Research On Social Support, Purpose, and Choosing Your Path
17 minAudio
Send us Fan Mail Talmage Thayne shares some research that he has done while looking for ways to help missionaries coming home. Significant elements that help transition include having social support, direction or purpose, and general understanding from the community around them. He shares what different social studies have shown and how we can best help the return missionaries we personally know. Remember, God is good and is planning on your success. And though you've been released from your mission, you haven't been released from your ministry.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Talmage ThayneWelcome to release the podcast. I'm Talmage the host. Now this week's episode is a little different because it's not the story form that we usually do with me interviewing somebody. This week's episode is me sharing some of the research that I've done about return missionaries and their struggle. And honestly, a lot of this research has helped me out a lot. And I'm hoping that it does the same for you.
Talmage ThayneBecause many Latter Day Saints returned missionary struggle to transition home, we should support the missionaries we personally know during the critical time of transition. Members of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints have the opportunity shortly after high school to serve a mission away from home. Young men served for two years and young women serve for 18 months, they're assigned to serve in one of 400 missions worldwide. While there, the missionaries have a strict schedule to keep, besides eating, sleeping and exercising, all their time is taken up by study service projects, and teaching people about their faith. This extreme lifestyle for an extended period of time is abnormal to the rest of the world. And after a while, a normal lifestyle is abnormal to these missionaries. Once these missionaries have been released from their service, and they return home, they're expected to hit the ground running. But many times that's not what happens.
Talmage ThayneThere are countless ways a return missionary can struggle. Now I won't be able to cover all of those, but I wanted to talk about some of the main ways that a missionary can be helped during their time of transition. And that is through social support a purpose filled life and structure and finding your own path in life. Social support can help missionaries deal with mental health issues. Humans are social creatures, and we are wired to seek that support, especially if we can have healthy relationships with people in different circles of life. There's a study recently done titled The influence of social support on dyadic function and mental health among military personnel during post deployment reintegration. They found if military men or women lacked support after he or she comes home from deployment, their depression, anxiety and PTSD dramatically increased.
Talmage ThayneThey also found that the healthiest were people that had support in different circles of life. They broke these circles down to three main categories, military, friends and leaders, family and non military personnel. They found that any kind of support is good, but it is best when it is balanced between these three groups. If someone only has support from his or her family, their anxiety goes down, but their PTSD and depression increase. If they only had support from their military, friends and leaders, their depression and PTSD would go down, but their anxiety would increase. The other part of the study that was examined was the relationship between dyadic function and mental health dyadic function is the ability to develop a one on one relationship with other people.
Talmage ThayneThis is also referred to as social skills. The post deployed military personnel who had better dyadic function could create faster and more intimate relationships, which in turn fostered more support and improved their mental health. Though this study focused on the demographic obviously different from LDS missionaries, it is very applicable, though their daily routines and purpose are vastly different. Both groups can experience similar symptoms on coming home from being in a similar structured environment.
Talmage ThayneIf these military men and women are helped with increased social support, then our young missionaries can be helped in the same way. As said previously, purpose is a significant component of a missionaries life. When they come home, many feel like they're stripped of that and are now told to find his or her purpose. This is difficult for most adults to do. So when a young adult struggles to find that purpose. It it causes them to start questioning their beliefs. It could lead to a behavior opposite of how they acted while on the mission. In Vernon Howard's article, the poignancy of purpose. He proposes that a lack of purpose leads to nihilism. Nihilism is the worldview that nothing matters and nothing you do has no In a significant consequence, in essence, nihilism is believing life is meaningless.
Talmage ThayneIt can go as far as hatred for existence itself. Some of the most horrific acts were done from a nihilistic outlook. The Columbine shooters, the Communist Russia, and Nazi Germany all had nihilistic outlooks on life. While those are extreme examples of this worldview, either way, is still negatively affects the individual if not society, humans need purpose. And when there is none, there's a void. We feel unsatisfied and lost. missionaries who come home and are unclear about their purpose, or in danger of feeling this void and experiencing a feelings of dissatisfaction being lost.
Talmage ThayneAnd at the far end of the spectrum, nihilism, many well meaning people and leaders of the Latter Day Saint faith do their best to give their returning missionaries a purpose when they arrive home. This can come in the form of advising them to go to school, enrolling in Institute of Religion, and getting married right away. While none of these suggestions are bad ideas, they're often seen as attempts to control the returned missionaries life. If it is viewed this way. It can cause missionaries to become resistant to any sort of advice because they feel it is someone else's purpose and not their own. But just because the common culture has encouraged something that should not be a reason not to consider it. On the other hand, it is good to question the purpose that a particular culture encourages, one of two things will happen either the return missionary will realize they personally and genuinely find purpose in what is being encouraged, or something completely different. A return missionary with purpose is nearly unstoppable. But a return missionary with no purpose is merely unmotivated. Many missionaries found great meaning and purpose on their mission, and they want that to continue while at home. In an attempt to help them keep that sense of purpose. They developed on their mission, they were advised to keep up their missionary practices. Oftentimes, church leaders, friends and family will counsel return missionaries to continue praying, reading scriptures, planning out their days, and looking for ways to serve others. These habits have been proven time and time again to help a missionary in his or her transition home. And that is because it transitions their purpose from a bootcamp structured life to the practical real world. If those practices are purposefully done, while in the real world, they will be an anchor for the mental and emotional health of that missionary. However, if those practices are done sporadically and merely out of obligation, in other words, if the missionary is practicing religiosity, it will become a source of mental distress.
Talmage ThayneA 2016 study titled religion purpose in life, social support, psychological distress and new Chinese University found that when an individual practices religiosity as defined previously, they were more susceptible to psychological distress. They also found that already distressed people sought out religion to find meaning in their lives. When they genuinely sought out religion, they generally found increased purpose and social support in their lives. Interestingly, the outcomes of the study were nearly identical across the board, no matter what university they went to. In a way, this study shows that it isn't so much what you do, but why you do it that matters most. This is also very clearly painted in the book 12 rules to life, an antidote to chaos by Jordan Peterson. The author talks about simple actions we all need to take to orient ourselves towards the most possible good that we can. One rule he discusses is to clean your room. It will help you distinguish between order and chaos. And when you clean your room and do those simple things. It'll bring more meaning and purpose to those everyday things that you have to do anyways. religious practices, if not done with heart has almost no benefit and can actually be negative. On the other hand, if an individual takes the practices he or she learned while on the mission and consistently uses them, they can experience greater mental and emotional stability, in addition to the sense of purpose, and more social support. Often the expectations of a community can be a cause of struggle and decline in mental health, specifically, in a place highly populated with members of the Church such as Utah, there can be cultural issues. There can be these cultural issues for return missionaries outside of these densely populated areas, but it is usually more intense in such regions. Whether you love the Latter Day Saint culture or not, no one argues that it's perfect.
Talmage ThayneThere are times when teachings of love and understanding can be forgotten or ignored. In an attempt to persuade or encourage returned missionaries to do the quote unquote right thing. Most of the time, it is well intentioned, but that doesn't make it any easier when you're feeling like you're getting controlled. Benjamin Knowles did a study about LGBTQ youth in the Latter Day Saint church and suicide rates. The rhetoric of the church suggested that in 2015, gay weddings were apostate and increased attention on the LGBTQ community. And lack of understanding caused the rhetoric of the culture, not the church to cause alienation and pressure to conform for all the youth openly part of the LGBTQ community, and those who are still in the closet. This study showed that suicide rate in Utah for youth between the ages of 15 and 19 Since 2011, which isn't the case for other states. There are other factors however, such as elevation, gun ownership, mental health issues, but the fact remains the isolating rhetoric has negative effects.
Talmage ThayneNow, I wanted to examine this study, because it makes the point I wanted to get across and it's not only for the LGBTQ community, oftentimes returned, missionaries can feel pressured socially, into being and doing what their community wants them to be or do. This is not to say that people should not share their opinions, advice, and encourage people one way or the other. But we need to be aware that a returned missionary is his or her own person, and they will ultimately live life the way they see fit. Agency is one of the core teachings of Jesus Christ as well as his church, and also includes love, service and support, even if there is disagreement.
Talmage ThayneNow when a missionary returns home, there's a belief that they are independent enough, because after all, they lived away for an extended period of time away from family and friends and their support network. I've often heard missionary say on returning home that they don't want to be mothered, and they want people to stay out of their business. Granted, no one wants to feel like they completed their mission simply to have other people breathe down their neck. Jordan Peterson also addresses this in the chapter don't bother children. While they're skateboarding. He talks about the importance of searching for independence and possible danger. When a skateboarder takes a risk and comes out on top, they feel empowered. Missionaries need to feel that risk success and empowerment as well. Some would argue that too much support could take that away from them.
Talmage ThayneOn the other hand, I feel like there's a way to support without being overbearing or crippling. So to finish this up, as many friends family and church leaders have experienced, return, missionaries can have a multitude of struggles while coming home, they can experience a loss of social support a loss of purpose, a loss of structure, and a feeling of pressure to conform. Now, there are many more reasons why a missionary can struggle while coming home.
Talmage ThayneI can't talk about them all here. That's why I've loved having people on the podcast to talk about their struggles, what's worked for them. And I'm just really grateful for that. And due to the fact that many of these return missionaries struggle, I believe that their support community should be aware of the pitfalls and equipped to offer understanding and resources during this time of transition. Now I've talked to many return missionaries off the podcast and a lot on the podcast. And one of the biggest things I've found is that a support network is so critical and crucial. And so if we can be that support network for a missionary returning home, letting them know that we care, we are understanding and that we will support them in their goals and in their life choices and in their purpose. That can be one of the biggest and most game changing things that we can do for them. Now missionaries and members are very aware that when somebody joins the Latter Day Saint faith They covenant or promise with God, that they will bear one another's burdens that they may be light. Yay. And are willing to mourn with those that mourn and comfort those that stand in need of comfort. The greatest gift that we can give to a return missionary, or anyone for that matter, is ourselves.
Talmage ThayneHey, guys, thank you so much for listening to this episode is a little shorter than usual. But honestly, I am so grateful that you guys come and listen. And you guys share your thoughts with me. Honestly, it means the world to me every single time I get a message about it. And so thank you so much. Now I want to do a shout out to one of the reviews that released got. It was James James said when I got home from my mission, I felt very discouraged. I felt guilty about feeling this. It's great to hear the stories of other people. So I know I wasn't alone. Thank you. Thanks so much, James. That means the world to me and and please, please, please go to social media. Tell me what you think.
Talmage ThayneLeave a review. Honestly, those reviews helped me so much in pushing it out to more people that need to hear it. And remember, God is good and he's planned on your success. And though you've been released from your mission, you've not been released from your ministry.
Send us Fan Mail Chandler Hendry, the man behind Restored_Truth, has passed away. But his ministry will not pass away. Chantry Hendry, Chuck’s brother, is continuing the work that was started. Chantry shares his story...
Send us Fan Mail God be with you till we meet again. Chandler Hendry shares his experience on the mission in Jackson, Mississippi, where he spent two years qualifying his testimony of the restored gospel. He did this by...
Send us Fan Mail Talmage sits down with Noah Canon, a public speaker who’s passionate about suicide prevention for teens. Noah grew up in Idaho, and during his teenage years, he began working-out in the gym and...
Send us Fan Mail Talmage sits down with Maddy Packer, a passionate LDS apologist and history buff, for an insightful episode. Maddy grew up in New Mexico, attending Catholic school from seventh through twelfth grade,...
Send us Fan Mail In this episode (Sz4 Ep5), Talmage sits down with his wife, Mary Thayne, for a vulnerable and inspiring conversation. Taken from a larger interview, this segment explores why Mary chose to move forward...