Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Resilience Across Borders Podcast

Resilience Across Borders Podcast artwork

Difference Between Necessary Pain and the Mental Loops

Jun 5, 202619 minAudio

How to Stop Replaying the Past, Break Free from Mental Loops, and Build Emotional Resilience In this episode of Resilience Across Borders, Rachid Zahidi explores the powerful distinction between "clean pain" and "dirty pain." Clean pain is the natural emotional response to a difficult event. Dirty pain is the additional suffering created through rumination, catastrophizing, self-judgment, resistance, and repetitive emotional replay. Drawing on neuroscience, emotion regulation research, predictive processing theory, and nervous system science, Rachid explains why the brain often struggles to distinguish between a real threat and a remembered one, and how this keeps many people trapped in cycles of stress long after the original event has passed. You'll learn how the brain's threat-detection systems can reinforce painful memories, why unresolved stress responses often become physical symptoms, and how identity-based thinking can transform temporary setbacks into long-term emotional burdens. Most importantly, this episode offers practical strategies for processing pain in healthy ways, interrupting destructive thought patterns, regulating the nervous system, and building the resilience needed to move forward without carrying unnecessary suffering. Whether you're recovering from a personal loss, navigating professional setbacks, rebuilding after disappointment, or simply looking to strengthen your emotional well-being, this episode provides a practical framework for keeping pain clean and preventing it from becoming a permanent part of your identity. 🎓 What You'll Learn in This Episode: The Clean Pain vs. Dirty Pain Framework: Understanding the difference between necessary emotional pain and the additional suffering created by mental habits. The Predictive Brain Effect: How past experiences influence your brain's expectations and shape your emotional reactions to future events. Why Rumination Becomes a Trap: The neuroscience behind repetitive thought loops and how they strengthen emotional suffering. Nervous System Survival States: How unresolved stress can leave the body stuck in fight, flight, freeze, or shutdown responses. Identity and Emotional Pain: Why turning painful experiences into identity statements can prolong suffering. Emotional Processing Strategies: Healthy approaches to working through difficult emotions without suppressing or avoiding them. Practical Tools for Recovery: Techniques for interrupting rumination, regulating your nervous system, and creating new evidence that supports growth and healing. 💡 Key Takeaways: Pain Is Inevitable, Suffering Is Often Amplified: The original event may hurt, but much of our long-term suffering comes from how we mentally revisit and interpret it. The Brain Predicts Based on Experience: Past disappointments can cause the nervous system to scan constantly for future threats, even when danger is no longer present. Rumination Strengthens Emotional Pathways: Repeatedly replaying painful stories reinforces neural circuits, making those emotions more automatic. Your Body Remembers Stress: Emotional experiences don't just live in your thoughts - they can also become stored in physical patterns and nervous system responses. Failure Is an Event, Not an Identity: Healthy resilience comes from separating what happened from who you are. Emotional Regulation Starts with the Body: Sleep, movement, breathing, and recovery often improve emotional clarity before any mindset work begins. New Experiences Create New Beliefs: Healing requires gathering evidence that challenges outdated assumptions and threat predictions. Closure Is Not Always Necessary: Acceptance often creates more freedom than endlessly searching for explanations. 🧘 Practical Reflections Think about a challenge you're currently facing. What part of your emotional response is clean pain, and what part may be dirty pain? Are there any stories you're telling yourself about a setback that go beyond the actual facts of what happened? What recurring thought patterns or mental loops keep pulling you back into old emotional wounds? How does your body typically respond when you're under stress, and what healthy practices help regulate your nervous system? Is there a painful experience you've unintentionally turned into part of your identity? How might you separate the event from your sense of self? What new evidence could you intentionally create that challenges an old belief about yourself or your future? 💬 Quotes from the Episode "Clean pain is the wound. Dirty pain is repeatedly reopening it." "Your brain is not simply reacting to reality - it is constantly predicting reality." "The body often responds to remembered danger similarly to present danger." "Failure is something you experience, not something you become." "Pain becomes much heavier when it turns into identity." "The best antidote to worry is often action." "Healing is not about avoiding pain. It's about refusing to let temporary pain become a permanent identity." "Pain is inevitable. Suffering often becomes optional when awareness enters the room." Featured Tool The EMO Gym Journal (Emotional Gym) A guided workbook designed to help you gain clarity, stay focused on your priorities, build better habits, and track both growth and rest. Resources & Links 📘 EMO Gym Journal - Available on Amazon 🌐 Blog & Episodes: atresilience.com 🎧 Resilience Across Borders Podcast - New episodes weekly If this episode resonated with you, please: Share it with someone who needs permission to pause Leave a review to help others find the podcast Subscribe so you don't miss future episodes Remember: be kind to yourself, be kind to others - and stay resilient. 🌊✨

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Hello and welcome back to Resonance Across Borders Podcast. I'm your host, Rashid Zaidi, and also the author of The EmoGym Journal, among other things. And The EmoGym Journal is a guide and workbook that helps you get clear and stay focused on your priorities and institute better habits, such as gratitude. So anyways, in this episode, we'll talk about the science of, quote, "cleaning pain" and how emerging neuroscience explains the difference between, uh, the necessary pain and the mental loops, uh, that follow, and then that

keep us stuck, and then tacking on the additional or secondary, uh, pain. So pain has always been part of the human experience. Uh, heartbreak, rejection, failure, grief, uncertainty, embarrassment, loss, uh, health scares, financial setbacks, identity shifts. Some pain is unavoidable. It's part of the process. But according to growing neuroscience research in emotional regulation, uh, predictive processing, stress physiology, and trauma recovery,

much of what exhausts people is not always the original painful event. It's the secondary suffering created afterward. Uh, this is often described as the difference between, clean pain, the original emotional, physical, or psychological discomfort caused by a real event. In other words, really justified pain. Examples, uh, okay, breakup hurts. Losing a loved one hurts. A failed business launch hurts. Uh, rejection, uh, hurts.

Conflict, uh, hurts. Certain injuries, difficult medical, uh, diagnosis, uh, hurts. This pain is real. It deserves acknowledgement Now, uh, what's referred to, uh, as the dirty pain is the additional suffering created by repetitive mental loops, um, catastrophizing, resistance, rumination, uh, shame narratives, and nervous system dysregulation that prolong the original, uh, pain.

So example, um, following one of these, uh, like a heartbreak, and you'd start thinking, "Okay," or saying, "I'll never find love again," or, "My life is ruined," or, "This always happens to me," uh, or, "I'm a failure." Constantly replaying conversations, uh, or checking an extra social, uh, media daily, avoiding life because of fear or future, uh, pain. So clean pain is, is the wound. Dirty pain is repeatedly reopening it.

So, and neuroscience is increasingly showing that your brain often struggles to distinguish between an actual threat happening now and a vividly replayed emotional threat from memory So, uh, let's talk about why the brain keeps replaying, uh, pain. One of the biggest developments in neuroscience continues to center around predictive processing, uh, theory. The idea that the brain is constantly trying to predict future

outcomes based on past experiences. , Lisa Feldman Barrett and other researchers have helped popularize the understanding that your brain is not simply reacting to reality, it is constantly, predicting, reality. So like if you experience betrayal, abandonment, humiliation, financial collapse, uh, or major disappointment, your brain may begin scanning for signs that it could happen again. And what this activates the amygdala or the threat detection, uh, area,

uh, of the brain and, uh, uh, triggers cortisol release, uh, can elevate the heart rate, can create muscle tension, can create hypervigilance and of course, intrusive, uh, thoughts. So the issue is that your nervous system may react to a memory as if the event is still happening. This is why someone can sit safely at home and still feel panic while replaying

a painful conversation from years ago. The body often responds to remembered danger similarly to present danger. That's where dirty pain, uh, grows. So, uh, let's talk about the rumination trap. I mean, I mentioned this in a c- in a few previous podcasts. So, uh, continuously emerging research, uh, continues strengthening what, um, what psychologists have long suspected. Rumination creates prolonged stress responses Uh, rumination

sounds like, why did this happen? What could I have done differently? What if this happens again? Why am I not over this yet? Um, again, like maybe the first two or three or whatever sometimes can be productive, like just in, to make, um, uh, sense of it or to extract some lessons and to move forward. But again, the difference is being stuck there and replaying it and ruminating it there and then twisting that knot, uh, you know, bigger and bigger. This activates repetitive, neural, pathways.

Think of it like repeatedly walking the same trail in a forest until it becomes the default route. So that's like how the neural pathways, uh, kind of work. The more you rehearse painful narratives, uh, the stronger they become, the more automatic they feel, the more your nervous system, uh, treats them as familiar, uh, patterns. So for example, after a breakup, someone checks their ex's social media every night. Each check triggers stress chemicals, emotional memories, self-comparison,

um, uh, disappointment cycles, and the, the breakup like was, was the original, uh, okay, if we're gonna call it clean pain, right? Um, but the compulsive check-in becomes dirty pain because it adds all this unnecessary, it piles on all this unnecessary, uh, suffering. So the body, um, stores unfinished stress cycles, so we have to keep that in mind. Um, so there's been researchers like, uh, Stephen Porges help expand conversations

around nervous system states. Uh, when stress responses are not completed, the body may remain stuck in one of these. It may remain stuck in fight, it may remain stuck in flight, it may remain, uh, stuck in freeze, it may remein- uh, remain stuck in shutdown. Um, this can show up as insomnia, it can show up as digestive issues, emotional numbness, irritability, exhaustion, chronic muscle tension Or difficulty, uh, focusing.

So example, a professional gets, publicly criticized at work. So of course, the original, uh, pain is feeling embarrassed and hurt, but the dirty pain is avoiding future presentations for years because the nervous system now associates visibility with danger. Um, this reminds me of, uh, wrong associations that we make sometimes. Uh, you know, it's just not what happened is not necessarily

what led to that feeling. It's just what we add onto it, and what we pile onto it, and what we associate with, uh, with those experiences wrongly. Because that happens to everybody, and then it's just the reactions, uh, that differ, and then who gets stuck there, uh, and who gets up and dusts themself off and gets going, and who doesn't take it personally, who thinks, "Okay, well, you know, that happened, but, uh, it's part of the process. I'm getting better at this, and then the next time I'm going to do this and that and whatever." So long story short, it's just not to pile on

and, uh, not to let it paralyze you. So, uh, which leads me to the main next point, which is pain becomes then identity. This is where suffering even deepens. So the original event becomes a personal identity statement. Instead of, "I experienced failure," then it can become, the danger is becomes, "I am a failure." So big difference if, like, we all experience failures here and there, but when we start taking it and, making it part of the identity, instead of saying,

"Okay, I failed here or there," I say, "Okay, I'm a failure." Big difference. Or instead of saying, "I was rejected," it becomes, " I am unworthy." See the difference? This activates areas of the brain associated with self-referential, uh, thinking, particularly, uh, the default mode network, which becomes highly active during repetitive self-focused rumination. So the longer this continues, the harder it becomes to separate yourself from the painful event.

So another example, uh, an entrepreneur loses one business. This is common in entrepreneurship, the failure rates are high. Um, instead of learning and rebuilding, they spend years saying, "I am not meant for success." But if you really look at the, uh, entrepreneurship and even the biggest stories in entrepreneurship, um, the biggest successes, if you look at their history, there is a trail of failures, that, uh, other ventures that never made it, they-- where they've learned, where they've kind

of, uh, found maybe ways not to do it. So, so anyways, the failed launch was clean pain, but the identity, uh, attachment became dirty pain. So how to clean pain before it becomes dirty pain, 'cause that's the main important thing that we wanna take away from this, is number one, name what actually happened. Your brain often amplifies vague emotional threats, so precision reduces panic.

So you may ask yourself, "What exactly happened? Uh, what story am I adding to this? Uh, what part is fact and what part is interpretation?" So for instance, uh, a fact is they ended the relationship, uh, but the story, I'll always be abandoned. You separate those two, and then you will realize, uh, you will find things that, uh, support, um, that you were, you were not gonna be abandoned just

because one relationship ended, right? Because you find proof for what you want. So, uh, find proof for the fact that relationships, you know, sometimes work, sometimes they don't, and, um, you will be able to find another relationship that's better. Maybe you're being redirected. So anyways, long story short, just Figure out what is fact, figure out what is that story that we add on. So separate them. Number two, allow emotional processing.

Suppressing emotions, uh, often prolongs them. So the sooner we bring them out to the surface and we name them, we identify them, and we process them, uh, the, the faster they will, uh, dissipate, they will leave. So healthy processing may include, uh, crying, it may include journaling, it may include therapy, it may include, uh, prayer, it may include meditation, it may include trusted conversations, uh, movement.

For everybody it's different, but figure out what is a healthy way to process, um, that information, uh, or that, that emotion. So instead of numbing it, for example, with, say, alcohol after rejection, uh, rejection, go for a long walk and journal what you're feeling. Number three, interrupt rumination loops. This takes practice, but, uh, with again, uh, if you repeat it, you, you can do it. When repetitive thinking starts, ask, "Is this problem-solving, uh, or emotional,

uh, recycling?" So there is a difference between that, uh, those thinking loops and productive reflection, where you think, where you reflect, and then you take away something, and then you move on. Uh, so you can try, uh, time-limited reflection. You can try mindfulness. You can try pattern, uh, interruption, where you even say to yourself, "Stop it," you know? And, um, or you tell your brain, "Stop it," or you say to yourself, uh, "Brain fight," uh, whatever, uh, just whatever interrupts that.

If you find yourself you're falling into the loops, you can call a friend. Uh, you can engage in meaningful work, something that really engages all your senses. Um, so, uh, you can give yourself, say, whatever, ten or twenty minutes to reflect on a setback, then shift into action if there is an action to be taken. Uh, sometimes the, for example, the best antidote to worry is action. So you can sit there for days and worry about it, or you can get up and do something about it if you can do something about it or let it go.

You know, it's like we focus on what we can control, and we let go of the rest. Again, I'm not saying this is always easy, but this requires mindfulness and practice. Number four, regulate the body first. Your thoughts become more catastrophic when your nervous system is dysregulated. We often underestimate this portion because we think we can fix everything in our head, but that's not, uh, that's not the case always. So, uh, a lot of times, uh, if the body is dysregulated, it's

hard to, uh, to get anywhere. So you can use deep breathing. Uh, you can even use cold exposure. I'm not saying you, you don't have to do ice plunges or, or whatnot. If you can't do that, I mean, just grab a piece of ice, right? Uh, just wash your, your face with cold water, right? Uh, take a shower, uh, sc- a cool, uh, you know, temperature as you can. Exercise. Do stretching. Sleep. You know, do sleep restoration. Do breathwork. There's so many different breathing techniques that

work for different situations. Um, do nature walks. Uh, if you're having trouble get out of your head, sometimes focusing outward i- is a good way to do it, like focusing in on what's going on outside, the trees, nature, the river, the, the ocean, uh, the birds, whatever. So Um, like one of my favorite, uh, people I listen to, uh, his podcast is Andrew Huberman. He has discussed how physiological regulation often precedes

emotional, uh, regulation, right? What I like him is a lot of the stuff that he does is based on, uh, science, research, and testing. So, but anyways, before making a major decision during emotional overwhelm, uh, make sure if you can get some sleep, hydrate, walk, breathe, then revisit the issue. Because if you're not in this good place and you're trying to make major decisions, uh, the result is not gonna be good. I can guarantee you that. So create, uh, excuse me, create new evidence.

Your brain updates predictions through lived experiences. If your brain says everyone leaves, you need new experiences that challenge that belief. So for example, after betrayal, uh, build healthy friendships, strengthen boundaries, slowly trust wisely again. New evidence weakens old threat predictions.

Number six, stop worshiping closure. Sometimes closure never comes. Sometimes apologies never come. Um, so your nervous system may wait forever for answers that don't arrive. Healing often comes from acceptance, not explanation, right? Sometimes we just have to accept what is and not look for explanations that may not be there or may not come. So, uh, you may never fully understand why someone, uh, betrayed you,

but you can still move forward. That's the portion, uh, we can, uh, control. Being resilient doesn't mean we don't feel like, uh, the pain. Resilient people s- still feel clean pain. Resilient people still grieve. Resilient people still cry. Resilient people still hurt. They feel disappointment, but they work hard not to manufacture unnecessary dirty pain. They don't repeatedly hand, uh, yesterday control over today.

They learn to feel pain fully, process it in a healthy way without building a permanent, uh, home inside it and s- and wallowing in it and staying there. They know how to get out. So, uh, pain is inevitable. Suffering often becomes optional when awareness enters the room. So ask yourself, "Am I feeling today's pain, or am I reliving yesterday's pain on repeat?"

That question alone can begin changing your nervous system, uh, your healing process, and can change your future. Because healing is not, uh, it's not about avoiding pain, it's about keeping pain clean enough to move through it and refusing to let mental loops turn temporary pain into a permanent identity. As always, thank you for tuning into the Resilience Across Borders podcast. If you're enjoying this podcast and finding it helpful to you, please pick

up a copy of the companion journal. It's called EmoGym. Uh, you can follow the blog posts and new episodes as they get added. The URL is at resilience.com. You can follow, uh, along with all the social media. We also post when new episodes, remember to be kind to yourself, be kind to others, and stay resilient

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Power of Becoming: How to Transform Your Identity and Build the Life You Want

    Nov 20, 202616 minAudio

    How to Become the Person Your Future Requires Through Identity, Habits, and Courageous Action We often spend time thinking about the life we want to create, the goals we want to achieve, and the person we hope to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Building a Life Beyond Achievement: How to Align Your Success With What Truly Matters

    Nov 13, 202615 minAudio

    How to Build Meaningful Success Without Losing Your Health, Relationships, and Purpose Success is often measured by what we accomplish - business growth, career milestones, financial achievements, and professional...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. How to Stop Over-Functioning and Build a Healthier Kind of Resilience

    Nov 6, 202612 minAudio

    How to Set Boundaries, Share Responsibility, and Protect Your Energy Without Losing Your Strength Resilience is often associated with pushing through challenges, staying strong under pressure, and being the person...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Less Proving, More Alignment: How to Live by Your Own Values

    Oct 30, 20266 minAudio

    How to Stop Seeking Approval and Start Making Choices That Reflect Who You Truly Are Many of the lives that look most impressive from the outside are quietly shaped by an invisible audience. We pursue, perform, explain,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Grief Hidden in Reinvention

    Oct 23, 20268 minAudio

    How to Navigate the Grief of Change and Turn Transitions Into Growth Reinvention is often described as an exciting new beginning, but meaningful change can also come with grief. Even when we know a transition is right...

    Credit the people on this episode