
A Love Letter to the Struggling Opera Singer
I’ve had several glorious and creativity-affirming weeks away from Instagram. But, all cards on the table, I logged back into my old account. Why? I have an audition coming up, and I want a curated body of work to be there. The app stays deleted; I have no intention of posting. But curiosity caught me, and I took a scroll down operagram lane. NGL, it was a crash back into the attention-grabbing world of social media to see a mezzo in heels, a bikini, and a set of wings give a Victoria’s Secret rendition of Rosina in her kitchen. More power to her, but in this economy, if I’m going to be cold and collect likes and saves from the ‘gaze’ on the internet, it will be in exchange for money. If I ever sing in my underwear (and I will later this season), it will either be because OF is paying me or a theater is. Honestly, in the history of this career, there is not much of a difference, and I’ve never had a problem with that. We deserve to be financially compensated for ‘the gaze,’ but that’s an article for another time… The cage match between Andrew Potter and Nicholas Brownlee Okay… less cage match and more of an ‘I love you, dude, but I think…’ kind of a situation. The next thing that caught my attention was the continuing Andrew Potter debate, the now (adorably kind) clapback from Nicholas Brownlee, and the returning lob from Potter’s wife advocating for the ‘other’ gender’s side. I somehow feel the need to say that all three of these artists come at the issue from different angles and career experiences, and we forget to see that they all clearly have squishy, loving human hearts and are out there posting on the internet with no cover. Artists be out there raw-dogging the internet, and I respect the time and the drama all three of them have 100% dealt with because of it. Been there. And having had personal time away from the absolute chaos that is social media, I finally have had the space to think about my perspective on this. And I hope you take time away from all of the 30-second clips on social media to create your own perspective, too. I kinda agree with all three of these artists, and I also agree with none of them at all, so let’s get into it: Brownlee is right - where tf do you expect the money to come from? I could present you with a bunch of numbers I found on the internet to prove that I know what I’m talking about. But instead, I’ll just cut to the chase and tell you what I know. Theaters are having their budgets cut, and here’s the kicker: it’s not always because ‘nobody cares about the arts!’ It’s because, at least if you work at a Staatstheater in Germany like me, the theater is just another entity in the Bundesland that needs to be funded. It’s on the same to-fund list as schools, hospitals, community centers, government offices, etc. And all of those are being cut. Also an article for another time, but if you ever play that word-association game on the NYT app, then you might recognize that one of the things in the list above isn’t like the other. The theater is one of the only things that makes an income. Theaters generate revenue but nobody is thinking about this with any creative possibility. It’s an article for another time, but Germans and people running theaters in Germany haven’t seen any opportunity there. There’s largely just a ‘this is how it’s always been done, so we have no power’ sort of lazy-ass-victim mentality. IMO. Anyway, Brownlee is right. I’ve been inside the German Fest system for 10 years, and we have felt the shifts. I’ve experienced the stress from those ‘running the show’ and seen the decline in funding affect who is able to be hired and the quality and volume of what goes on the stages. Here’s where I’ll side with Andrew Potter: As I wrote in an article ages ago, the math doesn’t math. And when I quit my Fest job, this is what was candidly said in the conversation that I will not so candidly write here because I think it’s important. In my conversation with one of the high-ups at my theater, they expressed, with legitimate frustration, that there just wasn’t any money. That the budget was a constant stress. It was genuine, and this person genuinely cared about how it affected the actual humans living with the ramifications of this budget. But here was and still is my response: Administrators and largely everyone else in the theater get to stress and complain about the budget crisis in opera. They get to argue and fumble around with it all day at work. And then they get to go home to lives they can afford, vacations they can afford, and wait for a retirement they can afford. We artists? We live out that budget cut at the end of every month. And I want to be clear that it wasn’t always like this. Things have changed. Fest singers may be the clearest marker of the opera industry’s overall health. And boy, oh boy, are we jumping ship. If you’re going into the Fest system right now, you can expect to make anywhere from 30K to 40K a year after taxes. If you can stack a guest contract or two, you may be able to save some money, which is necessary because there is no guarantee your Fest contract will last past 2-3 seasons. So many people don’t realise that it is not a stable job where, once you get a position, you get to keep it. Nope. I’ll just get so personal with this and tell you my experience and how it’s changed. Five years ago, I was able to afford a tiny lil apartment for me and my doggo, carry no debt, invest each month, have a healthy emergency fund, and put aside 12K for a future home and some travel. All on a 31K-netto-a-year income. It took discipline and being intentional in exchange for having the things in my life that mattered most. Cut to five years later, and I’m winning awards and singing leading roles at an A house - between 7 and 8 productions a season - and getting paid a net 33K a season. But it’s a larger city, and holy s**t, I’ve gone into the red every single month - to the point that the only choice was to quit. Frankly, our audience has no idea. The soloists are up there standing on stage, getting paid less than everyone else in the room. Less than the orchestra and often less than the chorus. And people are wondering why we are all choosing to move the f*ck on. Nobody is forcing you to be an opera singer Here’s where I’m going to nuance the Potter-Brownlee argument in a way that it hasn’t been yet and really needs to be. Nobody is forcing you to be an opera singer. This isn’t to say we don’t need to make the industry fairer, more respectful, and more open to singers. We should. If you read anything I said above, in the words of Brownlee on the issue, ‘those who know me will know my heart.’ But it’s because I care about singers so much that I will say: if you are unhappy or dissatisfied, leave. Leave because I want you to have a happy and stable life. You want a life where you have weekends and holidays with your family, have some stability, and can afford retirement and a few vacations? Don’t pursue a career as an opera singer rn. That’s okay! I’m not telling you to stop singing (i literally would never). In fact, there are so many options. The option I’ll personally be exploring is silent-quitting the industry while refocusing all of that hot air wasted online judging and needing and complaining - back into the two pillars of my life that will give me back what I deserve: my art and the security to create my art. To be so harsh for a second, I am so tired of the arguing and opinions. People are trying to survive, and on top of it, we need to be performing our own survival? Where are the stories of artists doing it? Where is the story of a singer making their Scala or Met debut in the evening while running a business in the morning? Not because we should have to do other things. But because we either function within the reality we exist in or choose to leave for a better life. Without shame. All this is to say… nothing will ever change if we waste all of our beautiful energy on griping over what’s not working when we c… This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit nicoharper.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
