founders who are in their late 60s or a team that's in their early 40s and is looking at growth? How do you help them figure out one, what their starting point should be?

SPEAKER_00And then two, how they should do the appropriate due diligence on the path that might be right for them if they do to choose to pursue something.

SPEAKER_01Yep. It all comes down to the why. It comes down to the why. And it comes down to having the right mindset because there's many. I just spoke with a seller last Friday, um, literally just last Friday, and he let me know that there were so many phone calls he was getting, and he ignored all those phone calls, and finally he made the decision to pick up the phone. But he made the decision because he wanted to, because he knew that was the best thing to do for his firm. Many sellers are reacting to phone calls from strategic acquires. And the decision to sell their firm might not have been in the forefront of their mind, but now it is because they're reacting.

SPEAKER_01So I I go back to rest on your laurels. What is the strategy of your firm? What is that mountain in the distance that you're looking to achieve? And why is this transaction going to be good for clients, good for your team, and good for your partners? There's many times where I'm consulting on a transaction or consulting on you know, somebody considering doing an MA transaction and they're telling me about the other side. Well, I think I could help this other firm with with you know succession, or I think I can other help this other firm with XYZ.

SPEAKER_01But that's great. But what about you? And what about your team and your clients? So I do think it comes down to the why. What I don't ever want to see, and I hope I'm not going to offend anybody here, but I I never want to see us become like the airline industry where clients are fighting to get on the phone with an advisor, or clients are really fighting for inches, literally inches, uh, whether their their seat reclines or not, or whether their bin fits the uh suitcase goes in the overhead bin or not.

SPEAKER_01MA should always be done for the benefit of clients. And if that's not first and foremost in your mind, I would you know suggest that you re-evaluate why you're thinking about doing the transaction.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and and that's a great way of really thinking about it. I think a lot of times sellers will go into the process and they'll say, All right, here's my checklist. Is it good for clients? Is it good for my employees? Right, is it good for me? Uh, in that order. Then you can get into the process and it flips very quickly. So to just have that sort of in your mind, uh, that's that anchor and the ability to sort of not only ask the question, how is this potential partnership, whether it's an outright sale or minority investment, how is this good for my clients?

SPEAKER_00If the firm or the people that you're talking to, if they don't have an answer for that, that's a pretty good tell early in the process, right? With the hundreds, if not thousands, of transactions that have taken place, very easy to pick up the phone and call somebody and get their open and honest take. I mean, you know just as well as anybody that this is an industry. It's one of the things I love about it that yes, there's competition, but there's a lot more cooperation, right? A lot more co-opetition than there is competition. And people are really truly willing to give back. It does have at large a very study group type of mentality.

SPEAKER_00I do there's a couple things specific to emigrant that I just wanted to run by you as well. We have an interesting seed, obviously, because we see the MA world not just from through the lens of a direct minority investor, but with our 19 partner firms, um, many of them are inquisitive. You mentioned Pure before doing three deals. You know, Dakota did you know five deals in seven months at the end of 2023 or the back end of 2023. So we see things that are happening at the upper end and sort of the middle and the lower end of the market too. On the minority side of things, just be curious to get your take.

SPEAKER_00When firms are interested in working with a minority partner, what are some of the problems that you're finding, not just emigrant, but just the solution in general, might conceptually be solving for in that instance? Because it's not classic MA, if you will.

SPEAKER_01Right. Well, I think it really comes down to what are you trying to achieve as a firm? And are you looking for a strategic partner to come in to help you? Are you looking for capital to help you grow? Although it's not a traditional MA, it certainly could be a nice partnership with having that capital infusion. So you could you can go out and you can be acquisitive, or you can go out and you can acquire, you know, additional talent or grow the way you need to grow. Um, because if you're not growing, you are dying. So it really comes down to again, I think it's having that firm strategy and understanding what you do want to achieve.

SPEAKER_01But not all capital partners are the same. Right. So really evaluating, you know, how is this going to work? Is this forever capital? And do we intend on buying ourselves back in the future? Or, you know, is uh are we thinking about having a strategic team come in and then there'll be a hold period and then another might come in in a in a couple of years or five to seven years from now. But again, it really comes down to the why and what firms are looking to achieve.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and I appreciate that perspective. And I brought it up just because, again, as we talk about optionality and we talk about the seller journey or the due diligence, we definitely are seeing you know a tremendous amount of interest from firms that are obviously entrepreneurial, who want to stay entrepreneurial and who want to grow. If they want to grow, there's a good number that want to grow through MA, and they now see all right, there is a right way to do this. And they don't want to go at it alone, right? They want to work with us to some extent.

SPEAKER_00They need the capital. But then this is sort of the most interesting thing that I think I've seen, you know, in my scene since I joined Emigrant in October. It's not just the MA activity and the volume that's evolved. It's the evolution of the MA strategy that I think is most interesting. But it's not every acquirer out there, but the ones that seem to be the most selective and the ones who are focusing on how do we make one plus one equal hell of a lot more than two, they're really looking at firms that and asking, how does this firm help or how do I help this firm grow?

SPEAKER_00Or accelerate their organic growth. You mentioned expansion of services, right? Expansion of footprint. I think there are a lot of firms now who are being laser focused and answering that, asking that question. How do we help turbocharge this firm? Because they're lacking more than just somebody to take all the operational things off of their plate, right? The capital, the talent, or even just the strategic partner who could say, let's go for it and let's do it in this direction. So, you know, I give you a couple of paragraphs of lead up to ask the question how have you seen MA strategy evolve?

SPEAKER_00And how do you think it will evolve going forward?

SPEAKER_01I think it comes down to uh the strategic acquirers and it's the different models that are out there. Uh, we see, you know, beauty's in the eye of the beholder and value is in the eye of the beholder, right? So it from a seller perspective, thinking about what is my non-negotiable? What am I absolutely happy giving up and what am I absolutely not going to give up? And it being that there are 15,000 SEC registered firms out there, still, it's great that there's choice and there still should be choice in the marketplace. We are not at a point where consolidated.

SPEAKER_01So, from an acquire point of view and from a seller point of view, you have the aggregators out there and you have the integrators out there. Now, the way I see things shifting is that it's always been, you know, you have your choice of where you want to land in the in uh in an MA transaction. There's a school of thought that says, I'm very still happy to wear my own hat, my own brand, have my own technology and do things the way I want to do that from an aggregator perspective. And then the integrator perspective is everybody wears the same hat.

SPEAKER_01Everybody sings from the same uh same sheet of music. Uh, we have our same brand and the same story and the same experience and the same technology, much more in terms of integration. But where I'm seeing things change is where somebody might have sold their firm to what was considered an aggregator, but the aggregator model might be shifting more toward the integrator model. So uh I, you know, difficult to make any assumptions for where that leads going forward, but I do think that it'll be interesting to see where the aggregator model goes from here versus the integrated model.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and I think the economics, right? When you start looking at where there might be you know cost savings or the benefits of shared platform, right? It's too hard to ignore sometimes. So, you know, I think we're seeing that too. It'll be interesting to see how it plays out, that is for sure. And I also think yeah, you mentioned value before. We haven't touched on valuations yet, which I don't know how we've managed to talk for 20 minutes, but we haven't talked about valuation. I was at a conference a couple of weeks ago. Jason Ehrlich, managing director who leads our investment team, was on the panel.

SPEAKER_00Somebody asked the question how many buyers are in the room? And you know, let's say 60, 70 percent of the hands went up, right? Sure. Um, how many sellers are in the room, and maybe two hands went up, right? So obviously that is not hard and fast quantitative research there, right?

SPEAKER_01But it's bold. I didn't mean to interrupt you, but that's bold because uh there's so much competition on the buy side. So for those two sellers, you know, they're they're going to be approached after that meeting. So interesting.

SPEAKER_00100%. But what was interesting to me was those numbers probably aren't that far off from the true ratios that are out there, depending on the research. And you you probably have a good sense for how many buyers there are for every seller. But it I no matter what the absolute you know answer to that question is, there are exponentially more buyers than sellers, right? Which obviously indicates that it's a good market for sellers and their valuations have are still strong. At a general level, where are you seeing valuations right now?

SPEAKER_00And as sort of a follow-up, I am curious, there's been so much MA, how many high quality firms are left, right? So if for the you know, quote unquote high quality firms, what are they seeing in terms of your multiples versus what just the typical firm might be getting right now?

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Remind me if I don't hit on both sides of the question, but for multiples, and we're seeing we released our evaluation and deal structure study last June. So if I'm doing my math correctly, that was a year ago. And I don't think this is a study that should be done every year. It's um not something that should be done hourly or monthly. I think it's a nice look at the industry from a period of time to say, where have we gone and where are the trends, right? So we might hopefully do that a couple of years from now. But we did it in 2019 and we found that the median multiple, median EBITDA multiple was seven times EBITDA.

SPEAKER_01Now that rose two turns to nine times EBITDA when we released the study this time last year. Now, if anybody would challenge me to say, well, that study is a year old, I would say this is very much where we are right now. Multiples are holding, they're holding very strong and steady. For high quality firms, EBITDA multiples are they've plateaued. They're not going up anymore. They're not yet coming down. They very much plateaued. I'm hearing a number in the industry like 9.6 might now be the median.

SPEAKER_01So, geez, like a little bit of a an uptick there, but still nine, give or give or take. Now, in terms of value drivers, can firms go for 15? Absolutely. Uh, can firms go for four with earnouts? Yes. And I've seen that. Yes, absolutely. But sellers, when I'm talking about the median multiple being nine times Ibita, in our study, sellers wanted 11. So there's a gap between buy side and sell side and what buyers are looking to pay. And they're not going to overpay for that emotional premium, but sellers are looking to put that emotional premium on their firm, right?

SPEAKER_01Because they built this and and rightly so, right? This is what they've built from the ground up, and they're putting value on the firm. So there's a where do you where do you meet in the middle? And what objectively, you know, do we get to? Um, so I forgot the other part of the.

SPEAKER_00That was the high quality firm question, which is the most important one because I think when you look at whether it's 227 or 230 transactions that take place in a given year, sure. Um, you can't just say that there's obviously a typical multiple out there. There are you know some firms that are doing things exceptionally well. And you know, I'm I specifically asked a question just because while we're talking about MA, you know, I tend to talk about organic growth on RA plus quite a bit. And it's pretty clear that as an industry, we're really not growing organically as much as we probably should, right?

SPEAKER_00If you were to look at the aggregate organic growth in the space, a very concentrated number of high-performing firms are responsible for for the majority of. And those firms are the ones that seem to be getting your premium. So when we hear you know, multiples that are thrown around on conferences or on podcasts or seen in articles, I think just to help people maybe level set those remarkable multiples, the 15, 16, 17, or more are for you know firms that are not only growing at incredible rates, but are you know large firms that have proven they have a scalable, you know, repeatable strategic approach to organic growth?

SPEAKER_00And I'm sure you're seeing that as well. Is there anything that you're seeing, like when you're seeing firms at the top end of the market, they're doing to stand out?

SPEAKER_01What we are seeing is we're tracking adjacent practices, which does not go on our main report. So there's there's we're we have very specific guardrails on our reporting. It's wealth manager firm requires a wealth manager firm, and that goes on the report. We also track uh minority stake transactions adjacent to our main report. And then we also now track, because it's becoming such a trend, uh wealth manager firm acquiring tax practice or OCIO practice or consulting practice, et cetera. Because of the point I made earlier, where client expectations are not decreasing, they're only increasing.

SPEAKER_01So this is the trend that I'm seeing that firms are really scaling up what they're offering to really meet those demands. So um I'll go into what I call chapter one of MA, chapter two of MA, and chapter three, if that's okay with you. So please chapter one, chapter one has been written, and not that we're closing the book on chapter one, but it's it's still very much in play. But we've turned the page now to chapter two. So chapter one is wealth manager firm acquires wealth manager firm. It's been done thousands of times.

SPEAKER_01Chapter two is just what I talked about, that it's sort of adjacent practices to really beef up the scale, the scale and the set of services that we're offering to clients. And I think it might be a precursor to chapter three. And chapter three, I'm always asked about that mega merger. When is that going to happen? And I think it's when firms feel that they're in a position to for the the acquisition to be accretive. That's I think that's the first sort of uh that needs to be in place. The numbers need to work, right?

SPEAKER_01Acquiring a firm at 15 is very expensive, but acquiring a firm at 20 times EBITDA is very expensive. And it for the acquire, it does need to be accreted. The numbers need to make sense for their investors. Um, so that's I think chapter three is a few years away. The first reason I think is the math's not there yet. And the second reason I think it's not there yet is because we st we're starting to see uh G1 leaders sort of step away from the business and let G2 kind of come in. I don't think that's mainstream yet. I think that they're G1 leaders who still have runway in front of them.

SPEAKER_01And until the G1 leaders say, you know, hey, my time is up and I'm gonna pass the baton, I think then that's when we'll start to see a little bit more of very large firm acquiring very large firm. But I don't think we're there yet. And the math doesn't work.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. And I and as you're kind of talking through chapter one, two, and three, it's funny. I'm thinking of our partner firm network. And we're seeing all of that to some extent, right? Just the obviously we've seen the traditional MA, MA and sort of service expansion. And then how do we really sort of scale our businesses and the firms moving forward? And I think I absolutely need to have you back on in June of 2025 because absolutely and a lot of interest in CPA firms, right? No question about that for a ton of different reasons.

SPEAKER_00Doing sort of adjacent acquisitions in that space, you know, OCIO, you mentioned as well, starting to see more in terms of you know trust acquisitions. We're seeing that the larger firms, larger traditional firms are starting to morph and looking a little bit more like you know family office light types of businesses and picking the service extensions that are the most logical and the most sort of uh natural for them to be acquiring and adding. Um, so I didn't realize that you had all of that data, and we're definitely seeing and hearing very directly a lot of that activity.

SPEAKER_00So that'll be very interesting to see how that all develops, right? Because to the opening question around consolidation and your point that it might take 50 years, yes, at least that might actually prolong it to some extent, right? Because these businesses end up becoming a little bit more independent enterprises, right, than they are, you know, just isolated RIAs. So I appreciate you bringing that up. And before we wrap here, one, I just want to say thank you for not just being on the show here today, but for producing as much research as you do.

SPEAKER_00I don't know that you realize how many people probably use it on a daily basis. It's awesome. But it you should know that it's put to good use every day across the board. As you look out, and not just for the next you know six months or so, and we talk about 2024, you kind of foreshadowed chapter three a little bit, talking about the mega merger. I am just kind of curious, you know, what are some of the things that you're watching? And I'll just sort of bucket it into two categories. One, what are some of the things that you're watching that could have a positive impact right on the future of MA in this space?

SPEAKER_00And two, the other side of the coin, what are some things that could you know either derail the activity or you know, kind of take MA in a direction that none of us would want to see it go?

SPEAKER_01What I'm watching, of course, are interest rates. You know, that is definitely something I think with all things being equal, MA has been pretty strong and it's going to continue to remain strong. I am watching those sort of adjacent practices and how that's ramping up, but I'm also really curious in terms of capital backers and what they plan to do with portfolio firms. Like beauty, again, is in the by in beauty is in the eye of the beholder. So is sort of integrating firms within the portfolio, is that something that is attractive?

SPEAKER_01You know, I don't know. That remains to be seen. But that is something I'm watching. And I do think that these are positive things. And as long as it's being done with the client in mind, it is always going to have a positive result. In terms of derailing activity, I always say that MA should never be a market timing activity. It'll be interesting to see when interest rates, hopefully when you know, when they come down, we'll see if that sparks new MA transactions. But what I would not want to see is that FOMO making that re-emergence, just doing it because I have the fear that I'm going to miss out.

SPEAKER_01I just need to get this done just so I can get sort of my name on the map. Uh, that should not be a reason for MA. I also think that as long as we keep seeing the fundamental reasons for MA and as long as capital backers are super excited about the industry, we're going to continue continue to see it. I don't see anything in that way derailing. I don't see those fundamentals going away anytime soon.

SPEAKER_00I lied when I said that that was my last question. One more quick question for you.

SPEAKER_01Sure.

SPEAKER_00Important place to end. Given everything that we've talked about, all the different options that sellers have right now. You gave a little bit of advice earlier just around how much consideration hiring a banker and legal counsel might be. But what would be your best piece of advice, right? Your top recommendation to any leader of an RAA firm who sees the potential benefit of selling part or all of their firm. But they're they're not down that path yet. They haven't hired anyone, they're not in a process, right? They're just evaluating is this the right next step for me?

SPEAKER_00What's your best piece of advice?

SPEAKER_01I'm going to say number one, evaluate your mindset. And are you reacting to a phone call? Because potential sellers are receiving multiple phone calls from multiple firms. And they're saying that we can get you a very lucrative deal. This can be very good for you. And when you really deconstruct the deal, uh, you know, there's there's earnouts in there. There's things that are not all going to be up front. So I would say evaluate your mindset, make sure you're just not being reactive. Uh, and again, I'm gonna keep beating that drum because it really is my point of view in the in the industry, but really ask yourself how does this help my clients?

SPEAKER_01And will they benefit?

SPEAKER_00I think you also laid out importantly, something that people don't really think about. It's a full-time job to run a firm and it's also a full job to sell a firm.

unknownRight.

SPEAKER_01100%. Absolutely.

SPEAKER_00If you don't have the physical and the mental stamina to do both, right, then the timing might not be right. And when we talk about all of the different options out there, right? Do nothing is an option too. And yeah, that might be right for some firms at a particular point in time. But I think you have help helping people understand what their options are is exactly what we're hoping to do with this podcast. So thank you, Laura, for taking the time to not only talk to some of the recent numbers, right, but go beyond the numbers and really get instructive and prescriptive and give direction to anybody listening who's thinking about what path is right for them and then how to go about evaluating all of the different options they have.

SPEAKER_00So really do appreciate you stopping by the podcast.

SPEAKER_01Thank you so much. And if if I could, I just really just want to talk about fidelity and what we have, really quick, if I could. So we have very good consulting on all aspects of the business. So if a firm owner is thinking, geez, what's most important to me today? We have consulting on organic growth, inorganic growth, business strategy, innovation, business protection, everything. And we do it in really three different layers. We have an enterprise consulting team that does a deep dive, it could be three to six month engagement to really dive deep and understand, do a discovery and do a nice readout after we uh do a lot of analysis.

SPEAKER_01We also have specialty consulting for those engagements where somebody's thinking about, hey, I have an offer, can you help me think through it? Or uh a business strategy question or what have you. And then we have thought leadership at events. So that's what we offer. And I appreciate you letting me uh talk about that for a second.

SPEAKER_00Of course, I'm very impressed and also very jealous of the growth hub that you just launched. Um I think it's an important tool, right, for your advisors for the industry in general to just actually have a framework and a different way of thinking about organic growth because we've talked about how fragmented the business is. There is no one right way to do it, right? We know that, but you do give people the appropriate way for thinking about the approach that is right for them. Appreciate you mentioning that. And of course, we're all very familiar with uh your thought leadership at events as well.

SPEAKER_00So it was great to have the opportunity to work with you in Scottsdale earlier this year. And it was great to have you on the podcast today.

SPEAKER_01Oh, it was great being there, and thank you so much for this opportunity. I appreciate the discussion. Thank you.

SPEAKER_00Again, Laura Delaney, Fidelity, thank you so much for stopping by the podcast today. On behalf of Immigrant Partners, thank you everybody for tuning in here today. Um, very much looking forward to having you all back listening to episode Lucky 13, the Baker's Dozen of RA Fox 1520. Have a great day, everyone. Take care.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Building a Forever Firm: The NextGen Talent & Partnership Playbook

    Nov 18, 202653 minAudio

    In this episode of RIA+, Mark Bruno is joined by Charlie Rocco, CEO of Moneco Advisors, and Kyle Gentile, Director of Research and Consulting at Emigrant Partners, for a practical discussion on how RIAs can turn their...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. People, Purpose and Growth: Inside Keen Wealth's Leadership Playbook

    Sep 10, 20261 hrAudio

    In the RIA industry, "good growth" is about much more than adding clients and assets - it's about being intentional, leaning into deep expertise and never losing focus on your existing clients and team. In this episode...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. From Data to Decisions: Building an AI-Ready RIA

    Jul 28, 202640 minAudio

    Every wealth management firm is talking about AI - yet only a few are truly prepared to capitalize on it. Emigrant's Mark Bruno sits down with Addepar's Janeen France in this episode of RIA+ to discuss the foundational...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Ray Sclafani's 10% Rule: Turbocharging Your Organic Growth (Part 2)

    Jun 15, 202636 minAudio

    It's been well-documented and researched: While valuations in the RIA industry have skyrocketed over the last decade, the large majority of firms are not proactively growing. Organic growth rates remain anemic when the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Reinventing the Model: Jim Dickson on the Future of Partnership

    May 5, 202632 minAudio

    What if today’s RIA partnership models aren’t solving the right problems? In this episode of RIA+, Jim Dickson explains to Emigrant's Mark Bruno why he launched Elevation Point in 2024 and the structural gaps he...

    Credit the people on this episode