Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

RevOps FM

The Future of Data Privacy in Digital Marketing - Stephane Hamel

May 14, 202446 minVideo
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Every company pays lip service to privacy. But few seem to really value it in practice. In marketing and sales, we rely on personal and behavioural data for so many commonplace tactics, and this reliance is only increasing. It's a kind of arms race. Even if you wanted to, it feels like you can't afford to give up the perceived advantages of using personal data. And even as we continually hear about the "death" of this or that type of tracking, the reality is that hundreds of billions of advertising revenue are on the line. The incentives to keep collecting and commodifying our data are huge. I wanted to dig deeper into the current state of privacy in marketing today, and I could think of no better person to reach out to than Stephane Hamel. He is a legendary practitioner and thought leader in the digital analytics space and one of the foremost advocates for privacy and ethics in marketing. Thanks to Our Sponsor Many thanks to the sponsor of this episode - Knak. If you don't know them (you should), Knak is an amazing email and landing page builder that integrates directly with your marketing automation platform. You set the brand guidelines and then give your users a building experience that’s slick, modern and beautiful. When they’re done, everything goes to your MAP at the push of a button. What's more, it supports global teams, approval workflows, and it’s got your integrations. Click the link below to get a special offer just for my listeners. Try Knak About Today's Guest Stephane Hamel is a digital analytics and marketing expert with over 35 years experience. He has spoken at over 150 industry events and was named one of the Most Influential Industry Contributors by the Digital Analytics Association. As an educator, he’s taught thousands of students at institutions including UBC, SimpliLearn, ULaval, Harvard, YorkU, and others. In recent years, he’s focused his attention on the ethical use of data in a marketing context https://www.linkedin.com/in/shamel/ Key Topics [00:00] - Introduction [01:49] - Current state of privacy in marketing [03:30] - Vision of a truly privacy-oriented company [08:20] - How a 100% consent-based model would work [10:59] - Is privacy-respecting marketing better marketing? [13:26] - Analogy of seatbelts [17:32] - Getting people to care about privacy [20:50] - Advertising in a privacy-first world [24:21] - Conflict between privacy and commercial interests [31:41] - Google and the “death” of third-party cookies [36:47] - AI literacy [41:44] - Career impact of being privacy-oriented Learn More Visit the RevOps FM Substack for our weekly newsletter: Newsletter

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show.

0:14Justin Norris: So a few weeks ago, there was a dust up on LinkedIn about a new intent tool that enables marketers to de anonymize specific individuals that visit your website. So not just companies, but specific individuals, which tool it is and the people involved aren't really the point of the story, the incident stuck in my mind. Though, because of how it reflected our attitudes towards privacy in the marketing world, so many commonplace marketing practices do very similar things, like when we drop a marketing automation cookie that lets us see all

0:46of a user's activity on our website. Or when we de anonymize a company and get a location that lets us triangulate a user's identity, or when we give money to massive corporations like Google and Facebook, there's entire business models essentially predicated on various forms. Of identity profiling. So the relationship of marketing to privacy is complicated to say the least. Never totally sat well with me, although it is something I've accepted kind of as a cost of being in this industry. However, the whole incident really made me want to dig deeper into the current

1:18state of privacy in marketing today. And so I could think of no better person to reach out to than Stefan Amel. He is a legendary practitioner and thought leader in the digital analytics space and one of the foremost advocates for privacy. And ethics and marketing. I first met Stefan incidentally about 12 years ago when he was my instructor for a web analytics certificate that I was taking. And I have followed his work ever since. So Stefan, I really appreciate you being here today. Stephane Hamel: Thank you for having me. It's a really a pleasure even after 12 years.

1:48That's amazing. Justin Norris: Let's dive in and maybe as a first step, just to understand from your point of view, you think about this a lot. A lot of marketers go about their day without giving too much thought necessarily to the privacy piece. From your perspective, where are we in terms of our attitudes, our practices with respect to privacy? Have we gotten better? Have we gotten worse? Or is it kind of a mess all in all? Stephane Hamel: that's a really good question. Is it better or worse? better in a sense that there is more consumer awareness. Sadly, maybe because of all the data leaks stories that we hear in the

2:20press and so on marketers are more. Aware and conscious about the legal frameworks be at the GDPR in Europe or the new law 25 in Quebec or even what's happening in the States and so on. The negative side of things is that I see that the. Ad network ecosystem or all the ad tech industry is basically saying, Oh, with the death of third party cookies organizations are enticed to collect more first party

2:53data one end and the marketing and ad tech industry is trying to find other ways of. Continuing to collect as much information as before, if not more information than before. So the net result is that from a privacy perspective, I'm not sure the end result is going to be better than using, let's say, third party cookies and stuff like that. It's evolving very quickly. there are positive and negative sides to it. But generally speaking, I think we're aiming into a more privacy friendly

3:24marketing ecosystem on the net. So. That's cross our fingers. Justin Norris: your example that you just gave, you kind of alluded to it. A lot of marketers and a lot of companies approach privacy kind of like a set of rules. That they have to comply with, but they can also get around in legitimate ways if they can. So, you know, we set up one loophole and then, so we go around it. Instead of using cookies, we use, some other form of tracking users. So it's kind of complying with the letter of things, but not necessarily the spirit.

3:56And you recently wrote about this distinction between legal compliance and having a true privacy orientation. What would it mean for a company to actually be privacy oriented? Stephane Hamel: For me, the huge difference between, especially if you look at the GDPR in Europe it wasn't, enacted several years ago. So they went through all of the steps and still are, dealing with you know, clarifications of the legal text and having specific cases where they can say,

4:26okay, this is a good example, or this is a bad example with bill 25 in Quebec, we see that the same thing is going on. So the law is there companies are trying to comply, but mostly from what I've seen is that for now, at least it's more like. Legal compliance. Okay. I need to do whatever I need to do the minimum amount of things in order not to get a slap on my wrist need to check the box that says, Oh, yes, I've

4:58done this and that and so on. And this creates a scenario where. You comply from a legal standpoint, but you don't necessarily comply from the principles of privacy from, basics of marketing, which is listening to your customers and being aware that if you have a banner on your website. And you offer them the choice to opt in not. If they say no, I reject all cookies and I don't want to be tracked, then why do

5:30you try to find ways to circumvent that and say, Oh yeah, okay, I'm going to use this tool that, It doesn't use cookies. So it must be right. Or I can still use Google analytics because Google tells us there's a consent mode that we should trust Google that when they say, Oh yeah, that's privacy aware. Trust us. You can use that. There was no problem. So, my hope is that we're going to go from legal compliance where really, it's a pain. It's an expense. And you need resources. It's a distraction.

6:01It's a barrier to innovation and so on and shift the mindset so that being privacy aware from the principles respective the ethics of it. It means that now it's not an expense. It's an investment. It means that it becomes a brand value. In the long term, and that financially it's worth something. It's an opportunity for innovation. It's an opportunity to say, okay, I've been using all of those marketing tools for so many years. Do I really need all of those?

6:33all of those tools that are collecting data? Each one trying to pull more data into whatever their system is. So shifting the mindset a little bit. Justin Norris: Are there any companies that are actually doing this today or does it remain aspirational from your point of view? Stephane Hamel: Sadly I guess I have to admit that it's more aspirational than, really seeing companies that are really embracing the whole principles of privacy. But I think that's going to change slowly, gradually.

7:04We're going to see changes where one example that I like to mention, which I find absolutely absurd is when you look at a privacy policy. Oftentimes the first statement is your privacy is really important to us. should be a value proposition from that brand, right? But then you realize that if you are in Europe, you get a banner. If you are in Quebec, you get a banner because the law forces you to put a banner and say, okay we want to collect such and such information and so on.

7:38But if you're anywhere in the rest of Canada, for example, there's no banner. If you are in the States. There is no banner and it's open bar. So it's like, okay, your privacy from a brand perspective, your privacy is important to us, but it depends where you live. to me, it doesn't make sense. Either the privacy is important to the brand as a whole, or it's not. Justin Norris: And obviously I smiled when you said, you know, that line, your privacy importance cause they all start with that.

8:10So it's a little bit of like a fig leaf or in a marketing speak. Is privacy actually important? So let's think about a potential company that really did value privacy. And you have this hashtag you often use in your posts, no consent, no tracking. So a hundred percent consent based model, maybe just walk us through what it would look like for a company to be using that model, what they would collect, not collect, how they would interact with customers and so on. Stephane Hamel: So I guess I came up with the no consent, no tracking hashtag just because It's an opportunity to step back and think about it as a marketer,

8:43before you actually do something. So, I didn't want it to be like an absolute. I want it to be an opportunity for really thinking about your marketing tactics and being proud about your marketing tactics also. one of the things I often mention is that we should be proud of what we do from a marketing standpoint and not wake up in the morning, being afraid that, Oh, it the day where someone will tweet something or post something What

9:14we're doing in our marketing tactics and we'll say, Oh yeah this company says they do this, but in reality they do something else or they are creepy and they are using tools that are arvested. Too much information, stuff like that. So really, basically no constant, no tracking is just an invitation to think about the principles of privacy, of data minimization, of consent of control and things like that. so a company could do that fairly easily by looking at. The Martek stack that they use right now and seeing if any of

9:48those tools are absolutely necessary in the first step, what data they are collecting for which purpose. So basically doing an audit. Of your martech stack and seeing if it's all relevant using a consent banner on your website where there's no tricks you know, you have the same types of buttons for agree and reject, for example, no dark pattern anywhere and respect the user choice. I don't want to be tracked, then. Don't track them.

10:19Actually, one of the mistake, is that most banners that we see are talking about cookies. But it doesn't really matter. And I'm not talking from a legal standpoint, but from a principle standpoint, it doesn't matter if it's cookies or not. What matter is, are you collecting personal information? I don't care how you do it. Whether you use cookies or fingerprinting or any other method. If I say I don't want to be tracked, then respect my choice. Otherwise what happened is that consumers are taking control

10:50and they are using ad blockers. And stuff like that. So at the end of the day, the marketers are not in any better situation. Justin Norris: if we model through mentally what that consent respecting mode of marketing would look like? I guess one thing that comes to mind is less gating, less trading contact information for content. And Lo and behold, a lot of people now are coming around to the notion that that's actually just a better customer experience and actually better marketing in general.

11:22Do you think that respecting the principles of privacy leads us to better marketing in all cases, in some cases, or is it sort of an, it depends scenario? Stephane Hamel: Well, I guess I have to say, you know, I've done so much consulting that I have to say, it depends. Justin Norris: Of course. Stephane Hamel: That's the universal question to everything. But seriously, I think there are so many scenarios where marketing could be improved if we only went back to the roots of marketing there were marketing campaigns before the web and before the internet and the world worked.

11:56existed, There was TV, radio, print and so on. Now everything is digitized. But the concepts of marketing remain the same. It's building trust. It's listening to your customers. It's offering value. And I think it's been too easy for people to simply, okay, I'm going to spend X amount of dollars on Google or on Facebook. So it's, Kind of reassuring to say, Oh I'm spending a couple of thousands of dollars. I see how much traffic I get and I see the net result of that.

12:27Well, as much as possible, given the data that I can collect, it's kind of reassuring to work in this way. And that's how it's been for the past, maybe 20 years. Can you imagine how the internet would be if from the start. The consumer had retained control over the data they want to share instead of the evolution that we've seen, where Oh, there's a new trick and there's a new technology that allows you to, you know, use geolocation and, collect so much information from different, browser behavior, navigation and so on.

13:02And then, Oh yeah. Okay. We can be data brokers and. Merge the data in one place or several places merged that with other sources of data. Oh, that's the only rail. That's a gold mine, except that the person that benefits the most. I would say probably the least is the consumer themselves. So I think we need to change that, prior bang and think differently, just like, you know, in, in the courses that I'm teaching I'm talking about the evolution of the seatbelts in cars where initially it was, you know, consumers didn't want it.

13:37And car manufacturers said, Oh, that's an additional cost. And it's going to be more expensive. It's a barrier to innovation and so on. And look at where we are today. We have super efficient cars, very secure very safe because we don't only have seatbelts, but we have airbags and we have the frame of the car. So all that innovation came because security was an important aspect. And consumers can choose between cars that are reputed to be more secure than others.

14:09So privacy is going to be the same. We, consumers will pick, will choose brands that they trust because they see that privacy is part of the value proposition of that brand. In the long run, I think that's how we're going to win. I would say the privacy battle. Justin Norris: taking the seat belt as an analogy, you think perhaps that, you know, our attitudes towards privacy will evolve from something that's let's pay lip service to it, but get around it to more like, no it's really going to be baked into the model and people are going to

14:40respect it. Stephane Hamel: Yeah. I think so. Because going back to that seatbelt analogy, it took regulations and laws to impose that people wear a seatbelt. And it also took about 20, 25 years of. marketing campaign in education so that people realize that when you get in a car you know, put on your seatbelt. So it has become a security by default in a way. I hope it won't take 20, 25 years to educate people so that privacy

15:13by default becomes the norm. That it becomes automatic that when you purchase something new, the default password is not password, for example. that's so obvious. But how many internet devices and IOTs and, things like that were shipped with default passwords? That's not privacy and security by default. When I do audits, I see the consent banner, I reject all, and I see there's still tracking going on not just one by mistake, it's almost like a deliberate

15:46facade so that you, okay, yeah, we have a consent banner, we have the nice legal text from a technical standpoint, it simply doesn't work because the privacy engineer which is a basically a new role that we see emerging. You need to have someone from an engineering standpoint that understands how to, enable that banner and make sure that they're tracking doesn't fire anyway. So there's a whole set of roles and new job functions that are emerging,

16:21be it from a legal standpoint or from a privacy engineering standpoint that are becoming like more important that didn't exist just a few years ago. Justin Norris: What you just described with the cookie banner, I've seen that too. Do you think that's often just incompetence or do you think it's malice, like deliberate flouting the user's Stephane Hamel: No, I I hope that most of the time it's simply because getting very difficult to merge. The profiles of someone who understand the legal perspective, who understand

16:53the marketing perspective, and also understand how technology works to do all of those things. Having a profile that merged the three areas is virtually impossible. So that's why it's a teamwork. And maybe now more than ever, because I feel like we're in a enabling phase, a transformation phase. And we need the skills and the people who have the right skills to do those kinds of things. So I think, You don't know what you don't know. So do your best, but it doesn't mean it's fully

17:25compliant. Justin Norris: that clicking the reject button doesn't magically disable all the scripts their, on their website. I want to pull on this thread of the seatbelt analogy a bit more, cause I find it actually really interesting, but I want to pull on And one of the things you could say about seatbelts is that the impact of not wearing one is very dramatic if something goes wrong and it's very visible and obviously very horrible. With privacy, and that debate I mentioned around this particular tool at the beginning is kind of interesting from that perspective.

17:55There were the people that were like, this is wrong, you're a bad person if you do this, you know, it's that point of view. And then there were people that were like, I don't care. Like whatever, de anonymize me. What's the big deal. And it's like, okay, yes, I can see that. It's not the same thing as shooting through your windshield at a hundred kilometers an hour, but there's this sort of cavalier attitude. And do you think that the lack of kind of visible impact or people like, Hey, I don't care if Google knows what I'm doing, or I don't care if my iPhone is listening to me or, you know. think it was one of the founders of Google that was like, if you're not

18:26doing anything bad, like, why would you, you know, would you want to Stephane Hamel: Oh yeah. I hear Justin Norris: Um, do you fight that sort of cavalier attitude towards privacy? Stephane Hamel: Yeah. Yeah. Either, you know, things like I have nothing to hide. They know everything anyway. And they is who exactly we don't know. But they know everything anyway. And also if I'm going to be exposed to some advertising, I would prefer to get something that is customized and tailored to my interests.

18:57And yeah, okay. I guess, you know, like the seatbelts people were saying What if I crash, you know, in a lake and I don't have enough time to get out of the car, I'm going to drown. so all kinds of saying, yeah, but what if. Exceptions, things that in reality have a very small chance of actually happening. But when you realize that your data has been leaked a couple of times, and that suddenly you see a credit card happening on your credit report.

19:30You see some credit cards popping up that you have no clue where it comes from. When you see that you can get in trouble because your identity is being stolen and stuff like that. Maybe it's like a crash. it creates such a situation of frustration, lack of control. You feel like you have that, possibility always over your head you're going to have issues the next time you want to purchase a car because your credit report is going to be so bad or issues with the government or issues crossing

20:02the border at the customs because someone else has stolen your identity. So those are pretty serious things. So I think people will care more and maybe that personally, that's one of the reasons why I went from being an advocate for analytics, and I'm still an advocate for analytics, of course, but more privacy aware because my identity was my data was leaked several times. Over the years and just recently I had an attempt of someone in Europe trying

20:35to purchase something using a credit card that I never ordered, So getting through the trouble of stopping the transaction, the stress that it creates you don't want to live that just like you don't want to live a crash in a car. Justin Norris: Well, no, that is serious. I wonder again, just thinking about consent and tracking, if given the choice. I usually say no, unless I'm in a hurry and they use a dark pattern. Like you said, it's hard to find the reject button. I'm like, ah, whatever, I just need to get on. But I do say no. I use an ad blocker.

21:07I try to use more privacy aware, you know, browsers and technology. Which again, I'm To some extent conflicts with you know, attempting to use those technologies as an advertiser in my work as a go to market professional But all that is to say if the choice is really clear and really respected And enough people say no eventually those marketing tactics lose their efficacy because they're no longer there So do you feel like those things maybe just die and we have different ways of reaching people and like what would those ways look like? Stephane Hamel: That's a good point.

21:38Two things on that. One is just yesterday I had a conversation where the concept that the internet or the web exists because it's subsidized by advertising, right? And that's why we get so many things for free because it's supported by advertising. And if there's too many people who are blocking those ads or saying no, then the whole system is going to fall apart. But at the same time, when I look at media websites. That are often complaining about you know, the big, bad, the Google

22:09and Facebook that are stealing their advertising revenue on media websites. Yet I go there and what I realize is that if I use an ad blocker, I don't see the ads. But there is no contextual ads either. And contextual ads doesn't require any, no collection of personal data. It's like, if I'm on a news website and I'm in the car section. Well, guess what? Maybe it's the right place to put ads about, the cars and

22:41all things related to cars. And even beyond that, because you know that if people are interested in cars, they might be interested in something else. You don't need to track everyone to do that. just makes sense. And at one point in the early days of the web, that's how it was. So there's that misconception that in order for ads to be effective, it absolutely needs to collect personal data to do it because you need to know what are the interests of your audience. To some extent, it's true, but collecting personal data is not the

23:13only way to know about your audience, And for that matter, if you go into your Google profile and your Facebook profile and go deep, because you need to find it, and look at what Google and Facebook think are your interests, and you're going to be in for a shock. Because they might say that I'm a woman, that I'm 35 years old, and that I'm interested in Pokemon and stuff like that. Well, when it's actually totally wrong.

23:43But I have very little control over that. So all those interest based advertising, and there's so much fraud also. That's the other issue. That maybe contextual ads are going to be. Maybe a good alternative, much more privacy friendly you don't need as much data. it can be much simpler. So why not? Why not Justin Norris: That's very interesting. It reminds me of magazines, you know, I haven't read like a real magazine in a while, but like back in the day you get like car and driver and it had a certain type of ad in it and you'd get, another type of magazine

24:15and you kind of know who the audience is and who's interested in that and you advertise accordingly. Thinking about, you know, the central issue here, the central conflict from my point of view is that at least on a level of perception. Companies are seeing a conflict between Respecting privacy and their own commercial interests, and I'm sure you've seen this as a consultant going in making Recommendations like the de anonymization tool is a perfect example Oh, we can see who exactly is on our website. We can reach out to them.

24:45It's a great play But is it okay in terms of privacy, but it could make us money, that's tough particularly, being somebody in house and having to stand up for that and say like let's make less money potentially for this abstract principle of privacy which feels like a victimless crime because nobody really sees Or is aware of the extent to which they're being tracked Like how do you make that case of like you need to sacrifice your tracking do less profiling have less effective potentially cold outreach less personalization I think the contextual advertising that you mentioned is one, effective potential

25:18way of thinking about that differently. How else, do you make that case? Stephane Hamel: I'm not saying not to track anything because if you have a, let's say a consent banner on your website and the person says, yes, I want to get your advertising. interested, And if it's done in a respectful way, you build additional trust, from a marketing standpoint, Do you prefer to have like a thousand prospects that are, not really qualified, or do you want to have maybe a hundred that really said, yes, I want.

25:49I think I would much rather go with the fewer that are much more qualified and not waste my daughter and my time on the 900 others that maybe I have a slight chance of converting them into, you know, clients. there was that obsession about data as if it would solve everything. discourse that was let's collect everything, dump it into a big data lake, and eventually we're going to figure out what we want to do with it. That doesn't work anymore.

26:21Even if the data is It's cheap to collect, cheap to store, but pretty expensive to actually leverage. So we need to change that and maybe, small data is pretty good too. You can make very good decisions on less data, but much better data. Hopefully that's, one of the aspects that we don't have a choice. We're going to see it anyway, because if we don't. Embrace concepts. We're going to be forced anyway.

26:51One clear example of that is if you look at the you mentioned you are using an ad blocker and I do too. If you look at the general population depending on the source, it might be 30 percent of the general population that use ad blockers recently, I saw 50 percent in the States I think that would be pretty high, but let's say between 30 and 50 percent of the General population use an ad blocker. Maybe sometimes they don't even know. It's just part of their system or they use a browser that, blocks third party

27:22cookies already and stuff like that. When I do conferences and I remember once I had about a thousand people in the room and they were largely marketers. And people in analytics and stuff like that. And I asked them if they were using an ad blocker, it's not super scientific. I didn't count them, but I can tell you 70 to 80 percent of their hands went up. So right there to me, there's something broken. If the general population use, let's say 30 percent of them use.

27:53And that blocker, but when you ask marketers, 70 percent of them use an ad blocker, what's wrong, does it make sense? And we are in this industry and we both use an ad blocker. So to me it's a really good example of something is broken. We need to fix that. Justin Norris: So knowing what we know, we choose not to be tracked. There is a hypocrisy in, in continuing to try to do that to other people. So your point of view is that through permission based models and through

28:25alternative models, you ultimately could have, let's say an equal, if not greater level of efficacy of your marketing. Or do you think there is a hard point at which there is that sort of. devil on one shoulder angel on the other shoulder where it's like am I going to make more money or am I going To do the right thing? Do you feel that marketers have to make that choice or can they have their cake and eat it too ultimately? Stephane Hamel: Yeah. one of the argument I hear very often is if, as a company, if I don't do it, my competitors will, so I don't have a choice. I need to continue to, you know, play the game.

28:57But as I mentioned, we're in a transition phase in the long run. If I have, as a consumer, I have a choice to do business with a company that is reputed to have, three data leaks over the past two years. And then the alternative is another company that has a really strong reputation in terms of privacy and their, and how they do marketing. Eventually a consumer is going to win and they will go with the one they trust the most. There is no way around that. I won't mention the company, but I saw a company that they had a

29:28data leak twice in the same year. not small ones. if I'm just a general consumer, maybe I'm not super educated, but I understand what is a data leak. I understand that, okay, they didn't take care of the data about their customers. Am I going to go with them or maybe the other alternative? Just like, There are consumers that really don't care that the company is, polluting the environment and they don't have good practice and stuff like that. And there are consumers who will be very conscious about selecting the

29:59products that are more environmentally friendly and stuff like that. The same thing is going to happen. It's a value proposition. Justin Norris: Almost like another branch of corporate social responsibility and we do see, environmentalism or even in the fashion industry Just noticed, for example, like at H and M saw someone who had bought something and they were promoting like that. It was like no sweatshop labor or something like these issues companies do not necessarily because they care deeply. Maybe they don't, but at least they see it as profitable to align

30:32themselves with those issues. Stephane Hamel: In the long run, we see the difference between, the fast fashion where. It's so cheap they are exploiting people and stuff like that. It's still sell, but you see in Europe, they actually enacted a law that goes against the fast fashion trend to limit the impact of those things. So right now for example, in Canada, we see that PIPEDA is over 20 years old and, Bill C 27. Is gradually and slowly coming back to which would be basically the new version

31:06of the privacy law in in the States. There is a lot of action going on in each of the states and even at the federal level to. have better privacy regulation. we're at that stage where there's a lot of lobbying, of course, also. So we'll see how it goes, but I think for sure it cannot go backward where. It's going to be the open bar and free for all, where you do anything you want, you collect everything you want and you sell it, share it and merge it with anything else that won't come back.

31:39And I think that's a good thing. Justin Norris: If we think about the major players in this industry, like. used the term in my post the other day the advertising industrial complex like sort of half tongue in cheek But we look at google ad revenue last year over 237 billion dollars facebook ad revenue over 100 billion dollars. These are not small numbers Will those sorts of you know corporate and institutional forces do they?

32:09have a role in, in terms of stopping progress or taking apparent progress and kind of redirecting it in ways that ultimately still allow them to do what they do and that they will benefit from Stephane Hamel: Yeah. if we look at Google, for example, it's funny because they postponed it again the famous death of third party cookies, or some people call it the cookie apocalypse. But it's essentially what the ad network industry has been relying on to, track people across different websites.

32:40And if you cannot use third party cookies, then it's much harder to do that. So Google say, oh, we care about your privacy and so on. Yet they've postponed the limiting of third party cookies for so long. When you look at other browsers. be it, you know, Firefox, be it Safari I'm using Brave. They all block third party cookies anyway, right now. And Chrome the browser from Google, is one of the last to do it. And Google still continues to say, Oh, we care about your privacy.

33:11We're going to stop trying, enabling third party cookies. But they postponed it again because their alternative. Either didn't pass the test of privacy or is already being challenged in court or, you know, risk of being challenged in court in Europe because the alternative to third party cookies is actually potentially more invasive. so again, it's a discourse where we care about your privacy, but we're going to hold back until we find another way that will pass the legal test. And then we're going to block the third party cookies.

33:44Why don't they do it right away if they really believe in privacy? Because most of the other browsers are already limiting the third party cookies. So, won't sacrifice, hundreds of millions or billions of dollars in revenue, by doing something that would basically, Just, cut that stream of revenue. They want to find another alternative and sadly the other alternative might involve hashing your email or your phone number and combining it, fingerprinting. So being able to identify the unique characteristics of your device.

34:18While people got used to clearing their cookies, changing your email address, your phone or your device. It's much more difficult. So that's why I'm saying the alternative to third party cookies, it might be actually worse because you won't change your email all the time. Justin Norris: the cure worse than the disease in that case. So, so the whole debate in essence then It's kind of moot because it's like, coming back to the idea of the letter of the law and the spirit of the law, it's like, all right, we'll not do this one thing, but then we'll use local storage or we'll

34:52use, like you said, some hash of the device does this whole cookie apocalypse then just kind of a Tempest in a teapot, like do marketers even really need to think about this because ultimately they're not going to be affected. Stephane Hamel: Yeah. I said for, let's look at each of the perspective for the consumer, it doesn't change anything. the web is. Still going to work. for a marketer. It will change the ability to do a retargeting, for example. But it's an opportunity to look at, as I mentioned, your market stack and

35:22see which are more effective and do you really need all of those tools that you subscribe at 19 bucks a month and you forgot about it, right? So that's for marketers for agencies. it's pretty sad to say that there are some agencies that are playing the card of talking about the cookie apocalypse as if it was absolutely terrible and, you know, your business won't survive if you don't pay us to fix it. So, I've seen agencies using this kind of language almost to maybe spread some you know, FUD, a fear, uncertainty and doubt to their clients

35:57who really are not expert in that. And then the last layer are the ad tech and martech industry itself that are, you know, some of them are probably going to probably not survive, but others are going to try to circumvent. The third party cookies by using something else, as I mentioned, like fingerprinting and stuff like that. And then there's others that will really innovate and find better ways of offering their services and their solution.

36:27And just like we've seen the seatbelts going from, just one. Strap and now we have like a strap on the chest that's innovation. So hopefully we're going to see some of the players embracing more privacy and improving their products. It's an opportunity to innovate or die. Justin Norris: Let's talk a little bit about AI, obviously a huge sea change in the last year and a half with privacy, risks and perils that really haven't even

36:58been fully identified, or most people aren't aware of from, companies maybe dumping their whole corporate strategy into chat GPT without really thinking, but where that goes to maybe the ability of AI to profile us in different ways. I don't know. There's all sorts of things. How are you thinking about this? What worries you? What maybe there are benefits that I haven't considered? What's your point of view? Stephane Hamel: Yeah. I think there's a distinction to make between the general publicly available. Gen AI, like a chat GPT, for example, where, as you mentioned, you know, don't

37:31go there and put all your strategy. there's now an option that you can say, don't use what I'm telling you to continue to train your model. But still, there's the availability of other AI models that you can actually enable within your environment. And in a secure way, and it can be amazingly powerful. It can be useful. And again, that's another thing where there's no way back. The genie is out of the bottle. That's for sure. And it's interesting because. When chat GPD came out I was teaching a marketing class to uh, executive MBA,

38:07basically, and I had about 30 managers in the class and that was in December, 2022 and we started talking about it and we said, well, you know, let's give it a try and let's ask marketing questions and see if we could use it to not do basic stuff like, okay you know, improve my text and stuff like that, but do market research and generate new ideas and stuff like that. And those 30 managers, they had never touched chat GPT before, and they were like kids in a candy store. They were so amazed and excited and seeing the possibility.

38:40So following that in January, 2023. I said in my class, okay, use it, go ahead, it won't be one of those classes or school where, you know, universities are saying, don't use it it's cheating, it's plagiarism and stuff like that, I said, no, go the other way. Use it just let me know how you use it. That's the only thing I ask is just be transparent about it. And what I see is there are students who are afraid of that and they don't know how to use it.

39:13And others that are embracing it and the distinction is very clear. I'm afraid there's going to be a literacy gap between those who know how to leverage those tools, be it. So those who know how to use them and those who don't, and that's going to make a difference in the workforce, that's for sure, because the quality of the result is not the same. On the other hand, my expectations from the students have increased. My exam questions are more difficult because I know they

39:45can use ChatGPT to answer. And sometimes, I will ask questions that I know cannot be answered by Google. GPT or any other tool. So my job is a little bit more difficult, but I use chat GPT to make my job a little bit easier also at the same time. So that's true of my role as a teacher, but it's true also in consulting it's true for marketers. It's I'm also giving a short course on data science and marketing and I use it to generate Python code.

40:17I do just so many things with it. So. It's amazing. It's I wish I had those tools when I was younger. Justin Norris: I know what you mean though, about it being a skillset, because I had another interview recently with someone using using an automation tool that allowed you to leverage AI within it for an outbound sales use case. And Yes, you can use it to do a lot of things, but the amount of thinking that had to go into saying like now go to this website and look at this and give me this specific question and you actually have to deconstruct

40:48a thought process and then encode it, and that is a skill that, person had developed to a very high Stephane Hamel: if, but that's the point. If you don't know what you're talking about, you won't be able to leverage those tools. You will ask very basic questions and you will get crappy answers and you will end up saying, Oh, Gen AI doesn't work. But that's not true. It works, but you need to first know which questions you want to ask. And in order to know that, you need to understand the discipline. Or the domain, the expertise of what you're talking about.

41:20Otherwise it doesn't work. and we're going to see either people using it to save time or people using it to increase the quality. Hopefully we're going to see more people using it to improve the quality of the end result, not just to save time. Because you can save time, but get crappy results. Justin Norris: Do bad stuff faster. Bad word faster. maybe the last question, Stefan, I'm just curious from a personal basis. You've been transparent and have written on a few occasions on LinkedIn

41:51about kind of the career impact that you've seen about being privacy first. Which in some cases has maybe limited some of your professional prospects. Can you talk about that a little bit and just how would you advise Other marketers who are out there maybe a bit earlier in their career and can even less sort of afford to have those impacts I guess Stephane Hamel: Yeah, was a combination of multiple things at the same time. One was having been a freelance for so long and on the consulting side, and I'm over 55 now and having that crazy idea that maybe with the amount

42:22of expertise and experience that I have, I could go and offer my expertise to, you know, Maybe a startup in privacy tech or something like that. So I faced multiple issues including ageism, including the fact that working remote is a barrier sometimes the fact that going from the consulting world actual client side is a challenge when you've done it for so many years. And then on top of that there's the aspect of being, more privacy conscious

42:56what I realized is that for example, while I was super, super busy with. Coaching agencies, for example, and working with clients directly. What happened is that if you take an agency, maybe they're a little bit shy of working with me because once I open the engine and I look behind what is going on, I might reveal some stuff that maybe they would rather not see. the same is true for companies also. So maybe I've cornered myself a little bit.

43:29But at the same time I see that's starting to change now. I see that I'm working with clients where they want to embrace. A more privacy aware privacy conscious, not just because of the legal aspect, but because they feel that's the right thing to do. It's a strategy, right? So this is starting to change. And even if I have I think a fair amount of credibility, I hope in the field I enrolled myself into New York University certificate in information privacy.

44:00Just to confirm my knowledge first and also to get that kind of stamp of credential that I felt that I needed to get. And in those courses, I see that people are coming from all kinds of background. So I expect there's going to be an increase in demand in the market for people who are in the field of information privacy, which is different from security standpoint. You know, security being really hardware network you know, the security aspect but with more knowledge into information privacy.

44:32So I think there's a great opportunities if you combine. Marketing, if you combine legal and you combine the technical aspect, at least a minimum understanding of it. I think there is a great future. Justin Norris: That's amazing. Well, I think we have to wrap now, but I just want to say I really appreciate how outspoken you are on this issue, your commitment to it, even when it's not necessarily easy or popular. I think it's an important discussion that has to be had. And just really interesting digging into this and exploring it with you.

45:04So thank you so much for being on the show. Stephane Hamel: Thank you, Justin, for having me.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Building a Company Brain for AI - Jacob Dietle

    Sep 27, 202646 minVideo

    Every time you explain your business to an AI from scratch, you’re repeating work. The opportunity with context engineering is to make your company’s expertise, processes, and past learning available whenever an agent...

    Listen to the audio

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Operator's Roadmap for AI in 2026 - Lily Luo

    Jan 9, 202644 minVideo

    Justin and Lily reflect on their parallel journeys diving deep into AI throughout 2025. They discuss why most AI content misses the mark for operators and system builders working within corporate constraints, share...

    Listen to the audio

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. SEO in the Age of AI - Gaetano DiNardi

    Jun 17, 202550 minVideo

    SEO used to be the ultimate growth lever - offering massive “free” traffic to marketers who could outsmart the algorithm. But in 2025, it's a different game. In this episode, I’m joined by Gaetano DiNardi - an SEO...

    Listen to the audio

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. How AI Agents Really Work - Daniel Vassilev

    Mar 21, 202549 minVideo

    AI agents are everywhere in conversation right now - but what actually makes them work? It’s not just slapping a large language model into a workflow and calling it a day. Under the hood, real agentic systems operate...

    Listen to the audio

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Journey to VP of Marketing Ops - Kimi Corrigan

    Feb 12, 202546 minVideo

    Not many people make it to VP of Marketing Operations - Kimi Corrigan has done it twice. In this episode, she shares her journey from marketing coordinator to leading marketing ops at companies like Duo Security, Cisco,...

    Listen to the audio

    Credit the people on this episode