Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Relatable Catholic

Relatable Catholic artwork

Holy or Haunted? The Truth About Halloween

Oct 23, 202554 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Fr. Andy and Katie are joined by Geoff Kaiser to talk all things Halloween - its Catholic roots, how it became so spooky, and of course… candy 🍫🍬 Tune in for a fun and faith-filled conversation about All Hallows’ Eve and what it really means for us today. Find us on our Socials! Facebook Instagram Youtube Venmo - @relatablecatholic

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_03Hello and welcome to Relatable Catholic, a podcast where faith and everyday life collide with humor, honesty, and hope. We're here to remind you you're not alone on the road to heaven. If you enjoy this podcast, please subscribe to the show and consider sharing it with a friend. Welcome back. We're so glad you're here. Hello, everyone. It is me, Katie.

SPEAKER_00It's Father Andy. And I'm Jeffrey Kaiser.

SPEAKER_03A new special guest this week, Mr. Kaiser.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, thank you. Thanks for the invitation. For those that don't know, I work at Marquette with Katie. I'm the principal at Marquette Catholic Schools and um have been in that position for the last 10 years. This is year number 11 at Marquette.

SPEAKER_01Wow. 11 years. Yeah. That's I've never been anywhere that long.

SPEAKER_00Time flies when you're having fun. Yeah. Yeah.

SPEAKER_03So and I was really happy that you stuck too, because when I started at Marquette, it took four principals to stick. Yeah. I had four principals my first four years.

SPEAKER_00Right, right. And then I was the last of those.

SPEAKER_03Yes, you were the last of those. And then we had four priests too in a row. So maybe hopefully you're the one that's gonna stick. Right. Four is a lucky number. Four is the lucky number, I guess. For a point, it's like, gosh, is it me? Like, how about these principals keep leaving?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, you know, and before I was at Marquette, I worked in um Milaukee's inner city for a few years. I always can kind of gauge how long I've been here because when I started, my wife and I, we didn't have any children at all. Um, now we have four kids, and our oldest is in fourth grade. And so it, you know, we kind of are like, well, he's gonna be turning 10 this year, and he wasn't here when we started here. So, yep, this would be year number 11 already.

SPEAKER_03So crazy.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, awesome.

SPEAKER_01Thanks for being here.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, thanks for thanks for the again, thanks for the invitation for the podcast. But you know, also the school board of 2015. Thanks for inviting me to come by. Yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_03Thanks for being here in the town and here in my home.

SPEAKER_00It's good to be here. Where however that matters, it's good to be here.

SPEAKER_03Well, we took a little two-week hiatus because it got a little wild. Um, but I am happy to say that conferences are officially checked off the list, parent-teacher conferences. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01How'd it go?

SPEAKER_03Yeah, they went great. It's always like it's nerve-wracking and it's a lot of work like leading up to it. But then, like, it is always nice to talk to everybody. And yeah, so they went well. And one quick thing, one thing we can check off our list. It's crazy. We can start checking things off the list already.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's hard to believe that already a quarter of the school years is uh just about complete. And I think you know, that that opportunity to really, you know, I think sometimes I kind of ask myself the question of how necessary are conferences sometimes because parents have access to the students' grades um, you know, through Power School regularly, they can check that. Parents have access to talk with teachers, or teachers are very, very good at communication, whether that be email or phone. But then so many parents come in and want to have these conversations, and we really value that they want to be partners in the education.

SPEAKER_00So, parent-teacher conferences. I always, I think, like Katie, you get a little bit nervous as they get they approach, and it seems like, well, you know, this is a lot to do. And then you see all these families come in, and really families that really value their their own child's education and where how that child's doing. And I tell our teachers, you know, they they don't want to know as much about what content we're teaching as much as they just want to know about how their kid is doing. And as parents, Kelsey and I asked the question, are they being nice? Like that's the most important thing, and that's not going to show up on a report card. And that's you know, a good time to ask that that type of question, too.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, it's always a good reminder too that um that the kids are, you know, it's easy to forget, like, because in the class they're your student, but it's it's it's good to remember that like these are people's most prized possessions, you know, and so it's a good reminder too. So yeah.

SPEAKER_00I I just one story I I I think about sometimes is, you know, if you go to a grocery store and you get a gallon of milk and that gallon of milk is expired, and you think about, you know, people can get really upset about that. They can leave reviews, they go online and they'll say, I'm never going to this grocery store again because the milk was bad, or whatever, whatever it might be. And and here, like you said, we have the most prized possessions. We're we're working with people's children. And so you think of how how frustrated we can get in an expired gallon of milk.

SPEAKER_00Like that, that that's what I find interesting about a school is that you know, we're working with with something people care a lot more about than a gallon of milk. And and you know, there's going to be points and times where you know that that they have questions over well, what how was this or what was that? But again, I think it's that that continued partnership and the wanting to be partners, and we want to work with families on that. And and um, yeah, and so so it's a lot, it's a lot, it's a lot to prepare for, a lot to get ready for because parents offer ask great questions and we want to be ready to answer those.

SPEAKER_03And now they're done. And now they're done in the and I mean now we really gotta start cheering on those boys' basketball team because spring conferences are during state basketball.

SPEAKER_02Oh are they really?

SPEAKER_03Yeah, which has happened before.

SPEAKER_02So right.

SPEAKER_03Well, uh there's a lot of fall things happening because it is we're knee deep in fall. The craziest thing happened the other day. I received a package that was addressed to me. It said Catherine Kiefer with my address on it, and it was a weird Waldo costume.

SPEAKER_00Wow, and you don't know where that came from.

SPEAKER_03I did not order it, it came from Amazon, and I looked and I was like, did I like accidentally order this? I wasn't looking for one. Were you waiting for a package at all from Amazon? I was, but I got that other package too in a separate package.

SPEAKER_00You know, I am I am actually just floored by this because the person who actually found Waldo is you now. I mean, where's Waldo in Katie's house?

SPEAKER_03Asian shoes like that's pretty ironic.

SPEAKER_00And all the costumes or all the things that you could have shown up in your house. It's a sign. Yeah. Well, when you when you first shared it, you said, you know, your package showed up, and I'm like, who who who sent it? But if it came from like dressed to me. Right, right.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. But you could, I mean, people can do that, right? They could address things to other people and not put their name on it.

SPEAKER_03But uh, yeah, I guess. Yeah. So if you sent me a Where's Waldo costume, please reveal yourself.

SPEAKER_00That's why it's a Where's Waldo? They're not going to. You gotta find me. Yeah, this is a mystery. Gotta get Scooby-Doo. Somebody's getting sent a Scooby-Doo costume somewhere else, and you guys are gonna come together and we're gonna find each other.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's really funny. Yeah. So, what are you gonna do with it?

SPEAKER_03I have no idea. Like, I can't send it back because I I don't know.

SPEAKER_01I'm just you gonna wear it for Halloween?

SPEAKER_03I don't usually dress up for Halloween, but I don't know, maybe.

SPEAKER_00Well, they just got done with that prime days and stuff like that with Amazon, so maybe they're just like something in the world.

SPEAKER_03That is what she needs a disguise.

SPEAKER_00That's funny.

SPEAKER_03It's the right size and everything.

SPEAKER_01Interesting.

SPEAKER_03Huh.

SPEAKER_01We've got a mystery, right?

SPEAKER_03A real mystery. But that Halloween costume really does lead into our topic for this week, which is uh all things Halloween.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, we just went to the pumpkin patch with our family last weekend. And so I guess I'm I'm ready. Bring on the the Halloween and the fall discussions.

SPEAKER_03All right. Well, I think that we should start with um where Halloween started, because I think until recently, I had no idea where Halloween started. Like I really just thought it was I did had no idea it was a Catholic holiday. Um so yeah, going back to its roots of where what Halloween is and why why it started.

SPEAKER_01Sounds good. So Halloween um is short for or means all hollows eve. It's basically in the in the Catholic Church when you have big feast days, we celebrate the Eve, right? So like Christmas Eve, um different Eves that we celebrate. It's the night before. So the big it's really not about uh October 31st, although it's become about October 31st, it's actually about November 1st. That's all Saints Day. So all you know, all Holy's Eve, All Saints Day are you know a really big um usually uh holy day of uh of obligation.

SPEAKER_01And um this year I guess it's not because it follows on a Saturday.

SPEAKER_03I didn't know if there was gonna be like Saturday morning mass and Saturday night mass or it's all in one, huh?

SPEAKER_01There will not be. So yeah, just uh just uh we're gonna kind of skip it in a way and move straight into all souls. So all souls then follows on November 2nd. And uh All Souls Day is is to pray for all those souls that are not yet saints, not in in purgatory basically. Uh pray for those those saints that are those souls that are be released from purgatory and become saints. So we celebrate all saints on the first and then all souls on the second.

SPEAKER_01And that is where that's why Halloween, All Hallows Eve is on the 31st.

SPEAKER_03Right. And then like a part of so back when it was like All Saints Day was the big celebration, so they would celebrate All Hallows Eve, and then the the children, which is where like the trick-or-treating comes in, right? The children would go to people's houses and they would say they were gonna pray for the dead of their family, and then they would receive soul cakes.

SPEAKER_00Oh yeah.

SPEAKER_03Oh, you didn't know that?

SPEAKER_00No.

SPEAKER_03Oh.

SPEAKER_00I'm here for the lecture. I appreciate this. I'm learning as we get.

SPEAKER_03So then they would receive soul cakes for praying for their family. So um, yeah, that's kind of like where the trick-or-treat part came in, is that they would go to people's houses, they would say they would say a prayer for their family and for the dead in preparation for All Souls Day and All Saints Day, and then um they would receive a soul cake, which is the special treat.

SPEAKER_01What's a soul cake taste like?

SPEAKER_03I don't know. Okay, I've never had a soul cake. I don't, I don't think many people celebrate with soul cakes anymore.

SPEAKER_01But maybe we should bring it back.

SPEAKER_03Maybe, yeah. You know, Brother Francis on Formed has a great video about Halloween and all Halloween, but yeah, so that's where that came from.

unknownOkay.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. So in uh um, I was watching something recently that was about like taking Halloween back and how it started as a Catholic holiday and how we can like take it back as Catholics to make it less demonic and a little more holy.

SPEAKER_01Because it is kind of scary.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, so let's talk about that a little bit. How like Halloween like it turned scary. And I listened to something that said that like back in the old days, like when they would celebrate All Souls Day, they would like sometimes wear like scary masks and stuff like that, but it was more to like um to like mock the devil. You're not powerful, and then like that's maybe where some of like a lot of the um like the creepy skeleton stuff came from.

SPEAKER_00Um well I think I think on this idea of you know Halloween becoming something where where the the emphasis uh is on the scary part or on that this is somehow a um you know an effort to um one day out of the year that we can just throw any of our you know virtue out the window. We're just gonna be okay that the now we're gonna celebrate the the opposite of virtue, we're gonna celebrate vices or something like that.

SPEAKER_00I think I think that that I can I can you know say you know, you can experience this. You don't have to look a lot farther than you know, college campus or something like that, or the the different, the different um Halloween costumes and how we can turn anything into uh sexualized or or you know, so so there's that element of Halloween, right? Where I think it's just kind of like this um I'm gonna I have this excuse to be able to do something that normally I wouldn't do, and on the on the other side of things, like the decorations, and I'm not an expert on this topic at all.

SPEAKER_00I can certainly, though, speak on behalf of a perspective of father with young kids. I can speak on behalf of a principal of a Catholic school type of look at this, and just somebody driving around town and and you see, you know, huge um uh you know um displays of of Halloween. I think some of those have grown. But uh, you know, I mean, I remember being a kid in trick-or-treating and you know, I'm trying to get the scary costume and stuff like that too. So it's kind of a it's a it's a topic that um I think is is very interesting.

SPEAKER_00And just as somebody who, again, is trying to live out the faith and and raise children in the faith, and and uh it's just how how to do that sometimes, I think can be a little bit of uh a fuzzy area for a lot of people of going, okay, well, what if my kid wanted to wear this costume or that costume, or how do you explain this scary thing when they ask, like, dad, what what does like why is that giant werewolf howling at me? Like it's decoration, but you're trying to explain that of any like I don't know.

SPEAKER_03I read that the mom, the son wanted to be a pirate, and she was like, Maybe not a pirate, like let's pick something else. And somebody had asked her, like, why wouldn't you just let your kid be a pirate? And she's like, Well, I wouldn't have them dress up like a hijacker or a terrorist. So, like, why would I let them dress up like a pirate? Like, because they do the same thing just kind of with the ocean, right? Right. You know, never thought of that. Yeah, and um, and I think this was I that like a lot, like I said how you know back in the old days they used to do like those creepy things to mock the devil, and how that like was okay, that is okay, but most most people's intent is not like to mock the devil, it's just kind of to be scary, I think.

SPEAKER_03And I do not like scary things, so I am always very excited when Halloween is over.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I'm not a big scary guy either. Like, I don't want to watch scary.

SPEAKER_03There are certain blocks that I avoid right now in our town. Wow, it scares me.

SPEAKER_00You know, I I think I think that's a uh, you know, on the discussion of like a pirate costume or something like that. I these these are kind of difficult things to consider, you know, of of again what what costumes would I allow my child to wear, what costumes would I feel comfortable wearing or or not wearing. And and sometimes it it's you know, I don't know what the right answer is, but it could be based on what your child's understanding of what this particular thing, what they want to dress like is, and what the parents' understanding is is as well, a pirate to a child, um you know, means probably something very different than somebody who's going to go you know plunder your boat and go sail away with it.

SPEAKER_00It's it's right, yeah. I mean, not it's a real problem, right? Right, right. Right, right. And and I'll just mention, you know, like um when when I was a kid, and I think you know, still a movie that that is watched sometimes, The Wizard of Oz, right? And and they just had um the the wicked movie come out. Um, but with Wizard of Oz, you have like this wicked witch of the West. And I remember when I was a kid dressing up like the Wicked Witch of the West.

SPEAKER_03You dress up like the Wicked Witch.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. My mom told me it was a warlock, so I was I was all right. Yeah. But yeah, yeah, I mean, and I remember like, you know, face painted green and uh, you know, this hat. And I remember walking around, and and to me, that this didn't really mean anything other than that's a scary character in the movie. But I I was also you know young and it was and I and I and I think you know, like we have um a Halloween dance that Marquette has, and it's a middle school PTO helps throw it, and students are able to dress up in costume.

SPEAKER_00Um and and I think there there's a a question, you know, we we um, you know, if somebody wants to dress up as a historical figure that's caused a lot of harm or it was a couple years ago. Do you remember like there was a documentary about like Jeffrey Dahmer, and that was a really popular Yeah, I was too scared to watch it. Right, right. I didn't watch it either. But but if you had a middle school student dress up as Jeffrey Dahmer, I don't think we did, but I think it was one that we kind of want to protect against and say, we're not going to dress up as historical figures that have caused harm or have uh have notorious for violence or something like that.

SPEAKER_00Um, but but you know, if somebody wanted to try drawing connections and say, well, witches are evil, and you have but but I will I was six and I asked my mom if I could dress up like a witch, and she's like, Well, you're a warlock, and and because that's what boys are called or something, and and and you know, still, still I never I never took anything beyond that. And I think that that's also another you know element of this of like what's our intent and what you know how how is I think I think that one of the things that's interesting with just every holiday is the anticipation that builds into that holiday.

SPEAKER_00I mean, you see Christmas decorations being put up right now, yeah. We see this it's this, you know. I I think that you know, when I was a kid getting ready for Halloween, we went to the pumpkin patch, and then on Halloween you dressed up, and then Halloween was over, and then you know you went trick-or-treating and you'd eat candy over the course of like two weeks, and then then it's over.

SPEAKER_03And then the candy would disappear.

SPEAKER_00Right, right, right, yes, yes, candy's gone. Um, but but now I think that there's a lot of people that take elements of Halloween or take elements of whatever whatever that they're celebrating, and you know you you you can see decorations going up in September. You can see this just kind of this build-up of we are living this for a long time of and and I think there there is some difference in that. And like I said, I'm not an not an expert on the topic, it but just a perspective of of seeing that and and um you know when when is it okay for kids to be scared?

SPEAKER_00When is it okay for us as parents to protect our kids from being scared? And if we protect our kids from any level of discomfort or or of being scared, then what lessons can they can they learn from from, you know, if if they just never have the the chance to ever be uncomfortable? And these are all probably much bigger than a topic of of just Halloween. But I think um, you know, it's it's a difficult time, I think, for a lot of parents to navigate through, especially parents that truly are trying their their best to you know to consider those things.

SPEAKER_00Like the parent who's going is a pirate okay. You know, that the intent there is is to protect her kid from something that that she wouldn't feel comfortable with going down that road. And and um yeah, that can be can be very hard. Just like you wouldn't give your kid an empty iPad and say, Yeah, you know, watch, I trust that you'll find something that's okay. Because like a lot of stuff with Halloween is not for children. And and probably doesn't need to be. And I think it's almost an invitation for some people to to kind of say, today it is though.

SPEAKER_00Today it is for everyone to to you know, for me to scare people.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_00And I think some people have maybe lost the right the guise of like, okay, maybe that doesn't mean anything goes though.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah, I agree. The the lady, she did ask her her her kid why he wanted to be a pirate. And in the end, he just wanted a sword. He just wanted a costume with the sword, so he was Saint Michael the Archangel.

SPEAKER_02Oh, yeah.

SPEAKER_00There you go. Found the way to do it. Get that sword, not stealing any boats.

SPEAKER_01That'd be one way to to kind of re-christianize it too, is to actually pick Saint Saints that that, you know, because Joan of Arc would be a wouldn't be a feedback.

SPEAKER_03I thought that's where it was going, but Saint Michael.

SPEAKER_01St. Michael, Joan of Arc. You got but you have some good options out there. There are some good good saint options if you if you wanted to try to Christianize this. I was also trying to think of like what would a what would a like a yard display look for a saints? You know, like like if we're really gonna celebrate all saints day, yeah, what would that be? That look like to have like a bunch of different put your favorite saying out. Um, yeah, I don't know.

SPEAKER_03Tombstones with the Saints name on them. I don't know.

SPEAKER_00No either.

SPEAKER_03But yeah.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I haven't seen that display over at Lowe's of the Halloween decorations and slightly. That'd be an interesting, interesting question. And and I think it it brings up too, you know, as you had mentioned, that the um, you know, when when Halloween and some of the scary stuff started emerging, it was to mock something. You have to be really careful too on that, on that same end. You know, kids going around and trick-or-treating, and and um, I think that you know, dressing up like St. Joan of Arc or something like that definitely has the power to re-christianize and say, hey, that this is taking it back.

SPEAKER_00I think that there's also the the okay, kid has to be aware of that that you know this is something too that they would be, you know, kind of helping helping to model of what that might look like as well. So if you got the kid that's dressing up like that, and then you know, on the buckets of candy that say, please take one, and they're dumping the candy in there, then maybe that's not getting the point of like, okay, we're right, you know, we're doing good here too. Yeah.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. And remembering to to teach about the holiday and its meaning. Like its real meaning is to prepare for sainthood and to prepare or and to pray for those who are either preparing to be saints or maybe already are saints or or need our prayers, but just to remember that that think about who you all received candy from and really make it a point to pray for those people that night.

SPEAKER_01If you're walking around in every house you go up to, just as you're going up to that house, you say a little a little prayer for all the deceased members of that family.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_01That'd be one way to go about it. And then and then you get a treat. It's like you know, like it's like uh, you know, the Knights of Columbus Handout.

SPEAKER_02Tootsie Rolls, yeah. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00And Ambrose running over everybody, got any money? I have my son was helping with the Tootsie Roll, the Knights of Columbus, and he he enjoyed collecting. He had a little bucket to collect the money, and he didn't quite get, you know, a four-year-old doesn't understand uh nuances when it comes to okay, we're we're he just running up to everybody you saw. Got any money? I'm like, okay, yeah. Slow down, kid. He was a good fundraiser, though.

SPEAKER_03I mean, I mean, how do you say no to that? Very direct ask.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Um, but but yeah, I think, I think, you know, that that's a that's really good advice because I think as parents too, you know, it's that struggle of okay, if I you want to you want your kid to be a part of an experience, and part of the experience that I think we had as as kids too, uh, you know, we went trick-or-treating, and uh, you know, just because the holiday maybe has changed in terms of the way that some people are looking at it, I don't think that that's a reason enough that I would say to my kids, well, it's turned into something that I don't agree with, and so we're not trick-or-treating anymore.

SPEAKER_00Or you're not going to dress up because I don't agree with the, you know, and and so there's that that that middle ground that I think parents are trying to find that this this is something that I'm okay with. And and you know, I mentioned um, you know, when I was a kid dressing up like a warlock, and and I think if Creighton asked me, you know, could I dress up like the wicked witch of the West, I I think I would have a harder time with that today. Um, because you know, again, just just kind of the message that it's kind of being sent there.

SPEAKER_00Maybe part of it said in my role, but I think, but it's not just my role as principal, it's my role as father. And and I I can tell you, you know, if my kid wanted to dress up like the devil or a goblin or a demon or something, I'd be like, you know what? There's other options out there. That's not what we're going to to do. Um, and and you know, so so again, where does where does the kid's idea on a Halloween costume? Luckily, I have a wife that's a very good planner, and she usually just lets us know what we're going to be for Halloween this year, and so I don't have to worry as much about my kids asking to do something.

SPEAKER_00So when I was a kid too, my mom had like a box of Halloween costumes. So every year, you were one of the seven things in that box. You're a black cat or a bat. Or and you didn't, we didn't ever, I didn't, we never had another costume that ever got bought.

SPEAKER_01What was your favorite thing in J War?

SPEAKER_00Well, I mean, the warlock was was was good, I guess. Obviously, one of your favorites. There's a picture. I have a sister that was born on the night that the town of Horror Con Wisconsin did trick-or-treating. So there's a picture of me dressed as the the wicked witch of the west and um the black cat and a bat all around this new baby that was just born. Because you know, we went to the hospital that night after trick-or-treating to get a big thing.

SPEAKER_03Well, we gotta trick-or-treat first, mom.

SPEAKER_00Um, yeah, I I think I think that was, I mean, I remember I remember too, you know, going to a Halloween costume contest and being surprised that we didn't win, and then you kind of realize like there's people that spend some real money on Halloween costumes. And my mom, I mean, that that makeup we had had to have expired in like 1982, and we're still taking it onto our face. Yeah, whatever.

SPEAKER_03It was maybe that was I don't remember any of my Halloween costumes. I can't think of a one. Really? No. I maybe was like a Packers cheerleader one year or something.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, go back.

SPEAKER_03Tim pretended to like sports for a while in his life, and I'm pretty sure he was a Packers player.

SPEAKER_00I had a friend that wanted to be one of the California raisins. And I think that homemade costumes were kind of the that's the nostalgic thing.

SPEAKER_03Homemade costumes are where it's at.

SPEAKER_00They're so sweet. But you know, you really get to see a parent's creativity on display. And this parent, it was one of my best friends, and for some reason, California raisin was what he wanted to be. So the mom took a guard uh, like a paper bag, a big paper bag, and she tried to color it purple, but like the marker kept running out, and then she tried crinkling it up so it looked like the raisin. And this kid was walking around, it did not look like a California raisin, it was just a big paper bag that was like halfway colored purple, and he's like everyone, what what are you supposed to be?

SPEAKER_00And you would tell him, and they were like, wouldn't to guess that. That's yeah, it looks nobody knew what it looked like. You look like a slug or something, but you're walking around and he was he's he gets as much candy as everybody else, everybody. Yeah, that's true.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah, he's still getting candy, yeah. Father, did you get to go trick-or-treating?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, um I think my favorite costume ever was I went as a tree. I thought that was a pretty creative bear. Exciting. Very exciting. My teddy bear.

SPEAKER_03Uh you were a teddy bear?

SPEAKER_01No, I had a teddy bear like I had him strapped to my leg. Like he was climbing up my leg. Wow. And then I made this hat with leaves on it, and I had a squirrel tail coming out the back. So the biggest.

SPEAKER_03Oh, there's a squirrel. Wow. Impressive. Two branches, and that was a tree.

SPEAKER_01Wow.

SPEAKER_03Present.

SPEAKER_01That's something. That really something. Yeah.

unknownYeah.

SPEAKER_01Bring it back this year.

unknownYeah.

SPEAKER_00Kids will be knocking on the rectory door and you'll open it up and holding two branches.

SPEAKER_03I am the tree of good and evil.

SPEAKER_00Right, right. Combining Arbor Day and Halloween all in the one. That's it's very nice.

SPEAKER_03But some people choose not to celebrate Halloween.

SPEAKER_01I think we've probably already alluded to it a little bit, just like the scariness of it and and this this it's probably turned into something it didn't have to ever be, you know. Um but it it's it's gotten there, and I think people are are worried about playing into that.

SPEAKER_03Like demonic. Um because the scary thing is, is like there are Satanists in the world, and I think this is like their big time to shine. You know, so it is kind of like scary too. Like, well, I'm treating it as like a good Catholic holiday, but you know, like there might be more demonic forces in the in the air than there normally are because it's kind of like their big holiday.

SPEAKER_03Like it they've quite they've kind of taken it as their own big scary holiday to do creepy satanic things.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and I think, I think um, you know, if we if we're here to celebrate you know the sin, that that's where Halloween does take that dark turn. If we if we're looking at things and saying, okay, this is our time to again to to live a life that for one night that we can forget virtue. I I think then then I wouldn't be for any of that. Um and and it and again, it can be it can be hard because uh, you know, a child's not looking at it like that.

SPEAKER_00Not looking at the holiday like that. I'm not looking at the holiday like that. Um and it and it also can offer a lot of a lot of good. I think, you know, especially if if there's that pause for the you know, for a genuine thank you for people opening up their doors. And you think, you know, a lot of people are in live in isolation. Um this is a day where where they get visitors all you know all afternoon and kids coming up. I remember that was one of the hardest parts about trick-or-treating for me was um you know, you knock on on some person's house and you know, you're kind of waiting there for the little old lady to come to the door, and then what's your name?

SPEAKER_00And like you're you're your parents have told you all along, don't he don't go to somebody's house asking for stuff and don't talk to strangers and all this as a kid. My dad in the back, he's like, tell them who you are.

SPEAKER_03Ask for some candy.

SPEAKER_00Right, right. And and and and to that to that person, how much Halloween meant to them? Because they're not looking at those kids that are knocking on their door as as anything other than, you know, again, a gift that that's now on their doorstep, that they can say, oh, what a nice costume. And and I think it does bring some goodwill towards neighbors and towards friends, and it is something that that we can um you know, you know, I again have an excuse to to celebrate.

SPEAKER_00But we do this a lot, you know. We do this when the the um the Packers win the Super Bowl. We do that.

SPEAKER_03Not everybody does that, but but it's we don't remember ever doing that.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's been a while. Actually, it's like a Super Bowl party, right? Like, like we have a reason, and and there's people who treat it as a as a as a reason that my a vice is now appropriate. I'm gonna drink a lot, I'm gonna do whatever. And and so that that's wrong, right? To to to be treating any celebration as a this gives me an excuse to to sin. Excuse to escape, right? Yeah, the same way with a vacation, right? Like, like, and and I think that that's ultimately what this kind of comes down to.

SPEAKER_00If if I'm going to a vacation so I can uh relax and unwind, nothing wrong with that. But if I'm going on a vacation because I want to go, you know, drink a lot and and get, you know, I don't know what else. Forget all my problems. Right, right, right. And and just you know, ignore my family. Let's say, you know, or whatever. Like that, that's problematic. And I think Halloween has that same risk. I think in Halloween it just is probably um that that that risk feels higher than like a great celebration of Christmas or Easter, a holiday that's you know, truly religious.

SPEAKER_00Um, and and like you said, this is one where I think that that there's a there's people that have tried turning Halloween into it is the time. And I think, I think, you know, you talk about corporations and the dangers that capitalism or whatever it could be, you know, like this is what sells. And today it's selling really well. And so, you know, we have to fight against that type of stuff, but it doesn't mean that we can't enjoy the good that can come from a holiday, too.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, if we were to all start requesting Saints decorations for the youngers, then they would start selling it.

SPEAKER_03We gotta come up with some sort of like prototype so they know what we're working with.

SPEAKER_00But I'm gonna get to Lowe's next year and I'm gonna see it there and say, All right, this is we started this.

SPEAKER_03But I think this year more than ever, like I've never liked Halloween more, like, because I don't like to be scared, but but I feel like more convicted this year to just like take it back. Like it doesn't have to be scary, like it is what you make of it, and like there are little ways that you could make Halloween holy again because Hallowe means holy, everyone.

unknownYeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_00It's true. When I was a kid, you know, going to a haunted house, did you go to haunted houses?

SPEAKER_03I attempted one time and I didn't make it in the building.

SPEAKER_00I think just like once or twice. And so we had like this this neighborhood friend of mine, his dad would take my parents. Never took us. Um, yeah, like like we we uh our high school through a hollow uh a haunted house, and then the elementary kids we were able to go to the house.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, we did that too. Yeah, and you're gonna be mortified.

SPEAKER_00No, no, I've heard the story. Father, I'm sure, hasn't though. You can tell this story. Where?

SPEAKER_03In like the sacristy, like it went up like up the back steps and like behind the altar, and yeah, it was before my time. It was like thinking about like looking back at it, like in high school, like, oh yeah, like it's totally like that's what we do, and like looking back on it now, it like gives me a stomachache. It's like so disrespectful.

SPEAKER_00I've done several primitive blessings. So okay, we're good. But but but again, I I think that this kind of goes back to what was the intent. And if it if it was just simply to spook a kid and say, boo, you know, the the boo boop I would I actually I actually worked in a haunted house, so yeah, I can uh that was kind of interesting too. Um, and it was a haunted house that that a Catholic school put together. Um, when I was in high school, it was one of the best jobs I ever had.

SPEAKER_00I didn't get paid anything. Not the most profiting, not the most profiting, but but on the weekends um in September and October, I would dress up and I would go work at this haunted house that my mom's school was was um hosting. And it was really, really well done. They would get people there from all over the state coming to this haunted house because they did such a good job with it. And and you know, again, like scaring people, you know, that's not against uh is it?

SPEAKER_00I don't know, probably not for people who consent to I want to be scared.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, probably running around and who actually paid money to be scared, right?

SPEAKER_00Right, like running and and saying boo to somebody that maybe doesn't want to get scared, probably it probably isn't gonna is probably against like respect of somebody else. But um, you you know, and it was it was interesting though, um, when I was a kid and my best friend, his dad, boy, we'd go to a haunted house, and he goes, Anytime you get scared, you just say, Frankenstein is a friend of mine, and that was his his like secret. So you don't get so scared, you just repeat that to yourself.

SPEAKER_00And I remember thinking, like, okay, but but you you know, I think there again is is I enjoyed as a kid being scared. I don't enjoy it as much as an adult because I get scared by different things that that that you know I then than I did as a kid.

SPEAKER_03That's scary.

SPEAKER_00Where did that come from? That's scary. Or like, or like, you know, Ambrose, he he is very good at scaring us. Um, he disappeared this summer and was found up at Marquez.

SPEAKER_03Oh, I remember that.

SPEAKER_00Yes, yeah, and and so those are the kind of things that scare me now. Back then, I would be, you know, I mean, like the idea of like uh again, uh a warlock chasing me down the road, like that would be scary back then, but it's not so scary now. But there was never real any any real danger I was in. And reading a book, a scary book, there was never any, you know, that this what danger is this doing, and when do I, you know, and and it and it's it's it's hard. Uh a time where you know, we talk about scary movies is another thing that people oftentimes do at Halloween, and and you know, you see these horror movies, lots and lots.

SPEAKER_00It's actually interesting. Dorothy does not sleep very well. Um, our youngest daughter, she's two. And so sometimes she'll be up with me at night, and we she knows like there when a commercial comes on. If I go, Dorothy, you can't see this because it's like something I don't want her to see. She runs over to me and I give her like this bear hug, and she holds, you know, like we'll cover her eyes until the commercial's done, and then she can open her eyes again. Because you can't get away from it. Yeah, you watch a a sporting event, you watch Monday Night Football or something, and all of a sudden you got this ad on them thinking like kids are not supposed to be seeing this.

SPEAKER_03I close my eyes. Oh, neither should adults. I close my eyes and I plug my ears and I go la la la. And then once in a while I'll peek out and see if it's over yet.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. And and there was there was once um when I was a teenager, and I think, you know, again, you kind of go through a phase where you kind of are deciding if you like scary movies. And and I remember there was this um show I was watching, and they were talking about a scary movie that was coming out. And so they're trying to promote this movie, and the the host of the show asked, you know, are you going to go see that movie? And he said, No. And again, they're trying to promote this, so it was kind of a surprising answer right away. And he goes, Oh, okay, you just don't like scary movies.

SPEAKER_00And the response I was given back was, once you see something like that, it's it's in you forever. You don't forget something like that oftentimes because it's intended to remind you to be graphic. And and you know, if we think to some of the scariest moments that the movies that we've seen are scariest moments, we can we can really visualize that pretty easily. And he goes, Well, why would I want to you know put something like that into myself if I want to be somebody who's positive and think of the good things and and to have that that lens? And if we just fill our lens up with things that are intentionally scary and to scare us and and um you know, like uh something that's demonic or something that's horror or gore or something like that, when we don't need to do that.

SPEAKER_00And it it stuck with me, I mean, even as a as a high schooler, and kind of like you know, you start being more aware of what you are consuming um and the dangers of of some of that consumption if if you're not careful about what it is, and you try to protect your kids from that too.

SPEAKER_01Who was it that said that?

SPEAKER_00It was uh the artist formerly known as Prince. He was talking to Carson Daly on TRL.

SPEAKER_01That's amazing that stuck with you. I that really was impactful. But it's so true, right? So yeah, why do you why do you want that in our in our brain and can't unsee it? Right, right.

SPEAKER_00I I think I think I can remember the first horror movie I ever saw, and and I think most people probably can. And and I think that that's because it's something that's unlike anything you've seen before, and it's something that's you know, emotionally it it it it it it it um you know you you can't go to sleep at night. You think about it, and you yeah.

SPEAKER_01I remember watching The Ring in the theater, yeah, I remember and I had a a popcorn and I I didn't eat it all because I was, I don't know, probably frightened, but I'm walking out and this this girl looks at me and I dropped the popcorn like I was like, there she is. What's happening?

SPEAKER_00She's gonna climb right out of a feet. Yeah, you know, I think I think though that there's a lot of people that enjoy that heightened sensation because I think we numb ourselves with a lot of stuff all the time, right? So so if we're constantly numbing ourselves by uh, you know, looking at a phone or or watching a mundane, it just life life doesn't seem very exciting sometimes. And then all of a sudden you go see this thing and it doesn't have resolve or it has the high suspense and you can feel your heart rate going up, and you you think like, man, I feel alive because I can feel the these emotions and I can feel this.

SPEAKER_00And and um again, like that that's the question though, or is are what are we stimulating ourselves with? Because there's plenty of things in the faith and and you know that that can create that same feeling. I think we've been, I I know I've you know, like the the the deep, deep peace that I can feel at adoration. Um the you know, the um the excitement that that you can get about hearing a a story or thinking back to a time or re you know, reading about somebody um who triumphed in the midst of of you know, um we watched the movie with uh St.

SPEAKER_00Maximus and Colby.

SPEAKER_03Oh yeah.

SPEAKER_00That that was not a uh it wasn't a horror movie, but but there were parts that were scary. Parts that were scary and parts that stuck with you, but now you're at least you're getting that same feeling through something that's that's good. So so you know that that's again where I did kind of divide that Halloween in being scared, it's not that's not bad. We can learn from feelings like that, we can understand ourselves better. But if the if the celebration is on the sin or celebration on the vice, or celebration on something like that, then then I I I think that that's where um as parents we we really do have to be very careful um because we're Trying to help young minds navigate through that.

SPEAKER_00And that differentiation, I think, is a lot harder for a young child. I remember when I was a kid and NBC ran Schindler's List with no commercial breaks. I was telling Kelsey about this, and she was like, What are you talking about? And I was like, I I remember this so vividly, just like you remember that first horror movie, right? Like, and and um and I looked it up and and it was like a big deal at the time. Like tons of people tuned in to watch this because it was so unusual that they'd be showing such a graphic movie unedited and and and and that way.

SPEAKER_03Now they'd have it on Disney Plus or something. Yeah, they'd be like, yeah, all kids can watch it. Anybody does this rage is tune up. Right.

SPEAKER_00I remember sitting there with my mom and dad, and we watched this, and and it impacted my parents, and it impacted me, and I knew that this was, you know, this was a big deal. And and and it was something that again stuck with me, but it sticks with you not on the grounds of I want to go out and scare people, but I want to go out and and be able to be a source of light, you know, for for other people. I want to live my life in a way that we can make sure that this doesn't happen again, but also that you know we can we can be uh uh you know a voice for for others.

SPEAKER_00And these are these are you know, if if if there's no point in it other than to um you know, then than to have an excuse to do the wrong thing, then it's probably not a good thing. And and I think unfortunately so many people treat Halloween or other celebrations as as that. It's just a reason to do something that that I nor in in most cases it wouldn't be socially acceptable to do. And here I can do it without without consequence.

SPEAKER_03So I think what we're saying is put the hollow back in Halloween.

SPEAKER_02That's good.

SPEAKER_03That's all we're doing. Right, right, yeah, and celebrate how you see fit for your family.

SPEAKER_00Keep the hollow in your heart, right?

SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah. Right. And maybe just like explain. Explain what the celebration is about and and why we do it, and eat a lot of candy.

SPEAKER_00Enjoy.

SPEAKER_03That's part of it too.

SPEAKER_00Amen.

SPEAKER_03Amen. What's your favorite Halloween candy?

SPEAKER_00Oh gosh. I like it.

SPEAKER_03I picked up my mom's Halloween candy today because my mom gets between like two to four hundred kids every day.

SPEAKER_02Every Halloween, every day.

SPEAKER_03Well, two to four hundred. It depends on the weather, honestly. And now they do like the Halloween parade.

SPEAKER_00It's at Bellevue this year. It's back at the school.

SPEAKER_03Oh, okay. Well, when it was at the park, that really Rotary Member here, I can tell you. Okay, yeah, that really, really, really made the numbers go up. Right, right. But I do think I picked out some good candy this year. Anyways, what's your favorite?

SPEAKER_00I like, I like the gummy sour patch type of kids. You know, sour patch kids are good.

SPEAKER_03Um Do you like nerd clusters?

SPEAKER_00Nerd clusters are good.

SPEAKER_03I got her a bag of nerd clusters, but there's only 75 in the bag because they're really good.

SPEAKER_00I'm not a fan of bad chocolate. And Halloween chocolate is mostly bad chocolate. You got cheap, it's not really, you know, it's like 5% chocolate or whatever, you know. That kind of stuff doesn't do it for me. But sour patch kids.

SPEAKER_01Reese's peanut butter cup, I think would be my go-to.

SPEAKER_00I don't I don't think there's any Reese's in my mom's qualified as bad chocolate and bad peanut butter. I'm not a fan of Reese's peanut butter cups.

SPEAKER_03That is not the all-day experience of peanut butter cups.

SPEAKER_00Oh, yeah.

SPEAKER_03Well, I've got some, don't worry. And you can try them before you leave.

SPEAKER_02Right.

SPEAKER_03Um mine, I love butterfingers, so I made sure to I like butterfingers.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's probably bad chocolate. Yeah, yeah, that's the worst. Butterfingers, that's that's a little different. That one hits. That one hits nostalgic for me. It's like that's why I like it when I was a kid. That was that was a good one.

SPEAKER_03All right, father, I think it's time.

SPEAKER_01Can you relate? So I I don't know if this has ever happened uh to you two, but it happens to me quite often. Where um someone told me that that in a homily the other day, I said something really impactful. And it was actually uh, it was it was a kid, and they they said, you know, Father Andy said, It's not supposed to be life isn't supposed to be this hard, like, like, like, you know, I don't know, something like that I I know I did not say that.

SPEAKER_01I just know I didn't say it. But they heard me say it, and it has changed your life.

SPEAKER_03Oh, that's amazing.

SPEAKER_01That's the Holy Spirit.

SPEAKER_03That is.

SPEAKER_01I don't know if that ever happens. I've never said a homily. Oh yeah, so actually, you're like, yeah, you're saying stuff all the time, actually. Yeah, right.

SPEAKER_03It's really hard to tell if anybody's listening.

SPEAKER_00But but that's what that's when I think that that you know, in their head that they come up with this thing that you said that was really good and own it. Yeah, thank you. So glad that that's what they heard. I'm so glad they heard that message. Because that's true, they heard that message. They did, they didn't hear those words, but they heard the message. Yeah. I think um, you know, I think that this is one that's m more relatable to the time right now. We're gonna have, you know, the I never know if daylight savings time is coming or going or and beginning or ending, but something falls.

SPEAKER_00Fall behind, right, right. I know that much. But it's but it's like daylight savings time. Does it is it ending now or is it starting?

SPEAKER_03Oh, no idea ending.

SPEAKER_00I think it's ending.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, because we're not saving daylight anymore.

SPEAKER_00We're just getting rid of it. We're just yeah, we're just gonna go without. Right, right. No more daylight. Um, and and I I can't get away with this as much, but my car is the same way. Where like a week goes by and you haven't changed your clock yet, and then you just go, I think I'm gonna ride this out because it's gonna be right again in another like six months. Yeah, and so so that that's my can you relay? Did you do that? I remember even like the microwave clock in college. I would just every time I look at it, you just subtract an hour, and then you're like, eventually it's gonna be right again.

SPEAKER_01I I think I have done that. I mean, I know I have done that. I'm just trying to think if I'm gonna if I do that now at all. Like, it seems like things are gotten easier, like the interfaces have gotten easier to it's not as hard to like a lot of it changes on its own, right?

SPEAKER_00But yeah, you see that clock and you're like, ah, I missed it. I missed that date. It's already been a week. Wasn't there five months?

SPEAKER_03Just let it rise. Maybe it's like a man thing because I am not like that, but my dad, like, all of his clocks are wrong. Right. They're not in, I mean, it seems like they're wrong on both sides.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Well, Kelsey, here's it. Yeah, I mean, Kelsey used to set a clock 15 minutes um fast. So that way we'd always be on time because she would always be struggling. And within like a day, you just are always doing mental math to go, okay. That clock's 15 minutes. I had it. I got 15 more minutes. Yeah, yeah. And then all of a sudden somebody fixes the clock, and now you're always 15 minutes late for everything because you're still doing the mental math.

SPEAKER_03I got 15 more minutes. Right, right.

SPEAKER_01One or two minutes, fine. But when you start getting more than that, you're doing the math. Right. Yeah.

SPEAKER_03Um, mine is um, I'm a creature of habit, and every Sunday, our Sunday's our laundry day. Um, and every Sunday night I risk my life to go back upstairs because I refuse to take more than one trip upstairs. So every Sunday I take two hampers and sometimes one to two wash baskets in one trip. Because it is so much better to just do one trip.

SPEAKER_00I think it's sad that two trips. Like show of strength that you get to accomplish with it.

SPEAKER_03Well, you know what I think it is, is when when we go to my grandma's house and we go into the basement, like she's always got a million things that she needs us to take downstairs, and she's always like, Don't take too much. Well, then that's like a challenge. Like, I'm gonna take all of it. I'm gonna show you, Grandma. And she's always like so impressed. So, like now, like every time I do it, I'm like, oh man, grandma would really think this is crazy. Yeah, two hampers, two wash baskets.

SPEAKER_00Well, it's like it's like when you get home with grocery shopping and you got you got seven bags on your middle finger, nine on the pointer finger. You're just every both handles and you're like arms or bullets, the milk milk carton being carried up by a pinky finger. But you you get it in the house in less trips. That's an important thing. You're like, I wish I could take a selfie right now.

SPEAKER_01Right, right.

SPEAKER_03So somebody can see this and appreciate it. I like to call it a one-trip wonder.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, one trip wonder. That's impressive. I can relate to that, definitely.

SPEAKER_03And my steps are super steep too. So one of these days. And then also, like another added challenge is Carl is usually racing me up the stairs at the same time.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_03So if I don't show up at school some Monday, I'll come over and you'll know.

SPEAKER_00I'll fold your laundry that's full and spring on the ball.

SPEAKER_03The worst of all is the laundry all unfolded.

SPEAKER_00Oh man. She's gonna be so mad when she wakes up.

SPEAKER_03Oh, all right. Well, thanks for joining us, Jeff.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, thank you again for having me. Yeah, great.

SPEAKER_03Thanks for stopping over, Father Andy.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, thanks to all our listeners.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. And um, yeah, that's it for this week. We hope you enjoyed it. Um, as always, we are praying for you.

SPEAKER_01May God bless you all.

SPEAKER_03Bye.

SPEAKER_01Bye. Bye bye now.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Love Beyond Death

    Nov 12, 202622 minAudio

    Have you ever felt like a loved one was has passed away was sending you a sign? What does the Catholic Church teach us about these experiences? In this solo episode, Katie shares one incredible sign her family received...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Pressure To Be Perfect

    Nov 5, 20261 hr 1 minAudio

    Friend of the podcast Kelsey Kaiser joins us this week for a conversation about perfectionism! We’re talking about the pressure we put on ourselves, the negative impacts it can have on us and those around us, and how we...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. From Blessed Fulton Sheen To The Georgia Martyrs

    Oct 28, 202644 minAudio

    Brandon Schetgen is back this week to share his experience at the Beatification Mass of Blessed Fulton Sheen. We are also diving into the Beatification of the Georgia Martyrs. Their story reminds us what it truly means...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Saint Stalkers

    Oct 22, 202645 minAudio

    Fr. Jacob Rouse is back on Relatable Catholic and this week we are talking about three incredible women of faith: St. Therese of Lisieux, St. Teresa of Calcutta, and St. Teresa of Avila. We are diving into their lives,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. What Does That Even Mean?! A Catholic Word Study

    Oct 15, 202639 minAudio

    What does that even mean?! This week Angie joins us as we put our Catholic knowledge to the test by guessing the meanings of some very Catholic words. Will we sound like theologians or have absolutely no idea what we’re...

    Credit the people on this episode