Ali Gull: Being On Both Sides of a Broken Engagement
1 hr 3 minAudio
Send us Fan Mail Talmage Thayne interviews Ali Gull. She tells her story about dating after the mission and getting engaged twice. The first time she was engaged she broke it off but the second time around her fiance ended it. She shares how she knows it was right to date them at the time, but ultimately it wasn't supposed to lead to marriage. Remember, God is good and is planning on your success. And though you've been released from your mission, you haven't been released from your ministry.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Allie GullPeople are gonna think there's something seriously wrong with me like to engagements like what? What you're doing wrong
Talmage ThayneWelcome to release the podcast. This is Talmage the host. Now I got to interview Allie goal this week, Ali has lived everywhere because of her father's job. But she was in Tennessee right before she went on her mission, came back, went to BYU Idaho, and recently graduated as a surgeon's assistant. Now, we did this interview over zoom, so the audio isn't as good as usual. But the content is still there.
Talmage ThayneSo Ali, thank you so much for being on release the podcast. I'm super excited to have you because your email, you have like a really cool story. And I'm just excited for other people to hear it as well.
Allie GullI'm excited to be here. Also nervous but very excited.
Talmage ThayneYeah, I don't blame you. I still get nervous about these kinds of things. But yeah, could you tell me just a little bit about yourself where you're from? And like, just kind of like, a bit about your childhood?
Allie GullYeah, yeah, of course. Um, I was born and raised in the church. I was born in Utah. I lived there for about until I was like eight and then moved to Idaho, and started high school in Idaho, and then moved to Tennessee, and finished high school in Tennessee. And I left for my mission from there and then went to back to Idaho for school. So I've been all over the place. I know oldest,
Talmage Thaynewhat made you guys move around so much
Allie Gullmy dad's job. I don't know why he likes to move us around. He's just as typical graphic designer, but you also he does. So there's this around. But
Talmage Thayneyeah, cool. How many kids are in your family?
Allie GullSo there's three of us. And I'm the oldest, a little two little siblings and they're adorable. But yeah, my brother. He's, oh, gosh, I think he's 22. Now, he lives in Provo, and then I have a little sister who's about to turn nine. So I'm fun.
Talmage ThayneThat is fun. And it's fun. So wait, sorry. You said you had a brother 22? Yeah. Okay, and how old are you?
Allie GullI'm 2323. Okay,
Talmage Thayneperfect. Awesome. Is there anything that you feel like, kind of defined you and made you kind of want to go on the mission?
Allie GullOh, man, that is a long story. I mean, I was raised in the church. And it's always been kind of pushed in our heads, like serving a mission is good. But I like, you know, it's more for the guys that they've kind of pushed it on. But I've had a lot of members that are like you should go. And that will kind of like push me away when now. I'm not going to go. So I I kind of didn't ever want to go on a mission. I kind of push that off. And I was like, No, I'm going to school, never serving a mission. But my senior year, things kind of got extremely crazy. And I started getting super, super nervous about leaving for school. And I thought it was because I was going to school like far away from my family. I just I didn't know what it was. And I had a testimony growing up. But I didn't feel like it was as strong as it could have been.
Allie GullAnd so I didn't, I didn't pray as much. I didn't read my scriptures as much. I kind of just went through the motions. I just went to church and mutual and all that stuff growing up and just went through those motions. And there was one time where I was super, super nervous about going to school. And so I decided that, you know, like, I'm going to pray about this. And I'm like, in my head. I'm like, This is crazy. Like, I don't pray very often. Why would I do this? So I knelt down for like for seven years, okay. And I prayed. And I was like, okay, Heavenly Father, this is my plan. I'm going on this day, I'm going to school. This is where I'm moving to like, is this where I'm supposed to go? And I ended my prayer. And I sat there for like two seconds. And I'm like, yeah, he's not answering me. So I went straight to bed like this. So then I was woken up like, three hours later, from this dream that I had that I served a mission. And it was kind of like a mesh of like me at school and the sky that I was dating so I was like, that's just a dream. That's not real.
Allie GullAnd I wasn't really serving a mission. It was just all these ideas, but I couldn't fall back asleep. Like the idea of serving a mission just like was haunting me. It felt like like Okay, fine. So I sat there and I was like fine, like Heavenly Father, I'm gonna make a deal with you. I will read Preach My Gospel for a month and And I won't tell anyone about this idea that I'm going to serve, like I'm thinking about serving a mission, and just leave it at that. And I could I fell asleep, right off the bat after that. The next day held true to my word. I read Preach My Gospel.
Allie GullAnd I think I got like halfway through the first chapter. And I was just like, Okay, this is this is good. And I felt super. I don't know, I felt kind of nervous. But the idea of a mission wouldn't leave my head. It was just constantly penetrating my head. And I don't know if your parents are the same way. But mine can tell when something's bugging me or when something's on my mind. Oh, yeah.
Talmage ThayneThat's like a parent superpower. My mom
Allie Gullis always the moms. I don't know what it is. Yeah,
Talmage Thaynemy dad. My dad's pretty good at that, too. Like, he just, he just is pretty good at that, too. So
Allie Gullanyway, so I texted my mom. And I was like, Hey, I've had something on my mind. All day. I just don't ask why I'm trying to figure it out first, and then I'll talk to you when I'm ready. And she was like, Okay, it's kind of weird. And I was like, sorry, I'm being vague. It just, I really want to think about this first before I talk to anybody else. And she responded, 30 minutes later, and she just all she said was one word. And it said Michigan with a question mark. And I'm like, What the heck is she No. Class, and I read her text, and I dropped my phone. And I was like, This is crazy. And my friend was what's wrong? I was like, How does my mom know? And she's like, What did you do?
Allie GullWhat did you do wrong? To do anything? It's like just something on my mind. She somehow knew. And I was like, yes, that's exactly what it is. And her response was, you know what, you can talk to me? When when you're ready. And at that point, I was like, I'm ready now. Like, how the heck does she even know? Yeah, so I went home, like, right after class. And I talked with her. And I told her the whole, like, the whole dream and everything. And come to find out my mom and my dad had a conversation about me serving admission that night, that I said, and my mom was like, Don't pressure her. Like, it has to be her decision and everything. And as my mom's telling me this, I'm like, Okay, this is another sign like, I'm gonna have to go. So I told my dad through, I was working on my graduation announcement. And I wrote it in there. And I had him read it.
Allie GullAnd he didn't read it. At first. He just looked at it, because I was like, here, I changed my graduation announcement. Well, you look at it. And he's like, sure. You looked at it briefly. And he's like, Hey, what did you want to talk about? And I'm like, No, you need to read it, like, the wording. And he was like, okay, and he just like started tearing up recycling serious. Like you wanted to go on a mission. I was like, Yeah, I think so. It's only like, hasn't even been 24 hours yet. But yeah, I'm going. So like, the next few days, I mean, this was a Friday. And so that coming Sunday, I immediately just pulled my bishop aside, I was like, I need to talk to you today. And he's like, okay, like, I'll just pull you out of class. And so he pulled me out.
Allie GullHe's like, What do you need to talk about? So I told him, that whole thing. And I told him that I definitely want to serve a mission. I just needed to know what I need to do about it. Because it's never been on my radar of what I wanted to do. And we can figure out how that works. And he, he told me that he sat there and he's like, you know, it's like, I thought about you this weekend. And I was like, what? Like, yeah, I was praying about the youth this this weekend. He's like, and I really felt like I needed to bring you in and talk to you about mission. And I'm like, Okay, the third sign, I need to go. And so from then on, I was like, Yeah, God told me, I needed to go on and mission. So
Talmage ThayneWow. That is crazy. That is so cool, though, that you had the dream, your parents were talking about it. Your Bishop was praying about it, and specifically thought of you and the mission. And it's like, all happened at the same time. And the fact that you kept to your word to be like, Okay, God, I promise I'll do that. You know how many times I've promised something to God. Like, I'm gonna do it.
Allie GullBut he kept pushing that mission in my head, and I was like, fine. throw my hands up. Like, I'll do it. Alright.
Talmage ThayneAnd didn't even take you a month. Tikki like 24 hours. Yeah, that's awesome. So did you start on your papers right then?
Allie GullI did. I still like wasn't of age to go. But I started on them then and then turned them in when I could like, as soon as I could, whenever I think it was like three months before you actually serve. I can't remember now. Yeah, I turn them in as soon as I could after that, and I left a month after my 90th birthday. Just off I went.
Talmage ThayneWhere'd you get called to?
UnknownSo I served in the California Redlands mission. And
Talmage Thayneso you graduated high school? And were you just kind of like working during that time working on your papers? Yeah. Did you go to any school at that point?
Allie GullNope. Just after the fact that I was so nervous about going to school, I was like, I guess my focus just needs to be my mission. And so I worked. I graduated as a see, like a nursing assistant. So I was working as that before I left on my mission. And then off I went, I was counting down the days because I, I told my bishop, I was like, I'm gonna have to start on this as soon as possible, or I'm going to talk myself out of this. Yeah, definitely didn't want to in the first place. He's like, Okay, let's do
Talmage Thaynethat. That is exactly me too. Like, whenever I like, have something good that I'm like, Okay, I know, I need to do this. I need to do it now. Otherwise, I will talk yourself out of it. Yeah, that's awesome. So could you tell me a little bit about your mission? When you got there, and just like a little bit about the lessons you learned the people?
Allie GullOh, man, so many of the contact a year and a half. I officially got out there in January of 2016. And I, I struggled at the beginning of my mission, I struggled a lot. And it's I think it's because I didn't really have that strong of a testimony that I was hoping I would have before I went out. I mean, in the MTC, I really, really struggled. I cried almost every day because I'm like, I can't teach. Like I can't get used to come out like I it's just not working. And I think it's because I just got so in my head. I didn't really have much of the testimony like you should missionary, but it was good.
Allie GullBecause I was able to build my testimony and watch my companions teach. I learned a lot about the Savior, and about his love for for everyone. And about the power of the atonement. I think that was the number one thing that I witnessed.
Talmage ThayneYeah, I totally feel that thing. And then you. So did you end your mission in 2017? Yeah. Yep. Awesome. Can you tell me a little bit about that with the transition home,
Allie Gulloh, boy. Got home in the summertime. And so that was a good time to adjust to normal life before jumping into school. But my adjustment home was It was rough. At first, I had a couple of friends that I would talk to, I would still keep in contact with people from my mission, and I still tried to, I could definitely do better, but there, I still try to keep in contact with as many as I possibly can. But, um, I don't know, there's a, you know how, like, you have that boost of energy where you're like, I'm returned missionary, like, everything at home is gonna be perfect, because I serve the Lord, and there's gonna be so much spirit in my home. Like, there's gonna be so many blessings that come from that.
Allie GullAnd so you call him I expected my family to be perfect. Like, I expected them to be like, oh, yeah, we do family home evening, every Monday. And we do all this, you know, like, just, you know, perfect to the tee. And when I came home, when I found out that you don't do family home, even we never really did that growing up. It's so disappointed. Like, I remember looking at my parents, and I was like, you have to do something about this. Like, this is not right. We'd have the Spirit in our home, we totally had the spirit in our home. But missionary mode, you've got to make sure everything is like everything is about that. So that was a weird adjustment.
Allie GullFinally, I got over that whole thing and realize you have to accept the reality of life. And not everything is perfect. But as as long as you were trusting in the Lord, you're living the gospel, which is exactly what my family has been doing. Everything's fine. point where I thought that they were.
Talmage ThayneYeah. And so did you kind of just start kind of just acclimating to being at home again. And were you planning you were still in Tennessee at this point? Yeah.
Allie GullSo back to Tennessee, and then waited for school to start. So I went up to BYU Idaho for school that fall. So yeah, it was a little weird. I had a lot of family that are like, Okay, go date, go meet people. And I'm like, I've been going for like a week. And like, did it right away. So a lot of adjustment was different because I feel like I don't know like you just like you're saying being like a missionary. You were so missionary minded that everything has to be related the gospel, all of those things because you can tie anything to the gospel. But I was thinking that like, I don't know, it took a lot for me to realize that like I I only have one. And I hate to say only one. But you only really have one responsibility as a missionary.
Allie GullAnd that is to teach the gospel to go find people to come to Christ. Now, when you come home, you have more than that. It's not just trying to find people to come to Christ, I mean, your friends, your family, people you come in contact with, but you also have to get your education, you have to keep the goals that you set before you left on your mission. I don't know, hopefully find that eternal companion. Like, there's so many things. To do that. I feel like, people forget that. That's like, that's like the main focus. And so when, when you start realizing that, oh, I have more responsibilities, I have to be more of an adult now. Those like missionary mindset kind of tapers away. And so your goals kind of disappear. And I watched that with me because I was so gung ho, I was like, Okay, I'm gonna keep to my missionary time, I'm going to wake up at six o'clock every morning, 630, I can't remember because clearly, I don't wake up at that time anymore. I'm going to exercise and I'm going to read my scriptures and all like, every day, and I did that for a week. And afterwards, I'm like, I'm tired. I have no one else.
Allie GullLike, it's not fun to do your workouts alone with your companion. So those would slowly taper off. And I watched, like, I'd still read my scriptures every day. But I realized that it wasn't praying as often. And I wasn't paying attention. In church meetings, everything I was like, up here again. So I was going back down on that slope that I was kind of that before my mission, but I still like, had a little bit more motivation to be better than I was. But
Talmage ThayneI totally feel that and you're like, Can you can you get mad at yourself? When you're not reaching those goals? You're like, Man, I'm an idiot. I can't do what I said. Even though that's not true. You shouldn't call us Oh, yeah, for sure. But I definitely did. Awesome. So you went to BYU Idaho, in the fall. I went to I went to BYU Idaho before my mission. And it was it was great, sort of. It's a great school. I didn't I didn't have a great time. But it's a great school. But yeah, tell me about that. You're you move. Did you just start dating right away once you got into college?
Allie GullUnfortunately, yes. Right into it. Right afterwards, I set up on blind dates. The whole nine yards. Yeah, it was a weird adjustment, like getting used to having roommates. And some roommates didn't serve a mission. So they were like, Oh, you have so much like a sister missionary. And I'm like, No, I don't really talk about it. Totally normal. So that was a weird adjustment to have people say but was also a compliment. Because they're like, you still talk like a missionary? And I'm like, Oh, that's good. Hopefully that won't change. But yeah, I don't know it. Yeah. So I started dating. And I actually I got engaged at the end of that semester. So I'd only been home for six months. And I got engaged to somebody that I got set up on a blind date when I didn't even know him at all. And it was a crazy, crazy been
Talmage Thaynea good blind date,
Allie Gullbecause it was a good point.
Talmage ThayneWhat did he do? Right?
Allie GullShe treated me like a queen that I think that's what he did. Right? And okay, like, that's just
Talmage Thayneguys. No, because you guys need to know that. They do.
Allie GullYou do need to open up your doors for those girls don't forget. Yeah. So for several reason. How do you say that word?
Talmage ThayneChivalry. Chivalry is not dead. That's good. That's good. So he treated you like a queen. And I guess it progressed all the way to being being engaged.
Allie GullYeah. And our engagement after that was pretty rough. Anything that had to do with a lot that we didn't really know each other, which is a given. But I mean, there's a lot of people in this world that can attest to we got married, like two weeks after knowing somebody, but I, I started learning more things about him and the struggles that he was having. And I mean, a through my mission, I was I've watched people change, I watched like I was telling you the power of the atonement. And I, I knew that no matter what somebody was going through, that they can change.
Allie GullAnd I had a lot of faith in him. And I was like, you know, I know that you're struggling with these things. And I know that whatever you're going through those keeping us from getting married in the temple. I feel like you can get through this and I'm here for you And we pushed our date, like, constantly, because there will be times where he would make choices. And it wouldn't it wouldn't mean up to, you know, being temple worthy. And that was very, very, very hard. I guess with his mom, she became like, my, what is the word?
Allie GullSomebody that I could just rely on during this whole thing, because she also was struggling a lot with what he was, what I guess the choices that he was making, because it was It wasn't only just affecting him, it was affecting everyone else. And, um, and I didn't realize how much it was affecting me because I was so focused on him. Like, I wanted to make sure that he was happy if there's anything that I could I could do for him. And I, even I talked with his bishop, I sat in meetings. And it just wasn't just wasn't working. And I remember one day, I was talking with my mom, I actually went home for a week. Because I was I was living with his his parents for a little bit. And I was working at their family business. And I went home, and my mom was like, here's something off, like, you're just not happy that you don't have a light about you anymore. And I was like, what, like,
Talmage Thayneit's so much what the heck,
Allie Gulllike you do have a light about you anymore. I'm like, Yeah, me wrong. Like, I know that this guy, he's struggling with things, but I love him and all these thoughts that went through my head. And I got in some huge arguments with my mom over this because I was like, You have no right to tell me all these things. And the more that I thought about it, the more I realized that I was actually extremely unhappy. And I didn't. And I didn't realize that because I was so focused on him. I wanted to make sure that he was happy, which is okay. But I started to forget about myself. And my mom, like, you know what, I feel like, you just need to go to the temple, we need to figure this out. And so I did, I went to the temple, and I just prayed and prayed and prayed. And I only got, the only answer I got was Be patient. I was like, be patient in what I'm like, in him and me. And my family. Like, I don't know what I'm supposed to do. And the more that I thought about it, my mom was like, You know what, he is struggling with something that is far bigger than you can help him. And, and I was hurt to hear because I'm like, I love them.
Allie GullHe loves me, we should be able to help each other through anything. And my mom was like, You're right. But it also needs to be with the right person to do that with. And I'm like, okay, true. And so the more that I thought about it, she was like, I think you just need to break off engagement, just let it go. I'm like, okay, um, I don't know, I'll think about it. And so I thought about it. I went back to California, where his family's from and spent like, an entire week with him.
Allie GullAnd I was like, you know, I think when we go home, we're still like together and everything. But I feel like I need to pull myself out of the picture. So you can kind of figure out what you're going through some things. Yeah. And that was really hard. He was definitely devastated. And so he actually drove me home. We didn't why he drove me home, because he was like, I feel so bad. He's like, I wish like it'd be more clear for you and everything. And I was like, and this is the best way we can do it is like the way that I can be there for you as if I'm out of the picture just so that you can focus on yourself. And that was very difficult. And so he did that. And he came back like a couple of weeks later to visit because his family lived up in Rexburg. And he had a couple family members lived in Rexburg.
Allie GullAnd we were planning on going on a date one last time before he was officially out to California. And I was talking to my mission mission president and his wife,
Talmage Thaynewhat was he going to California for sales or for work
Allie Gulllike he's before his parents and his mom and dad was live out there. Okay. I was out there family business out in California. But he has a sibling that lives in Rexburg. So he was up there visiting them for a little bit. But um, let's see, I lost my train of thought.
Talmage ThayneSo he, yeah, he came up asked to go on a date. Yeah.
Allie GullOh, yeah. Cuz he's like, I'm going back to California for a while. He's like, I'd like to go on one more date with you just you know, so we can see if everything's good. And that day, I was on the phone with my machine president and I was telling him and his wife about basically the whole situation, because I'm like, I don't know what to do. I was like, it hurts that I have to be far away that I can't be there with him, and I want to be able to support him. And that I just, there are things that they said that were super helpful. And I started realizing that I was kind of being used as a crutch.
Allie GullAnd that's not to say anything bad about him by any means. But it was more of the fact that he was struggling with something and it was very hard for him to get over your he'd basically think it's okay. ally will be there. We'll be fine. We'll make it through. And that in that mindset, and I didn't realize he was having that mindset until talking to his mom leader, that in reality that's that was hindering him from actually progressing because he's like, Okay, I made this mistake. It's okay. Like the person that I love still loves me. And there was just no progression. It was just this consistent.
Talmage ThayneThere's, there's no kind of like, ultimatum there's no there's no real consequence to anything and so yeah, it's easy to justify things when and I totally don't blame him because like it's easy to justify things when there is a crutch. And that's not saying that you were a bad, bad thing for him at all. It was just not what he needed at that time.
Allie GullExactly. So that was very, very difficult. And talking with my mission president everything about it. My they told me that, like, you just You seem calm about whatever situation that you're going to make. And I know, you know what you need to do. And when they said that, I was like, Yeah, this needs to end like, I need to break this off. And I didn't say that to them. But I was like, Yeah, I think you're right. And I think they knew deep down what I was gonna, like the decision I was gonna make, but the moment I ended that call with them, he was at my doorstep. And I'm like, oh, goodness, like, this is gonna happen. Now, and he comes up, and he's like, Hey, I feel like we should talk before we go. And I'm like, Okay. And so he brings up he's like, I feel like we, we just need to take a break. And I'm like, Oh, I was like, I think we need to take more than a break. And he's like, What do you mean? We need to end this like completely, like, I, I'm hindering you, from you progressing and you becoming the person that I know you can be.
Allie GullAnd I was like, as much as that pains me. I know that you're going to be able to overcome whatever you're going through. And unfortunately, I can't be that person to help you through that. And I was like, the only person I know. And I didn't say this, but in my head. I was like, the only person I know that can do this. This is Christ. And he's got a great support system. His his mom and his siblings are the greatest people. And so I know that, even though I wasn't there, that he's, he's got more people than it's not just me, you know?
Allie GullYeah. I was devastated as he was as devastated as I was ended. And I felt very at peace, but I also hurt. I definitely, I ate an entire pizza on my own. My watch to me that night, I was just like, Yep, I'm going to eat this entire thing. And just just move on. And it was interesting.
Talmage ThayneYou know, I did something similar. I didn't realize I did it. But it ended with this girl. That was just having a really crappy day. And I was like, You know what, I'm just gonna watch Netflix. I ended up watching. What is it leap year, that chick flick in Ireland? And then I ice cream. And I was like, What am I doing? I'm acting like a girl that just gotten into a breakup. But that's okay. Let's that happens.
Talmage ThayneIs our little continent. Good release? Yeah.
Allie GullI don't know why. Yes, sometimes
Talmage Thayneyou just need those times. Just binge watch a show, eat ice cream, cry a little bit.
Allie GullIt's a good release. Totally.
Talmage ThayneOh, man. Were you devastated for like a while after that? Or do you feel like you kind of were like, you know, this is good. Can I pick up my pace again, and just keep going?
Allie GullI think because it was just a constant struggle. Throughout our engagement, I mean, we are engaged for six months. And it was a constant struggle for that entire time. I think, deep down I was already slowly like, breaking way. Does that make sense? And so I was slowly coming to terms that it's okay. Like, I just need to move on. And so moving on from that was a little bit easier.
TalmageIt was much like a band aid.
Allie GullIt was. Yeah, it was like the band aid was slowly coming off. Like during that whole engagement. It wasn't it wasn't just like an instant, like, Okay, you're gone. Goodbye.
Talmage ThayneI think a final tear. Yeah, and I think
Allie Gullthat's how it was for him. I feel like it was a complete bandaid taken off for him. And that's something that that kills me that had to go through that but also, some you just got to do certain things to you know, happiness for other people. Sometimes it goes in a way that you don't expect it to go. So I got a lot of friends that are like, Okay, I'm gonna set you up with these people. Nice. People are just constantly going on all these dates and I made some really good friends. I got ghosted a lot, you know,
Talmage Thaynegetting ghosted? Yeah. I have done it a couple times. But I know it's bad knee. But after, after I got ghosted a couple times, I'm like, that is so rude. I'm not going to do that anymore. I've recently been telling my sister, because she goes on dates with guys. And I'm like, just like, You know what, I'm just gonna kind of just stop talking to them. I'm like, no, just tell them that you're not interested.
Allie GullI literally was telling my friend the other day about like her dating because she just got home from her mission too. And she's just very, like, dating experiences, whatever. And she's like, I don't know what he's thinking. Like, I think he likes me. I like him. I don't know. And I was like, girl, you gotta straight up ask him. Because I'm at this point where I was like, you don't need to be in this limbo. Stop wasting time. Just ask him. And I was like, but you also have to know where you stand before you are like, Hey, where are we at? You know? Because jumping in to be like, where are you at? And he's like, Oh, I'd really just, I want to be your boyfriend. And she's not at that point. But she like doesn't make that decision.
Allie GullLike, distinctively. She'll just be like, oh, yeah, let's go for it. And so relationship is in his hands might be the same level.
Talmage ThayneThey will communicate. Yeah, you know what you want to communicate it? And then work from there. Totally. Sounds like you have a lot of experience. Oh, yeah. Okay, awesome. So yeah, you're going on dates? I guess. Yeah. Just tell me about that time in your life, what was going on? I guess you were you were basically already kind of healed or like healing, at least from your previous engagement.
Allie GullSo I was trying to get through the healing process of dating. And I also I transferred schools and that process to, I started realizing that I didn't, I was planning going to nursing school, and I realized I don't want to be a nurse anymore. I want to do something different. And I want to do something surgery related, but I didn't want to be a surgeon. I definitely don't want that title. And so I think well for the surgeons that I work with, that have their job, because I couldn't do it. So I went to a different school and started studying like surgical assisting. And I, I loved it. I mean, it just it just like barely ended for me. But I was in the middle of just taking prerequisites during this time when I transferred. And I still kind of in this rut of like, you know, things are going well for me or so I'd really like to date I'd really like to find that person that I'm I want to marry basically. And that just I've had zero luck. And so I decided this mindset, I was like, You know what, I'm just looking in the wrong places. Like, maybe I need to put myself in a more spiritual experience to be able to find this person. And so my thought process, but just a terrible reason to do this. I applied to be a counselor for EF why? I'm like, You know what?
Allie GullGreat. Why in his world, but go and teach youth about the gospel during their summer time. Like, in my mind, I was like,
Talmage Thaynetotally, yeah. Yeah, if Why is a magical place. I actually got my first kiss at FY OC. As a counselor, how does the counselor I know totally against the rules, but
Allie GullI told me is, I had a cake is another girl once you so this past summer, I was rooting for him, which is terrible.
Talmage ThayneNice, dude. That's funny.
Allie GullBut so that's what I ended up doing. I ended up working that summer. I was actually last summer as a counselor, not necessarily looking for that person to marry. But it's just like, it'd be an extra bonus. There was just, I need a more spiritual experience. Because I noticed when I came home, and all the struggles I was going through with dating and trying to figure out what I wanted to do school wise. I started like, tapering off my spiritual side of myself. And I mean, I'd still attend the temple and everything, but I was like, I need something I need, like an extra boost. And I thought this was a great opportunity. And it really was, I felt like a missionary again.
Allie GullI mean, I got a name tag and everything. And I was teaching about Christ to these kids and hoping that they would come closer to Christ. I mean, that was the whole point. And so and that was like my whole summer. And I was like, This is so cool. I'm definitely a missionary again, but I don't have his name. I don't have Christ's name on my on my chest anymore. It's my name. And it just it was a very cool experience and I watched a lot of lot of youth change. I also So I watched a lot of youth cry, and struggle, because I was also a health counselor. So those that were sick I basically helped with throughout the rest of the summer. And sometimes it was rough. There were times we wake up at like three o'clock in the morning to help these kids that have a migraine and they didn't know what to do. And
Talmage Thayneit's crazy. Don't have their parents with me don't.
Allie GullAnd kudos to them that they could you go out of their way and trust some college student with their life, but
Talmage Thaynethat's awesome, though. I've always wanted to be an EFI counselor.
Allie GullDo it. I mean,
Talmage Thaynethe next hour Yeah, next summer, maybe that'd be great. That's awesome. And so did you find anybody? I guess while you were out there, was there any counselor that just caught your eye and you're like, Hey, he is good luck. It is in the gospel.
Allie GullYou know, there were a few. I will give you that. There were a few that I was like, Okay, I could date him. I totally could. But the more that I got to know them, it was like to be honest with you, I get like a Idaho and Provo are like polar opposites. And just like the way the dynamic is, and there is a thing, like there's a Provo bro vibe in Provo without doubt most of most of the EFI counselors or whatever, they have that little vibe and I'm like, about that vibe, which there's nothing bad about it. I mean, there's there's a girl for them, but it's not me. So I definitely did not. Did not find that. Prince Charming me if like
Talmage Thayneyou're doing FY and in Provo, at BYU.
Allie GullYeah, so I was there for housing. I went all over. I was in Provo for a couple weeks. I was in Salt Lake for a couple weeks. I went to Ohio, Florida. When I was in West Jordan. I went everywhere. It was so so fun. I wouldn't I wouldn't change it for the world.
Talmage ThayneThat's awesome. But you didn't find your guy and didn't find my guy. Same same, was it. And then that ended. That ended, went back to school and were you still at BYU Idaho.
Allie GullAt that point, I had officially transferred to a different school. And I had so once that summer ended, I just was about to start my surgical Assisting program. And I was terrified, absolutely terrified. Because I was like, I just had this summer hanging out with all these kids. And now I gotta get down and dirty. Like this is like, this is like the work.
Talmage ThayneSo put your head down, like back just Yeah,
Allie Gullexactly. So I was terrified. I was like, This isn't good. And I have made some really great friends during that. During that program. I mean, it just ended like a week ago. For me. So visually done, but
Talmage Thayneyou're graduated.
Allie GullYes, I graduated.
Talmage ThayneCongrats.
Allie GullThat's awesome. That's very exciting. But yeah, I saw I was that's what happened right afterwards, went to school, I had none again, I've got more friends are setting me up with their friends and going through that whole thing. And nothing's nothing's working. And I remember one day, I was just I was driving down to one of my rotations at a hospital. And so I I went down to this one hospital, and I got a text message. And that was from a guy that I went on a date with my very first semester of college like, right when I came home, it was like my, oh, I was only like, a month into school when I came like right after my meeting. And he just like texted me out of the blue. He was like, Hey, are you still like in our expert area? And I was like, yes, it was like, Who is this?
Allie GullLike is like deleted as a member since then? It's been like, two years since this point. Yeah. I don't know. He asked me on a date. And I was really skeptical. I was like, um, I don't know. I don't know if I should go on a date with him. He kind of goes to me a little bit in the past. Oh,
Talmage Thaynedid you bring that up?
Allie GullNo, actually, I didn't meet leader. I was like, I feel like you didn't really like me as much. You didn't really talk to me after like our second date. He's like, I was just dating a lot of people at the time, like, well, so I was I but still I know. I kind of push them off. And I was like, you know, maybe some other time we can go on a date and he's like, okay, maybe sometime next week. And I was like, Okay, I think that's kind of serious. So I gave him a chance and I went on a date that next week. And it was a good day like it was by far the best day I'd had since Smile last engagement. And I was like, okay, or let's be great, let's be great experience and whatever. And I had a lot of friends that were asking me like, you've been talking to this guy a lot, like, how are things going? I was like really well, really, really well. And, um, we dated for a while, like a couple months. And then we got engaged at the end of that year.
Allie GullAnd so it happened. It just happened so fast yet again. And I pushed off, like, making it official with him for as long as I possibly could, because I was like, I'm not ready, like, not necessarily ready for. Okay, it's not the fact that I wasn't ready to date. But it was like, I'm nervous about the whole, like, committing myself to someone because they didn't want it before. And it didn't work out as I thought it would. And so I was like, Ah, I don't know.
Allie GullAnd he was respectful that to an extent. And so he helped me kind of wait it out. That waiting out only lasted a month until I brought it up again. And he was like, So what are we? And I'm like, I don't know. But we ended up getting engaged at the end of that year. And wedding planning was exciting. More or less, I definitely was more excited around this this time around, because this relationship was a lot better than my first engagement.
Allie GullAnd there's, I don't know, it just it went a lot better. But they're there to call him out on this. But he, he doesn't know how to compromise very well. And so ever worked. It was constantly like, well, what would you like to do? And I'm like, well, maybe we should do this. And he's like, I'm thinking we should do this instead. I'm like, okay, so we ended up just doing whatever he wanted to do, which is fine, because he likes to do things that I normally don't like to do. So it kind of got me out of my comfort zone anyway. But I started losing the things that like I absolutely love to do.
Talmage ThayneYeah. started losing a little bit who you are being. Yeah,
Allie Gullyeah, exactly. I mean, I love football. Football is my all time favorite thing in the world. And every guy I've ever dated, hates it, like hates it with the passion. Well. It's fine, because I can I can teach him football. Like what girl has to teach a guy football. But yeah, um, he didn't like it. He didn't like it at all. And so I remember I was like, You know what? This is one game was like, can you just sit and watch one game with me? And he was so bored out of his mind. And I felt so bad. He's like, okay, I guess we won't watch this. So I didn't watch the rest of football season, this last football season. I've noticed I actually, here's the story. I actually talked to a lot of people about compromise after this whole like, throughout like this engagement and stuff. And they're like, that's kind of a problem. Like, you should be able to, to compromise with no problem. Like it should be a total equal balance. And it just never was. It was just, he's very hard headed. And I'm very hard headed. So we were just always like, but because we always just want it to go our way in some sort of aspect. But I would be more lenient. I was like, Okay, fine. Like, it can go his way for this this round, I guess. But I remember this one time. I think I mentioned this to you in the email that I wrote you. But there was this time that we were putting together our registry, and it took like an hour to pick one thing. One thing to put on our registry and it was just a bedspread and I was like How hard is it to pick a bedspread? Yeah. Compromise was definitely not a theme for us. It was it was pretty rough.
Talmage ThayneYeah, that sounds like it. And so you were engaged at this point? Had the registry going? Yep. Yeah, what happened next?
Allie GullOh, you're planning the wedding. We had everything paid for, um, we were actually planning on the well being ironically, we just wanted to start immediately family there. And we were gonna get married in San Diego, and get everything set in stone. And one day, I think since it was just such a hard, hard thing to compromise, he would constantly butt heads about certain things. And we had different opinions on like, bigger issues. Like, in a way of like, raising your future family. Yeah, we have different opinions on a lot of things. And things kind of just got very, very difficult. And I remember one day, we just kind of had like this little argument about, like, opposites of opinions, because we just had opposite opinions on a lot of things. But it wasn't like in my mind, it wasn't enough to end a relationship over it was just more of like, we have opposite opinions on this. We can compromise make it work, whatever but he just wasn't willing to and And so I remember I was talking to him about one of his easy loves to Off Road, and I love off roading. I think it's so fun. And he has this one off, like this car that's specific for off roading. And there was a couple of things that he needed to buy to change into fixing it. So it actually run properly. And I asked him, I was like, Well, is there a bigger issue like that needs to be fixed with this vehicle? Is it not just like this one thing.
Allie GullAnd so we're not like, because I felt like we were putting like band aids on like a situation, when it could have like, been a bigger thing that you could just, like, if the engine needs to be replaced, take the whole engine out, don't like put duct tape on it. So it makes sense. I felt and I don't think it was 100% that way, but he took that kind of offensively when I was just like, because I told him I was like, I feel like it's gonna be a bigger expense than like 20 or $30 to fix this one thing. And he kind of took that offensively in a way where I was not trusting him with, like, his choices with the vehicle because I don't know much about it. And he knows he knows I don't know much about the vehicle or anything. And so
Talmage ThayneI don't know, it just kind of so he kind of just, yeah, he's like, What the heck, yeah, this is my thing. This is my thing. Yeah. mad about it. Yeah.
Allie GullYeah, totally, totally get it. And I started getting in this argument about money, and how I don't trust him with, like, with money and saving and everything. But that was not the case, it was just more of like, I'd rather fix a bigger issue if there is one, and save money down the line and sort of, you know, end up paying more, because you're fixing this one small thing. And that was just my my thought. And of course, I didn't know the full situation. And he made that very clear to me afterwards that I definitely didn't understand the whole thing, which is fine. But I think that was kind of like that was the tipping point. You know how like, when you are struggling with so much you have so many internal emotions about things that things are bothering you, and they bottle up and all of a sudden, like, there's one thing that's added on top and you just explode. That's where he was just with this constant, compromising and everything. It just wasn't working, that he kind of just exploded. And that that day, he we just didn't talk for like an hour. After that. I just like we didn't know what to say, because I don't want to offend them anymore. And I just I felt so bad. And he actually, so a couple of weeks prior to this conversation, he actually rolled his truck really, really badly in the snow and in the lip. And I thought that like I thought he was gonna die. When I heard about the whole like, situation, and he jumped out of that wreck just fine. No concussion, no nothing. And I was like, this is a miracle. And so I had let him borrow my car on weekends. Because he he went off to school at BYU Idaho. And so he could just walk to school.
Allie GullBut I was like, on the weekends, if we want to go somewhere, we can just use my car. And so he was over at my house that night. And I let him borrow my car to drive back up to Rexburg, because I live in Rigby. So it's kind of like a little distance. Yeah, no, it's like you can, you can just take my car. And so he came back the next day. And he was planning on seeing you later because he had a bunch of homework to do, but he's like, I'm gonna come earlier. But like his text message made me a little nervous. Because he was like, Hey, can I come see you at nine instead of 11? And he's like, I'd really like to talk.
Allie GullAnd I'm like, Oh, crap. This is. And like, inside, I tried to like play it off. I'm like, Oh, you like, Can't stay away from me typing, just trying to like, lighten up the mood, Oh, he didn't respond to that at all. Know, this is so bad. So he comes over. And he like, I opened the door. And he's like, Hey, let's go for a walk. And I'm like, Oh, we never just go for walks like that. So I'm like, something's wrong. So we didn't even get halfway through my driveway when he's like, you know, I really feel like it's like, I really loved getting to know you and spending all this time. I was like, I know clackers going and I'm like, just like, what, what's wrong and he's like, it's like, I don't think we can make each other happy like this is this is just not going to be healthy relationship and everything and we just have different opinions on everything. And I was devastated at this point.
Allie GullBecause I had put like, my heart and soul into this like I was you compromise everything to accommodate any of his needs, or you rely on what I put him borrow my car, like all of these things. And I just felt super defeated and kind of used in a way and I was like, I don't know what to say. And I just sat there and I was bawling. And I was like, hi, I thought we loved each other. I was like, What? What happened? And he's like, I just don't think this is gonna work with our difference of opinions on all these things.
Allie GullAnd part of me is like, what? What opinions or do we differ on? And I told him, like, he went through all those things that I talked about earlier with you, but he was just like, we really just, it just won't work. And I'm like, but I thought we talked about it, I thought we were able to compromise and make things work. And he's like, it's just not good. It's not good enough for me. I was like, Okay, so I'm like, What are you saying? Are you saying that we're, like, I'm not good enough for you in that aspect? And he's, like, as hard as it for you to hear? Yes, you're, you're not good enough for me in this aspect. And I was like, okay, like that, just that. Yeah, so I gave him back the ring. And, and there was one point where I was saying, like, he's like saying goodbye. And I was like, Well, how are you getting home? Like, do you want my dad to drive you home? Because I'm like, I, I definitely just like, don't want to sit like in a car. 20 more minutes with them. You know, like, because I don't know what else to talk about. He's like, No, he's like, I have a friend that's coming. He'll be here soon. And I'm like, you have a friend, let's come in to pick you up. Like, he had this whole thing totally planned and knew exactly how it was gonna go and everything. And that, that was that killed me just a little bit because like he had, he knew exactly if you have like a time schedule, and he was very cold.
Allie GullLike, there wasn't any like reciprocation of I'm sorry, he did say I'm sorry. But you can tell when somebody is sincerely sorry. And it didn't feel like he was. And I think because he really wanted something to go a specific way. And it wasn't going his way, which by all means everyone. Everyone has their air title to their own opinion. But yeah, it just it was really rough. And I say goodbye to him. And he's like, I really hope that we can see each other's friends after this. And I'm like, I don't know.
Talmage ThayneLike you a nice acquaintance.
Allie GullYeah. Yeah, if I run into you, it's probably gonna be like a high.
Talmage ThayneCivil, but yeah,
Allie Gullnothing else after that. And he, when he hugged me goodbye. He said, Goodbye, my friend. And I was like, you weren't my fiancee like 20 minutes prior. Bad. So like, I didn't even look at him. After that. I let go of that hug. And I just walked right into my house. I was like, No, I'm not talking to anymore. Like this is just, this is not worth my time. And afterwards, I was extremely devastated. Like, I just got completely blindsided. Like I thought we were just fine. I was like, we just like, I kid you not like three days before this. We had paid for everything. Like so like, there's no way you're getting money back for any of this. And it just it made it very, very, very difficult. And I didn't know what to I don't know what to do. And I remember like running into my parents room, bawling and I like what's wrong. I was like, oh, not getting married anymore. And they're like, What, like what happened?
Talmage ThayneSo you kind of experienced broken engagement on both sides, where you kind of knew it was happening for a while, slowly turning off the band aid. So then he was blindsided. And then they kind of got flip flopped on you.
Allie GullExactly. So I know exactly how my first ex fiance feels like yeah, I'll in person. I feel I feel horrible for all of that. But also, on the other hand was the right
Talmage Thaynething to do
Allie Gullthe right thing to do. And her relationship, it was definitely the right thing to do as well. It just sucks that you have to go through two broken engagements and you have family like, Well, I'm not getting married anymore. And they're like, what, like, what is happening? Yeah, like, twice, two times in a row, but it's not happening. So do you
Talmage Thaynefeel like, um, his more kind of cold approach? Kind of just more factual, without too much like sugarcoating. And like, I'm so sorry. Like, I really do love you, but it's just not gonna work out. Do you feel like, in a way that was good? Because you're able to kind of get over it easier. I don't know. How do you feel about that? Because sometimes, I feel like I can sugarcoat things too much and right. And then I do know people that are like, I just really appreciate when people just sit straight out like, it's not gonna work between us. We won't make each other happy. Oh, yeah.
Allie GullI feel like it would have been better more half and half. Like I love when somebody He's completely honest with me and direct if it hurts, it doesn't matter. As long as you are open and direct with me. That's all that matters, because it's just it's fixing whatever. And yeah, sometimes the truth does hurt, but it's better that way. But I also, it would have been nice to have him feel more like, actually feel sorry for the way that
Talmage Thayneempathize. Yeah, I
Allie Gullalso feel like that's exactly how I was with my first engagement. I was very cold, because I was like, Yep, this is over. Like, there's no question about it, you're not changing my mind, because I've already made this decision. And it's not the fact that like, there's anything against him. It's just, this is not the right path for me. And I, and I know this will benefit you more because of this. And I know 100% That's the mindset that he was at as well. But it just came across. So like it just out of nowhere. Yeah, I don't know, I just I didn't feel like I was just like, you were like, You were my fiancee. And now you're all of a sudden, like, No, I want nothing to do with you.
Allie GullGoodbye. And I mean, he wrote me off out of his life completely, like, took me off of all of his social media. Everything, which is good, it was a very good thing that I could just break it off completely, you know? Because there's when you go back, and they're like, What is he doing? You know, like going back to Facebook or Instagram? Is there like, dating someone new and all of those things. And so it was good to have that completely cut off. And of course, it hurt. That was like another band aid being ripped off. But it was like, you know, what? Is this good? And it took me it took this one took me a lot longer to get over than the first one for sure.
Talmage ThayneDo you feel like in ways you're still kind of healing? through it? Yeah. Yeah. I
Allie Gullmean, it's only been two months since it broke off. And so I'm definitely still healing. But I'm also learning a lot more, I'm starting to see that. You know what, this is the right thing. This was meant to happen. And it could have gone in a very different way. But that's okay. Like, it's over. We can move on, I can learn something from this. And I think the part that hurts the most is that I hate the fact that I have to learn these lessons through engagements like like with DD, like normal daily experiences, learning a wedding, going through that whole whole thing.
Allie GullBut I mean, it's still it's still a good thing. Like I still, as much as it hurts. It's okay. And I've had a lot of friends be supportive of that, and helped me through that, because I've actually had a couple of friends that have broken engagements as well. And we've just been kind of helping each other through it in a way of like, there's nothing wrong with you. There's nothing wrong with him. It's just the situation was wrong. And it just isn't wrong. Yeah, it's totally fine. And I did come to this point, though, right after like, I guess you're not like maybe to two hours after the engagement broke off. I was like, There's something wrong with me. I was like, people are gonna think I'm crazy. And I, I can be kind of like you in this way, where I'm constantly like, what do people think about me? Like, walk into a room like, like too worried about? Like, yeah, all of these things. And so I'm like, people are gonna think there's something seriously wrong with me like, to engagements, like, what, what are you doing wrong, you know, these things? Like, there's nothing wrong with you.
Allie GullLike, it's just, you're learning lessons, and God put you those that put you in those positions. And that was hard to to accept that like, the promptings that I received, like I was I questioned, it was like, Are they Yeah. Or is it just because I actually want to get married to this person? That I thought thoughts it wasn't his or what he told me?
Talmage ThayneYeah, man, that would be hard. I remember the second episode of released, I was interviewing a friend on her broken engagement. She had the same thoughts, like, why, why was I feeling good about this? And then suddenly, not like, were all of my other revelations, like, just me, like, doing what I felt like was the right thing. And so that's cool that you have the perspective that, yeah, God, God put me in that situation. He knew that there's going to be in broke a broken engagement, too, because that was the plan. So that way, you could learn something, he can learn something. And yeah, that that is the plan. It's not that there's something wrong with you. Well, there's something wrong with everyone. We're all working through stuff.
Allie GullWe're not perfect.
Talmage ThayneBut yeah, it's not that you're crazy or anything. It's just that there's certain things that we all need to learn. And I think that's awesome. And I really appreciate Did you like being able to like, being willing to like, share all of this? Yeah. Because it is, it is super scary to share this stuff with, like, the world. And like just the public. It's
Allie Gullscary. It's like, especially like personal personal experiences. Yeah. You never really thought anyone would know, other than like, your immediate family, you know. So it's, it is scary. But it is it's also good at the same time, because I've learned a lot. And I know that there's one thing that my mission president's wife that said to me, that really hit home with me when I was talking with her about this engagement, because I kept telling her I was like, I just fell off. And I just like, the other girl that you interviewed, I just, you've questioned a lot. And I slept?
Allie GullDid I hear him? Right? Like, is this like, the is this real, basically? And she's like, I can't answer that for you. She's like you receive promptings differently than I do. And I was like, but why would I feel like I'm prompted to get married at that person if I don't get married, and it just didn't happen the way that I thought it would. And she's like, that's where you're wrong. She's like, you thought it was going to end up something different. It's like God has a different plan than you did than what you thought it would have been. And so just like, sometimes the thoughts you have aren't exactly the way that things like God has planned for you. And I was like, okay, she's right. But then again, I go back to why another engagement to learn these
Talmage Thaynelessons. Yeah. And that, yeah, I feel like, that's totally normal. Where people, like get the answer. They're like, okay, that makes sense. But why? I totally feel that it will. Ally. Thank you so much. I'm excited to get this out to people, because I feel like there's a lot of people that will totally relate to your story, and will be like, Yeah, I felt that way. And so thank you so much for being on these podcasts.
Allie GullThank you so much. I appreciate you being here.
Talmage ThayneAs always, thank you so much for listening to this episode. It was really fun getting that email from Ali, hearing her story talking to her. She'd mentioned something that was very pertinent after the fact. She talked about elder Holland's Mormon message when he prayed about which road to go down with his son, honestly, really good symbolic lesson in there, and very pertinent to her story. So go check out that Mormon message. Also, make sure to leave a review if you really like this. Leaving a review really helps this get out to more and more people that need to hear it. As always, tell me your thoughts. Go on social media. Tell me what you want to hear more about. And if you have a story, please reach out to me.
Talmage ThayneI want to hear it. And to remember, God is good and he's planned on your success. And though you've been released from your mission, you've not been released from your ministry.
Send us Fan Mail Chandler Hendry, the man behind Restored_Truth, has passed away. But his ministry will not pass away. Chantry Hendry, Chuck’s brother, is continuing the work that was started. Chantry shares his story...
Send us Fan Mail God be with you till we meet again. Chandler Hendry shares his experience on the mission in Jackson, Mississippi, where he spent two years qualifying his testimony of the restored gospel. He did this by...
Send us Fan Mail Talmage sits down with Noah Canon, a public speaker who’s passionate about suicide prevention for teens. Noah grew up in Idaho, and during his teenage years, he began working-out in the gym and...
Send us Fan Mail Talmage sits down with Maddy Packer, a passionate LDS apologist and history buff, for an insightful episode. Maddy grew up in New Mexico, attending Catholic school from seventh through twelfth grade,...
Send us Fan Mail In this episode (Sz4 Ep5), Talmage sits down with his wife, Mary Thayne, for a vulnerable and inspiring conversation. Taken from a larger interview, this segment explores why Mary chose to move forward...